SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 282
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670
This Leadership Development Plan serves as your road map for
training and development activities that will enhance your
leadership competencies. As you approach the end of your MBA
program reflect on your continuing career goals, the skills you
will need to achieve them, and the influence you would like to
have on your organization.
Your name: Your current job title
Career Goal Make sure your goal is SMART: specific,
measurable, achievable, realistic, and time-bound.
[Write a response of no more than 100 words here.]
Skills Development Needs
What are the constraints in your skills, knowledge, and
experience from the viewpoint of improving your organization’s
performance?
[Write a response of no more than 200 words here.]
How can you enhance your skills, knowledge, and experience to
influence changes in your organization?
[Write a response of no more than 200 words here.]
Personal Impact on Organization Performance
How can you personally influence one or more performance
measures in your organization?
[Write a response of no more than 200 words here.]
What role can you play to enhance the level of trust necessary
for strategic changes in your organization?
[Write a response of no more than 200 words here.]
Print this page, then sign and date the hard copy.Signature
_____________________Date _______________
What are examples of ethical climates in the accounting
discipline?
· Continuing education requirements for certified accountants -
state specific licensures and rules
· Certified Managerial Accounting - standards
· CMA Code of Conduct
· IMA Code of Conduct
· Auditing practices
· AICPA - Code of Conduct
· Internal Auditing practices
· Government regulations - SOX
· Climates to prevent insider trading
· Cultural influences to ethical climates in accounting
International Management Review Vol. 12 No. 2 2016
56
The Marketer’s Action Plan (MAP): Six Steps to Developing
Effective
Marketing Plans in B2B Marketing Programs
Eric Gagnon
The Business Marketing Institute, Chicago, IL 60610 USA
Business-to-business marketing professionals are always
interested in finding better tools to help them
create marketing plans that generate better, and more
measurable, response. In our BMI online CRM Field
Marketing (CRM-FM) training and certification program, we’ve
developed the Marketer’s Action Plan
(MAP), a step-by-step process for helping you plan, develop,
execute, measure, and adapt any marketing
activity. While intended for use with CRM systems, where
measurement of marketing programs (also
known as "campaigns" in most CRM systems) is made far easier
by tracking them within CRM, you don’t
need to use a CRM system to implement this process in any
marketing plan.
Even better, the Marketer’s Action Plan can be used for any
marketing activity that is part of your
overall marketing program—from print advertising, to direct
mail, trade shows, or online-based marketing
activities. The MAP helps you develop an organized mindset for
solid execution, and a discipline for
measurement in every marketing project you develop for your
company or client.
The Marketer’s Action Plan (MAP) describes the six stages in
the process of marketing execution using
on-demand CRM to plan, execute, measure, monitor, and
improve your marketing plan. This action plan
describes both the general execution steps required to develop
and execute any type of marketing project
as a campaign in your CRM system, and the actions required
over the process of the campaign to insure
that leads are properly tracked and measured for a campaign,
and then moved along into your lead
development program, where diligent coordination between you
and your sales team helps to convert as
many of these prospects into customers, over the length of your
sales cycle. This action plan also accounts
for the all-important final step of assessing and improving poor
sales response for a campaign which is
likely to occur during implementation of your marketing
program.
Steps in the MAP Process
Using MAP, the planning, execution, and management stages
for any individual marketing activity can be
broken down into six action steps for any marketing project
(campaign) in any on-demand CRM system,
as follows:
1) Create Your Plan;
2) Plan for Measurement;
3) Execute;
4) Track, Measure, Monitor, and Assess;
5) Evaluate, Adapt, and Improve;
6) Follow Through
Step 1. Create Your Plan
Marketing is mostly tactical: There are formal marketing plans
and there are informal ones, but for
marketing professionals in the real world, the best plan is a set
of tactical marketing projects (CRM
campaigns) you can develop and put into action immediately to
meet the marketing opportunities that
generate sales response for your company.
After all, when everyone gets up from the table from the
marketing planning meeting, what’s left is a
list of tactical activities that must be executed: Ads, mailings,
trade shows, and the other marketing projects
that must be developed and executed. Each of these tactical
activities is a campaign in your on-demand
CRM system, and the complete schedule of these campaigns
comprises your marketing plan. The MAP
helps you optimize each of these tactical activities for maximum
sales response and measurability.
Define your campaign’s objective: The first action planning
step is to define the objective (or goal) of
the campaign. Nearly always, this can be expressed as a
description of the execution of the marketing
International Management Review Vol. 12 No. 2 2016
57
project (campaign) at hand, tied to the goal to be accomplished
by this project.
For example, the execution of any specific direct mail campaign
is to develop a mailing targeted to
one or more identified mailing list(s), to meet the goal of
generating measurable sales leads for followup
by your company’s sales team; for a trade show, the purpose of
the execution is to draw potential prospects
to your booth at the show, qualify and capture their contact
information, with the goal of generating a
measurable number of leads to be followed up with by your
company’s sales reps after the show.
Define your prospect targeting: Once the objectives have been
established for the campaign, the next
step is to identify the types of individuals your campaign must
reach. This is a process of targeting these
individuals, by job title, purchasing responsibility, trade
publications read, trade shows attended, or some
other means which is identifiable by a marketing medium (trade
publication, trade show, mailing list,
keyword search program, etc.) to identify one or more groups of
potential prospects who might buy your
company’s products.
Just as an experienced sales professional knows how to identify
the most likely buyers at a company
for his or her product, as well as identifying the other
“influencers” who also must be convinced to buy the
product, prospect targeting reduces your market to the universe
of potential buyers who are more likely to
be interested in buying, using, or applying your product than
other individuals in your market.
Some marketing methods, such as direct mail and keyword
search text advertising, can be used to
target the kinds of prospects you want to reach more precisely
than other methods, such as print advertising
or trade shows. For example, if you’re involved in a market test
to determine who your prospect is, your
targeting may be broad; if you know your market, you are better
off targeting prospects as precisely as
possible, since you’re also very likely to know who buys your
company’s products and where they work in
your market.
Sometimes, even if incorrect prospect targeting was the cause of
an underperforming campaign, this
campaign may eventually lead you to better targeting on
subsequent marketing efforts, as you learn, from
the few prospects who did respond to your ad, mailing, or other
campaign, who are the better prospects to
reach with your marketing efforts.
Once defined, prospect targeting then dictates every other
aspect in the development of your marketing
program and its deliverables, such as sales copy, presentation,
positioning, and the promotional offer used
in the campaign. Defining your objectives and your targeting
also helps you to decide on (or confirm) the
best marketing method to use for your campaign.
Planning for lead development: Of course, most products sold in
business-to-business markets are
complex and expensive, which means they often require a fairly
lengthy sales cycle. During this period,
which may span many months (or even a year or more), consider
what happens to a lead after it is generated
by your campaign. If you already have a lead development
program in place, determine whether leads
generated from the campaign you’re planning should flow into
your existing lead development program, or
if prospects who reach you from this campaign are different in
some way (such as their job title or technical
background) that justifies sending them different messaging
deliverables for lead development. Plan ahead
for these changes, so you’ll have the necessary deliverables
(white papers, etc.) developed and ready as
leads arrive from your campaign.
Step 2. Plan for Measurement
After you have defined your objective and your prospect
targeting, give careful thought to how you are
going to measure your campaign. The best and usually the only
worthwhile way to measure a campaign is
sales response: Counting the number of leads who respond to
your ad or mailing, provide their contact
information in your company’s booth at a trade show, or fill in
their e-mail addresses on one of your Web
landing pages in response to your keyword search advertising.
Measuring sales response is only the first step in effective
campaign measurement: Because on-demand
CRM systems allow you to track every new sale all the way
back to the original campaign that generated
the lead which eventually led to the sale, you can also use your
CRM system to track any campaign’s overall
return on investment (ROI); this is one of the most powerful
features of on-demand CRM systems.
International Management Review Vol. 12 No. 2 2016
58
Develop a promotional offer: As you can see, calculating return
on investment in on-demand CRM
campaigns can only happen once sales response is generated,
but another important task at the planning
stage of every campaign as a marketing professional is to
determine not just how prospects will contact
your company, but to develop the means by which they’ll be
motivated to respond. You could rely solely
on the persuasive power of the strong, compelling copy and
benefits used in your ad or mailing to motivate
prospects to contact you, but you can increase your chances of
generating solid sales response by providing
“something extra:” An information premium, promotional offer,
or other “call-to-action” offer that
motivates potential prospects to contact your company sooner
instead of later (which usually means
“never”).
Associating leads to a campaign: Wherever there is a known
universe of potential prospects identified
and in your possession, such as a mailing list, or a list of
selected leads already in your on-demand CRM
database, the next step in planning to measure is linking, or
“associating” these identified potential prospects
to your campaign. By associating these records to the campaign,
you make it easy to match up the prospects
who respond to the campaign to their corresponding linked
record in your CRM system; these matches
count as sales response, which is the first step in measuring a
campaign’s effectiveness and final return on
investment.
The final step in planning for measurement is to insure that
leads received from a campaign will be
captured to your CRM system, either by sales reps or
administrative staff, who receive phone calls, e-mail,
or reply cards from prospects who respond to a campaign, from
trade show contacts, online, or from Web
landing pages on your Web site. This step occurs both during
this stage and during execution of the
campaign in the next stage.
Step 3. Execute
Marketing execution defines all the steps involved in the
process of developing any marketing project.
Marketing execution encompasses both the deliverables
required, like ad layouts, direct mail packages, etc.,
and the critical process of completing every step in the process
involved for every type of campaign.
Execution is the most important part of any marketing project
that is a campaign in your CRM system
and, next to the effective presentation of the deliverables used
in the campaign, poor execution is often a
major cause of failure in a marketing project. Solid, timely
execution that gets your campaign delivered on
time to meet the marketing or sales opportunity is such a
critical aspect of the success of your marketing
program using your company’s CRM system that most of the
content of this workbook is focused on
marketing execution.
The end result of all marketing execution results in completing
your campaign and getting it in front
of the prospects you’ve targeted in your market: Placing your ad
in a trade publication to be received by its
subscribers, dropping your mailing to its recipients, opening
your booth at a trade show, and any other
marketing activity that results in getting your deliverables in
front of your potential prospects completes its
execution and moves your action plan to the next stage.
Step 4. Track, Measure, Monitor, and Assess
Once the campaign is executed, the process of inputting or
capturing leads to your on-demand CRM
system takes place. Contact information for a lead is captured
by phone, e-mail, Web, or mailed-in reply
cards, and matched to their associated record in the CRM
campaign or, if a new lead, input or imported to
your CRM leads database.
Useful measurement of marketing programs in an on-demand
CRM system begins with accurate,
diligent logging of leads generated to the CRM campaign
responsible for generating the lead. At this stage,
by carefully monitoring this process as leads are input,
imported, and/or matched to existing leads
associated to a campaign in your company’s CRM system, you
can insure that all generated leads are linked
to the campaign that created them. Once a lead can be linked to
a campaign, the sales response of that
campaign can be measured. If as many generated leads as
possible can be precisely linked to this campaign,
the more accurate its final measurement will be.
International Management Review Vol. 12 No. 2 2016
59
As leads arrive in response to a campaign, over time you can
begin to assess the performance of the
campaign, using the measurement criteria you established in the
previous step 2.). You will usually be able
to get a fairly good early indication of how much sales response
is generated by the campaign over the first
couple of weeks, and you can determine the total sales response
to most marketing activities (i.e., number
of initial leads generated from that campaign) well within 60
days of the date the first leads responded to
that campaign.
Step 5. Evaluate, Adapt, and Improve
Over time, and as most of the sales response is generated by the
campaign, you can now more
accurately project its final sales response, and get an early
indication of its financial return. Since sales
cycles for B2B products often go for many months between the
time a lead is generated and before the
prospect decides to buy, it may be difficult for you to calculate
an accurate, final return on investment for a
campaign, but you can determine the reasonably accurate final
sales response (number of leads generated,
and cost-per-inquiry) for a campaign after a few weeks. By
comparing response to the campaign against
response received from previous campaigns, by this time you
will have a clear indication whether or not
the campaign was successful, failed, or landed somewhere in
between, relative to the other campaigns in
your marketing plan.
Sometimes, and this is especially true for marketing efforts
launched in new markets or industries, or
for new product launches or startups, response from a campaign
may fall well below your initial projections.
The smart marketing professional prepares for this possible
outcome, and knows the steps he or she must
take to examine the positive and negative results of their
underperforming campaign, find their underlying
marketing (and, sometimes, product-related) causes, revise and
improve the campaign, and, using effective
execution, get the new campaign back online, as fast as
possible, to generate better sales response on its
next iteration.
Step 6. Follow Through
As prospects respond to your campaign, as they are contacted
and qualified by your sales team, they
also enter into your lead development process: This is the
marketing program that begins after the lead is
generated, and which moves these interested prospects through
the sales cycle. As your sales reps contact
their prospects who have responded to a campaign, they learn
more about the prospect’s business, their
business problems, applications needs, product preferences,
buying intention, and other issues as they relate
to your company’s product.
During this process, sales reps provide the prospect with
additional information on your company’s
product from your CRM system’s document library, and give
their prospect the opportunity to receive
ongoing content from your company, in the form of opt-in e-
mail newsletters and periodic technical,
applications, and editorial information about your company and
its product. This is all part of your ongoing
lead development process, which is a combination of marketing
activities including e-mail messaging
programs, mailings, trade show and event promotions, and other
marketing projects specifically targeted to
prospects who, through this coordinated lead development effort
by marketing and sales, are being moved
closer to making their purchase decision in your company’s
sales cycle.
By providing a systematic approach to every marketing activity,
and by helping you to plan for
measurement of every marketing activity early in the planning
process, the Marketer’s Action Plan provides
an organized framework for helping you to better plan and
execute your marketing program.
Copyright of International Management Review is the property
of American Scholars Press
and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or
posted to a listserv without
the copyright holder's express written permission. However,
users may print, download, or
email articles for individual use.
VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016
149
Consumer Response
to Brand Placement in
Movies: Investigating
the Brand-Event Fit
Komal Nagar
R E S E A R C H
KEY WORDS
Brand Placement
Brand–Event Fit
Movies
Attitude towards the Brand
includes research articles
that focus on the analysis and
resolution of managerial and
academic issues based on
analytical and empirical or
case research
Movies offer the perfect media site for placement of brands as
part of the emerging
marketing strategy. Although attempts to analyse brand
placements have been made
in the past, the same needs more attention in the Indian context.
Given the exposure of
Indian audiences to both national and international
entertainment industry, it is only
reasonable to expect the entertainment event context to have an
impact on consumers’
evaluation of the brands placed in each context.
The present research attempts to extend the applicability of the
idea of fit, which was
till now largely confined to sponsorship and subjects it to the
exploration of finding a
fit between brands and specific events, in particular, movies.
Because the link between
country of origin of the entertainment event
(national/international) and brand, place-
ment is a relevant area of speculation, the present research aims
to study this relation-
ship within the national/international context. Results of an
experimental study among
120 respondents are as follows:
• Brands placed in a national event will create more positive
brand evaluations in
terms of positive attitude towards the placed brand and intention
to purchase than
brands that are placed in an international event.
• When the presence of a brand is consistent with the context in
which it is placed, it
would evoke more positive attitudes and behaviour than an
incongruent placement.
• Evaluation of results further reveals that although a brand that
fits well with the
context in which it is placed generates a positive evaluation of
the placed brand, the
condition of a brand-event misfit in a Hollywood context will
create more negative
evaluations among the Indian audiences than if such a
disconnect appeared in a
Hindi film. In other words, a brand may have more to lose in
case of a misfit with the
international entertainment event than with a national
entertainment event.
Based on the findings of the present study, it is suggested that
multinational brands
must look at the Indian movies as a suitable medium for
reaching out to the prospective
buyers as Indians have become consumers of global brands and
thus pose to be a huge
market for global brands.
VIKALPA
The Journal for Decision Makers
41(2) 149–167
© 2016 Indian Institute of
Management, Ahmedabad
SAGE Publications
sagepub.in/home.nav
DOI: 10.1177/0256090916642678
http://vik.sagepub.com
Executive
Summary
150 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN
MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT
A
s the line between entertainment and marketing
communication gets increasingly blended or
even erased (de Gregorio & Sung, 2010; Eagle,
2007; Steel, 2007; Winkler & Buckner, 2006), the notion
of brand placement in an entertainment context receives
considerable attention from scholars and practitioners
alike. Although there are many definitions of the term,
brand or product placement have often been used inter-
changeably and generally refer to the use of a prod-
uct’s name, packaging, signage, or other trademarks in
media (Steortz, 1987).
Screening thousands of films every year, the film industry
is fast emerging as the medium with the maximum
potential to capture and convert audiences to potential
consumers. Tag Heuer in Don (2006), Coke in Dhoom 2
(2006), Singapore Tourism Board in Krrish (2006), or Pepsi
in Pearl Harbour (2001), product placements have a very
significant role in Indian1 and international2 movies. Such
placements have also started to appear in television series
(Fitzgerald, 2002), live shows (Matthews, 2005), video-
games (Gunn, 2001; Nelson, Keum, & Yaros, 2004), and
even books (Kretchmer, 2004; Moser, Bryant, & Sylvester,
2004; Turner, 2004). The reason behind using product
placement in these media, however, remains the same:
generating additional income for the producer while
creating an opportunity for the advertisers to present
their offering in an entertainment context (Russell &
Belch, 2005). By doing so, not only does the offering reach
a larger audience, but it also gets a much longer life than
a 30-second commercial.
While product placement is riskier than conventional
advertising, it is becoming a common practice to place
products and brands into mainstream media, including
films, which are an extremely popular medium among
advertisers. Also, with the traditional media getting
overcrowded and nearly saturated, the concept of
product placement has become even more popular
as a communication technique, which is now being
used more than ever by advertisers (Karrh, Mckee,
& Pardum, 2003). A lot of research has focused on
product placement in all its forms (Gupta & Gould,
2007; Nelson, 2002), but more specifically on product
placement in movies (Karrh, 1998). Brand placement
in movies seems to be well accepted (O’Reilly, Cripps,
Kazani, Patel, & Zarra, 2005) and is sometimes consid-
ered less expensive and more effective than a 30-second
TV spot (Jaffe, 2005), resulting in a more frequent use of
this communication technique.
However, in the era of expanding global competition,
where companies are trying hard to reach out to their
customers effectively and efficiently to market their
product and services to different national cultures,
an important yet lurking question that remains unan-
swered is: To what extent have marketers been able
to successfully reach their customers? Although
product placement utilizes the global reach of movies,
minimal research has been conducted to study the
effects of product placement across cultures. Therefore,
of particular interest in this study is the influence of
brand placements in an entertainment event, especially
movies that represent two different cultures. How do
viewers perceive brands placed in movies? Do brands
placed in Indian movies have a different impact on
viewers than brands placed in international movies?
Should the advertisers and marketers, therefore, view
the placement of their brands in national and interna-
tional entertainment contexts differently? To answer
these questions, the study focuses on the opinions of
people who are viewers of both Indian and interna-
tional movies.
A review of brand placement studies indicates a major
gap in the literature. Previous studies of brand place-
ment were largely conducted in the US with little focus
on it as a global phenomenon (DeLorme, 1998; Grein
& Grould, 1996) given the fact that many movies play
to and are often produced for multinational audiences,
raising the issue of how consumers in other countries
perceive product placements. Also, while product
placement has been researched extensively (Karrh,
1998; McKechnie & Zhou, 2003; Russell & Belch, 2005)
in studies that have focused on one or more of the
placement’s characteristics, in particular, its prom-
inence (Gupta & Lord, 1998; Russell, 1998, 2002) and
plot connection (d’Astous & Chartier, 2000; Fontaine,
2002; Russell, 2002), it is not clear from the previous
studies if a brand placed in a matching context would
have any effect on consumer’s evaluation behaviour.
And till date no study, either at the national or the inter-
national level, has examined the effects of brand place-
ment’s fit/misfit within movies. Being the first of its
kind, the present study finds its need and relevance by
investigating congruence between entertainment event
and brand.
Furthermore, given the exposure of Indian audiences
to both national and international entertainment
industry, it is only reasonable to expect the country of
origin of the entertainment event to have an impact
VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016
151
on consumer ’s evaluation. Because the link between
the country of origin of the entertainment event and
brand placement is a relevant area of speculation,
the present research aims to study this relationship
including national/international context. And even
though measures of product placement evaluation
have been problematic, product placement is a fast
growing multi-billion dollar industry (McDonnell
& Drennan, 2010) making the present study relevant
for both, advertisers and marketers. A great deal of
research has already been devoted to product place-
ment in movies; however, this article strives to present,
for the first time, the effect of fit between brand and the
entertainment event on consumer ’s brand evaluation.
BRAND PLACEMENT IN MOVIES
There are enough reasons that suggest the growth of
product placement. The erosion of traditional media
audience and its fragmentation on the one hand
(Deloitte, 2005) and the use of alternate media such as
the internet, allowing consumers to skip ads (O’Neill &
Barrett, 2004) on the other hand, has forced the adver-
tisers to seek a more reliable media to re-establish the
link between their offering and their consumers. In
such a scenario, product placement has surfaced as
an important tool for the advertisers and marketers,
posing as competition to the traditional commercial
medium of advertising.
In movies, the role of brand placement has increased
in recent times. Initially, brands were typically featured
in movies in three ways: the product itself was shown,
a logo of the brand was displayed, or a brand was
displayed as a background prop (Smith, 1985). The role
has changed ever since, from the brand being a mere
prop in the background to being a central part of the
movie, thereby increasing its prominence. The promi-
nence of brand placement is defined as ‘the capacity of
the brand to attract the spectator’s attention’ (Fontaine,
2001). Among other factors, such as the size and dura-
tion of the brand’s placement on screen (Fontaine,
2002), this capacity can be linked to the brand’s location
in the scene (Gupta & Lord, 1998) and the number of
times the brand appears on the screen (Bressoud, Lehu,
& Russell, 2008).
No matter how the brand is placed in the movie, by
using brand placement, marketers hope to gain an
advantage in comparison with the traditional commer-
cial advertising format. The availability of a captive
audience with greater reach than traditional advertise-
ments and the advantage of showing brands in their
natural environment (Stephan & Coote, 2005) provide
motivation for product placements (Deigh, 1985;
Hulin-Salkin, 1989; Turcotte, 1995). Therefore, brand
placement provides an opportunity where the involved
audience gets exposure to the brands and products
during the natural process of narration of the movie.
The audience can undertake multiple tasks while
watching a television programme in a home setting,
which may affect the level and degree of the attention
span of the audience and hence reduce the overall effec-
tiveness of the medium for enhancing brand memory.
In the case of watching a movie in the theatre, the
audience makes a voluntary choice for viewing (expo-
sure) at a cost (financial, time, and opportunity cost)
for the purpose of entertainment, which makes him
more receptive to the information provided. Further,
the trend of zapping and change in television usage
behaviour due to surfing during commercial breaks has
reduced the effectiveness of television commercials.
And clearly, brand placements in movies also result
in a longer lifespan for the brands than typical adver-
tisements (Brennan, Dubas, & Babin, 1999; d’Astous &
Chartier, 2000).
While brand placement has obvious advantages, it is
not without its disadvantages. Such disadvantages
stem from the marketer’s general lack of control over
the brand placement process. Exposure does not actu-
ally guarantee that the placement will be noticed (Van
der Waldt, 2005). Also, there is little control over how
and when the brand will be shown or whether it will be
shown at all, as the risk of the scene featuring the brand
being edited runs high (Bergman, 1989) and the risk of
a negative portrayal of the brand in the movie setting
(Fleming, 1990). However, despite the pitfalls which
may not allow brand placements to stand as the lone
marketing tool, it is becoming an increasingly impor-
tant part of the integrated marketing strategy.
REVIEW OF LITERATURE AND HYPOTHESES
Over a period of time, researchers have used a number
of terms for the same purpose that somewhat overlap
each other. The term advertainment (Russell, 2007) was
coined to reflect the increasingly intertwined connec-
tions between advertising and entertainment and
refers to the promotional practices that integrate brand
communications within the content of entertainment
152 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN
MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT
products. The increased mingling of advertising with
the entertainment world has generated a slew of newly
coined terms to reflect the trends, such as hybrid adver-
tisement (Balasubramanian, 1994), branded entertain-
ment (Hudson & Hudson, 2006), and brand placement
and product placement. In one of the first reviews of
brand placement, Karrh (1998) argues that although
product placement is the most commonly used descrip-
tion, brand placement would be more correct. He argues
that it is a brand (e.g., Ray-Ban) and not a product
(e.g., sunglasses) that is placed. However, not many
researchers distinguish between the two and, therefore,
the terms brand placement and product placement have
been used interchangeably throughout the study.
Despite the widespread use of brand placements to
reach audiences, it is difficult to ascertain its effective-
ness because much of the related data is proprietary
(Yang, Roskos-Ewoldsen, & Roskos-Ewoldsen, 2004).
Consequently, too little is known about the effect of
brand placements given the dynamic nature of this prac-
tice (Bhatnagar, Aksoy, & Malkoc, 2004). For example,
how the brands are placed in the movies may influence
their effectiveness (Ong & Meri, 1994). Indeed, scholars
have tested the effect of different types of brand place-
