John Holt argues that school is bad for children in three main ways:
1. Children enter school as naturally curious and eager learners but school transforms them into anxious, lazy and dishonest students who dread being wrong.
2. School separates learning from living and places undue psychological pressure on children by positioning teachers as authoritarian figures.
3. The traditional school system exploits children by wasting their time, preventing true learning, and compelling children to think and behave in ways dictated by the school rather than themselves.
Holt recommends improving the system by empowering self-assessment, abolishing grades and compulsory attendance, and helping children learn about the world through direct experience rather than a fixed curriculum.
2. GROUP MEMBERS
RUPESH SHAH (LEADER)
VINEET GOEL (EDITOR)
JASHMINA PRADHANANGA
KRITI MANANDHAR
SRISTI SIDDHI BAJRACHARYA
PRIYA SINGH
3. AUTHOR INTRODUCTION
John Caldwell Holt (1923-1985)
Educational theorist in the USA
Lectured nationally and internationally
Wrote a number of books
Published in the magazine The
Saturday Evening Post(1969)
4. CONTENT
PRE-SCHOOL PERIOD
AT SCHOOL
CRITICISMS
CHANGE IN TRADITIONAL
EDUCATIONAL SYSTEMS
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR
IMPROVEMENT
CONCLUSION
5. PRE-SCHOOL PERIOD
Smarter and more curious
Better at finding and figuring things out
Solved the mystery of language
More confident and resourceful
Persistent and independent
Determined, energetic and skillful
learner
6. AT SCHOOL
“LEARNING AND LIVING”
Learning is separate from living
Psychological pressure
Teacher as god like figure
Hesitate to ask questions
Lazy, dodge, bluff, fake, cheat
Adopt bad habits
Limit creative learning power
7. Escape from reality to daydreams and
fantasies
Restrict interaction with other
To be wrong, uncertain, confused is a
crime
8. CRITICISMS
Exploitation of children
Time wastage
Prevents true learning
Ugly, cold, inhuman
Compels to do, think and be as “they”
want
Right answers are what the school
wants
Prevents interaction
9. CHANGE IN TRADITIONAL
EDUCATIONAL SYSTEMS
In Philadelphia and Portland, Oregon
– Public school without building
– Learn about the world at first hand
In Washington
In New York
– Teachers and Writer Collaborative
– Real writers visit schools
– Practicing attorney
Paired Learning (group work)
10. RECOMMENDATIONS FOR
IMPROVEMENT
Let them judge themselves
Compare performance
Self-assessment
Help them if they ask for
Get rid of grades, exams and marks
Abolish the fixed, required curriculum
Abolish compulsory school attendance