SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 10
Download to read offline
Loop Flow Study Phase II
Joint and Common Market Initiative
Joint Stakeholder Meeting
October 5, 2007
2
Loop Flow Study Phase I – Background and Purpose
Loop flows were increasing in the 2005 to 2006 timeframe
1,000 MW (about 200%) on the TVA-PJM and MECS-PJM
interfaces
500 MW (about 100%) on the NY-PJM interface
600 MW (about 60%) on the Michigan-Ontario interface
On June 28, 2006, the Midwest ISO and PJM included a new Joint and
Common Market (JCM) initiative to investigate loop flows across the
combined Midwest ISO and PJM footprint
Purpose
Increase the understanding of the impact that all entities have on
the creation of loop flows
Provide details on plans and actions to address the reliability
problems associated with loop flows
3
Midwest ISO and PJM Meeting with FERC Staff
Midwest ISO and PJM representatives met with the FERC Staff on September 5,
2007, to present the JCM Loop Flow Study results. Key points from the
presentation are as follows:
Loop flow is a reliability problem, not merely an economic one
Push the industry to require all Balancing Authorities (BAs) provide real-time
generation-to-load impacts along with point-to-point impacts to the IDC on an
hourly basis
Require NERC/NAESB to change the IDC to reduce its sensitivity factor cutoff
below the current 5% threshold to improve the short-term ability for TLR to
manage loop flows
Require other ISOs and RTOs who operate LMP-based markets in the Eastern
Interconnection to implement interregional congestion management protocols
based on the Midwest ISO/PJM process
Require NERC/NAESB to develop a more reliable approach to congestion
management beyond the current practice of curtailing point-to-point transactions
through TLR. The new approach should also provide more economic solutions.
4
Recommendations for Congestion Management Process Enhancements
All entities should calculate and post to the IDC, at least each hour,
all generation-to-load impacts on transmission facilities
The Midwest ISO and PJM currently post this information to the IDC
every 15 minutes
These flows are curtailable via the TLR process
All Midwest ISO and PJM impacts down to 0% are included in this
calculation
The TLR process only considers transmission service impacts across
BA boundaries greater than 5% and no generation-to-load impacts
An interconnection-wide Congestion Management Process should
include real-time calculation and accounting for generation-to-load
impacts by all neighboring entities
Reliability Coordinators need greater transaction tag visibility on a
real-time basis through a more open interregional data exchange
process
BA-to-BA energy tags
Generation-to-Load flows
5
Additional Recommendations
IESO and NYISO should adopt a Congestion
Management Process whereby they report their market
flows to the IDC and participate with Midwest ISO and
PJM to manage circulation flows around Lake Erie when
congestion occurs
An Energy Schedule Tag Database Archive that
contains tag impacts, market flow impacts, and
generation-to-load impacts for all flowgates in the IDC
should be created such that this data is readily available
to all reliability entities
6
Loop Flow Study Phase I – Follow-up
Phase I Study Follow-Up
Have received written comments on the Phase 1 study report
from ITC. Will confirm that IESO, NYISO and TVA do not
intend to submit written comments.
Met with FERC staff on September 5, 2007 to provide them
an overview of the Loop Flow Study Phase I report. Will
contact FERC staff whether they need additional information
beyond what was presented at the September 5, 2007
meeting.
Develop appropriate action items based on
recommendations from the Loop Flow Phase I Study report.
These action items will be tracked and progress will be
reported to the JCM Stakeholders.
7
Loop Flow Study Phase II Proposal Summary
Go to the next level of granularity on the Midwest ISO/PJM
loop flow study.
Analyze flowgates internal to Midwest ISO and PJM
markets as well as flowgates on the border between
Midwest ISO and PJM and between the two RTOs and
outside entities.
Identify flowgates located within the two markets that have
experienced congestion during the last two years.
Analysis will examine data for specific dates and times
when these flowgates experienced high flows and will
identify the contributors to these high flows.
8
Loop Flow Study Phase II Proposal Summary
Flowgates to be considered have a history of:
Significant Transmission Congestion
Significant Market-to-Market flows
High number and/or duration of TLR implementation
Midwest ISO and PJM will perform study in coordination
with other Reliability Coordinators and Transmission
Owners impacted by loop flows
Periodic reports will be made to the JCM Stakeholders
Develop additional mitigation strategies to better manage
loop flows in real-time operations
Develop the ability to predict loop flows based on system
conditions
9
Loop Flow Study Phase II
KEY ACCOMPLISHMENTS
• Developed Loop Flow Study Phase II Scope Document.
• Tag data for IESO, Midwest ISO, NYISO, PJM and TVA was
obtained for Phase I study.
UPCOMING ACTIVITIES
• Review Loop Flow Phase II scope with JCM Stakeholders
• Develop project plan.
• Initiate discussion on receiving updates to the tag data base on
previously executed confidentiality agreements.
ISSUES & CONCERNS
• None at this time.
On Target – No IssuesG
R
Y
Completed
Need to watch – Some Issues
In Jeopardy – Significant Issues
C
Legend
JCM Lead
• Midwest ISO: T. Mallinger
• PJM: S. Williams
Overall StatusG
Develop Project Plan
Milestone Summary
G Define Scope
G
10
Benefits
Enhanced Situational Awareness - Will provide
Reliability Coordinators with real-time information on
the sources of loop flow over a wider area
Enhanced Reliability - Will enable a more reliable
approach to managing transmission congestion than
is possible with the current TLR approach
Enhanced Economics – Will not only ensure a solution
to resolve congestion is always achieved but will also
ensure that the most economical solution is also
achieved

