SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 
Reid Smith 
Social Sustainability 588 
Portland State University 
6/3/10 
The Self, 
Meaning & 
Sustainability 
“As the care of nature increasingly becomes an intellectual 
concept severed from the joyful experience of the outdoors, you 
have to wonder: where will future environmentalists come 
from?” (Louv, p. 147)
2 
Introduction 
In the emerging field of sustainability, many authors identify three “pillars,” or 
components, which must be supported in order to achieve sustainable development. These 
are the economy, ecology, and society and are referred to as the triple bottom line for 
sustainability. Without all three components maintaining the ability of future generations 
to access them, as it was defined in the Bruntland Report in 1987, sustainability cannot be 
achieved. Just as the three pillars are needed to ensure sustainable development, I propose 
that individuals too need to have all three of these aspects within their Selves in order to 
feel whole. Only once a person has a whole Self can he or she begin to frame the world from 
a different perspective and make more sustainable choices. Moreover, one’s personal 
pursuit of wholeness, or happiness, has a ripple effect in society, which can either promote 
or discourage sustainable behaviors from others. Despite the individualistic, consumer 
society, it is possible for individuals to take control of their social, ecologic, and economic 
Selves and have a positive effect on both sustainable development and personal happiness. 
In a sustainable life, one’s personal sources of meaning come from more than just 
individual desires and needs – the economic Self – and begins to derive meaning from 
social and ecological Selves. 
The Three Selves 
In Western culture, the idea of the Self is narrow compared to the perspective from 
many other human cultures around the world. According to Naess (1973), western 
philosophers have described the Self as being composed of two different parts: the ego and 
the social Self. The ego, or what I call the economic Self in this paper, supports an
3 
individual’s selfish needs and desires. In highly individualized cultures like in the United 
States, people tend to regard the economic Self as the whole Self, or at least the most 
important part of the Self. The problem with the economic Self, is that it does not look out 
for the needs of other people or the natural world. Ultimately, a life driven only by the 
economic Self results in a natural and social environment that no longer supports the 
economic Self. 
What is frightening is that the individualistic model is quickly becoming adopted by 
other parts of the world as the global economy expands. The model of a good life has 
become skewed. According to Orr (1992), “We do not lack for bad role models: the 
careerist, the itinerant professional vandal devoid of any sense of place, the yuppie, the 
narrow specialist, the intellectual snob. In different ways, these all to common role models 
of today lack the capacity to relate their autobiography to the unfolding history of their 
time in a meaningful and positive way” (Orr, p.86). As society continues to put more value 
on the economic Self and its endeavors, many are losing the ecological and social parts of 
their Selves, which guide human values. Without the social and ecological self, where will 
values be derived from? According to Alasdair MacIntyre (1981), “it is not possible to be 
both modern and moral since the fully autonomous self knows no morality other than the 
expression of its own desires and principles” (MacIntyre, p. 237). The economic Self that is 
valued in western culture today is doing exactly that: acting in its own self interest at the 
cost of other people and the planet. 
The social Self, alternatively, is an individual’s role in society and is critical for 
enhancing meaning and happiness in an individual’s life. We all interact with one another 
in varying degrees and adhere to societal roles and obligations. People rely heavily on other
people for support, learning, love, and death and are not merely made up of selfish desires. 
However, in recent years, the social Self has not been cultivated as it used to be because of 
the rise of various technological and social transformations, such as the personal vehicle, 
the television, and the internet. This has caused people to have fewer acquaintances as 
people in the past, and more hours spent alone. David Myers (2003) explains what he calls 
the American Paradox, or that despite economic gains, “since 1957, the number of 
Americans who say they are “very happy” has declined from 35 to 32 percent. Meanwhile, 
the divorce rate has doubled, the teen suicide rate has more than doubled, the violent crime 
rate has tripled (even after the recent decline), and more people than ever (especially teens 
and young adults) are depressed” (Myers, p. 206). Clearly, a highly individualized culture 
like the United States that focuses heavily on the needs of the economic Self does not 
produce happy people or sustainable development (see figure 1 and 2). 
4 
Also in rapid disappearance since the industrial revolution, the ecological Self, first 
identified by Naess in his philosophy of deep ecology, encompasses an individual’s 
relationship with the natural world. According to Naess, deep ecology seeks to develop the 
ecological self by focusing on deep experience, deep questioning and deep commitment 
(Naess, p. 8). These constitute an interconnected system in which each gives rise to and 
supports the other in a new worldview that is “an evolving but consistent philosophy of 
being, thinking and acting in the world, that embodies ecological wisdom and harmony" 
(Naes, p.8). The ecological Self is one that, according to Orr, is derived from contact with 
the earth, soil, wildlife, trees and animals and is the substrate that orients adult thought 
and behavior to life. “Without this contact with nature, maturity is spurious, resulting in 
childish adults with the world’s flimsiest identity structures” (Orr p. 16). Personal
5 
relationships with nature may provide some insight into the way people treat the 
environment. That is, disconnection from the natural world may be contributing to our 
planet’s destruction and many social problems. 
Like the three components of sustainability, the Self is also comprised of economic, 
social, and ecological components. Just as with sustainable development, an individual 
must cultivate each of the three Selves in order to lead towards a Self‐sustainability, or as 
O’Brian (2005) calls it, sustainable happiness. “Sustainable happiness is the pursuit of 
meaning and happiness that does not have an adverse effect on other people, the natural 
world, or the economy for future generations. Sustainable happiness represents another 
paradigm shift. It suggests that the human pursuit of happiness has positive and adverse 
impacts, locally, and globally—in the present and far into the future” (O’Brian, p. 1). The 
challenge is for the human species to take responsibility for how it pursues happiness and 
for individuals to recognize the far‐reaching impact of everyday decisions and actions. 
Losing Touch with the Ecological Self 
The problem with western culture is not the lack of knowledge about ecosystem 
processes, but a lack of direct interaction with the natural world and a detachment from 
the interdependence with it. According to Richard Louv (2005), “80% of Americans live in 
metropolitan areas, and many of these areas are severely lacking in park space” (Louv, 
p.116). For example, only 30% of Los Angeles residents live within walking distance of a 
park, according to the Trust for Public Land. Without contact with natural landscapes 
people increasingly have the ability to detach from the natural world and still function in 
society via technological improvements such as the computer, TV, and cars. At no other 
time in human history could people work entirely from home with a computer, live thirty
miles outside of the city and commute to work, or engage in social gossip through the 
television like many people do today in the developed world. Researchers at the University 
of Maryland found that between 1981 and 2003, children during the typical week lost over 
nine hours of discretionary time (that is hours not spent in school, child care, and so forth). 
They spent less time in unstructured indoor and outdoor play; computer use doubled” 
(Louv 119). Television remains the most effective thief of time, says Louv. Studies 
conducted in association with the Kaiser Family Foundation, released in 2005 and 2006, 
found that children between the ages of eight and eighteen years old spend an average of 
nearly 6.5 hours a day plugged in electronically. That equals 45 hours a week, more time 
than was once considered an adult work week (Louv, p.119). 
6 
Additionally to staying indoors, when people do venture outside, they increasingly 
come into contact with man‐made elements and not natural elements. People no longer feel 
the connection with the earth around them, because their senses are no longer receiving 
any input from the natural world. According to Orr, “a sense of place requires more direct 
contact with the natural aspects of a place with soils landscape and wildlife. This sense is 
lost as we move down the continuum toward the totalized urban environment where 
nature exists in tiny, isolated fragments by permission only” (Orr, p. 89). It is a “sense of 
place” that fosters an individual’s care for the natural world around them because they feel 
connected to the land personally. Without an orientation to a specific place, everywhere 
just becomes space that is open for our use and not any better or worse than any other 
space of land. According to Orr, “Intimate knowledge of our landscapes is rapidly 
disappearing and can only impoverish our mental landscapes. People who do not know the 
ground on which they stand miss one of the elements of good thinking, which is the
7 
capacity to distinguish between health and disease in natural systems and their relation to 
health and disease in human ones” (Orr, p. 86). If human mental capacities are hindered 
because of a lack of understanding of natural processes, it is clear that humans need to 
understand nature in order to understand themselves. 
With so much more time being spent indoors and less time in nature, children in 
most areas of the developed world and an increasing number in the developing world are 
not establishing a relationship with the natural world at all and have no sense of place. 
Their ecological Selves never form. Instead of developing a healthy reciprocal relationship 
in which nature can offer children a sense of wonder, complexity, and humility, they learn 
to fear nature as something that could harm them, detach from it in order to deal with the 
immense scope of human damage, or see it as something that humans in the past had to 
deal with and is no longer important. According to Orr, “the young of our advanced society 
are increasingly shaped by the shopping mall, the freeway, the television, and the 
computer. They regard nature, if they see it at all, as through a rearview mirror receding in 
the haze. We should not be astonished, then, to discover rates of ecological literacy in 
decline, at the very time that literacy is most needed” (Orr, p. 105). Orr uses the term, 
ecological literacy, to mean someone who is in touch with their ecological Self and is 
therefore able to see the value of the natural world and their relation to it. “Ultimately, it 
[ecological literacy] is a tradition built on a view of ourselves as finite and fallible creature 
living in a world limited by natural laws” (Orr, p. 95). 
Loss of Ecological Self and Health 
With both the ecological and social Selves on decline in the developing world, 
society today has several direct problems as a result including climate change, huge global
8 
inequities, and human health concerns. The most pressing issue is human health. It seems 
that right when people start to become disconnected from the land, nature’s curative 
effects start to become apparent. Mental‐health pioneer Dr. Benjamin Rush – who was a 
signer of the Declaration of Independence – declared over two hundred years ago that, 
“digging in the soil has a curative effect on the mentally ill” (Louv, p. 45). Likewise, 
beginning in the 1870s, the Quakers’ Friends Hospital in Pennsylvania used natural 
landscape and greenhouses as part of its treatment of mental illness. During World War II, 
psychiatry pioneer Carl Menninger led a horticulture therapy movement in the Veterans 
Administration Hospital System. In the 1950’s, a wider movement began to emerge, one 
that recognized the therapeutic benefits of gardening for people with chronic illnesses 
(Louv, p. 45). During the 1990s, holistic thinkers known as ecopsychologists began 
exploring the idea that contemporary industrialized urban living erodes the ecologically 
connected sense of Self with which humans are born, leaving them psychologically 
distressed (Roszak et al., 1995). The evidence for the therapeutic value of human 
interaction with green space is persuasive. 
In addition to therapy, nature could be used to combat some modern diseases, such 
as obesity. Nature has seldom shown up in literature on child obesity although it has 
traditionally provided hours and hours of “exercise” for children. Louv argues, “playtime – 
especially unstructured, imaginative, exploratory play – is increasingly recognized as an 
essential component of wholesome child development” (Louv, p. 48). Research findings on 
outdoor play show that nature also has specific health benefits. According to Louv, “play in 
natural settings seems to offer special benefits. For one, children are more physically active 
when they are outside – a boon at a time of sedentary lifestyles and epidemic overweight”
9 
(Louv, p.48). Increased time outdoors inevitably increases the amount of time kids are 
swinging on trees, running through fields, or swimming in a lake, which lead to healthier 
adults. 
In addition to helping child obesity, nature is also shown to help children with some 
mental diseases, such as anxiety, depression and ADHD. “New evidence suggests that the 
need for medication is intensified by children’s disconnection from nature. Nature 
experiences can relieve some of the everyday pressures that may lead to childhood 
depression” (Louv, p. 50). If it is true that nature therapy reduces the symptoms of 
depression and ADHD, then the converse may also be true: ADHD may be a set of 
symptoms aggravated by lack of exposure to nature. Many children may benefit from 
medication, but the real disorder is less in the child than it is in the artificial, man‐made 
environment they grew up in. As Louv suggests, “to take nature and natural play away from 
children may be tantamount to withholding oxygen” (Louv, p. 109). Clearly, children need 
time for natural play and exploration in order to enhance their relationship with nature. 
Nature and Meaning 
In addition to childhood mental disorders, nature may also help adults with 
debilitating lifestyle choices derived from a lack of meaning. Because the ecological Self is 
an integral pillar to one’s whole Self, enhancing a personal connection with nature also 
enhances a person’s whole Self. An individual who is whole is more capable of making 
sustainable choices because he or she does not have to rely on any outside systems – which 
could be unsustainable – to find meaning. For example, people cling to consumer culture 
because it is a reliable source of meaning and happiness, despite its unsustainable social 
and ecological implications. According to Juliet Schor, people get locked into a consumer
culture because of the demands of individuals to keep up with escalating consumption 
norms of society. “The average American now finds it harder to achieve a satisfying 
standard of living than 25 years ago. Work requires longer hours, jobs are less secure, and 
pressures to spend more intense. Consumption‐induced environmental damage remains 
pervasive, and we are in the midst of widespread failures of public provision” (Schor, p. 2). 
Keeping up with the necessities of such inflated standards of living are causing people to 
live beyond their means and focus more of their time trying to make money to buy more 
things. Schor suggests that the economic boom has subdued consumers’ fears for the 
moment, but that many still have long‐term worries about meeting the needs of themselves 
and their families in the future (Schor). Due to preoccupation with the economic Self, 
people do not have enough time to cultivate the ecological and social Selves. 
A primary cause for consumer behavior may be an individual’s effort to replace the 
long‐lost ecological and social Selves as sources of meaning. A highly developed ecological 
Self within a whole Self can be an abundant source of meaning for people throughout their 
lives. According to Louv, “Through nature, the species is introduced to transcendence, in 
the sense that there is something more going on than the individual. Most people are either 
awaked to or are strengthened in their spiritual journey by experiences in the natural 
