Integration Of Immigrants Vs. Australia

Integration Of Immigrants Vs. Australia
Integration of immigrant skills in Canadian economy
Selective immigration policies are becoming very popular in developed countries such as Canada,
the United States and Australia to attract skilled immigrants. Different approaches and criteria are
being used to improve the process of selecting skilled immigrants. These selective immigration
policies fall under one of the following three groups (Doomernik, Koslowski & Thraenhardt, 2009):
1. The "human capital" model based on the selection of permanent immigrants using a point system,
as practiced by Canada.
2. The "neo–corporatist" model based on the selection using a point system with extensive business
and labor participation, as practiced by Australia.
3. The "market–oriented" model ... Show more content on Helpwriting.net ...
The foreign credentials and work experience of highly skilled immigrants is often not recognized by
employers and accreditation bodies. This results in underemployment of highly educated
internationally trained immigrants. Research on the difference in earnings of immigrants and their
Canadian counterparts clearly demonstrates the underutilization of immigrant skills (Bloom, Grenier
& Gunderson, 1994; Hum & Simpson, 1999; Pendakur & Pendakur, 1998). According to a study by
Reitz (2005), foreign–educated immigrants earned $2.4 billion less than native–born Canadians,
who had comparable skills because the immigrants were underemployed. He also reported that two–
thirds of the unutilized skills, which were worth $1.6 billion would have been productive in the
context of Canadian economy. Alboim, et al. (2005) found that a foreign degree appears on an
average to have a return worth less than one–third that of a degree obtained in Canada. The intended
economic impact of selective migration policies is not being achieved and the underutilization of
immigrants ' skills has become a significant issue in Canada's immigration program.
Profile of recent skilled immigrants to Canada
Between 2002 and 2008, there were approximately 327,000 FSW principal applicants who landed in
Canada (CIC, 2010). There has been an increase in the number of degree qualified immigrants. For
instance, from 1996 to
... Get more on HelpWriting.net ...

Donald Trump 's Position On Immigration Reform
Donald Trump's position on Immigration Reform is unique, one of his major policy changes is to
make a wall at the southern border and make Mexico pay for it. Other major points as well is "Any
immigration plan must improve jobs, wages and security for all Americans"(Trump). These first two
policies are not very reasonable, assuming that Mexico will pay for a very costly wall at the
southern border is concerning. Also, when he says that all immigration plans must improve life for
all Americans is unreasonable. There will always be situations where a plan does not improve life
for all Americans, but that does not mean the immigration plan should be stopped. On the flip side
Donald Trump brings up some strong points like returning illegal immigrants who have committed
crimes back to their home country. This policy is a good one, because if someone who is illegally
staying here is also committing crimes and just making life harder here in the U.S. they should be
deported. Overall the majority of his policies seemed weak and unrealistic. He had a couple good
points, but not enough to have a strong immigration reform. Marco Rubio has many different
policies he wants to change in the immigration reform. One strong policy that he does bring up is
"Making our legal immigration system a merit–based system that encourages innovators will have
broad benefits for our economy"(Rubio). This policy seems like a very logical and practical way to
improve the economy while letting immigrants

Current Immigration Process
Problems with the Current Immigration Process
The Visa Application System
The current visa application process is excessively cumbersome, time–consuming, and expensive.
Prospective immigrants must navigate a byzantine six–step process, which includes acquiring an
immigration lawyer, paying application fees, submitting a lengthy visa application form, obtaining
financial documents, collecting supporting documents, and finally submitting all of the documents
to the National Visa Center ("The Immigrant Visa Process"). In order to even begin to undertake this
lengthy immigrant visa process, a foreign citizen has to identify a U.S. citizen, U.S. lawful
permanent resident, or employer to sponsor and advocate for their immigration ("The Immigrant ...
Show more content on Helpwriting.net ...
This geriatric legislation–passed in a radically socially different America, with very different social
goals–still limits the number of annual immigrants that are allowed to apply for a visa in the United
States by country (Argueta). INA sets an inflexible yearly quota system that distributes access to
U.S. visas by a maximum of seven percent per country (Argueta). According to the President at the
time, Lyndon Baines Johnson, INA was implemented to change the fact that 70% of the immigration
supply was limited to three countries of origin (LBJ). The limited number of visas, however, results
in a longer waiting time for family members and workers who hope to enter the United States
legally, hitting heaviest the immigrants that come from countries with higher populations and levels
of immigration; Mexico, China, India, and the Philippines ("Why Don't They Just Get In Line?"). In
May 2016, of applicants from number of countries, unmarried children of American citizens had to
wait for more than five years while siblings of U.S citizens had to wait for more than ten years.
Married children of U.S. citizens have to wait for more than twenty years for a visa to become
available, and Filipino siblings of U.S. citizens have to wait around twenty–five years ("Why Don't
They Just Get In Line?"). Even after these waiting times, there is no guarantee that they will be
accepted. Madeleine

Immigration To Canada Research Paper
Press Release
Topic – Canada Permanent Residency
Nile Immigration Kicks–off New Permanent Residency Gateways to Maple Leaf Country – Canada
6th July 2016, New Delhi: Immigration to Canada depends on your skills, qualification, experience,
and the way you choose and follow the whole process. Canada is one of the most preferred countries
for migration –henceforth the country witnesses millions of people across the globe applying for
permanent residency of Canada. Here is an overview on gateways to get Canada PR.
Routes to Canada
The key immigration programs are mentioned below. Choose any of these programs to get
permanent residency in Canada.
Express Entry System
This immigration program was launched in January 2015. It is very popular and

Questions On Immigration Enforcement Programs Essay
This article seeks to first answer 5 basic research questions: Who are the deportees, what are their
experiences, how do immigration enforcement programs operate and are their any notable
differences between authorities' stated practices and people's experiences, what are the standard
practices and potential problems with costly immigration enforcement programs, what is "security"
and how are specific programs related to immigration enforcement helping to achieve this goal?
During 2010, 2011, and 2012 over 1113 interviews were conducted with recent deportees asking the
previous questions. This article uses statistical data collected using a sample population to argue
against current U.S. immigration policy while suggesting new reforms that better serve individuals
looking to work or become citizens in the United States. It argues that a more accessible path to
citizenship would facilitate safer border communities in both Mexico and the United States by
making illegal smuggling networks less profitable. Furthermore, this article spotlights the abuse of
immigrants in custody by U.S. Authorities. Half of all deportees interviewed had at the least one
family member who is a U.S. Citizen, with one in four having at least one child under the age of 18
who have U.S. citizenship. The article additionally discusses the more than 20 year wait time for
visas and the impossibility for average deportees to find a path to legal immigration under current
policy. The average deportee is

