SlideShare a Scribd company logo
International Journal of Business and Management Invention
ISSN (Online): 2319 – 8028, ISSN (Print): 2319 – 801X
www.ijbmi.org || Volume 5 Issue 8 || August. 2016 || PP—71-78
www.ijbmi.org 71 | Page
The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha:
Loss is almost certain Profit is Not
*Santosha Kumar Mallick, **Dr. Ansuman Sahoo
*Research Scholar, Department of Business Administration, Utkal University, Bhubaneswar, India,
**Lecturer (IMBA), Department of Business Administration, Utkal University, Bhubaneswar, India,
ABSTRACT: The research in this paper has been conducted from within the theoretical framework of
behavioural finance. The aim of this paper is to examine chit fund scams and its aftermath effect on Individuals
& Households of Odisha. The study provides post-mortem analysis of changes in attitude investors towards chit
funds. The data comprise a random sampling of 112 respondents drawn through a field survey. Different
statistical tests were performed to assess support for the hypothesis.The results of data analysis reveals due to
lack of financial literacy and sophistication, investors are simply more exposed to idiosyncrasies of the chit fund
companies. Expectations of earnings high commission and high rate of return attracted investors to join chit
funds. Someone known to investors or some of the family member or relative persuaded investors to join in chit
funds. Majority of the respondents believe that the chit fund agent cheated them and they were unknown about
the chit fund company and they believed the chit fund agents. The study shows that laxity in regulatory system
and nexus between the politicians and chit fund companies paved way for the perpetrators to commit frauds.
The study shows that investors are now more aware about these Chit Fund companies because of the relentless
media coverage and would be more careful before investing next time.
Keywords Behavioural finance, Chit-fund scams, Financial literacy, Household savings, Investment
I. INTRODUCTION
The economic theory of investment states that investors think and behave “rationally”. However keeping in
mind the recent trends in decline in ethical values and moral standards due to the detection and exposure of
series of scams and frauds in all forms of businesses and in government organisations including the recent chit
fund scams it is require to go for a behavioural explanation of investor's irrationality in a consistent and
correlated manner. It is found that investors are not always rational; rather investor's emotion has a major role to
play with the investment decision. Individuals and Households, by virtue of their relative immobility and lack of
financial sophistication, are simply more exposed to idiosyncrasies of the chit fund companies, banks, financial
institution and business houses. The recent chit-fund scams exposed the loopholes in the household financial
investments and hence necessitate the study.
Odisha is a state located on the eastern coast of Indian peninsula. Nearly 85% of its population live in rural areas
and depend mostly on agriculture for their livelihood. The state has abundant mineral resources including
precious and semi-precious stones. It has also plentiful water resources. Cultivators and Agricultural labourers
constitute 65% of the total workforce. Agriculture provides direct or indirect employment to 65% of the total
work force and contributes 26% of the net state domestic product and it is also counted among the poorest states
of the country.
The economy of Odisha is one the fastest growing state economies in India. According to 2014-15 economic
survey, Odisha's gross state domestic product (GSDP) was expected to grow at 8.78% in the 2014-15 fiscal
years. Odisha has an agriculture-based economy which is in transition towards an industry and service-based
economy. According to Dun & Bradstreet, the GSDP is expected to grow at a rate of 8.1% during 2015-2020.
Odisha is also one of the top FDI destinations in India. In the fiscal year 2011-12, Odisha received investment
proposals worth Rs.49, 527 crores (US$9.296 billion). According to the Reserve Bank of India, Odisha received
Rs.53, 000 crores (US$8.33 billion) worth of new FDI commitments in the 2012-13 fiscal.
However, in spite of all these developments the Individuals & Households of Odisha state has witnessed their
hard earned money being siphoned by Chit funds companies. Although there are many avenues for savings and
investment one‟s hard eared money. Chit funds and Ponzi schemes promises large returns on investments are
very common avenues of parallel investment since long. But, in recent years a good number of frauds have been
exposed involving thousands of crores rupees. A number of chit fund frauds in Odisha pressed the panic button
and investors rushed to get back their invested money from such chit. These scams lead to domestic and social
violence, harassment and even suicides.
As the bottom-of-the-pyramid population continues to fret about having lost one‟s life savings in the Odisha
“chit funds”. There is a necessity to analyze the determinants and rationale of frauds committed by chit funds in
The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is certain Profit is Not
www.ijbmi.org 72 | Page
Odisha. The lessons learned in recent chit fund scams and suggest remedial ways of proper managing of chit
funds in Odisha.
II. OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
The objectives of the study are
 To analyze the determinants of investment in chit funds in Odisha.
 To study rationale of frauds committed by chit funds in Odisha.
 To suggest the remedial ways of proper managing of chit funds in Odisha.
 To study the lessons learned in recent chit fund scams in Odisha.
III. LITERATURE REVIEW
Chit funds are the Indian equivalent of the Rotating Savings and Credit Associations (ROSCA) that are famous
throughout the world. 1
ROSCAs are a means to „save and borrow‟ at the same time. It is considered one of the
best instruments to cater to the needs of the poor.
There are numerous published literatures on Ponzi schemes. Ponzi schemes, which are another type of
investment scam, because it promises large returns on investments that are unachievable because they are solely
derived from new investor funds (2
Blaylock, 1998; 3
Entombed Albania's Pyramids, 1997). Investors in a Ponzi
scheme typically send their money to either a central investment house, or a person which is supposed to send
the promised returns back to investors.
The fact that most investors are not told that they are destined to lose their money in these schemes is the reason
why ponzi schemes are illegal. Motivating people into investment schemes is legal, and so is the giving of
money to other people, but it is the deception of the investors about their expected financial returns that
determines the illegality of pyramid schemes (4
Caroll, 1998; Commerce Commission, 1997).
Fundamentally, deception exists because new investors are typically convinced on the promise that they will
receive larger financial returns on their investments. The pyramid scheme that ran in Albania during 1995-1997
is a notable example of a pyramid scheme in which people invested and consequently suffered a financial loss.
In this instance the scheme quickly spread through Albania and engulfed most of the populace. The debt
incurred by Albanian citizens was estimated at one billion dollars, which if the Albanian government had
reimbursed would have produced bankruptcy (3
Entombed Albania's Pyramids, 1997). Investors in this scheme
were promised returns of 50% per month on their investments and people were motivated to sell assets in order
to invest cash for the expected monetary returns. For a short period of time the returns were achieved and a few
people did well, but, as with all pyramid schemes, the supply of new investors ran out and consequently further
payments were dishonoured, thus leaving investors in financial ruin.
The semantics surrounding deliberately misleading people includes such phrases as white lies, bluffs, and fibs,
but essentially all equate to deception (5
Hyman, 1989). The definition of deception encompasses all the previous
terms, but here it is confined to the parameters of deliberate economic behaviour. Cheating and dislike of it
display themselves cross culturally. People perceive it to be a socially unacceptable behaviour and react
adversely to known cheaters (6
Sigmund, 1993). Consequently, a cheater must assess the possible gains and risks
associated with cheating before engaging in deceptive behaviour (6
Sigmund, 1993; 7
Wokutch & Carson, 1999).
As such, the outcomes associated with cheating influence both an individual‟s choice to engage in deceptive
behaviour and the reactions of others if this behaviour is discovered (5
Hyman, 1989; 8
Ridley, 1997). Arguably,
either deliberate or unintentional deception is required for the successful recruitment of investors to pyramid
schemes.
People who are closer and are deceived react more severely. This closely relates to the principle of evolutionary
psychology that asserts people are more likely to act altruistically to people who are members of their kin group
and are themselves more likely to reciprocate (8
Ridley, 1997; 6
Sigmund, 1993). Therefore determining how
these relationship factors affect people‟s economic behaviours is a worthwhile area to research, especially in
respect to deception-based punzi schemes.
Furthermore, when people consider holding others responsible for acts of deception, they take into consideration
the agent‟s intent and knowledge of the consequences (9
DePaulo & Rosenthal, 1979). For example, a person
who knowingly deceives others to invest their life savings in a fraudulent company is judged more harshly than
someone who ignorantly advises someone to invest. Such distinctions about level of social undesirability are
reflected in the law and are used to determine fraud.
10
Bansal (2005) suggests that the international consensus in preserving the soundness of the banking system has
highlighted a number of necessities including careful attention to the audit report prepared by the internal and