More Related Content

Similar to 20071005 jcm-loop-flow-study-phase-02

Zimmerman.marybeth
Zimmerman.marybethZimmerman.marybeth
Zimmerman.marybeth
NASAPMC
 
E chain optimization at st. microelectronics
E  chain optimization at st. microelectronicsE  chain optimization at st. microelectronics
E chain optimization at st. microelectronics
shwetabakshi
 
Replacement of legacy cis with sap cr&b at phi
Replacement of legacy cis with sap cr&b at phiReplacement of legacy cis with sap cr&b at phi
Replacement of legacy cis with sap cr&b at phi
robgirvan
 

Similar to 20071005 jcm-loop-flow-study-phase-02 (20)

Zimmerman.marybeth
Zimmerman.marybethZimmerman.marybeth
Zimmerman.marybeth
 
E chain optimization at st. microelectronics
E  chain optimization at st. microelectronicsE  chain optimization at st. microelectronics
E chain optimization at st. microelectronics
 
The Insurance Reporting Challenge: Building an Integrated Framework
The Insurance Reporting Challenge: Building an Integrated FrameworkThe Insurance Reporting Challenge: Building an Integrated Framework
The Insurance Reporting Challenge: Building an Integrated Framework
 
Business Continuity Strategy Benchmarking April 8th, 2009
Business Continuity Strategy Benchmarking April 8th, 2009Business Continuity Strategy Benchmarking April 8th, 2009
Business Continuity Strategy Benchmarking April 8th, 2009
 
Overview of Variable Renewable Energy Regulatory Issues
Overview of Variable Renewable Energy Regulatory IssuesOverview of Variable Renewable Energy Regulatory Issues
Overview of Variable Renewable Energy Regulatory Issues
 
Rachhu
RachhuRachhu
Rachhu
 
Rachhu
RachhuRachhu
Rachhu
 
Edison International Business Update - May 2017
Edison International Business Update - May 2017Edison International Business Update - May 2017
Edison International Business Update - May 2017
 
Vancouver roundtable
Vancouver roundtableVancouver roundtable
Vancouver roundtable
 
Vancouver roundtable
Vancouver roundtableVancouver roundtable
Vancouver roundtable
 
Measuring and evaluating port performance and productivity
Measuring and evaluating port performance and productivityMeasuring and evaluating port performance and productivity
Measuring and evaluating port performance and productivity
 
Replacement of legacy cis with sap cr&b at phi
Replacement of legacy cis with sap cr&b at phiReplacement of legacy cis with sap cr&b at phi
Replacement of legacy cis with sap cr&b at phi
 
OSIsoft White Paper "Impacting the Bottom Line" in O&G
OSIsoft White Paper "Impacting the Bottom Line" in O&GOSIsoft White Paper "Impacting the Bottom Line" in O&G
OSIsoft White Paper "Impacting the Bottom Line" in O&G
 
CCXG Forum, September 2023, Karima Oustadi
CCXG Forum, September 2023, Karima OustadiCCXG Forum, September 2023, Karima Oustadi
CCXG Forum, September 2023, Karima Oustadi
 
IFRS - MINING SECTOR
IFRS - MINING SECTORIFRS - MINING SECTOR
IFRS - MINING SECTOR
 
Tgi & cálidda earnings call 1 q 2015
Tgi & cálidda earnings call 1 q 2015Tgi & cálidda earnings call 1 q 2015
Tgi & cálidda earnings call 1 q 2015
 
01397532
0139753201397532
01397532
 
Edison International Business Update - July 2017
Edison International Business Update - July 2017Edison International Business Update - July 2017
Edison International Business Update - July 2017
 