world” (Louv, p. 302). Clearly, becoming more ecologically literate will help us to live more 
personally meaningful lives. 
10 
Victor Frankl’s meaning‐centered philosophy offers a good framework for 
understanding how the personal search for meaning leads to a certain perception of the 
Self, which dictates our choices and behaviors. Frankl (1959) proposed that people make 
the choices they make because they are searching for meaning in their lives, and not
searching for pleasure as Freud suggested, or for power as Nietzsche proposed. Frankl 
argued that the neurosis of the present generation is meaninglessness. “Ever more people 
today have the means to live, but no meaning to live for” (Frankl, p. 133). Frankl noted that 
the modern person has almost too much freedom and is no longer guided through nature 
instinct or cultural tradition. This “existential vacuum” is compensated with “the urge for 
money, sex, entertainment, even violence” (Frankl, p. 135). The emptiness humans feel, 
because of our disconnection from nature and cultural tradition, results in a stronger 
emphasis on the economic Self as a source of meaning. Humans are not open to various 
sources of meaning and it is this search for meaning that dictates our decisions. 
Filling the Meaning Bucket 
A useful metaphor for the fulfillment of the Self is something that I call the meaning 
bucket. Picture the Self as a bucket and that the goal of this Self‐bucket is to be filled with 
meaning, happiness and a full life. If the bucket is full of meaning, the individual feels 
satisfied and whole. If the bucket is not full, like it is at the beginning of each day, we have 
to fill our buckets with meaning. Throughout human history and in other human cultures 
around, people filled their Self‐buckets with meaning derived from the natural world, their 
social networks and interactions, and the individual pursuit of one’s own desires. However, 
as the ecological and social Selves have deteriorated and become detached from the 
modern world, people are no longer able to derive any meaning from those sources. The 
resulting effect is that people now have to fill their entire bucket with meaning from the 
economic Self. In pursuit of meaning, because we have limited our sources of meaning to 
only economic pursuits, we highly exploit our own selfish desires. Consumerism and other 
social neuroses have become common‐place because people need more and more of their 
11
12 
own desires to replace the lost intrinsic meaning that was once derived from close social 
groups and nature. Maiteny (2002) suggests that modern humans appear to have a 
predisposition towards consumerism that is deeply rooted in our psyches. Furthermore, 
Maiteny suggests that the relentless pursuit of material wealth and goods may well be a 
response to the anxiety often experienced in pursuit of well‐being, or happiness. 
The Self and Panarchy 
A useful tool for understanding how a limited scope of individual sources of 
meaning is the cause for meaninglessness and unsustainability is through the concept of 
panarchy. Just as cycles of collapse and regeneration occur in ecological and social systems, 
the Self can also be understood in the panarchy model. According to C. S. Holling (2001), 
“adequate performance of ecosystem function depends on having all the necessary 
functional groups present. The persistence of ecosystem function over time (the resilience 
of ecosystem function) depends on the diversity of species within the functional group” 
(Holling, p.401). Applied to the Self, a variety of personal sources of meaning is more 
resilient than an individual that relies on just one of the Selves for all of their meaning. For 
example, in the recent economic downturn, an individual who knows how to derive 
meaning from their economic, ecological, and social Selves is more able to maintain a 
meaningful life than those individuals who relied entirely on their economic Selves and 
now have lost all purpose and direction in life. People with strong ecological and social 
Selves are less troubled by the downturn because economic troubles only cultivate one 
aspect of their whole Self. In fact, the economic downturn has been a blessing for the 
ecological and social Selves because now people have no choice but to use less and help 
each other out more.
13 
In addition to the ecologic and social Selves providing a variety of sources of 
meaning, the panarchy model is a good template to understand how the Self relates to 
larger and more complex structures that govern human lives. The individual Self is at a low 
level, or quick adaptive cycle in the panarchy model compared to larger, slower cycle 
adaptive cycles. Because of the ability of lower level adaptive cycles to affect larger cycles, 
individual pursuits of meaning and happiness have both positive and negative 
consequences on the rest of the levels of the adaptive cycle. “In a globalized world, policies 
and behaviors have repercussions on distant lands and people. Some impacts are 
immediate and short‐term while some have enduring effects” (O’brian, p. 2). Conversely, 
decisions made at larger levels can have an impact on lower levels, or the Self. Clearly, it is 
important for individuals to understand their place in relation to larger and more complex 
cycles because individuals are impacted by and can have an impact on larger systems by 
changing individual behavior. Therefore, an understanding of the whole Self is critical for 
understand how to change larger cycles, such as global economic policies and climate 
change. According to Holling, “with large threats such as climate change, water shortage, 
and terrorism, societies can become more resilient to such threats. Human systems with 
foresight that stabilize variability and exploit opportunity can avoid collapse within the 
panarchy model” (Holling, p. 403). It is possible for individuals and society to incorporate 
sustainability principles to move towards a sustainable society. To begin to shift towards a 
more resilient society, it is critical that people become responsible for their behaviors by 
developing a new appreciation for all three Selves. 
Other Human Cultures and the Self
14 
Despite how most modern, urban people have forgotten how to derive meaning 
from ecological and social sources, people can learn how to cultivate all three Selves once 
again. Luckily, there are many examples of human cultures on the earth today that have 
lived sustainably for thousands of years and have strongly incorporated the natural and 
social systems into their cultures and ideas of the Self. These cultures offer tips for our 
culture about how to live sustainably. From Orr’s perspective, “the study of other cultures 
offers a tantalizing glimpse of how culture can be linked to nature through ritual, myth, and 
social organization. Our alienation from the natural world is unprecedented. Healing this 
division is a large part of the difference between survival and extinction” (Orr, p. 17). The 
level of an individual’s environmental and social concern is directly related to the degree 
with which individuals see themselves as a part of the natural world. According to 
Elizabeth Nisbet, John Zelenski, and Steven Murphy, an ecological identity that includes the 
economic Self, the human community, and the planet’s ecosystems will lead people to view 
damage to the planet as damage to the Self (Nisbet et al., p.17). This ties into many other 
human cultures that treat the world with care and teach their children not to separate 
themselves from nature. 
For example, in Okanagan Native American culture, they regard the individual as 
only able to actualize his or her full human potential only as the result of physical, 
emotional, intellectual, and spiritual well‐being. According to Jeannette Armstrong (2005), 
“each person is one element of a trans‐generational organism known as a family. Through 
this organism flows the powerful lifeblood of cultural transference designed to secure the 
highest probability of well‐being for each generation” (Armstrong, p. 13). The idea of 
community in Okanagan culture encompassed a complex holistic view of
interconnectedness that demanded humans to be responsible for everything they are 
connected to, including the natural world, and the generations that come before and after. 
15 
In keeping with the wisdom of many other human cultures, many deep ecologists 
and other ecological and social philosophers are starting to integrate the idea that there is 
no distinction between the Self and the rest of the natural world. According to Orr, “we can 
make no absolute distinctions between the self and the world. Treating others as we would 
have them treat us isn’t just good for them, it’s also in our own self‐interest. Goodness, 
mercy, justice and ecological prudence have both survival value and spiritual rewards.” 
(Orr, p. 38). The value of seeing the Self as part of everything is that it causes people to see 
themselves as part of the web of life and not above it with the power to control it. This 
humility is integral for development of the ecological Self and is integrated into many other 
human cultures. For example, according to Malcome Margolin (2005), 
Built into California Indians’ traditional teaching methods, and indeed their 
overall philosophy, is something that I find heartbreakingly beautiful – a 
sense of humility: a sense that the world is far bigger, more complex, and 
more mysterious than the human mind can ever encompass, and that to be a 
full human being you need to learn to live with ambiguity and tolerance for 
the unknown. The alternative is to live with brittle delusions of certainty. 
(Margolin, p. 75) 
Nature opens the Self up to the vast complexities of the universe, which is both a humbling 
and nurturing process at the same time. There is a system more powerful and complex than 
any human can understand; but that this system takes care of us and we are a part. 
The Ecological Self and the Impact on Sustainable Development 
Given that nature provides humans with the ability to fulfill their whole Selves, it is 
critically important for local and national developers to understand the value of nature in 
planning. As more and more people move to cities, the development of sustainable cities is
central to moving humanity towards sustainability. Preserving islands of wild land – parks 
and preserves – in urban areas is not enough. According to Louv, 
16 
A healthy urban environment requires natural corridors for movement and 
genetic diversity. One can imagine such theory applied to entire urban 
regions, with natural corridors for wildlife extending deep into urban 
territory and the urban psyche, creating an entirely different environment in 
which children would grow up and adults could grow old where the nature 
deficit is replaced by natural abundance. (Louv, p. 247) 
This type of development is possible if all members of society begin to see the value in first‐hand 
interaction with nature once again. 
In addition to enhancing only the ecological Self, parks and other urban green 
spaces generally build social cohesion. According to The Trust for Public Land, “access to 
public parks and recreational facilities has been strongly linked to reduction in crime and 
in particular to reduced juvenile delinquency” (Louv, p. 179). Community gardeners also 
routinely site that one of the major benefits of being a part of the garden is that it provides 
social interaction, which is a key attribute in building or re‐building a community (Vogl, 
2003). In a study that aimed to connect how close people are with nature with 
environmental behavior found that “nature‐related (NR) people reported spending more 
time outdoors and in the natural environment. Those higher in NR reported more 
environmental concern and endorsement of pro‐environmental attitudes as well as more 
self‐reported environmental behavior” (Nisbet, p.20). Therefore, higher levels of personal 
contact with nature were predictive of ecological perspective, as well as strong views about 
the seriousness of ecological problems and human treatment of the environment. If cities 
and governments are serious about environmental concerns such as global warming and 
species extinction, getting people in closer contact with nature could be the best way to 
gain support.
17 
If embracing the connection to nature makes an individual’s life richer and more 
meaningful, becoming more in touch with the ecological Self may make humans happier. As 
individuals become more related to nature, they may feel more positive emotions. This 
sense of well‐being they experience could then result in more pro‐environmental 
behaviors. Nisbet et al. argues, “if people feel good about their natural environment, value 
and care about it, they might behave in ways that respect and protect it (Nisbet et al., p. 22). 
If people fully understand their connection to nature they may develop more empathy for 
all living creatures and the planet. As humans strive to find the solutions to environmental 
problems, we may find that in healing the planet, we may also be able to restore or improve 
human mental health and vice versa. According to Nisbet et al., “A self‐concept that includes 
the natural world, a biospheric orientation, may provide a motivational force toward 
nature protection and preservation.” (Nisbet et al., p. 23). Protection of nature protects the 
valuable sources that humans rely on, which benefits all people and societies. 
Conclusion 
The ecological and social crises that plague the world today are in large part a 
perceptual crisis. Ordinary human beings simply do not see that they are part of a delicate 
web of life and that their own actions are destructive. According to Ophuls, “any viable 
solution to this crisis will require them [humans] to see that they are part of the web of 
life.” (Ophuls p. 222) Therefore, in order to achieve sustainability, humans will require a 
psychological shift in thinking about one’s place on the earth. This will fundamentally
reshape people’s worldviews, motivators, and metrics. Because human behavior is the 
primary source of ecological damage, it is time that psychological and human philosophical 
experts start contributing to the sustainable development discussion. If tomorrow’s leaders 
are better educated about human behavior, the needs of the Self, and the pursuit for 
meaning, the ultimate benefit will be to the Earth and all of its inhabitants. 
18 
Figures 
Figure 1: (Myers)
19 
Figure 2: (Myers) 
Sources 
1. Alasdair MacIntyre. (1981). After Virtue. Notre Dame: Notre Dame University.
2. Armstrong, Jeannette. (2005). En’owkin: Decision‐Making as if Sustainability Mattered. 
In Michael Stone & Zenobia Barlow. Ecological Literacy. San Francisco: Sierra Club Books. 
3. Frankl, Victor. (1959). Man’s Search for Meaning. New York: Washington Square Press. 
p. 133. 
4. Holling, C.S. 2001. Understanding the complexity of economic, ecological, and social 
systems. Ecosystems. 4: 390‐405. 
5. Howard, G. S. (1997). Ecological psychology: Creating a more earth­friendly 
human nature. 
Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press. 
6. Louv, Richard. (2005). Last Child in the Woods. Chapel Hill, North Carolina: Algonquin 
Books. 
7. Maiteny, P.T. (2002). Mind in the Gap: summary of research exploring ‘inner’ influences 
on pro‐sustainability learning and behavior. Environmental Education Research, 8:3. 
8. Margolin, Malcolm. (2005) Indian Pedagogy: A Look at Traditional California Indian 
Teaching Techniques. In Michael Stone & Zenobia Barlow. Ecological Literacy. San 
Francisco: Sierra Club Books. 
9. Myers, David. (2003). The Social Psychology of Sustainability. World Futures, 59:3, 201‐ 
211. 
10. Naess, A. (1973) The Shallow and the Deep, Long Range Ecology Movements. Inquiry. 
16:95, 100. 
11. Nisbet, E., Zelenski, J.M., Murphy, S.A. (2008). The Nature Relatedness Scale: Linking 
Individuals' Connection With Nature to Environmental Concern and Behavior. 
Environment and Behavior, 41; 715 
12. O’Brien, C. (2005). Planning for Sustainable Happiness: Harmonizing Our Internal 
and External Landscapes. Prepared for Rethinking Development: 2nd International 
Conference on Gross National Happiness, Antigonish, Nova Scotia, Canada. 
13. Orr, David. (1992). Ecological Literacy: Education and the Transition to a 
Postmodern World. Albany, New York: State University of New York Press. 
14. Ophuls, W. (1977). Ecology and the politics of scarcity: Prologue to a political theory 
of the steady state. San Francisco: Freeman Press. 
15. Roszak, T., Gomes, M. E., & Kanner, A. D. (Eds.). (1995). Ecopsychology: Restoring the 
earth, healing the mind. San Francisco: Sierra Club Books. 
20
16. Sipos, Yona, Bryce Battisti, Kurt Grimm. (2006). Achieving transformative sustainability 
learning: Engaging head, hands and heart. International Journal of Sustainability in 
Higher Education, vol. 9, No. 1, 68‐86. 
17. Schultz, P. W., Shriver, C., Tabanico, J. J., & Khazian, A. M. (2004). Implicit connections 
with nature. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 24, 31‐42. 
18. Vogl, Christian R., Paul Axmann, and Brigitte Vogl‐Lukasser. 2003. Urban organic 
farming in Austria with the concept of selbsternte (`self‐harvest'): Anagronomic and socio‐economic 
21 
analysis. Renewable Agriculture and food Systems. 19: 67‐69.

