SlideShare a Scribd company logo
The Empty Chair at the
Metrics Table
Discussing the absence of
educational impact metrics and a
framework for their creation
Lauren Ashby: Associate Editor, SAGE Publications
Mathias Astell: Marketing Manager, Nature Publishing
Group
Why are we here?
Currently no metrics which
focus on the educational
impact of scholarly outputs
We propose the creation of
a quantitative metric for
educational impact
Questions
1. Who are the audiences of scholarly outputs?
2. What potential measures of educational impact currently exist?
3. What would an educational metric look like, and how might it be used?
Who are the audiences
of scholarly outputs?
Research focus in representing audiences
The Rest of the Picture
Practitioners
Students (School, Further and Higher Education)
Teachers
The journal as a universityJournal Textbook Monograph Reader Handbook Thesis
Web
Resource
Slides Videos
Researcher X X X X X X X
Practitioner X X X X X X
Student X X X X X X X X X
Teacher X X X X X X
What potential
measures of
educational impact
currently exist?
Online Syllabi and Reading Lists
Homa, N. et al. (2013) “An Analysis of Learning Objectives and Content
Coverage in Introductory Psychology Syllabi”, Teaching of Psychology, 40(3).
“...evidence from this research indicates that online syllabus citations are
useful sources of evidence about educational value...”
Kousha, K. & Thelwall, M.(2008) "Assessing the impact of disciplinary research on teaching: An automatic analysis of online
syllabuses." Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 59(13): p. 2067.
Usage
Publisher Usage Statistics
University Library Holdings Usage Data
Other sources
Counting of URLs
Journal clubs
Public and university library holdings
Cites in academic presentations
Reference management system
Dissertation and Thesis Citation Measurement
What would an
educational metric
look like, and how
might it be used?
Blending approaches
Data gathered in previous research studies chiefly focused on benefit to
researchers - recast techniques to help expressing educational impact
Open, not weighted and informational
Quantitative for use in qualitative assessments.
this information has to be used collectively in order to make a useful assessment of the
different ways in which a scholarly output is being used.
The benefits:
Credit for the creation of more educationally focussed outputs
Global awareness of usage of scholarly outputs in education
Support creating syllabi - and the post graduate teaching community
In conclusion
Our thinking aims to devise a quantitative measure of educational impact: a
count of when and how scholarly outputs are used in teaching and learning to
better represent and promote these valuable resources.

More Related Content

What's hot

Open Academic Analytics Initiative - Campus Technology Innovator Award Presen...
Open Academic Analytics Initiative - Campus Technology Innovator Award Presen...Open Academic Analytics Initiative - Campus Technology Innovator Award Presen...
Open Academic Analytics Initiative - Campus Technology Innovator Award Presen...
Joshua
 
Caspers Whyte II
Caspers Whyte IICaspers Whyte II
Caspers Whyte II
NAKLIV
 
Putting The P A L Model & Rt I Pieces Together
Putting The  P A L  Model &  Rt I  Pieces  TogetherPutting The  P A L  Model &  Rt I  Pieces  Together
Putting The P A L Model & Rt I Pieces Together
guest539850
 
Data-informed blended design and delivery
Data-informed blended design and deliveryData-informed blended design and delivery
Data-informed blended design and delivery
Jisc
 
From theory to practice blending the math classroom and creating a data cultu...
From theory to practice blending the math classroom and creating a data cultu...From theory to practice blending the math classroom and creating a data cultu...
From theory to practice blending the math classroom and creating a data cultu...
DreamBox Learning
 
Learning Analytics
Learning AnalyticsLearning Analytics
Learning Analytics
Viplav Baxi
 
Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"
Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"
Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"
CITE
 
Dennis Small
Dennis SmallDennis Small
Dennis Small
Glenn E. Malone, EdD
 
Wilson - Using Available Tools: Assessment Practices and Metrics for the 21st...
Wilson - Using Available Tools: Assessment Practices and Metrics for the 21st...Wilson - Using Available Tools: Assessment Practices and Metrics for the 21st...
Wilson - Using Available Tools: Assessment Practices and Metrics for the 21st...
National Information Standards Organization (NISO)
 
Using data to improve teaching and learning
Using data to improve teaching and learningUsing data to improve teaching and learning
Using data to improve teaching and learning
Stephanie Delaney
 
