SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Who bears the costs of conservation ?
Rina Mandimbiniaina
rrabemorasata@gmail.com
1
2
Mahesh Poudyal O.
Sarobidy Rakotonarivo, Neal
Hockley , James Gibbons,
Bruno S. Ramamonjisoa,
Rina Mandimbiniaina ,
Alexandra Rasoamanana ,
Nilsen S. Andrianantenaina,
Julia P.G. Jones (2017):
Who bears the cost of
forest conservation?
Alexandra
Rasoamanana
Bruno Ramamonjisoa Spener Nilsen
Sarobidy
rakotonarivo
Julia Jones
Neal HocleyMahesh Poudyal James Gibbon
WOW! There
are >36-
species of
frog in
Madagascar!
Global benefits of forest conservation
Lets ensure that the
forest is conserved
Pictures by Eric Andriantsialonina
Pictures by Eric Andriantsialonina
Forest conservation also can bring
local costs…..
We understand that forest has
value but we depend on forest
clearance for our livelihoods
“Land is the most valuable
inheritance you can leave to
your children, nothing is better
than an open forest frontier… I
am grieving that people are put
in jail because they are making
a living from the forestlands
which are Zanahary’s creation,
not the government’s
property.” Quoted in
Rakotonarivo et al 2016
...which are well recognised
World’s Park Congress 2003 – ‘protected areas
should do no harm to local people’
1)What is the magnitude
of local opportunity
costs of preventing
swidden agriculture on
forestlands ?
2)How are these costs
distributed across local
households?
3)How does the value of
compensation received
compare with the
estimated opportunity
cost?
Research questions
Contingent Valuation : 62 ( two
years after the compensation
project )
In-depth agricultural
survey: 171
Choice experiment: 450
CASE STUDY (sites) SURVEYS AND SAMPLE SIZE
Sites are similar in terms of
wealth
Costs of conservation vary
between sites but are high
Poudyal et al (submitted)
Costs are higher for those
closest to the forest
8
Wealth axis 2
Wealth axis 1
Education
Household age
(decades)
Distance from forest
(km)
Established PA
(Mantadia)
Established PA
(Zahamena)
REDD+ project
without safeguard
REDD+ project
with safeguard
-30000
-20000
-10000
0
10000
20000
Net opportunity cost ($)
Costs are higher for
those with lower
education
Poudyal et al (submitted)
Cost are very significant in terms of incomes and are felt
most strongly by the poorest
Poudyal et al (submitted)
▪ BUT the costs are
born over 60
years, still time
for this to be
addressed
▪ Estimates of the
social costs of the
carbon avoided are
MUCH higher
(10Xs) but so far
funds have been
slow to flow
Poudyal et al (submitted)
Compensation through social safeguards has not yet fully
compensated for these opportunity costs and many people
are uncompensated
Who bears the costs of conservation?
▪The poorest and those living in remote areas are
bearing costs of conservation restrictions (as yet
not fully compensated).
▪BUT the costs are born over 60 years, still time for
this to be addressed.
▪Estimates of the social costs of the carbon
avoided are MUCH higher (10Xs) but so far funds
have been slow to flow making compensation
difficult

More Related Content

Similar to Who bears for cost of forest conservation?

Drawing breath-in-borneo-tempo feb-12-2012
Drawing breath-in-borneo-tempo feb-12-2012Drawing breath-in-borneo-tempo feb-12-2012
Drawing breath-in-borneo-tempo feb-12-2012
Ade Soekadis
 
Linking great apes and poverty: the case of orangutans in Asia
Linking great apes and poverty: the case of orangutans in AsiaLinking great apes and poverty: the case of orangutans in Asia
Linking great apes and poverty: the case of orangutans in Asia
CIFOR-ICRAF
 
Sustainable Development Goals: Research Communication Ideas to Accelerate the...
Sustainable Development Goals: Research Communication Ideas to Accelerate the...Sustainable Development Goals: Research Communication Ideas to Accelerate the...
Sustainable Development Goals: Research Communication Ideas to Accelerate the...
Gregor Hagedorn
 