ments, such as whether the placement is visual or verbal
(Russell, 2002), the visual prominence of the placement
(Law & Braun, 2000), and if the placement is involved in
the plot of the story or not (Russell, 2002).
While all these past studies on brand placement have
been informative, research in the area of product place-
ment is still not widespread in the Indian context and is
concentrated on studying the impact of product place-
ments on a wide, general audience. India, which has a
huge and growing section of young consumers who are
poised to begin their consumption journey, offers a big
future growth market for branded products making it
even more important to discover, clarify, and check the
effectiveness of brand placements.
BRAND PLACEMENT IN INDIAN MOVIES
Films are a noticeable medium of entertainment in India
(Panda, 2004), communicating among other things,
the changing fashion trends and promoting market-
er’s products and services. Indian audience has always
been emotionally involved with onscreen actors and
the impact is evident from the fact that stars have iconic
status in India. The audience depends heavily on these
actors for setting new trends, fashions, and hairstyles
(Kripalani, 2006), and it was, therefore, not astonishing
when advertisers and marketers started exploiting
mainstream Indian cinema as an opportunity to adver-
tise their products and started relying on stars to set
trends for costumes, accessories, and other products and
services. When the audience watch a movie star with the
product placed in the movie, they connect the product
with the actor, thus, increasing the intrinsic expressive-
ness of the placement messages (Morton & Friedman,
2002) such that when the consumers see the movie star
using a certain product, they try to associate the credi-
bility of the actor with the product placed in the movie
and build a positive behaviour towards the product.
India’s popular Hindi film industry, commonly known
as Bollywood, being the largest producer of films in the
world (Minocha & Stonehouse, 2006), is fuelled by a
large audience eager for consumption (Akram, Dwight,
& Muhammad, 2011; Britt, 2002). In addition to the
display of national brands, Hollywood’s ‘big players’
of product placement also appear in Indian movies.
Coca-Cola, for instance, has benefited from placement
in movies in India along with celebrity endorsement
by Indian movie star, Amir Khan, helping it increase
its market share (Business Week, 2003). Display of both
foreign and local brands in the contemporary Indian
films is, therefore, a reflection of the globalization
forces at play within India, with a number of Indian
films being packed with loads of non-Indian product
placements. Since Indian or Hollywood movies mostly
remain unchanged across countries, international
brands, even if placed in local media through cable-
cast or broadcast, may serve as a global marketing
strategy (Gould, Gupta, & Grabner-Krauter, 2000). It is
for this reason that since the last few years, multina-
tional brands have looked to Indian movies to reach the
Indian market (Rajadhyaksha, 2003).
In addition to placing foreign brands in Indian films,
producers of movies have also started exploring different
types of product placements, on the lines similar to its
Hollywood counterpart. Apart from just a brand place-
ment in a movie or a prominent character talking about
it, they have started placing products integral to the sto-
ryline. The 2002 film, Road, shot mostly on roads with the
lead characters driving the cars, featured Tata Motors’
Safari 4-wheel SUV. For this placement, Tata Motors
paid about ` 12.5 million (USD 266,250) (Kripalani,
2006). Such a trend of weaving a product into the sto-
ryline has become common in the Hindi3 film industry
in the past few years. In fact, a recent film Heroine
(2012) included several brands that were integral to the
movie’s theme. After the release of the movie, Lakme
VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016
153
launched Heroine branded makeup under the Absolute
range, endorsed by Kareena Kapoor (an Indian actress)
while apparel brand Jealous 21 introduced a special
clothing line inspired by the clothes worn by Kareena in
the movie, which narrates the behind-the-scenes life of an
actor. Given the efforts made by the advertisers and the
enthusiasm with which the audiences are accepting brand
placements in the Indian movies, this practice has a huge
potential to grow.
Hypotheses
Brand placements are, by definition, brands placed
within a medium (Nelson & Deshpande, 2013). How
audience members respond to the medium likely
impacts their responses to the brands within that
medium, too. The body of research studying the influ-
ence of context on advertising effectiveness leads to the
finding that advertising context consists of two impor-
tant concepts: receiver context and medium context.
While the receiver context is described as the situa-
tional circumstances in which a person is exposed to
an advertisement (Pieters & Van Raaij, 1992), such as
the person’s physical environment (e.g., ‘at home, at
the dining table’), the social environment (e.g., ‘in the
company of friends’), the time frame (e.g., ‘during
lunch’), and the mental state a person is in prior to expo-
sure to the medium content (e.g., ‘an early morning
mood’), the medium context concerns the environment
of the ad provided by the vehicle carrying it, such as a
television programme, a book, a video game, or a film.
Although studies on context effect are not found in
the brand placement literature, there is some sugges-
tion that the medium context can have an effect on
consumers’ responses to an embedded ad (Moorman,
Neijens, & Smit, 2005). Some authors have even found
a congruency effect between context and embedded
ad (priming effect, e.g., Yi, 1990). Therefore, we expect
that the medium context should have an effect on the
responses to brand placements too. Further, while the
medium context may be the same (e.g., films), they may
still differ on the basis of culture, such as films made in
India and abroad, both of which depict widely different
cultures (de Mooij & Hofstede, 2002; Lewis, 2005). In the
present study, we conceptualize and explain the clas-
sification of film industries into foreign film industry
(Hollywood) and domestic film industry (Bollywood),
based on their country of origin and term them as the
film industry context. Films represent a very typical
entertainment medium and each film industry across
the globe is influenced by its culture and environment
as a whole; therefore, understanding of the film
industry context will help understand the differences
between domestic and foreign consumer behaviour. In
the present study, the film industry context has been
used as one of the independent variables that have two
levels, Indian and American. Films that were made in
India have been defined as Indian movies while those
that were made in America have been classified as
American movies.
Until recently, placement of branded products in
movies was considered an American concept (Segrave,
2004). However, the Indian mainstream Hindi films
have caught up with the trend with the Indian audi-
ence not only being exposed to product placement in
different media but also being exposed to it in both the
national and international entertainment industry. Just
as the Indian motion pictures have a huge overseas
market, Hollywood movies is a huge craze with the
Indian masses. With the coming of video-on-demand
and DTH, access to any kind of movies has become
easier than before; therefore, like many other countries,
Hollywood movies have a significant viewership in
India too. Also, interest in Hollywood movies is high,
with several Hollywood movies releasing in Indian
theatres every month. Given the massive exposure of
the Indian audiences to movies, it is a question of legit-
imate curiosity to find out the impact that brand place-
ments in movies have on the audiences.
Hall’s (1959) theory aims to explain culture on the basis
of high and low context which varies across cultures
(Hall, 1984). Indian culture, being a high context culture,
aims to communicate messages through symbols
(deMooij, 1998), including brands which may com-
municate the social standing. Hall (1976) also empha-
sizes that in a high-context culture, greater confidence
is placed in the nonverbal aspects of communication
than the verbal aspects. On the other hand, Hollywood
films are rooted in a low-context culture. The literature
on product placement demonstrates that cultural dif-
ferences exist vis-à-vis attitudes towards product place-
ment (Gould et al., 2000; Karrh, Frith, & Gallison, 2001).
This is primarily because cultural values and communi-
cation styles influence advertising persuasion (Aaker &
Maheswaran, 1997) and are also likely to influence the
way consumers process product placements. In other
words, how brand placements communicate is dictated
by the cultural context in which they are put. We argue
that consumers’ interpretation of brands placed in dif-
ferent contexts, namely, domestic versus foreign films
will show a potential bias. For example, Coca-Cola has
154 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN
MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT
been widely used in several international as well as
Indian movies. In each of the two scenarios, the same
brand might be looked at differently due to its place-
ment in two culturally different contexts. An Indian
consumer will be able to relate with Coca-Cola more
in Rang De Basanti (2006), an Indian film, rather than
Coca-Cola in Falling Down (1993). This implies that
differences exist in terms of consumers’ response to
brands placed in the two different contexts.
In addition to the difference in consumers’ response
to brand placements in national and international
films due to cultural diversity, we also argue, based
on research, that an increase in the number of ads in
the environment will have a negative influence on the
effectiveness of the target ad or the placed brand (Kent,
1995). Given that Hollywood films contain a greater
number of brands overall (Kureshi & Sood, 2011) as
compared to Indian films, it is likely that the reaction
of viewers towards brands placement in Hollywood
movies would be more negative as compared to their
reaction towards brand placement in Indian films. In
view of the literature on the medium context, cultural
differences and the effect of number of brands placed in
a movie, we predict that
H1: Brands placed in a national event will create
more positive brand evaluations than brands placed
in an international event.
Associations between a brand and an event that trigger
positive attitudes towards the brand may be an effec-
tive marketing strategy, leading to increased sales
which could potentially generate a sustainable compet-
itive advantage. However, not all brand–event rela-
tionships result in a positive outcome for the brand.
It has been suggested that when there is congru-
ence between the brand and the event, consumers are
more likely to respond favourably (Hamlin & Wilson,
2004). Meenaghan (2001) explains that perceptions of
congruity reflect the extent to which the sponsored
partner is seen as predictable. Therefore, it is highly
likely that congruence will allow the brand to generate
positive returns, whereas a non-congruent relation-
ship may even be detrimental to the brand (Gray, 2000;
Hamlin & Wilson, 2004; Murphy, 1996; Simmons &
Becker-Olsen, 2006; Welsh, 1999). These studies assume
that congruity between brand and event can have a
positive influence on consumer responses so that there
is a positive attitude towards the event and the brand
(Dousteyssier-Fleck, 2004).
The concept of fit, built on congruity theory (Osgood
& Tannenbaum, 1955), has been extensively applied to
the sponsorship arena and holds that sponsors should
seek events that have a logical congruence or fit with
the sponsors’ products. There is, however, no evidence
of congruence/fit studies in the context of product
placements. Nevertheless, given the similarity between
product placement and sponsorship, such that both
consist of a triangular relationship—a company willing
to support a certain activity (the sponsor), a sponsored
activity or the target (the sponsee), and in a majority
of cases also the different media covering the event or
activity (Burnett, 1993)—it is only reasonable to consider
that brands being placed in movies are, in a way, spon-
soring a part of the movie. For example, brands such as
Lakme, Head & Shoulders, Jealous 21, Cera, and so on
collectively spent roughly ̀ 250 million on in-film place-
ment in the movie Heroine. Therefore, application of fit
in the context of product placement may be built on the
same logic as that in the context of sponsorship.
Sponsorship literature confirms the importance of
congruence on the relationship between brand and
event, exemplified by brand image beliefs (Gwinner &
Eaton, 1999; Speed & Thomson, 2000). Academics and
practitioners have long relied on fit to explain sponsor-
ship (Olson & Thjomoe, 2011; Quester & Thompson,
2001). Simmons and Becker-Olsen (2006) showed that
high-fit sponsorships (sponsor partner is perceived as
congruent with sponsored event) can increase brand
value, whereas low-fit (sponsor partner is perceived
as incongruent with sponsored event) can dilute
brand value. Several studies have shown the impor-
tance of a strong link between the sponsor and the
sponsored event or entity: the greater the perceived fit
of brand associations between the sponsor/endorser
and the brand, the greater the impact on the sponsor ’s
image and the attitudes towards sponsoring itself
(McDonald, 1991; Smith, 2004). Since attitudes are
found to successfully transfer between parent brands
and brand extensions when perceived fit between
the two is high (Aaker & Keller, 1990), based on the
same argument, it is expected that the degree of fit or
congruence between brands and the context in which
they appear will determine the extent to which atti-
tudes towards the context transfers onto the placed
brand. Additionally, when consumers elaborate on
the sponsorship and discover a level of congruence,
they experience a sense of cognitive satisfaction that
influences their evaluation of the sponsoring brand
(Meyers-Levy & Tybout, 1989).
VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016
155
Likewise, strong sponsor–programme congruity sug-
gests that the sponsor’s products and activities are
clearly related to the contents of the programme, that is,
the product placement is likely to be natural and con-
sistent with the programme. However, when sponsor–
programme congruity is weak, the product placement
may be seen as inconsistent and not credible. Therefore,
extending this basic finding to brand placement in
movies, we expect that brands that are perceived as
consistent with the event in which they are placed will
lead to positive evaluation of the brand. We therefore
hypothesize that
H2: When the presence of the brand is consistent
with viewer expectations of the event (high fit),
it would create significantly more favourable
consumer evaluations than brands that are incon-
sistent (low fit) with the event.
Foreign films, being viewed by the Indian audiences in
addition to the contemporary Indian films, are sugges-
tive of the global forces within India. Films, being a
product of culture, reflect the cultural values of the
people such that the practices, behaviour, and brands
from other cultures flow into the domestic culture
(Appadurai, 1996). Just as brands are categorized
as foreign or domestic in terms of country of origin,
films, as a medium of entertainment, are also labelled
as foreign and local (Schaefer & Kavita, 2011). When
people are exposed to films, they gather information
from them in terms of brand schemas and compare
them, which determine their judgement with respect
to the appropriateness of the event (McDaniel, 1999).
Therefore, we can assume the same forces to play a
role in consumers’ evaluation of films that affect their
judgement about brands. A match leads to more posi-
tive evaluations because affect moves from the event
schema to the brand schema (Perrachio & Tybout, 1996).
However, the influence of films/media on consumers
is not automatic. Consumers in emerging markets, such
as India, may readily accept nonlocal brands due to
country-of-origin (COO) effects where foreign brands
convey quality or status. Conversely, they may reject
foreign brands or their depictions based on consumer
ethnocentrism, that is, preference for one’s own coun-
try’s products (e.g., Zhou & Russell, 2004).
We hope to examine consumers’ responses in terms of
their attitude towards the placed brand and their inten-
tion to purchase the brand within the context of COO
of the event (and not the brand). Given the individual
differences with respect to foreign and domestic brands/
films based on consumer ethnocentrism or openness to
other cultures (Batra et al., 2000), we assume the rela-
tionships of these factors to have an influence on atti-
tudes towards the brand. Past research also suggests
that a congruity between the brand and the context in
which it is placed has an effect on consumers’ evalu-
ation. Specifically, a brand–event fit will draw more
favourable responses. Therefore, brand placement and
congruity literature suggests that based on cultural
differences (Gould et al., 2000; Karrh et al., 2001), which
affect the way consumers process product placements
(Aaker & Maheswaran, 1997), a low fit between the
event and the brand is expected to create more positive
evaluation in case of the event being a national event
rather than an international event. Therefore,
H3: The low fit between the brand and the event
will create more favourable evaluation in a national
event context than a low brand–event fit in the
context of an international event.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Prior research suggests that the manner in which the
brands are presented in the movies, namely in the
background, used by the main character or as an inte-
gral part of the unfolding story, might lead to different
responses from the audience (Russell, 2002). Therefore,
the current study focused on only one type of brand
placement, that is, the effect of visual brand place-
ments, used by the main character in the movie. Visual
product placement means that the product is shown
prominently in the movie without the mention of the
brand name. For the present study, four different movies
were selected, each using product placement such that
the placement was visual in nature. Second, the study
explored the influence of brand placement using both
American and Indian movies so as to study the effect of
the link between COO of the entertainment event and
brand placement in the movie. For the present study,
four different movies were selected—two American
and two Indian—each using brand placement which
was visual in nature. Experimental design was chosen
as the method of study in the present research work
because of the ability of such designs to test theoretical
relations (Bagozzi & Yi, 1989).
Two pilot studies were conducted prior to the main
experimental study. The participants for all of the studies
were recruited from the same research participant pool
at a large university in North India for no extra credit
for their participation.
156 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN
MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT
Pilot Study 1: Selection of the Movies for the
Experiment
Ten subjects were asked to list five American and five
Indian (Hindi) movies that used brand placement.
Subjects were informed that used-by-main-character brand
placement should be part of the movies and should be
visual brand placement. Used-by-main-character brand
placement involved one of the main characters using
the brand in some manner such as opening the packet of
Tata Tea in the movie, Baghban (2003), by one of the lead
characters in that movie while visual brand placement
was the one in which no mention of the brand name
was made. The subjects were given enough time to
think and were allowed to discuss among themselves.
Pilot Study 2: Fit/Misfit Test
The second pre-test was conducted to select the brand–
event combination. Out of the list of 50 American and
50 Hindi movies generated by the subjects from the
first pre-test, the subjects were asked to separate those
movies where the presence of the brand in the movie
was a misfit in the movie scene and those where the
brand placement and movie scene fitted well. For
doing this, the participants were asked to indicate how
much they considered the brand–event (movie) fit
using a 7-point scale ranging from 1 (complete misfit)
to 7 (complete fit) for each of the movies listed. Using
this data, two American and two Hindi movies were
selected (Table 1) with the most fit and least fit.
Table 1: Brand Fit and Misfit with the Event
Entertainment Industry Event–Brand Fit Event–Brand Misfit
American Top Gun Twilight
Hindi Jab Tak Hai Jaan Student of the Year
Source: Author’s analysis.
The two movies selected with the most brand–event
fit were Top Gun (Ray-Ban) (1986) and Jab Tak Hai Jaan
(Canon) (2012) while the movies selected for the least
brand–event fit were Twilight (2008) and Student of the
Year (2012).
Pilot Study 3: Brand Stature, Brand Perception,
and Brand Familiarity
The third pilot study was conducted to establish if the
three selected brands, namely Ray-Ban, Canon, and
Apple, had the same stature, were similarly perceived,
and had the same level of familiarity. The pre-test was
conducted on 30 participants and analysis of vari-
ance (ANOVA) results reflect no significant difference
between the three brands, based on stature/importance
(F = 1.45, p = 1.89), perception about the brands
(F = 0.838, p = 0.502), and level of brand familiarity
(F = 1.127, p = 0.343).
Main Study
Design
The study used a 2X2 between-subjects experimental
design with two levels of events (American/Hindi
movies) and two levels of brand–event fit (high fit/low
fit). Each subject was assigned to only one of the four
conditions in the experiment.
Participants
For the purpose of this research, a non-probability
sampling approach was used. Non-probability sampling
is arbitrary and subjective, due to the fact that a partic-
ipant does not have a known non-zero chance of being
included (Cooper & Schindler, 2006).
The sample chosen for the study was roughly comparable
in terms of occupation (all were post-graduate students),
gender, and age. A total of 120 students participated in
the study (78 females and 42 males) and was drawn from
the subject pool of a large Indian university for no extra
course credit for their participation. The motivation for
this selection was that respondents were thought to be
an appropriate sample since young adults (18 to 24 years
of age) are passionate film-goers. Moreover, attending
movies is a common activity for the age range of the
sample (Nebenzahl & Secunda, 1993). Also, many social
psychological research studies have used college students
as participants but they are usually labelled as ‘adults’
(Arnett, 2000) who possess enough disposable income to
attend films (Gough, 2003), making product placement in
films an effective way to target young and well-educated
consumers. The 120 respondents were divided into four
groups such that each group consisted of 30 respondents.
Each group was shown one of the four stimuli in the form
of a movie clip and their responses were recorded with a
standardized scale.
Stimulus
Before the final experiment, five respondents (who
were not part of the final study) viewed the four movies
VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016
157
which were selected from the pre-tests, on a videotape
to identify and list the names of all the brands placed in
the movie scenes (Table 2).
Table 2: List of Movies, Name of Entertainment Industry, and
Brand Placed
Name of the Movie Entertainment Industry Brand Placed
Top Gun American Ray Ban
Twilight American Apple
Jab Tak Hai Jaan Hindi Canon
Student of the Year Hindi Ray Ban
Source: Author’s analysis.
Since all the movies had numerous brand placements,
we asked the subjects to identify the scenes where only
one brand was placed in a scene. It was also mentioned
that the brand should only be a visual prop being
used by one of the leading characters of the film but
should not be mentioned in the scene. Scenes from the
films, where the branded products were featured, were
selected. Last, the respondents were also asked if the
four movies were comparable in terms of their release
time such that none of the films was either too old or
too new. It was done to avoid the potential confound of
promotional tie-ins and sponsorships that could have
drawn the audience’s attention to the brand (Ong &
Meri, 1994).
Also, in order to control for star association with the
brand, those brand placements were not selected for
the final study in which the star of the movie was also
endorsing the brand in traditional advertisements, such
as Kareena Kapoor was seen holding a Sony Vaio in a
scene in Bodyguard (2011) while she is also an endorser
of the same brand and can be seen in television adver-
tisement as well. It was done to avoid clouding the
respondents’ judgement based on their assessment of
the celebrity–brand association.
In the brand–event fit for the international event,
Ray-Ban sunglasses worn by the protagonist appears
prominently in the centre of the screen in one scene
from the movie Top Gun (1986). Tom Cruise’s char-
acter in the movie, a US Naval Lieutenant Maverick,
embodied the image of a cool jet-fighter pilot, and due
to the natural cosmetic effects and military look of the
sunglasses donned by him in the movie, the brand was
considered to be an overall fit in the movie. The event–
brand misfit condition selected from the American
movie was a scene from the movie Twilight (2008) in
which the female lead of the film was seen working on
an Apple computer. The brand was seen to be a misfit
with the story of the film which was based on a young
adult vampire’s romance with a human.
The movie selected from the Indian panorama in the
brand–event fit category was Jab Tak Hai Jaan (2012)
in which one of the lead characters of the movie was
a Discovery Channel filmmaker and was seen taking
shots from her Canon camera. The brand seems to fit
perfectly in the movie as the use of the camera is justi-
fied by the character in the film. On the other hand,
the movie Student of the Year (2012) was selected in the
brand–event misfit category. The sunglasses brand
Ray-Ban was being used by one of the male leads whose
character was a boy from a middle-class background
on scholarship, but was seen wearing expensive clothes
and branded sunglasses. The audience took notice of
this apparent disconnect between the character and the
brand and categorized it as a misfit.
Manipulation Check
In order to determine the success of the experimental
design, it was necessary to check whether the manip-
ulation remained hidden or visibly obvious to the
respondents. The present study manipulated fit
between the event and the brand, and this manipula-
tion was checked by measuring the subjects’ response
to five items by Speed and Thompson (2000) that
were used to measure brand–event fit in this study
(Table 3). This manipulation check was carried out by
showing the respondents both the high brand–event
fit and low brand–event fit formats. The manipula-
tion check, brand–event fit, was assessed by indexing
two measures, that is, high and low brand fit. Scores
of subjects in the high fit setting (6.3) on a 7-point scale
were compared with the scores of subjects in the low-fit
setting (3.2). The data supports the intended manipula-
tion [F(1, 38) = 5.673, p < 0.05] and confirmed that our
manipulation was effective in creating required experi-
mental conditions.
Research Design
This study was presented as a movie entertainment
study and each session was conducted with 30 partic-
ipants. The methodology adopted for this study is
comparable to the one used by Gupta and Lord (1998).
Subjects participated in small groups. Stimulus tapes
for the four treatment conditions were randomly
assigned to sessions. Upon arrival at the assigned
158 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN
MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT
experimental session, subjects were informed that
they would be shown a videotape of a movie excerpt
and then asked some questions about the movie. The
participants were informed about the purpose of the
experiment and were allowed to watch the movie clip.
The clips of the movies listed above were edited to 30
minutes. The scenes with the target brand placement
were placed roughly in the middle of each 30-minute
clip and were shown to the subjects.
After watching the movie, subjects completed a ques-
tionnaire measuring demographic information, pre-
vious exposure to the movie, and enjoyment of the
movie they watched. Prior to the testing, respondents
were not made aware that the questionnaire was con-
cerned with product placements in the films. To check
on the cover story, respondents were asked to write
down what they thought was the purpose of the study
immediately after viewing the movie, with none of the
respondents indicating the true purpose.
Respondents completed the questionnaire on brand
evaluation by asking them their attitude towards
the brand and their intention to purchase. Attitude
towards the brand and intention to purchase were
measured using a 7-point scale. The entire task took
approximately 20 minutes. Another personality scale
was given as a distraction task. After this distraction
task, the participants were thanked for their participa-
tion and dismissed from the study.
Variable Operationalization
Several measures were modified from existing vali-
dated scales and in some cases measures were devel-
oped for use in this study based upon the related liter-
ature. All measures were subjected to confirmatory
factor analysis to assess their psychometric properties
and unidimensionality. The final scale items used in the
analysis, standardized factor loadings, and reliability
estimates are listed in Table 3.
Brand–Event Fit/Misfit
In the present study, the event was operationalized as
the appearance of a product in the released film and
the context (national event/international event) of its
appearance. The fit was conceptualized on a variety
of dimensions in the marketing literature. Consistent
with Speed and Thompson (2000), however, we did not
attempt to tease out the different dimensions of fit in
our measure. Rather, we adopted a five-item measure
that allowed respondents to consider fit on their own
terms without restricting the basis used to define fit. The
five items to measure fit, used by Speed and Thompson
(2000), were modified to fit the context of this study
(Table 3). All items on the perception of event–brand fit
were ranked on a 7-point Likert scale (1 = totally disa-
gree, 7 = totally agree).
Understanding brand placements requires that
researchers measure event attendees’ (i.e., viewers’)
perceptions. The two dependent variables measured
in the study are the attitude towards the brand placed
in the movie and viewers’ intention to purchase the
placed brand. The measurement of these constructs has
been summarized below.
Attitude towards the Placed Brand
This construct was measured with a three-item scale
using the traditional attitudinal aspects of liking and
favourable disposition on a 7-point agree–disagree
scale (e.g., Bruner & Hensel, 1992).
Table 3: Confirmatory Factor Analysis Results
Scale Items Factor Loadings
Event–Brand Fit (Cronbach’s α = 0.89)
There is a close fit between the placed brand and
the movie
0.830
The placed brand and the movie have many
similarities
0.748
It makes sense that this brand appears in the movie 0.732
There is a logical connection between the placed
brand and the movie
0.701
My image of the placed brand is consistent with my
image of the movie
0.675
Attitude towards the Placed Brand (Cronbach’s α = 0.97)
I like the brand placed in the movie 0.874
The brand placed in the movie is a very good brand 0.851
I have a favourable disposition towards the brand 0.817
Purchase Intentions (Cronbach’s α = 0.91)
I would buy the brand placed in the movie 0.890
The next time I want to buy a product of this type, I
would consider buying this brand
0.804
Source: Author’s analysis.
VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016
159
Purchase Intention
The behaviour intention measure used in this study
consisted of two items. It allows for a more robust
test of the paths from attitude to purchase intentions.
