The Depression-Era South
Pre-Depression

 Agricultural society shaped by plantations: cash poor
 Southern leaders failed attempt to reshape economy,
  lure factories from North with cheap labor
 Change in the cotton market: boll weevils in ’20s




    Boll weevils migrated from Mexico in the late 1800s;
    they are a type of beetle that feeds on cotton buds
Black Tuesday

                                 “Stocks Up
“Brokers
                                 in Strong
Believe
                                 Rally;
Worst Is
                                 Rockefellers
Over and
                                 Big Buyers;
Recommend
                                 Exchanges
Buying of
                                 Close 2-1/2
Real
                                 Days”
Bargains”
                                 -New York
-New York
                                 Herald
Herald,
                                 Tribune,
October 27,
                                 October 31,
1929
                                 1929

              October 29, 1929
Sunshine Syndrome

Southern cities had unparalleled growth in 1920s
   Memphis doubled in population, TN grew 1%
   Birmingham construction, $8 mil bond
   Atlanta raised $750k to advertise, lure people in

Southern newspapers downplayed adversity, “pessimism”

“The stockmarket collapse that shattered so many dreams elsewhere…finds
  our city less affected…and in a better position perhaps than almost all
  the rest to carry on through the year without distress.” – New Orleans
  Times-Picayune, Jan. 1, 1930


Isolation from national, international events
Reality

Mid-1931:
 production cut-backs
 lay-offs
 reduced wages (avg. of 50-75%)
 closings



New York Bureau of Business survey for Memphis, mid-1931:
“There are no positive indications of a turn in any
  industry.”
No. 1

South quickly became known as nation’s “No. 1
 Economic Problem”
• Continued farming problems: boll weevil,
share-cropping,
“outsider” mass land ownership

• Deficiencies & Corruption:
Georgia Power, school system,
FDR and New Deal

 With South as problem no. 1, FDR targeted many New
 Deal programs to the region:
Tennessee Valley Authority: (1933) federally owned
 corporattion for navigation, flood control, electricity
 generation, fertilizer manufacturing
Agricultural Adjustment Act: (1933) federal law which
 paid farmers subsidies not to plant part of their land, kill
 off excess livestock in hope of raising value
Federal Emergency Relief Administration: (1933)
 later known as Works Progress Administration, gave
 loans to states to operate relief programs such as creating
 unskilled jobs in local/state government (more
 expensive, but psychologically rewarding) (pg. 62)
Pride…

Why were the programs structured as they were?

Pride: Didn’t want hand-outs
Individualism: Didn’t want government stepping on
  their toes, making them change
Community: Southerners had a sense of looking after
  their own
…and Prejudice

During the height of the Depression, blacks suffered the most
• Unemployed whites began to take “black” jobs
• Laws were passed to keep blacks from applying for the few
  jobs there were

The New Deal’s economic
changes non-directly improved
the lot of low-class whites and blacks

Blacks statistically received
less aid, but FDR and Eleanor’s interest
in reform pushed things along
Most Powerful Force for Change Since Civil War
New South, Again

• At beginning of New Deal, stagnation of the social
  situation in the South ended: bigger problems at
  hand, national attention
• At the end of the Depression, there was a sense of a
  lost identity: no longer isolated, outside investors
  meant the new South was not homemade
• The move away from agriculture that had begun
  directly prior to the Depression increased, meaning a
  divorce of work from family
“The anguish that most of us have observed for some
 time now has been caused not by the fact that the South is
 alienated from the rest of the country, but by the fact that it
 is not  alienated enough, that every day we are
 getting more and more like the rest of the country, that we
 are being forced out, not only of our many sins
 but our few virtues.”


    -Flannery O’Connor, 1957
References

Colemna, Amanda. “Rehabilitating the Region: The New Deal, Gender, and the
  Remaking of the Rural South.” Southeastern Geographer, 50.2 (2010): 200 –
  17. Print.
Down and Out in the Great Depression: Letters from the “Forgotten Man.” Ed.
  Robert S. McElvaine. Chapel Hill: U of North Carolina P, 1983. Print.
McElvaine, Robert S. The Great Depression: America, 1929 – 1941. New York:
  Times, 1984. Print.
Smith, Douglas L. The New Deal in the Urban South. Baton Rouge: Louisiana
  State U P, 1988. Print.
The New Deal and the South. Ed. James C. Cobb and Michael V. Namorato.
  Jackson: U P of Mississippi, 1984. Print.

