SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 28
Download to read offline
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT
Automotive Product
Quality Optimisation
Early Cycle Failure
Proactive Prevention
FMEA Approach
October 2018
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Contents
3
Introduction 5
Key Today’s Challenges in Vehicle Quality Engineering 6
Many Ways Systems Fail to Function or Meet Requirements 7
Assuring Product Quality Robustness in the VDP 8
Early Cycle Product Development Failure Mode Prevention 9
Designing Failure-Tolerant Products 10
Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) Quality Management 11
FMEA Provides Many Benefits
There are Many Types of FMEA’s
Effective FMEA Deployment and Principles
FMA Process Flow
FMA Model and Rational Approach
Quality Risk Management is Getting More Important 19
Risk Analysis is not Easily and Commonly Incorporated
Common Delivery Pitfalls
Oversight and Quality Assurance
Examples: 23
Toyota Proactive Preventive Technique
How Porsche Ensures the Quality of its Products
Summary 25
How SSCG can help? 26
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Are you sometimes puzzled by
new products that suddenly fail
in customers’ hands, despite
successfully passing all
verification test procedures?
What could have prevented it?
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Introduction
5
Vehicle Quality and Reliability
are Key Megatrends and plays a
key role in maintaining customer
satisfaction. Appeal, reliability
and service determine quality as
it is perceived by the customer
throughout the entire product
experience.
Today, product quality is one of the most critical uptake or
purchasing factor for consideration by customers. Product recalls
due to serious quality and reliability concerns can ruin brand
reputation or put companies out of business. Less serious problems
may result in customer dissatisfaction, loss of sales, high cost of
poor quality and a delay in the launch of a new product.
Marketplace pressures to continuously deliver high quality products
in shorten period reduces development time and increases risks of
potential failures. Furthermore, new product failure uncertainties
remains present throughout Product Development Process (PDP) –
from the specification of requirements in design to build variation in
manufacturing and aftermarket operation. Therefore, companies
across the automotive sectors have to give priority in uncertainty
characterisation and propagation in the development of zero-defect
and failure tolerant designs and robust manufacturing processes to
minimise and eliminate risks of quality failures.
Uncertainty must be the focal point and inherent part of PDP if
companies are to improve product quality and reliability. To prevent
failures and improve process reliability, companies must follow key
best practices:
 PDP is a simulation of future production and consumption
 Greater importance in product detail consistency
 Product performance integrity
 Quality is a source of competitive advantage.
https://www.daimler.com/products/passenger-cars/mercedes-benz/a-class-kecskemet.html
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Key Today’s Challenges in Vehicle Quality Engineering
6
Late failure mode discovery is costly to
implement countermeasures
Stringent regulatory requirements and customer expectations are
placing increased demands on companies for high quality and
reliable products. The increasing capabilities and technical
functionality of many products are making it more difficult for
manufacturers to maintain superior quality and reliability required.
Traditionally, reliability has been achieved through extensive testing
and use of techniques such as probabilistic reliability modelling.
These are techniques done in the late stages of development no
longer suitable for today’s fast paced business environment.
For vehicle manufactures to succeed in the current competitive
market place over the long run, have to offer value driven
competitive products or services than their competitors.
Today’s market pressure points and challenges:
 Design integration of quality early in the PDP to prevent failures.
 Competition to offer higher value quality products with cutting
edge features and functionality.
 Performance - Product that outperforms their competitor.
 Reliability – Products that meets/exceed markets and operating
constraints.
 Process realignment for efficient, create more synergies,
accelerate innovation and improve quality.
 Increasingly complex vehicle technologies call for human and
intuitive operation.
 Make vehicle as fuel-efficient as possible while at all times
conforming to safety, design, quality and performance
requirements.
The Next Level in Early Cycle
Quality and Reliability Assurance
Management
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
7
While the Vehicle Development Process (VDP) may be viewed
from many perspectives, it is a series of complex processes and
decisions thus can be posed to complex multidimensional
problem and to generate potential quality failure modes.
Uncertainty are present throughout the VDP. Hence, establishing
early cycle failure mode avoidance and prevention measures is a
critical to eliminate later discovery.
Failure Mode Identification
A component / subsystem / system MUST consistently perform
its intended function in the presence of uncontrollable
influences (Noise Factors), including:
 Piece-to-piece variation
 Product changes over useful life
 Customer usage and duty cycles
 External environment
 System interactions with adjacent components
Ways which failure modes are
manifested
 No Function
 Partial – Over/Under Function:
 Degradation
 Intermittent Function
 Unintended Function
Many Ways Vehicle Systems Fail to Function or Meet Requirements
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Assuring Product Quality Robustness in the VDP
8
Quality can be broadly defined as meeting customer expectations,
conformance to standards, legislative and production tests. Robust
integration of uncertainty and failure modes early in the VDP phase
can limit risks both relative the business and products.
Clear and well defined details supported by well governed reviews
are critical to ensure product design quality robustness:
 Voice of the Customer Market Research: Stated and unstated
 Compatible product specs, requirements and quality attributes
 Product Development (PD) project scope and resources
 Quality history reviews and capture Lessons Learned
 Quality Risk Assessment
 Procedures, systems and techniques that increase PD efficiency
and efficacy
 Manage design and process change
 Manufacturing quality assurance plan
 Engineering talent and skills
Common advance quality planning underlying principles:
 Robustly defining customer requirements and expectations
 Early detection, prevention and control of failure to reduce
escapes
 Reduction of cost of poor quality: Customer dissatisfaction,
warrant and recalls, production FTT failures, rework, complaints,
potential arbitration, lost royalty and sales
 Forge effective cross functional quality management and
oversight
Effectiveness Foundation
Requirements and Principals
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Early Cycle Product Development Failure Mode Prevention
9
There are many opportunities to detect and prevent
failure modes early in product development phase.
Late failure modes discovery is costly to remedy and
require more countermeasures, with limited analysis
and deployment time.
Failure modes can be detected early through:
 Thought experiments (e.g. FMEA, Design Review)
 Engineering Standards and rules
 Virtual analysis (CAE, CFD, State Flow Models, etc)
 Physical testing.
By understanding product lifecycle operating
conditions and variables can facilitate to:
 Better understand the key performance factors
and thus develop better countermeasure.
 Identify improvement opportunities.
Quality requirements must be robustly
defined and clear at the start of
programme development
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Designing Failure-Tolerant Products
Reliability-Based Design Optimisation (RBDO)
10
The deviation from the ideal function indicates how close the
system is to the failure mode.
Robustness failures occur when the demand placed on the design
exceeds the capacity.
Robustness Sensitivity Noises:
• Production variations
• Wear out and drift over time
• Customer duty cycles
• Environment
• Component interactions
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA)
Quality Management
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) Quality Management
13
Why FMEA?
A methodology for discovering potential malfunction and reliability
problems that may exist within the design of a product or process
early in the development cycle to ensure meet or exceed customer
expectations, standards and regulatory requirements.
Extensively used in system development for anticipating failure
during design stage by identifying, analysing, evaluating and
prioritising actions to mitigate potential/known failure modes,
thereby enhancing reliability through design.
FMEA is not a substitute for good engineering. Rather, it enhances
good engineering by applying the knowledge and experience of a
Cross Functional Team (CFT) to review the design progress by
assessing its risk of failure. FMEA promotes corrective action to
prevent or decrease the possibility of defects being delivered to the
customer
While practical anticipation of every failure modes in a product
during design has its limitations and not possible, FMEA help to
formulate as extensive a list of potential failure modes as possible.
The early and consistent use of FMEAs in the design process allows
companies to design out failures and produce reliable, safe, and
customer pleasing products. FMEAs also capture historical
information for use in future product improvement.
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
14
Discovering failure modes early in
Product Development (PD) phase
using FMEA provides the several
benefits include:
 Documented method for selecting a design with a high
probability of successful quality operation and safety to
increase customer satisfaction.
 A uniform methodology of assessing potential failure
mechanisms, modes and impact on system operation to
improve product/process reliability and quality.
 Multiple choices early identification, verification and
elimination of failure points and system interface problems.
 An effective method for evaluating the effect of proposed
changes to the design and/or operational procedures.
 A basis for in-flight troubleshooting procedures and for
locating performance monitoring and fault-detection devices.
 Criteria for improved early planning of validation tests and
development, capture risks and engineering actions taken
 Prioritised product/process deficiencies management.
 Catalyst for teamwork and quality improvement knowledge
exchange between functions.
 Improved Design for Manufacturing and Assembly (DFM/A)
 Lower cost solutions and Cost of Poor Quality (CPQ) in
production and aftermarket operation.
FMEA Provides Many Benefits
One of many tools used to
discover failure at its earliest
possible point in product or
process design.
https://www.locusresearch.com/avoiding-failure/
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
15
FMEAs should always be done whenever
failures would mean potential harm or injury
to the user of the end item being designed
System - CFMEA Design - DFMEA Process - PFMEA Machinery - MFEMA Service - SFMEA
• Software SFMEA
• Foundation FFMEA
• Concept CFMEA
There are Many Types of FMEA’s
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Effective FMEA Deployment and Principles
16
The automotive industry has long used FMEA as means to improve
customer satisfaction and reduce non-conformance.
FMEA, is a tool for the identification and prioritisation of possible
ways a product or process can fail. The intent is to use that
information to make improvements to the product or process.
FMEA is primarily deployed to:
 Develop product or process requirements that minimise the
likelihood of failures.
 Evaluate customer requirements and functionality in the design
process to ensure that the requirements do not introduce
potential failures.
 Identify design characteristics that contribute to system failures
to minimise the resulting effects.
 Support the development of product/process test methods and
procedures to ensure that the failures have been successfully
verified and controlled.
 Track and manage potential risks in the design and development
process.
 Ensure that any product potential failures poses low safety risks
and impact to customers.
 When designing a new product, process or service, transforming
an existing process, quality improvement activities and need to
understand and improve the failures of a process
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Common FMEA Deployment Guiding
Principles
Right Objectivity and Focus:
 Problem Prevention
 Design and Process Improvements
 Leverage FMEAs to Improve Test Plans and Process Controls
 Select FMEA Projects Based on Preliminary Risk Assessment
 Lean and simplicity
Right Resource Allocation:
 Team-Based Activity
 Skills and Experience
 Lessons Learned
 Robust Management
 Effective Process
 Quality Knowledge
Procedures:
 Well defined and clear
 Requirements Driven and Data Driven
 Root Cause and Failure Definition Mechanisms
 Focus on Areas of High Concern and Risk
 Right Time Frame
 Fully Execution to Ensure Risk Reduction to an Acceptable Level
17
Input Process Output
FMEA
FMA Process Flow
Inputs & Outputs - Outcome Based Deliverables
 Customer Requirements
 System Design Specifications (SDS)
 Quality Function Deployment (QFD)
 Benchmarking
 Design and / or Process Assumptions
 Preliminary Bill of Material / Components
 Known causes from surrogate products
 Boundary diagram and interface matrix
 Parameter Diagrams (P-Diagrams)
 Potential causes from design choices
 Potential causes from noises and
environments
 Baseline FMEA (Historical FMEA)
 Past Test and Control Methods used on
similar products
 Past Failure or error states
 Process Flow Diagram
 Characteristics Matrix
 Design Verification Plan (DVP)
 Quality Risk Management (QRM) Plan
 Test Cases
 Design Rules
 Standards
 Special Characteristics:
Critical/Significant
 Deviation Plans
 Safety Sign-off
 Robustness Checklist
Avoiding Failure in Design
https://www.locusresearch.com/avoiding-failure/
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
18
Function Potential Design Controls Actions Verification
Failure Mode Effects Causes Prevention Detection
FMA Model and Rational Approach
A Structured Approach to Define Important Quality Focal Points
Potential Causes Analysis
Cause and effect (Ishikawa Diagram) and 5 whys
Typical Failure Effects
Noise
Inoperative
Unpleasant Odour
Leaks
Operation Impaired
Poor appearance
Unstable
Regulatory non-compliance
Rough-rattle/vibration
Preventions
Score
effectiveness of
countermeasures
Detections
Design Reviews
Assess Stds
Test cases
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Review
process
Define
potential
failure
modes
List failure
mode
potential
effects
Assign
severity
rating
Assign
occurrence
rating
Assign
detection
rating
Calculate
effect risk
priority
number
Prioritise the
failure
modes
Eliminateor
de-risk high-
risk failure
modes
Recalculate
RPN as risks
are reduced
