SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 18
Download to read offline
92 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 93
ALL ALONG THE LINE
OMSI/SE WATER STATION
Portland’s newest bridge
and light rail line slip
between an opera house
and a museum on the
Willamette’s eastern bank.
PORTLAND LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS BUILD COMMUNITY...
AND A NEW LIGHT RAIL LINE.
BY BETSY ANDERSON, ASSOCIATE ASLA/PHOTOGRAPHY BY BRUCE FORSTER
94 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016
N A HOT SEPTEMBER MORNING, Portland’s Central
Eastside shimmered with an unusual procession. Stand-
ing two, three, and four abreast, members of the Con-
federated Tribes of Grand Ronde emerged from the crowded
riverbank of this industrial district turned stylish hipster haunt.
In full regalia, tribal members stepped onto the city’s newest
bridge and began to cross the Willamette River, from east to
west. Joining them was a new light rail train—advancing at the
same rhythmic pace, its cars filled with state and local leaders
hovering above the river in a place no one had been before.
This was the grand opening of Portland’s latest stretch of light
rail, the MAX Orange Line. The inaugural crossing of the first
bridge built in this river city in four decades was broadcast
liberally by local television crews. Portlanders are an enthusi-
astic bunch when it comes to urban infrastructure—especially
transit—and the bridge, like any celebrity, has full Google cov-
erage. A quick search for the opening will result in numerous
video clips. As I am a Seattleite, this was my first glimpse of
the splashy new addition to our southern neighbor’s already
healthy and envied public transportation network. Dedicated
to transit, cyclists, and pedestrians, the bridge has received
considerable attention not for its many attributes but for
something it lacks—cars.
Called Tilikum Crossing, Bridge of the People, the lithe cable-
stayed structure honors the Chinookan belief that crossing a
river builds community. It is the linchpin of a 7.3-mile transit
alignment that conveys this idea from Portland’s city center to
a mosaic of southeast neighborhoods and suburbs, including
the town of Milwaukie in adjacent Clackamas County. Led by
landscape architects on all sides and in all phases of the project,
the Orange Line underscores the age-old Chinookan belief
that connectivity and community are mutually dependent.
In cultivating both, its designers propose a new paradigm for
transit in American cities.
O
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 95
Tilikum means “people” in Chinook Wawa, a composite in-
ternational dialect that the region’s first inhabitants used to
communicate with other tribes, and later with fur traders,
explorers, and missionaries. It is a fitting word to describe
part of the Orange Line, a collaborative $1.49 billion effort
that engaged hundreds of landscape architects, architects, en-
gineers, artists, and contractors, filling the desks and drafting
tables of design and construction offices in the midst of the
2007–2009 recession. And these were just the consultants.
Working alongside were counterparts from TriMet, the local
public transit agency in charge of the new rail line (in transit
circles called simply “the alignment”), and staff representing
the jurisdictions through which the trains would pass.
The bridge, like the rest of the alignment, was 50 percent fund-
ed by the Federal Transit Administration’s New Starts program.
The remaining project costs of $745 million were covered by
a mixture of state and local sources. Noting my surprise that
federal transportation funding could support such placemak-
ing gestures, TriMet’s Sean Batty, ASLA, explained that it was
possible as long as the project could guarantee a favorable
cost-to-transit-benefit ratio. Batty served as the agency’s overall
conceptual design manager for the project. The Federal Transit
Administration (FTA) awards funding based on criteria that
measure a project’s mobility improvements, environmental
LEFT
Eight miles of new
or replaced bike lanes
trace the alignment.
RIGHT
At Oregon Health &
Science University’s
South Waterfront
Campus, the line
crosses a restored
industrial site, poised
for redevelopment.
96 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016
DOLLYHOLMES
N
MAX ORANGE LINE
RIGHT
The Tilikum Crossing
bridge knits the east
and westside stations
of the Orange Line
together.
OPPOSITE, TOP
The South Waterfront
station area layers
streetcar, bus, light
rail, car, pedestrian,
and bicycle traffic.
OPPOSITE, BOTTOM
Vegetated trackway
offers hardscape
relief for people and
stormwater alike.
/
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 97
benefits, operating efficiencies, and cost-effectiveness against
a preinvestment baseline. Layering a shared transitway onto
Tilikum Crossing exponentially increased the project’s transit
benefit. In lieu of buses stuck in traffic on existing crossings, a
new light rail line, two unobstructed bus lines, and a city street-
car could now be factored into FTA calculations. The decision
to omit cars was also a cost-saving measure, one bolstered by
community members who didn’t want their neighborhoods
skewered by arterials and on-ramps. Instead, the 1,720-foot
bridge makes one community from two sides of the river,
elegantly joining the Oregon Health & Science University’s
South Waterfront Campus on the west bank with the Oregon
Museum of Science and Industry (OMSI) to the east.
Though functionally and economically indispensable, the
glamorous crossing is just one of many moving parts that con-
tributed to a transportation effort nearly heroic in its complex-
ity. I had a taste of the project’s intricacies in a recent meeting.
Seated around a conference table in TriMet’s Portland offices
were 11 landscape architects, including both public and private
practitioners, who had a hand in shaping the alignment’s loca-
tion, the design of its 10 stations, plantings and stormwater
mitigation, bicycle and pedestrian routes, and wayfinding. The
conversation quickly turned reflective—most in the room had
contributed to earlier light rail efforts, and some could trace
their involvement to the installation of the city’s first MAX—or
Metropolitan Area Express—line in 1986.
Only the third light rail line completed in the United States,
following San Diego’s (1981) and Buffalo’s (1984), Portland’s
Blue Line connected the city to its eastern suburb of Gresham
and was the direct result of community activism. After the
98 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016
defeat of the Mount Hood Freeway in 1974—which would
have eviscerated neighborhoods in the southeast section of
the city—Portland area residents pressed for light rail instead
of bus transit along the crowded corridor. TriMet (then the
Tri-County Metropolitan Transportation District of Oregon),
originally established to operate a regional bus system, sud-
denly found itself at the leading edge of light rail planning.
With the addition of each new section, the agency refined
its approach. Today Portland’s transit riders experience that
evolution: hopping from the Blue to the Red, Yellow, Green,
and Orange lines provides a strange sense of time travel. In
this way the Orange Line is a retrospective of Portland transit
projects, embodying what the agency has learned and revealing
the increasing clout of transit in this city.
“This not only represents a transect in the sense of physical
space, but it is also a transect of readiness—readiness for
things urban,” emphasizes TriMet’s Batty. A ride on the Orange
Line suggests that the transect was seamless, when in fact it
came together in two parts. To meet the project’s target 2015
completion, TriMet deployed two design teams, each working
from opposite ends of the alignment toward the Willamette
River, known as the “west segment” and “east segment” dur-
ing planning and construction. The urban design of each seg-
ment was managed by TriMet landscape architects Elizabeth
Higgins, Paige Schlupp, and Jeb Doran, ASLA, who oversaw
every facet and phase of the project. In addition to light rail,
this composite infrastructure included stormwater treatment,
ecosystem restoration, reforestation, alternative energy gen-
ABOVE
The project’s
286 bioswales treat
34 acres of runoff.
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 99
N
WILLAMETTE RIVER
OLDWATERAVENUE
SE CARUTHERS STREET
NEW
WATERAVENUE
McLOUGHLINBOULEVARDVIADUCT
SE4THAVENUE
OMSI
PORTLAND
OPERA
McCOY MILLWORK
MAYER/REED,RIGHT
eration, 25 public art installations,
and miles of improved pedestrian
and bicycle access.
Spliced into downtown Portland,
the westernmost segment encom-
passes two stations and nearly a
mile of track, stretching from the
Yellow Line terminus, near Port-
land State University, to the foot
of the new bridge. Led by TriMet’s
Higgins, the west segment team
included Brian McCarter, FASLA,
of ZGF Architects, in charge of
urban design and station architecture; and Marianne Zarkin,
ASLA, whose firm, Marianne Zarkin Landscape Architects,
was responsible for the planting and irrigation design.