Persuasive Essay On Immigration
With the recent presidential election, which resulted in the inauguration of Donald Trump,
immigration has been thrust into the spotlight, as it has been a heavy platform for the current
president. The president of the United States has been very harsh on immigration and has called for
stricter regulations and has expressed his displeasure with the current number of immigrants that the
United States has accepted. I currently am a consultant for the Federation for American Immigration
Reform (FAIR), which is the largest immigration reform group in the country and a public interest
organization of concerned Americans, united in the belief that our immigration policies and laws
should again serve the nation's future needs (About FAIR, n.d.). I am purposing a plan to raise
awareness of the issues with immigration with the goal of increasing regulations for incoming
immigrants into the United States and trying to introduce a merit–based immigration system to
combat the current problems that the United States faces in regards to immigration. I also think that
increasing funding to the border patrol to help reduce the problem of illegal immigration would be a
smart, but not necessary idea. Better border management, lower levels of overall immigration, and a
greater focus on highly skilled immigrants are important policies and ideas of FAIR's and my
agenda (About FAIR, n.d.). These proposals are important as the United States has a larger
immigrant population than any other country, and is a world leader on the policies of immigration.
Immigration to the United States should be based solely upon the following principles: the
reunification of families, admitting immigrants with skills that are valuable to the U.S. economy,
protecting refugees, and promoting diversity (How the United States Immigration System Works,
2017).
Immigration today To highlight the issue of immigration some brief facts must be addressed to fully
understand what the situation the United States currently faces. According to the 2016 Current
Population Survey (CPS), immigrants and their U.S.–born children now number approximately 84.3
million people, or 27 percent of the overall U.S. population (Zong & Batalova, 2017). Every year
the

Story Of A Black Immigrant From A Shithole Country Summary
Throughout the history of the United States people of color has become a part of the country's fabric
which began centuries ago. Immigrants of color come to the united states with smart brain and
colored skin to accomplish their dreams. When they try to fulfill their dreams they are limited by the
color of their skin. In the article "Story of a Black Immigrant from a 'Shithole' Country," Karla
Thomas shares her life experience of her immigration to change the mindset of the people of the U.S
about the color of immigrants. Thomas explains how she faced discrimination and hardships in
fulfilling her American dream. She had limited options for her desired job due to her visa status.
Furthermore, she was struggling with her personal relationship and trying to get better opportunities
regarding her desired job as well. After 14 years of her consistent efforts, when Thomas finally got
her green card. She explains how immigrants like her are a major contributor towards America's
cultural diversity and economic development. After summarizing the situation of Karla Thomas
Immigrants of color face the problem of inequity in the United States and the best solution to this
problem is adopting the points based Immigration system of Canada. ... Show more content on
Helpwriting.net ...
According to Karla Thomas, Immigrants of color work above board with their families for years to
ful fill their dreams,but their efforts are unacknowleged. She Says, "I also know that the narrative
expressed in my last few sentences is met with pride and joy when the immigrant we speak of is
Lrish, Russian or the ever attractive Norwegian. Yet when we tell these stories about Black and
Brown immigrants, the narrative

The Impacts of Changing Immigration Patterns of the...
Immigration has gone through many different stages of change just as the nation of Canada had
many stages of change. Transformations of immigration during the post–war period greatly
impacted the society and immigration patterns of today. These changes included the post–war
immigration boom, a less segregating Immigration Act and the rise of multicultural and refugee
immigration. Post–war immigration patterns have differed from previous waves of immigration due
to their size and source of immigration resulting in a grand change in the 'face' of Canada. During
the post–war period, Canada benefited from a boom of immigrants. After the war, 1.5 million
immigrants flocked to Canada consisting mainly of European immigrants (). These immigrants ...
However, the induction of the Point System coincided with restrictions from the Britain. This made
Canada more preferable to various immigrants. The ideals against discrimination of immigrants
have since been an integral part of immigration policy. The new vision for Immigration Act in 1976
led to the increased opportunities for "visible minorities" and refugees. In the 1986 Census of
Canada, a "visible minority" is defined by Statistics Canada as people of the following origins:
Blacks, Indo–Pakistani, Chinese, Korean, Japanese, South East Asian, Filipino, Other Pacific
Islanders, West Asian and Arab, and Latin American, excluding Argentinean and Chilean
(justice.gc.ca). This new revision of the Immigration Act dealt with many issues with the
immigration process from previous revisions. This Immigration Act defined 4 classes of immigrants
(independent, family, sponsored family member and refugees). The previous Act of 1952 had only
focused on independent and dependent (sponsored) immigrants. Even though this Act supported
family reunification of Asian Canadians, it discriminated and placed quotas on many ethnic groups.
The Immigration Act of 1976 on the other hand, focused on the right of immigrants to uniform and
fair treatment from government officials and generosity to refugees (). This allowed for more
"visible minorities" and refugees to make Canada their new home. For example, by 1978, the
number of refugees and reunited families outnumber that of immigrants

USA Immigration System Research Paper
Quotas and the U.S.A. Immigration System Parita Parekh (85035) International Technological
University Quotas and the U.S.A. Immigration System "We didn't raise the Statue of Liberty with
her back to the world; we did it with her light shining as a beacon to the world. And whether we
were Irish or Italians or Germans crossing the Atlantic, or Japanese or Chinese crossing the Pacific;
whether we crossed the Rio Grande or flew here from all over the world – generations of
immigrants have made this country into what it is. It's what makes us special." (President Obama,
November 21, 2014) U.S.A. is a country of immigrants. However, U.S.A. immigration law is very
complex and there is much confusion as to how it works. Immigration ... Show more content on
Helpwriting.net ...
Many of the spouses of the non–immigrant workers are highly educated and can add value to the
society, but are forced to be a homemaker. This causes frustrations and has led to several families
moving back to their home country or to some other country for better opportunities. It's important
to understand here that, in scenarios like these U.S. not only lost one highly skilled labor, but in fact
lost two of them! Giving opportunity for these spouses to work will not only help the spouses feel
better, but it will also allow U.S. economy to tap into a talented group of smart and intelligent
people who has the potential of making a significant impact on the economy. Immigrants from other
countries are uncertain about their future in U.S. due to visa. Unpredictable nature of when a person
from country like India and China would get their immigrant visa, make them hesitant in making
big purchases like buying a house or a fancy car. Consider the impetus this could have given to the
housing market during recession, had people from countries like India and China had the stability to
make big purchase like buying a

