Presentation from Professor Jo Boyden (Young Lives Director) and Dr Renu Singh (Young Lives India Country Director) at the International Association for Adolescent Health's 11th World Congress in New Delhi, 26th October 2017
Vision and reflection on Mining Software Repositories research in 2024
Social determinants of wellbeing in early adolescence
1. Social determinants of wellbeing in early
adolescence
Young Lives in India
Professor Jo Boyden, University of Oxford
Dr Renu Singh, Young Lives India
@yloxford
@YoungLivesIndia
7. 3. Educational aspirations reflect whole family’s
hopes for poverty-free future
‘Children must not be forced to do
hard work from childhood itself. If
they only study, it’s nice and their
lives will be good.’ Harika (12 years)
a rural girl.
‘If he studies and learns to read, when
he grows up he need not work hard in
the hot sun.’ Mother of Yaswanth (12
years) an OC boy from remote tribal
area.
Yaswanth ‘I just want to lead a simple
life and care of my mother and my self.’
8. 4. Rising school enrolment offers a platform for
engaging adolescents
Source Briones (2017)
9. 5. Most young adolescents are not fulfilling their
potential
11. 7. Poverty, risk and responsibility in early
adolescence shape later trajectories
Predictors of secondary school completion:
•No paid work at 12 years
•Fewer hours of domestic chores (girls)
•Better reading scores at age 8
•Higher self-efficacy at age 12
Predictors of early marriage & adolescent
fertility
•Not enrolled at 15 years
•Lower parental & child aspirations for education
•Parental expectation that daughter would marry before 19
years
•Lower wealth & caregiver aspiration
•Earlier age at menarche
•Having an older brother
Shocks intensify pressures but unevenly.
Adult illness and dowry expenses have long term
consequences for children in the household.
12. 8. Violence is pervasive in the lives of many
children and adolescents
‘If we are not naughty and
listen to what the sirs are
saying… then they don’t beat
us. Some children keep staring
outside the windows then they
beat us’
Now no one stays back
after school Big boys used
to come and sit there, at
the school... Because other
boys come to the school, so
[the girls] don’t come now.
(15 year old girl)
‘My father goes for work and
comes back drunk and beats my
mother. If I go in the middle he
will beat me!.. I want to take my
mother and leave this village…
When I grow up I would like to be
good .. I will love my wife and
not drink liquor or smoke beedi.’
(13 year old boy)
‘I do not like my school, since
the teachers beat me badly.
They beat with a stick on my
back, even if we are sitting
and talking…..’
(Government School student)
13. 9. Poverty and discriminatory gender norms are
mutually reinforcing
Bhavana’s mother did not complete primary school and married at 12.
Bhavana left school after Grade 2 following the death of her father and
the family migrating for seasonal work to Mumbai.
Her mother believed : “It makes no difference whether educated or not educated …
even if she were to be educated, still it not possible to get a job; she might still have
to work; there are no jobs around. Then what’s the point in getting schooled? …I
haven’t seen a single person from this village getting a job and feeding others.’
Interviewer: Do you find any difference in the work done and the life
between you and your mother?
Bhavana: I saw my mother since my childhood … she has been doing hard work
without taking a break even for a day… It is same [for me ... I am also working in the
same way.
Jo: why understanding adolescent well-being (and health) in context of wider lives and over the life courseis important
Why AP and Telangana are relevant for understanding gender and poverty in India?
Use Dercon and Serneels to explore gendered aspirations and outcomes.
Use Dercon and Serneels to explore gendered aspirations and outcomes.
Gender analysis of school enrolment shows that at age 12, the male-female gap for Younger Cohort is almost negligible (0.4 percentage points), and considerably lower than that for the Older Cohort at the same age in 2006, when there was gender gap of 3.3 percentage points.
: boys began to do better in maths and receptive vocabulary tests by age 12. Gaps increase until the age of 15, and then persist. (older cohort).
Stratification of better-off children and boys into private low-fee charging schools is a significant and growing equity issue
Equity
India is the only Young Lives country with systematic bias against girls in learning and enrolment outcomes. Gender disparities grow during early adolescence grow until 15, then persist.
Quality
One in four 12 year-olds in UAP failed to reach the low achievement benchmark for fourth-grade children (aged about 10 years) in maths proficiency.
Decline in maths scores at age 12 between 2006 and 2013.
increase in the percentage of 12 year-olds who were overage at school. Nearly half of 12 year olds overage in 2013: boys, children from poor and SC households, and children whose mothers had less education more likely to be overage.
Note that in other countries – overall girl-boy workload is similar, though they take different roles from adolescence. India is the only country where girls work more overall during early-mid adolescence.
: eg. UAP drought 2002/3: eldest sons in irrigation-farming households reduced work and increase school, the work of girls (both eldest and younger daughters) increased.
Findings reveal that girls from top-wealth tercile households have an 80% predicted probability of completion, in comparison to the 64% predicted probability for girls from bottom-wealth tercile households.
More than 9 in 10 eight-year olds in UAP witnessed a teacher administering corporal punishment in past week.
15 year olds reporting bullying: 22% (physical bullying); 27% (verbal bullying); 28% (indirect bullying); 27% (attacks on property).
Safety on the journey to school for girls –
Earlier we used to be in school [doing homework] but now no one stays back after school... we all decided now in 10th class we return home fast. […] Big boys used to come and sit there, at the school... Because other boys come to the school, so they [the girls] don’t come now. (Harika, UAP)
Experience of violence gendered and changes with age.
18% of 15 year old girls reported avoiding going to school during menstruation. Amongst those who attended school irregularly, 28% cited lack of disposal facilities while 19% cited lack of soap and water as reasons for missing school.