The eastern segment begins on the Willamette’s east bank, at
the Oregon Museum of Science and Industry, where it bends
south through a train track-laced swath of rail yards and former
warehouses. From here the Orange Line stitches itself, mostly
at grade, through a series of eight different neighborhoods be-
fore crossing the county line and culminating at a freshly built
park-and-ride garage in Oak Grove. TriMet assigned two urban
design leads, Schlupp and Doran, to wrangle the 6.1-mile seg-
ment, which includes eight stations and glides through a wildly
diverserangeoflandusesandcharacter.Froma110-acrerailyard
tosingle-familyhousestoagolfcourse,buriedstreams,
andaformerGoodwilloutletstore,thistransectexposes
both the products and tailings of more than a century
of urbanization.
“I call it a zipper,” explains Carol Mayer-Reed, FASLA,
“because it is zipping together two different kinds of
fabric: neighborhoods and the industrial core that
forms with the freight corridor.” Mayer-Reed’s mul-
tidisciplinary design studio, Mayer/Reed, steered the urban
design for this eastern stretch, “hand in glove,” as she puts it,
with Mike Faha, FASLA, of GreenWorks, PC, whose planting
design accentuates its liminal character.
The design of the stations was critical to the zipper concept:
“People aren’t used to walking through these neighborhoods,
these industrial nodes, because…why would they?” Mayer-Reed
asks. “All the development grows away from those areas, not
toward them. Yet when you put light rail stations there, you’re
asking people to go places they’ve never gone before.” This
is why landscape architecture is so important to transit, she
argues: “It really is a marketing effort. If you build a highway,
someone will always show up to drive on it. For light rail we
need to attract people on foot, and that’s much harder to do.”
The idea of creating a place where people might like to spend
time conflicts with the conventional notion of transit, which
calls for moving things along as quickly as possible.
OMSI/SE WATER STATION CONCEPT PLAN
LEGEND – Light Rail Components
EXISTING BUILDING
PROPOSED TRIMET BUILDING
HEAVY RAIL LINE
LIGHT RAIL LINE
SIGNALIZED INTERSECTION
STREET CAR
STATION PLATFORM AND SHELTER
PLANTING AREA
STORMWATER TREATMENT AREA
RAILING / FENCE
RETAINING WALL
BRIDGE ABUTMENT
STREET
STREET IMPROVEMENTS
SPECIAL PAVING
100 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016
Rather than a conduit, the Orange Line stations are places to
pause. Luminous columns tiled in handmade glass distinguish
each station. On a brisk January afternoon, I found myself
wanting to leap out at every stop just to compare, to touch
them. This was a first in my many years’ acquaintance with
public transportation. “These finer details create a sense of
place,” says TriMet’s Schlupp. “But they are transparent; they
let the community’s identity shine through.”
Schlupp’s comments echo a common refrain among design
team members: the notion of a station as a place. This philoso-
phy was forged through decades of transit experimentation,
says Bob Hastings, agency architect for TriMet. “What we’ve
learned over the years is the importance of including both ele-
ments of continuity and elements of distinction. Elements of
distinction are really about the human interaction and about
cultural identity—how you connect at a neighborhood level.”
Hastings provided design review for the entire rail line, man-
aged its rigorous sustainability program, and propelled the
project’s public involvement goals. These were inspired by the
Possibilities Project, what Hastings calls “a guerrilla exercise”
to engage future Orange Line neighbors in discussions about
design and community context.
Led by the artist Tad Savinar, the
grassroots effort also addressed
project and budget challenges, de-
velopment opportunities, and sus-
tainable practices. This outreach
took place in 2010 and early 2011,
after the Orange Line’s prelimi-
nary engineering phase but before
final design. TriMet’s landscape
architects credit the process with
galvanizing community design
aspirations and reducing the project’s environmental impacts.
“Without a doubt, we would not have had a net-zero park-
and-ride facility without the community pushing for it,” says
TriMet’s Doran, who managed the Milwaukie and Clackamas
County portion of the east segment. “The agency supported
solar infrastructure but was not ready to insist that we spend
the extra money for it.”
The SE Park Avenue Park & Ride, in Oak Grove, is a punctua-
tion mark for the line and for TriMet’s community engage-
ment process. By the time the garage design began, the agency
LEFT
The artist Bill Will’s
installation, Passage,
refers to a stream
that once flowed near
SE 17th Avenue.
OPPOSITE
The 38 rowboats and
wavelike plantings are
intended to be dynamic
when seen from a train
or bike.
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 101
GREENWORKS,PC
had built a strong enough relationship with nearby residents
that it invited them to participate in design development and
reviews with designers GBD Architects and PLACE Studio.
The result is a structure whose low profile belies its 401 car
and 102 bike parking spaces. Cradled in a scoop of hillside
that collects and treats stormwater, the building is crisscrossed
with a scheme of angled gutters that highlight the descent of
the region’s frequent rain. The rest of the facade is fringed
with weathered steel spires that evoke the reeds that once
grew along the neighborhood’s long-buried creek. The overall
effect is a bit chaotic but will be tempered as the building is
claimed by its site: Moss and streaks of rust already inscribe
its ground line, and scrambling China blue vines and star
jasmine subdue the steel piles. In time the concrete and cars
will be cloaked in tall stands of Oregon white oak, Douglas
fir, and western red cedar, consistent with the neighborhood’s
desire to build a forest.
The Orange Line vibrates with this promise of growth, whether
of adjacent development opportunities or urban reforesta-
tion. “We considered the landscape aspect of this project in
ecological terms,” says GreenWorks’s Faha. He compares the
102 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016
N
ACCESS DRIVE
PEDESTRIAN
BRIDGE
UNION PACIFIC RAILROAD
JOHN
SON
CREEK
TACOMAOVERPASS
STEPS W/
HANDRAIL
RESTORATION
PLANTING
BRIDGE
CONCRETE
STAMPING
SE MCLOUGHLIN BOULEVARD (99E)
ACCESSDRIVE
ART LOCATION
EXISTING
BUS STOP
ART LOCATION
STATION
PEDLETON
WOOLEN
MILLS
SPRINGWATERCORRIDORTRAIL
MULTI-USE
TRAIL
PROPERTYLINE
BIKE
SHELTER
SUBSTATION
SIG. COM.
MAYER/REED
planting design to restoration of an urban clear-cut: “What are
the pioneer species needed in these industrialized areas to start
an early repair? We thought long-term about the climax forest
that was needed to stitch those neighborhoods and the light rail
line together over time.” In other places creeks were daylighted,
riparian verges restored, and at the SE Tacoma Street station
(once a Goodwill megastore), waiting transit riders can zigzag
along a graceful viewing platform to observe a recently unfet-
tered stretch of Johnson Creek.
Community participation is evident in investments like these,
as well as in the fastidious railing and paving details and big
luxurious plantings throughout. In addition, each of the 10
stations features a site-specific art installation, ranging in scope
and tactic from poetry stamped in concrete to enormous earth-
cast wheels to the great white bridge itself, whose nighttime
illumination keeps a finger on the pulse of the river, changing
color to reflect a shift in water temperature or flow.
Though representative, and perhaps aspirational, these ges-
tures are not always as transparent as TriMet claims. The
designers only hint that allowing a neighborhood’s character
to shine through might not be desirable in some areas. In
fact, several Orange Line stations strive to reflect “place” in
spots many would describe as placeless. This includes the
nondescript terrain of abandoned big box stores, or swollen
arterials—like SE 17th Avenue, which the project transformed
into a mile-long sculpture garden of 38 rusted steel rowboats,
commemorating another buried stream.
The stations sit less eas-
ily, however, in areas with a
more appreciable identity—
for instance in downtown
Milwaukie, or especially in
Portland’s historic Halprin
District, where the Orange
Line stops at Lincoln Street
and SW 3rd Avenue. The Lin-
coln Street station is positioned as if it were a new measure in
Lawrence Halprin’s Open Space Sequence, an inward-looking
1960s network of pedestrian corridors and parks—including
Lovejoy Plaza and Pettygrove Park—sheltered by high-rise
apartment and office buildings and towering shade trees.
Here cues to Halprin’s legacy were carefully preserved by
ZGF in original aggregate paving and the nodding profiles of
replacement streetlights. But in a district marked by interior
activity and discovery of what is hidden, the new train platform
feels painfully exposed. This is owing to the loss of dozens
of London plane trees, which once created a “forest” along
Lincoln Street, according to Marianne Zarkin. The widening