external auditors.
11
Sathye (2007) suggests that to prevent scams of chit funds Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU) should be formed.
The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is certain Profit is Not
www.ijbmi.org 73 | Page
12
Hudon (2008) finds that under the veil of microfinance, the chit fund companies collect fund from the poor
people and the research further shows that even though the chit funds are registered under Companies Act,
Societies Act, RBI Act and SEBI Act, these are equally unsafe like their unregistered counterparts.
13
Manniono (2009) concludes that Ponzi schemes‟ arrangement usually falls apart when a large number of
investors want to withdraw their investments at the same time, especially during times when there is not enough
new money being supplied by new investors.
14
Rhee (2009) suggests that the informal credit market is vulnerable to the credit risk, interest rate risk, inflation
risk, re-investment risk, market risk, operation risk etc. Once any of the risk materializes, the entire informal
credit market collapses like anything.
15
Eeckhout and Munshi (2010) finds that by bringing both, borrowers and lenders, in close proximity and by
stimulating the competition, chit fund effectively created an informal credit market subject to different
constraints.
16
Ferri (2010) classified Ponzi agents as those who borrow more and more in order to repay their interest with
the simplistic anticipation that profit and capital gain will be available to repay their commitments when they
become due.
17
Nielsen (2012) finds that whistle-blowers‟ appeals did not pay attention to the regulators. This can result in
exposure of corporate‟s wrong doing, inaction by regulatory institutions and hindrance to institutional reform.
18
Roy (2012) concluded that many chit fund companies are using the media business as a stepping stone by
which they will be able to establish contacts with the political establishments, more so with people in power.
19
Kapoor et al. (2013) concluded that the chit fund industry addresses the savings needs of people, is considered
very safe and also offers loans at lower interest rates than money lenders.
20
Sen (2013) suggests that all the banks should conduct random check to the accounts of the chit fund
companies which collect money through collective investment schemes across the country.
IV. RESEARCH HYPOTHESIS
In addition to answering the research objectives the study tested the following hypothesis.
H0: There is no significant relationship between chit fund investment and demographic characteristics.
Ha: There is significant relationship between chit fund investment and demographic characteristics.And
H0: There is no relation between chit fund investments with awareness about frauds and scams, financial
education, excessive greed to expect windfall gains aftermath of these scams.
Ha: There is relation between chit fund investments with awareness about frauds and scams, financial education
aftermath of these scams
V. DATA AND RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
A. Data collection
The primary data to analyze the determinants and rationale of chit funds in Odisha was gathered from the
investors through a questionnaire which signify the motivating factors and causes of frauds as well as their
opinion regarding managing chit. The data comprised a sample survey of 112 investors covering observation for
last 03 months. The primary data was collected through a well designed questionnaire. The main variables of
interest related to individuals includes Gender, Age, Age group, Occupation, Education level, Religion, Caste,
Tenure of investment in chit funds, Amount of investment in chit funds. The survey was entirely based on the
information provided by the investors.
B. Research Methodology and Data analysis
The analysis of the determinants and rationale of chit funds in Odisha has been carried out in two steps. During
the first stage of analysis, the data gathered was analyzed using descriptive statistics. Descriptive statistics
explains the mean, median, minimum, maximum and standard deviation of the data. Examination of the
characteristics of the sample was carried out which showed the level of investors all distinguished by Age
group, Occupation, Education level, Religion, Caste, Tenure of investment in chit funds and Amount of
investment in chit funds.
The data collected through questionnaire has been further processed through SPSS (Statistical Package for
Social Sciences). Non-parametric tests mainly the chi-square test has been used to test the hypotheses. A Chi-
square test for independence is applied when two categorical variables are generated from a single population. It
is used to determine whether or not there is a significant association between the two variables.
The questionnaire with a 5 point Likert scale has been used for analyzing the behavioural attributes of the
respondents. The 5 point scale in the questionnaire bears the corresponding prefix, e. g. 1 as agree, 2 as strongly
agree, 3 as disagree, 4 as strongly disagree and 5 as do not know.
To test the reliability using Cronbach‟s Alpha score comes out as 0.958 hence it was accepted. To consolidate
the data, factor analysis was carried out. Statistical tools like Descriptive Statistics, Chi-square (x2
) test, linear
The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is certain Profit is Not
www.ijbmi.org 74 | Page
regression and Principal Component Analysis (PCA) is used to test the hypotheses. The hypotheses for the
aftermath effect and managing chit funds regulation which has been tested using Chi-square test. Finally, the
data were processed through the use of SPSS.
Table 1: Reliability Statistics
Cronbach‟s alpha Cronbach‟s alpha based on
standardized items
No. of items
0.958 0.958 39
Source: SPSS Analysis Result
C. Demographics of the respondents
The descriptive analyses for demographics profile of respondents which indicated below-
Table 2: Demographics profile of respondents.
Demographic Frequency Percent Cumulative Percent
Occupation
housewife 16 14.29 14.29
business 16 14.29 28.57
service 48 42.86 71.43
Agriculture 32 28.57 100.00
Total 112 100
Type of Job
Govt. 22 19.64 19.64
Private 23 20.54 40.18
Self Employed 11 9.82 50.00
Others 56 50.00 100.00
Total 112 100.00
Gender
Female 33 29.46 29.46
Male 79 70.54 100.00
Total 112 100
Age group:
18-25 years 16 14.29 14.29
26-40 years 54 48.21 62.50
41-60 years 34 30.36 92.86
61 and above 8 7.14 100.00
Total 112 100
Educational Qualification:
Under
Matriculation
45 40.18 40.18
Higher Secondary 23 20.54 60.71
Graduate 22 19.64 80.36
Post graduate 11 9.82 90.18
Any other 11 9.82 100.00
Total 112 100
Religion:
Hinduism 79 70.54 70.54
Muslim 22 19.64 90.18
Christian 11 9.82 100.00
Buddhism 0 0.00
Jainism 0 0.00
Any other 0 0.00
Total 112 100.00
Caste:
General 45 40.18 40.18
Scheduled Caste 25 22.32 62.50
Scheduled Tribe 8 7.14 69.64
Other Backward
Caste
34 30.36 100.00
Total 112 100.00
Tenure of investment in chit funds
0-2 years 42 37.50 37.50
2- 5 years 50 44.64 82.14
5 years and above 20 17.86 100.00
Total 112 100.00
Amount of investment in chit funds:
<= Rs. 10000 12 10.71 10.71
Rs.10001- 54 48.21 58.93
The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is certain Profit is Not
www.ijbmi.org 75 | Page
Rs.50000
Rs.50001-
Rs.100000
13 11.61 70.54
Rs.100001-
Rs.500000
33 29.46 100.00
>Rs.500000 0 0.00
Total 112 100.00
Source: Compiled from questionnaires
Table 3: Descriptive Statistics
Particulars N Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation
Type of Job 112 1 4 2.9018 1.22261
Gender 112 1 2 1.7054 0.45793
Age group 112 1 4 2.3036 0.80359
Educational
Qualification
112 1 5 2.2857 1.34519
Religion 112 1 3 1.3929 0.66247
Caste 112 1 4 1.7321 1.01326
Tenure of
investment in chit
funds
112 1 3 1.8036 0.72085
Amount of
investment in chit
funds
112 1 4 2.3839 0.80813
Valid N (listwise) 112
Hypothesis testing:
Here the researcher tests whether there is any relationship between chit fund investment and demographic
characteristics.
Ho: There is no significant relationship between chit fund investment and demographic characteristics.
Ha: There is significant relationship between chit fund investment and demographic characteristics
Table 4:Chi-square test for independence result.
Demographic
character
Value df Asymp. sig.(2 sided)
Job Type 86.576a 9 0
Gender 1.019a 3 0.397
Age 1.677a 9 0
Qualification 188.290a 12 0
Religion 176.270a 6 0
Caste 29.682a 9 0
Source: SPSS analysis result
Since the P-value is <0.05 the null hypothesis is rejected that is there is significant relationship between chit
fund investment and demographic characteristics. The result of the chi square independence result shows that
there is relationship between chit fund investment and demographic characteristics, therefore the research
hypothesis accepted.
D. Principal Component Analysis (PCA)
Principal Component Analysis (PCA) has been conducted to find and club the component under the suitable
head. The result of the PCA is as follows:
Table 5: Component Transformation Matrix
Component 1 2 3 4
1 .156 .733 .599 -.182
2 .950 .225 -.096 -.041
3 -.168 -.367 .631 .633
4 .134 .494 .412 .745
Extraction Method: Principal Component Analysis. Rotation Method: Varimax with Kaiser Normalization
On the basis of Rotated Component Matrix, the 19 parameters in the questionnaire are segregated into four
components. For each parameter, the highest factor loading has been taken for consideration for the under
different components. Hence, the four components derived from PCA are as under:
The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is certain Profit is Not
www.ijbmi.org 76 | Page
Table 7: Components Derived from PCA
Component 1 Component 2 Component 3 Component 4
Laxity in regulatory system Rigid banking formalities High rate of return and
high Commission
High rate of return and high
Commission
Proper coordination among
regulators
Stringent license norms and
close monitoring
Stronger regulations Present Chit Funds Act, 1982
is weak in its operation
Stringent license norms and
close monitoring
Rationalized Banking norms lack of Govt. sponsored
small investment schemes
friends, family and relatives
