SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 20
Be a Great
Product
Leader
Adam Nash, VP of Product & Growth,
@Dropbox, @adamnash
“There’s a thin line
between being a hero
and being a memory.”
World Class Product
• This all started with a conversation I had with Reid
Hoffman in 2007.
• Most people start or join new companies because they
think “we can do better this time.” They come to build a
company.
• These are the top lessons I’ve personally gained over the
past two decades about product management for
modern consumer software.
Prioritization: Three Buckets
• Metrics Movers

These pay the bills. In the end, software that doesn’t
justify itself will lose the ability to fund itself.
• Customer Requests

If you don’t listen to customers, they will lose faith and
eventually hate you.
• Delight

If you don’t delight customers, you won’t inspire passion
and loyalty in your users.
It’s About the Whole Product
• Can’t we find features that have all three? No.
• Metrics movers are rarely requested or delightful.
• Customer requests rarely move metrics or delight people.
• Delight features rarely move metrics & by definition, are
not requested.
• Great products, however, combine all three.
Find the Heat
• There are two ways to boost engagement: lower friction
or increasing desire.
• Software teams love to focus on the first, and rarely dive
into the second.
• Exceptional experiences depend on capturing the real
nuances of human interaction.
Don’t Be Afraid to Talk
About Emotion
• Heat is a placeholder term for emotions that drive action,
both positive and negative. Emotion. Passion. Desire.
• What strong emotions drive the actions in your products?
• Look for “Magic Moments.”
Simple is Hard
• It’s true in design, metrics, prioritization, and strategy.
• We all fear the fate of Microsoft Office.
• What’s the one thing you want the user to do?
• What’s the job your customers are hiring you to do?
• The great gift of mobile-first design.
Einstein’s Razor
• Make things as simple as possible, but not simpler.
Dropbox
Spaces
• Dropbox Spaces is the
evolution of the shared
folder, an experience
that brings the “smart
workspace” to life
• Dropbox users value
the simplicity of the
service
• Spaces allows
Dropbox to bring new
features to the
foreground, revealed
elegantly when users
add metadata to a
folder
• Software teams tend to focus
extensively on their users.
• They spend increasingly little time
on people who don’t use their
products.
Obsess About
Your Non-Users
• You have more non-users than
users.
• Your brand is often determined by
the way your product touches
non-users.
Growth Comes
from Your
Non-Users
• Common Product Questions:
• Should we build this?
• When should we build this?
• How should should we build this?
Solve the
Product Maze
Backwards
• Teams will debate “should” when
the question really is “when.”
• Thinking backwards from the
future helps.
• Visualize success in five years. If
you have the feature at that point,
you are just debating when.

• Debating when is critical, but it
tends to be a more objective
discussion than “if.”
Think Backwards
from the Future
Know Your Superpower
• Software is a team sport.
• Each function brings something critical & deserves respect.
• Every function has a superpower when it comes to decisions.
• Product - the power to frame the discussion w/ strategy & metrics.
• Design - the power of visualization of possible choices.
• Engineering - the power to show what is possible.
• These powers require hard work & specialization.
Final Thoughts
We can be our own
harshest critics.
Products are never
done.
Behavior matters. 

Values matter.
We are always learning,
and our customers are
always changing.
Be a Great
Product Leader
“Fate rarely calls upon us
at a moment
of our choosing.”
Be a great product leader by Adam Nash, VP Product, Dropbox

More Related Content

What's hot

What's hot (12)

business letter
business letterbusiness letter
business letter
 
Writing GREAT Agile User Stories
Writing GREAT Agile User StoriesWriting GREAT Agile User Stories
Writing GREAT Agile User Stories
 
How Kaiser Permanente uses Jira Software for Analytic Data Management
How Kaiser Permanente uses Jira Software for Analytic Data ManagementHow Kaiser Permanente uses Jira Software for Analytic Data Management
How Kaiser Permanente uses Jira Software for Analytic Data Management
 
Tools and techniques for better time management and outstanding productivity
Tools and techniques for better time management and outstanding productivityTools and techniques for better time management and outstanding productivity
Tools and techniques for better time management and outstanding productivity
 