More Related Content

What's hot

Land accessibility the burden on socio – economic livelihood of women in akpo...
Land accessibility the burden on socio – economic livelihood of women in akpo...Land accessibility the burden on socio – economic livelihood of women in akpo...
Land accessibility the burden on socio – economic livelihood of women in akpo...
Alexander Decker
 
Chapter 18
Chapter 18Chapter 18
New democratic movements for global regeneration_driessen 2019
New democratic movements for global regeneration_driessen 2019New democratic movements for global regeneration_driessen 2019
New democratic movements for global regeneration_driessen 2019
TravisDriessen1
 
The Postulate of Human Ecology
The Postulate of Human EcologyThe Postulate of Human Ecology
The Postulate of Human Ecology
Ernst Satvanyi
 
International conference on population in mexico
International conference on population in mexicoInternational conference on population in mexico
International conference on population in mexico
Saeed Anwar
 
THE SIGNIFICANCE OF WOMEN IN DETERMINING THE CONSUMPTION PATTERN IN THE HOUSE...
THE SIGNIFICANCE OF WOMEN IN DETERMINING THE CONSUMPTION PATTERN IN THE HOUSE...THE SIGNIFICANCE OF WOMEN IN DETERMINING THE CONSUMPTION PATTERN IN THE HOUSE...
THE SIGNIFICANCE OF WOMEN IN DETERMINING THE CONSUMPTION PATTERN IN THE HOUSE...
amita marwaha
 
asma and group: Women and environment
asma and group: Women and environmentasma and group: Women and environment
asma and group: Women and environment
6413Asma
 
Population
PopulationPopulation
Population
Uday Pal
 
Global issues ppt carlo
Global issues ppt carloGlobal issues ppt carlo
Global issues ppt carlo
carlonarbs
 
New democratic movements for global regeneration driessen 2019
New democratic movements for global regeneration driessen 2019New democratic movements for global regeneration driessen 2019
New democratic movements for global regeneration driessen 2019
TravisDriessen1
 
Ecofeminism seminar 4- Mary Phillips
Ecofeminism seminar 4- Mary PhillipsEcofeminism seminar 4- Mary Phillips
Ecofeminism seminar 4- Mary Phillips
FoodResearchCollaboration
 
UN, INGO,NGO Officials need Orientation on “sasrai-Movement” Pope’s “bold cul...
UN, INGO,NGO Officials need Orientation on “sasrai-Movement” Pope’s “bold cul...UN, INGO,NGO Officials need Orientation on “sasrai-Movement” Pope’s “bold cul...
UN, INGO,NGO Officials need Orientation on “sasrai-Movement” Pope’s “bold cul...
SM Farid Uddin Akhter
 
Sustainable Development with respect to Population Growth
Sustainable Development with respect to Population GrowthSustainable Development with respect to Population Growth
Sustainable Development with respect to Population Growth
Irfan Ansari
 
Outlines on environmental philosophy part 6
Outlines on environmental philosophy   part 6Outlines on environmental philosophy   part 6
Outlines on environmental philosophy part 6
Steven Ghezzo
 
Environment & Eco-Feminism
Environment & Eco-FeminismEnvironment & Eco-Feminism
Environment & Eco-Feminism
Amity University
 
Women and environment for jeju
Women and environment for jejuWomen and environment for jeju
Women and environment for jeju
Arzu Özyol
 
Final Paper
Final PaperFinal Paper
Final Paper
Mariah Bates
 
Sociology Unit 4 Part One: population, urbanization, and environment with v...
Sociology Unit 4 Part One:  population, urbanization, and environment  with v...Sociology Unit 4 Part One:  population, urbanization, and environment  with v...
Sociology Unit 4 Part One: population, urbanization, and environment with v...
Xena Crystal LC Huang
 
Women in sustainable development
Women in sustainable developmentWomen in sustainable development
Women in sustainable development
Aswani Raj
 
Child Protection and Poverty
Child Protection and PovertyChild Protection and Poverty
Child Protection and Poverty
Re-imagining Social Work Collective
 

What's hot (20)

Land accessibility the burden on socio – economic livelihood of women in akpo...
Land accessibility the burden on socio – economic livelihood of women in akpo...Land accessibility the burden on socio – economic livelihood of women in akpo...
Land accessibility the burden on socio – economic livelihood of women in akpo...
 