Iranian Immigration System
Assignment 3: How Does the Point System Apply to Iranians? Outline In nineteen seventy nine Iran
had a revolution called the Islamic revolution or Iranian revolution, where the Pahlavi dynasty, the
last Iranian monarchy was overthrown and Iranian government was replaced with the Islamic
Republic; a theocratic–republican government led by Grand Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini. This
revolution created political instability by getting rid of many freedoms that Iranians were
accustomed to under the monarchy, and were facing dangerous life situations. Many Iranian
immigrants desired Canada over other western countries because of the point system that Canada
had from 1967. The point system divided the Iranian immigrants into four classes: the family class;
whose point went towards immigrant relatives of Canadian citizens. The independent class;
rewarded to immigrants with economic means to invest, self employ, or self sustain. The refugee
class; given to those whose human rights had been violated, and the skilled workers class;
immigrants with relevant work experience and education could be ... Show more content on
Helpwriting.net ...
2007. "ENHANCING POLICY CAPACITY ON THE ISSUE OF FOREIGN CREDENTIAL
RECOGNITION." Canadian Issues / Thèmes Canadiens 55–58. America: History & Life,
EBSCOhost (accessed August 6, 2015). This article describes that role the Canadian immigration
had toward skilled immigrants by not accepting their credentials, in which the article's hypothesis is
that it might be related to the fact of Canadian openness towards immigrant in general. The method
of investigation is looking at previous case studies. The conclusion of the article states that Canada
must improve its immigration polices as more immigrants are coming, and that Canada should
become more open–minded toward the skilled immigrant, which is also the main argument. This
article restates my research question. Barriers to employment and utilization of highly skilled
Iranians in Greater Vancouver Regional

Immigration has been, and continues to be a sensitive issues facing the country. The conceptions of
who should and shouldn't be welcomed are evolving, causing the proposals of new policies that will
alter the current immigration system. In May, both the Senate and White House agreed on a new
policy, only to have it criticized by people from both the left and right wings ("Immigration"). This
act focuses on a shift from the importance of "family–reunification," or the advancement of those
with previous family–ties, to a point–based system, benefitting those with more education and
language skills (Immigration). Although transitioning to a point system hurts those U.S. citizens
hoping to bring family from other countries, immigration should focus on the halting of
discrimination against beneficial non–relative immigrants who would contribute considerable
capital to the American economy.
Per year, around one million immigrants are granted lawful permanent residence into the United
States: family–based immigration accounts for nearly two–thirds of this annual quota (Gelatt). The
"RAISE Act," as this new proposal is called, aims to reduce this number to half a million by
eliminating current family–sponsored immigration categories to allow only spouses or minor
children of U.S. citizens to gain citizenship (Gelatt). This would result in a reduction of 226,000
family–reunification green cards to 88,000 after the bill's passing (Gelatt). The most unfavorable
aspect of the revision

Donald Trump's Reforming American Immigration Act
President Donald Trump has announced his support for a new "merit–based" immigration bill called
the Reforming American Immigration Act, also known as the RAISE Act. After Donald Trump's
announcement of a "complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States" in 2015, this
RAISE Act marked Donald Trump's first try at reforming the legal immigration system, and the
country's most dramatic attempt in more than 50 years. This act will screen visa applicants using a
point system introduced by Republican Sens. David Perdue and Tom Cotton. If passed, this Act
could reduce the number of people allowed to legally immigrate to the United States by 50 percent
over the next 10 years. Donald Trump shows his support requiring immigrants to use a skills–based
... Show more content on Helpwriting.net ...
"Applicant's will need to show that they can financially support themselves and their families, and
demonstrate skills that can contribute to the US economy," Donald Trump said. He added "They're
not going to come in and just immediately collect welfare." Until you are an American citizen for at
least 5 years, the majority of immigrants cannot receive food stamps, Medicaid, and Social Security.
Donald Trump often speaks against illegal immigration and has accused immigrants of stealing jobs
from American workers and blames them for crime in the country. He suggests that the RAISE Act
will "reduce poverty, increase wages, and save tax payers billions and billions of dollars". The
remarks made caused huge controversy, many people stuck by his wide because he made it seem
like it was in their favor to pass this Act. He continued to endorse this Act by saying "the current
immigration system is unfair and that it benefits new immigrants over "struggling American
families". Despite the results that immigrants actually served a positive purpose in the United States
serving less crime than native–born American's and helped boost the economy.
Although Donald Trump's support is strong towards the new RAISE Act, it still requires 60 votes for
it to pass. 52 votes being Republicans and 8 Democrats. Eight democrats would need to come out in
support of the new RAISE Act. Already, though, Democrats and even some Republicans have
announced they don't support the Act. Some support moving to a merit–based immigration system
but don't agree with the cuts the bill makes to the number of legal immigrants who enter the U.S. to
500, 000 from 1 million a

Why The US Should Cut Immigration
Although President Trump's comments offer an anti–immigrant view based on fear of a Cold War
anomaly and lack of better quality immigrant selection, history, and economic statistics support the
idea that legal immigration has, and continues to be, vital to the development and prosperity of the
United States.
Immigration was the foundation of the United States. The founding fathers left the British Empire to
escape religious persecution in search of a new start in life. Today this American dream is what
immigrants long for. Without immigration, the United States would most likely have seen minimal
growth throughout history. Statistics prove that the economy and diversity of the United States
significantly increased in relation to the amount of immigration. Despite the apparent importance of
immigration to the United States, some argue that immigrants steal jobs and increase crime. In
reality, immigrants increase jobs and further increase the stability of the United States.
Supporters of cutting legal immigration fear the influx of undesirable immigrants as well as the
possibility of terrorists entering the United States through immigration programs. President Trump
and "his administration emphasize the idea that Americans and their jobs need to be protected from
all newcomers" (Capó Web) due to their belief that this position is true. One resource supporting
restrictions on immigration is Capó Jr.'s The White House Used This Moment as Proof the U.S.
Should Cut Immigration.