Rijsberman srf action plan 2 nov 2012 punta de este
Rijsberman srf action plan 2 nov 2012 punta de esteRijsberman srf action plan 2 nov 2012 punta de este
Rijsberman srf action plan 2 nov 2012 punta de este
 
Rijsberman srf action plan 2 nov 2012 punta del este
Rijsberman srf action plan 2 nov 2012 punta del esteRijsberman srf action plan 2 nov 2012 punta del este
Rijsberman srf action plan 2 nov 2012 punta del este
 

More from Kevin Forbes

Forbes usaee lecture lehigh university nov 5 2015
Forbes usaee lecture    lehigh university nov 5 2015Forbes usaee lecture    lehigh university nov 5 2015
Forbes usaee lecture lehigh university nov 5 2015
Kevin Forbes
 
Forbes co2 and temperature presentation for earth day at cua april 22 2015 ...
Forbes   co2 and temperature presentation for earth day at cua april 22 2015 ...Forbes   co2 and temperature presentation for earth day at cua april 22 2015 ...
Forbes co2 and temperature presentation for earth day at cua april 22 2015 ...
Kevin Forbes
 

More from Kevin Forbes (6)

Caiso MRTU implementation workshop nov 2008
Caiso   MRTU implementation workshop nov 2008Caiso   MRTU implementation workshop nov 2008
Caiso MRTU implementation workshop nov 2008
 
ELtra 2004 annual report
ELtra 2004 annual report ELtra 2004 annual report
ELtra 2004 annual report
 
Saee presentation august 24 2016 v2
Saee presentation   august 24 2016 v2Saee presentation   august 24 2016 v2
Saee presentation august 24 2016 v2
 
Forbes ams presentation 23 jan 2017
Forbes ams presentation   23 jan 2017Forbes ams presentation   23 jan 2017
Forbes ams presentation 23 jan 2017
 
Forbes usaee lecture lehigh university nov 5 2015
Forbes usaee lecture    lehigh university nov 5 2015Forbes usaee lecture    lehigh university nov 5 2015
Forbes usaee lecture lehigh university nov 5 2015
 
Forbes co2 and temperature presentation for earth day at cua april 22 2015 ...
Forbes   co2 and temperature presentation for earth day at cua april 22 2015 ...Forbes   co2 and temperature presentation for earth day at cua april 22 2015 ...
Forbes co2 and temperature presentation for earth day at cua april 22 2015 ...
 

Recently uploaded

scipt v1.pptxcxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx...
scipt v1.pptxcxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx...scipt v1.pptxcxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx...
scipt v1.pptxcxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx...
HenryBriggs2
 
"Lesotho Leaps Forward: A Chronicle of Transformative Developments"
"Lesotho Leaps Forward: A Chronicle of Transformative Developments""Lesotho Leaps Forward: A Chronicle of Transformative Developments"
"Lesotho Leaps Forward: A Chronicle of Transformative Developments"
mphochane1998
 
Kuwait City MTP kit ((+919101817206)) Buy Abortion Pills Kuwait
Kuwait City MTP kit ((+919101817206)) Buy Abortion Pills KuwaitKuwait City MTP kit ((+919101817206)) Buy Abortion Pills Kuwait
Kuwait City MTP kit ((+919101817206)) Buy Abortion Pills Kuwait
jaanualu31
 
DeepFakes presentation : brief idea of DeepFakes
DeepFakes presentation : brief idea of DeepFakesDeepFakes presentation : brief idea of DeepFakes
DeepFakes presentation : brief idea of DeepFakes
MayuraD1
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Online electricity billing project report..pdf
Online electricity billing project report..pdfOnline electricity billing project report..pdf
Online electricity billing project report..pdf
 
2016EF22_0 solar project report rooftop projects
2016EF22_0 solar project report rooftop projects2016EF22_0 solar project report rooftop projects
2016EF22_0 solar project report rooftop projects
 
Work-Permit-Receiver-in-Saudi-Aramco.pptx
Work-Permit-Receiver-in-Saudi-Aramco.pptxWork-Permit-Receiver-in-Saudi-Aramco.pptx
Work-Permit-Receiver-in-Saudi-Aramco.pptx
 
Online food ordering system project report.pdf
Online food ordering system project report.pdfOnline food ordering system project report.pdf
Online food ordering system project report.pdf
 
scipt v1.pptxcxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx...
scipt v1.pptxcxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx...scipt v1.pptxcxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx...
scipt v1.pptxcxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx...
 