Work from home
Work from homeWork from home
Work from home
 
Writing Better Emails.pptx
Writing Better Emails.pptxWriting Better Emails.pptx
Writing Better Emails.pptx
 
Email Writing Skills Slideshare
Email Writing Skills SlideshareEmail Writing Skills Slideshare
Email Writing Skills Slideshare
 
Jira guide
Jira guideJira guide
Jira guide
 
8 Tips to Write Better Business Emails
8 Tips to Write Better Business Emails8 Tips to Write Better Business Emails
8 Tips to Write Better Business Emails
 
Tips on Effective Email Writing
Tips on Effective Email WritingTips on Effective Email Writing
Tips on Effective Email Writing
 
Email writing skills
Email writing skillsEmail writing skills
Email writing skills
 
Addressing Key Selection Criteria
Addressing Key Selection CriteriaAddressing Key Selection Criteria
Addressing Key Selection Criteria
 

Similar to Be a great product leader by Adam Nash, VP Product, Dropbox

Introduction to Lean Startup & Lean User Experience Design
Introduction to Lean Startup & Lean User Experience Design Introduction to Lean Startup & Lean User Experience Design
Introduction to Lean Startup & Lean User Experience Design
William Evans
 

Similar to Be a great product leader by Adam Nash, VP Product, Dropbox (20)

501 Talks Tech: Design Thinking Workshop by Dupla Studios
501 Talks Tech: Design Thinking Workshop by Dupla Studios501 Talks Tech: Design Thinking Workshop by Dupla Studios
501 Talks Tech: Design Thinking Workshop by Dupla Studios
 
UX London 2013 - Notes and Key Themes
UX London 2013 - Notes and Key ThemesUX London 2013 - Notes and Key Themes
UX London 2013 - Notes and Key Themes
 
Rapid Product Development
Rapid Product DevelopmentRapid Product Development
Rapid Product Development
 
Spend Stack: An iOS Case Study
Spend Stack: An iOS Case StudySpend Stack: An iOS Case Study
Spend Stack: An iOS Case Study
 
Test & Learn: How to Leverage Design to Learn & Deliver Results Quickly
Test & Learn: How to Leverage Design to Learn & Deliver Results Quickly Test & Learn: How to Leverage Design to Learn & Deliver Results Quickly
Test & Learn: How to Leverage Design to Learn & Deliver Results Quickly
 
Enterprise UX: What, How & Why in 20 short minutes
Enterprise UX: What, How & Why in 20 short minutesEnterprise UX: What, How & Why in 20 short minutes
Enterprise UX: What, How & Why in 20 short minutes
 
Design Thinking For E-Commerce
Design Thinking For E-CommerceDesign Thinking For E-Commerce
Design Thinking For E-Commerce
 
Selling UX
Selling UXSelling UX
Selling UX
 
Present to-future-creation
Present to-future-creationPresent to-future-creation
Present to-future-creation
 
Comcast XFINITY Home: An Agile Case Study
Comcast XFINITY Home: An Agile Case Study Comcast XFINITY Home: An Agile Case Study
Comcast XFINITY Home: An Agile Case Study
 
Inbound Marketing Conference 2016 Summary
Inbound Marketing Conference 2016 SummaryInbound Marketing Conference 2016 Summary
Inbound Marketing Conference 2016 Summary
 
We're not "doing a startup", Topconf
We're not "doing a startup", TopconfWe're not "doing a startup", Topconf
We're not "doing a startup", Topconf
 
How 'Open' Changes Product Development
How 'Open' Changes Product DevelopmentHow 'Open' Changes Product Development
How 'Open' Changes Product Development
 
Rethinking Your DevOps Strategy
Rethinking Your DevOps StrategyRethinking Your DevOps Strategy
Rethinking Your DevOps Strategy
 
Building Shared Understanding Glenn McClure
Building Shared Understanding Glenn McClureBuilding Shared Understanding Glenn McClure
Building Shared Understanding Glenn McClure
 
