SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 4
Download to read offline
CTS EMBARQ México

The fragility of the Authority-Operator and
Operators-Shareholders relationship: The
impact on the sustainability of BRT systems




Adriana Lobo
New issues arise



                                                       Engagement with soft
                                                       contractual conditions


                                                             No bid out


Traditional bus                    Traditional bus                                Government
   operators                          operators

                                             Create bus
                                             companies
                    Aware of bus
                     companies
                     functioning

                                                                     Public Agency             Finance


                                                                                   Fare


                  Weakening        Bus companies
                  credibility                                              Potential for
                                                                           bankruptcy


                                                      Companies with several
                                                       accountability issues

                                    Shareholders
Proposals

Improve legal strategies to engage traditional
private bus operators with particular emphasis
on accountability responsibilities
Create mechanisms at the institutional level to
assess the financial and managerial situation of
bus companies
Improve training programs in areas of
management and finance
CTSEMBARQ-Mexico
CTSEMBARQ-Mexico has
made important progress
in initiating training
programs for private bus
operators
CTSEMBARQ-Mexico is
currently working with bus
companies in improving
areas of operation and
management
CTSEMBARQ-Mexico is
currently doing research
on the issues of
accountability in bus
companies and preparing
solutions to these issues.

More Related Content

More from BRTCoE

Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...
Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...
Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...BRTCoE
 
Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...
Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...
Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...BRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT Lite
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT LiteWorkshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT Lite
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT LiteBRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo Mobereola
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo MobereolaWorkshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo Mobereola
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo MobereolaBRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...BRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Mobilize
Workshop Innovation in Africa - MobilizeWorkshop Innovation in Africa - Mobilize
Workshop Innovation in Africa - MobilizeBRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina Albuquerque
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina AlbuquerqueWorkshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina Albuquerque
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina AlbuquerqueBRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...BRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...BRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo Venter
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo VenterWorkshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo Venter
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo VenterBRTCoE
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence Presentation
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence PresentationWorkshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence Presentation
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence PresentationBRTCoE
 
Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...
Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...
Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...BRTCoE
 
Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...
Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...
Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...BRTCoE
 
Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...
Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...
Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...BRTCoE
 
BRT Station Design in the Urban Context
BRT Station Design in the Urban ContextBRT Station Design in the Urban Context
BRT Station Design in the Urban ContextBRTCoE
 
Zhao emotional travel 20160920 p
Zhao emotional travel 20160920 pZhao emotional travel 20160920 p
Zhao emotional travel 20160920 pBRTCoE
 
Urban Road Congestion Management - Capacity Investments and Pricing Policies
Urban Road Congestion Management - Capacity Investments and Pricing PoliciesUrban Road Congestion Management - Capacity Investments and Pricing Policies
Urban Road Congestion Management - Capacity Investments and Pricing PoliciesBRTCoE
 
Rethinking the Next Generation of BRT in China
Rethinking the Next Generation of BRT in ChinaRethinking the Next Generation of BRT in China
Rethinking the Next Generation of BRT in ChinaBRTCoE
 
Habitat III can help accelerate action on sustainable urban transport
Habitat III can help accelerate action on sustainable urban transportHabitat III can help accelerate action on sustainable urban transport
Habitat III can help accelerate action on sustainable urban transportBRTCoE
 
2016 05-30 may session ulises navarro
2016 05-30 may session ulises navarro2016 05-30 may session ulises navarro
2016 05-30 may session ulises navarroBRTCoE
 

More from BRTCoE (20)

Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...
Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...
Gabriel Oliveira - BRT in Brazil: state of the practice as from the BRT Stand...
 
Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...
Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...
Heather Allen - Why do we need to consider how women move in urban transport ...
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT Lite
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT LiteWorkshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT Lite
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Manifesto for BRT Lite
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo Mobereola
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo MobereolaWorkshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo Mobereola
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Nigeria by Dr. Dayo Mobereola
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Context, challenges & opportunities for urban...
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Mobilize
Workshop Innovation in Africa - MobilizeWorkshop Innovation in Africa - Mobilize
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Mobilize
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina Albuquerque
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina AlbuquerqueWorkshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina Albuquerque
Workshop Innovation in Africa - Day one of operations by Cristina Albuquerque
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT Lessons from Dar es Salaam by Ronald Lwak...
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT, Minibus System and Innovation in African...
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo Venter
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo VenterWorkshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo Venter
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT in South Africa by Christo Venter
 
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence Presentation
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence PresentationWorkshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence Presentation
Workshop Innovation in Africa - BRT+ Centre of Excellence Presentation
 
Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...
Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...
Camila Balbontin - Do preferences for BRT and LRT change as a voter, citizen,...
 
Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...
Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...
Cristian Navas - Testing collaborative accessibility-based engagement tools: ...
 
Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...
Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...
Juan Carlos Muñoz - Connected and automated buses. An opportunity to bring re...
 
BRT Station Design in the Urban Context
BRT Station Design in the Urban ContextBRT Station Design in the Urban Context
BRT Station Design in the Urban Context
 
Zhao emotional travel 20160920 p
Zhao emotional travel 20160920 pZhao emotional travel 20160920 p
Zhao emotional travel 20160920 p
 
Urban Road Congestion Management - Capacity Investments and Pricing Policies
Urban Road Congestion Management - Capacity Investments and Pricing PoliciesUrban Road Congestion Management - Capacity Investments and Pricing Policies
Urban Road Congestion Management - Capacity Investments and Pricing Policies
 
Rethinking the Next Generation of BRT in China
Rethinking the Next Generation of BRT in ChinaRethinking the Next Generation of BRT in China
Rethinking the Next Generation of BRT in China
 
Habitat III can help accelerate action on sustainable urban transport
Habitat III can help accelerate action on sustainable urban transportHabitat III can help accelerate action on sustainable urban transport
Habitat III can help accelerate action on sustainable urban transport
 
2016 05-30 may session ulises navarro
2016 05-30 may session ulises navarro2016 05-30 may session ulises navarro
2016 05-30 may session ulises navarro
 

The fragility of the authority operator and operators-shareholders relat…

  • 1. CTS EMBARQ México The fragility of the Authority-Operator and Operators-Shareholders relationship: The impact on the sustainability of BRT systems Adriana Lobo
  • 2. New issues arise Engagement with soft contractual conditions No bid out Traditional bus Traditional bus Government operators operators Create bus companies Aware of bus companies functioning Public Agency Finance Fare Weakening Bus companies credibility Potential for bankruptcy Companies with several accountability issues Shareholders
  • 3. Proposals Improve legal strategies to engage traditional private bus operators with particular emphasis on accountability responsibilities Create mechanisms at the institutional level to assess the financial and managerial situation of bus companies Improve training programs in areas of management and finance
  • 4. CTSEMBARQ-Mexico CTSEMBARQ-Mexico has made important progress in initiating training programs for private bus operators CTSEMBARQ-Mexico is currently working with bus companies in improving areas of operation and management CTSEMBARQ-Mexico is currently doing research on the issues of accountability in bus companies and preparing solutions to these issues.