SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 9
Download to read offline
Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com
ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71
www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 63|P a g e
Validation of Experimental and Numerical Techniques for Flow
Analysis over an Ahmed Body
Rodrigo Mendes Alves*, Odenir de Almeida**
*(Department of Mechanical Engineering, Universidade Federal de Uberlândia, Brazil)
** (Department of Mechanical Engineering, Universidade Federal de Uberlândia, Brazil)
ABSTRACT
The impact of improvement in vehicle aerodynamics mainly reflects in lower fuel consumption and lower carbon
dioxide emissions into the atmosphere. The governments of many countries support continuous aerodynamics’
improvement programs as a way of mitigating the energy crisis and atmospheric pollution. This work has the
main goal to validate experimental and numerical techniques for application in road vehicles. The experimental
results were obtained through the analysis of the flow around a standard body with simple geometry called
Ahmed Body, using hot wire anemometry from experiments in wind tunnel. It was also proposed a
computational validation using a commercial software (Star CCM +) to further analyze the flow and to
corroborate the experimental results. Both results were compared and allowed characterizing the flow around the
vehicle. The results obtained analyzing the Ahmed Body aimed further application on aerodynamics of heavy-
duty vehicles, which is an ongoing research being developed at the Experimental Aerodynamics Research Center
– CPAERO, in Brazil.
Keywords-Aerodynamics, Ahmed Body, Experimental Techniques, Flow analysis, Road Vehicles
I. INTRODUCTION
The main reason to study the aerodynamics
of road vehicles is reducing the drag with the
objective to reduce the power necessary to motion,
and, by consequence, decreasingthe emission of
pollutants. Fig. 1 shows the relation between power
necessary to overcome aerodynamic drag and rolling
resistance for a 40 tons truck with a Cd (Drag
Coefficient) equal to 0.50. From this figure, it is
visible that over 80 km/h it is critical the increasing
of aerodynamic drag. That is the reason of the efforts
applied to mitigate the drag force in heavy-duty
vehicles industry and via academic researches
around the world.
According to the DOE (Department of
Energy of the United States) annual review of 2012,
the class 8 trucks (vehicles with gross weight rating
exceeding 33000 lb) are responsible for about 13%
of the fuel consumption in the United States. The
reduction of 12% on fuel consumption would lead to
13.2 billion dollars savings per year and reduction of
28 million tons of carbon dioxide emission [1].
Fig.1. Relation between the power necessary to
overcome aerodynamic drag and rolling resistance
for a 40 ton Truck with 0.5 Cd. Source: ICCT
(International Council on Clean Transportation).
Fig. 2 shows the energy losses in an
80000 lbtrucktravelling with a velocity of 105 km/h.
The energy loss caused by aerodynamic is about
53% of the total losses, while the rolling resistance is
responsible by 32% of total. Therefore, the study of
the interaction of the flow with truck’s structure is
very importance to reducing fuel consumption and
increasing energy efficiency.
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Power[kW]
Velocity [km/h]
Rolling resistance
Aerodynamic drag
RESEARCH ARTICLE OPEN ACCESS
Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com
ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71
www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 64|P a g e
Fig. 2.Energy losses in a moving truck, after [2].
In order to get a better understanding of the
flow and its interaction with the truck, it is necessary
to work in two different approaches: experimental
and numerical techniques applied to characterize the
flow dynamics.
One of the most usual and efficient
equipment to develop an experimental aerodynamic
analyses is the wind tunnel. Similar conditions to
real can be simulated in the wind tunnel in different
scales ratio. Since trucks are big structures, the real
condition simulation would require a very big wind
tunnel, high investment and technology. These are
the reasons for working with scale models, such
approach could lead to reasonable results when
compared to real cases flow analyses. This is true
only if a lot of expertise and care is taken during the
experiments.
Historically, the improvement of trucks’
aerodynamics had an important effort in developing
and implementing the air deflector by1950s as seen
in Ref. [3]. Then trucks’ shape has been changed
over the years (small radiator, rounded corners, etc.)
as seen on Ref. [4]. Nowadays, new structures have
been added to trucks for aerodynamics
improvements like skirts, wedges and base flaps; and
good results already obtained from experimental and
numerical analysis [4].
For the numerical approach, it is usual to
work with Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD)
analysis. This tool offers a chance to observe the
flow in limitless conditions in all scales with lower
costs and shorter time compared to the experimental
analyses. There are several commercial software
developed for aerodynamic investigation, which has
demonstrated good results compared to experiments.
For this specific work, STAR CCM+® software was
used based on the reliability of its results already
demonstrated in other researches like the work of
Ref. [5].
Hakansson and Lenngren [5] has developed
interesting analyses for the aerodynamics of trucks
using CFD, testing some trailer devices in order to
understand the influence of those on the flow and
drag force analyses. The results indicate that those
devices lead to lower drag for different yaw angle
and shows that the optimization of the carriage
would be a great deal for the industry of trucks.
The objective of this work is to study the
flowaerodynamic over an Ahmed Body with a
Reynolds number ranging from 0.7 × 105
up to
1.4 7 × 105
,through experimental and numerical
techniques aiming to apply the results on heavy-duty
vehicles’ aerodynamics. In order to achieve such
goal wind tunnel experiments were carried out by
using a hot-wire anemometry system to characterize
flow profiles in the Ahmed body’s wake. The
limitations of using hot-wire anemometry for
performing velocity profiles measurements in the
near-wake of the body were investigated in this
work.
Additionally a numerical approach, by
using the STAR CCM+ code, was validated against
ERCOFTAC(European Research Community on
Flow, Turbulence and Combustion) results [6]. The
numerical technique has been applied to corroborate
the experimental results with the purpose to validate
these tools for later use in the analyses of the flow
around heavy-duty vehicles such as trucks and
buses. With the purpose of validating such
techniques some remarks were registered during the
development of this work.
II. METHODOLOGY
The experimental procedure used in this
work aimed to analyze the flow around the model in
the wind tunnel using hot wire anemometry to
measure velocity profiles in the wake of the body.
The objectives here were to validate the newly
constructed small wind tunnel in the Experimental
Aerodynamics Research Center - CPAERO of the
Federal University of Uberlândia(UFU)and also
toverify the applicability of hot-wire sensors to
generate experimental data, for further comparison
purposes with the numerical model.
The numerical procedure was firstly
validated against experimental results obtained by
ERCOFTAC [6], aimed to offer a better
understanding about the interaction of the flow with
the Ahmed body. For this, the commercial software
STAR CCM + has been used for numerical
simulation of the flow with the same physical
characteristics of the body and conditions of the
experiment.
2.1 Experimental Approach
2.1.1 Wind Tunnel
The wind tunnel of the LEEAR was used for the
experimental part of this work. Some of the
specifications of the tunnel are described in
sequence:
 Maximum flow velocity of 33 m/s in free test-
section;
 Test-section with a cross section of 0.6 × 0.6 m
and 1 meter in length;
Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com
ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71
www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 65|P a g e
 6 meter in length for the whole tunnel;
 Maximum width of 1.90 meter;
 1.90 meter in height;
The Fan has 1.25 m in diameter and about
43,000 m³/h of flow rate. The engine has 24 HP,
220/380V, IP55, 60 Hz, with rotation of 1150 RPM.
The engine’s velocity is controlled by a frequency
inverter of 220/380V in three phase. The wind
tunnel also was equipped with a Pitot tube for
velocity measurement inside the test-section. Fig. 3
shows the test section of the wind tunnel with the
Ahmed body used for the experiment. A complete
set of flow measurements inside the test section and
also flow visualization allowed to well characterize
the flow pattern, as part of the verification of the
flow uniformity in this wind tunnel.
Fig.3 shows the velocity profiles for the
wind tunnel boundary layer development at different
test conditions.According to the results, the
boundary layer thickness is around an average of
4.0 mm in the middle of the test section.The
turbulent intensity of the tunnelis around 0.81% for
the range of velocities investigated in previously
work, being around 0.6% for 7 m/s and reaching a
peak level of 1% at 25.5 m/s.
Fig.3. Images from the test section of the wind
tunnel with the Ahmed body.
Fig. 4. Normalized profiles for boundary layer
development at different flow velocities.
2.1.2 Hot Wire Anemometry
The technique for flow velocity
measurement used in this work was the hot-wire
Anemometry. This technique has been widely used
in aerodynamic researches and constantly optimized
due to the technological development and the need
for a detailed description of turbulent flows. Fig. 5
shows the measurement system used for the
experiment of this work [7].
The probe is located in one of the four sides
of a Wheatstone bridge and an electronic circuit
powers it. According to the operation principle of
the Wheatstone bridge, all sides have the same
electrical tension, since the resistance is the same on
all four sides. Therefore, the electric current passing
through the bridge has the same intensity at the four
points.
Fig. 5.Measurement system used on the experiment.
When the sensor is inserted into the flow,
the heat exchange of the wire heated by the electric
current causes an imbalance in the bridge for the
change in temperature implies changing the
resistance of the sensor side. This electric tension
change can be measured and related to the flow
velocity through the 4th
order polynomial seen in
Fig. 6. The correlation is given by the polynomial U
= -0.000002E4
+ 0.0001E3
+ - 0.0041E2
+ + 0,0764E
+ 1.5827.
Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com
ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71
www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 66|P a g e
Fig. 6.Calibration curve of the hot-wire anemometer.
The typical dimensions of the heated wire
are 5 μm in diameter and 1 to 3 mm in length [8].
The hot-wire used in the experiment is from the
manufacturer DANTEC DYNAMICS, model 55P11
1D[7]. Fig. 7 shows the Hot-wire anemometer on the
back of the Ahmed Body inside the test-section. A
mechanical support was used to place the
anemometer inside the test-section with reasonable
accuracy in location and also avoiding vibration.
Fig. 7.Hot-wire anemometer on the back of Ahmed
Body.
2.1.3 The Ahmed Body
The Ahmed Body is a simplified model of a
vehicle, invented by Ahmed in 1984 [9]. It is widely
used on experiments over the world, which is the
reason it is possible to find many data from different
sources and laboratories. The geometry of the
Ahmed Body is similar to a general car with a flat
front and a slanted back. Detailed dimensions and
geometry used in this work is shown in Fig. 8 and
Fig. 9.
Fig. 8. Dimensions of the physical model used on
the main experiment of this work.
Fig. 9.Physical model for wind tunnel.
Beside the analyses of the velocity field, the
Ahmed Body is also used for drag force and lift
force analyses and rolling, pitching and yawing
moments. The slant angle on the back allows
studying the separation region and its influence on
the velocity profile and forces. In this case we have
selected 30° of slanted angle in the back.
2.2 Numerical Approach
The main reason to use computational
simulation was to compare the results from this
simulation with the experimental results and data
from literature. According to the results of this
comparison, it is possible to check more reliability
for the results from the numerical technique. The
main parameters analyzed are the velocity field, lift
coefficient and drag coefficient of the body. The
STAR CCM+ software was used for simulation.
The dimensions of the computational domain are
31L x 10L x 7.5L where L is the length of the body,
as seen in Fig. 10.
Fig. 10. Computational domain used in
computational simulation.
The simulation was performed in steady
state regime with 5000 iterations reaching a residual
level of order 1 × 10-4
. The turbulence model was
RANS k-ω SST (Shear Stress Transport). This
turbulence model was used since the flow is
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8
1.9
2.0
2.1
2.2
2.3
2.4
2.5
E[volts]
U [m/s]
Calibration curve
Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com
ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71
www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 67|P a g e
considered to be completely detached on the back of
the Ahmed body followed by a turbulent flow with
regions of recirculation behind the body.
In order to get a better simulation, the
domain was divided into ground, inlet, outlet, roof,
side wall and plane of symmetry. The boundary
conditions applied to the simulations were:
 Inlet: uniform velocity
 Outlet: Atmospheric pressure
 Roof: stationary wall
 Ground: stationary wall
 Side wall: stationary wall
 Plane of symmetry: symmetry
 Ahmed Body: stationary wall
It was used tetrahedral mesh and prismatic
layer for the boundary layer region. The total
amount of cells was about 2.3 millions. The mesh
was refined on critical regions like regions close to
the body and behind the body (wake flow region).
The mesh conditions were chosen based on
satisfactory results of Souza [10]. The computational
mesh is seen in Fig. 11.
Fig. 11.Computational domain. Detail of the mesh in
the body and plane of symmetry.
III. VALIDATION OF THE
NUMERICAL APPROACH
In order to validate the numerical approach
using STAR CCM+ software, it was compared the
experimental data from ERCOFTAC available
online with the results of the computational
simulation. For this work, the “Case 9.4 – Flow
around a simplified car (Ahmed Body)” [6] was used
for comparison.
This case has been simulated using the
same conditions as the Case 9.4 from ERCOFTAC
and the same dimensions of the Ahmed Body (Fig.
12). The parameters used are slant angle of 25°,
kinematic viscosity of 1.5 x10−5
m2
/s and flow
velocity of 40 m/s. The computational domain was
described on section 2.2. The results from STAR
CCM+ showing velocity contours and streamlines
can be seen on Fig.13.
Fig. 12. Dimension of the Ahmed Body [6]
Fig. 13. Velocity contours and streamlines.
The data from the streamwise velocity was
collected in four different positions: 38 mm, 88 mm,
138 mm and 188 mm from the back of the Ahmed
Body (the origin reference is the rear end of the
Ahmed body). Fig.14and Fig. 15 show the pattern of
the u-velocity component on the symmetry plane.
Both profiles in Fig. 14 and Fig. 15
presented the lowestvelocitiesalong 50 mm and
250 mm in height in all positions, which probably
were occasioned by the recirculation region (low
pressure region) behind the body. As the radial
position is moved downstream in the wake, it is
possible to observe a reduction in this velocity
profile inflexion. Outside this region of lower
velocities it is possible to see some small
discrepancies between the ERCOFTAC data and our
current simulations. However, it can be seen a
satisfactory similarity of the profiles with reasonable
identification of the flow actual flow structures,
which gives reliability for using the computational
approach selected in this work.
Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com
ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71
www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 68|P a g e
Fig. 14.Velocity profiles for validation of the
numerical technique – 38 and 88mm.
It is important to comment that the
numerical modeling was performed by using a
RANS approach with turbulence modeling to
characterize a flow pattern that is naturally transient
in actual condition with large regions of flow
detachments and recirculating flows in the wake of
the body. As a mean flow-prediction’s method this
numerical model is showing reasonable results
allowing the use of this approach for doing design
selections, at least, for industrial applications with a
low cost when compared to other numerical
techniques such as LES (Large Eddy Simulation)
and DNS (Direct Numerical Simulation).
Fig. 15. Velocity profiles for validation of the
numerical technique – 138 and 188mm.
IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
After the validation of the numerical
approach used in this work, the next step was to
generate new computational simulations for the
experiments with the Ahmed body,carried out in
thewindtunnel at CPAERO as explained in the
Methodology.
The main differences between the Ahmed
bodies used for validation and the physical model in
our experiment were the slant angle
(inourexperimentthe angle was 30° degrees), the
dimensions of the body (Fig. 8) and the velocity
range. For the physical model in our experiments we
planned to work with most critical scenario for
further turbulence analyses on Ahmed Body where
separation flow occurs, that is for a 30º slant angle
based on literature [9]. Based on the dimension of
the test section of the wind tunnel, we calculated the
best dimension for the Ahmed Body for a reasonable
blocking ratio (3.84% in this case).
After obtained the resultsfrom the
validation for computational data, the next step was
comparing experimental data with computational
data, aiming a better comprehension of the flow
around the body and also identifying potential
limitations from each technique employed. Then it
was manufactured a physical Ahmed body (Fig. 9)
with dimension shown in Fig. 8 for the experiment
in wind tunnel.
The experiment in the wind tunnel was set
for three different velocities: 10m/s (Re = 0.7 × 105
);
15m/s (Re = 1.05 × 105
) e 20m/s (Re = 1.4 × 105
).
Computational simulations were performed in STAR
CCM + looking for the same geometric and physical
conditions of the experimental approach and same
conditions as showed on section 2.2.
Three positions were set for the velocity
measurement and profiles comparison in all three
cases. The first position (P1) was located 160 mm
from the front of the body, the second position (P2)
was located 48 mm from the end of the body, and
-10 0 10 20 30 40 50
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
z-height(mm)
U-Velocity (m/s)
Velocity-profile (38mm)
Ercoftac data
Present work
-20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
z-height(mm)
U-Velocity (m/s)
Velocity-profile (88mm)
Ercoftac data
Present work
-20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
z-height(mm)
U-Velocity (m/s)
Velocity-profile (138mm)
Ercoftac data
Present work
-20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
z-height(mm)
U-Velocity (m/s)
Velocity-profile (188mm)
Ercoftac data
Present work
Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com
ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71
www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 69|P a g e
the third position (P3) was located 97 mm from the
end of the Ahmed body (49 mm from the second
position), as seen in Fig. 16. The maximum height
measured in the experiment was 160 mm. As
mentioned, a mechanical support was used to place
the hot-wire probe inside the flow in the indicated
positions.
In the next subsections the u-velocity
profiles will be shown, including the comparison
with the CFD simulations performed for each
specific position P1, P2 and P3.
Fig. 16. Positions for the velocities profiles: wind
tunnel experiment and computational simulation.
2.3 Velocity Profile Comparison in P1
The comparison between experimental and
simulation data for the position P1 is shown in Fig.
17. The position P1 was in front of the body, where
the flow is completed well established. The first
boundary layer measured point in the experiment
was about 1.5 mm, increasing up to 160 mm. The
velocities profiles were normalized independently by
dividing the measured velocity (u-velocity) by the
maximum velocity (Umax) measured along the
vertical experimental line. This allowed verifying
the similarity in the velocity profiles in both
experimental and numerical data.
Fig. 17.Velocity Profile for position P1.
It is notable the similarity on both data at
P1 for different velocities. The position in front of
the body have almost none influence of the body, so
it is expected a constant velocity as seen in Fig. 17.
The region where there is no match between data
was on the boundary layer region.
One of the main reasons for the non-
coincidence of data would be the in fact that, in the
computational model, there was an imposition of a
uniform velocity profile as a boundary condition.
This boundary condition imposition associated with
the wall-function modeling led to a development of
the boundary layer which is closely different in the
first measured positions close to the wall. On
coming flow simulations have been performed to
evaluate the influence of the boundary conditions in
the final simulations, taking into account the actual
boundary layer profile.
2.4 Velocity Profile Comparison in P2
The comparison between experimental and
simulation data for the position P2 is shown in Fig.
18 for the three velocities investigated.
In all cases, the effect of the recirculation
region (also called recirculation bubble) behind the
body is seen, creating an inflection in the velocity
profiles at intermediate positions
measured.Consequently, it is seen a velocity drop in
this region (with negative velocities calculated,
indicating the recirculating flow). However, as can
be seen, the result from the computational simulation
has this inflection much more pronounced than the
experimental results with values much smaller than
those collected by the sensor.
Thecause of this discrepancy was due to the
fact that the sensor (hot-wire) was not able to
measure negative velocities. In fact, this result can
be associated to the limitations of the measuring
technique, once values outside the calibration region
(including negative velocities) are not correctly
acquired. Also, according to the numerical results,
seen further, the points P2 and P3are well inside
where the recirculation bubble was located.
0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
Height(mm)
U-velocity / Umax
P1_10m/s:
Numerical
Experimental
0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
P1_15 m/s:
Numerical
Experimental
Height(mm)
U-velocity / Umax
0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
P1_20 m/s:
Numerical
Experimental
Height(mm)
U-velocity / Umax
Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com
ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71
www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 70|P a g e
The hot-wire technique is not a proper approach for
measuring inside recirculating flows and should be
used for well-established flow regions.
Fig. 18.Velocity Profile for position P2.
2.5 Velocity Profile Comparison in P3
In the position P3, one can observe the
complete qualitative and quantitative disparity in the
recirculation region in both cases. Although the
values in the free flow region are very close in both
cases, the profiles have opposite trend in the other
regions, as seen in Fig. 19, for the reasons already
explained.
Fig. 19.Velocity Profile for position P3.
While the velocity profiles from the CFD
simulation indicated negative velocity values in the
recirculation region, the velocity values of the
experiment shows a profile trend as it was located
outside the recirculation with smother curves. This
analysis leads to the possibility of the recirculation
bubble in the simulation being larger than the bubble
generated in the experiment.According to the flow
analysis performed through visualization tools by
using the software STAR CCM+, one could estimate
the size of the recirculation bubble for the three
cases investigated. Table 1 illustrates the
recirculation region sizing behind the Ahmed body
obtained numerically. Fig.20 presents the flow field
in the back of the Ahmed body, visualized by vector
plots, for 15 m/s.
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
P2_10 m/s:
Numerical
Experimental
Height(mm)
U-velocity / Umax
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
P2_15 m/s:
Numerical
Experimental
Height(mm)
U-velocity / Umax
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
P2_20 m/s:
Numerical
Experimental
Height(mm)
U-velocity / Umax
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
P3_10 m/s:
Numerical
Experimental
Height(mm)
U-velocity / Umax
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
P3_15 m/s:
Numerical
Experimental
Height(mm)
U-velocity / Umax
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
P3_20 m/s:
Numerical
Experimental
Height(mm)
U-velocity / Umax
Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com
ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71
www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 71|P a g e
Table 1.Recirculation region – Numerical results.
Recirculation bubble
10 m/s 15 m/s 20 m/s
0.150 0.140 0.135
Fig. 20.Vector plot of the flow behind the Ahmed
body.
Since there was no information about the
size of the recirculation bubble before the
experiment, the velocity acquisition points were
chosen in the tunnel 48 mm and 97 mm from the
rear of the body. As commented, for a massive
recirculation of the flow, using the anemometer as a
measurement technique is not indicated. Therefore,
the experimental profiles should be taken in
positions fartherawayfrom the back of the body. As
an ongoing research, new velocity profiles will be
undertaken and a deeper analysis will be performed.
Finally, by analyzing the computational
result for drag coefficients evaluated by Equation 1,
it can be seen from the Table 2 that the drag
coefficient drops as the velocity increases. The
values presented in Table 2are very close to those
ones listed in literature.
Table 1. Drag coefficient – Numerical results.
Drag Coefficient (Cd)
10 m/s 15 m/s 20 m/s
0.3042 0.2943 0.2886
Table 1
𝐶 𝐷=
𝐷
1
2
𝜌𝑉²𝐴
(1)
V. CONCLUSION
The results obtained from experiments
using the Ahmed body allowed some understanding
about how the flow behaves around such geometry.
The techniques employed in this work could also be
used further to study aerodynamics of heavy-trucks.
Mainly through the work of Hakansson and
Lenngren [5], it can be seen current and future
applications in the improvement of the aerodynamics
of trucks.
The Ahmed body’s computational
simulation results in this work were validated by the
experimental results from ERCOFTAC [6]. Despite
this, the comparison of the computational results
with the experimental results obtained in the wind
tunnel in this work contains some inconsistencies,
especially for the recirculation region behind the
body.
One source of errors identified was the
location of the body's recirculation bubble. By
analyzing velocity profiles behind the body, the
velocity values captured in the simulation are much
smaller than those captured in the experiment
confirming the presence of a recirculation bubble
just behind the body. Next experiments efforts could
confirm this, including a sizing for this recirculating
region behind the body.
As these results are part of an ongoing
study, for future work it is proposed a study of
velocity profiles in the slanted region of Ahmed
body, and study of velocity profiles in the post-
recirculation region of Ahmed body. It is also
proposed visualization with "tufts" and "China Clay"
(aiming a better understanding of the flow around
the body in the wind tunnel) and study of mesh
refinement, aiming a better accuracy in numerical
results.
REFERENCES
[1] Cooper K. R.,Commercial Vehicle Aerodynamic
Drag Reduction: Historical Perspective as a Guide,
National Research Council of Canada, 2004.
[2] J. Woodroofee, Reducing Truck Fuel use and
Emissions: Tires, Aerodynamics, Engine Efficiency,
and Size and Weight Regulations,Report No.
UMTRI-2014-27, Universityof Michigan, 2014.
[3] K. R.Cooper.,Commercial Vehicle Aerodynamic
Drag Reduction: Historical Perspective as a
Guide,National Research Council of Canada, 2004.
[4] F. Browand, Reducing Aerodynamic Drag and Fuel
Consumption,Global Climate and Energy Project,
Workshop on Advance Transportation, 2005.
[5] C. Hakansson, M. J. Lenngren, CDF Analysis of
Aerodynamic Trailer Devices for Drag Reduction of
Heavy Duty Trucks,Chalmers University of
Technology, 2010.
[6] B. Basara, CASE 9.4 - Flow around a simplified car
body (Ahmed body), 2001,Available in
http://www.ercoftac.org/fileadmin/user_upload/bigfi
les/sig15/database/9.4. Access on August 2016.
[7] MiniCTA Anemometer Package, How to get started
- a quick Guide. Dantec Dynamics A/S, 2004.
[8] Hot-wire measurements, Lecture notes.
Experimental Aerodynamics Class, Middle East
Technical University.
[9] S. R. Ahmed, Some salient features of the Time
Average Ground Vehicle, SAE-Paper 840300, 1984.
[10] P. R. C. Souza, Numerical and Experimental
Analysis of subsonic jets, Undergraduation thesis,
Federal University of Uberlândia, Uberlândia, 2012.

