SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 52
Outline
Before you start writing the first draft of your essay or research
project, it is always useful to make an
outline of your ideas. If you have already decided on your focus
or topic, and you have a rough list of
sources for support, then you are ready to draft an outline.
Keep in mind that outlines are required to follow a format style
(eg. APA). An outline is simply a
way to organize your ideas and information. The following is an
abbreviated version of what is often
referred to as a formal or “traditional” outline. It can be
expanded or condensed to fit the scope of
your essay or research project. The example below is based on
the five-paragraph essay model.
The Thesis Statement (TS) will be the
last 1-3 sentences of the introduction.
I. Introduction
A. Thesis Statement
II. Body paragraph #1 – Topic Sentence #1
A. Supporting Evidence
1. Name of & quote from source Supporting Evidence
Integrate an appropriate example,
such as a quote, statistic, case
study, etc.
2. Name of & quote from source #2 (if applicable)
B. Explanation
1. Explanation of source
2. Explanation of source #2 (if applicable)
C. So What?
Explanation
Explain how this evidence supports your
topic sentence. Try to develop your
explanation in 2-4 sentences.
III. Body paragraph #2 – Topic Sentence #2
A. Supporting Evidence
1.
So What?
What’s significant or important about the
ideas (topic sentence + evidence +
explanation) in this paragraph? Remind
your reader how all this connects back to
the TS.
2.
B. Explanation
1.
2.
C. So What?
IV. Body paragraph #3 – Topic Sentence #3
A. Supporting Evidence
The TS is the first 1-3 sentences of the
conclusion. It should be “rephrased” here
rather than repeated verbatim. Avoid
simply summarizing the main points in
the conclusion: synthesize them.
B. Explanation
C. So What?
V. Conclusion
A. Rephrase thesis statement
B. Bring closure by going from specific to broad
To see what a complete outline, refer to the model below. The
thesis statement has been taken from
the Thesis Statement Guide section of the Ashford Writing
Center.
I. Introduction
A. Thesis Statement
Although there are educational television programs,
parents should regulate the
amount of television their children watch because it is
not always intellectually
stimulating, it can distort a child’s perception of reality,
and it inhibits social
interaction.
II. Body paragraph #1 - Topic Sentence #1
While television has the potential to offer programs that can
be seen as educational
supplements, too much television has an even greater
potential for turning children
into passive viewers and getting in the way of intellectual
stimulation.
A. Supporting Evidence
As a recent article from the University of Michigan
Health Systems (2008)
maintains, “Too much television can negatively affect
early brain development.
This is especially true at younger ages, when learning to
talk and play with others
is so important” (qtd. in “Television”).
B. Explanation
Indeed, too much television can be detrimental to
cognitive development because
preschool-aged children need physical interaction, and
television for older children
acts as an unhealthy replacement for reading and being
read to. Children need to
engage in imaginative play; adolescents and teenagers
benefit from getting fresh
air and being more active.
C. So What?
While it would be too easy to dismiss every TV show
directed at youths—in fact,
PBS and Discovery Kids offer excellent programming—
children’s lives are
increasingly centered around TV-watching, and thus,
parents should regulate how
much their kids are viewing regardless of content or
perceived quality.
III. Body paragraph #2 - Topic Sentence #2
Moreover, with proper supervision or regulation, there are
television programs that can
distort a child’s perception of reality.
A. Supporting Evidence
In the online article “How TV Affects Your Child,” Dr.
Mary Gavin (2008) points
out that “TV characters often depict risky behaviors,
such as smoking and
drinking, and also reinforce gender-role and racial
stereotypes.”
B. Explanation
Certainly, seeing these types of behaviors and stereotypes
exhibited by favorite
television personalities and encouraged by favorite shows
can contradict with the
values parents want to instill in their children, which can
cause both tension and
confusion. While television does have entertainment value,
children cannot learn
all the differences between right and wrong from it.
C. So What?
Although it is difficult to prevent children’s total exposure
to questionable social
mores and limited multicultural representation in the media,
parents can have
some control by supervising their children’s viewing as well
as talk about what’s
portrayed on television.
IV. Body paragraph #3 - Topic Sentence #3
Finally, television can impede healthy relationship-building
and impose on family
time.
A. Supporting Evidence
For example, recent studies have found that the
television is on most of the time in
51% of households and that “[k]ids with a TV in their
bedroom spend an average
of almost 1.5 hours more per day watching TV than kids
without a TV in the
bedroom” (qtd. in “Television”).
B. Explanation
If children are spending this much time glued to the their
favorite television
programs, and if parents do not have rules about how much
is okay to watch, then
children are not only spending less time on important
cognitive development
activities such as reading and doing homework, but they are
also spending less
time on social interaction with peers and important family
time.
C. So What?
Given how long families are apart from each other during
the week because of
school and work, it is unfortunate that any extra time
outside of those obligations
should be wasted on watching television; therefore,
regulation is one key
approach to ensure a family’s closeness and the strength of
the parents’ bond with
their children.
V. Conclusion
A. Thesis Statement rephrased
Television can be both educational and entertaining for
children; however, only in
moderation. Thus, it’s important that parents step in to
supervise how much
television their children watch as it can negatively affect
their intellectual,
psychological, and social development.
130 ABLVol36No2 2010
Contributed Article
Balancing Work, Family and Life:
Introduction to the Special Edition
•John Burgess and Jennifer Waterhouse*
The papers in this special edition of Australian Bulletin of
Labour are about the
issue of balancing paid work with other aspects of life. Work-
life had its genesis
in the concept of work-family balance in the 1980s, when the
apparent tension
between work and family life began to be recognised. Woolcott
(1990) showed
that concerns about issues outside of work, particularly family
responsibilities,
had the potential to affect both the wellbeing and productivity
of workers. Failing
to address problems of imbalance between work and other life
aspects has also
been identified as resulting in detrimental social and economic
consequences
(OECD, 2008). As a result of these consequences, initiatives
that assist workers
to balance their work and family lives have gained increasing
support from policy
makers, employee and employer groups.
Early conceptualisations of work-family balance tended to
confine research,
policy and organisational attention to the matter of conflict
between work and the
rearing of dependent children. Research has since covered
significant terrain,
becoming multi-disciplinary, with studies emerging from
industrial relations,
economics, psychology and human resource management and
including topics
such as long working hours (for example. Bunting 2005), gender
(for example,
Gregory and Milner 2009) and power (for example, Mescher,
Benschop and
Doorewaard 2009).
*University of Newcastle
Burgess and Waterhouse 131
This special edition draws primarily from an industrial relations
and policy
perspective; but the eclectic nature of the topics covered
reflects the diverse
nature of the concept. Authors have used both the terms 'work-
family balance'
as well as the broader 'work-life balance'. This is in keeping
with a general trend
towards the inclusion of non-family aspects as an important
consideration for policy
makers, employers and employee groups. The trend is
contentious in that the
term 'work-life' can be considered a catch-all phrase arguably
disguising critical
social issues and over-simplifying the complexity and inequity
of life inside and
outside of paid work such as the gendered imbalance related to
child rearing and
domestic duties. For the purposes of this special edition, work-
life balance is,
however, a useful term to capture the full gamut of the topic.
The papers provide
insights into a wide range of issues, including consideration of
the approaches
and interventions of various entities at various levels,
discussion on the resultant
or potential outcomes of such approaches and observations
about current work-
life experience.
The study by Skinner and Pocock provides findings from a large
Australian
survey and highlights the varied experiences of work-life
balance for different
categories of workers. It provides a useful starting point for
themes developed
in other articles in this issue. One such theme that also appears
in the paper
on call centres by Hannif, McDonnell, Connell and Burgess and
the study by
Brown, Bradley, Lingard, Townsend and Ling is unsociable
working hours. The
latter study sheds new light on old ground when the benefits of
a two-day break
are discussed. In this, the study departs from the more common
focus on long
working hours to a consideration of a need for a long break. All
three studies
demonstrate the detrimental effects of unsociable hours and the
need to deal
with this important element in the work-life balance equation.
Another common theme is the extension of working hours
through the use of
informal or unofficial working time arrangements such as that
found in call centres,
discussed by Hannif, McDonnell, Connell and Burgess.
Organisational practice
as to working hours and access to work-life policy provisions
also forms a major
theme of Colley's study of a public sector agency. Of interest in
the Colley paper
is the broadening of organisational policy to encompass a work-
life framework;
but staff access to entitlements is limited by organisational
norms and managerial
preference and discretion. Both papers, therefore, highlight the
importance of
informal practices at workplace level for the extent of workers'
access to work-
life flexibility arrangements. The main question which these
observations on
working time and flexibility arrangements raise is the extent to
which legislation
132 Australian Bulletin of Labour
is able to identify and deal effectively with the informal aspects
of organisational
practice that adversely affect employees' ability to balance their
work and other
life activities. The paper by Waterhouse and Colley suggests
that the process
provisions of the Fair Work Act limit the scrutiny and the
enforcement of flexible
work arrangements that are necessary to meet the work-life
balance needs of
employees.
It can be argued that the economic and social effects of a failure
to address
work-life balance (OECD 2008) should extend the topic beyond
the interests of
traditional stakeholders in industrial relations. Community
groups, such as those
representing the interests of families, emergency and social
services, have also
sought to contribute to the debate on work-life balance through
their contributions
to govemment enquiries. The finding by Waterhouse and Colley,
that the interests
of these non-traditional stakeholders were largely overlooked in
favour of traditional
actors, suggests the continued view of work-life balance as
being more about the
needs of industry and the workplace than the needs of society.
Much remains to be done in terms of research and practice. The
direction for
future research is two-fold. First, there is a need for high-level,
multi-disciplinary
approaches to encompass the intersection of work-life balance
in different
disciplines. Secondly, and at the other end of the spectrum, is a
continued need for
investigation of individual cases and experiences. This special
edition contributes
to this future direction through research that extends from
national-level studies,
through to industry level and individual organisational cases.
References
Bunting, M. (2005), How the Overwork Culture is Ruling our
Lives, Harper
Perennial, London.
Gregory, A. and Milner, S. (2009), 'Editorial: Work-life
Balance: A Matter of
Choice?', Gender Work and Organization, vol. 16, pp. 1-13.
Mescher, S., Benschop, Y. and Doorewaard, H. (2009),
'Representations of
Work Life Balance Support', Human Relations, vol. 63, pp. 21-
39.
OECD (2008), Babies and Bosses: Baiancing Work and Family
Life, Policy
Brief, July.
Woolcott, I. (1990), 'The Structure of Work and the Work of
Families', Family
Matters, vol. 26, April, pp. 32-38.
Copyright of Australian Bulletin of Labour is the property of
National Institute of Labour Studies and its
content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted
to a listserv without the copyright holder's
express written permission. However, users may print,
download, or email articles for individual use.
Balancing Work–family Life in Academia:
The Power of Timegwao_571 283..296
Gudbjörg Linda Rafnsdóttir* and Thamar M. Heijstra
In the article we analyse the structuring of time among
academic employees in Iceland, how they
organize and reconcile their work and family life and whether
gender is a defining factor in this
context. Our analysis shows clear gender differences in time
use. Although flexible working hours
help academic parents to organize their working day and fulfil
the ever-changing needs of family
members, the women, rather than men interviewed, seem to be
stuck with the responsibility of
domestic and caring issues because of this very same flexibility.
It seems to remove, for more
women than for men, the possibility of going home early or not
being on call. The flexibility and
the gendered time use seem thus to reproduce traditional power
relations between women and
men and the gender segregated division in the homes.
Keywords: academia, flexibility, gender, power relations, time,
work–family balance
Women and men often spend their time differently due to the
widespread gender division inwork and family life. Thus,
Bryson (2007), Kvande (2007) and Davies (1989) emphasize the
importance of analyzing the structuring of time and time
consciousness when discussing gender
equality. Bryson (2007) mentions that the time squeeze can
cause decreased autonomy among indi-
viduals and diminish their ability to become active citizens. The
structuring of time is also a matter
of health and wellbeing. According to Frankenheuser (1993)
who compared managers in a Swedish
factory, women showed the same level of stress as men until the
afternoon when the stress increased
among women only due to their attempt to reconcile work and
family life.
As far as gender equality in Iceland is concerned, the country
passed an Act on gender equality
in 1976 in an attempt to secure the equal input of women and
men in society, to work against
gender-based discrimination in the labour market and to enable
both women and men to reconcile
work and family life. Today, the Icelandic welfare system is
based upon the Nordic welfare model
(Esping-Andersen, 1991). In Iceland this includes 9 months of
parental leave, of which 3 months is
reserved exclusively for fathers, and relatively cheap access to
qualified day care for children aged
between 1 and 6 years. Each parent is also entitled to ten fully
paid child sick days per year.
Iceland prides itself on promoting sexual equality and,
according to the World Economic Forum’s
Global Gender Gap Index (2009, 2010) the country has claimed
to be at the forefront of gender equality
in the world. The Index benchmarks national gender gaps using
economic, political, educational and
health-based criteria. It is thus of interest to investigate how
career-oriented people such as academics
manage to structure their time and combine their work and
private life in Iceland. This article revolves
around the question whether or not female and male academics
use the flexibility at work to balance
their work and family life, and if they do, how they do it. To
start, we first look more closely at the
concept of time.
Address for correspondence: *University of Iceland, Faculty of
Social and Human Sciences, Oddi, Sturlugata, IS 101
Reykjavík,
Iceland; e-mail: [email protected]
bs_bs_banner
Gender, Work and Organization. Vol. 20 No. 3 May 2013
doi:10.1111/j.1468-0432.2011.00571.x
© 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Time and gender
Our standpoint is that time is multiple and linked to power. That
means that we do not see time only
as clock time or as linear time that is to be divided into
different components. We picture it, rather, as
a web where people can move around, at times situated in one
compartment, and sometimes in many
simultaneously. Power is related to time since time is an
essential resource to which access may be
unequally distributed. Those who have more power in their
relationships are more likely to be able to
manage their own time and the time of others in both the private
and public realm.
The concept of time can be viewed from different perspectives.
Bryson (2007), Leccardi (1996) and
Davies (1989) point out that so-called traditional time was
based on the natural rhythm of the seasons
and the tasks that had to be done. The relation to time was
local, task-oriented, seasonal and repetitive.
With the development of capitalism and industrialization this
traditional time consciousness gradu-
ally gave way to the modern time of waged workers who were
paid for the hours they worked but not
on the basis of the tasks they performed or the service they
provided. As time consciousness changes,
Davies and Bryson argue that time is socially constructed.
Davies (1989, p. 17) states:
[T]ime consciousness and time measurement are crucial for the
structuring and direction of
women’s and men’s everyday lives. Time can furthermore be
used as an instrument of power and
control.
Former sociologists did not reflect much upon time when
discussing the power structures in society.
However, a few deal with time, though more obliquely.
Frederick W. Taylor (1964) became known for
the principle of scientific management or time and motion
studies based on breaking a job into its
component parts and measuring each to a hundredth of a minute.
The ideas behind Taylorism
resulted later on in theories like Fordism, principally known as
a mass production system theory, and
just in time production processes (Watson, 2003 [1980]). Émile
Durkheim noted that time is socially
constructed and linked to a society that encloses the individual
(Durkheim, 1971) and time spent in
production is in some ways central to the thought of Karl Marx
(1954). Even though these sociologists
discuss time, neither of them deals with time as being crucial
for their theories, nor do they theorize
gender. In contrast, the feministic sociologists Davies (1989),
Leccardi (1996) and Bryson (2007) do
shed light upon gender when analysing the structuring of time
in society.
Bryson (2007) points out that the ways in which time is used,
valued and understood are central
to the maintenance of gender inequalities in public and private
life, and are damaging for both men
and women. She shows that while parental time with children
and leisure in general have increased
during the last decades, parents, particularly mothers, partly
achieve this by combining the time they
spend with their children with other activities. This explains
why parents perceive themselves as
being more and more pressed for time because stress is not
simply a matter of the total hours of paid
and unpaid work, it is exacerbated by the intensity of their use
of time. Parents often have to force
different activities into the same period. Bryson refers to
Southerton (2003) who has coined the useful
term ‘harriedness’ to cover women’s sense of being both harried
and harassed by the seemingly
incompatible demands on their time and the need to co-ordinate
a host of fragmented activities.
Davies (1989) argues that there are two major ways of
conceiving time in modern society; cyclical
(female) and linear (male) time. However, she does note that
this generalization may not account for
individual cases as they can be much more complex and
partially dependent on lifestyle. The linear
conception of time — where time is seen as unfolding in a
straight and unbroken line, unidirectional
and heading towards an unlimited horizon — is the conception
that is preponderant today. It appears
to characterize men’s relation to time, in terms of the way in
which they organize their daily lives as
well as their life course. Usually they do so in a much more
clear-cut fashion than women. Linear time
also forms the dominant structure in present-day society and
may be used, as an instrument of power
and control over women.
Cyclical time, or female time, on the other hand, is usually
associated with everyday life prior to,
or concurrent with industrialization. Under a cyclical time
consciousness people order the events of
284 GENDER, WORK AND ORGANIZATION
Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing
Ltd
their lives according to local and natural rhythms and the future
is a perpetual recapitulation of the
present. The precise measurement of time in these
circumstances is superfluous. On a day-to-day
basis, people are not subject to clock time but rather to time
that is task oriented. According to Davies
(1989), the two facets of women’s lives, that is, wage labour
and reproduction, are associated with
time. She points out that the responsibility that women have for
care and reproduction make their
daily lives a complex weaving between the dominant linear
(male) time on the one hand, and cyclical
(female) time on the other.
In their experience, this work of weaving time goes beyond
economic rationality. Its special quality
derives from being at the same time within and outside of
economic logic. Davies (1989, pp. 37–8)
argues: ‘Time disposal is partly determined by the individual,
partly by social or legal coercion and
partly through negotiations with others’. Davies shows that
since women historically have been
responsible for the family, in addition to other tasks, these
activities have engulfed all their time due
to the temporal nature of care. Women’s time is thereby
characteristically others’ time. For these
women, doing several things at the same time appears to be the
norm. Nevertheless, she maintains
that social and legal coercion as well as negotiation with others
are closely related to the issue of
power. Thus, access to one’s own time and to leisure time is
quite simply a question of power and
may function to enforcer of male identity and provide one of the
means by which male hegemony is