Responses were operationalized using a 7-point scale
ranging from strongly disagree to strongly agree.
Before the final administration of the questionnaire,
pre-testing of the questionnaire was carried out for
qualitative investigation. Ten respondents were admin-
istered the questionnaire for this purpose. Subsequently,
the language of one of the questions was simplified.
Before the final data collection, respondents were
briefed about the purpose of the study and all queries
of the respondents were clarified.
RESULTS
A one-way multivariate analysis of variance (one-way
MANOVA) was used to determine whether there were
any significant differences between the independent
groups (brands placed in Indian and American movies)
on the dependent variables—attitude towards the brand
and intention to purchase. The two dependent varia-
bles were found to be highly correlated with each other
(correlation coefficient is 0.426; p < 0.05) and given the
positive correlation, MANOVA was applied to examine
whether there were differences in the respondents’
attitude towards the placed brand and their intention
to purchase on two different levels of entertainment
event (Indian movies versus international movies).
The multivariate effect (Table 4) was found to be signif-
icant, F
2,115
= 27.915; Wilks’ Lambda Value = 0.673; p <
0.05; indicating a statistically significant difference in
brand evaluation based on entertainment event levels
(brands placed in Indian and American movies).
Given the significance of the overall test, the univar-
iate main tests were examined. As indicated in Table 5,
there are significant differences across the levels
of entertainment event, indicating that significant
univariate main effects exist for attitude towards the
placed brand (A
b
), F
1,116
= 9.292, p < 0.05 and inten-
tion to purchase, F
1,116
= 50.067, p < 0.05. Further anal-
ysis indicates that mean scores for ‘Overall evaluation
of brands appearing in Indian movie’ (M = 5.06) and
‘Overall evaluation of brands appearing in American
movie’ (M = 4.37) are statistically different for two
independent groups (t = 3.08, p < 0.05). It suggests that
entertainment event is significantly predictive of an
increase in the evaluation of brands placed in movies
such that when a brand appears in an Indian movie,
the brand evaluation, measured in terms of A
b
and
purchase intention, is more as compared to when a
brand appears in an American flick. These results indi-
cate an overall support for H1.
Table 4: MANOVA Test Results
Effect Value F Hypothesis df Error df Sig. Partial Eta Squared
Entertainment Event Wilks’ Lambda 0.673 27.915 2 115 0.000*
0.327
Brand–Event Fit Wilks’ Lambda 0.750 19.146 2 115 0.000*
0.250
Source: Author’s analysis.
Note: *Significant at p < 0.05 level.
Table 5: Between-subjects Effect
Source Dependent
Variable
Type II Sum of
Squares
df Mean
Square
F Sig. Partial Eta
Squared
Entertainment
Event
Attitude towards
Brand (A
b
)
4.626 1 4.626 9.292 0.003* 0.074
Purchase Intention 29.284 1 29.284 50.067 0.000* 0.301
Brand–Event
Fit
Attitude towards
Brand (A
b
)
3.085 1 3.085 6.197 0.014* 0.051
Purchase Intention 20.172 1 20.172 34.488 0.000* 0.229
Source: Author’s analysis.
Note: *Significant at p < 0.05 level.
160 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN
MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT
Further analysis using one-way MANOVA reveals that
there is a significant difference in the respondents’ A
b
and purchase intention on two levels of brand–event
fit (high fit vs. low fit). The multivariate effect (Table 4)
is significant (F
2.115
= 19.146; p < 0.05). The overall result
suggests that the consumers’ evaluation of the brand
placed in the movie varies significantly depending on
the level of fit (high or low) between the brand and the
event, irrespective of the type of event, Indian movies
or international movies. There are significant differ-
ences across the levels of brand–event fit on brand
evaluation indicating that significant univariate main
effects exist for attitude towards the placed brand,
F
1.116
= 6.197, p < 0.05, and intention to purchase, F
1.116
=
34.488, p < 0.05 (Table 5). However, to find out in which
case the respondents evaluated the placed brand more
favourably, mean scores for brand–event fit (M = 5.01)
and brand–event misfit (M = 4.427) were measured and
were found to be statistically different for the two inde-
pendent groups (t = 3.158; p < 0.05). It suggests that
when a brand that fits well with the movie appears,
the brand evaluations, measured in terms of A
b
and
purchase intention, is more favourable as compared to
when a brand does not fit well with the movie. These
results support H2.
Further, a 2X2 (high/low brand–event fit X international
movies/Indian movies) between-subjects MANOVA
was used to determine if there was a significant effect of
brand–event fit and type of event on brand evaluation.
As shown in Table 6, the MANOVA results reveal signif-
icant main effects of brand–event fit (F
2,115
= 19.146; p
< 0.05) and entertainment event type (F
2,115
= 27.915; p
< 0.05), which indicate that the differences in brand–
event fit are not equal across the event types for both
the dependent variables (A
b
and intention to purchase).
The multivariate effects show that there is a significant
interaction effect of the brand–event fit X event type
interaction term on both the dependent variables (F
2,115
= 5.404; p < 0.05). When an interaction is significant,
the intervening effects of the two independent varia-
bles may obscure comparisons between the means of
one independent variable. In this research, the combi-
nation of the two independent variables played a more
important role in explaining the variability of attitude
towards the brand and intention to purchase.
Additionally, specific mean comparisons (Table 7)
suggest that the effect of brand–event fit on brand
evaluation will be larger when the brand appears
in a national event. A significant difference is found
(t = 4.02; p < 0.001) in A
b
between American (cell mean
= 3.17) and Indian (cell mean = 4.80) movies in a low
brand–event fit condition. It suggests that in a low
brand–event fit condition, brand evaluations will be
more positive in case of an Indian movie than when a
low fit condition occurs in an American movie. Also,
there is a significant difference (t = 3.25; p < 0.001) in
purchase intention in the low brand–event fit condition
for both Hollywood (cell mean = 3.72) and Hindi (cell
mean = 4.92) movies. However, there is no significant
difference (t = 1.89; p < 0.41) in A
b
between Hollywood
(cell mean = 3.91) and Hindi (cell mean = 4.13) movies
when the brand–event fit was high. Also, there is no
significant difference (t = 1.54; p < 0.32) in purchase
intention in the high brand–event fit condition for both
Hollywood (cell mean = 3.89) and Hindi (cell mean =
4.21) movies. Therefore, support is found for H3.
Table 7: Mean Comparisons
American Movie
Low fit
Indian Movie
Low fit
t-values
(Sig.)
American Movie
High fit
Indian Movie
High fit
t-values
(Sig.)
Attitude towards Brand (A
b
) 3.17 4.80 4.02 (0.001)* 3.91 4.13 1.89 (0.41)
Purchase Intention 3.72 4.92 3.25 (0.001)* 3.89 4.21 1.54 (0.32)
Source: Author’s analysis.
Note: *Significant at p < 0.05 level.
Table 6: Results of MANOVA
Sources
MANOVA
Wilk’s
Lambda Effect Size F (p value)
Main Effects
Brand–Event Fit
(B-EF)
0.750 0.250 19.146 (0.000)*
Event Type (ET) 0.673 0.327 27.915 (0.000)*
Interaction Effects
B-EF x ET 0.914 0.086 5.404 (0.006)*
Source: Author’s analysis.
Note: *Significant at p < 0.05 level.
VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016
161
To have a better understanding of the effects of the
two independent variables, graphs were constructed
showing the mean responses for both of them for each
of the dependent variables Figures 1a & 1b.
Figure 1a: Plot for Attitude towards Brand (Ab)
Event Type
4.20
4.30
4.40
4.50
4.80
4.70
Hollywood Bollywood
fit
low fit
high fit
Es
ti
m
at
ed
M
ar
gi
n
al
M
ea
n
s
of
A
b
4.60
Figure 1b: Plot for Intention to Purchase
Event Type
3.50
4.00
4.50
5.00
6.00
5.50
Hollywood Bollywood
fit
low fit
high fit
Es
ti
m
at
ed
M
ar
gi
na
l M
ea
ns
o
f
PI
Source: Author’s analysis.
The significant interaction for each dependent variable
is visually demonstrated by the absence of parallelism
of the lines in each of the plots. The ‘attitude towards
the placed brand’ plot (Figure 1a) shows that brands
with low fit with the movie tend to draw lesser posi-
tive attitude towards the placed brand than brands that
fit well with the movie. Also, brands placed in Hindi
movies generated much more positive attitude towards
the placed brand than when brands were placed in
American movies. The interaction effect shows that
although there is little difference in the A
b
when the
brand–event fit is high, the low fit condition leads to
more positive attitude towards the placed brand when
the brand appears in Hindi movies than when the low
brand fit condition appears in Hollywood movies. The
plot of ‘purchase intention’ (Figure 1b) shows similar
results suggesting that intention to purchase is high
when the brand fits well in a Hindi movie while it is
less when the brand is a low fit in a Hollywood movie.
DISCUSSION AND IMPLICATIONS
As one of the first attempts to analyse brand placements
in the context of Hollywood and Hindi movies vis-à-vis
brand fit, this study suggests that the idea of fit, match,
or congruence between the brand and the event can be
used as a key criterion when explaining brand evalu-
ations. Our research takes us one step closer to devel-
oping fitting brand placements, as the study extends the
applicability of the idea of fit, which was till now largely
confined to sponsorship, and subjects it to the explora-
tion of finding a fit between brands and specific events,
in particular, movies. Results of the present study reveal
that such relationships between brand placement and
the outcome variables is linked with another construct,
perceived fit between the brand and the event.
In this context, the purpose of the study was to examine
the extent to which matching the brands and the movies
in which they were placed would succeed in generating
positive consumer responses in terms of positive brand
attitude and intention to purchase the placed brand. The
study also hoped to find out the difference in the effect
of brand placements, if any, based on the context of the
entertainment industry in which they were placed.
Results of this study reveal that brands placed in a
national event, which in this case is Hindi movies,
will create more positive brand evaluations in terms
of positive attitude towards the placed brand and
intention to purchase than brands that are placed in
an international event, that is, American movies. One
can attribute a number of reasons for this result to
be true. The Indian film industry has always been a
reflection of the customs and traditions of the Indian
society (Kripalani, 2006) where the audience has been
expressively involved with onscreen actors, trying
to imitate their styles. A plausible explanation for the
Indian cultural values and communication styles being
an influence on message persuasiveness (Aaker &
Maheswaran, 1997) is that India is a collectivist society
(Hofstede, 2001) where individuals operate as part of
162 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN
MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT
one or more collectives, such as family or peers. Triandis
(1995) argues that Indians are not just collectivist but
also score high on vertical collectivism, which means
that their desire to stand out from others and admira-
tion of status and celebrity is high (Sivadas, Bruvold, &
Nelson, 2008). As a result of this verticality, individuals
look up to successful people in the hierarchy, such as
movie stars. And, since passion among the Indian audi-
ences for celebrities is no lesser than idol worshipping
(Bhatia, 2000), the impact of such emotional attachment
is that when an actor performs in a film, the audience
wants to emulate their style and image. What it means
in a product placement context is that when a celebrity is
seen communicating explicitly through endorsements or
implicitly through non-verbal or indirect communication,
such as brand placements in movies, the consumers view
the brand to be associated with the celebrity whom they
admire. Without further investigation of the brand, they
make a connection between the film, the actor, the product
and its consumption, and look at product placement as
a perceptual clue which directs behaviour to purchase a
product to satisfy a need or reinforce a social status.
On the other hand, results of the study show that brands
placed in Hollywood were not as successful in gener-
ating positive consumer reactions as brands placed
in Hindi movies. Although, in the product placement
literature, the impact of context effects has not yet been
thoroughly explored, it may be argued that the level of
involvement of the Indian audience with a foreign film,
which may not be very high given the cultural differ-
ences, may have affected the processing of brands tied
to the plot. Brands placed in Hollywood movies may be
at a disadvantage in terms of their being embedded in
a context which is culturally very different from that of
an emerging economy like India. Much like the Indian
film industry, Hollywood movies too are a reflection of
their society. However, unlike India, the US has an indi-
vidualistic culture characterized by individual bene-
fits and preferences, personal success, and independ-
ence. Evidently, brands placed in such a context are less
successful in generating the desired response from an
audience which is culturally more collectivist in nature.
Furthermore, findings of the present research have con-
tributed to an increased understanding of consumers’
reactions to congruity in brand placement literature. In
conjunction with the results of past researches in the
field of brand placement (Nelson & Deshpande, 2013),
this study reveals that when the presence of a brand
is consistent with the context in which it is placed, it
would evoke more positive attitudes and behaviour
than an incongruent placement. Evidently, when people
are faced with incongruity in a message, they begin to
wonder why seemingly disparate elements are paired
together in a message for no apparent reason, leading
to frustration and negative evaluations (Mandler, 1982).
Just as the viewers have become weary of excessive
exposure to advertisements in the traditional medium,
it is feared that unwarranted and obtrusive brand place-
ments that do not fit well with the plot of the movie, is
likely to do more harm than good to the sponsors. Also,
brands that are subtly placed in the movie and those
that are not glaringly forced in the face of the viewer are
considered to enjoy a more fitting relation in the film.
By doing so, the sponsors are not taking the fun out of
the main plot of the movie by focusing too much on
brands placed. The brand, therefore, does not become
the hero of the movie but is strategically made a part of
the scene like a supporting actor.
The direct implication of such a result is that spon-
sors need to be very selective in identifying movies
in which to place their brands. With both, American
and Indian movie business, being multibillion dollar
enterprises where hundreds of movies in all genres are
produced every year (Minocha & Stonehouse, 2006),
it should not be too difficult for sponsors to choose
the right film for brand placement. A brand like Aston
Martin, used by the protagonist in the James Bond
movies, helped the business because the character in
the film clearly identified with the brand. The result
suggests that the connection between the brand and
the film is of significance and needs to be considered
for improving brand evaluations.
Evaluation of results further reveals that although
a brand that fits well with the context in which it is
placed generates a positive evaluation of the placed
brand; the condition of a brand–event misfit in a
Hollywood context will create more negative evalua-
tions among the Indian audiences than if such a discon-
nect appeared in a Hindi film. A study by Kureshi
and Sood (2011) reveals that American films contain a
greater number of brands overall. The likelihood that
all the brands featured in the film will have the same
level of fit with the character and plot of the movie is
not very high. As a result of excessive brands being
placed in the movie, two possible outcomes are likely:
first, viewers will look at the placement as conspicuous;
and second, the misplacement of the brands, if any, in
the film will become prominent. With too many brands
sharing the screen space in a single exposure or spread
out throughout the film, it is likely to draw consumers’
VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016
163
attention much more and perhaps more negatively as
too much exposure of brands will lead the viewer to
think of the movie as yet another long commercial.
In the Bollywood context, however, where the brand
placement in movies is still growing as a new medium
of advertising, exposure to brands is relatively less,
leading to lesser chances of a misfit.
Additionally, the reason for a misfit leading to less
adverse brand evaluations in Indian movies as
compared to Hollywood is that while an Indian film
is a three-hour long affair, the Hollywood flicks are of
a much shorter duration. As a result, the brands that
are placed in the Hindi movies are spread over the
entire length of the movie and even if there are times
where the brand is a misfit with the context, it is likely
to be overlooked because of the length of the movie.
The same is not true for Hollywood movies where in
a much shorter window of exposure, the movie carries
a number of brands. And if the brand is perceived to
be disconnected from the film, it is likely to be noticed
more, generating more negative evaluations. It implies
that not only should sponsors be careful in choosing
what type of film to place their brands in, but they
should also put more emphasis on placing brands in
the national entertainment event when trying to reach
the Indian audience. As one of the BRIC (Brazil, Russia,
India, and China) countries, India presents an impor-
tant emerging market with an enormous and affluent
middle-class (Bose, 2006). Ever since the global brands
have been introduced since 1991, Indians have become
consumers of global brands, and thus, India poses to
be a huge market for global brands. Based on the find-
ings of the present study, it is suggested that multina-
tional brands must look at Indian movies as a suitable
medium for reaching out to the prospective buyers.
Contribution to Research
Although brand placement has been vastly researched
in different contexts, the present research has taken
a fresh approach to investigating the effects of brand
placements in national and international entertain-
ment contexts. And the questions, thus, undertaken
to be answered make the research contemporary and
useful for marketers who are faced with the ever
perplexing question of how and when to use brand
placements for greatest effectiveness. Although a few
studies have focused on examining the fit between
brands and movies, fewer have done so in the context
of the Indian film industry and none of the previous
studies focused on exploring consumers’ evaluation of
congruent and incongruent brand placements, espe-
cially within Hollywood movies, which have a huge
viewership among the Indian audiences. By studying
the main and interaction effects of fit and entertainment
event type on consumers’ brand evaluation, this study
offers useful insights to sponsors who are looking at the
growing India market for their brands by gauging the
way Indian audiences feel about brand placements.
Limitations and Future Research
The present research has advanced our understanding
of the fit between the event and the brand in the inter-
national and national contexts and its role in the frame-
work of brand evaluations. However, the findings of
the present research need to be considered in light of
some limitations. Any study employing student popu-
lation is at risk of external validity shortcomings.
Although the critical role of external validity in research
process is significant (McGrath & Brinberg, 1983), yet
this being a pioneering research study, we placed a
heavier emphasis on the internal validity, which can
be achieved by employing a relatively homogeneous
student sample (Cook & Campbell, 1979). While we
aimed at higher levels of internal validity, we recognize
that a broader and more robust subject pool needs to be
examined before drawing generalizations.
The product placement stimuli were presented outside
of the actual movie context. Viewing several placements
in isolation is an artificial situation and it is not clear
that the effects observed in this research would be repli-
cated in a real film-viewing context. The respondents
surveyed were not aware of the researchers’ intention of
testing respondents’ perceptions of product placements
in films. The motive behind this was to recreate a natural
viewing environment. Unfortunately, this may have
resulted in many respondents regarding the viewing
session as purely a form of entertainment and, therefore,
failed to notice the placed products in the film clips.
One should also understand that a very narrow stimuli
base was used in the present study where the focus was
only on the visual placement of brands in the scenes.
While used-by-main-character is only one of the types
of brand placements used in movies, it is not the only
one. As such, these results should be verified for other
types of brand placements. In addition, future research
should attempt to include additional factors in exam-
ining relationships investigated in this article. For
example, future researchers may want to find out the
outcome of brand evaluations if the brand is used by
164 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN
MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT
the villain in the movie and if there will be any effect,
positive or negative, on the brand image.
Also, researchers need to find answers to the relevant
question of what will be the impact on brand place-
ment if multiple brands are a part of the same entertain-
ment show, such as when a number of brands are used
as background props in a movie. An interesting avenue
for future research would also be to examine what
will happen if the character endorsing a brand in the
movie is also a brand ambassador for the same brand
and appears in traditional advertising medium? For
example, Shah Rukh Khan in Phir Bhi Dil Hai Hindustani
(2000) is seen driving a Hyundai car of which he is also
the brand ambassador and can be seen endorsing the
brand in TV ads as well.
Finally, it is necessary to investigate the extent to which
placement findings do not generalize across mediums.
For example, consumers may be more tolerant of
product placements in television because broad-
cast television is an advertising-supported medium.
Thus, differences in television and film viewing habits
(Russell & Stern, 2006) may also alter the factors that
drive the success of brand placements. Studies exam-
ining the results of this study with different samples
and in different settings are certainly another appro-
priate direction for future research.
NOTES
1 Here we are referring to so-called Bollywood movies.
2 Hollywood.
3 Bollywood.
REFERENCES
Aaker, D. A., & Keller, K. L. (1990). Consumer evaluations of
brand extensions. Journal of Marketing, 54(1), 27–41.
Aaker, J. L., & Maheswaran, D. (1997). The effect of cultural
orientation on persuasion. Journal of Consumer Research,
24(3), 315–328.
Akram, A., Dwight, M., & Muhammad, S. A. (2011). Perceived
brand globalness in emerging markets and the moder-
ating role of consumer ethnocentrism. International
Journal of Emerging Markets, 6(4), 291–303.
Appadurai, A. (1996). Modernity at large: Cultural dimensions
of
globalization. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Arnett, J. J. (2000). Emerging adulthood: A theory of develop-
ment from the late teens through the twenties. American
Psychologist, 55(5), 469–480.
Bagozzi, R. P., & Yi, Y. (1989). On the use of structural equa-
tion models in experimental designs. Journal of Marketing
Research, 26(August), 271–284.
Balasubramanian, S. K. (1994). Beyond advertising and
publicity: Hybrid messages and public policy issues.
Journal of Advertising, 23(4), 29–46.
Batra, R., Venkatram, R., Dana, L. A., Steenkamp, Jan-Benedict
E. M., & Ramachander, S. (2000). Effects of brand local
and nonlocal origin on consumer attitudes in developing
countries. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 9(2), 83–95.
Bergman, C. (1989). Tobacco’s cloudy image on the silver
screen. The Christian Science Monitor, 8(July), 19.
Bhatia, T. K. (2000). Advertising in rural India: Language,
marketing communication and consumerism. Tokyo, Japan:
Tokyo Press.
Bhatnagar, N., Aksoy, L., & Malkoc, S. A. (2004). Embedded
brands within media content: The impact of message,
media, and consumer characteristics on placement effi-
cacy. In L. J. Shrum (Ed.), The psychology of entertainment
media (pp. 99–116). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
Associates.
Bose, D. (2006). Brand Bollywood: A new global entertainment
order. New Delhi: SAGE PUBLICATIONS.
Brennan, I., Dubas, K. M., & Babin, L. A. (1999). The influ-
ence of product-placement type and exposure time on
product-placement recognition. International Journal of
Advertising, 18(3), 323–337.
Bressoud, E., Lehu, J. M., & Russell, C. (2008, June 27–28).
Integrating placement and audience characteristics to
assess the recall of product placements in film: Findings
from a field study. Paper presented at the seventh
International Conference Research in Advertising
(ICORIA), Antwerp, Belgium.
Britt, B. (2002). Content, commerce deals offer answers in
overseas markets. Advertising Age, 73(42), 18–22.
Bruner, G. C., & Hensel, P. J. (1992). Marketing scales
handbook.
Chicago: American Marketing Association.
Burnett, J. J. (1993). Promotion management. Boston,
Massachusetts: Houghton Mifflin.
Cook, T. D., & Campbell, D. T. (1979). Quasi-experimentation:
Design and analysis issues for field settings. Boston,
Massachusetts: Houghton Mifflin.
Cooper, D. R., & Schindler, P. S. (2006). Business research
methods (9th ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
d’Astous, A., & Chartier, F. (2000). A study of factors affecting
consumer evaluations and memory of product place-
ments in movies. Journal of Current Issues and Research in
Advertising, 22(2), 31–40.
de Gregorio, F., & Sung, Y. (2010). Understanding attitudes
toward and behaviors in response to product place-
ment: A consumer socialization framework. Journal of
Advertising, 39(1), 83–96.
VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016
165
Deigh, R. (1985, October 28,). Softest of sells: Placing products
in movies can be a lucrative business. Washington Times,
A9-A10.
Deloitte. (2005). TMT trends: Predictions, 2005: A focus on the
media sector. Retrieved 21 January 2014, from https://
industriasdecontenido.files.wordpress.com/2010/08/
deloitte-tendencias-medios-ww-2005.pdf
DeLorme, D. E. (1998). Brand placement: A historical over-
view. In Darrel D. Muehling (Ed.), Proceedings of the
1998 Conference of the American Academy of Advertising
(pp. 305–306). Pullman, WA: American Academy of
Advertising.
deMooij, M. (1998). Global marketing and advertising.
Thousand
Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
deMooij, M., & Hofstede, G. (2002). Convergence and diver-
gence in consumer behavior: Implications for interna-
tional retailing. Journal of Retailing, 78(1), 61–69.
Dousteyssier-Fleck, N. (2004). An application processing
models
sponsorship information: The role of congruency. Proceedings
of the first journée thématique sur marketing communi-
cations, Northeast of France.
Eagle, L. (2007). Commercial media literacy: What does it
do, to whom—and does it matter? Journal of Advertising,
36(2), 101–110.
Fitzgerald, K. (2002, June 10). Eager sponsors raise the ante.
Advertising Age, 18.
Fleming, M. (1990, May 9). Product pluggola padding pic
producers budgets. Variety, p. 1.
Fontaine, I. (2001, April). Le placement de marques dans les
films:
Apports du cadre théorique de la mémoireimplicite et prop-
osition d’uneméthodologie [The placement of brands in
movies: Contributions of the theoretical framework of
implicit memory and proposal methodology]. Working
paper 287, DMSP Research Centre, University of Paris IX
Dauphine.
Fontaine, I. (2002, May 23–24). Impact persuasif du rôleaccordé
aux marques au sein de supports non publicitaires: le cas du
placement de marques dans les films [Persuasive impact of the
role given to marks in non- advertising media: The case
of brand placement in movies]. Proceedings of the 18th
Congrès de l’Association Française du Marketing, Lille,
177–200.
Gough, P. J. (2003). Agencies explore product placement, find
consumers receptive. Retrieved 21 January 2014, from www.
media-post.com-/dtls_dsp_news.cfm? NewsId=229914/
Gould, S. J., Gupta, P. B., & Grabner-Krauter, S. (2000).
Product placements in movies: Across-cultural anal-
ysis of Austrian, French and American consumers’ atti-
tudes toward this emerging, international promotional
medium. Journal of Advertising, 29(4), 41–58.
Gray, R. (2000, May). Developing a tight fit is crucial to CRM.
Marketing, 37–38.
Grein, A. F., & Gould, S. J. (1996). Globally integrated
marketing communications. Journal of Marketing
Communications, 2(3), 141–158.
Gunn, E. (2001). Product placement prize. Advertising Age,
72(7), 10.
Gupta, P. B., & Gould, S. J. (2007). Recall of Products placed
as prizes versus commercials in game show. Journal of
Current Issues and Research in Advertising, 20(1), 43–53.
Gupta, P. B., & Lord, K. R. (1998). Product placement in
movies: The effect of prominence and mode on audience
recall. Journal of Current Issues and Research in Advertising,
20(1), 47–59.
Gwinner, K. P., & Eaton, J. (1999). Building brand image
through event sponsorship: The role of image transfer.
Journal of Advertising, 28(4), 47–57.
Hall, E. T. (1959). The silent language. New York: Doubleday.
Hall, E. T. (1976). Beyond culture. New York: Doubleday.
Hall, E. T. (1984). The dance of life. Garden City, NY:
Doubleday/
Anehor.
Hamlin, R. P., & Wilson, T. (2004). The impact of cause
branding on consumer reactions to products: Does
product/cause ‘fit’ really matter? Journal of Marketing
Management, 20(7/8), 663–681.
Hofstede, G. H. (2001). Culture’s consequences: Comparing
values, behaviours, institutions, and organizations across
nations. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
Hudson, S., & Hudson, D. (2006). Branded entertainment: A
new
advertising technique or product placement in disguise?
Journal of Marketing Management, 22(5/6), 489–504.
Hulin-Salkin, B. (1989). Movie tie-ins. Incentive, 163(6), 36–
41.
Jaffe, J. (2005). Life after the 30-second spot: Energize your
brand
with a bold mix of alternatives to traditional advertising.
Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.
Karrh, J. A. (1998). Brand placement: A review. Journal of
Current Issues and Research in Advertising, 20(2), 31–49.
Karrh, J. A., Frith, K. T., & Gallison, G. (2001). Audience atti-
tudes toward brand (product) placement: Singapore and
the United States. International Journal of Advertising,
20(1), 3–24.
Karrh, J. A., McKee, K. B., & Pardun, C. J. (2003).
Practitioners’
evolving views on product placement effectiveness.
Journal of Advertising Research, 43(2), 138–149.
Kent, R. J. (1995). Competitive clutter in network television
advertising: Current levels and advertiser responses.
Journal of Advertising Research, 35(1), 49–57.
Kretchmer, S. B. (2004). Advertainment: The evolution of
product placement as a mass media marketing strategy.
Journal of Promotion Management, 10(1/2), 37–54.
Kripalani, M., & Clifford, M. L. (2003, February 10). Finally
Coke gets it right. Business Week, p. 18.
166 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN
MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT
Kripalani, C. (2006). Trendsetting and product placement in
Bollywood film: Consumerism through consumption.
New Cinemas: Journal of Contemporary Film, 4(3), 197–215.
Kureshi, S., & Sood, V. (2011). In-Film placement trends: A
comparative study of Bollywood and Hollywood. Journal
of Indian Business Research, 3(4), 244–262.
Law, S., & Braun, K. A. (2000). I’ll have what she’s having:
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx
Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx

More Related Content

Similar to Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx

Digital Marketing Ebook Topic-1
Digital Marketing Ebook Topic-1Digital Marketing Ebook Topic-1
Digital Marketing Ebook Topic-1Artdizix
 
Rewiring marketing: a practice based approach
Rewiring marketing: a practice based approachRewiring marketing: a practice based approach
Rewiring marketing: a practice based approachBrowne & Mohan
 
Marketing Plan.ppt
Marketing Plan.pptMarketing Plan.ppt
Marketing Plan.pptAnup597384
 
Marketing Mix (Four Ps)Product StrategyBriefly describe your pro.docx
Marketing Mix (Four Ps)Product StrategyBriefly describe your pro.docxMarketing Mix (Four Ps)Product StrategyBriefly describe your pro.docx
Marketing Mix (Four Ps)Product StrategyBriefly describe your pro.docxdrennanmicah
 
Digital marketing strategy_guide_intermediate_level
Digital marketing strategy_guide_intermediate_levelDigital marketing strategy_guide_intermediate_level
Digital marketing strategy_guide_intermediate_levelNarendraNath26
 
Strategic Modern Marketing Workbook
Strategic Modern Marketing Workbook Strategic Modern Marketing Workbook
Strategic Modern Marketing Workbook Veronica Stenberg
 
Teamworks Customer Relationship Marketing
Teamworks Customer Relationship MarketingTeamworks Customer Relationship Marketing
Teamworks Customer Relationship MarketingJudy Lane
 
High performance marketing_plan_jan2015
High performance marketing_plan_jan2015High performance marketing_plan_jan2015
High performance marketing_plan_jan2015Cheryl Ponder
 
The High-Performance Marketing Plan
The High-Performance Marketing PlanThe High-Performance Marketing Plan
The High-Performance Marketing PlanMohamed Mahdy
 
Second Interview Questions and Answers for Marketing Roles
Second Interview Questions and Answers for Marketing RolesSecond Interview Questions and Answers for Marketing Roles
Second Interview Questions and Answers for Marketing RolesHireQuotient
 
What are the strategies for business startup ittisa
What are the strategies for business startup   ittisaWhat are the strategies for business startup   ittisa
What are the strategies for business startup ittisaIttisa
 
Key Parameters For A Successful Digital Marketing Campaign.pdf
Key Parameters For A Successful Digital Marketing Campaign.pdfKey Parameters For A Successful Digital Marketing Campaign.pdf
Key Parameters For A Successful Digital Marketing Campaign.pdfWebGuru Infosystems Pvt. Ltd.
 
marketing automation guide
marketing automation guidemarketing automation guide
marketing automation guideAlison Belsham
 
Demand Generation Program Playbook
Demand Generation Program PlaybookDemand Generation Program Playbook
Demand Generation Program PlaybookDemand Metric
 
marketing for dummies / introduction to marketing / what is marketing
marketing for dummies / introduction to marketing / what is marketingmarketing for dummies / introduction to marketing / what is marketing
marketing for dummies / introduction to marketing / what is marketingskyrocketskyrocket
 
HOW TO MEASURE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF INTEGRATED MARKETING CAMPAIGNS.pdf
HOW TO MEASURE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF INTEGRATED MARKETING CAMPAIGNS.pdfHOW TO MEASURE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF INTEGRATED MARKETING CAMPAIGNS.pdf
HOW TO MEASURE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF INTEGRATED MARKETING CAMPAIGNS.pdfiM4U Digital Marketing Agency
 

Similar to Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx (20)

Digital Marketing Ebook Topic-1
Digital Marketing Ebook Topic-1Digital Marketing Ebook Topic-1
Digital Marketing Ebook Topic-1
 
Rewiring marketing: a practice based approach
Rewiring marketing: a practice based approachRewiring marketing: a practice based approach
Rewiring marketing: a practice based approach
 
Marketing Plan.ppt
Marketing Plan.pptMarketing Plan.ppt
Marketing Plan.ppt
 
Marketing and start ups
Marketing and start ups Marketing and start ups
Marketing and start ups
 
Marketing and start ups
Marketing and start upsMarketing and start ups
Marketing and start ups
 
Marketing Mix (Four Ps)Product StrategyBriefly describe your pro.docx
Marketing Mix (Four Ps)Product StrategyBriefly describe your pro.docxMarketing Mix (Four Ps)Product StrategyBriefly describe your pro.docx
Marketing Mix (Four Ps)Product StrategyBriefly describe your pro.docx
 
Digital marketing strategy_guide_intermediate_level
Digital marketing strategy_guide_intermediate_levelDigital marketing strategy_guide_intermediate_level
Digital marketing strategy_guide_intermediate_level
 
Strategic Modern Marketing Workbook
Strategic Modern Marketing Workbook Strategic Modern Marketing Workbook
Strategic Modern Marketing Workbook
 
Teamworks Customer Relationship Marketing
Teamworks Customer Relationship MarketingTeamworks Customer Relationship Marketing
Teamworks Customer Relationship Marketing
 
High performance marketing_plan_jan2015
High performance marketing_plan_jan2015High performance marketing_plan_jan2015
High performance marketing_plan_jan2015
 
The High-Performance Marketing Plan
The High-Performance Marketing PlanThe High-Performance Marketing Plan
The High-Performance Marketing Plan
 
Second Interview Questions and Answers for Marketing Roles
Second Interview Questions and Answers for Marketing RolesSecond Interview Questions and Answers for Marketing Roles
Second Interview Questions and Answers for Marketing Roles
 
Content Marketing Metrics: What's Your Plan?
Content Marketing Metrics: What's Your Plan?Content Marketing Metrics: What's Your Plan?
Content Marketing Metrics: What's Your Plan?
 