More Related Content

What's hot

Background Concentrations and the Need for a New System to Update AERMOD
Background Concentrations and the Need for a New System to Update AERMODBackground Concentrations and the Need for a New System to Update AERMOD
Background Concentrations and the Need for a New System to Update AERMODSergio A. Guerra
 
Pairing aermod concentrations with the 50th percentile monitored value
Pairing aermod concentrations with the 50th percentile monitored valuePairing aermod concentrations with the 50th percentile monitored value
Pairing aermod concentrations with the 50th percentile monitored valueSergio A. Guerra
 
DMUG 2016 - Scott Hamilton, Ricardo Energy & Environment
DMUG 2016 - Scott Hamilton, Ricardo Energy & EnvironmentDMUG 2016 - Scott Hamilton, Ricardo Energy & Environment
DMUG 2016 - Scott Hamilton, Ricardo Energy & EnvironmentIES / IAQM
 
PRIME2_consequence_analysis_and _model_evaluation
PRIME2_consequence_analysis_and _model_evaluationPRIME2_consequence_analysis_and _model_evaluation
PRIME2_consequence_analysis_and _model_evaluationSergio A. Guerra
 
Impact of the Hydrographic Changing in the Open Drains Cross Sections on the ...
Impact of the Hydrographic Changing in the Open Drains Cross Sections on the ...Impact of the Hydrographic Changing in the Open Drains Cross Sections on the ...
Impact of the Hydrographic Changing in the Open Drains Cross Sections on the ...IJMER
 
AIR DISPERSION MODELING HIGHLIGHTS FROM 2012 ACE
AIR DISPERSION MODELING HIGHLIGHTS FROM 2012 ACEAIR DISPERSION MODELING HIGHLIGHTS FROM 2012 ACE
AIR DISPERSION MODELING HIGHLIGHTS FROM 2012 ACESergio A. Guerra
 
EVALUATION OF SO2 AND NOX OFFSET RATIOS TO ACCOUNT FOR SECONDARY PM2.5 FORMATION
EVALUATION OF SO2 AND NOX OFFSET RATIOS TO ACCOUNT FOR SECONDARY PM2.5 FORMATIONEVALUATION OF SO2 AND NOX OFFSET RATIOS TO ACCOUNT FOR SECONDARY PM2.5 FORMATION
EVALUATION OF SO2 AND NOX OFFSET RATIOS TO ACCOUNT FOR SECONDARY PM2.5 FORMATIONSergio A. Guerra
 
INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...
INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...
INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...Sergio A. Guerra
 
Using Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMOD at a Food Process...
Using Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMOD at a Food Process...Using Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMOD at a Food Process...
Using Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMOD at a Food Process...Sergio A. Guerra
 
Solution to AERMOD/PRIME PM10 Overpredictions for Extremely Short, Long and W...
Solution to AERMOD/PRIME PM10 Overpredictions for Extremely Short, Long and W...Solution to AERMOD/PRIME PM10 Overpredictions for Extremely Short, Long and W...
Solution to AERMOD/PRIME PM10 Overpredictions for Extremely Short, Long and W...Sergio A. Guerra
 
INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...
INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...
INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...Sergio A. Guerra
 
Complying with EPA's Guidance for SO2 Designations
Complying with EPA's Guidance for SO2 DesignationsComplying with EPA's Guidance for SO2 Designations
Complying with EPA's Guidance for SO2 DesignationsSergio A. Guerra
 