constructed and reconstructed:
The more power and influence we have, the more we can decide
over our own time and other’s
time, the more we can negotiate time and resist social control.
Women’s subordinate position in the
public sphere as well as their ascribed role in the private sphere
have major implications with
regard to this. . . . At home, their time — more than any other
family member’s — becomes others’
time . . . both men and women do not and cannot freely choose
how to use and structure their time,
but . . . for women there are specific structural relations which
have special implications for how
their time is used. (Davies, 1989, p. 38)
Leccardi (1996) argues along the same lines as Davies. She
insists that feminist theory calls into
question the representation of time in capitalist societies and
provides an approach that point to a
different conception of the relationship between life and time
for both women and men. Women’s
biographical time she says, as a result of their increasing
capacity to produce income in an indepen-
dent manner, is increasingly confronted by the logic, scansions
and rhythms of public time. The
various dimensions of women’s work are shaped by different
forms of logic where family work is
governed not by the logic of the market, but by expectations of
reciprocity. Even though the clock
remains an essential mediator in our everyday existence, its
claim to being time per se and its taken-for
granted hegemony have been undermined. ‘As such, “women’s
time” is shown to be “contaminated”
by emotions and affections, never to be merely clock time’
(Leccardi, 1996, p. 182).
Hassan (2007) connects the discussion about time to new
information and communication tech-
nologies (ICTs). He points out that the network time provides
people with the capability to create
their own time and spaces as ICTs and people in interaction
undermine and displace the time of the
clock. In pre-industrial societies task-oriented time was dictated
by the task itself and the interaction
between human, technological and local circumstances. Due to
the effects of high speed and com-
puter technology a network-generated ‘fragmented time’ is
emerging alongside the ‘industrial time’
of the clock. Hassan describes the possibilities within these
digital spaces to create, experience and
control our context-dependent time, where the clock will have
marginal or no effect:
The important point is that this context-created temporal
experience is disconnected from the local
clock times of the users. The clock no longer governs, as it once
did in the preinformation age.
(Hassan, 2007, p. 52)
Time use-studies
Davies (1989) and Bryson (2007) reveal that the problem with
time-use studies in general is that they
are based on a view of time in which time can be divided into
small measurable components. This
PROBLEM REPRESENTATIONS OF EQUAL PAY 285
© 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Volume 20 Number 3 May
2013
makes it difficult to measure tasks that are carried out
simultaneously and to measure the time that
is involved in caring for others and different kinds of caring
responsibilities in which ‘being there’ is
important. Bryson (2007, p. 157) stresses: ‘Studies are also
unable to record the intermittent worrying,
guilt and stress individuals may experience around what they
are not doing while they are doing
something else’. She highlights that the studies are not able to
show the different kinds of time people
experience and that all time is not equal. Some people’s time
seem to be worth more than others’,
which reflects a certain kind of power.
Leisure studies are becoming more frequent as leisure appears
to play an increasingly large role
in the life of adults, at least among the middle class. However,
Bryson (2007) notes that, while the
rhetoric of time poverty is widely used, writers disagree as to
the nature and significance of class and
gender-based differences in the availability and nature of free
time. In spite of this it is clear to Bryson
that the manual working class has less control over its leisure
time and does not have access to
time-saving resources. This finding is supported by Weigt and
Solomon (2008) who compared work
and family management among women in low-wage services and
female assistant professors at
universities in the USA. They found that women privileged by
class were also privileged in their
ability to manage work and family demands. While class muted
gendered experiences for the female
assistant professors it exacerbated gender experiences for
women in the low-wage service sector.
Flexibility at work
Whenever describing so-called good jobs, the features autonomy
and flexibility are often mentioned
(Constable et al., 2009). Flexibility at work has basically two
characteristics; flexible working hours
and telecommuting. Flexible working hours, on the one hand,
give employees a certain amount of
freedom to decide when to start and end their work day.
Telecommuting on the other hand, allows
employees to decide where they work, as long as there is an
Internet or phone connection (Dickisson,
1997). Autonomy is closely related to flexibility and it has been
argued that flexibility at work
improves the work–family balance of the worker (Blair-Loy and
Wharton, 2004; Reeves et al., 2007).
Moreover, some studies show that flexibility decreases stress
levels among workers and makes
people more productive (Golden and Veiga, 2005; Kurland and
Bailey, 1999). Dickisson (1997) notes
that employees in flexible organizations take fewer sick days
and are often more creative, although he
emphasizes the importance of having one’s own work space at
home, preferably with a door that can
be closed.
Kvande (2007) discusses flexibility from another point of view.
She points out that especially in
knowledge organizations, the shift from standardization to the
differentiation of working hours leads
to an endless flood of work, long working hours and less family
time. Kvande refers, for example, to
Hochschild (1997) when she points out that the formal contract
that regulates working hours is being
replaced by moral obligations and time norms that demand total
commitment. Blair-Loy (2009)
support this findings as her studies shows that stockbrokers in
firms with scheduling flexibility
experience more work–family conflict than those in firms with
scheduling rigidity.
Hassan (2007) argues that the reality of network time and
network communication for most
people is impelled by the need to constantly look for ways to be
more efficient and productive. Speed
is fetishized and short-term outcomes are valorized. This is in
line with Heijstra and Rafnsdóttir
(2010), who show that even though ICTs make some features of
the life of academics easier, they also
initiate a proliferation of the workload, trigger a prolonging of
the workday and enhance a demand
for extensive availability. While ICTs increase the flexibility of
academics at work this does not seem
to improve their work–family balance. On the contrary, ICTs
and flexibility are found to increase
work–family conflict, as the ICTs in combination with their
flexibility make it increasingly difficult for
academics to disengage from work. Furthermore, according to
Pétursdóttir (2009) and Rafnsdóttir
(1995) men often have more flexibility at work than women and
this improves their autonomy in
private and public life. However, most of them do not use this
flexibility to reconcile work and family
life.
286 GENDER, WORK AND ORGANIZATION
Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing
Ltd
Academics
Being an academic is generally characterized by having a large
amount of flexibility and autonomy.
Academics have for the most part the freedom to decide where,
how and even when to work. Most
come close to being their own supervisors even if they are
employees. With the arrival of ICTs the
possibilities of working from home have increased for them.
However, at the same time studies from
the UK (Doherty and Manfredi, 2006) and the USA (Jacobs and
Winslow, 2004) show that, while
academics have a high level of flexibility at work, they also
have to deal with an intensification of their
workload and long working hours. This might explain why one
out of five university teachers in the
USA displays serious burn-out symptoms (Lackritz, 2004). A
study among university staff in the
USA, Canada and UK found that university teachers scored
consistently lower on the work satisfac-
tion variable and that they were more negative about their
workload and work–family balance than
other university staff (Horton, 2006).
Furthermore, in a study among 18 female Michigan university
teachers, participants were asked
how they managed to balance career and family demands.
‘Getting used to little sleep’ turned out to
be the key answer (Damiano-Teixiera, 2006). Sleepless in
academia is the title of an article by Acker
and Armenti (2004) in which they present two Canadian studies
on academics. In these studies
women emphasized high stress levels, exhaustion, fatigue and
sleeplessness in association with
building an academic career and bringing up young children
simultaneously. Working harder and
sleeping less were the main responses when participants were
asked how they coped at the univer-
sities. Acker and Armenti point out that these coping strategies
can cause illness among women. The
men in the study were less likely to describe illness and their
jobs seemed not to be tearing them apart
in the same way as they did in women.
In academia in Iceland the working hours are unregulated and
the work is to a large extent
product oriented. Academics get monthly wages but they also
get a bonus payment once a year for
performing certain tasks, such as publishing peer-reviewed
articles in highly ranked international
journals. The pressure to publish has been intensified by actions
that reward or punish the individual
university teacher and departments on the strength of research
productivity.
The remaining part of the article revolves around our study and
the question whether high
flexibility at work influences the way in which academics in
Iceland manage their time and how they
reconcile their work–family balance. By emphasizing gender in
this context we focus on everyday
experiences at work, family and leisure time of the academics
interviewed and explore whether or not
gender meanings shape their time structure.
Method
The study is based on 42 semi-structured in-depth interviews
with academics and top managers in
private Icelandic companies. In this article we focus on the 20
academics interviewed, 10 women and
10 men. The academics are from different faculties and
different universities. They are employed full
time and rank either as lecturer, senior lecturer or professor.
They are all parents and most of them
have two to four children varying in age from 6 months to a
little over 20 years. According to Statistics
Iceland (2011) the fertility rate among Icelandic women in 2010
was 2.2, which is higher than in other
Nordic countries and among the highest in the western world
(Eurostat Demographic statistics, n.d.).
The average fertility rate of the academics interviewed was 2.7.
One of the participants was a single parent and all the others
were married or cohabiting. Most of
the interviews were done in or around the universities, but some
took place in the participants’
homes. The interviews, which lasted between 25 and 90
minutes, were tape-recorded, transcribed and
analysed according to grounded theory.
Smith (1987, p. 99) quotes Marx and Engels stating that
‘Individuals always started, and always
start, from themselves. Their relations are the relations of their
real life’. In accordance to this, we
focus on the interviewees’ everyday life when analysing their
structuring of time in the academy. We
PROBLEM REPRESENTATIONS OF EQUAL PAY 287
© 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Volume 20 Number 3 May
2013
asked them, among other things, about the organization of their
work, work procedures, flexibility,
leisure and family life, housework and childcare arrangements.
Regarding anonymity, performing qualitative research in a small
community is not easy. The
academics’ freedom of speech was based on our commitment to
anonymity, which is quite
complex in Iceland as there are only seven universities and a
few hundred tenured academics. In
order to strengthen anonymity, we have therefore decided not to
describe our interviewed
professors as precisely as we would have done in larger
communities. The only information pre-
sented here is whether the participants are male or female and if
they have small children, teenage or
grown-up children, or both. To give the reader further
information could put the anony-
mity of the interviewees into jeopardy. We believe that the
information given will be sufficient
for the reader to understand the topics we are presenting in the
article. Like Smith (1987)
we are constrained by our commitment to ensure that the
academics we spoke to speak again in what
we write, like active and reflective subjects, despite our
reinterpretation of what they had to say.
Findings
This section discusses the findings from the study with the
interviewed academics. We start from the
basic assumption that social life (Berger and Luckmann, [1966]
1987) and time (Bryson, 2007; Davies,
1989) are socially constructed and linked to power.
Flexibility
The academics in our study generally enjoy a high level of
flexibility at work. They refer to this
flexibility as one of the main advantages of working in
academia. They feel that the flexibility helps
them to balance work and family life. Nonetheless, the female
participants seem to utilize this
flexibility in different ways from the men. Even if there have
been certain changes during the last
years between women and men regarding the division of
housework and childcare, it may not be
as much as we would like in terms of gender equality. For
instance, mothers are more likely than
fathers to use this flexibility to be on call for the family. Ólöf,
an academic mother of both young
and teenage children, explains how flexibility at the university
helps family life to continue. She
says:
I always came home early . . . he, [her husband] couldn’t do it
himself and in the past I have always
taken more days off when the children were sick because my
workplace is more flexible.
Here Ólöf points out that because her husband does not have the
same flexibility at work as she does
it is always her duty to be on call. The academic male
participants that also have this flexibility do not
mention, as some of the women do, that it is their primary
obligation and not their partners’ to be on
call. However, they do stress that their flexible working
schedules are good for their family. Their
wives seem to take the primary responsibility for the household
and for ‘being there’, independent
of whether they themselves have flexible schedules or not.
This probably explains why some of the women interviewed
praise their flexibility but at the same
time point out that, unlike the men, they do not have flexibility
as individuals because their time
schedule is too tight. ‘I think it is probably more in my mind
than it is in reality [that I can decide]
when I work and where I work’, says Maria, one of the
academic mothers with both young and
grown-up children.
Even though the participants mention that the flexible working
schedules and telecommuting
improve their work and family balance, it turns out that those
work characteristics lengthen their
workday and prevent them from spending time with their family
without having work-related issues
on their mind all the time.
288 GENDER, WORK AND ORGANIZATION
Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing
Ltd
A double-edged sword
When asking about the negative side of the unregulated working
hours we see that what is felt as the
most positive aspect of their work, that is, the flexibility and
the freedom to work ‘whenever and
wherever’, is also the most negative aspect. The unregulated
working time in the academy thus feels
like a double-edged sword:
[The] disadvantage, of course, is that it’s much more difficult to
keep a clear distinction between
your free time and your work time and if you are not careful, all
your time will be swallowed up
by work. (Tómas, an academic father of small children)
Sigurdur, also a father of small children says: ‘You are never
off’. Johanna, a female colleague with
small children, has similar thoughts in relation to her workload:
I think [the workload] is too much. . . . So what I do in the
evening is to write, try to write some
articles. So I feel like I am doing all of that just in my free
time.
Interestingly enough, Johanna argues, however, that the balance
between her work and family life is
good, but she adds:
It has to be at the expense of feeling that I haven’t done
anything except work and be with the kids.
After saying this, she points out that having children was
something she decided to do: ‘Of course, it
was my choice’ she says. This is a remarkable statement which
we find in several of our interviews
with women. Some of them seem to feel that they were not
allowed to complain about a heavy
work–family workload because it was their choice to have
children. None of the interviewed fathers
refer to their own liability for having children when discussing
the combination of work and family
life and long working hours. Regardless of how many children
the academic fathers have, and even
if they do some of the household chores, they are less likely
than the academic mothers to say they
have a heavy family workload.
The flexible working hours and the possibility of going home
early to care for the children and the
household before they continue working in the evenings are
praised by both women and men.
However, women are more likely than men to express time
poverty and lack of personal time:
Last winter, and even more the year before that, I felt that I
never had time for myself to read a book
or do anything besides just working and being with the kids.
And, you know, when they are small
it’s like, it’s of course very nice being with your children but
it’s still a lot of work, you know, doing
all that. (Ólöf)
Working always and everywhere
Even if some scholars like Dickisson (1997) stress the
importance of having a separate room in the
home to work in, most of the academics choose to work where
the family was even if they have a
separate room. Favourite places to work in are the living room,
the children’s bedroom and the
kitchen. Working where the family is can partly be explained by
the fact that academics, especially
women, work ‘in bits and pieces’ at home. This means that they
work whenever they get the chance
and they feel it is easiest to do this by having the laptop closely
at hand in the places where they most
often are, that is, in the living room or the kitchen. Based on the
interviews, working everywhere also
seems to be a way for these academics to hide from themselves
and their families the fact that they are
constantly working. They hope that their families may not
experience it as work when they are
‘playing on the laptop’ in front of the television or in the
kitchen. In addition, for the academics
themselves it feels more as if they are supporting their family
when they do not isolate themselves in
a separate room.
Maria, who always has her laptop with her, says: ‘I am on the
computer in bits and pieces if I am
at home’. Ragnar, a father of small and grown-up children, says:
PROBLEM REPRESENTATIONS OF EQUAL PAY 289
© 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Volume 20 Number 3 May
2013
The laptop fits everywhere . . . we have an office at home but I
don’t use it much. I work . . . in the
living room, I have my laptop in the couch.
Nevertheless, how well the academic parents are able to work
while their children are around varies.
Tómas, who works a lot at weekends, says:
I like waking up early on Saturdays and Sundays, then the kids
want to watch TV. So maybe I will
just take my computer and sit with them for 2 or 3 hours. I get a
lot of work done and they are just
. . . watching television.
The quote shows that his children do not interrupt him while he
is working but he feels he is
supporting the family by his presence. Other parents give
examples of how they integrate work and
childcare, even in the children’s bedroom. Helena, a mother of
both young and teenage children says:
I often take my youngest daughter to bed . . . and then I bring
with me an article, books . . . so while
she is falling asleep I am reading something I need to read up
for work.
Johanna says:
Last winter I worked every single evening and it was very
difficult to do that, but, I mean, that was
just the price, really, that [I] had to pay for leaving work so
early.
She usually picks up her children from preschool in the
afternoon and experiences her university
work in the evenings as the ‘price I have to pay’ for this. The
men interviewed do not say that working
in the evenings is the price they have to pay. Magnús is a father
who has both young children and
teenagers. He says:
A long work week really means that you have a lot of time to
work on things that you added, you
know, you are working on it because you decided to and that’s
what you like to do, and that’s why
you are doing it.
Unlike Johanna, Magnús says that he has power over his own
working time. He works long hours
because he likes it and has decided to do so. Working late in the
evening is not a consequence of the
time he has to spend with his family.
The official summer leave in Iceland is 5 to 6 weeks for
academics, depending on their age. As in
other Nordic countries, many employees take these 5 to 6 weeks
for their summer vacation but also
make sure that they have some days left that they can use as a
Christmas break. However, this is not
the case for most of our interviewees. Ólöf says:
Actually when I started working here, I asked a lot of people,
‘How much time do we have as a
summer vacation?’ And nobody really knew that, and I was like,
‘Ooh, that’s very interesting’.
She continues:
I feel sometimes like . . . the atmosphere here is that you are not
supposed to have any family life.
Sometimes I feel like I can read between the lines . . . that
people who are working in the university
. . . should always be working. . . . And I feel a little bit like
it’s prestigious in this institution not to
take a summer vacation or not to know when you are going to
take it.
She mentions that when you have children you must take some
days off: ‘Having the kids forces you
a little bit to take vacation, which I think everyone should do
anyway’. Helena says that it is a
conscious effort not to work during the summer vacation. She
usually takes some books with her and
the laptop when she is on leave. But her husband doesn’t like
her working when the family is on
vacation and she usually makes an agreement with him about
how much she can work. She tries to
convince him that her work during the vacation is in the interest
of the family:
I got that piece published and now I was getting my points and I
was telling my partner, you know,
‘Just for this article we get this much money’. [Laughs]
290 GENDER, WORK AND ORGANIZATION
Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing
Ltd
The interviewed men do not express the need to justify their
work to their wives or their family. The
wives of these academic men in general seem to have a better
understanding of the ‘endless work’
than the academic women’s husbands.1 Furthermore, the
academic women express more guilt over
working at inconvenient times than their male colleagues. We
interviewed the academics’ partners, to
bring to the light their views on academic working schedules,
flexibility and the work–family life
balance. Actually none of the men interviewed talked about
remorse in relation to their family because
of their long working days. The reason for this might be that
some of the men still considered
themselves to be the main breadwinners, even though their
wives or partners worked full time and
had their own income. The breadwinner role thus releases them
from the main responsibility for the
household, even if they participate in the household tasks
allocated to them.
Maria often comments that she is the main breadwinner in the
family. However, this does not free
her from having the main responsibility in the household, which
she believes is unfair. It would be
interesting to know whether her partner also considers her as
the main breadwinner, or whether he
feels that he is the main breadwinner even though he earns less
than she does. Sigurdur often refers
to his father when describing why he likes to work long days
even during family vacations. His father
liked to work a lot, and so does he. The female academics do
not refer to their mothers or fathers when
describing their long days at work. Quite the opposite, their
image of a good mother rather seems to
make the women express bad feelings about their heavy
workload.
The time that never comes
The academics interviewed define their workload at the
university as heavy because ‘you have never
done enough’. Maria says:
I started to have health problems due to too much work and
some heavy family responsibilities. . . .
I am working my ass off. Of course, I am working because I like
it.
Like Johanna, who prefers to stress that she chose to have
children, when explaining the struggle for
mastering the work–family balance, Maria underlines that she
likes her job when talking about her
workload. In both cases these remarks are like excuses that tone
down their complaints and leave
images of a problem that is self-inflicted. What remains is that
these women blame themselves for
being unable to balance their work and family life.
The women and the men describe their workload differently.
Even if both genders say they work
about 60 hours a week, the men seem to get more support for
their long working schedules and they
seem to bear less overall responsibility for their work within the
family. The women are more likely
to make a formal or informal agreement with their family
members while working during periods
when the family expects them to be off, while the men’s
working time seems to be more on their own
premises. Some of the women interviewed express struggles in
their work–family life, while they are
fighting to create time for their work and for their family to
become more engaged in the household.
Iris, a mother of both young and teenage children, says: ‘I think
there is always gonna come a time
when things are better [laughs]. I always have that idea but that
time never comes’. She is referring
both to her husband and her teenagers, whom she feels take
little responsibility in the household.
In Icelandic academia research points are very important. As
mentioned above, Johanna convinced
her family that finishing an article during a family holiday is in
their best interest, and not without
good reason. Research points are built into the structure of their
wages, increasing the possibilities to
get grants and speed up the advancement process in the
academic career hierarchy. Also, research
points make it easy to keep track of who is productive and who
is not, and who publishes in highly
ranked journals. It seems to be more of a struggle for the female
participants in this study than for
academic males to earn an acceptable amount of research points
each year, which consequently
brings about lower wages and slower career advancement.
Hildur, who has teenagers and has been
working for many years in academia, supports this: ‘On the
whole, I mean, this job suits me but [it
is] very stressful, you know, I get very stressed’.
PROBLEM REPRESENTATIONS OF EQUAL PAY 291
© 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Volume 20 Number 3 May
2013
Maria, who is younger than Hildur and has been working in
academia for only a few years, is
critical of the structuring of time and the workload:
You look at things and think, ‘How much am I willing to
sacrifice? I am not going to sacrifice my
family completely. I am not going to sacrifice my health to be
this excellent researcher with the most
prestige. No. . . . I am not going to hang the whole of who I am
onto how many points I get. And I
am not gonna, you know, compare myself all the time with
somebody else’.
However, Maria has had health problems due to workload, as
remarked before. None of the partici-
pating men reflect on their work as a threat to their health or
family life and they do not seem to
question equating their work with who they are. They do not
express any sacrifice or struggle when
talking about overtime, research points and their everyday life.
When discussing work development
and promotion Johanna said:
Of course, it is sometimes annoying when young boys . . .
[speed up the career ladder], and you
think, oh my God, they’ve been carried in this world. . . . I
don’t wanna sound like a bitter woman
or something but, I think, for a lot of us women, we had to fight
to do what we love doing and to
get a position that enables us to do what we like doing. A lot of
support, and a lot of criticism.
Ragnar supports this view, referring to old role models and
social control. He refers to his colleague
who said that ‘being an academic was perfect for bachelors . . .
with wives’. This is certainly a joke but
one of these jokes that academics can easily identify with.
Managing time
It is interesting to notice that the men interviewed in general
were more likely than the women to say
they had power over their own time, and they seem to allocate
that time between the family and their
work much more easily than the women interviewed. The men
approach their work and family life
more like different projects in which they decide for themselves
when to start and when to finish.
Even though they are responsible for different household
chores, they appear to be better able than
the women to divide their time between these tasks without
bearing the generic responsibility for
them. Their time, unlike the women’s time, seems to be divided
into different projects on a timeline.
The men’s time seem in general to be what Davies (1989) calls
linear time:
If I am given a project to take care of I do it, even if that
project has to do with the family I do it . . .
I happily do it. That’s probably my way of managing the
balance between work and the family, to
create projects.
Here Sigurdur describes his participation in the household.
Someone gives him a project in the family.
Sigurdur is actually referring to his wife. He was far from being
the only one who used this rhetoric,
which seemed though to be quite gendered. Tómas said this
about how he used the flexibility at the
university: ‘Of course when they [the children] are sick and so
on, you sometimes are in a position to
take leave from work’.
Tómas is ‘sometimes’ in a position to take leave, indicating that
he has the choice not to take leave
when his children are sick if he is bound to other projects.
Pétur, another father of young children,
says:
To be completely honest, I am not very good at balancing work
and family life, but what I try to do
is to be available when needed.
This utterance indicates that Pétur, like Tómas, has the choice
not to be available. In general, the
academic men, as opposed to the academic women, participate
in paid work for longer hours than
their partners and thus have in general higher salaries. So, even
though the men in academia do not
necessarily work more than their female colleagues they seem to
get more support from their partners
than the academic women, who are more or less bogged down in
their daily time-consuming routines
292 GENDER, WORK AND ORGANIZATION
Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing
Ltd
and family responsibilities besides their work. When Maria is
commenting on the structuring of time
in academia she says: ‘it’s not a good deal for most women, I
think’. What she is referring to is that
the unequal distribution of responsibility within the family
together with the endless stream of work
in academia creates an unhealthy workload for women.
Similar to how I feel about being a mother
It turns out that a typical workday in academia does not exist.
Nothing is normal, every day is very
different. ‘The only thing that is constant is too little time and
too many tasks’, says Iris. The academics
workday generally continues into the evening or even into the
night. They work in the evening
because there is ‘this endless stream of work’, but also because
the evenings and the nights are times
when they are not interrupted and can work in relative peace
and quiet. When asked about the end
of the workday, Andrea, a mother of adolescents, says:
Never . . . when I fall asleep. . . . I don’t quit at five because I
work at home . . . if there is something
I want to do, or need to do, I work at night.
She doesn’t quit when she leaves the university because she
brings her work home with her in the
afternoon. The possibility of working at home seems to lengthen
her working day.
Maria says, ‘I am always working when I am not asleep’. Ólöf
takes a few days off when she feels
too tired and Iris states that when she starts dreaming about
work or isn’t able to fall asleep because
of work, it is time to take a day off.
Eirikur, a father of adolescent children, affirms that he does not
mind long working hours as long
as he can be creative. Iris supports his statement by revealing
that when she gets into the writing
mood she writes non-stop. Hildur has had health problems,
probably because of a work overload, and
she tries to follow the advice of her physical doctor of only
saying ‘yes’ to projects and things she
likes. However, she feels that this is easier said than done.
It turns out that many participants do not see their profession as
a job but rather as many different
jobs or even as a lifestyle rather than work. ‘Being an academic
is a way of life’ is a common phrase.
Some mention that their profession is a part of their identity,
something they cannot just switch on
and off. Iris says:
In many ways it’s the same thing as, or similar to how I feel
about being a mother: it is not a real
job, it is who I am, you know.
Defining work as a hobby or a life style is probably a way of
escaping the fact that the work tends to
drown both their families and their private lives in general.
Discussion and conclusion
In this article we have analysed how academics in Iceland
structure and use their time and reconcile
their work and family life. We have found that in general the
male participants manage their time
better than the female participants, independently of their age or
the number of their children. On the
other hand, time poverty is prominent among both the women
and men interviewed, even if the
academic women placed stronger emphasis on time scantiness,
as well as on fragmented and
constrained leisure and working time.
Earlier we referred to Bryson (2007), who argued that time is
linked to power. Our interviews with
women and men in academia support that view, as well as the
argument that time is linked to gender.
We also notice the paradox that at the same time as the flexible
working hours help academic parents
to organize their working day and fulfil the ever-changing needs
of family members, the women,
rather than the men interviewed seem to be stuck in the
responsibility of domestic and caring issues;
indeed, because of this very same flexibility. The flexibility
seems to remove, more from women than
men, the possibility of going home early or not being on call.
This flexibility and the gendered time
PROBLEM REPRESENTATIONS OF EQUAL PAY 293
© 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Volume 20 Number 3 May
2013
use seem thus to reproduce traditional power relations between
women and men and the gender-
segregated work division in their families. This probably
explains why the men interviewed seemed
to be more relaxed and happy with the structuring of their time
than their female colleagues, despite
their high workload.
ICT encourages academic teachers to bring work home thereby
blurring the boundaries between
family life and work. But, interestingly, this has in general
different consequences for each gender.
Davies wrote during the 1990s that women’s time at home
‘becomes others’ time’ (1989, p. 38). Our
data, collected more than 20 years later among highly educated
women and men in a country that
scores the highest on the gender gap index show that men are
still more able than women to be off
work when home, either to recharge their batteries or to work, if
they like. Our finding is also in
accordance with the 20-year-old Swedish study of
Frankenheuser (1993), who found that women
managers experience more stress than men while attempting to
balance their work and family life.
Even if the men in our study take care of their children and
perform different household tasks, we
also find similarities with Leccardi (1996) who, in the final
years of the 20th century, claimed that
‘women’s time’ is shown to be ‘contaminated’ by emotions and
affections, rather than clock time.
To conclude, when analysing our data, we do not get full
support for the assertion of Reeves et al.
(2007), Blair-Loy and Wharton (2004) and Golden and Veiga
(2005) that flexibility improves the
work–family balance, in the sense that this flexibility brings a
lot of their work into their homes and
diminishes their possibility not to be on call. It also does not
necessarily support Golden and Veiga’s
results that flexibility decreases stress levels, because working
during supposed family time can
create stress and strain. In both cases, however, this could be
more legitimated for men than for
women. Our results can support Blair-Loy (2009) who points
out that even if the common finding is
that workplace flexibility reduces work–family conflict, this is
not generalizable for all occupational
groups. As our study is based on only 20 interviews with female
and male academics, we cannot
generalize our results to other occupational groups or to
differences between men and women in
general. However the results highly support Kvande (2007),
who stresses the importance of analysing
the gender aspect of flexibility, and Davies (1989) and Bryson
(2007), who show the gender aspect of
the time. In future studies it would be of interest to include
academics who do not have children to
see if we notice similar patterns regarding the power of time
among couples without children.
However, there are only few in Icelandic academia, as it is
uncommon for married or cohabiting
Icelandic women to choose not to have children because of their
career.
It is important to stress that even though we question the
assertion that flexible and autonomous
working schedules improve the work–family balance, we cannot
claim that this flexibility makes
maintaining the balance more difficult. This sounds like a
paradox and leads us to rethink the
widespread results of much work–family and flexibility research
where we have to take gender
power and occupation into closer consideration.
In her study Rafnsdóttir (1995) referred to men’s greater
flexibility and mobility at work when
describing the fact that the gender division of labour in the
fishing factories leads men to jobs that
have more autonomy than the jobs women have. In our study we
are not dealing with a gendered
division of labour, as women’s and men’s work in the academia
were fully comparable. So the
contribution of this study to former studies is that, even when
comparing highly educated women
and men in the same kind of work, that is, academics, men seem
to have more personal autonomy
than their female colleagues and they are better able to utilize
this autonomy for their own interest.
The flexible working schedules seem to accentuate the gender
role and reproduce unequal gender
power.
Acknowledgements
We thank the University of Iceland Research Fund for
supporting the study, and the two anonymous
reviewers for their useful comments. We would also like to
thank the academics who gave us access
to their valuable time and important reflections.
294 GENDER, WORK AND ORGANIZATION
Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing
Ltd
Note
1. We interviewed the academics partners to bring to light their
views on academic working schedules, flexibility
and the work–family life balance.
References
Acker S. and Armenti, C. (2004) Sleepless in academia. Gender
& Education, 16,1, 3–24.
Berger, P. and Luckmann, T. (1987 [1966]) The Social
Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the Sociology of
Knowledge.
Garden City, NY: Doubleday.
Blair-Loy, M. and Wharton, A. (2004) Organizational
commitment and constraints on work–family policy use:
corporate flexibility policies in a global firm. Sociological
Perspectives, 47,3, 243–67.
Blair-Loy, M. (2009) Work without end? Scheduling flexibility
and work-to-family conflict among stockbrokers.
Work and Occupations, 36,4, 279–317.
Bryson, V. (2007) Gender And the Politics of Time. Feminist
Theory and Contemporary Debates. Bristol: Policy Press.
Constable, S., Coats, D., Bevan, S. and Mahdon, M. (2009)
Good jobs. London: The Work Foundation. available
online at
http://www.theworkfoundation.com/research/publications/public
ationdetail.aspx?oItemId=226&
parentPageID=102&PubType= Last accessed 3 December 2009.
Damiano-Teixiera, K. (2006) Managing conflicting roles: a
qualitative study with female faculty members. Journal
of Family and Economical Issues, 27,2, 310–34.
Davies, K. (1989) Women and Time. Weaving the Strands of
Everyday Life. Lund: Grahns Boktryckeri.
Dickisson, K. (1997) Telecommuting got your homework done?
Benefits of a flexible work option that is gaining
currency in the ’90s, and how to get around its potential
pitfalls. CMA Magazine, 70,10, 13–14.
Doherty, L. and Manfredi, S. (2006) Action research to develop
work–life balance in a UK university. Women in
Management Review, 21,3, 241–59.
Durkheim, E. (1971) The Elementary Forms of Religious Life.
London: SCN Press.
Esping-Andersen, G. (1991) The Three Worlds of Welfare
Capitalism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Eurostat Demographic Statistics. (n.d.) Total Fertility Rate
2007. Available online at http://epp.eurostat.
ec.europa.eu/tgm/graph.do;jsessionid=9ea7974b30dcf5dc3a9aa1
7b44ac842c818816276241.e34SbxiPb3uSb40L
b34LaxqRaxyTe0?tab=graph&plugin=1&language=en&pcode=ts
dde220&toolbox=type, last accessed 15
December 2009.
Frankenheuser, M. (1993) Kvinnligt, manligt, stressigt.
Höganäs: Bra. Böcker.
Golden, T. and Veiga, J. (2005) The Impact of extent of
telecommuting on job satisfaction: resolving inconsistent
findings. Journal of Management, 31,2, 301–18.
Hassan, R. (2007) Network time. In: Hassan, R. and Purser, R.
(eds) 24/7. Time and Temporality in the Network
Society, pp. 37–61. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Heijstra, T.M. and Rafnsdóttir, G.L. (2010) The Internet and
academic’s workload and work–family balance. The
Internet and Higher Education, 13,3, 158–63.
Hochschild, A.R. (1997) The Time Bind. When Work Becomes
Home and Home Becomes Work. New York: Henry Holt.
Horton, S. (2006) High aspirations: differences in employee
satisfaction between university faculty and staff.
Applied Research in Quality of Life, 1,3–4, 315–22.
Jacobs, A.J. and Winslow, S.E. (2004) Overworked faculty: job
stresses and family demands. The Annuals of the
American Academy of Political and Social Science, 596,1, 104–
29.
Kurland, N. and Bailey, D. (1999) Telework: the advantages and
challenges of working here, there, anywhere, and
anytime. Organisational Dynamics, 28,2, 53–68.
Kvande, E. (2007) Doing Gender in Flexible Organizations.
Bergen: Fagbokforlaget.
Lackritz, J. (2004) Exploring burnout among university faculty:
incidence, performance, and demographic issues.
Teaching and Teacher Education, 20,1, 713–29.
Leccardi, C. (1996) Rethinking social time: feminist
perspectives. Time & Society, 5,5, 169–86.
Marx, K. (1954) Capital. Vol 1. London: Lawrence & Wishart.
Pétursdóttir, G.M. (2009) Within the aura of gender equality:
Icelandic work cultures, gender relations and family
responsibility. PhD dissertation Faculty of Political Science.
Reykavík: University of Iceland.
Rafnsdóttir, G.L. (1995) Kvinnofack eller integrering som
strategi mot underordning. — Om kvinnliga fackföreningar på
Island (Women’s Strategies for overcoming subordination. a
discussion of women’s unions in Iceland). Lund:
Lund University Press.
Reeves, R., Gwyther, M. and Saunders, A. (2007) Still juggling
after all these years. Management Today, 36–42.
Smith, D. (1987) The Everyday World As Problematic: a
Feminist Sociology. Boston, MA: Northeastern University
Press.
Southerton, D. (2003) ‘Squeezing time’: allocating practices,
co-ordinating networks and scheduling society. Time
& Society, 12,1, 5–25.
PROBLEM REPRESENTATIONS OF EQUAL PAY 295
© 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Volume 20 Number 3 May
2013
Statistics Iceland (2011) Fertility 1853–2010. Available online
at http://www.statice.is/Statistics/Population/
Births-and-deaths. Last accessed 17 April 2011.
Taylor, F.W. (1964 [1903]) The Principles of Scientific
Management. New York: Harper & Row.
Watson, T.J. (2003 [1980]) Sociology, Work and Industry (4th
edn) London: Routledge.
Weigt, J.M. and Solomon, C.R. (2008) Work–family
management among low-wage service workers and assistant
professors in the USA: a comparative intersectional analysis.
Gender, Work & Organization, 15,6, 621–49.
World Economic Forum (2009) The Global Gender Gap Report
(2009) Geneva: World Economic Forum.
World Economic Forum (2010) The Global Gender Gap Report
(2010) Geneva: World Economic Forum.
296 GENDER, WORK AND ORGANIZATION
Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing
Ltd
Copyright of Gender, Work & Organization is the property of
Wiley-Blackwell and its content may not be
copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv
without the copyright holder's express written
permission. However, users may print, download, or email
articles for individual use.