or
eliminated
19
Quality Risk Management (QRM) is Getting More Important
The rise in focus on risk management and mitigation through FMEA
is so integral in the development process that Six Sigma, Production
Part Approval Process (PPAP), Tooling and Equipment (TE 9000), ISO
9000, QS-9000, and ISO/TS16949 have all required FMEA as one of
the suggested ways a company can improve.
An effective quality risk management approach can further ensure
the high quality vehicles and products to the customers by
providing a proactive means to identify and control potential quality
issues during development and manufacturing.
Risk identification and analysis, should effectively capture
knowledge, map processes, and allow the definition of an ontology
of objects (unit operations) with specific attributes (inputs and
outputs).
Risk Lifecycle Management Plan (RLMP) should be put in place to
manage unacceptable risks, evaluating the control strategy
performance, detecting improvement opportunities and managing
additional risks originated from new events.
Team alignment, empathy across multiple functions and an
effective knowledge-sharing and harvest right from the beginning,
all needed for a successful QRM.
The target of completing of an FMEA is in practice very limited and
extremely time-consuming to achieve if the initial 'knowledge-
based' steps are weak.
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
20
Risk identification
 Use of multiple techniques and tools
 Must be based on reason and factual data
 Should be what could, might or possibly happen
 Categorised as either threat (-ve) or opportunity (+ve)
 Written in the context
 Consequence of occurring or impact described
 Ownership assigned
 Proximity determined and assigned
Exposure Analysis
 Industry-specific quality management requirements
 Complex analytical or technical sampling and testing
 Complete finished product for cycle testing and analysis
 Highly technical quality controls or skills for process control
 Diversity of new products introduced in a short period
Controls
 Comprehensive quality planning, control and Standard Operating
Procedures (SOPs) for all significant processes
 Effective training programmes and suitably skilled employees
 Full familiarity of employees with quality management procedures
 Audit programmes and follow-up of findings
 Regular review and updating of procedures and processes
 State of the art systems, personnel, methods, processes and
documentation of results for quality control.
Risk Analysis is not Easily and Commonly Incorporated
What to look for: Identification, Exposure Analysis & Controls
Prof. Dr. José C. Menezes. CEO 4Tune Engineering and
Associate Professor, University of Lisbon for Bioengineering
The purpose of this Risk Factor is to
assess the quality management
system in place, and the quality
controls / quality assurance applied
to the product(s) under review.
Quality Controls are related to the
output (product / service) quality
and cover the whole product testing
in manufacturing cycle from
component to final product.
Failure Mode Criticality Matrix
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Common Delivery Pitfalls
Challenges with Applying FMEA to the VDP
21
For all its benefits, the FMEA does have a few limitations. There are
many challenges associated with performing FMEAs efficiently and
Effectively:
• Integration with other tools when used in isolation - FMEA and
other risk assessment methods, including SWIFT (Structured
What If Technique) and retrospective approaches, have been
found to have limited validity when used in isolation. Challenges
around scoping and organisational boundaries appear to be a
major factor in this lack of validity
• Function of the FMEA’s basis for prioritising failure modes
according to risk - Incorrect definition of rating scales for
criticality, and rating the criticality of the failure modes might
result in incorrect assessment and priorities. If used as a top-
down tool, FMEA may only identify major failure modes in a
system.
• A mistake is not adopting a known countermeasure for a known
failure mode - The countermeasure for mistakes is primarily a
matter of ensuring the correct use of design guidelines and
standards, and to avoid repeat past mistakes
• Unclear procedures links to details FMEA – Deployment of
standardised and clear FMEA document is critical as many
differing versions of FMEAs, deliverables and controls create
confusions and focus.
• Effective FMEA scoping - The FMEA is a time consuming, and the
team walks a fine-line between taking on too large of a scope and
taking on one that’s too small. Limited focus on the details may
results in many failure modes being missed. On the other hand,
too many details may make the analysis seem a daunting task.
The solution is to break the process down into manageable
segments.
• Failing to recognise that the FMEA is not a static model - For
successful risk management, the FMEA should be regularly
updated as new potential failure modes are identified and
corresponding control plans are developed.
• The desire to produce a refined FMEA require assembling an
effective team - Issues beyond team members’ knowledge aren’t
likely to be detected or resolved. if the team forgets to list failure
modes, they’ll be ignored.
• Knowledge and understanding of new innovations - Defining the
failure modes for new technologies.
• FMEA governance – Lack of strong leadership, emphasis on the
importance, controls and reviews for robustness can results in
poor quality and completion.
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
22
There is an increasing need for automotive companies to continually
refine their execution methods of FMEA, taking into account the
amount of time and cost on recalls and warranty repairs.
Implementation of quality assurance (QA) oversight processes
that ensures compliance with requirements, pursues achievement of
quality objectives and excellence through continuous improvement,
provides for timely identification and correction of deficient
conditions, and verifies the effectiveness of completed actions:
• Setting clear quality objectives, targets and goals
• Leadership and management consistency
• Robust quality policies, standards, processes and systems
• Proactive focus on identifying and addressing quality failure mode
in the early phase of VDP
• Standardised best practices and approach
• Evidenced based management reviews and approvals of FMEAs
• Cross Functional Team (CFT) involvement
• Effective translation of customer requirements into lower level
functional actions
• Taking the right quality focused actions and choices
• Avoiding deviations and late changes in the VDP
• Use of IDOV (Identify, Design, Optimize, Verify) process
• Reliability-Based Design Optimisation (RBDO) model
Oversight and Quality Assurance
Get the Most out of your FMEA Efforts
Steps for Risk Improvement
 Regular review of compliance with legal provisions
 Quality control strategy, plan and effectiveness
 Enable and Review Customer Feedback
 Transfer Risk through Management of Suppliers
 Plan quality into Design
 Review and audit activities and corrective actions for on-going
monitoring of quality
 Implementation of a system for continuous improvement
Strengthening Quality Management
Capabilities, Improving Efficiency and
Effectiveness
Design FMEA must not rely on process controls to overcome
potential design weaknesses, but it should take the technical and
physical limits of a manufacturing/assembly process into
consideration. If design deficiencies are identified that may cause
unacceptable variation, they should be highlighted and remedial
design actions taken in early stages of development phase.
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Example – Toyota Proactive Preventive Technique
Design Review Based on Failure Mode (DRBFM)
23
The development stage of a new product or component is a crucial time for identifying and addressing any problems. Taking action at an
early stage can prevent more serious and harder-to-fix issues occurring closer to production.
Toyota use Design Review Based on Failure Mode as a PROACTIVE preventive technique, in which designers focus on areas of change,
pinpoint any potential problem areas and apply knowledge they have gained from previous projects.
Fundamentals of proactive prevention cycle to identify and address
issues.
https://www.toyota-europe.com/world-of-toyota/feel/quality/designing-quality
Proactive Prevention cycle to prevent reliability problems from the
design stage.
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Example
How Porsche Ensures the Quality of its Products
24
Mission: to analyse the causes of failures and to qualify parts
from pilot production to end-of-product. Preventive analyses for
early quality optimisation.
Four pillars of Porsche quality:
Emotional quality
Functional quality
Image quality
Service quality
Top level quality is part of the Porsche brand identity -
There are various key indicators for measuring quality and
thus making it transparent, such as by generating precise
statistics on claims and warranty costs.
Central control, decentralised implementation - Quality
competence is thereby embodied throughout the entire
corporation, and each unit has a high level of self-motivation
to achieve the best possible quality
https://newsroom.porsche.com/en/company/porsche-quality-production-workshop-12502.html
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Summary
25
An FMEA:
 Identifies may ways which a product can fail to meet
requirements
 Estimate failure modes associated risks
 Prioritise validation and mitigation actions to reduce risks
 FMA is an integral part of the engineering process, not additional
to it.
A Cross Functional Team (CFT) tool
Many types of FMEA: Concept, Foundation, Design, Services,
System, Software, Process, Machine
FMEA inputs include several other process tools
Early discovery of failure modes in the VDP provides many
competitive benefits.
A large safety factor does not necessarily translate into a reliable
product. Instead, it often leads to an overdesigned product with
reliability problems.
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
 A failure mode only has to be found and fixed once. Always
assume the potential Failure Mode will be present rather than
hope that it won’t.
 Counter-measures must be applied in the phase that the failure
mode was created; otherwise the failure mode will escape.
 You have to be able to excite a failure mode to know that you
can, through a counter-measure, prevent it.
 Control of product liability may vary depending on the stage in
product’s life cycle. During development and production, you
have significant opportunity to build in safeguards against
potential liability claims.
 If a change is not necessary, re-use of proven designs in
comparable environments must be maximised.
About SSCG's Global Automotive Practice
26
SSCG provides a wide range of quality management consulting and
advisory services globally, to the automotive, manufacturing,
business services property and engineering sector.
Consulting involves understanding your overall product and process
development needs and developing a time and cost effective
process. There are two aspects of APQP that can be developed
through consulting: The prevention of failure on new product /
services within the organization and APQP deployment for the
supply chain.
Our quality consulting services help clients:
 Redefine business positioning in competitive markets and
unprecedented time of change
 Define strategies for competitive growth and profitability
 Define Voice of Customers (VoC) to put their expectations at the
centre of the business
 Define quality vision, objectives, standards and goals
 Establish Quality Management System(QMS)
 Develop and deploy quality process, procedures and tools: FMEA,
Kano Model, APQP, PPAP, TQM, Six Sigma
 IATF 16949/ISO9001 compliance and audit
 Quality project management assistance
 Product/service quality management: Planning, prevention,
detection and risk oversight
 Cost of poor quality reduction and return on investment
How we can help?
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
Contact Us
27
Eugene Nizeyimana
Principal Consultant, Automotive Products, Process and
Programmes Quality, SSCG Consulting
Phone: +44 7879150562/+44 1902 752758
Email: Eugene.Nizeyimana@sscg-group.com
AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
https://www.mckinsey.com/
https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/services/advisory.html
http://www.fticonsulting.com/industries/automotive
https://www2.deloitte.com/uk/en/services/consulting.html
https://www.grantthornton.co.uk/industries/automotive/
https://home.kpmg.com/uk/en/home/services/advisory/management-consulting.html
https://www.capgemini.com/service/automotive-2/
https://home.kpmg.com/xx/en/home/services/advisory/management-consulting.html
https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/industries/automotive.html
http://www.ey.com/uk/en/services/advisory
https://www.bcg.com/industries/automotive/default.aspx
https://www.boozallen.com/expertise/engineering.html
https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/services/advisory/consulting.html
http://www.bain.com/industry-expertise/automotive/index.aspx
https://www.boozallen.com/expertise/consulting.html
https://www.mckinsey.com/
https://www.boozallen.com/
https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/automotive-and-assembly/our-insights
https://www.atkearney.com/
https://www.accenture.com/gb-en/auto-industrial-index
https://www.accenture.com/gb-en/consulting-index
https://www.accenture.com/gb-en/consulting-index
http://www.ey.com/gl/en/industries/automotive
https://www2.deloitte.com/uk/en/pages/manufacturing/topics/automotive-manufacturing.html
https://home.kpmg.com/xx/en/home/industries/automotive.html
https://home.kpmg.com/uk/en/home/services/advisory.html
https://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/courses-listing/engineering-science?wssl=1
https://www2.deloitte.com/uk/en/pages/financial-advisory/topics/corporate-finance-advisory.html
https://www.cam.ac.uk/subjects/automotive
https://gsas.harvard.edu/programs-of-study/divisions/school-engineering-and-applied-sciences
http://www.ey.com/gl/en/services/advisory/advisory---home
http://meche.mit.edu/
http://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2016/12/15/the-automotive-sector-can-transform-south-asia-economically
http://www.oxan.com/services/advisory/
https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/strategy-and-corporate-finance/how-we-help-clients
https://www.atkearney.com/web/global-business-policy-council/advisory-services
https://www.grantthornton.co.uk/services/advisory/
https://www.bcg.com/
@ SSCG Copyright 2019, All Rights Reserved
Advisory | Consulting | Engineering
About SSCG
SSCG is global managementconsulting and professional firm. We provide
engineering and management advisory across business services, automotive,
industrial manufacturing and emerging markets sectors.
We provide informedperspective on the issues faced by our clients. The
insights and quality solutions delivered to support our clients to build trust
and confidence in the markets and in economies. We combines our multi-
disciplinaryapproach with deep, practicalindustry knowledge to support our
clients meet market dynamic challenges and respond to opportunities.
info@sscg-group.com
www.sscg-group.com

More Related Content

What's hot

Cmmi model – capabilities maturity model integration
Cmmi model – capabilities maturity model integrationCmmi model – capabilities maturity model integration
Cmmi model – capabilities maturity model integrationArshian Siddiqui
 
Standards / Models for Setting Up a Robust TCoE - Maveric Systems
Standards / Models for Setting Up a Robust TCoE - Maveric SystemsStandards / Models for Setting Up a Robust TCoE - Maveric Systems
Standards / Models for Setting Up a Robust TCoE - Maveric SystemsMaveric Systems
 
Quality management in bpo
Quality management in bpoQuality management in bpo
Quality management in bpoGrm Venkatesh
 
A Simple Introduction To CMMI For Beginer
A Simple Introduction To CMMI For BeginerA Simple Introduction To CMMI For Beginer
A Simple Introduction To CMMI For BeginerManas Das
 
Mellor Consulting Group approach toward a BKM OEE deployment
Mellor Consulting Group approach toward a BKM OEE deployment Mellor Consulting Group approach toward a BKM OEE deployment
Mellor Consulting Group approach toward a BKM OEE deployment Mellor Consulting Group
 
CMMI Certification (Level 1-5)
CMMI Certification (Level 1-5)CMMI Certification (Level 1-5)
CMMI Certification (Level 1-5)Akshat Gupta
 
Transformation Assurance
Transformation AssuranceTransformation Assurance
Transformation AssuranceMaveric Systems
 
Audit maturity model
Audit maturity modelAudit maturity model
Audit maturity modelcsandit
 
CMMI Capability Maturity Model Integration
CMMI   Capability Maturity Model Integration CMMI   Capability Maturity Model Integration
CMMI Capability Maturity Model Integration Anand Subramaniam
 
The True Costs and Benefits of CMMI Level 5
The True Costs and Benefits of CMMI Level 5The True Costs and Benefits of CMMI Level 5
The True Costs and Benefits of CMMI Level 5rhefner
 
Getting Started With CMMi level 3
Getting Started With CMMi level 3Getting Started With CMMi level 3
Getting Started With CMMi level 3Manas Das
 
Maveric - Automation of Release & Deployment Management
Maveric -  Automation of Release & Deployment ManagementMaveric -  Automation of Release & Deployment Management
Maveric - Automation of Release & Deployment ManagementMaveric Systems
 
Process auditing as per VDA 6.3
Process auditing as per VDA 6.3Process auditing as per VDA 6.3
Process auditing as per VDA 6.3Kiran Walimbe
 
Optimizing Product Realization Costs Across the Value Chain
Optimizing Product Realization Costs Across the Value ChainOptimizing Product Realization Costs Across the Value Chain
Optimizing Product Realization Costs Across the Value ChainCognizant
 
Test Process Consulting Services - Maveric Systems
Test Process Consulting Services - Maveric SystemsTest Process Consulting Services - Maveric Systems
Test Process Consulting Services - Maveric SystemsMaveric Systems
 
From 'Zero Defect Software' to 'First Time Right with Business'
From 'Zero Defect Software' to 'First Time Right with Business'From 'Zero Defect Software' to 'First Time Right with Business'
From 'Zero Defect Software' to 'First Time Right with Business'Cognizant
 
Applicability of CMMI for Small to Medium Enterprises
Applicability of CMMI for Small to Medium EnterprisesApplicability of CMMI for Small to Medium Enterprises
Applicability of CMMI for Small to Medium Enterprisesrhefner
 
CMMI v 1.2 Basics
CMMI v 1.2 BasicsCMMI v 1.2 Basics
CMMI v 1.2 BasicsQAI
 

What's hot (20)

Cmmi model – capabilities maturity model integration
Cmmi model – capabilities maturity model integrationCmmi model – capabilities maturity model integration
Cmmi model – capabilities maturity model integration
 
Assurance
AssuranceAssurance
Assurance
 
Standards / Models for Setting Up a Robust TCoE - Maveric Systems
Standards / Models for Setting Up a Robust TCoE - Maveric SystemsStandards / Models for Setting Up a Robust TCoE - Maveric Systems
Standards / Models for Setting Up a Robust TCoE - Maveric Systems
 
Quality management in bpo
Quality management in bpoQuality management in bpo
Quality management in bpo
 
A Simple Introduction To CMMI For Beginer
A Simple Introduction To CMMI For BeginerA Simple Introduction To CMMI For Beginer
A Simple Introduction To CMMI For Beginer
 
Mellor Consulting Group approach toward a BKM OEE deployment
Mellor Consulting Group approach toward a BKM OEE deployment Mellor Consulting Group approach toward a BKM OEE deployment
Mellor Consulting Group approach toward a BKM OEE deployment
 
What is cmmi & understanding
What is cmmi & understandingWhat is cmmi & understanding
What is cmmi & understanding
 
CMMI Certification (Level 1-5)
CMMI Certification (Level 1-5)CMMI Certification (Level 1-5)
CMMI Certification (Level 1-5)
 
Transformation Assurance
Transformation AssuranceTransformation Assurance
Transformation Assurance
 
Audit maturity model
Audit maturity modelAudit maturity model
Audit maturity model
 
CMMI Capability Maturity Model Integration
CMMI   Capability Maturity Model Integration CMMI   Capability Maturity Model Integration
CMMI Capability Maturity Model Integration
 
The True Costs and Benefits of CMMI Level 5
The True Costs and Benefits of CMMI Level 5The True Costs and Benefits of CMMI Level 5
The True Costs and Benefits of CMMI Level 5
 
Getting Started With CMMi level 3
Getting Started With CMMi level 3Getting Started With CMMi level 3
Getting Started With CMMi level 3
 
Maveric - Automation of Release & Deployment Management
Maveric -  Automation of Release & Deployment ManagementMaveric -  Automation of Release & Deployment Management
Maveric - Automation of Release & Deployment Management
 
Process auditing as per VDA 6.3
Process auditing as per VDA 6.3Process auditing as per VDA 6.3
Process auditing as per VDA 6.3
 
Optimizing Product Realization Costs Across the Value Chain
Optimizing Product Realization Costs Across the Value ChainOptimizing Product Realization Costs Across the Value Chain
Optimizing Product Realization Costs Across the Value Chain
 
Test Process Consulting Services - Maveric Systems
Test Process Consulting Services - Maveric SystemsTest Process Consulting Services - Maveric Systems
Test Process Consulting Services - Maveric Systems
 
From 'Zero Defect Software' to 'First Time Right with Business'
From 'Zero Defect Software' to 'First Time Right with Business'From 'Zero Defect Software' to 'First Time Right with Business'
From 'Zero Defect Software' to 'First Time Right with Business'
 
Applicability of CMMI for Small to Medium Enterprises
Applicability of CMMI for Small to Medium EnterprisesApplicability of CMMI for Small to Medium Enterprises
Applicability of CMMI for Small to Medium Enterprises
 
CMMI v 1.2 Basics
CMMI v 1.2 BasicsCMMI v 1.2 Basics
CMMI v 1.2 Basics
 

Similar to SSCG Automotive Insight - Vehicle Quality Engineering Optimisation through Early Cycle Failure Proactive Prevention FMEA Approach

IRPS rev 3-19-2012
IRPS rev 3-19-2012IRPS rev 3-19-2012
IRPS rev 3-19-2012Abe Salloum
 
Zero defect zero excursions
Zero defect zero excursionsZero defect zero excursions
Zero defect zero excursionsdotram
 
A project report on TQM by Abhinandan Kumar
A project report on TQM by Abhinandan KumarA project report on TQM by Abhinandan Kumar
A project report on TQM by Abhinandan KumarAbhinandan Kumar
 
John Gwozdz - resume 8-10-16
John Gwozdz - resume  8-10-16John Gwozdz - resume  8-10-16
John Gwozdz - resume 8-10-16John Gwozdz
 
Costof quality
Costof qualityCostof quality
Costof qualityOmnex Inc.
 
CH 3 Quality management and Control.pptx
CH 3 Quality management and Control.pptxCH 3 Quality management and Control.pptx
CH 3 Quality management and Control.pptxamanuel236786
 
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality Management
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality ManagementSSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality Management
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality ManagementSSCG Consulting
 
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality Management
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality ManagementSSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality Management
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality ManagementEugene Nizeyimana
 
Ajay_Training_Report[1]
Ajay_Training_Report[1]Ajay_Training_Report[1]
Ajay_Training_Report[1]AJAY KUMAR
 
SSCG Insight: Agile Automotive Quality Governance and Oversight
SSCG Insight: Agile Automotive Quality Governance and OversightSSCG Insight: Agile Automotive Quality Governance and Oversight
SSCG Insight: Agile Automotive Quality Governance and OversightSSCG Consulting
 
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality Management
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality ManagementSSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality Management
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality ManagementSSCG Consulting
 
QUALITY FUNCTION DEPLOYEMENT.pptx
QUALITY FUNCTION DEPLOYEMENT.pptxQUALITY FUNCTION DEPLOYEMENT.pptx
QUALITY FUNCTION DEPLOYEMENT.pptxAmuthaSaravanan3
 
Kwalita Business Profile 2009
Kwalita Business Profile 2009Kwalita Business Profile 2009
Kwalita Business Profile 2009Vongani
 
Quality management and quality planning
Quality management and quality planningQuality management and quality planning
Quality management and quality planningAmartya Talukdar
 

Similar to SSCG Automotive Insight - Vehicle Quality Engineering Optimisation through Early Cycle Failure Proactive Prevention FMEA Approach (20)

IRPS rev 3-19-2012
IRPS rev 3-19-2012IRPS rev 3-19-2012
IRPS rev 3-19-2012
 
Zero defect zero excursions
Zero defect zero excursionsZero defect zero excursions
Zero defect zero excursions
 
A project report on TQM by Abhinandan Kumar
A project report on TQM by Abhinandan KumarA project report on TQM by Abhinandan Kumar
A project report on TQM by Abhinandan Kumar
 
John Gwozdz - resume 8-10-16
John Gwozdz - resume  8-10-16John Gwozdz - resume  8-10-16
John Gwozdz - resume 8-10-16
 
Costof quality
Costof qualityCostof quality
Costof quality
 
Introduction to Software Quality & its' Challenges
Introduction to Software Quality & its' ChallengesIntroduction to Software Quality & its' Challenges
Introduction to Software Quality & its' Challenges
 
CH 3 Quality management and Control.pptx
CH 3 Quality management and Control.pptxCH 3 Quality management and Control.pptx
CH 3 Quality management and Control.pptx
 
Dbresume28
Dbresume28Dbresume28
Dbresume28
 
Rsume
RsumeRsume
Rsume
 
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality Management
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality ManagementSSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality Management
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality Management
 
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality Management
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality ManagementSSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality Management
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality Management
 
Ajay_Training_Report[1]
Ajay_Training_Report[1]Ajay_Training_Report[1]
Ajay_Training_Report[1]
 
SSCG Insight: Agile Automotive Quality Governance and Oversight
SSCG Insight: Agile Automotive Quality Governance and OversightSSCG Insight: Agile Automotive Quality Governance and Oversight
SSCG Insight: Agile Automotive Quality Governance and Oversight
 
Industrialization of testing
Industrialization of testing Industrialization of testing
Industrialization of testing
 
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality Management
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality ManagementSSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality Management
SSCG Automotive Manufacturing Quality Management
 
QUALITY FUNCTION DEPLOYEMENT.pptx
QUALITY FUNCTION DEPLOYEMENT.pptxQUALITY FUNCTION DEPLOYEMENT.pptx
QUALITY FUNCTION DEPLOYEMENT.pptx
 
A project report on TQM
A project report on TQMA project report on TQM
A project report on TQM
 
Kwalita Business Profile 2009
Kwalita Business Profile 2009Kwalita Business Profile 2009
Kwalita Business Profile 2009
 
Rishi_GuptaJ
Rishi_GuptaJRishi_GuptaJ
Rishi_GuptaJ
 
Quality management and quality planning
Quality management and quality planningQuality management and quality planning
Quality management and quality planning
 

More from Eugene Nizeyimana

SSCG Consulting US - Corporate Profile
SSCG Consulting US - Corporate ProfileSSCG Consulting US - Corporate Profile
SSCG Consulting US - Corporate ProfileEugene Nizeyimana
 
SSCG ISO 9001 Quality Management Systems (QMS)
SSCG ISO 9001 Quality Management Systems (QMS)SSCG ISO 9001 Quality Management Systems (QMS)
SSCG ISO 9001 Quality Management Systems (QMS)Eugene Nizeyimana
 
Eugene Nizeyimana - Executive Biography
Eugene Nizeyimana - Executive BiographyEugene Nizeyimana - Executive Biography
Eugene Nizeyimana - Executive BiographyEugene Nizeyimana
 
SSCG Business Problem Solving Consulting
SSCG Business Problem Solving ConsultingSSCG Business Problem Solving Consulting
SSCG Business Problem Solving ConsultingEugene Nizeyimana
 
SSCG Global Business Services (GBS)
SSCG Global Business Services (GBS)SSCG Global Business Services (GBS)
SSCG Global Business Services (GBS)Eugene Nizeyimana
 
Key Drivers and Challenges of Oil and Gas Industry Development in Africa
Key Drivers and Challenges of Oil and Gas Industry Development in AfricaKey Drivers and Challenges of Oil and Gas Industry Development in Africa
Key Drivers and Challenges of Oil and Gas Industry Development in AfricaEugene Nizeyimana
 
Africa Economic Opportunities and Growth Paradox
Africa Economic Opportunities and Growth ParadoxAfrica Economic Opportunities and Growth Paradox
Africa Economic Opportunities and Growth ParadoxEugene Nizeyimana
 
SSCG Project Management Services
SSCG Project Management ServicesSSCG Project Management Services
SSCG Project Management ServicesEugene Nizeyimana
 
SSCG Strategy, Business Services and Operating Model Dimensions
SSCG Strategy, Business Services and Operating Model DimensionsSSCG Strategy, Business Services and Operating Model Dimensions
SSCG Strategy, Business Services and Operating Model DimensionsEugene Nizeyimana
 
Global Automotive Industry Revolution
Global Automotive Industry RevolutionGlobal Automotive Industry Revolution
Global Automotive Industry RevolutionEugene Nizeyimana
 
Introducing SSCG’s Management & Engineering Consulting Services
Introducing SSCG’s Management & Engineering Consulting ServicesIntroducing SSCG’s Management & Engineering Consulting Services
Introducing SSCG’s Management & Engineering Consulting ServicesEugene Nizeyimana
 

More from Eugene Nizeyimana (20)

SSCG Consulting US - Corporate Profile
SSCG Consulting US - Corporate ProfileSSCG Consulting US - Corporate Profile
SSCG Consulting US - Corporate Profile
 
SSCG ISO 9001 Quality Management Systems (QMS)
SSCG ISO 9001 Quality Management Systems (QMS)SSCG ISO 9001 Quality Management Systems (QMS)
SSCG ISO 9001 Quality Management Systems (QMS)
 
Eugene Nizeyimana - Executive Biography
Eugene Nizeyimana - Executive BiographyEugene Nizeyimana - Executive Biography
Eugene Nizeyimana - Executive Biography
 
Entrepreneurial Leadership
Entrepreneurial LeadershipEntrepreneurial Leadership
Entrepreneurial Leadership
 
Don't limit your success
Don't limit your successDon't limit your success
Don't limit your success
 
Building you dream
Building you dreamBuilding you dream
Building you dream
 
Defining our future
Defining our futureDefining our future
Defining our future
 
Investing in Africa
Investing in AfricaInvesting in Africa
Investing in Africa
 
Our Career Desire
Our Career DesireOur Career Desire
Our Career Desire
 
Entrepreneurship
EntrepreneurshipEntrepreneurship
Entrepreneurship
 
Pursuing Your Dream
Pursuing Your DreamPursuing Your Dream
Pursuing Your Dream
 
SSCG Business Problem Solving Consulting
SSCG Business Problem Solving ConsultingSSCG Business Problem Solving Consulting
SSCG Business Problem Solving Consulting
 
SSCG Advisory Services
SSCG Advisory ServicesSSCG Advisory Services
SSCG Advisory Services
 
SSCG Global Business Services (GBS)
SSCG Global Business Services (GBS)SSCG Global Business Services (GBS)
SSCG Global Business Services (GBS)
 
Key Drivers and Challenges of Oil and Gas Industry Development in Africa
Key Drivers and Challenges of Oil and Gas Industry Development in AfricaKey Drivers and Challenges of Oil and Gas Industry Development in Africa
Key Drivers and Challenges of Oil and Gas Industry Development in Africa
 
Africa Economic Opportunities and Growth Paradox
Africa Economic Opportunities and Growth ParadoxAfrica Economic Opportunities and Growth Paradox
Africa Economic Opportunities and Growth Paradox
 
SSCG Project Management Services
SSCG Project Management ServicesSSCG Project Management Services
SSCG Project Management Services
 
SSCG Strategy, Business Services and Operating Model Dimensions
SSCG Strategy, Business Services and Operating Model DimensionsSSCG Strategy, Business Services and Operating Model Dimensions
SSCG Strategy, Business Services and Operating Model Dimensions
 
Global Automotive Industry Revolution
Global Automotive Industry RevolutionGlobal Automotive Industry Revolution
Global Automotive Industry Revolution
 
Introducing SSCG’s Management & Engineering Consulting Services
Introducing SSCG’s Management & Engineering Consulting ServicesIntroducing SSCG’s Management & Engineering Consulting Services
Introducing SSCG’s Management & Engineering Consulting Services
 

Recently uploaded

What Could Cause A VW Tiguan's Radiator Fan To Stop Working
What Could Cause A VW Tiguan's Radiator Fan To Stop WorkingWhat Could Cause A VW Tiguan's Radiator Fan To Stop Working
What Could Cause A VW Tiguan's Radiator Fan To Stop WorkingEscondido German Auto
 
(办理学位证)墨尔本大学毕业证(Unimelb毕业证书)成绩单留信学历认证原版一模一样
(办理学位证)墨尔本大学毕业证(Unimelb毕业证书)成绩单留信学历认证原版一模一样(办理学位证)墨尔本大学毕业证(Unimelb毕业证书)成绩单留信学历认证原版一模一样
(办理学位证)墨尔本大学毕业证(Unimelb毕业证书)成绩单留信学历认证原版一模一样whjjkkk
 
2024 WRC Hyundai World Rally Team’s i20 N Rally1 Hybrid
2024 WRC Hyundai World Rally Team’s i20 N Rally1 Hybrid2024 WRC Hyundai World Rally Team’s i20 N Rally1 Hybrid
2024 WRC Hyundai World Rally Team’s i20 N Rally1 HybridHyundai Motor Group
 
UNIT-II-ENGINE AUXILIARY SYSTEMS &TURBOCHARGER
UNIT-II-ENGINE AUXILIARY SYSTEMS &TURBOCHARGERUNIT-II-ENGINE AUXILIARY SYSTEMS &TURBOCHARGER
UNIT-II-ENGINE AUXILIARY SYSTEMS &TURBOCHARGERDineshKumar4165
 
What Causes DPF Failure In VW Golf Cars & How Can They Be Prevented
What Causes DPF Failure In VW Golf Cars & How Can They Be PreventedWhat Causes DPF Failure In VW Golf Cars & How Can They Be Prevented
What Causes DPF Failure In VW Golf Cars & How Can They Be PreventedAutobahn Automotive Service
 
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCR(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCRsoniya singh
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kasba 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kasba 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Kasba 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kasba 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomdivyansh0kumar0
 
( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607
( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607
( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607dollysharma2066
 
办理克莱姆森大学毕业证成绩单|购买美国文凭证书
办理克莱姆森大学毕业证成绩单|购买美国文凭证书办理克莱姆森大学毕业证成绩单|购买美国文凭证书
办理克莱姆森大学毕业证成绩单|购买美国文凭证书zdzoqco
 
原版工艺美国普林斯顿大学毕业证Princeton毕业证成绩单修改留信学历认证
原版工艺美国普林斯顿大学毕业证Princeton毕业证成绩单修改留信学历认证原版工艺美国普林斯顿大学毕业证Princeton毕业证成绩单修改留信学历认证
原版工艺美国普林斯顿大学毕业证Princeton毕业证成绩单修改留信学历认证jjrehjwj11gg
 
如何办理(UC毕业证书)堪培拉大学毕业证毕业证成绩单原版一比一
如何办理(UC毕业证书)堪培拉大学毕业证毕业证成绩单原版一比一如何办理(UC毕业证书)堪培拉大学毕业证毕业证成绩单原版一比一
如何办理(UC毕业证书)堪培拉大学毕业证毕业证成绩单原版一比一fjjwgk
 
call girls in G.T.B. Nagar (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in  G.T.B. Nagar (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in  G.T.B. Nagar (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in G.T.B. Nagar (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️9953056974 Low Rate Call Girls In Saket, Delhi NCR
 
Digamma / CertiCon Company Presentation
Digamma / CertiCon Company  PresentationDigamma / CertiCon Company  Presentation
Digamma / CertiCon Company PresentationMihajloManjak
 
GREEN VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024
GREEN VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024GREEN VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024
GREEN VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024AHOhOops1
 
2.2 CLSS hydraulic Pumps on komatsu pc200 series
2.2 CLSS hydraulic Pumps on komatsu pc200 series2.2 CLSS hydraulic Pumps on komatsu pc200 series
2.2 CLSS hydraulic Pumps on komatsu pc200 seriesdatazaky
 
原版1:1定制(IC大学毕业证)帝国理工学院大学毕业证国外文凭复刻成绩单#电子版制作#留信入库#多年经营绝对保证质量
原版1:1定制(IC大学毕业证)帝国理工学院大学毕业证国外文凭复刻成绩单#电子版制作#留信入库#多年经营绝对保证质量原版1:1定制(IC大学毕业证)帝国理工学院大学毕业证国外文凭复刻成绩单#电子版制作#留信入库#多年经营绝对保证质量
原版1:1定制(IC大学毕业证)帝国理工学院大学毕业证国外文凭复刻成绩单#电子版制作#留信入库#多年经营绝对保证质量208367051
 
2024 TOP 10 most fuel-efficient vehicles according to the US agency
2024 TOP 10 most fuel-efficient vehicles according to the US agency2024 TOP 10 most fuel-efficient vehicles according to the US agency
2024 TOP 10 most fuel-efficient vehicles according to the US agencyHyundai Motor Group
 
907MTAMount Coventry University Bachelor's Diploma in Engineering
907MTAMount Coventry University Bachelor's Diploma in Engineering907MTAMount Coventry University Bachelor's Diploma in Engineering
907MTAMount Coventry University Bachelor's Diploma in EngineeringFi sss
 

Recently uploaded (20)

What Could Cause A VW Tiguan's Radiator Fan To Stop Working
What Could Cause A VW Tiguan's Radiator Fan To Stop WorkingWhat Could Cause A VW Tiguan's Radiator Fan To Stop Working
What Could Cause A VW Tiguan's Radiator Fan To Stop Working
 
(办理学位证)墨尔本大学毕业证(Unimelb毕业证书)成绩单留信学历认证原版一模一样
(办理学位证)墨尔本大学毕业证(Unimelb毕业证书)成绩单留信学历认证原版一模一样(办理学位证)墨尔本大学毕业证(Unimelb毕业证书)成绩单留信学历认证原版一模一样
(办理学位证)墨尔本大学毕业证(Unimelb毕业证书)成绩单留信学历认证原版一模一样
 
2024 WRC Hyundai World Rally Team’s i20 N Rally1 Hybrid
2024 WRC Hyundai World Rally Team’s i20 N Rally1 Hybrid2024 WRC Hyundai World Rally Team’s i20 N Rally1 Hybrid
2024 WRC Hyundai World Rally Team’s i20 N Rally1 Hybrid
 
UNIT-II-ENGINE AUXILIARY SYSTEMS &TURBOCHARGER
UNIT-II-ENGINE AUXILIARY SYSTEMS &TURBOCHARGERUNIT-II-ENGINE AUXILIARY SYSTEMS &TURBOCHARGER
UNIT-II-ENGINE AUXILIARY SYSTEMS &TURBOCHARGER
 
What Causes DPF Failure In VW Golf Cars & How Can They Be Prevented
What Causes DPF Failure In VW Golf Cars & How Can They Be PreventedWhat Causes DPF Failure In VW Golf Cars & How Can They Be Prevented
What Causes DPF Failure In VW Golf Cars & How Can They Be Prevented
 
Indian Downtown Call Girls # 00971528903066 # Indian Call Girls In Downtown D...
Indian Downtown Call Girls # 00971528903066 # Indian Call Girls In Downtown D...Indian Downtown Call Girls # 00971528903066 # Indian Call Girls In Downtown D...
Indian Downtown Call Girls # 00971528903066 # Indian Call Girls In Downtown D...
 
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCR(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Shaheen Bagh 🔝 Delhi NCR
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kasba 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kasba 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Kasba 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kasba 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607
( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607
( Best ) Genuine Call Girls In Mandi House =DELHI-| 8377087607
 
办理克莱姆森大学毕业证成绩单|购买美国文凭证书
办理克莱姆森大学毕业证成绩单|购买美国文凭证书办理克莱姆森大学毕业证成绩单|购买美国文凭证书
办理克莱姆森大学毕业证成绩单|购买美国文凭证书
 
原版工艺美国普林斯顿大学毕业证Princeton毕业证成绩单修改留信学历认证
原版工艺美国普林斯顿大学毕业证Princeton毕业证成绩单修改留信学历认证原版工艺美国普林斯顿大学毕业证Princeton毕业证成绩单修改留信学历认证
原版工艺美国普林斯顿大学毕业证Princeton毕业证成绩单修改留信学历认证
 
如何办理(UC毕业证书)堪培拉大学毕业证毕业证成绩单原版一比一
如何办理(UC毕业证书)堪培拉大学毕业证毕业证成绩单原版一比一如何办理(UC毕业证书)堪培拉大学毕业证毕业证成绩单原版一比一
如何办理(UC毕业证书)堪培拉大学毕业证毕业证成绩单原版一比一
 
call girls in G.T.B. Nagar (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in  G.T.B. Nagar (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in  G.T.B. Nagar (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in G.T.B. Nagar (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
 
Digamma / CertiCon Company Presentation
Digamma / CertiCon Company  PresentationDigamma / CertiCon Company  Presentation
Digamma / CertiCon Company Presentation
 
sauth delhi call girls in Connaught Place🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
sauth delhi call girls in  Connaught Place🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Servicesauth delhi call girls in  Connaught Place🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
sauth delhi call girls in Connaught Place🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
 
GREEN VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024
GREEN VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024GREEN VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024
GREEN VEHICLES the kids picture show 2024
 
2.2 CLSS hydraulic Pumps on komatsu pc200 series
2.2 CLSS hydraulic Pumps on komatsu pc200 series2.2 CLSS hydraulic Pumps on komatsu pc200 series
2.2 CLSS hydraulic Pumps on komatsu pc200 series
 
原版1:1定制(IC大学毕业证)帝国理工学院大学毕业证国外文凭复刻成绩单#电子版制作#留信入库#多年经营绝对保证质量
原版1:1定制(IC大学毕业证)帝国理工学院大学毕业证国外文凭复刻成绩单#电子版制作#留信入库#多年经营绝对保证质量原版1:1定制(IC大学毕业证)帝国理工学院大学毕业证国外文凭复刻成绩单#电子版制作#留信入库#多年经营绝对保证质量
原版1:1定制(IC大学毕业证)帝国理工学院大学毕业证国外文凭复刻成绩单#电子版制作#留信入库#多年经营绝对保证质量
 
2024 TOP 10 most fuel-efficient vehicles according to the US agency
2024 TOP 10 most fuel-efficient vehicles according to the US agency2024 TOP 10 most fuel-efficient vehicles according to the US agency
2024 TOP 10 most fuel-efficient vehicles according to the US agency
 
907MTAMount Coventry University Bachelor's Diploma in Engineering
907MTAMount Coventry University Bachelor's Diploma in Engineering907MTAMount Coventry University Bachelor's Diploma in Engineering
907MTAMount Coventry University Bachelor's Diploma in Engineering
 

SSCG Automotive Insight - Vehicle Quality Engineering Optimisation through Early Cycle Failure Proactive Prevention FMEA Approach

  • 1. AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT Automotive Product Quality Optimisation Early Cycle Failure Proactive Prevention FMEA Approach October 2018
  • 2. AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 3. Contents 3 Introduction 5 Key Today’s Challenges in Vehicle Quality Engineering 6 Many Ways Systems Fail to Function or Meet Requirements 7 Assuring Product Quality Robustness in the VDP 8 Early Cycle Product Development Failure Mode Prevention 9 Designing Failure-Tolerant Products 10 Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) Quality Management 11 FMEA Provides Many Benefits There are Many Types of FMEA’s Effective FMEA Deployment and Principles FMA Process Flow FMA Model and Rational Approach Quality Risk Management is Getting More Important 19 Risk Analysis is not Easily and Commonly Incorporated Common Delivery Pitfalls Oversight and Quality Assurance Examples: 23 Toyota Proactive Preventive Technique How Porsche Ensures the Quality of its Products Summary 25 How SSCG can help? 26 AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 4. Are you sometimes puzzled by new products that suddenly fail in customers’ hands, despite successfully passing all verification test procedures? What could have prevented it? AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 5. Introduction 5 Vehicle Quality and Reliability are Key Megatrends and plays a key role in maintaining customer satisfaction. Appeal, reliability and service determine quality as it is perceived by the customer throughout the entire product experience. Today, product quality is one of the most critical uptake or purchasing factor for consideration by customers. Product recalls due to serious quality and reliability concerns can ruin brand reputation or put companies out of business. Less serious problems may result in customer dissatisfaction, loss of sales, high cost of poor quality and a delay in the launch of a new product. Marketplace pressures to continuously deliver high quality products in shorten period reduces development time and increases risks of potential failures. Furthermore, new product failure uncertainties remains present throughout Product Development Process (PDP) – from the specification of requirements in design to build variation in manufacturing and aftermarket operation. Therefore, companies across the automotive sectors have to give priority in uncertainty characterisation and propagation in the development of zero-defect and failure tolerant designs and robust manufacturing processes to minimise and eliminate risks of quality failures. Uncertainty must be the focal point and inherent part of PDP if companies are to improve product quality and reliability. To prevent failures and improve process reliability, companies must follow key best practices:  PDP is a simulation of future production and consumption  Greater importance in product detail consistency  Product performance integrity  Quality is a source of competitive advantage. https://www.daimler.com/products/passenger-cars/mercedes-benz/a-class-kecskemet.html AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 6. Key Today’s Challenges in Vehicle Quality Engineering 6 Late failure mode discovery is costly to implement countermeasures Stringent regulatory requirements and customer expectations are placing increased demands on companies for high quality and reliable products. The increasing capabilities and technical functionality of many products are making it more difficult for manufacturers to maintain superior quality and reliability required. Traditionally, reliability has been achieved through extensive testing and use of techniques such as probabilistic reliability modelling. These are techniques done in the late stages of development no longer suitable for today’s fast paced business environment. For vehicle manufactures to succeed in the current competitive market place over the long run, have to offer value driven competitive products or services than their competitors. Today’s market pressure points and challenges:  Design integration of quality early in the PDP to prevent failures.  Competition to offer higher value quality products with cutting edge features and functionality.  Performance - Product that outperforms their competitor.  Reliability – Products that meets/exceed markets and operating constraints.  Process realignment for efficient, create more synergies, accelerate innovation and improve quality.  Increasingly complex vehicle technologies call for human and intuitive operation.  Make vehicle as fuel-efficient as possible while at all times conforming to safety, design, quality and performance requirements. The Next Level in Early Cycle Quality and Reliability Assurance Management AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 7. 7 While the Vehicle Development Process (VDP) may be viewed from many perspectives, it is a series of complex processes and decisions thus can be posed to complex multidimensional problem and to generate potential quality failure modes. Uncertainty are present throughout the VDP. Hence, establishing early cycle failure mode avoidance and prevention measures is a critical to eliminate later discovery. Failure Mode Identification A component / subsystem / system MUST consistently perform its intended function in the presence of uncontrollable influences (Noise Factors), including:  Piece-to-piece variation  Product changes over useful life  Customer usage and duty cycles  External environment  System interactions with adjacent components Ways which failure modes are manifested  No Function  Partial – Over/Under Function:  Degradation  Intermittent Function  Unintended Function Many Ways Vehicle Systems Fail to Function or Meet Requirements AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 8. Assuring Product Quality Robustness in the VDP 8 Quality can be broadly defined as meeting customer expectations, conformance to standards, legislative and production tests. Robust integration of uncertainty and failure modes early in the VDP phase can limit risks both relative the business and products. Clear and well defined details supported by well governed reviews are critical to ensure product design quality robustness:  Voice of the Customer Market Research: Stated and unstated  Compatible product specs, requirements and quality attributes  Product Development (PD) project scope and resources  Quality history reviews and capture Lessons Learned  Quality Risk Assessment  Procedures, systems and techniques that increase PD efficiency and efficacy  Manage design and process change  Manufacturing quality assurance plan  Engineering talent and skills Common advance quality planning underlying principles:  Robustly defining customer requirements and expectations  Early detection, prevention and control of failure to reduce escapes  Reduction of cost of poor quality: Customer dissatisfaction, warrant and recalls, production FTT failures, rework, complaints, potential arbitration, lost royalty and sales  Forge effective cross functional quality management and oversight Effectiveness Foundation Requirements and Principals AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 9. Early Cycle Product Development Failure Mode Prevention 9 There are many opportunities to detect and prevent failure modes early in product development phase. Late failure modes discovery is costly to remedy and require more countermeasures, with limited analysis and deployment time. Failure modes can be detected early through:  Thought experiments (e.g. FMEA, Design Review)  Engineering Standards and rules  Virtual analysis (CAE, CFD, State Flow Models, etc)  Physical testing. By understanding product lifecycle operating conditions and variables can facilitate to:  Better understand the key performance factors and thus develop better countermeasure.  Identify improvement opportunities. Quality requirements must be robustly defined and clear at the start of programme development AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 10. Designing Failure-Tolerant Products Reliability-Based Design Optimisation (RBDO) 10 The deviation from the ideal function indicates how close the system is to the failure mode. Robustness failures occur when the demand placed on the design exceeds the capacity. Robustness Sensitivity Noises: • Production variations • Wear out and drift over time • Customer duty cycles • Environment • Component interactions AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 11. AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 12. Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) Quality Management AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 13. Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) Quality Management 13 Why FMEA? A methodology for discovering potential malfunction and reliability problems that may exist within the design of a product or process early in the development cycle to ensure meet or exceed customer expectations, standards and regulatory requirements. Extensively used in system development for anticipating failure during design stage by identifying, analysing, evaluating and prioritising actions to mitigate potential/known failure modes, thereby enhancing reliability through design. FMEA is not a substitute for good engineering. Rather, it enhances good engineering by applying the knowledge and experience of a Cross Functional Team (CFT) to review the design progress by assessing its risk of failure. FMEA promotes corrective action to prevent or decrease the possibility of defects being delivered to the customer While practical anticipation of every failure modes in a product during design has its limitations and not possible, FMEA help to formulate as extensive a list of potential failure modes as possible. The early and consistent use of FMEAs in the design process allows companies to design out failures and produce reliable, safe, and customer pleasing products. FMEAs also capture historical information for use in future product improvement. AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 14. 14 Discovering failure modes early in Product Development (PD) phase using FMEA provides the several benefits include:  Documented method for selecting a design with a high probability of successful quality operation and safety to increase customer satisfaction.  A uniform methodology of assessing potential failure mechanisms, modes and impact on system operation to improve product/process reliability and quality.  Multiple choices early identification, verification and elimination of failure points and system interface problems.  An effective method for evaluating the effect of proposed changes to the design and/or operational procedures.  A basis for in-flight troubleshooting procedures and for locating performance monitoring and fault-detection devices.  Criteria for improved early planning of validation tests and development, capture risks and engineering actions taken  Prioritised product/process deficiencies management.  Catalyst for teamwork and quality improvement knowledge exchange between functions.  Improved Design for Manufacturing and Assembly (DFM/A)  Lower cost solutions and Cost of Poor Quality (CPQ) in production and aftermarket operation. FMEA Provides Many Benefits One of many tools used to discover failure at its earliest possible point in product or process design. https://www.locusresearch.com/avoiding-failure/ AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 15. 15 FMEAs should always be done whenever failures would mean potential harm or injury to the user of the end item being designed System - CFMEA Design - DFMEA Process - PFMEA Machinery - MFEMA Service - SFMEA • Software SFMEA • Foundation FFMEA • Concept CFMEA There are Many Types of FMEA’s AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 16. Effective FMEA Deployment and Principles 16 The automotive industry has long used FMEA as means to improve customer satisfaction and reduce non-conformance. FMEA, is a tool for the identification and prioritisation of possible ways a product or process can fail. The intent is to use that information to make improvements to the product or process. FMEA is primarily deployed to:  Develop product or process requirements that minimise the likelihood of failures.  Evaluate customer requirements and functionality in the design process to ensure that the requirements do not introduce potential failures.  Identify design characteristics that contribute to system failures to minimise the resulting effects.  Support the development of product/process test methods and procedures to ensure that the failures have been successfully verified and controlled.  Track and manage potential risks in the design and development process.  Ensure that any product potential failures poses low safety risks and impact to customers.  When designing a new product, process or service, transforming an existing process, quality improvement activities and need to understand and improve the failures of a process AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation Common FMEA Deployment Guiding Principles Right Objectivity and Focus:  Problem Prevention  Design and Process Improvements  Leverage FMEAs to Improve Test Plans and Process Controls  Select FMEA Projects Based on Preliminary Risk Assessment  Lean and simplicity Right Resource Allocation:  Team-Based Activity  Skills and Experience  Lessons Learned  Robust Management  Effective Process  Quality Knowledge Procedures:  Well defined and clear  Requirements Driven and Data Driven  Root Cause and Failure Definition Mechanisms  Focus on Areas of High Concern and Risk  Right Time Frame  Fully Execution to Ensure Risk Reduction to an Acceptable Level
  • 17. 17 Input Process Output FMEA FMA Process Flow Inputs & Outputs - Outcome Based Deliverables  Customer Requirements  System Design Specifications (SDS)  Quality Function Deployment (QFD)  Benchmarking  Design and / or Process Assumptions  Preliminary Bill of Material / Components  Known causes from surrogate products  Boundary diagram and interface matrix  Parameter Diagrams (P-Diagrams)  Potential causes from design choices  Potential causes from noises and environments  Baseline FMEA (Historical FMEA)  Past Test and Control Methods used on similar products  Past Failure or error states  Process Flow Diagram  Characteristics Matrix  Design Verification Plan (DVP)  Quality Risk Management (QRM) Plan  Test Cases  Design Rules  Standards  Special Characteristics: Critical/Significant  Deviation Plans  Safety Sign-off  Robustness Checklist Avoiding Failure in Design https://www.locusresearch.com/avoiding-failure/ AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 18. 18 Function Potential Design Controls Actions Verification Failure Mode Effects Causes Prevention Detection FMA Model and Rational Approach A Structured Approach to Define Important Quality Focal Points Potential Causes Analysis Cause and effect (Ishikawa Diagram) and 5 whys Typical Failure Effects Noise Inoperative Unpleasant Odour Leaks Operation Impaired Poor appearance Unstable Regulatory non-compliance Rough-rattle/vibration Preventions Score effectiveness of countermeasures Detections Design Reviews Assess Stds Test cases AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation Review process Define potential failure modes List failure mode potential effects Assign severity rating Assign occurrence rating Assign detection rating Calculate effect risk priority number Prioritise the failure modes Eliminateor de-risk high- risk failure modes Recalculate RPN as risks are reduced or eliminated