Evaluating AERMOD and Wind Tunnel Derived Equivalent Building Dimensions
Evaluating AERMOD and Wind Tunnel Derived Equivalent Building DimensionsEvaluating AERMOD and Wind Tunnel Derived Equivalent Building Dimensions
Evaluating AERMOD and Wind Tunnel Derived Equivalent Building DimensionsSergio A. Guerra
 
Using Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMOD
Using Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMODUsing Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMOD
Using Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMODSergio A. Guerra
 
Probabilistic & Source Characterization Techniques in AERMOD Compliance
Probabilistic & Source Characterization Techniques in AERMOD ComplianceProbabilistic & Source Characterization Techniques in AERMOD Compliance
Probabilistic & Source Characterization Techniques in AERMOD ComplianceSergio A. Guerra
 
Investigation of particulate control in thermal power plant using
Investigation of particulate control in thermal power plant usingInvestigation of particulate control in thermal power plant using
Investigation of particulate control in thermal power plant usingIAEME Publication
 
Using Physical Modeling to Evaluate Re-entrainment of Stack Emissions
Using Physical Modeling to Evaluate Re-entrainment of Stack EmissionsUsing Physical Modeling to Evaluate Re-entrainment of Stack Emissions
Using Physical Modeling to Evaluate Re-entrainment of Stack EmissionsSergio A. Guerra
 
Air Dispersion Modeling Facts Sheet
Air Dispersion Modeling Facts SheetAir Dispersion Modeling Facts Sheet
Air Dispersion Modeling Facts SheetPatrick Ryan, Ph.D.
 

What's hot (20)

Background Concentrations and the Need for a New System to Update AERMOD
Background Concentrations and the Need for a New System to Update AERMODBackground Concentrations and the Need for a New System to Update AERMOD
Background Concentrations and the Need for a New System to Update AERMOD
 
Pairing aermod concentrations with the 50th percentile monitored value
Pairing aermod concentrations with the 50th percentile monitored valuePairing aermod concentrations with the 50th percentile monitored value
Pairing aermod concentrations with the 50th percentile monitored value
 
DMUG 2016 - Scott Hamilton, Ricardo Energy & Environment
DMUG 2016 - Scott Hamilton, Ricardo Energy & EnvironmentDMUG 2016 - Scott Hamilton, Ricardo Energy & Environment
DMUG 2016 - Scott Hamilton, Ricardo Energy & Environment
 
PRIME2_consequence_analysis_and _model_evaluation
PRIME2_consequence_analysis_and _model_evaluationPRIME2_consequence_analysis_and _model_evaluation
PRIME2_consequence_analysis_and _model_evaluation
 
Impact of the Hydrographic Changing in the Open Drains Cross Sections on the ...
Impact of the Hydrographic Changing in the Open Drains Cross Sections on the ...Impact of the Hydrographic Changing in the Open Drains Cross Sections on the ...
Impact of the Hydrographic Changing in the Open Drains Cross Sections on the ...
 
AIR DISPERSION MODELING HIGHLIGHTS FROM 2012 ACE
AIR DISPERSION MODELING HIGHLIGHTS FROM 2012 ACEAIR DISPERSION MODELING HIGHLIGHTS FROM 2012 ACE
AIR DISPERSION MODELING HIGHLIGHTS FROM 2012 ACE
 
PRIME2 Model Evaluation
PRIME2 Model EvaluationPRIME2 Model Evaluation
PRIME2 Model Evaluation
 
EVALUATION OF SO2 AND NOX OFFSET RATIOS TO ACCOUNT FOR SECONDARY PM2.5 FORMATION
EVALUATION OF SO2 AND NOX OFFSET RATIOS TO ACCOUNT FOR SECONDARY PM2.5 FORMATIONEVALUATION OF SO2 AND NOX OFFSET RATIOS TO ACCOUNT FOR SECONDARY PM2.5 FORMATION
EVALUATION OF SO2 AND NOX OFFSET RATIOS TO ACCOUNT FOR SECONDARY PM2.5 FORMATION
 
INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...
INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...
INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...
 
Using Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMOD at a Food Process...
Using Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMOD at a Food Process...Using Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMOD at a Food Process...
Using Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMOD at a Food Process...
 
Solution to AERMOD/PRIME PM10 Overpredictions for Extremely Short, Long and W...
Solution to AERMOD/PRIME PM10 Overpredictions for Extremely Short, Long and W...Solution to AERMOD/PRIME PM10 Overpredictions for Extremely Short, Long and W...
Solution to AERMOD/PRIME PM10 Overpredictions for Extremely Short, Long and W...
 
INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...
INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...
INNOVATIVE DISPERSION MODELING PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE A REASONABLE LEVEL OF CON...
 
Complying with EPA's Guidance for SO2 Designations
Complying with EPA's Guidance for SO2 DesignationsComplying with EPA's Guidance for SO2 Designations
Complying with EPA's Guidance for SO2 Designations
 
Evaluating AERMOD and Wind Tunnel Derived Equivalent Building Dimensions
Evaluating AERMOD and Wind Tunnel Derived Equivalent Building DimensionsEvaluating AERMOD and Wind Tunnel Derived Equivalent Building Dimensions
Evaluating AERMOD and Wind Tunnel Derived Equivalent Building Dimensions
 
Using Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMOD
Using Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMODUsing Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMOD
Using Physical Modeling to Refine Downwash Inputs to AERMOD
 
Projects Portfolio
Projects PortfolioProjects Portfolio
Projects Portfolio
 
Probabilistic & Source Characterization Techniques in AERMOD Compliance
Probabilistic & Source Characterization Techniques in AERMOD ComplianceProbabilistic & Source Characterization Techniques in AERMOD Compliance
Probabilistic & Source Characterization Techniques in AERMOD Compliance
 
Investigation of particulate control in thermal power plant using
Investigation of particulate control in thermal power plant usingInvestigation of particulate control in thermal power plant using
Investigation of particulate control in thermal power plant using
 
Using Physical Modeling to Evaluate Re-entrainment of Stack Emissions
Using Physical Modeling to Evaluate Re-entrainment of Stack EmissionsUsing Physical Modeling to Evaluate Re-entrainment of Stack Emissions
Using Physical Modeling to Evaluate Re-entrainment of Stack Emissions
 
Air Dispersion Modeling Facts Sheet
Air Dispersion Modeling Facts SheetAir Dispersion Modeling Facts Sheet
Air Dispersion Modeling Facts Sheet
 

Similar to Validation of Experimental and Numerical Techniques for Flow Analysis over an Ahmed Body

Aero-acoustic investigation over a 3-dimensional open sunroof using CFD
Aero-acoustic investigation over a 3-dimensional open sunroof using CFDAero-acoustic investigation over a 3-dimensional open sunroof using CFD
Aero-acoustic investigation over a 3-dimensional open sunroof using CFDIRJET Journal
 
Cdd mahesh dasar ijertv2 is120775
Cdd mahesh dasar ijertv2 is120775Cdd mahesh dasar ijertv2 is120775
Cdd mahesh dasar ijertv2 is120775Mahesh Dasar
 
Simulations Of Unsteady Flow Around A Generic Pickup Truck Using Reynolds Ave...
Simulations Of Unsteady Flow Around A Generic Pickup Truck Using Reynolds Ave...Simulations Of Unsteady Flow Around A Generic Pickup Truck Using Reynolds Ave...
Simulations Of Unsteady Flow Around A Generic Pickup Truck Using Reynolds Ave...Abhishek Jain
 
Strategies for aerodynamic development
Strategies for aerodynamic developmentStrategies for aerodynamic development
Strategies for aerodynamic developmentVamsi Kovalam
 
Soot Formation in Diesel Engines By Using Cfd
Soot Formation in Diesel Engines By Using CfdSoot Formation in Diesel Engines By Using Cfd
Soot Formation in Diesel Engines By Using CfdIJERA Editor
 
CFD modelling calculation and simulation of bus
CFD modelling calculation and simulation of busCFD modelling calculation and simulation of bus
CFD modelling calculation and simulation of busIRJET Journal
 
Comparison of CFD Simulation of a Hyundai I20 Model with Four Different Turbu...
Comparison of CFD Simulation of a Hyundai I20 Model with Four Different Turbu...Comparison of CFD Simulation of a Hyundai I20 Model with Four Different Turbu...
Comparison of CFD Simulation of a Hyundai I20 Model with Four Different Turbu...IJERA Editor
 
CFD analysis of commercial vehicle
CFD analysis of commercial vehicleCFD analysis of commercial vehicle
CFD analysis of commercial vehicleShih Cheng Tung
 
Aerodynamic Drag Reduction for A Generic Sport Utility Vehicle Using Rear Suc...
Aerodynamic Drag Reduction for A Generic Sport Utility Vehicle Using Rear Suc...Aerodynamic Drag Reduction for A Generic Sport Utility Vehicle Using Rear Suc...
Aerodynamic Drag Reduction for A Generic Sport Utility Vehicle Using Rear Suc...IJERA Editor
 
CFD Simulation for Flow over Passenger Car Using Tail Plates for Aerodynamic ...
CFD Simulation for Flow over Passenger Car Using Tail Plates for Aerodynamic ...CFD Simulation for Flow over Passenger Car Using Tail Plates for Aerodynamic ...
CFD Simulation for Flow over Passenger Car Using Tail Plates for Aerodynamic ...IOSR Journals
 
IRJET - Review on Design of Intake Manifold for Air Restricted Engine
IRJET - Review on Design of Intake Manifold for Air Restricted EngineIRJET - Review on Design of Intake Manifold for Air Restricted Engine
IRJET - Review on Design of Intake Manifold for Air Restricted EngineIRJET Journal
 
