SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 8
Download to read offline
IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC
To: Mr. XXXX XXXXXX
Re: Investigative Reporting – Bank of America Investment Account
Dear Mr. XXXXXXXX,
Insight Consultants and Advisors, LLC has completed reviewing your account documentation that you
have provided and have performed the accounting and research to come up with the following:
• Your account has suffered a cumulative loss since inception of $219,542 equal to a 36% loss on a
starting balance of $609,801
• Your annualized loss is 16.61% (unrealized) derived from February 28, 2007 through April 30,
2009
• To reach your original invested amount of $609,801 your account will need to generate the
following returns over the corresponding periods of time:
o 8.50 years at 6% compounded return
o 6.50 years at 8% compounded return
o 5.40 years at 10% compounded return
o 4.70 years at 12% compounded return
o 3.80 years at 15% compounded return
o 2.80 years at 20% compounded return
o 2.40 years at 25% compounded return
Based on our interviews with you and your preference for conservative no risk investments, and taking
into account the current interest rate environment, a number of approximately 3.25% (pre-tax) would
be the comparative number using the current yield on the 10 year Treasury Note.
After reviewing the emails between yourself and your representative, the actual purchases, amounts
and types of products purchased, there are several points of concern that we would like to point your
attention to.
IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC
Background Summary and Narrative
All assumptions contained within this summary are based upon information provided by Mr. XXXXXX
during interviews with Insight Consultants and Advisors, LLC during the months of April 2009 and May
2009. All figures are based on account statements, correspondence and other documentation provided
by Mr. XXXXXXX.
In 2007, Mr. XXXXXXX was solicited by Premier Banking Services at Bank of America to begin an all
encompassing banking relationship with money that he had recently come into from the operation of
his business.
Mr. XXXXXXX was solicited to transfer his money from his current FDIC Insured checking and savings
accounts into a brokerage account held at Banc of America Investment Services, Inc. This was done in
January of 2007 when Mr. XXXXXXX began a relationship with Mr. XXXXXXXX, Vice President of
Investments. Up to this point, Mr. XXXXXXX has stated that he had never invested in equity or bond
markets at any time and has never owned stocks, bonds, mutual funds or any other type of investments
outside of his employer retirement plan.
Mr. XXXXXX has stated in interviews with Insight that he specifically told his representative that he
wanted a “no-risk, interest bearing account, such as a CD or Money Market account.” He further stated
that he could have placed his money in a Lebanese Bank and received between 7% and 8% APY on his
funds but was willing to take less to have the money in the United States with a large banking
institution.
Beginning in February 28, 2007 and ending May 8th
, 2007 the following purchases occurred in Mr.
XXXXXXX’ account:
Citigroup Capital Trust XVII Preferred e $ 209,800
First Trust Closed End Municipal Unit Investment Trust $ 200,001
First Trust Dividend Income Unit Investment Trust $ 100,000
Eaton Vance Large Cap Growth, Class B share $ 25,000
Goldman Sachs Equity Growth Portfolio, Class A share $ 75,000
IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC
During the period of January 2007 and April 2009, Mr. XXXXXXX’ accounts suffered principal losses,
inclusive of dividends earned and reinvested, in the amount of $219,542.
During the same period, Mr. XXXXXXX’ presumed interest, not earned, (using Banc of America
Investment Services Money Market average effective 7 day yield throughout) was equal to $43,193.
This brings the total losses inclusive of opportunity costs $262,734.
It is important to note that these numbers are also net of the market recovery that has occurred since
the lows set on March 9th
, 2009. In fact Mr. XXXXXXX’ account’s low point based on statements
provided by Banc of America Invest Services, Inc. and not inclusive of opportunity costs was $274,720 or
a cumulative stated loss of 45.05%.
IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC
Sampled Supporting Documentation
The investment vehicles that were placed into Mr. XXXXXXX’ account; were subsequently questioned by
Mr. XXXXXXX in email form, addressed to Mr. XXXXXXX commencing on May 18, 2007.
Sent: Friday, May 18, 2007 4:47 AM
To:
XXXXXXX@bankofamerica.com
Attachments:
Hi XXXXXX,
I noticed that the value of the account is decreasing.
I thought the money is placed in a 6% or so earning mode.
If it loses value, what is the meaning of the 6% number here?
XXXXX.
Based on the email documentation provided by Mr. XXXXXXX, there was neither a verbal or written
response provided with an answer to his questions about his holdings at this time. Subsequent emails
sent by Mr. XXXXXXX follow a similar theme with even more fearful and specific questions to Mr. XXXXX
regarding his account:
Sent: Friday, June 08, 2007 10:41 AM
To: XXXXXX@bankofamerica.com
Attachments:
Hi XXXXX,
I have sent you a couple of email asking for clarifications about the account
and still have not heard back. The account is quickly losing money and I would like
to understand how the whole thing works. Specifically, I would like to understand
how the quoted 6% interest comes into play, and what the chance are that the account
loses money over a year's period. If I don't hear back from you soon, I
would be inclined to withdraw the money and place it in a more secure place. Please answer as soon as