The Immigration Policy Of The United States
Immigrating is to come to a country of which one is not a native, usually for permanent residence. It
goes along with drive and determination to seek pleasure out of life, chase dreams, and purse
happiness even in the most desperate of times. Migrating affects the communities that the migrants
leave as well as the communities that receive them. There are many views as to why people migrate
to different countries, the impact of immigration in countries, and how countries should go about
regulating immigration. When discussing the ethics of immigration, it is important to view this topic
from both sides and not just one side. In doing so, a person gets a sense of the bigger picture that the
U.S. is currently dealing with due to immigration. With that being said, the United States should
strive for an immigration policy that can benefit everyone involved as a whole.
Is it wrong to enter a country illegally? For a person to even consider this an option, he/she must be
in a position in which they need to migrate illegally. That is, considering all other factors, migrating
illegally to the United States is literally the best option available to that person. This answer is not a
simple yes or no, since it is easy to invent a case where the act of illegal migration is clearly morally
right or wrong. Obviously, if the immigrant's goal is to commit crimes in this country than they
should not be allowed entry. However, if an immigrant has nothing to live for and would

Corker-Hoeven Border Security System
From the moment of its inception, the United States has always been a nation of immigrants.
Throughout American history, the numerous immigration waves have undeniably defined the
infrastructure of America. By bringing a different set of views and innovative ideas, immigrants
injected the economy and advanced technology through innovative work. However, the United
States has not kept up its immigration policies with the changing times for the past three decades.
The faces of this broken immigration system are the estimated eleven million of undocumented
families, including two million children, who are living an American lifestyle as they work, live and
study in American soil (Garcia, 2013). Although undocumented individuals have adopted American
... Show more content on Helpwriting.net ...
For many years, immigration reform bill proposals have taken part in the House and Senate floor
but it has been obstructed by the conflicting views from both Democratic and Republican parties.
However, in 2013 the Democratic Party created a bipartisan bill with prospects to leave enough
space for compromise. In this arena, both Republican and Democrat Representatives can be united
to find consensus on immigration for the sake of fixing our dysfunctional immigration system.
Every year, millions of undocumented individuals face an avalanche of barriers due to their lack of
legality. Their legal and socioeconomic status denies them the opportunity to improve their lifestyle
and to contribute back to their community through human and monetary capital. A comprehensive
immigration reform would boost American economy, reduce deficit by 850 billion over the next two
decades, provide 300 billion dollars to the Social Security Trust fund and extend the life of this fund
for two years (White House, 2013). Moreover, it will create a sense of accountability between the
government and undocumented immigrants, which will encourage these immigrants for legalization
to remain on the right side of the law. As a consequence, fear will fade away from the hearts of
immigrants and they will begin actively participate

Border Security And Border Security In The United States
Empowering local law enforcement across the country to perform the functions of an immigration
officer is a public relations nightmare. This allows local law enforcement in the interior of the U.S.
to stop and ask individuals for their visas or other immigration papers. This practice is prone to
racial profiling and may encroach on the rights of U.S. citizens. This practice leads to mistrust of
local law enforcement and involves the use of limited resources to detain and subsequently remove
persons with only traffic stops or minor infractions. This also requires paid training programs for
local law enforcement officers across the country. The only states where this is socially acceptable
are the border states, where immigration rates are high and officers are already familiar with
immigration issues.
Border security is necessary for public safety and homeland security. However, building a bigger
and better wall is not the best way to increase border security. Improving the quality of current
fencing is the better route to go when it comes to a physical barrier. Spending less money on a new
wall would allow for money to go into other methods of physical security. Many immigrants are
digging border tunnels to cross the border undetected. A wall cannot stop this issue. It is imperative
for the United States border to have layered security. A layered approach allows for the prevention
of multiple ways of crossing the border. Many detection technologies are in development for

Unaccompanied Children Essay
Young and McKenna look at how the immigration policy approaches and immigration officials treat
unaccompanied children seeking entrance and asylum. The authors point out the weaknesses of the
current system and point to existing laws that can fix them with enforcement. The article is
descriptive and evaluative. The authors reference public immigration data and government policies
relating to immigration regulation and protection. The authors explain more unaccompanied
children are entering the United States over the years. From 2001–2006, CBP arrested 86,000
unaccompanied children (248). In 2008, the United States detained 7211 unaccompanied children,
compared to 6741 in 2004 and 200 in 1999. Those who are not promptly deported wait to go to
immigration court (248). The government sends children migrants who have entered illegally to
Department of Homeland Security (DHS) (249). If they are unaccompanied, they then go to (HHS)'s
Office of Refugee Resettlement as of 2002 (248). Before, they would go to Legacy Immigration and
Naturalization Service (INS) (250). The children stay in detention facilities from 6 months to 2
years (251). Many children stay in secure facilities due to few spaces in less restrictive places (251).
Over half the kids do ... Show more content on Helpwriting.net ...
Flores v. Messe 1996 calls for respectful and careful treatment, placement in appropriate
unrestricted facilities and also place custody under relatives or guardian (250). The Unaccompanied
Alien Child Protection Act 2000 calls for provision of legal counsel that specifically have
knowledge in working with unaccompanied minors and immigration (251). Pushed by the
Homeland Security Act, in 2005, the ORR established a Pro Bono program for providing counsel to
unaccompanied children (251). TVPRA 2008 also calls for stay in least restrictive setting that
regards the best interests and also calls for an independent child advocate

Persuasive Speech Impact On Immigration
Donald Trump's presidency has been filled with controversial language and his ability to keep his
promises. The president's remarks on issues as illegal and legal immigration have sparked debates
on the immigration policies currently in place. The biggest issue President Trump has pushed is
immigrant's ability to speak English. Two republican senators, Tom Cotton and David Perdue (See
Appendix A), put forth their new immigration bill in February of 2017. "The Reforming American
Immigration for Strong Employment Act" or "RAISE Act" is an overhaul of the current immigration
system. According to Perdue the new reform takes note of how Canada and Australia allows
immigrants to apply and that the new system is, "pro–worker, it's pro–growth, and it's been proven
to work." (White House 2017). This new reform implements a point based system for applicants.
One of the new emphasis' in the bill is the weight of the applicant's ability of the English language.
In the White House press briefing announcing the bill, Cotton states, "The 'RAISE Act' will change
all of that by re–orienting our Green Card system toward people who can speak English." All of
that, means the current issues, he and the president see in the current bill. Pre "RAISE Act" the US
had just three Green Card applicant groups with just a check list to be put into a category.
(Appendix B). Post "RAISE Act", the Green Card application system is now based on points. One
of the new parts of this bill is the English

Immigration Policy Of Canada And The United States
INTRODUCTION
The author chose immigration as the topic of this report to rationalize and review its various aspects
which will serve as the grounding to expand the author's business in immigration based countries
like Canada.
The report encompasses the most preferred countries for immigration, immigration policies in
Australia, Canada and the United States, and the economic impact of immigration. The report does
not cover refugee immigration, illegal immigration and the negative impacts of immigration.
There has been an increase in immigration to various countries in recent years. Different
immigration policies are adapted by various countries. There are a few flaws in the point based
immigration policy of Canada and measures are being taken by the local government to rectify this.
Immigration is important in the economic growth of a particular country. There can be a lot of
variance between the immigration policies of different countries.
Most of the information in this report has been sourced from the secondary data of the St. Clair
College library sources and from the website www.therichest.com. Other references are taken from
Canadian Ethnic Studies, International Migration, Journal of Population Economics.
GLOBAL IMMIGRATION SCENARIO
Yearly, a large number of people around the globe choose to immigrate to other countries, and this
rate is expected to increase in near future.
People immigrate to other countries due to various complex reasons. Some are