IRJET- A Literature Review on Investigation of Design Parameter of Cyclone Se...
IRJET- A Literature Review on Investigation of Design Parameter of Cyclone Se...IRJET- A Literature Review on Investigation of Design Parameter of Cyclone Se...
IRJET- A Literature Review on Investigation of Design Parameter of Cyclone Se...IRJET Journal
 
Assessment of Flow Control using Passive Devices around Bluff Bodies
Assessment of Flow Control using Passive Devices around Bluff BodiesAssessment of Flow Control using Passive Devices around Bluff Bodies
Assessment of Flow Control using Passive Devices around Bluff BodiesAnuragSingh1049
 
B041011119
B041011119B041011119
B041011119IOSR-JEN
 
Cfd Studies of Two Stroke Petrol Engine Scavenging
Cfd Studies of Two Stroke Petrol Engine ScavengingCfd Studies of Two Stroke Petrol Engine Scavenging
Cfd Studies of Two Stroke Petrol Engine ScavengingIJERA Editor
 

Similar to Validation of Experimental and Numerical Techniques for Flow Analysis over an Ahmed Body (20)

Aero-acoustic investigation over a 3-dimensional open sunroof using CFD
Aero-acoustic investigation over a 3-dimensional open sunroof using CFDAero-acoustic investigation over a 3-dimensional open sunroof using CFD
Aero-acoustic investigation over a 3-dimensional open sunroof using CFD
 
Cdd mahesh dasar ijertv2 is120775
Cdd mahesh dasar ijertv2 is120775Cdd mahesh dasar ijertv2 is120775
Cdd mahesh dasar ijertv2 is120775
 
Simulations Of Unsteady Flow Around A Generic Pickup Truck Using Reynolds Ave...
Simulations Of Unsteady Flow Around A Generic Pickup Truck Using Reynolds Ave...Simulations Of Unsteady Flow Around A Generic Pickup Truck Using Reynolds Ave...
Simulations Of Unsteady Flow Around A Generic Pickup Truck Using Reynolds Ave...
 
Strategies for aerodynamic development
Strategies for aerodynamic developmentStrategies for aerodynamic development
Strategies for aerodynamic development
 
E012513749
E012513749E012513749
E012513749
 
Soot Formation in Diesel Engines By Using Cfd
Soot Formation in Diesel Engines By Using CfdSoot Formation in Diesel Engines By Using Cfd
Soot Formation in Diesel Engines By Using Cfd
 
CFD modelling calculation and simulation of bus
CFD modelling calculation and simulation of busCFD modelling calculation and simulation of bus
CFD modelling calculation and simulation of bus
 
Ijmet 09 11_016
Ijmet 09 11_016Ijmet 09 11_016
Ijmet 09 11_016
 
ASSIGNMENT
ASSIGNMENTASSIGNMENT
ASSIGNMENT
 
Comparison of CFD Simulation of a Hyundai I20 Model with Four Different Turbu...
Comparison of CFD Simulation of a Hyundai I20 Model with Four Different Turbu...Comparison of CFD Simulation of a Hyundai I20 Model with Four Different Turbu...
Comparison of CFD Simulation of a Hyundai I20 Model with Four Different Turbu...
 
CFD analysis of commercial vehicle
CFD analysis of commercial vehicleCFD analysis of commercial vehicle
CFD analysis of commercial vehicle
 
Aerodynamic Drag Reduction for A Generic Sport Utility Vehicle Using Rear Suc...
Aerodynamic Drag Reduction for A Generic Sport Utility Vehicle Using Rear Suc...Aerodynamic Drag Reduction for A Generic Sport Utility Vehicle Using Rear Suc...
Aerodynamic Drag Reduction for A Generic Sport Utility Vehicle Using Rear Suc...
 
C012512230
C012512230C012512230
C012512230
 
CFD Simulation for Flow over Passenger Car Using Tail Plates for Aerodynamic ...
CFD Simulation for Flow over Passenger Car Using Tail Plates for Aerodynamic ...CFD Simulation for Flow over Passenger Car Using Tail Plates for Aerodynamic ...
CFD Simulation for Flow over Passenger Car Using Tail Plates for Aerodynamic ...
 
IRJET - Review on Design of Intake Manifold for Air Restricted Engine
IRJET - Review on Design of Intake Manifold for Air Restricted EngineIRJET - Review on Design of Intake Manifold for Air Restricted Engine
IRJET - Review on Design of Intake Manifold for Air Restricted Engine
 
IRJET- A Literature Review on Investigation of Design Parameter of Cyclone Se...
IRJET- A Literature Review on Investigation of Design Parameter of Cyclone Se...IRJET- A Literature Review on Investigation of Design Parameter of Cyclone Se...
IRJET- A Literature Review on Investigation of Design Parameter of Cyclone Se...
 
Assessment of Flow Control using Passive Devices around Bluff Bodies
Assessment of Flow Control using Passive Devices around Bluff BodiesAssessment of Flow Control using Passive Devices around Bluff Bodies
Assessment of Flow Control using Passive Devices around Bluff Bodies
 
Ek34827830
Ek34827830Ek34827830
Ek34827830
 
B041011119
B041011119B041011119
B041011119
 
Cfd Studies of Two Stroke Petrol Engine Scavenging
Cfd Studies of Two Stroke Petrol Engine ScavengingCfd Studies of Two Stroke Petrol Engine Scavenging
Cfd Studies of Two Stroke Petrol Engine Scavenging
 

Recently uploaded

Thermal Engineering Unit - I & II . ppt
Thermal Engineering  Unit - I & II . pptThermal Engineering  Unit - I & II . ppt
Thermal Engineering Unit - I & II . pptDineshKumar4165
 
Hospital management system project report.pdf
Hospital management system project report.pdfHospital management system project report.pdf
Hospital management system project report.pdfKamal Acharya
 
Unit 4_Part 1 CSE2001 Exception Handling and Function Template and Class Temp...
Unit 4_Part 1 CSE2001 Exception Handling and Function Template and Class Temp...Unit 4_Part 1 CSE2001 Exception Handling and Function Template and Class Temp...
Unit 4_Part 1 CSE2001 Exception Handling and Function Template and Class Temp...drmkjayanthikannan
 
Introduction to Serverless with AWS Lambda
Introduction to Serverless with AWS LambdaIntroduction to Serverless with AWS Lambda
Introduction to Serverless with AWS LambdaOmar Fathy
 
Double Revolving field theory-how the rotor develops torque
Double Revolving field theory-how the rotor develops torqueDouble Revolving field theory-how the rotor develops torque
Double Revolving field theory-how the rotor develops torqueBhangaleSonal
 
HAND TOOLS USED AT ELECTRONICS WORK PRESENTED BY KOUSTAV SARKAR
HAND TOOLS USED AT ELECTRONICS WORK PRESENTED BY KOUSTAV SARKARHAND TOOLS USED AT ELECTRONICS WORK PRESENTED BY KOUSTAV SARKAR
HAND TOOLS USED AT ELECTRONICS WORK PRESENTED BY KOUSTAV SARKARKOUSTAV SARKAR
 
Orlando’s Arnold Palmer Hospital Layout Strategy-1.pptx
Orlando’s Arnold Palmer Hospital Layout Strategy-1.pptxOrlando’s Arnold Palmer Hospital Layout Strategy-1.pptx
Orlando’s Arnold Palmer Hospital Layout Strategy-1.pptxMuhammadAsimMuhammad6
 
S1S2 B.Arch MGU - HOA1&2 Module 3 -Temple Architecture of Kerala.pptx
S1S2 B.Arch MGU - HOA1&2 Module 3 -Temple Architecture of Kerala.pptxS1S2 B.Arch MGU - HOA1&2 Module 3 -Temple Architecture of Kerala.pptx
S1S2 B.Arch MGU - HOA1&2 Module 3 -Temple Architecture of Kerala.pptxSCMS School of Architecture
 
Computer Lecture 01.pptxIntroduction to Computers
Computer Lecture 01.pptxIntroduction to ComputersComputer Lecture 01.pptxIntroduction to Computers
Computer Lecture 01.pptxIntroduction to ComputersMairaAshraf6
 
AIRCANVAS[1].pdf mini project for btech students
AIRCANVAS[1].pdf mini project for btech studentsAIRCANVAS[1].pdf mini project for btech students
AIRCANVAS[1].pdf mini project for btech studentsvanyagupta248
 
Online food ordering system project report.pdf
Online food ordering system project report.pdfOnline food ordering system project report.pdf
Online food ordering system project report.pdfKamal Acharya
 
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXssuser89054b
 
Online electricity billing project report..pdf
Online electricity billing project report..pdfOnline electricity billing project report..pdf
Online electricity billing project report..pdfKamal Acharya
 
Thermal Engineering-R & A / C - unit - V
Thermal Engineering-R & A / C - unit - VThermal Engineering-R & A / C - unit - V
Thermal Engineering-R & A / C - unit - VDineshKumar4165
 
Unleashing the Power of the SORA AI lastest leap
Unleashing the Power of the SORA AI lastest leapUnleashing the Power of the SORA AI lastest leap
Unleashing the Power of the SORA AI lastest leapRishantSharmaFr
 
A Study of Urban Area Plan for Pabna Municipality
A Study of Urban Area Plan for Pabna MunicipalityA Study of Urban Area Plan for Pabna Municipality
A Study of Urban Area Plan for Pabna MunicipalityMorshed Ahmed Rahath
 
Block diagram reduction techniques in control systems.ppt
Block diagram reduction techniques in control systems.pptBlock diagram reduction techniques in control systems.ppt
Block diagram reduction techniques in control systems.pptNANDHAKUMARA10
 
Engineering Drawing focus on projection of planes
Engineering Drawing focus on projection of planesEngineering Drawing focus on projection of planes
Engineering Drawing focus on projection of planesRAJNEESHKUMAR341697
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Thermal Engineering Unit - I & II . ppt
Thermal Engineering  Unit - I & II . pptThermal Engineering  Unit - I & II . ppt
Thermal Engineering Unit - I & II . ppt
 
Hospital management system project report.pdf
Hospital management system project report.pdfHospital management system project report.pdf
Hospital management system project report.pdf
 
Unit 4_Part 1 CSE2001 Exception Handling and Function Template and Class Temp...
Unit 4_Part 1 CSE2001 Exception Handling and Function Template and Class Temp...Unit 4_Part 1 CSE2001 Exception Handling and Function Template and Class Temp...
Unit 4_Part 1 CSE2001 Exception Handling and Function Template and Class Temp...
 