possible.Thanks,
IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC
Furthermore, Mr. XXXXXXX goes on to state to Mr. Dowd that he is gravely concerned about fluctuation,
loss of principal and the guarantees he was presented with by his Mr. XXXX:
“….however, the size of these fluctuations has reached 3.5% in the downturn in less than 3 days and
there is no guarantee that it would turn around. I have a couple of specific questions that I would like
answered:
1- If the account pays 6%, when should I expect these payments to occur?
2- What happens if I decide to withdraw the money before the payment is due?
Do I still get any interest payment?
3- Is it possible for the account to lose money over a year's time counting fluctuation
and interest payment together.
As you know, I am interested in the least amount of risk for this first batch of money.
If there is a likelyhood that a significant amount of it gets lost, I would be inclined to
remove it from the brokerage account.” (June 8
th
, 2007, 11:26a.m.) see attached
IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC
Areas of Concern and Statements of Fact:
• Account Opening Profile and any subsequent changes are imperative to determine Investment
Suitability, Risk Level, Time Horizon and Investment Experience
o Request Copies of all Account Opening Documentation and any profile updates for
comparison
• Money was transferred from FDIC Insured accounts into Non-FDIC Insured, non-guaranteed
brokerage account under the assumption of a fixed 6% APY return.
o It is important to note that Mr. XXXXXXX’ account did not even contain an FDIC option,
which is available for his cash reserves.
• Correspondence between Mr. XXXXXXX and Mr. XXXXX went unanswered numerous times and
specific investment related questions were not answered for periods up to three weeks. Market
volatility at that time dictates prompt, immediate response to clients. Representative also
appears to have sent unapproved correspondence to Mr. XXXXXXX.
o Possible negligence on representative’s behalf in not forwarding what could be
construed as written client complaint to immediate OSJ
o Representative provided unapproved email correspondence that contained unapproved
market commentary and a representation that
“The federal reserve meets next week, and I am expecting some relief from
this sell off then. There is no guarantee we will get it, but I do expect to
see prices rally back after their meeting. (June13, 209:46 a.m.) see
attached
• Possible Faliure to Supervise by OSJ should be looked into
o Request Copies of Incoming and Outgoing Correspondence logs from Representative
and compare to OSJ files
o Request Verbal and Written Complaint files for same
• Income style investments were presented as bonds (see email) when in fact no bonds exist in
portfolio
IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC
• Role of Principal transactions, markups, commissions, fees, loads and Deferred Sales Charges,
never disclosed to client, even when multiple, specific requests are made by client. Commissions
in excess of $20,000 believed to have occurred.
o Possible misrepresentation and non use of proper disclosures
• Questionable Mutual fund buys by representative
o Growth-oriented, non income producing investments purchased
o Did not utilize letter of intent, Rights of Accumulation, or maximize breakpoints
available to client
o $75,000 Goldman Sachs A share purchased with load – not disclosed
o $25,000 Same Day purchase of B share mutual fund – surrender charges not disclosed
o Different Fund Families utilized to increase commission for representative
• Expenses on Unit Investment Trusts not explained or disclosed, approximate expenses of 5%
including load per share and deferred sales charges (see attached)
• Longer term, illiquid, higher commissioned products chosen versus alternatives available
• Client specifically demands instruction on how to close account, no further orders to be placed
without specific direction of Mr. XXXXXXX suggests discretionary abuse in past purchases
• Even after wanting to close account, demanding explanations, client never received a
Supervisory call
• Failure to disclose that Citigroup Capital Trust XVII is not a bond, nor a direct preferred of
Citigroup, thus leaving Mr. Kyriakos unprotected as a bond holder would be, should company
default or declare bankruptcy
• Mr. XXXXXXX has never before invested in stock markets of any kind prior to account opening
• Representative shows client dispute on U4 in past
IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC
Conclusion
It is the opinion formed from this information, of Insight Consultants and Advisors, LLC that multiple
instances of product misrepresentation occurred in Mr. XXXXXXX’ account held at Banc of America
Investment Services, Inc.
It is also our opinion that a Failure to Supervise by the OSJ occurred throughout the duration of the
account and should be investigated further.
It is also our opinion that numerous incidents regarding expenses, commissions, mark-ups and general
product purchases occurred at a severe disservice to Mr. XXXXXXX and should be investigated further.
It is also our opinion that transactions occurred in an unauthorized manner on behalf of the client
without proper discretionary agreements in place and should be investigated as well.
Lastly, the disregard for a client’s written, multiple and specific questions during a time of severe market
volatility presents a possible negligent breach of fiduciary responsibility and should be included in any
future action pursued on behalf of Mr. XXXXXXX.
Adam J. Allison,
Managing Member
Insight Consultants and Advisors, LLC
Todd M. Lawrence,
Managing Member,
Insight Consultants and Advisors, LLC
Enclosures Attached