Xiao Hu "Learning Analytics Initiatives"
Xiao Hu "Learning Analytics Initiatives"Xiao Hu "Learning Analytics Initiatives"
Xiao Hu "Learning Analytics Initiatives"
CITE
 
Learning Analytics
Learning AnalyticsLearning Analytics
Learning Analytics
Stian Håklev
 
John SanGiovanni - Transitioning and Implementing the Common Core State Stand...
John SanGiovanni - Transitioning and Implementing the Common Core State Stand...John SanGiovanni - Transitioning and Implementing the Common Core State Stand...
John SanGiovanni - Transitioning and Implementing the Common Core State Stand...
DreamBox Learning
 
Exploring learning analytics
Exploring learning analyticsExploring learning analytics
Exploring learning analytics
Jisc
 
‘Eyes Wide Shut’: The Challenge of Evaluating E-Learning
‘Eyes Wide Shut’: The Challenge of Evaluating E-Learning‘Eyes Wide Shut’: The Challenge of Evaluating E-Learning
‘Eyes Wide Shut’: The Challenge of Evaluating E-Learning
cies
 
Nces 2008 Presentation
Nces 2008 PresentationNces 2008 Presentation
Nces 2008 Presentation
Christopher Thorn
 
EDUCA Leveraging Analytics FINAL
EDUCA Leveraging Analytics FINALEDUCA Leveraging Analytics FINAL
EDUCA Leveraging Analytics FINAL
Ellen Wagner
 
Assessing critical thinking in moo cs preliminary proposal 201309
Assessing critical thinking in moo cs  preliminary proposal 201309Assessing critical thinking in moo cs  preliminary proposal 201309
Assessing critical thinking in moo cs preliminary proposal 201309
Su-Tuan Lulee
 
Using Data for Informed Decision Making
Using Data for Informed Decision MakingUsing Data for Informed Decision Making
Using Data for Informed Decision Making
INGovConf
 
The story of GAeL (Graduate Attributes eLearning): Embedding Information Lit...
The story of GAeL (Graduate Attributes eLearning):  Embedding Information Lit...The story of GAeL (Graduate Attributes eLearning):  Embedding Information Lit...
The story of GAeL (Graduate Attributes eLearning): Embedding Information Lit...
Lorna Dodd
 

What's hot (20)

Open Academic Analytics Initiative - Campus Technology Innovator Award Presen...
Open Academic Analytics Initiative - Campus Technology Innovator Award Presen...Open Academic Analytics Initiative - Campus Technology Innovator Award Presen...
Open Academic Analytics Initiative - Campus Technology Innovator Award Presen...
 
Caspers Whyte II
Caspers Whyte IICaspers Whyte II
Caspers Whyte II
 
Putting The P A L Model & Rt I Pieces Together
Putting The  P A L  Model &  Rt I  Pieces  TogetherPutting The  P A L  Model &  Rt I  Pieces  Together
Putting The P A L Model & Rt I Pieces Together
 
Data-informed blended design and delivery
Data-informed blended design and deliveryData-informed blended design and delivery
Data-informed blended design and delivery
 
From theory to practice blending the math classroom and creating a data cultu...
From theory to practice blending the math classroom and creating a data cultu...From theory to practice blending the math classroom and creating a data cultu...
From theory to practice blending the math classroom and creating a data cultu...
 
Learning Analytics
Learning AnalyticsLearning Analytics
Learning Analytics
 
Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"
Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"
Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"
 
Dennis Small
Dennis SmallDennis Small
Dennis Small
 
Wilson - Using Available Tools: Assessment Practices and Metrics for the 21st...
Wilson - Using Available Tools: Assessment Practices and Metrics for the 21st...Wilson - Using Available Tools: Assessment Practices and Metrics for the 21st...
Wilson - Using Available Tools: Assessment Practices and Metrics for the 21st...
 
Using data to improve teaching and learning
Using data to improve teaching and learningUsing data to improve teaching and learning
Using data to improve teaching and learning
 
Xiao Hu "Learning Analytics Initiatives"
Xiao Hu "Learning Analytics Initiatives"Xiao Hu "Learning Analytics Initiatives"
Xiao Hu "Learning Analytics Initiatives"
 
Learning Analytics
Learning AnalyticsLearning Analytics
Learning Analytics
 
John SanGiovanni - Transitioning and Implementing the Common Core State Stand...
John SanGiovanni - Transitioning and Implementing the Common Core State Stand...John SanGiovanni - Transitioning and Implementing the Common Core State Stand...
John SanGiovanni - Transitioning and Implementing the Common Core State Stand...
 
