SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Paper Review Form
View:
Manuscript
Author's Comments
Close Comments

Author's Comments
Date Comments

I am ____ qualified to review this paper:

Well

Moderately

Has the essence of this paper been previously
published, to the best of your knowledge?

Yes

No

Minimally

Scores
Scores range from 1 to 10 with 1 being low and 10 being high.
Archival

Innovative

Integrity

Presentation

Quality

Conclusions

Manuscript
Rate:

Approved

Approved if Modified

Recommendations
Recommend for Journals:
Add Comments
Add Comment

Yes

No

Disapproved

More Related Content

More from Kamal Vora

Dfmea for engine systems
Dfmea for engine systemsDfmea for engine systems
Dfmea for engine systems
Kamal Vora
 

More from Kamal Vora (9)

Writing a good book review
Writing a good book reviewWriting a good book review
Writing a good book review
 
Personal branding & self assessment.ppt
Personal branding & self assessment.pptPersonal branding & self assessment.ppt
Personal branding & self assessment.ppt
 
Dfmea for engine systems
Dfmea for engine systemsDfmea for engine systems
Dfmea for engine systems
 
Dr. vora ppt chapter 6 crs
Dr. vora ppt chapter 6 crsDr. vora ppt chapter 6 crs
Dr. vora ppt chapter 6 crs
 
Dr. vora ppt chapter 5 diesel aftertreatment
Dr. vora ppt chapter 5 diesel aftertreatmentDr. vora ppt chapter 5 diesel aftertreatment
Dr. vora ppt chapter 5 diesel aftertreatment
 
Dr. vora ppt chapter 4 aftertreatment
Dr. vora ppt chapter 4 aftertreatmentDr. vora ppt chapter 4 aftertreatment
Dr. vora ppt chapter 4 aftertreatment
 
Dr. vora ppt chapter 3 emission control
Dr. vora ppt chapter 3 emission controlDr. vora ppt chapter 3 emission control
Dr. vora ppt chapter 3 emission control
 
Dr. vora ppt chapter 2 emission formation
Dr. vora ppt chapter 2 emission formationDr. vora ppt chapter 2 emission formation
Dr. vora ppt chapter 2 emission formation
 
Dr. vora ppt chapter 1 emission sources
Dr. vora ppt chapter 1 emission sourcesDr. vora ppt chapter 1 emission sources
Dr. vora ppt chapter 1 emission sources
 

Recently uploaded

Catalogue Yamaha Nouvo 115 S / Nouvo .pdf
Catalogue Yamaha Nouvo 115 S / Nouvo .pdfCatalogue Yamaha Nouvo 115 S / Nouvo .pdf
Catalogue Yamaha Nouvo 115 S / Nouvo .pdf
HafizLaziz
 
Solar Photovoltaic Plant Project Proposal by Slidesgo.pptx
Solar Photovoltaic Plant Project Proposal by Slidesgo.pptxSolar Photovoltaic Plant Project Proposal by Slidesgo.pptx
Solar Photovoltaic Plant Project Proposal by Slidesgo.pptx
AmarHaddad
 
Battery Management System Functions (Flowchart of BMS Operations)
Battery Management System Functions (Flowchart of BMS Operations)Battery Management System Functions (Flowchart of BMS Operations)
Battery Management System Functions (Flowchart of BMS Operations)
Electric Vehicle Geek
 
Car Seat Covers and Seat Protection Guide
Car Seat Covers and Seat Protection GuideCar Seat Covers and Seat Protection Guide
Car Seat Covers and Seat Protection Guide
AskXX.com
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Basic of Firmware & Embedded Software Programming in C
Basic of Firmware & Embedded Software Programming in CBasic of Firmware & Embedded Software Programming in C
Basic of Firmware & Embedded Software Programming in C
 
Battery Management System Circuit Diagram.pdf
Battery Management System Circuit Diagram.pdfBattery Management System Circuit Diagram.pdf
Battery Management System Circuit Diagram.pdf
 
Torque converter In automobile engineering
Torque converter In automobile engineeringTorque converter In automobile engineering
Torque converter In automobile engineering
 
-VDA-Special-Characteristics Special characteristics.pdf
-VDA-Special-Characteristics Special characteristics.pdf-VDA-Special-Characteristics Special characteristics.pdf
-VDA-Special-Characteristics Special characteristics.pdf
 
Catalogue Yamaha Nouvo 115 S / Nouvo .pdf
Catalogue Yamaha Nouvo 115 S / Nouvo .pdfCatalogue Yamaha Nouvo 115 S / Nouvo .pdf
Catalogue Yamaha Nouvo 115 S / Nouvo .pdf
 
Solar Photovoltaic Plant Project Proposal by Slidesgo.pptx
Solar Photovoltaic Plant Project Proposal by Slidesgo.pptxSolar Photovoltaic Plant Project Proposal by Slidesgo.pptx
Solar Photovoltaic Plant Project Proposal by Slidesgo.pptx
 
Nokia Drone Networks - Customer Presentation - MWC2.pdf
Nokia Drone Networks - Customer Presentation - MWC2.pdfNokia Drone Networks - Customer Presentation - MWC2.pdf
Nokia Drone Networks - Customer Presentation - MWC2.pdf
 
Battery Management System Functions (Flowchart of BMS Operations)
Battery Management System Functions (Flowchart of BMS Operations)Battery Management System Functions (Flowchart of BMS Operations)
Battery Management System Functions (Flowchart of BMS Operations)
 
Timer Handling in UDS | S3 Server Timer | P2 and P2 Start Timer
Timer Handling in UDS | S3 Server Timer | P2 and P2 Start TimerTimer Handling in UDS | S3 Server Timer | P2 and P2 Start Timer
Timer Handling in UDS | S3 Server Timer | P2 and P2 Start Timer
 
Benefits of Load Planning in Fleet Management
Benefits of Load Planning in Fleet ManagementBenefits of Load Planning in Fleet Management
Benefits of Load Planning in Fleet Management
 
Car Seat Covers and Seat Protection Guide
Car Seat Covers and Seat Protection GuideCar Seat Covers and Seat Protection Guide
Car Seat Covers and Seat Protection Guide
 
Automotive Bootloader Complete Guide with UDS Frame Format
Automotive Bootloader Complete Guide with UDS Frame FormatAutomotive Bootloader Complete Guide with UDS Frame Format
Automotive Bootloader Complete Guide with UDS Frame Format
 
Introduction to Automotive Bootloader | Programming Sequence
Introduction to Automotive Bootloader | Programming SequenceIntroduction to Automotive Bootloader | Programming Sequence
Introduction to Automotive Bootloader | Programming Sequence
 
CAMIONES TOYOTA N04C- Engine y HINO 300.
CAMIONES TOYOTA N04C- Engine y HINO 300.CAMIONES TOYOTA N04C- Engine y HINO 300.
CAMIONES TOYOTA N04C- Engine y HINO 300.
 
Introduction to UDS over CAN | UDS Service
Introduction to UDS over CAN | UDS ServiceIntroduction to UDS over CAN | UDS Service
Introduction to UDS over CAN | UDS Service
 
technical report on EV. EVs can offer benefitssuch as lower operating costs a...
technical report on EV. EVs can offer benefitssuch as lower operating costs a...technical report on EV. EVs can offer benefitssuch as lower operating costs a...
technical report on EV. EVs can offer benefitssuch as lower operating costs a...
 
Is Your Porsche Cayenne Radio On The Fritz Here's What It Could Mean
Is Your Porsche Cayenne Radio On The Fritz Here's What It Could MeanIs Your Porsche Cayenne Radio On The Fritz Here's What It Could Mean
Is Your Porsche Cayenne Radio On The Fritz Here's What It Could Mean
 
Quicker and better: South Korea’s new high-speed train 'EMU-320'
Quicker and better: South Korea’s new high-speed train 'EMU-320'Quicker and better: South Korea’s new high-speed train 'EMU-320'
Quicker and better: South Korea’s new high-speed train 'EMU-320'
 
What Should BMW Owners Know About Steptronic Transmission Problems
What Should BMW Owners Know About Steptronic Transmission ProblemsWhat Should BMW Owners Know About Steptronic Transmission Problems
What Should BMW Owners Know About Steptronic Transmission Problems
 
Car Audio Systems Enhancing Your Driving Experience
Car Audio Systems Enhancing Your Driving ExperienceCar Audio Systems Enhancing Your Driving Experience
Car Audio Systems Enhancing Your Driving Experience
 

SAE Paper Review Form

  • 1. Paper Review Form View: Manuscript Author's Comments Close Comments Author's Comments Date Comments I am ____ qualified to review this paper: Well Moderately Has the essence of this paper been previously published, to the best of your knowledge? Yes No Minimally Scores Scores range from 1 to 10 with 1 being low and 10 being high. Archival Innovative Integrity Presentation Quality Conclusions Manuscript Rate: Approved Approved if Modified Recommendations Recommend for Journals: Add Comments Add Comment Yes No Disapproved