pressurize
Lack of financial literacy Someone known and/or one
of your family member or
relative persuaded to join in
chit funds
Financial iliteracy Requirement of stringent Act
Encouragement of Investors
education
nexus between some
politicians and chit fund
companies
A Bank in the locality Scope of operation should be
controlled and limited
Weak Chit Funds Act, 1982 Lack of financial literacy Investors education
provision for caution/security
deposit
provision for
caution/security deposit
E. Liner regression analysis
The researcher here also tests whether the recent chit fund scams has any impact on investors perception on their
investments, where awareness about frauds and scams, financial education, excessive greed to expect windfall
gains are considered independent variable and chit fund investments is dependent variables. For testing the
hypothesis, a statistical test called liner regression analysis test was employed through the use of SPSS statistical
package.
a) Statement of hypothesis
H0: There is no relation between chit fund investments with awareness about frauds and scams, financial
education, excessive greed to expect windfall gains aftermath of these scams.
Ha: There is relation between chit fund investments with awareness about frauds and scams, financial education
aftermath of these scams.
b) Dependent variable (D1): chit fund investments
c) Independent variables (I1, I2 and I3): awareness about frauds and scams, financial education, excessive
greed to expect windfall gains.
Table 8: Model summary
Table 9: ANOVA
Model 1 Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
Regression 4.507 3 1.502 2.39 .073b
Residual 67.984 108 0.629
Total 72.491 111
a. Dependent Variable: chit fund _investment
b. Predictors: (Constant), I1,I2 and I3
Table 10: Coefficients
Model 1 Unstandardized
Coefficients
Standardized
Coefficients
t Sig. Correlations
B Std.
Error
Beta Zero-
order
Partial Part
(Constant) 2.411 0.174 13.895 0
I1 -0.084 0.054 -0.165 -1.536 0.127 -0.182 -0.146 -0.143
I2 0.13 0.075 0.221 1.717 0.089 0.131 0.163 0.16
I3 -0.056 0.078 -0.102 -0.713 0.477 -0.029 -0.068 -0.066
a. Dependent Variable: D1
R Square
Change
F
Change
df1 df2 Sig. F
Change
1 .249
a
0.062 0.036 0.7934 0.062 2.386 3 108 0.073
a. Predictors: (Constant), I1,I2 and I3
Model R R Square Adjusted
R Square
Std. Error
of the
Estimate
Change Statistics
The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is certain Profit is Not
www.ijbmi.org 77 | Page
Table 11: Change in Perception of Investors after math of chit fund scams in Odisha
Particulars Agree Strongly
agree
Disagree Strongly
disagree
Undecided Total
1 The chit fund agent cheated you 33.92 33.92 16.07 0 16.07 100
2 The chit fund company cheated you 25.89 50.00 8.03 8.03 8.03 100
3 You are now more confident not to
invest in chit funds again
25.00 41.96 8.03 0 25.00 100
4 You won't be recommending this option
to anyone else?
32.14 43.74 8.03 0 16.07 100
5 You now believe you would never
receive the financial returns as
promised by chit funds?
50.90 25 16.07 0 8.03 100
6 The Govt . is colluded with Chit funds
and cheated you?
33.03 17.85 8.03 8.03 33.03 100
7 You believe you are more aware about
frauds and scams now?
42.85 25.00 8.04 0.00 24.11 100
8 You now believe that the business
models of chit funds are unsustainable
in the long run?
58.03 8.04 8.04 0.00 25.89 100
9 You won't be excessive greed to expect
windfall gains?
50.89 16.07 16.96 0.00 16.96 100
10 You should invest more on financial
education?
33.93 41.07 8.04 0.00 16.96 100
From the above model summery R = .249a
which shows there is a negative relationship between investments
with awareness about frauds and scams, financial education, excessive greed to expect windfall, which means
investors are more aware about frauds and scams, excessive greed to expect windfall and financial education.
VI. FINDINGS
As the determinants and rationale of chit funds in Odisha was gathered from the investors through a well
developed questionnaire which signify the motivating factors and causes of frauds as well as their opinion
regarding managing chits, the following information have been captured and summarized.
 Due to lack of financial literacy and sophistication, investors are simply more exposed to idiosyncrasies of
the chit fund companies.
 Expectations of earning high commission and high rate of return attracted investors to join chit funds.
 Someone known to investors and/or some of the family member or relative persuaded investors to join in
chit funds.
 Majority of the respondents believe that the chit fund agent cheated them.
 Majority of the respondents claim that they were unknown about the chit fund companies and they believed
the chit fund agent.
 86% of the respondents the current interest rate of banks and post office is low; 65% of the respondents
believe that a bank in their locality would have avoided them to invest in chit funds; 48.4 % believe that due
to lack of Govt. sponsored small investment schemes investors invested in chit funds; 42% believe that the
present banking formalities are rigid and somewhat responsible for chit fund scams.
 The study shows that laxity in regulatory system and nexus between the political parties and chit fund
companies paved way for the perpetrators to commit frauds.
 The respondents also believe that the business models of the chit funds are unsustainable in the long run and
believe that the rate of interest offered by chit fund companies is unfeasible.
 The study further emphasizes the requirement of stringent Act is essential along with proper coordination is
needed among the regulators.
 The study suggests that banking norms should be rationalized; investors education must be encouraged and
stringent action must be taken against the perpetrators.
 The study shows that investors are now more aware about these Chit Fund companies because of the
relentless media coverage and would be more careful before investing next time.
VII. CONCLUSION
The study empirically analyzes the determinants and rationale of chit funds in Odisha by
constructing an econometric model to study the various factors of chit funds investments. The
business of chit funds is running in India in various names and forms since many years.
Recent Frauds have exposed these businesses of thousands of crores rupees because of laxity
The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is certain Profit is Not
www.ijbmi.org 78 | Page
in regulation and financial illiteracy. Weak provisions of the Chit Fund Act, 1982 along with
laxity in regulatory system and nexus between the politicians trembled the bottom-of-the-
pyramid. Many small investors lost their life savings in chit fund scams. Rationalizing
banking norms along with financial literacy and investors education must be encouraged to
safeguard the interest of the investors .The regulators must tighten their Act with proper
coordination among the various agencies so as to build investors confidence and to retain
their faith.
REFERENCES
[1] Besley, Timothy, Stephen Coate and Glenn Loury. 1993. "The Economics of Rotating Savings and Credit Associations", The
American Economic Review, Vol. 83, No.4.
[2] Blaylock, B. T. (1998). Pyramid Schemes, Ponzi Schemes, and Related Frauds. Retrieved from World Wide Web on
16/04/99.http://www.impulse.net/~thebob/pyramid.html.
[3] Entombed Albania's Pyramids. (1997). Entombed in Albania's Pyramids. The Economist, 42(8001), 49.
[4] Caroll, R. T. (1998). Becoming a Critical hinker. Retrieved from the World Wide Web on 21/04/99. http:// dcn.davis. ca.us/~
btcarrol/skeptic/pyramid.html.
[5] Hyman, R. (1989). The psychology of deception. Annual Review of Psychology. Vol 40.
[6] Sigmund, K. (1993). Games of life: explorations in ecology, evolution, and behaviour. Oxford [England]; New York: Oxford
University Press.
[7] Wokutch, R. E., & Carson, T. L. (1999). The ethics and profitability of bluffing in business. In R. J. Lewicki (Ed.), Lewicki, Roy;
Saunders, David; Minton, John. (1999). Negotiation: Readings, exercises, and cases (3rd ed.) (2nd . ed., pp. 228-233). Boston, MA,
US: Irwin/The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.
[8] Ridley, M. (1997). The origins of virtue: human instincts and the evolution of cooperation (1st American ed.). New York: Viking.
[9] DePaulo, B. M., & Rosenthal, R. (1979). Telling lies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 37(10), 1713-1722.
[10] Bansal, C. (2005). Corporate Governance in the Financial Organization. In C. Bansal, Corporate governance: Law practice and
procedures with Case Studies (pp. 512-543).New Delhi: Taxmann Allied Services (P) Limited.
[11] Sathye, M. A. (2007). Developing financial intelligence: an assessment of the FIUs in Australia and India. Journal of Money
Laundering Control, 10(4), 391-405.
[12] Hudson, M. (2008). Norms and values of the various microfinance institutions. International Journal of Social Economics, 35(1/2),
35-48.
[13] Mannino, L. L. (2009). 1RS Offers Reef for Investors of Fraudulent Investment Schemes. Revenue procedure, 84-90.
[14] Rhee, R. J. (2009). The mad off scandal, market regulatory failure and the business education of lawyers. The Journal of
Corporation Law.
[15] Eeckhout, J. A. (2010). Matching in informal financial institution. Journal of the European Economic Association, 8 (5), 947-988.
[16] Nielsen, R. P. (2012). Whistle-Blowing Methods for Navigating Within and Helping Reform Regulatory Institutions. Springer, 385-
395.
[17] Roy, R. (2012). Media and Bad Money. Changing world of finance (pp. 9 -15). Kolkata: Department of Commerce, Serampore
College in collaboration with ICAI
[18] Ferri, P. A. (2010). „Financial fragility, the minskian triadand economic dynamics‟. International Journal of Political Economy,
39(9), 70-82.
[19] Kapoor, M. A. (2013). Chit Funds as an Innovative Access to Finance for Low-income Households. Massachusetts: Institute for
financial management and research.
[20] Sen, S. (2013, May 7). Banks under Scanner for Saradha Transactions. The Times of India, Kolkata Ed., p. 4.
[21] Chit Funds, the evolution, operational scenario, Role and Regulatory Framework
[22] The co-operative movement in Odisha
[23] The Orissa Self Help Act 2001

