6. Real effectiveness can be defined
and measured. It is a useful idea any
leader-manager can embrace. It is
not personality, but performance.
7. Real effectiveness: The extent to which a leader-manager achieves the
output requirements of the job.
Apparent effectiveness: The appearance of effectiveness by observation of
behavior alone.
8. These are the type of things that apparent
effectiveness means...
• Looking good
• Appearing competent
• Talking, speaking, presenting well
• Working hard, putting in the hours
• Appearing knowledgeable
• On-time, efficient, responsive
• Great reports
• Come from the right schools
• Prepared
• Good body language
9.
10. “…when I rate you, on anything, my
rating reveals to the world far more
about me than it does about you.”
“The effect that ruins our ability to rate
others has a name: the Idiosyncratic
Rater Effect”
Marcus Buckingham, HBR.org
Most HR Data is Bad Data
https://hbr.org/2015/02/most-hr-data-is-bad-data
11. The only way to know if you’re really
effective is to define the measurable
outputs of the job.
23. Authority
You need to determine...
• Which decisions can you make on your own?
• Which decisions do you make but require approval?
• Which decisions do you make recommendations only?
24. Authority
You need to determine...
• Which decisions can you make on your own?
• Which decisions do you make but require approval?
• Which decisions do you make recommendations only?
Your Team
• Change Organizational
Structure
Spending
• Limits within budget
Strategy
• New systems -
technology
25. Go get agreement with your
boss about your outputs,
metrics and authorities!
27. “Focusing on real effectiveness is the key to
leading your organization to executing for
excellence, widespread engagement and fun! (and
no politics!)”
Lisa de Wilde, CEO of TVOntario
“Apparent effectiveness is important but only up to
20%. Real effectiveness is what gets the right
things done.”
Brendan Calder, Professor of GettingItDone,
Rotman School of Management
28. Want to be more effective this year than you
were last year?
http://bitly.com/e-suite
Challenge of being judged by apparent effectiveness
We all judge and are being judged constantly on how we look
We are all being judged and we are all judging at all times.
(Throw away point) As women, you’re unfortunately going to be held to a higher standard
The whole system is wrong.
Going back to Reddin’s definition, the only way to know real effectiveness is to measure it
The disturbing part is how frequently it’s embedded in a performance appraisal system…
HBR article: HR Data is Bad
The current systems are being challenged
Apparent effectiveness is a judgement
Real effectiveness can only be measured, it can’t be judged
Source: https://hbr.org/2015/02/most-hr-data-is-bad-data
You must measure not assess it.
The extent to which you achieve the output requirements of your job. This is a critical concept in management.
Take a moment and write down the responsibilities of your job. What do you do?
You were hired to do a job: Do you know how you are being evaluated?
Note: They are nouns. There are no verbs. There is not hint of “inputs”. Nothing ends in –ing.
Given what you know about outputs now, I’d like you to look at your list of responsibilities, and see if you can describe your role in 4-8 outputs. Take everything you do and narrow it right down to 4 – 8 nouns.
If you’re having trouble, use the questions at the bottom of your page.
Why does your role exist?
If you did that activity, what would happen? Why do you do the activity? If the activity didn’t get done, what would be the consequence?
I’ll give you guys 3 minutes to work on that.
Metrics are the way you measure achievement of the output (effectiveness areas).
How would you measure each of your outputs?
What authority do you have, and what do you need?
Explore examples: Katherine, Kelly, Michèle, Lisa
Describe the matrix
Be empowered to take responsibility in changing how things are done in your situation.
If you want to be seen as really effective, have true measures – if you’re not taking responsibility for coming up with measures, then others must resort to the only information that is available to them – you have the accountability to help fix this
How many of you would like to be seen as more effective this year than last year?
Free gift: In the member portal there will be a worksheet to help you identify outputs and metrics. This tool has a value of $150, and is the basis of what we teach our coaches and our clients. There is also a link there to sign up for a series of 6 of our articles that describe what you would need to focus on to be more effective.