Topic Two : Ethics And Immigration
Sydney Hutton
PHIL 453
Paper One
2/24/16
Topic Two: Ethics and Immigration
Without some sort of global government regime, the problems that plague nations around the world
are dealt with based on how their nations sees fit, or how their government is structured. One of the
main ethical issues that our world is facing is the issue of immigration, both legal and illegal. Each
nation has a different policy, thus allowing issues of morality to be questioned on an international
scale when dealing with immigration. Through careful consideration of the literature read in class
and the viewing of Posada, it is my understanding that the biggest moral problem relating to
immigration is the criteria of selection and criteria of exclusion in which nations operate under to
assess who is granted entry into a country. The lack of a unified system for admission, with variance
on criteria, clearly proposes flaws in the structure and faults within each approach.
In her essay, "A Note of Justice, Care and Immigration Policy", Annette Baier states that there are
multiple attitudes in which immigration policies can be approached. From a feminist ethics point of
view that would be best suited with regards to international ethics is that in which she describes as
"universalist and rights–based" (Baier 150). In this approach "all foreigners would have the same
right to apply for a visa to enter a given country, and only those with some special legally
recognized claim (those seeking political

Economics And Immigration : The Economics Of U.s....
Economics and Immigration Immigration is a topic on everyone 's minds these days. With
presidential candidates vying for votes in debates and political campaigns, immigration has been
talked about quite a bit. But what is truly known about immigration? Since it is such a divisive
issue, it is hard to know what is true and what isn't. Unfortunately, the information most readily
available to us comes in the form of opinionated articles and biased speeches by presidential
candidates. Because the information we receive is biased, not necessarily true, and only a piece of a
larger picture, it's hard to know what to believe. With some saying immigration hurts our economy
and others arguing for the benefits of immigration, no one truly understands the actual economic
impact of immigration. For this paper, I have chosen three academic journals on the topic of the
economics of immigration that agree on one important point: our immigration system is broken. The
first article is entitled "The Economics of U.S. Immigration Policy." This article was written by Pia
M. Orrenius, the Assistant Vice President and Senior Economist in the research department at the
Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas, and Madeline Zavodny, a professor of economics at Agnes Scott
College. This article explains that the public has become concerned with the issue of immigration
because of the fiscal impacts of immigrants on our labor markets. Orrenius and Zavodny relate a
plethora of facts about the economics of

Persuasive Essay On Immigration Reform
The United States, immigration policy is at a standstill due to intense political divisions.
Undocumented immigrants face major issues by coming to this country to get a chance in rising
socioeconomically and to achieve a better way of life for themselves, as well as for their families.
Refugees fleeing their unsafe and war destructed countries are punished by this political division,
waiting and seeking asylum in the United States. Immigration in the United States has long
supported the growth and power of the economy of this country. Immigrants are taxpayers,
consumers, entrepreneurs and job creators. They contribute trillions of dollars to the US economy
and are vital for the future of the United States. The new administration with its threats of increased
immigration enforcement and restrictions on legal immigrants and refugees will cost the taxpayer
huge amounts and is threatening immigrants and their families. An Immigration Reform needs to be
put in place to address the following issues; safety of immigrants, stop racial profiling by policy
officers, work visas and protecting the dreamers with the DREAM ACT which would help millions
of undocumented youth a pathway to citizenship through education.
Solutions
Our current administration perceives the current immigration system as broken and in need of
revision to help the current labor market and grow the economy. Driven by myths that immigrants
hurt economic growth and that immigrants steal American jobs. America

Express Entry Case Study
The Express Entry was introduced in January 2015 by Citizenship Canada and Immigration (CIC).
The Express entry is a new mechanism for processing the applications electronically not a new
immigration program. The applications are selected under three main classes of the federal
immigration programs. These consists of; the Federal Skilled Worker Program (FSWP), the Federal
Skilled Trades Program (FSTP) and the Canadian Experience Class (CEC). The applicants will need
to become eligible for one of the economic immigration programs.
The eligible applicants for Express Entry will then have to submit an Expression of Interest (EOI)
application. The applicants will be assessed based on the Comprehensive Ranking System(CRS).
The CRS has been based on the factors and corresponding points which determines the economic
benefit of the applicant in Canada. CRS is based on the 1200 point scale. The applicants are
awarded these points on basis of the following main categories; Core/Human factors including; age,
education, work experience, official language proficiency, Spouse/common–in law factors and the
Skills Transferability factors. Furthermore the applicants with a approved Canadian job offer or
those who are nominated by a province through Provincial Nominee Program ... Show more content
on Helpwriting.net ...
Instead, the province offers Quebec Selected Skilled workers program for the economic
immigration. For qualifying the program, the applicant first must have to receive the certificate of
selection to be accepted by Quebec through point grid system and then if selected, can apply for the
permanent residence to CIC.
The express entry program provides fast paced and efficient system of immigration programs. This
also gives the more consideration to the applicants who will be beneficial to the Canadian

Political Bloc Analysis
In a perfect society, everyone is equal. There is no one who can overpower another or become
suppressed and become subjugated to obey those in power. In this perfect society, people are not
discriminated against, or forced to sell their labour because of the circumstances of their birth. On
the contrary, capitalist societies promote divisions of economic wealth and create segregation
between the bourgeoisies and the proletariats. A society established on the concept of inequality
creates a reaction leading to further discrimination against other races. Everyone is entitled to their
opinion regarding political matters. But when there is a formation of a group based upon shared
political goals, a political bloc is formed. This political bloc ... Show more content on
Helpwriting.net ...
This group consists of the Canadian–born people who desperately seek employment but failed to do
so. Since proletariats do not have the strength to fight against the bourgeoisies and their exploitative
hiring trend, in order to find employment opportunity they revert to fighting a weaker class of
people. They blame immigrants and their cheap labour for filling up all the positions of potential job
opportunity as the cause of their unemployment. In society, especially for the lower class members
of society, it becomes a game of survival. This political bloc advocates for stricter immigration law
by blaming the cause of their unemployment to high number of immigration to Canada. They also
argue that Canadian–born people should receive priority when it comes to employment
opportunities because they are natives to the country. However, the upper class members of Canada
have a more influential role on the government than the proletariats