More Related Content

What's hot

Islamic Finance For Trade Development
Islamic Finance For Trade DevelopmentIslamic Finance For Trade Development
Islamic Finance For Trade Development
Mahmoud Sami Nabi
 
RATE OF INTEREST IN ANCIENT INDIA - WAY TOWARDS FINANCIAL INCLUSION AND SUST...
RATE OF INTEREST IN ANCIENT INDIA -  WAY TOWARDS FINANCIAL INCLUSION AND SUST...RATE OF INTEREST IN ANCIENT INDIA -  WAY TOWARDS FINANCIAL INCLUSION AND SUST...
RATE OF INTEREST IN ANCIENT INDIA - WAY TOWARDS FINANCIAL INCLUSION AND SUST...
Ranjan Bellarpady
 
Synopsis of my Ph.D Thesis - S.Periyasamy
Synopsis of my Ph.D Thesis - S.PeriyasamySynopsis of my Ph.D Thesis - S.Periyasamy
Synopsis of my Ph.D Thesis - S.Periyasamy
Dr. Sivasamy Periyasamy
 
Interaction of islamic banking sector with indonesian economic growth for 200...
Interaction of islamic banking sector with indonesian economic growth for 200...Interaction of islamic banking sector with indonesian economic growth for 200...
Interaction of islamic banking sector with indonesian economic growth for 200...
An Nisbah
 
The Factors Affecting Mudharabah Deposits of Sharia Banking in Indonesia
The Factors Affecting Mudharabah Deposits of Sharia Banking in IndonesiaThe Factors Affecting Mudharabah Deposits of Sharia Banking in Indonesia
The Factors Affecting Mudharabah Deposits of Sharia Banking in Indonesia
inventionjournals
 
A Study on Investors’ Awareness Level towards Nidhi Companies (Benefit Funds)
A Study on Investors’ Awareness Level towards Nidhi Companies (Benefit Funds)A Study on Investors’ Awareness Level towards Nidhi Companies (Benefit Funds)
A Study on Investors’ Awareness Level towards Nidhi Companies (Benefit Funds)
IOSRJBM
 
Regulating Islamic Banking : A Malaysian Perspective
Regulating Islamic Banking : A Malaysian PerspectiveRegulating Islamic Banking : A Malaysian Perspective
Regulating Islamic Banking : A Malaysian Perspective
Lokesh Gupta
 
Global trends in islamic banking - MIM Mediterranean Economic Forum 2014
Global trends in islamic banking - MIM Mediterranean Economic Forum 2014Global trends in islamic banking - MIM Mediterranean Economic Forum 2014
Global trends in islamic banking - MIM Mediterranean Economic Forum 2014
Jassim Mahadik
 
Islamic Finance
Islamic FinanceIslamic Finance
Islamic Finance
Islamiculture
 
FINANCIAL LITERACY, CASH MANAGEMENT AND BUSINESS GROWTH IN KAMPALA CITY COUNC...
FINANCIAL LITERACY, CASH MANAGEMENT AND BUSINESS GROWTH IN KAMPALA CITY COUNC...FINANCIAL LITERACY, CASH MANAGEMENT AND BUSINESS GROWTH IN KAMPALA CITY COUNC...
FINANCIAL LITERACY, CASH MANAGEMENT AND BUSINESS GROWTH IN KAMPALA CITY COUNC...
ectijjournal
 
Understanding Islamic Finance
Understanding Islamic FinanceUnderstanding Islamic Finance
Understanding Islamic Finance
United Interactive™
 
Islamic finance 2012
Islamic finance 2012Islamic finance 2012
Islamic finance 2012
Mostafa Younis
 
Model Example of Research Proposal
Model Example of Research Proposal Model Example of Research Proposal
Model Example of Research Proposal
SHAYA'A OTHMAN MANAGEMENT & RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
 
Book Chapter _ Shariah Governance in Bangladesh - Final.pdf
Book Chapter _ Shariah Governance in Bangladesh - Final.pdfBook Chapter _ Shariah Governance in Bangladesh - Final.pdf
Book Chapter _ Shariah Governance in Bangladesh - Final.pdf
Md. Hafij Ullah
 