Introduction to Serverless with AWS Lambda
Introduction to Serverless with AWS LambdaIntroduction to Serverless with AWS Lambda
Introduction to Serverless with AWS Lambda
 
Double Revolving field theory-how the rotor develops torque
Double Revolving field theory-how the rotor develops torqueDouble Revolving field theory-how the rotor develops torque
Double Revolving field theory-how the rotor develops torque
 
HAND TOOLS USED AT ELECTRONICS WORK PRESENTED BY KOUSTAV SARKAR
HAND TOOLS USED AT ELECTRONICS WORK PRESENTED BY KOUSTAV SARKARHAND TOOLS USED AT ELECTRONICS WORK PRESENTED BY KOUSTAV SARKAR
HAND TOOLS USED AT ELECTRONICS WORK PRESENTED BY KOUSTAV SARKAR
 
Orlando’s Arnold Palmer Hospital Layout Strategy-1.pptx
Orlando’s Arnold Palmer Hospital Layout Strategy-1.pptxOrlando’s Arnold Palmer Hospital Layout Strategy-1.pptx
Orlando’s Arnold Palmer Hospital Layout Strategy-1.pptx
 
S1S2 B.Arch MGU - HOA1&2 Module 3 -Temple Architecture of Kerala.pptx
S1S2 B.Arch MGU - HOA1&2 Module 3 -Temple Architecture of Kerala.pptxS1S2 B.Arch MGU - HOA1&2 Module 3 -Temple Architecture of Kerala.pptx
S1S2 B.Arch MGU - HOA1&2 Module 3 -Temple Architecture of Kerala.pptx
 
Computer Lecture 01.pptxIntroduction to Computers
Computer Lecture 01.pptxIntroduction to ComputersComputer Lecture 01.pptxIntroduction to Computers
Computer Lecture 01.pptxIntroduction to Computers
 
Call Girls in South Ex (delhi) call me [🔝9953056974🔝] escort service 24X7
Call Girls in South Ex (delhi) call me [🔝9953056974🔝] escort service 24X7Call Girls in South Ex (delhi) call me [🔝9953056974🔝] escort service 24X7
Call Girls in South Ex (delhi) call me [🔝9953056974🔝] escort service 24X7
 
AIRCANVAS[1].pdf mini project for btech students
AIRCANVAS[1].pdf mini project for btech studentsAIRCANVAS[1].pdf mini project for btech students
AIRCANVAS[1].pdf mini project for btech students
 
Online food ordering system project report.pdf
Online food ordering system project report.pdfOnline food ordering system project report.pdf
Online food ordering system project report.pdf
 
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
 
Online electricity billing project report..pdf
Online electricity billing project report..pdfOnline electricity billing project report..pdf
Online electricity billing project report..pdf
 
Thermal Engineering-R & A / C - unit - V
Thermal Engineering-R & A / C - unit - VThermal Engineering-R & A / C - unit - V
Thermal Engineering-R & A / C - unit - V
 
Unleashing the Power of the SORA AI lastest leap
Unleashing the Power of the SORA AI lastest leapUnleashing the Power of the SORA AI lastest leap
Unleashing the Power of the SORA AI lastest leap
 
Integrated Test Rig For HTFE-25 - Neometrix
Integrated Test Rig For HTFE-25 - NeometrixIntegrated Test Rig For HTFE-25 - Neometrix
Integrated Test Rig For HTFE-25 - Neometrix
 
A Study of Urban Area Plan for Pabna Municipality
A Study of Urban Area Plan for Pabna MunicipalityA Study of Urban Area Plan for Pabna Municipality
A Study of Urban Area Plan for Pabna Municipality
 
Block diagram reduction techniques in control systems.ppt
Block diagram reduction techniques in control systems.pptBlock diagram reduction techniques in control systems.ppt
Block diagram reduction techniques in control systems.ppt
 
Engineering Drawing focus on projection of planes
Engineering Drawing focus on projection of planesEngineering Drawing focus on projection of planes
Engineering Drawing focus on projection of planes
 

Validation of Experimental and Numerical Techniques for Flow Analysis over an Ahmed Body