Thermal Engineering-R & A / C - unit - V
Thermal Engineering-R & A / C - unit - VThermal Engineering-R & A / C - unit - V
Thermal Engineering-R & A / C - unit - V
 
Double Revolving field theory-how the rotor develops torque
Double Revolving field theory-how the rotor develops torqueDouble Revolving field theory-how the rotor develops torque
Double Revolving field theory-how the rotor develops torque
 
Employee leave management system project.
Employee leave management system project.Employee leave management system project.
Employee leave management system project.
 
"Lesotho Leaps Forward: A Chronicle of Transformative Developments"
"Lesotho Leaps Forward: A Chronicle of Transformative Developments""Lesotho Leaps Forward: A Chronicle of Transformative Developments"
"Lesotho Leaps Forward: A Chronicle of Transformative Developments"
 
Tamil Call Girls Bhayandar WhatsApp +91-9930687706, Best Service
Tamil Call Girls Bhayandar WhatsApp +91-9930687706, Best ServiceTamil Call Girls Bhayandar WhatsApp +91-9930687706, Best Service
Tamil Call Girls Bhayandar WhatsApp +91-9930687706, Best Service
 
Thermal Engineering Unit - I & II . ppt
Thermal Engineering  Unit - I & II . pptThermal Engineering  Unit - I & II . ppt
Thermal Engineering Unit - I & II . ppt
 
Bhubaneswar🌹Call Girls Bhubaneswar ❤Komal 9777949614 💟 Full Trusted CALL GIRL...
Bhubaneswar🌹Call Girls Bhubaneswar ❤Komal 9777949614 💟 Full Trusted CALL GIRL...Bhubaneswar🌹Call Girls Bhubaneswar ❤Komal 9777949614 💟 Full Trusted CALL GIRL...
Bhubaneswar🌹Call Girls Bhubaneswar ❤Komal 9777949614 💟 Full Trusted CALL GIRL...
 
DC MACHINE-Motoring and generation, Armature circuit equation
DC MACHINE-Motoring and generation, Armature circuit equationDC MACHINE-Motoring and generation, Armature circuit equation
DC MACHINE-Motoring and generation, Armature circuit equation
 
kiln thermal load.pptx kiln tgermal load
kiln thermal load.pptx kiln tgermal loadkiln thermal load.pptx kiln tgermal load
kiln thermal load.pptx kiln tgermal load
 
Bridge Jacking Design Sample Calculation.pptx
Bridge Jacking Design Sample Calculation.pptxBridge Jacking Design Sample Calculation.pptx
Bridge Jacking Design Sample Calculation.pptx
 
COST-EFFETIVE and Energy Efficient BUILDINGS ptx
COST-EFFETIVE  and Energy Efficient BUILDINGS ptxCOST-EFFETIVE  and Energy Efficient BUILDINGS ptx
COST-EFFETIVE and Energy Efficient BUILDINGS ptx
 
Design For Accessibility: Getting it right from the start
Design For Accessibility: Getting it right from the startDesign For Accessibility: Getting it right from the start
Design For Accessibility: Getting it right from the start
 
Kuwait City MTP kit ((+919101817206)) Buy Abortion Pills Kuwait
Kuwait City MTP kit ((+919101817206)) Buy Abortion Pills KuwaitKuwait City MTP kit ((+919101817206)) Buy Abortion Pills Kuwait
Kuwait City MTP kit ((+919101817206)) Buy Abortion Pills Kuwait
 
Unleashing the Power of the SORA AI lastest leap
Unleashing the Power of the SORA AI lastest leapUnleashing the Power of the SORA AI lastest leap
Unleashing the Power of the SORA AI lastest leap
 
DeepFakes presentation : brief idea of DeepFakes
DeepFakes presentation : brief idea of DeepFakesDeepFakes presentation : brief idea of DeepFakes
DeepFakes presentation : brief idea of DeepFakes
 