More Related Content

What's hot

Moody's Credit Ratings & the Subprime Mortgage Meltdown
Moody's Credit Ratings & the Subprime Mortgage MeltdownMoody's Credit Ratings & the Subprime Mortgage Meltdown
Moody's Credit Ratings & the Subprime Mortgage MeltdownKoyi Tan
 
Continuum Credit Conf SF_ ProsperMP
Continuum Credit Conf SF_ ProsperMPContinuum Credit Conf SF_ ProsperMP
Continuum Credit Conf SF_ ProsperMPRon Suber
 
The Upcoming U.S. Presidential Election and the Fiscal Cliff (Article)
The Upcoming U.S. Presidential Election and the Fiscal Cliff (Article)The Upcoming U.S. Presidential Election and the Fiscal Cliff (Article)
The Upcoming U.S. Presidential Election and the Fiscal Cliff (Article)NAFCU Services Corporation
 
Market Monitor 04 01 11
Market Monitor 04 01 11Market Monitor 04 01 11
Market Monitor 04 01 11John Cranstoun
 
The Economics of Structured
The Economics of StructuredThe Economics of Structured
The Economics of Structuredstockedin
 
Second Angel Ira Investment Webinar
Second Angel Ira Investment WebinarSecond Angel Ira Investment Webinar
Second Angel Ira Investment Webinarrzahm
 
Financial statements...Simplified
Financial statements...SimplifiedFinancial statements...Simplified
Financial statements...SimplifiedPrashanth Ravada
 
Unit 2C - Money - Paychecks
Unit 2C - Money - PaychecksUnit 2C - Money - Paychecks
Unit 2C - Money - Paycheckscelsesser
 
Unit 4: Cost of Money
Unit 4: Cost of MoneyUnit 4: Cost of Money
Unit 4: Cost of Moneycelsesser
 
Manual on loan policy procedure for ccs microfinance
Manual on loan policy procedure for ccs microfinanceManual on loan policy procedure for ccs microfinance
Manual on loan policy procedure for ccs microfinanceAbdalla Hersi
 
Can The Fed Boost The Economy?
Can The Fed Boost The Economy?Can The Fed Boost The Economy?
Can The Fed Boost The Economy?Lawrence R. Levin
 
Negative interest rates
Negative interest ratesNegative interest rates
Negative interest ratesChris Bagshaw
 
CREIDIT RATING AGENCY report
CREIDIT RATING  AGENCY reportCREIDIT RATING  AGENCY report
CREIDIT RATING AGENCY reportVenkatasaiMalla
 
Credit: Principles and Sources
Credit: Principles and SourcesCredit: Principles and Sources
Credit: Principles and Sourcesmandalina landy
 

What's hot (19)

Moody's Credit Ratings & the Subprime Mortgage Meltdown
Moody's Credit Ratings & the Subprime Mortgage MeltdownMoody's Credit Ratings & the Subprime Mortgage Meltdown
Moody's Credit Ratings & the Subprime Mortgage Meltdown
 