of the street for light rail and stormwater planters required the
removal of the trees, while the configuration of underground
utilities allowed the replacement of only a handful. “It was
very, very difficult,” says Zarkin. (TriMet states that it replaced
45 of the 48 trees taken from the right-of-way.)
In all, the Orange Line spelled the demise of more than 800
trees, although 3,325 new specimens were incorporated into
SE TACOMA/JOHNSON CREEK STATION CONCEPT PLAN
LEGEND – Light Rail Components
HEAVY RAIL & CROSSING
LIGHT RAIL LINE & CROSSING
EXISTING STREETS
STREET IMPROVEMENTS
EXISTING BUILDING
PROPOSED BUILDING
RETAINING WALL / SOUND WALL
SAFETY WALL
FENCE
RAILING
STATION PLATFORM/SHELTER
STORMWATER PLANTING
LANDSCAPE PLANTING
SEEDED AREA
PERVIOUS PAVING
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 103
TOP LEFT
ESA Vigil–Agrimis led
an effort to restore
salmon habitat at
Johnson Creek.
TOP RIGHT
Lynn Basa’s
handcrafted glass
mosaic evokes salmon
returning to the creek.
INSET
Hundreds of new
bike spaces were
constructed, many
in covered open-air
shelters at the SE
Tacoma/Johnson Creek
station.
104 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016
LEFT
The Milwaukie station
negotiates a complex
crossing adjacent to
a freight rail line.
INSET
Though town leaders
pushed for a more
central location,
the Milwaukie station
seems to be spurring
increased activity
and development.
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 105
SEMONROESTREET
SEWASHINGTONSTREET
SEADAMSSTREET
COVERED
BIKE RACK
SE 21ST AVENUE
SELAKEROAD
SEEDED
AREA
STATION PLATFORM
AND SHELTER
N
MAYER/REED,TOP
planting plans that introduced
more than nine acres of land-
scape to the urban corridor—
more often than not into gray-
field sites and along the back-
sides of wizened industry. These
humble working edges are
thickened with ample buffers of
young northwest conifers; un-
derfoot are bold swaths of plants
that read well from a train, in-
cluding grasses and leathery na-
tives like Oregon grape, salal,
and kinnikinnick. The roofs of
alignment bike facilities, signal
communications buildings, and
substations, and even a 200-foot section of track, are carpeted
with a jewel-toned tangle of Sedum.
This vegetated trackway may be a dubious consolation for
the Lincoln Street neighbors—the only station where it was
used—but its installation highlights the synergy that has come
to characterize Portland’s transit-building team. To mitigate the
nearly relentless concrete and absorb a modicum of stormwater,
TriMet’s designers persuaded the City of Portland, alignment
engineers, and the contractor, Stacy and Witbeck, to lay out the
one-inch-thick blanket of Sedum two years before the arrival of
the first trains. This allowed a sufficient testing and establish-
ment period: Although planted trackways have grown popular
in Europe, to date they’ve gained little traction in North Amer-
ica. A sympathetic regulatory environment made it all possible,
according to TriMet’s Hastings: “We had already tested ecoroofs
as an industry,” he explains. “We knew how they performed, we
knew the materials, and we had a city that understood that we
were essentially installing an ecoroof on the trackway.”
The designers around the table with me point out that such
consilience and willingness to experiment is the result of more
than 30 years of working hard, together. “We now have a shared
language with our team that transcends urban design and
landscape architecture and includes engineering,” says Jeramie
Shane, ASLA, who served as project manager for Mayer/Reed.
“It’s symbiotic.”
This expansive approach to infrastructure is visible in the 286
bioswales that trace the tracks, crammed with water-loving
Carex and Juncus, and in lovingly detailed sound and retain-
ing walls that integrate, rather than separate, the transit line
and its communities. But it may be most strongly conveyed
by the early assimilation of art into the rail line’s design and
construction. The light display on the bridge, otherwise pro-
hibitive, was incorporated into the design at the preliminary
engineering phase to ensure a cost-effective installation under
the structure’s design/build contract. TriMet’s robust public
art program serves as a model for public art in transit, largely
MILWAUKIE/MAIN STATION CONCEPT PLAN
LEGEND – Light Rail Components
HEAVY RAIL & CROSSING
LIGHT RAIL LINE & CROSSING
EXISTING STREETS
STREET IMPROVEMENTS
EXISTING BUILDING
PROPOSED BUILDING
RETAINING WALL
SAFETY WALL
FENCE
RAILING
STATION PLATFORM/SHELTER
STORMWATER PLANTING
LANDSCAPE PLANTING
SEEDED AREA
REINFORCED TURF
COBBLE PAVING
SPECIAL PAVING
106 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016
because it has artists on the payroll. “This is key to our suc-
cess,” stresses Mary Priester, the program’s manager. “Transit
is a unique environment, driven by engineering and practical
considerations that art programs are not necessarily subject to.”
Like connective tissue, the Orange Line is capable of flexing,
growing, and adapting over time. TriMet and consultant
designers never viewed the alignment as an inert corridor,
describing it instead as a living entity that both initiates and
responds to change. “Are we trying to solve a transportation
problem?” asks TriMet’s Batty. “No, we’re trying to solve an
urban design problem, which we’re defining as landscape
architects: We’re trying to create positive human habitat.
When you stop seeing these projects as infrastructure and
start seeing them as our habitat, you have to start seeing the
concept of succession in them. And that allows you to see how
malleable the city is.
“We didn’t solve an engineering problem and then tell the
public that we could only solve an engineering problem,” Batty
says. “We solved for the urban design problem and budgeted
for that,” he continues, to explain in part the project’s total bill,
which came in more than $40 million under budget. “People
want good places, walkable places, good urban design. They
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 107
OPPOSITE
Railings feature
Milwaukie’s symbolic
dogwood flower and
aim to impart a
small-town feeling.
RIGHT
A granite streambed
was carved by Brian
Goldbloom to convey
stormwater.
INSET
Stormwater planters
edge a future
development site at
the Milwaukie station.
108 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016
want infrastructure that is frugal and serves its purpose, but
that has some dedication to aesthetic issues, including scale,
appropriateness, and context—both historic and looking for-
ward. They want projects that facilitate the future.”
“We have lived in this community for a long time,” adds Mayer-
Reed, “and we see the results of every move we make.”
BETSY ANDERSON, ASSOCIATE ASLA, IS A RECENT MLA GRADUATE OFTHE UNI-
VERSITY OF WASHINGTON. SHE IS CURRENTLY BASED IN SEATTLE, WHERE SHE
WORKS FOR THE NATIONAL PARK SERVICE.
Project Credits
OWNER TRIMET, PORTLAND, OREGON. EAST SIDE: 8 STA-
TIONS PRIME CONSULTANT DAVID EVANS AND ASSOCI-
ATES, PORTLAND, OREGON. URBAN DESIGN TASK LEAD
MAYER/REED, INC., PORTLAND, OREGON. PLANTING AND
IRRIGATIONDESIGN;STORMWATERFACILITIESANDGREEN
ROOFSGREENWORKS,PC,PORTLAND,OREGON.FLOODPLAIN
RESTORATION DESIGN AT SE TACOMA/JOHNSON CREEK
STATION AND WATERWAY CROSSINGS ESA VIGIL-AGRIMIS,
PORTLAND,OREGON.STATIONARCHITECTUREANDKELLOGG
BRIDGE DESIGN WATERLEAF ARCHITECTURE, PORTLAND,
OREGON. SE PARK AVENUE PARK & RIDE DESIGN/BUILD
TEAMSKANSKABUILDINGUSA,NEWYORK;GBDARCHITECTS,
PORTLAND, OREGON; PLACE STUDIO, PORTLAND, OREGON.
WEST SIDE: 2 STATIONS PRIME CONSULTANT CH2M, PORT-
LAND, OREGON. URBAN DESIGN TASK LEAD AND STATION
ARCHITECTURE; STREETSCAPE, GREEN INFRASTRUCTURE,
MULTIMODAL DESIGN, HARBOR DRIVE BRIDGE ARCHI-
TECTURE ZGF ARCHITECTS LLP, PORTLAND, OREGON. AC-
TIVE TRANSPORTATION DESIGN ALTA PLANNING + DESIGN,
PORTLAND, OREGON. PLANTING AND IRRIGATION DESIGN
MARIANNE ZARKIN LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS, PORTLAND,
OREGON. COLLABORATEDWITH ZGF ON STATIONARCHITECTURE LEEKAARCHI-
TECTURE & PLANNING, PORTLAND, OREGON. OTHER KEY CONSULTANTS STATION
PAVING, PLAZAS, CUSTOM RAILINGS, FURNISHINGS AND SHELTERS DESIGN,
BICYCLEANDPEDESTRIANFACILITIESDESIGN;SIGNAGE/WAYFINDINGDESIGN;
JOHNSONCREEKANDHALPRINDISTRICTINTERPRETIVEPANELSMAYER/REED,
INC., PORTLAND, OREGON. SYSTEMS BUILDING DESIGN HENNEBERY EDDY
ARCHITECTS, INC., PORTLAND, OREGON. GREEN ROOF DESIGN FOR SYSTEMS
BUILDINGS LANGO HANSEN LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS, PORTLAND, OREGON.
SUSTAINABILITY STRATEGIES VIA ARCHITECTURE, SEATTLE. GENERAL CON-
TRACTOR STACY AND WITBECK, INC., PORTLAND, OREGON. TILIKUM CROSSING
BRIDGE DESIGN DONALD MACDONALDARCHITECTS, SAN FRANCISCO. CONCEP-
TUAL AND PRELIMINARY ENGINEERING AND OWNER’S TECHNICAL RESOURCE
HNTB, PORTLAND, OREGON. FINAL DESIGN AND ENGINEER OF RECORD T. Y. LIN
INTERNATIONAL GROUP, SAN FRANCISCO. CONTRACTOR KIEWIT INFRASTRUC-
TURE WEST COMPANY, OLYMPIA, WASHINGTON.
LEFT
The SE Park Avenue
Park & Ride varies
the terrain of a major
regional arterial.
OPPOSITE
The end of the line
came with a much-
needed gathering
space for the Oak
Grove neighborhood.
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 109