More Related Content

Similar to Outline Before you start writing the first draft of y.docx

As you compose your analysis, consider the following questions·.docx
As you compose your analysis, consider the following questions·.docxAs you compose your analysis, consider the following questions·.docx
As you compose your analysis, consider the following questions·.docxfredharris32
 
Assignment 3DUE Jan 27, 2019 1155 PMGrade DetailsGradeN.docx
Assignment 3DUE Jan 27, 2019 1155 PMGrade DetailsGradeN.docxAssignment 3DUE Jan 27, 2019 1155 PMGrade DetailsGradeN.docx
Assignment 3DUE Jan 27, 2019 1155 PMGrade DetailsGradeN.docxdanielfoster65629
 
ChAD 195 Senior Seminar Policy Paper Instructions Tot
ChAD 195 Senior Seminar  Policy Paper Instructions TotChAD 195 Senior Seminar  Policy Paper Instructions Tot
ChAD 195 Senior Seminar Policy Paper Instructions TotMaximaSheffield592
 
writing-introductions-and-conclusions.pdf
writing-introductions-and-conclusions.pdfwriting-introductions-and-conclusions.pdf
writing-introductions-and-conclusions.pdfKosorlDowm
 
The Cause And Effect Essay
The Cause And Effect EssayThe Cause And Effect Essay
The Cause And Effect Essaydldixon
 
Academic writing for special education 2014
Academic writing for special education 2014Academic writing for special education 2014
Academic writing for special education 2014Martin McMorrow
 
Thesis Statements Last revised July 2023.pptx
Thesis Statements Last revised July 2023.pptxThesis Statements Last revised July 2023.pptx
Thesis Statements Last revised July 2023.pptxHamidrezaMoeini1
 
PSY 1010, General Psychology 1 Course Descript.docx
PSY 1010, General Psychology 1     Course Descript.docxPSY 1010, General Psychology 1     Course Descript.docx
PSY 1010, General Psychology 1 Course Descript.docxamrit47
 
Findings and disscussion chapters
Findings and disscussion chaptersFindings and disscussion chapters
Findings and disscussion chaptersJAHennessyMurdoch
 
TitleABC123 Version X1Week 1 Practice WorksheetPSY.docx
TitleABC123 Version X1Week 1 Practice WorksheetPSY.docxTitleABC123 Version X1Week 1 Practice WorksheetPSY.docx
TitleABC123 Version X1Week 1 Practice WorksheetPSY.docxedwardmarivel
 
Essay plan and structure dw ss_new
Essay plan and structure dw ss_newEssay plan and structure dw ss_new
Essay plan and structure dw ss_newChuangDorinWang
 
Comparative Politics Essay.pdf
Comparative Politics Essay.pdfComparative Politics Essay.pdf
Comparative Politics Essay.pdfEmily Garcia
 
1 8Annotated Bib
1                                         8Annotated Bib1                                         8Annotated Bib
1 8Annotated BibVannaJoy20
 
In-Text Questions and Answers in ODL Course Material: How To
In-Text Questions and Answers in ODL Course Material: How ToIn-Text Questions and Answers in ODL Course Material: How To
In-Text Questions and Answers in ODL Course Material: How Toshekknett
 
Essay On First Day At School. First Day of School - GCSE English - Marked by ...
Essay On First Day At School. First Day of School - GCSE English - Marked by ...Essay On First Day At School. First Day of School - GCSE English - Marked by ...
Essay On First Day At School. First Day of School - GCSE English - Marked by ...Felicia Gonzales
 
Research Draft Iby D.docx
Research Draft Iby D.docxResearch Draft Iby D.docx
Research Draft Iby D.docxdebishakespeare
 
Good Example Of Argumentative Essay.pdf
Good Example Of Argumentative Essay.pdfGood Example Of Argumentative Essay.pdf
Good Example Of Argumentative Essay.pdfMichelle Green
 
ASSESSMENT TASK 2 Report Critique (2000 words)Aligned.docx
ASSESSMENT TASK 2 Report Critique (2000 words)Aligned.docxASSESSMENT TASK 2 Report Critique (2000 words)Aligned.docx
ASSESSMENT TASK 2 Report Critique (2000 words)Aligned.docxgalerussel59292
 

Similar to Outline Before you start writing the first draft of y.docx (20)

As you compose your analysis, consider the following questions·.docx
As you compose your analysis, consider the following questions·.docxAs you compose your analysis, consider the following questions·.docx
As you compose your analysis, consider the following questions·.docx
 
Assignment 3DUE Jan 27, 2019 1155 PMGrade DetailsGradeN.docx
Assignment 3DUE Jan 27, 2019 1155 PMGrade DetailsGradeN.docxAssignment 3DUE Jan 27, 2019 1155 PMGrade DetailsGradeN.docx
Assignment 3DUE Jan 27, 2019 1155 PMGrade DetailsGradeN.docx
 
ChAD 195 Senior Seminar Policy Paper Instructions Tot
ChAD 195 Senior Seminar  Policy Paper Instructions TotChAD 195 Senior Seminar  Policy Paper Instructions Tot
ChAD 195 Senior Seminar Policy Paper Instructions Tot
 
writing-introductions-and-conclusions.pdf
writing-introductions-and-conclusions.pdfwriting-introductions-and-conclusions.pdf
writing-introductions-and-conclusions.pdf
 
The Cause And Effect Essay
The Cause And Effect EssayThe Cause And Effect Essay
The Cause And Effect Essay
 
Academic writing for special education 2014
Academic writing for special education 2014Academic writing for special education 2014
Academic writing for special education 2014
 
Thesis Statements Last revised July 2023.pptx
Thesis Statements Last revised July 2023.pptxThesis Statements Last revised July 2023.pptx
Thesis Statements Last revised July 2023.pptx
 
PSY 1010, General Psychology 1 Course Descript.docx
PSY 1010, General Psychology 1     Course Descript.docxPSY 1010, General Psychology 1     Course Descript.docx
PSY 1010, General Psychology 1 Course Descript.docx
 
Findings and disscussion chapters
Findings and disscussion chaptersFindings and disscussion chapters
Findings and disscussion chapters
 
TitleABC123 Version X1Week 1 Practice WorksheetPSY.docx
TitleABC123 Version X1Week 1 Practice WorksheetPSY.docxTitleABC123 Version X1Week 1 Practice WorksheetPSY.docx
TitleABC123 Version X1Week 1 Practice WorksheetPSY.docx
 
Essay plan and structure dw ss_new
Essay plan and structure dw ss_newEssay plan and structure dw ss_new
Essay plan and structure dw ss_new
 
Argumentation Essays
Argumentation EssaysArgumentation Essays
Argumentation Essays
 
Comparative Politics Essay.pdf
Comparative Politics Essay.pdfComparative Politics Essay.pdf
Comparative Politics Essay.pdf
 
1 8Annotated Bib
1                                         8Annotated Bib1                                         8Annotated Bib
1 8Annotated Bib
 
EAPP.pptx
EAPP.pptxEAPP.pptx
EAPP.pptx
 
In-Text Questions and Answers in ODL Course Material: How To
In-Text Questions and Answers in ODL Course Material: How ToIn-Text Questions and Answers in ODL Course Material: How To
In-Text Questions and Answers in ODL Course Material: How To
 
Essay On First Day At School. First Day of School - GCSE English - Marked by ...
Essay On First Day At School. First Day of School - GCSE English - Marked by ...Essay On First Day At School. First Day of School - GCSE English - Marked by ...
Essay On First Day At School. First Day of School - GCSE English - Marked by ...
 