Continuum Credit Conf SF_ ProsperMP
Continuum Credit Conf SF_ ProsperMPContinuum Credit Conf SF_ ProsperMP
Continuum Credit Conf SF_ ProsperMP
 
Pcg.Financial Planning Ce Presentation
Pcg.Financial Planning Ce PresentationPcg.Financial Planning Ce Presentation
Pcg.Financial Planning Ce Presentation
 
The Upcoming U.S. Presidential Election and the Fiscal Cliff (Article)
The Upcoming U.S. Presidential Election and the Fiscal Cliff (Article)The Upcoming U.S. Presidential Election and the Fiscal Cliff (Article)
The Upcoming U.S. Presidential Election and the Fiscal Cliff (Article)
 
Market Monitor 04 01 11
Market Monitor 04 01 11Market Monitor 04 01 11
Market Monitor 04 01 11
 
The Economics of Structured
The Economics of StructuredThe Economics of Structured
The Economics of Structured
 
Second Angel Ira Investment Webinar
Second Angel Ira Investment WebinarSecond Angel Ira Investment Webinar
Second Angel Ira Investment Webinar
 
Liabilities
LiabilitiesLiabilities
Liabilities
 
102 credit
102 credit102 credit
102 credit
 
Financial statements...Simplified
Financial statements...SimplifiedFinancial statements...Simplified
Financial statements...Simplified
 
Credit After Foreclosure
Credit After ForeclosureCredit After Foreclosure
Credit After Foreclosure
 
Unit 2C - Money - Paychecks
Unit 2C - Money - PaychecksUnit 2C - Money - Paychecks
Unit 2C - Money - Paychecks
 
Unit 4: Cost of Money
Unit 4: Cost of MoneyUnit 4: Cost of Money
Unit 4: Cost of Money
 
Manual on loan policy procedure for ccs microfinance
Manual on loan policy procedure for ccs microfinanceManual on loan policy procedure for ccs microfinance
Manual on loan policy procedure for ccs microfinance
 
MoneyTap Credit Glossary
MoneyTap Credit Glossary MoneyTap Credit Glossary
MoneyTap Credit Glossary
 
Can The Fed Boost The Economy?
Can The Fed Boost The Economy?Can The Fed Boost The Economy?
Can The Fed Boost The Economy?
 
Negative interest rates
Negative interest ratesNegative interest rates
Negative interest rates
 
CREIDIT RATING AGENCY report
CREIDIT RATING  AGENCY reportCREIDIT RATING  AGENCY report
CREIDIT RATING AGENCY report
 
Credit: Principles and Sources
Credit: Principles and SourcesCredit: Principles and Sources
Credit: Principles and Sources
 

Viewers also liked

Viewers also liked (20)

Antartida
AntartidaAntartida
Antartida
 
Energia nuclear a debate
Energia nuclear a debateEnergia nuclear a debate
Energia nuclear a debate
 
La BúSqueda Perfecta
La BúSqueda PerfectaLa BúSqueda Perfecta
La BúSqueda Perfecta
 
Juan Carrasco_Energía: Una visión sobre los retos y oportunidades en América ...
Juan Carrasco_Energía: Una visión sobre los retos y oportunidades en América ...Juan Carrasco_Energía: Una visión sobre los retos y oportunidades en América ...
Juan Carrasco_Energía: Una visión sobre los retos y oportunidades en América ...
 
Hid Aysen Pro Cont 1
Hid Aysen Pro Cont 1Hid Aysen Pro Cont 1
Hid Aysen Pro Cont 1
 
Presentazione monitoraggio nazionale e regionale
Presentazione monitoraggio nazionale e regionalePresentazione monitoraggio nazionale e regionale
Presentazione monitoraggio nazionale e regionale
 
Tras subida al pascua lama
Tras subida al pascua lamaTras subida al pascua lama
Tras subida al pascua lama
 
RAIGAME nº11
RAIGAME nº11RAIGAME nº11
RAIGAME nº11
 
Tanz fertig
Tanz fertigTanz fertig
Tanz fertig
 
Felicitación de Navidad 2013
Felicitación de Navidad 2013Felicitación de Navidad 2013
Felicitación de Navidad 2013
 
Flawsome Trendi
Flawsome TrendiFlawsome Trendi
Flawsome Trendi
 
Introduccion reactoresnucleares
Introduccion reactoresnuclearesIntroduccion reactoresnucleares
Introduccion reactoresnucleares
 