FINANCIAL SERVICES SECTOR
FINANCIAL SERVICES SECTORFINANCIAL SERVICES SECTOR
Tr global-islamic-asset-mgmt-report-2014
Tr global-islamic-asset-mgmt-report-2014Tr global-islamic-asset-mgmt-report-2014
Tr global-islamic-asset-mgmt-report-2014Adil MSATFA
 
Islamic Finance and Economic Growth in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA): An ...
Islamic Finance and Economic Growth in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA): An ...Islamic Finance and Economic Growth in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA): An ...
Islamic Finance and Economic Growth in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA): An ...
scmsnoida5
 
Crisil fund services-wealth-mgmnt-feb11
Crisil fund services-wealth-mgmnt-feb11Crisil fund services-wealth-mgmnt-feb11
Crisil fund services-wealth-mgmnt-feb11Radhika Khant
 
Impediments to Capital Market Financing of Small and Medium Enterprises _Crim...
Impediments to Capital Market Financing of Small and Medium Enterprises _Crim...Impediments to Capital Market Financing of Small and Medium Enterprises _Crim...
Impediments to Capital Market Financing of Small and Medium Enterprises _Crim...
crimsonpublisherscojrr
 

What's hot (20)

Islamic Finance For Trade Development
Islamic Finance For Trade DevelopmentIslamic Finance For Trade Development
Islamic Finance For Trade Development
 
RATE OF INTEREST IN ANCIENT INDIA - WAY TOWARDS FINANCIAL INCLUSION AND SUST...
RATE OF INTEREST IN ANCIENT INDIA -  WAY TOWARDS FINANCIAL INCLUSION AND SUST...RATE OF INTEREST IN ANCIENT INDIA -  WAY TOWARDS FINANCIAL INCLUSION AND SUST...
RATE OF INTEREST IN ANCIENT INDIA - WAY TOWARDS FINANCIAL INCLUSION AND SUST...
 
Synopsis of my Ph.D Thesis - S.Periyasamy
Synopsis of my Ph.D Thesis - S.PeriyasamySynopsis of my Ph.D Thesis - S.Periyasamy
Synopsis of my Ph.D Thesis - S.Periyasamy
 
Islamic Financial System
Islamic Financial SystemIslamic Financial System
Islamic Financial System
 
Interaction of islamic banking sector with indonesian economic growth for 200...
Interaction of islamic banking sector with indonesian economic growth for 200...Interaction of islamic banking sector with indonesian economic growth for 200...
Interaction of islamic banking sector with indonesian economic growth for 200...
 
The Factors Affecting Mudharabah Deposits of Sharia Banking in Indonesia
The Factors Affecting Mudharabah Deposits of Sharia Banking in IndonesiaThe Factors Affecting Mudharabah Deposits of Sharia Banking in Indonesia
The Factors Affecting Mudharabah Deposits of Sharia Banking in Indonesia
 
A Study on Investors’ Awareness Level towards Nidhi Companies (Benefit Funds)
A Study on Investors’ Awareness Level towards Nidhi Companies (Benefit Funds)A Study on Investors’ Awareness Level towards Nidhi Companies (Benefit Funds)
A Study on Investors’ Awareness Level towards Nidhi Companies (Benefit Funds)
 
Regulating Islamic Banking : A Malaysian Perspective
Regulating Islamic Banking : A Malaysian PerspectiveRegulating Islamic Banking : A Malaysian Perspective
Regulating Islamic Banking : A Malaysian Perspective
 
Global trends in islamic banking - MIM Mediterranean Economic Forum 2014
Global trends in islamic banking - MIM Mediterranean Economic Forum 2014Global trends in islamic banking - MIM Mediterranean Economic Forum 2014
Global trends in islamic banking - MIM Mediterranean Economic Forum 2014
 
Islamic Finance
Islamic FinanceIslamic Finance
Islamic Finance
 
FINANCIAL LITERACY, CASH MANAGEMENT AND BUSINESS GROWTH IN KAMPALA CITY COUNC...
FINANCIAL LITERACY, CASH MANAGEMENT AND BUSINESS GROWTH IN KAMPALA CITY COUNC...FINANCIAL LITERACY, CASH MANAGEMENT AND BUSINESS GROWTH IN KAMPALA CITY COUNC...
FINANCIAL LITERACY, CASH MANAGEMENT AND BUSINESS GROWTH IN KAMPALA CITY COUNC...
 
Understanding Islamic Finance
Understanding Islamic FinanceUnderstanding Islamic Finance
Understanding Islamic Finance
 
Islamic finance 2012
Islamic finance 2012Islamic finance 2012
Islamic finance 2012
 
Model Example of Research Proposal
Model Example of Research Proposal Model Example of Research Proposal
Model Example of Research Proposal
 
Book Chapter _ Shariah Governance in Bangladesh - Final.pdf
Book Chapter _ Shariah Governance in Bangladesh - Final.pdfBook Chapter _ Shariah Governance in Bangladesh - Final.pdf
Book Chapter _ Shariah Governance in Bangladesh - Final.pdf
 
FINANCIAL SERVICES SECTOR
FINANCIAL SERVICES SECTORFINANCIAL SERVICES SECTOR
FINANCIAL SERVICES SECTOR
 
Tr global-islamic-asset-mgmt-report-2014
Tr global-islamic-asset-mgmt-report-2014Tr global-islamic-asset-mgmt-report-2014
Tr global-islamic-asset-mgmt-report-2014
 
Islamic Finance and Economic Growth in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA): An ...
Islamic Finance and Economic Growth in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA): An ...Islamic Finance and Economic Growth in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA): An ...
Islamic Finance and Economic Growth in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA): An ...
 
Crisil fund services-wealth-mgmnt-feb11
Crisil fund services-wealth-mgmnt-feb11Crisil fund services-wealth-mgmnt-feb11
Crisil fund services-wealth-mgmnt-feb11
 
Impediments to Capital Market Financing of Small and Medium Enterprises _Crim...
Impediments to Capital Market Financing of Small and Medium Enterprises _Crim...Impediments to Capital Market Financing of Small and Medium Enterprises _Crim...
Impediments to Capital Market Financing of Small and Medium Enterprises _Crim...
 

Viewers also liked

Platón (427–347 a.C.)
Platón (427–347 a.C.)Platón (427–347 a.C.)
Platón (427–347 a.C.)A. M.R.
 
ARTICULOS INTERESANTES A CIEN AÑOS DEL ROBO DE PANAMA -12/3/2003
ARTICULOS INTERESANTES A CIEN AÑOS DEL ROBO DE PANAMA -12/3/2003ARTICULOS INTERESANTES A CIEN AÑOS DEL ROBO DE PANAMA -12/3/2003
ARTICULOS INTERESANTES A CIEN AÑOS DEL ROBO DE PANAMA -12/3/2003
Oscar Ayala A. International Consulting Services
 
Electricidad estatica ¿un simple o susto o peligro real?
Electricidad estatica ¿un simple o susto o peligro real?Electricidad estatica ¿un simple o susto o peligro real?
Electricidad estatica ¿un simple o susto o peligro real?
Yezz Ortiz
 
Portfolio, Dimonte Group
Portfolio, Dimonte GroupPortfolio, Dimonte Group
Portfolio, Dimonte GroupMike Wilson
 
RIDIX: tecnologie meccaniche di successo
RIDIX: tecnologie meccaniche di successoRIDIX: tecnologie meccaniche di successo
RIDIX: tecnologie meccaniche di successo
Federica Ferrero
 
Proyecto de vida
Proyecto de vidaProyecto de vida
Proyecto de vida
Mateo Saldarriaga
 
Correccion 1 diseño
Correccion 1 diseñoCorreccion 1 diseño
Correccion 1 diseño
Kayglevisiyanu
 