Research Draft Iby D.docx
Research Draft Iby D.docxResearch Draft Iby D.docx
Research Draft Iby D.docx
 
Good Example Of Argumentative Essay.pdf
Good Example Of Argumentative Essay.pdfGood Example Of Argumentative Essay.pdf
Good Example Of Argumentative Essay.pdf
 
ASSESSMENT TASK 2 Report Critique (2000 words)Aligned.docx
ASSESSMENT TASK 2 Report Critique (2000 words)Aligned.docxASSESSMENT TASK 2 Report Critique (2000 words)Aligned.docx
ASSESSMENT TASK 2 Report Critique (2000 words)Aligned.docx
 

More from alfred4lewis58146

For this assignment, students will need to observe the activities th.docx
For this assignment, students will need to observe the activities th.docxFor this assignment, students will need to observe the activities th.docx
For this assignment, students will need to observe the activities th.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For this assignment, select a human service organization from .docx
For this assignment, select a human service organization from .docxFor this assignment, select a human service organization from .docx
For this assignment, select a human service organization from .docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For this Assignment, read the case study for Claudia and find tw.docx
For this Assignment, read the case study for Claudia and find tw.docxFor this Assignment, read the case study for Claudia and find tw.docx
For this Assignment, read the case study for Claudia and find tw.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For this assignment, download the A6 code pack. This zip fil.docx
For this assignment, download the A6 code pack. This zip fil.docxFor this assignment, download the A6 code pack. This zip fil.docx
For this assignment, download the A6 code pack. This zip fil.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For this assignment, create infographic using the Canva website..docx
For this assignment, create infographic using the Canva website..docxFor this assignment, create infographic using the Canva website..docx
For this assignment, create infographic using the Canva website..docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For this assignment, compare  California during the Great Depression.docx
For this assignment, compare  California during the Great Depression.docxFor this assignment, compare  California during the Great Depression.docx
For this assignment, compare  California during the Great Depression.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For this assignment, create a 10- to 12-slide presentation in Mi.docx
For this assignment, create a 10- to 12-slide presentation in Mi.docxFor this assignment, create a 10- to 12-slide presentation in Mi.docx
For this assignment, create a 10- to 12-slide presentation in Mi.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For this assignment, begin by reading chapters 12-15 in Dr. Bells t.docx
For this assignment, begin by reading chapters 12-15 in Dr. Bells t.docxFor this assignment, begin by reading chapters 12-15 in Dr. Bells t.docx
For this assignment, begin by reading chapters 12-15 in Dr. Bells t.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For this assignment, assume you are the new Secretary of Homelan.docx
For this assignment, assume you are the new Secretary of Homelan.docxFor this assignment, assume you are the new Secretary of Homelan.docx
For this assignment, assume you are the new Secretary of Homelan.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For this assignment, address the following promptsIntroductor.docx
For this assignment, address the following promptsIntroductor.docxFor this assignment, address the following promptsIntroductor.docx
For this assignment, address the following promptsIntroductor.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For this assignment, analyze the play by focusing on one of the .docx
For this assignment, analyze the play by focusing on one of the .docxFor this assignment, analyze the play by focusing on one of the .docx
For this assignment, analyze the play by focusing on one of the .docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For this assignment I would like you to answer these questions.docx
For this assignment I would like you to answer these questions.docxFor this assignment I would like you to answer these questions.docx
For this assignment I would like you to answer these questions.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For the Weekly Reports I need 2 reports. For the First two weeks the.docx
For the Weekly Reports I need 2 reports. For the First two weeks the.docxFor the Weekly Reports I need 2 reports. For the First two weeks the.docx
For the Weekly Reports I need 2 reports. For the First two weeks the.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For the shortanswer questions,you will need to respo.docx
For the shortanswer questions,you will need to respo.docxFor the shortanswer questions,you will need to respo.docx
For the shortanswer questions,you will need to respo.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For the sake of argument (this essay in particular), lets prete.docx
For the sake of argument (this essay in particular), lets prete.docxFor the sake of argument (this essay in particular), lets prete.docx
For the sake of argument (this essay in particular), lets prete.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For the proposal, each student must describe an interface they a.docx
For the proposal, each student must describe an interface they a.docxFor the proposal, each student must describe an interface they a.docx
For the proposal, each student must describe an interface they a.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For the project, you will be expected to apply the key concepts of p.docx
For the project, you will be expected to apply the key concepts of p.docxFor the project, you will be expected to apply the key concepts of p.docx
For the project, you will be expected to apply the key concepts of p.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For the past several weeks you have addressed several different area.docx
For the past several weeks you have addressed several different area.docxFor the past several weeks you have addressed several different area.docx
For the past several weeks you have addressed several different area.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For the Mash it Up assignment, we experimented with different ways t.docx
For the Mash it Up assignment, we experimented with different ways t.docxFor the Mash it Up assignment, we experimented with different ways t.docx
For the Mash it Up assignment, we experimented with different ways t.docxalfred4lewis58146
 
For the first time in modern history, the world is experiencing a he.docx
For the first time in modern history, the world is experiencing a he.docxFor the first time in modern history, the world is experiencing a he.docx
For the first time in modern history, the world is experiencing a he.docxalfred4lewis58146
 

More from alfred4lewis58146 (20)

For this assignment, students will need to observe the activities th.docx
For this assignment, students will need to observe the activities th.docxFor this assignment, students will need to observe the activities th.docx
For this assignment, students will need to observe the activities th.docx
 
For this assignment, select a human service organization from .docx
For this assignment, select a human service organization from .docxFor this assignment, select a human service organization from .docx
For this assignment, select a human service organization from .docx
 
For this Assignment, read the case study for Claudia and find tw.docx
For this Assignment, read the case study for Claudia and find tw.docxFor this Assignment, read the case study for Claudia and find tw.docx
For this Assignment, read the case study for Claudia and find tw.docx
 
For this assignment, download the A6 code pack. This zip fil.docx
For this assignment, download the A6 code pack. This zip fil.docxFor this assignment, download the A6 code pack. This zip fil.docx
For this assignment, download the A6 code pack. This zip fil.docx
 
For this assignment, create infographic using the Canva website..docx
For this assignment, create infographic using the Canva website..docxFor this assignment, create infographic using the Canva website..docx
For this assignment, create infographic using the Canva website..docx
 
For this assignment, compare  California during the Great Depression.docx
For this assignment, compare  California during the Great Depression.docxFor this assignment, compare  California during the Great Depression.docx
For this assignment, compare  California during the Great Depression.docx
 
For this assignment, create a 10- to 12-slide presentation in Mi.docx
For this assignment, create a 10- to 12-slide presentation in Mi.docxFor this assignment, create a 10- to 12-slide presentation in Mi.docx
For this assignment, create a 10- to 12-slide presentation in Mi.docx
 
For this assignment, begin by reading chapters 12-15 in Dr. Bells t.docx
For this assignment, begin by reading chapters 12-15 in Dr. Bells t.docxFor this assignment, begin by reading chapters 12-15 in Dr. Bells t.docx
For this assignment, begin by reading chapters 12-15 in Dr. Bells t.docx
 
For this assignment, assume you are the new Secretary of Homelan.docx
For this assignment, assume you are the new Secretary of Homelan.docxFor this assignment, assume you are the new Secretary of Homelan.docx
For this assignment, assume you are the new Secretary of Homelan.docx
 
For this assignment, address the following promptsIntroductor.docx
For this assignment, address the following promptsIntroductor.docxFor this assignment, address the following promptsIntroductor.docx
For this assignment, address the following promptsIntroductor.docx
 
For this assignment, analyze the play by focusing on one of the .docx
For this assignment, analyze the play by focusing on one of the .docxFor this assignment, analyze the play by focusing on one of the .docx
For this assignment, analyze the play by focusing on one of the .docx
 
For this assignment I would like you to answer these questions.docx
For this assignment I would like you to answer these questions.docxFor this assignment I would like you to answer these questions.docx
For this assignment I would like you to answer these questions.docx
 
For the Weekly Reports I need 2 reports. For the First two weeks the.docx
For the Weekly Reports I need 2 reports. For the First two weeks the.docxFor the Weekly Reports I need 2 reports. For the First two weeks the.docx
For the Weekly Reports I need 2 reports. For the First two weeks the.docx
 
For the shortanswer questions,you will need to respo.docx
For the shortanswer questions,you will need to respo.docxFor the shortanswer questions,you will need to respo.docx
For the shortanswer questions,you will need to respo.docx
 
For the sake of argument (this essay in particular), lets prete.docx
For the sake of argument (this essay in particular), lets prete.docxFor the sake of argument (this essay in particular), lets prete.docx
For the sake of argument (this essay in particular), lets prete.docx
 
For the proposal, each student must describe an interface they a.docx
For the proposal, each student must describe an interface they a.docxFor the proposal, each student must describe an interface they a.docx
For the proposal, each student must describe an interface they a.docx
 
For the project, you will be expected to apply the key concepts of p.docx
For the project, you will be expected to apply the key concepts of p.docxFor the project, you will be expected to apply the key concepts of p.docx
For the project, you will be expected to apply the key concepts of p.docx
 
For the past several weeks you have addressed several different area.docx
For the past several weeks you have addressed several different area.docxFor the past several weeks you have addressed several different area.docx
For the past several weeks you have addressed several different area.docx
 
For the Mash it Up assignment, we experimented with different ways t.docx
For the Mash it Up assignment, we experimented with different ways t.docxFor the Mash it Up assignment, we experimented with different ways t.docx
For the Mash it Up assignment, we experimented with different ways t.docx
 
For the first time in modern history, the world is experiencing a he.docx
For the first time in modern history, the world is experiencing a he.docxFor the first time in modern history, the world is experiencing a he.docx
For the first time in modern history, the world is experiencing a he.docx
 

Recently uploaded

DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginnersDATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginnersSabitha Banu
 
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptxCELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptxJiesonDelaCerna
 
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)eniolaolutunde
 
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentAlper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentInMediaRes1
 
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media Component
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media ComponentMeghan Sutherland In Media Res Media Component
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media ComponentInMediaRes1
 
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxEmployee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxNirmalaLoungPoorunde1
 
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher EducationIntroduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Educationpboyjonauth
 
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...jaredbarbolino94
 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPT
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPTECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPT
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPTiammrhaywood
 
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdfssuser54595a
 
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...Marc Dusseiller Dusjagr
 
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptxHistory Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptxsocialsciencegdgrohi
 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptxECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptxiammrhaywood
 
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdf
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdfBiting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdf
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdfadityarao40181
 
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxPOINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxSayali Powar
 
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsPresiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsanshu789521
 
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,Virag Sontakke
 
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developer
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developerinternship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developer
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developerunnathinaik
 
Painted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of India
Painted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of IndiaPainted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of India
Painted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of IndiaVirag Sontakke
 

Recently uploaded (20)

DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginnersDATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
 
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptxCELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
 
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
 
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentAlper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
 
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media Component
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media ComponentMeghan Sutherland In Media Res Media Component
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media Component
 
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxEmployee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
 
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher EducationIntroduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
 
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...
 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPT
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPTECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPT
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPT
 
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
18-04-UA_REPORT_MEDIALITERAСY_INDEX-DM_23-1-final-eng.pdf
 
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
 
OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...
OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...
OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...
 
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptxHistory Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptxECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
 
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdf
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdfBiting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdf
Biting mechanism of poisonous snakes.pdf
 
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxPOINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
 
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsPresiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
 
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
 
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developer
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developerinternship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developer
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developer
 
Painted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of India
Painted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of IndiaPainted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of India
Painted Grey Ware.pptx, PGW Culture of India
 

