By Jay Lineberry
12/05/2013
}  What makes a Successful Proposal
◦  #1 Imperative: Perform TODAY
◦  Customer Intimacy
◦  Empowerment
◦  Proposal Writing
}  Q&A
}  Our performance on our existing contract is a
key factor in winning
}  Delight our customer….daily
}  Past Performance could be 25-40% of our score
◦  Be Careful!! – Rarely are acquisitions released if the
customer wants more of the same.
}  Use the current opportunity to correct any
issues…
}  Stay “on message” with the customer
◦  Prevent the RFP in the first place.
}  Watch our customer: All sensors on FULL
}  Keep our sub-contractors happy: No Defectors
}  Successful Capture Managers (CM) are passionate about
knowing the Customer
◦  Spend every opportunity to meet with or learn from Customer
}  Leverage Resources: Business Development, Washington
Operations, Program Managers, Suppilers, Teammates
◦  Rule of Thumb – calibrate Customer Intel with at least 3
independent, unbiased sources if possible
}  Understand what the Customer has awarded in past
◦  Including acquisition trends & budget constraints
◦  Wash Ops can be very helpful here
}  Develop a high-fidelity Source Selection Authority (SSA) list
with confirmed hot buttons/motivators
◦  This is HARD
◦  System Engineering / Technical Advisors (SETAs) can be valuable
here.
}  Develop a customer contact plan
◦  Utilize at least 2 people in meetings
}  Start small, Empower People, Forge a
Common Bond, Co-locate to extent possible
◦  #1 – Its economical
◦  Team building and cohesion is a must
–  Proposals strain both personal and professional lives
◦  All players need to gel around a common set of
ideas that refine into unified win themes
◦  Churn and change is frequent and fast.
}  Ask for help when needed
}  Prop execution requires a combination of creative
visualization, precision, and conformance to
guidelines; while injecting strategies and innovation
to discriminate our offering.
}  Successful Props aren’t written, they’re illustrated.
◦  Words connect graphics
◦  Designed for the skimming reader
◦  Customer benefits leap out
◦  Conclusion is first, followed by proof
–  Anecdotal evidence that the customer knows
–  Verifiable metrics compared to recognizable benchmarks
–  Customer awards & recognition
–  Photographic evidence
◦  Persuasive; not tutorial
}  Best practice: Create a “Capstone” graphic that
represents Customer business, vision, goals, and how
we are going to help them reach those.
}  What makes a Successful Proposal
◦  #1 Imperative: Perform TODAY
◦  Customer Intimacy
◦  Empowerment
◦  Proposal Writing
Backup Slides
}  Not listening to the customer
}  Develop solutions early and expose them to criticism
}  Failure to communicate, in customers’ terms, our understanding of the
customer’s operational environment, and the value of our solution
}  Proposing an approach, when they wanted a point solution
}  Bidding the elegant (and expensive) solution rather than meeting the
customer’s stated requirements
}  Failure to maintain firm baselines – minimize churn and rework
}  Underestimating the competition's passion to win and willingness to take a
risk to win
}  Failure to understand and write to the offer design (win strategy and value
proposition)
}  Failure to price to the market rather than just the program
}  Not providing objective rationale for compliance
}  Failure to re-visit your early decisions as needed
}  Presenting unfounded assertions about performance, cost, etc.
}  Staffing with the “available” personnel rather than the “best people”
}  Failure to view the procurement with the customer’s best interest in mind
}  Failure to respond completely or on time

What makes a Successful Proposal

  • 1.
  • 2.
    }  What makesa Successful Proposal ◦  #1 Imperative: Perform TODAY ◦  Customer Intimacy ◦  Empowerment ◦  Proposal Writing }  Q&A
  • 3.
    }  Our performanceon our existing contract is a key factor in winning }  Delight our customer….daily }  Past Performance could be 25-40% of our score ◦  Be Careful!! – Rarely are acquisitions released if the customer wants more of the same. }  Use the current opportunity to correct any issues… }  Stay “on message” with the customer ◦  Prevent the RFP in the first place. }  Watch our customer: All sensors on FULL }  Keep our sub-contractors happy: No Defectors
  • 4.
    }  Successful CaptureManagers (CM) are passionate about knowing the Customer ◦  Spend every opportunity to meet with or learn from Customer }  Leverage Resources: Business Development, Washington Operations, Program Managers, Suppilers, Teammates ◦  Rule of Thumb – calibrate Customer Intel with at least 3 independent, unbiased sources if possible }  Understand what the Customer has awarded in past ◦  Including acquisition trends & budget constraints ◦  Wash Ops can be very helpful here }  Develop a high-fidelity Source Selection Authority (SSA) list with confirmed hot buttons/motivators ◦  This is HARD ◦  System Engineering / Technical Advisors (SETAs) can be valuable here. }  Develop a customer contact plan ◦  Utilize at least 2 people in meetings
  • 5.
    }  Start small,Empower People, Forge a Common Bond, Co-locate to extent possible ◦  #1 – Its economical ◦  Team building and cohesion is a must –  Proposals strain both personal and professional lives ◦  All players need to gel around a common set of ideas that refine into unified win themes ◦  Churn and change is frequent and fast. }  Ask for help when needed
  • 6.
    }  Prop executionrequires a combination of creative visualization, precision, and conformance to guidelines; while injecting strategies and innovation to discriminate our offering. }  Successful Props aren’t written, they’re illustrated. ◦  Words connect graphics ◦  Designed for the skimming reader ◦  Customer benefits leap out ◦  Conclusion is first, followed by proof –  Anecdotal evidence that the customer knows –  Verifiable metrics compared to recognizable benchmarks –  Customer awards & recognition –  Photographic evidence ◦  Persuasive; not tutorial }  Best practice: Create a “Capstone” graphic that represents Customer business, vision, goals, and how we are going to help them reach those.
  • 7.
    }  What makesa Successful Proposal ◦  #1 Imperative: Perform TODAY ◦  Customer Intimacy ◦  Empowerment ◦  Proposal Writing
  • 8.
  • 9.
    }  Not listeningto the customer }  Develop solutions early and expose them to criticism }  Failure to communicate, in customers’ terms, our understanding of the customer’s operational environment, and the value of our solution }  Proposing an approach, when they wanted a point solution }  Bidding the elegant (and expensive) solution rather than meeting the customer’s stated requirements }  Failure to maintain firm baselines – minimize churn and rework }  Underestimating the competition's passion to win and willingness to take a risk to win }  Failure to understand and write to the offer design (win strategy and value proposition) }  Failure to price to the market rather than just the program }  Not providing objective rationale for compliance }  Failure to re-visit your early decisions as needed }  Presenting unfounded assertions about performance, cost, etc. }  Staffing with the “available” personnel rather than the “best people” }  Failure to view the procurement with the customer’s best interest in mind }  Failure to respond completely or on time