America 's Foreign Policy And Domestic Policy
America has its fair share of issues on the political agenda. Debates about taxes, gay marriage,
health care, and gun control are all major issues that come up in Congress during almost every
session. There is one issue, however, that has been debated since the early colonial period, before
the United States of America was even a country. The issue of immigration is not only one of the
most heavily debated topics in Congress; it is one of the most complex. It is an issue that affects
both the nation's foreign policy and domestic policy. America is, at its core, a nation of immigrants.
This melting pot of people from around the world is what has caused this nation to be so successful.
Unfortunately, the current immigration system that America has is in need of a complete overhaul. A
comprehensive immigration reform package would be beneficial all across the board. The benefits
to the economy would be immense, especially in times like these with America's struggling
economy. Today there are over eleven million undocumented immigrants in America. While most of
these immigrants have jobs, they are paid "under the table" which keeps them from having to pay
taxes. The employers hiring these illegal immigrants are hurting America's economy rather than
helping it. An immigration reform package that provides a way for these immigrants to earn
legalization will greatly

Skilled Workers In Canada
Research Proposal Assignment: Immigrants Skilled Workers
Step 1: Topic Identification/Social Issues My topic of chosen is to look at how "Employment
Discrimination happen among Immigrants Skilled Workers in Canada using the point–based system.
I have chosen this topic because unemployment rate and poverty is significantly increasing among
immigrants with high education that could not work in their field of major. This also is largely
impacting their well–being in terms of health, especially, depression. This topic is highly important
to me because Canada is a country that comprises of mostly immigrants and there has been a drastic
increase of immigrants coming to Canada through the "Federal Skilled Worker Program (FSWP) or
Express Entrée." ... Show more content on Helpwriting.net ...
This article explains how the Canada multiculturalism act does not seems to clearly reflect its
integration of skilled workers into the system.
It as well explores the impact the skilled–based selection system has on immigrant skilled workers
by increasing the rate of poverty among them, especially, the African and Asian Canadian
communities. In addition, the article emphasizes on the declining of employment affecting the racial
minorities has a relationship with the issue of gang violence, which the governments are not paying
attention to. Why is the Immigration policy that determines the eligibility criteria of the workers
kept changing from time–to–time?
Why are there no proposed jobs in place for the skilled workers upon their arrival into Canada?
Is racial inequality and discrimination as a domestic issue threatens the unity of Canada, despite
multiculturalism?
"To what extent does a 'Canadian Model' for immigration explain the relative success of Canadian
immigration experience?"
"Which features of Canadian policy may be most important in this regard?"
"How many Canadians seek to reinvent their own policies in light of new

Essay On Quebec Immigration
Quebec, being the second–largest Canadian province, has a separate skilled worker visa category for
it. This province is different from the rest of the country as it is the only official French–speaking
province. However, to qualify for this program, applicant(s) has to go through points based
assessment for immigration to Canada.
Quebec offers permanent residency status for workers with desirable skills. Under the Canada–
Quebec Accord, in matters of immigration, Quebec takes a key role in determining which
immigrants settle in the province based on their ability to adapt to living in Quebec.
As the most efficient Canadian immigration consultancy, VMAKE Visas can help you move to
Quebec. If however you do not meet the requirements for this ... Show more content on
Helpwriting.net ...
Employability and Occupational Mobility
Quebec Skilled Worker visas process assesses an applicant's credentials based upon education, work
experience, age, language ability, time spent in Quebec, ties to Quebec and their spouse situation. If
a candidate is successful, the points are translated into the minimum pass mark for employment
section of the Quebec skilled work visa.
3. Work Experience
Work experience is another essential area under the Quebec immigration selection system for visas
for skilled workers. It is worth up to ten points even with a minimum of one point. Work experience
must be from the last ten years prior to applying.
5 years plus = Maximum points
4 years and 6 months
4 years
3 years
2 years
1 year and 6 months
1 year
6 months (minimum requirement) = Minimum point
4.

Illegal Immigration Article Summary
The article, the economics and policy of illegal immigration in Uunited sStates, written by sGordon
H. Hanson published during in December 2009 is very helpful article that enable not only policy
maker to critically analysis critically but it also enables the reader to think critically about benefits
of illegalof illegal immigration. The article was written based on the effect of illegal immigration in
United States. Current immigration policy regimes were blamed for the high level of illegal
immigration in United States by most of the policy maker. Most of points that describe the article
are to argue the above stated statement about the illegal immigration.
Gordon H had positively explained that illegal immigration has been highly beneficial to many
employers, often providing benefits that the ... Show more content on Helpwriting.net ...
There is statement in the article that states that "Despite all the positive effect, illegal immigration
overall impact on united state economy is small. However, they have focused more on the
development of their country and ignored the human rights that each individuals deserves which
often lead to low skilled work with less paid, child labor, human trafficking, forced labor and
women and girls being forced into prostitution.
"Unauthorized immigrates accounts for only 5.4 percent of the civilian labor force" this statement
stated seems to be like negative compliment made by the author about illegal immigration in United
States. The point stated by the author seems supportive in terms of low skilled labor supply, but
there is nothing mentioned about the benefits of immigrants where they are easy victims for
discrimination and exploitation in the work place. All the points mention was from destination
country point of view and from the economic perspective of nation where the loss of productive
labor in the home country is

Immigration Policy : A Permanent Legal Resident
Under the current immigration policy, immigrants struggle to enter the U.S. legally due to the
limitation of becoming a permanent legal resident. One of the most common ways for immigrants to
come to the U.S. is by a temporary work visa. However, in order to continue living and working in
the U.S. after the specified period, immigrants must either apply for permanent residency or
overstay their visa. Due to the nature of the arduous process of obtaining permanent residency,
many immigrants choose to overstay their visa. This leads to the problem of having too many
undocumented immigrants living in the U.S. According to the Immigration Policy Center (IPC)
(2009), there are approximately "11 to 12 million unauthorized immigrants living in ... Show more
content on Helpwriting.net ...
The current immigration policy in the U.S. needs to be reformed by developing a new system that
allows for a more accessible entry for immigrants to enter the U.S. legally in order to maintain a
stable workforce in the agricultural area, to protect the United States' security, and to secure the
loose borderlines. The way in which the immigration policy is formed will create an impact on not
only the citizens of the United States, but also the country itself. As one of the most diverse
countries in the world, it is imperative for the U.S. to obtain and maintain a well organized and
efficient immigration system. The way that the current U.S. immigration system functions,
according to IPC (2009), is that "There are four main ways of immigrating legally and permanently
to the United States. If you don't fit into of these categories, you cannot qualify for permanent legal
status (p. 6). Based on the document published by the IPC (2009), the four ways to immigrating are
family–based immigration, employment–based immigration, humanitarian–based immigration, and
others. Due to the limited options and the loose interpretation of the others section on becoming a
legal permanent legal resident, visa caps are frequently outdated and at least 4 million U.S.–citizen
children have one parent that is an undocumented immigrant. In addition, regardless of the billions
of dollars spent on the system, immigration