Burçinbudakoğlu
BurçinbudakoğluBurçinbudakoğlu
Burçinbudakoğlu
 
Lead bulgaria
Lead bulgariaLead bulgaria
Lead bulgaria
 
Proposal Kegiatan
Proposal KegiatanProposal Kegiatan
Proposal Kegiatan
 
8 Mart 2010 Tfl
8 Mart 2010 Tfl8 Mart 2010 Tfl
8 Mart 2010 Tfl
 
Eures presentation
Eures presentationEures presentation
Eures presentation
 
Video
VideoVideo
Video
 
Ideate. yessica alejandra helgueros anaya
Ideate.  yessica alejandra helgueros anayaIdeate.  yessica alejandra helgueros anaya
Ideate. yessica alejandra helgueros anaya
 
Sfe58u
Sfe58uSfe58u
Sfe58u
 

Similar to Sample1

imapct of financial crisis and role of financial institutions in this crisis
imapct of financial crisis and role of financial institutions in this crisisimapct of financial crisis and role of financial institutions in this crisis
imapct of financial crisis and role of financial institutions in this crisisRanjith Reddy
 
ACCION USA Partner Training
ACCION USA Partner TrainingACCION USA Partner Training
ACCION USA Partner TrainingACCION East
 
Ebook1ntrgudprimer2015 2
Ebook1ntrgudprimer2015 2Ebook1ntrgudprimer2015 2
Ebook1ntrgudprimer2015 2Greg Washington
 
Investor welcome guide 2018
Investor welcome guide 2018Investor welcome guide 2018
Investor welcome guide 2018PeterBenson26
 
SPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docx
SPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docxSPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docx
SPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docxsusanschei
 
SPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docx
SPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docxSPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docx
SPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docxwilliame8
 
UNIT 1 FINANCIAL CREDIT RISK ANALYTICS (1).pptx
UNIT 1    FINANCIAL CREDIT RISK ANALYTICS (1).pptxUNIT 1    FINANCIAL CREDIT RISK ANALYTICS (1).pptx
UNIT 1 FINANCIAL CREDIT RISK ANALYTICS (1).pptxVikash Barnwal
 
Guide to Investment Crowdfunding Regulations in Canada 2018 - Katipult Webinar
Guide to Investment Crowdfunding Regulations in Canada 2018 - Katipult WebinarGuide to Investment Crowdfunding Regulations in Canada 2018 - Katipult Webinar
Guide to Investment Crowdfunding Regulations in Canada 2018 - Katipult WebinarAlixe Cormick
 
Crowdfunding and it’s benefit for funding real estate 1 [autosaved]
Crowdfunding  and it’s benefit for funding real estate 1 [autosaved]Crowdfunding  and it’s benefit for funding real estate 1 [autosaved]
Crowdfunding and it’s benefit for funding real estate 1 [autosaved]Eddie Edwards
 
Pyatt Broadmark Real Estate Fund I Presentation Oct 2015
Pyatt Broadmark Real Estate Fund I Presentation Oct 2015Pyatt Broadmark Real Estate Fund I Presentation Oct 2015
Pyatt Broadmark Real Estate Fund I Presentation Oct 2015Alan Chu
 
Factor affecting the size of investment in receivables
Factor affecting the size of investment in receivablesFactor affecting the size of investment in receivables
Factor affecting the size of investment in receivablesMohit Garg
 
Picking Up The Pieces: Rebuilding Your Credit After Financial Disaster
Picking Up The Pieces: Rebuilding Your Credit After Financial DisasterPicking Up The Pieces: Rebuilding Your Credit After Financial Disaster
Picking Up The Pieces: Rebuilding Your Credit After Financial DisasterCurtis Rose
 

Similar to Sample1 (20)

imapct of financial crisis and role of financial institutions in this crisis
imapct of financial crisis and role of financial institutions in this crisisimapct of financial crisis and role of financial institutions in this crisis
imapct of financial crisis and role of financial institutions in this crisis
 
Bank of new york
Bank of new yorkBank of new york
Bank of new york
 
Brochure 2
Brochure 2Brochure 2
Brochure 2
 
ACCION USA Partner Training
ACCION USA Partner TrainingACCION USA Partner Training
ACCION USA Partner Training
 
