Language as a
Disguise for Information
TOPIC–STRESS
Lawrie Hunter
In a sentence,
in a paragraph,
in a chapter,
The topic should come near the beginning,
and
the stress should come near the end.
Topic-stress: a kind of rule
In a sentence,
in a paragraph,
in a chapter
Topic-stress: a kind of rule
TOPIC
.
.
.
.
STRESS
Here are 2 writings of the same information:
1. Although pattern languages are very useful for
developing an overview of a practical domain such as
architecture, they are not sufficiently rigorous for
ontology work.
2. Pattern languages are not sufficiently rigorous for
ontology work, although they are very useful for
developing an overview of a practical domain such as
architecture.
Topic-stress: a kind of rule
Here are 2 writings of the same information:
1. Although pattern languages are very useful for
developing an overview of a practical domain such as
architecture, they are not sufficiently rigorous for
ontology work.
2. Pattern languages are not sufficiently rigorous for
ontology work, although they are very useful for
developing an overview of a practical domain such as
architecture.
Topic-stress: a kind of rule
The 'stress' position in sentence 1 ends with a
somewhat negative adjective phrase. What
overall impression does the sentence give
about the topic, pattern languages?
Here are 2 writings of the same information:
1. Although pattern languages are very useful for
developing an overview of a practical domain such as
architecture, they are not sufficiently rigorous for
ontology work.
2. Pattern languages are not sufficiently rigorous for
ontology work, although they are very useful for
developing an overview of a practical domain such as
architecture.
Topic-stress: a kind of rule
Is sentence 2 a more positive comment about pattern
languages? Note the presence of the positive
adjectives 'useful' and practical' in the second half of
the sentence, i.e. in the 'stress' position.
TOPIC-STRESS
 
Irate driver yelling at incompetent driver:
1. Stay home next time!
1. Next time stay home!
 
Topic-stress: a kind of rule
TOPIC-STRESS
 
1.We drove from Selma to Wilma and never spoke once.
1.We never spoke once during the drive from Selma to Wilma.
Topic-stress: a kind of rule
TOPIC-STRESS
 
1.While working on his book, he died at the age of 68.
1.He was working on his book, when he died at the age of 68.
1.At the age of 68 he was working on his book, when he died.
Topic-stress: a kind of rule
TOPIC-STRESS
 
1.While working on his book, he died at the age of 68.
1.He died at the age of 68, while working on his book.
1.He was working on his book when he died at the age of 68.
2.He died while working on his book. He was 68.
3.At the age of 68 he was working on his book when he died.
4.At the age of 68 he died while working on his book.
Topic-stress: a kind of rule

Topic-stress in academic writing

  • 1.
    Language as a Disguisefor Information TOPIC–STRESS Lawrie Hunter
  • 2.
    In a sentence, ina paragraph, in a chapter, The topic should come near the beginning, and the stress should come near the end. Topic-stress: a kind of rule
  • 3.
    In a sentence, ina paragraph, in a chapter Topic-stress: a kind of rule TOPIC . . . . STRESS
  • 4.
    Here are 2writings of the same information: 1. Although pattern languages are very useful for developing an overview of a practical domain such as architecture, they are not sufficiently rigorous for ontology work. 2. Pattern languages are not sufficiently rigorous for ontology work, although they are very useful for developing an overview of a practical domain such as architecture. Topic-stress: a kind of rule
  • 5.
    Here are 2writings of the same information: 1. Although pattern languages are very useful for developing an overview of a practical domain such as architecture, they are not sufficiently rigorous for ontology work. 2. Pattern languages are not sufficiently rigorous for ontology work, although they are very useful for developing an overview of a practical domain such as architecture. Topic-stress: a kind of rule The 'stress' position in sentence 1 ends with a somewhat negative adjective phrase. What overall impression does the sentence give about the topic, pattern languages?
  • 6.
    Here are 2writings of the same information: 1. Although pattern languages are very useful for developing an overview of a practical domain such as architecture, they are not sufficiently rigorous for ontology work. 2. Pattern languages are not sufficiently rigorous for ontology work, although they are very useful for developing an overview of a practical domain such as architecture. Topic-stress: a kind of rule Is sentence 2 a more positive comment about pattern languages? Note the presence of the positive adjectives 'useful' and practical' in the second half of the sentence, i.e. in the 'stress' position.
  • 7.
    TOPIC-STRESS   Irate driver yelling at incompetent driver: 1. Stay homenext time! 1. Next time stay home!   Topic-stress: a kind of rule
  • 8.
    TOPIC-STRESS   1.We drove fromSelma to Wilma and never spoke once. 1.We never spoke once during the drive from Selma to Wilma. Topic-stress: a kind of rule
  • 9.
    TOPIC-STRESS   1.While working onhis book, he died at the age of 68. 1.He was working on his book, when he died at the age of 68. 1.At the age of 68 he was working on his book, when he died. Topic-stress: a kind of rule
  • 10.
    TOPIC-STRESS   1.While working onhis book, he died at the age of 68. 1.He died at the age of 68, while working on his book. 1.He was working on his book when he died at the age of 68. 2.He died while working on his book. He was 68. 3.At the age of 68 he was working on his book when he died. 4.At the age of 68 he died while working on his book. Topic-stress: a kind of rule