20071005 jcm-loop-flow-study-phase-02

  • 1. Loop Flow Study Phase II Joint and Common Market Initiative Joint Stakeholder Meeting October 5, 2007
  • 2. 2 Loop Flow Study Phase I – Background and Purpose Loop flows were increasing in the 2005 to 2006 timeframe 1,000 MW (about 200%) on the TVA-PJM and MECS-PJM interfaces 500 MW (about 100%) on the NY-PJM interface 600 MW (about 60%) on the Michigan-Ontario interface On June 28, 2006, the Midwest ISO and PJM included a new Joint and Common Market (JCM) initiative to investigate loop flows across the combined Midwest ISO and PJM footprint Purpose Increase the understanding of the impact that all entities have on the creation of loop flows Provide details on plans and actions to address the reliability problems associated with loop flows
  • 3. 3 Midwest ISO and PJM Meeting with FERC Staff Midwest ISO and PJM representatives met with the FERC Staff on September 5, 2007, to present the JCM Loop Flow Study results. Key points from the presentation are as follows: Loop flow is a reliability problem, not merely an economic one Push the industry to require all Balancing Authorities (BAs) provide real-time generation-to-load impacts along with point-to-point impacts to the IDC on an hourly basis Require NERC/NAESB to change the IDC to reduce its sensitivity factor cutoff below the current 5% threshold to improve the short-term ability for TLR to manage loop flows Require other ISOs and RTOs who operate LMP-based markets in the Eastern Interconnection to implement interregional congestion management protocols based on the Midwest ISO/PJM process Require NERC/NAESB to develop a more reliable approach to congestion management beyond the current practice of curtailing point-to-point transactions through TLR. The new approach should also provide more economic solutions.
  • 4. 4 Recommendations for Congestion Management Process Enhancements All entities should calculate and post to the IDC, at least each hour, all generation-to-load impacts on transmission facilities The Midwest ISO and PJM currently post this information to the IDC every 15 minutes These flows are curtailable via the TLR process All Midwest ISO and PJM impacts down to 0% are included in this calculation The TLR process only considers transmission service impacts across BA boundaries greater than 5% and no generation-to-load impacts An interconnection-wide Congestion Management Process should include real-time calculation and accounting for generation-to-load impacts by all neighboring entities Reliability Coordinators need greater transaction tag visibility on a real-time basis through a more open interregional data exchange process BA-to-BA energy tags Generation-to-Load flows
  • 5. 5 Additional Recommendations IESO and NYISO should adopt a Congestion Management Process whereby they report their market flows to the IDC and participate with Midwest ISO and PJM to manage circulation flows around Lake Erie when congestion occurs An Energy Schedule Tag Database Archive that contains tag impacts, market flow impacts, and generation-to-load impacts for all flowgates in the IDC should be created such that this data is readily available to all reliability entities
  • 6. 6 Loop Flow Study Phase I – Follow-up Phase I Study Follow-Up Have received written comments on the Phase 1 study report from ITC. Will confirm that IESO, NYISO and TVA do not intend to submit written comments. Met with FERC staff on September 5, 2007 to provide them an overview of the Loop Flow Study Phase I report. Will contact FERC staff whether they need additional information beyond what was presented at the September 5, 2007 meeting. Develop appropriate action items based on recommendations from the Loop Flow Phase I Study report. These action items will be tracked and progress will be reported to the JCM Stakeholders.
  • 7. 7 Loop Flow Study Phase II Proposal Summary Go to the next level of granularity on the Midwest ISO/PJM loop flow study. Analyze flowgates internal to Midwest ISO and PJM markets as well as flowgates on the border between Midwest ISO and PJM and between the two RTOs and outside entities. Identify flowgates located within the two markets that have experienced congestion during the last two years. Analysis will examine data for specific dates and times when these flowgates experienced high flows and will identify the contributors to these high flows.
  • 8. 8 Loop Flow Study Phase II Proposal Summary Flowgates to be considered have a history of: Significant Transmission Congestion Significant Market-to-Market flows High number and/or duration of TLR implementation Midwest ISO and PJM will perform study in coordination with other Reliability Coordinators and Transmission Owners impacted by loop flows Periodic reports will be made to the JCM Stakeholders Develop additional mitigation strategies to better manage loop flows in real-time operations Develop the ability to predict loop flows based on system conditions
  • 9. 9 Loop Flow Study Phase II KEY ACCOMPLISHMENTS • Developed Loop Flow Study Phase II Scope Document. • Tag data for IESO, Midwest ISO, NYISO, PJM and TVA was obtained for Phase I study. UPCOMING ACTIVITIES • Review Loop Flow Phase II scope with JCM Stakeholders • Develop project plan. • Initiate discussion on receiving updates to the tag data base on previously executed confidentiality agreements. ISSUES & CONCERNS • None at this time. On Target – No IssuesG R Y Completed Need to watch – Some Issues In Jeopardy – Significant Issues C Legend JCM Lead • Midwest ISO: T. Mallinger • PJM: S. Williams Overall StatusG Develop Project Plan Milestone Summary G Define Scope G
  • 10. 10 Benefits Enhanced Situational Awareness - Will provide Reliability Coordinators with real-time information on the sources of loop flow over a wider area Enhanced Reliability - Will enable a more reliable approach to managing transmission congestion than is possible with the current TLR approach Enhanced Economics – Will not only ensure a solution to resolve congestion is always achieved but will also ensure that the most economical solution is also achieved