SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 57
UNIT 6
AIRPORT ECONOMICS
Unit Objectives
At the end of this unit, you should be able to:
 Explain Airport economic characteristics
 Identify Airport aeronautical charges
 Identify Airport commercial revenues
 Understand Airport regulation and ownership
 Perform Airport performance benchmarking
(a) Airport Economic Characteristics
 Economics of air transport infrastructure consists of
airports and air traffic services required by airlines to
operate air transport services.
 Airports provide runways, taxiways, apron and
terminal building facilities for airlines carrying
passengers or cargo.
 Airlines must pay for the costs of these infrastructure
through a set of airport user charges.
Air Traffic Services (ATS)
 Air Traffic Services include communication,
navigation and Air Traffic Control (ATC) provided to
airlines flying between two airports.
 Again ATS costs are in most cases covered by user
charges paid by airlines (and in turn, by its passengers
and shippers).
 User charges is the key of both airports and air traffic
services economics.
ATS
 In some countries ATS is separated from airports
authorities.
 In Tanzania ATS is provided by the Regulator of sector,
TCAA
 ICAO recommends that ATS must be separated from
the Regulator of the sector.
Principles of Establishing User
Charges
 1. Airports can collect full costs of the services provided
from users, including a reasonable rate of return on
investment.
 2. Users should be consulted before significant
changes are made to the fee structure or level of user
charge
 3. Airports should make financial information
available to the users to ensure that the charges relate
to the costs of providing services.
Principles of Establishing User
Charges
 4. providers must not discriminate between foreign
and national air carriers, or carriers of different
countries in applying the charges.
 5. Movement towards full cost recovery, or any
increases in user charges, should be gradual.
 6. The structure of user charges should be as simple as
possible.
Airport Costs
 Expenses incurred by airports are of two types –
operating and capital. Operating costs these are the
ones incurred by airports to meet their daily
operational costs while capital involves management
of capital its self in its structure.
Airport Costs as “Cost Items”
 ICAO has developed an airport cost
categorization scheme that recommends that
airport costs be classified both by cost item
and by area of service (or cost
center).
Cost Items
 Cost Items include the following:
 Direct personnel costs (wages and benefits)
 Supplies and externally provided services
 Depreciation and amortization
 Taxes
 Interest
 Administrative overheads
 Other expenses
Area of Service (Cost Center)
 The ICAO airport cost classification scheme requires that
airports operators to allocate each of the cost items to the
following areas of service or cost center:
 Aircraft Movement Areas (runways, taxiways, apron etc)
 Hangar and Maintenance Areas
 Air Traffic Control and Communications
 Meteorological services
 Fire-fighting, ambulance and security services
 Passenger and cargo terminal facilities
 Other facilities and services
(b) Sources of Revenue for Airports
 Airports Revenue are Categorized to revenue centers
which establishes a basis for the type of financial
transparency suggested in the overall principles of air
transport infrastructure charges.
Objectives of Revenue Centers
 These revenue centers are used by airport operators to:
 Group services or facilities together to set revenue
targets and collect user charges
 Allocate costs associated with services or facilities
in each revenue center in order to establish user
charges that can be defended as being related to the
airports operating costs.
Examples of Airport
Cost Centers & Revenue Centers
Cost Centers Revenue Centers
 Airfield Area
 Passenger terminal
 Hangars
 Cargo terminals
 Landside area
 General and
Administrative
 Landing/Air traffic
charge
 Rentals or concessions
 Airline Leasing charges
 Other leased charges
 Car Parking fees/rentals
 Other Operating areas
Types of Airport Revenues
Regardless of how an airport defines its revenue centers,
airports have essentially two sources of revenues:
 Aeronautical Revenues: These revenues are paid
by airlines operators that used the airport airside
services and facilities, in the form of user charge.
 Non-aeronautical revenues: These are collected
from concessionnaires, meaning businesses that use
the airport land side to make their own profit such as
restaurants, duty free shops, other shops, car
parking, hotels, office premises, display,
amusements, etc.
(i) Aeronautical Revenues
 The Airport Aeronautical Revenues are also called
Airport Aeronautical Charges
 These revenues are paid by air transport operators as
fees for the use of the airport airside/airfield services
and facilities provided by the airport operators.
 They are paid in the form of user charges.
 They are being used by airports operators as source of
revenues.
 The most common types of user charges are:
Cont..
 Landing Fees
 Aircraft Parking fees
 Air Navigation Charges
 Passenger service fees
 Aviation security charge
 Lighting charge
 Aerobridge charge
Cont..
 Airport noise fees
 Airport emission fees
 Fuel flowage fees
 Hangar fees
 Cargo service fees
 Ground Handling fees
(ii) Non-aeronautical Revenues
 The Airport Non-aeronautical Revenues are also
called Airport Commercial Revenues.
 These are revenues collected from concessionnaires,
meaning businesses that use the airport land side to
make their own profit.
 These business are such as restaurants, office
premises, duty free shops, other shops, display
advertising, amusements, car parking, hotels and
motels,, ground transportation, etc.
Examples of aeronautical charges in Tanzania
(i) Passenger Service charges
 Domestic Flight = Tshs. 10,000.00
 International Flight = USD 40.00
(ii) Air Navigation Charges
 Various rates between USD 60 - USD 104
depending on aircraft weight and time of the day.
Cont..
(iii) Landing charges
Airport Charge Per 1,000kg
Dsm, Klm, Zb, Pemba USD 5.00
Dodoma, Kigoma, Mtwara,
Mwanza, Songea, Tabora, Tanga.
USD 4.5
Arusha, Bukoba, Iringa, Kilwa, … USD 4.00
Other government aerodromes USD 3.00
Cont..
(iv) Parking charges
Aircraft Weight Charge Per Aircraft (After the first 2 hours)
Aircraft Registered
in Tanzania
Foreign Registered
Aircraft
Up to 20,000kg Tshs. 1,000 per 6hrs
or part thereof
USD 5.00 per 12hrs
or part thereof
20,000 –
60,000kg
Tshs. 1,000 per 6hrs
or part thereof
USD 5.00 per 6hrs
or part thereof
More than
60,000kg
Tshs. 1,000 per 6hrs
or part thereof
USD 5.00 per hrs
or part thereof
Aeronautical Charges in other countries
Country Passenger service fee Parking fees
International Domestic
Uganda USD 40 Ushs.
3000
> 270,000kg
USD 100 per 24hrs
Kenya
(Wilson airport)
USD 20 Kshs. 300 > 300,000kg
USD 130 per 24hrs
UK
(Heathrow airport)
£44.41 £31.63 Wide bodied aircraft
£ 52.49 per 15min.
(c) Airport regulation and ownership
 There are several different governance models being
used to operate airports.
 In many countries, airports are still the responsibility
of some level of government either directly, by the
Department of Transport, or indirectly, by an agency
or corporation.
 Elsewhere, models embrace some degree of
privatization such as the Airport Authority model or
private corporation governance. The major models are
summarised below.
(i) Operation by Federal Government
Department
 This was the model used in Canada and has been the
traditional model in most other countries, with the
Federal Government owning and operating airports.
 Typically, airports are the responsibility of a
Department/Minister of Transport.
 The Department will generally oversee regulation, air
traffic control, and air navigation and in some case
operate a national airline in addition to airport
operations.
(ii) Operation by Municipal Governments
 This model has been unique to the U.S. Many
airports, large and small are run directly by the city as
an administrative department. Chicago, San Francisco
and Los Angeles are examples.
 In some cases, the city run airports and establish
boards which provide an advisory role.
 However, the board has limited powers and is
specifically excluded from day to day operation
decisions of the airport. City Council and the Mayor
are the ultimate decision makers.
(iii) Operation by Government Agency
 This is a variation of the Government Department
format. In this model all aviation matters are assigned
to a semi-independent government agency, rather than
being a direct responsibility of the
department/Minister of Transport.
 The department is responsible for the establishment of
broad policy toward aviation, but the Agency is
responsible for day to day establishment of
regulations as well as operations.
(iv) Operation by a Government Corporation
 This format vertically separates the airport system by