Framework Thinking - 7 Frameworks To Skyrocket Your Career
Framework Thinking - 7 Frameworks To Skyrocket Your CareerFramework Thinking - 7 Frameworks To Skyrocket Your Career
Framework Thinking - 7 Frameworks To Skyrocket Your Career
 
Reactive Writing Techniques for Rewarding and Retaining Users
Reactive Writing Techniques for Rewarding and Retaining UsersReactive Writing Techniques for Rewarding and Retaining Users
Reactive Writing Techniques for Rewarding and Retaining Users
 
Whats my MVP?
Whats my MVP?Whats my MVP?
Whats my MVP?
 
The elements of product success for designers and developers
The elements of product success for designers and developersThe elements of product success for designers and developers
The elements of product success for designers and developers
 
Introduction to Lean Startup & Lean User Experience Design
Introduction to Lean Startup & Lean User Experience Design Introduction to Lean Startup & Lean User Experience Design
Introduction to Lean Startup & Lean User Experience Design
 

More from Amplitude

More from Amplitude (20)

Amplitude Behavioral Cohorts Deep Dive
Amplitude Behavioral Cohorts Deep DiveAmplitude Behavioral Cohorts Deep Dive
Amplitude Behavioral Cohorts Deep Dive
 
Product and Marketing Maximize Impact by Elie Javice, RBI and Marcelo Pascoa,...
Product and Marketing Maximize Impact by Elie Javice, RBI and Marcelo Pascoa,...Product and Marketing Maximize Impact by Elie Javice, RBI and Marcelo Pascoa,...
Product and Marketing Maximize Impact by Elie Javice, RBI and Marcelo Pascoa,...
 
Product Intelligence by Justin Bauer and Shadi Rostami, Product and Engineeri...
Product Intelligence by Justin Bauer and Shadi Rostami, Product and Engineeri...Product Intelligence by Justin Bauer and Shadi Rostami, Product and Engineeri...
Product Intelligence by Justin Bauer and Shadi Rostami, Product and Engineeri...
 
On Change by Siqi Chen, President and CPO, Sandbox VR
On Change by Siqi Chen, President and CPO, Sandbox VROn Change by Siqi Chen, President and CPO, Sandbox VR
On Change by Siqi Chen, President and CPO, Sandbox VR
 
Happy to Help by Merci Victoria Grace, Partner, Lightspeed Venture Partners
Happy to Help by Merci Victoria Grace, Partner, Lightspeed Venture PartnersHappy to Help by Merci Victoria Grace, Partner, Lightspeed Venture Partners
Happy to Help by Merci Victoria Grace, Partner, Lightspeed Venture Partners
 
Building a Successful B2B Paid Growth Marketing Program by Lisa Sullivan Cros...
Building a Successful B2B Paid Growth Marketing Program by Lisa Sullivan Cros...Building a Successful B2B Paid Growth Marketing Program by Lisa Sullivan Cros...
Building a Successful B2B Paid Growth Marketing Program by Lisa Sullivan Cros...
 
Product Vision by Spenser Skates, CEO & Co-founder, Amplitude
Product Vision by Spenser Skates, CEO & Co-founder, AmplitudeProduct Vision by Spenser Skates, CEO & Co-founder, Amplitude
Product Vision by Spenser Skates, CEO & Co-founder, Amplitude
 
Backstage 2019 - The UX of Data - Lex Roman
Backstage 2019 - The UX of Data - Lex RomanBackstage 2019 - The UX of Data - Lex Roman
Backstage 2019 - The UX of Data - Lex Roman
 
Backstage 2019 - How to find friends and influence product - Rebecca Nackson
Backstage 2019 - How to find friends and influence product - Rebecca NacksonBackstage 2019 - How to find friends and influence product - Rebecca Nackson
Backstage 2019 - How to find friends and influence product - Rebecca Nackson
 
Backstage 2019 - Data Our Common Language - Jonathan Hastings
Backstage 2019 - Data Our Common Language - Jonathan HastingsBackstage 2019 - Data Our Common Language - Jonathan Hastings
Backstage 2019 - Data Our Common Language - Jonathan Hastings
 
