SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 44
Joel Dreessen
11/10/2015
2015 Ozone Exceedance Days
22
2
3
0
3
4
14
15
20
2
8
33
DC
VA
Notes:
* 2015 Data is Preliminary
** Data Provided by Tom Downs (ME)
2015 Maryland Ozone SummaryMetropolitan Statistical Area (Group Number)
Dailymax8-hourozoneconc.(ppb)
Dailynumberofsiteswithanoccurrence
1 2 3 4 5 6
Aldino
Davidsonville
Edgewood
Essex
Furley
Padonia
SouthCarroll
Calvert
PGEquest.Ctr.
Frederick
Airport
HowardU.
Beltsville*
Rockville
So.Maryland
FairHill
Blackwater
NWR*
Millington
HornPoint
Hagerstown
PineyRun
2014 Design
Value 73 74 75 72 64 72 69 73 76 70 70 75 68 71 77 70 74 73 67 68
06/11/2015 83 81 88 86 83 100 100 6
08/07/2015 79 79 1
08/15/2015 76 76 1
9/02/2015 88 77 88 2
9/04/2015 80 78 79 80 3
9/16/2015 76 82 78 76 81 79 82 6
9/17/2015 83 82 77 78 83 4
9/18/2015 76 78 78 2
2015 DV 70 69 71 68 65 71 67 68 69 67 68 69 68 66 73 66 69 64 65 64
Number of days >75ppb
2015: 8
2014: 5
2013: 9
2012: 30
2011: 29
2010: 43
2009: 11
2015 Summary:
1) Second fewest since 1980
2) Four days with potential smoke influence; three
were exceedance days: Only 5 non-smoke exceedances
3) Two “single-monitor” exceedances
4) No “old school” exceedances
In 2015:
•8 days above
75ppb
2015 Maryland Ozone SummaryMetropolitan Statistical Area (Group Number)
Dailymax8-hourozoneconc.(ppb)
Dailynumberofsiteswithanoccurrence
1 2 3 4 5 6
Aldino
Davidsonville
Edgewood
Essex
Furley
Padonia
SouthCarroll
Calvert
PGEquest.Ctr.
Frederick
Airport
HowardU.
Beltsville*
Rockville
So.Maryland
FairHill
Blackwater
NWR*
Millington
HornPoint
Hagerstown
PineyRun
2014 Design
Value 73 74 75 72 64 72 69 73 76 70 70 75 68 71 77 70 74 73 67 68
06/11/2015 83 74 75 81 75 88 86 83 100 73 100 10
08/07/2015 79 79 1
08/15/2015 76 71 76 2
9/02/2015 72 88 74 72 73 77 88 6
9/04/2015 80 74 74 78 79 72 74 72 80 8
9/16/2015 76 72 82 78 76 81 79 72 72 82 9
9/17/2015 74 72 83 82 77 78 74 83 7
9/18/2015 75 76 78 78 3
2015 DV 70 69 71 68 65 71 67 68 69 67 68 69 68 66 73 66 69 64 65 64
Number of days >75ppb
2015: 8
2014: 5
2013: 9
2012: 30
2011: 29
2010: 43
2009: 11
2015 Summary:
1) Second fewest since 1980
2) Four days with potential smoke influence; three
were exceedance days: Only 5 non-smoke exceedances
3) Two “single-monitor” exceedances
4) No “old school” exceedances
In 2015:
•20 days
above 70ppb
Average: 31 days
Standard Deviation: 14 days
The number of 90 degree days is
extremely variable!
2 standard
deviations from
the mean
suggests a
strong outlier in
2010
MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEP
2 6 7 4 7
No. Days
each month
MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEP
11 16 23 20 12
Above average 85 degree days
(65). What has changed to not
have as many exceedances?
No. Days
each month
Source: NCDC Temperature and Precipitaiton Maps
Source: NCDC Temperature and Precipitaiton Maps
Source: NCDC Temperature and Precipitaiton Maps
Source: NCDC Temperature and Precipitaiton Maps
Source: NCDC Temperature and Precipitaiton Maps
Monthly CAMD Emissions from:
IN, OH, WV, VA, PA, MD, DC
Emissions of Indiana, Ohio, West Virginia, Virginia, Pennsylvania, Maryland and
the District of Columbia were summed together on a monthly basis
All Coal Units as of 2012
Non-Retiring, Non-SCR/SNCR
Controlled Coal Burning EGUs
Source region for NOx transport in to
Maryland has seen a drastic drop in TOTAL
ozone season (April – October) coal NOx
emissions. Approximately a 20% to 40%
reduction has occurred in the past 2 years,
compared to a 160,000 ton level.
Coal EGUs
Blue dots are EGUs
included in the NOx
summations below
Region bounded by
rectangle is roughly
the transport region
of Maryland
2009: 45135 fewer NOx tons emitted than in 2011
2010: 7011 fewer NOx tons emitted than in 2011
2012: 14830 fewer NOx tons emitted than in 2011
2013: 40462 fewer NOx tons emitted than in 2011
2014: 67983 fewer NOx tons emitted than in 2011
2015 Summary
• Relatively cool ozone season in the Midwest
