Improving safety in lithium-ion batteries using thermally stable separators including ceramic coatings. Ceramics Expos April 26, 2016. Richard Clark, Senior Technical Specialist, Morgan Advanced Materials.
Call for Papers - International Journal of Intelligent Systems and Applicatio...
Morgan Advanced Materials, Ceramics Expo
1. www.morganadvancedmaterials.com
Improving safety in lithium-ion batteries
using thermally stable separators
including ceramic coatings
Ceramics Expo April 26, 2016
Richard Clark richard.clark@morganplc.com
2. Contents
• Overview of Morgan Advanced Materials
• Role and types of separators in lithium ion batteries
• Separators – market situation
• Introduction to advanced non-woven separators
• Questions
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 2
04/05/2016
3. Morgan Advanced Materials
Founded in England in 1856
Ticker on LSE: MGAM
2015 revenue: GBP911.8 million (USD1.3 billion)
2 Divisions and 6 Global Business Units
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 3
04/05/2016
4. Focus on technically demanding, growth markets
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 4
04/05/2016
Energy
Electronics
Healthcare
Transportation
Security and Defence
PetrochemicalIndustrial
5. Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 5
04/05/2016
Morgan Advanced Materials
Global Business Units
Thermal Ceramics
Molten Metal Systems
Electrical Carbon
Seals and Bearings
Technical Ceramics
Composites and Defense
Systems
indicates GBU with one or
more LIB industry solutions
6. Contents
• Overview of Morgan Advanced Materials
• Role and types of separators in lithium ion batteries
• Separators – market situation
• Introduction to advanced non-woven separators
• Questions
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 6
04/05/2016
7. Ceramics in lithium-ion battery separators
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 7
In 2000, for ion permeable separators, the market was
essentially 100% polyolefin, but by 2015 ceramic is included
in 44% (by area)
04/05/2016
Separators
Ion conducting
Polymer (gel)
PVDF
Ceramic or
glass
NaSICON,
others
Ion permeable
Polymer
Porous:
PE / PP /
PVDF
Fibrous:
Non-woven
Ceramic /
composite
Alumina,
Zirconia,
Silica
Shift is primarily based on drive for safety and
market changes in product type and cell size
Market data from Christophe Pillot, Avicenne
8. Lithium-ion batteries and role of separator
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 8
04/05/2016
Source: Argonne National Laboratory, used under Creative Commons license
(https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/2.0/legalcode)
• Main battery components
• Anode
• Cathode
• Electrolyte
• Separator
• Separator has three jobs
• Barrier to electrodes
• Window to ions
• Reservoir for electrolyte
• Ideal separator would take up no space,
weigh nothing and be free!
• Separators also play a key role in battery
performance and in safety
9. Features of separators
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 9
04/05/2016
Characteristic Control parameters
Barrier to
electrodes
Thickness,
mechanical strength,
dielectric strength
Ion conduction Air permeability, ionic
resistance, tortuosity,
pore size, pore
distribution
Electrolyte
reservoir
Porosity, wettability
Feature Importance for battery
Chemical
stability
Safety, cycle life
Thickness and
pore size
Capacity and power
Shut-down
feature
Safety (thermal
runaway)
Thermal
stability
Low shrinkage, high
temperature integrity
Uniformity Cell balancing
Features data derived from Polypore 2012 Investor Day presentation; Market information supplied by and used with permission of Christophe Pillot, Avicenne, “The
Rechargeable Battery Market and Main Trends 2015 to 2025”, Lithium Battery International Summit, Shenzhen, China, April 9 to 12, 2016
10. Contents
• Overview of Morgan Advanced Materials
• Role and types of separators in lithium ion batteries
• Separators – market situation
• Introduction to advanced non-woven separators
• Questions
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 10
04/05/2016
11. Market situation and development
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 11
04/05/2016
LIB separator market, M$,
CAGR 2005/2015: +16%
Average selling price (2015) = US$1.24/m2
LIB separator supplier,
market share (US$) in 2015
Others: TDK/Nitto Denko, Foshan Jinhui Hi-Tech,
Shenzhen Senior Technology Material, Xinxiang Green
next Energy, DuPont,…
Information supplied by and used with permission of Christophe Pillot, Avicenne, “The Rechargeable Battery Market
and Main Trends 2015 to 2025”, Lithium Battery International Summit, Shenzhen, China, April 9 to 12, 2016
12. Continuing rapid growth – CAGR 12% for next decade
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 12
04/05/2016
Assumptions (1)From 900 million m² in 2015 to almost
3000 million m² in 2025
(1) Taking into account cell and pack process yield
Information supplied by and used with permission of Christophe Pillot, Avicenne, “The Rechargeable Battery Market and Main Trends 2015 to 2025”, Lithium Battery
International Summit, Shenzhen, China, April 9 to 12, 2016
13. The number of patent applications for lithium battery
separators has increased rapidly since 1990
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 13
04/05/2016
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Numberofapplications/
interval
Applications
Polyolefin
Cellulose
Ceramic
Non-woven
Notes:
a) Search conducted using PatSnap® of patent applications including “Separator” in title and
“Lithium” and “Separator” in claims - other terms listed were also in claims
b) “Polyolefin” search incorporated “Polyethylene”, “Polypropylene” and “PTFE”
c) “Ceramic” search incorporated “Alumina”
d) Numbers are of INPADOC family representatives
14. Contents
• Overview of Morgan Advanced Materials
• Role and types of separators in lithium ion batteries
• Separators – market situation
• Introduction to advanced non-woven separators
• Questions
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 14
04/05/2016
15. DreamWeaver Technology: Nanofiber nonwovens from
advanced fibers stable >500°C
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 15
04/05/2016
• Nanofiber on microfiber
• Nanofibers form good barrier
• Microfibers give open structure
• Good window
• Microfibers also add strength
• Has potential to be thinnest high
temperature separator in the world
Advantages
• Temperature stability
• Safety
• Chemical stability
• Rate capabilityImages and information provided by and used with
permission of Dr. Brian Morin, CEO, DreamWeaver
16. 170°C hot box performance test
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 16
04/05/2016
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
0:00:00 0:14:24 0:28:48 0:43:12 0:57:36 1:12:00 1:26:24 1:40:48
Temperature(C)
PP Ceramic Temp Silver Temp Gold Temp
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
0:00:00 0:14:24 0:28:48 0:43:12 0:57:36 1:12:00 1:26:24 1:40:48
PP Ceramic Voltage Silver Voltage Gold Voltage
Temperature vs Time Voltage vs Time
Polyolefin separators failed at softening point of polymer. DWI separators did not fail.
Images and information provided by and used with
permission of Dr. Brian Morin, CEO, DreamWeaver
17. Nail penetration performance test
Voltage
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 17
04/05/2016
00
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
0:00:00 0:07:12 0:14:24 0:21:36
Voltage(V)
PP Voltage Ceramic PE Voltage
DWI Silver Voltage DWI Gold Voltage
15
35
55
75
95
115
135
0:00:00 0:07:12 0:14:24 0:21:36
Temperature(C)
PP Temp Ceramic PE Temp
DWI Silver Temp DWI Gold Temp
Temperature
DWI Silver & Gold maintained their voltage
and functionality during the test, unlike
polyolefin separators
DWI Silver & Gold had slower temperature
increase and reached a lower maximum
temperature than polyolefin separators Images and information provided by and used with
permission of Dr. Brian Morin, CEO, DreamWeaver
18. Nail penetration test – standard PP material
• Maximum cell temperature 75°C
• Significant shrinkage around nail
• Significant shrinkage far from nail
• Splitting character around nail
• Anisotropic tear characteristics
• Significant exposed electrode
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 18
04/05/2016
Images and information provided by and used with permission of Dr. Brian Morin, CEO, DreamWeaver
19. Nail penetration test – standard PE/Ceramic material
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 19
04/05/2016
• Maximum cell temperature 115 °C
• Significant shrinkage around nail
• Cracking and splitting around nail
• Isotropic strength character
• Significant exposed electrode
Images and information provided by and used with permission of Dr. Brian Morin, CEO, DreamWeaver
20. Nail penetration test – DreamWeaver Silver
• Maximum cell temperature 63°C
• No shrinkage
• No cracking or splitting
• Physical damage from nail
penetration
• Some charring around nail
• No visible exposed electrode
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 20
04/05/2016
21. Nail penetration test – DreamWeaver Gold
• Maximum cell temperature 41°C
• No shrinkage
• No cracking or splitting
• Physical damage from nail
penetration
• No charring
• No visible exposed electrode
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 21
04/05/2016
22. Nail penetration: what is happening
Morgan Advanced Materials Confidential Information 22
04/05/2016
• Prior to test, electrodes are isolated
• Nail closes circuit from aluminum to copper
• HEAT is generated
• Traditional Separator
• Heat melts and cracks separator
• Anode and cathode touch
• Electrical short persists
• Thermal runaway
• DWI Thermally Stable Separator
• Separator is stable: some charring, but no shrinkage
• Anode and cathode remain isolated
• Aluminum melts or oxidizes
• Electrical short is broken
• No thermal runaway
Aluminum shutdown breaks circuit
before separator failure creates
permanent closed circuit
Images and information provided by and used with permission of Dr. Brian Morin, CEO, DreamWeaver