More Related Content

What's hot

The Benefits Of Public Transport
The Benefits Of Public TransportThe Benefits Of Public Transport
The Benefits Of Public TransportGen Ndoci
 
Passenger Rail vs. Multi-Modal Transportation Corridor
Passenger Rail vs. Multi-Modal Transportation CorridorPassenger Rail vs. Multi-Modal Transportation Corridor
Passenger Rail vs. Multi-Modal Transportation Corridorbudcolligan
 
2002-Youve-Got-Connections
2002-Youve-Got-Connections2002-Youve-Got-Connections
2002-Youve-Got-ConnectionsKatherine Brower
 
Transport and communication
Transport and communicationTransport and communication
Transport and communicationAli jili'ow
 
Olympic Discovery Trail
Olympic Discovery TrailOlympic Discovery Trail
Olympic Discovery Trailwprf
 
2016 Engineering Excellence Diamond Award Panels
2016 Engineering Excellence Diamond Award Panels2016 Engineering Excellence Diamond Award Panels
2016 Engineering Excellence Diamond Award PanelsACEC New York
 
Feasibility of Straddling Bus – Smart Transportation Technology for a city of...
Feasibility of Straddling Bus – Smart Transportation Technology for a city of...Feasibility of Straddling Bus – Smart Transportation Technology for a city of...
Feasibility of Straddling Bus – Smart Transportation Technology for a city of...Sundar Surya Ganesh Gonella
 
Metra Presentation - A Vision for the Fulton Market Area
Metra Presentation - A Vision for the Fulton Market AreaMetra Presentation - A Vision for the Fulton Market Area
Metra Presentation - A Vision for the Fulton Market AreaWest Central Association
 
Inland waterways final
Inland waterways finalInland waterways final
Inland waterways finalAjay Chathli
 

What's hot (20)

TOD presentation
TOD presentationTOD presentation
TOD presentation
 
The Benefits Of Public Transport
The Benefits Of Public TransportThe Benefits Of Public Transport
The Benefits Of Public Transport
 
Passenger Rail vs. Multi-Modal Transportation Corridor
Passenger Rail vs. Multi-Modal Transportation CorridorPassenger Rail vs. Multi-Modal Transportation Corridor
Passenger Rail vs. Multi-Modal Transportation Corridor
 
2002-Youve-Got-Connections
2002-Youve-Got-Connections2002-Youve-Got-Connections
2002-Youve-Got-Connections
 
Nationalization of Inland Water Navigation
Nationalization of Inland Water NavigationNationalization of Inland Water Navigation
Nationalization of Inland Water Navigation
 
Transport and communication
Transport and communicationTransport and communication
Transport and communication
 
Olympic Discovery Trail
Olympic Discovery TrailOlympic Discovery Trail
Olympic Discovery Trail
 
2016 Engineering Excellence Diamond Award Panels
2016 Engineering Excellence Diamond Award Panels2016 Engineering Excellence Diamond Award Panels
2016 Engineering Excellence Diamond Award Panels
 
Paratransit
ParatransitParatransit
Paratransit
 
Feasibility of Straddling Bus – Smart Transportation Technology for a city of...
Feasibility of Straddling Bus – Smart Transportation Technology for a city of...Feasibility of Straddling Bus – Smart Transportation Technology for a city of...
Feasibility of Straddling Bus – Smart Transportation Technology for a city of...
 
CIVICCRUSADERS
CIVICCRUSADERSCIVICCRUSADERS
CIVICCRUSADERS
 
2040 RTP Rollout Event Presentation
2040 RTP Rollout Event Presentation2040 RTP Rollout Event Presentation
2040 RTP Rollout Event Presentation
 
public transport
public transportpublic transport
public transport
 
Metra Station - Fulton Market/Kinzie
Metra Station - Fulton Market/KinzieMetra Station - Fulton Market/Kinzie
Metra Station - Fulton Market/Kinzie
 
Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1
 
First-Last Mile Presentation
First-Last Mile PresentationFirst-Last Mile Presentation
First-Last Mile Presentation
 
Metra Presentation - A Vision for the Fulton Market Area
Metra Presentation - A Vision for the Fulton Market AreaMetra Presentation - A Vision for the Fulton Market Area
Metra Presentation - A Vision for the Fulton Market Area
 
Public transport
Public transportPublic transport
Public transport
 
Inland waterways final
Inland waterways finalInland waterways final
Inland waterways final
 
Union station
Union stationUnion station
Union station
 

Similar to Portland's Orange Line Connects Communities with Transit and Landscape

The Best of CityLab's The Future of Transportation
The Best of CityLab's The Future of TransportationThe Best of CityLab's The Future of Transportation
The Best of CityLab's The Future of TransportationThe Rockefeller Foundation
 
Rails to-green rails green space is the future for rail stations and rail cor...
Rails to-green rails green space is the future for rail stations and rail cor...Rails to-green rails green space is the future for rail stations and rail cor...
Rails to-green rails green space is the future for rail stations and rail cor...Dania Abdel-aziz
 
VC Research Final tcb
VC Research Final tcbVC Research Final tcb
VC Research Final tcbThomas Bothen
 
AJCEditorialPage5.5.13
AJCEditorialPage5.5.13AJCEditorialPage5.5.13
AJCEditorialPage5.5.13David Ibata
 
GuidryNews.com_Columbia Tap Hike and Bike Trail 2011
GuidryNews.com_Columbia Tap Hike and Bike Trail 2011GuidryNews.com_Columbia Tap Hike and Bike Trail 2011
GuidryNews.com_Columbia Tap Hike and Bike Trail 2011Jose Enriquez
 
Example of the Department of Architecture Outreach Work
Example of the Department of Architecture Outreach WorkExample of the Department of Architecture Outreach Work
Example of the Department of Architecture Outreach WorkKwesi Daniels
 
UCT Winter Report - Conway School - Final
UCT Winter Report - Conway School - FinalUCT Winter Report - Conway School - Final
UCT Winter Report - Conway School - FinalJordan Clark
 
HUNTERS POINT SOUTH_PROJECT_
HUNTERS POINT SOUTH_PROJECT_HUNTERS POINT SOUTH_PROJECT_
HUNTERS POINT SOUTH_PROJECT_Christian Gabriel
 
Daylighting the Amorsolo Creek - Participatory Design and the Revival of an U...
Daylighting the Amorsolo Creek - Participatory Design and the Revival of an U...Daylighting the Amorsolo Creek - Participatory Design and the Revival of an U...
Daylighting the Amorsolo Creek - Participatory Design and the Revival of an U...Rodelon Ramos
 
Architectural Framework For The Development Of Boat Terminals
Architectural Framework For The Development Of Boat TerminalsArchitectural Framework For The Development Of Boat Terminals
Architectural Framework For The Development Of Boat TerminalsSara Perez
 

Similar to Portland's Orange Line Connects Communities with Transit and Landscape (20)

The Best of CityLab's The Future of Transportation
The Best of CityLab's The Future of TransportationThe Best of CityLab's The Future of Transportation
The Best of CityLab's The Future of Transportation
 
Rails to-green rails green space is the future for rail stations and rail cor...
Rails to-green rails green space is the future for rail stations and rail cor...Rails to-green rails green space is the future for rail stations and rail cor...
Rails to-green rails green space is the future for rail stations and rail cor...
 
What if 280 came down
What if 280 came downWhat if 280 came down
What if 280 came down
 
VC Research Final tcb
VC Research Final tcbVC Research Final tcb
VC Research Final tcb
 
AJCEditorialPage5.5.13
AJCEditorialPage5.5.13AJCEditorialPage5.5.13
AJCEditorialPage5.5.13
 
GuidryNews.com_Columbia Tap Hike and Bike Trail 2011
GuidryNews.com_Columbia Tap Hike and Bike Trail 2011GuidryNews.com_Columbia Tap Hike and Bike Trail 2011
GuidryNews.com_Columbia Tap Hike and Bike Trail 2011
 
Example of the Department of Architecture Outreach Work
Example of the Department of Architecture Outreach WorkExample of the Department of Architecture Outreach Work
Example of the Department of Architecture Outreach Work
 
UCT Winter Report - Conway School - Final
UCT Winter Report - Conway School - FinalUCT Winter Report - Conway School - Final
UCT Winter Report - Conway School - Final
 
05.ENTRIPS
05.ENTRIPS05.ENTRIPS
05.ENTRIPS
 
HUNTERS POINT SOUTH_PROJECT_
HUNTERS POINT SOUTH_PROJECT_HUNTERS POINT SOUTH_PROJECT_
HUNTERS POINT SOUTH_PROJECT_
 
Trichy ppt
Trichy pptTrichy ppt
Trichy ppt
 
Daylighting the Amorsolo Creek - Participatory Design and the Revival of an U...
Daylighting the Amorsolo Creek - Participatory Design and the Revival of an U...Daylighting the Amorsolo Creek - Participatory Design and the Revival of an U...
Daylighting the Amorsolo Creek - Participatory Design and the Revival of an U...
 
The Tube
The Tube The Tube
The Tube
 
TOD Honolulu
TOD HonoluluTOD Honolulu
TOD Honolulu
 
APWA mid atlantic awards
APWA mid atlantic awardsAPWA mid atlantic awards
APWA mid atlantic awards
 
highspeedrail_FINAL2
highspeedrail_FINAL2highspeedrail_FINAL2
highspeedrail_FINAL2
 
Architectural Framework For The Development Of Boat Terminals
Architectural Framework For The Development Of Boat TerminalsArchitectural Framework For The Development Of Boat Terminals
Architectural Framework For The Development Of Boat Terminals
 
URBAN TRANSPORTATION
URBAN TRANSPORTATIONURBAN TRANSPORTATION
URBAN TRANSPORTATION
 
Bernstein Street History
Bernstein Street HistoryBernstein Street History
Bernstein Street History
 
Development In Transportation
Development In TransportationDevelopment In Transportation
Development In Transportation
 