Backstage 2019 - Building the Product Intelligence Muscle - John Cutler
Backstage 2019 - Building the Product Intelligence Muscle - John CutlerBackstage 2019 - Building the Product Intelligence Muscle - John Cutler
Backstage 2019 - Building the Product Intelligence Muscle - John Cutler
 
Backstage 2019 - Accelerating Product Insights at Intuit - John Humphrey
Backstage 2019 - Accelerating Product Insights at Intuit - John HumphreyBackstage 2019 - Accelerating Product Insights at Intuit - John Humphrey
Backstage 2019 - Accelerating Product Insights at Intuit - John Humphrey
 
Backstage 2019 - The Atlassian Journey with Amplitude - Itzik Feldman
Backstage 2019 - The Atlassian Journey with Amplitude - Itzik FeldmanBackstage 2019 - The Atlassian Journey with Amplitude - Itzik Feldman
Backstage 2019 - The Atlassian Journey with Amplitude - Itzik Feldman
 
Putting Your North Star Metric Into Action
Putting Your North Star Metric Into ActionPutting Your North Star Metric Into Action
Putting Your North Star Metric Into Action
 
Hire More Designers, OK?
Hire More Designers, OK?Hire More Designers, OK?
Hire More Designers, OK?
 
Creating Value and Flow in Product Development
Creating Value and Flow in Product DevelopmentCreating Value and Flow in Product Development
Creating Value and Flow in Product Development
 
Product Oriented Engineering Teams
Product Oriented Engineering TeamsProduct Oriented Engineering Teams
Product Oriented Engineering Teams
 
How to Stop Wasting Time—Jake Knapp at Amplify
How to Stop Wasting Time—Jake Knapp at AmplifyHow to Stop Wasting Time—Jake Knapp at Amplify
How to Stop Wasting Time—Jake Knapp at Amplify
 
A Framework for Integrity-Driven Product Development
A Framework for Integrity-Driven Product DevelopmentA Framework for Integrity-Driven Product Development
A Framework for Integrity-Driven Product Development
 
Customer Obsession—Gib BIddle at Amplify
Customer Obsession—Gib BIddle at AmplifyCustomer Obsession—Gib BIddle at Amplify
Customer Obsession—Gib BIddle at Amplify
 

Recently uploaded

TECUNIQUE: Success Stories: IT Service provider
TECUNIQUE: Success Stories: IT Service providerTECUNIQUE: Success Stories: IT Service provider
TECUNIQUE: Success Stories: IT Service provider
mohitmore19
 
CHEAP Call Girls in Pushp Vihar (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICE
CHEAP Call Girls in Pushp Vihar (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICECHEAP Call Girls in Pushp Vihar (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICE
CHEAP Call Girls in Pushp Vihar (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICE
9953056974 Low Rate Call Girls In Saket, Delhi NCR
 
AI Mastery 201: Elevating Your Workflow with Advanced LLM Techniques
AI Mastery 201: Elevating Your Workflow with Advanced LLM TechniquesAI Mastery 201: Elevating Your Workflow with Advanced LLM Techniques
AI Mastery 201: Elevating Your Workflow with Advanced LLM Techniques
VictorSzoltysek
 

Recently uploaded (20)

%in tembisa+277-882-255-28 abortion pills for sale in tembisa
%in tembisa+277-882-255-28 abortion pills for sale in tembisa%in tembisa+277-882-255-28 abortion pills for sale in tembisa
%in tembisa+277-882-255-28 abortion pills for sale in tembisa
 
Chinsurah Escorts ☎️8617697112 Starting From 5K to 15K High Profile Escorts ...
Chinsurah Escorts ☎️8617697112  Starting From 5K to 15K High Profile Escorts ...Chinsurah Escorts ☎️8617697112  Starting From 5K to 15K High Profile Escorts ...
Chinsurah Escorts ☎️8617697112 Starting From 5K to 15K High Profile Escorts ...
 