  • 1. Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71 www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 63|P a g e Validation of Experimental and Numerical Techniques for Flow Analysis over an Ahmed Body Rodrigo Mendes Alves*, Odenir de Almeida** *(Department of Mechanical Engineering, Universidade Federal de Uberlândia, Brazil) ** (Department of Mechanical Engineering, Universidade Federal de Uberlândia, Brazil) ABSTRACT The impact of improvement in vehicle aerodynamics mainly reflects in lower fuel consumption and lower carbon dioxide emissions into the atmosphere. The governments of many countries support continuous aerodynamics’ improvement programs as a way of mitigating the energy crisis and atmospheric pollution. This work has the main goal to validate experimental and numerical techniques for application in road vehicles. The experimental results were obtained through the analysis of the flow around a standard body with simple geometry called Ahmed Body, using hot wire anemometry from experiments in wind tunnel. It was also proposed a computational validation using a commercial software (Star CCM +) to further analyze the flow and to corroborate the experimental results. Both results were compared and allowed characterizing the flow around the vehicle. The results obtained analyzing the Ahmed Body aimed further application on aerodynamics of heavy- duty vehicles, which is an ongoing research being developed at the Experimental Aerodynamics Research Center – CPAERO, in Brazil. Keywords-Aerodynamics, Ahmed Body, Experimental Techniques, Flow analysis, Road Vehicles I. INTRODUCTION The main reason to study the aerodynamics of road vehicles is reducing the drag with the objective to reduce the power necessary to motion, and, by consequence, decreasingthe emission of pollutants. Fig. 1 shows the relation between power necessary to overcome aerodynamic drag and rolling resistance for a 40 tons truck with a Cd (Drag Coefficient) equal to 0.50. From this figure, it is visible that over 80 km/h it is critical the increasing of aerodynamic drag. That is the reason of the efforts applied to mitigate the drag force in heavy-duty vehicles industry and via academic researches around the world. According to the DOE (Department of Energy of the United States) annual review of 2012, the class 8 trucks (vehicles with gross weight rating exceeding 33000 lb) are responsible for about 13% of the fuel consumption in the United States. The reduction of 12% on fuel consumption would lead to 13.2 billion dollars savings per year and reduction of 28 million tons of carbon dioxide emission [1]. Fig.1. Relation between the power necessary to overcome aerodynamic drag and rolling resistance for a 40 ton Truck with 0.5 Cd. Source: ICCT (International Council on Clean Transportation). Fig. 2 shows the energy losses in an 80000 lbtrucktravelling with a velocity of 105 km/h. The energy loss caused by aerodynamic is about 53% of the total losses, while the rolling resistance is responsible by 32% of total. Therefore, the study of the interaction of the flow with truck’s structure is very importance to reducing fuel consumption and increasing energy efficiency. 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 Power[kW] Velocity [km/h] Rolling resistance Aerodynamic drag RESEARCH ARTICLE OPEN ACCESS
  • 2. Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71 www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 64|P a g e Fig. 2.Energy losses in a moving truck, after [2]. In order to get a better understanding of the flow and its interaction with the truck, it is necessary to work in two different approaches: experimental and numerical techniques applied to characterize the flow dynamics. One of the most usual and efficient equipment to develop an experimental aerodynamic analyses is the wind tunnel. Similar conditions to real can be simulated in the wind tunnel in different scales ratio. Since trucks are big structures, the real condition simulation would require a very big wind tunnel, high investment and technology. These are the reasons for working with scale models, such approach could lead to reasonable results when compared to real cases flow analyses. This is true only if a lot of expertise and care is taken during the experiments. Historically, the improvement of trucks’ aerodynamics had an important effort in developing and implementing the air deflector by1950s as seen in Ref. [3]. Then trucks’ shape has been changed over the years (small radiator, rounded corners, etc.) as seen on Ref. [4]. Nowadays, new structures have been added to trucks for aerodynamics improvements like skirts, wedges and base flaps; and good results already obtained from experimental and numerical analysis [4]. For the numerical approach, it is usual to work with Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) analysis. This tool offers a chance to observe the flow in limitless conditions in all scales with lower costs and shorter time compared to the experimental analyses. There are several commercial software developed for aerodynamic investigation, which has demonstrated good results compared to experiments. For this specific work, STAR CCM+® software was used based on the reliability of its results already demonstrated in other researches like the work of Ref. [5]. Hakansson and Lenngren [5] has developed interesting analyses for the aerodynamics of trucks using CFD, testing some trailer devices in order to understand the influence of those on the flow and drag force analyses. The results indicate that those devices lead to lower drag for different yaw angle and shows that the optimization of the carriage would be a great deal for the industry of trucks. The objective of this work is to study the flowaerodynamic over an Ahmed Body with a Reynolds number ranging from 0.7 × 105 up to 1.4 7 × 105 ,through experimental and numerical techniques aiming to apply the results on heavy-duty vehicles’ aerodynamics. In order to achieve such goal wind tunnel experiments were carried out by using a hot-wire anemometry system to characterize flow profiles in the Ahmed body’s wake. The limitations of using hot-wire anemometry for performing velocity profiles measurements in the near-wake of the body were investigated in this work. Additionally a numerical approach, by using the STAR CCM+ code, was validated against ERCOFTAC(European Research Community on Flow, Turbulence and Combustion) results [6]. The numerical technique has been applied to corroborate the experimental results with the purpose to validate these tools for later use in the analyses of the flow around heavy-duty vehicles such as trucks and buses. With the purpose of validating such techniques some remarks were registered during the development of this work. II. METHODOLOGY The experimental procedure used in this work aimed to analyze the flow around the model in the wind tunnel using hot wire anemometry to measure velocity profiles in the wake of the body. The objectives here were to validate the newly constructed small wind tunnel in the Experimental Aerodynamics Research Center - CPAERO of the Federal University of Uberlândia(UFU)and also toverify the applicability of hot-wire sensors to generate experimental data, for further comparison purposes with the numerical model. The numerical procedure was firstly validated against experimental results obtained by ERCOFTAC [6], aimed to offer a better understanding about the interaction of the flow with the Ahmed body. For this, the commercial software STAR CCM + has been used for numerical simulation of the flow with the same physical characteristics of the body and conditions of the experiment. 2.1 Experimental Approach 2.1.1 Wind Tunnel The wind tunnel of the LEEAR was used for the experimental part of this work. Some of the specifications of the tunnel are described in sequence:  Maximum flow velocity of 33 m/s in free test- section;  Test-section with a cross section of 0.6 × 0.6 m and 1 meter in length;
  • 3. Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71 www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 65|P a g e  6 meter in length for the whole tunnel;  Maximum width of 1.90 meter;  1.90 meter in height; The Fan has 1.25 m in diameter and about 43,000 m³/h of flow rate. The engine has 24 HP, 220/380V, IP55, 60 Hz, with rotation of 1150 RPM. The engine’s velocity is controlled by a frequency inverter of 220/380V in three phase. The wind tunnel also was equipped with a Pitot tube for velocity measurement inside the test-section. Fig. 3 shows the test section of the wind tunnel with the Ahmed body used for the experiment. A complete set of flow measurements inside the test section and also flow visualization allowed to well characterize the flow pattern, as part of the verification of the flow uniformity in this wind tunnel. Fig.3 shows the velocity profiles for the wind tunnel boundary layer development at different test conditions.According to the results, the boundary layer thickness is around an average of 4.0 mm in the middle of the test section.The turbulent intensity of the tunnelis around 0.81% for the range of velocities investigated in previously work, being around 0.6% for 7 m/s and reaching a peak level of 1% at 25.5 m/s. Fig.3. Images from the test section of the wind tunnel with the Ahmed body. Fig. 4. Normalized profiles for boundary layer development at different flow velocities. 2.1.2 Hot Wire Anemometry The technique for flow velocity measurement used in this work was the hot-wire Anemometry. This technique has been widely used in aerodynamic researches and constantly optimized due to the technological development and the need for a detailed description of turbulent flows. Fig. 5 shows the measurement system used for the experiment of this work [7]. The probe is located in one of the four sides of a Wheatstone bridge and an electronic circuit powers it. According to the operation principle of the Wheatstone bridge, all sides have the same electrical tension, since the resistance is the same on all four sides. Therefore, the electric current passing through the bridge has the same intensity at the four points. Fig. 5.Measurement system used on the experiment. When the sensor is inserted into the flow, the heat exchange of the wire heated by the electric current causes an imbalance in the bridge for the change in temperature implies changing the resistance of the sensor side. This electric tension change can be measured and related to the flow velocity through the 4th order polynomial seen in Fig. 6. The correlation is given by the polynomial U = -0.000002E4 + 0.0001E3 + - 0.0041E2 + + 0,0764E + 1.5827.
  • 4. Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71 www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 66|P a g e Fig. 6.Calibration curve of the hot-wire anemometer. The typical dimensions of the heated wire are 5 μm in diameter and 1 to 3 mm in length [8]. The hot-wire used in the experiment is from the manufacturer DANTEC DYNAMICS, model 55P11 1D[7]. Fig. 7 shows the Hot-wire anemometer on the back of the Ahmed Body inside the test-section. A mechanical support was used to place the anemometer inside the test-section with reasonable accuracy in location and also avoiding vibration. Fig. 7.Hot-wire anemometer on the back of Ahmed Body. 2.1.3 The Ahmed Body The Ahmed Body is a simplified model of a vehicle, invented by Ahmed in 1984 [9]. It is widely used on experiments over the world, which is the reason it is possible to find many data from different sources and laboratories. The geometry of the Ahmed Body is similar to a general car with a flat front and a slanted back. Detailed dimensions and geometry used in this work is shown in Fig. 8 and Fig. 9. Fig. 8. Dimensions of the physical model used on the main experiment of this work. Fig. 9.Physical model for wind tunnel. Beside the analyses of the velocity field, the Ahmed Body is also used for drag force and lift force analyses and rolling, pitching and yawing moments. The slant angle on the back allows studying the separation region and its influence on the velocity profile and forces. In this case we have selected 30° of slanted angle in the back. 2.2 Numerical Approach The main reason to use computational simulation was to compare the results from this simulation with the experimental results and data from literature. According to the results of this comparison, it is possible to check more reliability for the results from the numerical technique. The main parameters analyzed are the velocity field, lift coefficient and drag coefficient of the body. The STAR CCM+ software was used for simulation. The dimensions of the computational domain are 31L x 10L x 7.5L where L is the length of the body, as seen in Fig. 10. Fig. 10. Computational domain used in computational simulation. The simulation was performed in steady state regime with 5000 iterations reaching a residual level of order 1 × 10-4 . The turbulence model was RANS k-ω SST (Shear Stress Transport). This turbulence model was used since the flow is 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 E[volts] U [m/s] Calibration curve
  • 5. Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71 www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 67|P a g e considered to be completely detached on the back of the Ahmed body followed by a turbulent flow with regions of recirculation behind the body. In order to get a better simulation, the domain was divided into ground, inlet, outlet, roof, side wall and plane of symmetry. The boundary conditions applied to the simulations were:  Inlet: uniform velocity  Outlet: Atmospheric pressure  Roof: stationary wall  Ground: stationary wall  Side wall: stationary wall  Plane of symmetry: symmetry  Ahmed Body: stationary wall It was used tetrahedral mesh and prismatic layer for the boundary layer region. The total amount of cells was about 2.3 millions. The mesh was refined on critical regions like regions close to the body and behind the body (wake flow region). The mesh conditions were chosen based on satisfactory results of Souza [10]. The computational mesh is seen in Fig. 11. Fig. 11.Computational domain. Detail of the mesh in the body and plane of symmetry. III. VALIDATION OF THE NUMERICAL APPROACH In order to validate the numerical approach using STAR CCM+ software, it was compared the experimental data from ERCOFTAC available online with the results of the computational simulation. For this work, the “Case 9.4 – Flow around a simplified car (Ahmed Body)” [6] was used for comparison. This case has been simulated using the same conditions as the Case 9.4 from ERCOFTAC and the same dimensions of the Ahmed Body (Fig. 12). The parameters used are slant angle of 25°, kinematic viscosity of 1.5 x10−5 m2 /s and flow velocity of 40 m/s. The computational domain was described on section 2.2. The results from STAR CCM+ showing velocity contours and streamlines can be seen on Fig.13. Fig. 12. Dimension of the Ahmed Body [6] Fig. 13. Velocity contours and streamlines. The data from the streamwise velocity was collected in four different positions: 38 mm, 88 mm, 138 mm and 188 mm from the back of the Ahmed Body (the origin reference is the rear end of the Ahmed body). Fig.14and Fig. 15 show the pattern of the u-velocity component on the symmetry plane. Both profiles in Fig. 14 and Fig. 15 presented the lowestvelocitiesalong 50 mm and 250 mm in height in all positions, which probably were occasioned by the recirculation region (low pressure region) behind the body. As the radial position is moved downstream in the wake, it is possible to observe a reduction in this velocity profile inflexion. Outside this region of lower velocities it is possible to see some small discrepancies between the ERCOFTAC data and our current simulations. However, it can be seen a satisfactory similarity of the profiles with reasonable identification of the flow actual flow structures, which gives reliability for using the computational approach selected in this work.
