SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
CONTENTS
1. LAW VS CONSTRUCTION CONTRACT
2. HISTORY OF FIDIC
3. STANDARD CONTRACT FORMS
4. PEC-1987 VS FIDIC-1999 & 2017 MAJOR SUITES
5. HIERARCHY OF CONTRACT
6. WHILE MAKING A CONTRACT, ONE SHOULD CONSIDER
7. DISPUTE RESOLUTION
8. ALTERNATE DISPUTE RESOLUTION MECHANISM
9. ARBITRATION VS ADJUDICATION
LAW VS CONSTRUCTION CONTRACT
• COMPLETE
• ACCURATE
• FINAL
• EXECUTABLE (CONSTRUCTABLE)
Still carried on, because;
People are Willing to Work,
They want to Make it Work.
HISTORY OF FIDIC
• FOUNDED IN 1913 (BYBELGIUM,FRANCE&SWITZERLAND)
• 1957 – COC FOR CONSTRUCTION –REDBOOK
• TODAY > 95 ASSOCIATEDMEMBERS
• 1999 – 1ST EDITION OFMAJORSUITOFCONTRACTS
• 2017 – 2ND EDITION OFMAJORSUITOFCONTRACTS
STANDARD CONTRACT FORMS
NOTE: ONLY ONE BOOK WILL BE SELECTED ON THE BASIS OF MAJOR/CORE DISCIPLINE* COMING UNDER THE PROJECT WITH A BLEND OF SOME CLAUSES
FROM OTHER BOOK. *(IF PROJECT INVOLVES MULTIPLE DISCIPLINES)
(LIKEINCASE OFHYDRO-POWER PROJECT CHOOSE REDBOOK + CLAUSE #5 OFYELLOW BOOK)
# SCOPE FRAMEWORK
GREEN BOOK Short Form of Contract Low Risk Factor
WHITE BOOK Consultancy Terms used as Client - Consultant
RED BOOK Construction
(CivilGeneralWorksas Major)
Terms used as Employer- Engineer- Contractor
(EmployerDoesDesign)
PINK BOOK Construction Fundedby Multi Lateral
DevelopmentBank
Basically is; Red Book with Minor Modification as
required by MDB
YELLOW BOOK EPC - Mechanical&ElectricalasMajor EPC Contractor takes the whole Design Responsibility,
evenifEmployerhavetheInitial Design/FEED
SILVER BOOK Turnkey Projects Risk Imbalance as All Responsibility Shifts to Contractor,
(Thereis noEngineerinSilverBook)
GOLDEN BOOK Design, Build & Operate
EMARALD BOOK Underground Works Published in 2019, consideringtheimportanceof HighRisk
involvementwhileworkingUnderground
PEC-1987 VS FIDIC-1999 & 2017 MAJOR SUITES
• PEC IS CURRENTLY USING 1987 - 4TH EDITION RED BOOK & 3RD EDITION YELLOW BOOK
EACHBOOKCONTAINSDIFFERENT NUMBEROFCLAUSES
(DIFFICULT TOMAKEAHYBRID CONTRACT)
• 1999 SUIT IS MORE HARMONISED AS ALL BOOKS CONTAINS 20 CLAUSES
(EASYTOMAKEAHYBRID CONTRACT)
• 2017 IS VERY AUTHORITATIVE & RESTRICTED (SHALLIS USED MOREOFTEN),
LOTSOFMETHODOLOGIESINCLUDED IN GCC
CLAUSE#20 FURTHER SPLITS INTOCLAIMS&DISPUTES
(FORSMOOTHTRANSITION ITWOULDBEBETTERTOFIRST TRY1999 SUIT FORSOMETIMEBEFORESWITCHING TO2017VERSION)
HIERARCHY OF CONTRACT
1. LETTER OF AWARD
2. PCC/GCC
3. SPECIFICATIONS
4. DRAWINGS
NOTE: THISISGENERALHIERARCHY,ONECANINJECTANYTHINGIN-BETWEENOROVER-RIDEIT,
LIKEFINANCE,SCHEDULES,BOQ’SETC.
WHILE MAKING A CONTRACT, ONE SHOULD CONSIDER
• FIDIC
• PEC & FIDIC
• LAW OF THE COUNTRY FIT IN.
(LIKECONTRACTHASSOMEDURATIONFORSPECIFICCLAIM,BUTINSHARIALAW;CLAIMNEVEREXPIRESETC.)
• FIDIC DOESN’T OVER-RIDE THE LAW OF THE COUNTRY.
DISPUTE RESOLUTION
• DISPUTE RESOLUTION (THROUGHNATIONALCOURTS)
• ALTERNATE DISPUTE RESOLUTION(ANYTHINGBUTNATIONALCOURTS)
TO WAYS TO SETTLEIT:
1. DECISIONIMPOSED
2. CONSENSUS
ALTERNATE DISPUTE RESOLUTION MECHANISM
1. DECISIONIMPOSED
• ARBITRATION
• ADJUDICATION
• EXPERT DETERMINATION
2. CONSENSUS
• TALKING
• MEDIATION
• NEGOTIATION
• EXPERT OPINION
ARBITRATION VS ADJUDICATION
• ARBITRATION
• LEGALTYPE; LIKE A COURT, BUT OUTSIDETHECOURT
• PRIVATE& CONFIDENTIAL
• OUTCOME IS FIXED& BINDING
(NATIONAL COURT CAN’T REVIEW THE JUDGMENT, BUTONLY CHECK IF ARBITRATOR FOLLOW THE PROCEDURES OR NOT)
• ADJUDICATION
• MR. ENGINEER REVIEW & GIVERECOMMENDATION
• OUTCOME IS NEITHERFIXED NOR BINDING
Understanding FIDIC.pptx

More Related Content

More from Zeeshan Yousaf

Types of Construction Contracts.pptx
Types of Construction Contracts.pptxTypes of Construction Contracts.pptx
Types of Construction Contracts.pptxZeeshan Yousaf
 
Fire and Safety Engineering.pptx
Fire and Safety Engineering.pptxFire and Safety Engineering.pptx
Fire and Safety Engineering.pptxZeeshan Yousaf
 
Safety protocols of construction site.pptx
Safety protocols of construction site.pptxSafety protocols of construction site.pptx
Safety protocols of construction site.pptxZeeshan Yousaf
 
Pronounciation Skills .pptx
Pronounciation Skills .pptxPronounciation Skills .pptx
Pronounciation Skills .pptxZeeshan Yousaf
 
Comprehension skills.pptx
Comprehension skills.pptxComprehension skills.pptx
Comprehension skills.pptxZeeshan Yousaf
 

More from Zeeshan Yousaf (6)

Types of Construction Contracts.pptx
Types of Construction Contracts.pptxTypes of Construction Contracts.pptx
Types of Construction Contracts.pptx
 
Fire and Safety Engineering.pptx
Fire and Safety Engineering.pptxFire and Safety Engineering.pptx
Fire and Safety Engineering.pptx
 
General hospital.pptx
General hospital.pptxGeneral hospital.pptx
General hospital.pptx
 
Safety protocols of construction site.pptx
Safety protocols of construction site.pptxSafety protocols of construction site.pptx
Safety protocols of construction site.pptx
 
Pronounciation Skills .pptx
Pronounciation Skills .pptxPronounciation Skills .pptx
Pronounciation Skills .pptx
 
Comprehension skills.pptx
Comprehension skills.pptxComprehension skills.pptx
Comprehension skills.pptx
 

Recently uploaded

Filters for Electromagnetic Compatibility Applications
Filters for Electromagnetic Compatibility ApplicationsFilters for Electromagnetic Compatibility Applications
Filters for Electromagnetic Compatibility ApplicationsMathias Magdowski
 
Passive Air Cooling System and Solar Water Heater.ppt
Passive Air Cooling System and Solar Water Heater.pptPassive Air Cooling System and Solar Water Heater.ppt
Passive Air Cooling System and Solar Water Heater.pptamrabdallah9
 
一比一原版(NEU毕业证书)东北大学毕业证成绩单原件一模一样
一比一原版(NEU毕业证书)东北大学毕业证成绩单原件一模一样一比一原版(NEU毕业证书)东北大学毕业证成绩单原件一模一样
一比一原版(NEU毕业证书)东北大学毕业证成绩单原件一模一样A
 
