SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 15
Download to read offline
Pursuit of Excellence
Staff Selection in North Shore
      School District 112
      Michael Lubelfeld Ed.D.
      Assistant Superintendent
Partnership
Training, Consulting, Research,
            Support
                Since 2005
     Certification in Selection for all
        building administrators
Organizational Missions



        Our Mission
  To nurture every child as an       Ventures for Excellence
           individual;                     Commitment
                                      Professionals educating,
                                 equipping, serving, and supporting
 To empower every child as a
                                  professionals to build significant
         learner;                and sustained impact and legacies.

   To inspire every child to
become a contributing member
      of the community.
From the District 112 Strategic Plan
Selection & Hiring Process
for all employees, (teachers, administrators, frontline
                    support staff)


On-line application (information, essay
responses, on-line computer assessment)
In-person interview with principal (structured
for all teacher candidates)
Team input at building level (unstructured)
In-person interview with district administrator
(structured for all candidates - all categories)
Recommendation to Superintendent
Approval by the Board of Education
Selection Process
Style Profile
 Builder On
    Line

                 Application,
                essay, resume B22 Structured
                    review        Interview
                              Reference Checks      C30
                                            Structured Interview
                                             Reference Checks




                                                                    Right
                                                                   Talent &
                                                                      Fit
Style Profile
                      Builder On
                         Line         Application,
                                     essay, resume
                                         review    B22 Structured
                                                     Interview                 C30
                                                     Reference             Structured
                                                      Checks                Interview
                                                                        Reference Checks




  300 Applicants
                          45 Applicants        15                  6-8                1-3        Right
Respond to posting
                             remain         Applicants          Applicants         Applicants   Talent &
                                             remain              remain             remain
                                                                                                   Fit



                     Screened out     Screened out       Screened out        Screen out 20-
                         85%              30%              40-50%                40%
Themes of Excellence
Predictive Excellence in Life Themes:

           Purpose
  mission, positive nature, etc.

      Relationships
  communication, personable

     Teaching & Learning
    objective, lesson design

        Specialty Areas
     diversity, accountability
How many interviews?
    969 Structured Interviews since 2006

      526 "Form B-22" teacher interviews
      164 "Form C-30" teacher interviews
                 279 Other

[Administrator (71), Frontline Support Staff (156),
       General Screener interviews (52)]
Research

Retention Rates - One "metric" or measurement

Teachers in Year One to Year Two

2005-2006 80% (loss of 1 out of every 5 teachers from
year one to year two)

2008-2009 94% - major improvement in retention after
four years of structured selection process based upon
research, shared committment, training, support, and
predictive themes of excellence
Research
Research
                  Predictive Validity
We conducted a predictive validity study in which we
used job applicants’ scores from the C-30 and
principals’ ratings of their performance two years
after they were selected.

There is a strong significant correlation between
teachers’ C-30 scores and the principals’ ratings of
their performance.

This means that scores from the C-30 interview do
predict future teacher performance, and so it is
useful as a selection tool.
How many selected & hired?
221 Teachers Selected and Hired since 2006 using
         a structured selection process

     111 Teachers Using both Form B and C

 188 Teachers Using the Form B-22 (since 2006)

 144 Teachers Using the Form C-30 (since 2008)
         14 Administrators since 2008

  75 Frontline Support Staff & "other" since 2007
Summary Statements
More than 200 teachers selected using structured
selection process over past four school years (07-
                    08 -09-10)
     Administrative/Leadership professional
         development and shared values

 Consistent practices - selection of excellence

 Four year longitudinal research project - multi-
faceted, selection instruments, observational data,
 correlations, comparisons, relationships, planning

Positive trends in student growth & achievement
Pursuit of Excellence
Staff Selection in North Shore
      School District 112
      Michael Lubelfeld Ed.D.
      Assistant Superintendent

More Related Content

Similar to Pursuit Of Excellence Staff Selection

Bschool criteria-process
Bschool criteria-processBschool criteria-process
Bschool criteria-processakashdrock
 
MM Bagali, Training and Development Project
MM Bagali, Training and Development ProjectMM Bagali, Training and Development Project
MM Bagali, Training and Development Projectdr m m bagali, phd in hr
 
Performance appraisal in Human Resource Management
Performance appraisal in Human Resource ManagementPerformance appraisal in Human Resource Management
Performance appraisal in Human Resource ManagementPreji M P
 