disconnecting operations from regulatory functions.
 The Department of Transport retains direct
responsibility for the establishment and enforcement
of regulations for airports but operations are assigned
to a government owned corporation, eliminating
conflict of interest.
 Although the corporation will report to the
Department of Transport, it has a degree of
independence due to its corporate structure.
Cont..
 While a departmental operation requires that all
airport expenditures must go through the annual
government budget review process, a government
corporation has some independence in its financial
planning.
 In some cases the government corporation has the
ability to issue bonds to finance major projects,
removing it somewhat from the vagaries of the federal
budgeting and political process.
(iv) Airport Authority
 It is used in Canada as a private sector corporate
alternative to the government corporation.
 Here, the airport authority governance concept is that
of a private sector corporation which operates an
airport.
 To distinguish the airport authority concept from the
private corporation concept discussed later, the term is
applied to the governance model where the private
sector corporation is not-for-profit, and thus has no
shareholders (or shareholder paid in equity).
(vi) Joint Government/Private Corporations
 Under this model, the airport is governed via the
corporate format, but there is some private
participation in the ownership of the airport.
(vii) Private Corporation
 This is when the airport corporation is wholly owned
by a private for-profit corporation.
 The airport may be publicly traded with ownership
dispersed among a number of shareholders (e.g., BAA
plc which operates the London UK airports, among
others), or closely held (e.g., TradePort Corporation
which leases and operates the Hamilton Ontario
airport).
PPP Options for Airports Infrastructure
 Public Private Partnership (PPP) process, is a process
in which government or airport authority transfers the
exclusive rights to a private operator or investor
through a development contract to develop and/or
operate the airport or airport facility under certain
conditions for a fixed period.
Cont..
 Governments offer traditionally public assets to
private sector lease holders and operators to boost
cash flow.
 This is due to lack of capacity of governments to
finance the capital expenditures needed to expand and
modernize airport infrastructure
PPP Models
PPP can be done in the following ways:
 Individual facility vs. entire airport contract
 Build Operate and Transfer (BOT) contract
 Build Operate and Own (BOO)
 Concession contracts
 Management contracts
PPP Models None Revenues Airports
Again, the PPP for non revenue airports can be done in
the following ways:
 Built, Operate, and Lease (BOL )
For airports not generating enough revenues
 Built, Design, and Finance
Objectives of PPP
PPP is considered to serve the following purposes:
 To obtain capital to modernize and expand
infrastructure; (Private Equity)
 To recover public funds invested on an operating asset
 To achieve the efficiency improvements and
innovations typically associated with private sector
management; or
 To achieve clearer separation among policymaking,
regulation, and operations.
Advantages of PPP
 Reduction of operating costs
 Improved marketing and ability to attract more airline
services and passengers
 Improve the competitive position of an airport within
its region
 Consideration of innovative designs and more cost-
saving approaches in construction programs
 Improve quality of services
 Flexibility and ability to respond more rapidly to
market changes
 Higher labor productivity
 Ability to increase concession revenues from
commercial operations
 Flexibility in procurement and operating procedures
Cont..
(d) Airport Performance Benchmarking
 Airports operate under very different circumstances in
terms of aviation activities, commercial activities, site
constraints, governance and ownership structure, etc.,
and as a result, individual airports will find different
performance indicators to be most relevant and useful.
 For example, privatized airports are likely to focus on
different financial PIs than non-profit government-
owned airports.
Cont..
 Larger airports are likely to focus on different PIs than
smaller airports. Airports with large developable land
areas are likely to focus on different PIs than tightly
constrained airports in large urban areas.
 Even among airports with similar characteristics,
managers will have different views regarding which
PIs are most important, and how many PIs the
airport should track.
Cont..
 A smaller set of closely-monitored PIs is likely to be a
more effective performance management tool than a
larger set of PIs that attracts less focus.
 And over time, the set of PIs of most importance to
the individual airport will change as new issues arise.
A key example of this is the currently evolving area
of Environmental PIs, which until recently was not a
key performance management area for many airports.
Types of airport benchmarking
Airport benchmarking is divided into two types of
comparisons:
 Internal (or self-benchmarking): An airport compares
its performance with itself over time.
 External (or peer benchmarking): An airport compares
its performance against other airports, either at a
single point in time or over a period of time.
Classification of Performance Indicators
There are five classes/categories of performance
indicators
 Key/Core performance indicators
 Safety and Security performance indicators
 Service Quality performance indicators
 Financial/Commercial performance indictors
 Environmental performance indicators
Core/Key Performance Indicators
Core indicators are used to track the fundamental
measures of airport activity, such as passengers and
operations.
There are five types which are:
 Passengers
 Origination and Destination Passengers
 Aircraft Movements
 Freight or Mail Loaded/Unloaded
 Destinations—Nonstop
(i)Passengers (total annual)
 Definition
Passengers, including embarking and disembarking,
measured over the course of a year.
 Applicability
All commercial service airports
Cont..
 Drivers
Primary drivers are local demand and airline route
planning and pricing decisions (which will influence,
among other things, number of transfer passengers).
 Benchmarking
As a Core PI, most useful for internal benchmarking
to track growth or decline from year-to-year, and to
identify other airports of similar size for further study.
(ii)Origination and Destination Passengers
(total annual)
 Definition
Passengers whose air travel begins or ends at the
airport, measured over the course of a year. Excludes
passengers who are changing planes at the airport to
embark on a flight to another destination. A passenger
who makes a round-trip is counted as two Origination
and Destination (O&D) Passengers.
Cont..
 Applicability
Applicable primarily to airports with a significant
number of connecting passengers. For other airports,
the number of O&D passengers will be approximately
the same as the number of total passengers.
Cont..
 Drivers
Primary drivers are local demand, competing airports
in the same catchment area, and airline route planning
and pricing decisions.
 Benchmarking
As a Core PI, most useful for internal benchmarking to
track growth or decline from year-to-year, and to
identify other airports of similar size for further study.
(iii) Aircraft Movements (total annual)
 Definition
Aircraft take-offs or landings at an airport, measured
over the course of a year. One arrival and one
departure are counted as two movements.
 Applicability
All airports
Cont..
 Drivers
Primary drivers are local demand and airline route
planning and pricing decisions.
 Benchmarking
 As a Core PI, most useful for internal benchmarking to
track growth or decline from year-to-year, and to
identify other airports of similar size for further study.
(iv) Freight or Mail Loaded/Unloaded
(total annual tonnes)
 Definition
Freight or mail loaded or unloaded at the airport,
measured in metric tonnes over the course of a year.
 Applicability
All airports with freight
Cont..
 Drivers
Primary drivers are local demand and airline route
planning and pricing decisions.
 Benchmarking
As a Core PI, most useful for internal benchmarking to
track growth or decline from year-to-year, and to
identify other airports of similar size for further study.
(v) Destinations - Nonstop
 Definition
Number of airports with nonstop service, including
destinations with only seasonal service, measured over
the course of a year.
 Applicability
All commercial service airports
Cont..
 Drivers
Primary drivers are local demand and airline route
planning and pricing decisions.
 Benchmarking
As a Core PI, most useful for internal benchmarking to
track growth or decline from year-to-year, and to
identify other airports of similar size for further study.
THE END