The Depression-Era South

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Pre-Depression  Agricultural societyshaped by plantations: cash poor  Southern leaders failed attempt to reshape economy, lure factories from North with cheap labor  Change in the cotton market: boll weevils in ’20s Boll weevils migrated from Mexico in the late 1800s; they are a type of beetle that feeds on cotton buds
  • 3.
    Black Tuesday “Stocks Up “Brokers in Strong Believe Rally; Worst Is Rockefellers Over and Big Buyers; Recommend Exchanges Buying of Close 2-1/2 Real Days” Bargains” -New York -New York Herald Herald, Tribune, October 27, October 31, 1929 1929 October 29, 1929
  • 4.
    Sunshine Syndrome Southern citieshad unparalleled growth in 1920s  Memphis doubled in population, TN grew 1%  Birmingham construction, $8 mil bond  Atlanta raised $750k to advertise, lure people in Southern newspapers downplayed adversity, “pessimism” “The stockmarket collapse that shattered so many dreams elsewhere…finds our city less affected…and in a better position perhaps than almost all the rest to carry on through the year without distress.” – New Orleans Times-Picayune, Jan. 1, 1930 Isolation from national, international events
  • 5.
    Reality Mid-1931: production cut-backs lay-offs reduced wages (avg. of 50-75%) closings New York Bureau of Business survey for Memphis, mid-1931: “There are no positive indications of a turn in any industry.”
  • 6.
    No. 1 South quicklybecame known as nation’s “No. 1 Economic Problem” • Continued farming problems: boll weevil, share-cropping, “outsider” mass land ownership • Deficiencies & Corruption: Georgia Power, school system,
  • 7.
    FDR and NewDeal  With South as problem no. 1, FDR targeted many New Deal programs to the region: Tennessee Valley Authority: (1933) federally owned corporattion for navigation, flood control, electricity generation, fertilizer manufacturing Agricultural Adjustment Act: (1933) federal law which paid farmers subsidies not to plant part of their land, kill off excess livestock in hope of raising value Federal Emergency Relief Administration: (1933) later known as Works Progress Administration, gave loans to states to operate relief programs such as creating unskilled jobs in local/state government (more expensive, but psychologically rewarding) (pg. 62)
  • 8.
    Pride… Why were theprograms structured as they were? Pride: Didn’t want hand-outs Individualism: Didn’t want government stepping on their toes, making them change Community: Southerners had a sense of looking after their own
  • 9.
    …and Prejudice During theheight of the Depression, blacks suffered the most • Unemployed whites began to take “black” jobs • Laws were passed to keep blacks from applying for the few jobs there were The New Deal’s economic changes non-directly improved the lot of low-class whites and blacks Blacks statistically received less aid, but FDR and Eleanor’s interest in reform pushed things along
  • 10.
    Most Powerful Forcefor Change Since Civil War
  • 11.
    New South, Again •At beginning of New Deal, stagnation of the social situation in the South ended: bigger problems at hand, national attention • At the end of the Depression, there was a sense of a lost identity: no longer isolated, outside investors meant the new South was not homemade • The move away from agriculture that had begun directly prior to the Depression increased, meaning a divorce of work from family
  • 12.
    “The anguish thatmost of us have observed for some time now has been caused not by the fact that the South is alienated from the rest of the country, but by the fact that it is not alienated enough, that every day we are getting more and more like the rest of the country, that we are being forced out, not only of our many sins but our few virtues.” -Flannery O’Connor, 1957
  • 13.
    References Colemna, Amanda. “Rehabilitatingthe Region: The New Deal, Gender, and the Remaking of the Rural South.” Southeastern Geographer, 50.2 (2010): 200 – 17. Print. Down and Out in the Great Depression: Letters from the “Forgotten Man.” Ed. Robert S. McElvaine. Chapel Hill: U of North Carolina P, 1983. Print. McElvaine, Robert S. The Great Depression: America, 1929 – 1941. New York: Times, 1984. Print. Smith, Douglas L. The New Deal in the Urban South. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State U P, 1988. Print. The New Deal and the South. Ed. James C. Cobb and Michael V. Namorato. Jackson: U P of Mississippi, 1984. Print.