– Cool and wet June and July in Midwest (upstream)
– Lowest emissions ever seen “upstream” of Maryland
• Warm in Maryland (much warmer than 2013 & 2014)
with slightly below average extreme heat
– 15th warmest year for maximum temperature (statewide)
– “Normal” July temperatures and precipitation (NCDC)
• No Exceedances
• Smoke was a big contributor this year – potentially 3
exceedance days with smoke influence
ALL CAMD EGUs (>25MW) O3 Season
NOx Emissions
NARR 1000m Trajectory Density for all Baltimore NAA Exceedance Days (1980-2014)
April – October
1589 Trajectories
This map is showing, by rank (1 is greatest, 37 least), which state’s summer cooling degree day (CDDs)
numbers most correlate with the number of Maryland’s ozone exceedance days. Indiana, Illinois and
Kentucky’s summer CDDs are the top three.
Correlation does not mean causation: Indiana’s CDDs correlate most with Maryland ozone exceedance days but this does not
mean Indiana is causing Maryland’s exceedances. It does mean that of all the states considered, Indiana’s temperature record
most closely follows Maryland ozone exceedance annual variability. It is also quite profound the lack of correlation between
Maryland CDDs and Maryland exceedance days.
“Strongly” Anti-correlated
Not Correlated
“Strongly” Correlated
The correlation between cooling degree days for
individual states with the number of Maryland ozone
exceedance days (1980-2013)
The highest correlation between cooling degree days and Maryland ozone exceedance days is found from
Iowa southeastward to Tennessee (red areas). This suggests that when these states experience a hot summer
Maryland is more likely to have a greater than average number of ozone exceedance days. Also, the
electrical demand of these states appears to be more closely connected to Maryland exceedance day annual
variability than other states. This correlation is likely due to the position of the continental ridge which is
stronger in some years than others. This CAN NOT be directly interpreted that any state showing a higher
correlation is actually causing the poor air quality (e.g., contains the actual emissions sources).
The GUT of Maryland’s Ozone
• In years with a weak Bermuda High
– Continental (U.S.) Highs/Ridges are more prevalent
– Increased temperatures across the Midwest
– Continental ridging near PBL top creates a long fetch across ORV
emissions (which are increased due to regionally higher
temperatures)
– Amplified lee-troughing with W to WSW surface winds due to
increase “mountain-top” orthogonal component
• This causes local I-95 transport within Maryland (Edgewood??)
• In years with a strong Bermuda High
– Continental Highs/Ridges are less prevalent
• 850mb flow is more cyclonic preventing ridging (and subsidence)
• Cooler temperatures across the MidWest (less emissions)
– Weaker lee-troughing (less orthogonal mountain flow)
– Less fetch from ORV (if any) entering Maryland (more across PA)
– Increased southerly winds and maritime influence (cleaner)
• Accounts for the wide variability in both O3 days and 90F days.
2010: Bad Year (43) 2011: Bad Year (29)
2013: Good Year (9) 2014: Good Year (5)
Composite Sea Level
Pressure (mb)
2015: May (Hot, bad AQ in Northeast) 2015: Sept (Hot, bad AQ along East Coast)
Cool in MW. No exceedances in Maryland except with smoke)
Composite Sea Level
Pressure (mb)
2015: June and July
BAD YEARS
Hot
2014
cool
2011: 29
2014: 5
Exceedance Days
2011
2014
Comparison of the atmosphere
Approximately 750 m above earth’s
surface. The largest differences between
a bad year such as 2011 and a clean year
in 2014 is:
•The strength of the Bermuda High in the
Western Atlantic (A)
• The amplitude of the Midwest
Continental Ridge, and (B)
•The shift in wind direction (angle of the
lines) across Maryland, which switches
from West-Northwest in 2011 to West-
Southwest (C)
(A)
(B)
(C)
2011: 29
2014: 5
Exceedance Days
Comparison of southerly wind strength