What are the strategies for business startup ittisa
What are the strategies for business startup   ittisaWhat are the strategies for business startup   ittisa
What are the strategies for business startup ittisa
 
Adman Lecture 6
Adman Lecture 6Adman Lecture 6
Adman Lecture 6
 
Key Parameters For A Successful Digital Marketing Campaign.pdf
Key Parameters For A Successful Digital Marketing Campaign.pdfKey Parameters For A Successful Digital Marketing Campaign.pdf
Key Parameters For A Successful Digital Marketing Campaign.pdf
 
marketing automation guide
marketing automation guidemarketing automation guide
marketing automation guide
 
Demand Generation Program Playbook
Demand Generation Program PlaybookDemand Generation Program Playbook
Demand Generation Program Playbook
 
marketing for dummies / introduction to marketing / what is marketing
marketing for dummies / introduction to marketing / what is marketingmarketing for dummies / introduction to marketing / what is marketing
marketing for dummies / introduction to marketing / what is marketing
 
HOW TO MEASURE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF INTEGRATED MARKETING CAMPAIGNS.pdf
HOW TO MEASURE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF INTEGRATED MARKETING CAMPAIGNS.pdfHOW TO MEASURE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF INTEGRATED MARKETING CAMPAIGNS.pdf
HOW TO MEASURE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF INTEGRATED MARKETING CAMPAIGNS.pdf
 

More from croysierkathey

1.  Discuss the organization and the family role in every one of the.docx
1.  Discuss the organization and the family role in every one of the.docx1.  Discuss the organization and the family role in every one of the.docx
1.  Discuss the organization and the family role in every one of the.docxcroysierkathey
 
1.  Compare and contrast DEmilios Capitalism and Gay Identity .docx
1.  Compare and contrast DEmilios Capitalism and Gay Identity .docx1.  Compare and contrast DEmilios Capitalism and Gay Identity .docx
1.  Compare and contrast DEmilios Capitalism and Gay Identity .docxcroysierkathey
 
1.Purpose the purpose of this essay is to spread awareness .docx
1.Purpose the purpose of this essay is to spread awareness .docx1.Purpose the purpose of this essay is to spread awareness .docx
1.Purpose the purpose of this essay is to spread awareness .docxcroysierkathey
 
1.  Tell us why it is your favorite film.2.  Talk about the .docx
1.  Tell us why it is your favorite film.2.  Talk about the .docx1.  Tell us why it is your favorite film.2.  Talk about the .docx
1.  Tell us why it is your favorite film.2.  Talk about the .docxcroysierkathey
 
1.What are the main issues facing Fargo and Town Manager Susan.docx
1.What are the main issues facing Fargo and Town Manager Susan.docx1.What are the main issues facing Fargo and Town Manager Susan.docx
1.What are the main issues facing Fargo and Town Manager Susan.docxcroysierkathey
 
1.Writing Practice in Reading a PhotographAttached Files.docx
1.Writing Practice in Reading a PhotographAttached Files.docx1.Writing Practice in Reading a PhotographAttached Files.docx
1.Writing Practice in Reading a PhotographAttached Files.docxcroysierkathey
 
1.Some say that analytics in general dehumanize managerial activitie.docx
1.Some say that analytics in general dehumanize managerial activitie.docx1.Some say that analytics in general dehumanize managerial activitie.docx
1.Some say that analytics in general dehumanize managerial activitie.docxcroysierkathey
 
1.What is the psychological term for the symptoms James experiences .docx
1.What is the psychological term for the symptoms James experiences .docx1.What is the psychological term for the symptoms James experiences .docx
1.What is the psychological term for the symptoms James experiences .docxcroysierkathey
 
1.Write at least 500 words discussing the benefits of using R with H.docx
1.Write at least 500 words discussing the benefits of using R with H.docx1.Write at least 500 words discussing the benefits of using R with H.docx
1.Write at least 500 words discussing the benefits of using R with H.docxcroysierkathey
 
1.What is Starbucks’ ROA for 2012, 2011, and 2010 Why might focusin.docx
1.What is Starbucks’ ROA for 2012, 2011, and 2010 Why might focusin.docx1.What is Starbucks’ ROA for 2012, 2011, and 2010 Why might focusin.docx
1.What is Starbucks’ ROA for 2012, 2011, and 2010 Why might focusin.docxcroysierkathey
 
1.  Discuss the cultural development of the Japanese and the Jewis.docx
1.  Discuss the cultural development of the Japanese and the Jewis.docx1.  Discuss the cultural development of the Japanese and the Jewis.docx
1.  Discuss the cultural development of the Japanese and the Jewis.docxcroysierkathey
 
1.  Discuss at least 2  contextual factors(family, peers,  school,.docx
1.  Discuss at least 2  contextual factors(family, peers,  school,.docx1.  Discuss at least 2  contextual factors(family, peers,  school,.docx
1.  Discuss at least 2  contextual factors(family, peers,  school,.docxcroysierkathey
 
1.Write at least 500 words in APA format discussing how to use senti.docx
1.Write at least 500 words in APA format discussing how to use senti.docx1.Write at least 500 words in APA format discussing how to use senti.docx
1.Write at least 500 words in APA format discussing how to use senti.docxcroysierkathey
 
1.The following clause was added to the Food and Drug Actthe S.docx
1.The following clause was added to the Food and Drug Actthe S.docx1.The following clause was added to the Food and Drug Actthe S.docx
1.The following clause was added to the Food and Drug Actthe S.docxcroysierkathey
 
1.What are social determinants of health  Explain how social determ.docx
1.What are social determinants of health  Explain how social determ.docx1.What are social determinants of health  Explain how social determ.docx
1.What are social determinants of health  Explain how social determ.docxcroysierkathey
 
1.This week, we’ve been introduced to the humanities and have ta.docx
1.This week, we’ve been introduced to the humanities and have ta.docx1.This week, we’ve been introduced to the humanities and have ta.docx
1.This week, we’ve been introduced to the humanities and have ta.docxcroysierkathey
 
1.What are barriers to listening2.Communicators identif.docx
1.What are barriers to listening2.Communicators identif.docx1.What are barriers to listening2.Communicators identif.docx
1.What are barriers to listening2.Communicators identif.docxcroysierkathey
 
1.Timeline description and details There are multiple way.docx
1.Timeline description and details There are multiple way.docx1.Timeline description and details There are multiple way.docx
1.Timeline description and details There are multiple way.docxcroysierkathey
 
1.The PresidentArticle II of the Constitution establishe.docx
1.The PresidentArticle II of the Constitution establishe.docx1.The PresidentArticle II of the Constitution establishe.docx
1.The PresidentArticle II of the Constitution establishe.docxcroysierkathey
 
1.What other potential root causes might influence patient fal.docx
1.What other potential root causes might influence patient fal.docx1.What other potential root causes might influence patient fal.docx
1.What other potential root causes might influence patient fal.docxcroysierkathey
 

More from croysierkathey (20)

1.  Discuss the organization and the family role in every one of the.docx
1.  Discuss the organization and the family role in every one of the.docx1.  Discuss the organization and the family role in every one of the.docx
1.  Discuss the organization and the family role in every one of the.docx
 
1.  Compare and contrast DEmilios Capitalism and Gay Identity .docx
1.  Compare and contrast DEmilios Capitalism and Gay Identity .docx1.  Compare and contrast DEmilios Capitalism and Gay Identity .docx
1.  Compare and contrast DEmilios Capitalism and Gay Identity .docx
 
1.Purpose the purpose of this essay is to spread awareness .docx
1.Purpose the purpose of this essay is to spread awareness .docx1.Purpose the purpose of this essay is to spread awareness .docx
1.Purpose the purpose of this essay is to spread awareness .docx
 
1.  Tell us why it is your favorite film.2.  Talk about the .docx
1.  Tell us why it is your favorite film.2.  Talk about the .docx1.  Tell us why it is your favorite film.2.  Talk about the .docx
1.  Tell us why it is your favorite film.2.  Talk about the .docx
 
1.What are the main issues facing Fargo and Town Manager Susan.docx
1.What are the main issues facing Fargo and Town Manager Susan.docx1.What are the main issues facing Fargo and Town Manager Susan.docx
1.What are the main issues facing Fargo and Town Manager Susan.docx
 
1.Writing Practice in Reading a PhotographAttached Files.docx
1.Writing Practice in Reading a PhotographAttached Files.docx1.Writing Practice in Reading a PhotographAttached Files.docx
1.Writing Practice in Reading a PhotographAttached Files.docx
 
1.Some say that analytics in general dehumanize managerial activitie.docx
1.Some say that analytics in general dehumanize managerial activitie.docx1.Some say that analytics in general dehumanize managerial activitie.docx
1.Some say that analytics in general dehumanize managerial activitie.docx
 
1.What is the psychological term for the symptoms James experiences .docx
1.What is the psychological term for the symptoms James experiences .docx1.What is the psychological term for the symptoms James experiences .docx
1.What is the psychological term for the symptoms James experiences .docx
 
1.Write at least 500 words discussing the benefits of using R with H.docx
1.Write at least 500 words discussing the benefits of using R with H.docx1.Write at least 500 words discussing the benefits of using R with H.docx
1.Write at least 500 words discussing the benefits of using R with H.docx
 
1.What is Starbucks’ ROA for 2012, 2011, and 2010 Why might focusin.docx
1.What is Starbucks’ ROA for 2012, 2011, and 2010 Why might focusin.docx1.What is Starbucks’ ROA for 2012, 2011, and 2010 Why might focusin.docx
1.What is Starbucks’ ROA for 2012, 2011, and 2010 Why might focusin.docx
 
1.  Discuss the cultural development of the Japanese and the Jewis.docx
1.  Discuss the cultural development of the Japanese and the Jewis.docx1.  Discuss the cultural development of the Japanese and the Jewis.docx
1.  Discuss the cultural development of the Japanese and the Jewis.docx
 
1.  Discuss at least 2  contextual factors(family, peers,  school,.docx
1.  Discuss at least 2  contextual factors(family, peers,  school,.docx1.  Discuss at least 2  contextual factors(family, peers,  school,.docx
1.  Discuss at least 2  contextual factors(family, peers,  school,.docx
 
1.Write at least 500 words in APA format discussing how to use senti.docx
1.Write at least 500 words in APA format discussing how to use senti.docx1.Write at least 500 words in APA format discussing how to use senti.docx
1.Write at least 500 words in APA format discussing how to use senti.docx
 
1.The following clause was added to the Food and Drug Actthe S.docx
1.The following clause was added to the Food and Drug Actthe S.docx1.The following clause was added to the Food and Drug Actthe S.docx
1.The following clause was added to the Food and Drug Actthe S.docx
 
1.What are social determinants of health  Explain how social determ.docx
1.What are social determinants of health  Explain how social determ.docx1.What are social determinants of health  Explain how social determ.docx
1.What are social determinants of health  Explain how social determ.docx
 
1.This week, we’ve been introduced to the humanities and have ta.docx
1.This week, we’ve been introduced to the humanities and have ta.docx1.This week, we’ve been introduced to the humanities and have ta.docx
1.This week, we’ve been introduced to the humanities and have ta.docx
 
1.What are barriers to listening2.Communicators identif.docx
1.What are barriers to listening2.Communicators identif.docx1.What are barriers to listening2.Communicators identif.docx
1.What are barriers to listening2.Communicators identif.docx
 
1.Timeline description and details There are multiple way.docx
1.Timeline description and details There are multiple way.docx1.Timeline description and details There are multiple way.docx
1.Timeline description and details There are multiple way.docx
 
1.The PresidentArticle II of the Constitution establishe.docx
1.The PresidentArticle II of the Constitution establishe.docx1.The PresidentArticle II of the Constitution establishe.docx
1.The PresidentArticle II of the Constitution establishe.docx
 
1.What other potential root causes might influence patient fal.docx
1.What other potential root causes might influence patient fal.docx1.What other potential root causes might influence patient fal.docx
1.What other potential root causes might influence patient fal.docx
 

Recently uploaded

Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...Krashi Coaching
 
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxEmployee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxNirmalaLoungPoorunde1
 
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdfssuser54595a
 
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptxOrganic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptxVS Mahajan Coaching Centre
 
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxIntroduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxpboyjonauth
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Celine George
 
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentAlper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentInMediaRes1
 
_Math 4-Q4 Week 5.pptx Steps in Collecting Data
_Math 4-Q4 Week 5.pptx Steps in Collecting Data_Math 4-Q4 Week 5.pptx Steps in Collecting Data
_Math 4-Q4 Week 5.pptx Steps in Collecting DataJhengPantaleon
 
Proudly South Africa powerpoint Thorisha.pptx
Proudly South Africa powerpoint Thorisha.pptxProudly South Africa powerpoint Thorisha.pptx
Proudly South Africa powerpoint Thorisha.pptxthorishapillay1
 
ENGLISH5 QUARTER4 MODULE1 WEEK1-3 How Visual and Multimedia Elements.pptx
ENGLISH5 QUARTER4 MODULE1 WEEK1-3 How Visual and Multimedia Elements.pptxENGLISH5 QUARTER4 MODULE1 WEEK1-3 How Visual and Multimedia Elements.pptx
ENGLISH5 QUARTER4 MODULE1 WEEK1-3 How Visual and Multimedia Elements.pptxAnaBeatriceAblay2
 
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy ReformA Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy ReformChameera Dedduwage
 
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxiammrhaywood
 
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfSanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfsanyamsingh5019
 
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionMastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionSafetyChain Software
 
Painted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of India
Painted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of IndiaPainted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of India
Painted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of IndiaVirag Sontakke
 
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityParis 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityGeoBlogs
 
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17Celine George
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
 
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxEmployee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
 
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
 
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptxOrganic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
 
9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini Delhi NCR
9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini  Delhi NCR9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini  Delhi NCR
9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini Delhi NCR
 
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxIntroduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
 
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentAlper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
 
_Math 4-Q4 Week 5.pptx Steps in Collecting Data
_Math 4-Q4 Week 5.pptx Steps in Collecting Data_Math 4-Q4 Week 5.pptx Steps in Collecting Data
_Math 4-Q4 Week 5.pptx Steps in Collecting Data
 
Proudly South Africa powerpoint Thorisha.pptx
Proudly South Africa powerpoint Thorisha.pptxProudly South Africa powerpoint Thorisha.pptx
Proudly South Africa powerpoint Thorisha.pptx
 
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
 
ENGLISH5 QUARTER4 MODULE1 WEEK1-3 How Visual and Multimedia Elements.pptx
ENGLISH5 QUARTER4 MODULE1 WEEK1-3 How Visual and Multimedia Elements.pptxENGLISH5 QUARTER4 MODULE1 WEEK1-3 How Visual and Multimedia Elements.pptx
ENGLISH5 QUARTER4 MODULE1 WEEK1-3 How Visual and Multimedia Elements.pptx
 
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy ReformA Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
 
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
 
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfSanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
 
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionMastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
 
Painted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of India
Painted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of IndiaPainted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of India
Painted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of India
 
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityParis 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
 
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
How to Configure Email Server in Odoo 17
 
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSDStaff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
 