More Related Content

What's hot

Freedoms of the Air
Freedoms of the AirFreedoms of the Air
Freedoms of the AirCSE Aviation
 
Ground Handling
Ground HandlingGround Handling
Ground HandlingToy Ang
 
Introduction to Civil Aviation 1 (1).pptx
Introduction to Civil Aviation 1 (1).pptxIntroduction to Civil Aviation 1 (1).pptx
Introduction to Civil Aviation 1 (1).pptxMaclenny
 
AIRLINE TERMINAL MANAGEMENT
AIRLINE TERMINAL MANAGEMENTAIRLINE TERMINAL MANAGEMENT
AIRLINE TERMINAL MANAGEMENTJetline Marvel
 
Airline business- Air Industry II
Airline business- Air Industry IIAirline business- Air Industry II
Airline business- Air Industry IIToy Ang
 
Baggage handling in Airports (sortation)
Baggage handling in Airports (sortation)Baggage handling in Airports (sortation)
Baggage handling in Airports (sortation)cidroypaes
 
International civil aviation organization
International civil aviation organizationInternational civil aviation organization
International civil aviation organizationShahnur Munna
 
Aviation Industry
Aviation IndustryAviation Industry
Aviation IndustryDena Alavi
 
Principles of airline and airport management
Principles of airline and airport managementPrinciples of airline and airport management
Principles of airline and airport managementJetline Marvel
 
Aviation terminology by Kalyan S Patil
Aviation terminology by Kalyan S PatilAviation terminology by Kalyan S Patil
Aviation terminology by Kalyan S PatilKalyan S Patil
 

What's hot (20)

Airfare pricing process & strategies
Airfare pricing process & strategiesAirfare pricing process & strategies
Airfare pricing process & strategies
 
Freedoms of the Air
Freedoms of the AirFreedoms of the Air
Freedoms of the Air
 
Airline Revenue Managemant
Airline Revenue ManagemantAirline Revenue Managemant
Airline Revenue Managemant
 
Safety & Security Airports
Safety & Security AirportsSafety & Security Airports
Safety & Security Airports
 
Ground Handling
Ground HandlingGround Handling
Ground Handling
 
Introduction to Civil Aviation 1 (1).pptx
Introduction to Civil Aviation 1 (1).pptxIntroduction to Civil Aviation 1 (1).pptx
Introduction to Civil Aviation 1 (1).pptx
 
AIRLINE TERMINAL MANAGEMENT
AIRLINE TERMINAL MANAGEMENTAIRLINE TERMINAL MANAGEMENT
AIRLINE TERMINAL MANAGEMENT
 
Air transportation
Air transportationAir transportation
Air transportation
 
Airline business- Air Industry II
Airline business- Air Industry IIAirline business- Air Industry II
Airline business- Air Industry II
 