at the surface between 2011 and 2014
shows cleaner years have stronger
southerly winds. In fact, 2011, a dirty
year, has slightly northerly winds
(negative color – bright purple). The
largest differences between a bad year
such as 2011 and a clean year in 2014 is:
•The strength of the southerly winds in
Maryland (A)
2011
2014
(A)
a
WIND PROFILER – Beltsville, MD
b
42
4
4
12
10
8
6
6
September 16, 2015
September 17, 2015 September 18, 2015
OZONE LIDARS
H:SMOKEDMOVESJUL2011
2.58
Mobile Average Tons per Day: July 2018
June 11, 2015
Max 8-hour avg: 74 ppb
Region 1 (Day Of):
•Total NOx Mass: 24 Tons
•100% controlled
•0% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 1 Tons
•Bin 1 unit count: 4
•Bin 2 unit count: 5
•Bin 3 unit count: 0
Domain (3-Day Total):
•Total NOx Mass: 8,669 Tons
• 52% controlled
• 48% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 1,937 Tons
•3-Day Average:
•Daily NOx Mass: 2,890 Tons
•Daily Savings: 646 Tons/day
Region 2 (Day Before):
•Total NOx Mass: 241 Tons
•91% controlled
•9% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 141 Tons
•Bin 1 unit count: 3
•Bin 2 unit count: 17
•Bin 3 unit count: 13
Region 3 (2 Days Before):
•Total NOx Mass: 450 Tons
•64% controlled
•36% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 115 Tons
•Bin 1 unit count: 15
•Bin 2 unit count: 38
•Bin 3 unit count: 16
2015 BIAS Very low bias
Region wide
I-95 high bias
2015 RMSE Low RMSE
Region wide
I-95 RMSE
NYC & LI
SOUND RMSE
HORN POINT / BAY OVER-PREDICTION
2015 ERROR STDEV
July 11, 2014
Max 8-hour avg: 78 ppb
Region 1 (Day Of):
•Total NOx Mass: 5 Tons
•100% controlled
•0% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 1 Tons
•Bin 1 unit count: 0
•Bin 2 unit count: 3
•Bin 3 unit count: 0
Domain (3-Day Total):
•Total NOx Mass: 10,672Tons
• 50% controlled
• 50% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 2,258 Tons
•3-Day Average:
•Daily NOx Mass: 3,557 Tons
•Daily Savings: 753 Tons/day
Region 2 (Day Before):
•Total NOx Mass: 9 Tons
•88% controlled
•12% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 1 Tons
•Bin 1 unit count: 1
•Bin 2 unit count: 4
•Bin 3 unit count: 0
Region 3 (2 Days Before):
•Total NOx Mass: 148 Tons
•68% controlled
•32% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 44 Tons
•Bin 1 unit count: 8
•Bin 2 unit count: 28
•Bin 3 unit count: 2
July 18, 2013
Max 8-hour avg: 80 ppb
Region 1 (Day Of):
•Total NOx Mass: 91 Tons
•44% controlled
•56% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 14 Tons
•Bin 1 unit count: 2
•Bin 2 unit count: 3
•Bin 3 unit count: 1
Domain (3-Day Total):
•Total NOx Mass: 12,909 Tons
• 47% controlled
• 53% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 2,488 Tons
•3-Day Average:
•Daily NOx Mass: 4,303 Tons
•Daily Savings: 829 Tons/day
Region 2 (Day Before):
•Total NOx Mass: 164 Tons
•66% controlled
•34% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 68Tons
•Bin 1 unit count: 1
•Bin 2 unit count: 5
•Bin 3 unit count: 3
Region 3 (2 Days Before):
•Total NOx Mass: 260 Tons
•36% controlled
•64% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 51 Tons
•Bin 1 unit count: 3
•Bin 2 unit count: 7
•Bin 3 unit count: 3
July 19, 2013
Max 8-hour avg: 78 ppb
Region 1 (Day Of):
•Total NOx Mass: 56 Tons
•100% controlled
•0% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 21 Tons
•Bin 1 unit count: 3
•Bin 2 unit count: 6
•Bin 3 unit count: 1
Domain (3-Day Total):
•Total NOx Mass: 13,048 Tons
• 47% controlled
• 53% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 2,517 Tons
•3-Day Average:
•Daily NOx Mass: 4,349 Tons
•Daily Savings: 839 Tons/day
Region 2 (Day Before):
•Total NOx Mass: 167 Tons
•73% controlled
•27% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 65 Tons
•Bin 1 unit count: 4
•Bin 2 unit count: 16
•Bin 3 unit count: 5
Region 3 (2 Days Before):
•Total NOx Mass: 411 Tons
•76% controlled
•24% uncontrolled
•Potential savings: 155 Tons
•Bin 1 unit count: 6
•Bin 2 unit count: 32
•Bin 3 unit count: 12

More Related Content

Similar to 2015MetRoundTable

DreessenWorkingLunch_JuneSmoke2015
DreessenWorkingLunch_JuneSmoke2015DreessenWorkingLunch_JuneSmoke2015
DreessenWorkingLunch_JuneSmoke2015
Joel Dreessen
 
Climatology of High Impact Winter Weather Events for U.S. Transport Hubs
Climatology of High Impact Winter Weather Events for U.S. Transport HubsClimatology of High Impact Winter Weather Events for U.S. Transport Hubs
Climatology of High Impact Winter Weather Events for U.S. Transport Hubs
Dominique Watson
 
RPAC_Monthly_Report_Example
RPAC_Monthly_Report_ExampleRPAC_Monthly_Report_Example
RPAC_Monthly_Report_Example
Matthew B. Shaw
 
Glenn Peters, faglig innlegg MDG lsm 14.06.2014
Glenn Peters, faglig innlegg MDG lsm 14.06.2014Glenn Peters, faglig innlegg MDG lsm 14.06.2014
Glenn Peters, faglig innlegg MDG lsm 14.06.2014
partiet
 
TrailLecture
TrailLectureTrailLecture
TrailLecture
Hong Li
 

Similar to 2015MetRoundTable (20)

LES_POSTER
LES_POSTERLES_POSTER
LES_POSTER
 
Top-down constraints on the North American carbon cycle from the first decade...
Top-down constraints on the North American carbon cycle from the first decade...Top-down constraints on the North American carbon cycle from the first decade...
Top-down constraints on the North American carbon cycle from the first decade...
 
Top-down constraints on the North American carbon cycle from the first decade...
Top-down constraints on the North American carbon cycle from the first decade...Top-down constraints on the North American carbon cycle from the first decade...
Top-down constraints on the North American carbon cycle from the first decade...
 
Professor Lesley Hughes - IPCC climate science briefing event
Professor Lesley Hughes - IPCC climate science briefing  eventProfessor Lesley Hughes - IPCC climate science briefing  event
Professor Lesley Hughes - IPCC climate science briefing event
 
DreessenWorkingLunch_JuneSmoke2015
DreessenWorkingLunch_JuneSmoke2015DreessenWorkingLunch_JuneSmoke2015
DreessenWorkingLunch_JuneSmoke2015
 
CLIMATE CHANGE - UNEP.ppt
CLIMATE CHANGE - UNEP.pptCLIMATE CHANGE - UNEP.ppt
CLIMATE CHANGE - UNEP.ppt
 
envi..green
envi..greenenvi..green
envi..green
 
olhoff_e.ppt
olhoff_e.pptolhoff_e.ppt
olhoff_e.ppt
 
Climatology of High Impact Winter Weather Events for U.S. Transport Hubs
Climatology of High Impact Winter Weather Events for U.S. Transport HubsClimatology of High Impact Winter Weather Events for U.S. Transport Hubs
Climatology of High Impact Winter Weather Events for U.S. Transport Hubs
 
Workshop 1 - Aaron Wilson
Workshop 1 - Aaron WilsonWorkshop 1 - Aaron Wilson
Workshop 1 - Aaron Wilson
 
ICLR Forecast: 2019 Wildfire Season (May 17, 2019)
ICLR Forecast: 2019 Wildfire Season (May 17, 2019)ICLR Forecast: 2019 Wildfire Season (May 17, 2019)
ICLR Forecast: 2019 Wildfire Season (May 17, 2019)
 
2015 Ozone Standard Nonattainment Areas
2015 Ozone Standard Nonattainment Areas2015 Ozone Standard Nonattainment Areas
2015 Ozone Standard Nonattainment Areas
 
RPAC_Monthly_Report_Example
RPAC_Monthly_Report_ExampleRPAC_Monthly_Report_Example
RPAC_Monthly_Report_Example
 
Looking Beyond CRZ. by- Arun B. Inamdar
Looking Beyond CRZ. by- Arun B. Inamdar Looking Beyond CRZ. by- Arun B. Inamdar
Looking Beyond CRZ. by- Arun B. Inamdar
 
Glenn Peters, faglig innlegg MDG lsm 14.06.2014
Glenn Peters, faglig innlegg MDG lsm 14.06.2014Glenn Peters, faglig innlegg MDG lsm 14.06.2014
Glenn Peters, faglig innlegg MDG lsm 14.06.2014
 
ICLR wildfire season forecast 2021 (May 20, 2021)
ICLR wildfire season forecast 2021 (May 20, 2021)ICLR wildfire season forecast 2021 (May 20, 2021)
ICLR wildfire season forecast 2021 (May 20, 2021)
 
SST & Canes [Compatibility Mode]
SST & Canes [Compatibility Mode]SST & Canes [Compatibility Mode]
SST & Canes [Compatibility Mode]
 
Climate Review 2014-15 and NIDIS Update
Climate Review 2014-15 and NIDIS UpdateClimate Review 2014-15 and NIDIS Update
Climate Review 2014-15 and NIDIS Update
 
Kelly Redmond - US Drought Monitor Forum Presentation - April 14, 2015
Kelly Redmond - US Drought Monitor Forum Presentation - April 14, 2015Kelly Redmond - US Drought Monitor Forum Presentation - April 14, 2015
Kelly Redmond - US Drought Monitor Forum Presentation - April 14, 2015
 
TrailLecture
TrailLectureTrailLecture
TrailLecture
 

2015MetRoundTable

  • 2. 2015 Ozone Exceedance Days 22 2 3 0 3 4 14 15 20 2 8 33 DC VA Notes: * 2015 Data is Preliminary ** Data Provided by Tom Downs (ME)
  • 3. 2015 Maryland Ozone SummaryMetropolitan Statistical Area (Group Number) Dailymax8-hourozoneconc.(ppb) Dailynumberofsiteswithanoccurrence 1 2 3 4 5 6 Aldino Davidsonville Edgewood Essex Furley Padonia SouthCarroll Calvert PGEquest.Ctr. Frederick Airport HowardU. Beltsville* Rockville So.Maryland FairHill Blackwater NWR* Millington HornPoint Hagerstown PineyRun 2014 Design Value 73 74 75 72 64 72 69 73 76 70 70 75 68 71 77 70 74 73 67 68 06/11/2015 83 81 88 86 83 100 100 6 08/07/2015 79 79 1 08/15/2015 76 76 1 9/02/2015 88 77 88 2 9/04/2015 80 78 79 80 3 9/16/2015 76 82 78 76 81 79 82 6 9/17/2015 83 82 77 78 83 4 9/18/2015 76 78 78 2 2015 DV 70 69 71 68 65 71 67 68 69 67 68 69 68 66 73 66 69 64 65 64 Number of days >75ppb 2015: 8 2014: 5 2013: 9 2012: 30 2011: 29 2010: 43 2009: 11 2015 Summary: 1) Second fewest since 1980 2) Four days with potential smoke influence; three were exceedance days: Only 5 non-smoke exceedances 3) Two “single-monitor” exceedances 4) No “old school” exceedances In 2015: •8 days above 75ppb
  • 4. 2015 Maryland Ozone SummaryMetropolitan Statistical Area (Group Number) Dailymax8-hourozoneconc.(ppb) Dailynumberofsiteswithanoccurrence 1 2 3 4 5 6 Aldino Davidsonville Edgewood Essex Furley Padonia SouthCarroll Calvert PGEquest.Ctr. Frederick Airport HowardU. Beltsville* Rockville So.Maryland FairHill Blackwater NWR* Millington HornPoint Hagerstown PineyRun 2014 Design Value 73 74 75 72 64 72 69 73 76 70 70 75 68 71 77 70 74 73 67 68 06/11/2015 83 74 75 81 75 88 86 83 100 73 100 10 08/07/2015 79 79 1 08/15/2015 76 71 76 2 9/02/2015 72 88 74 72 73 77 88 6 9/04/2015 80 74 74 78 79 72 74 72 80 8 9/16/2015 76 72 82 78 76 81 79 72 72 82 9 9/17/2015 74 72 83 82 77 78 74 83 7 9/18/2015 75 76 78 78 3 2015 DV 70 69 71 68 65 71 67 68 69 67 68 69 68 66 73 66 69 64 65 64 Number of days >75ppb 2015: 8 2014: 5 2013: 9 2012: 30 2011: 29 2010: 43 2009: 11 2015 Summary: 1) Second fewest since 1980 2) Four days with potential smoke influence; three were exceedance days: Only 5 non-smoke exceedances 3) Two “single-monitor” exceedances 4) No “old school” exceedances In 2015: •20 days above 70ppb
  • 5. Average: 31 days Standard Deviation: 14 days The number of 90 degree days is extremely variable! 2 standard deviations from the mean suggests a strong outlier in 2010 MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEP 2 6 7 4 7 No. Days each month
  • 6. MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEP 11 16 23 20 12 Above average 85 degree days (65). What has changed to not have as many exceedances? No. Days each month
  • 7. Source: NCDC Temperature and Precipitaiton Maps
  • 8. Source: NCDC Temperature and Precipitaiton Maps
  • 9. Source: NCDC Temperature and Precipitaiton Maps
  • 10. Source: NCDC Temperature and Precipitaiton Maps
  • 11. Source: NCDC Temperature and Precipitaiton Maps
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17. Monthly CAMD Emissions from: IN, OH, WV, VA, PA, MD, DC Emissions of Indiana, Ohio, West Virginia, Virginia, Pennsylvania, Maryland and the District of Columbia were summed together on a monthly basis
  • 18. All Coal Units as of 2012
  • 20. Source region for NOx transport in to Maryland has seen a drastic drop in TOTAL ozone season (April – October) coal NOx emissions. Approximately a 20% to 40% reduction has occurred in the past 2 years, compared to a 160,000 ton level. Coal EGUs Blue dots are EGUs included in the NOx summations below Region bounded by rectangle is roughly the transport region of Maryland 2009: 45135 fewer NOx tons emitted than in 2011 2010: 7011 fewer NOx tons emitted than in 2011 2012: 14830 fewer NOx tons emitted than in 2011 2013: 40462 fewer NOx tons emitted than in 2011 2014: 67983 fewer NOx tons emitted than in 2011
  • 21. 2015 Summary • Relatively cool ozone season in the Midwest – Cool and wet June and July in Midwest (upstream) – Lowest emissions ever seen “upstream” of Maryland • Warm in Maryland (much warmer than 2013 & 2014) with slightly below average extreme heat – 15th warmest year for maximum temperature (statewide) – “Normal” July temperatures and precipitation (NCDC) • No Exceedances • Smoke was a big contributor this year – potentially 3 exceedance days with smoke influence
  • 22. ALL CAMD EGUs (>25MW) O3 Season NOx Emissions
  • 23. NARR 1000m Trajectory Density for all Baltimore NAA Exceedance Days (1980-2014) April – October 1589 Trajectories
  • 24. This map is showing, by rank (1 is greatest, 37 least), which state’s summer cooling degree day (CDDs) numbers most correlate with the number of Maryland’s ozone exceedance days. Indiana, Illinois and Kentucky’s summer CDDs are the top three. Correlation does not mean causation: Indiana’s CDDs correlate most with Maryland ozone exceedance days but this does not mean Indiana is causing Maryland’s exceedances. It does mean that of all the states considered, Indiana’s temperature record most closely follows Maryland ozone exceedance annual variability. It is also quite profound the lack of correlation between Maryland CDDs and Maryland exceedance days.
  • 25. “Strongly” Anti-correlated Not Correlated “Strongly” Correlated The correlation between cooling degree days for individual states with the number of Maryland ozone exceedance days (1980-2013) The highest correlation between cooling degree days and Maryland ozone exceedance days is found from Iowa southeastward to Tennessee (red areas). This suggests that when these states experience a hot summer Maryland is more likely to have a greater than average number of ozone exceedance days. Also, the electrical demand of these states appears to be more closely connected to Maryland exceedance day annual variability than other states. This correlation is likely due to the position of the continental ridge which is stronger in some years than others. This CAN NOT be directly interpreted that any state showing a higher correlation is actually causing the poor air quality (e.g., contains the actual emissions sources).
  • 26. The GUT of Maryland’s Ozone • In years with a weak Bermuda High – Continental (U.S.) Highs/Ridges are more prevalent – Increased temperatures across the Midwest – Continental ridging near PBL top creates a long fetch across ORV emissions (which are increased due to regionally higher temperatures) – Amplified lee-troughing with W to WSW surface winds due to increase “mountain-top” orthogonal component • This causes local I-95 transport within Maryland (Edgewood??) • In years with a strong Bermuda High – Continental Highs/Ridges are less prevalent • 850mb flow is more cyclonic preventing ridging (and subsidence) • Cooler temperatures across the MidWest (less emissions) – Weaker lee-troughing (less orthogonal mountain flow) – Less fetch from ORV (if any) entering Maryland (more across PA) – Increased southerly winds and maritime influence (cleaner) • Accounts for the wide variability in both O3 days and 90F days.
  • 27. 2010: Bad Year (43) 2011: Bad Year (29) 2013: Good Year (9) 2014: Good Year (5) Composite Sea Level Pressure (mb)
  • 28. 2015: May (Hot, bad AQ in Northeast) 2015: Sept (Hot, bad AQ along East Coast) Cool in MW. No exceedances in Maryland except with smoke) Composite Sea Level Pressure (mb) 2015: June and July
  • 31. 2011: 29 2014: 5 Exceedance Days 2011 2014 Comparison of the atmosphere Approximately 750 m above earth’s surface. The largest differences between a bad year such as 2011 and a clean year in 2014 is: •The strength of the Bermuda High in the Western Atlantic (A) • The amplitude of the Midwest Continental Ridge, and (B) •The shift in wind direction (angle of the lines) across Maryland, which switches from West-Northwest in 2011 to West- Southwest (C) (A) (B) (C)
