SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Una crítica al Communicative
    Language Teaching



                       Lic. Nick Izquierdo
• CLT fails to take account of the knowledge
  and skills which language students bring with
  them from the mother tongue.

• The Communicative Approach generally
  presents an over-simplified and misleading
  account of [the proces of acquiring a foreign
  language]

• The dominance of CLT has led to the neglect
  of one crucial aspect of language pedagogy,
  namely the context in which that pedagogy
  takes place.
References

Swan, M. (January 01, 1985). A Critical Look at
the Communicative Approach (1). Elt Journal,
39, 1, 2-12.
Swan, M. (April 01, 1985). A Critical Look at
the Communicative Approach (2). Elt Journal,
39, 2, 76-87.
Bax, S. (July 01, 2003). The end of CLT: a
context approach to language teaching. Elt
Journal, 57, 3, 278-287
Gracias

More Related Content

What's hot

Isfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammar
Isfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammarIsfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammar
Isfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammar
stellams
 
A taste of applied linguistics
A taste of applied linguisticsA taste of applied linguistics
A taste of applied linguistics
Sungwoo Kim
 
Week 3 4
Week 3 4Week 3 4
Week 3 4
Sreenivasa Rao
 
Applied linguistics introduction
Applied linguistics introductionApplied linguistics introduction
Applied linguistics introductionSilviaMorgavi
 
An overview of applied linguistics
An overview of applied linguisticsAn overview of applied linguistics
An overview of applied linguisticsAlicia Ruiz
 
Week 5
Week 5Week 5
Five generations of Applied Linguistics
Five generations of Applied LinguisticsFive generations of Applied Linguistics
Five generations of Applied Linguistics
edac4co
 
Co-Constructing Representations of Culture in ESL and EFL Classrooms: Discurs...
Co-Constructing Representations of Culture in ESL and EFL Classrooms: Discurs...Co-Constructing Representations of Culture in ESL and EFL Classrooms: Discurs...
Co-Constructing Representations of Culture in ESL and EFL Classrooms: Discurs...Samira Rahmdel
 
What is applied linguistics
What is applied linguisticsWhat is applied linguistics
What is applied linguistics
King Saud University
 
Iaslt 2011
Iaslt 2011Iaslt 2011
Iaslt 2011CameliaN
 
Applied linguistics
Applied linguisticsApplied linguistics
Applied linguistics
Johanna Villanueva
 
Linguistic and Applied linguistic contribution to English Teaching
Linguistic and Applied linguistic contribution to English TeachingLinguistic and Applied linguistic contribution to English Teaching
Linguistic and Applied linguistic contribution to English TeachingKing Saud University
 
Applied Linguistics: an emerging discipline for twenty first century.
Applied Linguistics: an emerging discipline for twenty first century.Applied Linguistics: an emerging discipline for twenty first century.
Applied Linguistics: an emerging discipline for twenty first century.edac4co
 
Edulearn 2014 - Barcelona/Spain
Edulearn 2014 - Barcelona/SpainEdulearn 2014 - Barcelona/Spain
Edulearn 2014 - Barcelona/Spain
Adolfo Tanzi Neto - University of Oxford
 
Week 1
Week 1Week 1
A Genre-Based Model Language
A Genre-Based Model LanguageA Genre-Based Model Language
A Genre-Based Model Language
Erica Gisela Delgado
 
What is Applied Linguistics?
What is Applied Linguistics?What is Applied Linguistics?
What is Applied Linguistics?
Shajaira Lopez
 
Historical overview of esl education feb. 21
Historical overview of esl education feb. 21Historical overview of esl education feb. 21
Historical overview of esl education feb. 21candyvdv
 
Sociolinguistics
SociolinguisticsSociolinguistics
Sociolinguistics
Achmad Philip
 
Second Class Applied Linguistics
Second Class Applied LinguisticsSecond Class Applied Linguistics
Second Class Applied Linguistics
jesler
 

What's hot (20)

Isfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammar
Isfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammarIsfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammar
Isfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammar
 
A taste of applied linguistics
A taste of applied linguisticsA taste of applied linguistics
A taste of applied linguistics
 
Week 3 4
Week 3 4Week 3 4
Week 3 4
 
Applied linguistics introduction
Applied linguistics introductionApplied linguistics introduction
Applied linguistics introduction
 
An overview of applied linguistics
An overview of applied linguisticsAn overview of applied linguistics
An overview of applied linguistics
 
Week 5
Week 5Week 5
Week 5
 
Five generations of Applied Linguistics
Five generations of Applied LinguisticsFive generations of Applied Linguistics
Five generations of Applied Linguistics
 
Co-Constructing Representations of Culture in ESL and EFL Classrooms: Discurs...
Co-Constructing Representations of Culture in ESL and EFL Classrooms: Discurs...Co-Constructing Representations of Culture in ESL and EFL Classrooms: Discurs...
Co-Constructing Representations of Culture in ESL and EFL Classrooms: Discurs...
 
What is applied linguistics
What is applied linguisticsWhat is applied linguistics
What is applied linguistics
 
Iaslt 2011
Iaslt 2011Iaslt 2011
Iaslt 2011
 
Applied linguistics
Applied linguisticsApplied linguistics
Applied linguistics
 
Linguistic and Applied linguistic contribution to English Teaching
Linguistic and Applied linguistic contribution to English TeachingLinguistic and Applied linguistic contribution to English Teaching
Linguistic and Applied linguistic contribution to English Teaching
 
Applied Linguistics: an emerging discipline for twenty first century.
Applied Linguistics: an emerging discipline for twenty first century.Applied Linguistics: an emerging discipline for twenty first century.
Applied Linguistics: an emerging discipline for twenty first century.
 
Edulearn 2014 - Barcelona/Spain
Edulearn 2014 - Barcelona/SpainEdulearn 2014 - Barcelona/Spain
Edulearn 2014 - Barcelona/Spain
 
Week 1
Week 1Week 1
Week 1
 
A Genre-Based Model Language
A Genre-Based Model LanguageA Genre-Based Model Language
A Genre-Based Model Language
 
What is Applied Linguistics?
What is Applied Linguistics?What is Applied Linguistics?
What is Applied Linguistics?
 
Historical overview of esl education feb. 21
Historical overview of esl education feb. 21Historical overview of esl education feb. 21
Historical overview of esl education feb. 21
 
Sociolinguistics
SociolinguisticsSociolinguistics
Sociolinguistics
 
Second Class Applied Linguistics
Second Class Applied LinguisticsSecond Class Applied Linguistics
Second Class Applied Linguistics
 

Similar to Una crítica al communicative language teaching

Communicative language method
Communicative language methodCommunicative language method
Communicative language method
Pawarit Pingmaung
 
English language teaching, ch4
English language teaching, ch4English language teaching, ch4
English language teaching, ch4
VivaAs
 
The framework of materials and methods and current approaches to materials an...
The framework of materials and methods and current approaches to materials an...The framework of materials and methods and current approaches to materials an...
The framework of materials and methods and current approaches to materials an...
UNY Pasca PBI-B
 
An analysis of cultural contents ... work-in-progress-seminar
An analysis of cultural contents ...  work-in-progress-seminarAn analysis of cultural contents ...  work-in-progress-seminar
An analysis of cultural contents ... work-in-progress-seminar
iwanmunandar2014
 
Tmuj p48
Tmuj p48Tmuj p48
Tmuj p48
TMUJ_2016
 
Deductive and inductive_grammar_teaching-libre
Deductive and inductive_grammar_teaching-libreDeductive and inductive_grammar_teaching-libre
Deductive and inductive_grammar_teaching-libreAlrasheed Eisa
 
Communicative Language Teaching (Complete)
Communicative Language Teaching (Complete)Communicative Language Teaching (Complete)
Communicative Language Teaching (Complete)
Haidee Sanchez
 
English Language Teaching Materials and Learners’ Cultural Identity
English Language Teaching Materials and Learners’ Cultural Identity English Language Teaching Materials and Learners’ Cultural Identity
English Language Teaching Materials and Learners’ Cultural Identity
Samaneh Shafeie
 
Communicative approaches to teaching grammar
Communicative approaches to teaching grammarCommunicative approaches to teaching grammar
Communicative approaches to teaching grammarzainun_zain
 
research proposal qualitative.pptx
research proposal qualitative.pptxresearch proposal qualitative.pptx
research proposal qualitative.pptx
AERINAFAZLINBINTIARJ
 
MACAM-MACAM TEACHING TECHNIQUES info gap.pdf
MACAM-MACAM TEACHING TECHNIQUES info gap.pdfMACAM-MACAM TEACHING TECHNIQUES info gap.pdf
MACAM-MACAM TEACHING TECHNIQUES info gap.pdf
SyahariSukandar1
 
Features of foreign language education
Features of foreign language educationFeatures of foreign language education
Features of foreign language education
SubmissionResearchpa
 
Unit1_Accessible (1).doc FHHRYHRYH6HHHYYY
Unit1_Accessible (1).doc FHHRYHRYH6HHHYYYUnit1_Accessible (1).doc FHHRYHRYH6HHHYYY
Unit1_Accessible (1).doc FHHRYHRYH6HHHYYY
gardiamail12
 
Unit1_Accessible (1).docznnz hnznfnzfnzzf
Unit1_Accessible (1).docznnz hnznfnzfnzzfUnit1_Accessible (1).docznnz hnznfnzfnzzf
Unit1_Accessible (1).docznnz hnznfnzfnzzf
gardiamail12
 
Incorporating Culture into EFL Curriculum
Incorporating Culture into EFL Curriculum Incorporating Culture into EFL Curriculum
Incorporating Culture into EFL Curriculum
yohanes11
 
A Review Of Second Language Teaching And Learning Through Short Fiction And C...
A Review Of Second Language Teaching And Learning Through Short Fiction And C...A Review Of Second Language Teaching And Learning Through Short Fiction And C...
A Review Of Second Language Teaching And Learning Through Short Fiction And C...
Wendy Berg
 
Social Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFL
Social Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFLSocial Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFL
Social Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFL
Soth Sok
 

Similar to Una crítica al communicative language teaching (20)

Communicative language method
Communicative language methodCommunicative language method
Communicative language method
 
English language teaching, ch4
English language teaching, ch4English language teaching, ch4
English language teaching, ch4
 
The framework of materials and methods and current approaches to materials an...
The framework of materials and methods and current approaches to materials an...The framework of materials and methods and current approaches to materials an...
The framework of materials and methods and current approaches to materials an...
 
An analysis of cultural contents ... work-in-progress-seminar
An analysis of cultural contents ...  work-in-progress-seminarAn analysis of cultural contents ...  work-in-progress-seminar
An analysis of cultural contents ... work-in-progress-seminar
 
Tmuj p48
Tmuj p48Tmuj p48
Tmuj p48
 
Deductive and inductive_grammar_teaching-libre
Deductive and inductive_grammar_teaching-libreDeductive and inductive_grammar_teaching-libre
Deductive and inductive_grammar_teaching-libre
 
Communicative Language Teaching (Complete)
Communicative Language Teaching (Complete)Communicative Language Teaching (Complete)
Communicative Language Teaching (Complete)
 
English Language Teaching Materials and Learners’ Cultural Identity
English Language Teaching Materials and Learners’ Cultural Identity English Language Teaching Materials and Learners’ Cultural Identity
English Language Teaching Materials and Learners’ Cultural Identity
 
Communicative approaches to teaching grammar
Communicative approaches to teaching grammarCommunicative approaches to teaching grammar
Communicative approaches to teaching grammar
 
research proposal qualitative.pptx
research proposal qualitative.pptxresearch proposal qualitative.pptx
research proposal qualitative.pptx
 
MACAM-MACAM TEACHING TECHNIQUES info gap.pdf
MACAM-MACAM TEACHING TECHNIQUES info gap.pdfMACAM-MACAM TEACHING TECHNIQUES info gap.pdf
MACAM-MACAM TEACHING TECHNIQUES info gap.pdf
 
Task based language teaching
Task based language teachingTask based language teaching
Task based language teaching
 
Features of foreign language education
Features of foreign language educationFeatures of foreign language education
Features of foreign language education
 
Unit1_Accessible (1).doc FHHRYHRYH6HHHYYY
Unit1_Accessible (1).doc FHHRYHRYH6HHHYYYUnit1_Accessible (1).doc FHHRYHRYH6HHHYYY
Unit1_Accessible (1).doc FHHRYHRYH6HHHYYY
 
Unit1_Accessible (1).docznnz hnznfnzfnzzf
Unit1_Accessible (1).docznnz hnznfnzfnzzfUnit1_Accessible (1).docznnz hnznfnzfnzzf
Unit1_Accessible (1).docznnz hnznfnzfnzzf
 
AICLE-CLIL
AICLE-CLILAICLE-CLIL
AICLE-CLIL
 
CLIL
CLILCLIL
CLIL
 
Incorporating Culture into EFL Curriculum
Incorporating Culture into EFL Curriculum Incorporating Culture into EFL Curriculum
Incorporating Culture into EFL Curriculum
 
A Review Of Second Language Teaching And Learning Through Short Fiction And C...
A Review Of Second Language Teaching And Learning Through Short Fiction And C...A Review Of Second Language Teaching And Learning Through Short Fiction And C...
A Review Of Second Language Teaching And Learning Through Short Fiction And C...
 