American Immigration Entropy : The Land Of Opportunity And...
Cherub Ravoori.
Eng 102– 050.
Daniel Listoe.
Draft 1, 10– x–15 "American Immigration Entropy" Stars and stripes, the land of opportunity and
the nation of immigrants. The United States of America, one of the largest and most influential
countries today, is and always has been a grand attraction to people all over the world. America has
become home to people from all corners on this planet; especially to Europeans seeking wealth and
religious freedom, to several African slaves brought to America against their will from the 17th to
19th centuries; and today to the major immigrant groups in America: Asians and Latin Americans.
My family and I emigrated from Hyderabad, Pakistan to Milwaukee, Wisconsin, United States of
America in 2014. We fortunately managed to receive our Green cards and Social Security after
much toil and expense. It is a big question to me to and several Americans as to why people do not
immigrate to America simply legally as we did and reside in America without worry. More than 12
million people in US aren't fortunate as we were in successfully finding legal permanent residence
(Immigration policy center). America's Immigration System has several problems because of which
several immigrants and the country itself is suffering. The American Immigration System has
several problems and fails to meet the demands of today's globalized society. The fault of the US
government is not just its

Immigration is a highly discussed topic, ranging from how many immigrants should be permitted
into the United States to should we limit the type of jobs immigrants receive? On one side, there are
people who feel that legal status should immediately be granted citizenship based on merit and need
while others believe citizenship is a right. In this paper, I'll be arguing how the government should
allow for those who meet certain requirements to have an easier pathway to achieving citizenship.
Immigration is the movement of people into a place that is not their native country. There are around
20.7 million U.S. citizens and 22.6 million noncitizens. Of the noncitizens, around 13.1 million are
legal permanent residents, 11.1 million are unauthorized immigrants, and 1.7 million hold
temporary visas, which can include a green card or work visas. (Strength in Diversity: The
Economic and Political Power of Immigrants, Latinos, and Asians) Typically the term 'alien' is used
to describe the foreign immigrants and in the Immigration Act of 1921, it was specifically defined to
be "any person not a native–born or naturalized citizen of the United States" (Ebsco Host), but does
not include Native Americans. This law is significant because it was the first in U.S History that a
federal law was instituted to stop the immigration numbers of European countries from entering the
U.S. The United States also deals with Mexicans representing half of unauthorized immigrants, but
the number of

The Problem Of Illegal Immigration
Regardless of what your personal beliefs are on the matter, the topic of illegal immigration has
exploded into the spotlight with the upcoming 2016 election. The best estimate at this point,
although there are no exact figures, states that there are nearly 12 million people living illegally in
the United States. Opinions are as diverse as America's population, ranging from tighter border
security and the criminalization of anyone caught entering the country illegally to opening the
borders and issuing invitations. What people from both sides of the argument can agree on is that
the process of immigration into this country is broken and in dire need of a reboot. This essay will
explore what it means to be an immigrant, the shortcomings of ... Show more content on
Helpwriting.net ...
Besides the process of naturalization, there are two traditional means of citizenship. The most
common is jus sanguinis, Latin for "right of blood". It refers to those who are considered citizens
based on family ties. A child born of two American citizens will likewise be considered an American
citizen, even if the child was born on foreign soil. The other path, jus soli, Latin for "right of soil" is
based on the physical presence in the country at the time of birth. According to Bourke (2014), of
the countries considered by the International Monetary Fund to have advanced economies, only the
United States and Canada offer citizenship based on birth in the country (p.29). Section I of the 14th
Amendment to the Constitution states that any child born in the United States becomes a citizen at
birth. This is known as "birthright citizenship" and has become a topic of much debate in the
ongoing attempts to manage illegal immigration.
Why do people enter the United States illegally? Why not just do it the "right" way? Unfortunately,
as Bourke (2014) explains,
US immigration admission standards are a complex set of preferences, categories, and numerical
limits; these change yearly, making navigating the system difficult. An estimated 4.5 million people
are currently waiting to have their visa applications processed. People from Mexico or the
Philippines may wait nearly 15

The Immigration Of The United States
From the moment of its inception, the United States has always been a nation of immigrants.
Throughout American history, the numerous immigration waves have undeniably defined the
infrastructure of America. By bringing a different set of views and innovative ideas, immigrants
injected the economy and advanced technology through innovative work. However, the United
States has not kept up its immigration policies with the changing times for the past three decades.
Many people are blaming illegal immigration for the loss of "American" jobs and why many
Americans cannot find work today. Many businesses are hardly ever penalized due to the fact that
this Nation lacks a practical method to verify the newly hired workers work eligibility. The ... Show
more content on Helpwriting.net ...
Democrats enacted this immigration bill compromising in different areas in order to attract the vote
of Republican Representatives. This brief will analyze H.R. 15 by revising its content, analyzing the
compromise made between both Democrats and Republicans and exploring the possible
implications an immigration reform could have in the socio–economic status of the United States.
It has been nearly three decades since the last time Congress reformed our immigration system.
From the Reagan era to the Obama administration, the country has undergone financial, social and
political changes yet our immigration policies continue to be the same. Since the implementation of
the last immigration reform in 1986, the United States government has spent nearly $187 billion in
immigration enforcement agencies and programs alone (Meissner, Kerwin, Muzaffar & Bergeron).
The high costs and the increasing public concern has led Americans to recognize the brokenness of
our current immigration system and how it has not kept up with changing times. Research has
shown 71% of Americans say undocumented immigrants should have a pathway to remain in the
country legally (Pew Research Center). Although Congress and the White House have had
numerous failed attempts to pass immigration reform in the past, H.R. 15 proposes an updated
bipartisan system that can further secure the borders and solve problems surrounding immigration
(Border Security, Economic Opportunity and Immigration Modernization

