1. Aon Limited is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council
Angelos Deftereos
Aon Limited
16th April 2003
Operational Risk and its impact on the Fund &
Investment Management Industry
An Insurance Perspective
2. Aon Limited is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council
Contents
1. What may be the extent of its impact?
2. What is Operational Risk?
3. How can you influence Capital Charge?
4. How may insurance assist?
5. Summary
3. Aon Limited is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council
What may be the extent of it’s impact?
Study of impact on European Asset Managers
Currently 13 week expenditure
Impact - 20% increase for large asset managers
- 60% increase for medium asset
managers
- ?% increase for small asset managers
Source: Bank Reputation and Asset Management Industry:
Professor Colin Meyer 2001
4. Aon Limited is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council
What is Operational Risk?
“The risk of loss resulting from inadequate or failed
internal processes, people and systems or from external
events.”
Source: Basel II Consultative Paper
January 2001
Revised Working Paper
September 2002
5. Aon Limited is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council
What is the Regulatory Timeframe?
Jan 2001 Second Consultative Package
End May 2001 Deadline for Comments
September 2001 Issue of Working Paper on Operational Risk
End October 2001 Deadline for Responses to this paper
4th Quarter 2002 Consultative Paper Three Issued
2003 Publication on the New Accord
2006 Implementation of the New Accord
6. Aon Limited is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council
How can you influence the Capital Charge?
“Intention is to make minimum
capital requirements of Banks
more risk sensitive.”
Basel II Consultative Paper
January 2001
7. Aon Limited is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council
How can you influence the Capital Charge?
Pillar One
Minimum Capital
Requirement
Pillar Two
Supervisory
Review Process
Market Discipline
Pillar One
Minimum Capital
Requirement
Pillar Two
Supervisory
Review Process
Market Discipline
Reduced Capital
Requirement
8. 5 Steps to a Risk Management Framework
Step 1
Identification & Risk Mapping
Setting framework for implementation - Overall Operational Risk
Strategy
Definition of loss
Set-up & implementation of data capturing mechanisms
Assist in mapping losses into agreed risk categories
9. Step 2
Quantification
Application of modelling techniques
Enhance external benchmarking, modelling & forecasting using
Aon’s OpBase database
5 Steps to a Risk Management Framework
11. Step 4
Risk solutions
Internal solutions
captive analysis / risk financing analysis / risk retention
Insurance
Mapping availability of insurance to risks identified
Advise & agree appropriate retention level & limit
Design insurance programme
Provide a range of alternatives in conjunction with
business goals
Capital markets
Hybrids
5 Steps to a Risk Management Framework
12. Step 5
Monitoring & updating
Assist in ensuring operational risk management strategy is
implemented & maintained
Updates on operational risk market developments
5 Steps to a Risk Management Framework
13. Aon Limited is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council
How may insurance assist?
Insurance Road Map
0%
OPERATIONAL RISK PROTECTION
100%
Hedge
BBB
D&O
ECCP
PI
Typical
Non-Financial
Property
AllRisks
General&
OtherLiability
14. Aon Limited is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council
Insurance Road Map
How may insurance assist?
OPERATIONAL RISK PROTECTION
Non-Financial
Property
AllRisks
General&
OtherLiability
BBB
D&O
ECCP
PI
Typical
Organisational
Liability
Non-Financial
Property
AllRisks
General&
OtherLiability
Unauthorised
Trading
BBB
D&O
ECCP
EPL
Advanced
PI
100%
Hedge
0%
15. Aon Limited is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council
Insurance Road Map
How may insurance assist?
0%
OPERATIONAL RISK PROTECTION
Property
AllRisks
General&
OtherLiability
BBB
ECCP
PI
Typical
Organisational
Liability
Non-Financial
Property
AllRisks
General&
Other
Liability
Unauthorised
Trading
BBB
D&O
ECCP
EPL
Advanced
PI
External
Fraud
People
Risks
Technology
Risk
Physical
Assets
All Risks
Relationship
Risk
Leading
Edge
100%
Hedge
D&O
16. Aon Limited is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council
How may insurance assist?
Insurance Road Map
Organisational
Liability
Non-Financial
Property
AllRisks
0%
OPERATIONAL RISK PROTECTION 100%
Hedge
BBB
D&O
ECCP
PI
Typical
BBB
D&O
ECCP
EPL
Advanced
PI
External
Fraud
People
Risks
Technology
Risk
Physical
Assets
All Risks
Relationship
Risk
Leading
Edge
External
Fraud
People
Risks
Technology
Risk
Capital
Physical
Assets
All Risks
Relationship
Risk
Future
Property
AllRisks
General&
OtherLiability
General&
Other
Liability
Unauthorised
Trading
17. Aon Limited is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council
How may insurance assist?
Severity of Loss
Expected
Retained
Severe
Unexpected
Catastrophic
Unexpected
18. Catastrophic
Unexpected
Aon Limited is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council
How may insurance
assist?
Frequency
Severity of Loss
Expected
Retained
Severe
Unexpected
Catastrophic
Unexpected
Insurance
19. Aon Limited is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council
Summary
Fund Management industry will be impacted by
the proposed new capital charges
‘Fat tail’ risks expensive to retain on balance
sheet, risk transfer more economic
Insurance market working to obtain regulatory
relief for its products
Insurance will form a more significant part of
overall operational risk management strategy for
Fund and Investment Management Industry
20. Aon Limited is a member of the General Insurance Standards Council
Angelos Deftereos
Aon Professional Risks
Telephone: 0207 668 9750
email: angelos.deftereos@aon.co.uk