Oss survey 2013 - Human Resources Presentation
Oss survey 2013 - Human Resources PresentationOss survey 2013 - Human Resources Presentation
Oss survey 2013 - Human Resources Presentationcsustudentservices
 
Bagali, MM, HR, HRD, HRM, MBA, Research, India
Bagali, MM, HR, HRD, HRM, MBA, Research, IndiaBagali, MM, HR, HRD, HRM, MBA, Research, India
Bagali, MM, HR, HRD, HRM, MBA, Research, Indiadr m m bagali, phd in hr
 
Pinstripe Presents Quality of Hire Myth or Measurement
Pinstripe Presents Quality of Hire Myth or MeasurementPinstripe Presents Quality of Hire Myth or Measurement
Pinstripe Presents Quality of Hire Myth or MeasurementCielo
 
Employee Assessments: How Employers Are Using Them
Employee Assessments: How Employers Are Using ThemEmployee Assessments: How Employers Are Using Them
Employee Assessments: How Employers Are Using ThemBrandon Hall Group
 
IRJET- Performance Management in Road Construction Project
IRJET-  	  Performance Management in Road Construction ProjectIRJET-  	  Performance Management in Road Construction Project
IRJET- Performance Management in Road Construction ProjectIRJET Journal
 
Marilyn Jesse's Resume
Marilyn Jesse's ResumeMarilyn Jesse's Resume
Marilyn Jesse's ResumeMarilyn Jesse
 
How to Avoid Bad Hires Through Reference Checking
How to Avoid Bad Hires Through Reference CheckingHow to Avoid Bad Hires Through Reference Checking
How to Avoid Bad Hires Through Reference CheckingHuman Capital Media
 
Webinar-Job Architecture: Best Practices for Leading the Market
Webinar-Job Architecture: Best Practices for Leading the MarketWebinar-Job Architecture: Best Practices for Leading the Market
Webinar-Job Architecture: Best Practices for Leading the MarketPayScale, Inc.
 
The Pearls and Perils of For-Profit Education (Deborah Riemer)
The Pearls and Perils of For-Profit Education (Deborah Riemer)The Pearls and Perils of For-Profit Education (Deborah Riemer)
The Pearls and Perils of For-Profit Education (Deborah Riemer)ODLAA
 
"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin Mann
"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin Mann"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin Mann
"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin MannDubai Quality Group
 

Similar to Pursuit Of Excellence Staff Selection (20)

Bschool criteria-process
Bschool criteria-processBschool criteria-process
Bschool criteria-process
 
MM Bagali, Training and Development Project
MM Bagali, Training and Development ProjectMM Bagali, Training and Development Project
MM Bagali, Training and Development Project
 
Performance appraisal in Human Resource Management
Performance appraisal in Human Resource ManagementPerformance appraisal in Human Resource Management
Performance appraisal in Human Resource Management
 
Oss survey 2013 - Human Resources Presentation
Oss survey 2013 - Human Resources PresentationOss survey 2013 - Human Resources Presentation
Oss survey 2013 - Human Resources Presentation
 
Bagali, MM, HR, HRD, HRM, MBA, Research, India
Bagali, MM, HR, HRD, HRM, MBA, Research, IndiaBagali, MM, HR, HRD, HRM, MBA, Research, India
Bagali, MM, HR, HRD, HRM, MBA, Research, India
 
Setzer Group Boston About Us
Setzer Group Boston About UsSetzer Group Boston About Us
Setzer Group Boston About Us
 
Pinstripe Presents Quality of Hire Myth or Measurement
Pinstripe Presents Quality of Hire Myth or MeasurementPinstripe Presents Quality of Hire Myth or Measurement
Pinstripe Presents Quality of Hire Myth or Measurement
 
Employee Assessments: How Employers Are Using Them
Employee Assessments: How Employers Are Using ThemEmployee Assessments: How Employers Are Using Them
Employee Assessments: How Employers Are Using Them
 
360 degree final ppt
360 degree final ppt360 degree final ppt
360 degree final ppt
 
IRJET- Performance Management in Road Construction Project
IRJET-  	  Performance Management in Road Construction ProjectIRJET-  	  Performance Management in Road Construction Project
IRJET- Performance Management in Road Construction Project
 
Marilyn Jesse's Resume
Marilyn Jesse's ResumeMarilyn Jesse's Resume
Marilyn Jesse's Resume
 
360 performance appraisal
360 performance appraisal360 performance appraisal
360 performance appraisal
 
How to Avoid Bad Hires Through Reference Checking
How to Avoid Bad Hires Through Reference CheckingHow to Avoid Bad Hires Through Reference Checking
How to Avoid Bad Hires Through Reference Checking
 