Chapter 18
Chapter 18Chapter 18
Chapter 18
 
New democratic movements for global regeneration_driessen 2019
New democratic movements for global regeneration_driessen 2019New democratic movements for global regeneration_driessen 2019
New democratic movements for global regeneration_driessen 2019
 
The Postulate of Human Ecology
The Postulate of Human EcologyThe Postulate of Human Ecology
The Postulate of Human Ecology
 
International conference on population in mexico
International conference on population in mexicoInternational conference on population in mexico
International conference on population in mexico
 
THE SIGNIFICANCE OF WOMEN IN DETERMINING THE CONSUMPTION PATTERN IN THE HOUSE...
THE SIGNIFICANCE OF WOMEN IN DETERMINING THE CONSUMPTION PATTERN IN THE HOUSE...THE SIGNIFICANCE OF WOMEN IN DETERMINING THE CONSUMPTION PATTERN IN THE HOUSE...
THE SIGNIFICANCE OF WOMEN IN DETERMINING THE CONSUMPTION PATTERN IN THE HOUSE...
 
asma and group: Women and environment
asma and group: Women and environmentasma and group: Women and environment
asma and group: Women and environment
 
Population
PopulationPopulation
Population
 
Global issues ppt carlo
Global issues ppt carloGlobal issues ppt carlo
Global issues ppt carlo
 
New democratic movements for global regeneration driessen 2019
New democratic movements for global regeneration driessen 2019New democratic movements for global regeneration driessen 2019
New democratic movements for global regeneration driessen 2019
 
Ecofeminism seminar 4- Mary Phillips
Ecofeminism seminar 4- Mary PhillipsEcofeminism seminar 4- Mary Phillips
Ecofeminism seminar 4- Mary Phillips
 
UN, INGO,NGO Officials need Orientation on “sasrai-Movement” Pope’s “bold cul...
UN, INGO,NGO Officials need Orientation on “sasrai-Movement” Pope’s “bold cul...UN, INGO,NGO Officials need Orientation on “sasrai-Movement” Pope’s “bold cul...
UN, INGO,NGO Officials need Orientation on “sasrai-Movement” Pope’s “bold cul...
 
Sustainable Development with respect to Population Growth
Sustainable Development with respect to Population GrowthSustainable Development with respect to Population Growth
Sustainable Development with respect to Population Growth
 
Outlines on environmental philosophy part 6
Outlines on environmental philosophy   part 6Outlines on environmental philosophy   part 6
Outlines on environmental philosophy part 6
 
Environment & Eco-Feminism
Environment & Eco-FeminismEnvironment & Eco-Feminism
Environment & Eco-Feminism
 
Women and environment for jeju
Women and environment for jejuWomen and environment for jeju
Women and environment for jeju
 
Final Paper
Final PaperFinal Paper
Final Paper
 
Sociology Unit 4 Part One: population, urbanization, and environment with v...
Sociology Unit 4 Part One:  population, urbanization, and environment  with v...Sociology Unit 4 Part One:  population, urbanization, and environment  with v...
Sociology Unit 4 Part One: population, urbanization, and environment with v...
 
Women in sustainable development
Women in sustainable developmentWomen in sustainable development
Women in sustainable development
 
Child Protection and Poverty
Child Protection and PovertyChild Protection and Poverty
Child Protection and Poverty
 

Viewers also liked

Keynote presented by Nathan Shedroff
Keynote presented by Nathan ShedroffKeynote presented by Nathan Shedroff
Keynote presented by Nathan Shedroff
IxDASF
 
The potential and shortcomings of strategic ambiguity as management practice ...
The potential and shortcomings of strategic ambiguity as management practice ...The potential and shortcomings of strategic ambiguity as management practice ...
The potential and shortcomings of strategic ambiguity as management practice ...
Luca Simeone
 
Lecture # 04 (13.07.14) the content & context of decision making, evaluations
Lecture # 04 (13.07.14) the content & context of decision making, evaluationsLecture # 04 (13.07.14) the content & context of decision making, evaluations
Lecture # 04 (13.07.14) the content & context of decision making, evaluations
Dynamic Research Centre & institute
 
Sustainability Power Point
Sustainability Power PointSustainability Power Point
Sustainability Power Point
HowardLitwak
 
04 ethical decision making
04 ethical decision making04 ethical decision making
04 ethical decision making
Nimantha Perera
 
Ethical Decision Making Process
Ethical Decision Making ProcessEthical Decision Making Process
Ethical Decision Making Process
Coky Fauzi Alfi
 

Viewers also liked (6)

Keynote presented by Nathan Shedroff
Keynote presented by Nathan ShedroffKeynote presented by Nathan Shedroff
Keynote presented by Nathan Shedroff
 
The potential and shortcomings of strategic ambiguity as management practice ...
The potential and shortcomings of strategic ambiguity as management practice ...The potential and shortcomings of strategic ambiguity as management practice ...
The potential and shortcomings of strategic ambiguity as management practice ...
 
Lecture # 04 (13.07.14) the content & context of decision making, evaluations
Lecture # 04 (13.07.14) the content & context of decision making, evaluationsLecture # 04 (13.07.14) the content & context of decision making, evaluations
Lecture # 04 (13.07.14) the content & context of decision making, evaluations
 
Sustainability Power Point
Sustainability Power PointSustainability Power Point
Sustainability Power Point
 
04 ethical decision making
04 ethical decision making04 ethical decision making
04 ethical decision making
 
Ethical Decision Making Process
Ethical Decision Making ProcessEthical Decision Making Process
Ethical Decision Making Process
 

Similar to The Self, Meaning and Sustainability

Ecopsychology Fosters Sustainable Behavior-Final Paper
Ecopsychology Fosters Sustainable Behavior-Final PaperEcopsychology Fosters Sustainable Behavior-Final Paper
Ecopsychology Fosters Sustainable Behavior-Final Paper
Jason E Evitt
 
Environmental Essays
Environmental EssaysEnvironmental Essays
What_s_Wrong_with_The_World_and_What_Can_IWe_Do_About_It.docx.pdf
What_s_Wrong_with_The_World_and_What_Can_IWe_Do_About_It.docx.pdfWhat_s_Wrong_with_The_World_and_What_Can_IWe_Do_About_It.docx.pdf
What_s_Wrong_with_The_World_and_What_Can_IWe_Do_About_It.docx.pdf
Drog3
 
RETHINKING GLOBAL DEVELOPMENT
RETHINKING GLOBAL DEVELOPMENTRETHINKING GLOBAL DEVELOPMENT
RETHINKING GLOBAL DEVELOPMENT
Efiong Etuk
 
Parchment Paper Stationery Set. Writing Paper Hand Stamped Etsy
Parchment Paper Stationery Set. Writing Paper Hand Stamped  EtsyParchment Paper Stationery Set. Writing Paper Hand Stamped  Etsy
Parchment Paper Stationery Set. Writing Paper Hand Stamped Etsy
Jessica Cotter
 
Old Age Essay
Old Age EssayOld Age Essay
Old Age Essay
Kimberly Powell
 
Abstract Essay
Abstract EssayAbstract Essay
Abstract Essay
Essay Helper Washington
 
Abstract Essay
Abstract EssayAbstract Essay
Pertemuan Ke 2- What Is Sociology.pptx
Pertemuan Ke 2- What Is Sociology.pptxPertemuan Ke 2- What Is Sociology.pptx
Pertemuan Ke 2- What Is Sociology.pptx
fiandy1017
 
Humans and the environmentLECTURE 1Environment and P.docx
Humans and the environmentLECTURE 1Environment and P.docxHumans and the environmentLECTURE 1Environment and P.docx
Humans and the environmentLECTURE 1Environment and P.docx
sheronlewthwaite
 
Creativity and multiculturalism
Creativity and multiculturalismCreativity and multiculturalism
Creativity and multiculturalism
alicarnold
 

Similar to The Self, Meaning and Sustainability (11)

Ecopsychology Fosters Sustainable Behavior-Final Paper
Ecopsychology Fosters Sustainable Behavior-Final PaperEcopsychology Fosters Sustainable Behavior-Final Paper
Ecopsychology Fosters Sustainable Behavior-Final Paper
 
Environmental Essays
Environmental EssaysEnvironmental Essays
Environmental Essays
 
What_s_Wrong_with_The_World_and_What_Can_IWe_Do_About_It.docx.pdf
What_s_Wrong_with_The_World_and_What_Can_IWe_Do_About_It.docx.pdfWhat_s_Wrong_with_The_World_and_What_Can_IWe_Do_About_It.docx.pdf
What_s_Wrong_with_The_World_and_What_Can_IWe_Do_About_It.docx.pdf
 
RETHINKING GLOBAL DEVELOPMENT
RETHINKING GLOBAL DEVELOPMENTRETHINKING GLOBAL DEVELOPMENT
RETHINKING GLOBAL DEVELOPMENT
 
Parchment Paper Stationery Set. Writing Paper Hand Stamped Etsy
Parchment Paper Stationery Set. Writing Paper Hand Stamped  EtsyParchment Paper Stationery Set. Writing Paper Hand Stamped  Etsy
Parchment Paper Stationery Set. Writing Paper Hand Stamped Etsy
 
Old Age Essay
Old Age EssayOld Age Essay
Old Age Essay
 
Abstract Essay
Abstract EssayAbstract Essay
Abstract Essay
 
Abstract Essay
Abstract EssayAbstract Essay
Abstract Essay
 
Pertemuan Ke 2- What Is Sociology.pptx
Pertemuan Ke 2- What Is Sociology.pptxPertemuan Ke 2- What Is Sociology.pptx
Pertemuan Ke 2- What Is Sociology.pptx
 
Humans and the environmentLECTURE 1Environment and P.docx
Humans and the environmentLECTURE 1Environment and P.docxHumans and the environmentLECTURE 1Environment and P.docx
Humans and the environmentLECTURE 1Environment and P.docx
 
Creativity and multiculturalism
Creativity and multiculturalismCreativity and multiculturalism
Creativity and multiculturalism
 