Portland's Orange Line Connects Communities with Transit and Landscape

  • 1. 92 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016
  • 2. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 93 ALL ALONG THE LINE OMSI/SE WATER STATION Portland’s newest bridge and light rail line slip between an opera house and a museum on the Willamette’s eastern bank. PORTLAND LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS BUILD COMMUNITY... AND A NEW LIGHT RAIL LINE. BY BETSY ANDERSON, ASSOCIATE ASLA/PHOTOGRAPHY BY BRUCE FORSTER
  • 3. 94 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 N A HOT SEPTEMBER MORNING, Portland’s Central Eastside shimmered with an unusual procession. Stand- ing two, three, and four abreast, members of the Con- federated Tribes of Grand Ronde emerged from the crowded riverbank of this industrial district turned stylish hipster haunt. In full regalia, tribal members stepped onto the city’s newest bridge and began to cross the Willamette River, from east to west. Joining them was a new light rail train—advancing at the same rhythmic pace, its cars filled with state and local leaders hovering above the river in a place no one had been before. This was the grand opening of Portland’s latest stretch of light rail, the MAX Orange Line. The inaugural crossing of the first bridge built in this river city in four decades was broadcast liberally by local television crews. Portlanders are an enthusi- astic bunch when it comes to urban infrastructure—especially transit—and the bridge, like any celebrity, has full Google cov- erage. A quick search for the opening will result in numerous video clips. As I am a Seattleite, this was my first glimpse of the splashy new addition to our southern neighbor’s already healthy and envied public transportation network. Dedicated to transit, cyclists, and pedestrians, the bridge has received considerable attention not for its many attributes but for something it lacks—cars. Called Tilikum Crossing, Bridge of the People, the lithe cable- stayed structure honors the Chinookan belief that crossing a river builds community. It is the linchpin of a 7.3-mile transit alignment that conveys this idea from Portland’s city center to a mosaic of southeast neighborhoods and suburbs, including the town of Milwaukie in adjacent Clackamas County. Led by landscape architects on all sides and in all phases of the project, the Orange Line underscores the age-old Chinookan belief that connectivity and community are mutually dependent. In cultivating both, its designers propose a new paradigm for transit in American cities. O
  • 4. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 95 Tilikum means “people” in Chinook Wawa, a composite in- ternational dialect that the region’s first inhabitants used to communicate with other tribes, and later with fur traders, explorers, and missionaries. It is a fitting word to describe part of the Orange Line, a collaborative $1.49 billion effort that engaged hundreds of landscape architects, architects, en- gineers, artists, and contractors, filling the desks and drafting tables of design and construction offices in the midst of the 2007–2009 recession. And these were just the consultants. Working alongside were counterparts from TriMet, the local public transit agency in charge of the new rail line (in transit circles called simply “the alignment”), and staff representing the jurisdictions through which the trains would pass. The bridge, like the rest of the alignment, was 50 percent fund- ed by the Federal Transit Administration’s New Starts program. The remaining project costs of $745 million were covered by a mixture of state and local sources. Noting my surprise that federal transportation funding could support such placemak- ing gestures, TriMet’s Sean Batty, ASLA, explained that it was possible as long as the project could guarantee a favorable cost-to-transit-benefit ratio. Batty served as the agency’s overall conceptual design manager for the project. The Federal Transit Administration (FTA) awards funding based on criteria that measure a project’s mobility improvements, environmental LEFT Eight miles of new or replaced bike lanes trace the alignment. RIGHT At Oregon Health & Science University’s South Waterfront Campus, the line crosses a restored industrial site, poised for redevelopment.
  • 5. 96 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 DOLLYHOLMES N MAX ORANGE LINE RIGHT The Tilikum Crossing bridge knits the east and westside stations of the Orange Line together. OPPOSITE, TOP The South Waterfront station area layers streetcar, bus, light rail, car, pedestrian, and bicycle traffic. OPPOSITE, BOTTOM Vegetated trackway offers hardscape relief for people and stormwater alike. /
  • 6. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 97 benefits, operating efficiencies, and cost-effectiveness against a preinvestment baseline. Layering a shared transitway onto Tilikum Crossing exponentially increased the project’s transit benefit. In lieu of buses stuck in traffic on existing crossings, a new light rail line, two unobstructed bus lines, and a city street- car could now be factored into FTA calculations. The decision to omit cars was also a cost-saving measure, one bolstered by community members who didn’t want their neighborhoods skewered by arterials and on-ramps. Instead, the 1,720-foot bridge makes one community from two sides of the river, elegantly joining the Oregon Health & Science University’s South Waterfront Campus on the west bank with the Oregon Museum of Science and Industry (OMSI) to the east. Though functionally and economically indispensable, the glamorous crossing is just one of many moving parts that con- tributed to a transportation effort nearly heroic in its complex- ity. I had a taste of the project’s intricacies in a recent meeting. Seated around a conference table in TriMet’s Portland offices were 11 landscape architects, including both public and private practitioners, who had a hand in shaping the alignment’s loca- tion, the design of its 10 stations, plantings and stormwater mitigation, bicycle and pedestrian routes, and wayfinding. The conversation quickly turned reflective—most in the room had contributed to earlier light rail efforts, and some could trace their involvement to the installation of the city’s first MAX—or Metropolitan Area Express—line in 1986. Only the third light rail line completed in the United States, following San Diego’s (1981) and Buffalo’s (1984), Portland’s Blue Line connected the city to its eastern suburb of Gresham and was the direct result of community activism. After the
  • 7. 98 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 defeat of the Mount Hood Freeway in 1974—which would have eviscerated neighborhoods in the southeast section of the city—Portland area residents pressed for light rail instead of bus transit along the crowded corridor. TriMet (then the Tri-County Metropolitan Transportation District of Oregon), originally established to operate a regional bus system, sud- denly found itself at the leading edge of light rail planning. With the addition of each new section, the agency refined its approach. Today Portland’s transit riders experience that evolution: hopping from the Blue to the Red, Yellow, Green, and Orange lines provides a strange sense of time travel. In this way the Orange Line is a retrospective of Portland transit projects, embodying what the agency has learned and revealing the increasing clout of transit in this city. “This not only represents a transect in the sense of physical space, but it is also a transect of readiness—readiness for things urban,” emphasizes TriMet’s Batty. A ride on the Orange Line suggests that the transect was seamless, when in fact it came together in two parts. To meet the project’s target 2015 completion, TriMet deployed two design teams, each working from opposite ends of the alignment toward the Willamette River, known as the “west segment” and “east segment” dur- ing planning and construction. The urban design of each seg- ment was managed by TriMet landscape architects Elizabeth Higgins, Paige Schlupp, and Jeb Doran, ASLA, who oversaw every facet and phase of the project. In addition to light rail, this composite infrastructure included stormwater treatment, ecosystem restoration, reforestation, alternative energy gen- ABOVE The project’s 286 bioswales treat 34 acres of runoff.
