SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 7
Marriage Or Prostitution: How Can
You Possibly Price The Priceless?
           By Nidhi Khurana
The Exchange of women
• Levi Strauss in ‘Elementary Forms of Kinship’ emphasized the 
  women as the “ultimate gifts” involved in creating of alliances 
  and networks. 
• According  to  him,  the  flow  of  women  is  essential  to  social 
  integration,  and  groups  are  held  together  by  giving  and 
  receiving daughters, sisters and wives. . 
• But  this  is  not  to  be  forgotten  that  Levi  Strauss’s  account  is 
  based on a huge ethnographic observations, which conclude 
  that women are just exchanged. 
• The  “exchange of women”,  which  he  does  explain,  is 
  considered to be the archetype of marriage, almost in every 
  part of the globe. 
Dowry a much talked issue
• Parents spend extravagantly to get their daughters married
  off to a good husband.
• They present their daughters decorated like a gift to the
  groom.
• However, in a scenario, where women are turning into scarce
  objects with males outnumbering females as per the 2011
  census, the institution of dowry, it seems will collapse in the
  near future.
• This institution makes sense on account of the compensation
  it offers to the girl’s parents, but if we contemplate closely, is
  this not another kind of prostitution, institutionalized
  prostitution to be precise?
That bargain
• Recently, in Madhya Pradesh, in the districts of Ashoknagar
  and Guna, some cases have been reported in which women
  were sold to the grooms in return for some cash and cattle.
• The girls involved were mostly minors in the age group of 14
  to 16.
• These girls were sold at a meagre amount of thirty to fifty
  thousand or in return for a buffalo.
• Well, seriously? They are humans and not objects that have
  such low prices.
Marriage is a sacrosanct contract or a
           sexual contract?
• With institutions like dowry and bride wealth, the contract
  loses all it sacredness and reduces itself to a sexual contract
  based on monetary exchanges.
• It can be considered to be a sexual contract especially in the
  cases of bride price because traffickers usually buy brides and
  sell them in the other states or overseas, after satisfying their
  own sexual needs.
• These women belong to the lower classes and their parents
  have no option but to sell them in return for some money
  that can sustain their life for a little while.
• What else can they do when the cost of raising a daughter are
  rising like anything, when there is a little chance that parents
  can protect their daughters from the eyes of the man ready
  to wither her gullible being.
When everything fails
• Sadly, the state has also not been doing anything to protect
  the interests of the women belonging to the weaker and poor
  sections of the society.
• When it can let the rapists flout without impunity, when
  traffickers can go unnoticed, there is no way we can stop
  crimes against women.
• Feminists’ movements have also failed to subsume the
  interests of these women in the mainstream agenda.
• And while the Indian society itself carries on its hypocritical
  nature of worshipping and exploiting women at the same
  time, the only question which looms in my mind is- How can
  we possibly price the priceless
• Read more on Youth Ki Awaaz at http://bit.ly/16aLE2I

More Related Content

What's hot

Internte Mail
Internte MailInternte Mail
Internte Mail
jelias
 
Prostitution, Vd's and Statistics
Prostitution, Vd's and StatisticsProstitution, Vd's and Statistics
Prostitution, Vd's and Statistics
Angelica Vargas
 
The Legalization of Prostitution in the Philippines
The Legalization of Prostitution in the PhilippinesThe Legalization of Prostitution in the Philippines
The Legalization of Prostitution in the Philippines
MichelleBabb
 
Prostitution presentation
Prostitution presentationProstitution presentation
Prostitution presentation
asalmons
 
Governor Kayode Fayemi's Address at the 11th (Committee of Wives of Lagos Sta...
Governor Kayode Fayemi's Address at the 11th (Committee of Wives of Lagos Sta...Governor Kayode Fayemi's Address at the 11th (Committee of Wives of Lagos Sta...
Governor Kayode Fayemi's Address at the 11th (Committee of Wives of Lagos Sta...
Kayode Fayemi
 
Grant_card_Final
Grant_card_FinalGrant_card_Final
Grant_card_Final
tjacks01
 

What's hot (20)

Internte Mail
Internte MailInternte Mail
Internte Mail
 
History of prostitution in medieval period
History of prostitution in medieval periodHistory of prostitution in medieval period
History of prostitution in medieval period
 
Dowry deaths
Dowry deathsDowry deaths
Dowry deaths
 
Ron Herndon Reference Letter
Ron Herndon Reference LetterRon Herndon Reference Letter
Ron Herndon Reference Letter
 
Legalising prostitution
Legalising prostitutionLegalising prostitution
Legalising prostitution
 
Prostitution pdf
Prostitution pdfProstitution pdf
Prostitution pdf
 
Aakefa
Aakefa Aakefa
Aakefa
 
Prostitution, Vd's and Statistics
Prostitution, Vd's and StatisticsProstitution, Vd's and Statistics
Prostitution, Vd's and Statistics
 
Host Organization Information
Host Organization InformationHost Organization Information
Host Organization Information
 
Prostitution
ProstitutionProstitution
Prostitution
 
legalizing prostitution in india
legalizing prostitution in indialegalizing prostitution in india
legalizing prostitution in india
 
The Legalization of Prostitution in the Philippines
The Legalization of Prostitution in the PhilippinesThe Legalization of Prostitution in the Philippines
The Legalization of Prostitution in the Philippines
 
Prostitution presentation
Prostitution presentationProstitution presentation
Prostitution presentation
 
child trafficking
child traffickingchild trafficking
child trafficking
 
How do we socialize our kids?
How do we socialize our kids?How do we socialize our kids?
How do we socialize our kids?
 
Governor Kayode Fayemi's Address at the 11th (Committee of Wives of Lagos Sta...
Governor Kayode Fayemi's Address at the 11th (Committee of Wives of Lagos Sta...Governor Kayode Fayemi's Address at the 11th (Committee of Wives of Lagos Sta...
Governor Kayode Fayemi's Address at the 11th (Committee of Wives of Lagos Sta...
 
Dowry
DowryDowry
Dowry
 
LEGALIZING PROSTITUTION-SPRING FEST-IIT KGP 2015
LEGALIZING PROSTITUTION-SPRING FEST-IIT KGP 2015LEGALIZING PROSTITUTION-SPRING FEST-IIT KGP 2015
LEGALIZING PROSTITUTION-SPRING FEST-IIT KGP 2015
 
Ellis case dmst_2-6-14
Ellis case  dmst_2-6-14Ellis case  dmst_2-6-14
Ellis case dmst_2-6-14
 
Grant_card_Final
Grant_card_FinalGrant_card_Final
Grant_card_Final
 

Similar to Marriage or prostitution

Loving The African man final layout
Loving The African man final layoutLoving The African man final layout
Loving The African man final layout
Chiedza Simbo PhD
 
Female infanticide 10
Female infanticide 10Female infanticide 10
Female infanticide 10
shilpapatel14
 

Similar to Marriage or prostitution (9)

dowry and suicide
 dowry and suicide  dowry and suicide
dowry and suicide
 
Loving The African man final layout
Loving The African man final layoutLoving The African man final layout
Loving The African man final layout
 
Changing The Story: A Road Map For Addressing Violence Against Women And Gi...
 Changing The Story:  A Road Map For Addressing Violence Against Women And Gi... Changing The Story:  A Road Map For Addressing Violence Against Women And Gi...
Changing The Story: A Road Map For Addressing Violence Against Women And Gi...
 
Female infanticide 10
Female infanticide 10Female infanticide 10
Female infanticide 10
 
Gender, Sex and the Patriachry
Gender, Sex and the PatriachryGender, Sex and the Patriachry
Gender, Sex and the Patriachry
 
Harshita varshney
Harshita varshneyHarshita varshney
Harshita varshney
 
Women discrimination in india
Women discrimination in indiaWomen discrimination in india
Women discrimination in india
 
cena
cenacena
cena
 
Sisterhood Essay
Sisterhood EssaySisterhood Essay
Sisterhood Essay
 

More from Youth Ki Awaaz: Mouthpiece for the Youth

Dear justice katju, your reasons justifying pardon for sunjay dutt are ridicu...
Dear justice katju, your reasons justifying pardon for sunjay dutt are ridicu...Dear justice katju, your reasons justifying pardon for sunjay dutt are ridicu...
Dear justice katju, your reasons justifying pardon for sunjay dutt are ridicu...
Youth Ki Awaaz: Mouthpiece for the Youth
 

More from Youth Ki Awaaz: Mouthpiece for the Youth (20)

Annexure4 151204181641-lva1-app6892
Annexure4 151204181641-lva1-app6892Annexure4 151204181641-lva1-app6892
Annexure4 151204181641-lva1-app6892
 
Water activists remain unheard
Water activists remain unheardWater activists remain unheard
Water activists remain unheard
 
Bbs bfia-bbe course merger
Bbs bfia-bbe course mergerBbs bfia-bbe course merger
Bbs bfia-bbe course merger
 
Is the mass media sexist
Is the mass media sexistIs the mass media sexist
Is the mass media sexist
 
Holi is not a consent free-day
Holi is not a consent free-dayHoli is not a consent free-day
Holi is not a consent free-day
 
Dear justice katju, your reasons justifying pardon for sunjay dutt are ridicu...
Dear justice katju, your reasons justifying pardon for sunjay dutt are ridicu...Dear justice katju, your reasons justifying pardon for sunjay dutt are ridicu...
Dear justice katju, your reasons justifying pardon for sunjay dutt are ridicu...
 
Elegantly
ElegantlyElegantly
Elegantly
 
What does india need
What does india needWhat does india need
What does india need
 
A foreigner in my own country!
A foreigner in my own country!A foreigner in my own country!
A foreigner in my own country!
 
I celebrate the death of this beast, do you
I celebrate the death of this beast, do youI celebrate the death of this beast, do you
I celebrate the death of this beast, do you
 
Greenpeace india brings people powered campaigns to it’s supporters
Greenpeace india brings people powered campaigns to it’s supportersGreenpeace india brings people powered campaigns to it’s supporters
Greenpeace india brings people powered campaigns to it’s supporters
 
The time you enjoy wasting is not wasted
The time you enjoy wasting is not wastedThe time you enjoy wasting is not wasted
The time you enjoy wasting is not wasted
 
Indo pak relations
Indo pak relationsIndo pak relations
Indo pak relations
 
Where the upsc is going wrong with its language choices
Where the upsc is going wrong with its language choicesWhere the upsc is going wrong with its language choices
Where the upsc is going wrong with its language choices
 
Has ram singh’s suicide been of any help
Has ram singh’s suicide been of any helpHas ram singh’s suicide been of any help
Has ram singh’s suicide been of any help
 
Speaking against the ‘de facto’ status
Speaking against the ‘de facto’ statusSpeaking against the ‘de facto’ status
Speaking against the ‘de facto’ status
 
Here’s the story of a man
Here’s the story of a manHere’s the story of a man
Here’s the story of a man
 
Budget on middle class
Budget on middle classBudget on middle class
Budget on middle class
 
I am on the right track,
I am on the right track,I am on the right track,
I am on the right track,
 
Why are undisputed rights at work, natural
Why are undisputed rights at work, naturalWhy are undisputed rights at work, natural
Why are undisputed rights at work, natural
 

Marriage or prostitution

  • 1. Marriage Or Prostitution: How Can You Possibly Price The Priceless? By Nidhi Khurana
  • 2. The Exchange of women • Levi Strauss in ‘Elementary Forms of Kinship’ emphasized the  women as the “ultimate gifts” involved in creating of alliances  and networks.  • According  to  him,  the  flow  of  women  is  essential  to  social  integration,  and  groups  are  held  together  by  giving  and  receiving daughters, sisters and wives. .  • But  this  is  not  to  be  forgotten  that  Levi  Strauss’s  account  is  based on a huge ethnographic observations, which conclude  that women are just exchanged.  • The  “exchange of women”,  which  he  does  explain,  is  considered to be the archetype of marriage, almost in every  part of the globe. 
  • 3. Dowry a much talked issue • Parents spend extravagantly to get their daughters married off to a good husband. • They present their daughters decorated like a gift to the groom. • However, in a scenario, where women are turning into scarce objects with males outnumbering females as per the 2011 census, the institution of dowry, it seems will collapse in the near future. • This institution makes sense on account of the compensation it offers to the girl’s parents, but if we contemplate closely, is this not another kind of prostitution, institutionalized prostitution to be precise?
  • 4. That bargain • Recently, in Madhya Pradesh, in the districts of Ashoknagar and Guna, some cases have been reported in which women were sold to the grooms in return for some cash and cattle. • The girls involved were mostly minors in the age group of 14 to 16. • These girls were sold at a meagre amount of thirty to fifty thousand or in return for a buffalo. • Well, seriously? They are humans and not objects that have such low prices.
  • 5. Marriage is a sacrosanct contract or a sexual contract? • With institutions like dowry and bride wealth, the contract loses all it sacredness and reduces itself to a sexual contract based on monetary exchanges. • It can be considered to be a sexual contract especially in the cases of bride price because traffickers usually buy brides and sell them in the other states or overseas, after satisfying their own sexual needs. • These women belong to the lower classes and their parents have no option but to sell them in return for some money that can sustain their life for a little while. • What else can they do when the cost of raising a daughter are rising like anything, when there is a little chance that parents can protect their daughters from the eyes of the man ready to wither her gullible being.
  • 6. When everything fails • Sadly, the state has also not been doing anything to protect the interests of the women belonging to the weaker and poor sections of the society. • When it can let the rapists flout without impunity, when traffickers can go unnoticed, there is no way we can stop crimes against women. • Feminists’ movements have also failed to subsume the interests of these women in the mainstream agenda. • And while the Indian society itself carries on its hypocritical nature of worshipping and exploiting women at the same time, the only question which looms in my mind is- How can we possibly price the priceless
  • 7. • Read more on Youth Ki Awaaz at http://bit.ly/16aLE2I