%in Stilfontein+277-882-255-28 abortion pills for sale in Stilfontein
%in Stilfontein+277-882-255-28 abortion pills for sale in Stilfontein%in Stilfontein+277-882-255-28 abortion pills for sale in Stilfontein
%in Stilfontein+277-882-255-28 abortion pills for sale in Stilfontein
 
W01_panagenda_Navigating-the-Future-with-The-Hitchhikers-Guide-to-Notes-and-D...
W01_panagenda_Navigating-the-Future-with-The-Hitchhikers-Guide-to-Notes-and-D...W01_panagenda_Navigating-the-Future-with-The-Hitchhikers-Guide-to-Notes-and-D...
W01_panagenda_Navigating-the-Future-with-The-Hitchhikers-Guide-to-Notes-and-D...
 
The Top App Development Trends Shaping the Industry in 2024-25 .pdf
The Top App Development Trends Shaping the Industry in 2024-25 .pdfThe Top App Development Trends Shaping the Industry in 2024-25 .pdf
The Top App Development Trends Shaping the Industry in 2024-25 .pdf
 
VTU technical seminar 8Th Sem on Scikit-learn
VTU technical seminar 8Th Sem on Scikit-learnVTU technical seminar 8Th Sem on Scikit-learn
VTU technical seminar 8Th Sem on Scikit-learn
 
TECUNIQUE: Success Stories: IT Service provider
TECUNIQUE: Success Stories: IT Service providerTECUNIQUE: Success Stories: IT Service provider
TECUNIQUE: Success Stories: IT Service provider
 
Learn the Fundamentals of XCUITest Framework_ A Beginner's Guide.pdf
Learn the Fundamentals of XCUITest Framework_ A Beginner's Guide.pdfLearn the Fundamentals of XCUITest Framework_ A Beginner's Guide.pdf
Learn the Fundamentals of XCUITest Framework_ A Beginner's Guide.pdf
 
Exploring the Best Video Editing App.pdf
Exploring the Best Video Editing App.pdfExploring the Best Video Editing App.pdf
Exploring the Best Video Editing App.pdf
 
AI & Machine Learning Presentation Template
AI & Machine Learning Presentation TemplateAI & Machine Learning Presentation Template
AI & Machine Learning Presentation Template
 
CHEAP Call Girls in Pushp Vihar (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICE
CHEAP Call Girls in Pushp Vihar (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICECHEAP Call Girls in Pushp Vihar (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICE
CHEAP Call Girls in Pushp Vihar (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICE
 
%in Bahrain+277-882-255-28 abortion pills for sale in Bahrain
%in Bahrain+277-882-255-28 abortion pills for sale in Bahrain%in Bahrain+277-882-255-28 abortion pills for sale in Bahrain
%in Bahrain+277-882-255-28 abortion pills for sale in Bahrain
 
Microsoft AI Transformation Partner Playbook.pdf
Microsoft AI Transformation Partner Playbook.pdfMicrosoft AI Transformation Partner Playbook.pdf
Microsoft AI Transformation Partner Playbook.pdf
 
call girls in Vaishali (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Vaishali (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in Vaishali (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Vaishali (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
 
AI Mastery 201: Elevating Your Workflow with Advanced LLM Techniques
AI Mastery 201: Elevating Your Workflow with Advanced LLM TechniquesAI Mastery 201: Elevating Your Workflow with Advanced LLM Techniques
AI Mastery 201: Elevating Your Workflow with Advanced LLM Techniques
 
call girls in Vaishali (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Vaishali (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in Vaishali (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Vaishali (Ghaziabad) 🔝 >༒8448380779 🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
 
BUS PASS MANGEMENT SYSTEM USING PHP.pptx
BUS PASS MANGEMENT SYSTEM USING PHP.pptxBUS PASS MANGEMENT SYSTEM USING PHP.pptx
BUS PASS MANGEMENT SYSTEM USING PHP.pptx
 
MarTech Trend 2024 Book : Marketing Technology Trends (2024 Edition) How Data...
MarTech Trend 2024 Book : Marketing Technology Trends (2024 Edition) How Data...MarTech Trend 2024 Book : Marketing Technology Trends (2024 Edition) How Data...
MarTech Trend 2024 Book : Marketing Technology Trends (2024 Edition) How Data...
 