Baggage handling in Airports (sortation)
Baggage handling in Airports (sortation)Baggage handling in Airports (sortation)
Baggage handling in Airports (sortation)
 
Air Transport Industry (Contribution in world Economy)
Air Transport Industry (Contribution in world Economy)Air Transport Industry (Contribution in world Economy)
Air Transport Industry (Contribution in world Economy)
 
Airline codes
Airline codesAirline codes
Airline codes
 
Air cargo overview ppt
Air cargo overview pptAir cargo overview ppt
Air cargo overview ppt
 
airline deregulation
airline deregulationairline deregulation
airline deregulation
 
Profit maximization
Profit maximizationProfit maximization
Profit maximization
 
International civil aviation organization
International civil aviation organizationInternational civil aviation organization
International civil aviation organization
 
Aviation Industry
Aviation IndustryAviation Industry
Aviation Industry
 
Principles of airline and airport management
Principles of airline and airport managementPrinciples of airline and airport management
Principles of airline and airport management
 
Airport Management 11
Airport Management  11Airport Management  11
Airport Management 11
 
Aviation terminology by Kalyan S Patil
Aviation terminology by Kalyan S PatilAviation terminology by Kalyan S Patil
Aviation terminology by Kalyan S Patil
 

Similar to 6 Airport Economics.ppt

ATM Approach GARS
ATM Approach GARSATM Approach GARS
ATM Approach GARShueyguy1g
 
UNIT-1 A OPERATIONS PPT.pptx
UNIT-1 A OPERATIONS PPT.pptxUNIT-1 A OPERATIONS PPT.pptx
UNIT-1 A OPERATIONS PPT.pptxReganFernandes2
 
Introduction to Airport 2023.pptx
Introduction to Airport 2023.pptxIntroduction to Airport 2023.pptx
Introduction to Airport 2023.pptxMaclenny
 
Alazen ACDM Overview
Alazen ACDM OverviewAlazen ACDM Overview
Alazen ACDM OverviewNick Fisher
 
Air Traffic Control Database Management System for Seamless Transit
Air Traffic Control Database Management System for Seamless TransitAir Traffic Control Database Management System for Seamless Transit
Air Traffic Control Database Management System for Seamless TransitIRJET Journal
 
Analysis Of Airport Stakeholders
Analysis Of Airport StakeholdersAnalysis Of Airport Stakeholders
Analysis Of Airport StakeholdersStephen Faucher
 
Report on airport engineering
Report on airport engineeringReport on airport engineering
Report on airport engineeringAbhishekChavan63
 
What are the revenue classifications of the U.S. based for-hire air .pdf
What are the revenue classifications of the U.S. based for-hire air .pdfWhat are the revenue classifications of the U.S. based for-hire air .pdf
What are the revenue classifications of the U.S. based for-hire air .pdfanaxeetech
 
European Airport PerformanceFramework
European Airport PerformanceFrameworkEuropean Airport PerformanceFramework
European Airport PerformanceFrameworkJLGChico
 
Full paper template - 0020
Full paper template - 0020Full paper template - 0020
Full paper template - 0020Nick Durston
 
AIRPORT OPERATIONS.pptx
AIRPORT OPERATIONS.pptxAIRPORT OPERATIONS.pptx
AIRPORT OPERATIONS.pptxGAUTAMHALDAR6
 
Aeronautical Billing System at O’Hare Airport
Aeronautical Billing System at O’Hare AirportAeronautical Billing System at O’Hare Airport
Aeronautical Billing System at O’Hare AirportEricsson
 
Revenue and Cost Saving Ideas for IAA
Revenue and Cost Saving Ideas for IAARevenue and Cost Saving Ideas for IAA
Revenue and Cost Saving Ideas for IAAChris Homko MS, ATP
 
Types of airlines and airline business models
Types of airlines and airline business modelsTypes of airlines and airline business models
Types of airlines and airline business modelsMirza Rihad Ali Sunny
 

Similar to 6 Airport Economics.ppt (20)

ATM Approach GARS
ATM Approach GARSATM Approach GARS
ATM Approach GARS
 
UNIT-1 A OPERATIONS PPT.pptx
UNIT-1 A OPERATIONS PPT.pptxUNIT-1 A OPERATIONS PPT.pptx
UNIT-1 A OPERATIONS PPT.pptx
 
Introduction to Airport 2023.pptx
Introduction to Airport 2023.pptxIntroduction to Airport 2023.pptx
Introduction to Airport 2023.pptx
 
Alazen ACDM Overview
Alazen ACDM OverviewAlazen ACDM Overview
Alazen ACDM Overview
 
Air Traffic Control Database Management System for Seamless Transit
Air Traffic Control Database Management System for Seamless TransitAir Traffic Control Database Management System for Seamless Transit
Air Traffic Control Database Management System for Seamless Transit
 
Aviation business basics 3
Aviation business basics   3Aviation business basics   3
Aviation business basics 3
 
Analysis Of Airport Stakeholders
Analysis Of Airport StakeholdersAnalysis Of Airport Stakeholders
Analysis Of Airport Stakeholders
 
Finance101
Finance101Finance101
Finance101
 
Public law paper `q
Public law paper `qPublic law paper `q
Public law paper `q
 
Report on airport engineering
Report on airport engineeringReport on airport engineering
Report on airport engineering
 
Airport management services
Airport management servicesAirport management services
Airport management services
 
What are the revenue classifications of the U.S. based for-hire air .pdf
What are the revenue classifications of the U.S. based for-hire air .pdfWhat are the revenue classifications of the U.S. based for-hire air .pdf
What are the revenue classifications of the U.S. based for-hire air .pdf
 
European Airport PerformanceFramework
European Airport PerformanceFrameworkEuropean Airport PerformanceFramework
European Airport PerformanceFramework
 