More from School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens

Behind Enemy Lines - Marthe Cohn - One Woman against Nazi Germany
Behind Enemy Lines - Marthe Cohn - One Woman against Nazi GermanyBehind Enemy Lines - Marthe Cohn - One Woman against Nazi Germany
Behind Enemy Lines - Marthe Cohn - One Woman against Nazi Germany
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Classical Art School Gardening Posters
Classical Art School Gardening PostersClassical Art School Gardening Posters
Classical Art School Gardening Posters
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
One Teacher Saves her School & her Students
One Teacher Saves her School & her StudentsOne Teacher Saves her School & her Students
One Teacher Saves her School & her Students
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Coconut Oil helps Heal Children's ADHD - ADD Disease, Autism & Alzheimer Disease
Coconut Oil helps Heal Children's ADHD - ADD Disease, Autism & Alzheimer DiseaseCoconut Oil helps Heal Children's ADHD - ADD Disease, Autism & Alzheimer Disease
Coconut Oil helps Heal Children's ADHD - ADD Disease, Autism & Alzheimer Disease
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
One Teacher Makes Students into Champions
One Teacher Makes Students into ChampionsOne Teacher Makes Students into Champions
One Teacher Makes Students into Champions
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Good Books help Students Excel in Life & School
Good Books help Students Excel in Life & SchoolGood Books help Students Excel in Life & School
Good Books help Students Excel in Life & School
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Greening & Restoring the Sahara Desert with the Groasis Waterboxx
Greening & Restoring the Sahara Desert with the Groasis WaterboxxGreening & Restoring the Sahara Desert with the Groasis Waterboxx
Greening & Restoring the Sahara Desert with the Groasis Waterboxx
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Groasis Waterboxx Lets Trees Grow Up in Unfriendly Places
Groasis Waterboxx Lets Trees Grow Up in Unfriendly PlacesGroasis Waterboxx Lets Trees Grow Up in Unfriendly Places
Groasis Waterboxx Lets Trees Grow Up in Unfriendly Places
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Explanation of the Groasis Technology for Growing Food in Desert Regions
Explanation of the Groasis Technology for Growing Food in Desert RegionsExplanation of the Groasis Technology for Growing Food in Desert Regions
Explanation of the Groasis Technology for Growing Food in Desert Regions
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Groasis Waterboxx & the Agua, Vida Naturaleza Project for Growing Food in Des...
Groasis Waterboxx & the Agua, Vida Naturaleza Project for Growing Food in Des...Groasis Waterboxx & the Agua, Vida Naturaleza Project for Growing Food in Des...
Groasis Waterboxx & the Agua, Vida Naturaleza Project for Growing Food in Des...
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Groasis Waterboxx Handbook on Planting Instructions for Trees & Crops in Dese...
Groasis Waterboxx Handbook on Planting Instructions for Trees & Crops in Dese...Groasis Waterboxx Handbook on Planting Instructions for Trees & Crops in Dese...
Groasis Waterboxx Handbook on Planting Instructions for Trees & Crops in Dese...
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Groasis Waterboxx Manual for Growing Vegetables in Arid Lands
Groasis Waterboxx Manual for Growing Vegetables in Arid LandsGroasis Waterboxx Manual for Growing Vegetables in Arid Lands
Groasis Waterboxx Manual for Growing Vegetables in Arid Lands
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in ...
Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in ...Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in ...
Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in ...
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Making a Week’s Worth of Rain Last the Whole Year
Making a Week’s Worth of Rain Last the Whole YearMaking a Week’s Worth of Rain Last the Whole Year
Making a Week’s Worth of Rain Last the Whole Year
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Using the Groasis Waterboxx to Plant New Trees in Desert Regions
Using the Groasis Waterboxx to Plant New Trees in Desert RegionsUsing the Groasis Waterboxx to Plant New Trees in Desert Regions
Using the Groasis Waterboxx to Plant New Trees in Desert Regions
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Greening the World - Desert Restoration, Reduce CO2, Feed the People & Create...
Greening the World - Desert Restoration, Reduce CO2, Feed the People & Create...Greening the World - Desert Restoration, Reduce CO2, Feed the People & Create...
Greening the World - Desert Restoration, Reduce CO2, Feed the People & Create...
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Groasis Technology Compared to Drip Irrigation
Groasis Technology Compared to Drip IrrigationGroasis Technology Compared to Drip Irrigation
Groasis Technology Compared to Drip Irrigation
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Groasis Waterboxx - Palm Springs Students Test New Planter Designed to Fight ...
Groasis Waterboxx - Palm Springs Students Test New Planter Designed to Fight ...Groasis Waterboxx - Palm Springs Students Test New Planter Designed to Fight ...
Groasis Waterboxx - Palm Springs Students Test New Planter Designed to Fight ...
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Groasis Waterboxx Handbook for Planting Methods & Sample of Crop Test Results...
Groasis Waterboxx Handbook for Planting Methods & Sample of Crop Test Results...Groasis Waterboxx Handbook for Planting Methods & Sample of Crop Test Results...
Groasis Waterboxx Handbook for Planting Methods & Sample of Crop Test Results...
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 
Groasis Waterboxx Technology Offers Possible Cure for the Deserts
Groasis Waterboxx Technology Offers Possible Cure for the DesertsGroasis Waterboxx Technology Offers Possible Cure for the Deserts
Groasis Waterboxx Technology Offers Possible Cure for the Deserts
School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens
 

More from School Vegetable Gardening - Victory Gardens (20)

Behind Enemy Lines - Marthe Cohn - One Woman against Nazi Germany
Behind Enemy Lines - Marthe Cohn - One Woman against Nazi GermanyBehind Enemy Lines - Marthe Cohn - One Woman against Nazi Germany
Behind Enemy Lines - Marthe Cohn - One Woman against Nazi Germany
 
Classical Art School Gardening Posters
Classical Art School Gardening PostersClassical Art School Gardening Posters
Classical Art School Gardening Posters
 
One Teacher Saves her School & her Students
One Teacher Saves her School & her StudentsOne Teacher Saves her School & her Students
One Teacher Saves her School & her Students
 
Coconut Oil helps Heal Children's ADHD - ADD Disease, Autism & Alzheimer Disease
Coconut Oil helps Heal Children's ADHD - ADD Disease, Autism & Alzheimer DiseaseCoconut Oil helps Heal Children's ADHD - ADD Disease, Autism & Alzheimer Disease
Coconut Oil helps Heal Children's ADHD - ADD Disease, Autism & Alzheimer Disease
 
One Teacher Makes Students into Champions
One Teacher Makes Students into ChampionsOne Teacher Makes Students into Champions
One Teacher Makes Students into Champions
 
Good Books help Students Excel in Life & School
Good Books help Students Excel in Life & SchoolGood Books help Students Excel in Life & School
Good Books help Students Excel in Life & School
 
Greening & Restoring the Sahara Desert with the Groasis Waterboxx
Greening & Restoring the Sahara Desert with the Groasis WaterboxxGreening & Restoring the Sahara Desert with the Groasis Waterboxx
Greening & Restoring the Sahara Desert with the Groasis Waterboxx
 
Groasis Waterboxx Lets Trees Grow Up in Unfriendly Places
Groasis Waterboxx Lets Trees Grow Up in Unfriendly PlacesGroasis Waterboxx Lets Trees Grow Up in Unfriendly Places
Groasis Waterboxx Lets Trees Grow Up in Unfriendly Places
 
Explanation of the Groasis Technology for Growing Food in Desert Regions
Explanation of the Groasis Technology for Growing Food in Desert RegionsExplanation of the Groasis Technology for Growing Food in Desert Regions
Explanation of the Groasis Technology for Growing Food in Desert Regions
 
Groasis Waterboxx & the Agua, Vida Naturaleza Project for Growing Food in Des...
Groasis Waterboxx & the Agua, Vida Naturaleza Project for Growing Food in Des...Groasis Waterboxx & the Agua, Vida Naturaleza Project for Growing Food in Des...
Groasis Waterboxx & the Agua, Vida Naturaleza Project for Growing Food in Des...
 
Groasis Waterboxx Handbook on Planting Instructions for Trees & Crops in Dese...
Groasis Waterboxx Handbook on Planting Instructions for Trees & Crops in Dese...Groasis Waterboxx Handbook on Planting Instructions for Trees & Crops in Dese...
Groasis Waterboxx Handbook on Planting Instructions for Trees & Crops in Dese...
 
Groasis Waterboxx Manual for Growing Vegetables in Arid Lands
Groasis Waterboxx Manual for Growing Vegetables in Arid LandsGroasis Waterboxx Manual for Growing Vegetables in Arid Lands
Groasis Waterboxx Manual for Growing Vegetables in Arid Lands
 
Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in ...
Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in ...Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in ...
Water Saving Measures of Using the Groasis Waterboxx in Organic Gardening in ...
 
Making a Week’s Worth of Rain Last the Whole Year
Making a Week’s Worth of Rain Last the Whole YearMaking a Week’s Worth of Rain Last the Whole Year
Making a Week’s Worth of Rain Last the Whole Year
 
Using the Groasis Waterboxx to Plant New Trees in Desert Regions
Using the Groasis Waterboxx to Plant New Trees in Desert RegionsUsing the Groasis Waterboxx to Plant New Trees in Desert Regions
Using the Groasis Waterboxx to Plant New Trees in Desert Regions
 
Greening the World - Desert Restoration, Reduce CO2, Feed the People & Create...
Greening the World - Desert Restoration, Reduce CO2, Feed the People & Create...Greening the World - Desert Restoration, Reduce CO2, Feed the People & Create...
Greening the World - Desert Restoration, Reduce CO2, Feed the People & Create...
 
Groasis Technology Compared to Drip Irrigation
Groasis Technology Compared to Drip IrrigationGroasis Technology Compared to Drip Irrigation
Groasis Technology Compared to Drip Irrigation
 
Groasis Waterboxx - Palm Springs Students Test New Planter Designed to Fight ...
Groasis Waterboxx - Palm Springs Students Test New Planter Designed to Fight ...Groasis Waterboxx - Palm Springs Students Test New Planter Designed to Fight ...
Groasis Waterboxx - Palm Springs Students Test New Planter Designed to Fight ...
 
Groasis Waterboxx Handbook for Planting Methods & Sample of Crop Test Results...
Groasis Waterboxx Handbook for Planting Methods & Sample of Crop Test Results...Groasis Waterboxx Handbook for Planting Methods & Sample of Crop Test Results...
Groasis Waterboxx Handbook for Planting Methods & Sample of Crop Test Results...
 
Groasis Waterboxx Technology Offers Possible Cure for the Deserts
Groasis Waterboxx Technology Offers Possible Cure for the DesertsGroasis Waterboxx Technology Offers Possible Cure for the Deserts
Groasis Waterboxx Technology Offers Possible Cure for the Deserts
 

Recently uploaded

BBR 2024 Summer Sessions Interview Training
BBR  2024 Summer Sessions Interview TrainingBBR  2024 Summer Sessions Interview Training
BBR 2024 Summer Sessions Interview Training
Katrina Pritchard
 
Leveraging Generative AI to Drive Nonprofit Innovation
Leveraging Generative AI to Drive Nonprofit InnovationLeveraging Generative AI to Drive Nonprofit Innovation
Leveraging Generative AI to Drive Nonprofit Innovation
TechSoup
 
Advanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docx
Advanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docxAdvanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docx
Advanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docx
adhitya5119
 
Your Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective Upskilling
Your Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective UpskillingYour Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective Upskilling
Your Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective Upskilling
Excellence Foundation for South Sudan
 
A IndependĂȘncia da AmĂ©rica Espanhola LAPBOOK.pdf
A IndependĂȘncia da AmĂ©rica Espanhola LAPBOOK.pdfA IndependĂȘncia da AmĂ©rica Espanhola LAPBOOK.pdf
A IndependĂȘncia da AmĂ©rica Espanhola LAPBOOK.pdf
Jean Carlos Nunes PaixĂŁo
 
Philippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) Curriculum
Philippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) CurriculumPhilippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) Curriculum
Philippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) Curriculum
MJDuyan
 
BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH 8 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH 8 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH 8 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH 8 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
spot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skills
spot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skillsspot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skills
spot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skills
haiqairshad
 