  • 32. 2011: 29 2014: 5 Exceedance Days Comparison of southerly wind strength at the surface between 2011 and 2014 shows cleaner years have stronger southerly winds. In fact, 2011, a dirty year, has slightly northerly winds (negative color – bright purple). The largest differences between a bad year such as 2011 and a clean year in 2014 is: •The strength of the southerly winds in Maryland (A) 2011 2014 (A)
  • 33. a WIND PROFILER – Beltsville, MD b 42 4 4 12 10 8 6 6
  • 34. September 16, 2015 September 17, 2015 September 18, 2015 OZONE LIDARS
  • 36.
  • 37. 2.58 Mobile Average Tons per Day: July 2018
  • 38. June 11, 2015 Max 8-hour avg: 74 ppb Region 1 (Day Of): •Total NOx Mass: 24 Tons •100% controlled •0% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 1 Tons •Bin 1 unit count: 4 •Bin 2 unit count: 5 •Bin 3 unit count: 0 Domain (3-Day Total): •Total NOx Mass: 8,669 Tons • 52% controlled • 48% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 1,937 Tons •3-Day Average: •Daily NOx Mass: 2,890 Tons •Daily Savings: 646 Tons/day Region 2 (Day Before): •Total NOx Mass: 241 Tons •91% controlled •9% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 141 Tons •Bin 1 unit count: 3 •Bin 2 unit count: 17 •Bin 3 unit count: 13 Region 3 (2 Days Before): •Total NOx Mass: 450 Tons •64% controlled •36% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 115 Tons •Bin 1 unit count: 15 •Bin 2 unit count: 38 •Bin 3 unit count: 16
  • 39. 2015 BIAS Very low bias Region wide I-95 high bias
  • 40. 2015 RMSE Low RMSE Region wide I-95 RMSE NYC & LI SOUND RMSE HORN POINT / BAY OVER-PREDICTION
  • 42. July 11, 2014 Max 8-hour avg: 78 ppb Region 1 (Day Of): •Total NOx Mass: 5 Tons •100% controlled •0% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 1 Tons •Bin 1 unit count: 0 •Bin 2 unit count: 3 •Bin 3 unit count: 0 Domain (3-Day Total): •Total NOx Mass: 10,672Tons • 50% controlled • 50% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 2,258 Tons •3-Day Average: •Daily NOx Mass: 3,557 Tons •Daily Savings: 753 Tons/day Region 2 (Day Before): •Total NOx Mass: 9 Tons •88% controlled •12% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 1 Tons •Bin 1 unit count: 1 •Bin 2 unit count: 4 •Bin 3 unit count: 0 Region 3 (2 Days Before): •Total NOx Mass: 148 Tons •68% controlled •32% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 44 Tons •Bin 1 unit count: 8 •Bin 2 unit count: 28 •Bin 3 unit count: 2
  • 43. July 18, 2013 Max 8-hour avg: 80 ppb Region 1 (Day Of): •Total NOx Mass: 91 Tons •44% controlled •56% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 14 Tons •Bin 1 unit count: 2 •Bin 2 unit count: 3 •Bin 3 unit count: 1 Domain (3-Day Total): •Total NOx Mass: 12,909 Tons • 47% controlled • 53% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 2,488 Tons •3-Day Average: •Daily NOx Mass: 4,303 Tons •Daily Savings: 829 Tons/day Region 2 (Day Before): •Total NOx Mass: 164 Tons •66% controlled •34% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 68Tons •Bin 1 unit count: 1 •Bin 2 unit count: 5 •Bin 3 unit count: 3 Region 3 (2 Days Before): •Total NOx Mass: 260 Tons •36% controlled •64% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 51 Tons •Bin 1 unit count: 3 •Bin 2 unit count: 7 •Bin 3 unit count: 3
  • 44. July 19, 2013 Max 8-hour avg: 78 ppb Region 1 (Day Of): •Total NOx Mass: 56 Tons •100% controlled •0% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 21 Tons •Bin 1 unit count: 3 •Bin 2 unit count: 6 •Bin 3 unit count: 1 Domain (3-Day Total): •Total NOx Mass: 13,048 Tons • 47% controlled • 53% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 2,517 Tons •3-Day Average: •Daily NOx Mass: 4,349 Tons •Daily Savings: 839 Tons/day Region 2 (Day Before): •Total NOx Mass: 167 Tons •73% controlled •27% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 65 Tons •Bin 1 unit count: 4 •Bin 2 unit count: 16 •Bin 3 unit count: 5 Region 3 (2 Days Before): •Total NOx Mass: 411 Tons •76% controlled •24% uncontrolled •Potential savings: 155 Tons •Bin 1 unit count: 6 •Bin 2 unit count: 32 •Bin 3 unit count: 12

Editor's Notes

  1. https://marama.sharefile.com/login.aspx