Lack of Profitability.ppt
Lack of Profitability.pptLack of Profitability.ppt
Lack of Profitability.ppt
 
Full paper template - 0020
Full paper template - 0020Full paper template - 0020
Full paper template - 0020
 
sa-06x01.pdf
sa-06x01.pdfsa-06x01.pdf
sa-06x01.pdf
 
AIRPORT OPERATIONS.pptx
AIRPORT OPERATIONS.pptxAIRPORT OPERATIONS.pptx
AIRPORT OPERATIONS.pptx
 
Aeronautical Billing System at O’Hare Airport
Aeronautical Billing System at O’Hare AirportAeronautical Billing System at O’Hare Airport
Aeronautical Billing System at O’Hare Airport
 
Revenue and Cost Saving Ideas for IAA
Revenue and Cost Saving Ideas for IAARevenue and Cost Saving Ideas for IAA
Revenue and Cost Saving Ideas for IAA
 
Types of airlines and airline business models
Types of airlines and airline business modelsTypes of airlines and airline business models
Types of airlines and airline business models
 

Recently uploaded

Dubai Call Girls O528786472 Call Girls Dubai Big Juicy
Dubai Call Girls O528786472 Call Girls Dubai Big JuicyDubai Call Girls O528786472 Call Girls Dubai Big Juicy
Dubai Call Girls O528786472 Call Girls Dubai Big Juicyhf8803863
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking MenDelhi Call girls
 
"Fly with Ease: Booking Your Flights with Air Europa"
"Fly with Ease: Booking Your Flights with Air Europa""Fly with Ease: Booking Your Flights with Air Europa"
"Fly with Ease: Booking Your Flights with Air Europa"flyn goo
 
VIP Call Girls in Noida 9711199012 Escorts in Greater Noida,Ms
VIP Call Girls in Noida 9711199012 Escorts in Greater Noida,MsVIP Call Girls in Noida 9711199012 Escorts in Greater Noida,Ms
VIP Call Girls in Noida 9711199012 Escorts in Greater Noida,Msankitnayak356677
 
A Comprehensive Guide to The Types of Dubai Residence Visas.pdf
A Comprehensive Guide to The Types of Dubai Residence Visas.pdfA Comprehensive Guide to The Types of Dubai Residence Visas.pdf
A Comprehensive Guide to The Types of Dubai Residence Visas.pdfDisha Global Tours
 
Akshay Mehndiratta Summer Special Light Meal Ideas From Across India.pptx
Akshay Mehndiratta Summer Special Light Meal Ideas From Across India.pptxAkshay Mehndiratta Summer Special Light Meal Ideas From Across India.pptx
Akshay Mehndiratta Summer Special Light Meal Ideas From Across India.pptxAkshay Mehndiratta
 
Moving to Italy - A Relocation Rollercoaster
Moving to Italy - A Relocation RollercoasterMoving to Italy - A Relocation Rollercoaster
Moving to Italy - A Relocation RollercoasterStefSmulders1
 
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Nand Nagri 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Nand Nagri 🔝 Delhi NCR(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Nand Nagri 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Nand Nagri 🔝 Delhi NCRsoniya singh
 
Hoi An Ancient Town, Vietnam (越南 會安古鎮).ppsx
Hoi An Ancient Town, Vietnam (越南 會安古鎮).ppsxHoi An Ancient Town, Vietnam (越南 會安古鎮).ppsx
Hoi An Ancient Town, Vietnam (越南 會安古鎮).ppsxChung Yen Chang
 
DARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda Bux
DARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda BuxDARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda Bux
DARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda BuxBeEducate
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Shahdara Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Shahdara Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Shahdara Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Shahdara Women Seeking MenDelhi Call girls
 
Exploring Sicily Your Comprehensive Ebook Travel Guide
Exploring Sicily Your Comprehensive Ebook Travel GuideExploring Sicily Your Comprehensive Ebook Travel Guide
Exploring Sicily Your Comprehensive Ebook Travel GuideTime for Sicily
 
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdf
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdfbest weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdf
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdftour guide
 
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptx
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptxBERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptx
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptxseribangash
 
How can I fly with the British Airways Unaccompanied Minor Policy?
How can I fly with the British Airways Unaccompanied Minor Policy?How can I fly with the British Airways Unaccompanied Minor Policy?
How can I fly with the British Airways Unaccompanied Minor Policy?flightsvillacom
 
Italia Lucca 1 Un tesoro nascosto tra le sue mura
Italia Lucca 1 Un tesoro nascosto tra le sue muraItalia Lucca 1 Un tesoro nascosto tra le sue mura
Italia Lucca 1 Un tesoro nascosto tra le sue murasandamichaela *
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Rohini Sector 18 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
Rohini Sector 18 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No AdvanceRohini Sector 18 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
Rohini Sector 18 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
 
Dubai Call Girls O528786472 Call Girls Dubai Big Juicy
Dubai Call Girls O528786472 Call Girls Dubai Big JuicyDubai Call Girls O528786472 Call Girls Dubai Big Juicy
Dubai Call Girls O528786472 Call Girls Dubai Big Juicy
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men
 
"Fly with Ease: Booking Your Flights with Air Europa"
"Fly with Ease: Booking Your Flights with Air Europa""Fly with Ease: Booking Your Flights with Air Europa"
"Fly with Ease: Booking Your Flights with Air Europa"
 
VIP Call Girls in Noida 9711199012 Escorts in Greater Noida,Ms
VIP Call Girls in Noida 9711199012 Escorts in Greater Noida,MsVIP Call Girls in Noida 9711199012 Escorts in Greater Noida,Ms
VIP Call Girls in Noida 9711199012 Escorts in Greater Noida,Ms
 
A Comprehensive Guide to The Types of Dubai Residence Visas.pdf
A Comprehensive Guide to The Types of Dubai Residence Visas.pdfA Comprehensive Guide to The Types of Dubai Residence Visas.pdf
A Comprehensive Guide to The Types of Dubai Residence Visas.pdf
 
Akshay Mehndiratta Summer Special Light Meal Ideas From Across India.pptx
Akshay Mehndiratta Summer Special Light Meal Ideas From Across India.pptxAkshay Mehndiratta Summer Special Light Meal Ideas From Across India.pptx
Akshay Mehndiratta Summer Special Light Meal Ideas From Across India.pptx
 
Moving to Italy - A Relocation Rollercoaster
Moving to Italy - A Relocation RollercoasterMoving to Italy - A Relocation Rollercoaster
Moving to Italy - A Relocation Rollercoaster
 
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Nand Nagri 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Nand Nagri 🔝 Delhi NCR(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Nand Nagri 🔝 Delhi NCR
(8264348440) 🔝 Call Girls In Nand Nagri 🔝 Delhi NCR
 
Hoi An Ancient Town, Vietnam (越南 會安古鎮).ppsx
Hoi An Ancient Town, Vietnam (越南 會安古鎮).ppsxHoi An Ancient Town, Vietnam (越南 會安古鎮).ppsx
Hoi An Ancient Town, Vietnam (越南 會安古鎮).ppsx
 
DARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda Bux
DARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda BuxDARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda Bux
DARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda Bux
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Shahdara Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Shahdara Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Shahdara Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Shahdara Women Seeking Men
 
Exploring Sicily Your Comprehensive Ebook Travel Guide
Exploring Sicily Your Comprehensive Ebook Travel GuideExploring Sicily Your Comprehensive Ebook Travel Guide
Exploring Sicily Your Comprehensive Ebook Travel Guide
 
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdf
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdfbest weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdf
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdf
 
Call Girls Service !! New Friends Colony!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance VV...
Call Girls Service !! New Friends Colony!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance  VV...Call Girls Service !! New Friends Colony!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance  VV...
Call Girls Service !! New Friends Colony!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance VV...
 
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptx
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptxBERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptx
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptx
 
Call Girls In Munirka 📱 9999965857 🤩 Delhi 🫦 HOT AND SEXY VVIP 🍎 SERVICE
Call Girls In Munirka 📱  9999965857  🤩 Delhi 🫦 HOT AND SEXY VVIP 🍎 SERVICECall Girls In Munirka 📱  9999965857  🤩 Delhi 🫦 HOT AND SEXY VVIP 🍎 SERVICE
Call Girls In Munirka 📱 9999965857 🤩 Delhi 🫦 HOT AND SEXY VVIP 🍎 SERVICE
 
How can I fly with the British Airways Unaccompanied Minor Policy?
How can I fly with the British Airways Unaccompanied Minor Policy?How can I fly with the British Airways Unaccompanied Minor Policy?
How can I fly with the British Airways Unaccompanied Minor Policy?
 
Italia Lucca 1 Un tesoro nascosto tra le sue mura
Italia Lucca 1 Un tesoro nascosto tra le sue muraItalia Lucca 1 Un tesoro nascosto tra le sue mura
Italia Lucca 1 Un tesoro nascosto tra le sue mura
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
 