Exploring learning analytics
Exploring learning analyticsExploring learning analytics
Exploring learning analytics
 
‘Eyes Wide Shut’: The Challenge of Evaluating E-Learning
‘Eyes Wide Shut’: The Challenge of Evaluating E-Learning‘Eyes Wide Shut’: The Challenge of Evaluating E-Learning
‘Eyes Wide Shut’: The Challenge of Evaluating E-Learning
 
Nces 2008 Presentation
Nces 2008 PresentationNces 2008 Presentation
Nces 2008 Presentation
 
EDUCA Leveraging Analytics FINAL
EDUCA Leveraging Analytics FINALEDUCA Leveraging Analytics FINAL
EDUCA Leveraging Analytics FINAL
 
Assessing critical thinking in moo cs preliminary proposal 201309
Assessing critical thinking in moo cs  preliminary proposal 201309Assessing critical thinking in moo cs  preliminary proposal 201309
Assessing critical thinking in moo cs preliminary proposal 201309
 
Using Data for Informed Decision Making
Using Data for Informed Decision MakingUsing Data for Informed Decision Making
Using Data for Informed Decision Making
 
The story of GAeL (Graduate Attributes eLearning): Embedding Information Lit...
The story of GAeL (Graduate Attributes eLearning):  Embedding Information Lit...The story of GAeL (Graduate Attributes eLearning):  Embedding Information Lit...
The story of GAeL (Graduate Attributes eLearning): Embedding Information Lit...
 

Viewers also liked

Untitled Presentation
Untitled PresentationUntitled Presentation
Untitled Presentation
rogeriosan10
 
Vip manual p1
Vip manual p1Vip manual p1
Vip manual p1
Narisara Note
 
Nitesh_javaDeveloper_2.1year
Nitesh_javaDeveloper_2.1yearNitesh_javaDeveloper_2.1year
Nitesh_javaDeveloper_2.1year
Nitesh Varshney
 
Tudományterületek
TudományterületekTudományterületek
Tudományterületek
jaszai95
 
Email research & email lead collection
Email research & email lead collectionEmail research & email lead collection
Email research & email lead collection
Alomgir Hossen
 
JUDE #3 - THROUGH THE FIRE - PTR. ALAN ESPORAS - 630PM EVENING SERVICE
JUDE #3 - THROUGH THE FIRE - PTR. ALAN ESPORAS - 630PM EVENING SERVICEJUDE #3 - THROUGH THE FIRE - PTR. ALAN ESPORAS - 630PM EVENING SERVICE
JUDE #3 - THROUGH THE FIRE - PTR. ALAN ESPORAS - 630PM EVENING SERVICE
Faithworks Christian Church
 
St FA JF Wins Pentecost Award CT 3p
St FA JF Wins Pentecost Award CT 3pSt FA JF Wins Pentecost Award CT 3p
St FA JF Wins Pentecost Award CT 3p
William Johnson
 
Resume 10-1-15(2)
Resume 10-1-15(2)Resume 10-1-15(2)
Resume 10-1-15(2)
Richard McClain
 
Догляд за Братськими могилами
Догляд за Братськими могиламиДогляд за Братськими могилами
Догляд за Братськими могилами
kopanki2015
 
Presentation design pt1
Presentation design   pt1Presentation design   pt1
Presentation design pt1
stevetalks81
 
Una giornata a Monti
Una giornata a MontiUna giornata a Monti
Una giornata a Monti
Andrea Ciantar
 
Pylon restaurant
Pylon restaurantPylon restaurant
Pylon restaurant
Babis Papachristou
 
Desktop enviroments
Desktop enviroments Desktop enviroments
Desktop enviroments
afraalfalasii
 

Viewers also liked (13)

Untitled Presentation
Untitled PresentationUntitled Presentation
Untitled Presentation
 
Vip manual p1
Vip manual p1Vip manual p1
Vip manual p1
 
Nitesh_javaDeveloper_2.1year
Nitesh_javaDeveloper_2.1yearNitesh_javaDeveloper_2.1year
Nitesh_javaDeveloper_2.1year
 
Tudományterületek
TudományterületekTudományterületek
Tudományterületek
 
Email research & email lead collection
Email research & email lead collectionEmail research & email lead collection
Email research & email lead collection
 
JUDE #3 - THROUGH THE FIRE - PTR. ALAN ESPORAS - 630PM EVENING SERVICE
JUDE #3 - THROUGH THE FIRE - PTR. ALAN ESPORAS - 630PM EVENING SERVICEJUDE #3 - THROUGH THE FIRE - PTR. ALAN ESPORAS - 630PM EVENING SERVICE
JUDE #3 - THROUGH THE FIRE - PTR. ALAN ESPORAS - 630PM EVENING SERVICE
 
St FA JF Wins Pentecost Award CT 3p
St FA JF Wins Pentecost Award CT 3pSt FA JF Wins Pentecost Award CT 3p
St FA JF Wins Pentecost Award CT 3p
 
Resume 10-1-15(2)
Resume 10-1-15(2)Resume 10-1-15(2)
Resume 10-1-15(2)
 
Догляд за Братськими могилами
Догляд за Братськими могиламиДогляд за Братськими могилами
Догляд за Братськими могилами
 
Presentation design pt1
Presentation design   pt1Presentation design   pt1
Presentation design pt1
 
Una giornata a Monti
Una giornata a MontiUna giornata a Monti
Una giornata a Monti
 
Pylon restaurant
Pylon restaurantPylon restaurant
Pylon restaurant
 
Desktop enviroments
Desktop enviroments Desktop enviroments
Desktop enviroments
 

Similar to The Empty Chair at the Metrics Table

A Three-Pronged Model To Learning Analysis And Instructional Design
A Three-Pronged Model To Learning Analysis And Instructional DesignA Three-Pronged Model To Learning Analysis And Instructional Design
A Three-Pronged Model To Learning Analysis And Instructional Design
Courtney Esco
 
Learning analytics - what can we achieve together.pptx
Learning analytics - what can we achieve together.pptxLearning analytics - what can we achieve together.pptx
Learning analytics - what can we achieve together.pptx
Rebecca Ferguson
 
Information Literacy Assessment: From the Classroom to the Curriculum
Information Literacy Assessment: From the Classroom to the CurriculumInformation Literacy Assessment: From the Classroom to the Curriculum
Information Literacy Assessment: From the Classroom to the Curriculum
Michigan State University Libraries - Information Literacy
 
Action Research in a Community of Practice: from Disciplinary Teaching to Sch...
Action Research in a Community of Practice: from Disciplinary Teaching to Sch...Action Research in a Community of Practice: from Disciplinary Teaching to Sch...
Action Research in a Community of Practice: from Disciplinary Teaching to Sch...
witthaus
 
Designing Learning Analytics for Humans with Humans
Designing Learning Analytics for Humans with HumansDesigning Learning Analytics for Humans with Humans
Designing Learning Analytics for Humans with Humans
alywise
 
Towards contemp ed power point presentation
Towards contemp ed power point presentationTowards contemp ed power point presentation
Towards contemp ed power point presentation
Abi Woldhuis
 
Towards contemp ed power point presentation
Towards contemp ed power point presentationTowards contemp ed power point presentation
Towards contemp ed power point presentation
Abi Woldhuis
 
Cdst12 ijtel
Cdst12 ijtelCdst12 ijtel
Cdst12 ijtel
Idriss Blm
 
Keynote presentation OOFHEC2016: Bart Rienties
Keynote presentation OOFHEC2016: Bart RientiesKeynote presentation OOFHEC2016: Bart Rienties
Keynote presentation OOFHEC2016: Bart Rienties
EADTU
 
Vocce action research
Vocce action researchVocce action research
Vocce action research
Thanavathi C
 
Pan Canadian Research Agenda 2008
Pan Canadian Research Agenda 2008Pan Canadian Research Agenda 2008
Pan Canadian Research Agenda 2008
BCcampus
 
Naf july10 handouts
Naf july10 handoutsNaf july10 handouts
Naf july10 handouts
NAFCareerAcads
 
Evaluating the effects of a Community of Practice on teaching
Evaluating the effects of a  Community of Practice on teachingEvaluating the effects of a  Community of Practice on teaching
Evaluating the effects of a Community of Practice on teaching
witthaus
 
Action Plan TemplateUse this template to assist you with develop.docx
Action Plan TemplateUse this template to assist you with develop.docxAction Plan TemplateUse this template to assist you with develop.docx
Action Plan TemplateUse this template to assist you with develop.docx
AMMY30
 
Educational Data Mining/Learning Analytics issue brief overview
Educational Data Mining/Learning Analytics issue brief overviewEducational Data Mining/Learning Analytics issue brief overview
Educational Data Mining/Learning Analytics issue brief overview
Marie Bienkowski
 
Sociology in action: A comparative study of embedded Interventions for improv...
Sociology in action: A comparative study of embedded Interventions for improv...Sociology in action: A comparative study of embedded Interventions for improv...
Sociology in action: A comparative study of embedded Interventions for improv...
IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
 
Vol 15 No 2 - February 2016
Vol 15 No 2 - February 2016Vol 15 No 2 - February 2016
Vol 15 No 2 - February 2016
ijlterorg
 
ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024
ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024
ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024
EADTU
 
academix_sem1_2016
academix_sem1_2016academix_sem1_2016
academix_sem1_2016
Mandy Te
 
Research Approaches in Higher Education RK 10082023.pptx
Research Approaches in Higher Education RK 10082023.pptxResearch Approaches in Higher Education RK 10082023.pptx
Research Approaches in Higher Education RK 10082023.pptx
Rita Ndagire Kizito
 

Similar to The Empty Chair at the Metrics Table (20)

A Three-Pronged Model To Learning Analysis And Instructional Design
A Three-Pronged Model To Learning Analysis And Instructional DesignA Three-Pronged Model To Learning Analysis And Instructional Design
A Three-Pronged Model To Learning Analysis And Instructional Design
 
Learning analytics - what can we achieve together.pptx
Learning analytics - what can we achieve together.pptxLearning analytics - what can we achieve together.pptx
Learning analytics - what can we achieve together.pptx
 
Information Literacy Assessment: From the Classroom to the Curriculum
Information Literacy Assessment: From the Classroom to the CurriculumInformation Literacy Assessment: From the Classroom to the Curriculum
Information Literacy Assessment: From the Classroom to the Curriculum
 
Action Research in a Community of Practice: from Disciplinary Teaching to Sch...
Action Research in a Community of Practice: from Disciplinary Teaching to Sch...Action Research in a Community of Practice: from Disciplinary Teaching to Sch...
Action Research in a Community of Practice: from Disciplinary Teaching to Sch...
 
Designing Learning Analytics for Humans with Humans
Designing Learning Analytics for Humans with HumansDesigning Learning Analytics for Humans with Humans
Designing Learning Analytics for Humans with Humans
 
Towards contemp ed power point presentation
Towards contemp ed power point presentationTowards contemp ed power point presentation
Towards contemp ed power point presentation
 
Towards contemp ed power point presentation
Towards contemp ed power point presentationTowards contemp ed power point presentation
Towards contemp ed power point presentation
 
Cdst12 ijtel
Cdst12 ijtelCdst12 ijtel
Cdst12 ijtel
 
Keynote presentation OOFHEC2016: Bart Rienties
Keynote presentation OOFHEC2016: Bart RientiesKeynote presentation OOFHEC2016: Bart Rienties
Keynote presentation OOFHEC2016: Bart Rienties
 
Vocce action research
Vocce action researchVocce action research
Vocce action research
 
Pan Canadian Research Agenda 2008
Pan Canadian Research Agenda 2008Pan Canadian Research Agenda 2008
Pan Canadian Research Agenda 2008
 
Naf july10 handouts
Naf july10 handoutsNaf july10 handouts
Naf july10 handouts
 
Evaluating the effects of a Community of Practice on teaching
Evaluating the effects of a  Community of Practice on teachingEvaluating the effects of a  Community of Practice on teaching
Evaluating the effects of a Community of Practice on teaching
 
Action Plan TemplateUse this template to assist you with develop.docx
Action Plan TemplateUse this template to assist you with develop.docxAction Plan TemplateUse this template to assist you with develop.docx
Action Plan TemplateUse this template to assist you with develop.docx
 
Educational Data Mining/Learning Analytics issue brief overview
Educational Data Mining/Learning Analytics issue brief overviewEducational Data Mining/Learning Analytics issue brief overview
Educational Data Mining/Learning Analytics issue brief overview
 
Sociology in action: A comparative study of embedded Interventions for improv...
Sociology in action: A comparative study of embedded Interventions for improv...Sociology in action: A comparative study of embedded Interventions for improv...
Sociology in action: A comparative study of embedded Interventions for improv...
 