  • 6. Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71 www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 68|P a g e Fig. 14.Velocity profiles for validation of the numerical technique – 38 and 88mm. It is important to comment that the numerical modeling was performed by using a RANS approach with turbulence modeling to characterize a flow pattern that is naturally transient in actual condition with large regions of flow detachments and recirculating flows in the wake of the body. As a mean flow-prediction’s method this numerical model is showing reasonable results allowing the use of this approach for doing design selections, at least, for industrial applications with a low cost when compared to other numerical techniques such as LES (Large Eddy Simulation) and DNS (Direct Numerical Simulation). Fig. 15. Velocity profiles for validation of the numerical technique – 138 and 188mm. IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION After the validation of the numerical approach used in this work, the next step was to generate new computational simulations for the experiments with the Ahmed body,carried out in thewindtunnel at CPAERO as explained in the Methodology. The main differences between the Ahmed bodies used for validation and the physical model in our experiment were the slant angle (inourexperimentthe angle was 30° degrees), the dimensions of the body (Fig. 8) and the velocity range. For the physical model in our experiments we planned to work with most critical scenario for further turbulence analyses on Ahmed Body where separation flow occurs, that is for a 30º slant angle based on literature [9]. Based on the dimension of the test section of the wind tunnel, we calculated the best dimension for the Ahmed Body for a reasonable blocking ratio (3.84% in this case). After obtained the resultsfrom the validation for computational data, the next step was comparing experimental data with computational data, aiming a better comprehension of the flow around the body and also identifying potential limitations from each technique employed. Then it was manufactured a physical Ahmed body (Fig. 9) with dimension shown in Fig. 8 for the experiment in wind tunnel. The experiment in the wind tunnel was set for three different velocities: 10m/s (Re = 0.7 × 105 ); 15m/s (Re = 1.05 × 105 ) e 20m/s (Re = 1.4 × 105 ). Computational simulations were performed in STAR CCM + looking for the same geometric and physical conditions of the experimental approach and same conditions as showed on section 2.2. Three positions were set for the velocity measurement and profiles comparison in all three cases. The first position (P1) was located 160 mm from the front of the body, the second position (P2) was located 48 mm from the end of the body, and -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 z-height(mm) U-Velocity (m/s) Velocity-profile (38mm) Ercoftac data Present work -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 z-height(mm) U-Velocity (m/s) Velocity-profile (88mm) Ercoftac data Present work -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 z-height(mm) U-Velocity (m/s) Velocity-profile (138mm) Ercoftac data Present work -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 z-height(mm) U-Velocity (m/s) Velocity-profile (188mm) Ercoftac data Present work
  • 7. Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71 www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 69|P a g e the third position (P3) was located 97 mm from the end of the Ahmed body (49 mm from the second position), as seen in Fig. 16. The maximum height measured in the experiment was 160 mm. As mentioned, a mechanical support was used to place the hot-wire probe inside the flow in the indicated positions. In the next subsections the u-velocity profiles will be shown, including the comparison with the CFD simulations performed for each specific position P1, P2 and P3. Fig. 16. Positions for the velocities profiles: wind tunnel experiment and computational simulation. 2.3 Velocity Profile Comparison in P1 The comparison between experimental and simulation data for the position P1 is shown in Fig. 17. The position P1 was in front of the body, where the flow is completed well established. The first boundary layer measured point in the experiment was about 1.5 mm, increasing up to 160 mm. The velocities profiles were normalized independently by dividing the measured velocity (u-velocity) by the maximum velocity (Umax) measured along the vertical experimental line. This allowed verifying the similarity in the velocity profiles in both experimental and numerical data. Fig. 17.Velocity Profile for position P1. It is notable the similarity on both data at P1 for different velocities. The position in front of the body have almost none influence of the body, so it is expected a constant velocity as seen in Fig. 17. The region where there is no match between data was on the boundary layer region. One of the main reasons for the non- coincidence of data would be the in fact that, in the computational model, there was an imposition of a uniform velocity profile as a boundary condition. This boundary condition imposition associated with the wall-function modeling led to a development of the boundary layer which is closely different in the first measured positions close to the wall. On coming flow simulations have been performed to evaluate the influence of the boundary conditions in the final simulations, taking into account the actual boundary layer profile. 2.4 Velocity Profile Comparison in P2 The comparison between experimental and simulation data for the position P2 is shown in Fig. 18 for the three velocities investigated. In all cases, the effect of the recirculation region (also called recirculation bubble) behind the body is seen, creating an inflection in the velocity profiles at intermediate positions measured.Consequently, it is seen a velocity drop in this region (with negative velocities calculated, indicating the recirculating flow). However, as can be seen, the result from the computational simulation has this inflection much more pronounced than the experimental results with values much smaller than those collected by the sensor. Thecause of this discrepancy was due to the fact that the sensor (hot-wire) was not able to measure negative velocities. In fact, this result can be associated to the limitations of the measuring technique, once values outside the calibration region (including negative velocities) are not correctly acquired. Also, according to the numerical results, seen further, the points P2 and P3are well inside where the recirculation bubble was located. 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 Height(mm) U-velocity / Umax P1_10m/s: Numerical Experimental 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 P1_15 m/s: Numerical Experimental Height(mm) U-velocity / Umax 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 P1_20 m/s: Numerical Experimental Height(mm) U-velocity / Umax
  • 8. Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71 www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 70|P a g e The hot-wire technique is not a proper approach for measuring inside recirculating flows and should be used for well-established flow regions. Fig. 18.Velocity Profile for position P2. 2.5 Velocity Profile Comparison in P3 In the position P3, one can observe the complete qualitative and quantitative disparity in the recirculation region in both cases. Although the values in the free flow region are very close in both cases, the profiles have opposite trend in the other regions, as seen in Fig. 19, for the reasons already explained. Fig. 19.Velocity Profile for position P3. While the velocity profiles from the CFD simulation indicated negative velocity values in the recirculation region, the velocity values of the experiment shows a profile trend as it was located outside the recirculation with smother curves. This analysis leads to the possibility of the recirculation bubble in the simulation being larger than the bubble generated in the experiment.According to the flow analysis performed through visualization tools by using the software STAR CCM+, one could estimate the size of the recirculation bubble for the three cases investigated. Table 1 illustrates the recirculation region sizing behind the Ahmed body obtained numerically. Fig.20 presents the flow field in the back of the Ahmed body, visualized by vector plots, for 15 m/s. -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 P2_10 m/s: Numerical Experimental Height(mm) U-velocity / Umax -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 P2_15 m/s: Numerical Experimental Height(mm) U-velocity / Umax -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 P2_20 m/s: Numerical Experimental Height(mm) U-velocity / Umax -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 P3_10 m/s: Numerical Experimental Height(mm) U-velocity / Umax -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 P3_15 m/s: Numerical Experimental Height(mm) U-velocity / Umax -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 P3_20 m/s: Numerical Experimental Height(mm) U-velocity / Umax
  • 9. Rodrigo Mendes Alves Int. Journal of Engineering Research and Application www.ijera.com ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 7, Issue 4, ( Part -3) April 2017, pp.63-71 www.ijera.com DOI: 10.9790/9622-0704036371 71|P a g e Table 1.Recirculation region – Numerical results. Recirculation bubble 10 m/s 15 m/s 20 m/s 0.150 0.140 0.135 Fig. 20.Vector plot of the flow behind the Ahmed body. Since there was no information about the size of the recirculation bubble before the experiment, the velocity acquisition points were chosen in the tunnel 48 mm and 97 mm from the rear of the body. As commented, for a massive recirculation of the flow, using the anemometer as a measurement technique is not indicated. Therefore, the experimental profiles should be taken in positions fartherawayfrom the back of the body. As an ongoing research, new velocity profiles will be undertaken and a deeper analysis will be performed. Finally, by analyzing the computational result for drag coefficients evaluated by Equation 1, it can be seen from the Table 2 that the drag coefficient drops as the velocity increases. The values presented in Table 2are very close to those ones listed in literature. Table 1. Drag coefficient – Numerical results. Drag Coefficient (Cd) 10 m/s 15 m/s 20 m/s 0.3042 0.2943 0.2886 Table 1 𝐶 𝐷= 𝐷 1 2 𝜌𝑉²𝐴 (1) V. CONCLUSION The results obtained from experiments using the Ahmed body allowed some understanding about how the flow behaves around such geometry. The techniques employed in this work could also be used further to study aerodynamics of heavy-trucks. Mainly through the work of Hakansson and Lenngren [5], it can be seen current and future applications in the improvement of the aerodynamics of trucks. The Ahmed body’s computational simulation results in this work were validated by the experimental results from ERCOFTAC [6]. Despite this, the comparison of the computational results with the experimental results obtained in the wind tunnel in this work contains some inconsistencies, especially for the recirculation region behind the body. One source of errors identified was the location of the body's recirculation bubble. By analyzing velocity profiles behind the body, the velocity values captured in the simulation are much smaller than those captured in the experiment confirming the presence of a recirculation bubble just behind the body. Next experiments efforts could confirm this, including a sizing for this recirculating region behind the body. As these results are part of an ongoing study, for future work it is proposed a study of velocity profiles in the slanted region of Ahmed body, and study of velocity profiles in the post- recirculation region of Ahmed body. It is also proposed visualization with "tufts" and "China Clay" (aiming a better understanding of the flow around the body in the wind tunnel) and study of mesh refinement, aiming a better accuracy in numerical results. REFERENCES [1] Cooper K. R.,Commercial Vehicle Aerodynamic Drag Reduction: Historical Perspective as a Guide, National Research Council of Canada, 2004. [2] J. Woodroofee, Reducing Truck Fuel use and Emissions: Tires, Aerodynamics, Engine Efficiency, and Size and Weight Regulations,Report No. UMTRI-2014-27, Universityof Michigan, 2014. [3] K. R.Cooper.,Commercial Vehicle Aerodynamic Drag Reduction: Historical Perspective as a Guide,National Research Council of Canada, 2004. [4] F. Browand, Reducing Aerodynamic Drag and Fuel Consumption,Global Climate and Energy Project, Workshop on Advance Transportation, 2005. [5] C. Hakansson, M. J. Lenngren, CDF Analysis of Aerodynamic Trailer Devices for Drag Reduction of Heavy Duty Trucks,Chalmers University of Technology, 2010. [6] B. Basara, CASE 9.4 - Flow around a simplified car body (Ahmed body), 2001,Available in http://www.ercoftac.org/fileadmin/user_upload/bigfi les/sig15/database/9.4. Access on August 2016. [7] MiniCTA Anemometer Package, How to get started - a quick Guide. Dantec Dynamics A/S, 2004. [8] Hot-wire measurements, Lecture notes. Experimental Aerodynamics Class, Middle East Technical University. [9] S. R. Ahmed, Some salient features of the Time Average Ground Vehicle, SAE-Paper 840300, 1984. [10] P. R. C. Souza, Numerical and Experimental Analysis of subsonic jets, Undergraduation thesis, Federal University of Uberlândia, Uberlândia, 2012.