WHY TRANSFORMATION
EFFORTS FAIL
BY JOHN P. KOTTER
HARVARD BUSINESS REVIEW MARCH-APRIL 1995

Presented by: Javed
JavedSarwar@live.com
ABOUT AUTHOR
John P. Kotter is the Konosuke Matsushita Professor of Leadership (retired) at Harvard
Business School in Boston. He is the author of 15 books, including The Heart of Change:
Real-Life Stories of How People Change Their Organizations,John P. Kotter
on What Leaders Really Do, and Leading Change.

He has published six articles in HBR, including “What Leaders Really Do”
and “What Effective General Managers Really Do.”
OBJECTIVE
To discuss eight reasons why transformation efforts
fail in organizations and to learn some strategies for
successful organization transformation.
ERROR #1: NOT ESTABLISHING A GREAT ENOUGH SENSE OF
URGENCY
 How most successful changes begin.
▪ Crises, potential crises or great opportunities.
▪ Over 50% have failed in phase 1, because of:
•
•
•
•

Underestimating the need for motivating people.
Overestimating their success.
A lack of patience.
A paralyzed senior management.

 The need for a leader, CEO or division manager to sense
urgency.
ERROR #2 NOT CREATING A POWERFUL ENOUGH GUIDING
COALITION
• Coalition
• Senior management
• Reasons for failing:
• No history of teamwork at top
ERROR#3: LACKING A VISION

 coalition develops a picture of future.
 A vision says something that helps clarify the direction in
which an organization needs to move.
 A list of confusing and incompatible projects.
ERROR #4: UNDER COMMUNICATING THE VISION
▪ Three patterns with respect to communication:
▪ Holding a single meeting.

▪ Making speeches to group of employees.
▪ Newsletters and speeches.

▪ Walk the talk, nothing undermines change more
than wrong behavior by important individuals.
Error #5: Not Removing Obstacles to the New Vision

▪ Emboldened employees.
▪ Obstacles for employees:
▪ Narrow job definitions.
▪ Compensation and appraisal systems.

▪ The action is essential both to empower others and to
maintain the credibility of change effort.
Error #6: Not Systematically Planning For and Creating Short-Term Wins
▪ Most people go on a long march unless…
▪ In one or two years you should find:
▪ Quality beginning to go up.
▪ Product introduction.
▪ Upward shift in market share.

▪ In successful cases managers actively plan to
achieve objectives. They don’t hope for.
▪ The benefits of commitments to produce shortterm wins.
Error #7: Declaring Victory Too Soon

▪ declaring the war won .

▪ Until change changes sink deeply into a company’s culture.
▪ What, instead of declaring premature victory.
Until change changes sink deeply into a company’s culture
Error #8: Not Anchoring Changes in the Corporation’s Culture

▪ In the final analysis change sticks when it becomes “ the
way we do things around here”
▪ Two factor in institutionalizing change:
▪ To show people , the effects of new approaches.
▪ Make sure that next generation of top management will personify
the new approach.
THANK

YOU

Why transformation efforts fail

  • 1.
    WHY TRANSFORMATION EFFORTS FAIL BYJOHN P. KOTTER HARVARD BUSINESS REVIEW MARCH-APRIL 1995 Presented by: Javed JavedSarwar@live.com
  • 2.
    ABOUT AUTHOR John P.Kotter is the Konosuke Matsushita Professor of Leadership (retired) at Harvard Business School in Boston. He is the author of 15 books, including The Heart of Change: Real-Life Stories of How People Change Their Organizations,John P. Kotter on What Leaders Really Do, and Leading Change. He has published six articles in HBR, including “What Leaders Really Do” and “What Effective General Managers Really Do.”
  • 3.
    OBJECTIVE To discuss eightreasons why transformation efforts fail in organizations and to learn some strategies for successful organization transformation.
  • 4.
    ERROR #1: NOTESTABLISHING A GREAT ENOUGH SENSE OF URGENCY  How most successful changes begin. ▪ Crises, potential crises or great opportunities. ▪ Over 50% have failed in phase 1, because of: • • • • Underestimating the need for motivating people. Overestimating their success. A lack of patience. A paralyzed senior management.  The need for a leader, CEO or division manager to sense urgency.
  • 5.
    ERROR #2 NOTCREATING A POWERFUL ENOUGH GUIDING COALITION • Coalition • Senior management • Reasons for failing: • No history of teamwork at top
  • 6.
    ERROR#3: LACKING AVISION  coalition develops a picture of future.  A vision says something that helps clarify the direction in which an organization needs to move.  A list of confusing and incompatible projects.
  • 7.
    ERROR #4: UNDERCOMMUNICATING THE VISION ▪ Three patterns with respect to communication: ▪ Holding a single meeting. ▪ Making speeches to group of employees. ▪ Newsletters and speeches. ▪ Walk the talk, nothing undermines change more than wrong behavior by important individuals.
  • 8.
    Error #5: NotRemoving Obstacles to the New Vision ▪ Emboldened employees. ▪ Obstacles for employees: ▪ Narrow job definitions. ▪ Compensation and appraisal systems. ▪ The action is essential both to empower others and to maintain the credibility of change effort.
  • 9.
    Error #6: NotSystematically Planning For and Creating Short-Term Wins ▪ Most people go on a long march unless… ▪ In one or two years you should find: ▪ Quality beginning to go up. ▪ Product introduction. ▪ Upward shift in market share. ▪ In successful cases managers actively plan to achieve objectives. They don’t hope for. ▪ The benefits of commitments to produce shortterm wins.
  • 10.
    Error #7: DeclaringVictory Too Soon ▪ declaring the war won . ▪ Until change changes sink deeply into a company’s culture. ▪ What, instead of declaring premature victory. Until change changes sink deeply into a company’s culture
  • 11.
    Error #8: NotAnchoring Changes in the Corporation’s Culture ▪ In the final analysis change sticks when it becomes “ the way we do things around here” ▪ Two factor in institutionalizing change: ▪ To show people , the effects of new approaches. ▪ Make sure that next generation of top management will personify the new approach.
  • 12.