Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
04.24.2020
How PCB Design Choices Affect Overall
Cost From Your PCB Fabricator
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
2
Agenda
 Intro – HDI PCBs
 Via Types – How they are made
 Filled Vias – It’s more complicated than it looks
 Castellated Edges/Half Plated Holes
 Cavities, Air Pockets, and Heat Sinks
 Hybrids – PCBs with mixed dielectrics
 Materials – Type and other factors
 Inspection AS9100 – What it takes
 Summary
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
3
HDI Printed Circuit Boards
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
4
HDI – High Density Interconnect PCB
 HDI is a PCB with a higher wiring density
per area, finer lines and spacing, smaller
vias, higher aspect ratios, and pads than
conventional PCBs.
 HDI boards contain blind and/or buried
vias and often contain microvias of
0.006” or less in diameter.
 To produce HDI boards, investment in
laser direct imaging, laser drilling,
vacuum controlled pressure plugging,
alkaline permanganate desmear, and
advanced planarization equipment is a
must.
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
5
Via Types
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
6
Via Types
 Need Laser Drilling Equipment to accurately control the depth of the
hole with such a small diameter.
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
7
Via – Definitions
 IPC definition of a microvia = a hole with an aspect ratio of 1:1
– They usually are:
1. Filled with epoxy resin (b-stage) during a sequential lamination process step.
2. Filled with non-conductive or conductive material other than copper as a
separate processing step.
3. Plated closed with electroplated copper.
4. Screen printed closed with a copper paste.
 A stacked microvia is usually filled with electroplated copper to make
electrical interconnections between multiple HDI layers and provide
structural support for the outer level(s) of the microvia or for a
component mounted on the outermost copper pad.
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
8
Lamination Cycles
Every buried or
stacked via requires
a lamination cycle.
Think Delivery…
75% Processes Every Time
2
Hours
1
Hour
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
9
Blind and Buried Vias
 It’s all about lamination and plating cycles.
 6 Layer Example:
– Each Cycle Requires
• Drill & Hole Prep
• Plate
• Deburr
• Via Fill
• Image/Etch/AOI
• Repeat
– Standard 6 Layer
• Image/Etch/AOI (A)
• Laminate
• Drill
1
2
2
3
A
A
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
10
Blind versus Buried
 3 sets of blind vias
 Only one lamination cycle
 Control depth laser drill
 One exception
– Dissimilar laminates
 Buried, staggered, or stacked vias
all require more lamination cycles.
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
11
Filled Vias
 It’s more complicated than you think…
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
12
Old School
 Many companies still use these
methods today.
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
13
Processes Needed – 3 ways
 Drilling of only the vias that
need filling
 Cleaning: plasma and brushing
 Electroless copper
 Apply dry resist
 Imaging of ONLY the via holes
 Electrolytic plating
 Strip dry resist
 Baking: 150°C for 2 hours
 Via plugging with resin
 Baking: 150°C for 1.5 hours
 Planarize the panel
 Drilling the remainder of the
holes
 Cleaning: plasma and brushing
 Electroless copper
 Apply dry resist
 Imaging of ONLY the via holes
 Electrolytic plating
 Drilling of all vias
 Cleaning: plasma and brushing
 Electroless copper
 Electrolytic plating
 Baking: 150°C for 2 hours
 Build a fixture so to only fill the
holes that need filling
 Via plugging with resin
 Baking: 150°C for 1.5 hours
 Planarize the panel
 Electroless copper
 Apply dry resist
 Imaging of the circuitry
 Electrolytic plating
 Drilling of all vias
 Cleaning: plasma and brushing
 Electroless copper
 Electrolytic plating
 Baking: 150°C for 2 hours
 Fluid nozzle fill of only the
holes – Requires CNC
programming
 Via plugging with resin
 Baking: 150°C for 1.5 hours
 Planarize the panel
 Electroless copper
 Apply dry resist
 Imaging of the circuitry
 Electrolytic plating
 All 3 add at least 6-8 hours
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
14
Proper Filled Vias
 >10 mil vias – Easy to Fill
 <10 mil vias – Easier to Plate Shut
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
15
Castellated Edges/Half Plated Holes
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
16
Castellated Edges/Half Plated Holes
 The process is very specialized, and
everyone thinks that they have a secret
sauce.
 Pre-Plate Route
 Feeds and Speeds
 Tool Sharpness
 Customers need to specify what is
acceptable.
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
17
What happens if you try and go cheap?
 You can’t just plate a standard PTH and then try and mechanically
rout through the plating or this happens.
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
18
Cavities, Air Pockets, and Heat Sinks
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
19
 Required tight tolerance machining
 Traditional PCB CNC equipment is
not suitable for controlled depth
tight tolerance machining.
 OR – no flow pre-preg, which
requires intricate machining
 How to help?
– Specify a radius
– Minimize 90% edges on internal
features
Cavities and Air Pockets
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
20
Heat Sinks
 Heat sink made separate
 Attach using no flow precut prepreg
 Need a lamination press
 How to help?
– Work with your fabricator when
choosing the type of prepreg to be
used
– Make sure that your heat sink and
your PCB laminate can withstand
the temperature of lamination
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
21
Hybrid PCBs
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
22
Hybrid PCBs
 2 different materials in the same stack-up.
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
23
Materials
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
24
Materials
 Many Choices
– FR-4 (Epoxy)
– PTFE
– Ceramic
– Polyimide
– PTFE/Glass
– Hydrocarbon/Ceramic
– High Temp FR-4
– FR-4/Phenolic
 Copper Weight
 Weave Type
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
25
IPC-4101 – Slash Sheet
 Gives your fabricator flexibility
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
26
Inspection AS9100
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
27
AS9100 Inspection - Bubble Drawing
Is it really needed?
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
28
AS9100 Inspection
 InspectionXpert Software
 Balloon your part drawings and extract the characteristics in one step.
Your tolerances are automatically applied, and the spec limits are
calculated.
 Reduces time and cost to complete AS9100 reports and improves
accuracy.
 Import the CMM data into a project and have the measurement results
auto-assign to the corresponding feature. Then publish the data
directly to your inspection report.
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
29
A few more things to know….
 Teflon – Drill hit counts reduce 50% (additional cost)
 PTFE – Needs to be in press soon after etch (can’t sit overnight)
 ENEPIG – Most fabricators outsource this (adds time)
– Very expensive and plates out without enough use
 Embedded Resistors – Bigger is better for tolerance
– 25 Ohm material – with a +/-1 mil etch tolerance
• 10 mil x 10 mil: 9/11 x 25 = 20.45 Ohms
• 100 mil x 100 mil: 99/101 x 25 = 24.8 Ohms
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
30
Summary
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
31
Summary
 Design choices factor into the cost and
delivery of PCBs.
 Not all vias are the same.
 Material choices – anything just not
everything
 When delivery is paramount – can you
make it easier.
 Working with your fabricator EARLY is
critical in meeting all your cost and
delivery targets.
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
32
Upcoming Webinars
 Go to…
https://www.epectec.com/webinar/
– May 29th
• Do You Really Need Lithium or Will
Nickel Metal Hydride Suffice?
– August – TBD
– November 20th
• Reducing Risk in Your Custom
Cable Assembly
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
33
Our Products
Battery Packs Flex & Rigid-Flex PCBs Cable Assemblies Printed Circuit Boards
RF Products User Interfaces Flexible Heaters EC Fans & Motors
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
34
Q&A
 Questions?
– Enter any questions you may have
in the Control Panel
– If we don’t have time to get to it, we
will reply via email
Manufacturing That Eliminates Risk & Improves Reliability
35
Thank You
Check out our website at www.epectec.com.
For more information email sales@epectec.com.
Stay Connected with Epec Engineered Technologies
Follow us on our social media sites for continuous technical updates and information:

How PCB Design Choices Affect Overall Cost from Your PCB Fabricator

  • 1.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 04.24.2020 How PCB Design Choices Affect Overall Cost From Your PCB Fabricator
  • 2.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 2 Agenda  Intro – HDI PCBs  Via Types – How they are made  Filled Vias – It’s more complicated than it looks  Castellated Edges/Half Plated Holes  Cavities, Air Pockets, and Heat Sinks  Hybrids – PCBs with mixed dielectrics  Materials – Type and other factors  Inspection AS9100 – What it takes  Summary
  • 3.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 3 HDI Printed Circuit Boards
  • 4.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 4 HDI – High Density Interconnect PCB  HDI is a PCB with a higher wiring density per area, finer lines and spacing, smaller vias, higher aspect ratios, and pads than conventional PCBs.  HDI boards contain blind and/or buried vias and often contain microvias of 0.006” or less in diameter.  To produce HDI boards, investment in laser direct imaging, laser drilling, vacuum controlled pressure plugging, alkaline permanganate desmear, and advanced planarization equipment is a must.
  • 5.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 5 Via Types
  • 6.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 6 Via Types  Need Laser Drilling Equipment to accurately control the depth of the hole with such a small diameter.
  • 7.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 7 Via – Definitions  IPC definition of a microvia = a hole with an aspect ratio of 1:1 – They usually are: 1. Filled with epoxy resin (b-stage) during a sequential lamination process step. 2. Filled with non-conductive or conductive material other than copper as a separate processing step. 3. Plated closed with electroplated copper. 4. Screen printed closed with a copper paste.  A stacked microvia is usually filled with electroplated copper to make electrical interconnections between multiple HDI layers and provide structural support for the outer level(s) of the microvia or for a component mounted on the outermost copper pad.
  • 8.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 8 Lamination Cycles Every buried or stacked via requires a lamination cycle. Think Delivery… 75% Processes Every Time 2 Hours 1 Hour
  • 9.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 9 Blind and Buried Vias  It’s all about lamination and plating cycles.  6 Layer Example: – Each Cycle Requires • Drill & Hole Prep • Plate • Deburr • Via Fill • Image/Etch/AOI • Repeat – Standard 6 Layer • Image/Etch/AOI (A) • Laminate • Drill 1 2 2 3 A A
  • 10.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 10 Blind versus Buried  3 sets of blind vias  Only one lamination cycle  Control depth laser drill  One exception – Dissimilar laminates  Buried, staggered, or stacked vias all require more lamination cycles.
  • 11.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 11 Filled Vias  It’s more complicated than you think…
  • 12.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 12 Old School  Many companies still use these methods today.
  • 13.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 13 Processes Needed – 3 ways  Drilling of only the vias that need filling  Cleaning: plasma and brushing  Electroless copper  Apply dry resist  Imaging of ONLY the via holes  Electrolytic plating  Strip dry resist  Baking: 150°C for 2 hours  Via plugging with resin  Baking: 150°C for 1.5 hours  Planarize the panel  Drilling the remainder of the holes  Cleaning: plasma and brushing  Electroless copper  Apply dry resist  Imaging of ONLY the via holes  Electrolytic plating  Drilling of all vias  Cleaning: plasma and brushing  Electroless copper  Electrolytic plating  Baking: 150°C for 2 hours  Build a fixture so to only fill the holes that need filling  Via plugging with resin  Baking: 150°C for 1.5 hours  Planarize the panel  Electroless copper  Apply dry resist  Imaging of the circuitry  Electrolytic plating  Drilling of all vias  Cleaning: plasma and brushing  Electroless copper  Electrolytic plating  Baking: 150°C for 2 hours  Fluid nozzle fill of only the holes – Requires CNC programming  Via plugging with resin  Baking: 150°C for 1.5 hours  Planarize the panel  Electroless copper  Apply dry resist  Imaging of the circuitry  Electrolytic plating  All 3 add at least 6-8 hours
  • 14.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 14 Proper Filled Vias  >10 mil vias – Easy to Fill  <10 mil vias – Easier to Plate Shut
  • 15.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 15 Castellated Edges/Half Plated Holes
  • 16.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 16 Castellated Edges/Half Plated Holes  The process is very specialized, and everyone thinks that they have a secret sauce.  Pre-Plate Route  Feeds and Speeds  Tool Sharpness  Customers need to specify what is acceptable.
  • 17.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 17 What happens if you try and go cheap?  You can’t just plate a standard PTH and then try and mechanically rout through the plating or this happens.
  • 18.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 18 Cavities, Air Pockets, and Heat Sinks
  • 19.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 19  Required tight tolerance machining  Traditional PCB CNC equipment is not suitable for controlled depth tight tolerance machining.  OR – no flow pre-preg, which requires intricate machining  How to help? – Specify a radius – Minimize 90% edges on internal features Cavities and Air Pockets
  • 20.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 20 Heat Sinks  Heat sink made separate  Attach using no flow precut prepreg  Need a lamination press  How to help? – Work with your fabricator when choosing the type of prepreg to be used – Make sure that your heat sink and your PCB laminate can withstand the temperature of lamination
  • 21.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 21 Hybrid PCBs
  • 22.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 22 Hybrid PCBs  2 different materials in the same stack-up.
  • 23.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 23 Materials
  • 24.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 24 Materials  Many Choices – FR-4 (Epoxy) – PTFE – Ceramic – Polyimide – PTFE/Glass – Hydrocarbon/Ceramic – High Temp FR-4 – FR-4/Phenolic  Copper Weight  Weave Type
  • 25.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 25 IPC-4101 – Slash Sheet  Gives your fabricator flexibility
  • 26.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 26 Inspection AS9100
  • 27.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 27 AS9100 Inspection - Bubble Drawing Is it really needed?
  • 28.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 28 AS9100 Inspection  InspectionXpert Software  Balloon your part drawings and extract the characteristics in one step. Your tolerances are automatically applied, and the spec limits are calculated.  Reduces time and cost to complete AS9100 reports and improves accuracy.  Import the CMM data into a project and have the measurement results auto-assign to the corresponding feature. Then publish the data directly to your inspection report.
  • 29.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 29 A few more things to know….  Teflon – Drill hit counts reduce 50% (additional cost)  PTFE – Needs to be in press soon after etch (can’t sit overnight)  ENEPIG – Most fabricators outsource this (adds time) – Very expensive and plates out without enough use  Embedded Resistors – Bigger is better for tolerance – 25 Ohm material – with a +/-1 mil etch tolerance • 10 mil x 10 mil: 9/11 x 25 = 20.45 Ohms • 100 mil x 100 mil: 99/101 x 25 = 24.8 Ohms
  • 30.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 30 Summary
  • 31.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 31 Summary  Design choices factor into the cost and delivery of PCBs.  Not all vias are the same.  Material choices – anything just not everything  When delivery is paramount – can you make it easier.  Working with your fabricator EARLY is critical in meeting all your cost and delivery targets.
  • 32.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 32 Upcoming Webinars  Go to… https://www.epectec.com/webinar/ – May 29th • Do You Really Need Lithium or Will Nickel Metal Hydride Suffice? – August – TBD – November 20th • Reducing Risk in Your Custom Cable Assembly
  • 33.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 33 Our Products Battery Packs Flex & Rigid-Flex PCBs Cable Assemblies Printed Circuit Boards RF Products User Interfaces Flexible Heaters EC Fans & Motors
  • 34.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 34 Q&A  Questions? – Enter any questions you may have in the Control Panel – If we don’t have time to get to it, we will reply via email
  • 35.
    Manufacturing That EliminatesRisk & Improves Reliability 35 Thank You Check out our website at www.epectec.com. For more information email sales@epectec.com. Stay Connected with Epec Engineered Technologies Follow us on our social media sites for continuous technical updates and information: