http://www.msit.no/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/Notes-on-the-Science-of-Hadeeth.pdf

1. ! " # $ % # $ &
!" #$ %&'(" )*+,-. /01 2 34 (567(8 8 89
' ( ) * ) " ( ( + ) +
, - ./0+ % ..12
! " # $ ## % 3 " "" ( 4 +
" " ( " ( $$ , & % +
5 2
" 5 & )
3 + ( ) ( 3 + & + ( 4 %
+ " ( ) + -
&
$ 6 7 ( ( 8 5
% 9% 7 7 : # ;1. $ 6 3
) ) -
<$ 5 9=
% 9% 9% 3 # /.> $
;$ ? 3 - 9 5 9=
% 5 # /;. $
/$ @ 9 7 (
% A 3 % 9% @ A 4 # /1; $
>$ B 5 3 C 7 ( ( % 5
@ A 4
1$ 5 5 9= 7 ( ( C 5
9 D # >// $
E$ D 5 B
% 9= 9% - - # >F. $
F$ 9=
% 9% 9= 9% 7 : & # 1/; $ '
3 + 3 ( C
0$ C ( 5 A
D ( ( # 1E1 $
.$ 7 ( C ( (
B 9% 7 % A 3 # 0 $

2. $ : 9 %
G 9% 7 5 C # F.1 $
<$ 6 4 %
9% 7 3 ( # 0.< $
;$ 3 6 3 % %
: - 5% C # F>< $
/$ : A C
9= A C # .F. $
>$ ( 5
B # ;;< $
&
/:
3 ( 4 " " ( # $ # $
3 ( 4 " - 5 3 4 "
( ( 3
</
H 4 4 (
( ! " # $ 4 ( + "" ) + "
H 4 (
4 &
$
<$ ( ! " # $+
;$ ! " # $
>+?
H 4 %
( 4 &
$ +
<$ 4 I " 5
@( 'A
( 4 &
$ % 4 3 ( 4 +
<$ ( 3 (
H 4 % ""
(

3. H 4 % " 4 "
( # $
H 4 (
4 &
$ J) 3 4 4 5 I " "
<$ ( 3 ! " # $+ # 5$ ( # $+
;$
/
( (
( " ( (
3 ( 4
D"(</
( 4 &
$ +
<$ 4 ( 3 ( ) 4 (
3 (
*(</
( 3 ( 4 " 4 ) ( "
&
( " !
% "
! /
H 4 + )
( 4 " " " ) )
I &
$ 4 " " C
<$ ) )
;$ " ) 4 4 "
I ( &
$ FG/H4 ! / # ( ( 4$
( ( 4 4 ( 4 ## ( "
3 " 6 $$

4. <$ I; ! / # ( 4$
4 5 ( " +
4 # $ 5 4
( + # $ +
3 ( &
$ %: %3 (
<$ %:
;$ : ( B 5 @
H 4 !
( (
) 4 &
$
<$ N N:
;$ O P
H 4 8 3 (
( " " ) ) +
(
Q H! /
H 4 ( " "
4 &
$ +
<$ " C +
;$ 4
4 &
( ( 3 ( 4 " " + (
) 4 &
$ ( 4 +
<$ ( +
;$ (
" &
$ " " " + 4 % & % 5 4
# $ C 3 5 ) 3 4 4 7 5 3( , A 3
2
<$ " " + " " + 4
( 4 , A 3 2
;$ C # $+ 4 " % )
, 5 % ( + - 3 2
/$ #" " C $+ 4 3 4 )

5. ( # 4 ) $ = ( ,
( 2
>$ " " 4
1$ ? " "
3 " 4 " " &
$ C 9 % 3 (
<$ @ @ ( : 9 % 5%-
;$ : @ 9 % K
5
N NI/
H 4 J 4
( ( ) ) + 4 ##
) ) + " " $$ , A 3
2 ! " # $ % 9% 5%: : +
5 5
J !7'! J # $
< % %
< 9% 9%: :
< 5 5
O R/
H 4 4
( 4 4 ) 4
+ 4 "
% &
) ( : - 4 + "
C # ( " 4 I " $+ 4
#( $
" 4 ( &
$ # $ & / ); O R/ + # C $
( K 4 4 I " + 4
##L $$ ,7 " 9= @ # $2
<$ # ) $ F C O R/ + # $
( 4 ( + (
" 4

6. " 4 &
$ 4 " C # $ 4& "
"
<$ ' " " " 4& '
) 4 4 ) 4
;$ 4 " " ( 4&
" " 33 + " "
/$ " " " " " " 4&
" " " A " " +
% % 4 ( 4 &
$ 4 # $ + ( " 4
<$ 4 + " 4 " I " +
4 " ( + 4 4
4 ( -
6 ( 3 4 4 &
$ M 3 C
<$ % C
;$ ( " " " " + , 3
2 % (
) 3 4 4 5 ( 3 5 &
$ % " S T/U # C $ " "
4 4 " "
<$ 7 - @V@ T # $ " "
4 " ) "
3 C # " " $ ( - " # $ #4 $
( 3 ( &
$ <W ( +
<$ 4 X R <W "" +
;$ Y 3 ( +
/$ 4 X R ""
<
H 4 N
( 4 - #9 $ " # $ 4 4 +
4 ) 4 #9 $
) &
$ )S(T C )
" 4 +
<$ 5 K 9 #- $O + ' 4 # 4 $+ #9 C $+
" # C$+ ) 4 # 3 $
;$ #" $+ ( ( 3 &

7. K L )[ T #" $
" 4 4
3 ](!^ )[ #" ( 4$ ( ( + " ) 3
"
/$ 9 _V)3T6M ` T: % (
4 (
>$ 9 9 K ZT4I ` T: K #9 $ ( 3 9
"" ( + ( "" +
4 4 "
) (
4 4 4 &
4 " 4 (
( C " 5 "
) 4 "
&
) ( A 3 & 3 5 9= ,
3 ( # 4 $2
) ( C 7 ( % & : G
9=
) ( 6 & 9% 9%
) ( 5 & % %5 % 3 5 9% C 9%
5
) ( % & : G 9% 9%
3 ( &
A 3 ( ( ( ( 4
A 3
A 3 4 3 &
A 3 E+<E> 4 " /+... ( "
<+... ( " /+... (
8 A 3 ) 4 4 P&
' ( " ( % (
" ( 4 +
&T4I / A 3 " 4 + (
3 % ( " &
$ ( " ( + 4 + + - 4
"
<$ " ( + 4 + " # 4 " ) $+
4 4

8. H ) &
$ " A 3 +
<$ " A 3 +
;$ " +
/$ 4 A 3 + " +
>$ 4 A 3 + " +
1$ 4 + " +
E$ + 4 A 3
H 4 M N
- " ( " "
+ # $ #>$ "
#;$ 4 +
4 Y 3
5 4& ) 4 ( 4
7 4 4&
$ % (
<$ 4 + # $
4 )
( ) + ? #<$ ) )
( ) # $ " : +
" 4
4 &
<W
" - 4 ( &
$ ( +
<$ ) ( +
) (
! X R < # "" $&
( ( 3 4 +
( "" ) 4 ) +
(
! X R </ # "" $&
( 4 5 + + 4
( 3 4
) ( &
$ 4 4 +
4 +
<$ 4 ( 3 ( 5 ) 4 " + 4
3 + 4 3 (

9. ) +
4 ) "
4 & " "
( 4 ) " &
" + 4&
$ " A 3 +
<$ ( " ) + ( 3
+
;$ ( " " + 4 " % +
5 + 3
+ 4 ) "
3 ( 3 &
H 4 (
" # C $ ( 4 "
3
a != &
" ( 4 3 ( + 4
8 ( " P&
( 4 " ( &
$ " + + "
<$ ( " ( + &
$ 3 ( 4 + ( 3 4 4 )
4 O
<$ 8 4 ) " ) ( 4 +
O
;$ % ( ( " ) + ( 4
( "
3 - &
$ 3 5
<$ ( 3
;$ ? 3 % (
" # YK V b'(c
H 4 7 ) )
% 5 " 4 4 (
@ ( 4 " 3 ( 4
" ( ) ( 5 % & 8 3 (
4 "" " + 4 4 4 ( (
5
( 4 4 4 3 ( P&

10. 3 ( ( 4 ( &
$ % 5 4 # $ + 4 A &
## ) 4 4 ) + # ($ ) (
$$
<$ A 4 I " + 4 4 B # $& ( % 5
4 # $ ( ) ( , / 2
;$ A 3 ( 4 + 4 %( & ## ""
"" ) 3 $$ ,% ( 2+ ( 4 5%
! " # $ "" ( 4 , 2+
( C 33 +
9% ( 4 ( 6 ( --
/$ A ) - 5 - 5 4 4+ ) 4
3 "
6 ( 3 - &
$ 5 3 ( 3 % :
<$ 3 ( 3 %
;$ - % 3 B (:
" #
" + ( &
$ 4 4 +
<$ 4 "
a Id
H 4 '"" 4
( +
% - ) + ) ( 3 ( 3
( 3 + 4 4 4 &
" # a I
"$ ! # e . a I
" # Ff V
" #
" # + ( - "
( 3 &
( 3 ( 4 % A 3 # $ & C C C
6 C 3
( 3 " " & 9=
G Q% D : % = # $
( 3 ( 4 9% # $ 4
( @ % , - & I M
# $+ I H # 3 $
4 4 4 4 5 &

11. 4 + 4 A 3 + + 5 :
( 3 - 4 " 3 ( 4 '
" + ( 4 4
4 4 ) 4 ) " - 4&
$ ( 3 ) +
<$ 4 4 5 +
;$ 4 ) 4 ! " # $
( 5 4 " &
( " &
$ % $ & %f(h i[/U' # C : $
( ) " 4 + 3 (
) " &
j
'
j
j l U /
<$ % & j mFHK i[/U' # C 3 $
'
' oFHp )k' /
H 4 " + 4 4
( + ) + + &
$ + + " & ! " # $
<$ " I " + " 5
5 4& 5 C - 4 " +
4 5 C &
& & + " ( ) +
C & & + ( - 4
- " ( 3 4 C 5 C (
" ) 5 C A 3
H 4
( + 5 + 4O 5
! " # $
5 4& " " 5 # - $+
" + + ( 3 ( 4
3+ I " ( 3 ( ) + ) )
4 " 3 3 + ( I " +

12. " " ( 3 ( (
4 4 4 &
$ 5 " C
" ( 3 ( 4 +
I "
<$ + " % 4 % + 3 ( ( 3 (
% & 8 3 # C $
" A 4 " ( "
5 " 4 ! " # $ (
;$ % " ( " 5 &
$ ( 5 +
<$ " + +
;$ ( : 4 ( + +
/$ ( 4 &
$ +
<$ " 4
( 4 +
3 3 + ( 4
" +
;$ 4 ( 4 I " +
/$ 4 ) ( ( 3 ( 4
+ "
F (< )k'
( I " " ) 4
! " # $+ 4 4 + " %
3 " ) 4 I " 9% : G
4 & 8 " +
I " 5 % 4
( 4 I " + "
6 ( 3 &
$ % (
<$ %
;$ B 5 3 5%
H 4 8 3 +
( ( ) 4
4& 5 ( C 5 4
8 5 C ( &
$ ( ) 4 & 5 C 5
<$ ( ) 4 & 5 5 C
;$ 4 4 & 5 C 5
l U /

13. H 4 I +
4 ( + ( ) 4 3
" ( ) + "" +
Q C Q ( & ( + +
5 C 5 % C 5 4 " + "
4& 5 4 + ( 3 ( 4
( n !
H 4 4 4
4 3 4 ""
" & ( - " &
$
<$ 3
$ @( 'A n
" ( + ( + 4
( 4 ( ) " + 4 4 8
3 " " 3 + (
+ ( ) " +
( 3 + " C
3 4 ( 4 ( ) + & 3
& 3 & + ( ) ( 4 &
& ( 3
" #
FHp S('L1 V @( 'A n q "&
" 4 + 4 (
8 " 4 4
# ( 3 $
! ! n
" & % 4 3 (
"" 4 ( 3 4 ( ( (
3 ( ) + 3 ( #%$& (
( 3 #A$& ( #I$
#%$, 2 #A$,( 32 #I$, 2 A 4 4 #%$, 2
#I$, 2 + "" 4 ( 3 + 4 "
#%$ #I$ " ( %
( ( 3 ( " 4 ( &
A C 8 8
<$ ! r 6M n
( 3 + 4 ) 3 + 3
( 3 ( + 4
4 4 4 &
$ & ) 4 5 &

14. <$ ( & ) + C 4
" (
;$ 3 & ""
7 ( " " " &
&
$ 3 ( #9 ((
$
<$ 4 3 ( + "
(
;$ 3 ( 3
/$ ) 4 + ( 4 "
4
>$ 3 4 4
3 &
$ 3 ( 3
<$ ) 4 + ( 4 "
4
;$ 3 4 4
/$ 4 + 3 ""
5
4 4 4 &
) " 5 + ( " 4&
$ 5 - 4 + )
3 , " " 2
<$ " + (
3 " % ( # 4 4
$ " , " " 2
( ) P J &
$ 4 ( 3 +
<$ A "
6 ( 3 &
$ @ A 4
<$ ( ( 3 @ " "
;$ A
/$ 5 % C ( : -
" # oFHp )k' /
3 ( ) + ) + )
4 + 4 ( 4 & &
( ) P A ( &
$ # $ ) 3 4

15. <$ 4 ) 3
;$ ( " ( ( 3 #
( ) ( : $
4& 5
6 ( 3 &
$ @ A 4
4& #9 $
4 # $ 3 # C 5$P + ) 4 ( 4 &
$ 3 (
<$ ,8 ( 4 - 2& " " + (
+ ( ( 4 " ( ( 4
" &
$ 4
<$ ( " ( C )
% 4 ( &
$ + A 3 +
<$ ( " 4 " + 9%
: 5
;$ 3 ( + % 9%
)
4& # $ , 2&
4&
$ % 3 (
<$ - #9 $ " (
( - &
+ ) ( ( #9 $
) ( " # $ % 4 9 + &
$ H 4 # 3 $ K ]3^/
<$ A 4 4 # 3 $ ]3^/( Z 56!
;$ '" # C$ & "
/$ ) # 5 $ Z: /
>$ 4 3 ( # - $ K
% 4 + &
$ ! # :$ D/H u, '
<$ I 4 # 3 C $
;$ 3 4 O 4 4 3 #3 ( $ fV+? )y /x*

16. /$ 4 ( ( 3 # 4 $
>$ 3 # 4 $
( 4 " ( 3 + 4 4 ( ( 3 &
" #
H 4 4 " (
+ ) ! " # $
) & ( ) ( 3 "
( + 4 " ( 3
4 4 4 & ) 4 " "
"
( P 3 ( ) + &
$ 4
<$ ( 4 + 4 4 3
5
;$ ( + 4 7 "" "
/$ + 4 4 4 4
7 ( " " &
$ 4 4 ( ( + 4 4 ( " " 4 )
4 4 4
<$ "" (
;$ 3 + ( 3
/$ 3 4 + 4 ) "
>$ 3 4 4
1$ 3 4 + 4 "
6 ( 3 &
$ @ ( 5 B (:
<$ H 5 ( 5
;$ : 5 5 9 5 ( 5 9 C @
H 4 % +
( 4
7 4 4&
$ " 4 + " "
<$ 3 ( ) "
H ) ( 3 # ( 3 4 4 : - $&
$ ( 5
<$ 3

17. ;$ 3
/$ 5
>$ -
1$ C
E$
I 3 + 4 ( "
H 4 + "
$ ( ( +
4 " # C : - $
<$ ( ( 3 "
( 3 &
( " (
3 ( ( 3 " (
) & ) ( 3 # 5 - $
5 3 4 4
% ( "" + 4
" # Z I 8 ( &
$ + "" +
<$
9 &
% 4 + % + A 3 + % C
( " 4 9 &
$ % 4 "
<$
;$ ' # $ #<$
( 9 ) P A 4 4 4 (
8 5 P&
$ + 4 (C + 5
<$ #( $
6 ( 3 5 &
$ @ 9
<$ %
;$ 5 ( 5 7 - %
/$ 5 @ 5 4
>$ ? 5 C #( 4 ) $

18. 3 C # 4 $ ) " &
$ j
<$ '
;$ j c('+? k ! F" N /
/$ j ] d /
>$ '
H 4 4 4
( + ( 4
(
( " &
$ - @( 'A |L T & ( + 4
+ 4 "" ( 4
+ ( 3
"
<$ - !; |L T & ( 4 ( + (
" % " &
$ - 4 4 #( $+ 4 3
C "" + 3
"
<$ - # ) $+ 4 "
( C 4
;$ -
I - 6 &
$ I 4
<$ J 4 " 4
;$ J " 4 (
( ) P A ) ( + &
$ " ( "
<$
;$
/$ " 4 ! " 5 # $ 4
4 -& 4 " 4 ( +
: G
6 ( 3 -&
$ 6 ( - C @ A 4
<$ C - - -
H 4 4

19. I 4 4 ( 4
" &
$ C + ( ( &
$ 5 ) + 4 @ 5 +
@ 5
<$ " " + " 4 (
' ( 4
<$ C + ( ( &
$ ( ( ) + 4 ( " %
) ( % ( +
( & ( 4 ) 4 3 (
( 4 ) ( 4 4 5 3 + ) 4&
3 ( ( 4 4 ) , A 3 2
<$ M ) 4 4 ) 4 +
" + 3 " " A 4 A 3
7 " 4 C + &
$ " ( + " " " 4
$ 5 "
$
4 4 4 C ]}/~A N# C $ K
$ # $+ ( + ) ) 4 4
<$ + " ( ( "
4
;$ 3 + ( + "
" ( 3
% ( C & ( 3
6 ( 3 &
$ 7 5 C % ( % C @ A 4
: # $ c('+? k ! F" N /
% 4
I - &
$ ( " ( ( " (
<$ " ( ( 4
3 + 4 + " + &
( + ( " " + (
( # C 5$+ ( 3
! 4 &
$ ( " + ( " 4 9 # $+

20. 4 C 5 7 " &
<$ " 4 3 + " "
+ 7 " & 4
" + 3 ) )
6 ( 3 &
$ : : % @
]
H 4 4
( " + C 4
( " &
$ 4 +
<$ % 4 C 4 + " )
" " + " ( +
" &
$ ' TdT ] #( $+ 4 % A 3
& ) ( C & +
" " ( % C+ " "
( + " 4 4 + 4 ( O 4
% A 3 + 5 9% ( %
" " )
<$ !; ] + 4 6 & L
4 " ( G 3 ( ) - 5 &
4 " ( G 3 5 C & (
" (
6 ( P&
$ 4 ( " ( +
<$ 4 " " " 4 4
( 3 &
( ) " ( 4
6 ( 3 &
$ ? C -
H 4 % 3
I 4 4 ( ( "
( 4 4
" &
$ 8 &
$

21. <$
<$ &
$ # $+ 4
<$ 5 # 4$+ 4
;$ 8 4 ( 4&
$ ( 4 # : $
<$ 4 # 5 ( $+ 4 " ( 4 +
" + 4 % 5% : & 8 " " + " "
9% : + % 5 4 # $ "
! " # $ " ( 5% : ( 4 5% :
( ) " ( # $ 3 4 " (
: - ) &
$ # ) $+ 3 4 A +
<$ # ) ( 4$
P&
$ + ( "
<$ ( ) + ( " ( "
" 4 ) &
( 4 3 3
6 ( 3 &
$ C
<$ @ @
;$ % % 3
" && #*
H 4
( "
8 &
: # N $&
"" + (
4&
5 -
: "
JV ( Z (5t/ 4 3 (
" 3 (
&

22. $ + " +
<$ ) + 4 "
;$ + 4 3 +
J " # $& A @ A +
+ % + % 5 %
4 4 " " "
" - &
$ ! & ( "
4 4 4 "
( P A ( 4 &
$ +
<$ " 4 + (
<$ S( )S T5t ' & ( 3 ( (
( +
4 4 4 ) ( - + -
;$ ' "+ ,#& 4 (
4 -
8 " 4 3
P ( " ) ( +
) (
6 ( 3 - &
$ %( B 5 ( C @
<$ 8
;$ % % 3 @
/$ ( 8 5 C
Z: /
( " &
$ 5 3 y 4H^ )Z: & ( 3 3 "
<$ 5 C ZU H )Z: & ( 3 " C 3
4 4 4 ) &
$ 5 " + 5 -
<$ " + 4 - 5 " (
( &
$ ) +

23. <$ ( "" )
) u, 'D/H " !#
' ( : ( 3
" &
$ ' ( ( ( 4 %
5
<$ ' ( ( 3+ 4 + 4 3 4 +
3
4 &
$ % 4 + 5 -
<$ % 4 + &
$ 8 3 ( ) " 3 "
<$ 8 " 3 -
;$ ( 3 ( ( ( + - 4 "
(
"+ ,#
( " ( ( 3 " O ""
3 + -
I 4 &
$ F' )U ) </
( ! " # $ H + J 4
( ) &
$ % + 4 ( 4 % C + 4
% ( 4 ! " # $
<$ ! " ( "+ C
;$ ( C )
I " C & %
9% 7 5 ( + ( <E<
<$
H 4 7 "
! " # $
;$
H 4 "
I "
I " + 4 (C : G
4 " " @ &
$ 5& 3

24. <$ (C &
( 4 4 5 &
" ) "" (C 4 ) 4 4 5
6 " &
$ 4 I " ( 3 ( " 4 ! " A 3+ 4 (
" ( + 4
$ 4 " +
<$
<$ I " 5 4& 8 ! " # $
;$ I " 5 4& 8 ( + 8 ( +
6
/$ I " 4 )
% (C " "
/$
H 4 I
5 + 4 A &
"
= 4 5 + 4 5
+ C 5 C 5
H 4 %
( 3 ! " # $
k ! / (
H 4 I
( ( 5 (C
% 3 5 4 + 4
: G
: C v(Uwx v @( •
( " (
) 4 ) &
% A 3 9% G
% 5 B -
% 8
8 &
$ (
<$ 4 ( (C 5+

25. 4 : ) &
$ ( " +
<$ ( - +
;$ - " " "
) + ( ( ( 4 &
$ ( ( " + "
<$ ( ( " +
-
;$ ( " + (
3 &
$ 7 +
<$ ! 4 4
% ( ( "
4 + ( + (
5 (C + ) 4 4 &
$ 4 4 ) ) ( 5 #
" $
<$ 4 4 ) ) ( (C #
- $ , 4 4 2
;$ 4 4 ) ) -
/$ 4 4 ) ) (
L( !:A
M 4 " "
l (! / ( l (!
( ( 4 C " ( 4
4+ 4 " I "
f(M
( ( 4 C " ( 4
4 4+ I "
5 " ( 4 " "
"" # ( 5 $
% 4 &
5 "" 4 ( ( 4+ ( "
I " +
"" 4 ( 4+ ( "
I "
% 4 ( " " + "" 4
4
H 4 %4
4 4

26. ( 3 &
$ " & #+ 4 ( 4 4
<$ y TW(~ ZI (!T "& #+ - ( 4 (
4 ( +
J " #C - $& ( 5 " = 3+
9% + 9= % 5 4 # $ & ## ( +
( 3 + )
" $$
" " 4 ( ( 4 " 3 "
5 + ( 4 4 + 3 " ( +
( 4 ( 4
( ) 4 5 ( 5 + 5 + 5 C
&
$ % 5 + ( A 3 " 9%
5 3 ( 5 5 ( 4
<$ % 5 C + ( @ : " ( 9%
G + 4 9% 5= ( 5 5
( 4
;$ % + ( " (
9% ! " # $+ ( 5 5 ( 4
& % ( 7 A 3+