Timing young researchers' decisions


Published on

This is a presentation intended to stimulate discussion during the FEBS YSF Career Session at http://www.febs2009.org/special-events.html , where I was to represent http://www.eurodoc.net. Based in large parts upon presentations by Björn Brembs ( http://www.slideshare.net/brembs/whats-wrong-with-scholarly-publishing-today-ii
), Cameron Neylon ( http://www.slideshare.net/CameronNeylon/nesta-science-in-society ) and Duncan Hull (
http://www.slideshare.net/dullhunk/defrosting-the-digital-library-a-survey-of-bibliographic-tools-for-the-next-generation-web ).

License: CC-BY unless noted otherwise on the slides.

Timing young researchers' decisions

  1. 1. Timing your decisions daniel.mietchen@uni-jena.de for www.eurodoc.net 34th FEBS Congress, Praha, July 5, 2009
  2. 2. Cameron Neylon http://www.flickr.com/photos/24801682@N08/3662760870/ CC-BY
  3. 3. Eurodoc overview The European Council of Doctoral Candidates and Junior Researchers Aim : Increase Europe's attractiveness for Early Stage Researchers Federation of national organisations: 32 Members Think tank on doctoral Mobility research in Europe PhD supervision and training Career Gender Surveys development equality (after Lara Passante, EC) Partner of EC, EUA and others in Bologna and Lisbon processes
  4. 4. http://twitter.com/CameronNeylon/status/2325135458 Cameron Neylon
  5. 5. Björn Brembs
  6. 6. http://twitter.com/lorddrayson/statuses/2346918193 Cameron Neylon
  7. 7. Björn Brembs
  8. 8. Hobbies Society Family Planet Your life Research Knowledge © Tiehuis et al., Diabetologia 51:1321–1326, 2008
  9. 9. Cameron Neylon
  10. 10. Cameron Neylon
  11. 11. http://twitter.com/larsjuhljensen/statuses/2315036730 Cameron Neylon
  12. 12. Cameron Neylon
  13. 13. Cameron Neylon
  14. 14. Cameron Neylon
  15. 15. Cameron Neylon
  16. 16. How do you maximise efficiency in generating impact for your research? Cameron Neylon 16
  17. 17. Cameron Neylon
  18. 18. In the last five years...? Cameron Neylon 18 http://fickr.com/photos/stewart/461099066/ CC-BY
  19. 19. What is... Cameron Neylon http://www.fickr.com/photos/schnurrbart/43568532/ CC-BY-SA ...?
  20. 20. Too much to read, and neither searchable nor hyperlinked... Cameron Neylon http://www.fickr.com/photos/orinrobertjohn/2188277801 CC-BY
  21. 21. www.scopus.com www.pubmed.gov http://ukpmc.ac.uk isiknowledge.com scholar.google.com Duncan Hull
  22. 22. ...in the past 24 hours? Cameron Neylon
  23. 23. What would science look like if it were invented today? after Duncan Hull http://www.flickr.com/photos/dullhunk/3389581452/ CC-BY
  24. 24. Björn Brembs, Freie Universität Berlin http://brembs.net http://www.slideshare.net/brembs/whats-wrong-with-scholarly-publishing-today-ii
  25. 25. • Isolation – each discipline has its own data silo • Impersonal and unsociable – “who the hell are you”? – Where are “my” papers? (authored by me, or of interest to me) – What are my friends and colleagues reading? – What are the experts reading? What is popular this week / month / year ? • “Cold”: Identity of publications and authors is inadequate • Obsolete models of publication, not everything fits publication-sized holes – Micro-attribution – Mega-attribution – Digital contributions (databases, software, wikis/blogs?) Duncan Hull
  26. 26. Yesterday T oday Paper Bits and bytes Brick and mortar libraries Cyberspace Institute library address Uniform resource identifiers (URIs) High cost of printing and distribution Publishing costs fallen by orders of magnitude Only comprehensible to a few humans Read and indexed by machines (e.g., Googlebot) Restricted access to a few subscribers Increasingly public Björn Brembs
  27. 27. Björn Brembs
  28. 28. Björn Brembs
  29. 29. • Won‘t go away • Should always be a last resort • They are much too valuable to be satisfied with the current pitiful state of affairs • Let‘s make them as good as we possibly can! Björn Brembs
  30. 30. Your article: • Received X citations (de-duped from Google Scholar, Scopus, and Web of Science) • It was viewed X times, placing it in the top Y% of all articles in this journal/community • It received X Comments • It was bookmarked X times in Social Bookmarking sites • Experts in your community rated it as X, Y, Z • It was discussed on X ‘respected’ blogs • It appeared in X, Y, Z International News media Björn Brembs Peter Binfield
  31. 31. Björn Brembs
  32. 32. refworks.com zotero.org hubmed.org mendeley.com 2collab.com connotea.org citeulike.org Re-couple metadata that has be de-coupled from data www.mekentosj.com Björn Brembs “iTunes for PDF files”
  33. 33. How would knowledge sharing look like if it were invented today? • No more publishers – libraries archive everything according to a world-wide standard • Single semantic, decentralized database of data in context • Personalized filtering • Peer-review after posting, supervised by an independent body • Link typology for text/text, data/data and text/data links (formerly „citations“) • Semantic Text/Datamining • All the metrics you (don‘t) want (but need) • Tagging, bookmarking, etc. • Unique contributor IDs with attribution/reputation system (teaching, reviewing, curating, blogging, etc.) • Technically feasible today (almost) Björn Brembs http://www.slideshare.net/brembs/whats-wrong-with-scholarly-publishing-today-ii
  34. 34. Not just papers, but ideas, web pages, data, materials, software Cameron Neylon
  35. 35. Cameron Neylon
  36. 36. Cameron Neylon http://tinyurl.com/dku869
  37. 37. Cameron Neylon
  38. 38. Cameron Neylon
  39. 39. ...making the right connections Cameron Neylon http://www.fickr.com/photos/mararie/3313582639/ CC-BY-SA
  40. 40. Make your work available 40 Cameron Neylon
  41. 41. Let others build on it... 41 Cameron Neylon
  42. 42. ...to increase your impact 42 Cameron Neylon
  43. 43. http://twitter.com/EvoMRI/statuses/2316110674 Cameron Neylon
  44. 44. OK, but what about timing all these decisions? 44
  45. 45. If you share as things arise, timing is not the issue. 45
  46. 46. The issue is whether or not to do science in the open, especially if you are a young researcher. 46
  1. A particular slide catching your eye?

    Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.