  • 8. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 99 N WILLAMETTE RIVER OLDWATERAVENUE SE CARUTHERS STREET NEW WATERAVENUE McLOUGHLINBOULEVARDVIADUCT SE4THAVENUE OMSI PORTLAND OPERA McCOY MILLWORK MAYER/REED,RIGHT eration, 25 public art installations, and miles of improved pedestrian and bicycle access. Spliced into downtown Portland, the westernmost segment encom- passes two stations and nearly a mile of track, stretching from the Yellow Line terminus, near Port- land State University, to the foot of the new bridge. Led by TriMet’s Higgins, the west segment team included Brian McCarter, FASLA, of ZGF Architects, in charge of urban design and station architecture; and Marianne Zarkin, ASLA, whose firm, Marianne Zarkin Landscape Architects, was responsible for the planting and irrigation design. The eastern segment begins on the Willamette’s east bank, at the Oregon Museum of Science and Industry, where it bends south through a train track-laced swath of rail yards and former warehouses. From here the Orange Line stitches itself, mostly at grade, through a series of eight different neighborhoods be- fore crossing the county line and culminating at a freshly built park-and-ride garage in Oak Grove. TriMet assigned two urban design leads, Schlupp and Doran, to wrangle the 6.1-mile seg- ment, which includes eight stations and glides through a wildly diverserangeoflandusesandcharacter.Froma110-acrerailyard tosingle-familyhousestoagolfcourse,buriedstreams, andaformerGoodwilloutletstore,thistransectexposes both the products and tailings of more than a century of urbanization. “I call it a zipper,” explains Carol Mayer-Reed, FASLA, “because it is zipping together two different kinds of fabric: neighborhoods and the industrial core that forms with the freight corridor.” Mayer-Reed’s mul- tidisciplinary design studio, Mayer/Reed, steered the urban design for this eastern stretch, “hand in glove,” as she puts it, with Mike Faha, FASLA, of GreenWorks, PC, whose planting design accentuates its liminal character. The design of the stations was critical to the zipper concept: “People aren’t used to walking through these neighborhoods, these industrial nodes, because…why would they?” Mayer-Reed asks. “All the development grows away from those areas, not toward them. Yet when you put light rail stations there, you’re asking people to go places they’ve never gone before.” This is why landscape architecture is so important to transit, she argues: “It really is a marketing effort. If you build a highway, someone will always show up to drive on it. For light rail we need to attract people on foot, and that’s much harder to do.” The idea of creating a place where people might like to spend time conflicts with the conventional notion of transit, which calls for moving things along as quickly as possible. OMSI/SE WATER STATION CONCEPT PLAN LEGEND – Light Rail Components EXISTING BUILDING PROPOSED TRIMET BUILDING HEAVY RAIL LINE LIGHT RAIL LINE SIGNALIZED INTERSECTION STREET CAR STATION PLATFORM AND SHELTER PLANTING AREA STORMWATER TREATMENT AREA RAILING / FENCE RETAINING WALL BRIDGE ABUTMENT STREET STREET IMPROVEMENTS SPECIAL PAVING
  • 9. 100 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 Rather than a conduit, the Orange Line stations are places to pause. Luminous columns tiled in handmade glass distinguish each station. On a brisk January afternoon, I found myself wanting to leap out at every stop just to compare, to touch them. This was a first in my many years’ acquaintance with public transportation. “These finer details create a sense of place,” says TriMet’s Schlupp. “But they are transparent; they let the community’s identity shine through.” Schlupp’s comments echo a common refrain among design team members: the notion of a station as a place. This philoso- phy was forged through decades of transit experimentation, says Bob Hastings, agency architect for TriMet. “What we’ve learned over the years is the importance of including both ele- ments of continuity and elements of distinction. Elements of distinction are really about the human interaction and about cultural identity—how you connect at a neighborhood level.” Hastings provided design review for the entire rail line, man- aged its rigorous sustainability program, and propelled the project’s public involvement goals. These were inspired by the Possibilities Project, what Hastings calls “a guerrilla exercise” to engage future Orange Line neighbors in discussions about design and community context. Led by the artist Tad Savinar, the grassroots effort also addressed project and budget challenges, de- velopment opportunities, and sus- tainable practices. This outreach took place in 2010 and early 2011, after the Orange Line’s prelimi- nary engineering phase but before final design. TriMet’s landscape architects credit the process with galvanizing community design aspirations and reducing the project’s environmental impacts. “Without a doubt, we would not have had a net-zero park- and-ride facility without the community pushing for it,” says TriMet’s Doran, who managed the Milwaukie and Clackamas County portion of the east segment. “The agency supported solar infrastructure but was not ready to insist that we spend the extra money for it.” The SE Park Avenue Park & Ride, in Oak Grove, is a punctua- tion mark for the line and for TriMet’s community engage- ment process. By the time the garage design began, the agency LEFT The artist Bill Will’s installation, Passage, refers to a stream that once flowed near SE 17th Avenue. OPPOSITE The 38 rowboats and wavelike plantings are intended to be dynamic when seen from a train or bike.
  • 10. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 101 GREENWORKS,PC had built a strong enough relationship with nearby residents that it invited them to participate in design development and reviews with designers GBD Architects and PLACE Studio. The result is a structure whose low profile belies its 401 car and 102 bike parking spaces. Cradled in a scoop of hillside that collects and treats stormwater, the building is crisscrossed with a scheme of angled gutters that highlight the descent of the region’s frequent rain. The rest of the facade is fringed with weathered steel spires that evoke the reeds that once grew along the neighborhood’s long-buried creek. The overall effect is a bit chaotic but will be tempered as the building is claimed by its site: Moss and streaks of rust already inscribe its ground line, and scrambling China blue vines and star jasmine subdue the steel piles. In time the concrete and cars will be cloaked in tall stands of Oregon white oak, Douglas fir, and western red cedar, consistent with the neighborhood’s desire to build a forest. The Orange Line vibrates with this promise of growth, whether of adjacent development opportunities or urban reforesta- tion. “We considered the landscape aspect of this project in ecological terms,” says GreenWorks’s Faha. He compares the
  • 11. 102 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 N ACCESS DRIVE PEDESTRIAN BRIDGE UNION PACIFIC RAILROAD JOHN SON CREEK TACOMAOVERPASS STEPS W/ HANDRAIL RESTORATION PLANTING BRIDGE CONCRETE STAMPING SE MCLOUGHLIN BOULEVARD (99E) ACCESSDRIVE ART LOCATION EXISTING BUS STOP ART LOCATION STATION PEDLETON WOOLEN MILLS SPRINGWATERCORRIDORTRAIL MULTI-USE TRAIL PROPERTYLINE BIKE SHELTER SUBSTATION SIG. COM. MAYER/REED planting design to restoration of an urban clear-cut: “What are the pioneer species needed in these industrialized areas to start an early repair? We thought long-term about the climax forest that was needed to stitch those neighborhoods and the light rail line together over time.” In other places creeks were daylighted, riparian verges restored, and at the SE Tacoma Street station (once a Goodwill megastore), waiting transit riders can zigzag along a graceful viewing platform to observe a recently unfet- tered stretch of Johnson Creek. Community participation is evident in investments like these, as well as in the fastidious railing and paving details and big luxurious plantings throughout. In addition, each of the 10 stations features a site-specific art installation, ranging in scope and tactic from poetry stamped in concrete to enormous earth- cast wheels to the great white bridge itself, whose nighttime illumination keeps a finger on the pulse of the river, changing color to reflect a shift in water temperature or flow. Though representative, and perhaps aspirational, these ges- tures are not always as transparent as TriMet claims. The designers only hint that allowing a neighborhood’s character to shine through might not be desirable in some areas. In fact, several Orange Line stations strive to reflect “place” in spots many would describe as placeless. This includes the nondescript terrain of abandoned big box stores, or swollen arterials—like SE 17th Avenue, which the project transformed into a mile-long sculpture garden of 38 rusted steel rowboats, commemorating another buried stream. The stations sit less eas- ily, however, in areas with a more appreciable identity— for instance in downtown Milwaukie, or especially in Portland’s historic Halprin District, where the Orange Line stops at Lincoln Street and SW 3rd Avenue. The Lin- coln Street station is positioned as if it were a new measure in Lawrence Halprin’s Open Space Sequence, an inward-looking 1960s network of pedestrian corridors and parks—including Lovejoy Plaza and Pettygrove Park—sheltered by high-rise apartment and office buildings and towering shade trees. Here cues to Halprin’s legacy were carefully preserved by ZGF in original aggregate paving and the nodding profiles of replacement streetlights. But in a district marked by interior activity and discovery of what is hidden, the new train platform feels painfully exposed. This is owing to the loss of dozens of London plane trees, which once created a “forest” along Lincoln Street, according to Marianne Zarkin. The widening of the street for light rail and stormwater planters required the removal of the trees, while the configuration of underground utilities allowed the replacement of only a handful. “It was very, very difficult,” says Zarkin. (TriMet states that it replaced 45 of the 48 trees taken from the right-of-way.) In all, the Orange Line spelled the demise of more than 800 trees, although 3,325 new specimens were incorporated into SE TACOMA/JOHNSON CREEK STATION CONCEPT PLAN LEGEND – Light Rail Components HEAVY RAIL & CROSSING LIGHT RAIL LINE & CROSSING EXISTING STREETS STREET IMPROVEMENTS EXISTING BUILDING PROPOSED BUILDING RETAINING WALL / SOUND WALL SAFETY WALL FENCE RAILING STATION PLATFORM/SHELTER STORMWATER PLANTING LANDSCAPE PLANTING SEEDED AREA PERVIOUS PAVING