How to Create a More Engaging and Human Online Learning Experience
How to Create a More Engaging and Human Online Learning Experience How to Create a More Engaging and Human Online Learning Experience
How to Create a More Engaging and Human Online Learning Experience
Wahiba Chair Training & Consulting
 
math operations ued in python and all used
math operations ued in python and all usedmath operations ued in python and all used
math operations ued in python and all used
ssuser13ffe4
 
ANATOMY AND BIOMECHANICS OF HIP JOINT.pdf
ANATOMY AND BIOMECHANICS OF HIP JOINT.pdfANATOMY AND BIOMECHANICS OF HIP JOINT.pdf
ANATOMY AND BIOMECHANICS OF HIP JOINT.pdf
Priyankaranawat4
 
BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH LỚP 9 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...
BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH LỚP 9 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH LỚP 9 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...
BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH LỚP 9 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...
Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
C1 Rubenstein AP HuG xxxxxxxxxxxxxx.pptx
C1 Rubenstein AP HuG xxxxxxxxxxxxxx.pptxC1 Rubenstein AP HuG xxxxxxxxxxxxxx.pptx
C1 Rubenstein AP HuG xxxxxxxxxxxxxx.pptx
mulvey2
 
The History of Stoke Newington Street Names
The History of Stoke Newington Street NamesThe History of Stoke Newington Street Names
The History of Stoke Newington Street Names
History of Stoke Newington
 
UGC NET Exam Paper 1- Unit 1:Teaching Aptitude
UGC NET Exam Paper 1- Unit 1:Teaching AptitudeUGC NET Exam Paper 1- Unit 1:Teaching Aptitude
UGC NET Exam Paper 1- Unit 1:Teaching Aptitude
S. Raj Kumar
 
What is Digital Literacy? A guest blog from Andy McLaughlin, University of Ab...
What is Digital Literacy? A guest blog from Andy McLaughlin, University of Ab...What is Digital Literacy? A guest blog from Andy McLaughlin, University of Ab...
What is Digital Literacy? A guest blog from Andy McLaughlin, University of Ab...
GeorgeMilliken2
 
Walmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdf
Walmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdfWalmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdf
Walmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdf
TechSoup
 
RHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem students
RHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem studentsRHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem students
RHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem students
Himanshu Rai
 
ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...
ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...
ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...
PECB
 
How to deliver Powerpoint Presentations.pptx
How to deliver Powerpoint  Presentations.pptxHow to deliver Powerpoint  Presentations.pptx
How to deliver Powerpoint Presentations.pptx
HajraNaeem15
 

Recently uploaded (20)

BBR 2024 Summer Sessions Interview Training
BBR  2024 Summer Sessions Interview TrainingBBR  2024 Summer Sessions Interview Training
BBR 2024 Summer Sessions Interview Training
 
Leveraging Generative AI to Drive Nonprofit Innovation
Leveraging Generative AI to Drive Nonprofit InnovationLeveraging Generative AI to Drive Nonprofit Innovation
Leveraging Generative AI to Drive Nonprofit Innovation
 
Advanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docx
Advanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docxAdvanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docx
Advanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docx
 
Your Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective Upskilling
Your Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective UpskillingYour Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective Upskilling
Your Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective Upskilling
 
A IndependĂȘncia da AmĂ©rica Espanhola LAPBOOK.pdf
A IndependĂȘncia da AmĂ©rica Espanhola LAPBOOK.pdfA IndependĂȘncia da AmĂ©rica Espanhola LAPBOOK.pdf
A IndependĂȘncia da AmĂ©rica Espanhola LAPBOOK.pdf
 
Philippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) Curriculum
Philippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) CurriculumPhilippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) Curriculum
Philippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) Curriculum
 
BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH 8 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH 8 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH 8 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH 8 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
 
spot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skills
spot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skillsspot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skills
spot a liar (Haiqa 146).pptx Technical writhing and presentation skills
 
How to Create a More Engaging and Human Online Learning Experience
How to Create a More Engaging and Human Online Learning Experience How to Create a More Engaging and Human Online Learning Experience
How to Create a More Engaging and Human Online Learning Experience
 
math operations ued in python and all used
math operations ued in python and all usedmath operations ued in python and all used
math operations ued in python and all used
 
ANATOMY AND BIOMECHANICS OF HIP JOINT.pdf
ANATOMY AND BIOMECHANICS OF HIP JOINT.pdfANATOMY AND BIOMECHANICS OF HIP JOINT.pdf
ANATOMY AND BIOMECHANICS OF HIP JOINT.pdf
 
BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH LỚP 9 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...
BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH LỚP 9 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH LỚP 9 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...
BÀI TáșŹP BỔ TRỹ TIáșŸNG ANH LỚP 9 Cáșą NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2024-2025 - ...
 
C1 Rubenstein AP HuG xxxxxxxxxxxxxx.pptx
C1 Rubenstein AP HuG xxxxxxxxxxxxxx.pptxC1 Rubenstein AP HuG xxxxxxxxxxxxxx.pptx
C1 Rubenstein AP HuG xxxxxxxxxxxxxx.pptx
 
The History of Stoke Newington Street Names
The History of Stoke Newington Street NamesThe History of Stoke Newington Street Names
The History of Stoke Newington Street Names
 
UGC NET Exam Paper 1- Unit 1:Teaching Aptitude
UGC NET Exam Paper 1- Unit 1:Teaching AptitudeUGC NET Exam Paper 1- Unit 1:Teaching Aptitude
UGC NET Exam Paper 1- Unit 1:Teaching Aptitude
 
What is Digital Literacy? A guest blog from Andy McLaughlin, University of Ab...
What is Digital Literacy? A guest blog from Andy McLaughlin, University of Ab...What is Digital Literacy? A guest blog from Andy McLaughlin, University of Ab...
What is Digital Literacy? A guest blog from Andy McLaughlin, University of Ab...
 
Walmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdf
Walmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdfWalmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdf
Walmart Business+ and Spark Good for Nonprofits.pdf
 
RHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem students
RHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem studentsRHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem students
RHEOLOGY Physical pharmaceutics-II notes for B.pharm 4th sem students
 
ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...
ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...
ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...
 
How to deliver Powerpoint Presentations.pptx
How to deliver Powerpoint  Presentations.pptxHow to deliver Powerpoint  Presentations.pptx
How to deliver Powerpoint Presentations.pptx
 