Incidencia de cáncer en el área metropolitana de Bucaramanga 2000-2004
Incidencia de cáncer en el área metropolitana de Bucaramanga 2000-2004Incidencia de cáncer en el área metropolitana de Bucaramanga 2000-2004
Incidencia de cáncer en el área metropolitana de Bucaramanga 2000-2004
Alejandra Alfonso
 
Tesoro ecologico-en-riesgo-los-manglares-de-marismas-nacionales
Tesoro ecologico-en-riesgo-los-manglares-de-marismas-nacionalesTesoro ecologico-en-riesgo-los-manglares-de-marismas-nacionales
Tesoro ecologico-en-riesgo-los-manglares-de-marismas-nacionales
Yezz Ortiz
 
Planejamento cei 2014
Planejamento cei 2014Planejamento cei 2014
Planejamento cei 2014
Beth Sousa Tavares
 
Gerencia de proyectos alb
Gerencia de proyectos albGerencia de proyectos alb
Gerencia de proyectos alb
Albeiro Fajardo
 
Hay quien ensucia más 2
Hay quien ensucia más 2Hay quien ensucia más 2
Hay quien ensucia más 2
Yezz Ortiz
 
Psychology homework help
Psychology homework helpPsychology homework help
Psychology homework help
roman nnelson
 
Silabo parte uno
Silabo parte unoSilabo parte uno
Silabo parte uno
Lourdes Moreira
 
2016.10.26 digitalteknikk - adc og dac - studieveiledning for onsdag 26.1...
2016.10.26   digitalteknikk  - adc og  dac - studieveiledning for onsdag 26.1...2016.10.26   digitalteknikk  - adc og  dac - studieveiledning for onsdag 26.1...
2016.10.26 digitalteknikk - adc og dac - studieveiledning for onsdag 26.1...
Sven Åge Eriksen
 
spring bed lady americana
spring bed lady americanaspring bed lady americana
spring bed lady americana
surabaya spring
 
3 g tech
3 g tech3 g tech
3 g tech
Yatin Sawant
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Platón (427–347 a.C.)
Platón (427–347 a.C.)Platón (427–347 a.C.)
Platón (427–347 a.C.)
 
Haciendo Universidad No. 45
Haciendo Universidad No. 45Haciendo Universidad No. 45
Haciendo Universidad No. 45
 
ARTICULOS INTERESANTES A CIEN AÑOS DEL ROBO DE PANAMA -12/3/2003
ARTICULOS INTERESANTES A CIEN AÑOS DEL ROBO DE PANAMA -12/3/2003ARTICULOS INTERESANTES A CIEN AÑOS DEL ROBO DE PANAMA -12/3/2003
ARTICULOS INTERESANTES A CIEN AÑOS DEL ROBO DE PANAMA -12/3/2003
 
Electricidad estatica ¿un simple o susto o peligro real?
Electricidad estatica ¿un simple o susto o peligro real?Electricidad estatica ¿un simple o susto o peligro real?
Electricidad estatica ¿un simple o susto o peligro real?
 
Portfolio, Dimonte Group
Portfolio, Dimonte GroupPortfolio, Dimonte Group
Portfolio, Dimonte Group
 
Acuerdo 696
Acuerdo 696Acuerdo 696
Acuerdo 696
 
RIDIX: tecnologie meccaniche di successo
RIDIX: tecnologie meccaniche di successoRIDIX: tecnologie meccaniche di successo
RIDIX: tecnologie meccaniche di successo
 
Bdonovanresume
BdonovanresumeBdonovanresume
Bdonovanresume
 
Proyecto de vida
Proyecto de vidaProyecto de vida
Proyecto de vida
 
Correccion 1 diseño
Correccion 1 diseñoCorreccion 1 diseño
Correccion 1 diseño
 
Incidencia de cáncer en el área metropolitana de Bucaramanga 2000-2004
Incidencia de cáncer en el área metropolitana de Bucaramanga 2000-2004Incidencia de cáncer en el área metropolitana de Bucaramanga 2000-2004
Incidencia de cáncer en el área metropolitana de Bucaramanga 2000-2004
 
Tesoro ecologico-en-riesgo-los-manglares-de-marismas-nacionales
Tesoro ecologico-en-riesgo-los-manglares-de-marismas-nacionalesTesoro ecologico-en-riesgo-los-manglares-de-marismas-nacionales
Tesoro ecologico-en-riesgo-los-manglares-de-marismas-nacionales
 
Planejamento cei 2014
Planejamento cei 2014Planejamento cei 2014
Planejamento cei 2014
 
Gerencia de proyectos alb
Gerencia de proyectos albGerencia de proyectos alb
Gerencia de proyectos alb
 
Hay quien ensucia más 2
Hay quien ensucia más 2Hay quien ensucia más 2
Hay quien ensucia más 2
 
Psychology homework help
Psychology homework helpPsychology homework help
Psychology homework help
 
Silabo parte uno
Silabo parte unoSilabo parte uno
Silabo parte uno
 
2016.10.26 digitalteknikk - adc og dac - studieveiledning for onsdag 26.1...
2016.10.26   digitalteknikk  - adc og  dac - studieveiledning for onsdag 26.1...2016.10.26   digitalteknikk  - adc og  dac - studieveiledning for onsdag 26.1...
2016.10.26 digitalteknikk - adc og dac - studieveiledning for onsdag 26.1...
 
spring bed lady americana
spring bed lady americanaspring bed lady americana
spring bed lady americana
 
3 g tech
3 g tech3 g tech
3 g tech
 

Similar to The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is almost certain Profit is Not

A Study on Factors Influencing Investment Decision Regarding Various Financia...
A Study on Factors Influencing Investment Decision Regarding Various Financia...A Study on Factors Influencing Investment Decision Regarding Various Financia...
A Study on Factors Influencing Investment Decision Regarding Various Financia...
ijtsrd
 
investors' perception towards investment avenues with reference to mangalore ...
investors' perception towards investment avenues with reference to mangalore ...investors' perception towards investment avenues with reference to mangalore ...
investors' perception towards investment avenues with reference to mangalore ...
abhinaya19
 
A Study on Investors Perception towards Mutual Fund Investments (With Special...
A Study on Investors Perception towards Mutual Fund Investments (With Special...A Study on Investors Perception towards Mutual Fund Investments (With Special...
A Study on Investors Perception towards Mutual Fund Investments (With Special...
Dr. Amarjeet Singh
 
D554450.pdf
D554450.pdfD554450.pdf
D554450.pdf
aijbm
 
Socio economic factors on individual behaviour of mutual fund in chennai city...
Socio economic factors on individual behaviour of mutual fund in chennai city...Socio economic factors on individual behaviour of mutual fund in chennai city...
Socio economic factors on individual behaviour of mutual fund in chennai city...Alexander Decker
 
Role of Behavioural Finance in the Financial Market
Role of Behavioural Finance in the Financial MarketRole of Behavioural Finance in the Financial Market
Role of Behavioural Finance in the Financial Market
inventionjournals
 
TRADING AND DEMAT BEHAVIOUR OF ACCOUNT HOLDERS IN THE TIRUCHIRAPPALLI CITY
TRADING AND DEMAT BEHAVIOUR OF ACCOUNT HOLDERS IN THE TIRUCHIRAPPALLI CITYTRADING AND DEMAT BEHAVIOUR OF ACCOUNT HOLDERS IN THE TIRUCHIRAPPALLI CITY
TRADING AND DEMAT BEHAVIOUR OF ACCOUNT HOLDERS IN THE TIRUCHIRAPPALLI CITY
IAEME Publication
 
FINAL FIELD.pdf
FINAL FIELD.pdfFINAL FIELD.pdf
FINAL FIELD.pdf
anchitkatoch
 
Investment strategies and motivational factors among small investors a study
Investment strategies and motivational factors among small investors a studyInvestment strategies and motivational factors among small investors a study
Investment strategies and motivational factors among small investors a studyIAEME Publication
 
