CLUSTER DEVELOPMENT IN TURKEY:
INTERNATIONALIZATION, INNOVATION AND
       REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
             VEDAT KUNT
           VEGO CONSULTING

          Vienna, 20th April 2012
Two project cases from the less developed
regions of Turkey are examined;
     1. Harnessing Sustainable Linkages in the
     Textile Sector of Turkey- UNIDO (funded
     by the MDGF)
     2. Empowering SMEs for Networking and
     Inter-Regional Cooperation- Ministry of
     Economy (funded by the EU)
                              European Commission
                              Enterprise and Industry   26.04.2012   2
1. Harnessing Sustainable Linkages in
the Textile Sector of Turkey- UNIDO




                                  European Commission
                                  Enterprise and Industry   26.04.2012   3
1. Harnessing Sustainable Linkages in
the Textile Sector of Turkey- UNIDO

• UNIDO’s unique approach to Cluster
  Development is followed;
      1. Social Capital /Trust Building
      2. Establishment of Joint Actions
      3. Performing Cluster
      4. Poverty Reduction


                                  European Commission
                                  Enterprise and Industry   26.04.2012   4
1. Harnessing Sustainable Linkages in
the Textile Sector of Turkey- UNIDO

“Growth ... is an important means to enlarge human choices
  but it is not an end in itself. Growth at all costs can result
  in:
*Jobless growth (that does not expand employment
  opportunities);
*Ruthless growth (the fruits of growth mostly benefit the
  rich);
*Rootless growth (stifles cultural diversity and identity);
*Futureless growth (depletes natural resources);
*Voiceless growth (growth without expansion of democracy,
  empowerment)”

• UNDP – Human Development Report (1999)


                                        European Commission
                                        Enterprise and Industry   26.04.2012   5
1. Harnessing Sustainable Linkages in
the Textile Sector of Turkey- UNIDO

WHO ARE THE POOR???
The poor addressed in a cluster initiative are…
1. Poor cluster entrepreneurs
2. Poor farmers and/or suppliers supplying cluster firms
3. Poor workers in cluster firms and job-seekers
4. Poor consumers of clusters goods/services




                                        European Commission
                                        Enterprise and Industry   26.04.2012   6
1. Harnessing Sustainable Linkages in
the Textile Sector of Turkey- UNIDO

Pro-poor economic opportunities:
• For poor entrepreneurs: increased productivity, investments,
   sales, returns and income from business activities
• For poor suppliers and farmers: increased sales (volume and
   frequency), better prices, higher returns
• For poor employees and job-seekers: new / more stable
   employment, higher wages, better working conditions
• For poor consumers: increased affordability of goods/services
   produced by the cluster, improved quality of the products




                                        European Commission
                                        Enterprise and Industry   26.04.2012   7
Lessons learned 1

• Finding, training and developing CDAs (Cluster
  Development Agents/Cluster Managers) is the most
  important first step.
• Trust building between CDA and the cluster members is
  critical
• Mobilizing state incentives in the direction is the ultimate
  support tool to establish joint actions
• Local and national stakeholders’ governance plays a key
  role for sustainability
• Being a part of an “Environment” which enables
  innovation is the ultimate target for Companies,
  Academia and Institutions…

                                         European Commission
                                         Enterprise and Industry   26.04.2012   8
2. Empowering SMEs for Networking
and Inter-Regional Cooperation-
Ministry of Economy
MoE’s SME Development and Networking project

• 5 Pilot cities + 5 Co-op regions in the west + 5 Target
  international markets
• 5 priority sectors
• 5 Cluster Info Spots established as one stop shops for cluster
  development




                                        European Commission
                                        Enterprise and Industry   26.04.2012   9
Lessons learned 2


• Value Chain and Supply Chains Analysis play an
  important role in identifying upgrading opportunities
  both horizontal and vertical for the companies at
  implementation level and to mobilize right support
  mechanisms at policy level.
• Concentrating on leadership and creativity,
  understanding “project psychology” is critical.
  Unleashing creativity, developing human resources
  accordingly, who will ultimately manage the cluster
  activities will determine success or failure…
                                   European Commission
                                   Enterprise and Industry   26.04.2012   10
Lessons learned 2


• Not only B2B,C2C, B2C and C2B; but also B2I,
  C2I, B2A, C2A and vice versa, There is
  extensive flow of information, knowledge,
  technology, finance, products, processes
  between each peer.
• Being a part of an “Environment” which
  enables innovation is the ultimate target for
  Companies, Academia and Institutions…

                              European Commission
                              Enterprise and Industry   26.04.2012   11
Thank you very much for your attention…
               Vedat Kunt
        Partner, VEGO Consulting
   • UNIDO Consultant for Cluster Development
• Key Expert for SME Development and Networking
                   Project of MoE
             v.kunt@vego.com.tr