Webinar-Job Architecture: Best Practices for Leading the Market
Webinar-Job Architecture: Best Practices for Leading the MarketWebinar-Job Architecture: Best Practices for Leading the Market
Webinar-Job Architecture: Best Practices for Leading the Market
 
MM Bagali 2012
MM Bagali 2012MM Bagali 2012
MM Bagali 2012
 
The Pearls and Perils of For-Profit Education (Deborah Riemer)
The Pearls and Perils of For-Profit Education (Deborah Riemer)The Pearls and Perils of For-Profit Education (Deborah Riemer)
The Pearls and Perils of For-Profit Education (Deborah Riemer)
 
Assess Tbe
Assess TbeAssess Tbe
Assess Tbe
 
Spring Personnel
Spring PersonnelSpring Personnel
Spring Personnel
 
Spring Personnel
Spring PersonnelSpring Personnel
Spring Personnel
 
"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin Mann
"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin Mann"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin Mann
"Views on 2030" by Dr. Robin Mann
 

Pursuit Of Excellence Staff Selection

  • 1. Pursuit of Excellence Staff Selection in North Shore School District 112 Michael Lubelfeld Ed.D. Assistant Superintendent
  • 2. Partnership Training, Consulting, Research, Support Since 2005 Certification in Selection for all building administrators
  • 3. Organizational Missions Our Mission To nurture every child as an Ventures for Excellence individual; Commitment Professionals educating, equipping, serving, and supporting To empower every child as a professionals to build significant learner; and sustained impact and legacies. To inspire every child to become a contributing member of the community.
  • 4. From the District 112 Strategic Plan
  • 5. Selection & Hiring Process for all employees, (teachers, administrators, frontline support staff) On-line application (information, essay responses, on-line computer assessment) In-person interview with principal (structured for all teacher candidates) Team input at building level (unstructured) In-person interview with district administrator (structured for all candidates - all categories) Recommendation to Superintendent Approval by the Board of Education
  • 6. Selection Process Style Profile Builder On Line Application, essay, resume B22 Structured review Interview Reference Checks C30 Structured Interview Reference Checks Right Talent & Fit
  • 7. Style Profile Builder On Line Application, essay, resume review B22 Structured Interview C30 Reference Structured Checks Interview Reference Checks 300 Applicants 45 Applicants 15 6-8 1-3 Right Respond to posting remain Applicants Applicants Applicants Talent & remain remain remain Fit Screened out Screened out Screened out Screen out 20- 85% 30% 40-50% 40%
  • 8. Themes of Excellence Predictive Excellence in Life Themes: Purpose mission, positive nature, etc. Relationships communication, personable Teaching & Learning objective, lesson design Specialty Areas diversity, accountability
  • 9. How many interviews? 969 Structured Interviews since 2006 526 "Form B-22" teacher interviews 164 "Form C-30" teacher interviews 279 Other [Administrator (71), Frontline Support Staff (156), General Screener interviews (52)]
  • 10. Research Retention Rates - One "metric" or measurement Teachers in Year One to Year Two 2005-2006 80% (loss of 1 out of every 5 teachers from year one to year two) 2008-2009 94% - major improvement in retention after four years of structured selection process based upon research, shared committment, training, support, and predictive themes of excellence
  • 12. Research Predictive Validity We conducted a predictive validity study in which we used job applicants’ scores from the C-30 and principals’ ratings of their performance two years after they were selected. There is a strong significant correlation between teachers’ C-30 scores and the principals’ ratings of their performance. This means that scores from the C-30 interview do predict future teacher performance, and so it is useful as a selection tool.
  • 13. How many selected & hired? 221 Teachers Selected and Hired since 2006 using a structured selection process 111 Teachers Using both Form B and C 188 Teachers Using the Form B-22 (since 2006) 144 Teachers Using the Form C-30 (since 2008) 14 Administrators since 2008 75 Frontline Support Staff & "other" since 2007
  • 14. Summary Statements More than 200 teachers selected using structured selection process over past four school years (07- 08 -09-10) Administrative/Leadership professional development and shared values Consistent practices - selection of excellence Four year longitudinal research project - multi- faceted, selection instruments, observational data, correlations, comparisons, relationships, planning Positive trends in student growth & achievement
  • 15. Pursuit of Excellence Staff Selection in North Shore School District 112 Michael Lubelfeld Ed.D. Assistant Superintendent