A Study of Determinants Influencing Financial Literacy of Individual Investor...
A Study of Determinants Influencing Financial Literacy of Individual Investor...A Study of Determinants Influencing Financial Literacy of Individual Investor...
A Study of Determinants Influencing Financial Literacy of Individual Investor...
RSIS International
 
A STUDY ON BEHAVIOR OF INVESTORS TOWARDS POST OFFICE SAVING SCHEMES IN PUNE CITY
A STUDY ON BEHAVIOR OF INVESTORS TOWARDS POST OFFICE SAVING SCHEMES IN PUNE CITYA STUDY ON BEHAVIOR OF INVESTORS TOWARDS POST OFFICE SAVING SCHEMES IN PUNE CITY
A STUDY ON BEHAVIOR OF INVESTORS TOWARDS POST OFFICE SAVING SCHEMES IN PUNE CITY
Joe Osborn
 
A Study of Investment Pattern of a Common Man A Literature Review
A Study of Investment Pattern of a Common Man A Literature ReviewA Study of Investment Pattern of a Common Man A Literature Review
A Study of Investment Pattern of a Common Man A Literature Review
ijtsrd
 
15562101 project-rt-idfc-mutual-fundepor
15562101 project-rt-idfc-mutual-fundepor15562101 project-rt-idfc-mutual-fundepor
15562101 project-rt-idfc-mutual-fundepor
mrchavan143
 
Evaluating the Effect of Financial Knowledge on Investment Decisions of Inves...
Evaluating the Effect of Financial Knowledge on Investment Decisions of Inves...Evaluating the Effect of Financial Knowledge on Investment Decisions of Inves...
Evaluating the Effect of Financial Knowledge on Investment Decisions of Inves...
Dr. Amarjeet Singh
 
Evaluation Research on Development Level of Energy Internet
Evaluation Research on Development Level of Energy InternetEvaluation Research on Development Level of Energy Internet
Evaluation Research on Development Level of Energy Internet
Dr. Amarjeet Singh
 
Factors Influencing Investment Decisions of Retail Investors- A Descriptive S...
Factors Influencing Investment Decisions of Retail Investors- A Descriptive S...Factors Influencing Investment Decisions of Retail Investors- A Descriptive S...
Factors Influencing Investment Decisions of Retail Investors- A Descriptive S...
inventionjournals
 
Financial literacy for Mutual Fund Investment: An extensive study on investor...
Financial literacy for Mutual Fund Investment: An extensive study on investor...Financial literacy for Mutual Fund Investment: An extensive study on investor...
Financial literacy for Mutual Fund Investment: An extensive study on investor...
AI Publications
 
Running head Business Environment Analysis ReportPUT SHORT TITL.docx
Running head Business Environment Analysis ReportPUT SHORT TITL.docxRunning head Business Environment Analysis ReportPUT SHORT TITL.docx
Running head Business Environment Analysis ReportPUT SHORT TITL.docx
carlstromcurtis
 

Similar to The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is almost certain Profit is Not (20)

A Study on Factors Influencing Investment Decision Regarding Various Financia...
A Study on Factors Influencing Investment Decision Regarding Various Financia...A Study on Factors Influencing Investment Decision Regarding Various Financia...
A Study on Factors Influencing Investment Decision Regarding Various Financia...
 
10120130406024
1012013040602410120130406024
10120130406024
 
investors' perception towards investment avenues with reference to mangalore ...
investors' perception towards investment avenues with reference to mangalore ...investors' perception towards investment avenues with reference to mangalore ...
investors' perception towards investment avenues with reference to mangalore ...
 
A Study on Investors Perception towards Mutual Fund Investments (With Special...
A Study on Investors Perception towards Mutual Fund Investments (With Special...A Study on Investors Perception towards Mutual Fund Investments (With Special...
A Study on Investors Perception towards Mutual Fund Investments (With Special...
 
D554450.pdf
D554450.pdfD554450.pdf
D554450.pdf
 
Socio economic factors on individual behaviour of mutual fund in chennai city...
Socio economic factors on individual behaviour of mutual fund in chennai city...Socio economic factors on individual behaviour of mutual fund in chennai city...
Socio economic factors on individual behaviour of mutual fund in chennai city...
 
Role of Behavioural Finance in the Financial Market
Role of Behavioural Finance in the Financial MarketRole of Behavioural Finance in the Financial Market
Role of Behavioural Finance in the Financial Market
 
TRADING AND DEMAT BEHAVIOUR OF ACCOUNT HOLDERS IN THE TIRUCHIRAPPALLI CITY
TRADING AND DEMAT BEHAVIOUR OF ACCOUNT HOLDERS IN THE TIRUCHIRAPPALLI CITYTRADING AND DEMAT BEHAVIOUR OF ACCOUNT HOLDERS IN THE TIRUCHIRAPPALLI CITY
TRADING AND DEMAT BEHAVIOUR OF ACCOUNT HOLDERS IN THE TIRUCHIRAPPALLI CITY
 
FINAL FIELD.pdf
FINAL FIELD.pdfFINAL FIELD.pdf
FINAL FIELD.pdf
 
Investment strategies and motivational factors among small investors a study
Investment strategies and motivational factors among small investors a studyInvestment strategies and motivational factors among small investors a study
Investment strategies and motivational factors among small investors a study
 
10120130405013
1012013040501310120130405013
10120130405013
 
A Study of Determinants Influencing Financial Literacy of Individual Investor...
A Study of Determinants Influencing Financial Literacy of Individual Investor...A Study of Determinants Influencing Financial Literacy of Individual Investor...
A Study of Determinants Influencing Financial Literacy of Individual Investor...
 
A STUDY ON BEHAVIOR OF INVESTORS TOWARDS POST OFFICE SAVING SCHEMES IN PUNE CITY
A STUDY ON BEHAVIOR OF INVESTORS TOWARDS POST OFFICE SAVING SCHEMES IN PUNE CITYA STUDY ON BEHAVIOR OF INVESTORS TOWARDS POST OFFICE SAVING SCHEMES IN PUNE CITY
A STUDY ON BEHAVIOR OF INVESTORS TOWARDS POST OFFICE SAVING SCHEMES IN PUNE CITY
 
A Study of Investment Pattern of a Common Man A Literature Review
A Study of Investment Pattern of a Common Man A Literature ReviewA Study of Investment Pattern of a Common Man A Literature Review
A Study of Investment Pattern of a Common Man A Literature Review
 
15562101 project-rt-idfc-mutual-fundepor
15562101 project-rt-idfc-mutual-fundepor15562101 project-rt-idfc-mutual-fundepor
15562101 project-rt-idfc-mutual-fundepor
 
Evaluating the Effect of Financial Knowledge on Investment Decisions of Inves...
Evaluating the Effect of Financial Knowledge on Investment Decisions of Inves...Evaluating the Effect of Financial Knowledge on Investment Decisions of Inves...
Evaluating the Effect of Financial Knowledge on Investment Decisions of Inves...
 
Evaluation Research on Development Level of Energy Internet
Evaluation Research on Development Level of Energy InternetEvaluation Research on Development Level of Energy Internet
Evaluation Research on Development Level of Energy Internet
 
Factors Influencing Investment Decisions of Retail Investors- A Descriptive S...
Factors Influencing Investment Decisions of Retail Investors- A Descriptive S...Factors Influencing Investment Decisions of Retail Investors- A Descriptive S...
Factors Influencing Investment Decisions of Retail Investors- A Descriptive S...
 
Financial literacy for Mutual Fund Investment: An extensive study on investor...
Financial literacy for Mutual Fund Investment: An extensive study on investor...Financial literacy for Mutual Fund Investment: An extensive study on investor...
Financial literacy for Mutual Fund Investment: An extensive study on investor...
 