  • 19. 19 Quality Risk Management (QRM) is Getting More Important The rise in focus on risk management and mitigation through FMEA is so integral in the development process that Six Sigma, Production Part Approval Process (PPAP), Tooling and Equipment (TE 9000), ISO 9000, QS-9000, and ISO/TS16949 have all required FMEA as one of the suggested ways a company can improve. An effective quality risk management approach can further ensure the high quality vehicles and products to the customers by providing a proactive means to identify and control potential quality issues during development and manufacturing. Risk identification and analysis, should effectively capture knowledge, map processes, and allow the definition of an ontology of objects (unit operations) with specific attributes (inputs and outputs). Risk Lifecycle Management Plan (RLMP) should be put in place to manage unacceptable risks, evaluating the control strategy performance, detecting improvement opportunities and managing additional risks originated from new events. Team alignment, empathy across multiple functions and an effective knowledge-sharing and harvest right from the beginning, all needed for a successful QRM. The target of completing of an FMEA is in practice very limited and extremely time-consuming to achieve if the initial 'knowledge- based' steps are weak. AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 20. 20 Risk identification  Use of multiple techniques and tools  Must be based on reason and factual data  Should be what could, might or possibly happen  Categorised as either threat (-ve) or opportunity (+ve)  Written in the context  Consequence of occurring or impact described  Ownership assigned  Proximity determined and assigned Exposure Analysis  Industry-specific quality management requirements  Complex analytical or technical sampling and testing  Complete finished product for cycle testing and analysis  Highly technical quality controls or skills for process control  Diversity of new products introduced in a short period Controls  Comprehensive quality planning, control and Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) for all significant processes  Effective training programmes and suitably skilled employees  Full familiarity of employees with quality management procedures  Audit programmes and follow-up of findings  Regular review and updating of procedures and processes  State of the art systems, personnel, methods, processes and documentation of results for quality control. Risk Analysis is not Easily and Commonly Incorporated What to look for: Identification, Exposure Analysis & Controls Prof. Dr. José C. Menezes. CEO 4Tune Engineering and Associate Professor, University of Lisbon for Bioengineering The purpose of this Risk Factor is to assess the quality management system in place, and the quality controls / quality assurance applied to the product(s) under review. Quality Controls are related to the output (product / service) quality and cover the whole product testing in manufacturing cycle from component to final product. Failure Mode Criticality Matrix AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 21. Common Delivery Pitfalls Challenges with Applying FMEA to the VDP 21 For all its benefits, the FMEA does have a few limitations. There are many challenges associated with performing FMEAs efficiently and Effectively: • Integration with other tools when used in isolation - FMEA and other risk assessment methods, including SWIFT (Structured What If Technique) and retrospective approaches, have been found to have limited validity when used in isolation. Challenges around scoping and organisational boundaries appear to be a major factor in this lack of validity • Function of the FMEA’s basis for prioritising failure modes according to risk - Incorrect definition of rating scales for criticality, and rating the criticality of the failure modes might result in incorrect assessment and priorities. If used as a top- down tool, FMEA may only identify major failure modes in a system. • A mistake is not adopting a known countermeasure for a known failure mode - The countermeasure for mistakes is primarily a matter of ensuring the correct use of design guidelines and standards, and to avoid repeat past mistakes • Unclear procedures links to details FMEA – Deployment of standardised and clear FMEA document is critical as many differing versions of FMEAs, deliverables and controls create confusions and focus. • Effective FMEA scoping - The FMEA is a time consuming, and the team walks a fine-line between taking on too large of a scope and taking on one that’s too small. Limited focus on the details may results in many failure modes being missed. On the other hand, too many details may make the analysis seem a daunting task. The solution is to break the process down into manageable segments. • Failing to recognise that the FMEA is not a static model - For successful risk management, the FMEA should be regularly updated as new potential failure modes are identified and corresponding control plans are developed. • The desire to produce a refined FMEA require assembling an effective team - Issues beyond team members’ knowledge aren’t likely to be detected or resolved. if the team forgets to list failure modes, they’ll be ignored. • Knowledge and understanding of new innovations - Defining the failure modes for new technologies. • FMEA governance – Lack of strong leadership, emphasis on the importance, controls and reviews for robustness can results in poor quality and completion. AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 22. 22 There is an increasing need for automotive companies to continually refine their execution methods of FMEA, taking into account the amount of time and cost on recalls and warranty repairs. Implementation of quality assurance (QA) oversight processes that ensures compliance with requirements, pursues achievement of quality objectives and excellence through continuous improvement, provides for timely identification and correction of deficient conditions, and verifies the effectiveness of completed actions: • Setting clear quality objectives, targets and goals • Leadership and management consistency • Robust quality policies, standards, processes and systems • Proactive focus on identifying and addressing quality failure mode in the early phase of VDP • Standardised best practices and approach • Evidenced based management reviews and approvals of FMEAs • Cross Functional Team (CFT) involvement • Effective translation of customer requirements into lower level functional actions • Taking the right quality focused actions and choices • Avoiding deviations and late changes in the VDP • Use of IDOV (Identify, Design, Optimize, Verify) process • Reliability-Based Design Optimisation (RBDO) model Oversight and Quality Assurance Get the Most out of your FMEA Efforts Steps for Risk Improvement  Regular review of compliance with legal provisions  Quality control strategy, plan and effectiveness  Enable and Review Customer Feedback  Transfer Risk through Management of Suppliers  Plan quality into Design  Review and audit activities and corrective actions for on-going monitoring of quality  Implementation of a system for continuous improvement Strengthening Quality Management Capabilities, Improving Efficiency and Effectiveness Design FMEA must not rely on process controls to overcome potential design weaknesses, but it should take the technical and physical limits of a manufacturing/assembly process into consideration. If design deficiencies are identified that may cause unacceptable variation, they should be highlighted and remedial design actions taken in early stages of development phase. AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 23. Example – Toyota Proactive Preventive Technique Design Review Based on Failure Mode (DRBFM) 23 The development stage of a new product or component is a crucial time for identifying and addressing any problems. Taking action at an early stage can prevent more serious and harder-to-fix issues occurring closer to production. Toyota use Design Review Based on Failure Mode as a PROACTIVE preventive technique, in which designers focus on areas of change, pinpoint any potential problem areas and apply knowledge they have gained from previous projects. Fundamentals of proactive prevention cycle to identify and address issues. https://www.toyota-europe.com/world-of-toyota/feel/quality/designing-quality Proactive Prevention cycle to prevent reliability problems from the design stage. AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 24. Example How Porsche Ensures the Quality of its Products 24 Mission: to analyse the causes of failures and to qualify parts from pilot production to end-of-product. Preventive analyses for early quality optimisation. Four pillars of Porsche quality: Emotional quality Functional quality Image quality Service quality Top level quality is part of the Porsche brand identity - There are various key indicators for measuring quality and thus making it transparent, such as by generating precise statistics on claims and warranty costs. Central control, decentralised implementation - Quality competence is thereby embodied throughout the entire corporation, and each unit has a high level of self-motivation to achieve the best possible quality https://newsroom.porsche.com/en/company/porsche-quality-production-workshop-12502.html AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 25. Summary 25 An FMEA:  Identifies may ways which a product can fail to meet requirements  Estimate failure modes associated risks  Prioritise validation and mitigation actions to reduce risks  FMA is an integral part of the engineering process, not additional to it. A Cross Functional Team (CFT) tool Many types of FMEA: Concept, Foundation, Design, Services, System, Software, Process, Machine FMEA inputs include several other process tools Early discovery of failure modes in the VDP provides many competitive benefits. A large safety factor does not necessarily translate into a reliable product. Instead, it often leads to an overdesigned product with reliability problems. AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation  A failure mode only has to be found and fixed once. Always assume the potential Failure Mode will be present rather than hope that it won’t.  Counter-measures must be applied in the phase that the failure mode was created; otherwise the failure mode will escape.  You have to be able to excite a failure mode to know that you can, through a counter-measure, prevent it.  Control of product liability may vary depending on the stage in product’s life cycle. During development and production, you have significant opportunity to build in safeguards against potential liability claims.  If a change is not necessary, re-use of proven designs in comparable environments must be maximised.
  • 26. About SSCG's Global Automotive Practice 26 SSCG provides a wide range of quality management consulting and advisory services globally, to the automotive, manufacturing, business services property and engineering sector. Consulting involves understanding your overall product and process development needs and developing a time and cost effective process. There are two aspects of APQP that can be developed through consulting: The prevention of failure on new product / services within the organization and APQP deployment for the supply chain. Our quality consulting services help clients:  Redefine business positioning in competitive markets and unprecedented time of change  Define strategies for competitive growth and profitability  Define Voice of Customers (VoC) to put their expectations at the centre of the business  Define quality vision, objectives, standards and goals  Establish Quality Management System(QMS)  Develop and deploy quality process, procedures and tools: FMEA, Kano Model, APQP, PPAP, TQM, Six Sigma  IATF 16949/ISO9001 compliance and audit  Quality project management assistance  Product/service quality management: Planning, prevention, detection and risk oversight  Cost of poor quality reduction and return on investment How we can help? AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 27. Contact Us 27 Eugene Nizeyimana Principal Consultant, Automotive Products, Process and Programmes Quality, SSCG Consulting Phone: +44 7879150562/+44 1902 752758 Email: Eugene.Nizeyimana@sscg-group.com AUTOMOTIVE INSIGHT | Automotive Product Quality Optimisation
  • 28. https://www.mckinsey.com/ https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/services/advisory.html http://www.fticonsulting.com/industries/automotive https://www2.deloitte.com/uk/en/services/consulting.html https://www.grantthornton.co.uk/industries/automotive/ https://home.kpmg.com/uk/en/home/services/advisory/management-consulting.html https://www.capgemini.com/service/automotive-2/ https://home.kpmg.com/xx/en/home/services/advisory/management-consulting.html https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/industries/automotive.html http://www.ey.com/uk/en/services/advisory https://www.bcg.com/industries/automotive/default.aspx https://www.boozallen.com/expertise/engineering.html https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/services/advisory/consulting.html http://www.bain.com/industry-expertise/automotive/index.aspx https://www.boozallen.com/expertise/consulting.html https://www.mckinsey.com/ https://www.boozallen.com/ https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/automotive-and-assembly/our-insights https://www.atkearney.com/ https://www.accenture.com/gb-en/auto-industrial-index https://www.accenture.com/gb-en/consulting-index https://www.accenture.com/gb-en/consulting-index http://www.ey.com/gl/en/industries/automotive https://www2.deloitte.com/uk/en/pages/manufacturing/topics/automotive-manufacturing.html https://home.kpmg.com/xx/en/home/industries/automotive.html https://home.kpmg.com/uk/en/home/services/advisory.html https://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/courses-listing/engineering-science?wssl=1 https://www2.deloitte.com/uk/en/pages/financial-advisory/topics/corporate-finance-advisory.html https://www.cam.ac.uk/subjects/automotive https://gsas.harvard.edu/programs-of-study/divisions/school-engineering-and-applied-sciences http://www.ey.com/gl/en/services/advisory/advisory---home http://meche.mit.edu/ http://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2016/12/15/the-automotive-sector-can-transform-south-asia-economically http://www.oxan.com/services/advisory/ https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/strategy-and-corporate-finance/how-we-help-clients https://www.atkearney.com/web/global-business-policy-council/advisory-services https://www.grantthornton.co.uk/services/advisory/ https://www.bcg.com/ @ SSCG Copyright 2019, All Rights Reserved Advisory | Consulting | Engineering About SSCG SSCG is global managementconsulting and professional firm. We provide engineering and management advisory across business services, automotive, industrial manufacturing and emerging markets sectors. We provide informedperspective on the issues faced by our clients. The insights and quality solutions delivered to support our clients to build trust and confidence in the markets and in economies. We combines our multi- disciplinaryapproach with deep, practicalindustry knowledge to support our clients meet market dynamic challenges and respond to opportunities. info@sscg-group.com www.sscg-group.com