Social Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFL
Social Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFLSocial Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFL
Social Contexts of SLA, Sok Soth, RUPP, IFL
 

More from Videoconferencias UTPL

La oración en clave de espiritualidad misionera
La oración en clave de espiritualidad misioneraLa oración en clave de espiritualidad misionera
La oración en clave de espiritualidad misioneraVideoconferencias UTPL
 
Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (Lineas y proyectos de investigación )
Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (Lineas y proyectos de investigación )Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (Lineas y proyectos de investigación )
Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (Lineas y proyectos de investigación )Videoconferencias UTPL
 
Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (objetivos y planificacion)
Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (objetivos y planificacion)Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (objetivos y planificacion)
Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (objetivos y planificacion)
Videoconferencias UTPL
 
Introducción a las ciencias ambientales
Introducción a las ciencias ambientalesIntroducción a las ciencias ambientales
Introducción a las ciencias ambientalesVideoconferencias UTPL
 

More from Videoconferencias UTPL (20)

La oración en clave de espiritualidad misionera
La oración en clave de espiritualidad misioneraLa oración en clave de espiritualidad misionera
La oración en clave de espiritualidad misionera
 
Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (Lineas y proyectos de investigación )
Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (Lineas y proyectos de investigación )Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (Lineas y proyectos de investigación )
Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (Lineas y proyectos de investigación )
 
Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (objetivos y planificacion)
Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (objetivos y planificacion)Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (objetivos y planificacion)
Asesoria trabajo fin de titulacion (objetivos y planificacion)
 
Generos graficos
Generos graficosGeneros graficos
Generos graficos
 
Periodismo digital
Periodismo digitalPeriodismo digital
Periodismo digital
 
El editorial
El editorialEl editorial
El editorial
 
La entrevista
La entrevistaLa entrevista
La entrevista
 
La noticia
La noticiaLa noticia
La noticia
 
Generos periodisticos
Generos periodisticosGeneros periodisticos
Generos periodisticos
 
Biología general
Biología generalBiología general
Biología general
 
Introducción a las ciencias ambientales
Introducción a las ciencias ambientalesIntroducción a las ciencias ambientales
Introducción a las ciencias ambientales
 
Expresion oral y escrita
Expresion oral y escritaExpresion oral y escrita
Expresion oral y escrita
 
Matematicas I
Matematicas IMatematicas I
Matematicas I
 
Contabilidad general I
Contabilidad general IContabilidad general I
Contabilidad general I
 
Realidad Nacional
Realidad NacionalRealidad Nacional
Realidad Nacional
 
Aplicación de nuevas tecnologías
Aplicación de nuevas tecnologíasAplicación de nuevas tecnologías
Aplicación de nuevas tecnologías
 
Marketing y protocolo empresarial
Marketing y protocolo empresarialMarketing y protocolo empresarial
Marketing y protocolo empresarial
 
Gerencia educativa
Gerencia educativaGerencia educativa
Gerencia educativa
 
Toma de decisiones
Toma de decisiones Toma de decisiones
Toma de decisiones
 
Ejercicios fonetica y fonologia
Ejercicios fonetica y fonologiaEjercicios fonetica y fonologia
Ejercicios fonetica y fonologia
 

Una crítica al communicative language teaching

  • 1. Una crítica al Communicative Language Teaching Lic. Nick Izquierdo
  • 2. • CLT fails to take account of the knowledge and skills which language students bring with them from the mother tongue. • The Communicative Approach generally presents an over-simplified and misleading account of [the proces of acquiring a foreign language] • The dominance of CLT has led to the neglect of one crucial aspect of language pedagogy, namely the context in which that pedagogy takes place.
  • 3. References Swan, M. (January 01, 1985). A Critical Look at the Communicative Approach (1). Elt Journal, 39, 1, 2-12. Swan, M. (April 01, 1985). A Critical Look at the Communicative Approach (2). Elt Journal, 39, 2, 76-87. Bax, S. (July 01, 2003). The end of CLT: a context approach to language teaching. Elt Journal, 57, 3, 278-287