6 Airport Economics.ppt

  • 2. Unit Objectives At the end of this unit, you should be able to:  Explain Airport economic characteristics  Identify Airport aeronautical charges  Identify Airport commercial revenues  Understand Airport regulation and ownership  Perform Airport performance benchmarking
  • 3. (a) Airport Economic Characteristics  Economics of air transport infrastructure consists of airports and air traffic services required by airlines to operate air transport services.  Airports provide runways, taxiways, apron and terminal building facilities for airlines carrying passengers or cargo.  Airlines must pay for the costs of these infrastructure through a set of airport user charges.
  • 4. Air Traffic Services (ATS)  Air Traffic Services include communication, navigation and Air Traffic Control (ATC) provided to airlines flying between two airports.  Again ATS costs are in most cases covered by user charges paid by airlines (and in turn, by its passengers and shippers).  User charges is the key of both airports and air traffic services economics.
  • 5. ATS  In some countries ATS is separated from airports authorities.  In Tanzania ATS is provided by the Regulator of sector, TCAA  ICAO recommends that ATS must be separated from the Regulator of the sector.
  • 6. Principles of Establishing User Charges  1. Airports can collect full costs of the services provided from users, including a reasonable rate of return on investment.  2. Users should be consulted before significant changes are made to the fee structure or level of user charge  3. Airports should make financial information available to the users to ensure that the charges relate to the costs of providing services.
  • 7. Principles of Establishing User Charges  4. providers must not discriminate between foreign and national air carriers, or carriers of different countries in applying the charges.  5. Movement towards full cost recovery, or any increases in user charges, should be gradual.  6. The structure of user charges should be as simple as possible.
  • 8. Airport Costs  Expenses incurred by airports are of two types – operating and capital. Operating costs these are the ones incurred by airports to meet their daily operational costs while capital involves management of capital its self in its structure.
  • 9. Airport Costs as “Cost Items”  ICAO has developed an airport cost categorization scheme that recommends that airport costs be classified both by cost item and by area of service (or cost center).
  • 10. Cost Items  Cost Items include the following:  Direct personnel costs (wages and benefits)  Supplies and externally provided services  Depreciation and amortization  Taxes  Interest  Administrative overheads  Other expenses
  • 11. Area of Service (Cost Center)  The ICAO airport cost classification scheme requires that airports operators to allocate each of the cost items to the following areas of service or cost center:  Aircraft Movement Areas (runways, taxiways, apron etc)  Hangar and Maintenance Areas  Air Traffic Control and Communications  Meteorological services  Fire-fighting, ambulance and security services  Passenger and cargo terminal facilities  Other facilities and services
  • 12. (b) Sources of Revenue for Airports  Airports Revenue are Categorized to revenue centers which establishes a basis for the type of financial transparency suggested in the overall principles of air transport infrastructure charges.
  • 13. Objectives of Revenue Centers  These revenue centers are used by airport operators to:  Group services or facilities together to set revenue targets and collect user charges  Allocate costs associated with services or facilities in each revenue center in order to establish user charges that can be defended as being related to the airports operating costs.
  • 14. Examples of Airport Cost Centers & Revenue Centers Cost Centers Revenue Centers  Airfield Area  Passenger terminal  Hangars  Cargo terminals  Landside area  General and Administrative  Landing/Air traffic charge  Rentals or concessions  Airline Leasing charges  Other leased charges  Car Parking fees/rentals  Other Operating areas
  • 15. Types of Airport Revenues Regardless of how an airport defines its revenue centers, airports have essentially two sources of revenues:  Aeronautical Revenues: These revenues are paid by airlines operators that used the airport airside services and facilities, in the form of user charge.  Non-aeronautical revenues: These are collected from concessionnaires, meaning businesses that use the airport land side to make their own profit such as restaurants, duty free shops, other shops, car parking, hotels, office premises, display, amusements, etc.
  • 16. (i) Aeronautical Revenues  The Airport Aeronautical Revenues are also called Airport Aeronautical Charges  These revenues are paid by air transport operators as fees for the use of the airport airside/airfield services and facilities provided by the airport operators.  They are paid in the form of user charges.  They are being used by airports operators as source of revenues.  The most common types of user charges are:
  • 17. Cont..  Landing Fees  Aircraft Parking fees  Air Navigation Charges  Passenger service fees  Aviation security charge  Lighting charge  Aerobridge charge
  • 18. Cont..  Airport noise fees  Airport emission fees  Fuel flowage fees  Hangar fees  Cargo service fees  Ground Handling fees
  • 19. (ii) Non-aeronautical Revenues  The Airport Non-aeronautical Revenues are also called Airport Commercial Revenues.  These are revenues collected from concessionnaires, meaning businesses that use the airport land side to make their own profit.  These business are such as restaurants, office premises, duty free shops, other shops, display advertising, amusements, car parking, hotels and motels,, ground transportation, etc.
  • 20. Examples of aeronautical charges in Tanzania (i) Passenger Service charges  Domestic Flight = Tshs. 10,000.00  International Flight = USD 40.00 (ii) Air Navigation Charges  Various rates between USD 60 - USD 104 depending on aircraft weight and time of the day.
  • 21. Cont.. (iii) Landing charges Airport Charge Per 1,000kg Dsm, Klm, Zb, Pemba USD 5.00 Dodoma, Kigoma, Mtwara, Mwanza, Songea, Tabora, Tanga. USD 4.5 Arusha, Bukoba, Iringa, Kilwa, … USD 4.00 Other government aerodromes USD 3.00
  • 22. Cont.. (iv) Parking charges Aircraft Weight Charge Per Aircraft (After the first 2 hours) Aircraft Registered in Tanzania Foreign Registered Aircraft Up to 20,000kg Tshs. 1,000 per 6hrs or part thereof USD 5.00 per 12hrs or part thereof 20,000 – 60,000kg Tshs. 1,000 per 6hrs or part thereof USD 5.00 per 6hrs or part thereof More than 60,000kg Tshs. 1,000 per 6hrs or part thereof USD 5.00 per hrs or part thereof
  • 23. Aeronautical Charges in other countries Country Passenger service fee Parking fees International Domestic Uganda USD 40 Ushs. 3000 > 270,000kg USD 100 per 24hrs Kenya (Wilson airport) USD 20 Kshs. 300 > 300,000kg USD 130 per 24hrs UK (Heathrow airport) £44.41 £31.63 Wide bodied aircraft £ 52.49 per 15min.
  • 24. (c) Airport regulation and ownership  There are several different governance models being used to operate airports.  In many countries, airports are still the responsibility of some level of government either directly, by the Department of Transport, or indirectly, by an agency or corporation.  Elsewhere, models embrace some degree of privatization such as the Airport Authority model or private corporation governance. The major models are summarised below.
  • 25. (i) Operation by Federal Government Department  This was the model used in Canada and has been the traditional model in most other countries, with the Federal Government owning and operating airports.  Typically, airports are the responsibility of a Department/Minister of Transport.  The Department will generally oversee regulation, air traffic control, and air navigation and in some case operate a national airline in addition to airport operations.
  • 26. (ii) Operation by Municipal Governments  This model has been unique to the U.S. Many airports, large and small are run directly by the city as an administrative department. Chicago, San Francisco and Los Angeles are examples.  In some cases, the city run airports and establish boards which provide an advisory role.  However, the board has limited powers and is specifically excluded from day to day operation decisions of the airport. City Council and the Mayor are the ultimate decision makers.
  • 27. (iii) Operation by Government Agency  This is a variation of the Government Department format. In this model all aviation matters are assigned to a semi-independent government agency, rather than being a direct responsibility of the department/Minister of Transport.  The department is responsible for the establishment of broad policy toward aviation, but the Agency is responsible for day to day establishment of regulations as well as operations.
  • 28. (iv) Operation by a Government Corporation  This format vertically separates the airport system by disconnecting operations from regulatory functions.  The Department of Transport retains direct responsibility for the establishment and enforcement of regulations for airports but operations are assigned to a government owned corporation, eliminating conflict of interest.  Although the corporation will report to the Department of Transport, it has a degree of independence due to its corporate structure.
  • 29. Cont..  While a departmental operation requires that all airport expenditures must go through the annual government budget review process, a government corporation has some independence in its financial planning.  In some cases the government corporation has the ability to issue bonds to finance major projects, removing it somewhat from the vagaries of the federal budgeting and political process.
  • 30. (iv) Airport Authority  It is used in Canada as a private sector corporate alternative to the government corporation.  Here, the airport authority governance concept is that of a private sector corporation which operates an airport.  To distinguish the airport authority concept from the private corporation concept discussed later, the term is applied to the governance model where the private sector corporation is not-for-profit, and thus has no shareholders (or shareholder paid in equity).
  • 31. (vi) Joint Government/Private Corporations  Under this model, the airport is governed via the corporate format, but there is some private participation in the ownership of the airport.
  • 32. (vii) Private Corporation  This is when the airport corporation is wholly owned by a private for-profit corporation.  The airport may be publicly traded with ownership dispersed among a number of shareholders (e.g., BAA plc which operates the London UK airports, among others), or closely held (e.g., TradePort Corporation which leases and operates the Hamilton Ontario airport).
  • 33. PPP Options for Airports Infrastructure  Public Private Partnership (PPP) process, is a process in which government or airport authority transfers the exclusive rights to a private operator or investor through a development contract to develop and/or operate the airport or airport facility under certain conditions for a fixed period.
  • 34. Cont..  Governments offer traditionally public assets to private sector lease holders and operators to boost cash flow.  This is due to lack of capacity of governments to finance the capital expenditures needed to expand and modernize airport infrastructure
  • 35. PPP Models PPP can be done in the following ways:  Individual facility vs. entire airport contract  Build Operate and Transfer (BOT) contract  Build Operate and Own (BOO)  Concession contracts  Management contracts
  • 36. PPP Models None Revenues Airports Again, the PPP for non revenue airports can be done in the following ways:  Built, Operate, and Lease (BOL ) For airports not generating enough revenues  Built, Design, and Finance
  • 37. Objectives of PPP PPP is considered to serve the following purposes:  To obtain capital to modernize and expand infrastructure; (Private Equity)  To recover public funds invested on an operating asset  To achieve the efficiency improvements and innovations typically associated with private sector management; or  To achieve clearer separation among policymaking, regulation, and operations.
  • 38. Advantages of PPP  Reduction of operating costs  Improved marketing and ability to attract more airline services and passengers  Improve the competitive position of an airport within its region  Consideration of innovative designs and more cost- saving approaches in construction programs
  • 39.  Improve quality of services  Flexibility and ability to respond more rapidly to market changes  Higher labor productivity  Ability to increase concession revenues from commercial operations  Flexibility in procurement and operating procedures Cont..
  • 40. (d) Airport Performance Benchmarking  Airports operate under very different circumstances in terms of aviation activities, commercial activities, site constraints, governance and ownership structure, etc., and as a result, individual airports will find different performance indicators to be most relevant and useful.  For example, privatized airports are likely to focus on different financial PIs than non-profit government- owned airports.
  • 41. Cont..  Larger airports are likely to focus on different PIs than smaller airports. Airports with large developable land areas are likely to focus on different PIs than tightly constrained airports in large urban areas.  Even among airports with similar characteristics, managers will have different views regarding which PIs are most important, and how many PIs the airport should track.
  • 42. Cont..  A smaller set of closely-monitored PIs is likely to be a more effective performance management tool than a larger set of PIs that attracts less focus.  And over time, the set of PIs of most importance to the individual airport will change as new issues arise. A key example of this is the currently evolving area of Environmental PIs, which until recently was not a key performance management area for many airports.
  • 43. Types of airport benchmarking Airport benchmarking is divided into two types of comparisons:  Internal (or self-benchmarking): An airport compares its performance with itself over time.  External (or peer benchmarking): An airport compares its performance against other airports, either at a single point in time or over a period of time.
  • 44. Classification of Performance Indicators There are five classes/categories of performance indicators  Key/Core performance indicators  Safety and Security performance indicators  Service Quality performance indicators  Financial/Commercial performance indictors  Environmental performance indicators
  • 45. Core/Key Performance Indicators Core indicators are used to track the fundamental measures of airport activity, such as passengers and operations. There are five types which are:  Passengers  Origination and Destination Passengers  Aircraft Movements  Freight or Mail Loaded/Unloaded  Destinations—Nonstop
  • 46. (i)Passengers (total annual)  Definition Passengers, including embarking and disembarking, measured over the course of a year.  Applicability All commercial service airports
  • 47. Cont..  Drivers Primary drivers are local demand and airline route planning and pricing decisions (which will influence, among other things, number of transfer passengers).  Benchmarking As a Core PI, most useful for internal benchmarking to track growth or decline from year-to-year, and to identify other airports of similar size for further study.
  • 48. (ii)Origination and Destination Passengers (total annual)  Definition Passengers whose air travel begins or ends at the airport, measured over the course of a year. Excludes passengers who are changing planes at the airport to embark on a flight to another destination. A passenger who makes a round-trip is counted as two Origination and Destination (O&D) Passengers.
  • 49. Cont..  Applicability Applicable primarily to airports with a significant number of connecting passengers. For other airports, the number of O&D passengers will be approximately the same as the number of total passengers.
  • 50. Cont..  Drivers Primary drivers are local demand, competing airports in the same catchment area, and airline route planning and pricing decisions.  Benchmarking As a Core PI, most useful for internal benchmarking to track growth or decline from year-to-year, and to identify other airports of similar size for further study.
  • 51. (iii) Aircraft Movements (total annual)  Definition Aircraft take-offs or landings at an airport, measured over the course of a year. One arrival and one departure are counted as two movements.  Applicability All airports
  • 52. Cont..  Drivers Primary drivers are local demand and airline route planning and pricing decisions.  Benchmarking  As a Core PI, most useful for internal benchmarking to track growth or decline from year-to-year, and to identify other airports of similar size for further study.
  • 53. (iv) Freight or Mail Loaded/Unloaded (total annual tonnes)  Definition Freight or mail loaded or unloaded at the airport, measured in metric tonnes over the course of a year.  Applicability All airports with freight
  • 54. Cont..  Drivers Primary drivers are local demand and airline route planning and pricing decisions.  Benchmarking As a Core PI, most useful for internal benchmarking to track growth or decline from year-to-year, and to identify other airports of similar size for further study.
  • 55. (v) Destinations - Nonstop  Definition Number of airports with nonstop service, including destinations with only seasonal service, measured over the course of a year.  Applicability All commercial service airports
  • 56. Cont..  Drivers Primary drivers are local demand and airline route planning and pricing decisions.  Benchmarking As a Core PI, most useful for internal benchmarking to track growth or decline from year-to-year, and to identify other airports of similar size for further study.