clavical fractures are most controversial in case of treatment modalities in orthopaedics. it is one of the common fracture of all ages. so we are explaining our point what to do or not?
2. INTRODUCTION
A clavicle fracture accounts for 3-6% of adult
fractures.
Fractures in the middle third represent 70 to
80% of all clavicular fractures.
There is no consensus among orthopaedic
surgeons regarding treatment for these
fractures.
Many supports conservative treatment even for
displaced middle third clavicular fractures while
other choose surgical management.
4. OLD STUDIES
According to Neer & Rowe’s large series
non union rate is <1% in non operative
cases
non union rate is 4% in operated cases
more recently studies have questioned
1. union rates
2. Functional recovery
3. Morbidity of malunions
following to conservative treatment.
5. STUDY
A meta analysis including 2144 cases have
been done by Canadian orthopaedic association
in which
conservative : non union seen in 15% cases in
displaced fractures
surgery : non union seen in 2% cases in
displaced fractures
Finally it was concluded that
1. Operative complications were 37% while
2. Conservatively treated had 63%
6. WHAT CAMPBELL SAYS
Non operative treatment is only a sling for
comfort as figure of 8 bandages are
inconvenient to the patient.
13. INDICATIONS
INDICATION FOR PRIMARY FIXATION OF MID SHAFT
CLAVICULAR FRACTURES
Absolute
1. Compound injuries,
associated
neurovascular injuries
2. When used as an
“approach” for surgery.
Relative
1. Displacement >2 cm
2. Shortening >2 cm
3. Comminution >3
fragments
4. Segmental fractures
5. Ipsilateral upper
extremity fractures
6. Upper multiple rib
fractures
7. Bilateral clavicular
fractures
14. ..
Fractures have been treated conservatively
for many years by all of us & our
predecessors.
We don’t see “ those many “ complications.
Why??
15. ..
Conservative treatment is a “neglected” “entity”.
Sling alone is no treatment.
Proper, monitored use of “figure 8” bandages
still give us good union rates.
Many fractures, even comminuted unite well
which may be initially displaced.
Regular follow up preferably, weekly &
adjusting sling, will go on long way in preventing
complications.
16. ..
Finally I ask myself which treatment I will
prefer for myself in this scenario that should
decide the outcome.
17. CONCLUSION
No treatment is full proof.
Treat with an open mind & proper
supervision.
Surgical treatment may be needed.
(primary/late : personal choice)
Disability/ discomfort of treatment & malunion
VS cosmetic scar & other complications
should decide the line of management.