Outline Before you start writing the first draft of y.docx

  • 1. Outline Before you start writing the first draft of your essay or research project, it is always useful to make an outline of your ideas. If you have already decided on your focus or topic, and you have a rough list of sources for support, then you are ready to draft an outline. Keep in mind that outlines are required to follow a format style (eg. APA). An outline is simply a way to organize your ideas and information. The following is an abbreviated version of what is often referred to as a formal or “traditional” outline. It can be expanded or condensed to fit the scope of your essay or research project. The example below is based on the five-paragraph essay model. The Thesis Statement (TS) will be the last 1-3 sentences of the introduction. I. Introduction A. Thesis Statement II. Body paragraph #1 – Topic Sentence #1 A. Supporting Evidence 1. Name of & quote from source Supporting Evidence Integrate an appropriate example, such as a quote, statistic, case
  • 2. study, etc. 2. Name of & quote from source #2 (if applicable) B. Explanation 1. Explanation of source 2. Explanation of source #2 (if applicable) C. So What? Explanation Explain how this evidence supports your topic sentence. Try to develop your explanation in 2-4 sentences. III. Body paragraph #2 – Topic Sentence #2 A. Supporting Evidence 1. So What? What’s significant or important about the ideas (topic sentence + evidence + explanation) in this paragraph? Remind your reader how all this connects back to the TS. 2. B. Explanation 1. 2. C. So What? IV. Body paragraph #3 – Topic Sentence #3 A. Supporting Evidence
  • 3. The TS is the first 1-3 sentences of the conclusion. It should be “rephrased” here rather than repeated verbatim. Avoid simply summarizing the main points in the conclusion: synthesize them. B. Explanation C. So What? V. Conclusion A. Rephrase thesis statement B. Bring closure by going from specific to broad To see what a complete outline, refer to the model below. The thesis statement has been taken from the Thesis Statement Guide section of the Ashford Writing Center. I. Introduction A. Thesis Statement Although there are educational television programs, parents should regulate the amount of television their children watch because it is not always intellectually stimulating, it can distort a child’s perception of reality, and it inhibits social interaction. II. Body paragraph #1 - Topic Sentence #1 While television has the potential to offer programs that can
  • 4. be seen as educational supplements, too much television has an even greater potential for turning children into passive viewers and getting in the way of intellectual stimulation. A. Supporting Evidence As a recent article from the University of Michigan Health Systems (2008) maintains, “Too much television can negatively affect early brain development. This is especially true at younger ages, when learning to talk and play with others is so important” (qtd. in “Television”). B. Explanation Indeed, too much television can be detrimental to cognitive development because preschool-aged children need physical interaction, and television for older children acts as an unhealthy replacement for reading and being read to. Children need to engage in imaginative play; adolescents and teenagers benefit from getting fresh air and being more active. C. So What? While it would be too easy to dismiss every TV show directed at youths—in fact, PBS and Discovery Kids offer excellent programming— children’s lives are increasingly centered around TV-watching, and thus, parents should regulate how much their kids are viewing regardless of content or perceived quality.
  • 5. III. Body paragraph #2 - Topic Sentence #2 Moreover, with proper supervision or regulation, there are television programs that can distort a child’s perception of reality. A. Supporting Evidence In the online article “How TV Affects Your Child,” Dr. Mary Gavin (2008) points out that “TV characters often depict risky behaviors, such as smoking and drinking, and also reinforce gender-role and racial stereotypes.” B. Explanation Certainly, seeing these types of behaviors and stereotypes exhibited by favorite television personalities and encouraged by favorite shows can contradict with the values parents want to instill in their children, which can cause both tension and confusion. While television does have entertainment value, children cannot learn all the differences between right and wrong from it. C. So What? Although it is difficult to prevent children’s total exposure to questionable social mores and limited multicultural representation in the media, parents can have
  • 6. some control by supervising their children’s viewing as well as talk about what’s portrayed on television. IV. Body paragraph #3 - Topic Sentence #3 Finally, television can impede healthy relationship-building and impose on family time. A. Supporting Evidence For example, recent studies have found that the television is on most of the time in 51% of households and that “[k]ids with a TV in their bedroom spend an average of almost 1.5 hours more per day watching TV than kids without a TV in the bedroom” (qtd. in “Television”). B. Explanation If children are spending this much time glued to the their favorite television programs, and if parents do not have rules about how much is okay to watch, then children are not only spending less time on important cognitive development activities such as reading and doing homework, but they are also spending less time on social interaction with peers and important family time. C. So What? Given how long families are apart from each other during
  • 7. the week because of school and work, it is unfortunate that any extra time outside of those obligations should be wasted on watching television; therefore, regulation is one key approach to ensure a family’s closeness and the strength of the parents’ bond with their children. V. Conclusion A. Thesis Statement rephrased Television can be both educational and entertaining for children; however, only in moderation. Thus, it’s important that parents step in to supervise how much television their children watch as it can negatively affect their intellectual, psychological, and social development. 130 ABLVol36No2 2010 Contributed Article Balancing Work, Family and Life: Introduction to the Special Edition
  • 8. •John Burgess and Jennifer Waterhouse* The papers in this special edition of Australian Bulletin of Labour are about the issue of balancing paid work with other aspects of life. Work- life had its genesis in the concept of work-family balance in the 1980s, when the apparent tension between work and family life began to be recognised. Woolcott (1990) showed that concerns about issues outside of work, particularly family responsibilities, had the potential to affect both the wellbeing and productivity of workers. Failing to address problems of imbalance between work and other life aspects has also been identified as resulting in detrimental social and economic consequences (OECD, 2008). As a result of these consequences, initiatives that assist workers to balance their work and family lives have gained increasing support from policy makers, employee and employer groups. Early conceptualisations of work-family balance tended to confine research, policy and organisational attention to the matter of conflict between work and the rearing of dependent children. Research has since covered significant terrain, becoming multi-disciplinary, with studies emerging from industrial relations, economics, psychology and human resource management and including topics such as long working hours (for example. Bunting 2005), gender (for example,
  • 9. Gregory and Milner 2009) and power (for example, Mescher, Benschop and Doorewaard 2009). *University of Newcastle Burgess and Waterhouse 131 This special edition draws primarily from an industrial relations and policy perspective; but the eclectic nature of the topics covered reflects the diverse nature of the concept. Authors have used both the terms 'work- family balance' as well as the broader 'work-life balance'. This is in keeping with a general trend towards the inclusion of non-family aspects as an important consideration for policy makers, employers and employee groups. The trend is contentious in that the term 'work-life' can be considered a catch-all phrase arguably disguising critical social issues and over-simplifying the complexity and inequity of life inside and outside of paid work such as the gendered imbalance related to child rearing and domestic duties. For the purposes of this special edition, work- life balance is, however, a useful term to capture the full gamut of the topic. The papers provide insights into a wide range of issues, including consideration of the approaches and interventions of various entities at various levels, discussion on the resultant
  • 10. or potential outcomes of such approaches and observations about current work- life experience. The study by Skinner and Pocock provides findings from a large Australian survey and highlights the varied experiences of work-life balance for different categories of workers. It provides a useful starting point for themes developed in other articles in this issue. One such theme that also appears in the paper on call centres by Hannif, McDonnell, Connell and Burgess and the study by Brown, Bradley, Lingard, Townsend and Ling is unsociable working hours. The latter study sheds new light on old ground when the benefits of a two-day break are discussed. In this, the study departs from the more common focus on long working hours to a consideration of a need for a long break. All three studies demonstrate the detrimental effects of unsociable hours and the need to deal with this important element in the work-life balance equation. Another common theme is the extension of working hours through the use of informal or unofficial working time arrangements such as that found in call centres, discussed by Hannif, McDonnell, Connell and Burgess. Organisational practice as to working hours and access to work-life policy provisions also forms a major theme of Colley's study of a public sector agency. Of interest in the Colley paper
  • 11. is the broadening of organisational policy to encompass a work- life framework; but staff access to entitlements is limited by organisational norms and managerial preference and discretion. Both papers, therefore, highlight the importance of informal practices at workplace level for the extent of workers' access to work- life flexibility arrangements. The main question which these observations on working time and flexibility arrangements raise is the extent to which legislation 132 Australian Bulletin of Labour is able to identify and deal effectively with the informal aspects of organisational practice that adversely affect employees' ability to balance their work and other life activities. The paper by Waterhouse and Colley suggests that the process provisions of the Fair Work Act limit the scrutiny and the enforcement of flexible work arrangements that are necessary to meet the work-life balance needs of employees. It can be argued that the economic and social effects of a failure to address work-life balance (OECD 2008) should extend the topic beyond the interests of traditional stakeholders in industrial relations. Community groups, such as those representing the interests of families, emergency and social
  • 12. services, have also sought to contribute to the debate on work-life balance through their contributions to govemment enquiries. The finding by Waterhouse and Colley, that the interests of these non-traditional stakeholders were largely overlooked in favour of traditional actors, suggests the continued view of work-life balance as being more about the needs of industry and the workplace than the needs of society. Much remains to be done in terms of research and practice. The direction for future research is two-fold. First, there is a need for high-level, multi-disciplinary approaches to encompass the intersection of work-life balance in different disciplines. Secondly, and at the other end of the spectrum, is a continued need for investigation of individual cases and experiences. This special edition contributes to this future direction through research that extends from national-level studies, through to industry level and individual organisational cases. References Bunting, M. (2005), How the Overwork Culture is Ruling our Lives, Harper Perennial, London. Gregory, A. and Milner, S. (2009), 'Editorial: Work-life Balance: A Matter of Choice?', Gender Work and Organization, vol. 16, pp. 1-13. Mescher, S., Benschop, Y. and Doorewaard, H. (2009),
  • 13. 'Representations of Work Life Balance Support', Human Relations, vol. 63, pp. 21- 39. OECD (2008), Babies and Bosses: Baiancing Work and Family Life, Policy Brief, July. Woolcott, I. (1990), 'The Structure of Work and the Work of Families', Family Matters, vol. 26, April, pp. 32-38. Copyright of Australian Bulletin of Labour is the property of National Institute of Labour Studies and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. Balancing Work–family Life in Academia: The Power of Timegwao_571 283..296 Gudbjörg Linda Rafnsdóttir* and Thamar M. Heijstra In the article we analyse the structuring of time among academic employees in Iceland, how they organize and reconcile their work and family life and whether gender is a defining factor in this context. Our analysis shows clear gender differences in time
  • 14. use. Although flexible working hours help academic parents to organize their working day and fulfil the ever-changing needs of family members, the women, rather than men interviewed, seem to be stuck with the responsibility of domestic and caring issues because of this very same flexibility. It seems to remove, for more women than for men, the possibility of going home early or not being on call. The flexibility and the gendered time use seem thus to reproduce traditional power relations between women and men and the gender segregated division in the homes. Keywords: academia, flexibility, gender, power relations, time, work–family balance Women and men often spend their time differently due to the widespread gender division inwork and family life. Thus, Bryson (2007), Kvande (2007) and Davies (1989) emphasize the importance of analyzing the structuring of time and time consciousness when discussing gender equality. Bryson (2007) mentions that the time squeeze can cause decreased autonomy among indi- viduals and diminish their ability to become active citizens. The structuring of time is also a matter of health and wellbeing. According to Frankenheuser (1993) who compared managers in a Swedish factory, women showed the same level of stress as men until the afternoon when the stress increased among women only due to their attempt to reconcile work and family life. As far as gender equality in Iceland is concerned, the country passed an Act on gender equality in 1976 in an attempt to secure the equal input of women and men in society, to work against
  • 15. gender-based discrimination in the labour market and to enable both women and men to reconcile work and family life. Today, the Icelandic welfare system is based upon the Nordic welfare model (Esping-Andersen, 1991). In Iceland this includes 9 months of parental leave, of which 3 months is reserved exclusively for fathers, and relatively cheap access to qualified day care for children aged between 1 and 6 years. Each parent is also entitled to ten fully paid child sick days per year. Iceland prides itself on promoting sexual equality and, according to the World Economic Forum’s Global Gender Gap Index (2009, 2010) the country has claimed to be at the forefront of gender equality in the world. The Index benchmarks national gender gaps using economic, political, educational and health-based criteria. It is thus of interest to investigate how career-oriented people such as academics manage to structure their time and combine their work and private life in Iceland. This article revolves around the question whether or not female and male academics use the flexibility at work to balance their work and family life, and if they do, how they do it. To start, we first look more closely at the concept of time. Address for correspondence: *University of Iceland, Faculty of Social and Human Sciences, Oddi, Sturlugata, IS 101 Reykjavík, Iceland; e-mail: [email protected] bs_bs_banner Gender, Work and Organization. Vol. 20 No. 3 May 2013 doi:10.1111/j.1468-0432.2011.00571.x
  • 16. © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Time and gender Our standpoint is that time is multiple and linked to power. That means that we do not see time only as clock time or as linear time that is to be divided into different components. We picture it, rather, as a web where people can move around, at times situated in one compartment, and sometimes in many simultaneously. Power is related to time since time is an essential resource to which access may be unequally distributed. Those who have more power in their relationships are more likely to be able to manage their own time and the time of others in both the private and public realm. The concept of time can be viewed from different perspectives. Bryson (2007), Leccardi (1996) and Davies (1989) point out that so-called traditional time was based on the natural rhythm of the seasons and the tasks that had to be done. The relation to time was local, task-oriented, seasonal and repetitive. With the development of capitalism and industrialization this traditional time consciousness gradu- ally gave way to the modern time of waged workers who were paid for the hours they worked but not on the basis of the tasks they performed or the service they provided. As time consciousness changes, Davies and Bryson argue that time is socially constructed. Davies (1989, p. 17) states: [T]ime consciousness and time measurement are crucial for the structuring and direction of
  • 17. women’s and men’s everyday lives. Time can furthermore be used as an instrument of power and control. Former sociologists did not reflect much upon time when discussing the power structures in society. However, a few deal with time, though more obliquely. Frederick W. Taylor (1964) became known for the principle of scientific management or time and motion studies based on breaking a job into its component parts and measuring each to a hundredth of a minute. The ideas behind Taylorism resulted later on in theories like Fordism, principally known as a mass production system theory, and just in time production processes (Watson, 2003 [1980]). Émile Durkheim noted that time is socially constructed and linked to a society that encloses the individual (Durkheim, 1971) and time spent in production is in some ways central to the thought of Karl Marx (1954). Even though these sociologists discuss time, neither of them deals with time as being crucial for their theories, nor do they theorize gender. In contrast, the feministic sociologists Davies (1989), Leccardi (1996) and Bryson (2007) do shed light upon gender when analysing the structuring of time in society. Bryson (2007) points out that the ways in which time is used, valued and understood are central to the maintenance of gender inequalities in public and private life, and are damaging for both men and women. She shows that while parental time with children and leisure in general have increased during the last decades, parents, particularly mothers, partly achieve this by combining the time they spend with their children with other activities. This explains
  • 18. why parents perceive themselves as being more and more pressed for time because stress is not simply a matter of the total hours of paid and unpaid work, it is exacerbated by the intensity of their use of time. Parents often have to force different activities into the same period. Bryson refers to Southerton (2003) who has coined the useful term ‘harriedness’ to cover women’s sense of being both harried and harassed by the seemingly incompatible demands on their time and the need to co-ordinate a host of fragmented activities. Davies (1989) argues that there are two major ways of conceiving time in modern society; cyclical (female) and linear (male) time. However, she does note that this generalization may not account for individual cases as they can be much more complex and partially dependent on lifestyle. The linear conception of time — where time is seen as unfolding in a straight and unbroken line, unidirectional and heading towards an unlimited horizon — is the conception that is preponderant today. It appears to characterize men’s relation to time, in terms of the way in which they organize their daily lives as well as their life course. Usually they do so in a much more clear-cut fashion than women. Linear time also forms the dominant structure in present-day society and may be used, as an instrument of power and control over women. Cyclical time, or female time, on the other hand, is usually associated with everyday life prior to, or concurrent with industrialization. Under a cyclical time consciousness people order the events of 284 GENDER, WORK AND ORGANIZATION
  • 19. Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd their lives according to local and natural rhythms and the future is a perpetual recapitulation of the present. The precise measurement of time in these circumstances is superfluous. On a day-to-day basis, people are not subject to clock time but rather to time that is task oriented. According to Davies (1989), the two facets of women’s lives, that is, wage labour and reproduction, are associated with time. She points out that the responsibility that women have for care and reproduction make their daily lives a complex weaving between the dominant linear (male) time on the one hand, and cyclical (female) time on the other. In their experience, this work of weaving time goes beyond economic rationality. Its special quality derives from being at the same time within and outside of economic logic. Davies (1989, pp. 37–8) argues: ‘Time disposal is partly determined by the individual, partly by social or legal coercion and partly through negotiations with others’. Davies shows that since women historically have been responsible for the family, in addition to other tasks, these activities have engulfed all their time due to the temporal nature of care. Women’s time is thereby characteristically others’ time. For these women, doing several things at the same time appears to be the norm. Nevertheless, she maintains that social and legal coercion as well as negotiation with others are closely related to the issue of
