SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 8
The United Nations Sustainable
Development Goals (SDGs)
have set a new global agenda
through 2030 with a strong green
dimension cutting across many
goals and targets. Subsequently at
the 21st Conference of the Parties
to the United Nations Framework
Convention on Climate Change
(COP21) in Paris, 195 member
States agreed on further measures
to reduce green-house gas (GHG)
emissions with the aim of keeping
the rise in global temperature for
this century well below two degrees
Celsius (°C) above pre-industrial
levels. These ambitious action plans
call for profound transformations of
energy, transportation, and dozens
of other industries, demanding
investment in the order of trillions
of U.S. dollars.1
This will translate
into more public institutions,
including investment promotion
agencies (IPAs), being asked by
their governments to actively look
for ways to contribute to national
climate goals. It is, therefore,
incumbent upon all IPAs to
integrate climate goals and green
investment promotion in their
strategic considerations.
Meanwhile, green technologies
are becoming increasingly viable
in commercial terms, making
them bigger and better targets for
investment promotion. For example,
in some places the costs of wind
and solar energy generation have
become competitive with traditional
fossil fuel energy sources.2
As described by UNCTAD,3
low-
carbon investment, which we will
name green investment in this
study, can comprise of: investment
in production processes with a
PROMOTING GREEN FDI:
Practices and Lessons from the Field
HIGHLIGHTS
• Government policies and initiatives matter for green sectors.
• Investment promotion agencies (IPAs) should ‘think outside
the box’ to identify opportunities and ways to use foreign
direct investment (FDI) to green their economies.
• IPAs can improve visibility of green investment opportunities
through successful pilot projects and the preparation of
pipelines of bankable projects.
• Promoting green FDI requires sector knowledge and a
focused strategy.
• Partnerships and networks can play a key role in developing
investment opportunities in the green economy.
U N I T E D N AT I O N S C O N F E R E N C E O N T R A D E A N D D E V E L O P M E N T
TheIPAObserveripa
The IPA Observer
series is prepared
by the Investment
Promotion Section
of UNCTAD’s
Division on
Investment and
Enterprise (DIAE).
Its objective is to
show examples
of strategic
and operational
best practice
in investment
promotion
from agencies
worldwide to
practitioners and
governments
in developing
countries, with
a view to share
lessons that are
practical and
replicable for
their investment
promotion
agencies (IPAs).
1
By 2030, an estimate of up to US$1.2 trillion per year will be required to limit GHG
emissions to the level needed for a 2 °C target to be met. Page xxvii, World Investment
Report 2010, UNCTAD.
2
The Economist, August 2015, Renewable Energy: Puffs of Hope.
3
UNCTAD, 2013, Promoting Low-Carbon Investment.
1
No.5 – 2016
This publication has not been formally edited.
reduced GHG impact; investment in clean
energy generation; and investment in research
and production facilities to manufacture
GHG reducing products and provide related
services. These are technology-intensive
and often capital-intensive industries with
technologies that are quickly evolving. In
those developing countries, where green
industries and practices are still nascent or
non-existent, foreign companies are vital to
jump-starting the low-carbon economy and
should be more aggressively pursued.
This note uses three case studies to extract
lessons on how this can be done. It examines
IPAs, including investment promotion and
business development agencies from
developed and emerging economies, in
diverse locations and circumstances. The
very different approaches taken by the three
IPAs to green their economies show that
there is no one-size-fits-all solution and that a
going-green strategy must be tailored to local
circumstances. In many cases, an IPA needs
to ‘think outside the box’ to seek niches and
possibilities for green investment, consider
what can be done given each agency’s
limited resources and look for partners to
pursue the strategy, programme or project.
Practices and lessons highlighted in this note
are therefore relevant to a range of IPAs and
business development agencies, including
those from low-income countries.
The first agency featured in this note is
Investment South Africa (InvestSA), the
national IPA of South Africa that has facilitated
the country’s first foreign direct investment
(FDI) projects in renewable energy generation
and equipment manufacturing. The second
is the Portland Development Commission
(PDC) in Oregon, United States of America, a
subnational IPA that has proactively attracted
foreign venture capital for the expansion
of local cleantech clusters. The third is the
Ulsan Eco-Industrial Park (EIP) Center of the
Republic of Korea, which has coordinated the
creation of a symbiotic network of companies
in the Ulsan EIP that give rise to opportunities
to reduce waste and environmental impact
while cutting costs.
INVESTMENT SOUTH AFRICA
USING FDI TO JUMP START
RENEWABLE INDUSTRIES
In South Africa, InvestSA,4
the national IPA
which is embedded in the Department of Trade
and Industry (DTI), leveraged FDI in renewable
power generation and turned this investment
into a catalyst for domestic manufacturing
of renewable energy equipment. InvestSA
did this with strategically commissioned
studies, a practical approach to local
linkages and good stakeholder networks
including agencies such as the South African
Independent Power Producers (IPP) Office
and the National Department of Energy.
Policy background
South Africa is heavily dependent on fossil
fuels, which represent 87 per cent of the
national energy supply. The country has
large coal reserves, making that energy
source easy and cheap, yet a green
economy features prominently in national
development plans. In 2011, the South
African government, business community,
organized labour, and civil society signed a
Green Economy Accord. The Accord is one
of several development plans that need to be
reflected in DTI’s Industrial Policy Action Plan.
The Action Plan, in turn, provides strategic
direction to InvestSA, which is expected to
identify areas to which it can contribute by
generating investment and jobs.
The Green Economy Accord makes 12
commitments to the advancement of a green
economy, including the roll-out of renewable
energy, the reduction of industrial waste
through reuse and recycling, and industrial
retrofitting. The roll-out of renewable energy
includes a government commitment to
purchase four gigawatts of electricity by
2016 from new, renewable, and domestically
generated capacity.5
By guaranteeing a
market in this way and awarding contracts
through public bidding, the government
has stimulated major interest from foreign
investors, which InvestSA is responsible for
managing.
Another government measure in support of
renewable energy is a cash grant of up to
US$3 million to cover 30 per cent of the costs
4
In April 2015, the decision was made to separate the trade and investment functions of Trade and Investment South
Africa. As of this note’s publication, the new structures have yet to be settled.
5
Economic Development Department of the Republic of South Africa, 2011, Green Economy Accord.
2
6
Website of GRI (http://www.gri.com.es/en/gestamp-to-build-wind-tower-manufacturing-facility-in-south-africa/).
3
incurred by a company retrofitting existing
industrial facilities to use renewable energy,
such as through the purchase and installation
of rooftop solar panels.
How InvestSA promotes green investment
InvestSA targets three types of green
investments: renewable energy (generation
and equipment manufacturing), waste
management (reduction, treatment,
conversion to energy), and energy efficiency
(biofuels and greening of traditional industries).
This note looks into the agency’s experience
in promoting FDI in renewable energy
generation. While the IPP Office, together
with the South African Department of Energy,
administers the bidding process for would-be
energy providers, InvestSA provides foreign
investors with information and assistance
before and during the bidding process,
coordinates procedures for startups with
provincial and local governments, and helps
bid winners tap into other sources of support
for green projects. Bids are scored on the
dual basis of electricity price (70   per cent)
and economic development impact (30 per
cent), which includes linkages that investors
can create with local suppliers and the use of
locally sourced equipment and services.
About 60 per cent of InvestSA’s work is
spent proactively marketing opportunities
to targeted investors, and promoting the
cash grant to green traditional industries
(including encouraging existing companies
to use renewable energy in their operations).
The other 40 per cent of InvestSA’s work is
devoted to supporting firms that are attracted
to South Africa, due to the country’s strategic
location and its government’s procurement
commitments.
Challenges and lessons learned
The country strategy for the promotion of
green FDI was well defined by the national
government, and it provided a framework for
the work of the agency in the area. However,
InvestSA’s green economy department
was created only after the signing of the
Green Economy Accord, and initially the
staff assigned to the department had little
knowledge of the diverse range of highly
technical fields under that label.
The first challenge faced by the agency was
how to fill this knowledge gap as rapidly as
possible through learning-by-doing. The
renewable industry is relatively new, and
the country itself had no experience in the
sector setting. The localization potential
for photovoltaics and wind equipment
manufacturing, which InvestSA should
promote, was unclear for the agency itself
as well as for other partner government
agencies. To meet this challenge, DTI’s
Industrial Development Division (IDD)
commissioned two studies on the localization
potential for photovoltaics and for wind
equipment. The two studies gave InvestSA
the understanding of domestic production
capacity and competitiveness to make the
business case to potential investors.
Recognizing the need for energy suppliers to
buy into the technical feasibility of local content
and linkages, IDD took a flexible position on
requirement levels in its first negotiations,
which were with the Spanish wind giant
Gestamp Renewable Industries (GRI).
InvestSA was involved in the negotiations
from the very beginning and the overall
government objective was to ensure that an
appropriate and feasible level of local linkages
was achieved. Effective consultations among
relevant government agencies, such as
InvestSA, IDD and the Department of Energy,
were extremely helpful to develop a good
understanding of the potential for localization,
and finally helped bring GRI on board. In the
end, GRI invested US$210 million in a wind
farm,6
stimulating substantial local production
of wind towers. The following year, GRI
announced a US$29 million investment
expected to create more than 200 jobs in the
manufacturing of 150 towers per year for the
South African market. The success of the first
projects not only generated much needed
buzz for renewable projects in the investment
community, but also revealed the potential for
localization in the industry.
InvestSA’s support for local suppliers to
increase their absorption capacity also proved
crucial. With collaboration and support from
the agency, DCD Wind Towers, a South
African company, became the first African
company to manufacture wind towers.
The support appears to be essential to the
development of domestic suppliers, as it has
proven difficult for domestic manufacturers to
obtain finance, even with the growing demand
of energy suppliers. Another six companies
supported by InvestSA are now assembling or
manufacturing renewable energy equipment,
including four making solar panels and two
making inverters.
PORTLAND DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
(OREGON, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA)
PROMOTING INDIGENOUS
CLEANTECH IN GLOBAL MARKETS
Portland’s public policies and popular culture
have earned it a strong reputation as a green
city. Over the last several years, it has been
repeatedly ranked as the greenest city in
the United States, the number one forward-
thinker in environmental awareness and
resource conservation, first in LEED-certified
buildings per capita, third best city to live in,
and the fourth hottest spot for knowledge
workers.7
The Portland region has a large
pool of cleantech and green building startups.
However, none of the startups have yet grown
to be large companies, and Portland has not
yet fully tapped into its potential as a green
FDI location. Portland is therefore supporting
local green businesses in exporting green
products and services and in attracting
capital and investment, including FDI.
How the PDC promotes green investment
This confluence of factors is aptly reflected
in the investment promotion strategy of the
PDC, known as the Greater Portland Global
Trade and Investment Plan. Developed in
collaboration with the Brookings Institution,
the PDC’s strategy prioritizes cleantech as
an emerging sector to be nurtured and more
firmly established.
The PDC has found a niche as a matchmaker
and facilitator among companies looking
for partners and as an aftercare provider to
domestic and foreign firms, helping them
grow through access to new markets. With
the governments of Portland and the state
of Oregon having earned strong, increasingly
global reputations for their leadership in
environmental policy, the PDC has found that
it enjoys a level of clout when bringing parties
together and helping them seal deals with the
glue of government support.
The most public manifestation of the PDC’s
ability to bring cleantech companies together
in productive collaboration is an annual
investor match-making event at Oregon BEST
FEST,8
a cleantech innovation conference
opened by the governor of Oregon and
featuring a cleantech competition, a speed
networking event, company exhibits, and
speakers from industry financers, potential
technology partners, and entrepreneurs.
It is through this event that the PDC introduced
Portland-based Energy Storage Systems
(ESS) to Pangaea Ventures, the Canadian
venture capitalist that would eventually lead
a US$3.2 million in venture capital funding
in 2015.9
ESS is a maker of innovative, all-
iron flow batteries, which are used in the
storage and off-peak discharge of renewable
energy, which was accorded the Portland
Business Journal’s award for Sustainable
Product Innovation in 2015.10
This company
of 17 people will use the funding to ramp up
production and commercialize its product.
Targeting solar photovoltaic producers close
to grid parity, ESS seeks to provide a low-cost
storage option that will support the spread of
profitable solar energy production.
Of equal importance to the PDC’s
matchmaking is its innovative aftercare
service tailored to cleantech startups.
Considering the large number of cleantech
startups in the Portland region and the high
rate of startup failure, the PDC’s assistance in
accessing new markets can be significant to
company survival. Lucid Energy, a company
with patented technology to generate
electricity from the flow of water through
gravity-fed pipes, had installed capacity at
only one public utility, with one more under
development, when it asked for the PDC’s
4
7
Portland Development Commission, 2010, Economic Development Strategy: A Five-Year Plan for Promoting Job
Creation and Economic Growth.
8
http://oregonbest.org/news-events/events-opportunities/oregon-best-fest/
9
“Energy Storage Systems secures $3.2 million flow battery VC funding,” 8 October 2015. PV Magazine (http://
www.pv-magazine.com/news/details/beitrag/energy-storage-systems-secures-32-million-flow-battery-vc-
funding_100021458/#ixzz3o0H62Jaj)
10
“Meet Oregon’s Top 3 Sustainable Manufacturers of the Year for 2015,” 29 October 2015. Portland Business Journal
(http://www.bizjournals.com/portland/blog/sbo/2015/10/meet-oregons-3-sustainable-manufacturers-of-the.
html?ana=e_du_pubs=article_dued=2015-10-29u=kQWEms%2FdGNCV4AwEKpZG7a1n0vt=1446158429)
ULSAN ECO-INDUSTRIAL PARK CENTER
(CITY OF ULSAN, REPUBLIC OF KOREA)
LEADING EXISTING INVESTORS TO
A BUSINESS MODEL FOR GOING
GREEN
The region around the city of Ulsan is
known as the Ulsan Industrial District. It is
the Republic of Korea’s largest industrial
center and a global industrial leader in
many respects. On just over 1,000 square
kilometers of land, the Ulsan region hosts
15 industrial parks. For a sense of scale, just
two of these parks, Ulsan Mipo and Onsan,
include about 1,200 companies and more
than 120,000 employees. Among them
are more than 130 foreign companies from
Japan, Germany, the Netherlands and the
United States, such as BASF, Du Pont, Dow
Chemical and the Solvay Group.12
However,
few of the companies operating in Ulsan are
engaged in green industries as their primary
business lines.
With this level of economic activity in such a
concentrated area, the environmental impact
must be carefully planned and monitored to
manage waste and limit pollution. So in 2005
the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy
introduced the EIP initiative for the transition
of industrial complexes into eco-industrial
parks. As part of this initiative the Korea
Industrial Complex Corporation and the
Ulsan Metropolitan Authority established the
Ulsan EIP Center, which acts as a business
development agency to identify and make
the case for investment in green production
processes with a reduced GHG impact.
Going beyond waste disposal and pollution
mitigation, the agency tries to reuse and
recycle waste, cascading the use of energy
and water in a way that optimizes efficiency
and creates new value through industrial
symbiosis.
How the Ulsan EIP Center promotes green
investment
The Ulsan EIP Center, established for
implementing the Ulsan EIP project, explored
symbiotic relationships and shared facilities
among individual companies that would
contribute to clusters achieving collective
help in introducing the technology to the city
government of Johannesburg, South Africa.
Lucid Energy knew that Johannesburg was
looking at low-carbon options for mitigating
power shortages, and the PDC was able
to quickly obtain a letter from the mayor of
Portland introducing the company to his
counterpart in Johannesburg. Portland
received a response within a week, and within
three weeks, the mayor of Johannesburg
came to Portland with a team, on an agenda
organized by the PDC. Meeting with Lucid
Energy, Portland’s mayor and a roundtable
of city bureaus, the Johannesburg delegation
learned how the turbines were integrated into
the municipal water lines and saw an effective
demonstration of Lucid Energy. In May 2015,
the mayor of Johannesburg announced plans
to implement the same technology.11
Challenges and lessons learned
In doing company matchmaking, the PDC’s
effectiveness depends greatly on the two
mutually reinforcing factors of strong sector
knowledge and relationships with a wide
range of sector players. The PDC has only
two full-time staff working on the green
economy, neither of whom started their roles
with experience in the field. Like InvestSA, the
PDC has built knowledge and relationships
through extensive desk research and strong
customer service. This level of attention to
clients keeps the PDC in close contact with
companies throughout their projects and
gives it privileged insights into the workings
of each company and the sector. Knowledge
of the industry’s players, trends, and quickly
changing technologies enables the PDC to
design and promote BEST FEST as a high-
value, well-attended event and to create
a roster of priority companies for targeted
aftercare.
The PDC maintains a roster of more than 60
priority companies, together with information
on their technologies, markets, levels of
development, international footprint and
financial needs. This gives the PDC a bird’s
eye view of subsectoral strengths and gaps,
which informs not only company-specific
objectives but also investor-targeting efforts
and policy advocacy.
5
11
“How Joburg’s energy-from-water-pipes will work,” 7 May 2015. Mybroadband News ( http://mybroadband.co.za/
news/energy/125756-how-joburgs-energy-from-water-pipes-will-work.html)
12
http://www.investkorea.org/ulsan_en/invest/invest02.do
efficiencies that cut costs and
increase eco-friendliness.
The EIP committee included
representatives of the national
agency in charge of industrial park
management, private companies,
non-governmental organizations,
and an RD center of the University
of Ulsan.
Potential project identification
started with mapping the
companies in a park, their inputs
and their waste products. The
Center then identified a series
of potential projects for steam
recycling. Potential projects were
shared with stakeholders and
the RD center, which together
investigated project feasibility and
produced a final report of projects
and their business cases.
Then the EIP Center started to run
a few well selected pilot projects
to show the feasibility of the green
concept. With several sound
business cases established for
the sale and distribution of waste
steam generated by a number of
companiesinthedistrict,theCenter
worked with those companies to
undertake the permitting, financing
and construction needed for
implementation. In the first phase,
steam networks were established
between two pairs of companies,
which showed very positive
results. For example, Sungam
Municipal Waste Incinerator Facility
and Hyosung Company together
invested US$5 million in the
network but accrued over US$7
million per year in cost savings.
Steam replaced enough fossil
fuels to reduce carbon dioxide
emissions by 55,500 tons per year,
and Hyosung generated so much
excess steam that it made sense
to expand its production facilities,
employing another 150 people.
With demonstrated success,
several more projects came
online quickly, and the rationale
for larger scale public-private
investments in the infrastructure
for a “steam highway” became
evident. Eventually, US$26 million
in public investment established
a six-kilometer steam pipeline
with multiple entrances and exits,
allowing companies that invested
in the infrastructure to connect
their facilities to the highway.
This is expected to reduce GHG
by 100,000 tons per year while
creating US$20 million in energy
supply and cost savings.
At every step the Ulsan EIP
Center was the lead coordinator,
articulating the vision for park-
level symbiosis, making the
business case, and negotiating
commitments and prices with
participants, who had to find a way
to share the costs and benefits
of these joint projects. Company
due diligence typically took about
a year, while negotiations lasted
anywhere from three months to
more than four years.
By the end of 2014, eight years
after Ulsan EIP’s first symbiosis
was established, projects involving
31 companies were up and
running. These generated annual
cost savings of US$74 million, new
revenue of US$45 million, and the
following environmentally beneficial
reductions per year:
• 487,626 tons of carbon dioxide
• 196,102 tons of energy
• 79,007 tons of wastewater
• 38,544 tons of industrial
by-products
• 4,052 tons of air pollutants
Today, Ulsan EIP enjoys a global
reputation that brings new
investments from companies for
whom the symbiotic aspect is a
driving factor. As of the publication
of this note, a German chemical
company is planning a US$500
million investment project in Ulsan,
attracted by cheap utility cost and
stable raw material acquisition
through industrial symbiosis. In
addition, this concept is being tested
in other developing countries, for
example, in eight low-carbon export
processing zones in Bangladesh.
6
Challenges and lessons learned
According to a Director of the
Ulsan EIP Center, the Ulsan EIP
experience was private sector-
driven. The government-created
centerwasacatalystandfocalpoint
for the discussions that occurred
among private companies, but it
was the companies themselves
that determined whether there
was a business case for a project.
The greatest challenge to Ulsan
EIP Center was, therefore, in
convening, engaging, and enlisting
investors that were not normally
enthusiastic about government
involvement in the workings of
what was felt to be an already well-
functioning industrial ecosystem.
During the mapping of a park’s
companies and their inputs and
waste, most companies were
secretive and did not want to
participate, viewing EIP Center
experts as “spies” out to discover
environmental violations. Even
those companies that were
relatively welcoming had little
interest in proactively pursuing
GHG mitigation measures, as
they were not a part of their
core business and had little
incentive to propose them to their
headquarters. Ulsan EIP Center
addressed these reservations
by framing the project at every
turn as a business innovation to
enhance efficiency, risk mitigation
and profit. Ulsan EIP Center also
gave stakeholders the company
mapping and list of potential
projects upfront as an enticement
and demonstration of the project’s
commitment to solving practical
problems that the companies were
facing.
Once buy-in was achieved and the
first phases of the EIP project were
implemented, project successes
were well-publicized with credit
freely given to all stakeholders
involved, thereby strengthening
their resolve and bringing in new
waves of participants. According
to the Director of the EIP Center,
leadership and the patient building
of a series of achievements, one
after the other, have been the key
to success.
LESSONS FOR IPAS
The cases of InvestSA, the PDC
and the Ulsan EIP Center have
significant differences, in terms
of IPA nature, jurisdictional size,
level of industrial development,
and green activities facilitated. Yet
their challenges and successes
demonstrate certain shared
characteristics. This suggests
that most IPAs with green
objectives could benefit from an
understanding of their lessons
learned. Five main lessons stand
out:
1. Government policies matter.
The three cases discussed
in this note each started
with a different set of local
characteristics which needed
to be examined—close vicinity
of many industrial activities in
Ulsan, but little connectivity
between companies for waste
disposal; good potential for
renewable energy in South Africa
but a nascent renewable market
with very limited manufacturing
activities; and a sizable pool of
cleantech startups in Portland
but none that had really taken
off. The government’s vision in
Ulsan, public policies in South
Africa, and environmental
credentials with local
government support in Portland
were all instrumental in creating
investment opportunities.
2. IPAs and partners need to ‘think
outside the box’ to identify
opportunities and ways to use
FDI to green their economies.
It usually requires innovative
approaches that take into
consideration local market
conditions and IPA resource
constraints. Green investment
opportunities are widespread,
both in the development of
renewable energy sources
and the greening of existing
7
8
economic activities. The
challenge is to identify an
appropriate target area, and
select the right model to tackle
hurdles. The case studies in
this note show that an agency
can take a light approach in
some cases, while a more
comprehensive approach may
be necessary under different
conditions.
3. Green investment opportunities
and business cases need to be
visible. Investment promotion
and business development
agencies can make a difference
by undertaking successful pilot
projects or preparing a pipeline
of bankable projects, which can
be readily promoted to potential
investors. For example, IPAs
can help create viable business
cases (InvestSA) or show
investors in traditional industries
how applying low-carbon
practices can be profitable
(Ulsan EIP).
4. Promoting green FDI requires
strong sector knowledge and
a focused strategy based on
sector competitiveness. Both
market development and policy
support contribute to a sector’s
competitiveness. A few basic
studies can go a long way to
identifying sector gaps and top
opportunities for investment
promotion. It also helps
developing in-house expertise.
5. IPA partnerships and networks
can help broker opportunities in
the formative green economy.
This was evidenced in all three
cases, where IPAs facilitated
linkageswithdomesticsuppliers,
matched venture capitalists to
technology developers, and
organized partners in industrial
symbiosis.
CONCLUSIONS
Most green industries and their
technologies are relatively young,
with markets and value chains that
remain fluid and owe much of their
early growth to supportive public
policies. IPAs that understand
well that landscape and design
strategies around the most
competitive sectors are in a good
position to connect investors to
their markets.
As demonstrated by the three
case studies, IPAs and business
development agencies can
make a difference in promoting
green investment by developing
expertise, targeting the right
sectors and activities and creating
or demonstrating the business
case. Equally important is the
development of local absorptive
capacity, so that linkages and
partnerships could be created. The
eventual networks that are formed
will help retain green investment
and secure a long-term impact on
sustainable development.
For more
information visit
the Division on
Investment
and Enterprise
(DIAE) at
www.unctad.org/diae
or email
ips@unctad.org
UNCTAD/WEB/DIAE/PCB/2015/6

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Doubling The Green Investment
Doubling The Green InvestmentDoubling The Green Investment
Doubling The Green InvestmentMark A. Caldwell
 
Green Investment, Innovation and Productivity Vol. 2/2014
Green Investment, Innovation and Productivity Vol. 2/2014Green Investment, Innovation and Productivity Vol. 2/2014
Green Investment, Innovation and Productivity Vol. 2/2014Farhan Helmy
 
GREEN ECONOMY AS A VIABLE STRATEGY FOR ABATING CLIMATE CHANGE EFFECTS IN NI...
GREEN ECONOMY AS A VIABLE STRATEGY FOR ABATING  CLIMATE CHANGE EFFECTS IN  NI...GREEN ECONOMY AS A VIABLE STRATEGY FOR ABATING  CLIMATE CHANGE EFFECTS IN  NI...
GREEN ECONOMY AS A VIABLE STRATEGY FOR ABATING CLIMATE CHANGE EFFECTS IN NI...Mabel Tola-Winjobi
 
The New Earth Economy
The New Earth EconomyThe New Earth Economy
The New Earth EconomyGuy Dauncey
 
Principles of the Green Economy
Principles of the Green EconomyPrinciples of the Green Economy
Principles of the Green Economygt2012
 
Towards a Green Economy
Towards a Green EconomyTowards a Green Economy
Towards a Green EconomyZ3P
 
Presentation On Green Economy For Sustainable Development
Presentation On Green Economy For Sustainable DevelopmentPresentation On Green Economy For Sustainable Development
Presentation On Green Economy For Sustainable DevelopmentAsif A. Kabani
 
Green economy and sustainable development
Green economy and sustainable developmentGreen economy and sustainable development
Green economy and sustainable developmentTanya Mukherjee
 

Viewers also liked (11)

Doubling The Green Investment
Doubling The Green InvestmentDoubling The Green Investment
Doubling The Green Investment
 
Green Investment, Innovation and Productivity Vol. 2/2014
Green Investment, Innovation and Productivity Vol. 2/2014Green Investment, Innovation and Productivity Vol. 2/2014
Green Investment, Innovation and Productivity Vol. 2/2014
 
GREEN ECONOMY AS A VIABLE STRATEGY FOR ABATING CLIMATE CHANGE EFFECTS IN NI...
GREEN ECONOMY AS A VIABLE STRATEGY FOR ABATING  CLIMATE CHANGE EFFECTS IN  NI...GREEN ECONOMY AS A VIABLE STRATEGY FOR ABATING  CLIMATE CHANGE EFFECTS IN  NI...
GREEN ECONOMY AS A VIABLE STRATEGY FOR ABATING CLIMATE CHANGE EFFECTS IN NI...
 
Green economy
Green economyGreen economy
Green economy
 
The New Earth Economy
The New Earth EconomyThe New Earth Economy
The New Earth Economy
 
Principles of the Green Economy
Principles of the Green EconomyPrinciples of the Green Economy
Principles of the Green Economy
 
Towards a Green Economy
Towards a Green EconomyTowards a Green Economy
Towards a Green Economy
 
Green Economy
Green Economy Green Economy
Green Economy
 
Green economy
Green economyGreen economy
Green economy
 
Presentation On Green Economy For Sustainable Development
Presentation On Green Economy For Sustainable DevelopmentPresentation On Green Economy For Sustainable Development
Presentation On Green Economy For Sustainable Development
 
Green economy and sustainable development
Green economy and sustainable developmentGreen economy and sustainable development
Green economy and sustainable development
 

Similar to Promoting green foreign direct investment practices and lessons from the field

Promoting Green Financing Mechanisms.pdf
Promoting Green Financing Mechanisms.pdfPromoting Green Financing Mechanisms.pdf
Promoting Green Financing Mechanisms.pdfLukmanulhakim Almamalik
 
Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916
Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916
Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916Gori Daniel
 
Cova Advisory Budget 2018/19 Incentives
Cova Advisory Budget 2018/19 IncentivesCova Advisory Budget 2018/19 Incentives
Cova Advisory Budget 2018/19 IncentivesMohamed Ameen Ismail
 
Dian Lestari, BFK, Ministry of Finance - Green Finance Facility to Support Cl...
Dian Lestari, BFK, Ministry of Finance - Green Finance Facility to Support Cl...Dian Lestari, BFK, Ministry of Finance - Green Finance Facility to Support Cl...
Dian Lestari, BFK, Ministry of Finance - Green Finance Facility to Support Cl...OECD Environment
 
Just Green It, article
Just Green It, articleJust Green It, article
Just Green It, articleTunde Saduwa
 
FROM RISK TO RETURN: INVESTING IN CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATION
FROM RISK TO RETURN: INVESTING IN CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATIONFROM RISK TO RETURN: INVESTING IN CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATION
FROM RISK TO RETURN: INVESTING IN CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATIONTurlough Guerin GAICD FGIA
 
Green ICT in Singapore - Path to responsible and sustainable growth
Green ICT in Singapore - Path to responsible and sustainable growthGreen ICT in Singapore - Path to responsible and sustainable growth
Green ICT in Singapore - Path to responsible and sustainable growthVikas Sharma
 
CRESPAI Presentation
CRESPAI PresentationCRESPAI Presentation
CRESPAI PresentationRamesh Goel
 
Financing a global deal in climate change
Financing a global deal in climate changeFinancing a global deal in climate change
Financing a global deal in climate changeDr Lendy Spires
 
Climate Summit Action Areas Financing2
Climate Summit Action Areas Financing2Climate Summit Action Areas Financing2
Climate Summit Action Areas Financing2Dr Lendy Spires
 
Standard Chartered Opportunity 2030 - SDG Investment Map
Standard Chartered Opportunity 2030 - SDG Investment MapStandard Chartered Opportunity 2030 - SDG Investment Map
Standard Chartered Opportunity 2030 - SDG Investment MapJohn Smith
 
Unlocking financial opportunities for the attainment of sustainable Developme...
Unlocking financial opportunities for the attainment of sustainable Developme...Unlocking financial opportunities for the attainment of sustainable Developme...
Unlocking financial opportunities for the attainment of sustainable Developme...Tunde Ekundayo
 
Summary Report: B4E COP17 Dialogue 2011, Durban
Summary Report: B4E COP17 Dialogue 2011, DurbanSummary Report: B4E COP17 Dialogue 2011, Durban
Summary Report: B4E COP17 Dialogue 2011, DurbanGlobal Initiatives
 
Howtocatalyzeprivatemoneyintoinfrastructureinvestments
HowtocatalyzeprivatemoneyintoinfrastructureinvestmentsHowtocatalyzeprivatemoneyintoinfrastructureinvestments
Howtocatalyzeprivatemoneyintoinfrastructureinvestmentsussal
 
Bold new initiative aims to ensure green recovery from COVID-19
Bold new initiative aims to ensure green recovery from COVID-19Bold new initiative aims to ensure green recovery from COVID-19
Bold new initiative aims to ensure green recovery from COVID-19WE-SECO
 

Similar to Promoting green foreign direct investment practices and lessons from the field (20)

Mobilising private investment in clean energy infrastructure
Mobilising private investment in clean energy infrastructureMobilising private investment in clean energy infrastructure
Mobilising private investment in clean energy infrastructure
 
UNEP_Investing
UNEP_InvestingUNEP_Investing
UNEP_Investing
 
Promoting Green Financing Mechanisms.pdf
Promoting Green Financing Mechanisms.pdfPromoting Green Financing Mechanisms.pdf
Promoting Green Financing Mechanisms.pdf
 
Green business investment_report
Green business investment_reportGreen business investment_report
Green business investment_report
 
Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916
Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916
Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916
 
Cova Advisory Budget 2018/19 Incentives
Cova Advisory Budget 2018/19 IncentivesCova Advisory Budget 2018/19 Incentives
Cova Advisory Budget 2018/19 Incentives
 
Dian Lestari, BFK, Ministry of Finance - Green Finance Facility to Support Cl...
Dian Lestari, BFK, Ministry of Finance - Green Finance Facility to Support Cl...Dian Lestari, BFK, Ministry of Finance - Green Finance Facility to Support Cl...
Dian Lestari, BFK, Ministry of Finance - Green Finance Facility to Support Cl...
 
United innovations
United innovationsUnited innovations
United innovations
 
JUST GREEN IT
JUST GREEN ITJUST GREEN IT
JUST GREEN IT
 
Just Green It, article
Just Green It, articleJust Green It, article
Just Green It, article
 
FROM RISK TO RETURN: INVESTING IN CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATION
FROM RISK TO RETURN: INVESTING IN CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATIONFROM RISK TO RETURN: INVESTING IN CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATION
FROM RISK TO RETURN: INVESTING IN CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATION
 
Green ICT in Singapore - Path to responsible and sustainable growth
Green ICT in Singapore - Path to responsible and sustainable growthGreen ICT in Singapore - Path to responsible and sustainable growth
Green ICT in Singapore - Path to responsible and sustainable growth
 
CRESPAI Presentation
CRESPAI PresentationCRESPAI Presentation
CRESPAI Presentation
 
Financing a global deal in climate change
Financing a global deal in climate changeFinancing a global deal in climate change
Financing a global deal in climate change
 
Climate Summit Action Areas Financing2
Climate Summit Action Areas Financing2Climate Summit Action Areas Financing2
Climate Summit Action Areas Financing2
 
Standard Chartered Opportunity 2030 - SDG Investment Map
Standard Chartered Opportunity 2030 - SDG Investment MapStandard Chartered Opportunity 2030 - SDG Investment Map
Standard Chartered Opportunity 2030 - SDG Investment Map
 
Unlocking financial opportunities for the attainment of sustainable Developme...
Unlocking financial opportunities for the attainment of sustainable Developme...Unlocking financial opportunities for the attainment of sustainable Developme...
Unlocking financial opportunities for the attainment of sustainable Developme...
 
Summary Report: B4E COP17 Dialogue 2011, Durban
Summary Report: B4E COP17 Dialogue 2011, DurbanSummary Report: B4E COP17 Dialogue 2011, Durban
Summary Report: B4E COP17 Dialogue 2011, Durban
 
Howtocatalyzeprivatemoneyintoinfrastructureinvestments
HowtocatalyzeprivatemoneyintoinfrastructureinvestmentsHowtocatalyzeprivatemoneyintoinfrastructureinvestments
Howtocatalyzeprivatemoneyintoinfrastructureinvestments
 
Bold new initiative aims to ensure green recovery from COVID-19
Bold new initiative aims to ensure green recovery from COVID-19Bold new initiative aims to ensure green recovery from COVID-19
Bold new initiative aims to ensure green recovery from COVID-19
 

More from Ira Kristina Lumban Tobing

Introduction to the Psychology of International Cooperation Seventeen motivat...
Introduction to the Psychology of International Cooperation Seventeen motivat...Introduction to the Psychology of International Cooperation Seventeen motivat...
Introduction to the Psychology of International Cooperation Seventeen motivat...Ira Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
UNCTAD ¬ cocoa study industry structures and competition
UNCTAD ¬ cocoa study industry structures and competitionUNCTAD ¬ cocoa study industry structures and competition
UNCTAD ¬ cocoa study industry structures and competitionIra Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
Cocoa ¬ a guide to trade practices of ITC. #NeedToSaveThis
Cocoa ¬   a guide to trade practices of ITC. #NeedToSaveThisCocoa ¬   a guide to trade practices of ITC. #NeedToSaveThis
Cocoa ¬ a guide to trade practices of ITC. #NeedToSaveThisIra Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
Study on the costs, advantages and disadvantages of cocoa certification commi...
Study on the costs, advantages and disadvantages of cocoa certification commi...Study on the costs, advantages and disadvantages of cocoa certification commi...
Study on the costs, advantages and disadvantages of cocoa certification commi...Ira Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
A Guide to traceAbility A Practical Approach to Advance Sustainability in Glo...
A Guide to traceAbility A Practical Approach to Advance Sustainability in Glo...A Guide to traceAbility A Practical Approach to Advance Sustainability in Glo...
A Guide to traceAbility A Practical Approach to Advance Sustainability in Glo...Ira Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
IDENTIFICATION OF KEY SUCCESS FACTORS OF STRATEGIES IN ENTERING THE INDIAN MA...
IDENTIFICATION OF KEY SUCCESS FACTORS OF STRATEGIES IN ENTERING THE INDIAN MA...IDENTIFICATION OF KEY SUCCESS FACTORS OF STRATEGIES IN ENTERING THE INDIAN MA...
IDENTIFICATION OF KEY SUCCESS FACTORS OF STRATEGIES IN ENTERING THE INDIAN MA...Ira Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
Analysis of Cocoa Beans Processing And Quality in Post Harvest in South East ...
Analysis of Cocoa Beans Processing And Quality in Post Harvest in South East ...Analysis of Cocoa Beans Processing And Quality in Post Harvest in South East ...
Analysis of Cocoa Beans Processing And Quality in Post Harvest in South East ...Ira Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
STRATEGI PEMBANGUNAN DAYA SAING INDUSTRI DALAM NEGERI MENGHADAPI ACFTA
STRATEGI PEMBANGUNAN DAYA SAING INDUSTRI DALAM NEGERI MENGHADAPI ACFTASTRATEGI PEMBANGUNAN DAYA SAING INDUSTRI DALAM NEGERI MENGHADAPI ACFTA
STRATEGI PEMBANGUNAN DAYA SAING INDUSTRI DALAM NEGERI MENGHADAPI ACFTAIra Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ LG Electronic Global Strategy in Em...
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~  LG Electronic Global Strategy in Em...Marketing Management Course Assignment ~  LG Electronic Global Strategy in Em...
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ LG Electronic Global Strategy in Em...Ira Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ Brand In the Hand ADIDAS
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~  Brand In the Hand  ADIDASMarketing Management Course Assignment ~  Brand In the Hand  ADIDAS
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ Brand In the Hand ADIDASIra Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ Dove Evolution of a Brand
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~  Dove Evolution of a BrandMarketing Management Course Assignment ~  Dove Evolution of a Brand
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ Dove Evolution of a BrandIra Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ Moods of Norway
Marketing Management Course Assignment  ~  Moods of NorwayMarketing Management Course Assignment  ~  Moods of Norway
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ Moods of NorwayIra Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
Marketing management course assignment ~Marcks and Spencer plan a
Marketing management course assignment   ~Marcks and Spencer plan aMarketing management course assignment   ~Marcks and Spencer plan a
Marketing management course assignment ~Marcks and Spencer plan aIra Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~STARBUCKS
Marketing Management Course Assignment   ~STARBUCKSMarketing Management Course Assignment   ~STARBUCKS
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~STARBUCKSIra Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
Marketing Management Course Paper Assignment ~LV in India
Marketing Management Course Paper Assignment ~LV in IndiaMarketing Management Course Paper Assignment ~LV in India
Marketing Management Course Paper Assignment ~LV in IndiaIra Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
Information technology environment ~ ira kristina l. tobing
Information technology environment ~ ira kristina l. tobingInformation technology environment ~ ira kristina l. tobing
Information technology environment ~ ira kristina l. tobingIra Kristina Lumban Tobing
 
Governmental environment ~ ir kristina l. tobing
Governmental environment ~ ir kristina l. tobingGovernmental environment ~ ir kristina l. tobing
Governmental environment ~ ir kristina l. tobingIra Kristina Lumban Tobing
 

More from Ira Kristina Lumban Tobing (20)

Introduction to the Psychology of International Cooperation Seventeen motivat...
Introduction to the Psychology of International Cooperation Seventeen motivat...Introduction to the Psychology of International Cooperation Seventeen motivat...
Introduction to the Psychology of International Cooperation Seventeen motivat...
 
State of commodity dependance 2019
State of commodity dependance 2019State of commodity dependance 2019
State of commodity dependance 2019
 
UNCTAD ¬ cocoa study industry structures and competition
UNCTAD ¬ cocoa study industry structures and competitionUNCTAD ¬ cocoa study industry structures and competition
UNCTAD ¬ cocoa study industry structures and competition
 
Cocoa ¬ a guide to trade practices of ITC. #NeedToSaveThis
Cocoa ¬   a guide to trade practices of ITC. #NeedToSaveThisCocoa ¬   a guide to trade practices of ITC. #NeedToSaveThis
Cocoa ¬ a guide to trade practices of ITC. #NeedToSaveThis
 
CHOCOLATE GREENWASHING
CHOCOLATE GREENWASHINGCHOCOLATE GREENWASHING
CHOCOLATE GREENWASHING
 
Study on the costs, advantages and disadvantages of cocoa certification commi...
Study on the costs, advantages and disadvantages of cocoa certification commi...Study on the costs, advantages and disadvantages of cocoa certification commi...
Study on the costs, advantages and disadvantages of cocoa certification commi...
 
A Guide to traceAbility A Practical Approach to Advance Sustainability in Glo...
A Guide to traceAbility A Practical Approach to Advance Sustainability in Glo...A Guide to traceAbility A Practical Approach to Advance Sustainability in Glo...
A Guide to traceAbility A Practical Approach to Advance Sustainability in Glo...
 
IDENTIFICATION OF KEY SUCCESS FACTORS OF STRATEGIES IN ENTERING THE INDIAN MA...
IDENTIFICATION OF KEY SUCCESS FACTORS OF STRATEGIES IN ENTERING THE INDIAN MA...IDENTIFICATION OF KEY SUCCESS FACTORS OF STRATEGIES IN ENTERING THE INDIAN MA...
IDENTIFICATION OF KEY SUCCESS FACTORS OF STRATEGIES IN ENTERING THE INDIAN MA...
 
Analysis of Cocoa Beans Processing And Quality in Post Harvest in South East ...
Analysis of Cocoa Beans Processing And Quality in Post Harvest in South East ...Analysis of Cocoa Beans Processing And Quality in Post Harvest in South East ...
Analysis of Cocoa Beans Processing And Quality in Post Harvest in South East ...
 
STRATEGI PEMBANGUNAN DAYA SAING INDUSTRI DALAM NEGERI MENGHADAPI ACFTA
STRATEGI PEMBANGUNAN DAYA SAING INDUSTRI DALAM NEGERI MENGHADAPI ACFTASTRATEGI PEMBANGUNAN DAYA SAING INDUSTRI DALAM NEGERI MENGHADAPI ACFTA
STRATEGI PEMBANGUNAN DAYA SAING INDUSTRI DALAM NEGERI MENGHADAPI ACFTA
 
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ LG Electronic Global Strategy in Em...
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~  LG Electronic Global Strategy in Em...Marketing Management Course Assignment ~  LG Electronic Global Strategy in Em...
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ LG Electronic Global Strategy in Em...
 
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ Brand In the Hand ADIDAS
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~  Brand In the Hand  ADIDASMarketing Management Course Assignment ~  Brand In the Hand  ADIDAS
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ Brand In the Hand ADIDAS
 
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ Dove Evolution of a Brand
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~  Dove Evolution of a BrandMarketing Management Course Assignment ~  Dove Evolution of a Brand
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ Dove Evolution of a Brand
 
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ Moods of Norway
Marketing Management Course Assignment  ~  Moods of NorwayMarketing Management Course Assignment  ~  Moods of Norway
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~ Moods of Norway
 
Marketing management course assignment ~Marcks and Spencer plan a
Marketing management course assignment   ~Marcks and Spencer plan aMarketing management course assignment   ~Marcks and Spencer plan a
Marketing management course assignment ~Marcks and Spencer plan a
 
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~STARBUCKS
Marketing Management Course Assignment   ~STARBUCKSMarketing Management Course Assignment   ~STARBUCKS
Marketing Management Course Assignment ~STARBUCKS
 
Marketing Management Course Paper Assignment ~LV in India
Marketing Management Course Paper Assignment ~LV in IndiaMarketing Management Course Paper Assignment ~LV in India
Marketing Management Course Paper Assignment ~LV in India
 
Information technology environment ~ ira kristina l. tobing
Information technology environment ~ ira kristina l. tobingInformation technology environment ~ ira kristina l. tobing
Information technology environment ~ ira kristina l. tobing
 
Governmental environment ~ ir kristina l. tobing
Governmental environment ~ ir kristina l. tobingGovernmental environment ~ ir kristina l. tobing
Governmental environment ~ ir kristina l. tobing
 
Fiscal policy ~ ira kristina l. tobing
Fiscal policy ~ ira kristina l. tobingFiscal policy ~ ira kristina l. tobing
Fiscal policy ~ ira kristina l. tobing
 

Recently uploaded

2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 28
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 282024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 28
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 28JSchaus & Associates
 
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...ResolutionFoundation
 
Club of Rome: Eco-nomics for an Ecological Civilization
Club of Rome: Eco-nomics for an Ecological CivilizationClub of Rome: Eco-nomics for an Ecological Civilization
Club of Rome: Eco-nomics for an Ecological CivilizationEnergy for One World
 
(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.Christina Parmionova
 
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up NumberMs Riya
 
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists Lawmakers
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists LawmakersHow the Congressional Budget Office Assists Lawmakers
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists LawmakersCongressional Budget Office
 
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escortsranjana rawat
 
Climate change and occupational safety and health.
Climate change and occupational safety and health.Climate change and occupational safety and health.
Climate change and occupational safety and health.Christina Parmionova
 
Global debate on climate change and occupational safety and health.
Global debate on climate change and occupational safety and health.Global debate on climate change and occupational safety and health.
Global debate on climate change and occupational safety and health.Christina Parmionova
 
Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…
Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…
Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…nishakur201
 
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
VIP Mumbai Call Girls Andheri West Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash on...
VIP Mumbai Call Girls Andheri West Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash on...VIP Mumbai Call Girls Andheri West Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash on...
VIP Mumbai Call Girls Andheri West Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash on...Garima Khatri
 
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
PPT Item # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only)
PPT Item # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only)PPT Item # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only)
PPT Item # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only)ahcitycouncil
 
Zechariah Boodey Farmstead Collaborative presentation - Humble Beginnings
Zechariah Boodey Farmstead Collaborative presentation -  Humble BeginningsZechariah Boodey Farmstead Collaborative presentation -  Humble Beginnings
Zechariah Boodey Farmstead Collaborative presentation - Humble Beginningsinfo695895
 
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CT
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CTFair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CT
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CTaccounts329278
 
High Class Call Girls Bangalore Komal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service B...
High Class Call Girls Bangalore Komal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service B...High Class Call Girls Bangalore Komal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service B...
High Class Call Girls Bangalore Komal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service B...narwatsonia7
 

Recently uploaded (20)

2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 28
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 282024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 28
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 28
 
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...
Precarious profits? Why firms use insecure contracts, and what would change t...
 
Club of Rome: Eco-nomics for an Ecological Civilization
Club of Rome: Eco-nomics for an Ecological CivilizationClub of Rome: Eco-nomics for an Ecological Civilization
Club of Rome: Eco-nomics for an Ecological Civilization
 
(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(VASUDHA) Call Girls Balaji Nagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.
WIPO magazine issue -1 - 2024 World Intellectual Property organization.
 
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up Number
 
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists Lawmakers
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists LawmakersHow the Congressional Budget Office Assists Lawmakers
How the Congressional Budget Office Assists Lawmakers
 
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
(NEHA) Bhosari Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune Escorts
 
Climate change and occupational safety and health.
Climate change and occupational safety and health.Climate change and occupational safety and health.
Climate change and occupational safety and health.
 
Delhi Russian Call Girls In Connaught Place ➡️9999965857 India's Finest Model...
Delhi Russian Call Girls In Connaught Place ➡️9999965857 India's Finest Model...Delhi Russian Call Girls In Connaught Place ➡️9999965857 India's Finest Model...
Delhi Russian Call Girls In Connaught Place ➡️9999965857 India's Finest Model...
 
Global debate on climate change and occupational safety and health.
Global debate on climate change and occupational safety and health.Global debate on climate change and occupational safety and health.
Global debate on climate change and occupational safety and health.
 
Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…
Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…
Goa Escorts WhatsApp Number South Goa Call Girl … 8588052666…
 
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SHINA) Call Girls Khed ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
VIP Mumbai Call Girls Andheri West Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash on...
VIP Mumbai Call Girls Andheri West Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash on...VIP Mumbai Call Girls Andheri West Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash on...
VIP Mumbai Call Girls Andheri West Just Call 9920874524 with A/C Room Cash on...
 
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Chakan ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
PPT Item # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only)
PPT Item # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only)PPT Item # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only)
PPT Item # 4 - 231 Encino Ave (Significance Only)
 
Zechariah Boodey Farmstead Collaborative presentation - Humble Beginnings
Zechariah Boodey Farmstead Collaborative presentation -  Humble BeginningsZechariah Boodey Farmstead Collaborative presentation -  Humble Beginnings
Zechariah Boodey Farmstead Collaborative presentation - Humble Beginnings
 
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CT
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CTFair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CT
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CT
 
High Class Call Girls Bangalore Komal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service B...
High Class Call Girls Bangalore Komal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service B...High Class Call Girls Bangalore Komal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service B...
High Class Call Girls Bangalore Komal 7001305949 Independent Escort Service B...
 

Promoting green foreign direct investment practices and lessons from the field

  • 1. The United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) have set a new global agenda through 2030 with a strong green dimension cutting across many goals and targets. Subsequently at the 21st Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (COP21) in Paris, 195 member States agreed on further measures to reduce green-house gas (GHG) emissions with the aim of keeping the rise in global temperature for this century well below two degrees Celsius (°C) above pre-industrial levels. These ambitious action plans call for profound transformations of energy, transportation, and dozens of other industries, demanding investment in the order of trillions of U.S. dollars.1 This will translate into more public institutions, including investment promotion agencies (IPAs), being asked by their governments to actively look for ways to contribute to national climate goals. It is, therefore, incumbent upon all IPAs to integrate climate goals and green investment promotion in their strategic considerations. Meanwhile, green technologies are becoming increasingly viable in commercial terms, making them bigger and better targets for investment promotion. For example, in some places the costs of wind and solar energy generation have become competitive with traditional fossil fuel energy sources.2 As described by UNCTAD,3 low- carbon investment, which we will name green investment in this study, can comprise of: investment in production processes with a PROMOTING GREEN FDI: Practices and Lessons from the Field HIGHLIGHTS • Government policies and initiatives matter for green sectors. • Investment promotion agencies (IPAs) should ‘think outside the box’ to identify opportunities and ways to use foreign direct investment (FDI) to green their economies. • IPAs can improve visibility of green investment opportunities through successful pilot projects and the preparation of pipelines of bankable projects. • Promoting green FDI requires sector knowledge and a focused strategy. • Partnerships and networks can play a key role in developing investment opportunities in the green economy. U N I T E D N AT I O N S C O N F E R E N C E O N T R A D E A N D D E V E L O P M E N T TheIPAObserveripa The IPA Observer series is prepared by the Investment Promotion Section of UNCTAD’s Division on Investment and Enterprise (DIAE). Its objective is to show examples of strategic and operational best practice in investment promotion from agencies worldwide to practitioners and governments in developing countries, with a view to share lessons that are practical and replicable for their investment promotion agencies (IPAs). 1 By 2030, an estimate of up to US$1.2 trillion per year will be required to limit GHG emissions to the level needed for a 2 °C target to be met. Page xxvii, World Investment Report 2010, UNCTAD. 2 The Economist, August 2015, Renewable Energy: Puffs of Hope. 3 UNCTAD, 2013, Promoting Low-Carbon Investment. 1 No.5 – 2016 This publication has not been formally edited.
  • 2. reduced GHG impact; investment in clean energy generation; and investment in research and production facilities to manufacture GHG reducing products and provide related services. These are technology-intensive and often capital-intensive industries with technologies that are quickly evolving. In those developing countries, where green industries and practices are still nascent or non-existent, foreign companies are vital to jump-starting the low-carbon economy and should be more aggressively pursued. This note uses three case studies to extract lessons on how this can be done. It examines IPAs, including investment promotion and business development agencies from developed and emerging economies, in diverse locations and circumstances. The very different approaches taken by the three IPAs to green their economies show that there is no one-size-fits-all solution and that a going-green strategy must be tailored to local circumstances. In many cases, an IPA needs to ‘think outside the box’ to seek niches and possibilities for green investment, consider what can be done given each agency’s limited resources and look for partners to pursue the strategy, programme or project. Practices and lessons highlighted in this note are therefore relevant to a range of IPAs and business development agencies, including those from low-income countries. The first agency featured in this note is Investment South Africa (InvestSA), the national IPA of South Africa that has facilitated the country’s first foreign direct investment (FDI) projects in renewable energy generation and equipment manufacturing. The second is the Portland Development Commission (PDC) in Oregon, United States of America, a subnational IPA that has proactively attracted foreign venture capital for the expansion of local cleantech clusters. The third is the Ulsan Eco-Industrial Park (EIP) Center of the Republic of Korea, which has coordinated the creation of a symbiotic network of companies in the Ulsan EIP that give rise to opportunities to reduce waste and environmental impact while cutting costs. INVESTMENT SOUTH AFRICA USING FDI TO JUMP START RENEWABLE INDUSTRIES In South Africa, InvestSA,4 the national IPA which is embedded in the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI), leveraged FDI in renewable power generation and turned this investment into a catalyst for domestic manufacturing of renewable energy equipment. InvestSA did this with strategically commissioned studies, a practical approach to local linkages and good stakeholder networks including agencies such as the South African Independent Power Producers (IPP) Office and the National Department of Energy. Policy background South Africa is heavily dependent on fossil fuels, which represent 87 per cent of the national energy supply. The country has large coal reserves, making that energy source easy and cheap, yet a green economy features prominently in national development plans. In 2011, the South African government, business community, organized labour, and civil society signed a Green Economy Accord. The Accord is one of several development plans that need to be reflected in DTI’s Industrial Policy Action Plan. The Action Plan, in turn, provides strategic direction to InvestSA, which is expected to identify areas to which it can contribute by generating investment and jobs. The Green Economy Accord makes 12 commitments to the advancement of a green economy, including the roll-out of renewable energy, the reduction of industrial waste through reuse and recycling, and industrial retrofitting. The roll-out of renewable energy includes a government commitment to purchase four gigawatts of electricity by 2016 from new, renewable, and domestically generated capacity.5 By guaranteeing a market in this way and awarding contracts through public bidding, the government has stimulated major interest from foreign investors, which InvestSA is responsible for managing. Another government measure in support of renewable energy is a cash grant of up to US$3 million to cover 30 per cent of the costs 4 In April 2015, the decision was made to separate the trade and investment functions of Trade and Investment South Africa. As of this note’s publication, the new structures have yet to be settled. 5 Economic Development Department of the Republic of South Africa, 2011, Green Economy Accord. 2
  • 3. 6 Website of GRI (http://www.gri.com.es/en/gestamp-to-build-wind-tower-manufacturing-facility-in-south-africa/). 3 incurred by a company retrofitting existing industrial facilities to use renewable energy, such as through the purchase and installation of rooftop solar panels. How InvestSA promotes green investment InvestSA targets three types of green investments: renewable energy (generation and equipment manufacturing), waste management (reduction, treatment, conversion to energy), and energy efficiency (biofuels and greening of traditional industries). This note looks into the agency’s experience in promoting FDI in renewable energy generation. While the IPP Office, together with the South African Department of Energy, administers the bidding process for would-be energy providers, InvestSA provides foreign investors with information and assistance before and during the bidding process, coordinates procedures for startups with provincial and local governments, and helps bid winners tap into other sources of support for green projects. Bids are scored on the dual basis of electricity price (70   per cent) and economic development impact (30 per cent), which includes linkages that investors can create with local suppliers and the use of locally sourced equipment and services. About 60 per cent of InvestSA’s work is spent proactively marketing opportunities to targeted investors, and promoting the cash grant to green traditional industries (including encouraging existing companies to use renewable energy in their operations). The other 40 per cent of InvestSA’s work is devoted to supporting firms that are attracted to South Africa, due to the country’s strategic location and its government’s procurement commitments. Challenges and lessons learned The country strategy for the promotion of green FDI was well defined by the national government, and it provided a framework for the work of the agency in the area. However, InvestSA’s green economy department was created only after the signing of the Green Economy Accord, and initially the staff assigned to the department had little knowledge of the diverse range of highly technical fields under that label. The first challenge faced by the agency was how to fill this knowledge gap as rapidly as possible through learning-by-doing. The renewable industry is relatively new, and the country itself had no experience in the sector setting. The localization potential for photovoltaics and wind equipment manufacturing, which InvestSA should promote, was unclear for the agency itself as well as for other partner government agencies. To meet this challenge, DTI’s Industrial Development Division (IDD) commissioned two studies on the localization potential for photovoltaics and for wind equipment. The two studies gave InvestSA the understanding of domestic production capacity and competitiveness to make the business case to potential investors. Recognizing the need for energy suppliers to buy into the technical feasibility of local content and linkages, IDD took a flexible position on requirement levels in its first negotiations, which were with the Spanish wind giant Gestamp Renewable Industries (GRI). InvestSA was involved in the negotiations from the very beginning and the overall government objective was to ensure that an appropriate and feasible level of local linkages was achieved. Effective consultations among relevant government agencies, such as InvestSA, IDD and the Department of Energy, were extremely helpful to develop a good understanding of the potential for localization, and finally helped bring GRI on board. In the end, GRI invested US$210 million in a wind farm,6 stimulating substantial local production of wind towers. The following year, GRI announced a US$29 million investment expected to create more than 200 jobs in the manufacturing of 150 towers per year for the South African market. The success of the first projects not only generated much needed buzz for renewable projects in the investment community, but also revealed the potential for localization in the industry. InvestSA’s support for local suppliers to increase their absorption capacity also proved crucial. With collaboration and support from the agency, DCD Wind Towers, a South African company, became the first African company to manufacture wind towers. The support appears to be essential to the development of domestic suppliers, as it has proven difficult for domestic manufacturers to
  • 4. obtain finance, even with the growing demand of energy suppliers. Another six companies supported by InvestSA are now assembling or manufacturing renewable energy equipment, including four making solar panels and two making inverters. PORTLAND DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION (OREGON, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA) PROMOTING INDIGENOUS CLEANTECH IN GLOBAL MARKETS Portland’s public policies and popular culture have earned it a strong reputation as a green city. Over the last several years, it has been repeatedly ranked as the greenest city in the United States, the number one forward- thinker in environmental awareness and resource conservation, first in LEED-certified buildings per capita, third best city to live in, and the fourth hottest spot for knowledge workers.7 The Portland region has a large pool of cleantech and green building startups. However, none of the startups have yet grown to be large companies, and Portland has not yet fully tapped into its potential as a green FDI location. Portland is therefore supporting local green businesses in exporting green products and services and in attracting capital and investment, including FDI. How the PDC promotes green investment This confluence of factors is aptly reflected in the investment promotion strategy of the PDC, known as the Greater Portland Global Trade and Investment Plan. Developed in collaboration with the Brookings Institution, the PDC’s strategy prioritizes cleantech as an emerging sector to be nurtured and more firmly established. The PDC has found a niche as a matchmaker and facilitator among companies looking for partners and as an aftercare provider to domestic and foreign firms, helping them grow through access to new markets. With the governments of Portland and the state of Oregon having earned strong, increasingly global reputations for their leadership in environmental policy, the PDC has found that it enjoys a level of clout when bringing parties together and helping them seal deals with the glue of government support. The most public manifestation of the PDC’s ability to bring cleantech companies together in productive collaboration is an annual investor match-making event at Oregon BEST FEST,8 a cleantech innovation conference opened by the governor of Oregon and featuring a cleantech competition, a speed networking event, company exhibits, and speakers from industry financers, potential technology partners, and entrepreneurs. It is through this event that the PDC introduced Portland-based Energy Storage Systems (ESS) to Pangaea Ventures, the Canadian venture capitalist that would eventually lead a US$3.2 million in venture capital funding in 2015.9 ESS is a maker of innovative, all- iron flow batteries, which are used in the storage and off-peak discharge of renewable energy, which was accorded the Portland Business Journal’s award for Sustainable Product Innovation in 2015.10 This company of 17 people will use the funding to ramp up production and commercialize its product. Targeting solar photovoltaic producers close to grid parity, ESS seeks to provide a low-cost storage option that will support the spread of profitable solar energy production. Of equal importance to the PDC’s matchmaking is its innovative aftercare service tailored to cleantech startups. Considering the large number of cleantech startups in the Portland region and the high rate of startup failure, the PDC’s assistance in accessing new markets can be significant to company survival. Lucid Energy, a company with patented technology to generate electricity from the flow of water through gravity-fed pipes, had installed capacity at only one public utility, with one more under development, when it asked for the PDC’s 4 7 Portland Development Commission, 2010, Economic Development Strategy: A Five-Year Plan for Promoting Job Creation and Economic Growth. 8 http://oregonbest.org/news-events/events-opportunities/oregon-best-fest/ 9 “Energy Storage Systems secures $3.2 million flow battery VC funding,” 8 October 2015. PV Magazine (http:// www.pv-magazine.com/news/details/beitrag/energy-storage-systems-secures-32-million-flow-battery-vc- funding_100021458/#ixzz3o0H62Jaj) 10 “Meet Oregon’s Top 3 Sustainable Manufacturers of the Year for 2015,” 29 October 2015. Portland Business Journal (http://www.bizjournals.com/portland/blog/sbo/2015/10/meet-oregons-3-sustainable-manufacturers-of-the. html?ana=e_du_pubs=article_dued=2015-10-29u=kQWEms%2FdGNCV4AwEKpZG7a1n0vt=1446158429)
  • 5. ULSAN ECO-INDUSTRIAL PARK CENTER (CITY OF ULSAN, REPUBLIC OF KOREA) LEADING EXISTING INVESTORS TO A BUSINESS MODEL FOR GOING GREEN The region around the city of Ulsan is known as the Ulsan Industrial District. It is the Republic of Korea’s largest industrial center and a global industrial leader in many respects. On just over 1,000 square kilometers of land, the Ulsan region hosts 15 industrial parks. For a sense of scale, just two of these parks, Ulsan Mipo and Onsan, include about 1,200 companies and more than 120,000 employees. Among them are more than 130 foreign companies from Japan, Germany, the Netherlands and the United States, such as BASF, Du Pont, Dow Chemical and the Solvay Group.12 However, few of the companies operating in Ulsan are engaged in green industries as their primary business lines. With this level of economic activity in such a concentrated area, the environmental impact must be carefully planned and monitored to manage waste and limit pollution. So in 2005 the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy introduced the EIP initiative for the transition of industrial complexes into eco-industrial parks. As part of this initiative the Korea Industrial Complex Corporation and the Ulsan Metropolitan Authority established the Ulsan EIP Center, which acts as a business development agency to identify and make the case for investment in green production processes with a reduced GHG impact. Going beyond waste disposal and pollution mitigation, the agency tries to reuse and recycle waste, cascading the use of energy and water in a way that optimizes efficiency and creates new value through industrial symbiosis. How the Ulsan EIP Center promotes green investment The Ulsan EIP Center, established for implementing the Ulsan EIP project, explored symbiotic relationships and shared facilities among individual companies that would contribute to clusters achieving collective help in introducing the technology to the city government of Johannesburg, South Africa. Lucid Energy knew that Johannesburg was looking at low-carbon options for mitigating power shortages, and the PDC was able to quickly obtain a letter from the mayor of Portland introducing the company to his counterpart in Johannesburg. Portland received a response within a week, and within three weeks, the mayor of Johannesburg came to Portland with a team, on an agenda organized by the PDC. Meeting with Lucid Energy, Portland’s mayor and a roundtable of city bureaus, the Johannesburg delegation learned how the turbines were integrated into the municipal water lines and saw an effective demonstration of Lucid Energy. In May 2015, the mayor of Johannesburg announced plans to implement the same technology.11 Challenges and lessons learned In doing company matchmaking, the PDC’s effectiveness depends greatly on the two mutually reinforcing factors of strong sector knowledge and relationships with a wide range of sector players. The PDC has only two full-time staff working on the green economy, neither of whom started their roles with experience in the field. Like InvestSA, the PDC has built knowledge and relationships through extensive desk research and strong customer service. This level of attention to clients keeps the PDC in close contact with companies throughout their projects and gives it privileged insights into the workings of each company and the sector. Knowledge of the industry’s players, trends, and quickly changing technologies enables the PDC to design and promote BEST FEST as a high- value, well-attended event and to create a roster of priority companies for targeted aftercare. The PDC maintains a roster of more than 60 priority companies, together with information on their technologies, markets, levels of development, international footprint and financial needs. This gives the PDC a bird’s eye view of subsectoral strengths and gaps, which informs not only company-specific objectives but also investor-targeting efforts and policy advocacy. 5 11 “How Joburg’s energy-from-water-pipes will work,” 7 May 2015. Mybroadband News ( http://mybroadband.co.za/ news/energy/125756-how-joburgs-energy-from-water-pipes-will-work.html) 12 http://www.investkorea.org/ulsan_en/invest/invest02.do
  • 6. efficiencies that cut costs and increase eco-friendliness. The EIP committee included representatives of the national agency in charge of industrial park management, private companies, non-governmental organizations, and an RD center of the University of Ulsan. Potential project identification started with mapping the companies in a park, their inputs and their waste products. The Center then identified a series of potential projects for steam recycling. Potential projects were shared with stakeholders and the RD center, which together investigated project feasibility and produced a final report of projects and their business cases. Then the EIP Center started to run a few well selected pilot projects to show the feasibility of the green concept. With several sound business cases established for the sale and distribution of waste steam generated by a number of companiesinthedistrict,theCenter worked with those companies to undertake the permitting, financing and construction needed for implementation. In the first phase, steam networks were established between two pairs of companies, which showed very positive results. For example, Sungam Municipal Waste Incinerator Facility and Hyosung Company together invested US$5 million in the network but accrued over US$7 million per year in cost savings. Steam replaced enough fossil fuels to reduce carbon dioxide emissions by 55,500 tons per year, and Hyosung generated so much excess steam that it made sense to expand its production facilities, employing another 150 people. With demonstrated success, several more projects came online quickly, and the rationale for larger scale public-private investments in the infrastructure for a “steam highway” became evident. Eventually, US$26 million in public investment established a six-kilometer steam pipeline with multiple entrances and exits, allowing companies that invested in the infrastructure to connect their facilities to the highway. This is expected to reduce GHG by 100,000 tons per year while creating US$20 million in energy supply and cost savings. At every step the Ulsan EIP Center was the lead coordinator, articulating the vision for park- level symbiosis, making the business case, and negotiating commitments and prices with participants, who had to find a way to share the costs and benefits of these joint projects. Company due diligence typically took about a year, while negotiations lasted anywhere from three months to more than four years. By the end of 2014, eight years after Ulsan EIP’s first symbiosis was established, projects involving 31 companies were up and running. These generated annual cost savings of US$74 million, new revenue of US$45 million, and the following environmentally beneficial reductions per year: • 487,626 tons of carbon dioxide • 196,102 tons of energy • 79,007 tons of wastewater • 38,544 tons of industrial by-products • 4,052 tons of air pollutants Today, Ulsan EIP enjoys a global reputation that brings new investments from companies for whom the symbiotic aspect is a driving factor. As of the publication of this note, a German chemical company is planning a US$500 million investment project in Ulsan, attracted by cheap utility cost and stable raw material acquisition through industrial symbiosis. In addition, this concept is being tested in other developing countries, for example, in eight low-carbon export processing zones in Bangladesh. 6
  • 7. Challenges and lessons learned According to a Director of the Ulsan EIP Center, the Ulsan EIP experience was private sector- driven. The government-created centerwasacatalystandfocalpoint for the discussions that occurred among private companies, but it was the companies themselves that determined whether there was a business case for a project. The greatest challenge to Ulsan EIP Center was, therefore, in convening, engaging, and enlisting investors that were not normally enthusiastic about government involvement in the workings of what was felt to be an already well- functioning industrial ecosystem. During the mapping of a park’s companies and their inputs and waste, most companies were secretive and did not want to participate, viewing EIP Center experts as “spies” out to discover environmental violations. Even those companies that were relatively welcoming had little interest in proactively pursuing GHG mitigation measures, as they were not a part of their core business and had little incentive to propose them to their headquarters. Ulsan EIP Center addressed these reservations by framing the project at every turn as a business innovation to enhance efficiency, risk mitigation and profit. Ulsan EIP Center also gave stakeholders the company mapping and list of potential projects upfront as an enticement and demonstration of the project’s commitment to solving practical problems that the companies were facing. Once buy-in was achieved and the first phases of the EIP project were implemented, project successes were well-publicized with credit freely given to all stakeholders involved, thereby strengthening their resolve and bringing in new waves of participants. According to the Director of the EIP Center, leadership and the patient building of a series of achievements, one after the other, have been the key to success. LESSONS FOR IPAS The cases of InvestSA, the PDC and the Ulsan EIP Center have significant differences, in terms of IPA nature, jurisdictional size, level of industrial development, and green activities facilitated. Yet their challenges and successes demonstrate certain shared characteristics. This suggests that most IPAs with green objectives could benefit from an understanding of their lessons learned. Five main lessons stand out: 1. Government policies matter. The three cases discussed in this note each started with a different set of local characteristics which needed to be examined—close vicinity of many industrial activities in Ulsan, but little connectivity between companies for waste disposal; good potential for renewable energy in South Africa but a nascent renewable market with very limited manufacturing activities; and a sizable pool of cleantech startups in Portland but none that had really taken off. The government’s vision in Ulsan, public policies in South Africa, and environmental credentials with local government support in Portland were all instrumental in creating investment opportunities. 2. IPAs and partners need to ‘think outside the box’ to identify opportunities and ways to use FDI to green their economies. It usually requires innovative approaches that take into consideration local market conditions and IPA resource constraints. Green investment opportunities are widespread, both in the development of renewable energy sources and the greening of existing 7
  • 8. 8 economic activities. The challenge is to identify an appropriate target area, and select the right model to tackle hurdles. The case studies in this note show that an agency can take a light approach in some cases, while a more comprehensive approach may be necessary under different conditions. 3. Green investment opportunities and business cases need to be visible. Investment promotion and business development agencies can make a difference by undertaking successful pilot projects or preparing a pipeline of bankable projects, which can be readily promoted to potential investors. For example, IPAs can help create viable business cases (InvestSA) or show investors in traditional industries how applying low-carbon practices can be profitable (Ulsan EIP). 4. Promoting green FDI requires strong sector knowledge and a focused strategy based on sector competitiveness. Both market development and policy support contribute to a sector’s competitiveness. A few basic studies can go a long way to identifying sector gaps and top opportunities for investment promotion. It also helps developing in-house expertise. 5. IPA partnerships and networks can help broker opportunities in the formative green economy. This was evidenced in all three cases, where IPAs facilitated linkageswithdomesticsuppliers, matched venture capitalists to technology developers, and organized partners in industrial symbiosis. CONCLUSIONS Most green industries and their technologies are relatively young, with markets and value chains that remain fluid and owe much of their early growth to supportive public policies. IPAs that understand well that landscape and design strategies around the most competitive sectors are in a good position to connect investors to their markets. As demonstrated by the three case studies, IPAs and business development agencies can make a difference in promoting green investment by developing expertise, targeting the right sectors and activities and creating or demonstrating the business case. Equally important is the development of local absorptive capacity, so that linkages and partnerships could be created. The eventual networks that are formed will help retain green investment and secure a long-term impact on sustainable development. For more information visit the Division on Investment and Enterprise (DIAE) at www.unctad.org/diae or email ips@unctad.org UNCTAD/WEB/DIAE/PCB/2015/6