                              European Commission
                              Enterprise and Industry   26.04.2012   12

01 vedat kunt day 3_s3_ecc2012

  • 1.
    CLUSTER DEVELOPMENT INTURKEY: INTERNATIONALIZATION, INNOVATION AND REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT VEDAT KUNT VEGO CONSULTING Vienna, 20th April 2012
  • 2.
    Two project casesfrom the less developed regions of Turkey are examined; 1. Harnessing Sustainable Linkages in the Textile Sector of Turkey- UNIDO (funded by the MDGF) 2. Empowering SMEs for Networking and Inter-Regional Cooperation- Ministry of Economy (funded by the EU) European Commission Enterprise and Industry 26.04.2012 2
  • 3.
    1. Harnessing SustainableLinkages in the Textile Sector of Turkey- UNIDO European Commission Enterprise and Industry 26.04.2012 3
  • 4.
    1. Harnessing SustainableLinkages in the Textile Sector of Turkey- UNIDO • UNIDO’s unique approach to Cluster Development is followed; 1. Social Capital /Trust Building 2. Establishment of Joint Actions 3. Performing Cluster 4. Poverty Reduction European Commission Enterprise and Industry 26.04.2012 4
  • 5.
    1. Harnessing SustainableLinkages in the Textile Sector of Turkey- UNIDO “Growth ... is an important means to enlarge human choices but it is not an end in itself. Growth at all costs can result in: *Jobless growth (that does not expand employment opportunities); *Ruthless growth (the fruits of growth mostly benefit the rich); *Rootless growth (stifles cultural diversity and identity); *Futureless growth (depletes natural resources); *Voiceless growth (growth without expansion of democracy, empowerment)” • UNDP – Human Development Report (1999) European Commission Enterprise and Industry 26.04.2012 5
  • 6.
    1. Harnessing SustainableLinkages in the Textile Sector of Turkey- UNIDO WHO ARE THE POOR??? The poor addressed in a cluster initiative are… 1. Poor cluster entrepreneurs 2. Poor farmers and/or suppliers supplying cluster firms 3. Poor workers in cluster firms and job-seekers 4. Poor consumers of clusters goods/services European Commission Enterprise and Industry 26.04.2012 6
  • 7.
    1. Harnessing SustainableLinkages in the Textile Sector of Turkey- UNIDO Pro-poor economic opportunities: • For poor entrepreneurs: increased productivity, investments, sales, returns and income from business activities • For poor suppliers and farmers: increased sales (volume and frequency), better prices, higher returns • For poor employees and job-seekers: new / more stable employment, higher wages, better working conditions • For poor consumers: increased affordability of goods/services produced by the cluster, improved quality of the products European Commission Enterprise and Industry 26.04.2012 7
  • 8.
    Lessons learned 1 •Finding, training and developing CDAs (Cluster Development Agents/Cluster Managers) is the most important first step. • Trust building between CDA and the cluster members is critical • Mobilizing state incentives in the direction is the ultimate support tool to establish joint actions • Local and national stakeholders’ governance plays a key role for sustainability • Being a part of an “Environment” which enables innovation is the ultimate target for Companies, Academia and Institutions… European Commission Enterprise and Industry 26.04.2012 8
  • 9.
    2. Empowering SMEsfor Networking and Inter-Regional Cooperation- Ministry of Economy MoE’s SME Development and Networking project • 5 Pilot cities + 5 Co-op regions in the west + 5 Target international markets • 5 priority sectors • 5 Cluster Info Spots established as one stop shops for cluster development European Commission Enterprise and Industry 26.04.2012 9
  • 10.
    Lessons learned 2 •Value Chain and Supply Chains Analysis play an important role in identifying upgrading opportunities both horizontal and vertical for the companies at implementation level and to mobilize right support mechanisms at policy level. • Concentrating on leadership and creativity, understanding “project psychology” is critical. Unleashing creativity, developing human resources accordingly, who will ultimately manage the cluster activities will determine success or failure… European Commission Enterprise and Industry 26.04.2012 10
  • 11.
    Lessons learned 2 •Not only B2B,C2C, B2C and C2B; but also B2I, C2I, B2A, C2A and vice versa, There is extensive flow of information, knowledge, technology, finance, products, processes between each peer. • Being a part of an “Environment” which enables innovation is the ultimate target for Companies, Academia and Institutions… European Commission Enterprise and Industry 26.04.2012 11
  • 12.
    Thank you verymuch for your attention… Vedat Kunt Partner, VEGO Consulting • UNIDO Consultant for Cluster Development • Key Expert for SME Development and Networking Project of MoE v.kunt@vego.com.tr European Commission Enterprise and Industry 26.04.2012 12