  • 20. power. Thus, access to one’s own time and to leisure time is quite simply a question of power and may function to enforcer of male identity and provide one of the means by which male hegemony is constructed and reconstructed: The more power and influence we have, the more we can decide over our own time and other’s time, the more we can negotiate time and resist social control. Women’s subordinate position in the public sphere as well as their ascribed role in the private sphere have major implications with regard to this. . . . At home, their time — more than any other family member’s — becomes others’ time . . . both men and women do not and cannot freely choose how to use and structure their time, but . . . for women there are specific structural relations which have special implications for how their time is used. (Davies, 1989, p. 38) Leccardi (1996) argues along the same lines as Davies. She insists that feminist theory calls into question the representation of time in capitalist societies and provides an approach that point to a different conception of the relationship between life and time for both women and men. Women’s biographical time she says, as a result of their increasing capacity to produce income in an indepen- dent manner, is increasingly confronted by the logic, scansions and rhythms of public time. The various dimensions of women’s work are shaped by different forms of logic where family work is governed not by the logic of the market, but by expectations of reciprocity. Even though the clock remains an essential mediator in our everyday existence, its claim to being time per se and its taken-for
  • 21. granted hegemony have been undermined. ‘As such, “women’s time” is shown to be “contaminated” by emotions and affections, never to be merely clock time’ (Leccardi, 1996, p. 182). Hassan (2007) connects the discussion about time to new information and communication tech- nologies (ICTs). He points out that the network time provides people with the capability to create their own time and spaces as ICTs and people in interaction undermine and displace the time of the clock. In pre-industrial societies task-oriented time was dictated by the task itself and the interaction between human, technological and local circumstances. Due to the effects of high speed and com- puter technology a network-generated ‘fragmented time’ is emerging alongside the ‘industrial time’ of the clock. Hassan describes the possibilities within these digital spaces to create, experience and control our context-dependent time, where the clock will have marginal or no effect: The important point is that this context-created temporal experience is disconnected from the local clock times of the users. The clock no longer governs, as it once did in the preinformation age. (Hassan, 2007, p. 52) Time use-studies Davies (1989) and Bryson (2007) reveal that the problem with time-use studies in general is that they are based on a view of time in which time can be divided into small measurable components. This PROBLEM REPRESENTATIONS OF EQUAL PAY 285
  • 22. © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 makes it difficult to measure tasks that are carried out simultaneously and to measure the time that is involved in caring for others and different kinds of caring responsibilities in which ‘being there’ is important. Bryson (2007, p. 157) stresses: ‘Studies are also unable to record the intermittent worrying, guilt and stress individuals may experience around what they are not doing while they are doing something else’. She highlights that the studies are not able to show the different kinds of time people experience and that all time is not equal. Some people’s time seem to be worth more than others’, which reflects a certain kind of power. Leisure studies are becoming more frequent as leisure appears to play an increasingly large role in the life of adults, at least among the middle class. However, Bryson (2007) notes that, while the rhetoric of time poverty is widely used, writers disagree as to the nature and significance of class and gender-based differences in the availability and nature of free time. In spite of this it is clear to Bryson that the manual working class has less control over its leisure time and does not have access to time-saving resources. This finding is supported by Weigt and Solomon (2008) who compared work and family management among women in low-wage services and female assistant professors at universities in the USA. They found that women privileged by class were also privileged in their
  • 23. ability to manage work and family demands. While class muted gendered experiences for the female assistant professors it exacerbated gender experiences for women in the low-wage service sector. Flexibility at work Whenever describing so-called good jobs, the features autonomy and flexibility are often mentioned (Constable et al., 2009). Flexibility at work has basically two characteristics; flexible working hours and telecommuting. Flexible working hours, on the one hand, give employees a certain amount of freedom to decide when to start and end their work day. Telecommuting on the other hand, allows employees to decide where they work, as long as there is an Internet or phone connection (Dickisson, 1997). Autonomy is closely related to flexibility and it has been argued that flexibility at work improves the work–family balance of the worker (Blair-Loy and Wharton, 2004; Reeves et al., 2007). Moreover, some studies show that flexibility decreases stress levels among workers and makes people more productive (Golden and Veiga, 2005; Kurland and Bailey, 1999). Dickisson (1997) notes that employees in flexible organizations take fewer sick days and are often more creative, although he emphasizes the importance of having one’s own work space at home, preferably with a door that can be closed. Kvande (2007) discusses flexibility from another point of view. She points out that especially in knowledge organizations, the shift from standardization to the differentiation of working hours leads to an endless flood of work, long working hours and less family
  • 24. time. Kvande refers, for example, to Hochschild (1997) when she points out that the formal contract that regulates working hours is being replaced by moral obligations and time norms that demand total commitment. Blair-Loy (2009) support this findings as her studies shows that stockbrokers in firms with scheduling flexibility experience more work–family conflict than those in firms with scheduling rigidity. Hassan (2007) argues that the reality of network time and network communication for most people is impelled by the need to constantly look for ways to be more efficient and productive. Speed is fetishized and short-term outcomes are valorized. This is in line with Heijstra and Rafnsdóttir (2010), who show that even though ICTs make some features of the life of academics easier, they also initiate a proliferation of the workload, trigger a prolonging of the workday and enhance a demand for extensive availability. While ICTs increase the flexibility of academics at work this does not seem to improve their work–family balance. On the contrary, ICTs and flexibility are found to increase work–family conflict, as the ICTs in combination with their flexibility make it increasingly difficult for academics to disengage from work. Furthermore, according to Pétursdóttir (2009) and Rafnsdóttir (1995) men often have more flexibility at work than women and this improves their autonomy in private and public life. However, most of them do not use this flexibility to reconcile work and family life. 286 GENDER, WORK AND ORGANIZATION
  • 25. Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Academics Being an academic is generally characterized by having a large amount of flexibility and autonomy. Academics have for the most part the freedom to decide where, how and even when to work. Most come close to being their own supervisors even if they are employees. With the arrival of ICTs the possibilities of working from home have increased for them. However, at the same time studies from the UK (Doherty and Manfredi, 2006) and the USA (Jacobs and Winslow, 2004) show that, while academics have a high level of flexibility at work, they also have to deal with an intensification of their workload and long working hours. This might explain why one out of five university teachers in the USA displays serious burn-out symptoms (Lackritz, 2004). A study among university staff in the USA, Canada and UK found that university teachers scored consistently lower on the work satisfac- tion variable and that they were more negative about their workload and work–family balance than other university staff (Horton, 2006). Furthermore, in a study among 18 female Michigan university teachers, participants were asked how they managed to balance career and family demands. ‘Getting used to little sleep’ turned out to be the key answer (Damiano-Teixiera, 2006). Sleepless in academia is the title of an article by Acker and Armenti (2004) in which they present two Canadian studies
  • 26. on academics. In these studies women emphasized high stress levels, exhaustion, fatigue and sleeplessness in association with building an academic career and bringing up young children simultaneously. Working harder and sleeping less were the main responses when participants were asked how they coped at the univer- sities. Acker and Armenti point out that these coping strategies can cause illness among women. The men in the study were less likely to describe illness and their jobs seemed not to be tearing them apart in the same way as they did in women. In academia in Iceland the working hours are unregulated and the work is to a large extent product oriented. Academics get monthly wages but they also get a bonus payment once a year for performing certain tasks, such as publishing peer-reviewed articles in highly ranked international journals. The pressure to publish has been intensified by actions that reward or punish the individual university teacher and departments on the strength of research productivity. The remaining part of the article revolves around our study and the question whether high flexibility at work influences the way in which academics in Iceland manage their time and how they reconcile their work–family balance. By emphasizing gender in this context we focus on everyday experiences at work, family and leisure time of the academics interviewed and explore whether or not gender meanings shape their time structure. Method
  • 27. The study is based on 42 semi-structured in-depth interviews with academics and top managers in private Icelandic companies. In this article we focus on the 20 academics interviewed, 10 women and 10 men. The academics are from different faculties and different universities. They are employed full time and rank either as lecturer, senior lecturer or professor. They are all parents and most of them have two to four children varying in age from 6 months to a little over 20 years. According to Statistics Iceland (2011) the fertility rate among Icelandic women in 2010 was 2.2, which is higher than in other Nordic countries and among the highest in the western world (Eurostat Demographic statistics, n.d.). The average fertility rate of the academics interviewed was 2.7. One of the participants was a single parent and all the others were married or cohabiting. Most of the interviews were done in or around the universities, but some took place in the participants’ homes. The interviews, which lasted between 25 and 90 minutes, were tape-recorded, transcribed and analysed according to grounded theory. Smith (1987, p. 99) quotes Marx and Engels stating that ‘Individuals always started, and always start, from themselves. Their relations are the relations of their real life’. In accordance to this, we focus on the interviewees’ everyday life when analysing their structuring of time in the academy. We PROBLEM REPRESENTATIONS OF EQUAL PAY 287 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013
  • 28. asked them, among other things, about the organization of their work, work procedures, flexibility, leisure and family life, housework and childcare arrangements. Regarding anonymity, performing qualitative research in a small community is not easy. The academics’ freedom of speech was based on our commitment to anonymity, which is quite complex in Iceland as there are only seven universities and a few hundred tenured academics. In order to strengthen anonymity, we have therefore decided not to describe our interviewed professors as precisely as we would have done in larger communities. The only information pre- sented here is whether the participants are male or female and if they have small children, teenage or grown-up children, or both. To give the reader further information could put the anony- mity of the interviewees into jeopardy. We believe that the information given will be sufficient for the reader to understand the topics we are presenting in the article. Like Smith (1987) we are constrained by our commitment to ensure that the academics we spoke to speak again in what we write, like active and reflective subjects, despite our reinterpretation of what they had to say. Findings This section discusses the findings from the study with the interviewed academics. We start from the basic assumption that social life (Berger and Luckmann, [1966] 1987) and time (Bryson, 2007; Davies, 1989) are socially constructed and linked to power.
  • 29. Flexibility The academics in our study generally enjoy a high level of flexibility at work. They refer to this flexibility as one of the main advantages of working in academia. They feel that the flexibility helps them to balance work and family life. Nonetheless, the female participants seem to utilize this flexibility in different ways from the men. Even if there have been certain changes during the last years between women and men regarding the division of housework and childcare, it may not be as much as we would like in terms of gender equality. For instance, mothers are more likely than fathers to use this flexibility to be on call for the family. Ólöf, an academic mother of both young and teenage children, explains how flexibility at the university helps family life to continue. She says: I always came home early . . . he, [her husband] couldn’t do it himself and in the past I have always taken more days off when the children were sick because my workplace is more flexible. Here Ólöf points out that because her husband does not have the same flexibility at work as she does it is always her duty to be on call. The academic male participants that also have this flexibility do not mention, as some of the women do, that it is their primary obligation and not their partners’ to be on call. However, they do stress that their flexible working schedules are good for their family. Their wives seem to take the primary responsibility for the household and for ‘being there’, independent
  • 30. of whether they themselves have flexible schedules or not. This probably explains why some of the women interviewed praise their flexibility but at the same time point out that, unlike the men, they do not have flexibility as individuals because their time schedule is too tight. ‘I think it is probably more in my mind than it is in reality [that I can decide] when I work and where I work’, says Maria, one of the academic mothers with both young and grown-up children. Even though the participants mention that the flexible working schedules and telecommuting improve their work and family balance, it turns out that those work characteristics lengthen their workday and prevent them from spending time with their family without having work-related issues on their mind all the time. 288 GENDER, WORK AND ORGANIZATION Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd A double-edged sword When asking about the negative side of the unregulated working hours we see that what is felt as the most positive aspect of their work, that is, the flexibility and the freedom to work ‘whenever and wherever’, is also the most negative aspect. The unregulated working time in the academy thus feels like a double-edged sword:
  • 31. [The] disadvantage, of course, is that it’s much more difficult to keep a clear distinction between your free time and your work time and if you are not careful, all your time will be swallowed up by work. (Tómas, an academic father of small children) Sigurdur, also a father of small children says: ‘You are never off’. Johanna, a female colleague with small children, has similar thoughts in relation to her workload: I think [the workload] is too much. . . . So what I do in the evening is to write, try to write some articles. So I feel like I am doing all of that just in my free time. Interestingly enough, Johanna argues, however, that the balance between her work and family life is good, but she adds: It has to be at the expense of feeling that I haven’t done anything except work and be with the kids. After saying this, she points out that having children was something she decided to do: ‘Of course, it was my choice’ she says. This is a remarkable statement which we find in several of our interviews with women. Some of them seem to feel that they were not allowed to complain about a heavy work–family workload because it was their choice to have children. None of the interviewed fathers refer to their own liability for having children when discussing the combination of work and family life and long working hours. Regardless of how many children the academic fathers have, and even if they do some of the household chores, they are less likely
  • 32. than the academic mothers to say they have a heavy family workload. The flexible working hours and the possibility of going home early to care for the children and the household before they continue working in the evenings are praised by both women and men. However, women are more likely than men to express time poverty and lack of personal time: Last winter, and even more the year before that, I felt that I never had time for myself to read a book or do anything besides just working and being with the kids. And, you know, when they are small it’s like, it’s of course very nice being with your children but it’s still a lot of work, you know, doing all that. (Ólöf) Working always and everywhere Even if some scholars like Dickisson (1997) stress the importance of having a separate room in the home to work in, most of the academics choose to work where the family was even if they have a separate room. Favourite places to work in are the living room, the children’s bedroom and the kitchen. Working where the family is can partly be explained by the fact that academics, especially women, work ‘in bits and pieces’ at home. This means that they work whenever they get the chance and they feel it is easiest to do this by having the laptop closely at hand in the places where they most often are, that is, in the living room or the kitchen. Based on the interviews, working everywhere also seems to be a way for these academics to hide from themselves and their families the fact that they are
  • 33. constantly working. They hope that their families may not experience it as work when they are ‘playing on the laptop’ in front of the television or in the kitchen. In addition, for the academics themselves it feels more as if they are supporting their family when they do not isolate themselves in a separate room. Maria, who always has her laptop with her, says: ‘I am on the computer in bits and pieces if I am at home’. Ragnar, a father of small and grown-up children, says: PROBLEM REPRESENTATIONS OF EQUAL PAY 289 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 The laptop fits everywhere . . . we have an office at home but I don’t use it much. I work . . . in the living room, I have my laptop in the couch. Nevertheless, how well the academic parents are able to work while their children are around varies. Tómas, who works a lot at weekends, says: I like waking up early on Saturdays and Sundays, then the kids want to watch TV. So maybe I will just take my computer and sit with them for 2 or 3 hours. I get a lot of work done and they are just . . . watching television. The quote shows that his children do not interrupt him while he is working but he feels he is supporting the family by his presence. Other parents give
  • 34. examples of how they integrate work and childcare, even in the children’s bedroom. Helena, a mother of both young and teenage children says: I often take my youngest daughter to bed . . . and then I bring with me an article, books . . . so while she is falling asleep I am reading something I need to read up for work. Johanna says: Last winter I worked every single evening and it was very difficult to do that, but, I mean, that was just the price, really, that [I] had to pay for leaving work so early. She usually picks up her children from preschool in the afternoon and experiences her university work in the evenings as the ‘price I have to pay’ for this. The men interviewed do not say that working in the evenings is the price they have to pay. Magnús is a father who has both young children and teenagers. He says: A long work week really means that you have a lot of time to work on things that you added, you know, you are working on it because you decided to and that’s what you like to do, and that’s why you are doing it. Unlike Johanna, Magnús says that he has power over his own working time. He works long hours because he likes it and has decided to do so. Working late in the evening is not a consequence of the time he has to spend with his family.
  • 35. The official summer leave in Iceland is 5 to 6 weeks for academics, depending on their age. As in other Nordic countries, many employees take these 5 to 6 weeks for their summer vacation but also make sure that they have some days left that they can use as a Christmas break. However, this is not the case for most of our interviewees. Ólöf says: Actually when I started working here, I asked a lot of people, ‘How much time do we have as a summer vacation?’ And nobody really knew that, and I was like, ‘Ooh, that’s very interesting’. She continues: I feel sometimes like . . . the atmosphere here is that you are not supposed to have any family life. Sometimes I feel like I can read between the lines . . . that people who are working in the university . . . should always be working. . . . And I feel a little bit like it’s prestigious in this institution not to take a summer vacation or not to know when you are going to take it. She mentions that when you have children you must take some days off: ‘Having the kids forces you a little bit to take vacation, which I think everyone should do anyway’. Helena says that it is a conscious effort not to work during the summer vacation. She usually takes some books with her and the laptop when she is on leave. But her husband doesn’t like her working when the family is on vacation and she usually makes an agreement with him about how much she can work. She tries to convince him that her work during the vacation is in the interest of the family:
  • 36. I got that piece published and now I was getting my points and I was telling my partner, you know, ‘Just for this article we get this much money’. [Laughs] 290 GENDER, WORK AND ORGANIZATION Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd The interviewed men do not express the need to justify their work to their wives or their family. The wives of these academic men in general seem to have a better understanding of the ‘endless work’ than the academic women’s husbands.1 Furthermore, the academic women express more guilt over working at inconvenient times than their male colleagues. We interviewed the academics’ partners, to bring to the light their views on academic working schedules, flexibility and the work–family life balance. Actually none of the men interviewed talked about remorse in relation to their family because of their long working days. The reason for this might be that some of the men still considered themselves to be the main breadwinners, even though their wives or partners worked full time and had their own income. The breadwinner role thus releases them from the main responsibility for the household, even if they participate in the household tasks allocated to them. Maria often comments that she is the main breadwinner in the family. However, this does not free her from having the main responsibility in the household, which
  • 37. she believes is unfair. It would be interesting to know whether her partner also considers her as the main breadwinner, or whether he feels that he is the main breadwinner even though he earns less than she does. Sigurdur often refers to his father when describing why he likes to work long days even during family vacations. His father liked to work a lot, and so does he. The female academics do not refer to their mothers or fathers when describing their long days at work. Quite the opposite, their image of a good mother rather seems to make the women express bad feelings about their heavy workload. The time that never comes The academics interviewed define their workload at the university as heavy because ‘you have never done enough’. Maria says: I started to have health problems due to too much work and some heavy family responsibilities. . . . I am working my ass off. Of course, I am working because I like it. Like Johanna, who prefers to stress that she chose to have children, when explaining the struggle for mastering the work–family balance, Maria underlines that she likes her job when talking about her workload. In both cases these remarks are like excuses that tone down their complaints and leave images of a problem that is self-inflicted. What remains is that these women blame themselves for being unable to balance their work and family life. The women and the men describe their workload differently.
  • 38. Even if both genders say they work about 60 hours a week, the men seem to get more support for their long working schedules and they seem to bear less overall responsibility for their work within the family. The women are more likely to make a formal or informal agreement with their family members while working during periods when the family expects them to be off, while the men’s working time seems to be more on their own premises. Some of the women interviewed express struggles in their work–family life, while they are fighting to create time for their work and for their family to become more engaged in the household. Iris, a mother of both young and teenage children, says: ‘I think there is always gonna come a time when things are better [laughs]. I always have that idea but that time never comes’. She is referring both to her husband and her teenagers, whom she feels take little responsibility in the household. In Icelandic academia research points are very important. As mentioned above, Johanna convinced her family that finishing an article during a family holiday is in their best interest, and not without good reason. Research points are built into the structure of their wages, increasing the possibilities to get grants and speed up the advancement process in the academic career hierarchy. Also, research points make it easy to keep track of who is productive and who is not, and who publishes in highly ranked journals. It seems to be more of a struggle for the female participants in this study than for academic males to earn an acceptable amount of research points each year, which consequently brings about lower wages and slower career advancement. Hildur, who has teenagers and has been
  • 39. working for many years in academia, supports this: ‘On the whole, I mean, this job suits me but [it is] very stressful, you know, I get very stressed’. PROBLEM REPRESENTATIONS OF EQUAL PAY 291 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 Maria, who is younger than Hildur and has been working in academia for only a few years, is critical of the structuring of time and the workload: You look at things and think, ‘How much am I willing to sacrifice? I am not going to sacrifice my family completely. I am not going to sacrifice my health to be this excellent researcher with the most prestige. No. . . . I am not going to hang the whole of who I am onto how many points I get. And I am not gonna, you know, compare myself all the time with somebody else’. However, Maria has had health problems due to workload, as remarked before. None of the partici- pating men reflect on their work as a threat to their health or family life and they do not seem to question equating their work with who they are. They do not express any sacrifice or struggle when talking about overtime, research points and their everyday life. When discussing work development and promotion Johanna said: Of course, it is sometimes annoying when young boys . . . [speed up the career ladder], and you
  • 40. think, oh my God, they’ve been carried in this world. . . . I don’t wanna sound like a bitter woman or something but, I think, for a lot of us women, we had to fight to do what we love doing and to get a position that enables us to do what we like doing. A lot of support, and a lot of criticism. Ragnar supports this view, referring to old role models and social control. He refers to his colleague who said that ‘being an academic was perfect for bachelors . . . with wives’. This is certainly a joke but one of these jokes that academics can easily identify with. Managing time It is interesting to notice that the men interviewed in general were more likely than the women to say they had power over their own time, and they seem to allocate that time between the family and their work much more easily than the women interviewed. The men approach their work and family life more like different projects in which they decide for themselves when to start and when to finish. Even though they are responsible for different household chores, they appear to be better able than the women to divide their time between these tasks without bearing the generic responsibility for them. Their time, unlike the women’s time, seems to be divided into different projects on a timeline. The men’s time seem in general to be what Davies (1989) calls linear time: If I am given a project to take care of I do it, even if that project has to do with the family I do it . . . I happily do it. That’s probably my way of managing the balance between work and the family, to
  • 41. create projects. Here Sigurdur describes his participation in the household. Someone gives him a project in the family. Sigurdur is actually referring to his wife. He was far from being the only one who used this rhetoric, which seemed though to be quite gendered. Tómas said this about how he used the flexibility at the university: ‘Of course when they [the children] are sick and so on, you sometimes are in a position to take leave from work’. Tómas is ‘sometimes’ in a position to take leave, indicating that he has the choice not to take leave when his children are sick if he is bound to other projects. Pétur, another father of young children, says: To be completely honest, I am not very good at balancing work and family life, but what I try to do is to be available when needed. This utterance indicates that Pétur, like Tómas, has the choice not to be available. In general, the academic men, as opposed to the academic women, participate in paid work for longer hours than their partners and thus have in general higher salaries. So, even though the men in academia do not necessarily work more than their female colleagues they seem to get more support from their partners than the academic women, who are more or less bogged down in their daily time-consuming routines 292 GENDER, WORK AND ORGANIZATION Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing
  • 42. Ltd and family responsibilities besides their work. When Maria is commenting on the structuring of time in academia she says: ‘it’s not a good deal for most women, I think’. What she is referring to is that the unequal distribution of responsibility within the family together with the endless stream of work in academia creates an unhealthy workload for women. Similar to how I feel about being a mother It turns out that a typical workday in academia does not exist. Nothing is normal, every day is very different. ‘The only thing that is constant is too little time and too many tasks’, says Iris. The academics workday generally continues into the evening or even into the night. They work in the evening because there is ‘this endless stream of work’, but also because the evenings and the nights are times when they are not interrupted and can work in relative peace and quiet. When asked about the end of the workday, Andrea, a mother of adolescents, says: Never . . . when I fall asleep. . . . I don’t quit at five because I work at home . . . if there is something I want to do, or need to do, I work at night. She doesn’t quit when she leaves the university because she brings her work home with her in the afternoon. The possibility of working at home seems to lengthen her working day. Maria says, ‘I am always working when I am not asleep’. Ólöf
  • 43. takes a few days off when she feels too tired and Iris states that when she starts dreaming about work or isn’t able to fall asleep because of work, it is time to take a day off. Eirikur, a father of adolescent children, affirms that he does not mind long working hours as long as he can be creative. Iris supports his statement by revealing that when she gets into the writing mood she writes non-stop. Hildur has had health problems, probably because of a work overload, and she tries to follow the advice of her physical doctor of only saying ‘yes’ to projects and things she likes. However, she feels that this is easier said than done. It turns out that many participants do not see their profession as a job but rather as many different jobs or even as a lifestyle rather than work. ‘Being an academic is a way of life’ is a common phrase. Some mention that their profession is a part of their identity, something they cannot just switch on and off. Iris says: In many ways it’s the same thing as, or similar to how I feel about being a mother: it is not a real job, it is who I am, you know. Defining work as a hobby or a life style is probably a way of escaping the fact that the work tends to drown both their families and their private lives in general. Discussion and conclusion In this article we have analysed how academics in Iceland structure and use their time and reconcile their work and family life. We have found that in general the
  • 44. male participants manage their time better than the female participants, independently of their age or the number of their children. On the other hand, time poverty is prominent among both the women and men interviewed, even if the academic women placed stronger emphasis on time scantiness, as well as on fragmented and constrained leisure and working time. Earlier we referred to Bryson (2007), who argued that time is linked to power. Our interviews with women and men in academia support that view, as well as the argument that time is linked to gender. We also notice the paradox that at the same time as the flexible working hours help academic parents to organize their working day and fulfil the ever-changing needs of family members, the women, rather than the men interviewed seem to be stuck in the responsibility of domestic and caring issues; indeed, because of this very same flexibility. The flexibility seems to remove, more from women than men, the possibility of going home early or not being on call. This flexibility and the gendered time PROBLEM REPRESENTATIONS OF EQUAL PAY 293 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 use seem thus to reproduce traditional power relations between women and men and the gender- segregated work division in their families. This probably explains why the men interviewed seemed to be more relaxed and happy with the structuring of their time
  • 45. than their female colleagues, despite their high workload. ICT encourages academic teachers to bring work home thereby blurring the boundaries between family life and work. But, interestingly, this has in general different consequences for each gender. Davies wrote during the 1990s that women’s time at home ‘becomes others’ time’ (1989, p. 38). Our data, collected more than 20 years later among highly educated women and men in a country that scores the highest on the gender gap index show that men are still more able than women to be off work when home, either to recharge their batteries or to work, if they like. Our finding is also in accordance with the 20-year-old Swedish study of Frankenheuser (1993), who found that women managers experience more stress than men while attempting to balance their work and family life. Even if the men in our study take care of their children and perform different household tasks, we also find similarities with Leccardi (1996) who, in the final years of the 20th century, claimed that ‘women’s time’ is shown to be ‘contaminated’ by emotions and affections, rather than clock time. To conclude, when analysing our data, we do not get full support for the assertion of Reeves et al. (2007), Blair-Loy and Wharton (2004) and Golden and Veiga (2005) that flexibility improves the work–family balance, in the sense that this flexibility brings a lot of their work into their homes and diminishes their possibility not to be on call. It also does not necessarily support Golden and Veiga’s results that flexibility decreases stress levels, because working during supposed family time can
  • 46. create stress and strain. In both cases, however, this could be more legitimated for men than for women. Our results can support Blair-Loy (2009) who points out that even if the common finding is that workplace flexibility reduces work–family conflict, this is not generalizable for all occupational groups. As our study is based on only 20 interviews with female and male academics, we cannot generalize our results to other occupational groups or to differences between men and women in general. However the results highly support Kvande (2007), who stresses the importance of analysing the gender aspect of flexibility, and Davies (1989) and Bryson (2007), who show the gender aspect of the time. In future studies it would be of interest to include academics who do not have children to see if we notice similar patterns regarding the power of time among couples without children. However, there are only few in Icelandic academia, as it is uncommon for married or cohabiting Icelandic women to choose not to have children because of their career. It is important to stress that even though we question the assertion that flexible and autonomous working schedules improve the work–family balance, we cannot claim that this flexibility makes maintaining the balance more difficult. This sounds like a paradox and leads us to rethink the widespread results of much work–family and flexibility research where we have to take gender power and occupation into closer consideration. In her study Rafnsdóttir (1995) referred to men’s greater flexibility and mobility at work when describing the fact that the gender division of labour in the
  • 47. fishing factories leads men to jobs that have more autonomy than the jobs women have. In our study we are not dealing with a gendered division of labour, as women’s and men’s work in the academia were fully comparable. So the contribution of this study to former studies is that, even when comparing highly educated women and men in the same kind of work, that is, academics, men seem to have more personal autonomy than their female colleagues and they are better able to utilize this autonomy for their own interest. The flexible working schedules seem to accentuate the gender role and reproduce unequal gender power. Acknowledgements We thank the University of Iceland Research Fund for supporting the study, and the two anonymous reviewers for their useful comments. We would also like to thank the academics who gave us access to their valuable time and important reflections. 294 GENDER, WORK AND ORGANIZATION Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Note 1. We interviewed the academics partners to bring to light their views on academic working schedules, flexibility and the work–family life balance.
  • 48. References Acker S. and Armenti, C. (2004) Sleepless in academia. Gender & Education, 16,1, 3–24. Berger, P. and Luckmann, T. (1987 [1966]) The Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge. Garden City, NY: Doubleday. Blair-Loy, M. and Wharton, A. (2004) Organizational commitment and constraints on work–family policy use: corporate flexibility policies in a global firm. Sociological Perspectives, 47,3, 243–67. Blair-Loy, M. (2009) Work without end? Scheduling flexibility and work-to-family conflict among stockbrokers. Work and Occupations, 36,4, 279–317. Bryson, V. (2007) Gender And the Politics of Time. Feminist Theory and Contemporary Debates. Bristol: Policy Press. Constable, S., Coats, D., Bevan, S. and Mahdon, M. (2009) Good jobs. London: The Work Foundation. available online at http://www.theworkfoundation.com/research/publications/public ationdetail.aspx?oItemId=226& parentPageID=102&PubType= Last accessed 3 December 2009. Damiano-Teixiera, K. (2006) Managing conflicting roles: a qualitative study with female faculty members. Journal of Family and Economical Issues, 27,2, 310–34. Davies, K. (1989) Women and Time. Weaving the Strands of Everyday Life. Lund: Grahns Boktryckeri. Dickisson, K. (1997) Telecommuting got your homework done? Benefits of a flexible work option that is gaining
  • 49. currency in the ’90s, and how to get around its potential pitfalls. CMA Magazine, 70,10, 13–14. Doherty, L. and Manfredi, S. (2006) Action research to develop work–life balance in a UK university. Women in Management Review, 21,3, 241–59. Durkheim, E. (1971) The Elementary Forms of Religious Life. London: SCN Press. Esping-Andersen, G. (1991) The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Eurostat Demographic Statistics. (n.d.) Total Fertility Rate 2007. Available online at http://epp.eurostat. ec.europa.eu/tgm/graph.do;jsessionid=9ea7974b30dcf5dc3a9aa1 7b44ac842c818816276241.e34SbxiPb3uSb40L b34LaxqRaxyTe0?tab=graph&plugin=1&language=en&pcode=ts dde220&toolbox=type, last accessed 15 December 2009. Frankenheuser, M. (1993) Kvinnligt, manligt, stressigt. Höganäs: Bra. Böcker. Golden, T. and Veiga, J. (2005) The Impact of extent of telecommuting on job satisfaction: resolving inconsistent findings. Journal of Management, 31,2, 301–18. Hassan, R. (2007) Network time. In: Hassan, R. and Purser, R. (eds) 24/7. Time and Temporality in the Network Society, pp. 37–61. Stanford: Stanford University Press. Heijstra, T.M. and Rafnsdóttir, G.L. (2010) The Internet and academic’s workload and work–family balance. The Internet and Higher Education, 13,3, 158–63. Hochschild, A.R. (1997) The Time Bind. When Work Becomes Home and Home Becomes Work. New York: Henry Holt.
  • 50. Horton, S. (2006) High aspirations: differences in employee satisfaction between university faculty and staff. Applied Research in Quality of Life, 1,3–4, 315–22. Jacobs, A.J. and Winslow, S.E. (2004) Overworked faculty: job stresses and family demands. The Annuals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 596,1, 104– 29. Kurland, N. and Bailey, D. (1999) Telework: the advantages and challenges of working here, there, anywhere, and anytime. Organisational Dynamics, 28,2, 53–68. Kvande, E. (2007) Doing Gender in Flexible Organizations. Bergen: Fagbokforlaget. Lackritz, J. (2004) Exploring burnout among university faculty: incidence, performance, and demographic issues. Teaching and Teacher Education, 20,1, 713–29. Leccardi, C. (1996) Rethinking social time: feminist perspectives. Time & Society, 5,5, 169–86. Marx, K. (1954) Capital. Vol 1. London: Lawrence & Wishart. Pétursdóttir, G.M. (2009) Within the aura of gender equality: Icelandic work cultures, gender relations and family responsibility. PhD dissertation Faculty of Political Science. Reykavík: University of Iceland. Rafnsdóttir, G.L. (1995) Kvinnofack eller integrering som strategi mot underordning. — Om kvinnliga fackföreningar på Island (Women’s Strategies for overcoming subordination. a discussion of women’s unions in Iceland). Lund: Lund University Press. Reeves, R., Gwyther, M. and Saunders, A. (2007) Still juggling after all these years. Management Today, 36–42.
  • 51. Smith, D. (1987) The Everyday World As Problematic: a Feminist Sociology. Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press. Southerton, D. (2003) ‘Squeezing time’: allocating practices, co-ordinating networks and scheduling society. Time & Society, 12,1, 5–25. PROBLEM REPRESENTATIONS OF EQUAL PAY 295 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 Statistics Iceland (2011) Fertility 1853–2010. Available online at http://www.statice.is/Statistics/Population/ Births-and-deaths. Last accessed 17 April 2011. Taylor, F.W. (1964 [1903]) The Principles of Scientific Management. New York: Harper & Row. Watson, T.J. (2003 [1980]) Sociology, Work and Industry (4th edn) London: Routledge. Weigt, J.M. and Solomon, C.R. (2008) Work–family management among low-wage service workers and assistant professors in the USA: a comparative intersectional analysis. Gender, Work & Organization, 15,6, 621–49. World Economic Forum (2009) The Global Gender Gap Report (2009) Geneva: World Economic Forum. World Economic Forum (2010) The Global Gender Gap Report (2010) Geneva: World Economic Forum. 296 GENDER, WORK AND ORGANIZATION
  • 52. Volume 20 Number 3 May 2013 © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd Copyright of Gender, Work & Organization is the property of Wiley-Blackwell and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.