SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 17
Download to read offline
DLM & Associates, LLC.
Affordable Housing Supply and Demand Analysis
For the Town of East Spencer
February 2010
By
Dana Merck
DLM & Associates, LLC.
DLM & Associates, LLC. 2
Table of Contents
Section Page #
Executive Summary 3
I. Purpose of Analysis 6
II. Background Information 6
III. Expected Buyers 9
IV. Effective Market Area 10
V. Demand/Need for Affordable Housing 12
VI. Number of Potential Buffers in EMA 15
VII. Competition and Capture Rate 16
VIII. Conclusion 18
IX: Recommendations 18
DLM & Associates, LLC. 3
Executive Summary:
East Spencer is proposing to build 8-18 affordable homes in the Dunbar
Renaissance Village Redevelopment Area along Robin Cr., E. Broad St.,
and S. Long St. near the vacant Dunbar School. The Town expects to
build 3 bedroom 2 bath homes and to sell these homes for $105,000 over
a two and one-half year period.
I. Conclusion:
It is the determination of this Supply and Demand Analysis that that the
proposed housing project can be developed and successfully sold. This
determination has been reached by examining and developing answers to
the following questions:
Q: Who are the most likely potential buyers of the proposed homes?
A: The most likely potential buyers for the proposed homes are minority
households with incomes of 51%-80% Area Median Family Income.
Q: What is the Effective Market Area from which these buyers are most
likely to come?
A: The most likely Effective Market Area for the proposed homes is the
greater Salisbury urban area including the City of Salisbury, and the
adjacent Towns of East Spencer, Spencer, Granite Quarry, and Faith.
Although the buyers described above are expected to come only from
Salisbury, East Spencer, and Spencer.
Q: Within this EMA, is there a demand/need for affordable, single-family
housing, such as East Spencer proposes?
A: There is believed to be a serious demand/need for affordable housing
within the EMA, since 27% of EMA households pay more than the HUD
recommended 30% of monthly income for housing, and 55% of EMA
housing units, considered affordable to low-income households with
incomes 51%-80% AMFI, are actually occupied by non low-income
households.
Q: How many potential buyers for the proposed homes exist in the EMA?
A: There are 340 minority, family households with incomes of 51%-
80%AMFI, but as many as 50% of this number may be constrained
from purchasing a home due to credit history or debt load, leaving 170
potential buyers for East Spencer’s proposed homes.
DLM & Associates, LLC. 4
Q: How will the proposed homes compete in the local housing market,
and is it reasonable to expect that they can capture the necessary
percentage of these buyers to be sold?
A. East Spencer’s homes are priced within the $85-$95 per square foot
range of newer homes offering similar square footage and amenities,
and are expected to compete well. To sell 8 homes, East Spencer would
only have to capture 5% of the potential buyers in EMA and to sell 18
homes capture only 11%, therefore an 18-home development appears
reasonable.
II. Recommendations:
To help East Spencer and its development partners better plan and
implement its proposed housing project, this analysis provides the
following recommendations:
A. Number of Homes to Develop:
Although the local for-sale market might absorb 18 new homes planned
by East Spencer, the Town may want to consider a phased development
project with a first phase providing 8 homes to test the market before
committing to develop the remaining 10 homes.
C. The Product:
It is recommended that East Spencer’s housing product contain 1,100-
1,200 square feet, a paved driveway, but no garage, a rear deck, central
heat and air conditioning, and built in stove, refrigerator, and automatic
dishwasher.
D. Marketing:
East Spencer should focus its marketing on obtaining its target buyers
from East Spencer, Spencer, and Salisbury. An attractive promotional
piece with information about proposed homes to attract buyers should be
developed. Minority churches and social services agencies in all three
communities should be consulted to identify prospective buyers. The
Town should also conduct a quarterly workshop to promote the
homeownership opportunity it will provide in Dunbar Renaissance
Village. The Town should develop a profile of the buyer its is seeking, in
terms of income and debt load and be able to collect information, analyze
credit reports and assess a potential buyer’s likelihood of purchasing in 2
years. If buyers show potential, East Spencer must be able to provide
intensive credit counseling, debt management advice, and
DLM & Associates, LLC. 5
homeownership preparation to ensure that buyers are ready to purchase
when homes are available.
I. Purpose of Analysis:
The Town of East Spencer desires to develop new affordable housing in
the area adjacent to the now-vacant Dunbar school, bounded by S. Long
St., E. Broad St., and Robin Circle, to help revitalize the area. The
specific project area and the entire town of East Spencer, as well, suffer
from distressed economic, demographic, income, and housing trends.
Therefore, the Town, as well as government agencies, from whom the
Town is seeking redevelopment funds, and potential development
partners, whom the Town seeks to attract to invest in the project, desire
to have some information indicating that it is reasonable to expect that
the proposed homes can be sold at the proposed project site, and how
many homes should be developed.
This supply and demand analysis is meant to serve such a purpose. It is
not meant to be a detailed market study for East Spencer’s affordable
housing plans. Rather it is meant to provide some basic information that
indicates that that the proposed housing project can be developed and
successfully sold. This analysis attempts to reach this determination by
examining the following issues or questions:
 Who are the most likely potential buyers of the proposed homes?
 What is the Effective Market Area from which these buyers are most
likely to come?
 Within this EMA, is there a demand/need for affordable single-family
housing, such as East Spencer proposes?
 How many potential buyers for the proposed homes exist in the EMA?
 How will the proposed homes compete in the local housing market,
and is it reasonable to expect that they can capture the necessary
percentage of these buyers to be sold?
II. Background Information:
A. Project Location:
1. The Larger Community:
The project site is located along Robin Cir., E. Broad St., and S. Long
St. at the southern edge of East Spencer, where the Town’s boundary
meets that of Salisbury. East Spencer is a distressed, predominantly
DLM & Associates, LLC. 6
minority community. Its population is 85% African-American.1
Unfortunately it is characterized by a variety of urban distress
indicators as noted in the table below:
Distress Indicator Level2
Low Median Household Income $18,947
High Poverty Rate 35.8%
Low Homeownership Rate 47.3%
High Housing Vacancy Rate 12%
Low Median Home Value $66,600
2. The Surrounding Neighborhood:
The general neighborhood (Census Block Group) in which the proposed
project is located is also a predominantly minority area with an African-
American population of 89.4%. However, some of the distress indicators
noted above are more positive than those of the entire Town. At
$30,633, its Median Household Income is much higher and
consequently its poverty rate is much lower at 21.5%. Its Median Home
Value at $65,900 is about the same, but at 59.9%, its homeownership
rate is higher.3
3. The Specific Project Area:
The specific project area is a distressed urban area. Its population is
also predominantly African-American, but only 6 households actually
occupy the immediate project are site. Most of these Households are
believed to be low to moderate income households. Of the homes in the
specific project area, 30% are vacant and most of these are dilapidated
and need to be demolished.4
B. The Proposed Product:
East Spencer proposes to build modular, 3 bedroom, 2 bath, energy-
efficient homes, with central heat and air conditioning, of approximately
1,150 square feet, with built-in appliances that include stove,
refrigerator, and dishwasher. East Spencer expects that these modular
homes may cost $80-$90 per square foot to build, or $92,000-$103,500
and that these homes will appraise for $105,000. This expectation is
based on a recent appraisal of a similar home just built in East Spencer
by a local non-profit affordable housing developer. East Spencer expects
1
2000 US Census data-American Fact Finder.
2
2000 US Census data-American Fact Finder
3
2000 US Census data-American Fact Finder
4
Preparer’s personal inspection of project site
DLM & Associates, LLC. 7
to sell the developed homes for appraised value. East Spencer is
considering building 8-18 dwelling units.5
C. The Proposed Financing:
To make the purchase of the homes it plans to develop affordable for
low-income buyers, East Spencer proposes to provide a special financing
program to eligible purchasers. USDA Rural Development Services will
provide first mortgages. The product most likely to be used will be the
agency’s Payment Assistance Loan, which provides up 80% of the
purchase price (provided a buyer can qualify for this amount). The
remaining 20% of the sales price, up to a maximum of $20,000, would be
provided as a “soft” second mortgage through the North Carolina
Housing Finance Agency’s (NCHFA) New Homes Loan Pool (NHLP), which
the Town expects to join. These loans are provided at 0%, and payments
are deferred until the sale of the house or for 20 years. This NCHFA
program requires that buyers invest $750 of their own funds in the
purchase.
These USDA and NCHFA loan products require that buyers maintain
underwriting ratios not exceeding 29%/41%. This means that the
monthly mortgage payment cannot be more than 29% of a buyer’s
monthly income, and the monthly payment combined with the buyer’s
other recurring monthly debts cannot exceed 41% of monthly income.
The table below provides a summary of purchase financing for four-
person households, consisting of 2 parents and 2 children, @ 50% and
80% AMFI, using the USDA Payment Assistance Loan first mortgage and
the NCHFA New Homes Loan Pool second mortgage.
50% AMFI 80% AMFI
Annual Income $32,050 $51,300
Monthly Income $2,670 $4,275
Maximum Recurring Monthly Debt $745 $1,200
Sales Price $105,000 $105,000
Buyer Investment $750 $750
Balance of Funds Needed $104,250 $104,250
NCHFA 2nd Mortgage -$20,000 -$20,000
USDA 1st Mortgage $84,200 $84,200
Current USDA Rate 5.25% 5.25%
Normal Monthly Principal/Interest Payment $448 $448
Payment Assistance Amount -$198 -0*
Actual Monthly Principal/Interest Payment $250 $448
5
The town of East Spencer
DLM & Associates, LLC. 8
Monthly Taxes/Insurance Escrow Amount +$100 +$100
Total Actual Monthly Payment $350 $548
Underwriting Ratios 29%/41% 15%/41% 13%/41%
*Because of its income this household does not qualify for payment
assistance.
III. The Expected Buyers:
It is believed that the number potential buyers of the proposed homes
will be constrained by income, race, and current tenure, as follows:
A. Income:
This analysis takes a conservative approach and assumes that buyers of
the proposed homes will fall within an income range of 51%-80% AMFI.
As East Spencer expects to use special federal, state and private
financing to fund its redevelopment activity, sale of the homes must be
restricted to buyers with incomes not exceeding 80% of Area Median
Family Income (AMFI) for Rowan County, based on family size.
Homeownership can often be a difficult financial goal for households
earning less than 51% AMFI. Although some such households may
eventually purchase the proposed homes, and there should be concerted
effort to exclude any such eligible households, it is believed prudent for
the purposes of this analysis not to consider such households as
potential buyers of the proposed homes. It is believed, therefore, that as
far as income is concerned, prospective buyers for project homes should
be considered to households with income 51%-80% AMFI. Based on
family size, such households would have the incomes shown in the table
below.6
Family Size Minimum Income Maximum Income
1 $22,450 $35,900
2 $25,650 $41,050
3 $28,850 $46,150
4 $32,050 $51,300
5 $34,600 $55,400
6 $37,200 $59,500
7 $39,750 $63,600
8 $42,300 $67,700
6
The amounts in this table are 2006 HUD income levels. 2007 levels should be released soon and may
likely be slightly higher.
DLM & Associates, LLC. 9
B. Race:
East Spencer will employ an affirmative marketing strategy in an effort
to attract potential buyers who might not otherwise be attracted to the
project site. Unfortunately, however, East Spencer may have a difficult
task in attracting non-minority households, and the pool of eligible
buyers for East Spencer’s proposed homes may also be shaped by race.
The project is located in a distressed urban community with a minority
population of 89% that also experiences low property values, high
housing vacancy rates, and poor housing conditions. There are other
purchasing opportunities in the same price range in other sections of the
likely Effective Market Area that have different racial compositions and
fewer distress indicators. There should be no effort to engage in racial
discrimination in the sale of the proposed homes. However, it just may be
too much to expect that the proposed project can transcend established
local settlement patterns. Including non-minority households in the pool
of prospective buyers could add for consideration a large number of
households that just may not be realistically attracted to the homes, and
thereby unrealistically skew the conclusions of this analysis. It is
therefore, recommended that for the purposes of this study, that the pool
of prospective buyers for the proposed homes be considered to be
minority households within the above income range.
C. Tenure:
It is also believed that current homeowners should be excluded from the
pool of prospective buyers. It is believed that such buyers are much less
likely to be attracted to the proposed homes. These homes may offer
such buyers little improvement in terms of space, ambiance, or
amenities, and owners in more established residential areas are probably
less likely to purchase in a reviving urban area. Sales in which buyers
own existing homes are typically more complicated and require buyers to
condition offers and actual purchase on selling their current home. East
Spencer may want to avoid such sales.
IV. The Effective Market Area:
Although East Spencer is a small town with a population of only 1,755,
it is located along I-85 in the midst of a larger metropolitan area.
Concord, with a population of 63,429, and Kannapolis, with a population
of 40,139 lie within a 20-minute drive to the south along I-85, and
Charlotte, with a population of 640,270 within a 30-minute drive to the
south. Lexington, with a population of 20,918, is located within a 15-
minute drive north along I-85, and Winston-Salem, with a population of
198,593, lies within a 30-minute dive north along I-85 and US 52. East
Spencer is also part of a smaller contiguous urban metro area which
DLM & Associates, LLC. 10
includes the Town of Spencer, with a population of 3,394, and the City of
Salisbury, with a population of 29,058, the Town of Granite Quarry, with
a population of 2,175, and the small community of Faith, with a
population of 695.7 One million people, therefore, reside within what is
an easy commuting distance of the project site. It is certainly possible
that a household might relocate from one of these other larger
municipalities, and purchase a project area home; especially if they had
some employment, family, or birth connection to the area. However, this
is not believed to be very likely. It is believed that the realistic EMA for
the proposed project must be a much smaller area closer to the project
site. The entire County of Rowan could be used as the EMA, however, the
likelihood of households relocating from the rural areas of a large county
to a reviving small town urban setting are also believed to be low, and the
entire county, therefore, is considered too large to be the EMA for the
project. It is believed that the most logical EMA for the proposed project
is the Salisbury urban, metropolitan area, consisting of the
municipalities of East Spencer, Spencer, Salisbury, Granite Quarry, and
Faith as shown on the map below.
7
2005 municipal population data from the NC Demographics web site of the North Carolina Office of
Budget and management
Effective Market Area
DLM & Associates, LLC. 11
V. Demand/Need for Affordable Housing:
This analysis determines that there is a serious demand or need for
affordable housing in the EMA. As noted below, a significant number of
households are cost burdened, paying more than 30% of income for rent
or mortgage payment, and, as a result, a serious housing affordability
“mismatch” exists between housing units considered affordable to certain
income groups, and the income of many of the households that occupy
these units.
A. Cost Burdened Households:
The US Department of Housing and Urban development (HUD) considers
households, paying more than 30% of monthly income for rent or
mortgage payments, to be cost burdened and to occupy unaffordable
housing.
EMA Households Paying More Than 30% of Income for Housing-
20008
EMA
Component
Household Type Payments
>30%
Payments
>50%
# % # %
East Spencer Total 290 38% 138 18%
Renter 50%-80% AMFI 16 26% 0 0%
Owner 50%-80% AMFI 45 35% 4 3%
Spencer Total 238 19% 88 7%
Renter 50%-80% AMFI 19 12% 0 0%
Owner 50%-80% AMFI 40 14% 0 0%
Salisbury Total 2,799 27% 1,140 11%
Renter 50%-80% AMFI 158 14% 23 2%
Owner 50%-80% AMFI 461 21% 88 4%
Granite
Quarry
Total 230 25% 83 9%
Renter 50%-80% AMFI 8 19% 4 9%
Owner 50%-80% AMFI 54 35% 8 5%
Faith Total 73 23% 32 10%
Renter 50%-80% AMFI 4 33% 4 33%
Owner 50%-80% AMFI 16 29% 8 15%
Entire EMA Total 3,630 27% 341 3%
Renter 50%-80% AMFI 205 15% 31 2%
Owner 50%-80% AMFI 616 22% 108 4%
8
Comprehensive Housing Affordability Strategy data from State of the Cities Data Set web site
DLM & Associates, LLC. 12
B. Affordability Mismatch:
Competition for housing in an unaffordable housing market often
creates an affordability “mismatch”. In such a market, as households
compete for housing and attempt to lower their housing costs, higher
income households push their way into occupancy of housing units
considered affordable to the next lowest income range. Thus many
housing units, affordable to households in the 51%-80% AMFI income
range, are actually occupied by households with incomes above 80%
AMFI. Many households in the 51%-80%, in turn, then push their way
into units affordable to the 31%-50% income range, while many
households in that income group, in their turn, push their way into units
affordable to households in the 0%-30% AMFI range.
As can be seen in the table below there is a serious affordability
mismatch for households in the 51%-80% income range within the EMA
for East Spencer’s proposed homes. Of the 3,996 occupied housing units
in the EMA considered affordable to households with income 51%-80%
AMFI, less than half, 45%, are actually occupied by low-income
households with incomes at or below 80% AMFI. The remaining 55% are
occupied by higher income households, who, in an effort to lower their
own housing costs, have pushed the 51%-80% AMFI households into
even cheaper housing, or forced them to occupy unaffordable housing.
The need for affordable homeownership units in the EMA for households
with incomes of 51%-80% AMFI, the target income range for East
Spencer’s proposed homes, is significant. Of the 2,743 existing
homeowner households in this income group within the EMA, 60%, or
1,674 occupy unaffordable housing. Of the 1,253 renter households with
incomes 51%-80%, the income range most likely to purchase East
Spencer’s proposed homes, 505, or 40%, are occupying unaffordable
housing. Many of these might be attracted to a homeownership
opportunity that offered an opportunity to obtain more affordable
housing.
Its is interesting to note, in the table below, that East Spencer has a
significantly lower incidence of affordability mismatch than do the other
components of the EMA. Perhaps the lower income of East Spencer’s
households, compared to the surrounding communities, has held down
housing costs. More likely, due to their lower incomes, East Spencer’s
households are making greater use of HUD’s Housing Choice vouchers to
contain their housing cost at 30%. This may indicate, however, that East
Spencer’s proposed homes are more likely to attract buyers from the
other components of the EMA than from East Spencer itself, a marketing
issue that East Spencer should consider.
DLM & Associates, LLC. 13
Affordability Mismatch9
Area # Occupied
Units
Affordable To
Households
51%-80% MHI
% Units
Actually
Occupied by
Households
<80% MHI
# Affordable
Units Actually
Occupied by
Households
<80% MHI
East Spencer 178 67.9% 121
Rental Units 82 78.8% 65
Owner Units 96 58.3% 56
Spencer 385 33.2% 128
Rental Units 88 60.2% 53
Owner Units 297 25.3% 75
Granite Quarry 309 42% 129
Rental Units 57 35.1% 20
Owner Units 252 43.2% 109
Salisbury 3,002 46.2% 1,387
Rental Units 1,010 60.4% 610
Owner Units 1,992 39% 777
Faith 122 43% 52
Rental Units 16 0% 0
Owner Units 106 43% 52
Total EMA 3,996 45% 1,817
Rental Units 1,253 60% 748
Owner Units 2,743 40% 1,069
VI. The Number of Potential Buyers in the Effective Market Area
It has earlier been determined that the most likely buyers of East
Spencer’s proposed homes will be minority households with incomes
51%-80% AMFI. As can be seen in the table below, there are 579
minority households in 51%-80% AMFI income range in the EMA; in
East Spencer, Spencer, and Salisbury. However, all of these cannot be
considered potential buyers. Some are elderly 1-2 person households,
unlikely to be attracted to homeownership opportunities. Others may be
younger single-person households, not yet ready for homeownership, or
larger families needing more than 3 bedrooms. After factoring out such
households, there remain 340 minority, renter, family, households in the
51%-80% AMFI income range in the EMA, who may be potential
candidates for purchasing the proposed East Spencer homes.
9
All of the figures in this section were obtained from the State of the Cities Data System-Comprehensive
Housing Affordability Strategy data
DLM & Associates, LLC. 14
Effective Market Area Minority Renter Households
With Incomes 51%-80% AMFI10
Area # Households
Total 51%-
80%
Elderly Other Remaining Potential
Family Household Buyers
East Spencer 51 -8 -8 35
Spencer 30 -0 -20 10
Granite Quarry 0 -0 -0 0
Salisbury 498 -8 -195 295
Faith 0 -0 -0 0
Total EMA 579 -16 -223 340
Although these 340 households may be potential prospects for
purchasing the homes planned by East Spencer, they may not be
financially capable of purchasing in the near future. East Spencer should
expect that the ability of a significant portion of these households to
obtain a mortgage, at the level required to purchase one of the proposed
homes during an initial 2-year period, may be constrained by their credit
history, or debt load. For example, within the Charlotte Metropolitan
Statistical Area in 2005, 23% of all denied home purchase loan
applications from minority households were denied due to debt to income
ratio, and 42% due to credit history. Of households with incomes 51%-
80% AMFI, 19% of all denied home mortgage applications were denied
due to debt to income ratio, and 40% were denied due to credit history.11
The experience of the preparer leads him to a conservative approach to
this issue and it is estimated that as many as 50%, or 170, of these
households may have serious credit and debt issues that will make them
poor candidates for home purchase in the near future. Therefore, it is
estimated that there are 170 minority, renter households with incomes
51%-80% MHI within the EMA that could be potential buyers for the
proposed homes.
VII. Competition and Capture Rate:
A. Competition:
It appears that the proposed homes could compete well in the residential
for-sale market within the EMA. As far as new homes are concerned, 600
were built in Rowan County in 2006 at an average price of $190,00012.
Priced at $105,000, the proposed homes would certainly be priced at a
point well below the average price of a new home in the general area.
10
State of the Cities Data System-Comprehensive Housing Affordability Strategy data
11
Home Mortgage Disclosure Act information-FFIEC web site
12
US Census Data on Rowan County Building Permits
DLM & Associates, LLC. 15
At the time of the preparation of this analysis, there were 14 homes listed
for sale in the multiple listing service of the Salisbury/Rowan County
Association of Realtors, which with 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, central air and
heat, and priced from $90,000-$110,000, were good comparables to the
homes proposed by East Spencer. Information about these homes is
presented in the table below. These homes were priced from $95,000-
$109,000. Those with 1,100-1,200 square feet, similar to East Spencer’s,
were priced from $83-$95 per square foot. All but one of those built
within the past 6 years were priced at $86-$95 per square foot. With a
proposed selling price of $105,000 for 1,100-1,200 square feet of livable
area, or $87-$95 per square foot, East Spencer homes fall right into this
range and would appear to be competitively priced. Some of these homes
do offer potential buyers the opportunity to obtain substantially greater
square footage for a similar, and, in some cases, lower price. However,
these are typically much older homes. Two homes, in particular, are
newly built and with 1,120 square feet are very similar to the proposed
East Spencer homes. These are listed for $99,000 and $99,999.
It is believed that East Spencer’s proposed homes could compete well in
the residential single-family for-sale housing market within the EMA. The
homes would be especially competitive if priced at just under $100,000
and under $90 per square feet.
Current Listings Residential, Single-Family Listings
Salisbury/Rowan County Association of Realtors Multiple Listing
Service13
($90,000-$110,000 with 3 Bedrooms and 2 Bathrooms)
# Price Year
Built
Square Footage Price Per Square Foot
1 99,900 1930 1,555 $64
2 99,999 2006 1,120 $89
3 99,000 2006 1,120 $88
4 109,900 2001 1,160 $95
5 109,900 1885 1,996 $55
6 102,000 1963 1,756 $58
7 99,900 1954 1,420 $70
8 96,000 2001 1,344 $71
9 95,000 2001 1,104 $86
10 99,900 1995 1,400 $71
11 95,900 1943 1,353 $71
12 98,500 1998 1,456 $67
13 101,500 1949 1,713 $59
13
Salisbury/Rowan County Association of Realtors Multiple Service web site
DLM & Associates, LLC. 16
14 99,900 1995 1,200 $83
B. Capture Rate:
East Spencer proposes to build and sell 8-18 homes over a two and one-
half year period. To sell 8 homes, East Spencer would only have to
capture 5% of the 170 potential buyers for its proposed homes within the
EMA. To sell 18, the Town would only have to capture 11%. This seems
reasonable given the market described above. The potential buyers of
East Spencer’s product, minority households with incomes of 51%-80%
AMFI residing the urban areas of East Spencer, Spencer, and Salisbury,
should be attracted to the opportunity to own a new home with a
payment of 29% of monthly income, which may be less than they are
paying for rent.
VIII. Conclusion:
It is the determination of this analysis, therefore, that there is
reasonable prospect of selling, within two and one-half years, as many as
18 3-bedroom, 2-bath homes for $100,000-$105,000 at the proposed
project site.
IX. Recommendations:
The following recommendations are made to assist the Town of East
Spencer and its development partners in planning and marketing the
affordable homes it hopes to develop in the Dunbar Renaissance Village
Redevelopment Project.
 Number of Homes to Develop:
Although the local market might be able to absorb 18 new homes at
the project site, East Spencer may want to develop its project in
phases, with its first phase contain 8 homes. As the market is tested
and proves successful, East Spencer can build additional homes.
 The Product:
To keep building costs and eventual selling prices low to fit the
incomes of the potential buyers, and to be competitive, East Spencer is
advised to consider building as small a product as reasonable, 1,100-
1,200 square feet, to provide a paved driveway, but to not provide a
garage. The product should have a rear deck, central heat and air
condition, and since buyers are expected to be apartment dwellers,
provide built in stove, refrigerator, and automatic dishwasher.
DLM & Associates, LLC. 17
 Marketing:
Buyers of the proposed homes are most likely to come from the
minority populations of East Spencer, Spencer, and Salisbury. East
Spencer should, therefore, develop a non-traditional marketing out-
reach to identify potential buyers. East Spencer is encouraged to
develop an attractive promotional piece with information about
proposed homes to attract buyers. The Town should work with
minority churches and social services agencies in all three
communities to identify prospective buyers. The Town should also
conduct quarterly workshops to promote the homeownership
opportunity it will provide in Dunbar Renaissance Village. The Town
should develop a profile of the buyer its is seeking, in terms of income
and debt load and be able to collect information, analyze credit reports
and assess a potential buyer’s likelihood of purchasing in 2 years. If
buyers show potential, East Spencer must be able to provide intensive
credit counseling, debt management advice, and homeownership
preparation to ensure that buyers are ready to purchase when homes
are available.