Leadership Development PlanMBA 670This Leadership Development.docx

  • 1. Leadership Development PlanMBA 670 This Leadership Development Plan serves as your road map for training and development activities that will enhance your leadership competencies. As you approach the end of your MBA program reflect on your continuing career goals, the skills you will need to achieve them, and the influence you would like to have on your organization. Your name: Your current job title Career Goal Make sure your goal is SMART: specific, measurable, achievable, realistic, and time-bound. [Write a response of no more than 100 words here.] Skills Development Needs What are the constraints in your skills, knowledge, and experience from the viewpoint of improving your organization’s performance? [Write a response of no more than 200 words here.] How can you enhance your skills, knowledge, and experience to
  • 2. influence changes in your organization? [Write a response of no more than 200 words here.] Personal Impact on Organization Performance How can you personally influence one or more performance measures in your organization? [Write a response of no more than 200 words here.] What role can you play to enhance the level of trust necessary for strategic changes in your organization? [Write a response of no more than 200 words here.] Print this page, then sign and date the hard copy.Signature _____________________Date _______________ What are examples of ethical climates in the accounting discipline? · Continuing education requirements for certified accountants - state specific licensures and rules · Certified Managerial Accounting - standards · CMA Code of Conduct · IMA Code of Conduct · Auditing practices · AICPA - Code of Conduct
  • 3. · Internal Auditing practices · Government regulations - SOX · Climates to prevent insider trading · Cultural influences to ethical climates in accounting International Management Review Vol. 12 No. 2 2016 56 The Marketer’s Action Plan (MAP): Six Steps to Developing Effective Marketing Plans in B2B Marketing Programs Eric Gagnon The Business Marketing Institute, Chicago, IL 60610 USA Business-to-business marketing professionals are always interested in finding better tools to help them create marketing plans that generate better, and more measurable, response. In our BMI online CRM Field Marketing (CRM-FM) training and certification program, we’ve developed the Marketer’s Action Plan (MAP), a step-by-step process for helping you plan, develop, execute, measure, and adapt any marketing activity. While intended for use with CRM systems, where measurement of marketing programs (also known as "campaigns" in most CRM systems) is made far easier
  • 4. by tracking them within CRM, you don’t need to use a CRM system to implement this process in any marketing plan. Even better, the Marketer’s Action Plan can be used for any marketing activity that is part of your overall marketing program—from print advertising, to direct mail, trade shows, or online-based marketing activities. The MAP helps you develop an organized mindset for solid execution, and a discipline for measurement in every marketing project you develop for your company or client. The Marketer’s Action Plan (MAP) describes the six stages in the process of marketing execution using on-demand CRM to plan, execute, measure, monitor, and improve your marketing plan. This action plan describes both the general execution steps required to develop and execute any type of marketing project as a campaign in your CRM system, and the actions required over the process of the campaign to insure that leads are properly tracked and measured for a campaign, and then moved along into your lead development program, where diligent coordination between you and your sales team helps to convert as many of these prospects into customers, over the length of your sales cycle. This action plan also accounts for the all-important final step of assessing and improving poor sales response for a campaign which is likely to occur during implementation of your marketing program. Steps in the MAP Process Using MAP, the planning, execution, and management stages for any individual marketing activity can be
  • 5. broken down into six action steps for any marketing project (campaign) in any on-demand CRM system, as follows: 1) Create Your Plan; 2) Plan for Measurement; 3) Execute; 4) Track, Measure, Monitor, and Assess; 5) Evaluate, Adapt, and Improve; 6) Follow Through Step 1. Create Your Plan Marketing is mostly tactical: There are formal marketing plans and there are informal ones, but for marketing professionals in the real world, the best plan is a set of tactical marketing projects (CRM campaigns) you can develop and put into action immediately to meet the marketing opportunities that generate sales response for your company. After all, when everyone gets up from the table from the marketing planning meeting, what’s left is a list of tactical activities that must be executed: Ads, mailings, trade shows, and the other marketing projects that must be developed and executed. Each of these tactical activities is a campaign in your on-demand CRM system, and the complete schedule of these campaigns comprises your marketing plan. The MAP helps you optimize each of these tactical activities for maximum sales response and measurability. Define your campaign’s objective: The first action planning step is to define the objective (or goal) of the campaign. Nearly always, this can be expressed as a description of the execution of the marketing
  • 6. International Management Review Vol. 12 No. 2 2016 57 project (campaign) at hand, tied to the goal to be accomplished by this project. For example, the execution of any specific direct mail campaign is to develop a mailing targeted to one or more identified mailing list(s), to meet the goal of generating measurable sales leads for followup by your company’s sales team; for a trade show, the purpose of the execution is to draw potential prospects to your booth at the show, qualify and capture their contact information, with the goal of generating a measurable number of leads to be followed up with by your company’s sales reps after the show. Define your prospect targeting: Once the objectives have been established for the campaign, the next step is to identify the types of individuals your campaign must reach. This is a process of targeting these individuals, by job title, purchasing responsibility, trade publications read, trade shows attended, or some other means which is identifiable by a marketing medium (trade publication, trade show, mailing list, keyword search program, etc.) to identify one or more groups of potential prospects who might buy your company’s products. Just as an experienced sales professional knows how to identify
  • 7. the most likely buyers at a company for his or her product, as well as identifying the other “influencers” who also must be convinced to buy the product, prospect targeting reduces your market to the universe of potential buyers who are more likely to be interested in buying, using, or applying your product than other individuals in your market. Some marketing methods, such as direct mail and keyword search text advertising, can be used to target the kinds of prospects you want to reach more precisely than other methods, such as print advertising or trade shows. For example, if you’re involved in a market test to determine who your prospect is, your targeting may be broad; if you know your market, you are better off targeting prospects as precisely as possible, since you’re also very likely to know who buys your company’s products and where they work in your market. Sometimes, even if incorrect prospect targeting was the cause of an underperforming campaign, this campaign may eventually lead you to better targeting on subsequent marketing efforts, as you learn, from the few prospects who did respond to your ad, mailing, or other campaign, who are the better prospects to reach with your marketing efforts. Once defined, prospect targeting then dictates every other aspect in the development of your marketing program and its deliverables, such as sales copy, presentation, positioning, and the promotional offer used in the campaign. Defining your objectives and your targeting also helps you to decide on (or confirm) the best marketing method to use for your campaign.
  • 8. Planning for lead development: Of course, most products sold in business-to-business markets are complex and expensive, which means they often require a fairly lengthy sales cycle. During this period, which may span many months (or even a year or more), consider what happens to a lead after it is generated by your campaign. If you already have a lead development program in place, determine whether leads generated from the campaign you’re planning should flow into your existing lead development program, or if prospects who reach you from this campaign are different in some way (such as their job title or technical background) that justifies sending them different messaging deliverables for lead development. Plan ahead for these changes, so you’ll have the necessary deliverables (white papers, etc.) developed and ready as leads arrive from your campaign. Step 2. Plan for Measurement After you have defined your objective and your prospect targeting, give careful thought to how you are going to measure your campaign. The best and usually the only worthwhile way to measure a campaign is sales response: Counting the number of leads who respond to your ad or mailing, provide their contact information in your company’s booth at a trade show, or fill in their e-mail addresses on one of your Web landing pages in response to your keyword search advertising. Measuring sales response is only the first step in effective campaign measurement: Because on-demand CRM systems allow you to track every new sale all the way back to the original campaign that generated the lead which eventually led to the sale, you can also use your CRM system to track any campaign’s overall return on investment (ROI); this is one of the most powerful
  • 9. features of on-demand CRM systems. International Management Review Vol. 12 No. 2 2016 58 Develop a promotional offer: As you can see, calculating return on investment in on-demand CRM campaigns can only happen once sales response is generated, but another important task at the planning stage of every campaign as a marketing professional is to determine not just how prospects will contact your company, but to develop the means by which they’ll be motivated to respond. You could rely solely on the persuasive power of the strong, compelling copy and benefits used in your ad or mailing to motivate prospects to contact you, but you can increase your chances of generating solid sales response by providing “something extra:” An information premium, promotional offer, or other “call-to-action” offer that motivates potential prospects to contact your company sooner instead of later (which usually means “never”). Associating leads to a campaign: Wherever there is a known universe of potential prospects identified and in your possession, such as a mailing list, or a list of selected leads already in your on-demand CRM database, the next step in planning to measure is linking, or “associating” these identified potential prospects to your campaign. By associating these records to the campaign,
  • 10. you make it easy to match up the prospects who respond to the campaign to their corresponding linked record in your CRM system; these matches count as sales response, which is the first step in measuring a campaign’s effectiveness and final return on investment. The final step in planning for measurement is to insure that leads received from a campaign will be captured to your CRM system, either by sales reps or administrative staff, who receive phone calls, e-mail, or reply cards from prospects who respond to a campaign, from trade show contacts, online, or from Web landing pages on your Web site. This step occurs both during this stage and during execution of the campaign in the next stage. Step 3. Execute Marketing execution defines all the steps involved in the process of developing any marketing project. Marketing execution encompasses both the deliverables required, like ad layouts, direct mail packages, etc., and the critical process of completing every step in the process involved for every type of campaign. Execution is the most important part of any marketing project that is a campaign in your CRM system and, next to the effective presentation of the deliverables used in the campaign, poor execution is often a major cause of failure in a marketing project. Solid, timely execution that gets your campaign delivered on time to meet the marketing or sales opportunity is such a critical aspect of the success of your marketing program using your company’s CRM system that most of the content of this workbook is focused on marketing execution.
  • 11. The end result of all marketing execution results in completing your campaign and getting it in front of the prospects you’ve targeted in your market: Placing your ad in a trade publication to be received by its subscribers, dropping your mailing to its recipients, opening your booth at a trade show, and any other marketing activity that results in getting your deliverables in front of your potential prospects completes its execution and moves your action plan to the next stage. Step 4. Track, Measure, Monitor, and Assess Once the campaign is executed, the process of inputting or capturing leads to your on-demand CRM system takes place. Contact information for a lead is captured by phone, e-mail, Web, or mailed-in reply cards, and matched to their associated record in the CRM campaign or, if a new lead, input or imported to your CRM leads database. Useful measurement of marketing programs in an on-demand CRM system begins with accurate, diligent logging of leads generated to the CRM campaign responsible for generating the lead. At this stage, by carefully monitoring this process as leads are input, imported, and/or matched to existing leads associated to a campaign in your company’s CRM system, you can insure that all generated leads are linked to the campaign that created them. Once a lead can be linked to a campaign, the sales response of that campaign can be measured. If as many generated leads as possible can be precisely linked to this campaign, the more accurate its final measurement will be.
  • 12. International Management Review Vol. 12 No. 2 2016 59 As leads arrive in response to a campaign, over time you can begin to assess the performance of the campaign, using the measurement criteria you established in the previous step 2.). You will usually be able to get a fairly good early indication of how much sales response is generated by the campaign over the first couple of weeks, and you can determine the total sales response to most marketing activities (i.e., number of initial leads generated from that campaign) well within 60 days of the date the first leads responded to that campaign. Step 5. Evaluate, Adapt, and Improve Over time, and as most of the sales response is generated by the campaign, you can now more accurately project its final sales response, and get an early indication of its financial return. Since sales cycles for B2B products often go for many months between the time a lead is generated and before the prospect decides to buy, it may be difficult for you to calculate an accurate, final return on investment for a campaign, but you can determine the reasonably accurate final sales response (number of leads generated, and cost-per-inquiry) for a campaign after a few weeks. By comparing response to the campaign against response received from previous campaigns, by this time you will have a clear indication whether or not
  • 13. the campaign was successful, failed, or landed somewhere in between, relative to the other campaigns in your marketing plan. Sometimes, and this is especially true for marketing efforts launched in new markets or industries, or for new product launches or startups, response from a campaign may fall well below your initial projections. The smart marketing professional prepares for this possible outcome, and knows the steps he or she must take to examine the positive and negative results of their underperforming campaign, find their underlying marketing (and, sometimes, product-related) causes, revise and improve the campaign, and, using effective execution, get the new campaign back online, as fast as possible, to generate better sales response on its next iteration. Step 6. Follow Through As prospects respond to your campaign, as they are contacted and qualified by your sales team, they also enter into your lead development process: This is the marketing program that begins after the lead is generated, and which moves these interested prospects through the sales cycle. As your sales reps contact their prospects who have responded to a campaign, they learn more about the prospect’s business, their business problems, applications needs, product preferences, buying intention, and other issues as they relate to your company’s product. During this process, sales reps provide the prospect with additional information on your company’s product from your CRM system’s document library, and give their prospect the opportunity to receive
  • 14. ongoing content from your company, in the form of opt-in e- mail newsletters and periodic technical, applications, and editorial information about your company and its product. This is all part of your ongoing lead development process, which is a combination of marketing activities including e-mail messaging programs, mailings, trade show and event promotions, and other marketing projects specifically targeted to prospects who, through this coordinated lead development effort by marketing and sales, are being moved closer to making their purchase decision in your company’s sales cycle. By providing a systematic approach to every marketing activity, and by helping you to plan for measurement of every marketing activity early in the planning process, the Marketer’s Action Plan provides an organized framework for helping you to better plan and execute your marketing program. Copyright of International Management Review is the property of American Scholars Press and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016 149
  • 15. Consumer Response to Brand Placement in Movies: Investigating the Brand-Event Fit Komal Nagar R E S E A R C H KEY WORDS Brand Placement Brand–Event Fit Movies Attitude towards the Brand includes research articles that focus on the analysis and resolution of managerial and academic issues based on analytical and empirical or case research Movies offer the perfect media site for placement of brands as part of the emerging marketing strategy. Although attempts to analyse brand placements have been made in the past, the same needs more attention in the Indian context. Given the exposure of Indian audiences to both national and international entertainment industry, it is only
  • 16. reasonable to expect the entertainment event context to have an impact on consumers’ evaluation of the brands placed in each context. The present research attempts to extend the applicability of the idea of fit, which was till now largely confined to sponsorship and subjects it to the exploration of finding a fit between brands and specific events, in particular, movies. Because the link between country of origin of the entertainment event (national/international) and brand, place- ment is a relevant area of speculation, the present research aims to study this relation- ship within the national/international context. Results of an experimental study among 120 respondents are as follows: • Brands placed in a national event will create more positive brand evaluations in terms of positive attitude towards the placed brand and intention to purchase than brands that are placed in an international event. • When the presence of a brand is consistent with the context in which it is placed, it would evoke more positive attitudes and behaviour than an incongruent placement. • Evaluation of results further reveals that although a brand that fits well with the context in which it is placed generates a positive evaluation of the placed brand, the condition of a brand-event misfit in a Hollywood context will create more negative evaluations among the Indian audiences than if such a
  • 17. disconnect appeared in a Hindi film. In other words, a brand may have more to lose in case of a misfit with the international entertainment event than with a national entertainment event. Based on the findings of the present study, it is suggested that multinational brands must look at the Indian movies as a suitable medium for reaching out to the prospective buyers as Indians have become consumers of global brands and thus pose to be a huge market for global brands. VIKALPA The Journal for Decision Makers 41(2) 149–167 © 2016 Indian Institute of Management, Ahmedabad SAGE Publications sagepub.in/home.nav DOI: 10.1177/0256090916642678 http://vik.sagepub.com Executive Summary 150 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT
  • 18. A s the line between entertainment and marketing communication gets increasingly blended or even erased (de Gregorio & Sung, 2010; Eagle, 2007; Steel, 2007; Winkler & Buckner, 2006), the notion of brand placement in an entertainment context receives considerable attention from scholars and practitioners alike. Although there are many definitions of the term, brand or product placement have often been used inter- changeably and generally refer to the use of a prod- uct’s name, packaging, signage, or other trademarks in media (Steortz, 1987). Screening thousands of films every year, the film industry is fast emerging as the medium with the maximum potential to capture and convert audiences to potential consumers. Tag Heuer in Don (2006), Coke in Dhoom 2 (2006), Singapore Tourism Board in Krrish (2006), or Pepsi in Pearl Harbour (2001), product placements have a very significant role in Indian1 and international2 movies. Such placements have also started to appear in television series (Fitzgerald, 2002), live shows (Matthews, 2005), video- games (Gunn, 2001; Nelson, Keum, & Yaros, 2004), and even books (Kretchmer, 2004; Moser, Bryant, & Sylvester, 2004; Turner, 2004). The reason behind using product placement in these media, however, remains the same: generating additional income for the producer while creating an opportunity for the advertisers to present their offering in an entertainment context (Russell & Belch, 2005). By doing so, not only does the offering reach a larger audience, but it also gets a much longer life than a 30-second commercial. While product placement is riskier than conventional advertising, it is becoming a common practice to place
  • 19. products and brands into mainstream media, including films, which are an extremely popular medium among advertisers. Also, with the traditional media getting overcrowded and nearly saturated, the concept of product placement has become even more popular as a communication technique, which is now being used more than ever by advertisers (Karrh, Mckee, & Pardum, 2003). A lot of research has focused on product placement in all its forms (Gupta & Gould, 2007; Nelson, 2002), but more specifically on product placement in movies (Karrh, 1998). Brand placement in movies seems to be well accepted (O’Reilly, Cripps, Kazani, Patel, & Zarra, 2005) and is sometimes consid- ered less expensive and more effective than a 30-second TV spot (Jaffe, 2005), resulting in a more frequent use of this communication technique. However, in the era of expanding global competition, where companies are trying hard to reach out to their customers effectively and efficiently to market their product and services to different national cultures, an important yet lurking question that remains unan- swered is: To what extent have marketers been able to successfully reach their customers? Although product placement utilizes the global reach of movies, minimal research has been conducted to study the effects of product placement across cultures. Therefore, of particular interest in this study is the influence of brand placements in an entertainment event, especially movies that represent two different cultures. How do viewers perceive brands placed in movies? Do brands placed in Indian movies have a different impact on viewers than brands placed in international movies? Should the advertisers and marketers, therefore, view the placement of their brands in national and interna- tional entertainment contexts differently? To answer
  • 20. these questions, the study focuses on the opinions of people who are viewers of both Indian and interna- tional movies. A review of brand placement studies indicates a major gap in the literature. Previous studies of brand place- ment were largely conducted in the US with little focus on it as a global phenomenon (DeLorme, 1998; Grein & Grould, 1996) given the fact that many movies play to and are often produced for multinational audiences, raising the issue of how consumers in other countries perceive product placements. Also, while product placement has been researched extensively (Karrh, 1998; McKechnie & Zhou, 2003; Russell & Belch, 2005) in studies that have focused on one or more of the placement’s characteristics, in particular, its prom- inence (Gupta & Lord, 1998; Russell, 1998, 2002) and plot connection (d’Astous & Chartier, 2000; Fontaine, 2002; Russell, 2002), it is not clear from the previous studies if a brand placed in a matching context would have any effect on consumer’s evaluation behaviour. And till date no study, either at the national or the inter- national level, has examined the effects of brand place- ment’s fit/misfit within movies. Being the first of its kind, the present study finds its need and relevance by investigating congruence between entertainment event and brand. Furthermore, given the exposure of Indian audiences to both national and international entertainment industry, it is only reasonable to expect the country of origin of the entertainment event to have an impact VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016
  • 21. 151 on consumer ’s evaluation. Because the link between the country of origin of the entertainment event and brand placement is a relevant area of speculation, the present research aims to study this relationship including national/international context. And even though measures of product placement evaluation have been problematic, product placement is a fast growing multi-billion dollar industry (McDonnell & Drennan, 2010) making the present study relevant for both, advertisers and marketers. A great deal of research has already been devoted to product place- ment in movies; however, this article strives to present, for the first time, the effect of fit between brand and the entertainment event on consumer ’s brand evaluation. BRAND PLACEMENT IN MOVIES There are enough reasons that suggest the growth of product placement. The erosion of traditional media audience and its fragmentation on the one hand (Deloitte, 2005) and the use of alternate media such as the internet, allowing consumers to skip ads (O’Neill & Barrett, 2004) on the other hand, has forced the adver- tisers to seek a more reliable media to re-establish the link between their offering and their consumers. In such a scenario, product placement has surfaced as an important tool for the advertisers and marketers, posing as competition to the traditional commercial medium of advertising. In movies, the role of brand placement has increased in recent times. Initially, brands were typically featured in movies in three ways: the product itself was shown, a logo of the brand was displayed, or a brand was
  • 22. displayed as a background prop (Smith, 1985). The role has changed ever since, from the brand being a mere prop in the background to being a central part of the movie, thereby increasing its prominence. The promi- nence of brand placement is defined as ‘the capacity of the brand to attract the spectator’s attention’ (Fontaine, 2001). Among other factors, such as the size and dura- tion of the brand’s placement on screen (Fontaine, 2002), this capacity can be linked to the brand’s location in the scene (Gupta & Lord, 1998) and the number of times the brand appears on the screen (Bressoud, Lehu, & Russell, 2008). No matter how the brand is placed in the movie, by using brand placement, marketers hope to gain an advantage in comparison with the traditional commer- cial advertising format. The availability of a captive audience with greater reach than traditional advertise- ments and the advantage of showing brands in their natural environment (Stephan & Coote, 2005) provide motivation for product placements (Deigh, 1985; Hulin-Salkin, 1989; Turcotte, 1995). Therefore, brand placement provides an opportunity where the involved audience gets exposure to the brands and products during the natural process of narration of the movie. The audience can undertake multiple tasks while watching a television programme in a home setting, which may affect the level and degree of the attention span of the audience and hence reduce the overall effec- tiveness of the medium for enhancing brand memory. In the case of watching a movie in the theatre, the audience makes a voluntary choice for viewing (expo- sure) at a cost (financial, time, and opportunity cost) for the purpose of entertainment, which makes him
  • 23. more receptive to the information provided. Further, the trend of zapping and change in television usage behaviour due to surfing during commercial breaks has reduced the effectiveness of television commercials. And clearly, brand placements in movies also result in a longer lifespan for the brands than typical adver- tisements (Brennan, Dubas, & Babin, 1999; d’Astous & Chartier, 2000). While brand placement has obvious advantages, it is not without its disadvantages. Such disadvantages stem from the marketer’s general lack of control over the brand placement process. Exposure does not actu- ally guarantee that the placement will be noticed (Van der Waldt, 2005). Also, there is little control over how and when the brand will be shown or whether it will be shown at all, as the risk of the scene featuring the brand being edited runs high (Bergman, 1989) and the risk of a negative portrayal of the brand in the movie setting (Fleming, 1990). However, despite the pitfalls which may not allow brand placements to stand as the lone marketing tool, it is becoming an increasingly impor- tant part of the integrated marketing strategy. REVIEW OF LITERATURE AND HYPOTHESES Over a period of time, researchers have used a number of terms for the same purpose that somewhat overlap each other. The term advertainment (Russell, 2007) was coined to reflect the increasingly intertwined connec- tions between advertising and entertainment and refers to the promotional practices that integrate brand communications within the content of entertainment
  • 24. 152 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT products. The increased mingling of advertising with the entertainment world has generated a slew of newly coined terms to reflect the trends, such as hybrid adver- tisement (Balasubramanian, 1994), branded entertain- ment (Hudson & Hudson, 2006), and brand placement and product placement. In one of the first reviews of brand placement, Karrh (1998) argues that although product placement is the most commonly used descrip- tion, brand placement would be more correct. He argues that it is a brand (e.g., Ray-Ban) and not a product (e.g., sunglasses) that is placed. However, not many researchers distinguish between the two and, therefore, the terms brand placement and product placement have been used interchangeably throughout the study. Despite the widespread use of brand placements to reach audiences, it is difficult to ascertain its effective- ness because much of the related data is proprietary (Yang, Roskos-Ewoldsen, & Roskos-Ewoldsen, 2004). Consequently, too little is known about the effect of brand placements given the dynamic nature of this prac- tice (Bhatnagar, Aksoy, & Malkoc, 2004). For example, how the brands are placed in the movies may influence their effectiveness (Ong & Meri, 1994). Indeed, scholars have tested the effect of different types of brand place- ments, such as whether the placement is visual or verbal (Russell, 2002), the visual prominence of the placement (Law & Braun, 2000), and if the placement is involved in the plot of the story or not (Russell, 2002). While all these past studies on brand placement have been informative, research in the area of product place- ment is still not widespread in the Indian context and is