The Self, Meaning and Sustainability

  • 1. 1 Reid Smith Social Sustainability 588 Portland State University 6/3/10 The Self, Meaning & Sustainability “As the care of nature increasingly becomes an intellectual concept severed from the joyful experience of the outdoors, you have to wonder: where will future environmentalists come from?” (Louv, p. 147)
  • 2. 2 Introduction In the emerging field of sustainability, many authors identify three “pillars,” or components, which must be supported in order to achieve sustainable development. These are the economy, ecology, and society and are referred to as the triple bottom line for sustainability. Without all three components maintaining the ability of future generations to access them, as it was defined in the Bruntland Report in 1987, sustainability cannot be achieved. Just as the three pillars are needed to ensure sustainable development, I propose that individuals too need to have all three of these aspects within their Selves in order to feel whole. Only once a person has a whole Self can he or she begin to frame the world from a different perspective and make more sustainable choices. Moreover, one’s personal pursuit of wholeness, or happiness, has a ripple effect in society, which can either promote or discourage sustainable behaviors from others. Despite the individualistic, consumer society, it is possible for individuals to take control of their social, ecologic, and economic Selves and have a positive effect on both sustainable development and personal happiness. In a sustainable life, one’s personal sources of meaning come from more than just individual desires and needs – the economic Self – and begins to derive meaning from social and ecological Selves. The Three Selves In Western culture, the idea of the Self is narrow compared to the perspective from many other human cultures around the world. According to Naess (1973), western philosophers have described the Self as being composed of two different parts: the ego and the social Self. The ego, or what I call the economic Self in this paper, supports an
  • 3. 3 individual’s selfish needs and desires. In highly individualized cultures like in the United States, people tend to regard the economic Self as the whole Self, or at least the most important part of the Self. The problem with the economic Self, is that it does not look out for the needs of other people or the natural world. Ultimately, a life driven only by the economic Self results in a natural and social environment that no longer supports the economic Self. What is frightening is that the individualistic model is quickly becoming adopted by other parts of the world as the global economy expands. The model of a good life has become skewed. According to Orr (1992), “We do not lack for bad role models: the careerist, the itinerant professional vandal devoid of any sense of place, the yuppie, the narrow specialist, the intellectual snob. In different ways, these all to common role models of today lack the capacity to relate their autobiography to the unfolding history of their time in a meaningful and positive way” (Orr, p.86). As society continues to put more value on the economic Self and its endeavors, many are losing the ecological and social parts of their Selves, which guide human values. Without the social and ecological self, where will values be derived from? According to Alasdair MacIntyre (1981), “it is not possible to be both modern and moral since the fully autonomous self knows no morality other than the expression of its own desires and principles” (MacIntyre, p. 237). The economic Self that is valued in western culture today is doing exactly that: acting in its own self interest at the cost of other people and the planet. The social Self, alternatively, is an individual’s role in society and is critical for enhancing meaning and happiness in an individual’s life. We all interact with one another in varying degrees and adhere to societal roles and obligations. People rely heavily on other
  • 4. people for support, learning, love, and death and are not merely made up of selfish desires. However, in recent years, the social Self has not been cultivated as it used to be because of the rise of various technological and social transformations, such as the personal vehicle, the television, and the internet. This has caused people to have fewer acquaintances as people in the past, and more hours spent alone. David Myers (2003) explains what he calls the American Paradox, or that despite economic gains, “since 1957, the number of Americans who say they are “very happy” has declined from 35 to 32 percent. Meanwhile, the divorce rate has doubled, the teen suicide rate has more than doubled, the violent crime rate has tripled (even after the recent decline), and more people than ever (especially teens and young adults) are depressed” (Myers, p. 206). Clearly, a highly individualized culture like the United States that focuses heavily on the needs of the economic Self does not produce happy people or sustainable development (see figure 1 and 2). 4 Also in rapid disappearance since the industrial revolution, the ecological Self, first identified by Naess in his philosophy of deep ecology, encompasses an individual’s relationship with the natural world. According to Naess, deep ecology seeks to develop the ecological self by focusing on deep experience, deep questioning and deep commitment (Naess, p. 8). These constitute an interconnected system in which each gives rise to and supports the other in a new worldview that is “an evolving but consistent philosophy of being, thinking and acting in the world, that embodies ecological wisdom and harmony" (Naes, p.8). The ecological Self is one that, according to Orr, is derived from contact with the earth, soil, wildlife, trees and animals and is the substrate that orients adult thought and behavior to life. “Without this contact with nature, maturity is spurious, resulting in childish adults with the world’s flimsiest identity structures” (Orr p. 16). Personal
  • 5. 5 relationships with nature may provide some insight into the way people treat the environment. That is, disconnection from the natural world may be contributing to our planet’s destruction and many social problems. Like the three components of sustainability, the Self is also comprised of economic, social, and ecological components. Just as with sustainable development, an individual must cultivate each of the three Selves in order to lead towards a Self‐sustainability, or as O’Brian (2005) calls it, sustainable happiness. “Sustainable happiness is the pursuit of meaning and happiness that does not have an adverse effect on other people, the natural world, or the economy for future generations. Sustainable happiness represents another paradigm shift. It suggests that the human pursuit of happiness has positive and adverse impacts, locally, and globally—in the present and far into the future” (O’Brian, p. 1). The challenge is for the human species to take responsibility for how it pursues happiness and for individuals to recognize the far‐reaching impact of everyday decisions and actions. Losing Touch with the Ecological Self The problem with western culture is not the lack of knowledge about ecosystem processes, but a lack of direct interaction with the natural world and a detachment from the interdependence with it. According to Richard Louv (2005), “80% of Americans live in metropolitan areas, and many of these areas are severely lacking in park space” (Louv, p.116). For example, only 30% of Los Angeles residents live within walking distance of a park, according to the Trust for Public Land. Without contact with natural landscapes people increasingly have the ability to detach from the natural world and still function in society via technological improvements such as the computer, TV, and cars. At no other time in human history could people work entirely from home with a computer, live thirty
  • 6. miles outside of the city and commute to work, or engage in social gossip through the television like many people do today in the developed world. Researchers at the University of Maryland found that between 1981 and 2003, children during the typical week lost over nine hours of discretionary time (that is hours not spent in school, child care, and so forth). They spent less time in unstructured indoor and outdoor play; computer use doubled” (Louv 119). Television remains the most effective thief of time, says Louv. Studies conducted in association with the Kaiser Family Foundation, released in 2005 and 2006, found that children between the ages of eight and eighteen years old spend an average of nearly 6.5 hours a day plugged in electronically. That equals 45 hours a week, more time than was once considered an adult work week (Louv, p.119). 6 Additionally to staying indoors, when people do venture outside, they increasingly come into contact with man‐made elements and not natural elements. People no longer feel the connection with the earth around them, because their senses are no longer receiving any input from the natural world. According to Orr, “a sense of place requires more direct contact with the natural aspects of a place with soils landscape and wildlife. This sense is lost as we move down the continuum toward the totalized urban environment where nature exists in tiny, isolated fragments by permission only” (Orr, p. 89). It is a “sense of place” that fosters an individual’s care for the natural world around them because they feel connected to the land personally. Without an orientation to a specific place, everywhere just becomes space that is open for our use and not any better or worse than any other space of land. According to Orr, “Intimate knowledge of our landscapes is rapidly disappearing and can only impoverish our mental landscapes. People who do not know the ground on which they stand miss one of the elements of good thinking, which is the
  • 7. 7 capacity to distinguish between health and disease in natural systems and their relation to health and disease in human ones” (Orr, p. 86). If human mental capacities are hindered because of a lack of understanding of natural processes, it is clear that humans need to understand nature in order to understand themselves. With so much more time being spent indoors and less time in nature, children in most areas of the developed world and an increasing number in the developing world are not establishing a relationship with the natural world at all and have no sense of place. Their ecological Selves never form. Instead of developing a healthy reciprocal relationship in which nature can offer children a sense of wonder, complexity, and humility, they learn to fear nature as something that could harm them, detach from it in order to deal with the immense scope of human damage, or see it as something that humans in the past had to deal with and is no longer important. According to Orr, “the young of our advanced society are increasingly shaped by the shopping mall, the freeway, the television, and the computer. They regard nature, if they see it at all, as through a rearview mirror receding in the haze. We should not be astonished, then, to discover rates of ecological literacy in decline, at the very time that literacy is most needed” (Orr, p. 105). Orr uses the term, ecological literacy, to mean someone who is in touch with their ecological Self and is therefore able to see the value of the natural world and their relation to it. “Ultimately, it [ecological literacy] is a tradition built on a view of ourselves as finite and fallible creature living in a world limited by natural laws” (Orr, p. 95). Loss of Ecological Self and Health With both the ecological and social Selves on decline in the developing world, society today has several direct problems as a result including climate change, huge global
  • 8. 8 inequities, and human health concerns. The most pressing issue is human health. It seems that right when people start to become disconnected from the land, nature’s curative effects start to become apparent. Mental‐health pioneer Dr. Benjamin Rush – who was a signer of the Declaration of Independence – declared over two hundred years ago that, “digging in the soil has a curative effect on the mentally ill” (Louv, p. 45). Likewise, beginning in the 1870s, the Quakers’ Friends Hospital in Pennsylvania used natural landscape and greenhouses as part of its treatment of mental illness. During World War II, psychiatry pioneer Carl Menninger led a horticulture therapy movement in the Veterans Administration Hospital System. In the 1950’s, a wider movement began to emerge, one that recognized the therapeutic benefits of gardening for people with chronic illnesses (Louv, p. 45). During the 1990s, holistic thinkers known as ecopsychologists began exploring the idea that contemporary industrialized urban living erodes the ecologically connected sense of Self with which humans are born, leaving them psychologically distressed (Roszak et al., 1995). The evidence for the therapeutic value of human interaction with green space is persuasive. In addition to therapy, nature could be used to combat some modern diseases, such as obesity. Nature has seldom shown up in literature on child obesity although it has traditionally provided hours and hours of “exercise” for children. Louv argues, “playtime – especially unstructured, imaginative, exploratory play – is increasingly recognized as an essential component of wholesome child development” (Louv, p. 48). Research findings on outdoor play show that nature also has specific health benefits. According to Louv, “play in natural settings seems to offer special benefits. For one, children are more physically active when they are outside – a boon at a time of sedentary lifestyles and epidemic overweight”
  • 9. 9 (Louv, p.48). Increased time outdoors inevitably increases the amount of time kids are swinging on trees, running through fields, or swimming in a lake, which lead to healthier adults. In addition to helping child obesity, nature is also shown to help children with some mental diseases, such as anxiety, depression and ADHD. “New evidence suggests that the need for medication is intensified by children’s disconnection from nature. Nature experiences can relieve some of the everyday pressures that may lead to childhood depression” (Louv, p. 50). If it is true that nature therapy reduces the symptoms of depression and ADHD, then the converse may also be true: ADHD may be a set of symptoms aggravated by lack of exposure to nature. Many children may benefit from medication, but the real disorder is less in the child than it is in the artificial, man‐made environment they grew up in. As Louv suggests, “to take nature and natural play away from children may be tantamount to withholding oxygen” (Louv, p. 109). Clearly, children need time for natural play and exploration in order to enhance their relationship with nature. Nature and Meaning In addition to childhood mental disorders, nature may also help adults with debilitating lifestyle choices derived from a lack of meaning. Because the ecological Self is an integral pillar to one’s whole Self, enhancing a personal connection with nature also enhances a person’s whole Self. An individual who is whole is more capable of making sustainable choices because he or she does not have to rely on any outside systems – which could be unsustainable – to find meaning. For example, people cling to consumer culture because it is a reliable source of meaning and happiness, despite its unsustainable social and ecological implications. According to Juliet Schor, people get locked into a consumer
  • 10. culture because of the demands of individuals to keep up with escalating consumption norms of society. “The average American now finds it harder to achieve a satisfying standard of living than 25 years ago. Work requires longer hours, jobs are less secure, and pressures to spend more intense. Consumption‐induced environmental damage remains pervasive, and we are in the midst of widespread failures of public provision” (Schor, p. 2). Keeping up with the necessities of such inflated standards of living are causing people to live beyond their means and focus more of their time trying to make money to buy more things. Schor suggests that the economic boom has subdued consumers’ fears for the moment, but that many still have long‐term worries about meeting the needs of themselves and their families in the future (Schor). Due to preoccupation with the economic Self, people do not have enough time to cultivate the ecological and social Selves. A primary cause for consumer behavior may be an individual’s effort to replace the long‐lost ecological and social Selves as sources of meaning. A highly developed ecological Self within a whole Self can be an abundant source of meaning for people throughout their lives. According to Louv, “Through nature, the species is introduced to transcendence, in the sense that there is something more going on than the individual. Most people are either awaked to or are strengthened in their spiritual journey by experiences in the natural world” (Louv, p. 302). Clearly, becoming more ecologically literate will help us to live more personally meaningful lives. 10 Victor Frankl’s meaning‐centered philosophy offers a good framework for understanding how the personal search for meaning leads to a certain perception of the Self, which dictates our choices and behaviors. Frankl (1959) proposed that people make the choices they make because they are searching for meaning in their lives, and not