Forest Dependence, Livelihoods and Poverty - Class Assigment
Forest Dependence, Livelihoods and Poverty - Class AssigmentForest Dependence, Livelihoods and Poverty - Class Assigment
Forest Dependence, Livelihoods and Poverty - Class Assigment
Ashish Bharadwaj
 
Frediani Wakehurst tree diversity 2015 final
Frediani Wakehurst tree diversity  2015 final Frediani Wakehurst tree diversity  2015 final
Frediani Wakehurst tree diversity 2015 final
Kevin Frediani
 
Empower 2017Development Education Day
Empower 2017Development Education DayEmpower 2017Development Education Day
Empower 2017Development Education Day
Tom Roche
 
APES Ch. 1, part 1
APES Ch. 1, part 1APES Ch. 1, part 1
APES Ch. 1, part 1
Stephanie Beck
 
GFW Partner Meeting 2017 - Parallel Discussions 1: Forests and Biodiversity
GFW Partner Meeting 2017 - Parallel Discussions 1: Forests and BiodiversityGFW Partner Meeting 2017 - Parallel Discussions 1: Forests and Biodiversity
GFW Partner Meeting 2017 - Parallel Discussions 1: Forests and Biodiversity
World Resources Institute (WRI)
 
Assessing indigenous communities socio economic status as catalyst for forest...
Assessing indigenous communities socio economic status as catalyst for forest...Assessing indigenous communities socio economic status as catalyst for forest...
Assessing indigenous communities socio economic status as catalyst for forest...
Alexander Decker
 
Jon Bridle
Jon BridleJon Bridle
Jon Bridle
Communicate
 
Saving the Wild - 21st Century Imperatives, by Dr. Jane Smart
Saving the Wild - 21st Century Imperatives, by Dr. Jane SmartSaving the Wild - 21st Century Imperatives, by Dr. Jane Smart
Saving the Wild - 21st Century Imperatives, by Dr. Jane Smart
WILD Foundation
 
ESD
ESD ESD
Sandra's presentation
Sandra's presentationSandra's presentation
Sandra's presentation
amiladesaram
 
Forestry and landscapes: Solutions for sustainable development
Forestry and landscapes: Solutions for sustainable developmentForestry and landscapes: Solutions for sustainable development
Forestry and landscapes: Solutions for sustainable development
CIFOR-ICRAF
 
ecosystem services SW Ethiopia, Jannik, Jimma 2018
ecosystem services SW Ethiopia, Jannik, Jimma 2018ecosystem services SW Ethiopia, Jannik, Jimma 2018
ecosystem services SW Ethiopia, Jannik, Jimma 2018
joernfischer
 
Statement by the executive secretary of the convention on biological diversit...
Statement by the executive secretary of the convention on biological diversit...Statement by the executive secretary of the convention on biological diversit...
Statement by the executive secretary of the convention on biological diversit...
Christina Parmionova
 
Agreement with a tree (Greek work)
Agreement with a tree (Greek work)Agreement with a tree (Greek work)
Agreement with a tree (Greek work)
Nursery Rizario School -Greece
 
The Amazon as a Bioeconomy Superpower: Investing in Innovation & Technology f...
The Amazon as a Bioeconomy Superpower: Investing in Innovation & Technology f...The Amazon as a Bioeconomy Superpower: Investing in Innovation & Technology f...
The Amazon as a Bioeconomy Superpower: Investing in Innovation & Technology f...
catherine870535
 

Similar to Who bears for cost of forest conservation? (18)

Drawing breath-in-borneo-tempo feb-12-2012
Drawing breath-in-borneo-tempo feb-12-2012Drawing breath-in-borneo-tempo feb-12-2012
Drawing breath-in-borneo-tempo feb-12-2012
 
Linking great apes and poverty: the case of orangutans in Asia
Linking great apes and poverty: the case of orangutans in AsiaLinking great apes and poverty: the case of orangutans in Asia
Linking great apes and poverty: the case of orangutans in Asia
 
Sustainable Development Goals: Research Communication Ideas to Accelerate the...
Sustainable Development Goals: Research Communication Ideas to Accelerate the...Sustainable Development Goals: Research Communication Ideas to Accelerate the...
Sustainable Development Goals: Research Communication Ideas to Accelerate the...
 
Forest Dependence, Livelihoods and Poverty - Class Assigment
Forest Dependence, Livelihoods and Poverty - Class AssigmentForest Dependence, Livelihoods and Poverty - Class Assigment
Forest Dependence, Livelihoods and Poverty - Class Assigment
 
Frediani Wakehurst tree diversity 2015 final
Frediani Wakehurst tree diversity  2015 final Frediani Wakehurst tree diversity  2015 final
Frediani Wakehurst tree diversity 2015 final
 
Empower 2017Development Education Day
Empower 2017Development Education DayEmpower 2017Development Education Day
Empower 2017Development Education Day
 
APES Ch. 1, part 1
APES Ch. 1, part 1APES Ch. 1, part 1
APES Ch. 1, part 1
 
GFW Partner Meeting 2017 - Parallel Discussions 1: Forests and Biodiversity
GFW Partner Meeting 2017 - Parallel Discussions 1: Forests and BiodiversityGFW Partner Meeting 2017 - Parallel Discussions 1: Forests and Biodiversity
GFW Partner Meeting 2017 - Parallel Discussions 1: Forests and Biodiversity
 
Assessing indigenous communities socio economic status as catalyst for forest...
Assessing indigenous communities socio economic status as catalyst for forest...Assessing indigenous communities socio economic status as catalyst for forest...
Assessing indigenous communities socio economic status as catalyst for forest...
 
Jon Bridle
Jon BridleJon Bridle
Jon Bridle
 
Saving the Wild - 21st Century Imperatives, by Dr. Jane Smart
Saving the Wild - 21st Century Imperatives, by Dr. Jane SmartSaving the Wild - 21st Century Imperatives, by Dr. Jane Smart
Saving the Wild - 21st Century Imperatives, by Dr. Jane Smart
 
ESD
ESD ESD
ESD
 
Sandra's presentation
Sandra's presentationSandra's presentation
Sandra's presentation
 
Forestry and landscapes: Solutions for sustainable development
Forestry and landscapes: Solutions for sustainable developmentForestry and landscapes: Solutions for sustainable development
Forestry and landscapes: Solutions for sustainable development
 
ecosystem services SW Ethiopia, Jannik, Jimma 2018
ecosystem services SW Ethiopia, Jannik, Jimma 2018ecosystem services SW Ethiopia, Jannik, Jimma 2018
ecosystem services SW Ethiopia, Jannik, Jimma 2018
 
Statement by the executive secretary of the convention on biological diversit...
Statement by the executive secretary of the convention on biological diversit...Statement by the executive secretary of the convention on biological diversit...
Statement by the executive secretary of the convention on biological diversit...
 
Agreement with a tree (Greek work)
Agreement with a tree (Greek work)Agreement with a tree (Greek work)
Agreement with a tree (Greek work)
 
The Amazon as a Bioeconomy Superpower: Investing in Innovation & Technology f...
The Amazon as a Bioeconomy Superpower: Investing in Innovation & Technology f...The Amazon as a Bioeconomy Superpower: Investing in Innovation & Technology f...
The Amazon as a Bioeconomy Superpower: Investing in Innovation & Technology f...
 

Recently uploaded

Optimizing Post Remediation Groundwater Performance with Enhanced Microbiolog...
Optimizing Post Remediation Groundwater Performance with Enhanced Microbiolog...Optimizing Post Remediation Groundwater Performance with Enhanced Microbiolog...
Optimizing Post Remediation Groundwater Performance with Enhanced Microbiolog...
Joshua Orris
 
Environment Conservation Rules 2023 (ECR)-2023.pptx
Environment Conservation Rules 2023 (ECR)-2023.pptxEnvironment Conservation Rules 2023 (ECR)-2023.pptx
Environment Conservation Rules 2023 (ECR)-2023.pptx
neilsencassidy
 
快速办理(Calabria毕业证书)卡拉布里亚大学毕业证在读证明一模一样
快速办理(Calabria毕业证书)卡拉布里亚大学毕业证在读证明一模一样快速办理(Calabria毕业证书)卡拉布里亚大学毕业证在读证明一模一样
快速办理(Calabria毕业证书)卡拉布里亚大学毕业证在读证明一模一样
astuz
 