  • 12. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 103 TOP LEFT ESA Vigil–Agrimis led an effort to restore salmon habitat at Johnson Creek. TOP RIGHT Lynn Basa’s handcrafted glass mosaic evokes salmon returning to the creek. INSET Hundreds of new bike spaces were constructed, many in covered open-air shelters at the SE Tacoma/Johnson Creek station.
  • 13. 104 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 LEFT The Milwaukie station negotiates a complex crossing adjacent to a freight rail line. INSET Though town leaders pushed for a more central location, the Milwaukie station seems to be spurring increased activity and development.
  • 14. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 105 SEMONROESTREET SEWASHINGTONSTREET SEADAMSSTREET COVERED BIKE RACK SE 21ST AVENUE SELAKEROAD SEEDED AREA STATION PLATFORM AND SHELTER N MAYER/REED,TOP planting plans that introduced more than nine acres of land- scape to the urban corridor— more often than not into gray- field sites and along the back- sides of wizened industry. These humble working edges are thickened with ample buffers of young northwest conifers; un- derfoot are bold swaths of plants that read well from a train, in- cluding grasses and leathery na- tives like Oregon grape, salal, and kinnikinnick. The roofs of alignment bike facilities, signal communications buildings, and substations, and even a 200-foot section of track, are carpeted with a jewel-toned tangle of Sedum. This vegetated trackway may be a dubious consolation for the Lincoln Street neighbors—the only station where it was used—but its installation highlights the synergy that has come to characterize Portland’s transit-building team. To mitigate the nearly relentless concrete and absorb a modicum of stormwater, TriMet’s designers persuaded the City of Portland, alignment engineers, and the contractor, Stacy and Witbeck, to lay out the one-inch-thick blanket of Sedum two years before the arrival of the first trains. This allowed a sufficient testing and establish- ment period: Although planted trackways have grown popular in Europe, to date they’ve gained little traction in North Amer- ica. A sympathetic regulatory environment made it all possible, according to TriMet’s Hastings: “We had already tested ecoroofs as an industry,” he explains. “We knew how they performed, we knew the materials, and we had a city that understood that we were essentially installing an ecoroof on the trackway.” The designers around the table with me point out that such consilience and willingness to experiment is the result of more than 30 years of working hard, together. “We now have a shared language with our team that transcends urban design and landscape architecture and includes engineering,” says Jeramie Shane, ASLA, who served as project manager for Mayer/Reed. “It’s symbiotic.” This expansive approach to infrastructure is visible in the 286 bioswales that trace the tracks, crammed with water-loving Carex and Juncus, and in lovingly detailed sound and retain- ing walls that integrate, rather than separate, the transit line and its communities. But it may be most strongly conveyed by the early assimilation of art into the rail line’s design and construction. The light display on the bridge, otherwise pro- hibitive, was incorporated into the design at the preliminary engineering phase to ensure a cost-effective installation under the structure’s design/build contract. TriMet’s robust public art program serves as a model for public art in transit, largely MILWAUKIE/MAIN STATION CONCEPT PLAN LEGEND – Light Rail Components HEAVY RAIL & CROSSING LIGHT RAIL LINE & CROSSING EXISTING STREETS STREET IMPROVEMENTS EXISTING BUILDING PROPOSED BUILDING RETAINING WALL SAFETY WALL FENCE RAILING STATION PLATFORM/SHELTER STORMWATER PLANTING LANDSCAPE PLANTING SEEDED AREA REINFORCED TURF COBBLE PAVING SPECIAL PAVING
  • 15. 106 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 because it has artists on the payroll. “This is key to our suc- cess,” stresses Mary Priester, the program’s manager. “Transit is a unique environment, driven by engineering and practical considerations that art programs are not necessarily subject to.” Like connective tissue, the Orange Line is capable of flexing, growing, and adapting over time. TriMet and consultant designers never viewed the alignment as an inert corridor, describing it instead as a living entity that both initiates and responds to change. “Are we trying to solve a transportation problem?” asks TriMet’s Batty. “No, we’re trying to solve an urban design problem, which we’re defining as landscape architects: We’re trying to create positive human habitat. When you stop seeing these projects as infrastructure and start seeing them as our habitat, you have to start seeing the concept of succession in them. And that allows you to see how malleable the city is. “We didn’t solve an engineering problem and then tell the public that we could only solve an engineering problem,” Batty says. “We solved for the urban design problem and budgeted for that,” he continues, to explain in part the project’s total bill, which came in more than $40 million under budget. “People want good places, walkable places, good urban design. They
  • 16. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 / 107 OPPOSITE Railings feature Milwaukie’s symbolic dogwood flower and aim to impart a small-town feeling. RIGHT A granite streambed was carved by Brian Goldbloom to convey stormwater. INSET Stormwater planters edge a future development site at the Milwaukie station.
  • 17. 108 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE MAY 2016 want infrastructure that is frugal and serves its purpose, but that has some dedication to aesthetic issues, including scale, appropriateness, and context—both historic and looking for- ward. They want projects that facilitate the future.” “We have lived in this community for a long time,” adds Mayer- Reed, “and we see the results of every move we make.” BETSY ANDERSON, ASSOCIATE ASLA, IS A RECENT MLA GRADUATE OFTHE UNI- VERSITY OF WASHINGTON. SHE IS CURRENTLY BASED IN SEATTLE, WHERE SHE WORKS FOR THE NATIONAL PARK SERVICE. Project Credits OWNER TRIMET, PORTLAND, OREGON. EAST SIDE: 8 STA- TIONS PRIME CONSULTANT DAVID EVANS AND ASSOCI- ATES, PORTLAND, OREGON. URBAN DESIGN TASK LEAD MAYER/REED, INC., PORTLAND, OREGON. PLANTING AND IRRIGATIONDESIGN;STORMWATERFACILITIESANDGREEN ROOFSGREENWORKS,PC,PORTLAND,OREGON.FLOODPLAIN RESTORATION DESIGN AT SE TACOMA/JOHNSON CREEK STATION AND WATERWAY CROSSINGS ESA VIGIL-AGRIMIS, PORTLAND,OREGON.STATIONARCHITECTUREANDKELLOGG BRIDGE DESIGN WATERLEAF ARCHITECTURE, PORTLAND, OREGON. SE PARK AVENUE PARK & RIDE DESIGN/BUILD TEAMSKANSKABUILDINGUSA,NEWYORK;GBDARCHITECTS, PORTLAND, OREGON; PLACE STUDIO, PORTLAND, OREGON. WEST SIDE: 2 STATIONS PRIME CONSULTANT CH2M, PORT- LAND, OREGON. URBAN DESIGN TASK LEAD AND STATION ARCHITECTURE; STREETSCAPE, GREEN INFRASTRUCTURE, MULTIMODAL DESIGN, HARBOR DRIVE BRIDGE ARCHI- TECTURE ZGF ARCHITECTS LLP, PORTLAND, OREGON. AC- TIVE TRANSPORTATION DESIGN ALTA PLANNING + DESIGN, PORTLAND, OREGON. PLANTING AND IRRIGATION DESIGN MARIANNE ZARKIN LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS, PORTLAND, OREGON. COLLABORATEDWITH ZGF ON STATIONARCHITECTURE LEEKAARCHI- TECTURE & PLANNING, PORTLAND, OREGON. OTHER KEY CONSULTANTS STATION PAVING, PLAZAS, CUSTOM RAILINGS, FURNISHINGS AND SHELTERS DESIGN, BICYCLEANDPEDESTRIANFACILITIESDESIGN;SIGNAGE/WAYFINDINGDESIGN; JOHNSONCREEKANDHALPRINDISTRICTINTERPRETIVEPANELSMAYER/REED, INC., PORTLAND, OREGON. SYSTEMS BUILDING DESIGN HENNEBERY EDDY ARCHITECTS, INC., PORTLAND, OREGON. GREEN ROOF DESIGN FOR SYSTEMS BUILDINGS LANGO HANSEN LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS, PORTLAND, OREGON. SUSTAINABILITY STRATEGIES VIA ARCHITECTURE, SEATTLE. GENERAL CON- TRACTOR STACY AND WITBECK, INC., PORTLAND, OREGON. TILIKUM CROSSING BRIDGE DESIGN DONALD MACDONALDARCHITECTS, SAN FRANCISCO. CONCEP- TUAL AND PRELIMINARY ENGINEERING AND OWNER’S TECHNICAL RESOURCE HNTB, PORTLAND, OREGON. FINAL DESIGN AND ENGINEER OF RECORD T. Y. LIN INTERNATIONAL GROUP, SAN FRANCISCO. CONTRACTOR KIEWIT INFRASTRUC- TURE WEST COMPANY, OLYMPIA, WASHINGTON. LEFT The SE Park Avenue Park & Ride varies the terrain of a major regional arterial. OPPOSITE The end of the line came with a much- needed gathering space for the Oak Grove neighborhood.