  • 25. concentrated on studying the impact of product place- ments on a wide, general audience. India, which has a huge and growing section of young consumers who are poised to begin their consumption journey, offers a big future growth market for branded products making it even more important to discover, clarify, and check the effectiveness of brand placements. BRAND PLACEMENT IN INDIAN MOVIES Films are a noticeable medium of entertainment in India (Panda, 2004), communicating among other things, the changing fashion trends and promoting market- er’s products and services. Indian audience has always been emotionally involved with onscreen actors and the impact is evident from the fact that stars have iconic status in India. The audience depends heavily on these actors for setting new trends, fashions, and hairstyles (Kripalani, 2006), and it was, therefore, not astonishing when advertisers and marketers started exploiting mainstream Indian cinema as an opportunity to adver- tise their products and started relying on stars to set trends for costumes, accessories, and other products and services. When the audience watch a movie star with the product placed in the movie, they connect the product with the actor, thus, increasing the intrinsic expressive- ness of the placement messages (Morton & Friedman, 2002) such that when the consumers see the movie star using a certain product, they try to associate the credi- bility of the actor with the product placed in the movie and build a positive behaviour towards the product. India’s popular Hindi film industry, commonly known as Bollywood, being the largest producer of films in the world (Minocha & Stonehouse, 2006), is fuelled by a
  • 26. large audience eager for consumption (Akram, Dwight, & Muhammad, 2011; Britt, 2002). In addition to the display of national brands, Hollywood’s ‘big players’ of product placement also appear in Indian movies. Coca-Cola, for instance, has benefited from placement in movies in India along with celebrity endorsement by Indian movie star, Amir Khan, helping it increase its market share (Business Week, 2003). Display of both foreign and local brands in the contemporary Indian films is, therefore, a reflection of the globalization forces at play within India, with a number of Indian films being packed with loads of non-Indian product placements. Since Indian or Hollywood movies mostly remain unchanged across countries, international brands, even if placed in local media through cable- cast or broadcast, may serve as a global marketing strategy (Gould, Gupta, & Grabner-Krauter, 2000). It is for this reason that since the last few years, multina- tional brands have looked to Indian movies to reach the Indian market (Rajadhyaksha, 2003). In addition to placing foreign brands in Indian films, producers of movies have also started exploring different types of product placements, on the lines similar to its Hollywood counterpart. Apart from just a brand place- ment in a movie or a prominent character talking about it, they have started placing products integral to the sto- ryline. The 2002 film, Road, shot mostly on roads with the lead characters driving the cars, featured Tata Motors’ Safari 4-wheel SUV. For this placement, Tata Motors paid about ` 12.5 million (USD 266,250) (Kripalani, 2006). Such a trend of weaving a product into the sto- ryline has become common in the Hindi3 film industry in the past few years. In fact, a recent film Heroine (2012) included several brands that were integral to the movie’s theme. After the release of the movie, Lakme
  • 27. VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016 153 launched Heroine branded makeup under the Absolute range, endorsed by Kareena Kapoor (an Indian actress) while apparel brand Jealous 21 introduced a special clothing line inspired by the clothes worn by Kareena in the movie, which narrates the behind-the-scenes life of an actor. Given the efforts made by the advertisers and the enthusiasm with which the audiences are accepting brand placements in the Indian movies, this practice has a huge potential to grow. Hypotheses Brand placements are, by definition, brands placed within a medium (Nelson & Deshpande, 2013). How audience members respond to the medium likely impacts their responses to the brands within that medium, too. The body of research studying the influ- ence of context on advertising effectiveness leads to the finding that advertising context consists of two impor- tant concepts: receiver context and medium context. While the receiver context is described as the situa- tional circumstances in which a person is exposed to an advertisement (Pieters & Van Raaij, 1992), such as the person’s physical environment (e.g., ‘at home, at the dining table’), the social environment (e.g., ‘in the company of friends’), the time frame (e.g., ‘during lunch’), and the mental state a person is in prior to expo- sure to the medium content (e.g., ‘an early morning mood’), the medium context concerns the environment of the ad provided by the vehicle carrying it, such as a
  • 28. television programme, a book, a video game, or a film. Although studies on context effect are not found in the brand placement literature, there is some sugges- tion that the medium context can have an effect on consumers’ responses to an embedded ad (Moorman, Neijens, & Smit, 2005). Some authors have even found a congruency effect between context and embedded ad (priming effect, e.g., Yi, 1990). Therefore, we expect that the medium context should have an effect on the responses to brand placements too. Further, while the medium context may be the same (e.g., films), they may still differ on the basis of culture, such as films made in India and abroad, both of which depict widely different cultures (de Mooij & Hofstede, 2002; Lewis, 2005). In the present study, we conceptualize and explain the clas- sification of film industries into foreign film industry (Hollywood) and domestic film industry (Bollywood), based on their country of origin and term them as the film industry context. Films represent a very typical entertainment medium and each film industry across the globe is influenced by its culture and environment as a whole; therefore, understanding of the film industry context will help understand the differences between domestic and foreign consumer behaviour. In the present study, the film industry context has been used as one of the independent variables that have two levels, Indian and American. Films that were made in India have been defined as Indian movies while those that were made in America have been classified as American movies. Until recently, placement of branded products in movies was considered an American concept (Segrave, 2004). However, the Indian mainstream Hindi films
  • 29. have caught up with the trend with the Indian audi- ence not only being exposed to product placement in different media but also being exposed to it in both the national and international entertainment industry. Just as the Indian motion pictures have a huge overseas market, Hollywood movies is a huge craze with the Indian masses. With the coming of video-on-demand and DTH, access to any kind of movies has become easier than before; therefore, like many other countries, Hollywood movies have a significant viewership in India too. Also, interest in Hollywood movies is high, with several Hollywood movies releasing in Indian theatres every month. Given the massive exposure of the Indian audiences to movies, it is a question of legit- imate curiosity to find out the impact that brand place- ments in movies have on the audiences. Hall’s (1959) theory aims to explain culture on the basis of high and low context which varies across cultures (Hall, 1984). Indian culture, being a high context culture, aims to communicate messages through symbols (deMooij, 1998), including brands which may com- municate the social standing. Hall (1976) also empha- sizes that in a high-context culture, greater confidence is placed in the nonverbal aspects of communication than the verbal aspects. On the other hand, Hollywood films are rooted in a low-context culture. The literature on product placement demonstrates that cultural dif- ferences exist vis-à-vis attitudes towards product place- ment (Gould et al., 2000; Karrh, Frith, & Gallison, 2001). This is primarily because cultural values and communi- cation styles influence advertising persuasion (Aaker & Maheswaran, 1997) and are also likely to influence the way consumers process product placements. In other words, how brand placements communicate is dictated by the cultural context in which they are put. We argue
  • 30. that consumers’ interpretation of brands placed in dif- ferent contexts, namely, domestic versus foreign films will show a potential bias. For example, Coca-Cola has 154 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT been widely used in several international as well as Indian movies. In each of the two scenarios, the same brand might be looked at differently due to its place- ment in two culturally different contexts. An Indian consumer will be able to relate with Coca-Cola more in Rang De Basanti (2006), an Indian film, rather than Coca-Cola in Falling Down (1993). This implies that differences exist in terms of consumers’ response to brands placed in the two different contexts. In addition to the difference in consumers’ response to brand placements in national and international films due to cultural diversity, we also argue, based on research, that an increase in the number of ads in the environment will have a negative influence on the effectiveness of the target ad or the placed brand (Kent, 1995). Given that Hollywood films contain a greater number of brands overall (Kureshi & Sood, 2011) as compared to Indian films, it is likely that the reaction of viewers towards brands placement in Hollywood movies would be more negative as compared to their reaction towards brand placement in Indian films. In view of the literature on the medium context, cultural differences and the effect of number of brands placed in a movie, we predict that H1: Brands placed in a national event will create
  • 31. more positive brand evaluations than brands placed in an international event. Associations between a brand and an event that trigger positive attitudes towards the brand may be an effec- tive marketing strategy, leading to increased sales which could potentially generate a sustainable compet- itive advantage. However, not all brand–event rela- tionships result in a positive outcome for the brand. It has been suggested that when there is congru- ence between the brand and the event, consumers are more likely to respond favourably (Hamlin & Wilson, 2004). Meenaghan (2001) explains that perceptions of congruity reflect the extent to which the sponsored partner is seen as predictable. Therefore, it is highly likely that congruence will allow the brand to generate positive returns, whereas a non-congruent relation- ship may even be detrimental to the brand (Gray, 2000; Hamlin & Wilson, 2004; Murphy, 1996; Simmons & Becker-Olsen, 2006; Welsh, 1999). These studies assume that congruity between brand and event can have a positive influence on consumer responses so that there is a positive attitude towards the event and the brand (Dousteyssier-Fleck, 2004). The concept of fit, built on congruity theory (Osgood & Tannenbaum, 1955), has been extensively applied to the sponsorship arena and holds that sponsors should seek events that have a logical congruence or fit with the sponsors’ products. There is, however, no evidence of congruence/fit studies in the context of product placements. Nevertheless, given the similarity between product placement and sponsorship, such that both consist of a triangular relationship—a company willing to support a certain activity (the sponsor), a sponsored activity or the target (the sponsee), and in a majority
  • 32. of cases also the different media covering the event or activity (Burnett, 1993)—it is only reasonable to consider that brands being placed in movies are, in a way, spon- soring a part of the movie. For example, brands such as Lakme, Head & Shoulders, Jealous 21, Cera, and so on collectively spent roughly ̀ 250 million on in-film place- ment in the movie Heroine. Therefore, application of fit in the context of product placement may be built on the same logic as that in the context of sponsorship. Sponsorship literature confirms the importance of congruence on the relationship between brand and event, exemplified by brand image beliefs (Gwinner & Eaton, 1999; Speed & Thomson, 2000). Academics and practitioners have long relied on fit to explain sponsor- ship (Olson & Thjomoe, 2011; Quester & Thompson, 2001). Simmons and Becker-Olsen (2006) showed that high-fit sponsorships (sponsor partner is perceived as congruent with sponsored event) can increase brand value, whereas low-fit (sponsor partner is perceived as incongruent with sponsored event) can dilute brand value. Several studies have shown the impor- tance of a strong link between the sponsor and the sponsored event or entity: the greater the perceived fit of brand associations between the sponsor/endorser and the brand, the greater the impact on the sponsor ’s image and the attitudes towards sponsoring itself (McDonald, 1991; Smith, 2004). Since attitudes are found to successfully transfer between parent brands and brand extensions when perceived fit between the two is high (Aaker & Keller, 1990), based on the same argument, it is expected that the degree of fit or congruence between brands and the context in which they appear will determine the extent to which atti- tudes towards the context transfers onto the placed brand. Additionally, when consumers elaborate on
  • 33. the sponsorship and discover a level of congruence, they experience a sense of cognitive satisfaction that influences their evaluation of the sponsoring brand (Meyers-Levy & Tybout, 1989). VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016 155 Likewise, strong sponsor–programme congruity sug- gests that the sponsor’s products and activities are clearly related to the contents of the programme, that is, the product placement is likely to be natural and con- sistent with the programme. However, when sponsor– programme congruity is weak, the product placement may be seen as inconsistent and not credible. Therefore, extending this basic finding to brand placement in movies, we expect that brands that are perceived as consistent with the event in which they are placed will lead to positive evaluation of the brand. We therefore hypothesize that H2: When the presence of the brand is consistent with viewer expectations of the event (high fit), it would create significantly more favourable consumer evaluations than brands that are incon- sistent (low fit) with the event. Foreign films, being viewed by the Indian audiences in addition to the contemporary Indian films, are sugges- tive of the global forces within India. Films, being a product of culture, reflect the cultural values of the people such that the practices, behaviour, and brands from other cultures flow into the domestic culture (Appadurai, 1996). Just as brands are categorized
  • 34. as foreign or domestic in terms of country of origin, films, as a medium of entertainment, are also labelled as foreign and local (Schaefer & Kavita, 2011). When people are exposed to films, they gather information from them in terms of brand schemas and compare them, which determine their judgement with respect to the appropriateness of the event (McDaniel, 1999). Therefore, we can assume the same forces to play a role in consumers’ evaluation of films that affect their judgement about brands. A match leads to more posi- tive evaluations because affect moves from the event schema to the brand schema (Perrachio & Tybout, 1996). However, the influence of films/media on consumers is not automatic. Consumers in emerging markets, such as India, may readily accept nonlocal brands due to country-of-origin (COO) effects where foreign brands convey quality or status. Conversely, they may reject foreign brands or their depictions based on consumer ethnocentrism, that is, preference for one’s own coun- try’s products (e.g., Zhou & Russell, 2004). We hope to examine consumers’ responses in terms of their attitude towards the placed brand and their inten- tion to purchase the brand within the context of COO of the event (and not the brand). Given the individual differences with respect to foreign and domestic brands/ films based on consumer ethnocentrism or openness to other cultures (Batra et al., 2000), we assume the rela- tionships of these factors to have an influence on atti- tudes towards the brand. Past research also suggests that a congruity between the brand and the context in which it is placed has an effect on consumers’ evalu- ation. Specifically, a brand–event fit will draw more favourable responses. Therefore, brand placement and
  • 35. congruity literature suggests that based on cultural differences (Gould et al., 2000; Karrh et al., 2001), which affect the way consumers process product placements (Aaker & Maheswaran, 1997), a low fit between the event and the brand is expected to create more positive evaluation in case of the event being a national event rather than an international event. Therefore, H3: The low fit between the brand and the event will create more favourable evaluation in a national event context than a low brand–event fit in the context of an international event. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY Prior research suggests that the manner in which the brands are presented in the movies, namely in the background, used by the main character or as an inte- gral part of the unfolding story, might lead to different responses from the audience (Russell, 2002). Therefore, the current study focused on only one type of brand placement, that is, the effect of visual brand place- ments, used by the main character in the movie. Visual product placement means that the product is shown prominently in the movie without the mention of the brand name. For the present study, four different movies were selected, each using product placement such that the placement was visual in nature. Second, the study explored the influence of brand placement using both American and Indian movies so as to study the effect of the link between COO of the entertainment event and brand placement in the movie. For the present study, four different movies were selected—two American and two Indian—each using brand placement which was visual in nature. Experimental design was chosen as the method of study in the present research work
  • 36. because of the ability of such designs to test theoretical relations (Bagozzi & Yi, 1989). Two pilot studies were conducted prior to the main experimental study. The participants for all of the studies were recruited from the same research participant pool at a large university in North India for no extra credit for their participation. 156 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT Pilot Study 1: Selection of the Movies for the Experiment Ten subjects were asked to list five American and five Indian (Hindi) movies that used brand placement. Subjects were informed that used-by-main-character brand placement should be part of the movies and should be visual brand placement. Used-by-main-character brand placement involved one of the main characters using the brand in some manner such as opening the packet of Tata Tea in the movie, Baghban (2003), by one of the lead characters in that movie while visual brand placement was the one in which no mention of the brand name was made. The subjects were given enough time to think and were allowed to discuss among themselves. Pilot Study 2: Fit/Misfit Test The second pre-test was conducted to select the brand– event combination. Out of the list of 50 American and 50 Hindi movies generated by the subjects from the first pre-test, the subjects were asked to separate those
  • 37. movies where the presence of the brand in the movie was a misfit in the movie scene and those where the brand placement and movie scene fitted well. For doing this, the participants were asked to indicate how much they considered the brand–event (movie) fit using a 7-point scale ranging from 1 (complete misfit) to 7 (complete fit) for each of the movies listed. Using this data, two American and two Hindi movies were selected (Table 1) with the most fit and least fit. Table 1: Brand Fit and Misfit with the Event Entertainment Industry Event–Brand Fit Event–Brand Misfit American Top Gun Twilight Hindi Jab Tak Hai Jaan Student of the Year Source: Author’s analysis. The two movies selected with the most brand–event fit were Top Gun (Ray-Ban) (1986) and Jab Tak Hai Jaan (Canon) (2012) while the movies selected for the least brand–event fit were Twilight (2008) and Student of the Year (2012). Pilot Study 3: Brand Stature, Brand Perception, and Brand Familiarity The third pilot study was conducted to establish if the three selected brands, namely Ray-Ban, Canon, and Apple, had the same stature, were similarly perceived, and had the same level of familiarity. The pre-test was conducted on 30 participants and analysis of vari- ance (ANOVA) results reflect no significant difference
  • 38. between the three brands, based on stature/importance (F = 1.45, p = 1.89), perception about the brands (F = 0.838, p = 0.502), and level of brand familiarity (F = 1.127, p = 0.343). Main Study Design The study used a 2X2 between-subjects experimental design with two levels of events (American/Hindi movies) and two levels of brand–event fit (high fit/low fit). Each subject was assigned to only one of the four conditions in the experiment. Participants For the purpose of this research, a non-probability sampling approach was used. Non-probability sampling is arbitrary and subjective, due to the fact that a partic- ipant does not have a known non-zero chance of being included (Cooper & Schindler, 2006). The sample chosen for the study was roughly comparable in terms of occupation (all were post-graduate students), gender, and age. A total of 120 students participated in the study (78 females and 42 males) and was drawn from the subject pool of a large Indian university for no extra course credit for their participation. The motivation for this selection was that respondents were thought to be an appropriate sample since young adults (18 to 24 years of age) are passionate film-goers. Moreover, attending movies is a common activity for the age range of the sample (Nebenzahl & Secunda, 1993). Also, many social psychological research studies have used college students as participants but they are usually labelled as ‘adults’
  • 39. (Arnett, 2000) who possess enough disposable income to attend films (Gough, 2003), making product placement in films an effective way to target young and well-educated consumers. The 120 respondents were divided into four groups such that each group consisted of 30 respondents. Each group was shown one of the four stimuli in the form of a movie clip and their responses were recorded with a standardized scale. Stimulus Before the final experiment, five respondents (who were not part of the final study) viewed the four movies VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016 157 which were selected from the pre-tests, on a videotape to identify and list the names of all the brands placed in the movie scenes (Table 2). Table 2: List of Movies, Name of Entertainment Industry, and Brand Placed Name of the Movie Entertainment Industry Brand Placed Top Gun American Ray Ban Twilight American Apple Jab Tak Hai Jaan Hindi Canon Student of the Year Hindi Ray Ban
  • 40. Source: Author’s analysis. Since all the movies had numerous brand placements, we asked the subjects to identify the scenes where only one brand was placed in a scene. It was also mentioned that the brand should only be a visual prop being used by one of the leading characters of the film but should not be mentioned in the scene. Scenes from the films, where the branded products were featured, were selected. Last, the respondents were also asked if the four movies were comparable in terms of their release time such that none of the films was either too old or too new. It was done to avoid the potential confound of promotional tie-ins and sponsorships that could have drawn the audience’s attention to the brand (Ong & Meri, 1994). Also, in order to control for star association with the brand, those brand placements were not selected for the final study in which the star of the movie was also endorsing the brand in traditional advertisements, such as Kareena Kapoor was seen holding a Sony Vaio in a scene in Bodyguard (2011) while she is also an endorser of the same brand and can be seen in television adver- tisement as well. It was done to avoid clouding the respondents’ judgement based on their assessment of the celebrity–brand association. In the brand–event fit for the international event, Ray-Ban sunglasses worn by the protagonist appears prominently in the centre of the screen in one scene from the movie Top Gun (1986). Tom Cruise’s char- acter in the movie, a US Naval Lieutenant Maverick, embodied the image of a cool jet-fighter pilot, and due to the natural cosmetic effects and military look of the sunglasses donned by him in the movie, the brand was
  • 41. considered to be an overall fit in the movie. The event– brand misfit condition selected from the American movie was a scene from the movie Twilight (2008) in which the female lead of the film was seen working on an Apple computer. The brand was seen to be a misfit with the story of the film which was based on a young adult vampire’s romance with a human. The movie selected from the Indian panorama in the brand–event fit category was Jab Tak Hai Jaan (2012) in which one of the lead characters of the movie was a Discovery Channel filmmaker and was seen taking shots from her Canon camera. The brand seems to fit perfectly in the movie as the use of the camera is justi- fied by the character in the film. On the other hand, the movie Student of the Year (2012) was selected in the brand–event misfit category. The sunglasses brand Ray-Ban was being used by one of the male leads whose character was a boy from a middle-class background on scholarship, but was seen wearing expensive clothes and branded sunglasses. The audience took notice of this apparent disconnect between the character and the brand and categorized it as a misfit. Manipulation Check In order to determine the success of the experimental design, it was necessary to check whether the manip- ulation remained hidden or visibly obvious to the respondents. The present study manipulated fit between the event and the brand, and this manipula- tion was checked by measuring the subjects’ response to five items by Speed and Thompson (2000) that were used to measure brand–event fit in this study (Table 3). This manipulation check was carried out by
  • 42. showing the respondents both the high brand–event fit and low brand–event fit formats. The manipula- tion check, brand–event fit, was assessed by indexing two measures, that is, high and low brand fit. Scores of subjects in the high fit setting (6.3) on a 7-point scale were compared with the scores of subjects in the low-fit setting (3.2). The data supports the intended manipula- tion [F(1, 38) = 5.673, p < 0.05] and confirmed that our manipulation was effective in creating required experi- mental conditions. Research Design This study was presented as a movie entertainment study and each session was conducted with 30 partic- ipants. The methodology adopted for this study is comparable to the one used by Gupta and Lord (1998). Subjects participated in small groups. Stimulus tapes for the four treatment conditions were randomly assigned to sessions. Upon arrival at the assigned 158 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT experimental session, subjects were informed that they would be shown a videotape of a movie excerpt and then asked some questions about the movie. The participants were informed about the purpose of the experiment and were allowed to watch the movie clip. The clips of the movies listed above were edited to 30 minutes. The scenes with the target brand placement were placed roughly in the middle of each 30-minute clip and were shown to the subjects.
  • 43. After watching the movie, subjects completed a ques- tionnaire measuring demographic information, pre- vious exposure to the movie, and enjoyment of the movie they watched. Prior to the testing, respondents were not made aware that the questionnaire was con- cerned with product placements in the films. To check on the cover story, respondents were asked to write down what they thought was the purpose of the study immediately after viewing the movie, with none of the respondents indicating the true purpose. Respondents completed the questionnaire on brand evaluation by asking them their attitude towards the brand and their intention to purchase. Attitude towards the brand and intention to purchase were measured using a 7-point scale. The entire task took approximately 20 minutes. Another personality scale was given as a distraction task. After this distraction task, the participants were thanked for their participa- tion and dismissed from the study. Variable Operationalization Several measures were modified from existing vali- dated scales and in some cases measures were devel- oped for use in this study based upon the related liter- ature. All measures were subjected to confirmatory factor analysis to assess their psychometric properties and unidimensionality. The final scale items used in the analysis, standardized factor loadings, and reliability estimates are listed in Table 3. Brand–Event Fit/Misfit In the present study, the event was operationalized as
  • 44. the appearance of a product in the released film and the context (national event/international event) of its appearance. The fit was conceptualized on a variety of dimensions in the marketing literature. Consistent with Speed and Thompson (2000), however, we did not attempt to tease out the different dimensions of fit in our measure. Rather, we adopted a five-item measure that allowed respondents to consider fit on their own terms without restricting the basis used to define fit. The five items to measure fit, used by Speed and Thompson (2000), were modified to fit the context of this study (Table 3). All items on the perception of event–brand fit were ranked on a 7-point Likert scale (1 = totally disa- gree, 7 = totally agree). Understanding brand placements requires that researchers measure event attendees’ (i.e., viewers’) perceptions. The two dependent variables measured in the study are the attitude towards the brand placed in the movie and viewers’ intention to purchase the placed brand. The measurement of these constructs has been summarized below. Attitude towards the Placed Brand This construct was measured with a three-item scale using the traditional attitudinal aspects of liking and favourable disposition on a 7-point agree–disagree scale (e.g., Bruner & Hensel, 1992). Table 3: Confirmatory Factor Analysis Results Scale Items Factor Loadings Event–Brand Fit (Cronbach’s α = 0.89)
  • 45. There is a close fit between the placed brand and the movie 0.830 The placed brand and the movie have many similarities 0.748 It makes sense that this brand appears in the movie 0.732 There is a logical connection between the placed brand and the movie 0.701 My image of the placed brand is consistent with my image of the movie 0.675 Attitude towards the Placed Brand (Cronbach’s α = 0.97) I like the brand placed in the movie 0.874 The brand placed in the movie is a very good brand 0.851 I have a favourable disposition towards the brand 0.817 Purchase Intentions (Cronbach’s α = 0.91) I would buy the brand placed in the movie 0.890 The next time I want to buy a product of this type, I would consider buying this brand