Wildlife-AnIntroduction.pdf so that you know more about our environment
Wildlife-AnIntroduction.pdf so that you know more about our environmentWildlife-AnIntroduction.pdf so that you know more about our environment
Wildlife-AnIntroduction.pdf so that you know more about our environment
amishajha2407
 
Lessons from operationalizing integrated landscape approaches
Lessons from operationalizing integrated landscape approachesLessons from operationalizing integrated landscape approaches
Lessons from operationalizing integrated landscape approaches
CIFOR-ICRAF
 
PACKAGING OF FROZEN FOODS ( food technology)
PACKAGING OF FROZEN FOODS  ( food technology)PACKAGING OF FROZEN FOODS  ( food technology)
PACKAGING OF FROZEN FOODS ( food technology)
Addu25809
 
原版制作(Manitoba毕业证书)曼尼托巴大学毕业证学位证一模一样
原版制作(Manitoba毕业证书)曼尼托巴大学毕业证学位证一模一样原版制作(Manitoba毕业证书)曼尼托巴大学毕业证学位证一模一样
原版制作(Manitoba毕业证书)曼尼托巴大学毕业证学位证一模一样
mvrpcz6
 
在线办理(lboro毕业证书)拉夫堡大学毕业证学历证书一模一样
在线办理(lboro毕业证书)拉夫堡大学毕业证学历证书一模一样在线办理(lboro毕业证书)拉夫堡大学毕业证学历证书一模一样
在线办理(lboro毕业证书)拉夫堡大学毕业证学历证书一模一样
pjq9n1lk
 
BASIC CONCEPT OF ENVIRONMENT AND DIFFERENT CONSTITUTENET OF ENVIRONMENT
BASIC CONCEPT OF ENVIRONMENT AND DIFFERENT CONSTITUTENET OF ENVIRONMENTBASIC CONCEPT OF ENVIRONMENT AND DIFFERENT CONSTITUTENET OF ENVIRONMENT
BASIC CONCEPT OF ENVIRONMENT AND DIFFERENT CONSTITUTENET OF ENVIRONMENT
AmitKumar619042
 
Biomimicry in agriculture: Nature-Inspired Solutions for a Greener Future
Biomimicry in agriculture: Nature-Inspired Solutions for a Greener FutureBiomimicry in agriculture: Nature-Inspired Solutions for a Greener Future
Biomimicry in agriculture: Nature-Inspired Solutions for a Greener Future
Dr. P.B.Dharmasena
 
world-environment-day-2024-240601103559-14f4c0b4.pptx
world-environment-day-2024-240601103559-14f4c0b4.pptxworld-environment-day-2024-240601103559-14f4c0b4.pptx
world-environment-day-2024-240601103559-14f4c0b4.pptx
mfasna35
 
Improving the viability of probiotics by encapsulation methods for developmen...
Improving the viability of probiotics by encapsulation methods for developmen...Improving the viability of probiotics by encapsulation methods for developmen...
Improving the viability of probiotics by encapsulation methods for developmen...
Open Access Research Paper
 
RoHS stands for Restriction of Hazardous Substances, which is also known as t...
RoHS stands for Restriction of Hazardous Substances, which is also known as t...RoHS stands for Restriction of Hazardous Substances, which is also known as t...
RoHS stands for Restriction of Hazardous Substances, which is also known as t...
vijaykumar292010
 
Evolving Lifecycles with High Resolution Site Characterization (HRSC) and 3-D...
Evolving Lifecycles with High Resolution Site Characterization (HRSC) and 3-D...Evolving Lifecycles with High Resolution Site Characterization (HRSC) and 3-D...
Evolving Lifecycles with High Resolution Site Characterization (HRSC) and 3-D...
Joshua Orris
 
Kinetic studies on malachite green dye adsorption from aqueous solutions by A...
Kinetic studies on malachite green dye adsorption from aqueous solutions by A...Kinetic studies on malachite green dye adsorption from aqueous solutions by A...
Kinetic studies on malachite green dye adsorption from aqueous solutions by A...
Open Access Research Paper
 
原版制作(Newcastle毕业证书)纽卡斯尔大学毕业证在读证明一模一样
原版制作(Newcastle毕业证书)纽卡斯尔大学毕业证在读证明一模一样原版制作(Newcastle毕业证书)纽卡斯尔大学毕业证在读证明一模一样
原版制作(Newcastle毕业证书)纽卡斯尔大学毕业证在读证明一模一样
p2npnqp
 

Recently uploaded (16)

Optimizing Post Remediation Groundwater Performance with Enhanced Microbiolog...
Optimizing Post Remediation Groundwater Performance with Enhanced Microbiolog...Optimizing Post Remediation Groundwater Performance with Enhanced Microbiolog...
Optimizing Post Remediation Groundwater Performance with Enhanced Microbiolog...
 
Environment Conservation Rules 2023 (ECR)-2023.pptx
Environment Conservation Rules 2023 (ECR)-2023.pptxEnvironment Conservation Rules 2023 (ECR)-2023.pptx
Environment Conservation Rules 2023 (ECR)-2023.pptx
 
快速办理(Calabria毕业证书)卡拉布里亚大学毕业证在读证明一模一样
快速办理(Calabria毕业证书)卡拉布里亚大学毕业证在读证明一模一样快速办理(Calabria毕业证书)卡拉布里亚大学毕业证在读证明一模一样
快速办理(Calabria毕业证书)卡拉布里亚大学毕业证在读证明一模一样
 
Wildlife-AnIntroduction.pdf so that you know more about our environment
Wildlife-AnIntroduction.pdf so that you know more about our environmentWildlife-AnIntroduction.pdf so that you know more about our environment
Wildlife-AnIntroduction.pdf so that you know more about our environment
 
Lessons from operationalizing integrated landscape approaches
Lessons from operationalizing integrated landscape approachesLessons from operationalizing integrated landscape approaches
Lessons from operationalizing integrated landscape approaches
 
PACKAGING OF FROZEN FOODS ( food technology)
PACKAGING OF FROZEN FOODS  ( food technology)PACKAGING OF FROZEN FOODS  ( food technology)
PACKAGING OF FROZEN FOODS ( food technology)
 
原版制作(Manitoba毕业证书)曼尼托巴大学毕业证学位证一模一样
原版制作(Manitoba毕业证书)曼尼托巴大学毕业证学位证一模一样原版制作(Manitoba毕业证书)曼尼托巴大学毕业证学位证一模一样
原版制作(Manitoba毕业证书)曼尼托巴大学毕业证学位证一模一样
 
在线办理(lboro毕业证书)拉夫堡大学毕业证学历证书一模一样
在线办理(lboro毕业证书)拉夫堡大学毕业证学历证书一模一样在线办理(lboro毕业证书)拉夫堡大学毕业证学历证书一模一样
在线办理(lboro毕业证书)拉夫堡大学毕业证学历证书一模一样
 
BASIC CONCEPT OF ENVIRONMENT AND DIFFERENT CONSTITUTENET OF ENVIRONMENT
BASIC CONCEPT OF ENVIRONMENT AND DIFFERENT CONSTITUTENET OF ENVIRONMENTBASIC CONCEPT OF ENVIRONMENT AND DIFFERENT CONSTITUTENET OF ENVIRONMENT
BASIC CONCEPT OF ENVIRONMENT AND DIFFERENT CONSTITUTENET OF ENVIRONMENT
 
Biomimicry in agriculture: Nature-Inspired Solutions for a Greener Future
Biomimicry in agriculture: Nature-Inspired Solutions for a Greener FutureBiomimicry in agriculture: Nature-Inspired Solutions for a Greener Future
Biomimicry in agriculture: Nature-Inspired Solutions for a Greener Future
 
world-environment-day-2024-240601103559-14f4c0b4.pptx
world-environment-day-2024-240601103559-14f4c0b4.pptxworld-environment-day-2024-240601103559-14f4c0b4.pptx
world-environment-day-2024-240601103559-14f4c0b4.pptx
 
Improving the viability of probiotics by encapsulation methods for developmen...
Improving the viability of probiotics by encapsulation methods for developmen...Improving the viability of probiotics by encapsulation methods for developmen...
Improving the viability of probiotics by encapsulation methods for developmen...
 
RoHS stands for Restriction of Hazardous Substances, which is also known as t...
RoHS stands for Restriction of Hazardous Substances, which is also known as t...RoHS stands for Restriction of Hazardous Substances, which is also known as t...
RoHS stands for Restriction of Hazardous Substances, which is also known as t...
 
Evolving Lifecycles with High Resolution Site Characterization (HRSC) and 3-D...
Evolving Lifecycles with High Resolution Site Characterization (HRSC) and 3-D...Evolving Lifecycles with High Resolution Site Characterization (HRSC) and 3-D...
Evolving Lifecycles with High Resolution Site Characterization (HRSC) and 3-D...
 
Kinetic studies on malachite green dye adsorption from aqueous solutions by A...
Kinetic studies on malachite green dye adsorption from aqueous solutions by A...Kinetic studies on malachite green dye adsorption from aqueous solutions by A...
Kinetic studies on malachite green dye adsorption from aqueous solutions by A...
 
原版制作(Newcastle毕业证书)纽卡斯尔大学毕业证在读证明一模一样
原版制作(Newcastle毕业证书)纽卡斯尔大学毕业证在读证明一模一样原版制作(Newcastle毕业证书)纽卡斯尔大学毕业证在读证明一模一样
原版制作(Newcastle毕业证书)纽卡斯尔大学毕业证在读证明一模一样
 

Who bears for cost of forest conservation?

  • 1. Who bears the costs of conservation ? Rina Mandimbiniaina rrabemorasata@gmail.com 1
  • 2. 2 Mahesh Poudyal O. Sarobidy Rakotonarivo, Neal Hockley , James Gibbons, Bruno S. Ramamonjisoa, Rina Mandimbiniaina , Alexandra Rasoamanana , Nilsen S. Andrianantenaina, Julia P.G. Jones (2017): Who bears the cost of forest conservation? Alexandra Rasoamanana Bruno Ramamonjisoa Spener Nilsen Sarobidy rakotonarivo Julia Jones Neal HocleyMahesh Poudyal James Gibbon
  • 3. WOW! There are >36- species of frog in Madagascar! Global benefits of forest conservation Lets ensure that the forest is conserved Pictures by Eric Andriantsialonina
  • 4. Pictures by Eric Andriantsialonina Forest conservation also can bring local costs….. We understand that forest has value but we depend on forest clearance for our livelihoods “Land is the most valuable inheritance you can leave to your children, nothing is better than an open forest frontier… I am grieving that people are put in jail because they are making a living from the forestlands which are Zanahary’s creation, not the government’s property.” Quoted in Rakotonarivo et al 2016 ...which are well recognised World’s Park Congress 2003 – ‘protected areas should do no harm to local people’
  • 5. 1)What is the magnitude of local opportunity costs of preventing swidden agriculture on forestlands ? 2)How are these costs distributed across local households? 3)How does the value of compensation received compare with the estimated opportunity cost? Research questions
  • 6. Contingent Valuation : 62 ( two years after the compensation project ) In-depth agricultural survey: 171 Choice experiment: 450 CASE STUDY (sites) SURVEYS AND SAMPLE SIZE
  • 7. Sites are similar in terms of wealth Costs of conservation vary between sites but are high Poudyal et al (submitted)
  • 8. Costs are higher for those closest to the forest 8 Wealth axis 2 Wealth axis 1 Education Household age (decades) Distance from forest (km) Established PA (Mantadia) Established PA (Zahamena) REDD+ project without safeguard REDD+ project with safeguard -30000 -20000 -10000 0 10000 20000 Net opportunity cost ($) Costs are higher for those with lower education Poudyal et al (submitted)
  • 9. Cost are very significant in terms of incomes and are felt most strongly by the poorest Poudyal et al (submitted)
  • 10. ▪ BUT the costs are born over 60 years, still time for this to be addressed ▪ Estimates of the social costs of the carbon avoided are MUCH higher (10Xs) but so far funds have been slow to flow Poudyal et al (submitted) Compensation through social safeguards has not yet fully compensated for these opportunity costs and many people are uncompensated
  • 11. Who bears the costs of conservation? ▪The poorest and those living in remote areas are bearing costs of conservation restrictions (as yet not fully compensated). ▪BUT the costs are born over 60 years, still time for this to be addressed. ▪Estimates of the social costs of the carbon avoided are MUCH higher (10Xs) but so far funds have been slow to flow making compensation difficult