Dynamo Scripts for Task IDs and Space Naming.pptx
Dynamo Scripts for Task IDs and Space Naming.pptxDynamo Scripts for Task IDs and Space Naming.pptx
Dynamo Scripts for Task IDs and Space Naming.pptxMustafa Ahmed
 
Involute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdf
Involute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdfInvolute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdf
Involute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdfJNTUA
 
Seismic Hazard Assessment Software in Python by Prof. Dr. Costas Sachpazis
Seismic Hazard Assessment Software in Python by Prof. Dr. Costas SachpazisSeismic Hazard Assessment Software in Python by Prof. Dr. Costas Sachpazis
Seismic Hazard Assessment Software in Python by Prof. Dr. Costas SachpazisDr.Costas Sachpazis
 
litvinenko_Henry_Intrusion_Hong-Kong_2024.pdf
litvinenko_Henry_Intrusion_Hong-Kong_2024.pdflitvinenko_Henry_Intrusion_Hong-Kong_2024.pdf
litvinenko_Henry_Intrusion_Hong-Kong_2024.pdfAlexander Litvinenko
 
Databricks Generative AI FoundationCertified.pdf
Databricks Generative AI FoundationCertified.pdfDatabricks Generative AI FoundationCertified.pdf
Databricks Generative AI FoundationCertified.pdfVinayVadlagattu
 
Presentation on Slab, Beam, Column, and Foundation/Footing
Presentation on Slab,  Beam, Column, and Foundation/FootingPresentation on Slab,  Beam, Column, and Foundation/Footing
Presentation on Slab, Beam, Column, and Foundation/FootingEr. Suman Jyoti
 
DBMS-Report on Student management system.pptx
DBMS-Report on Student management system.pptxDBMS-Report on Student management system.pptx
DBMS-Report on Student management system.pptxrajjais1221
 
01-vogelsanger-stanag-4178-ed-2-the-new-nato-standard-for-nitrocellulose-test...
01-vogelsanger-stanag-4178-ed-2-the-new-nato-standard-for-nitrocellulose-test...01-vogelsanger-stanag-4178-ed-2-the-new-nato-standard-for-nitrocellulose-test...
01-vogelsanger-stanag-4178-ed-2-the-new-nato-standard-for-nitrocellulose-test...AshwaniAnuragi1
 
Call for Papers - Journal of Electrical Systems (JES), E-ISSN: 1112-5209, ind...
Call for Papers - Journal of Electrical Systems (JES), E-ISSN: 1112-5209, ind...Call for Papers - Journal of Electrical Systems (JES), E-ISSN: 1112-5209, ind...
Call for Papers - Journal of Electrical Systems (JES), E-ISSN: 1112-5209, ind...Christo Ananth
 
Developing a smart system for infant incubators using the internet of things ...
Developing a smart system for infant incubators using the internet of things ...Developing a smart system for infant incubators using the internet of things ...
Developing a smart system for infant incubators using the internet of things ...IJECEIAES
 
Max. shear stress theory-Maximum Shear Stress Theory ​ Maximum Distortional ...
Max. shear stress theory-Maximum Shear Stress Theory ​  Maximum Distortional ...Max. shear stress theory-Maximum Shear Stress Theory ​  Maximum Distortional ...
Max. shear stress theory-Maximum Shear Stress Theory ​ Maximum Distortional ...ronahami
 
History of Indian Railways - the story of Growth & Modernization
History of Indian Railways - the story of Growth & ModernizationHistory of Indian Railways - the story of Growth & Modernization
History of Indian Railways - the story of Growth & ModernizationEmaan Sharma
 
Maximizing Incident Investigation Efficacy in Oil & Gas: Techniques and Tools
Maximizing Incident Investigation Efficacy in Oil & Gas: Techniques and ToolsMaximizing Incident Investigation Efficacy in Oil & Gas: Techniques and Tools
Maximizing Incident Investigation Efficacy in Oil & Gas: Techniques and Toolssoginsider
 
Instruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdf
Instruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdfInstruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdf
Instruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdfEr.Sonali Nasikkar
 
NO1 Best Powerful Vashikaran Specialist Baba Vashikaran Specialist For Love V...
NO1 Best Powerful Vashikaran Specialist Baba Vashikaran Specialist For Love V...NO1 Best Powerful Vashikaran Specialist Baba Vashikaran Specialist For Love V...
NO1 Best Powerful Vashikaran Specialist Baba Vashikaran Specialist For Love V...Amil baba
 
SLIDESHARE PPT-DECISION MAKING METHODS.pptx
SLIDESHARE PPT-DECISION MAKING METHODS.pptxSLIDESHARE PPT-DECISION MAKING METHODS.pptx
SLIDESHARE PPT-DECISION MAKING METHODS.pptxCHAIRMAN M
 
Path loss model, OKUMURA Model, Hata Model
Path loss model, OKUMURA Model, Hata ModelPath loss model, OKUMURA Model, Hata Model
Path loss model, OKUMURA Model, Hata ModelDrAjayKumarYadav4
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Filters for Electromagnetic Compatibility Applications
Filters for Electromagnetic Compatibility ApplicationsFilters for Electromagnetic Compatibility Applications
Filters for Electromagnetic Compatibility Applications
 
Passive Air Cooling System and Solar Water Heater.ppt
Passive Air Cooling System and Solar Water Heater.pptPassive Air Cooling System and Solar Water Heater.ppt
Passive Air Cooling System and Solar Water Heater.ppt
 
一比一原版(NEU毕业证书)东北大学毕业证成绩单原件一模一样
一比一原版(NEU毕业证书)东北大学毕业证成绩单原件一模一样一比一原版(NEU毕业证书)东北大学毕业证成绩单原件一模一样
一比一原版(NEU毕业证书)东北大学毕业证成绩单原件一模一样
 
Dynamo Scripts for Task IDs and Space Naming.pptx
Dynamo Scripts for Task IDs and Space Naming.pptxDynamo Scripts for Task IDs and Space Naming.pptx
Dynamo Scripts for Task IDs and Space Naming.pptx
 
Involute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdf
Involute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdfInvolute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdf
Involute of a circle,Square, pentagon,HexagonInvolute_Engineering Drawing.pdf
 
Seismic Hazard Assessment Software in Python by Prof. Dr. Costas Sachpazis
Seismic Hazard Assessment Software in Python by Prof. Dr. Costas SachpazisSeismic Hazard Assessment Software in Python by Prof. Dr. Costas Sachpazis
Seismic Hazard Assessment Software in Python by Prof. Dr. Costas Sachpazis
 
litvinenko_Henry_Intrusion_Hong-Kong_2024.pdf
litvinenko_Henry_Intrusion_Hong-Kong_2024.pdflitvinenko_Henry_Intrusion_Hong-Kong_2024.pdf
litvinenko_Henry_Intrusion_Hong-Kong_2024.pdf
 
Databricks Generative AI FoundationCertified.pdf
Databricks Generative AI FoundationCertified.pdfDatabricks Generative AI FoundationCertified.pdf
Databricks Generative AI FoundationCertified.pdf
 
Presentation on Slab, Beam, Column, and Foundation/Footing
Presentation on Slab,  Beam, Column, and Foundation/FootingPresentation on Slab,  Beam, Column, and Foundation/Footing
Presentation on Slab, Beam, Column, and Foundation/Footing
 
DBMS-Report on Student management system.pptx
DBMS-Report on Student management system.pptxDBMS-Report on Student management system.pptx
DBMS-Report on Student management system.pptx
 
01-vogelsanger-stanag-4178-ed-2-the-new-nato-standard-for-nitrocellulose-test...
01-vogelsanger-stanag-4178-ed-2-the-new-nato-standard-for-nitrocellulose-test...01-vogelsanger-stanag-4178-ed-2-the-new-nato-standard-for-nitrocellulose-test...
01-vogelsanger-stanag-4178-ed-2-the-new-nato-standard-for-nitrocellulose-test...
 
Call for Papers - Journal of Electrical Systems (JES), E-ISSN: 1112-5209, ind...
Call for Papers - Journal of Electrical Systems (JES), E-ISSN: 1112-5209, ind...Call for Papers - Journal of Electrical Systems (JES), E-ISSN: 1112-5209, ind...
Call for Papers - Journal of Electrical Systems (JES), E-ISSN: 1112-5209, ind...
 
Developing a smart system for infant incubators using the internet of things ...
Developing a smart system for infant incubators using the internet of things ...Developing a smart system for infant incubators using the internet of things ...
Developing a smart system for infant incubators using the internet of things ...
 
Max. shear stress theory-Maximum Shear Stress Theory ​ Maximum Distortional ...
Max. shear stress theory-Maximum Shear Stress Theory ​  Maximum Distortional ...Max. shear stress theory-Maximum Shear Stress Theory ​  Maximum Distortional ...
Max. shear stress theory-Maximum Shear Stress Theory ​ Maximum Distortional ...
 
History of Indian Railways - the story of Growth & Modernization
History of Indian Railways - the story of Growth & ModernizationHistory of Indian Railways - the story of Growth & Modernization
History of Indian Railways - the story of Growth & Modernization
 
Maximizing Incident Investigation Efficacy in Oil & Gas: Techniques and Tools
Maximizing Incident Investigation Efficacy in Oil & Gas: Techniques and ToolsMaximizing Incident Investigation Efficacy in Oil & Gas: Techniques and Tools
Maximizing Incident Investigation Efficacy in Oil & Gas: Techniques and Tools
 
Instruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdf
Instruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdfInstruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdf
Instruct Nirmaana 24-Smart and Lean Construction Through Technology.pdf
 
NO1 Best Powerful Vashikaran Specialist Baba Vashikaran Specialist For Love V...
NO1 Best Powerful Vashikaran Specialist Baba Vashikaran Specialist For Love V...NO1 Best Powerful Vashikaran Specialist Baba Vashikaran Specialist For Love V...
NO1 Best Powerful Vashikaran Specialist Baba Vashikaran Specialist For Love V...
 
SLIDESHARE PPT-DECISION MAKING METHODS.pptx
SLIDESHARE PPT-DECISION MAKING METHODS.pptxSLIDESHARE PPT-DECISION MAKING METHODS.pptx
SLIDESHARE PPT-DECISION MAKING METHODS.pptx
 
Path loss model, OKUMURA Model, Hata Model
Path loss model, OKUMURA Model, Hata ModelPath loss model, OKUMURA Model, Hata Model
Path loss model, OKUMURA Model, Hata Model
 