  • 46. 0.804 Source: Author’s analysis. VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016 159 Purchase Intention The behaviour intention measure used in this study consisted of two items. It allows for a more robust test of the paths from attitude to purchase intentions. Responses were operationalized using a 7-point scale ranging from strongly disagree to strongly agree. Before the final administration of the questionnaire, pre-testing of the questionnaire was carried out for qualitative investigation. Ten respondents were admin- istered the questionnaire for this purpose. Subsequently, the language of one of the questions was simplified. Before the final data collection, respondents were briefed about the purpose of the study and all queries of the respondents were clarified. RESULTS A one-way multivariate analysis of variance (one-way MANOVA) was used to determine whether there were any significant differences between the independent groups (brands placed in Indian and American movies) on the dependent variables—attitude towards the brand and intention to purchase. The two dependent varia- bles were found to be highly correlated with each other
  • 47. (correlation coefficient is 0.426; p < 0.05) and given the positive correlation, MANOVA was applied to examine whether there were differences in the respondents’ attitude towards the placed brand and their intention to purchase on two different levels of entertainment event (Indian movies versus international movies). The multivariate effect (Table 4) was found to be signif- icant, F 2,115 = 27.915; Wilks’ Lambda Value = 0.673; p < 0.05; indicating a statistically significant difference in brand evaluation based on entertainment event levels (brands placed in Indian and American movies). Given the significance of the overall test, the univar- iate main tests were examined. As indicated in Table 5, there are significant differences across the levels of entertainment event, indicating that significant univariate main effects exist for attitude towards the placed brand (A b ), F 1,116 = 9.292, p < 0.05 and inten- tion to purchase, F 1,116 = 50.067, p < 0.05. Further anal- ysis indicates that mean scores for ‘Overall evaluation
  • 48. of brands appearing in Indian movie’ (M = 5.06) and ‘Overall evaluation of brands appearing in American movie’ (M = 4.37) are statistically different for two independent groups (t = 3.08, p < 0.05). It suggests that entertainment event is significantly predictive of an increase in the evaluation of brands placed in movies such that when a brand appears in an Indian movie, the brand evaluation, measured in terms of A b and purchase intention, is more as compared to when a brand appears in an American flick. These results indi- cate an overall support for H1. Table 4: MANOVA Test Results Effect Value F Hypothesis df Error df Sig. Partial Eta Squared Entertainment Event Wilks’ Lambda 0.673 27.915 2 115 0.000* 0.327 Brand–Event Fit Wilks’ Lambda 0.750 19.146 2 115 0.000* 0.250 Source: Author’s analysis. Note: *Significant at p < 0.05 level. Table 5: Between-subjects Effect Source Dependent Variable Type II Sum of
  • 49. Squares df Mean Square F Sig. Partial Eta Squared Entertainment Event Attitude towards Brand (A b ) 4.626 1 4.626 9.292 0.003* 0.074 Purchase Intention 29.284 1 29.284 50.067 0.000* 0.301 Brand–Event Fit Attitude towards Brand (A b ) 3.085 1 3.085 6.197 0.014* 0.051 Purchase Intention 20.172 1 20.172 34.488 0.000* 0.229 Source: Author’s analysis.
  • 50. Note: *Significant at p < 0.05 level. 160 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT Further analysis using one-way MANOVA reveals that there is a significant difference in the respondents’ A b and purchase intention on two levels of brand–event fit (high fit vs. low fit). The multivariate effect (Table 4) is significant (F 2.115 = 19.146; p < 0.05). The overall result suggests that the consumers’ evaluation of the brand placed in the movie varies significantly depending on the level of fit (high or low) between the brand and the event, irrespective of the type of event, Indian movies or international movies. There are significant differ- ences across the levels of brand–event fit on brand evaluation indicating that significant univariate main effects exist for attitude towards the placed brand, F 1.116 = 6.197, p < 0.05, and intention to purchase, F 1.116 =
  • 51. 34.488, p < 0.05 (Table 5). However, to find out in which case the respondents evaluated the placed brand more favourably, mean scores for brand–event fit (M = 5.01) and brand–event misfit (M = 4.427) were measured and were found to be statistically different for the two inde- pendent groups (t = 3.158; p < 0.05). It suggests that when a brand that fits well with the movie appears, the brand evaluations, measured in terms of A b and purchase intention, is more favourable as compared to when a brand does not fit well with the movie. These results support H2. Further, a 2X2 (high/low brand–event fit X international movies/Indian movies) between-subjects MANOVA was used to determine if there was a significant effect of brand–event fit and type of event on brand evaluation. As shown in Table 6, the MANOVA results reveal signif- icant main effects of brand–event fit (F 2,115 = 19.146; p < 0.05) and entertainment event type (F 2,115 = 27.915; p < 0.05), which indicate that the differences in brand– event fit are not equal across the event types for both the dependent variables (A b and intention to purchase).
  • 52. The multivariate effects show that there is a significant interaction effect of the brand–event fit X event type interaction term on both the dependent variables (F 2,115 = 5.404; p < 0.05). When an interaction is significant, the intervening effects of the two independent varia- bles may obscure comparisons between the means of one independent variable. In this research, the combi- nation of the two independent variables played a more important role in explaining the variability of attitude towards the brand and intention to purchase. Additionally, specific mean comparisons (Table 7) suggest that the effect of brand–event fit on brand evaluation will be larger when the brand appears in a national event. A significant difference is found (t = 4.02; p < 0.001) in A b between American (cell mean = 3.17) and Indian (cell mean = 4.80) movies in a low brand–event fit condition. It suggests that in a low brand–event fit condition, brand evaluations will be more positive in case of an Indian movie than when a low fit condition occurs in an American movie. Also, there is a significant difference (t = 3.25; p < 0.001) in purchase intention in the low brand–event fit condition for both Hollywood (cell mean = 3.72) and Hindi (cell mean = 4.92) movies. However, there is no significant difference (t = 1.89; p < 0.41) in A
  • 53. b between Hollywood (cell mean = 3.91) and Hindi (cell mean = 4.13) movies when the brand–event fit was high. Also, there is no significant difference (t = 1.54; p < 0.32) in purchase intention in the high brand–event fit condition for both Hollywood (cell mean = 3.89) and Hindi (cell mean = 4.21) movies. Therefore, support is found for H3. Table 7: Mean Comparisons American Movie Low fit Indian Movie Low fit t-values (Sig.) American Movie High fit Indian Movie High fit t-values (Sig.) Attitude towards Brand (A b ) 3.17 4.80 4.02 (0.001)* 3.91 4.13 1.89 (0.41) Purchase Intention 3.72 4.92 3.25 (0.001)* 3.89 4.21 1.54 (0.32)
  • 54. Source: Author’s analysis. Note: *Significant at p < 0.05 level. Table 6: Results of MANOVA Sources MANOVA Wilk’s Lambda Effect Size F (p value) Main Effects Brand–Event Fit (B-EF) 0.750 0.250 19.146 (0.000)* Event Type (ET) 0.673 0.327 27.915 (0.000)* Interaction Effects B-EF x ET 0.914 0.086 5.404 (0.006)* Source: Author’s analysis. Note: *Significant at p < 0.05 level. VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016 161
  • 55. To have a better understanding of the effects of the two independent variables, graphs were constructed showing the mean responses for both of them for each of the dependent variables Figures 1a & 1b. Figure 1a: Plot for Attitude towards Brand (Ab) Event Type 4.20 4.30 4.40 4.50 4.80 4.70 Hollywood Bollywood fit low fit high fit Es ti m at ed M
  • 56. ar gi n al M ea n s of A b 4.60 Figure 1b: Plot for Intention to Purchase Event Type 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 6.00 5.50 Hollywood Bollywood
  • 57. fit low fit high fit Es ti m at ed M ar gi na l M ea ns o f PI Source: Author’s analysis. The significant interaction for each dependent variable is visually demonstrated by the absence of parallelism of the lines in each of the plots. The ‘attitude towards the placed brand’ plot (Figure 1a) shows that brands with low fit with the movie tend to draw lesser posi- tive attitude towards the placed brand than brands that
  • 58. fit well with the movie. Also, brands placed in Hindi movies generated much more positive attitude towards the placed brand than when brands were placed in American movies. The interaction effect shows that although there is little difference in the A b when the brand–event fit is high, the low fit condition leads to more positive attitude towards the placed brand when the brand appears in Hindi movies than when the low brand fit condition appears in Hollywood movies. The plot of ‘purchase intention’ (Figure 1b) shows similar results suggesting that intention to purchase is high when the brand fits well in a Hindi movie while it is less when the brand is a low fit in a Hollywood movie. DISCUSSION AND IMPLICATIONS As one of the first attempts to analyse brand placements in the context of Hollywood and Hindi movies vis-à-vis brand fit, this study suggests that the idea of fit, match, or congruence between the brand and the event can be used as a key criterion when explaining brand evalu- ations. Our research takes us one step closer to devel- oping fitting brand placements, as the study extends the applicability of the idea of fit, which was till now largely confined to sponsorship, and subjects it to the explora- tion of finding a fit between brands and specific events, in particular, movies. Results of the present study reveal that such relationships between brand placement and the outcome variables is linked with another construct, perceived fit between the brand and the event. In this context, the purpose of the study was to examine
  • 59. the extent to which matching the brands and the movies in which they were placed would succeed in generating positive consumer responses in terms of positive brand attitude and intention to purchase the placed brand. The study also hoped to find out the difference in the effect of brand placements, if any, based on the context of the entertainment industry in which they were placed. Results of this study reveal that brands placed in a national event, which in this case is Hindi movies, will create more positive brand evaluations in terms of positive attitude towards the placed brand and intention to purchase than brands that are placed in an international event, that is, American movies. One can attribute a number of reasons for this result to be true. The Indian film industry has always been a reflection of the customs and traditions of the Indian society (Kripalani, 2006) where the audience has been expressively involved with onscreen actors, trying to imitate their styles. A plausible explanation for the Indian cultural values and communication styles being an influence on message persuasiveness (Aaker & Maheswaran, 1997) is that India is a collectivist society (Hofstede, 2001) where individuals operate as part of 162 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT one or more collectives, such as family or peers. Triandis (1995) argues that Indians are not just collectivist but also score high on vertical collectivism, which means that their desire to stand out from others and admira- tion of status and celebrity is high (Sivadas, Bruvold, & Nelson, 2008). As a result of this verticality, individuals
  • 60. look up to successful people in the hierarchy, such as movie stars. And, since passion among the Indian audi- ences for celebrities is no lesser than idol worshipping (Bhatia, 2000), the impact of such emotional attachment is that when an actor performs in a film, the audience wants to emulate their style and image. What it means in a product placement context is that when a celebrity is seen communicating explicitly through endorsements or implicitly through non-verbal or indirect communication, such as brand placements in movies, the consumers view the brand to be associated with the celebrity whom they admire. Without further investigation of the brand, they make a connection between the film, the actor, the product and its consumption, and look at product placement as a perceptual clue which directs behaviour to purchase a product to satisfy a need or reinforce a social status. On the other hand, results of the study show that brands placed in Hollywood were not as successful in gener- ating positive consumer reactions as brands placed in Hindi movies. Although, in the product placement literature, the impact of context effects has not yet been thoroughly explored, it may be argued that the level of involvement of the Indian audience with a foreign film, which may not be very high given the cultural differ- ences, may have affected the processing of brands tied to the plot. Brands placed in Hollywood movies may be at a disadvantage in terms of their being embedded in a context which is culturally very different from that of an emerging economy like India. Much like the Indian film industry, Hollywood movies too are a reflection of their society. However, unlike India, the US has an indi- vidualistic culture characterized by individual bene- fits and preferences, personal success, and independ- ence. Evidently, brands placed in such a context are less successful in generating the desired response from an
  • 61. audience which is culturally more collectivist in nature. Furthermore, findings of the present research have con- tributed to an increased understanding of consumers’ reactions to congruity in brand placement literature. In conjunction with the results of past researches in the field of brand placement (Nelson & Deshpande, 2013), this study reveals that when the presence of a brand is consistent with the context in which it is placed, it would evoke more positive attitudes and behaviour than an incongruent placement. Evidently, when people are faced with incongruity in a message, they begin to wonder why seemingly disparate elements are paired together in a message for no apparent reason, leading to frustration and negative evaluations (Mandler, 1982). Just as the viewers have become weary of excessive exposure to advertisements in the traditional medium, it is feared that unwarranted and obtrusive brand place- ments that do not fit well with the plot of the movie, is likely to do more harm than good to the sponsors. Also, brands that are subtly placed in the movie and those that are not glaringly forced in the face of the viewer are considered to enjoy a more fitting relation in the film. By doing so, the sponsors are not taking the fun out of the main plot of the movie by focusing too much on brands placed. The brand, therefore, does not become the hero of the movie but is strategically made a part of the scene like a supporting actor. The direct implication of such a result is that spon- sors need to be very selective in identifying movies in which to place their brands. With both, American and Indian movie business, being multibillion dollar enterprises where hundreds of movies in all genres are produced every year (Minocha & Stonehouse, 2006),
  • 62. it should not be too difficult for sponsors to choose the right film for brand placement. A brand like Aston Martin, used by the protagonist in the James Bond movies, helped the business because the character in the film clearly identified with the brand. The result suggests that the connection between the brand and the film is of significance and needs to be considered for improving brand evaluations. Evaluation of results further reveals that although a brand that fits well with the context in which it is placed generates a positive evaluation of the placed brand; the condition of a brand–event misfit in a Hollywood context will create more negative evalua- tions among the Indian audiences than if such a discon- nect appeared in a Hindi film. A study by Kureshi and Sood (2011) reveals that American films contain a greater number of brands overall. The likelihood that all the brands featured in the film will have the same level of fit with the character and plot of the movie is not very high. As a result of excessive brands being placed in the movie, two possible outcomes are likely: first, viewers will look at the placement as conspicuous; and second, the misplacement of the brands, if any, in the film will become prominent. With too many brands sharing the screen space in a single exposure or spread out throughout the film, it is likely to draw consumers’ VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016 163 attention much more and perhaps more negatively as too much exposure of brands will lead the viewer to think of the movie as yet another long commercial.
  • 63. In the Bollywood context, however, where the brand placement in movies is still growing as a new medium of advertising, exposure to brands is relatively less, leading to lesser chances of a misfit. Additionally, the reason for a misfit leading to less adverse brand evaluations in Indian movies as compared to Hollywood is that while an Indian film is a three-hour long affair, the Hollywood flicks are of a much shorter duration. As a result, the brands that are placed in the Hindi movies are spread over the entire length of the movie and even if there are times where the brand is a misfit with the context, it is likely to be overlooked because of the length of the movie. The same is not true for Hollywood movies where in a much shorter window of exposure, the movie carries a number of brands. And if the brand is perceived to be disconnected from the film, it is likely to be noticed more, generating more negative evaluations. It implies that not only should sponsors be careful in choosing what type of film to place their brands in, but they should also put more emphasis on placing brands in the national entertainment event when trying to reach the Indian audience. As one of the BRIC (Brazil, Russia, India, and China) countries, India presents an impor- tant emerging market with an enormous and affluent middle-class (Bose, 2006). Ever since the global brands have been introduced since 1991, Indians have become consumers of global brands, and thus, India poses to be a huge market for global brands. Based on the find- ings of the present study, it is suggested that multina- tional brands must look at Indian movies as a suitable medium for reaching out to the prospective buyers. Contribution to Research
  • 64. Although brand placement has been vastly researched in different contexts, the present research has taken a fresh approach to investigating the effects of brand placements in national and international entertain- ment contexts. And the questions, thus, undertaken to be answered make the research contemporary and useful for marketers who are faced with the ever perplexing question of how and when to use brand placements for greatest effectiveness. Although a few studies have focused on examining the fit between brands and movies, fewer have done so in the context of the Indian film industry and none of the previous studies focused on exploring consumers’ evaluation of congruent and incongruent brand placements, espe- cially within Hollywood movies, which have a huge viewership among the Indian audiences. By studying the main and interaction effects of fit and entertainment event type on consumers’ brand evaluation, this study offers useful insights to sponsors who are looking at the growing India market for their brands by gauging the way Indian audiences feel about brand placements. Limitations and Future Research The present research has advanced our understanding of the fit between the event and the brand in the inter- national and national contexts and its role in the frame- work of brand evaluations. However, the findings of the present research need to be considered in light of some limitations. Any study employing student popu- lation is at risk of external validity shortcomings. Although the critical role of external validity in research process is significant (McGrath & Brinberg, 1983), yet this being a pioneering research study, we placed a heavier emphasis on the internal validity, which can
  • 65. be achieved by employing a relatively homogeneous student sample (Cook & Campbell, 1979). While we aimed at higher levels of internal validity, we recognize that a broader and more robust subject pool needs to be examined before drawing generalizations. The product placement stimuli were presented outside of the actual movie context. Viewing several placements in isolation is an artificial situation and it is not clear that the effects observed in this research would be repli- cated in a real film-viewing context. The respondents surveyed were not aware of the researchers’ intention of testing respondents’ perceptions of product placements in films. The motive behind this was to recreate a natural viewing environment. Unfortunately, this may have resulted in many respondents regarding the viewing session as purely a form of entertainment and, therefore, failed to notice the placed products in the film clips. One should also understand that a very narrow stimuli base was used in the present study where the focus was only on the visual placement of brands in the scenes. While used-by-main-character is only one of the types of brand placements used in movies, it is not the only one. As such, these results should be verified for other types of brand placements. In addition, future research should attempt to include additional factors in exam- ining relationships investigated in this article. For example, future researchers may want to find out the outcome of brand evaluations if the brand is used by 164 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT
  • 66. the villain in the movie and if there will be any effect, positive or negative, on the brand image. Also, researchers need to find answers to the relevant question of what will be the impact on brand place- ment if multiple brands are a part of the same entertain- ment show, such as when a number of brands are used as background props in a movie. An interesting avenue for future research would also be to examine what will happen if the character endorsing a brand in the movie is also a brand ambassador for the same brand and appears in traditional advertising medium? For example, Shah Rukh Khan in Phir Bhi Dil Hai Hindustani (2000) is seen driving a Hyundai car of which he is also the brand ambassador and can be seen endorsing the brand in TV ads as well. Finally, it is necessary to investigate the extent to which placement findings do not generalize across mediums. For example, consumers may be more tolerant of product placements in television because broad- cast television is an advertising-supported medium. Thus, differences in television and film viewing habits (Russell & Stern, 2006) may also alter the factors that drive the success of brand placements. Studies exam- ining the results of this study with different samples and in different settings are certainly another appro- priate direction for future research. NOTES 1 Here we are referring to so-called Bollywood movies. 2 Hollywood. 3 Bollywood. REFERENCES
  • 67. Aaker, D. A., & Keller, K. L. (1990). Consumer evaluations of brand extensions. Journal of Marketing, 54(1), 27–41. Aaker, J. L., & Maheswaran, D. (1997). The effect of cultural orientation on persuasion. Journal of Consumer Research, 24(3), 315–328. Akram, A., Dwight, M., & Muhammad, S. A. (2011). Perceived brand globalness in emerging markets and the moder- ating role of consumer ethnocentrism. International Journal of Emerging Markets, 6(4), 291–303. Appadurai, A. (1996). Modernity at large: Cultural dimensions of globalization. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. Arnett, J. J. (2000). Emerging adulthood: A theory of develop- ment from the late teens through the twenties. American Psychologist, 55(5), 469–480. Bagozzi, R. P., & Yi, Y. (1989). On the use of structural equa- tion models in experimental designs. Journal of Marketing Research, 26(August), 271–284. Balasubramanian, S. K. (1994). Beyond advertising and publicity: Hybrid messages and public policy issues. Journal of Advertising, 23(4), 29–46. Batra, R., Venkatram, R., Dana, L. A., Steenkamp, Jan-Benedict E. M., & Ramachander, S. (2000). Effects of brand local and nonlocal origin on consumer attitudes in developing countries. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 9(2), 83–95. Bergman, C. (1989). Tobacco’s cloudy image on the silver screen. The Christian Science Monitor, 8(July), 19.
  • 68. Bhatia, T. K. (2000). Advertising in rural India: Language, marketing communication and consumerism. Tokyo, Japan: Tokyo Press. Bhatnagar, N., Aksoy, L., & Malkoc, S. A. (2004). Embedded brands within media content: The impact of message, media, and consumer characteristics on placement effi- cacy. In L. J. Shrum (Ed.), The psychology of entertainment media (pp. 99–116). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Bose, D. (2006). Brand Bollywood: A new global entertainment order. New Delhi: SAGE PUBLICATIONS. Brennan, I., Dubas, K. M., & Babin, L. A. (1999). The influ- ence of product-placement type and exposure time on product-placement recognition. International Journal of Advertising, 18(3), 323–337. Bressoud, E., Lehu, J. M., & Russell, C. (2008, June 27–28). Integrating placement and audience characteristics to assess the recall of product placements in film: Findings from a field study. Paper presented at the seventh International Conference Research in Advertising (ICORIA), Antwerp, Belgium. Britt, B. (2002). Content, commerce deals offer answers in overseas markets. Advertising Age, 73(42), 18–22. Bruner, G. C., & Hensel, P. J. (1992). Marketing scales handbook. Chicago: American Marketing Association. Burnett, J. J. (1993). Promotion management. Boston, Massachusetts: Houghton Mifflin.
  • 69. Cook, T. D., & Campbell, D. T. (1979). Quasi-experimentation: Design and analysis issues for field settings. Boston, Massachusetts: Houghton Mifflin. Cooper, D. R., & Schindler, P. S. (2006). Business research methods (9th ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill. d’Astous, A., & Chartier, F. (2000). A study of factors affecting consumer evaluations and memory of product place- ments in movies. Journal of Current Issues and Research in Advertising, 22(2), 31–40. de Gregorio, F., & Sung, Y. (2010). Understanding attitudes toward and behaviors in response to product place- ment: A consumer socialization framework. Journal of Advertising, 39(1), 83–96. VIKALPA • VOLUME 41 • ISSUE 2 • APRIL-JUNE 2016 165 Deigh, R. (1985, October 28,). Softest of sells: Placing products in movies can be a lucrative business. Washington Times, A9-A10. Deloitte. (2005). TMT trends: Predictions, 2005: A focus on the media sector. Retrieved 21 January 2014, from https:// industriasdecontenido.files.wordpress.com/2010/08/ deloitte-tendencias-medios-ww-2005.pdf DeLorme, D. E. (1998). Brand placement: A historical over- view. In Darrel D. Muehling (Ed.), Proceedings of the 1998 Conference of the American Academy of Advertising (pp. 305–306). Pullman, WA: American Academy of
  • 70. Advertising. deMooij, M. (1998). Global marketing and advertising. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications. deMooij, M., & Hofstede, G. (2002). Convergence and diver- gence in consumer behavior: Implications for interna- tional retailing. Journal of Retailing, 78(1), 61–69. Dousteyssier-Fleck, N. (2004). An application processing models sponsorship information: The role of congruency. Proceedings of the first journée thématique sur marketing communi- cations, Northeast of France. Eagle, L. (2007). Commercial media literacy: What does it do, to whom—and does it matter? Journal of Advertising, 36(2), 101–110. Fitzgerald, K. (2002, June 10). Eager sponsors raise the ante. Advertising Age, 18. Fleming, M. (1990, May 9). Product pluggola padding pic producers budgets. Variety, p. 1. Fontaine, I. (2001, April). Le placement de marques dans les films: Apports du cadre théorique de la mémoireimplicite et prop- osition d’uneméthodologie [The placement of brands in movies: Contributions of the theoretical framework of implicit memory and proposal methodology]. Working paper 287, DMSP Research Centre, University of Paris IX Dauphine. Fontaine, I. (2002, May 23–24). Impact persuasif du rôleaccordé
  • 71. aux marques au sein de supports non publicitaires: le cas du placement de marques dans les films [Persuasive impact of the role given to marks in non- advertising media: The case of brand placement in movies]. Proceedings of the 18th Congrès de l’Association Française du Marketing, Lille, 177–200. Gough, P. J. (2003). Agencies explore product placement, find consumers receptive. Retrieved 21 January 2014, from www. media-post.com-/dtls_dsp_news.cfm? NewsId=229914/ Gould, S. J., Gupta, P. B., & Grabner-Krauter, S. (2000). Product placements in movies: Across-cultural anal- ysis of Austrian, French and American consumers’ atti- tudes toward this emerging, international promotional medium. Journal of Advertising, 29(4), 41–58. Gray, R. (2000, May). Developing a tight fit is crucial to CRM. Marketing, 37–38. Grein, A. F., & Gould, S. J. (1996). Globally integrated marketing communications. Journal of Marketing Communications, 2(3), 141–158. Gunn, E. (2001). Product placement prize. Advertising Age, 72(7), 10. Gupta, P. B., & Gould, S. J. (2007). Recall of Products placed as prizes versus commercials in game show. Journal of Current Issues and Research in Advertising, 20(1), 43–53. Gupta, P. B., & Lord, K. R. (1998). Product placement in movies: The effect of prominence and mode on audience recall. Journal of Current Issues and Research in Advertising, 20(1), 47–59.
  • 72. Gwinner, K. P., & Eaton, J. (1999). Building brand image through event sponsorship: The role of image transfer. Journal of Advertising, 28(4), 47–57. Hall, E. T. (1959). The silent language. New York: Doubleday. Hall, E. T. (1976). Beyond culture. New York: Doubleday. Hall, E. T. (1984). The dance of life. Garden City, NY: Doubleday/ Anehor. Hamlin, R. P., & Wilson, T. (2004). The impact of cause branding on consumer reactions to products: Does product/cause ‘fit’ really matter? Journal of Marketing Management, 20(7/8), 663–681. Hofstede, G. H. (2001). Culture’s consequences: Comparing values, behaviours, institutions, and organizations across nations. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications. Hudson, S., & Hudson, D. (2006). Branded entertainment: A new advertising technique or product placement in disguise? Journal of Marketing Management, 22(5/6), 489–504. Hulin-Salkin, B. (1989). Movie tie-ins. Incentive, 163(6), 36– 41. Jaffe, J. (2005). Life after the 30-second spot: Energize your brand with a bold mix of alternatives to traditional advertising. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons. Karrh, J. A. (1998). Brand placement: A review. Journal of Current Issues and Research in Advertising, 20(2), 31–49.
  • 73. Karrh, J. A., Frith, K. T., & Gallison, G. (2001). Audience atti- tudes toward brand (product) placement: Singapore and the United States. International Journal of Advertising, 20(1), 3–24. Karrh, J. A., McKee, K. B., & Pardun, C. J. (2003). Practitioners’ evolving views on product placement effectiveness. Journal of Advertising Research, 43(2), 138–149. Kent, R. J. (1995). Competitive clutter in network television advertising: Current levels and advertiser responses. Journal of Advertising Research, 35(1), 49–57. Kretchmer, S. B. (2004). Advertainment: The evolution of product placement as a mass media marketing strategy. Journal of Promotion Management, 10(1/2), 37–54. Kripalani, M., & Clifford, M. L. (2003, February 10). Finally Coke gets it right. Business Week, p. 18. 166 CONSUMER RESPONSE TO BRAND PLACEMENT IN MOVIES: INVESTIGATING THE BRAND-EVENT FIT Kripalani, C. (2006). Trendsetting and product placement in Bollywood film: Consumerism through consumption. New Cinemas: Journal of Contemporary Film, 4(3), 197–215. Kureshi, S., & Sood, V. (2011). In-Film placement trends: A comparative study of Bollywood and Hollywood. Journal of Indian Business Research, 3(4), 244–262. Law, S., & Braun, K. A. (2000). I’ll have what she’s having: