SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
Download to read offline
Mental health training of primary
health care workers: case reports
from Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan
Boris Budosan
Evidencesuggeststhat providingsupportto primary
healthcarewithtraining,assistanceandsupervision
by available mental health professionals is the best
way to extend mental health care to the population.
Three cases of mental health training programmes
for primary health care workers were implemented
in di¡erent countries, and are described in this
article.The objective was to share the lessons learnt
in di¡erent settings. Relevant primary and second-
ary data were used to present the cases.The mental
health trainings generally improved the mental
health knowledge of primary health care workers.
Moresustainablechangesintheirmentalhealthcare
practices wereachievedonlyasaresult ofseveralfac-
tors combined together: a) professionally designed
and implemented mental health training; b) motiv-
ation byallkeyplayersto develop community mental
health services; c) political will by the government
followed byformulation of mental health policy pro-
moting integration of mental health into primary
care;d)goodtimingoftheprogramme;ande)in£ux
of funding and professional expertise.The ¢ndings
of this article support the viewpoint of the World
Health Organization that mental health training
for primary health care workers is just one of the
factors necessary for the successful integration of
mental health care into primary health care.
Keywords: mental health, mental health
care services, primary health care, pro-
gramme development, sta¡ development
Introduction
One of the 10 recommendations by World
Health Organization (WHO) on how to
approach the problem of the existing short-
age of mental health care professionals in
many countries around the world, close the
treatment gap and improve mental health
care services, stresses the provision of man-
agement and treatment of mental disorders
in primary health care (World Health
Organization,2001).The integration of men-
tal health care into primary care is a funda-
mental process that enables the largest
number of people to gain faster and easier
access to mental health care services. It is
also helpful in reducing the stigma attached
to mental illness existing in many commu-
nities around the world (World Health
Organization, 2008). The basic component
of this process is the training of primary
health care (PHC) workers in the recog-
nition and management of a range of mental
disorders (World Health Organization,
2001). Appropriate mental health training
needs to be combined with continued super-
vision and support by mental health care
professionals in order to achieve e¡ective
mental health care in primary care settings
(World Health Organization,2008). Accord-
ing to Saxena et al. (2007), training, assist-
ance and supervision of primary health
care services by available mental health care
professionals is a necessary prerequisite for
a successful integration process. It is also
important to emphasise that, although
mental health care investments in primary
care are important, they are unlikely to be
Boris Budosan
125
sustained unless they are preceded and/or
accompanied by the simultaneous develop-
ment of community mental health care
services (Saraceno et al., 2007).
Many studies have evaluated the e¡ective-
ness of mental health care training for
various groups of bene¢ciaries (residents,
general practitioners, nurses, etc.) in di¡er-
ent countries. (Cohen, 2001; Harding et al.,
1983; Hodges, Inch, & Silver, 2001; Hodgins
etal.,2007; Kroenke etal.,2000; Lum, Kwok
& Chong,2008;World Health Organization,
2008). In general, a large majority of such
training were successful in improving diag-
nostic accuracy (i.e. diagnostic speci¢city)
and sensitivity of trainees, as well as their
attitudes towards mental health issues, but
was also found to be less successful in chan-
ging their actual clinical practices and
patientoutcomes, especially inthe long-term
(Kroenke et al., 2000, Cohen, 2001).
This article describes how opportunities,
initially provided by relief e¡orts after the
2004 tsunami in Sri Lanka, the 2005 earth-
quake in Pakistan, and the 2003 war in Iraq,
were used to deliver mental health care
training for PHC workers in two districts
of Sri Lanka, one district in Pakistan and
the eastern part of the city of Amman, in
Jordan. The objective of the paper was to
assess the e¡ectiveness of training inter-
ventions, and to share the lessons learnt in
di¡erent settings. According to Saraceno
et al. (2007), professional understanding of
the e¡ects of disasters, paired with post
emergency mental health care interest
(including media and politicians), can
provide enormous opportunities for the
development of mental health care systems.
Mental health training programmes of
primary health care workers in all targeted
areaswere implementedby the international
nongovernmental organisation (INGO),
International Medical Corps (IMC), in a
close collaboration with the Ministries
of Health of the countries, WHO local
representative o⁄ces, local psychiatric
colleagues, PHC workers and local and
provincial health authorities.
Context
In Sri Lanka, mental healthcaretrainings of
primaryhealthcareworkers were conducted
in two administrative areas called districts,
both hit hard in the 2004 Tsunami natural
disaster, which killed about 40,000 people
in Sri Lanka, speci¢cally the district of
Kalmunai in the north-east of the country,
with a population of 401,534 (Deputy Pro-
vincial Directorate of Health Services
(DPDHS) Kalmunai, 2003), and the district
of Hambantota in the South, with the esti-
mated population of 525,370 people (World
Health Organization, 2005). In Pakistan,
mental health care training of PHC workers
was conducted in the district of Mansehra,
intheNorth-WestFrontierProvince(NWFP),
with a population of 1,152,839 people (1998
census), that was hit hard by the 2005 earth-
quake that killed around 80,000 people in
Pakistan. In Jordan, mental health training
of PHC workers was conducted in Eastern
Amman, which hosted many Iraqi refugees
after the 2003 Iraqi war, with an estimated
population of 149,775 people. In all targeted
areas, except the Hambantota district in
Sri Lanka, the population consisted of
di¡erent ethnic groups; Tamils and Muslims
in Kalmunai, Pashto and Urdu speaking
populations in Mansehra, and Jordanian
and Iraqi populations in Eastern Amman.
All targeted areas were economically poor
compared to the national standards of
Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan.
Mental health care services in targeted areas
Only two physicians, with the title of
Medical O⁄cers of Mental Health,
Mental health training of primary health care workers: case reports from Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan
Intervention 2011, Volume 9, Number 2, Page 125 - 136
126
provided mental health care services, in
both the Kalmunai and Hambantota dis-
tricts in Sri Lanka. They were basically
general practitioners with three-month
additional postgraduate mental health
training. Both districts had only visiting psy-
chiatrists, who used to perform psychiatric
consultations in the districts, once or twice
a month. The district general hospitals had
no separate wards and/or departments to
treat mental health patients. Only two psy-
chiatrists and one mental health hospital,
in the town of Mansehra, provided mental
health services in the Mansehra district in
Pakistan. In Jordan, people from Eastern
Amman had to seek mental health services
either from private psychiatrists (with a fee
charged for service), or from the (350 bed)
public mental health hospital in Amman,
with long waiting lists and a shortage of
medications. It is also worth mentioning
that at the time of this project, there were
no psychiatric wards in Jordanian general
hospitals.
Methods
First, secondary data from the relevant men-
tal health literature were collected. Basic
psychiatric epidemiological data and data
on mental health resources for all three
countries (Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan)
were obtained from the WHO Mental
Health Atlas project (WHO, Department
of Mental Health and Substance Abuse,
2005). Local mental health care studies, pub-
lished in various national and international
journals, were the additional source of infor-
mation on mental health needs and services,
as well as on speci¢c mental health issues,
(e.g. high suicide rates in Sri Lanka, high
rate of depression in women in Pakistan,
and the link between violence and mental
health in Iraqi refugees in Jordan). The fol-
lowing literature was reviewed: Sri Lanka
(de Silva, 2002; Mendis, 2004; Eddleston,
et al., 1998); Pakistan (Ahmer, et al., 2006;
Husain, et al., 2007; Karim, et al., 2004;
Mubbashar & Saeed, 2001; Mumford et al.,
1996; Mumford et al.,1997; Mumford et al.,
2000); and Jordan (Al-Haddad et al., 1999;
Daradkeh et al., 2006; Takriti, 2004).
Primary data on mental health care needs
and services were collected only in those
areas of thetargetedcountries, wheremental
health training of primary health care
workers was implemented. Both qualitative
and quantitative data collection methods
were used. Qualitative data collection
methods included open ended, semi-struc-
tured key informant interviews, structured
focus groups and unstructured participant
observation. These were also used for ¢eld
assessment purposes and focus groups were
used for the evaluation of satisfaction with
the training. Observation was used for the
evaluation of the mental health skills of the
PHC workers.
Quantitative data collection methods
included 30-item multiple choice knowledge
tests for PHC doctors, and 15-item multiple
choice knowledge test for PHC mid-level
workers. They were used to evaluate theo-
retical mental health care knowledge of
participants, before, and after the training.
The construct validity of all study instru-
ments was determined by: a) the profes-
sional judgment of local and international
experts; b) the available evidence on the use
of similar instruments in similar situations;
and c) general recommendations in the
literature on questionnaire design (Fathala,
2004). An on-the-job training competency
checklist (Table 1) was used immediately at
the end of comprehensive training (theoreti-
calandon-the-job), in order to evaluate prac-
tical skills of the PHC doctors, in regard to
their detection rate, diagnostic accuracy
and treatment of mental health problems in
Boris Budosan
127
Table1.On-the-jobtrainingcompetencychecklist
TaskorusageofskillDemonstrationoftaskorusageofskill
GoodFairPoor
1Takingrelevanthistoryofpatientspresentingcomplaints
2Takingrelevantmedicalhistory
3Takingrelevantpsychiatrichistory
4Demonstratinggoodcommunicationskillswithpatient
5Makingcorrectpsychiatricdiagnosis
6Takingappropriatedecisionsregardingmedicationand
treatment
7Ifprescribing,givecorrectadviceandinformation
aboutmedications
8Recordingdatacorrectly
9Providingclearinstructionsandexplanationsto
patientabouthis/herproblem
10Spendingsu⁄cienttimewitheachpatient
Mental health training of primary health care workers: case reports from Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan
Intervention 2011, Volume 9, Number 2, Page 125 - 136
128
general practice.The statistical index, Cron-
bach alfa, was used to measure the degree
of internal consistency of knowledge tests
(Wells & Wollack, 2003), and it was 0.84
(Cronbach’s alpha is a coe⁄cient of reliabi-
lity, and is commonly used as a measure
of the internal consistency or reliability of a
test score, a Cronbach’s alfa of at least 0.7 is
required before the instrument could be
considered reliable enough for testing).
The mental health training manuals used
were developed for each training separately,
and they included several core elements
that should shape the development and
implementation of training curricula (Wein
et al., 2002):
1) competence in listening and other com-
munication skills;
2) training in properly recognising mental
health problems within a community;
3) teachingestablishedmentalhealthinter-
ventions;
4) providing strategies for problem solving;
5) training in the treatment of medically
unexplained somatic pain; and
6) learning to collaborate with existing
local resources, e.g. indigenous healers
(practitioners of alternative medicine),
who are often the ¢rst point of contact
for mental health problems in many
developing countries (Budosan & Aziz,
2009; Budosan et al., 2007).
Results
Sri Lanka (Kalmunai and Hambantota districts)
The analysis of qualitative data from the
interviews with mental health professionals,
and focus groups with the PHC doctors,
identi¢ed several important issues. The
majority of interviewed participants in both
districts agreed on following: a) there was
a signi¢cant gap between mental health
needs and services; b) a signi¢cant number
of mental health care issues were dealt with
through traditional healers; and c) improve-
ment of availability, accessibility and a¡ord-
ability of mental health care services was
considered as necessary to improve the over-
all mental health of the population. The
observation of practices of the PHC workers
identi¢ed a lack of skills in the recognition
and treatment of mental health problems.
The mental health training in Kalmunai
was conducted from April to October 2005,
andin Hambanotota from AugusttoJanuary
2006. Both trainings were designed with
local mental health care professionals and
the PHC workers, and received institutional,
ethical clearance from both local and gov-
ernmental health authorities. Consent of
the participants was obtained either through
direct communication, or through the
responsible health authorities. A combi-
nation of theoretical and practical (on-the-
job) training was identi¢edasthebest model
to deliver the training. Five 2-day workshops
(held monthly), or 50 hours of comprehen-
sive theoretical training, and (on average)
3.7 on-the job training sessions per partici-
pant, supervised by either local and/or inter-
national psychiatrists, were delivered to the
PHC doctors in Kalmunai during a six
month period. Seven 2-day workshops, or
70 hours of comprehensive theoretical train-
ing, and (on average) 7.7 on-the-job training
sessions per participant were delivered to
PHC doctors in Hambantota, also over a
6 month period. Twelve hours of intensive
theoretical training were delivered to mid-
level public PHC workers (mid-level sta¡
involved in health promotion and pre-
vention) during a 3 month period. Fifteen
percent of primary health care doctors, and
almost 100% of mid-level public PHC
workers in Kalmunai, as well as 23%
primary health care doctors and almost
100% mid-level public PHC sta¡ in
Boris Budosan
129
Hambantota, received this training. The
success of the theoretical part of the training
was measured by the pre/post knowledge
test, only in the Hambantota district
(Table 2).
On-the-job training improved the practical
skills of the PHC doctors, which were
virtually nonexistent before the training
intervention (Table 2). On average, 72% of
the participants in Kalmunai, and 79% in
Hambantota, expressed their satisfaction
with di¡erent aspects of the delivered train-
ing (Budosan & Jones, 2009).
Pakistan (Mansehra district)
The gaps between mental health care needs
and services, the stigma attached to mental
health problems, the important role of
traditional healing systems in dealing with
mental health problems, and the need for a
mental health training of PHC workers were
identi¢ed as the most important issues in
boththe focus groups withthe PHC workers,
and in interviews with key informants
(Budosan & Aziz, 2009). Both a lack of men-
tal health care knowledge/skills by the
PHC doctors, and poor involvement of the
PHC mid-level workers in the management
of mental health care problems, was
observed during patient encounters. The
mental health training in Mansehra was
conducted from May to August 2006. Both
local and district health authorities author-
ised this training, and when informed by
district and local health authorities, the
PHC workers gave their consent to partici-
pate. Twenty-¢ve hours of comprehensive,
theoretical mental health care training
were delivered to Mansehra PHC doctors,
and 18 hours to Mansehra PHC mid-level
workers (named Lady HealthVisitors), during
a 3 month period. Sixteen half-day, weekly
mental health care training sessions were
delivered to nongovernmental organisation
(NGO) workers helping the earthquake-
a¡ected population. Seventy-one percent of
the Mansehra government based primary
health care doctors, and 50% of Mansehra
government based PHC mid-level workers,
received basic mental health care training,
in order to begin to integrate mental health
into their practices.There was no evaluation
of the success of this training (which was
only theoretical) by knowledge testing, but
on average, more than 80% of training
participants expressed satisfaction with the
training (Table 2).
Jordan (eastern Amman)
The analysis of qualitative data from the
interviews with mental health care pro-
fessionals and focus groups with the PHC
doctors, concluded that the provision of
equitable, comprehensive and a¡ordable
mental health care services, a multi-disci-
plinary approach to mental health care,
and community education on mental health
issues were the best ways to improve mental
health care. Observation of patient encoun-
ters in the PHC clinic run by the Jordanian
Red Crescent in Eastern Amman revealed
that the PHC workers did not have either
the time or adequate knowledge/skills to
properly address mental health issues within
primary care. InJordan, mental health care
training of the PHC workers was conducted
for 30 primary health care doctors, working
for three local NGOs (Jordanian Red
Crescent, Caritas and Jordanian Health
Aid Society), helping Iraqi refugees and
the poor population of Jordan.This training
was conducted in the period from April to
August 2008. The Ministry of Health in
Jordan gave an ethical clearance for the
training, and the PHC workers of three of
the above mentioned NGOs agreed to parti-
cipate.Twelve weekly sessions, or 60 hours of
comprehensive theoretical mental health
Mental health training of primary health care workers: case reports from Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan
Intervention 2011, Volume 9, Number 2, Page 125 - 136
130
Table2.Resultsofmentalhealthtrainingsintargetedareas
Country(area)
Mentalhealthknowledge
(percentageofcorrect
answers)
Mentalhealthskills
(percentageofdoctorswith
goodusageofmentalskills)
Satisfactionwith
training
Kalmunaidistrict(SriLanka)NodatacollectedPractically0%before
training
Onaverage72%satis¢edwith
di¡erentaspectsoftraining
77%afterthetraining
Hambantotadistrict(SriLanka)Pretest64%Practically0%before
training
Onaverage79%satis¢edwith
di¡erentaspectsoftraining
Posttest81%(medicaldoctors)
(t¼10.88,p<0.05)
85%aftertraining
Pretest54.6%
Posttest66.6%(mid-levelsta¡)
(t¼17.2,p<0.05)
Mansehradistrict(NWFP,Pakistan)NodatacollectedNodatacollectedOnaveragemorethan80%
satis¢edwithtraining
EasternAmman(Jordan)Pretest55%DatapendingDatapending
Posttest80%(medicaldoctors)
(t¼11.77,p<0.01)
Boris Budosan
131
training, were delivered. The success of the
training was evaluated with pre/post know-
ledge test (Table 2).
Discussion
The evaluation of training results clearly
shows improvements of the theoretical
mental health knowledge (Sri Lanka and
Jordan), satisfaction of the great majority
of participants with the training (Sri Lanka
and Pakistan), and improved mental health
care skills of the PHC doctors (Sri Lanka).
In Sri Lanka, the mental health care train-
ing programme also improved the actual
mental health clinical practices of the PHC
workers, and served as a catalyst for the
further development of community mental
health care services, which are likely to be
sustainable in the long term (Budosan &
Jones, 2009). Until now,13 outpatient mental
health clinics, operated by trained PHC
sta¡, from once aweekto once amonth, were
opened in all health administrative areas of
the Kalmunai district. Three PHC doctors,
with one year postgraduate training in men-
tal health, as well as a multi-disciplinary
team consisting of psychiatric social worker,
nurse and occupational therapist, were
appointed to that district in the north east
of Sri Lanka. Four new mental healthclinics,
operated by trained PHC sta¡, have now
opened in Hambantota, during the mental
health training period. The number of
detected and properly diagnosed mental
health patients, who also received treat-
ment in primary health care, increased
in all health administrative areas in both
districts (Budosan & Jones, 2009). On-the
job training of the PHC doctors in Jordan
¢nished only recently, so there are still no
evaluation data on that part of the mental
health training, or on the satisfaction
with the Jordan training in general. So far,
this training was successful in increasing
detection rates, diagnostic accuracy, and
the number of referrals of mental health
cases to psychiatrists. In 2008 and 2009,
it also expanded to two more areas in
Jordan (Dr. Jacob Joseph Panikulam, IMC
Mental Health Coordinator, Jordan,
personal communication).
However, the lack of political will, separate
budget allocations for mental health care,
the lack of a formulation of a mental health
policy promoting integration of mental
health care into primary care, and the lack
of development of community mental health
services remain obstacles to sustainable
change in the mental health care practices
of the PHC practitioners.
Although mental health care policy promot-
ing integration of mental health into the
primary care had been formulated in
Pakistan in 1997, so far the major challenge
in this country has been poor implementa-
tion of this policy by trained PHC workers.
According to a personal communication
from Prof. Dr. Saeed Farooq, psychiatrist
from Lady Reading Hospital in Peshawar
(2008), two years after the implemented
training in Mansehra, trained PHC doctors
were still only detecting and referring cases
of severe mental disorders to psychiatrists,
at the same time providing only minimal
treatment forboth common and severe men-
tal health problems in their own practices.
Lack of mental health research in Pakistan
prevents making any de¢nitive conclusions
in regard to the longer term outcome of this
training, and the integration of mental
health into primary health care in general
(Mubbashar & Saeed, 2001).
The strength of the mental health training
programme in Sri Lanka, compared to
training programmes in Pakistan and
Jordan (so far), appears to be the result of
several factors combined: a) the politicalwill
of the government of Sri Lanka (Ministry
Mental health training of primary health care workers: case reports from Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan
Intervention 2011, Volume 9, Number 2, Page 125 - 136
132
of Health) to develop community mental
health care services (Saraceno et al., 2007);
b) the formulation of a Sri Lankan mental
health care policy promoting the integration
of mental health into primary health care
(Democratic Socialist Republic of Sri
Lanka, 2005); c) commitment of the PHC
and mental health professionals to imple-
ment the policy; d) professionally designed
mental health trainings, with both theoreti-