Ebook1ntrgudprimer2015 2
Ebook1ntrgudprimer2015 2Ebook1ntrgudprimer2015 2
Ebook1ntrgudprimer2015 2
 
Investor welcome guide 2018
Investor welcome guide 2018Investor welcome guide 2018
Investor welcome guide 2018
 
SPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docx
SPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docxSPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docx
SPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docx
 
2010 Us Real Estate Outlook
2010   Us Real Estate Outlook2010   Us Real Estate Outlook
2010 Us Real Estate Outlook
 
SPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docx
SPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docxSPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docx
SPM 4723 Annotated Bibliography You second major proje.docx
 
WHAT IS A BANK, CLASSIFY AND DISCUSS BANKS.
WHAT IS A BANK, CLASSIFY AND DISCUSS BANKS.WHAT IS A BANK, CLASSIFY AND DISCUSS BANKS.
WHAT IS A BANK, CLASSIFY AND DISCUSS BANKS.
 
UNIT 1 FINANCIAL CREDIT RISK ANALYTICS (1).pptx
UNIT 1    FINANCIAL CREDIT RISK ANALYTICS (1).pptxUNIT 1    FINANCIAL CREDIT RISK ANALYTICS (1).pptx
UNIT 1 FINANCIAL CREDIT RISK ANALYTICS (1).pptx
 
Guide to Investment Crowdfunding Regulations in Canada 2018 - Katipult Webinar
Guide to Investment Crowdfunding Regulations in Canada 2018 - Katipult WebinarGuide to Investment Crowdfunding Regulations in Canada 2018 - Katipult Webinar
Guide to Investment Crowdfunding Regulations in Canada 2018 - Katipult Webinar
 
Crowdfunding and it’s benefit for funding real estate 1 [autosaved]
Crowdfunding  and it’s benefit for funding real estate 1 [autosaved]Crowdfunding  and it’s benefit for funding real estate 1 [autosaved]
Crowdfunding and it’s benefit for funding real estate 1 [autosaved]
 
Pyatt Broadmark Real Estate Fund I Presentation Oct 2015
Pyatt Broadmark Real Estate Fund I Presentation Oct 2015Pyatt Broadmark Real Estate Fund I Presentation Oct 2015
Pyatt Broadmark Real Estate Fund I Presentation Oct 2015
 
102 credit
102 credit102 credit
102 credit
 
Stocks And Bonds
Stocks And BondsStocks And Bonds
Stocks And Bonds
 
Factor affecting the size of investment in receivables
Factor affecting the size of investment in receivablesFactor affecting the size of investment in receivables
Factor affecting the size of investment in receivables
 
Philadelphia cafr presentation
Philadelphia cafr presentationPhiladelphia cafr presentation
Philadelphia cafr presentation
 
Picking Up The Pieces: Rebuilding Your Credit After Financial Disaster
Picking Up The Pieces: Rebuilding Your Credit After Financial DisasterPicking Up The Pieces: Rebuilding Your Credit After Financial Disaster
Picking Up The Pieces: Rebuilding Your Credit After Financial Disaster
 