The Ultimate Test Automation Guide_ Best Practices and Tips.pdf
The Ultimate Test Automation Guide_ Best Practices and Tips.pdfThe Ultimate Test Automation Guide_ Best Practices and Tips.pdf
The Ultimate Test Automation Guide_ Best Practices and Tips.pdf
 
Unlocking the Future of AI Agents with Large Language Models
Unlocking the Future of AI Agents with Large Language ModelsUnlocking the Future of AI Agents with Large Language Models
Unlocking the Future of AI Agents with Large Language Models
 

Be a great product leader by Adam Nash, VP Product, Dropbox

  • 1.
  • 2. Be a Great Product Leader Adam Nash, VP of Product & Growth, @Dropbox, @adamnash
  • 3. “There’s a thin line between being a hero and being a memory.”
  • 4. World Class Product • This all started with a conversation I had with Reid Hoffman in 2007. • Most people start or join new companies because they think “we can do better this time.” They come to build a company. • These are the top lessons I’ve personally gained over the past two decades about product management for modern consumer software.
  • 5. Prioritization: Three Buckets • Metrics Movers
 These pay the bills. In the end, software that doesn’t justify itself will lose the ability to fund itself. • Customer Requests
 If you don’t listen to customers, they will lose faith and eventually hate you. • Delight
 If you don’t delight customers, you won’t inspire passion and loyalty in your users.
  • 6. It’s About the Whole Product • Can’t we find features that have all three? No. • Metrics movers are rarely requested or delightful. • Customer requests rarely move metrics or delight people. • Delight features rarely move metrics & by definition, are not requested. • Great products, however, combine all three.
  • 7. Find the Heat • There are two ways to boost engagement: lower friction or increasing desire. • Software teams love to focus on the first, and rarely dive into the second. • Exceptional experiences depend on capturing the real nuances of human interaction.
  • 8. Don’t Be Afraid to Talk About Emotion • Heat is a placeholder term for emotions that drive action, both positive and negative. Emotion. Passion. Desire. • What strong emotions drive the actions in your products? • Look for “Magic Moments.”
  • 9. Simple is Hard • It’s true in design, metrics, prioritization, and strategy. • We all fear the fate of Microsoft Office. • What’s the one thing you want the user to do? • What’s the job your customers are hiring you to do? • The great gift of mobile-first design.
  • 10. Einstein’s Razor • Make things as simple as possible, but not simpler.
  • 11. Dropbox Spaces • Dropbox Spaces is the evolution of the shared folder, an experience that brings the “smart workspace” to life • Dropbox users value the simplicity of the service • Spaces allows Dropbox to bring new features to the foreground, revealed elegantly when users add metadata to a folder
  • 12. • Software teams tend to focus extensively on their users. • They spend increasingly little time on people who don’t use their products. Obsess About Your Non-Users
  • 13. • You have more non-users than users. • Your brand is often determined by the way your product touches non-users. Growth Comes from Your Non-Users
  • 14. • Common Product Questions: • Should we build this? • When should we build this? • How should should we build this? Solve the Product Maze Backwards • Teams will debate “should” when the question really is “when.”
  • 15. • Thinking backwards from the future helps. • Visualize success in five years. If you have the feature at that point, you are just debating when.
 • Debating when is critical, but it tends to be a more objective discussion than “if.” Think Backwards from the Future
  • 16. Know Your Superpower • Software is a team sport. • Each function brings something critical & deserves respect. • Every function has a superpower when it comes to decisions. • Product - the power to frame the discussion w/ strategy & metrics. • Design - the power of visualization of possible choices. • Engineering - the power to show what is possible. • These powers require hard work & specialization.
  • 17. Final Thoughts We can be our own harshest critics. Products are never done. Behavior matters. 
 Values matter. We are always learning, and our customers are always changing.
  • 19. “Fate rarely calls upon us at a moment of our choosing.”