Understanding FIDIC.pptx

  • 1.
  • 2. CONTENTS 1. LAW VS CONSTRUCTION CONTRACT 2. HISTORY OF FIDIC 3. STANDARD CONTRACT FORMS 4. PEC-1987 VS FIDIC-1999 & 2017 MAJOR SUITES 5. HIERARCHY OF CONTRACT 6. WHILE MAKING A CONTRACT, ONE SHOULD CONSIDER 7. DISPUTE RESOLUTION 8. ALTERNATE DISPUTE RESOLUTION MECHANISM 9. ARBITRATION VS ADJUDICATION
  • 3. LAW VS CONSTRUCTION CONTRACT • COMPLETE • ACCURATE • FINAL • EXECUTABLE (CONSTRUCTABLE) Still carried on, because; People are Willing to Work, They want to Make it Work.
  • 4. HISTORY OF FIDIC • FOUNDED IN 1913 (BYBELGIUM,FRANCE&SWITZERLAND) • 1957 – COC FOR CONSTRUCTION –REDBOOK • TODAY > 95 ASSOCIATEDMEMBERS • 1999 – 1ST EDITION OFMAJORSUITOFCONTRACTS • 2017 – 2ND EDITION OFMAJORSUITOFCONTRACTS
  • 5. STANDARD CONTRACT FORMS NOTE: ONLY ONE BOOK WILL BE SELECTED ON THE BASIS OF MAJOR/CORE DISCIPLINE* COMING UNDER THE PROJECT WITH A BLEND OF SOME CLAUSES FROM OTHER BOOK. *(IF PROJECT INVOLVES MULTIPLE DISCIPLINES) (LIKEINCASE OFHYDRO-POWER PROJECT CHOOSE REDBOOK + CLAUSE #5 OFYELLOW BOOK) # SCOPE FRAMEWORK GREEN BOOK Short Form of Contract Low Risk Factor WHITE BOOK Consultancy Terms used as Client - Consultant RED BOOK Construction (CivilGeneralWorksas Major) Terms used as Employer- Engineer- Contractor (EmployerDoesDesign) PINK BOOK Construction Fundedby Multi Lateral DevelopmentBank Basically is; Red Book with Minor Modification as required by MDB YELLOW BOOK EPC - Mechanical&ElectricalasMajor EPC Contractor takes the whole Design Responsibility, evenifEmployerhavetheInitial Design/FEED SILVER BOOK Turnkey Projects Risk Imbalance as All Responsibility Shifts to Contractor, (Thereis noEngineerinSilverBook) GOLDEN BOOK Design, Build & Operate EMARALD BOOK Underground Works Published in 2019, consideringtheimportanceof HighRisk involvementwhileworkingUnderground
  • 6. PEC-1987 VS FIDIC-1999 & 2017 MAJOR SUITES • PEC IS CURRENTLY USING 1987 - 4TH EDITION RED BOOK & 3RD EDITION YELLOW BOOK EACHBOOKCONTAINSDIFFERENT NUMBEROFCLAUSES (DIFFICULT TOMAKEAHYBRID CONTRACT) • 1999 SUIT IS MORE HARMONISED AS ALL BOOKS CONTAINS 20 CLAUSES (EASYTOMAKEAHYBRID CONTRACT) • 2017 IS VERY AUTHORITATIVE & RESTRICTED (SHALLIS USED MOREOFTEN), LOTSOFMETHODOLOGIESINCLUDED IN GCC CLAUSE#20 FURTHER SPLITS INTOCLAIMS&DISPUTES (FORSMOOTHTRANSITION ITWOULDBEBETTERTOFIRST TRY1999 SUIT FORSOMETIMEBEFORESWITCHING TO2017VERSION)
  • 7. HIERARCHY OF CONTRACT 1. LETTER OF AWARD 2. PCC/GCC 3. SPECIFICATIONS 4. DRAWINGS NOTE: THISISGENERALHIERARCHY,ONECANINJECTANYTHINGIN-BETWEENOROVER-RIDEIT, LIKEFINANCE,SCHEDULES,BOQ’SETC.
  • 8. WHILE MAKING A CONTRACT, ONE SHOULD CONSIDER • FIDIC • PEC & FIDIC • LAW OF THE COUNTRY FIT IN. (LIKECONTRACTHASSOMEDURATIONFORSPECIFICCLAIM,BUTINSHARIALAW;CLAIMNEVEREXPIRESETC.) • FIDIC DOESN’T OVER-RIDE THE LAW OF THE COUNTRY.
  • 9. DISPUTE RESOLUTION • DISPUTE RESOLUTION (THROUGHNATIONALCOURTS) • ALTERNATE DISPUTE RESOLUTION(ANYTHINGBUTNATIONALCOURTS) TO WAYS TO SETTLEIT: 1. DECISIONIMPOSED 2. CONSENSUS
  • 10. ALTERNATE DISPUTE RESOLUTION MECHANISM 1. DECISIONIMPOSED • ARBITRATION • ADJUDICATION • EXPERT DETERMINATION 2. CONSENSUS • TALKING • MEDIATION • NEGOTIATION • EXPERT OPINION
  • 11. ARBITRATION VS ADJUDICATION • ARBITRATION • LEGALTYPE; LIKE A COURT, BUT OUTSIDETHECOURT • PRIVATE& CONFIDENTIAL • OUTCOME IS FIXED& BINDING (NATIONAL COURT CAN’T REVIEW THE JUDGMENT, BUTONLY CHECK IF ARBITRATOR FOLLOW THE PROCEDURES OR NOT) • ADJUDICATION • MR. ENGINEER REVIEW & GIVERECOMMENDATION • OUTCOME IS NEITHERFIXED NOR BINDING