SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 19
Download to read offline
1
Rick Jones
RECOGNITION MATTERS
This is a strategic employee-recognition program
Planned and written for TriOcean Engineering ASRC Energy Services
It accompanies the newsletter “Recognition Matters”
Tri Ocean’s employees were thanked and recognized for their efforts
after the company reduced its work force
I submitted this work sample to pass IABC’s* accreditation program
*IABC is the International Association of Business Communicators
Copyright 2015 by Susan Lee Blanchard
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Description of the Organization (Tri Ocean Engineering) ........................ 3
2. Susan Blanchard’s Role.............................................................................. 3
3. Problem to be Solved ................................................................................. 3
4. Recognition Programs ............................................................................... 4
5. Employee Performance Goals and Objectives ......................................... 5
6. Target Groups of Employees...................................................................... 5
7. Developing the Strategic Plan .................................................................... 6
Research ...................................................................................................... 6
Planning ....................................................................................................... 7
Communication Vehicles ............................................................................ 9
Timeline ...................................................................................................... 10
Budget ....................................................................................................... 11
Selling the Plan to Management .............................................................. 11
8. Implementing the Plan .............................................................................. 12
Key Messages to Target Groups .............................................................. 12
Workshop to Train Managers ................................................................... 13
Newsletter titled “Recognition Matters” .................................................. 14
Presentation of Research Results ........................................................... 14
“Recognition Matters” Information Booklet for Managers .................... 14
9. Evaluating the Plan’s Effectiveness (measuring the results) ............... 15
Objective 1 for Managers was Surpassed ............................................... 15
Objective 2 for Managers was Met ........................................................... 15
Highlights of the Survey Results.............................................................. 16
Objective 3 for Employees was Surpassed ............................................. 16
Lessons Learned ....................................................................................... 18
3
INTRODUCTION
While working for TriOcean of ASRC Energy Services, I strategically planned a recognition
program that successfully lifted the spirits of employees when a recession hit and TriOcean reduced its
workforce by thousands of employees. What kind of program would motivate the down-in-the-dumps
employees who remained on the job after their colleagues had been laid off?
A recognition program for managers, team leaders and their deserving employees with the side
benefit of refreshing managers’ leadership knowledge.
Recognition from team leaders is the best recognition there is.
Studies show that employees want to be appreciated by their team leaders more than they want
cash bonuses.
Companies are starting to learn this lesson, since Walt Disney and Hallmark have used formal
and informal recognition as a reward to motivate employees through programs similar to mine.
Some of the most memorable, meaningful, words employees hear are genuine compliments and
positive encouragement. These can go a long way to inspiring the best performance. The trick is to give
honest praise when deserved.
Honest words of thanks and encouragement motivated the TriOcean employees who remained on
the job after management reduced its workforce during the 2006 recession.
1. DESCRIPTION OF THE ORGANIZATION (TRI OCEAN)
Tri Ocean Engineering had designed projects for oil and gas clients in the upstream, midstream,
and downstream sectors of the world petroleum industry for three decades. Its commitment to succeed,
and its history of domestic and international design work were impressive—until the global economic
recession of 2006.
That year, the price of a barrel of oil soared to over $70 and then fell back from that level in
subsequent months. Tri Ocean’s profits reached a record low.
While there were bound to be frequent fluctuations in the oil price caused by shifts in demand and
political crises in the Middle East, most experts predicted the trend line would be toward still higher oil
prices. However, in September 2006 oil prices fell to $60 a barrel.
At the time, Tri Ocean lost work from its largest client—Shell Canada. Later, Imperial Oil reeled
back its engineering projects and Tri Ocean reduced its workforce for the first time. By 2010, Tri Ocean
had leveled its workforce three times. Seven hundred employees lost their jobs.
4
2. SUSAN BLANCHARD’S ROLE
Before the layoffs, Blanchard worked as a Technical Writer-Lead who oversaw marketing projects
and two technical writers and a designer.
Because she had many years of expertise in employee communications, she recommended an
innovative way of boosting employee morale through the following communications:
 Personal (face-to-face) recognition. The manager personally thanks or congratulates an
employee for doing a good job when deserved.
 Written recognition. The manager writes a personal note about good performance, gives the
employee a thank-you card, or recommends that the Communications unit recognize the employee in a
news story, a personality profile, in Tri Ocean’s new recognition newsletter.
 Electronic recognition. The manager thanks the employee via email, text-message, voice-mail,
pager, or other electronic communications.
 Public recognition. The manager commends the employee in a recognition ceremony, an annual
event called Awards Night, or in a staff or town-hall meeting, depending on the type of recognition the
employee prefers.
 Positive gossip. The manager says positive things about an employee to his or her co-workers
with the underlying presumption that this indirect praise will get back to the employee.
3. PROBLEM TO BE SOLVED
After the layoffs, Tri Ocean’s remaining 323 employees wore gloomy expressions and seemed
crestfallen about the loss of their fellow workers. Blanchard’s employee workplace survey showed that
managers and employees alike were worried about further job loss and gloomy about the company’s
prospects.
Then in one town-hall meeting Tri Ocean’s Chief Executive Officer (CEO) overheard a group of
engineers say, “We never get a word of thanks.” And in staff meetings, employees lacked their usual
enthusiasm about tackling new projects.
To deal with the underlying gloom that pervaded the culture, Blanchard was tasked to research,
plan, implement, and evaluate a new morale-boosting program for the employees and managers of Tri
Ocean Engineering.
5
In the past, Tri Ocean’s only way of recognizing employees had been through years-of-service
awards, pay increases, and flextime. Blanchard wanted to build on these incentives to show employees
that Tri Ocean managers really cared about employees’ efforts.
Blanchard began by surveying employees to:
 Determine how to support Tri Ocean’s new performance objectives to motivate and
recognize employees
 Find out how employees like to be recognized for doing good work
4. RECOGNITION PROGRAMS
Recognition and rewards fall into two categories: “formal” and “informal.” Formal rewards tend
to be planned, structured programs that continue for years, such as years-of-service awards and cash
bonuses. Informal rewards are just-in-time forms of appreciation for good work and specific behaviors.
Informal rewards acknowledge valuable suggestions, project milestones, a closed business deal, or
successes ranging from a finished project to graduation from a degree program.
5. EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE GOALS & OBJECTIVES
After losing hundreds of employees, Tri Ocean’s management team looked over Blanchard’s
communications plan and made it a priority to recognize and try to motivate existing workers.
To support this new direction, Blanchard set three objectives with specific metrics:
1. Eighty percent of managers will understand their role in increasing employee recognition
over the next three months (September to December 2006).
2. Sixty percent of managers will enact some form of recognition for employees by the end of
February 2007.
3. Increase from 20 to 40 percent the number of employees who state on the employee
appreciation questionnaire that they feel more appreciated by their managers (in December
2007).
6
6. TARGET GROUPS
Managers charged with managing and coaching employees. As team leaders managers were
in the categories of “Seasoned Recruits” and “Senior Recruits.” Seasoned Recruits (managers) were the
15 percent of employees who had been with Tri Ocean for six to 10 years. They worked in senior-level
roles and had greater autonomy and decision-making authority than other employees.
Senior Recruits were the remaining 10 percent of employees who had been with Tri Ocean for
more than 10 years. When Blanchard conducted her study for this project, most of these individuals
were near retirement and worked in senior-level or managerial roles.
Regular employees: Regular employees were called “New Recruits” and “Experienced
Recruits.”
New Recruits were the 55 percent of employees who had been employed for less than two years.
Typically, New Recruits were recent college or university graduates whose average age was 23 to 31
years. They had little work experience and entered Tri Ocean’s training programs for entry-level
workers.
New Recruits included experienced employees from other companies and English-speaking
university graduates from other countries. Studies showed that New Recruits, the younger employees,
appreciated recognition more than Experienced Recruits.
Experienced Recruits (the slightly older employees) made up 20 percent of all employees
employed for three to five years. Some of these individuals entered Tri Ocean’s training program at the
start of their TriOcean careers. They typically managed projects with great autonomy.
Demographics:
 In 2006, more than 75 percent of Tri Ocean’s employees worked in cross-functional teams
organized around client projects.
 Males comprised 68 percent of Tri Ocean’s workforce.
 Average age: 31
 Education levels: 7% have a master’s degree, 38% have bachelor’s degree, 22% have a
college diploma, and 22% have little or no formal education.
 Ethnicity and nationality: 46% were born outside Canada
 Average years manager has worked in current position: 6 years
7
To ensure the appreciation program took hold, Tri Ocean’s CEO asked all managers to attend a
one-day recognition workshop outlining Blanchard’s new program. He shared the news that Blanchard
would wrap up her employee workplace survey and host a workshop on the topic of recognition on three
occasions during work hours, so all managers could attend.
The CEO championed the project by sending every manager an email invitation, asking him or her
to join him at the workshop.
7. DEVELOPING THE STRATEGIC PLAN
Research
Shortly after Blanchard was hired, her immediate task was to conduct upfront research—to assess
through in-depth interviews and questionnaires how managers typically recognize their employees. In
the interviews, she wanted to know how managers would feel about recognizing their workers through a
new recognition program. Her second task was to survey employees to learn about Tri Ocean’s existing
recognition practices—she wanted to know which types of personal recognition employees most prefer.
Employee Research
According to the questionnaire results, employees said that Tri Ocean Engineering workers
preferred personalized, instant appreciation from their direct managers more than any other kind of
recognition. As many as 92 percent of employees reported that it was somewhat (31%), very (27%), or
extremely important (34%) for their managers to recognize them when they do good work. The
questionnaire asked employees to rate the way in which they want to be recognized:
 Personal (face-to-face) recognition. The manager personally thanks or congratulates an
employee for doing a good job.
 Written recognition. The manager writes a personal note about good performance, gives the
employee a thank-you card, or commends the employee in a news story for Tri Ocean’s recognition
newsletter.
 Electronic recognition. The manager thanks the employee via email, text-message, voice-mail,
pager, or other form of electronic communications.
 Public recognition. The manager commends an employee in a recognition ceremony, staff
meeting, or town-hall meeting.
8
 Positive gossip. The manager says positive things about an employee. For example, he or she
might say something nice about an employee to his or her co-workers with the underlying presumption
that this indirect praise will get back to the employee.
Employees also indicated how they wanted the recognition. In Blanchard’s questionnaire, they
indicated it was “extremely important,” “very important,” and “somewhat important” that:
 My manager involves me when making decisions
 My manager asks for my opinions or ideas
 My manager lets me know when I am doing a good job
 Personally thanks me for doing good work
Management Research
Blanchard learned there was a large discrepancy between the amount of recognition that managers
reported giving employees compared to the amount of recognition employees reported receiving. For
example, Blanchard asked managers to rank on a scale of 1 to 5 (1 = never, 5 = always) the following
statement: “I let my employees know when they’re doing a good job.” Managers said they “always”
recognized employees. However, many employees indicated that managers “never” recognize them.
Planning
Blanchard’s work involved:
1. Writing, conducting, tabulating, and analyzing the research
2. Writing research reports about the findings
3. Planning and outlining the new employee-recognition program for Tri Ocean’s managers, and
“selling” her ideas to Human Resources for the program
4. Writing an information booklet describing the ways to recognize employees
5. Implementing a workshop for managers to introduce them to Tri Ocean’s new employee
recognition practices
6. Developing and issuing a quarterly newsletter titled “Recognition Matters” to inform
managers and employees about Tri Ocean’s recognition practices
7. Evaluating the recognition program through employee surveys and through meetings with
managers to assess the effectiveness and practical application of the program
9
To get managers’ buy-in, Blanchard asked them to participate in the workshop and become directly
involved in hosting it. After the workshop, she asked managers to inform employees of the good work
and behaviors they can exhibit to earn recognition.
Three Recognition Levels
The levels of recognition were as follows: Level 1 rewards were informal forms of recognition
such as saying thank-you and sharing positive gossip. For every three informal rewards there was a more
official recognition or a Level 2 reward.
Level 2 rewards included tangible gifts such as movie or hockey tickets (up to a value of $100).
Level 3 rewards included an article in the employee newsletter, public praise at a company meeting,
and a monetary reward of $200.
All managers were asked to forgive and support employees when they make minor mistakes, and
to involve employees in decision-making and idea generation. Because of the importance of
communicating these forms of recognition, Blanchard suggested that the verbal or email recognition be
delivered before offering money or movie tickets.
10
Communication Vehicles or Tools
Communication Vehicles Target Audience Purpose Frequency
Indepth interviews and
research report presented to managers.
Managers Learn about their recognition
practices. Determine their
readiness and willingness for
a recognition program.
Did this once before the
program was planned
Surveys (questionnaires) Managers and employees
(different surveys for each
group)
Learn about managers’
recognition practices and
about employees’ recognition
needs.
Once before the program was
planned and again at the
end of the program.
PowerPoint presentation to present
research findings to each group
separately.
Managers Outline results from
in-depth interviews and
surveys.
Presented after summing up
the research results.
Workshop Managers Educate managers about
the power of appreciation and
how the new program worked.
Offer one workshop three
times to educate all
managers on Tri Ocean’s
new recognition program.
The workshop would become
an annual event.
Recognition information booklet Managers Provide guidelines on how to
recognize employees.
Offered with the workshop
and emailed to managers.
Newsletter (Recognition Matters) Regular employees
and managers
- Introduce recognition
program.
- Recognize employees by
profiling their success in
news stories.
- Communicate TriOcean’s
recognition practices and
guidelines.
Issued four times a year with
Tri Ocean’s regular employee
newsletter.
Survey managers and employees
separately.
Managers and employees See how the new recognition
program is working.
See if it meets its objectives.
Once
11
Timeline
Date Tool Audience Purpose
Last two weeks, August Analyze the problem. Human Resources To determine my role and begin my work.
September
Research. Conducted
in-depth interviews
and surveys
(questionnaires).
Write research reports.
Managers Determine if managers are ready and willing to
implement a recognition program.
Find out if they feel it’s their job to recognize
employees. Learn about their existing
recognition and communication efforts.
Survey (questionnaire). Employees Determine if employees feel supported and
recognized. Learn of their desired forms of
recognition, both formal and informal.
October Present research
findings in meetings
to the two audiences.
One presentation to
managers
One presentation to
employees
Present research results.
Newsletter for
employees and
managers.
Primary: employees
Secondary: managers
Roll-out new program. Educate regular
employees about the power of appreciation
and then recognize them.
November Recruit a group of
managers to help
facilitate workshop.
Eight managers
helped with the work-
shop.
Elicit their recommendations, buy-in, and
assistance.
Host workshop in
November and again
in December.
Managers Host workshop to reach first objective.
December Host workshop a final
time for those who
missed the earlier two
workshops.
Managers Educate managers on how to recognize
employees.
Write another issue of
recognition newsletter.
Primary target:
employees.
Educate employees about the appreciation
program.
Two months later Return to Tri Ocean to
speak with and survey
managers.
Group meeting with
Managers
To see how program is working for them.
Learn if they are practicing appreciation
techniques and answer their questions
about the program.
A year later Return to Tri Ocean to
survey employees to
determine if 40%
feel more recognized.
Employees and
managers
Recommend improvements to recognition
program to meet the needs of all
audiences better. Brief face-to-face
meeting with HR.
12
Budget
Human Resources indicated there would be a small budget for creative collateral. As a result, Tri
Ocean incurred only a printing and design fee for the two newsletters that Blanchard wrote and designed.
A cost of $115 was budgeted to provide a catered lunch on the days of the workshops.
BUDGET FOR A PRINTED NEWSLETTER
Amount budgeted: $6,500 Planned Costs
Printing and Design
Actual
Costs
Amount
over/
under budget
Recognition Matters (Winter 2006) $300 $300 0
Recognition Matters (Spring 2006) $300 $300 0
Workshops (catered lunch) $400 $300 $448
TOTALS $1000
budget
$900
Costs
$50 under budget
Selling the Plan to Management
To sell her plan to management, Blanchard explained the program’s implementation strategy. She
built a groundswell of support for the program by indicating how recognition programs have been
effective in other organizations and explaining the results of her research suggesting that employees
want feedback from their managers.
Blanchard’s indepth interview guide for manager answered the following questions
1. How does Tri Ocean retain key employees?
2. What behaviors do you want the employees to adopt?
In her face-to-face presentation to the Human Resources manager, Blanchard explained the
timeline and communication plan for the program step-by-step. She wanted to ensure that the manager
had the opportunity to hear how the program would work, especially the how and when to recognize an
employee.
After the presentation, Blanchard was eager for feedback of any kind. She invited the managers to
ask questions, play Devil’s advocate, and suggest innovative ways of implementing the program.
13
8. IMPLEMENTING THE PLAN
Blanchard was at the helm of the work, steering it according to plan. Fortunately, she was able to
navigate with HR’s trust.
Because she was adept at conducting research, planning, and writing, Blanchard avoided the high
costs of hiring a market research firm. Of the few challenges she faced, the one most disconcerting was
the problem of researching and rolling out the program in four months.
After the employees and managers presented the recognition program in workshops, Blanchard
encouraged managers to recognize employees face-to-face. Some of the managers felt uncomfortable
giving compliments. However, Blanchard did not expect the glitch she encountered with one reluctant
manager during the workshop.
The manager in question, “Hillard,” found it easier to give criticism than compliments. He had let
trouble in his department percolate for too long. At work, he saw his employees as a collection of
problems rather than as a group of young engineers who were learning and maneuvering learning curves.
Hillard had quietly voiced his fears about the recognition program to Blanchard during the
workshop, and Blanchard had promised to meet with him a day later. Before the meeting, Blanchard
gathered evidence that clearly showed the effectiveness of recognition and rewards, and of managers
delivering them face-to-face to employees. Hilliard looked at Blanchard’s evidence, he admitted that he
felt uncomfortable complimenting employees, noting that this behavior felt “strange.”
However, by hearing Blanchard’s words on how to support employees verbally, by scripting his
own words, and by role-playing with Blanchard, Bill eventually developed a communication skill that
would increase his ability to support and recognize his employees.
Key messages
Blanchard communicated these key messages in the recognition workshop:
Key messages for managers:
 “Recognition matters.” This message became the title of Tri Ocean’s recognition program and
any communication collateral associated with it
 “At Tri Ocean, we stick up for our employees.” This message was needed to show the extent
of management’s support for employees.
 “You get the best effort from others by building a fire within them.”
14
Key messages for employees:
 “Recognition matters”
 “Hard work, good ideas, and results are rewarded”
 “At Tri Ocean, we stick up for our employees”
Workshop to Train Managers
The full-day workshop was the primary tool for communicating the key messages and the
recognition program to managers. Blanchard offered a one-day workshop on three separate occasions so
that she could include every manager, and she achieved that goal, thanks to Tri Ocean’s CEO who urged
the company’s managers to attend. The workshop included the following elements:
1. An introduction by the CEO who shared his excitement about the appreciation program and
briefly identified Tri Ocean Engineering’s performance goals for employees
2. Words of thanks to the managers in attendance
3. Next, the CEO and a few managers presented the 18 ways that managers can recognize
employees most effectively
4. The Human Resources manager demonstrated ways to recognize employees face-to-face, in
writing, electronically, publicly, and through positive gossip. She role-played with Blanchard as
she demonstrated how to compliment employees for good behavior or work
5. A group exercise in which managers shared their own techniques for recognizing and supervising
employees effectively
6. A brief explanation of the types of recognition Tri Ocean employees said they prefer in the
survey
7. A group discussion on which behaviors, ideas, and actions deserve recognition
8. The Human Resources manager presented the three recognition levels and the rules for issuing
the formal and informal recognition
9. Next, managers paired up and recognized one another to demonstrate how to recognize someone
verbally.
10. A workshop evaluation that called for feedback on both the workshop and the recognition
program.
After the workshop, Blanchard surveyed and then met with the managers in a group to talk about
how the recognition program was working for them.
15
Newsletter titled Recognition Matters
The newsletter was a tool that focused on Tri Ocean’s new recognition practices in the following
ways:
1. Articles featuring employees who have been recognized for significant achievements
2. Stories about Tri Ocean’s recognition program and how it works
3. Key messages
4. Case studies of written, face-to-face, electronic, and public forms of communication
5. Events for recognizing employees—awards ceremonies and company anniversary celebrations
6. Ideas for other reward programs—such as the “Reward Your Client program”
7. Requests for employees to nominate colleagues for recognition
Presentation of Research Results
Blanchard developed a research report to explain the results of the her indepth interviewing, a
qualitative form of research. She presented the report in a PowerPoint presentation to the managers, and
she presented the results of the employee survey in a PowerPoint presentation to employees.
“Recognition Matters” Booklet
Blanchard disseminated the information booklet at the workshop and later emailed an electronic
copy to each manager. It describes all of Tri Ocean’s recognition practices and outlines the actions
managers need to take to recognize employees. For example, the booklet urges managers to recognize
employees who reach strategic goals, deliver exceptional customer service, work hard, and show a
positive attitude.
16
9. EVALUATING THE PLAN’S EFFECTIVENESS
Objective 1 for Managers was Surpassed
Blanchard’s first objective was to help 80 percent of managers understand their role in increasing
employee recognition at Tri Ocean. This objective was surpassed. All 26 managers attended the one-
day workshop offered on three occasions, and this meant that 100 percent of managers had learned their
role in recognizing employees.
Up to 17 managers attended the first workshop (offered November 16, 2006) and gave positive
workshop evaluations. The most common responses on the workshop evaluation form were “good,”
“very good,” or “excellent,” when managers rated their knowledge of Tri Ocean’s recognition program.
The workshop alone helped managers understand how to recognize employees, but the information
booklet, indepth interviews, and survey results added to their depth of knowledge.
A side benefit: over time Managers got better at supporting and thanking their employees.
Objective 2 for Managers was Met
Tri Ocean surpassed the objective of getting 60 percent of the 26 managers to enact some form of
recognition for employees by the end of February.
As indicated in the summary of survey highlights below, 69 percent of managers indicated they
frequently praise employees face-to-face. Another 73 percent of managers indicated they spend more
time with their employees. Overall, 69 percent of the managers surveyed indicated they had enacted
some form of recognition for employees. Blanchard’s objective of getting 60 percent of the managers to
recognize their employees was surpassed by nine percent.
Highlights of Survey Results
Recognition activity
Managers noted the frequency of
each activity below, and the
importance they attached to it when
recognizing their employees
Frequency ranges from:
1) always
2) frequently
3) occasionally
4) seldom
5) never
Importance ranges from:
1) extremely important
2) very important
3) somewhat important
4) not very important
5) unimportant
Recognition Most common response Most common response
Please read across
17
Employee is given verbal thanks or praise Frequently (69%) Extremely important (77%)
Employee is praised via email Frequently (62%) Very important (73%)
Employee is given $25 and informal
recognition (thanks and positive feedback)
Occasionally (58%) Somewhat important (65%)
Employee is given a choice of assignments Occasionally (46%) Extremely important (46%)
Employee is given increased job autonomy Occasionally (42%) Extremely important (65%)
Employee is given more authority Occasionally (56%) Somewhat important (62%)
Manager spends more time with employee Frequently (73%) Somewhat important (65%)
The workshop to educate managers about the program had to be relaunched every three years, so
that new hires would learn about the three recognition reward levels and continue to support their
employees, even when the employees were busy and faced tight deadlines.
Managers were accountable for making the recognition program a success, and they learned not to
wait until performance appraisal to appraise an employee’s performance.
Objective 3 for Regular Employees was Surpassed
The goal for employees was to increase from 20 to 40 percent the number of employees who state
on the employee questionnaire that they feel appreciated by their managers. Blanchard’s research
findings confirmed that more than 49 percent, not just 40 percent, of the employees felt recognized for a
job well done. While monetary compensation was important to Tri Ocean employees, the activities that
really motivated them to perform are listed in the highlights below.
18
Lessons Learned
If Blanchard were to implement the program again, she would:
Highlights of Survey Results
Recognition activity
Employees noted the frequency and
Important of each form of
recognition
Frequency ranges from:
1. always
2. frequently
3. occasionally
4. seldom
5. never
Importance ranges from:
1. extremely important
2. very important
3. somewhat important
4. not very important
5. unimportant
Recognition Most common response Most common response
My manager gives me the information
that I need to do my job.
Frequently (67%) Extremely important (39%)
My manager involves me when making
decisions.
Sometimes (55%) Very important (77%)
My manager asks me for my opinion or
ideas.
Occasionally (49%) Extremely important (78%)
My manager lets me know when I’m
doing a good job.
Occasionally (73%) Very important (66%)
My manager personally thanks me for
doing good work.
Occasionally (51%) Somewhat important (72%)
My manager recognizes me verbally. Occasionally (52%) Somewhat important (69%)
My manager gives me a choice of
assignments.
Occasionally (43%) Somewhat important (49%)
My manager spends time with me. Occasionally (58%) Somewhat important (62%%)
My manager lets me leave work when
essential.
Occasionally (73%) Extremely important (72%)
19
 Host the workshop in two off-site, half-day sessions rather than in one full-day presentation. The
post-event evaluation indicated that managers wanted to leave the full-day event to answer phone
calls and text messages.
 Even though Tri Ocean’s CEO and VPs were sold on the concept of recognizing employees, they
needed mid-level managers get implementing the program. To do this, senior-level managers
needed to raise the topic of the program in meetings with the mid-level managers.
WORK SAMPLES AVAILABLE
Communication for Employees
1. Recognition Matters, Tri Ocean’s newsletter for employees, winter edition.
2. PowerPoint presentation of survey results to employees. These were presented and emailed to
employees
Communication for Managers
1. Blanchard’s research report on indepth interviews with managers
2. PowerPoint presentation of survey results to managers
3. Blanchard’s survey results from the workshop
4. The information booklet that was handed to managers at the workshop and emailed to them
5. The PowerPoint presentation that Blanchard and the managers developed for the full-day
workshop.

More Related Content

What's hot

Employee engagement hdfc bank
Employee engagement hdfc bankEmployee engagement hdfc bank
Employee engagement hdfc bankKAILASH KUSHWAHA
 
PM Talent Management wp
PM Talent Management wpPM Talent Management wp
PM Talent Management wpColin Turner
 
How to Build a Stronger Happier Workplace - whitepaper
How to Build a Stronger Happier Workplace - whitepaperHow to Build a Stronger Happier Workplace - whitepaper
How to Build a Stronger Happier Workplace - whitepapersmartOne Prepaid
 
Entrepreneurship CAPE SBA Unit 1
Entrepreneurship CAPE SBA Unit 1Entrepreneurship CAPE SBA Unit 1
Entrepreneurship CAPE SBA Unit 1Phillescia Jean
 
Trainingmag 2014/1-2 JIFFY LUBE REVS UP TO NO.1
Trainingmag 2014/1-2 JIFFY LUBE REVS UP TO NO.1Trainingmag 2014/1-2 JIFFY LUBE REVS UP TO NO.1
Trainingmag 2014/1-2 JIFFY LUBE REVS UP TO NO.1TalentPool Vietnam
 
Changing Dimensions of Employee Engagement
Changing Dimensions of Employee EngagementChanging Dimensions of Employee Engagement
Changing Dimensions of Employee EngagementM Ravish Malgi
 
ECX-EC3 - Ret Ed_Corp Brochure_email
ECX-EC3 - Ret Ed_Corp Brochure_emailECX-EC3 - Ret Ed_Corp Brochure_email
ECX-EC3 - Ret Ed_Corp Brochure_emailAv Lieberman
 

What's hot (9)

Employee engagement hdfc bank
Employee engagement hdfc bankEmployee engagement hdfc bank
Employee engagement hdfc bank
 
PM Talent Management wp
PM Talent Management wpPM Talent Management wp
PM Talent Management wp
 
eBook #5
eBook #5eBook #5
eBook #5
 
How to Build a Stronger Happier Workplace - whitepaper
How to Build a Stronger Happier Workplace - whitepaperHow to Build a Stronger Happier Workplace - whitepaper
How to Build a Stronger Happier Workplace - whitepaper
 
HRM in SME
HRM in SME HRM in SME
HRM in SME
 
Entrepreneurship CAPE SBA Unit 1
Entrepreneurship CAPE SBA Unit 1Entrepreneurship CAPE SBA Unit 1
Entrepreneurship CAPE SBA Unit 1
 
Trainingmag 2014/1-2 JIFFY LUBE REVS UP TO NO.1
Trainingmag 2014/1-2 JIFFY LUBE REVS UP TO NO.1Trainingmag 2014/1-2 JIFFY LUBE REVS UP TO NO.1
Trainingmag 2014/1-2 JIFFY LUBE REVS UP TO NO.1
 
Changing Dimensions of Employee Engagement
Changing Dimensions of Employee EngagementChanging Dimensions of Employee Engagement
Changing Dimensions of Employee Engagement
 
ECX-EC3 - Ret Ed_Corp Brochure_email
ECX-EC3 - Ret Ed_Corp Brochure_emailECX-EC3 - Ret Ed_Corp Brochure_email
ECX-EC3 - Ret Ed_Corp Brochure_email
 

Similar to Internal communication program

Employee recognition thesis
Employee recognition thesisEmployee recognition thesis
Employee recognition thesisJames Brown
 
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcingMu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcingsmumbahelp
 
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcingMu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcingsmumbahelp
 
Employee Engagement Initiative
Employee Engagement InitiativeEmployee Engagement Initiative
Employee Engagement InitiativeAnurag Chakraborty
 
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcingMu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcingsmumbahelp
 
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcingMu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcingsmumbahelp
 
Human resource Management of Coca Cola Bangladesh
Human resource Management of Coca Cola BangladeshHuman resource Management of Coca Cola Bangladesh
Human resource Management of Coca Cola BangladeshMd. Mehadi Hassan Bappy
 
Managerial Report FINAL
Managerial Report FINALManagerial Report FINAL
Managerial Report FINALDouglas Petty
 
Mu0013 summer-2016
Mu0013 summer-2016Mu0013 summer-2016
Mu0013 summer-2016smumbahelp
 
Mu0010 – manpower planning & resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning & resourcingMu0010 – manpower planning & resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning & resourcingsmumbahelp
 
Employee retention-tipsheet
Employee retention-tipsheetEmployee retention-tipsheet
Employee retention-tipsheetAmanda Winstead
 
Mh0057 – management of healthcare human resources
Mh0057 – management of healthcare human resourcesMh0057 – management of healthcare human resources
Mh0057 – management of healthcare human resourcessmumbahelp
 
Employee-retention-
 Employee-retention- Employee-retention-
Employee-retention-Dinesh Reddy
 
Internship Report By Mashruk Zaman Khan
Internship Report By Mashruk Zaman KhanInternship Report By Mashruk Zaman Khan
Internship Report By Mashruk Zaman KhanMashruk Khan
 
Mba project on manappuram gold loan
Mba project on  manappuram gold loan Mba project on  manappuram gold loan
Mba project on manappuram gold loan Deepash Rajak
 
Stop losing your best talent! Mini case study
Stop losing your best talent!  Mini case studyStop losing your best talent!  Mini case study
Stop losing your best talent! Mini case studyHedda Bird
 
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcingMu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcingStudy Stuff
 
Performance Appraisal Methods of Multinational organization
Performance Appraisal Methods of Multinational organizationPerformance Appraisal Methods of Multinational organization
Performance Appraisal Methods of Multinational organizationTanjil Sakhawat
 

Similar to Internal communication program (20)

Employee recognition thesis
Employee recognition thesisEmployee recognition thesis
Employee recognition thesis
 
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcingMu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
 
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcingMu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
 
Employee Engagement Initiative
Employee Engagement InitiativeEmployee Engagement Initiative
Employee Engagement Initiative
 
Career Management
Career ManagementCareer Management
Career Management
 
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcingMu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
 
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcingMu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
 
Human resource Management of Coca Cola Bangladesh
Human resource Management of Coca Cola BangladeshHuman resource Management of Coca Cola Bangladesh
Human resource Management of Coca Cola Bangladesh
 
Managerial Report FINAL
Managerial Report FINALManagerial Report FINAL
Managerial Report FINAL
 
Mu0013 summer-2016
Mu0013 summer-2016Mu0013 summer-2016
Mu0013 summer-2016
 
Mu0010 – manpower planning & resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning & resourcingMu0010 – manpower planning & resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning & resourcing
 
Resource Development
Resource DevelopmentResource Development
Resource Development
 
Employee retention-tipsheet
Employee retention-tipsheetEmployee retention-tipsheet
Employee retention-tipsheet
 
Mh0057 – management of healthcare human resources
Mh0057 – management of healthcare human resourcesMh0057 – management of healthcare human resources
Mh0057 – management of healthcare human resources
 
Employee-retention-
 Employee-retention- Employee-retention-
Employee-retention-
 
Internship Report By Mashruk Zaman Khan
Internship Report By Mashruk Zaman KhanInternship Report By Mashruk Zaman Khan
Internship Report By Mashruk Zaman Khan
 
Mba project on manappuram gold loan
Mba project on  manappuram gold loan Mba project on  manappuram gold loan
Mba project on manappuram gold loan
 
Stop losing your best talent! Mini case study
Stop losing your best talent!  Mini case studyStop losing your best talent!  Mini case study
Stop losing your best talent! Mini case study
 
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcingMu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
Mu0010 – manpower planning and resourcing
 
Performance Appraisal Methods of Multinational organization
Performance Appraisal Methods of Multinational organizationPerformance Appraisal Methods of Multinational organization
Performance Appraisal Methods of Multinational organization
 

Recently uploaded

Day 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC Bootcamp
Day 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC BootcampDay 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC Bootcamp
Day 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC BootcampPLCLeadershipDevelop
 
ANIn Gurugram April 2024 |Can Agile and AI work together? by Pramodkumar Shri...
ANIn Gurugram April 2024 |Can Agile and AI work together? by Pramodkumar Shri...ANIn Gurugram April 2024 |Can Agile and AI work together? by Pramodkumar Shri...
ANIn Gurugram April 2024 |Can Agile and AI work together? by Pramodkumar Shri...AgileNetwork
 
LPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations Review
LPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations ReviewLPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations Review
LPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations Reviewthomas851723
 
crisiscommunication-presentation in crisis management.pptx
crisiscommunication-presentation in crisis management.pptxcrisiscommunication-presentation in crisis management.pptx
crisiscommunication-presentation in crisis management.pptxSamahhassan30
 
Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...
Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...
Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...Pooja Nehwal
 
Fifteenth Finance Commission Presentation
Fifteenth Finance Commission PresentationFifteenth Finance Commission Presentation
Fifteenth Finance Commission Presentationmintusiprd
 
Board Diversity Initiaive Launch Presentation
Board Diversity Initiaive Launch PresentationBoard Diversity Initiaive Launch Presentation
Board Diversity Initiaive Launch Presentationcraig524401
 
Introduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-Engineering
Introduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-EngineeringIntroduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-Engineering
Introduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-Engineeringthomas851723
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomdivyansh0kumar0
 
LPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business Sector
LPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business SectorLPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business Sector
LPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business Sectorthomas851723
 
Reflecting, turning experience into insight
Reflecting, turning experience into insightReflecting, turning experience into insight
Reflecting, turning experience into insightWayne Abrahams
 
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual service
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual serviceCALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual service
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual serviceanilsa9823
 
CEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biography
CEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biographyCEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biography
CEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biographyHafizMuhammadAbdulla5
 

Recently uploaded (17)

Day 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC Bootcamp
Day 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC BootcampDay 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC Bootcamp
Day 0- Bootcamp Roadmap for PLC Bootcamp
 
ANIn Gurugram April 2024 |Can Agile and AI work together? by Pramodkumar Shri...
ANIn Gurugram April 2024 |Can Agile and AI work together? by Pramodkumar Shri...ANIn Gurugram April 2024 |Can Agile and AI work together? by Pramodkumar Shri...
ANIn Gurugram April 2024 |Can Agile and AI work together? by Pramodkumar Shri...
 
LPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations Review
LPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations ReviewLPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations Review
LPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations Review
 
crisiscommunication-presentation in crisis management.pptx
crisiscommunication-presentation in crisis management.pptxcrisiscommunication-presentation in crisis management.pptx
crisiscommunication-presentation in crisis management.pptx
 
Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...
Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...
Pooja Mehta 9167673311, Trusted Call Girls In NAVI MUMBAI Cash On Payment , V...
 
Fifteenth Finance Commission Presentation
Fifteenth Finance Commission PresentationFifteenth Finance Commission Presentation
Fifteenth Finance Commission Presentation
 
Board Diversity Initiaive Launch Presentation
Board Diversity Initiaive Launch PresentationBoard Diversity Initiaive Launch Presentation
Board Diversity Initiaive Launch Presentation
 
Introduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-Engineering
Introduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-EngineeringIntroduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-Engineering
Introduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-Engineering
 
sauth delhi call girls in Defence Colony🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
sauth delhi call girls in Defence Colony🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Servicesauth delhi call girls in Defence Colony🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
sauth delhi call girls in Defence Colony🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
 
Call Girls Service Tilak Nagar @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance VVIP 🍎 SERVICE
Call Girls Service Tilak Nagar @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance  VVIP 🍎 SERVICECall Girls Service Tilak Nagar @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance  VVIP 🍎 SERVICE
Call Girls Service Tilak Nagar @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance VVIP 🍎 SERVICE
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Rajarhat 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
LPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business Sector
LPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business SectorLPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business Sector
LPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business Sector
 
Reflecting, turning experience into insight
Reflecting, turning experience into insightReflecting, turning experience into insight
Reflecting, turning experience into insight
 
Becoming an Inclusive Leader - Bernadette Thompson
Becoming an Inclusive Leader - Bernadette ThompsonBecoming an Inclusive Leader - Bernadette Thompson
Becoming an Inclusive Leader - Bernadette Thompson
 
Rohini Sector 16 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
Rohini Sector 16 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No AdvanceRohini Sector 16 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
Rohini Sector 16 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
 
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual service
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual serviceCALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual service
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Charbagh Lucknow best sexual service
 
CEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biography
CEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biographyCEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biography
CEO of Google, Sunder Pichai's biography
 

Internal communication program

  • 1. 1 Rick Jones RECOGNITION MATTERS This is a strategic employee-recognition program Planned and written for TriOcean Engineering ASRC Energy Services It accompanies the newsletter “Recognition Matters” Tri Ocean’s employees were thanked and recognized for their efforts after the company reduced its work force I submitted this work sample to pass IABC’s* accreditation program *IABC is the International Association of Business Communicators Copyright 2015 by Susan Lee Blanchard
  • 2. 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Description of the Organization (Tri Ocean Engineering) ........................ 3 2. Susan Blanchard’s Role.............................................................................. 3 3. Problem to be Solved ................................................................................. 3 4. Recognition Programs ............................................................................... 4 5. Employee Performance Goals and Objectives ......................................... 5 6. Target Groups of Employees...................................................................... 5 7. Developing the Strategic Plan .................................................................... 6 Research ...................................................................................................... 6 Planning ....................................................................................................... 7 Communication Vehicles ............................................................................ 9 Timeline ...................................................................................................... 10 Budget ....................................................................................................... 11 Selling the Plan to Management .............................................................. 11 8. Implementing the Plan .............................................................................. 12 Key Messages to Target Groups .............................................................. 12 Workshop to Train Managers ................................................................... 13 Newsletter titled “Recognition Matters” .................................................. 14 Presentation of Research Results ........................................................... 14 “Recognition Matters” Information Booklet for Managers .................... 14 9. Evaluating the Plan’s Effectiveness (measuring the results) ............... 15 Objective 1 for Managers was Surpassed ............................................... 15 Objective 2 for Managers was Met ........................................................... 15 Highlights of the Survey Results.............................................................. 16 Objective 3 for Employees was Surpassed ............................................. 16 Lessons Learned ....................................................................................... 18
  • 3. 3 INTRODUCTION While working for TriOcean of ASRC Energy Services, I strategically planned a recognition program that successfully lifted the spirits of employees when a recession hit and TriOcean reduced its workforce by thousands of employees. What kind of program would motivate the down-in-the-dumps employees who remained on the job after their colleagues had been laid off? A recognition program for managers, team leaders and their deserving employees with the side benefit of refreshing managers’ leadership knowledge. Recognition from team leaders is the best recognition there is. Studies show that employees want to be appreciated by their team leaders more than they want cash bonuses. Companies are starting to learn this lesson, since Walt Disney and Hallmark have used formal and informal recognition as a reward to motivate employees through programs similar to mine. Some of the most memorable, meaningful, words employees hear are genuine compliments and positive encouragement. These can go a long way to inspiring the best performance. The trick is to give honest praise when deserved. Honest words of thanks and encouragement motivated the TriOcean employees who remained on the job after management reduced its workforce during the 2006 recession. 1. DESCRIPTION OF THE ORGANIZATION (TRI OCEAN) Tri Ocean Engineering had designed projects for oil and gas clients in the upstream, midstream, and downstream sectors of the world petroleum industry for three decades. Its commitment to succeed, and its history of domestic and international design work were impressive—until the global economic recession of 2006. That year, the price of a barrel of oil soared to over $70 and then fell back from that level in subsequent months. Tri Ocean’s profits reached a record low. While there were bound to be frequent fluctuations in the oil price caused by shifts in demand and political crises in the Middle East, most experts predicted the trend line would be toward still higher oil prices. However, in September 2006 oil prices fell to $60 a barrel. At the time, Tri Ocean lost work from its largest client—Shell Canada. Later, Imperial Oil reeled back its engineering projects and Tri Ocean reduced its workforce for the first time. By 2010, Tri Ocean had leveled its workforce three times. Seven hundred employees lost their jobs.
  • 4. 4 2. SUSAN BLANCHARD’S ROLE Before the layoffs, Blanchard worked as a Technical Writer-Lead who oversaw marketing projects and two technical writers and a designer. Because she had many years of expertise in employee communications, she recommended an innovative way of boosting employee morale through the following communications:  Personal (face-to-face) recognition. The manager personally thanks or congratulates an employee for doing a good job when deserved.  Written recognition. The manager writes a personal note about good performance, gives the employee a thank-you card, or recommends that the Communications unit recognize the employee in a news story, a personality profile, in Tri Ocean’s new recognition newsletter.  Electronic recognition. The manager thanks the employee via email, text-message, voice-mail, pager, or other electronic communications.  Public recognition. The manager commends the employee in a recognition ceremony, an annual event called Awards Night, or in a staff or town-hall meeting, depending on the type of recognition the employee prefers.  Positive gossip. The manager says positive things about an employee to his or her co-workers with the underlying presumption that this indirect praise will get back to the employee. 3. PROBLEM TO BE SOLVED After the layoffs, Tri Ocean’s remaining 323 employees wore gloomy expressions and seemed crestfallen about the loss of their fellow workers. Blanchard’s employee workplace survey showed that managers and employees alike were worried about further job loss and gloomy about the company’s prospects. Then in one town-hall meeting Tri Ocean’s Chief Executive Officer (CEO) overheard a group of engineers say, “We never get a word of thanks.” And in staff meetings, employees lacked their usual enthusiasm about tackling new projects. To deal with the underlying gloom that pervaded the culture, Blanchard was tasked to research, plan, implement, and evaluate a new morale-boosting program for the employees and managers of Tri Ocean Engineering.
  • 5. 5 In the past, Tri Ocean’s only way of recognizing employees had been through years-of-service awards, pay increases, and flextime. Blanchard wanted to build on these incentives to show employees that Tri Ocean managers really cared about employees’ efforts. Blanchard began by surveying employees to:  Determine how to support Tri Ocean’s new performance objectives to motivate and recognize employees  Find out how employees like to be recognized for doing good work 4. RECOGNITION PROGRAMS Recognition and rewards fall into two categories: “formal” and “informal.” Formal rewards tend to be planned, structured programs that continue for years, such as years-of-service awards and cash bonuses. Informal rewards are just-in-time forms of appreciation for good work and specific behaviors. Informal rewards acknowledge valuable suggestions, project milestones, a closed business deal, or successes ranging from a finished project to graduation from a degree program. 5. EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE GOALS & OBJECTIVES After losing hundreds of employees, Tri Ocean’s management team looked over Blanchard’s communications plan and made it a priority to recognize and try to motivate existing workers. To support this new direction, Blanchard set three objectives with specific metrics: 1. Eighty percent of managers will understand their role in increasing employee recognition over the next three months (September to December 2006). 2. Sixty percent of managers will enact some form of recognition for employees by the end of February 2007. 3. Increase from 20 to 40 percent the number of employees who state on the employee appreciation questionnaire that they feel more appreciated by their managers (in December 2007).
  • 6. 6 6. TARGET GROUPS Managers charged with managing and coaching employees. As team leaders managers were in the categories of “Seasoned Recruits” and “Senior Recruits.” Seasoned Recruits (managers) were the 15 percent of employees who had been with Tri Ocean for six to 10 years. They worked in senior-level roles and had greater autonomy and decision-making authority than other employees. Senior Recruits were the remaining 10 percent of employees who had been with Tri Ocean for more than 10 years. When Blanchard conducted her study for this project, most of these individuals were near retirement and worked in senior-level or managerial roles. Regular employees: Regular employees were called “New Recruits” and “Experienced Recruits.” New Recruits were the 55 percent of employees who had been employed for less than two years. Typically, New Recruits were recent college or university graduates whose average age was 23 to 31 years. They had little work experience and entered Tri Ocean’s training programs for entry-level workers. New Recruits included experienced employees from other companies and English-speaking university graduates from other countries. Studies showed that New Recruits, the younger employees, appreciated recognition more than Experienced Recruits. Experienced Recruits (the slightly older employees) made up 20 percent of all employees employed for three to five years. Some of these individuals entered Tri Ocean’s training program at the start of their TriOcean careers. They typically managed projects with great autonomy. Demographics:  In 2006, more than 75 percent of Tri Ocean’s employees worked in cross-functional teams organized around client projects.  Males comprised 68 percent of Tri Ocean’s workforce.  Average age: 31  Education levels: 7% have a master’s degree, 38% have bachelor’s degree, 22% have a college diploma, and 22% have little or no formal education.  Ethnicity and nationality: 46% were born outside Canada  Average years manager has worked in current position: 6 years
  • 7. 7 To ensure the appreciation program took hold, Tri Ocean’s CEO asked all managers to attend a one-day recognition workshop outlining Blanchard’s new program. He shared the news that Blanchard would wrap up her employee workplace survey and host a workshop on the topic of recognition on three occasions during work hours, so all managers could attend. The CEO championed the project by sending every manager an email invitation, asking him or her to join him at the workshop. 7. DEVELOPING THE STRATEGIC PLAN Research Shortly after Blanchard was hired, her immediate task was to conduct upfront research—to assess through in-depth interviews and questionnaires how managers typically recognize their employees. In the interviews, she wanted to know how managers would feel about recognizing their workers through a new recognition program. Her second task was to survey employees to learn about Tri Ocean’s existing recognition practices—she wanted to know which types of personal recognition employees most prefer. Employee Research According to the questionnaire results, employees said that Tri Ocean Engineering workers preferred personalized, instant appreciation from their direct managers more than any other kind of recognition. As many as 92 percent of employees reported that it was somewhat (31%), very (27%), or extremely important (34%) for their managers to recognize them when they do good work. The questionnaire asked employees to rate the way in which they want to be recognized:  Personal (face-to-face) recognition. The manager personally thanks or congratulates an employee for doing a good job.  Written recognition. The manager writes a personal note about good performance, gives the employee a thank-you card, or commends the employee in a news story for Tri Ocean’s recognition newsletter.  Electronic recognition. The manager thanks the employee via email, text-message, voice-mail, pager, or other form of electronic communications.  Public recognition. The manager commends an employee in a recognition ceremony, staff meeting, or town-hall meeting.
  • 8. 8  Positive gossip. The manager says positive things about an employee. For example, he or she might say something nice about an employee to his or her co-workers with the underlying presumption that this indirect praise will get back to the employee. Employees also indicated how they wanted the recognition. In Blanchard’s questionnaire, they indicated it was “extremely important,” “very important,” and “somewhat important” that:  My manager involves me when making decisions  My manager asks for my opinions or ideas  My manager lets me know when I am doing a good job  Personally thanks me for doing good work Management Research Blanchard learned there was a large discrepancy between the amount of recognition that managers reported giving employees compared to the amount of recognition employees reported receiving. For example, Blanchard asked managers to rank on a scale of 1 to 5 (1 = never, 5 = always) the following statement: “I let my employees know when they’re doing a good job.” Managers said they “always” recognized employees. However, many employees indicated that managers “never” recognize them. Planning Blanchard’s work involved: 1. Writing, conducting, tabulating, and analyzing the research 2. Writing research reports about the findings 3. Planning and outlining the new employee-recognition program for Tri Ocean’s managers, and “selling” her ideas to Human Resources for the program 4. Writing an information booklet describing the ways to recognize employees 5. Implementing a workshop for managers to introduce them to Tri Ocean’s new employee recognition practices 6. Developing and issuing a quarterly newsletter titled “Recognition Matters” to inform managers and employees about Tri Ocean’s recognition practices 7. Evaluating the recognition program through employee surveys and through meetings with managers to assess the effectiveness and practical application of the program
  • 9. 9 To get managers’ buy-in, Blanchard asked them to participate in the workshop and become directly involved in hosting it. After the workshop, she asked managers to inform employees of the good work and behaviors they can exhibit to earn recognition. Three Recognition Levels The levels of recognition were as follows: Level 1 rewards were informal forms of recognition such as saying thank-you and sharing positive gossip. For every three informal rewards there was a more official recognition or a Level 2 reward. Level 2 rewards included tangible gifts such as movie or hockey tickets (up to a value of $100). Level 3 rewards included an article in the employee newsletter, public praise at a company meeting, and a monetary reward of $200. All managers were asked to forgive and support employees when they make minor mistakes, and to involve employees in decision-making and idea generation. Because of the importance of communicating these forms of recognition, Blanchard suggested that the verbal or email recognition be delivered before offering money or movie tickets.
  • 10. 10 Communication Vehicles or Tools Communication Vehicles Target Audience Purpose Frequency Indepth interviews and research report presented to managers. Managers Learn about their recognition practices. Determine their readiness and willingness for a recognition program. Did this once before the program was planned Surveys (questionnaires) Managers and employees (different surveys for each group) Learn about managers’ recognition practices and about employees’ recognition needs. Once before the program was planned and again at the end of the program. PowerPoint presentation to present research findings to each group separately. Managers Outline results from in-depth interviews and surveys. Presented after summing up the research results. Workshop Managers Educate managers about the power of appreciation and how the new program worked. Offer one workshop three times to educate all managers on Tri Ocean’s new recognition program. The workshop would become an annual event. Recognition information booklet Managers Provide guidelines on how to recognize employees. Offered with the workshop and emailed to managers. Newsletter (Recognition Matters) Regular employees and managers - Introduce recognition program. - Recognize employees by profiling their success in news stories. - Communicate TriOcean’s recognition practices and guidelines. Issued four times a year with Tri Ocean’s regular employee newsletter. Survey managers and employees separately. Managers and employees See how the new recognition program is working. See if it meets its objectives. Once
  • 11. 11 Timeline Date Tool Audience Purpose Last two weeks, August Analyze the problem. Human Resources To determine my role and begin my work. September Research. Conducted in-depth interviews and surveys (questionnaires). Write research reports. Managers Determine if managers are ready and willing to implement a recognition program. Find out if they feel it’s their job to recognize employees. Learn about their existing recognition and communication efforts. Survey (questionnaire). Employees Determine if employees feel supported and recognized. Learn of their desired forms of recognition, both formal and informal. October Present research findings in meetings to the two audiences. One presentation to managers One presentation to employees Present research results. Newsletter for employees and managers. Primary: employees Secondary: managers Roll-out new program. Educate regular employees about the power of appreciation and then recognize them. November Recruit a group of managers to help facilitate workshop. Eight managers helped with the work- shop. Elicit their recommendations, buy-in, and assistance. Host workshop in November and again in December. Managers Host workshop to reach first objective. December Host workshop a final time for those who missed the earlier two workshops. Managers Educate managers on how to recognize employees. Write another issue of recognition newsletter. Primary target: employees. Educate employees about the appreciation program. Two months later Return to Tri Ocean to speak with and survey managers. Group meeting with Managers To see how program is working for them. Learn if they are practicing appreciation techniques and answer their questions about the program. A year later Return to Tri Ocean to survey employees to determine if 40% feel more recognized. Employees and managers Recommend improvements to recognition program to meet the needs of all audiences better. Brief face-to-face meeting with HR.
  • 12. 12 Budget Human Resources indicated there would be a small budget for creative collateral. As a result, Tri Ocean incurred only a printing and design fee for the two newsletters that Blanchard wrote and designed. A cost of $115 was budgeted to provide a catered lunch on the days of the workshops. BUDGET FOR A PRINTED NEWSLETTER Amount budgeted: $6,500 Planned Costs Printing and Design Actual Costs Amount over/ under budget Recognition Matters (Winter 2006) $300 $300 0 Recognition Matters (Spring 2006) $300 $300 0 Workshops (catered lunch) $400 $300 $448 TOTALS $1000 budget $900 Costs $50 under budget Selling the Plan to Management To sell her plan to management, Blanchard explained the program’s implementation strategy. She built a groundswell of support for the program by indicating how recognition programs have been effective in other organizations and explaining the results of her research suggesting that employees want feedback from their managers. Blanchard’s indepth interview guide for manager answered the following questions 1. How does Tri Ocean retain key employees? 2. What behaviors do you want the employees to adopt? In her face-to-face presentation to the Human Resources manager, Blanchard explained the timeline and communication plan for the program step-by-step. She wanted to ensure that the manager had the opportunity to hear how the program would work, especially the how and when to recognize an employee. After the presentation, Blanchard was eager for feedback of any kind. She invited the managers to ask questions, play Devil’s advocate, and suggest innovative ways of implementing the program.
  • 13. 13 8. IMPLEMENTING THE PLAN Blanchard was at the helm of the work, steering it according to plan. Fortunately, she was able to navigate with HR’s trust. Because she was adept at conducting research, planning, and writing, Blanchard avoided the high costs of hiring a market research firm. Of the few challenges she faced, the one most disconcerting was the problem of researching and rolling out the program in four months. After the employees and managers presented the recognition program in workshops, Blanchard encouraged managers to recognize employees face-to-face. Some of the managers felt uncomfortable giving compliments. However, Blanchard did not expect the glitch she encountered with one reluctant manager during the workshop. The manager in question, “Hillard,” found it easier to give criticism than compliments. He had let trouble in his department percolate for too long. At work, he saw his employees as a collection of problems rather than as a group of young engineers who were learning and maneuvering learning curves. Hillard had quietly voiced his fears about the recognition program to Blanchard during the workshop, and Blanchard had promised to meet with him a day later. Before the meeting, Blanchard gathered evidence that clearly showed the effectiveness of recognition and rewards, and of managers delivering them face-to-face to employees. Hilliard looked at Blanchard’s evidence, he admitted that he felt uncomfortable complimenting employees, noting that this behavior felt “strange.” However, by hearing Blanchard’s words on how to support employees verbally, by scripting his own words, and by role-playing with Blanchard, Bill eventually developed a communication skill that would increase his ability to support and recognize his employees. Key messages Blanchard communicated these key messages in the recognition workshop: Key messages for managers:  “Recognition matters.” This message became the title of Tri Ocean’s recognition program and any communication collateral associated with it  “At Tri Ocean, we stick up for our employees.” This message was needed to show the extent of management’s support for employees.  “You get the best effort from others by building a fire within them.”
  • 14. 14 Key messages for employees:  “Recognition matters”  “Hard work, good ideas, and results are rewarded”  “At Tri Ocean, we stick up for our employees” Workshop to Train Managers The full-day workshop was the primary tool for communicating the key messages and the recognition program to managers. Blanchard offered a one-day workshop on three separate occasions so that she could include every manager, and she achieved that goal, thanks to Tri Ocean’s CEO who urged the company’s managers to attend. The workshop included the following elements: 1. An introduction by the CEO who shared his excitement about the appreciation program and briefly identified Tri Ocean Engineering’s performance goals for employees 2. Words of thanks to the managers in attendance 3. Next, the CEO and a few managers presented the 18 ways that managers can recognize employees most effectively 4. The Human Resources manager demonstrated ways to recognize employees face-to-face, in writing, electronically, publicly, and through positive gossip. She role-played with Blanchard as she demonstrated how to compliment employees for good behavior or work 5. A group exercise in which managers shared their own techniques for recognizing and supervising employees effectively 6. A brief explanation of the types of recognition Tri Ocean employees said they prefer in the survey 7. A group discussion on which behaviors, ideas, and actions deserve recognition 8. The Human Resources manager presented the three recognition levels and the rules for issuing the formal and informal recognition 9. Next, managers paired up and recognized one another to demonstrate how to recognize someone verbally. 10. A workshop evaluation that called for feedback on both the workshop and the recognition program. After the workshop, Blanchard surveyed and then met with the managers in a group to talk about how the recognition program was working for them.
  • 15. 15 Newsletter titled Recognition Matters The newsletter was a tool that focused on Tri Ocean’s new recognition practices in the following ways: 1. Articles featuring employees who have been recognized for significant achievements 2. Stories about Tri Ocean’s recognition program and how it works 3. Key messages 4. Case studies of written, face-to-face, electronic, and public forms of communication 5. Events for recognizing employees—awards ceremonies and company anniversary celebrations 6. Ideas for other reward programs—such as the “Reward Your Client program” 7. Requests for employees to nominate colleagues for recognition Presentation of Research Results Blanchard developed a research report to explain the results of the her indepth interviewing, a qualitative form of research. She presented the report in a PowerPoint presentation to the managers, and she presented the results of the employee survey in a PowerPoint presentation to employees. “Recognition Matters” Booklet Blanchard disseminated the information booklet at the workshop and later emailed an electronic copy to each manager. It describes all of Tri Ocean’s recognition practices and outlines the actions managers need to take to recognize employees. For example, the booklet urges managers to recognize employees who reach strategic goals, deliver exceptional customer service, work hard, and show a positive attitude.
  • 16. 16 9. EVALUATING THE PLAN’S EFFECTIVENESS Objective 1 for Managers was Surpassed Blanchard’s first objective was to help 80 percent of managers understand their role in increasing employee recognition at Tri Ocean. This objective was surpassed. All 26 managers attended the one- day workshop offered on three occasions, and this meant that 100 percent of managers had learned their role in recognizing employees. Up to 17 managers attended the first workshop (offered November 16, 2006) and gave positive workshop evaluations. The most common responses on the workshop evaluation form were “good,” “very good,” or “excellent,” when managers rated their knowledge of Tri Ocean’s recognition program. The workshop alone helped managers understand how to recognize employees, but the information booklet, indepth interviews, and survey results added to their depth of knowledge. A side benefit: over time Managers got better at supporting and thanking their employees. Objective 2 for Managers was Met Tri Ocean surpassed the objective of getting 60 percent of the 26 managers to enact some form of recognition for employees by the end of February. As indicated in the summary of survey highlights below, 69 percent of managers indicated they frequently praise employees face-to-face. Another 73 percent of managers indicated they spend more time with their employees. Overall, 69 percent of the managers surveyed indicated they had enacted some form of recognition for employees. Blanchard’s objective of getting 60 percent of the managers to recognize their employees was surpassed by nine percent. Highlights of Survey Results Recognition activity Managers noted the frequency of each activity below, and the importance they attached to it when recognizing their employees Frequency ranges from: 1) always 2) frequently 3) occasionally 4) seldom 5) never Importance ranges from: 1) extremely important 2) very important 3) somewhat important 4) not very important 5) unimportant Recognition Most common response Most common response Please read across
  • 17. 17 Employee is given verbal thanks or praise Frequently (69%) Extremely important (77%) Employee is praised via email Frequently (62%) Very important (73%) Employee is given $25 and informal recognition (thanks and positive feedback) Occasionally (58%) Somewhat important (65%) Employee is given a choice of assignments Occasionally (46%) Extremely important (46%) Employee is given increased job autonomy Occasionally (42%) Extremely important (65%) Employee is given more authority Occasionally (56%) Somewhat important (62%) Manager spends more time with employee Frequently (73%) Somewhat important (65%) The workshop to educate managers about the program had to be relaunched every three years, so that new hires would learn about the three recognition reward levels and continue to support their employees, even when the employees were busy and faced tight deadlines. Managers were accountable for making the recognition program a success, and they learned not to wait until performance appraisal to appraise an employee’s performance. Objective 3 for Regular Employees was Surpassed The goal for employees was to increase from 20 to 40 percent the number of employees who state on the employee questionnaire that they feel appreciated by their managers. Blanchard’s research findings confirmed that more than 49 percent, not just 40 percent, of the employees felt recognized for a job well done. While monetary compensation was important to Tri Ocean employees, the activities that really motivated them to perform are listed in the highlights below.
  • 18. 18 Lessons Learned If Blanchard were to implement the program again, she would: Highlights of Survey Results Recognition activity Employees noted the frequency and Important of each form of recognition Frequency ranges from: 1. always 2. frequently 3. occasionally 4. seldom 5. never Importance ranges from: 1. extremely important 2. very important 3. somewhat important 4. not very important 5. unimportant Recognition Most common response Most common response My manager gives me the information that I need to do my job. Frequently (67%) Extremely important (39%) My manager involves me when making decisions. Sometimes (55%) Very important (77%) My manager asks me for my opinion or ideas. Occasionally (49%) Extremely important (78%) My manager lets me know when I’m doing a good job. Occasionally (73%) Very important (66%) My manager personally thanks me for doing good work. Occasionally (51%) Somewhat important (72%) My manager recognizes me verbally. Occasionally (52%) Somewhat important (69%) My manager gives me a choice of assignments. Occasionally (43%) Somewhat important (49%) My manager spends time with me. Occasionally (58%) Somewhat important (62%%) My manager lets me leave work when essential. Occasionally (73%) Extremely important (72%)
  • 19. 19  Host the workshop in two off-site, half-day sessions rather than in one full-day presentation. The post-event evaluation indicated that managers wanted to leave the full-day event to answer phone calls and text messages.  Even though Tri Ocean’s CEO and VPs were sold on the concept of recognizing employees, they needed mid-level managers get implementing the program. To do this, senior-level managers needed to raise the topic of the program in meetings with the mid-level managers. WORK SAMPLES AVAILABLE Communication for Employees 1. Recognition Matters, Tri Ocean’s newsletter for employees, winter edition. 2. PowerPoint presentation of survey results to employees. These were presented and emailed to employees Communication for Managers 1. Blanchard’s research report on indepth interviews with managers 2. PowerPoint presentation of survey results to managers 3. Blanchard’s survey results from the workshop 4. The information booklet that was handed to managers at the workshop and emailed to them 5. The PowerPoint presentation that Blanchard and the managers developed for the full-day workshop.