Vol 15 No 2 - February 2016
Vol 15 No 2 - February 2016Vol 15 No 2 - February 2016
Vol 15 No 2 - February 2016
 
ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024
ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024
ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024
 
academix_sem1_2016
academix_sem1_2016academix_sem1_2016
academix_sem1_2016
 
Research Approaches in Higher Education RK 10082023.pptx
Research Approaches in Higher Education RK 10082023.pptxResearch Approaches in Higher Education RK 10082023.pptx
Research Approaches in Higher Education RK 10082023.pptx
 

Recently uploaded

Genesis chapter 3 Isaiah Scudder.pptx
Genesis    chapter 3 Isaiah Scudder.pptxGenesis    chapter 3 Isaiah Scudder.pptx
Genesis chapter 3 Isaiah Scudder.pptx
FamilyWorshipCenterD
 
怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样
怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样
怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样
kekzed
 
Cybersecurity Presentation PowerPoint!!!
Cybersecurity Presentation PowerPoint!!!Cybersecurity Presentation PowerPoint!!!
Cybersecurity Presentation PowerPoint!!!
arichardson21686
 
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Finance Balance
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Finance Balance2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Finance Balance
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Finance Balance
UkraineCrisisMediaCenter
 
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Financial Report
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Financial Report2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Financial Report
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Financial Report
UkraineCrisisMediaCenter
 
Prsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptx
Prsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptxPrsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptx
Prsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptx
prafulpawar29
 
ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]
ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]
ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]
SkillCertProExams
 
一比一原版(unc毕业证书)美国北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(unc毕业证书)美国北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证如何办理一比一原版(unc毕业证书)美国北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(unc毕业证书)美国北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证如何办理
gfysze
 
Data Processing in PHP - PHPers 2024 Poznań
Data Processing in PHP - PHPers 2024 PoznańData Processing in PHP - PHPers 2024 Poznań
Data Processing in PHP - PHPers 2024 Poznań
Norbert Orzechowicz
 
ACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPE
ACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPEACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPE
ACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPE
Charmi13
 
Gamify it until you make it Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...
Gamify it until you make it  Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...Gamify it until you make it  Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...
Gamify it until you make it Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...
Ben Linders
 
Proposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP Inc
Proposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP IncProposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP Inc
Proposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP Inc
Raheem Muhammad
 
AWS User Group Torino 2024 #3 - 18/06/2024
AWS User Group Torino 2024 #3 - 18/06/2024AWS User Group Torino 2024 #3 - 18/06/2024
AWS User Group Torino 2024 #3 - 18/06/2024
Guido Maria Nebiolo
 
Bridging the visual gap between cultural heritage and digital scholarship
Bridging the visual gap between cultural heritage and digital scholarshipBridging the visual gap between cultural heritage and digital scholarship
Bridging the visual gap between cultural heritage and digital scholarship
Inesm9
 
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Annual Report
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Annual Report2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Annual Report
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Annual Report
UkraineCrisisMediaCenter
 
Legislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptx
Legislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptxLegislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptx
Legislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptx
Charmi13
 
Kalyan chart satta matka guessing result
Kalyan chart satta matka guessing resultKalyan chart satta matka guessing result
Kalyan chart satta matka guessing result
sanammadhu484
 
SASi-SPi Science Policy Lab Pre-engagement
SASi-SPi Science Policy Lab Pre-engagementSASi-SPi Science Policy Lab Pre-engagement
SASi-SPi Science Policy Lab Pre-engagement
Francois Stepman
 
Presentation agenda of three-day conference
Presentation agenda of three-day conferencePresentation agenda of three-day conference
Presentation agenda of three-day conference
bernadettalaurentia1
 

Recently uploaded (19)

Genesis chapter 3 Isaiah Scudder.pptx
Genesis    chapter 3 Isaiah Scudder.pptxGenesis    chapter 3 Isaiah Scudder.pptx
Genesis chapter 3 Isaiah Scudder.pptx
 
怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样
怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样
怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样
 
Cybersecurity Presentation PowerPoint!!!
Cybersecurity Presentation PowerPoint!!!Cybersecurity Presentation PowerPoint!!!
Cybersecurity Presentation PowerPoint!!!
 
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Finance Balance
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Finance Balance2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Finance Balance
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Finance Balance
 
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Financial Report
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Financial Report2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Financial Report
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Financial Report
 
Prsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptx
Prsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptxPrsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptx
Prsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptx
 
ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]
ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]
ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]
 
一比一原版(unc毕业证书)美国北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(unc毕业证书)美国北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证如何办理一比一原版(unc毕业证书)美国北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证如何办理
一比一原版(unc毕业证书)美国北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校毕业证如何办理
 
Data Processing in PHP - PHPers 2024 Poznań
Data Processing in PHP - PHPers 2024 PoznańData Processing in PHP - PHPers 2024 Poznań
Data Processing in PHP - PHPers 2024 Poznań
 
ACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPE
ACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPEACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPE
ACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPE
 
Gamify it until you make it Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...
Gamify it until you make it  Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...Gamify it until you make it  Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...
Gamify it until you make it Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...
 
Proposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP Inc
Proposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP IncProposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP Inc
Proposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP Inc
 
AWS User Group Torino 2024 #3 - 18/06/2024
AWS User Group Torino 2024 #3 - 18/06/2024AWS User Group Torino 2024 #3 - 18/06/2024
AWS User Group Torino 2024 #3 - 18/06/2024
 
Bridging the visual gap between cultural heritage and digital scholarship
Bridging the visual gap between cultural heritage and digital scholarshipBridging the visual gap between cultural heritage and digital scholarship
Bridging the visual gap between cultural heritage and digital scholarship
 
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Annual Report
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Annual Report2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Annual Report
2023 Ukraine Crisis Media Center Annual Report
 
Legislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptx
Legislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptxLegislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptx
Legislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptx
 
Kalyan chart satta matka guessing result
Kalyan chart satta matka guessing resultKalyan chart satta matka guessing result
Kalyan chart satta matka guessing result
 
SASi-SPi Science Policy Lab Pre-engagement
SASi-SPi Science Policy Lab Pre-engagementSASi-SPi Science Policy Lab Pre-engagement
SASi-SPi Science Policy Lab Pre-engagement
 
Presentation agenda of three-day conference
Presentation agenda of three-day conferencePresentation agenda of three-day conference
Presentation agenda of three-day conference
 

The Empty Chair at the Metrics Table

  • 1. The Empty Chair at the Metrics Table Discussing the absence of educational impact metrics and a framework for their creation Lauren Ashby: Associate Editor, SAGE Publications Mathias Astell: Marketing Manager, Nature Publishing Group
  • 2. Why are we here? Currently no metrics which focus on the educational impact of scholarly outputs We propose the creation of a quantitative metric for educational impact
  • 3. Questions 1. Who are the audiences of scholarly outputs? 2. What potential measures of educational impact currently exist? 3. What would an educational metric look like, and how might it be used?
  • 4. Who are the audiences of scholarly outputs?
  • 5. Research focus in representing audiences
  • 6. The Rest of the Picture Practitioners Students (School, Further and Higher Education) Teachers The journal as a universityJournal Textbook Monograph Reader Handbook Thesis Web Resource Slides Videos Researcher X X X X X X X Practitioner X X X X X X Student X X X X X X X X X Teacher X X X X X X
  • 7. What potential measures of educational impact currently exist?
  • 8. Online Syllabi and Reading Lists Homa, N. et al. (2013) “An Analysis of Learning Objectives and Content Coverage in Introductory Psychology Syllabi”, Teaching of Psychology, 40(3). “...evidence from this research indicates that online syllabus citations are useful sources of evidence about educational value...” Kousha, K. & Thelwall, M.(2008) "Assessing the impact of disciplinary research on teaching: An automatic analysis of online syllabuses." Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 59(13): p. 2067.
  • 9. Usage Publisher Usage Statistics University Library Holdings Usage Data
  • 10. Other sources Counting of URLs Journal clubs Public and university library holdings Cites in academic presentations Reference management system Dissertation and Thesis Citation Measurement
  • 11. What would an educational metric look like, and how might it be used?
  • 12. Blending approaches Data gathered in previous research studies chiefly focused on benefit to researchers - recast techniques to help expressing educational impact Open, not weighted and informational Quantitative for use in qualitative assessments. this information has to be used collectively in order to make a useful assessment of the different ways in which a scholarly output is being used. The benefits: Credit for the creation of more educationally focussed outputs Global awareness of usage of scholarly outputs in education Support creating syllabi - and the post graduate teaching community
  • 13. In conclusion Our thinking aims to devise a quantitative measure of educational impact: a count of when and how scholarly outputs are used in teaching and learning to better represent and promote these valuable resources.