School Punishments Are Ineffective And Necessary

School Punishments Are Ineffective And Necessary
Disruptive students trudge down the hallways to the principal's office knowing their fate as soon as they walk through the door. Detentions,
suspensions, or corporal punishment are usually their options and most students hope to decrease their class time when they misbehave and detentions
and suspensions accomplish this. Corporal punishment is the spanking of students which creates fear. School punishments are ineffective and need to be
altered toward counseling techniques between the student committing the offense and the teacher to lower student misconduct.
Background
Controversy takes place when school systems facilitate familiar disciplinary action plans to students and how these punishments may or may not be the
best...show more content...
Teachers need to have all the time they can grasp in order to follow the curriculum for state tests (2016, p. 2) which is why schools feel detentions and
suspensions sometimes take students away from learning and corporal punishments are a quick and effective punishment if allowed by parents. Most
teachers claim "Discipline is necessary to keep children accountable, and to ensure that the few who refuse to follow directions do not unfairly hamper
the chances of others to learn essential skills" (2016, p. 2). Because of this, corporal punishment does not take away from school time, although it is
frowned upon more than detentions and suspensions.
Premises
When schools determine repercussions for both major and minor offenses, they should not be treated in the same manner. Typically, schools hand out
suspensions for miniscule actions students partake in, such as having insubordination with a teacher, or even major offenses such as bringing a weapon
to school. A distinct separation must exist between punishments because the "tough and swift 'one–size–fits–all' punishment has resulted in a near
epidemic of out–of–school suspensions" which reveals ineffectiveness in school punishments (2012, p. 1). Disciplinary actions taken by the school
systems should be geared toward the seriousness of the student's action, not the handbook of the school.
Get more content on HelpWriting.net

Pros And Cons Of Corporal Punishment In Schools
Over the years, schools have been debating whether or not to ban or allow corporal punishment in school. Schools do not know what to do,
considering the 8th Amendment and students and their own children. Corporal Punishment is necessary in schools because it teaches kids not to
get in trouble, teachers would feel empowered and will be listened to more often, and the final reason is that kids' behavior will become better. One
reason why corporal punishment is necessary is because it teaches kids to not get in trouble. Kids are always getting into trouble, and that is
because of either peer pressure, or their parents are not helping them enough at home. Some schools have no corporal punishment, so they just give
them detentions and barely do anything, which is why kids keep getting into trouble. This is what schools are supposed to do. Schools, enforce
stronger discipline on the students but to an extent! Some children in Florida, said that they should get a word of say before they get hit. Basically,
what this means is that two students got into trouble and were supposed to get hit. They wanted to have a say of what happened and tried to console
with them, but the teachers denied. This case went to the Supreme Court, and the statement was that "Students cannot have a word of say before
they get hit." (Ingraham VS Wright). This is understandable because students have a chance to get away before they get hit, which leads them to
become criminals or something that is dangerous to the open world. Not only would it teach kids to not get into trouble, teachers would feel more
powerful and will be listened to more often than usual. Another reason why corporal punishment should be allowed is because teachers would feel
more powerful and have less of a chance of getting stress over yelling at the kids to listen. Kids all over the world don't fully listen to the teachers
who help them(Sifferlin). This causes teachers to get angry and yell at the pupils. Instead of yelling and sending them out of the room, the teachers
should whack their hand to let them know they mean business. This would help teachers because they would have less stress. This helps the world and
the students because the world would be smarter if

Kids Should Have Harsher Punishment For Bullying
I conclude that kids should have harsher punishments for bullying.Bullying is a bad thing it makes people feel insecure about themself,it can
make people commit suicide if the bullying gets bad, and it can also cause more arguments and fights. I get how the people that got bullied feel,
i've been bullied before and it is not a nice feeling. People can get bullied for all kinds of things like what they wear,how they act, and even
sometimes how they look. What's worse is that people get bullied by peers,if people get bullied at school it's bad because they can be taunted every
day. Kids can make other kids feel insecure about themselves, like if they are called fat,ugly,or that they have problems then sometimes they will start
to believe

Pros And Cons Of Corporal Punishment In Schools
The bell rings. Students walk to art class where they are told not to drop the rulers on the floor. One student accidentally drops the ruler, hoping the
teacher will not notice, fearing he will be beaten. However, the teacher sees it and paddles the student five times. The student now has severe bruising
on his bottom just for dropping a ruler. This is not how it should be. Thirty–nine states have banned corporal punishment because it is dangerous in
schools and not a suitable punishment for students(Morin). Corporal Punishment should not be allowed in schools because it promotes violence, it
creates an unsafe environment, and it has a lasting impact on kids. Corporal punishment should not be allowed in schools because it promotes violence.
Many students have been beaten by their teachers for doing something negative in school, and have gotten the message that violence is a good thing.
The American Academy of Pediatrics has stated some examples of this in the article "Should Corporal Punishment Be Used in K–12 Schools".They
explained that "Children who experience corporal punishment are more likely to hit or use violence against people to get their way." (Procon.com)
This example shows that schools that use corporal punishment, teach that it is ok to use violence to get what students want. Students who see or
experience corporal punishment get the message that violence is necessary to get their way. In other words, when those kids are out in the real world,
they can not

Harsh Punishment In School Research
The writers of The Editorial Board for the New York Times have recently published a report based on research from the Council of State Governments
Justice Center, a nonprofit organization that serves policymakers at local, state and federal levels, which reveals that too many students are being
punished in schools for minor offenses. These harsh punishments are due to the zero–tolerance policy in many schools across the nation, and a high
percentage of the students who are being punished based on this policy are Back or Latino. It has been said by the federal civil rights officials that
discipline methods used in schools are discriminatory against minorities. However, these harsh policies are beginning to be reined in by school districts.
The

Why We Shouldn T Be Punished In School
Students shouldn't be punished in school.
The school's rule on punishments in schools and why this rule is unfair because kids don't need to be punished for something they did the punishments
will just keep causing them to do more bad things like engaging in any activity that could be disruptive to the educational process, lying, deception,
forgery, cheating, and possession of or altering officialschool documents, parents' notes, and doctor/dental excuse.
I feel like this rule should be changed because the punishments are too strict, the dates of the punishments, and the amount of days for suspension
because if they have a suspension that the students will just be missing more work and they still won't follow the rules
I think they have this

Corporal Punishment in Schools
Corporal punishment in schools??
Advocates of school corporal punishment argue that it provides an immediate response to indiscipline and that the student is quickly back in the
classroom learning, rather than being suspended from school. Opponents believe that other disciplinary methods are equally or more effective. Some
regard it as tantamount to violence or abuse.
In the United States and the United Kingdom, and generally in the English–speaking world, the use by schools of corporal punishment has historically
been covered by the common law doctrine of in loco parentis, whereby a school has the same rights over a minor as its parent.
In most places nowadays where it is allowed, corporal punishment inpublic schools is governed by...show more content...
It is not democracy which enhances or hinders our growth. Rather it is the approach that we take for our growth with proper utilization of the
democratic machinery which is the real propellant to our overall socio–economic growth. Democracy in good hands would definitely induce growth
but in wrong hands may lead to restrictive growth.
DEMOCRATIC GOVERNANCE IN INDIA– NEW CHALLENGES
Jogamaya Sandhibigraha
Part– II
Roll No. 01
India's status as a shining jewel of democracy in the poor man's world, and the sheer size of its electorate which alone entitles it to the designation of the
world's largest democracy, have earned the country an easy ride among skeptics in the past, despite misgivings about its blemishes. But critical voices
have raised their heads in recent times which in turn gave an open challenge to the democratic governance in the country. Especially after the advent of
new technologies the insignificant issues are much able to challenge the continual process of governance. Among these issues poverty ,unemployment,
corruption ,different kinds of bandhs, dharanas, terrorism, web activism ,degradation of the environment can be cited as the major challenges that are
enough to shatter the very structure of democratic governance in India.
Corruption – a social malady– hold its strong grip over the every human activities ranging from cradle to grave. A recent survey gave the fourth

Essay on Corporal Punishment in Schools
Corporal Punishment
Beat the students! Beat the students! Beat the students! The way most school systems want to discipline their students in the school system, is to beat
them. This is the concept most schools look at corporal punishment. Corporal punishment has been used in school for centuries. Many schools have
limited the use of corporal punishment but most schools continue to use corporal punishment. Corporal punishment is defined as "physical pain
inflicted on the body of a child as a penalty for disapproved behavior." These physical pains schools allow to use on students have become a problem.
These problems consist of physical injuries and lawsuits. Over half of the states in the United States have banned corporal punishment,...show more
content...
The teacher asks John to step into the hall to receive the corporal punishment which is to be paddled three times. John takes the paddling and return to
the classroom. The students in the classroom began to laugh at John and John becomes discourage and will not enjoy the learning environment of the
classroom. If John does not learn, he will continue to misbehave and think of himself unworthy. Corporal punishment has been a negative form of
discipline in recent years.
Hicks–Pass suggests that the majority of the states that have corporal punishment in their schools are the states in the South, the Bible belt. The Bible
belt believes the scripture Proverbs 13:24, whoever spares the rod hates their children, but the one who loves their children is careful to discipline
them. The Bible belt believes in discipline the child through paddling, spanking, switches, or any other form they consider the 'rod' they could use to
beat the child. To link corporal punishment to religious practices is not good if schools cannot link prayer back to schools and the reading of the
National Anthem and leave God out. This design is now full of laws and constitutional rights and also unequal to gender. (Hicks–Pass, 2009) Another
design of corporal punishment is for it to equal and for all students of all races and gender to receive the same punishment. If corporal punishment is
not an equal form of discipline, then it should not be allowed in the school system. When school

Corporal punishment in schools should be abolished
Corporal punishment has been used in schools as a way of handling disciplinary problems. It refers to school rules which allow students to be punished
using physical pain without causing injury. It is believed that using punitive method can promote students' obedience and reduce problematic behaviour.
As a result, it can decrease the number of disciplinary cases and maintain order inside the classroom. Indirectly, it will help to build students' discipline.
Thus, teachers can focus on teaching the students. However, I believe that corporal punishment will bring more harm than benefits. Therefore, the
practice of corporal punishment in schools should be abolished.
The first reason why...show more content...
This is because they will feel humiliated and their reputation among other students will be affected. Most of the students are still in the stage where
their peers' perceptions influence them. They need to feel good about themselves. Other students will perceive those who being punished as
problematic students and they will think twice when they want to approach these problematic students. The situation where they are often being
neglected can affect their self–esteem and confidence. Some of the students will also feel insecure when they are in schools. They will develop
anxiety symptoms because they are too afraid of being punished. The case of my neighbour's son is one fine example. He is too afraid of going to
school as he has witnessed many of his friends being punished by their teacher. He is such a good boy and it is almost impossible to see him
misbehave. However, witnessing his own friends being punished has given a great impact to him. When he is in school, he can't focus in his class
because he's afraid of the teacher. This implies that young children can have some kind of 'traumatic effect' when they observed unpleasant stimulus
being performed. These psychological effects will lead to low achievement among punished students as well as those who witnessed the punishment.
The worst thing that can happen to students is that such aversive punishment will increase students' aggressive behaviour. Using

Essay On Corporal Punishment In Schools
Corporal punishment is the deliberate infliction of pain as retribution for an offence, or for the purpose of disciplining or reforming a wrongdoer, or to
deter attitudes or behaviour deemed unacceptable (Miller, Vandome, & McBrewster, 2009). Corporal punishment can be divided into three
categories, these include: judicial, domestic and school. For the purpose of this essay we will be focusing on school corporal punishment, the advantages
and guidelines to follow when using corporal punishment and the disadvantages and effects on children when child abuse is used in the name of
corporal punishment.
According to Vockell (1991), "Corporal punishment is the infliction of physicalpain, contingent upon the...show more content...
Punishment must be administered soon after the offence. Children tend to forget the reason why they are being punished after a long period of time
has passed, making them believe that they should not be punished. It is also best to specify the behavior being punished.
Educators must administer corporal punishment dispassionately. Teachers tend to spank or hit a child more aggressively because they might not like
the child as a person. Not to mention, teachers should be bother when they are administering corporal punishment to any child.
Administer corporal punishment in front of appropriate witnesses, these witnesses should be regarded as reliable and truthful in case of litigation. And,
corporal punishment should be carried out with appropriate confidentiality, because, what good would it do to humiliate the child.
And finally, make sure you follow all the rules and regulations prescribed by the school system, this is to assure you have the support and an effective
defense, should a legal challenge arise.
But with every advantage there is an equal disadvantage. Most people believe that corporal punishment in schools is not morally acceptance. This is
where the disadvantages occur. According to Vockell (1991), "punishment is not likely to be logically related to the misbehavior" (p. 279). This just
means that the students who are punished for misbehavior not worthy of punishment are victims of artificial punishment. Artificial

If you saw a teacher hitting their student, would you think it was okay or would you disagree? Corporal punishment of any child in school should be
illegal in all states. Corporal punishment in school is causing the student pain in response to undesired behavior. It might involve hitting the student
across the buttocks or the hand with a cane, wooden paddle, slipper, belt, or wooden yardstick (ruler). With corporal punishment you are not promoting
a safe school, you can't sue the teacher who hit your child if the child gets hurt badly, and your also promoting violence into the vulnerable child's life;
you're making a criminal. But, some might care to see that corporal punishment is okay and we can have it.
For instance, when you go to school their motto might be, "We have a safe school"; Jefferson's motto is "Safe, respectful, and
responsible."According to http://www.debate.org/, if there are teachers corporeally punishing the student as a form of discipline, the child will never
feel safe in that school. Students are supposed to go to their teachers for help but if their teacher is beating them the student will never ask for help
and they will struggle in class, possibly causing grades to go down. Some schools also have a moto that includes being healthy. If the child was hit hard
enough to the point where...show more content...
We all don't want to promote a dangerous school, children getting hurt with no charge of the person who did it, and we don't want to promote
violence into one's life. We want to be known as the country that keeps our children safe, but if we are punishing them just for their behavior, we will
no longer be keeping them safe. Lets give The United States of America a good reputation and discipline students in other ways. We will make every
fifty two states have corporal punishment illegal in

For years Corporal Punishment in schools has been a highly debated topic all over the world that deeply divides opinions. Many studies have been
made to determine if corporal punishment encourages good behavior among students to follow the rules set out by the school. However, research has
disproved this form of punishment which is outdated, ineffective, not to mention inhuman. Corporal punishment is defined by the American Academy
of Pediatrics (AAP) as "striking a child with an open hand on the buttocks or extremities with the intention of modifying behavior without causing
physical harm." But in the case where a child of no less than let's say one hundred pounds is being "disciplined" by someone twice their size, how does
that not inflict physical pain!? Usually in schools corporal punishment comes in a form of a wooden or fiberglass paddle; which can result in a great
deal of physical bruising, abrasions, and muscle injuries. A two hundred plus pound male teacher delivering the punishment is absolutely unfair to the
students and only makes abuse more likely.
There are also discriminatory factors when it comes to corporal punishment in schools. Studies have shown that minorities are greatly affected by
corporal punishment. According to the journal Children & Schools, "corporal punishment in schools is most prevalent among boys, low– income
children, and African –American students." In Mississippi, Alabama, and Georgia which hold the highest rating of corporal punishment are also the
three states that have the largest population of African–American students. And what about the students that have a disability such as ADHD, a chronic
condition that makes it difficult for such a student to focus due to the hyperactivity and impulsive behavior of this disorder. According to a mother
interviewed by Time Magazine, her autistic son was "physically punished repeatedly when he was seven years old, noted, "The teacher felt he was
doing some stuff on purpose." I cannot imagine that these children would comprehend the physical force being brought upon by an administrator. What
about the psychological crippling that this form of punishment has on these children? Evidence shows that spanking is bad for kids. Elizabeth

Should Corporal Punishment Be Used In Schools?
Corporal punishment is a form of punishment used on children to correct bad behavior. The definition of corporal punishment is, a physical
punishment , as flogging, inflicted on the body of one convicted of a crime (Dictionary.com). While several states strictly prohibit corporal punishment
in schools, 44% of states in the U.S. still allow it to occur. Corporal punishment is an inappropriate way to correct bad behavior. However, almost 50%
of the states in the U.S. still allow it to occur. Corporal punishment is always wrong to use in schools because it causes long–term negative effects on
students, negative opinions of school or teachers, and it can increase the rate of crime and violence from students.
Corporal punishment is wrong because it causes long–term negative effects on students. If a student receives a paddling as a punishment it could cause
serious problems for that student mentally and physically. One example of this is in an article called Should Corporal Punishment Be Used in K–12
Schools?. It says "frequent use of corporal punishment leads to a higher risk for anxiety, depression, substance abuse, stress, and other mental health".
These would be dangerous for a child's health. In serious cases this could even lead to suicidal thoughts. Not only can corporal punishment affect a
child's mental health, it can also have an affect on their performance in school. Another example from an article says, "Students who experience
corporal punishment in

Rewards And Punishment At School Learning
In order to understand whether rewards and punishment operate as similar factors an experiment was designed. Subjects underwent an auditory task
where they had to mark down answers on an answer sheet. Answers marked down showed that punishment had a greater effect on behavior. Once
analyzed, the results showed that punishment and reward do not have a symmetric law of effect. In fact, giving a punishment had a stronger effect on
behavior than giving a reward. Introduction A staggering twelve years is spent in school learning about a variety of pertinent subjects. Teachers, the
people that work in these learning institutes have used both reward and punishment to guide behavior. For instance, some teachers offer a prize to
whoever gets the highest score on a test. While others choose to take away free time to those who do poorly on a test. All those programs are put in
place with the goal of improving performance. Unfortunately, not all systems are successful. In fact, some are incredibly more effective than others.
Perhaps, the consequences of a behavior dictate the outcomes next time. The question posed by this is, "Do punishment and reward operate as distinct
factors in influencing behavior?" It may seem that gaining something and losing something of the same value has the same effect on behavior.
Surprisingly, that is not the case. Humans tend to be more mindful of being stripped of an object than gaining possession of that object. Completely
encapsulating that thought is

Corporal Punishment in Schools Essay
I wrote this paper for Contemporary Moral Issues class. This was an assignment of our choice and I chose to do this topic, because the week before in
Intro to Education we had discussed discipline methods and I was astonished to learn that corporal punishment still existed in schools. I am hoping that
by including this piece of work on my webfolio others will become aware that corporal punishment is alive and used often in our schools.
In the following paper I will discuss the controversial issue of the use of corporal punishment in schools. Supporters for corporal punishment say that it
is a deterrent to misbehavior and delinquency, is needed to maintain discipline, and is not a...show more content...
Corporal punishment that is administered by an educator is not a form of abuse; however, if someone other than an educator inflicted the same
bruises or injuries it would obviously be abuse. Regardless of where the child is, they never deserve to be punished in such a way, because even the
smallest amount of corporal punishment may lead to ever–lasting negative effects on the child. It should not matter who inflicted the bruises or
injuries, because if it could clearly qualify as abuse then it is abuse, which then supports the argument that corporal punishment is a form of abuse.
The next key argument that I will present against corporal punishment in schools is that it is not administered properly. Corporal punishment is often
administered by several objects and certain students are targeted. The schools are not being consistent with the instruments that are being used, because
in addition to schools using the traditional wooden paddle, a variety of other instruments have been used. These include leather straps, switches,
baseball bats, size 13 cowboy boots, canes, yardsticks, belts, hands, feet, and many other objects. The adult usually hits various parts of the child's body
with the above

The Practice Of Corporal Punishment In Schools
For decades leading back to slavery, corporal punishment has been used as a form of discipline to correct misbehavior on the plantation. In today's
society, it has been used by parents and even incorporated into our schools as a form of punishment. In Kenyan schools it is used as form of classroom
management and to punish children for poor academic performance (Kenyan children suffer frequent beatings by teachers, 1999). Corporal punishment,
according to the Committee on the Rights of the Child, is the use of physical force with the intention to cause some degree of pain or discomfort,
however light. In schools, it mostly involves the use of the hand, a ruler or belt to strike a person across the back or hand. But it can also involve, for
example, shaking, pinching or forcing students to stay in uncomfortable positions (Committee on the Rights of the Child, 2006).
The practice of corporal punishment in schools as a form of discipline is dated back to ancient times (Greven, 1992). In the early civilizations of Egypt
and Babylonia, the practice of physical punishment is related to the severity of the curriculum and atmosphere of schools. Also, it is recorded in history
books, that corporal punishment was used in schools in the Western Judeo–Christian cultures. This is because in the Christian culture, as still been
referred to and practiced today, many still believed in the scripture according to Proverbs 13 verse 24 which states one should not spare the road and
spoil the

Speech On Punishment In School
Imagine this: You are an Indian just sitting there minding your own business, in your own tribe, on your own island, that you and your tribe found
and BAM!! A man sails his boat up the sand on your island. This island that you found first and says without seeing you or anybody else "Men we
own this island now". Then he sees you and forces you and your tribe into these schools. which at this point you might be thinking "OK. So. They got
put into schools that isn't bad I mean I went to school too." The problem isn't them getting put into the schools it is that they were treated the way to
brutally because they got disciplined for pointless things, the punishments were way too violent, and lastly because they couldn't be themselves.
First of all the punishments were pointless. Some people might think " well obviously they had a point to them otherwise why they would they do
it?" But I realized that not many people know why, but that is misleading because someone might think that they are only being good teachers because
they give consequences for the things they did wrong. But here is they they were punished for pointless things, including the fact that they would get
punished for not getting up in time to clean the bathrooms. Like this quote from Iyotte a supervisor from Sherman, a school that was interviewed by
the writer of NPR.com : '"They get demerits if they're not up by 6," Iyotte says. Students get more demerits if they are not up by 6:15 a.m. and even
more if

Importance Of Corporal Punishment In Schools
Corporal punishment should be in schools because it makes sure kids have good behavior, it also teaches kids to be respectful, and makes sure
kids are safe. Every school should have corporal punishment in schools because it teaches kids to have good behavior. In 2014, 94% of parents with
kids from three to four years old reported they had smacked their kid. This shows if a kid is acting up or not being good give him a quick smack and
it should change their perspective on the situation. Corporal punishment should be in schools because if a kid is being bad in class they will most likely
not do it again. They would not be afraid of their teacher either because they are most likely not the one spanking them if they're bad. In many schools
bad behavior could get people detention, Anastasia explained "In 19 states, that behavior could get you spanked". This is a better punishment because
detention does nothing but just make people stay at school for longer, but if they get a spanking they might not want to get in trouble again. Most
people think that kids need to be safe and nurtured but if they aren't getting in trouble than they will have all those things. It also helps the school have
a good learning environment with no distractions during class. Finney says," Detentions are not big enough for some students". This shows how things
can be sorted out better with a couple smacks and to make sure they have better behavior.
Every school should have corporal punishment in schools because it teaches kids to be respectful. In the 2005–2006 school year many students were
acting up in class or doing bad things, and it shows that year having the most reported swats ever. This shows many kids weren't being respectful to
their peers and got in trouble for that, but if they would have gotten detention they wouldn't have cared. When another student gets a detention for
being late or something multiple times they'll have a good laugh about it and carry on with life. They don't care as much but a quick smack and they
won't be laughing about that and they would most likely learn their lesson. Jacobs explained "The principal questioned her and asked to see her purse.
Inside was a pack of cigarettes, rolling paper, and

Punishment And Punishment In Education
One of the basic human functions is to learn, whether it be a specific school subject or a behavior through observation. As one grows up, it is
important to see how he or she was taught to treat people – good, bad, honest, fair? How can violence be eliminated very early on in development? One
form of learning is through punishment. Many times, punishment is used to inform a child or even an adult to not do a certain thing again while
educating them on what is good or bad behavior considering the circumstance. Therefore, punishment is not only a teaching tool, but also a
process that decreases the likelihood reoccurrence of a behavior (Hockenbury, S. E., Nolan, S. A, & Hockenbury, D. H. 2015). As a young child, a
punishment may have included taking away a desired toy or a treat that we wanted to obtain, such as going to the movies or getting McDonalds for
dinner. It is easy to look back and reflect on past experiences of punishment that shaped us into who we are today. However, punishment is not
simply a negative consequence of being a child; it can happen to people of all ages. For example, a punishment can be directed at adults who don't
dress properly or arrive late to work. Punishment can be effective for all age groups because human beings are an imperfect species. It is never too late
to improve one's behavior. Overall, the main purpose of punishment is to stop wrongdoings among all ages from happening repeatedly. When thinking
of punishment regarding psychology,

School Punishments Are Ineffective And Necessary

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (20)

Featured

Featured (20)

School Punishments Are Ineffective And Necessary