3. The system of justice
The system of justice that we are going
to examine is the prevailing system in
England and Wales, both regions in
the United Kingdom.
There are things that make them
different from the usual justice system
in the U.S.
What makes them different is the
apparent traditional style that they
incorporate in the proceedings related
3
4. Civil cases and Criminal
cases
Civil cases are those concerned with
issues between individuals like:
dispute over land
disagreement about existing
documents
labor problems
marital battles, etc.
4
5. Civil cases and Criminal
cases
Criminal cases are those more serious
cases such as:
theft
murder
arson
kidnapping
rape, etc.
5
6. Two kinds of court
There are two kinds of court existing:
1. Magistrates’ court
2. Higher court (crown court)
Court of Criminal Appeal
House of Lords (the highest court)
6
7. Magistrates’ court
more than 90% of all cases are dealt
with in magistrates’ courts
every town has one
a panel of magistrates passes judgment
(usually three magistrates for each court)
if they decide that someone is guilty of a
crime, they can also impose a
punishment
can be imprisonment for a year or a fine
if it’s first offence and not serious, there
may not be any punishments at all
7
8. the person can be unconditionally
discharged
the next higher step to this is the
conditional discharge
it can be on probation
it can be a fine
it can be community service
8
9. The magistrates
The magistrates are also known as
Justices of the Peace (JPs)
they are not trained lawyers
they are ordinary people with good
reputation
they have been appointed to be JPs
by a local committee
they do not get a salary or a fee for
their work
9
10. The magistrates
they tend to come from the wealthier
sections of society
there are times when their prejudice
is obvious:
they are especially harsh on people
found guilty of poaching (hunting
animals on private lands)
nowadays, magistrates are chosen
from a broad section of society
10
11. Prima facie
Criminal cases can initially be heard in
magistrates’ court just to make sure
that there’s a possibility that the
accused may be guilty of a crime
If there’s a possibility that the accused
may be guilty, it is called a prima facie
case
It will then be brought to a higher court
11
12. Higher court
The higher court would be a crown
court
CROWN COURT:
a professional lawyer acts as a judge
a jury to determine the guilt or
innocence of the accused
JURY
composed of twelve people randomly
selected from a list of voters
12
13. Higher court
juries are not paid and are obliged to
perform this duty
the verdict must have at least 10
votes of either guilty or innocent to be
deemed legal
if less than ten, it is a mistrial and
must be heard all over again with a
new set of juries
13
14. Appeal
a convicted person may appeal to the
Court of Criminal Appeal (Appeal
Court) in London for
1. the verdict to be quashed
2. the sentence to be reduced
14
15. The Judge
the judge’s duty is to be the “referee”
during the trial
it is the judge’s duty to impose
punishment ( “pronouncing sentence”)
15
16. Two kinds of lawyer– Solicitor
and Barrister
Solicitor
they handle most legal matters for
their clients
they draw up documents (wills,
divorce papers, contracts, etc.)
they communicate with other parties
they present their cases in
magistrates’ courts
16
17. Two kinds of lawyer– Solicitor
and Barrister
Barrister
they present the cases in higher
courts
they present the cases not usually
given as a duty for the solicitors (until
1994)
17
18. Training
The two kinds of lawyer have different
trainings:
SOLICITORS:
have to pass the Law Society exam
they study for this exam while
“articled” to established firms of
solicitors where they do everyday
junior works
18
19. Training
BARRISTERS:
have to attend one of the four Inns of
Court in London
attendance requirement:
eat dinner there on a certain number
of evenings each term
sit exams after four years
if they pass, they are “called to the
bar” and are recognized as barristers
19
20. Training
BARRISTERS (cont’d.)
They can only present a case in a
crown court after several years of
association with a senior barrister
(apprenticeship)
20
21. Similarities
both of them don’t need a university
qualification
though they go to university, they do
not necessarily study law there
21
22. Further comparison
Solicitors Barristers
Have to deal with the
realities of the everyday
world
most of the work is done
away from the courts
they become experts in
the details of particular
areas of the law
they tend to come from the
wealthier level of society
they are experts on general
principles of the law, but not
on details
eloquence in public speaking
have to wear a gown and a
wig to emphasize the
impersonal majesty of the law
later retiring age, higher
salary
sometimes criticized for their
outdated judgments and
opinions
22
24. Some commonly used legal
terms
Refer to pp. 65 and 67 for definition:
Acquitted
Bail
Barrister
Brief
Civil action
Convicted
Common law
Committal proceedings
24
25. Some commonly used legal
terms
Defendant
Judge
Jury
Magistrate
On remand
Party
Plaintiff
Precedent
Prosecutor
Solicitor
Trial
verdict
25