Merit Based Immigration Case Study
The most compelling evidence that an increase in the H–1B visa system will have a positive effect
on the workers in the industry, as well as the economy as a whole, is to look at the effect of past
expansions of the H–1B quota. Judging the effects of the proposed Merit Based immigration
systems is more difficult, as there is no direct comparison since the United States has never
employed such a system. However, other countries such as Canada and Australia employ such
systems, and a careful comparison controlling for other expounding variables demonstrates that the
Merit Based economic system can effectively offer an additional pathway to citizenship while
serving as an economically beneficial force. A study of the expansion of the H–1B visa program in
the 90's found that "a 1 percentage–point rise ... Show more content on Helpwriting.net ...
By introducing a Merit Based immigration system both of these countries dramatically increased
their skills based principal applicants, showing how the policy effectively reduced reliance on
companies for sponsorship. This is also demonstrative of the ability to effectively utilize the skills
and cultural knowledge that the economy wouldn't otherwise have access to, as this number
represents the flow of economic immigrants to the country. Finally, while not a major point of
emphasis in the Canadian and Australian citizens, S. 744 had a significant amount of points allotted
for experience in the United State, thereby giving H–1B visa holders a leg up on their competition
simply by the very nature of their visas. That is because any H–1B visa holder is going to have
experience working in the U.S. that other economic immigrants probably do not have and, as a
result, the inclusion of a preference for American work experience in the Merit Based immigration
system is a de–facto preference for H–1B visa

Reforming American Immigration
President Trump backed a bill on August 2, 2017 which is titled The Reforming American
Immigration for Strong Employment Act, that if passed, would cut legal immigration in half over
the next ten years from one million down to five hundred thousand per year. The bill would also put
emphasis on skill of a potential immigrant rather than their family ties to the United States. I believe
that this bill if passed would help the United States of America by reducing the amount of people
looking for jobs and giving American workers more opportunities.
President Trump and the Grand Old Party, focuses on some key changes to the current policy. The
first point of the bill is to change from letting in one million people, to letting in five hundred ...
This quote shows that the bill is not something that is brand new or doesn't work. I believe that
bringing in skilled and educated citizens to the United States will be good for our country as a
whole. The third and final point that I will be talking about is that the current immigration system is
unfair. It is unfair because of the fact that it shows extreme bias to potential immigrants who have
family ties to America and makes it hard for others who do not have family in America already. In
the same article from The Economist (The Republican Party is turning against legal immigration)
the author quotes a co–sponsor of the bill, New York congressman Emanuel Celler, "Since the
people of Africa and Asia have very few relatives here, comparatively few could immigrate from
those countries." He is saying that if you do not have a family member in the United Sates already
then, the odds are not in your favor.
The Reforming American Immigration for Strong Employment Act has been passed through the
House of Representatives and now is on to the Senate. It has opposition like that in this article from
The Washington Post written by David Nakamura, he quoted Alex Nowrasteh, an immigration
policy analysist and the Cato institute, saying that the bill "would do nothing to boost skilled
immigration and only increase the amounts of employments based green cards...". While he is right
about increasing

Essay On Market Based Immigration
U.S is known to be the most united country in because of its variety of immigration from all over
the world. In recent years, America need more skilled people to support for economic growing. To
respond for this issues, Becker and Lazear suggest a quick solution is " A market – based
immigration," the policy that sell the right to become a U.S citizen.
A way to perform the policy is selling the right up to $50,000 to anyone who want to be U.S citizen.
According to Becker and Lazear, this new method brings a lot of advantages that not only provide
more oppotutinies for people who want to come to a promised land, but also decreased the amount
of illegal immigrants. A loan program is also available for people to borrow and they can pay it back
by the loan payment automatically take out from their income or paycheck. Besides that, there are
many benefits that a market–based immigration can do to help America. First, it attract more skilled
workers who are the positive labors for economy system. For example, an India software engineer
work in Silicon Valley can easily earn ... Show more content on Helpwriting.net ...
However, a market – based immigration may be a positive way for America to solve this problem
because it can immediately respond to the economy worker needs of U.S. May be the proposal of a
market is "radical at the first glance," but the authors also give others solution for avoiding
underground immigrant, a point system that government award to citizens based on skills, family
ties, age, time living in the US. Another concern about the system is the person who has green card
for a number of years is allowed to stay in America. With the people want to stay temporarily, they
will be allowed to pay annual fee and renewable for up to three

Analysis Of The RAISE Act
Nathan Chan Period 6 U.S Gov Honors 10/17/2017 The RAISE Act Policy Overview: In February
2017, a new immigration bill was introduced in the Senate. This bill is known as the Reforming
American Immigration for Strong Employment Act (RAISE Act). The RAISE Act aims to improve
the economy by cutting the number of green cards in half, causing the number of legal immigrants
per year to be halved. In addition to this, it will amend the Immigration and Nationality act in order
to eliminate the idea of diverse immigration. This new bill would cap the number of refugee
admissions at 50,000 per year, remove immigrant welfare, remove family priority (unless for
spouses or minors), and change the employment green card system into a point based ... Show more
content on Helpwriting.net ...
Perdue said. 'It keeps America from being competitive and it does not meet the needs of our
economy today'" (Baker). This quote from the article shows the reasoning behind why some people
support the bill. Baker however provides the other side of the argument when he writes, "But
Senator Lindsey Graham, Republican of South Carolina, noted that agriculture and tourism were his
state's top two industries. 'If this proposal were to become law, it would be devastating to our state's
economy, which relies on this immigrant work force,' he said" (Baker). This represents the
opposition the RAISE Act faces. By using direct quotes to explain the two contrasting sides of the
RAISE Act, the content of this article improves the validity of the source. However, this article is
also limited by its origin and content. The origin of this article is that it comes from the New York
Times. This can be limiting because the New York Times is usually a more liberal source, causing
the information to be slightly biased when connecting President Trump to the RAISE Act. On the
topic of how this bill will affect Trump, Baker writes, "Cutting legal immigration would make it
harder for Mr. Trump to reach the stronger economic growth that he has promised. Bringing in more
workers, especially during a time of low unemployment, increases the size of an economy. Critics
said the plan would

Market-Based Immigration System Analysis
Despite the recession formally ended in June 2009, the American economy had been growing at a
rate of 2%, about one percentage point below its long–term average. The author say that we need
lots of capable people to solve this problem and immigration is the quick way to get such people and
a market–based immigration system can encourage immigration. The market–based system is to sell
the right to become a citizen to immigrants. Today, about 70% of legal immigrants enter through the
relative–based immigration system. Relative system is not bad but workers with skills, who can be
the solution, especially if they have no relative in America, don't like the system. Specifically, there
are several benefits of the market–based system. First, it

Integration Of Immigrants Vs. Australia

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

More from Sara Harris

More from Sara Harris (12)

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (20)

Integration Of Immigrants Vs. Australia