Ec agent training
Ec agent trainingEc agent training
Ec agent training
 

Sample1

  • 1. IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC To: Mr. XXXX XXXXXX Re: Investigative Reporting – Bank of America Investment Account Dear Mr. XXXXXXXX, Insight Consultants and Advisors, LLC has completed reviewing your account documentation that you have provided and have performed the accounting and research to come up with the following: • Your account has suffered a cumulative loss since inception of $219,542 equal to a 36% loss on a starting balance of $609,801 • Your annualized loss is 16.61% (unrealized) derived from February 28, 2007 through April 30, 2009 • To reach your original invested amount of $609,801 your account will need to generate the following returns over the corresponding periods of time: o 8.50 years at 6% compounded return o 6.50 years at 8% compounded return o 5.40 years at 10% compounded return o 4.70 years at 12% compounded return o 3.80 years at 15% compounded return o 2.80 years at 20% compounded return o 2.40 years at 25% compounded return Based on our interviews with you and your preference for conservative no risk investments, and taking into account the current interest rate environment, a number of approximately 3.25% (pre-tax) would be the comparative number using the current yield on the 10 year Treasury Note. After reviewing the emails between yourself and your representative, the actual purchases, amounts and types of products purchased, there are several points of concern that we would like to point your attention to.
  • 2. IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC Background Summary and Narrative All assumptions contained within this summary are based upon information provided by Mr. XXXXXX during interviews with Insight Consultants and Advisors, LLC during the months of April 2009 and May 2009. All figures are based on account statements, correspondence and other documentation provided by Mr. XXXXXXX. In 2007, Mr. XXXXXXX was solicited by Premier Banking Services at Bank of America to begin an all encompassing banking relationship with money that he had recently come into from the operation of his business. Mr. XXXXXXX was solicited to transfer his money from his current FDIC Insured checking and savings accounts into a brokerage account held at Banc of America Investment Services, Inc. This was done in January of 2007 when Mr. XXXXXXX began a relationship with Mr. XXXXXXXX, Vice President of Investments. Up to this point, Mr. XXXXXXX has stated that he had never invested in equity or bond markets at any time and has never owned stocks, bonds, mutual funds or any other type of investments outside of his employer retirement plan. Mr. XXXXXX has stated in interviews with Insight that he specifically told his representative that he wanted a “no-risk, interest bearing account, such as a CD or Money Market account.” He further stated that he could have placed his money in a Lebanese Bank and received between 7% and 8% APY on his funds but was willing to take less to have the money in the United States with a large banking institution. Beginning in February 28, 2007 and ending May 8th , 2007 the following purchases occurred in Mr. XXXXXXX’ account: Citigroup Capital Trust XVII Preferred e $ 209,800 First Trust Closed End Municipal Unit Investment Trust $ 200,001 First Trust Dividend Income Unit Investment Trust $ 100,000 Eaton Vance Large Cap Growth, Class B share $ 25,000 Goldman Sachs Equity Growth Portfolio, Class A share $ 75,000
  • 3. IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC During the period of January 2007 and April 2009, Mr. XXXXXXX’ accounts suffered principal losses, inclusive of dividends earned and reinvested, in the amount of $219,542. During the same period, Mr. XXXXXXX’ presumed interest, not earned, (using Banc of America Investment Services Money Market average effective 7 day yield throughout) was equal to $43,193. This brings the total losses inclusive of opportunity costs $262,734. It is important to note that these numbers are also net of the market recovery that has occurred since the lows set on March 9th , 2009. In fact Mr. XXXXXXX’ account’s low point based on statements provided by Banc of America Invest Services, Inc. and not inclusive of opportunity costs was $274,720 or a cumulative stated loss of 45.05%.
  • 4. IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC Sampled Supporting Documentation The investment vehicles that were placed into Mr. XXXXXXX’ account; were subsequently questioned by Mr. XXXXXXX in email form, addressed to Mr. XXXXXXX commencing on May 18, 2007. Sent: Friday, May 18, 2007 4:47 AM To: XXXXXXX@bankofamerica.com Attachments: Hi XXXXXX, I noticed that the value of the account is decreasing. I thought the money is placed in a 6% or so earning mode. If it loses value, what is the meaning of the 6% number here? XXXXX. Based on the email documentation provided by Mr. XXXXXXX, there was neither a verbal or written response provided with an answer to his questions about his holdings at this time. Subsequent emails sent by Mr. XXXXXXX follow a similar theme with even more fearful and specific questions to Mr. XXXXX regarding his account: Sent: Friday, June 08, 2007 10:41 AM To: XXXXXX@bankofamerica.com Attachments: Hi XXXXX, I have sent you a couple of email asking for clarifications about the account and still have not heard back. The account is quickly losing money and I would like to understand how the whole thing works. Specifically, I would like to understand how the quoted 6% interest comes into play, and what the chance are that the account loses money over a year's period. If I don't hear back from you soon, I would be inclined to withdraw the money and place it in a more secure place. Please answer as soon as possible.Thanks,