More Related Content

What's hot

This Month in Real Estate July 2011
This Month in Real Estate July 2011This Month in Real Estate July 2011
This Month in Real Estate July 2011pdrury
 
Annie Williams Real Estate Report - Dec 2015
Annie Williams Real Estate Report - Dec 2015Annie Williams Real Estate Report - Dec 2015
Annie Williams Real Estate Report - Dec 2015Jon Weaver
 
E-book_The Ultimate Guide to Real Estate Investing in Orange County_SK Articl...
E-book_The Ultimate Guide to Real Estate Investing in Orange County_SK Articl...E-book_The Ultimate Guide to Real Estate Investing in Orange County_SK Articl...
E-book_The Ultimate Guide to Real Estate Investing in Orange County_SK Articl...Jason Townsend
 
RECREATIONAL PROPERTY REPORTS 2019
RECREATIONAL PROPERTY REPORTS 2019RECREATIONAL PROPERTY REPORTS 2019
RECREATIONAL PROPERTY REPORTS 2019Shawn Venasse
 
This Month in Real Estate - Sept 2011
This Month in Real Estate - Sept  2011This Month in Real Estate - Sept  2011
This Month in Real Estate - Sept 2011pdrury
 
Weichert, Princeton January Market Recap & Forecast
Weichert, Princeton January Market Recap & ForecastWeichert, Princeton January Market Recap & Forecast
Weichert, Princeton January Market Recap & ForecastWeichert Realtors
 
5 Reasons To Sell Your Home This Winter
5 Reasons To Sell Your Home This Winter5 Reasons To Sell Your Home This Winter
5 Reasons To Sell Your Home This WinterGina Madeya
 
Annie Williams Real Estate Report Nov-Dec 2015
Annie Williams Real Estate Report Nov-Dec 2015Annie Williams Real Estate Report Nov-Dec 2015
Annie Williams Real Estate Report Nov-Dec 2015Jon Weaver
 
Beverly-Hanks 2016_q1_market_report
Beverly-Hanks 2016_q1_market_reportBeverly-Hanks 2016_q1_market_report
Beverly-Hanks 2016_q1_market_reportWes Morgan
 
John Burns National Housing Update
John Burns National Housing UpdateJohn Burns National Housing Update
John Burns National Housing Updatehollybernie
 
October 2009 Presentation To Gov Council
October 2009 Presentation To Gov CouncilOctober 2009 Presentation To Gov Council
October 2009 Presentation To Gov CouncilPeabody & Smith Realty
 
Selling Your House Winter 2017
Selling Your House Winter 2017Selling Your House Winter 2017
Selling Your House Winter 2017Bill Butler
 
Home Buyer Guide Winter 2017
Home Buyer Guide Winter 2017Home Buyer Guide Winter 2017
Home Buyer Guide Winter 2017Bill Butler
 
Princeton Real Estate Market Presentation March 2017
Princeton Real Estate Market Presentation March 2017Princeton Real Estate Market Presentation March 2017
Princeton Real Estate Market Presentation March 2017Weichert Realtors
 

What's hot (20)

This Month in Real Estate July 2011
This Month in Real Estate July 2011This Month in Real Estate July 2011
This Month in Real Estate July 2011
 
Annie Williams Real Estate Report - Dec 2015
Annie Williams Real Estate Report - Dec 2015Annie Williams Real Estate Report - Dec 2015
Annie Williams Real Estate Report - Dec 2015
 
Newsletter 4 2010
Newsletter 4 2010Newsletter 4 2010
Newsletter 4 2010
 
1 11 league of cities
1 11 league of cities1 11 league of cities
1 11 league of cities
 
Newsletter dec 2010t
Newsletter dec 2010tNewsletter dec 2010t
Newsletter dec 2010t
 
April Realtor Report
April Realtor ReportApril Realtor Report
April Realtor Report
 
E-book_The Ultimate Guide to Real Estate Investing in Orange County_SK Articl...
E-book_The Ultimate Guide to Real Estate Investing in Orange County_SK Articl...E-book_The Ultimate Guide to Real Estate Investing in Orange County_SK Articl...
E-book_The Ultimate Guide to Real Estate Investing in Orange County_SK Articl...
 
RECREATIONAL PROPERTY REPORTS 2019
RECREATIONAL PROPERTY REPORTS 2019RECREATIONAL PROPERTY REPORTS 2019
RECREATIONAL PROPERTY REPORTS 2019
 
May 2014 Realtor Report
May 2014 Realtor ReportMay 2014 Realtor Report
May 2014 Realtor Report
 
This Month in Real Estate - Sept 2011
This Month in Real Estate - Sept  2011This Month in Real Estate - Sept  2011
This Month in Real Estate - Sept 2011
 
Weichert, Princeton January Market Recap & Forecast
Weichert, Princeton January Market Recap & ForecastWeichert, Princeton January Market Recap & Forecast
Weichert, Princeton January Market Recap & Forecast
 
5 Reasons To Sell Your Home This Winter
5 Reasons To Sell Your Home This Winter5 Reasons To Sell Your Home This Winter
5 Reasons To Sell Your Home This Winter
 
Annie Williams Real Estate Report Nov-Dec 2015
Annie Williams Real Estate Report Nov-Dec 2015Annie Williams Real Estate Report Nov-Dec 2015
Annie Williams Real Estate Report Nov-Dec 2015
 
Beverly-Hanks 2016_q1_market_report
Beverly-Hanks 2016_q1_market_reportBeverly-Hanks 2016_q1_market_report
Beverly-Hanks 2016_q1_market_report
 
John Burns National Housing Update
John Burns National Housing UpdateJohn Burns National Housing Update
John Burns National Housing Update
 
October 2009 Presentation To Gov Council
October 2009 Presentation To Gov CouncilOctober 2009 Presentation To Gov Council
October 2009 Presentation To Gov Council
 
Selling Your House Winter 2017
Selling Your House Winter 2017Selling Your House Winter 2017
Selling Your House Winter 2017
 
Month in-review-february-2018-residential
Month in-review-february-2018-residentialMonth in-review-february-2018-residential
Month in-review-february-2018-residential
 
Home Buyer Guide Winter 2017
Home Buyer Guide Winter 2017Home Buyer Guide Winter 2017
Home Buyer Guide Winter 2017
 
Princeton Real Estate Market Presentation March 2017
Princeton Real Estate Market Presentation March 2017Princeton Real Estate Market Presentation March 2017
Princeton Real Estate Market Presentation March 2017
 

Viewers also liked

Brother to Brother Pres 2014
Brother to Brother Pres 2014Brother to Brother Pres 2014
Brother to Brother Pres 2014Dana Merck
 
Carolina Business Incubator
Carolina Business IncubatorCarolina Business Incubator
Carolina Business IncubatorDana Merck
 
20150224 Dissertation Joost Poort - Table of contents and abstract
20150224 Dissertation Joost Poort - Table of contents and abstract20150224 Dissertation Joost Poort - Table of contents and abstract
20150224 Dissertation Joost Poort - Table of contents and abstractJoost Poort
 
conflict res pres
conflict res presconflict res pres
conflict res presDana Merck
 
Thiết kế shop mỹ phẩm
Thiết kế shop mỹ phẩmThiết kế shop mỹ phẩm
Thiết kế shop mỹ phẩmnoithatphangia
 
Business Analytics
Business AnalyticsBusiness Analytics
Business AnalyticsPrem Anand
 
Geschiedenis van twitter marketing
Geschiedenis van twitter marketingGeschiedenis van twitter marketing
Geschiedenis van twitter marketingBlog4leads
 
Thiết kế khu vui chơi trẻ em
Thiết kế khu vui chơi trẻ emThiết kế khu vui chơi trẻ em
Thiết kế khu vui chơi trẻ emnoithatphangia
 
Question 2
Question 2Question 2
Question 2Kirsty98
 
ми всі майбутні таланти
ми всі майбутні талантими всі майбутні таланти
ми всі майбутні талантиJohn_Fikus
 
summarize system analysis and design ch2
summarize system analysis and design ch2 summarize system analysis and design ch2
summarize system analysis and design ch2 Dana dia
 

Viewers also liked (14)

Brother to Brother Pres 2014
Brother to Brother Pres 2014Brother to Brother Pres 2014
Brother to Brother Pres 2014
 
subhash__cv
subhash__cvsubhash__cv
subhash__cv
 
Carolina Business Incubator
Carolina Business IncubatorCarolina Business Incubator
Carolina Business Incubator
 
20150224 Dissertation Joost Poort - Table of contents and abstract
20150224 Dissertation Joost Poort - Table of contents and abstract20150224 Dissertation Joost Poort - Table of contents and abstract
20150224 Dissertation Joost Poort - Table of contents and abstract
 
conflict res pres
conflict res presconflict res pres
conflict res pres
 
Thiết kế shop mỹ phẩm
Thiết kế shop mỹ phẩmThiết kế shop mỹ phẩm
Thiết kế shop mỹ phẩm
 
Mission and Strategy
Mission and StrategyMission and Strategy
Mission and Strategy
 
Business Analytics
Business AnalyticsBusiness Analytics
Business Analytics
 
Geschiedenis van twitter marketing
Geschiedenis van twitter marketingGeschiedenis van twitter marketing
Geschiedenis van twitter marketing
 
Thiết kế khu vui chơi trẻ em
Thiết kế khu vui chơi trẻ emThiết kế khu vui chơi trẻ em
Thiết kế khu vui chơi trẻ em
 
Question 2
Question 2Question 2
Question 2
 
ми всі майбутні таланти
ми всі майбутні талантими всі майбутні таланти
ми всі майбутні таланти
 
summarize system analysis and design ch2
summarize system analysis and design ch2 summarize system analysis and design ch2
summarize system analysis and design ch2
 
Elwira Katkowska CV 2015
Elwira Katkowska CV 2015Elwira Katkowska CV 2015
Elwira Katkowska CV 2015
 

Similar to DLM MarketAnalysis[1]

Things To Consider When Selling Your House - Fall 2017
Things To Consider When Selling Your House - Fall 2017Things To Consider When Selling Your House - Fall 2017
Things To Consider When Selling Your House - Fall 2017Kris and Kim Darney
 
2009 Deuel County Housing Assessment Updated Key Findings 1st
2009 Deuel County Housing Assessment Updated Key Findings 1st2009 Deuel County Housing Assessment Updated Key Findings 1st
2009 Deuel County Housing Assessment Updated Key Findings 1stJoan Sacrison
 
AMA Presentation-Buyer Profile: Hispanic Home Buyer
AMA Presentation-Buyer Profile:  Hispanic Home BuyerAMA Presentation-Buyer Profile:  Hispanic Home Buyer
AMA Presentation-Buyer Profile: Hispanic Home Buyerbrianjohnson
 
Weichert Princeton March 2016 Market Update Seminar
Weichert Princeton March 2016 Market Update SeminarWeichert Princeton March 2016 Market Update Seminar
Weichert Princeton March 2016 Market Update SeminarWeichert Realtors
 
Buying a Home Spring 2016
Buying a Home Spring 2016Buying a Home Spring 2016
Buying a Home Spring 2016Holly Pinkerton
 
Buying a Home With Debbie Railey
Buying a Home With Debbie RaileyBuying a Home With Debbie Railey
Buying a Home With Debbie Raileyexcell4him
 
Things To Consider When Buying A Home Spring 2015
Things To Consider When Buying A Home Spring 2015Things To Consider When Buying A Home Spring 2015
Things To Consider When Buying A Home Spring 2015The Denver Real Estate Firm
 
Debbie Railey's Home Buyers Guide 2015 Summer
Debbie Railey's Home Buyers Guide 2015 SummerDebbie Railey's Home Buyers Guide 2015 Summer
Debbie Railey's Home Buyers Guide 2015 Summerexcell4him
 
Housing Trends - NAWRB Magazine
Housing Trends - NAWRB MagazineHousing Trends - NAWRB Magazine
Housing Trends - NAWRB MagazineDesiree Patno
 
Irene_Cuffe_BuyingaHome_Spring2016
Irene_Cuffe_BuyingaHome_Spring2016Irene_Cuffe_BuyingaHome_Spring2016
Irene_Cuffe_BuyingaHome_Spring2016Irene Cuffe
 
This Month in Real Estate For U.S. - June 2010
This Month in Real Estate For U.S. - June 2010This Month in Real Estate For U.S. - June 2010
This Month in Real Estate For U.S. - June 2010Keller Williams Careers
 
Buying a Home...Top Things to Consider!
Buying a Home...Top Things to Consider!Buying a Home...Top Things to Consider!
Buying a Home...Top Things to Consider!Tiffany Curry
 

Similar to DLM MarketAnalysis[1] (20)

Selling Your Home - Fall 2017
Selling Your Home - Fall 2017Selling Your Home - Fall 2017
Selling Your Home - Fall 2017
 
Things To Consider When Selling Your House - Fall 2017
Things To Consider When Selling Your House - Fall 2017Things To Consider When Selling Your House - Fall 2017
Things To Consider When Selling Your House - Fall 2017
 
2009 Deuel County Housing Assessment Updated Key Findings 1st
2009 Deuel County Housing Assessment Updated Key Findings 1st2009 Deuel County Housing Assessment Updated Key Findings 1st
2009 Deuel County Housing Assessment Updated Key Findings 1st
 
AMA Presentation-Buyer Profile: Hispanic Home Buyer
AMA Presentation-Buyer Profile:  Hispanic Home BuyerAMA Presentation-Buyer Profile:  Hispanic Home Buyer
AMA Presentation-Buyer Profile: Hispanic Home Buyer
 
Weichert Princeton March 2016 Market Update Seminar
Weichert Princeton March 2016 Market Update SeminarWeichert Princeton March 2016 Market Update Seminar
Weichert Princeton March 2016 Market Update Seminar
 
Acecourseinvestorsession1
Acecourseinvestorsession1Acecourseinvestorsession1
Acecourseinvestorsession1
 
Buying a Home Spring 2016
Buying a Home Spring 2016Buying a Home Spring 2016
Buying a Home Spring 2016
 
Buying a Home With Debbie Railey
Buying a Home With Debbie RaileyBuying a Home With Debbie Railey
Buying a Home With Debbie Railey
 
Things To Consider When Buying A Home Spring 2015
Things To Consider When Buying A Home Spring 2015Things To Consider When Buying A Home Spring 2015
Things To Consider When Buying A Home Spring 2015
 
Purchasing a Home Summer 2015
Purchasing a Home Summer 2015Purchasing a Home Summer 2015
Purchasing a Home Summer 2015
 
Guide to Buying a Home
Guide to Buying a HomeGuide to Buying a Home
Guide to Buying a Home
 
Debbie Railey's Home Buyers Guide 2015 Summer
Debbie Railey's Home Buyers Guide 2015 SummerDebbie Railey's Home Buyers Guide 2015 Summer
Debbie Railey's Home Buyers Guide 2015 Summer
 
This Month in Real Estate: June 2010
This Month in Real Estate: June 2010This Month in Real Estate: June 2010
This Month in Real Estate: June 2010
 
Housing Trends - NAWRB Magazine
Housing Trends - NAWRB MagazineHousing Trends - NAWRB Magazine
Housing Trends - NAWRB Magazine
 
Irene_Cuffe_BuyingaHome_Spring2016
Irene_Cuffe_BuyingaHome_Spring2016Irene_Cuffe_BuyingaHome_Spring2016
Irene_Cuffe_BuyingaHome_Spring2016
 
June 2010 Market Update
June 2010 Market UpdateJune 2010 Market Update
June 2010 Market Update
 
This Month in Real Estate For U.S. - June 2010
This Month in Real Estate For U.S. - June 2010This Month in Real Estate For U.S. - June 2010
This Month in Real Estate For U.S. - June 2010
 
Buying a Home Guide Summer 2015
Buying a Home Guide Summer 2015Buying a Home Guide Summer 2015
Buying a Home Guide Summer 2015
 
Totalmarketoverview june10
Totalmarketoverview june10Totalmarketoverview june10
Totalmarketoverview june10
 
Buying a Home...Top Things to Consider!
Buying a Home...Top Things to Consider!Buying a Home...Top Things to Consider!
Buying a Home...Top Things to Consider!
 

DLM MarketAnalysis[1]

  • 1. DLM & Associates, LLC. Affordable Housing Supply and Demand Analysis For the Town of East Spencer February 2010 By Dana Merck DLM & Associates, LLC.
  • 2. DLM & Associates, LLC. 2 Table of Contents Section Page # Executive Summary 3 I. Purpose of Analysis 6 II. Background Information 6 III. Expected Buyers 9 IV. Effective Market Area 10 V. Demand/Need for Affordable Housing 12 VI. Number of Potential Buffers in EMA 15 VII. Competition and Capture Rate 16 VIII. Conclusion 18 IX: Recommendations 18
  • 3. DLM & Associates, LLC. 3 Executive Summary: East Spencer is proposing to build 8-18 affordable homes in the Dunbar Renaissance Village Redevelopment Area along Robin Cr., E. Broad St., and S. Long St. near the vacant Dunbar School. The Town expects to build 3 bedroom 2 bath homes and to sell these homes for $105,000 over a two and one-half year period. I. Conclusion: It is the determination of this Supply and Demand Analysis that that the proposed housing project can be developed and successfully sold. This determination has been reached by examining and developing answers to the following questions: Q: Who are the most likely potential buyers of the proposed homes? A: The most likely potential buyers for the proposed homes are minority households with incomes of 51%-80% Area Median Family Income. Q: What is the Effective Market Area from which these buyers are most likely to come? A: The most likely Effective Market Area for the proposed homes is the greater Salisbury urban area including the City of Salisbury, and the adjacent Towns of East Spencer, Spencer, Granite Quarry, and Faith. Although the buyers described above are expected to come only from Salisbury, East Spencer, and Spencer. Q: Within this EMA, is there a demand/need for affordable, single-family housing, such as East Spencer proposes? A: There is believed to be a serious demand/need for affordable housing within the EMA, since 27% of EMA households pay more than the HUD recommended 30% of monthly income for housing, and 55% of EMA housing units, considered affordable to low-income households with incomes 51%-80% AMFI, are actually occupied by non low-income households. Q: How many potential buyers for the proposed homes exist in the EMA? A: There are 340 minority, family households with incomes of 51%- 80%AMFI, but as many as 50% of this number may be constrained from purchasing a home due to credit history or debt load, leaving 170 potential buyers for East Spencer’s proposed homes.
  • 4. DLM & Associates, LLC. 4 Q: How will the proposed homes compete in the local housing market, and is it reasonable to expect that they can capture the necessary percentage of these buyers to be sold? A. East Spencer’s homes are priced within the $85-$95 per square foot range of newer homes offering similar square footage and amenities, and are expected to compete well. To sell 8 homes, East Spencer would only have to capture 5% of the potential buyers in EMA and to sell 18 homes capture only 11%, therefore an 18-home development appears reasonable. II. Recommendations: To help East Spencer and its development partners better plan and implement its proposed housing project, this analysis provides the following recommendations: A. Number of Homes to Develop: Although the local for-sale market might absorb 18 new homes planned by East Spencer, the Town may want to consider a phased development project with a first phase providing 8 homes to test the market before committing to develop the remaining 10 homes. C. The Product: It is recommended that East Spencer’s housing product contain 1,100- 1,200 square feet, a paved driveway, but no garage, a rear deck, central heat and air conditioning, and built in stove, refrigerator, and automatic dishwasher. D. Marketing: East Spencer should focus its marketing on obtaining its target buyers from East Spencer, Spencer, and Salisbury. An attractive promotional piece with information about proposed homes to attract buyers should be developed. Minority churches and social services agencies in all three communities should be consulted to identify prospective buyers. The Town should also conduct a quarterly workshop to promote the homeownership opportunity it will provide in Dunbar Renaissance Village. The Town should develop a profile of the buyer its is seeking, in terms of income and debt load and be able to collect information, analyze credit reports and assess a potential buyer’s likelihood of purchasing in 2 years. If buyers show potential, East Spencer must be able to provide intensive credit counseling, debt management advice, and
  • 5. DLM & Associates, LLC. 5 homeownership preparation to ensure that buyers are ready to purchase when homes are available. I. Purpose of Analysis: The Town of East Spencer desires to develop new affordable housing in the area adjacent to the now-vacant Dunbar school, bounded by S. Long St., E. Broad St., and Robin Circle, to help revitalize the area. The specific project area and the entire town of East Spencer, as well, suffer from distressed economic, demographic, income, and housing trends. Therefore, the Town, as well as government agencies, from whom the Town is seeking redevelopment funds, and potential development partners, whom the Town seeks to attract to invest in the project, desire to have some information indicating that it is reasonable to expect that the proposed homes can be sold at the proposed project site, and how many homes should be developed. This supply and demand analysis is meant to serve such a purpose. It is not meant to be a detailed market study for East Spencer’s affordable housing plans. Rather it is meant to provide some basic information that indicates that that the proposed housing project can be developed and successfully sold. This analysis attempts to reach this determination by examining the following issues or questions:  Who are the most likely potential buyers of the proposed homes?  What is the Effective Market Area from which these buyers are most likely to come?  Within this EMA, is there a demand/need for affordable single-family housing, such as East Spencer proposes?  How many potential buyers for the proposed homes exist in the EMA?  How will the proposed homes compete in the local housing market, and is it reasonable to expect that they can capture the necessary percentage of these buyers to be sold? II. Background Information: A. Project Location: 1. The Larger Community: The project site is located along Robin Cir., E. Broad St., and S. Long St. at the southern edge of East Spencer, where the Town’s boundary meets that of Salisbury. East Spencer is a distressed, predominantly
  • 6. DLM & Associates, LLC. 6 minority community. Its population is 85% African-American.1 Unfortunately it is characterized by a variety of urban distress indicators as noted in the table below: Distress Indicator Level2 Low Median Household Income $18,947 High Poverty Rate 35.8% Low Homeownership Rate 47.3% High Housing Vacancy Rate 12% Low Median Home Value $66,600 2. The Surrounding Neighborhood: The general neighborhood (Census Block Group) in which the proposed project is located is also a predominantly minority area with an African- American population of 89.4%. However, some of the distress indicators noted above are more positive than those of the entire Town. At $30,633, its Median Household Income is much higher and consequently its poverty rate is much lower at 21.5%. Its Median Home Value at $65,900 is about the same, but at 59.9%, its homeownership rate is higher.3 3. The Specific Project Area: The specific project area is a distressed urban area. Its population is also predominantly African-American, but only 6 households actually occupy the immediate project are site. Most of these Households are believed to be low to moderate income households. Of the homes in the specific project area, 30% are vacant and most of these are dilapidated and need to be demolished.4 B. The Proposed Product: East Spencer proposes to build modular, 3 bedroom, 2 bath, energy- efficient homes, with central heat and air conditioning, of approximately 1,150 square feet, with built-in appliances that include stove, refrigerator, and dishwasher. East Spencer expects that these modular homes may cost $80-$90 per square foot to build, or $92,000-$103,500 and that these homes will appraise for $105,000. This expectation is based on a recent appraisal of a similar home just built in East Spencer by a local non-profit affordable housing developer. East Spencer expects 1 2000 US Census data-American Fact Finder. 2 2000 US Census data-American Fact Finder 3 2000 US Census data-American Fact Finder 4 Preparer’s personal inspection of project site
  • 7. DLM & Associates, LLC. 7 to sell the developed homes for appraised value. East Spencer is considering building 8-18 dwelling units.5 C. The Proposed Financing: To make the purchase of the homes it plans to develop affordable for low-income buyers, East Spencer proposes to provide a special financing program to eligible purchasers. USDA Rural Development Services will provide first mortgages. The product most likely to be used will be the agency’s Payment Assistance Loan, which provides up 80% of the purchase price (provided a buyer can qualify for this amount). The remaining 20% of the sales price, up to a maximum of $20,000, would be provided as a “soft” second mortgage through the North Carolina Housing Finance Agency’s (NCHFA) New Homes Loan Pool (NHLP), which the Town expects to join. These loans are provided at 0%, and payments are deferred until the sale of the house or for 20 years. This NCHFA program requires that buyers invest $750 of their own funds in the purchase. These USDA and NCHFA loan products require that buyers maintain underwriting ratios not exceeding 29%/41%. This means that the monthly mortgage payment cannot be more than 29% of a buyer’s monthly income, and the monthly payment combined with the buyer’s other recurring monthly debts cannot exceed 41% of monthly income. The table below provides a summary of purchase financing for four- person households, consisting of 2 parents and 2 children, @ 50% and 80% AMFI, using the USDA Payment Assistance Loan first mortgage and the NCHFA New Homes Loan Pool second mortgage. 50% AMFI 80% AMFI Annual Income $32,050 $51,300 Monthly Income $2,670 $4,275 Maximum Recurring Monthly Debt $745 $1,200 Sales Price $105,000 $105,000 Buyer Investment $750 $750 Balance of Funds Needed $104,250 $104,250 NCHFA 2nd Mortgage -$20,000 -$20,000 USDA 1st Mortgage $84,200 $84,200 Current USDA Rate 5.25% 5.25% Normal Monthly Principal/Interest Payment $448 $448 Payment Assistance Amount -$198 -0* Actual Monthly Principal/Interest Payment $250 $448 5 The town of East Spencer
  • 8. DLM & Associates, LLC. 8 Monthly Taxes/Insurance Escrow Amount +$100 +$100 Total Actual Monthly Payment $350 $548 Underwriting Ratios 29%/41% 15%/41% 13%/41% *Because of its income this household does not qualify for payment assistance. III. The Expected Buyers: It is believed that the number potential buyers of the proposed homes will be constrained by income, race, and current tenure, as follows: A. Income: This analysis takes a conservative approach and assumes that buyers of the proposed homes will fall within an income range of 51%-80% AMFI. As East Spencer expects to use special federal, state and private financing to fund its redevelopment activity, sale of the homes must be restricted to buyers with incomes not exceeding 80% of Area Median Family Income (AMFI) for Rowan County, based on family size. Homeownership can often be a difficult financial goal for households earning less than 51% AMFI. Although some such households may eventually purchase the proposed homes, and there should be concerted effort to exclude any such eligible households, it is believed prudent for the purposes of this analysis not to consider such households as potential buyers of the proposed homes. It is believed, therefore, that as far as income is concerned, prospective buyers for project homes should be considered to households with income 51%-80% AMFI. Based on family size, such households would have the incomes shown in the table below.6 Family Size Minimum Income Maximum Income 1 $22,450 $35,900 2 $25,650 $41,050 3 $28,850 $46,150 4 $32,050 $51,300 5 $34,600 $55,400 6 $37,200 $59,500 7 $39,750 $63,600 8 $42,300 $67,700 6 The amounts in this table are 2006 HUD income levels. 2007 levels should be released soon and may likely be slightly higher.
  • 9. DLM & Associates, LLC. 9 B. Race: East Spencer will employ an affirmative marketing strategy in an effort to attract potential buyers who might not otherwise be attracted to the project site. Unfortunately, however, East Spencer may have a difficult task in attracting non-minority households, and the pool of eligible buyers for East Spencer’s proposed homes may also be shaped by race. The project is located in a distressed urban community with a minority population of 89% that also experiences low property values, high housing vacancy rates, and poor housing conditions. There are other purchasing opportunities in the same price range in other sections of the likely Effective Market Area that have different racial compositions and fewer distress indicators. There should be no effort to engage in racial discrimination in the sale of the proposed homes. However, it just may be too much to expect that the proposed project can transcend established local settlement patterns. Including non-minority households in the pool of prospective buyers could add for consideration a large number of households that just may not be realistically attracted to the homes, and thereby unrealistically skew the conclusions of this analysis. It is therefore, recommended that for the purposes of this study, that the pool of prospective buyers for the proposed homes be considered to be minority households within the above income range. C. Tenure: It is also believed that current homeowners should be excluded from the pool of prospective buyers. It is believed that such buyers are much less likely to be attracted to the proposed homes. These homes may offer such buyers little improvement in terms of space, ambiance, or amenities, and owners in more established residential areas are probably less likely to purchase in a reviving urban area. Sales in which buyers own existing homes are typically more complicated and require buyers to condition offers and actual purchase on selling their current home. East Spencer may want to avoid such sales. IV. The Effective Market Area: Although East Spencer is a small town with a population of only 1,755, it is located along I-85 in the midst of a larger metropolitan area. Concord, with a population of 63,429, and Kannapolis, with a population of 40,139 lie within a 20-minute drive to the south along I-85, and Charlotte, with a population of 640,270 within a 30-minute drive to the south. Lexington, with a population of 20,918, is located within a 15- minute drive north along I-85, and Winston-Salem, with a population of 198,593, lies within a 30-minute dive north along I-85 and US 52. East Spencer is also part of a smaller contiguous urban metro area which
  • 10. DLM & Associates, LLC. 10 includes the Town of Spencer, with a population of 3,394, and the City of Salisbury, with a population of 29,058, the Town of Granite Quarry, with a population of 2,175, and the small community of Faith, with a population of 695.7 One million people, therefore, reside within what is an easy commuting distance of the project site. It is certainly possible that a household might relocate from one of these other larger municipalities, and purchase a project area home; especially if they had some employment, family, or birth connection to the area. However, this is not believed to be very likely. It is believed that the realistic EMA for the proposed project must be a much smaller area closer to the project site. The entire County of Rowan could be used as the EMA, however, the likelihood of households relocating from the rural areas of a large county to a reviving small town urban setting are also believed to be low, and the entire county, therefore, is considered too large to be the EMA for the project. It is believed that the most logical EMA for the proposed project is the Salisbury urban, metropolitan area, consisting of the municipalities of East Spencer, Spencer, Salisbury, Granite Quarry, and Faith as shown on the map below. 7 2005 municipal population data from the NC Demographics web site of the North Carolina Office of Budget and management Effective Market Area
  • 11. DLM & Associates, LLC. 11 V. Demand/Need for Affordable Housing: This analysis determines that there is a serious demand or need for affordable housing in the EMA. As noted below, a significant number of households are cost burdened, paying more than 30% of income for rent or mortgage payment, and, as a result, a serious housing affordability “mismatch” exists between housing units considered affordable to certain income groups, and the income of many of the households that occupy these units. A. Cost Burdened Households: The US Department of Housing and Urban development (HUD) considers households, paying more than 30% of monthly income for rent or mortgage payments, to be cost burdened and to occupy unaffordable housing. EMA Households Paying More Than 30% of Income for Housing- 20008 EMA Component Household Type Payments >30% Payments >50% # % # % East Spencer Total 290 38% 138 18% Renter 50%-80% AMFI 16 26% 0 0% Owner 50%-80% AMFI 45 35% 4 3% Spencer Total 238 19% 88 7% Renter 50%-80% AMFI 19 12% 0 0% Owner 50%-80% AMFI 40 14% 0 0% Salisbury Total 2,799 27% 1,140 11% Renter 50%-80% AMFI 158 14% 23 2% Owner 50%-80% AMFI 461 21% 88 4% Granite Quarry Total 230 25% 83 9% Renter 50%-80% AMFI 8 19% 4 9% Owner 50%-80% AMFI 54 35% 8 5% Faith Total 73 23% 32 10% Renter 50%-80% AMFI 4 33% 4 33% Owner 50%-80% AMFI 16 29% 8 15% Entire EMA Total 3,630 27% 341 3% Renter 50%-80% AMFI 205 15% 31 2% Owner 50%-80% AMFI 616 22% 108 4% 8 Comprehensive Housing Affordability Strategy data from State of the Cities Data Set web site
  • 12. DLM & Associates, LLC. 12 B. Affordability Mismatch: Competition for housing in an unaffordable housing market often creates an affordability “mismatch”. In such a market, as households compete for housing and attempt to lower their housing costs, higher income households push their way into occupancy of housing units considered affordable to the next lowest income range. Thus many housing units, affordable to households in the 51%-80% AMFI income range, are actually occupied by households with incomes above 80% AMFI. Many households in the 51%-80%, in turn, then push their way into units affordable to the 31%-50% income range, while many households in that income group, in their turn, push their way into units affordable to households in the 0%-30% AMFI range. As can be seen in the table below there is a serious affordability mismatch for households in the 51%-80% income range within the EMA for East Spencer’s proposed homes. Of the 3,996 occupied housing units in the EMA considered affordable to households with income 51%-80% AMFI, less than half, 45%, are actually occupied by low-income households with incomes at or below 80% AMFI. The remaining 55% are occupied by higher income households, who, in an effort to lower their own housing costs, have pushed the 51%-80% AMFI households into even cheaper housing, or forced them to occupy unaffordable housing. The need for affordable homeownership units in the EMA for households with incomes of 51%-80% AMFI, the target income range for East Spencer’s proposed homes, is significant. Of the 2,743 existing homeowner households in this income group within the EMA, 60%, or 1,674 occupy unaffordable housing. Of the 1,253 renter households with incomes 51%-80%, the income range most likely to purchase East Spencer’s proposed homes, 505, or 40%, are occupying unaffordable housing. Many of these might be attracted to a homeownership opportunity that offered an opportunity to obtain more affordable housing. Its is interesting to note, in the table below, that East Spencer has a significantly lower incidence of affordability mismatch than do the other components of the EMA. Perhaps the lower income of East Spencer’s households, compared to the surrounding communities, has held down housing costs. More likely, due to their lower incomes, East Spencer’s households are making greater use of HUD’s Housing Choice vouchers to contain their housing cost at 30%. This may indicate, however, that East Spencer’s proposed homes are more likely to attract buyers from the other components of the EMA than from East Spencer itself, a marketing issue that East Spencer should consider.
  • 13. DLM & Associates, LLC. 13 Affordability Mismatch9 Area # Occupied Units Affordable To Households 51%-80% MHI % Units Actually Occupied by Households <80% MHI # Affordable Units Actually Occupied by Households <80% MHI East Spencer 178 67.9% 121 Rental Units 82 78.8% 65 Owner Units 96 58.3% 56 Spencer 385 33.2% 128 Rental Units 88 60.2% 53 Owner Units 297 25.3% 75 Granite Quarry 309 42% 129 Rental Units 57 35.1% 20 Owner Units 252 43.2% 109 Salisbury 3,002 46.2% 1,387 Rental Units 1,010 60.4% 610 Owner Units 1,992 39% 777 Faith 122 43% 52 Rental Units 16 0% 0 Owner Units 106 43% 52 Total EMA 3,996 45% 1,817 Rental Units 1,253 60% 748 Owner Units 2,743 40% 1,069 VI. The Number of Potential Buyers in the Effective Market Area It has earlier been determined that the most likely buyers of East Spencer’s proposed homes will be minority households with incomes 51%-80% AMFI. As can be seen in the table below, there are 579 minority households in 51%-80% AMFI income range in the EMA; in East Spencer, Spencer, and Salisbury. However, all of these cannot be considered potential buyers. Some are elderly 1-2 person households, unlikely to be attracted to homeownership opportunities. Others may be younger single-person households, not yet ready for homeownership, or larger families needing more than 3 bedrooms. After factoring out such households, there remain 340 minority, renter, family, households in the 51%-80% AMFI income range in the EMA, who may be potential candidates for purchasing the proposed East Spencer homes. 9 All of the figures in this section were obtained from the State of the Cities Data System-Comprehensive Housing Affordability Strategy data
  • 14. DLM & Associates, LLC. 14 Effective Market Area Minority Renter Households With Incomes 51%-80% AMFI10 Area # Households Total 51%- 80% Elderly Other Remaining Potential Family Household Buyers East Spencer 51 -8 -8 35 Spencer 30 -0 -20 10 Granite Quarry 0 -0 -0 0 Salisbury 498 -8 -195 295 Faith 0 -0 -0 0 Total EMA 579 -16 -223 340 Although these 340 households may be potential prospects for purchasing the homes planned by East Spencer, they may not be financially capable of purchasing in the near future. East Spencer should expect that the ability of a significant portion of these households to obtain a mortgage, at the level required to purchase one of the proposed homes during an initial 2-year period, may be constrained by their credit history, or debt load. For example, within the Charlotte Metropolitan Statistical Area in 2005, 23% of all denied home purchase loan applications from minority households were denied due to debt to income ratio, and 42% due to credit history. Of households with incomes 51%- 80% AMFI, 19% of all denied home mortgage applications were denied due to debt to income ratio, and 40% were denied due to credit history.11 The experience of the preparer leads him to a conservative approach to this issue and it is estimated that as many as 50%, or 170, of these households may have serious credit and debt issues that will make them poor candidates for home purchase in the near future. Therefore, it is estimated that there are 170 minority, renter households with incomes 51%-80% MHI within the EMA that could be potential buyers for the proposed homes. VII. Competition and Capture Rate: A. Competition: It appears that the proposed homes could compete well in the residential for-sale market within the EMA. As far as new homes are concerned, 600 were built in Rowan County in 2006 at an average price of $190,00012. Priced at $105,000, the proposed homes would certainly be priced at a point well below the average price of a new home in the general area. 10 State of the Cities Data System-Comprehensive Housing Affordability Strategy data 11 Home Mortgage Disclosure Act information-FFIEC web site 12 US Census Data on Rowan County Building Permits
  • 15. DLM & Associates, LLC. 15 At the time of the preparation of this analysis, there were 14 homes listed for sale in the multiple listing service of the Salisbury/Rowan County Association of Realtors, which with 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, central air and heat, and priced from $90,000-$110,000, were good comparables to the homes proposed by East Spencer. Information about these homes is presented in the table below. These homes were priced from $95,000- $109,000. Those with 1,100-1,200 square feet, similar to East Spencer’s, were priced from $83-$95 per square foot. All but one of those built within the past 6 years were priced at $86-$95 per square foot. With a proposed selling price of $105,000 for 1,100-1,200 square feet of livable area, or $87-$95 per square foot, East Spencer homes fall right into this range and would appear to be competitively priced. Some of these homes do offer potential buyers the opportunity to obtain substantially greater square footage for a similar, and, in some cases, lower price. However, these are typically much older homes. Two homes, in particular, are newly built and with 1,120 square feet are very similar to the proposed East Spencer homes. These are listed for $99,000 and $99,999. It is believed that East Spencer’s proposed homes could compete well in the residential single-family for-sale housing market within the EMA. The homes would be especially competitive if priced at just under $100,000 and under $90 per square feet. Current Listings Residential, Single-Family Listings Salisbury/Rowan County Association of Realtors Multiple Listing Service13 ($90,000-$110,000 with 3 Bedrooms and 2 Bathrooms) # Price Year Built Square Footage Price Per Square Foot 1 99,900 1930 1,555 $64 2 99,999 2006 1,120 $89 3 99,000 2006 1,120 $88 4 109,900 2001 1,160 $95 5 109,900 1885 1,996 $55 6 102,000 1963 1,756 $58 7 99,900 1954 1,420 $70 8 96,000 2001 1,344 $71 9 95,000 2001 1,104 $86 10 99,900 1995 1,400 $71 11 95,900 1943 1,353 $71 12 98,500 1998 1,456 $67 13 101,500 1949 1,713 $59 13 Salisbury/Rowan County Association of Realtors Multiple Service web site
  • 16. DLM & Associates, LLC. 16 14 99,900 1995 1,200 $83 B. Capture Rate: East Spencer proposes to build and sell 8-18 homes over a two and one- half year period. To sell 8 homes, East Spencer would only have to capture 5% of the 170 potential buyers for its proposed homes within the EMA. To sell 18, the Town would only have to capture 11%. This seems reasonable given the market described above. The potential buyers of East Spencer’s product, minority households with incomes of 51%-80% AMFI residing the urban areas of East Spencer, Spencer, and Salisbury, should be attracted to the opportunity to own a new home with a payment of 29% of monthly income, which may be less than they are paying for rent. VIII. Conclusion: It is the determination of this analysis, therefore, that there is reasonable prospect of selling, within two and one-half years, as many as 18 3-bedroom, 2-bath homes for $100,000-$105,000 at the proposed project site. IX. Recommendations: The following recommendations are made to assist the Town of East Spencer and its development partners in planning and marketing the affordable homes it hopes to develop in the Dunbar Renaissance Village Redevelopment Project.  Number of Homes to Develop: Although the local market might be able to absorb 18 new homes at the project site, East Spencer may want to develop its project in phases, with its first phase contain 8 homes. As the market is tested and proves successful, East Spencer can build additional homes.  The Product: To keep building costs and eventual selling prices low to fit the incomes of the potential buyers, and to be competitive, East Spencer is advised to consider building as small a product as reasonable, 1,100- 1,200 square feet, to provide a paved driveway, but to not provide a garage. The product should have a rear deck, central heat and air condition, and since buyers are expected to be apartment dwellers, provide built in stove, refrigerator, and automatic dishwasher.
  • 17. DLM & Associates, LLC. 17  Marketing: Buyers of the proposed homes are most likely to come from the minority populations of East Spencer, Spencer, and Salisbury. East Spencer should, therefore, develop a non-traditional marketing out- reach to identify potential buyers. East Spencer is encouraged to develop an attractive promotional piece with information about proposed homes to attract buyers. The Town should work with minority churches and social services agencies in all three communities to identify prospective buyers. The Town should also conduct quarterly workshops to promote the homeownership opportunity it will provide in Dunbar Renaissance Village. The Town should develop a profile of the buyer its is seeking, in terms of income and debt load and be able to collect information, analyze credit reports and assess a potential buyer’s likelihood of purchasing in 2 years. If buyers show potential, East Spencer must be able to provide intensive credit counseling, debt management advice, and homeownership preparation to ensure that buyers are ready to purchase when homes are available.