  • 11. searching for pleasure as Freud suggested, or for power as Nietzsche proposed. Frankl argued that the neurosis of the present generation is meaninglessness. “Ever more people today have the means to live, but no meaning to live for” (Frankl, p. 133). Frankl noted that the modern person has almost too much freedom and is no longer guided through nature instinct or cultural tradition. This “existential vacuum” is compensated with “the urge for money, sex, entertainment, even violence” (Frankl, p. 135). The emptiness humans feel, because of our disconnection from nature and cultural tradition, results in a stronger emphasis on the economic Self as a source of meaning. Humans are not open to various sources of meaning and it is this search for meaning that dictates our decisions. Filling the Meaning Bucket A useful metaphor for the fulfillment of the Self is something that I call the meaning bucket. Picture the Self as a bucket and that the goal of this Self‐bucket is to be filled with meaning, happiness and a full life. If the bucket is full of meaning, the individual feels satisfied and whole. If the bucket is not full, like it is at the beginning of each day, we have to fill our buckets with meaning. Throughout human history and in other human cultures around, people filled their Self‐buckets with meaning derived from the natural world, their social networks and interactions, and the individual pursuit of one’s own desires. However, as the ecological and social Selves have deteriorated and become detached from the modern world, people are no longer able to derive any meaning from those sources. The resulting effect is that people now have to fill their entire bucket with meaning from the economic Self. In pursuit of meaning, because we have limited our sources of meaning to only economic pursuits, we highly exploit our own selfish desires. Consumerism and other social neuroses have become common‐place because people need more and more of their 11
  • 12. 12 own desires to replace the lost intrinsic meaning that was once derived from close social groups and nature. Maiteny (2002) suggests that modern humans appear to have a predisposition towards consumerism that is deeply rooted in our psyches. Furthermore, Maiteny suggests that the relentless pursuit of material wealth and goods may well be a response to the anxiety often experienced in pursuit of well‐being, or happiness. The Self and Panarchy A useful tool for understanding how a limited scope of individual sources of meaning is the cause for meaninglessness and unsustainability is through the concept of panarchy. Just as cycles of collapse and regeneration occur in ecological and social systems, the Self can also be understood in the panarchy model. According to C. S. Holling (2001), “adequate performance of ecosystem function depends on having all the necessary functional groups present. The persistence of ecosystem function over time (the resilience of ecosystem function) depends on the diversity of species within the functional group” (Holling, p.401). Applied to the Self, a variety of personal sources of meaning is more resilient than an individual that relies on just one of the Selves for all of their meaning. For example, in the recent economic downturn, an individual who knows how to derive meaning from their economic, ecological, and social Selves is more able to maintain a meaningful life than those individuals who relied entirely on their economic Selves and now have lost all purpose and direction in life. People with strong ecological and social Selves are less troubled by the downturn because economic troubles only cultivate one aspect of their whole Self. In fact, the economic downturn has been a blessing for the ecological and social Selves because now people have no choice but to use less and help each other out more.
  • 13. 13 In addition to the ecologic and social Selves providing a variety of sources of meaning, the panarchy model is a good template to understand how the Self relates to larger and more complex structures that govern human lives. The individual Self is at a low level, or quick adaptive cycle in the panarchy model compared to larger, slower cycle adaptive cycles. Because of the ability of lower level adaptive cycles to affect larger cycles, individual pursuits of meaning and happiness have both positive and negative consequences on the rest of the levels of the adaptive cycle. “In a globalized world, policies and behaviors have repercussions on distant lands and people. Some impacts are immediate and short‐term while some have enduring effects” (O’brian, p. 2). Conversely, decisions made at larger levels can have an impact on lower levels, or the Self. Clearly, it is important for individuals to understand their place in relation to larger and more complex cycles because individuals are impacted by and can have an impact on larger systems by changing individual behavior. Therefore, an understanding of the whole Self is critical for understand how to change larger cycles, such as global economic policies and climate change. According to Holling, “with large threats such as climate change, water shortage, and terrorism, societies can become more resilient to such threats. Human systems with foresight that stabilize variability and exploit opportunity can avoid collapse within the panarchy model” (Holling, p. 403). It is possible for individuals and society to incorporate sustainability principles to move towards a sustainable society. To begin to shift towards a more resilient society, it is critical that people become responsible for their behaviors by developing a new appreciation for all three Selves. Other Human Cultures and the Self
  • 14. 14 Despite how most modern, urban people have forgotten how to derive meaning from ecological and social sources, people can learn how to cultivate all three Selves once again. Luckily, there are many examples of human cultures on the earth today that have lived sustainably for thousands of years and have strongly incorporated the natural and social systems into their cultures and ideas of the Self. These cultures offer tips for our culture about how to live sustainably. From Orr’s perspective, “the study of other cultures offers a tantalizing glimpse of how culture can be linked to nature through ritual, myth, and social organization. Our alienation from the natural world is unprecedented. Healing this division is a large part of the difference between survival and extinction” (Orr, p. 17). The level of an individual’s environmental and social concern is directly related to the degree with which individuals see themselves as a part of the natural world. According to Elizabeth Nisbet, John Zelenski, and Steven Murphy, an ecological identity that includes the economic Self, the human community, and the planet’s ecosystems will lead people to view damage to the planet as damage to the Self (Nisbet et al., p.17). This ties into many other human cultures that treat the world with care and teach their children not to separate themselves from nature. For example, in Okanagan Native American culture, they regard the individual as only able to actualize his or her full human potential only as the result of physical, emotional, intellectual, and spiritual well‐being. According to Jeannette Armstrong (2005), “each person is one element of a trans‐generational organism known as a family. Through this organism flows the powerful lifeblood of cultural transference designed to secure the highest probability of well‐being for each generation” (Armstrong, p. 13). The idea of community in Okanagan culture encompassed a complex holistic view of
  • 15. interconnectedness that demanded humans to be responsible for everything they are connected to, including the natural world, and the generations that come before and after. 15 In keeping with the wisdom of many other human cultures, many deep ecologists and other ecological and social philosophers are starting to integrate the idea that there is no distinction between the Self and the rest of the natural world. According to Orr, “we can make no absolute distinctions between the self and the world. Treating others as we would have them treat us isn’t just good for them, it’s also in our own self‐interest. Goodness, mercy, justice and ecological prudence have both survival value and spiritual rewards.” (Orr, p. 38). The value of seeing the Self as part of everything is that it causes people to see themselves as part of the web of life and not above it with the power to control it. This humility is integral for development of the ecological Self and is integrated into many other human cultures. For example, according to Malcome Margolin (2005), Built into California Indians’ traditional teaching methods, and indeed their overall philosophy, is something that I find heartbreakingly beautiful – a sense of humility: a sense that the world is far bigger, more complex, and more mysterious than the human mind can ever encompass, and that to be a full human being you need to learn to live with ambiguity and tolerance for the unknown. The alternative is to live with brittle delusions of certainty. (Margolin, p. 75) Nature opens the Self up to the vast complexities of the universe, which is both a humbling and nurturing process at the same time. There is a system more powerful and complex than any human can understand; but that this system takes care of us and we are a part. The Ecological Self and the Impact on Sustainable Development Given that nature provides humans with the ability to fulfill their whole Selves, it is critically important for local and national developers to understand the value of nature in planning. As more and more people move to cities, the development of sustainable cities is
  • 16. central to moving humanity towards sustainability. Preserving islands of wild land – parks and preserves – in urban areas is not enough. According to Louv, 16 A healthy urban environment requires natural corridors for movement and genetic diversity. One can imagine such theory applied to entire urban regions, with natural corridors for wildlife extending deep into urban territory and the urban psyche, creating an entirely different environment in which children would grow up and adults could grow old where the nature deficit is replaced by natural abundance. (Louv, p. 247) This type of development is possible if all members of society begin to see the value in first‐hand interaction with nature once again. In addition to enhancing only the ecological Self, parks and other urban green spaces generally build social cohesion. According to The Trust for Public Land, “access to public parks and recreational facilities has been strongly linked to reduction in crime and in particular to reduced juvenile delinquency” (Louv, p. 179). Community gardeners also routinely site that one of the major benefits of being a part of the garden is that it provides social interaction, which is a key attribute in building or re‐building a community (Vogl, 2003). In a study that aimed to connect how close people are with nature with environmental behavior found that “nature‐related (NR) people reported spending more time outdoors and in the natural environment. Those higher in NR reported more environmental concern and endorsement of pro‐environmental attitudes as well as more self‐reported environmental behavior” (Nisbet, p.20). Therefore, higher levels of personal contact with nature were predictive of ecological perspective, as well as strong views about the seriousness of ecological problems and human treatment of the environment. If cities and governments are serious about environmental concerns such as global warming and species extinction, getting people in closer contact with nature could be the best way to gain support.
  • 17. 17 If embracing the connection to nature makes an individual’s life richer and more meaningful, becoming more in touch with the ecological Self may make humans happier. As individuals become more related to nature, they may feel more positive emotions. This sense of well‐being they experience could then result in more pro‐environmental behaviors. Nisbet et al. argues, “if people feel good about their natural environment, value and care about it, they might behave in ways that respect and protect it (Nisbet et al., p. 22). If people fully understand their connection to nature they may develop more empathy for all living creatures and the planet. As humans strive to find the solutions to environmental problems, we may find that in healing the planet, we may also be able to restore or improve human mental health and vice versa. According to Nisbet et al., “A self‐concept that includes the natural world, a biospheric orientation, may provide a motivational force toward nature protection and preservation.” (Nisbet et al., p. 23). Protection of nature protects the valuable sources that humans rely on, which benefits all people and societies. Conclusion The ecological and social crises that plague the world today are in large part a perceptual crisis. Ordinary human beings simply do not see that they are part of a delicate web of life and that their own actions are destructive. According to Ophuls, “any viable solution to this crisis will require them [humans] to see that they are part of the web of life.” (Ophuls p. 222) Therefore, in order to achieve sustainability, humans will require a psychological shift in thinking about one’s place on the earth. This will fundamentally
  • 18. reshape people’s worldviews, motivators, and metrics. Because human behavior is the primary source of ecological damage, it is time that psychological and human philosophical experts start contributing to the sustainable development discussion. If tomorrow’s leaders are better educated about human behavior, the needs of the Self, and the pursuit for meaning, the ultimate benefit will be to the Earth and all of its inhabitants. 18 Figures Figure 1: (Myers)
  • 19. 19 Figure 2: (Myers) Sources 1. Alasdair MacIntyre. (1981). After Virtue. Notre Dame: Notre Dame University.
  • 20. 2. Armstrong, Jeannette. (2005). En’owkin: Decision‐Making as if Sustainability Mattered. In Michael Stone & Zenobia Barlow. Ecological Literacy. San Francisco: Sierra Club Books. 3. Frankl, Victor. (1959). Man’s Search for Meaning. New York: Washington Square Press. p. 133. 4. Holling, C.S. 2001. Understanding the complexity of economic, ecological, and social systems. Ecosystems. 4: 390‐405. 5. Howard, G. S. (1997). Ecological psychology: Creating a more earth­friendly human nature. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press. 6. Louv, Richard. (2005). Last Child in the Woods. Chapel Hill, North Carolina: Algonquin Books. 7. Maiteny, P.T. (2002). Mind in the Gap: summary of research exploring ‘inner’ influences on pro‐sustainability learning and behavior. Environmental Education Research, 8:3. 8. Margolin, Malcolm. (2005) Indian Pedagogy: A Look at Traditional California Indian Teaching Techniques. In Michael Stone & Zenobia Barlow. Ecological Literacy. San Francisco: Sierra Club Books. 9. Myers, David. (2003). The Social Psychology of Sustainability. World Futures, 59:3, 201‐ 211. 10. Naess, A. (1973) The Shallow and the Deep, Long Range Ecology Movements. Inquiry. 16:95, 100. 11. Nisbet, E., Zelenski, J.M., Murphy, S.A. (2008). The Nature Relatedness Scale: Linking Individuals' Connection With Nature to Environmental Concern and Behavior. Environment and Behavior, 41; 715 12. O’Brien, C. (2005). Planning for Sustainable Happiness: Harmonizing Our Internal and External Landscapes. Prepared for Rethinking Development: 2nd International Conference on Gross National Happiness, Antigonish, Nova Scotia, Canada. 13. Orr, David. (1992). Ecological Literacy: Education and the Transition to a Postmodern World. Albany, New York: State University of New York Press. 14. Ophuls, W. (1977). Ecology and the politics of scarcity: Prologue to a political theory of the steady state. San Francisco: Freeman Press. 15. Roszak, T., Gomes, M. E., & Kanner, A. D. (Eds.). (1995). Ecopsychology: Restoring the earth, healing the mind. San Francisco: Sierra Club Books. 20
  • 21. 16. Sipos, Yona, Bryce Battisti, Kurt Grimm. (2006). Achieving transformative sustainability learning: Engaging head, hands and heart. International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, vol. 9, No. 1, 68‐86. 17. Schultz, P. W., Shriver, C., Tabanico, J. J., & Khazian, A. M. (2004). Implicit connections with nature. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 24, 31‐42. 18. Vogl, Christian R., Paul Axmann, and Brigitte Vogl‐Lukasser. 2003. Urban organic farming in Austria with the concept of selbsternte (`self‐harvest'): Anagronomic and socio‐economic 21 analysis. Renewable Agriculture and food Systems. 19: 67‐69.