  • 5. IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC Furthermore, Mr. XXXXXXX goes on to state to Mr. Dowd that he is gravely concerned about fluctuation, loss of principal and the guarantees he was presented with by his Mr. XXXX: “….however, the size of these fluctuations has reached 3.5% in the downturn in less than 3 days and there is no guarantee that it would turn around. I have a couple of specific questions that I would like answered: 1- If the account pays 6%, when should I expect these payments to occur? 2- What happens if I decide to withdraw the money before the payment is due? Do I still get any interest payment? 3- Is it possible for the account to lose money over a year's time counting fluctuation and interest payment together. As you know, I am interested in the least amount of risk for this first batch of money. If there is a likelyhood that a significant amount of it gets lost, I would be inclined to remove it from the brokerage account.” (June 8 th , 2007, 11:26a.m.) see attached
  • 6. IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC Areas of Concern and Statements of Fact: • Account Opening Profile and any subsequent changes are imperative to determine Investment Suitability, Risk Level, Time Horizon and Investment Experience o Request Copies of all Account Opening Documentation and any profile updates for comparison • Money was transferred from FDIC Insured accounts into Non-FDIC Insured, non-guaranteed brokerage account under the assumption of a fixed 6% APY return. o It is important to note that Mr. XXXXXXX’ account did not even contain an FDIC option, which is available for his cash reserves. • Correspondence between Mr. XXXXXXX and Mr. XXXXX went unanswered numerous times and specific investment related questions were not answered for periods up to three weeks. Market volatility at that time dictates prompt, immediate response to clients. Representative also appears to have sent unapproved correspondence to Mr. XXXXXXX. o Possible negligence on representative’s behalf in not forwarding what could be construed as written client complaint to immediate OSJ o Representative provided unapproved email correspondence that contained unapproved market commentary and a representation that “The federal reserve meets next week, and I am expecting some relief from this sell off then. There is no guarantee we will get it, but I do expect to see prices rally back after their meeting. (June13, 209:46 a.m.) see attached • Possible Faliure to Supervise by OSJ should be looked into o Request Copies of Incoming and Outgoing Correspondence logs from Representative and compare to OSJ files o Request Verbal and Written Complaint files for same • Income style investments were presented as bonds (see email) when in fact no bonds exist in portfolio
  • 7. IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC • Role of Principal transactions, markups, commissions, fees, loads and Deferred Sales Charges, never disclosed to client, even when multiple, specific requests are made by client. Commissions in excess of $20,000 believed to have occurred. o Possible misrepresentation and non use of proper disclosures • Questionable Mutual fund buys by representative o Growth-oriented, non income producing investments purchased o Did not utilize letter of intent, Rights of Accumulation, or maximize breakpoints available to client o $75,000 Goldman Sachs A share purchased with load – not disclosed o $25,000 Same Day purchase of B share mutual fund – surrender charges not disclosed o Different Fund Families utilized to increase commission for representative • Expenses on Unit Investment Trusts not explained or disclosed, approximate expenses of 5% including load per share and deferred sales charges (see attached) • Longer term, illiquid, higher commissioned products chosen versus alternatives available • Client specifically demands instruction on how to close account, no further orders to be placed without specific direction of Mr. XXXXXXX suggests discretionary abuse in past purchases • Even after wanting to close account, demanding explanations, client never received a Supervisory call • Failure to disclose that Citigroup Capital Trust XVII is not a bond, nor a direct preferred of Citigroup, thus leaving Mr. Kyriakos unprotected as a bond holder would be, should company default or declare bankruptcy • Mr. XXXXXXX has never before invested in stock markets of any kind prior to account opening • Representative shows client dispute on U4 in past
  • 8. IINNSSIIGGHHTT CCOONNSSUULLTTAANNTTSS AANNDD AADDVVIISSOORRSS,, LLLLCC Conclusion It is the opinion formed from this information, of Insight Consultants and Advisors, LLC that multiple instances of product misrepresentation occurred in Mr. XXXXXXX’ account held at Banc of America Investment Services, Inc. It is also our opinion that a Failure to Supervise by the OSJ occurred throughout the duration of the account and should be investigated further. It is also our opinion that numerous incidents regarding expenses, commissions, mark-ups and general product purchases occurred at a severe disservice to Mr. XXXXXXX and should be investigated further. It is also our opinion that transactions occurred in an unauthorized manner on behalf of the client without proper discretionary agreements in place and should be investigated as well. Lastly, the disregard for a client’s written, multiple and specific questions during a time of severe market volatility presents a possible negligent breach of fiduciary responsibility and should be included in any future action pursued on behalf of Mr. XXXXXXX. Adam J. Allison, Managing Member Insight Consultants and Advisors, LLC Todd M. Lawrence, Managing Member, Insight Consultants and Advisors, LLC Enclosures Attached