cal and on-the-job training components, in
tune with the IASC Guidelines being devel-
oped at that time (Inter-Agency Standing
Committee, 2007); e) good timing of the
programme (right after a major disaster),
which resulted in an in£ux of international
funding and expertise; and f) cohesive work
of all the major stakeholders (government,
WHO, local health authorities, local and
international mental health professionals
and local PHC workers).
According to Hodges et al. (2001), all
described here mental health care training
programmes described here met three
importantrequirementsforthee¡ectiveness
of an educational intervention: 1) duration
of the intervention (training interventions
were ongoing longitudinal educational
interventions); 2) the degree of active
participation of the learners (training inter-
ventions were interactive, using participa-
tory teaching methodology); and 3) the
degree of integration of the new knowledge
into the learner’s clinical context (location
of training interventions were held in pre-
existing primary care settings). Mental
health trainings also followed consensus
based guidelines for international training
in mental health care, as established by the
task force of the International Society for
Traumatic Stress Studies (Wein, 2002).
During training, an open dialogue was pro-
moted between trainers, training partici-
pants, and other key mental health players
(i.e. the Ministries of Health, local WHO
representative o⁄ces, and other local and
international organisations working on
mental health issues).This approach helped
to integrate di¡erent perspectives and atti-
tudes on mental healthwithinthe countries.
Training sessions were culturally sensitive,
and appropriate for the context, which was
especially important for on-the-jobtraining
involving mental health patients.The con¢-
dentiality of patients’data was of the utmost
importance; data were shared only with
health professionals directly involved in
training. The patients’ wishes as to whether
to provide, or not to provide, certain infor-
mation were respected.
Conclusion
Case reports on mental health trainings of
the PHC workers in three di¡erent settings
suggest that sustainable changes in their
mental health care practices canbe achieved
only as a result of a several e¡orts combined
(see the example of Sri Lanka above).
Political will of the government, followed
by formulationof mental healthcare policies
in the country promoting the integration of
mental health into primary care, in£ux of
funding and professional expertise, motiv-
ation of the PHC workers and mental health
care professionals to develop community
mental health services, and professionally
designed and implemented mental health
care training of the PHC workers, including
on-the-job training supervised by psychia-
trists, are all important for the success of
such an e¡ort. However, the results pre-
sented in this paper cannot be considered
as conclusive, because all the data from the
mental healthcaretraining inJordanare still
not available. A future comprehensive evalu-
ation of mental health training in Jordan is
recommended to complement the results
presented here.
Boris Budosan
133
Acknowledgements
The author would like to thank Dr. Lynne
Jones for initiating the training model described
in this paper, and Dr. Farooq A.L., Dr. Nowfel,
M.J., Dr. Joe Asare, Dr. Sabah Aziz, Dr. Joseph
Panikulam and Dr. Raghad Ali for implement-
ing the training programmes in Sri Lanka,
Pakistan and Jordan. Also, my thanks to the
following donors for providing funding under
various grants; SV-Netherlands Refugee
Foundation (projects in Sri Lanka), DFID,
AusAid and SV (project in Pakistan), and
UNHCR and BPRM (project in Jordan).
I would also like to thank the WHO Depart-
ment of Mental Health and Substance Abuse,
Dr. Harischandra Gambheera, President of
Sri Lankan College of Psychiatrists, Prof. Dr.
Saeed Farooq, Lady Reading Hospital in
Peshawar, Pakistan and Prof. Abdul Monaf
Al-Jadiry, chief psychiatrist at the University
of Jordan, for their help and support during the
design and implementation of the trainings, and
the international and national staff of the Inter-
national Medical Corps in Sri Lanka, Pakistan
and Jordan for help in administering the pro-
gramme, and Heidi Gillis from IMC Washing-
ton, DC office for her help in proofreading and
finalising this article.
REFERENCES
Ahmer, S., Naqvy, H., Karman Khan, M., Siddi-
qui, N. & Moosa Khan, M. (2006). Psychologi-
cal morbidity among primary care attendees
in earthquake a¡ected areas of Pakistan.
Journal of Pakistani Psychiatric Association, 3(2).
Al-Haddad, M. K., Al-Garf, A., Al-Jowder, S. &
Al-Zurba, F. I. (1999). Psychiatric morbidity
in primary care. Eastern Mediterranean Health
Journal, 5(1), 20-26.
Budosan, B. & Aziz, S. (2009). A mixed methods
¢eld based assessment to design a mental
health intervention after the 2005 earthquake
in Mansehra, North-West Frontier Province,
Pakistan. Intervention, 7(3).
Budosan, B., Jones, L.,Wickramasinghe,W. A. L.,
Farook, A. L., Edirisooriya,V., Abeywardena,
G. & Nowfel, M. J. (2007). AftertheWave: APi-
lot Project to Develop Mental Health Services
in Ampara District, Sri Lanka Post-Tsunami.
Journal of Humanitarian Assistance, published
on September 16, 2007. Available online:
http://jha.ac.
Budosan, B. & Jones, L. (2009). Evaluation of
e¡ectiveness of mental health training
program for primary health care sta¡ in
Hambantota district, Sri Lanka, post-
tsunami. Journal of Humanitarian Assistance,
published May 1st, 2009. Available online:
http://jha.ac.
Cohen, A. (2001).Thee¡ectivenessofmentalhealth ser-
vices in primary care: the view from the developing
world. Publication WHO/MSD/MPS/01.1.
Department of Mental Health and Substance
Dependence,WHO, Geneva, Switzerland.
Daradkeh,T. K., Alawan, A., Al Ma’aitah, R. &
Otoom, S. A. (2006). Psychiatric morbidity
and its sociodemographic correlate among
women in Irbid, Jordan. Eastern Mediterranean
HealthJournal, 12 (Supplement 2).
Democratic Socialist Republic of Sri Lanka
(2005). National mental health policy, Colombo, Sri
Lanka: Government of Sri Lanka, 2005. Available
online: http://www.searo.who.int/LinkFiles/
On-going_projects_mhp-slr.pdf.
de Silva, D. (2002). Psychiatric service delivery in
anAsiancountry:theexperience ofSriLanka.
International Review of Psychiatry, 14,66-70.
Deputy Provincial Directorate of Health Services
(DPDHS), Kalmunai (2003). District health
sector pro¢le-Kalmunai 2003. Deputy Provincial
Directorate of Health Services: Kalmunai,
Sri Lanka.
Mental health training of primary health care workers: case reports from Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan
Intervention 2011, Volume 9, Number 2, Page 125 - 136
134
Eddleston, M., Rezvi Sheri¡, M. H. & Hawton,
K. (1998). Deliberate self harm in Sri Lanka:
anoverlookedtragedyinthedevelopingworld.
British MedicalJournal, 317,133-135.
Fathalla, M. F. (2004). A practical guide for health
researchers. WHO Regional Publications East-
ern Mediterranean Series 30. World Health
Organization. Available online: www.whqlib
doc.who.int/emro/2004/9290213639.pdf.
Harding, W. T., Busnello, E., Climent, C., El-
Hakim, A., Giel, R., Ibrahim, H. H. A.,
Lourdes, L. I. & Narendra, N. W. (1983). The
WHO Collaborative Study on Strategies for
Extending Mental Health Care, III: Evalua-
tive Design and Illustrative results. American
Journal of Psychiatry, 140,1481-1485.
Hodges, B., Inch,C. &Silver, I. (2001).Improving
the psychiatricknowledge, skills, andattitudes
of primary care physicians, 1995^2000: A
Review. AmericanJournal of Psychiatry, 158,10.
Hodgins,G., Judd,F., Davis,J.&Fahey,A.(2007).
An integrated approach to general mental
health training: the importance of context.
Australas Psychiatry, 15(1), 52-57.
Husain, N., Chaudry, I. B., Afridi, M. A., Tomen-
son, B. & Creed, F. (2007). Life stress and
depression in a tribal area of Pakistan. The
BritishJournal of Psychiatry, 190,36-41.
Inter-Agency Standing Committee (2007). IASC
Guidelines on Mental Health and Psychosocial
Support in Emergency Settings. Geneva: IASC.
Available online: http://icn.ch/IASC_MHPSS_
guidelines.pdf.
Karim, S., Saeed, K., Rana, M. H., Mubasshar,
M. H. & Jenkins, R. (2004). Pakistan mental
health country pro¢le. International Review of
Psychiatry, 16(1),83-92.
Kroenke, K.,Taylor-Vaisey, A., Dietrich, J. A. &
Oxman, T. (2000). Interventions to improve
provider diagnosis and treatment of mental
disorders in primary care. Psychosomatics, 41:1,
Jan^Feb 2000.
Lum, A.W., Kwok, K.W. & Chong, S. A. (2008).
Providing integrated mental health services
in the Singapore primary care setting ^ the
general practitioner psychiatric program
experience. Annals of Academic Medicine Singa-
pore, 37(2),128-131.
Mendis, N. (2004) Mental health services in Sri
Lanka. International Psychiatry, 3,10-12.
Mubbashar, M. H. & Saeed, K. (2001). Develop-
ment of mental health services in Pakistan.
Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal, 7(3), 392-
396.
Mumford, D. B., Nazir, M., Jilani, F. U. & Baig, I.
Y. (1996). Stress and psychiatric disorder in
the Hindu Kush: a community survey of
mountain villages in Chitral, Pakistan. The
BritishJournal of Psychiatry, 168, 299-307.
Mumford, D. B., Saeed, K., Ahmad, S. &
Mubbashar, M. H. (1997). Stress and psychia-
tric disorder in rural Punjab. A community
survey. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 170,
473-478.
Mumford, D. B., Fareed, A. F., Imtiaz, A.,
Akhteer, S. & Mubbashar, M. H. (2000). Stress
andpsychiatric disorder inurban Rawalpindi.
The BritishJournal of Psychiatry, 177, 557-662.
Saraceno, B., Ommeren, M., Batniji, R., Cohen,
A., Gureje, O., Mahoney, J., Sridhar, D. &
Underhill, C. (2007). Barriers to improvement
of mental health services in low-income and
middle-income countries. Lancet, 370, 1164-
1174.
Boris Budosan
135
Saxena,S., Thornicroft,G., Knapp,M.&White-
ford, H. (2007). Resources for mental health:
scarcity, inequity and ine⁄ciency. Lancet, 370,
878-889.
Takriti A. (2004). Psychiatry in Jordan. Inter-
national psychiatry, Issue 5, July 2004.
Wein, S., Danieli,Y., Silove, D., Ommeren,V. M.,
Fairbank, J. & Saul, J. (2002). Guidelines for
international training in mental health and
psychosocialinterventionsfortraumaexposed
populations in clinical and community set-
tings. Psychiatry 65(2).
Wells, S. C. & Wollack, J. A. (2003). An instructor’s
guide to understanding test reliability. Testing &
Evaluation Services publication, University
of Wisconsin. RetrievedJanuary 4,2006 from:
www.wiscinfo.doit.wisc.edu/exams/Reliability.
pdf.
WHO Department of Mental Health and
Substance Abuse (2005). Mental health atlas
2005, Geneva, Switzerland: WHO. Available
online:http://www.who.int/globalatlas/default.
asp.
World Health Organization (2001). The world
health report 2001. Geneva, Switzerland:WHO.
World Health Organization (2005). Health systems
in Tsunami a¡ected areas in Sri Lanka. On CD-
ROM. WHO, PO Box 780, 226 Bauddhaloka
Mawatha, Colombo 7, Sri Lanka.
WorldHealthOrganization(2008).Integratingmen-
tal health into primary care: A global perspective.
Geneva, Switzerland:WHO.
Dr. Boris Budosan, Ms.sci., M.P.H., psychia-
trist (corresponding author), Mental Health
Advisor for Cordaid, former Mental Health
Coordinator for International Medical Corps
in Sri Lanka and Pakistan and former Roving
Mental Health Advisor for International
Medical Corps in the Middle East, Vocarsko
Naselje 22, 10000 Zagreb, Croatia.
Tel: +385123 20 298;
email: bbudosan@yahoo.com
Mental health training of primary health care workers: case reports from Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan
Intervention 2011, Volume 9, Number 2, Page 125 - 136
136

More Related Content

What's hot

Out of Pocket Expenditure on Non-Communicable Diseases among Households: Evid...
Out of Pocket Expenditure on Non-Communicable Diseases among Households: Evid...Out of Pocket Expenditure on Non-Communicable Diseases among Households: Evid...
Out of Pocket Expenditure on Non-Communicable Diseases among Households: Evid...Premier Publishers
 
Basic health issues and role of private healthcare System in Pakistan
Basic health issues  and role of private healthcare System in PakistanBasic health issues  and role of private healthcare System in Pakistan
Basic health issues and role of private healthcare System in PakistanDr Abdul Ghafoor
 
Συχνότερα χρόνια νοσήματα, καταστάσεις υγείας, συχνότερα συμπτώματα στην κοιν...
Συχνότερα χρόνια νοσήματα, καταστάσεις υγείας, συχνότερα συμπτώματα στην κοιν...Συχνότερα χρόνια νοσήματα, καταστάσεις υγείας, συχνότερα συμπτώματα στην κοιν...
Συχνότερα χρόνια νοσήματα, καταστάσεις υγείας, συχνότερα συμπτώματα στην κοιν...Evangelos Fragkoulis
 
Epidemiological studies in psychiatry in India
Epidemiological studies in psychiatry in IndiaEpidemiological studies in psychiatry in India
Epidemiological studies in psychiatry in IndiaSujit Kumar Kar
 
Prevalence and predictors of mental health among farmworkers in Southeastern ...
Prevalence and predictors of mental health among farmworkers in Southeastern ...Prevalence and predictors of mental health among farmworkers in Southeastern ...
Prevalence and predictors of mental health among farmworkers in Southeastern ...Agriculture Journal IJOEAR
 
community health nursing
community health nursingcommunity health nursing
community health nursingArun Kumar
 
Challenges in Indian Healthcare Sector
Challenges in Indian Healthcare SectorChallenges in Indian Healthcare Sector
Challenges in Indian Healthcare SectorPrashant Mehta
 
National health policy
National health policyNational health policy
National health policyRinkupatel55
 
healthcare delivery system
healthcare delivery systemhealthcare delivery system
healthcare delivery systemNisha Yadav
 
3.1_Whitepaper_IndiaHealthReport (Indicus Analytics-A Nielsen Company)
3.1_Whitepaper_IndiaHealthReport (Indicus Analytics-A Nielsen Company)3.1_Whitepaper_IndiaHealthReport (Indicus Analytics-A Nielsen Company)
3.1_Whitepaper_IndiaHealthReport (Indicus Analytics-A Nielsen Company)Ankur Gupta
 
Factors Associated with Anemia among Pregnant Women of Underprivileged Ethnic...
Factors Associated with Anemia among Pregnant Women of Underprivileged Ethnic...Factors Associated with Anemia among Pregnant Women of Underprivileged Ethnic...
Factors Associated with Anemia among Pregnant Women of Underprivileged Ethnic...Prabesh Ghimire
 
Evidence for Public Health Decision Making
Evidence for Public Health Decision MakingEvidence for Public Health Decision Making
Evidence for Public Health Decision MakingVineetha K
 
Innovation and Development in Indian Healthcare
Innovation and Development in Indian HealthcareInnovation and Development in Indian Healthcare
Innovation and Development in Indian HealthcareSahana Bose
 
Η διαχείριση των μειζόνων συμπεριφορικών παραγόντων κινδύνου στην ΠΦΥ
Η διαχείριση των μειζόνων συμπεριφορικών παραγόντων κινδύνου στην ΠΦΥΗ διαχείριση των μειζόνων συμπεριφορικών παραγόντων κινδύνου στην ΠΦΥ
Η διαχείριση των μειζόνων συμπεριφορικών παραγόντων κινδύνου στην ΠΦΥEvangelos Fragkoulis
 
TOPIC:APPLICATION OF EPIDEMIOLOGY IN HEALTH CARE DELIVERY, HEALTH SURVELLIA...
TOPIC:APPLICATION  OF  EPIDEMIOLOGY IN HEALTH CARE DELIVERY, HEALTH SURVELLIA...TOPIC:APPLICATION  OF  EPIDEMIOLOGY IN HEALTH CARE DELIVERY, HEALTH SURVELLIA...
TOPIC:APPLICATION OF EPIDEMIOLOGY IN HEALTH CARE DELIVERY, HEALTH SURVELLIA...tusharkedar2
 
Referral system in india
Referral system in indiaReferral system in india
Referral system in indiaKailash Nagar
 
Tata Institute of Social Sciences - Master of Public Health 2016-18
Tata Institute of Social Sciences - Master of Public Health 2016-18Tata Institute of Social Sciences - Master of Public Health 2016-18
Tata Institute of Social Sciences - Master of Public Health 2016-18Anshuman
 
Human right in mentally ill prson
Human right in mentally ill prsonHuman right in mentally ill prson
Human right in mentally ill prsonSantanu Ghosh
 
National mental health policy vis-a-vis National health policy
National mental health policy vis-a-vis National health policyNational mental health policy vis-a-vis National health policy
National mental health policy vis-a-vis National health policyVipin Chandran
 

What's hot (20)

Out of Pocket Expenditure on Non-Communicable Diseases among Households: Evid...
Out of Pocket Expenditure on Non-Communicable Diseases among Households: Evid...Out of Pocket Expenditure on Non-Communicable Diseases among Households: Evid...
Out of Pocket Expenditure on Non-Communicable Diseases among Households: Evid...
 
Basic health issues and role of private healthcare System in Pakistan
Basic health issues  and role of private healthcare System in PakistanBasic health issues  and role of private healthcare System in Pakistan
Basic health issues and role of private healthcare System in Pakistan
 
Συχνότερα χρόνια νοσήματα, καταστάσεις υγείας, συχνότερα συμπτώματα στην κοιν...
Συχνότερα χρόνια νοσήματα, καταστάσεις υγείας, συχνότερα συμπτώματα στην κοιν...Συχνότερα χρόνια νοσήματα, καταστάσεις υγείας, συχνότερα συμπτώματα στην κοιν...
Συχνότερα χρόνια νοσήματα, καταστάσεις υγείας, συχνότερα συμπτώματα στην κοιν...
 
Epidemiological studies in psychiatry in India
Epidemiological studies in psychiatry in IndiaEpidemiological studies in psychiatry in India
Epidemiological studies in psychiatry in India
 
Prevalence and predictors of mental health among farmworkers in Southeastern ...
Prevalence and predictors of mental health among farmworkers in Southeastern ...Prevalence and predictors of mental health among farmworkers in Southeastern ...
Prevalence and predictors of mental health among farmworkers in Southeastern ...
 
community health nursing
community health nursingcommunity health nursing
community health nursing
 
Challenges in Indian Healthcare Sector
Challenges in Indian Healthcare SectorChallenges in Indian Healthcare Sector
Challenges in Indian Healthcare Sector
 
National health policy
National health policyNational health policy
National health policy
 
healthcare delivery system
healthcare delivery systemhealthcare delivery system
healthcare delivery system
 
3.1_Whitepaper_IndiaHealthReport (Indicus Analytics-A Nielsen Company)
3.1_Whitepaper_IndiaHealthReport (Indicus Analytics-A Nielsen Company)3.1_Whitepaper_IndiaHealthReport (Indicus Analytics-A Nielsen Company)
3.1_Whitepaper_IndiaHealthReport (Indicus Analytics-A Nielsen Company)
 
Factors Associated with Anemia among Pregnant Women of Underprivileged Ethnic...
Factors Associated with Anemia among Pregnant Women of Underprivileged Ethnic...Factors Associated with Anemia among Pregnant Women of Underprivileged Ethnic...
Factors Associated with Anemia among Pregnant Women of Underprivileged Ethnic...
 
Epidemiology
EpidemiologyEpidemiology
Epidemiology
 
Evidence for Public Health Decision Making
Evidence for Public Health Decision MakingEvidence for Public Health Decision Making
Evidence for Public Health Decision Making
 
Innovation and Development in Indian Healthcare
Innovation and Development in Indian HealthcareInnovation and Development in Indian Healthcare
Innovation and Development in Indian Healthcare
 
Η διαχείριση των μειζόνων συμπεριφορικών παραγόντων κινδύνου στην ΠΦΥ
Η διαχείριση των μειζόνων συμπεριφορικών παραγόντων κινδύνου στην ΠΦΥΗ διαχείριση των μειζόνων συμπεριφορικών παραγόντων κινδύνου στην ΠΦΥ
Η διαχείριση των μειζόνων συμπεριφορικών παραγόντων κινδύνου στην ΠΦΥ
 
TOPIC:APPLICATION OF EPIDEMIOLOGY IN HEALTH CARE DELIVERY, HEALTH SURVELLIA...
TOPIC:APPLICATION  OF  EPIDEMIOLOGY IN HEALTH CARE DELIVERY, HEALTH SURVELLIA...TOPIC:APPLICATION  OF  EPIDEMIOLOGY IN HEALTH CARE DELIVERY, HEALTH SURVELLIA...
TOPIC:APPLICATION OF EPIDEMIOLOGY IN HEALTH CARE DELIVERY, HEALTH SURVELLIA...
 
Referral system in india
Referral system in indiaReferral system in india
Referral system in india
 
Tata Institute of Social Sciences - Master of Public Health 2016-18
Tata Institute of Social Sciences - Master of Public Health 2016-18Tata Institute of Social Sciences - Master of Public Health 2016-18
Tata Institute of Social Sciences - Master of Public Health 2016-18
 
Human right in mentally ill prson
Human right in mentally ill prsonHuman right in mentally ill prson
Human right in mentally ill prson
 
National mental health policy vis-a-vis National health policy
National mental health policy vis-a-vis National health policyNational mental health policy vis-a-vis National health policy
National mental health policy vis-a-vis National health policy
 

Viewers also liked

Guadalinex Edu y PDI: Instalación y partes de la PDI
Guadalinex Edu y PDI: Instalación y partes de la PDIGuadalinex Edu y PDI: Instalación y partes de la PDI
Guadalinex Edu y PDI: Instalación y partes de la PDIMarina Navarrete
 
2015/11/23付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス
2015/11/23付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス2015/11/23付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス
2015/11/23付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックスThe Natsu Style
 
Avances Tecnologicos
Avances TecnologicosAvances Tecnologicos
Avances TecnologicosMaro Retiz
 
Evolution of storytelling - Noah Falstein
Evolution of storytelling - Noah FalsteinEvolution of storytelling - Noah Falstein
Evolution of storytelling - Noah FalsteinKreativeAsia
 
SW12.9X: ChinaX (Part 9) - Communist Liberations
SW12.9X: ChinaX (Part 9) - Communist LiberationsSW12.9X: ChinaX (Part 9) - Communist Liberations
SW12.9X: ChinaX (Part 9) - Communist LiberationsPavao Pahljina
 
Campañas y nuevas tecnologíasppt
Campañas y nuevas tecnologíaspptCampañas y nuevas tecnologíasppt
Campañas y nuevas tecnologíaspptclubdemarketing2
 
2015/10/12付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス
2015/10/12付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス2015/10/12付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス
2015/10/12付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックスThe Natsu Style
 
2015 06 27_СТОЛИЧНИЙ ОКРУГ
2015 06 27_СТОЛИЧНИЙ ОКРУГ2015 06 27_СТОЛИЧНИЙ ОКРУГ
2015 06 27_СТОЛИЧНИЙ ОКРУГIgor Naida
 
Motherboard
MotherboardMotherboard
Motherboardjorx34
 
2015/09/07付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス
2015/09/07付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス2015/09/07付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス
2015/09/07付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックスThe Natsu Style
 
A/B Testing - Quantitative Analysis
A/B Testing - Quantitative AnalysisA/B Testing - Quantitative Analysis
A/B Testing - Quantitative AnalysisLili Maria Lau
 
ご当地グルメを題材とする4択クイズの生成
ご当地グルメを題材とする4択クイズの生成ご当地グルメを題材とする4択クイズの生成
ご当地グルメを題材とする4択クイズの生成utsuro_lab
 
Kuormalavakeskus_esite-1
Kuormalavakeskus_esite-1Kuormalavakeskus_esite-1
Kuormalavakeskus_esite-1Ken Ryyn
 
Schizophernia ( sahrish darjat)
Schizophernia ( sahrish darjat)Schizophernia ( sahrish darjat)
Schizophernia ( sahrish darjat)Sahrish Darjat
 
Mental health issues in pakistan (July 2010)
Mental health issues in pakistan  (July 2010)Mental health issues in pakistan  (July 2010)
Mental health issues in pakistan (July 2010)Pk Doctors
 
Community Mental Health Services in india At Nmhans Power Point Students.
Community Mental Health Services  in india At Nmhans Power Point Students.Community Mental Health Services  in india At Nmhans Power Point Students.
Community Mental Health Services in india At Nmhans Power Point Students.AIIMS
 
Mental models - Final Presentation
Mental models - Final PresentationMental models - Final Presentation
Mental models - Final PresentationKishan Salian
 
Mental health in Pakistan
Mental health in PakistanMental health in Pakistan
Mental health in PakistanNayyar Kazmi
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Bitola
BitolaBitola
Bitola
 
Guadalinex Edu y PDI: Instalación y partes de la PDI
Guadalinex Edu y PDI: Instalación y partes de la PDIGuadalinex Edu y PDI: Instalación y partes de la PDI
Guadalinex Edu y PDI: Instalación y partes de la PDI
 
2015/11/23付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス
2015/11/23付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス2015/11/23付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス
2015/11/23付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス
 
Avances Tecnologicos
Avances TecnologicosAvances Tecnologicos
Avances Tecnologicos
 
Evolution of storytelling - Noah Falstein
Evolution of storytelling - Noah FalsteinEvolution of storytelling - Noah Falstein
Evolution of storytelling - Noah Falstein
 
SW12.9X: ChinaX (Part 9) - Communist Liberations
SW12.9X: ChinaX (Part 9) - Communist LiberationsSW12.9X: ChinaX (Part 9) - Communist Liberations
SW12.9X: ChinaX (Part 9) - Communist Liberations
 
Campañas y nuevas tecnologíasppt
Campañas y nuevas tecnologíaspptCampañas y nuevas tecnologíasppt
Campañas y nuevas tecnologíasppt
 
2015/10/12付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス
2015/10/12付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス2015/10/12付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス
2015/10/12付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス
 
2015 06 27_СТОЛИЧНИЙ ОКРУГ
2015 06 27_СТОЛИЧНИЙ ОКРУГ2015 06 27_СТОЛИЧНИЙ ОКРУГ
2015 06 27_СТОЛИЧНИЙ ОКРУГ
 
Motherboard
MotherboardMotherboard
Motherboard
 
2015/09/07付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス
2015/09/07付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス2015/09/07付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス
2015/09/07付 オリジナルiTunes週間トップソングトピックス
 
A/B Testing - Quantitative Analysis
A/B Testing - Quantitative AnalysisA/B Testing - Quantitative Analysis
A/B Testing - Quantitative Analysis
 
ご当地グルメを題材とする4択クイズの生成
ご当地グルメを題材とする4択クイズの生成ご当地グルメを題材とする4択クイズの生成
ご当地グルメを題材とする4択クイズの生成
 
Kuormalavakeskus_esite-1
Kuormalavakeskus_esite-1Kuormalavakeskus_esite-1
Kuormalavakeskus_esite-1
 
Schizophernia ( sahrish darjat)
Schizophernia ( sahrish darjat)Schizophernia ( sahrish darjat)
Schizophernia ( sahrish darjat)
 
Mental health issues in pakistan (July 2010)
Mental health issues in pakistan  (July 2010)Mental health issues in pakistan  (July 2010)
Mental health issues in pakistan (July 2010)
 
Community Mental Health Services in india At Nmhans Power Point Students.
Community Mental Health Services  in india At Nmhans Power Point Students.Community Mental Health Services  in india At Nmhans Power Point Students.
Community Mental Health Services in india At Nmhans Power Point Students.
 
Mental models - Final Presentation
Mental models - Final PresentationMental models - Final Presentation
Mental models - Final Presentation
 
Mental health in Pakistan
Mental health in PakistanMental health in Pakistan
Mental health in Pakistan
 
Brand image0 (1) g
Brand image0 (1) g Brand image0 (1) g
Brand image0 (1) g
 

Similar to Mental health training of primary healthcare workers in Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Jordan

A mixed methods field based assessment in Pakistan
A mixed methods field based assessment in PakistanA mixed methods field based assessment in Pakistan
A mixed methods field based assessment in PakistanBoris Budosan
 
Service delivery system of mental health in india
Service delivery system of mental health in indiaService delivery system of mental health in india
Service delivery system of mental health in indiaRobin Victor
 
Evaluation of effectiveness of mental health training prog…
Evaluation of effectiveness of mental health training prog…Evaluation of effectiveness of mental health training prog…
Evaluation of effectiveness of mental health training prog…Boris Budosan
 
Ibyt04i8p63
Ibyt04i8p63Ibyt04i8p63
Ibyt04i8p63prynag
 
COMMUNITY MENTAL HEALTH NURSING
COMMUNITY MENTAL HEALTH NURSINGCOMMUNITY MENTAL HEALTH NURSING
COMMUNITY MENTAL HEALTH NURSINGArun Madanan
 
The Current Condition of Mental Health in Afghanistan: Integrating Mental Hea...
The Current Condition of Mental Health in Afghanistan: Integrating Mental Hea...The Current Condition of Mental Health in Afghanistan: Integrating Mental Hea...
The Current Condition of Mental Health in Afghanistan: Integrating Mental Hea...jehill3
 
Management of mental health disorders in the community
Management of mental health disorders in the communityManagement of mental health disorders in the community
Management of mental health disorders in the communityTuti Mohd Daud
 
Social Work in Psychiatric Settings
Social Work in Psychiatric Settings Social Work in Psychiatric Settings
Social Work in Psychiatric Settings Kiran MSD
 
National mental health programme (nmhp)
National mental health programme (nmhp)National mental health programme (nmhp)
National mental health programme (nmhp)SATYAKAM MOHAPARTA
 
Prevalence of psychological morbidity among medically – ill
Prevalence of psychological morbidity among medically – illPrevalence of psychological morbidity among medically – ill
Prevalence of psychological morbidity among medically – illSathish Rajamani
 
Indian Mental Health Act 2017_Dr._Ruchi Kushwaha.pptx
Indian Mental Health Act 2017_Dr._Ruchi Kushwaha.pptxIndian Mental Health Act 2017_Dr._Ruchi Kushwaha.pptx
Indian Mental Health Act 2017_Dr._Ruchi Kushwaha.pptxDr Ruchi Kushwaha
 
National mental health program
National mental health programNational mental health program
National mental health programdrravimr
 
National mental health programm by Ritika Soni
National mental health programm by Ritika SoniNational mental health programm by Ritika Soni
National mental health programm by Ritika SoniShimla
 
National health programmes : National Mental Health Programme
National health programmes : National Mental Health ProgrammeNational health programmes : National Mental Health Programme
National health programmes : National Mental Health ProgrammeDr Jyoti Prasad Pattanayak
 
EPIDEMIOLOGical research in mental health.pptx
EPIDEMIOLOGical research in mental health.pptxEPIDEMIOLOGical research in mental health.pptx
EPIDEMIOLOGical research in mental health.pptxfathimahasanathkp
 
National Mental Health Programme
National Mental Health ProgrammeNational Mental Health Programme
National Mental Health ProgrammeSandeep Das
 
Community mental health services
Community mental health services Community mental health services
Community mental health services Musa Abu Sbeih
 
Feature Article Police and mental health clinician partnership in .docx
Feature Article Police and mental health clinician partnership in .docxFeature Article Police and mental health clinician partnership in .docx
Feature Article Police and mental health clinician partnership in .docxssuser454af01
 

Similar to Mental health training of primary healthcare workers in Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Jordan (20)

A mixed methods field based assessment in Pakistan
A mixed methods field based assessment in PakistanA mixed methods field based assessment in Pakistan
A mixed methods field based assessment in Pakistan
 
Service delivery system of mental health in india
Service delivery system of mental health in indiaService delivery system of mental health in india
Service delivery system of mental health in india
 
Evaluation of effectiveness of mental health training prog…
Evaluation of effectiveness of mental health training prog…Evaluation of effectiveness of mental health training prog…
Evaluation of effectiveness of mental health training prog…
 
Ibyt04i8p63
Ibyt04i8p63Ibyt04i8p63
Ibyt04i8p63
 
COMMUNITY MENTAL HEALTH NURSING
COMMUNITY MENTAL HEALTH NURSINGCOMMUNITY MENTAL HEALTH NURSING
COMMUNITY MENTAL HEALTH NURSING
 
The Current Condition of Mental Health in Afghanistan: Integrating Mental Hea...
The Current Condition of Mental Health in Afghanistan: Integrating Mental Hea...The Current Condition of Mental Health in Afghanistan: Integrating Mental Hea...
The Current Condition of Mental Health in Afghanistan: Integrating Mental Hea...
 
Management of mental health disorders in the community
Management of mental health disorders in the communityManagement of mental health disorders in the community
Management of mental health disorders in the community
 
JRelig
JReligJRelig
JRelig
 
Social Work in Psychiatric Settings
Social Work in Psychiatric Settings Social Work in Psychiatric Settings
Social Work in Psychiatric Settings
 
National mental health programme (nmhp)
National mental health programme (nmhp)National mental health programme (nmhp)
National mental health programme (nmhp)
 
Prevalence of psychological morbidity among medically – ill
Prevalence of psychological morbidity among medically – illPrevalence of psychological morbidity among medically – ill
Prevalence of psychological morbidity among medically – ill
 
Indian Mental Health Act 2017_Dr._Ruchi Kushwaha.pptx
Indian Mental Health Act 2017_Dr._Ruchi Kushwaha.pptxIndian Mental Health Act 2017_Dr._Ruchi Kushwaha.pptx
Indian Mental Health Act 2017_Dr._Ruchi Kushwaha.pptx
 
National mental health program
National mental health programNational mental health program
National mental health program
 
National mental health programm by Ritika Soni
National mental health programm by Ritika SoniNational mental health programm by Ritika Soni
National mental health programm by Ritika Soni
 
National health programmes : National Mental Health Programme
National health programmes : National Mental Health ProgrammeNational health programmes : National Mental Health Programme
National health programmes : National Mental Health Programme
 
EPIDEMIOLOGical research in mental health.pptx
EPIDEMIOLOGical research in mental health.pptxEPIDEMIOLOGical research in mental health.pptx
EPIDEMIOLOGical research in mental health.pptx
 
National Mental Health Programme
National Mental Health ProgrammeNational Mental Health Programme
National Mental Health Programme
 
Community mental health services
Community mental health services Community mental health services
Community mental health services
 
NMHP-1982.pptx
NMHP-1982.pptxNMHP-1982.pptx
NMHP-1982.pptx
 
Feature Article Police and mental health clinician partnership in .docx
Feature Article Police and mental health clinician partnership in .docxFeature Article Police and mental health clinician partnership in .docx
Feature Article Police and mental health clinician partnership in .docx
 

More from Boris Budosan

Kosovo paper-published
Kosovo paper-publishedKosovo paper-published
Kosovo paper-publishedBoris Budosan
 
Planting seed for developing community mental health services in Croatia
Planting seed for developing community mental health services in CroatiaPlanting seed for developing community mental health services in Croatia
Planting seed for developing community mental health services in CroatiaBoris Budosan
 
After the Vawe-Journal of Humanitarian Assistance
After the Vawe-Journal of Humanitarian AssistanceAfter the Vawe-Journal of Humanitarian Assistance
After the Vawe-Journal of Humanitarian AssistanceBoris Budosan
 
Strategy_for_providing_integrated_mental.99990
Strategy_for_providing_integrated_mental.99990Strategy_for_providing_integrated_mental.99990
Strategy_for_providing_integrated_mental.99990Boris Budosan
 

More from Boris Budosan (6)

Kosovo paper-published
Kosovo paper-publishedKosovo paper-published
Kosovo paper-published
 
Planting seed for developing community mental health services in Croatia
Planting seed for developing community mental health services in CroatiaPlanting seed for developing community mental health services in Croatia
Planting seed for developing community mental health services in Croatia
 
After the Vawe-Journal of Humanitarian Assistance
After the Vawe-Journal of Humanitarian AssistanceAfter the Vawe-Journal of Humanitarian Assistance
After the Vawe-Journal of Humanitarian Assistance
 
Strategy_for_providing_integrated_mental.99990
Strategy_for_providing_integrated_mental.99990Strategy_for_providing_integrated_mental.99990
Strategy_for_providing_integrated_mental.99990
 
Haiti paper
Haiti paperHaiti paper
Haiti paper
 
Kilis paper
Kilis paperKilis paper
Kilis paper
 

Mental health training of primary healthcare workers in Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Jordan

  • 1. Mental health training of primary health care workers: case reports from Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan Boris Budosan Evidencesuggeststhat providingsupportto primary healthcarewithtraining,assistanceandsupervision by available mental health professionals is the best way to extend mental health care to the population. Three cases of mental health training programmes for primary health care workers were implemented in di¡erent countries, and are described in this article.The objective was to share the lessons learnt in di¡erent settings. Relevant primary and second- ary data were used to present the cases.The mental health trainings generally improved the mental health knowledge of primary health care workers. Moresustainablechangesintheirmentalhealthcare practices wereachievedonlyasaresult ofseveralfac- tors combined together: a) professionally designed and implemented mental health training; b) motiv- ation byallkeyplayersto develop community mental health services; c) political will by the government followed byformulation of mental health policy pro- moting integration of mental health into primary care;d)goodtimingoftheprogramme;ande)in£ux of funding and professional expertise.The ¢ndings of this article support the viewpoint of the World Health Organization that mental health training for primary health care workers is just one of the factors necessary for the successful integration of mental health care into primary health care. Keywords: mental health, mental health care services, primary health care, pro- gramme development, sta¡ development Introduction One of the 10 recommendations by World Health Organization (WHO) on how to approach the problem of the existing short- age of mental health care professionals in many countries around the world, close the treatment gap and improve mental health care services, stresses the provision of man- agement and treatment of mental disorders in primary health care (World Health Organization,2001).The integration of men- tal health care into primary care is a funda- mental process that enables the largest number of people to gain faster and easier access to mental health care services. It is also helpful in reducing the stigma attached to mental illness existing in many commu- nities around the world (World Health Organization, 2008). The basic component of this process is the training of primary health care (PHC) workers in the recog- nition and management of a range of mental disorders (World Health Organization, 2001). Appropriate mental health training needs to be combined with continued super- vision and support by mental health care professionals in order to achieve e¡ective mental health care in primary care settings (World Health Organization,2008). Accord- ing to Saxena et al. (2007), training, assist- ance and supervision of primary health care services by available mental health care professionals is a necessary prerequisite for a successful integration process. It is also important to emphasise that, although mental health care investments in primary care are important, they are unlikely to be Boris Budosan 125
  • 2. sustained unless they are preceded and/or accompanied by the simultaneous develop- ment of community mental health care services (Saraceno et al., 2007). Many studies have evaluated the e¡ective- ness of mental health care training for various groups of bene¢ciaries (residents, general practitioners, nurses, etc.) in di¡er- ent countries. (Cohen, 2001; Harding et al., 1983; Hodges, Inch, & Silver, 2001; Hodgins etal.,2007; Kroenke etal.,2000; Lum, Kwok & Chong,2008;World Health Organization, 2008). In general, a large majority of such training were successful in improving diag- nostic accuracy (i.e. diagnostic speci¢city) and sensitivity of trainees, as well as their attitudes towards mental health issues, but was also found to be less successful in chan- ging their actual clinical practices and patientoutcomes, especially inthe long-term (Kroenke et al., 2000, Cohen, 2001). This article describes how opportunities, initially provided by relief e¡orts after the 2004 tsunami in Sri Lanka, the 2005 earth- quake in Pakistan, and the 2003 war in Iraq, were used to deliver mental health care training for PHC workers in two districts of Sri Lanka, one district in Pakistan and the eastern part of the city of Amman, in Jordan. The objective of the paper was to assess the e¡ectiveness of training inter- ventions, and to share the lessons learnt in di¡erent settings. According to Saraceno et al. (2007), professional understanding of the e¡ects of disasters, paired with post emergency mental health care interest (including media and politicians), can provide enormous opportunities for the development of mental health care systems. Mental health training programmes of primary health care workers in all targeted areaswere implementedby the international nongovernmental organisation (INGO), International Medical Corps (IMC), in a close collaboration with the Ministries of Health of the countries, WHO local representative o⁄ces, local psychiatric colleagues, PHC workers and local and provincial health authorities. Context In Sri Lanka, mental healthcaretrainings of primaryhealthcareworkers were conducted in two administrative areas called districts, both hit hard in the 2004 Tsunami natural disaster, which killed about 40,000 people in Sri Lanka, speci¢cally the district of Kalmunai in the north-east of the country, with a population of 401,534 (Deputy Pro- vincial Directorate of Health Services (DPDHS) Kalmunai, 2003), and the district of Hambantota in the South, with the esti- mated population of 525,370 people (World Health Organization, 2005). In Pakistan, mental health care training of PHC workers was conducted in the district of Mansehra, intheNorth-WestFrontierProvince(NWFP), with a population of 1,152,839 people (1998 census), that was hit hard by the 2005 earth- quake that killed around 80,000 people in Pakistan. In Jordan, mental health training of PHC workers was conducted in Eastern Amman, which hosted many Iraqi refugees after the 2003 Iraqi war, with an estimated population of 149,775 people. In all targeted areas, except the Hambantota district in Sri Lanka, the population consisted of di¡erent ethnic groups; Tamils and Muslims in Kalmunai, Pashto and Urdu speaking populations in Mansehra, and Jordanian and Iraqi populations in Eastern Amman. All targeted areas were economically poor compared to the national standards of Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan. Mental health care services in targeted areas Only two physicians, with the title of Medical O⁄cers of Mental Health, Mental health training of primary health care workers: case reports from Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan Intervention 2011, Volume 9, Number 2, Page 125 - 136 126
  • 3. provided mental health care services, in both the Kalmunai and Hambantota dis- tricts in Sri Lanka. They were basically general practitioners with three-month additional postgraduate mental health training. Both districts had only visiting psy- chiatrists, who used to perform psychiatric consultations in the districts, once or twice a month. The district general hospitals had no separate wards and/or departments to treat mental health patients. Only two psy- chiatrists and one mental health hospital, in the town of Mansehra, provided mental health services in the Mansehra district in Pakistan. In Jordan, people from Eastern Amman had to seek mental health services either from private psychiatrists (with a fee charged for service), or from the (350 bed) public mental health hospital in Amman, with long waiting lists and a shortage of medications. It is also worth mentioning that at the time of this project, there were no psychiatric wards in Jordanian general hospitals. Methods First, secondary data from the relevant men- tal health literature were collected. Basic psychiatric epidemiological data and data on mental health resources for all three countries (Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan) were obtained from the WHO Mental Health Atlas project (WHO, Department of Mental Health and Substance Abuse, 2005). Local mental health care studies, pub- lished in various national and international journals, were the additional source of infor- mation on mental health needs and services, as well as on speci¢c mental health issues, (e.g. high suicide rates in Sri Lanka, high rate of depression in women in Pakistan, and the link between violence and mental health in Iraqi refugees in Jordan). The fol- lowing literature was reviewed: Sri Lanka (de Silva, 2002; Mendis, 2004; Eddleston, et al., 1998); Pakistan (Ahmer, et al., 2006; Husain, et al., 2007; Karim, et al., 2004; Mubbashar & Saeed, 2001; Mumford et al., 1996; Mumford et al.,1997; Mumford et al., 2000); and Jordan (Al-Haddad et al., 1999; Daradkeh et al., 2006; Takriti, 2004). Primary data on mental health care needs and services were collected only in those areas of thetargetedcountries, wheremental health training of primary health care workers was implemented. Both qualitative and quantitative data collection methods were used. Qualitative data collection methods included open ended, semi-struc- tured key informant interviews, structured focus groups and unstructured participant observation. These were also used for ¢eld assessment purposes and focus groups were used for the evaluation of satisfaction with the training. Observation was used for the evaluation of the mental health skills of the PHC workers. Quantitative data collection methods included 30-item multiple choice knowledge tests for PHC doctors, and 15-item multiple choice knowledge test for PHC mid-level workers. They were used to evaluate theo- retical mental health care knowledge of participants, before, and after the training. The construct validity of all study instru- ments was determined by: a) the profes- sional judgment of local and international experts; b) the available evidence on the use of similar instruments in similar situations; and c) general recommendations in the literature on questionnaire design (Fathala, 2004). An on-the-job training competency checklist (Table 1) was used immediately at the end of comprehensive training (theoreti- calandon-the-job), in order to evaluate prac- tical skills of the PHC doctors, in regard to their detection rate, diagnostic accuracy and treatment of mental health problems in Boris Budosan 127
  • 5. general practice.The statistical index, Cron- bach alfa, was used to measure the degree of internal consistency of knowledge tests (Wells & Wollack, 2003), and it was 0.84 (Cronbach’s alpha is a coe⁄cient of reliabi- lity, and is commonly used as a measure of the internal consistency or reliability of a test score, a Cronbach’s alfa of at least 0.7 is required before the instrument could be considered reliable enough for testing). The mental health training manuals used were developed for each training separately, and they included several core elements that should shape the development and implementation of training curricula (Wein et al., 2002): 1) competence in listening and other com- munication skills; 2) training in properly recognising mental health problems within a community; 3) teachingestablishedmentalhealthinter- ventions; 4) providing strategies for problem solving; 5) training in the treatment of medically unexplained somatic pain; and 6) learning to collaborate with existing local resources, e.g. indigenous healers (practitioners of alternative medicine), who are often the ¢rst point of contact for mental health problems in many developing countries (Budosan & Aziz, 2009; Budosan et al., 2007). Results Sri Lanka (Kalmunai and Hambantota districts) The analysis of qualitative data from the interviews with mental health professionals, and focus groups with the PHC doctors, identi¢ed several important issues. The majority of interviewed participants in both districts agreed on following: a) there was a signi¢cant gap between mental health needs and services; b) a signi¢cant number of mental health care issues were dealt with through traditional healers; and c) improve- ment of availability, accessibility and a¡ord- ability of mental health care services was considered as necessary to improve the over- all mental health of the population. The observation of practices of the PHC workers identi¢ed a lack of skills in the recognition and treatment of mental health problems. The mental health training in Kalmunai was conducted from April to October 2005, andin Hambanotota from AugusttoJanuary 2006. Both trainings were designed with local mental health care professionals and the PHC workers, and received institutional, ethical clearance from both local and gov- ernmental health authorities. Consent of the participants was obtained either through direct communication, or through the responsible health authorities. A combi- nation of theoretical and practical (on-the- job) training was identi¢edasthebest model to deliver the training. Five 2-day workshops (held monthly), or 50 hours of comprehen- sive theoretical training, and (on average) 3.7 on-the job training sessions per partici- pant, supervised by either local and/or inter- national psychiatrists, were delivered to the PHC doctors in Kalmunai during a six month period. Seven 2-day workshops, or 70 hours of comprehensive theoretical train- ing, and (on average) 7.7 on-the-job training sessions per participant were delivered to PHC doctors in Hambantota, also over a 6 month period. Twelve hours of intensive theoretical training were delivered to mid- level public PHC workers (mid-level sta¡ involved in health promotion and pre- vention) during a 3 month period. Fifteen percent of primary health care doctors, and almost 100% of mid-level public PHC workers in Kalmunai, as well as 23% primary health care doctors and almost 100% mid-level public PHC sta¡ in Boris Budosan 129
  • 6. Hambantota, received this training. The success of the theoretical part of the training was measured by the pre/post knowledge test, only in the Hambantota district (Table 2). On-the-job training improved the practical skills of the PHC doctors, which were virtually nonexistent before the training intervention (Table 2). On average, 72% of the participants in Kalmunai, and 79% in Hambantota, expressed their satisfaction with di¡erent aspects of the delivered train- ing (Budosan & Jones, 2009). Pakistan (Mansehra district) The gaps between mental health care needs and services, the stigma attached to mental health problems, the important role of traditional healing systems in dealing with mental health problems, and the need for a mental health training of PHC workers were identi¢ed as the most important issues in boththe focus groups withthe PHC workers, and in interviews with key informants (Budosan & Aziz, 2009). Both a lack of men- tal health care knowledge/skills by the PHC doctors, and poor involvement of the PHC mid-level workers in the management of mental health care problems, was observed during patient encounters. The mental health training in Mansehra was conducted from May to August 2006. Both local and district health authorities author- ised this training, and when informed by district and local health authorities, the PHC workers gave their consent to partici- pate. Twenty-¢ve hours of comprehensive, theoretical mental health care training were delivered to Mansehra PHC doctors, and 18 hours to Mansehra PHC mid-level workers (named Lady HealthVisitors), during a 3 month period. Sixteen half-day, weekly mental health care training sessions were delivered to nongovernmental organisation (NGO) workers helping the earthquake- a¡ected population. Seventy-one percent of the Mansehra government based primary health care doctors, and 50% of Mansehra government based PHC mid-level workers, received basic mental health care training, in order to begin to integrate mental health into their practices.There was no evaluation of the success of this training (which was only theoretical) by knowledge testing, but on average, more than 80% of training participants expressed satisfaction with the training (Table 2). Jordan (eastern Amman) The analysis of qualitative data from the interviews with mental health care pro- fessionals and focus groups with the PHC doctors, concluded that the provision of equitable, comprehensive and a¡ordable mental health care services, a multi-disci- plinary approach to mental health care, and community education on mental health issues were the best ways to improve mental health care. Observation of patient encoun- ters in the PHC clinic run by the Jordanian Red Crescent in Eastern Amman revealed that the PHC workers did not have either the time or adequate knowledge/skills to properly address mental health issues within primary care. InJordan, mental health care training of the PHC workers was conducted for 30 primary health care doctors, working for three local NGOs (Jordanian Red Crescent, Caritas and Jordanian Health Aid Society), helping Iraqi refugees and the poor population of Jordan.This training was conducted in the period from April to August 2008. The Ministry of Health in Jordan gave an ethical clearance for the training, and the PHC workers of three of the above mentioned NGOs agreed to parti- cipate.Twelve weekly sessions, or 60 hours of comprehensive theoretical mental health Mental health training of primary health care workers: case reports from Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan Intervention 2011, Volume 9, Number 2, Page 125 - 136 130
  • 7. Table2.Resultsofmentalhealthtrainingsintargetedareas Country(area) Mentalhealthknowledge (percentageofcorrect answers) Mentalhealthskills (percentageofdoctorswith goodusageofmentalskills) Satisfactionwith training Kalmunaidistrict(SriLanka)NodatacollectedPractically0%before training Onaverage72%satis¢edwith di¡erentaspectsoftraining 77%afterthetraining Hambantotadistrict(SriLanka)Pretest64%Practically0%before training Onaverage79%satis¢edwith di¡erentaspectsoftraining Posttest81%(medicaldoctors) (t¼10.88,p<0.05) 85%aftertraining Pretest54.6% Posttest66.6%(mid-levelsta¡) (t¼17.2,p<0.05) Mansehradistrict(NWFP,Pakistan)NodatacollectedNodatacollectedOnaveragemorethan80% satis¢edwithtraining EasternAmman(Jordan)Pretest55%DatapendingDatapending Posttest80%(medicaldoctors) (t¼11.77,p<0.01) Boris Budosan 131
  • 8. training, were delivered. The success of the training was evaluated with pre/post know- ledge test (Table 2). Discussion The evaluation of training results clearly shows improvements of the theoretical mental health knowledge (Sri Lanka and Jordan), satisfaction of the great majority of participants with the training (Sri Lanka and Pakistan), and improved mental health care skills of the PHC doctors (Sri Lanka). In Sri Lanka, the mental health care train- ing programme also improved the actual mental health clinical practices of the PHC workers, and served as a catalyst for the further development of community mental health care services, which are likely to be sustainable in the long term (Budosan & Jones, 2009). Until now,13 outpatient mental health clinics, operated by trained PHC sta¡, from once aweekto once amonth, were opened in all health administrative areas of the Kalmunai district. Three PHC doctors, with one year postgraduate training in men- tal health, as well as a multi-disciplinary team consisting of psychiatric social worker, nurse and occupational therapist, were appointed to that district in the north east of Sri Lanka. Four new mental healthclinics, operated by trained PHC sta¡, have now opened in Hambantota, during the mental health training period. The number of detected and properly diagnosed mental health patients, who also received treat- ment in primary health care, increased in all health administrative areas in both districts (Budosan & Jones, 2009). On-the job training of the PHC doctors in Jordan ¢nished only recently, so there are still no evaluation data on that part of the mental health training, or on the satisfaction with the Jordan training in general. So far, this training was successful in increasing detection rates, diagnostic accuracy, and the number of referrals of mental health cases to psychiatrists. In 2008 and 2009, it also expanded to two more areas in Jordan (Dr. Jacob Joseph Panikulam, IMC Mental Health Coordinator, Jordan, personal communication). However, the lack of political will, separate budget allocations for mental health care, the lack of a formulation of a mental health policy promoting integration of mental health care into primary care, and the lack of development of community mental health services remain obstacles to sustainable change in the mental health care practices of the PHC practitioners. Although mental health care policy promot- ing integration of mental health into the primary care had been formulated in Pakistan in 1997, so far the major challenge in this country has been poor implementa- tion of this policy by trained PHC workers. According to a personal communication from Prof. Dr. Saeed Farooq, psychiatrist from Lady Reading Hospital in Peshawar (2008), two years after the implemented training in Mansehra, trained PHC doctors were still only detecting and referring cases of severe mental disorders to psychiatrists, at the same time providing only minimal treatment forboth common and severe men- tal health problems in their own practices. Lack of mental health research in Pakistan prevents making any de¢nitive conclusions in regard to the longer term outcome of this training, and the integration of mental health into primary health care in general (Mubbashar & Saeed, 2001). The strength of the mental health training programme in Sri Lanka, compared to training programmes in Pakistan and Jordan (so far), appears to be the result of several factors combined: a) the politicalwill of the government of Sri Lanka (Ministry Mental health training of primary health care workers: case reports from Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan Intervention 2011, Volume 9, Number 2, Page 125 - 136 132
  • 9. of Health) to develop community mental health care services (Saraceno et al., 2007); b) the formulation of a Sri Lankan mental health care policy promoting the integration of mental health into primary health care (Democratic Socialist Republic of Sri Lanka, 2005); c) commitment of the PHC and mental health professionals to imple- ment the policy; d) professionally designed mental health trainings, with both theoreti- cal and on-the-job training components, in tune with the IASC Guidelines being devel- oped at that time (Inter-Agency Standing Committee, 2007); e) good timing of the programme (right after a major disaster), which resulted in an in£ux of international funding and expertise; and f) cohesive work of all the major stakeholders (government, WHO, local health authorities, local and international mental health professionals and local PHC workers). According to Hodges et al. (2001), all described here mental health care training programmes described here met three importantrequirementsforthee¡ectiveness of an educational intervention: 1) duration of the intervention (training interventions were ongoing longitudinal educational interventions); 2) the degree of active participation of the learners (training inter- ventions were interactive, using participa- tory teaching methodology); and 3) the degree of integration of the new knowledge into the learner’s clinical context (location of training interventions were held in pre- existing primary care settings). Mental health trainings also followed consensus based guidelines for international training in mental health care, as established by the task force of the International Society for Traumatic Stress Studies (Wein, 2002). During training, an open dialogue was pro- moted between trainers, training partici- pants, and other key mental health players (i.e. the Ministries of Health, local WHO representative o⁄ces, and other local and international organisations working on mental health issues).This approach helped to integrate di¡erent perspectives and atti- tudes on mental healthwithinthe countries. Training sessions were culturally sensitive, and appropriate for the context, which was especially important for on-the-jobtraining involving mental health patients.The con¢- dentiality of patients’data was of the utmost importance; data were shared only with health professionals directly involved in training. The patients’ wishes as to whether to provide, or not to provide, certain infor- mation were respected. Conclusion Case reports on mental health trainings of the PHC workers in three di¡erent settings suggest that sustainable changes in their mental health care practices canbe achieved only as a result of a several e¡orts combined (see the example of Sri Lanka above). Political will of the government, followed by formulationof mental healthcare policies in the country promoting the integration of mental health into primary care, in£ux of funding and professional expertise, motiv- ation of the PHC workers and mental health care professionals to develop community mental health services, and professionally designed and implemented mental health care training of the PHC workers, including on-the-job training supervised by psychia- trists, are all important for the success of such an e¡ort. However, the results pre- sented in this paper cannot be considered as conclusive, because all the data from the mental healthcaretraining inJordanare still not available. A future comprehensive evalu- ation of mental health training in Jordan is recommended to complement the results presented here. Boris Budosan 133
  • 10. Acknowledgements The author would like to thank Dr. Lynne Jones for initiating the training model described in this paper, and Dr. Farooq A.L., Dr. Nowfel, M.J., Dr. Joe Asare, Dr. Sabah Aziz, Dr. Joseph Panikulam and Dr. Raghad Ali for implement- ing the training programmes in Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan. Also, my thanks to the following donors for providing funding under various grants; SV-Netherlands Refugee Foundation (projects in Sri Lanka), DFID, AusAid and SV (project in Pakistan), and UNHCR and BPRM (project in Jordan). I would also like to thank the WHO Depart- ment of Mental Health and Substance Abuse, Dr. Harischandra Gambheera, President of Sri Lankan College of Psychiatrists, Prof. Dr. Saeed Farooq, Lady Reading Hospital in Peshawar, Pakistan and Prof. Abdul Monaf Al-Jadiry, chief psychiatrist at the University of Jordan, for their help and support during the design and implementation of the trainings, and the international and national staff of the Inter- national Medical Corps in Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan for help in administering the pro- gramme, and Heidi Gillis from IMC Washing- ton, DC office for her help in proofreading and finalising this article. REFERENCES Ahmer, S., Naqvy, H., Karman Khan, M., Siddi- qui, N. & Moosa Khan, M. (2006). Psychologi- cal morbidity among primary care attendees in earthquake a¡ected areas of Pakistan. Journal of Pakistani Psychiatric Association, 3(2). Al-Haddad, M. K., Al-Garf, A., Al-Jowder, S. & Al-Zurba, F. I. (1999). Psychiatric morbidity in primary care. Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal, 5(1), 20-26. Budosan, B. & Aziz, S. (2009). A mixed methods ¢eld based assessment to design a mental health intervention after the 2005 earthquake in Mansehra, North-West Frontier Province, Pakistan. Intervention, 7(3). Budosan, B., Jones, L.,Wickramasinghe,W. A. L., Farook, A. L., Edirisooriya,V., Abeywardena, G. & Nowfel, M. J. (2007). AftertheWave: APi- lot Project to Develop Mental Health Services in Ampara District, Sri Lanka Post-Tsunami. Journal of Humanitarian Assistance, published on September 16, 2007. Available online: http://jha.ac. Budosan, B. & Jones, L. (2009). Evaluation of e¡ectiveness of mental health training program for primary health care sta¡ in Hambantota district, Sri Lanka, post- tsunami. Journal of Humanitarian Assistance, published May 1st, 2009. Available online: http://jha.ac. Cohen, A. (2001).Thee¡ectivenessofmentalhealth ser- vices in primary care: the view from the developing world. Publication WHO/MSD/MPS/01.1. Department of Mental Health and Substance Dependence,WHO, Geneva, Switzerland. Daradkeh,T. K., Alawan, A., Al Ma’aitah, R. & Otoom, S. A. (2006). Psychiatric morbidity and its sociodemographic correlate among women in Irbid, Jordan. Eastern Mediterranean HealthJournal, 12 (Supplement 2). Democratic Socialist Republic of Sri Lanka (2005). National mental health policy, Colombo, Sri Lanka: Government of Sri Lanka, 2005. Available online: http://www.searo.who.int/LinkFiles/ On-going_projects_mhp-slr.pdf. de Silva, D. (2002). Psychiatric service delivery in anAsiancountry:theexperience ofSriLanka. International Review of Psychiatry, 14,66-70. Deputy Provincial Directorate of Health Services (DPDHS), Kalmunai (2003). District health sector pro¢le-Kalmunai 2003. Deputy Provincial Directorate of Health Services: Kalmunai, Sri Lanka. Mental health training of primary health care workers: case reports from Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan Intervention 2011, Volume 9, Number 2, Page 125 - 136 134
  • 11. Eddleston, M., Rezvi Sheri¡, M. H. & Hawton, K. (1998). Deliberate self harm in Sri Lanka: anoverlookedtragedyinthedevelopingworld. British MedicalJournal, 317,133-135. Fathalla, M. F. (2004). A practical guide for health researchers. WHO Regional Publications East- ern Mediterranean Series 30. World Health Organization. Available online: www.whqlib doc.who.int/emro/2004/9290213639.pdf. Harding, W. T., Busnello, E., Climent, C., El- Hakim, A., Giel, R., Ibrahim, H. H. A., Lourdes, L. I. & Narendra, N. W. (1983). The WHO Collaborative Study on Strategies for Extending Mental Health Care, III: Evalua- tive Design and Illustrative results. American Journal of Psychiatry, 140,1481-1485. Hodges, B., Inch,C. &Silver, I. (2001).Improving the psychiatricknowledge, skills, andattitudes of primary care physicians, 1995^2000: A Review. AmericanJournal of Psychiatry, 158,10. Hodgins,G., Judd,F., Davis,J.&Fahey,A.(2007). An integrated approach to general mental health training: the importance of context. Australas Psychiatry, 15(1), 52-57. Husain, N., Chaudry, I. B., Afridi, M. A., Tomen- son, B. & Creed, F. (2007). Life stress and depression in a tribal area of Pakistan. The BritishJournal of Psychiatry, 190,36-41. Inter-Agency Standing Committee (2007). IASC Guidelines on Mental Health and Psychosocial Support in Emergency Settings. Geneva: IASC. Available online: http://icn.ch/IASC_MHPSS_ guidelines.pdf. Karim, S., Saeed, K., Rana, M. H., Mubasshar, M. H. & Jenkins, R. (2004). Pakistan mental health country pro¢le. International Review of Psychiatry, 16(1),83-92. Kroenke, K.,Taylor-Vaisey, A., Dietrich, J. A. & Oxman, T. (2000). Interventions to improve provider diagnosis and treatment of mental disorders in primary care. Psychosomatics, 41:1, Jan^Feb 2000. Lum, A.W., Kwok, K.W. & Chong, S. A. (2008). Providing integrated mental health services in the Singapore primary care setting ^ the general practitioner psychiatric program experience. Annals of Academic Medicine Singa- pore, 37(2),128-131. Mendis, N. (2004) Mental health services in Sri Lanka. International Psychiatry, 3,10-12. Mubbashar, M. H. & Saeed, K. (2001). Develop- ment of mental health services in Pakistan. Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal, 7(3), 392- 396. Mumford, D. B., Nazir, M., Jilani, F. U. & Baig, I. Y. (1996). Stress and psychiatric disorder in the Hindu Kush: a community survey of mountain villages in Chitral, Pakistan. The BritishJournal of Psychiatry, 168, 299-307. Mumford, D. B., Saeed, K., Ahmad, S. & Mubbashar, M. H. (1997). Stress and psychia- tric disorder in rural Punjab. A community survey. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 170, 473-478. Mumford, D. B., Fareed, A. F., Imtiaz, A., Akhteer, S. & Mubbashar, M. H. (2000). Stress andpsychiatric disorder inurban Rawalpindi. The BritishJournal of Psychiatry, 177, 557-662. Saraceno, B., Ommeren, M., Batniji, R., Cohen, A., Gureje, O., Mahoney, J., Sridhar, D. & Underhill, C. (2007). Barriers to improvement of mental health services in low-income and middle-income countries. Lancet, 370, 1164- 1174. Boris Budosan 135
  • 12. Saxena,S., Thornicroft,G., Knapp,M.&White- ford, H. (2007). Resources for mental health: scarcity, inequity and ine⁄ciency. Lancet, 370, 878-889. Takriti A. (2004). Psychiatry in Jordan. Inter- national psychiatry, Issue 5, July 2004. Wein, S., Danieli,Y., Silove, D., Ommeren,V. M., Fairbank, J. & Saul, J. (2002). Guidelines for international training in mental health and psychosocialinterventionsfortraumaexposed populations in clinical and community set- tings. Psychiatry 65(2). Wells, S. C. & Wollack, J. A. (2003). An instructor’s guide to understanding test reliability. Testing & Evaluation Services publication, University of Wisconsin. RetrievedJanuary 4,2006 from: www.wiscinfo.doit.wisc.edu/exams/Reliability. pdf. WHO Department of Mental Health and Substance Abuse (2005). Mental health atlas 2005, Geneva, Switzerland: WHO. Available online:http://www.who.int/globalatlas/default. asp. World Health Organization (2001). The world health report 2001. Geneva, Switzerland:WHO. World Health Organization (2005). Health systems in Tsunami a¡ected areas in Sri Lanka. On CD- ROM. WHO, PO Box 780, 226 Bauddhaloka Mawatha, Colombo 7, Sri Lanka. WorldHealthOrganization(2008).Integratingmen- tal health into primary care: A global perspective. Geneva, Switzerland:WHO. Dr. Boris Budosan, Ms.sci., M.P.H., psychia- trist (corresponding author), Mental Health Advisor for Cordaid, former Mental Health Coordinator for International Medical Corps in Sri Lanka and Pakistan and former Roving Mental Health Advisor for International Medical Corps in the Middle East, Vocarsko Naselje 22, 10000 Zagreb, Croatia. Tel: +385123 20 298; email: bbudosan@yahoo.com Mental health training of primary health care workers: case reports from Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Jordan Intervention 2011, Volume 9, Number 2, Page 125 - 136 136