Running head Business Environment Analysis ReportPUT SHORT TITL.docx
Running head Business Environment Analysis ReportPUT SHORT TITL.docxRunning head Business Environment Analysis ReportPUT SHORT TITL.docx
Running head Business Environment Analysis ReportPUT SHORT TITL.docx
 

Recently uploaded

14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
SyedAbiiAzazi1
 
Final project report on grocery store management system..pdf
Final project report on grocery store management system..pdfFinal project report on grocery store management system..pdf
Final project report on grocery store management system..pdf
Kamal Acharya
 
Harnessing WebAssembly for Real-time Stateless Streaming Pipelines
Harnessing WebAssembly for Real-time Stateless Streaming PipelinesHarnessing WebAssembly for Real-time Stateless Streaming Pipelines
Harnessing WebAssembly for Real-time Stateless Streaming Pipelines
Christina Lin
 
Unbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptx
Unbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptxUnbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptx
Unbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptx
ChristineTorrepenida1
 
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptxInvestor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
AmarGB2
 
Fundamentals of Induction Motor Drives.pptx
Fundamentals of Induction Motor Drives.pptxFundamentals of Induction Motor Drives.pptx
Fundamentals of Induction Motor Drives.pptx
manasideore6
 
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
thanhdowork
 
Technical Drawings introduction to drawing of prisms
Technical Drawings introduction to drawing of prismsTechnical Drawings introduction to drawing of prisms
Technical Drawings introduction to drawing of prisms
heavyhaig
 
road safety engineering r s e unit 3.pdf
road safety engineering  r s e unit 3.pdfroad safety engineering  r s e unit 3.pdf
road safety engineering r s e unit 3.pdf
VENKATESHvenky89705
 
Forklift Classes Overview by Intella Parts
Forklift Classes Overview by Intella PartsForklift Classes Overview by Intella Parts
Forklift Classes Overview by Intella Parts
Intella Parts
 
6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)
6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)
6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)
ClaraZara1
 
Pile Foundation by Venkatesh Taduvai (Sub Geotechnical Engineering II)-conver...
Pile Foundation by Venkatesh Taduvai (Sub Geotechnical Engineering II)-conver...Pile Foundation by Venkatesh Taduvai (Sub Geotechnical Engineering II)-conver...
Pile Foundation by Venkatesh Taduvai (Sub Geotechnical Engineering II)-conver...
AJAYKUMARPUND1
 
weather web application report.pdf
weather web application report.pdfweather web application report.pdf
weather web application report.pdf
Pratik Pawar
 
Steel & Timber Design according to British Standard
Steel & Timber Design according to British StandardSteel & Timber Design according to British Standard
Steel & Timber Design according to British Standard
AkolbilaEmmanuel1
 
Tutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdf
Tutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdfTutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdf
Tutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdf
aqil azizi
 
NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...
NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...
NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...
ssuser7dcef0
 
Design and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&B
Design and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&BDesign and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&B
Design and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&B
Sreedhar Chowdam
 
Planning Of Procurement o different goods and services
Planning Of Procurement o different goods and servicesPlanning Of Procurement o different goods and services
Planning Of Procurement o different goods and services
JoytuBarua2
 
Railway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdf
Railway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdfRailway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdf
Railway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdf
TeeVichai
 
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine LearningUnderstanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
SUTEJAS
 

Recently uploaded (20)

14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
14 Template Contractual Notice - EOT Application
 
Final project report on grocery store management system..pdf
Final project report on grocery store management system..pdfFinal project report on grocery store management system..pdf
Final project report on grocery store management system..pdf
 
Harnessing WebAssembly for Real-time Stateless Streaming Pipelines
Harnessing WebAssembly for Real-time Stateless Streaming PipelinesHarnessing WebAssembly for Real-time Stateless Streaming Pipelines
Harnessing WebAssembly for Real-time Stateless Streaming Pipelines
 
Unbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptx
Unbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptxUnbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptx
Unbalanced Three Phase Systems and circuits.pptx
 
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptxInvestor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
 
Fundamentals of Induction Motor Drives.pptx
Fundamentals of Induction Motor Drives.pptxFundamentals of Induction Motor Drives.pptx
Fundamentals of Induction Motor Drives.pptx
 
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
 
Technical Drawings introduction to drawing of prisms
Technical Drawings introduction to drawing of prismsTechnical Drawings introduction to drawing of prisms
Technical Drawings introduction to drawing of prisms
 
road safety engineering r s e unit 3.pdf
road safety engineering  r s e unit 3.pdfroad safety engineering  r s e unit 3.pdf
road safety engineering r s e unit 3.pdf
 
Forklift Classes Overview by Intella Parts
Forklift Classes Overview by Intella PartsForklift Classes Overview by Intella Parts
Forklift Classes Overview by Intella Parts
 
6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)
6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)
6th International Conference on Machine Learning & Applications (CMLA 2024)
 
Pile Foundation by Venkatesh Taduvai (Sub Geotechnical Engineering II)-conver...
Pile Foundation by Venkatesh Taduvai (Sub Geotechnical Engineering II)-conver...Pile Foundation by Venkatesh Taduvai (Sub Geotechnical Engineering II)-conver...
Pile Foundation by Venkatesh Taduvai (Sub Geotechnical Engineering II)-conver...
 
weather web application report.pdf
weather web application report.pdfweather web application report.pdf
weather web application report.pdf
 
Steel & Timber Design according to British Standard
Steel & Timber Design according to British StandardSteel & Timber Design according to British Standard
Steel & Timber Design according to British Standard
 
Tutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdf
Tutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdfTutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdf
Tutorial for 16S rRNA Gene Analysis with QIIME2.pdf
 
NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...
NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...
NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...
 
Design and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&B
Design and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&BDesign and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&B
Design and Analysis of Algorithms-DP,Backtracking,Graphs,B&B
 
Planning Of Procurement o different goods and services
Planning Of Procurement o different goods and servicesPlanning Of Procurement o different goods and services
Planning Of Procurement o different goods and services
 
Railway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdf
Railway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdfRailway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdf
Railway Signalling Principles Edition 3.pdf
 
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine LearningUnderstanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
 

The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is almost certain Profit is Not

  • 1. International Journal of Business and Management Invention ISSN (Online): 2319 – 8028, ISSN (Print): 2319 – 801X www.ijbmi.org || Volume 5 Issue 8 || August. 2016 || PP—71-78 www.ijbmi.org 71 | Page The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is almost certain Profit is Not *Santosha Kumar Mallick, **Dr. Ansuman Sahoo *Research Scholar, Department of Business Administration, Utkal University, Bhubaneswar, India, **Lecturer (IMBA), Department of Business Administration, Utkal University, Bhubaneswar, India, ABSTRACT: The research in this paper has been conducted from within the theoretical framework of behavioural finance. The aim of this paper is to examine chit fund scams and its aftermath effect on Individuals & Households of Odisha. The study provides post-mortem analysis of changes in attitude investors towards chit funds. The data comprise a random sampling of 112 respondents drawn through a field survey. Different statistical tests were performed to assess support for the hypothesis.The results of data analysis reveals due to lack of financial literacy and sophistication, investors are simply more exposed to idiosyncrasies of the chit fund companies. Expectations of earnings high commission and high rate of return attracted investors to join chit funds. Someone known to investors or some of the family member or relative persuaded investors to join in chit funds. Majority of the respondents believe that the chit fund agent cheated them and they were unknown about the chit fund company and they believed the chit fund agents. The study shows that laxity in regulatory system and nexus between the politicians and chit fund companies paved way for the perpetrators to commit frauds. The study shows that investors are now more aware about these Chit Fund companies because of the relentless media coverage and would be more careful before investing next time. Keywords Behavioural finance, Chit-fund scams, Financial literacy, Household savings, Investment I. INTRODUCTION The economic theory of investment states that investors think and behave “rationally”. However keeping in mind the recent trends in decline in ethical values and moral standards due to the detection and exposure of series of scams and frauds in all forms of businesses and in government organisations including the recent chit fund scams it is require to go for a behavioural explanation of investor's irrationality in a consistent and correlated manner. It is found that investors are not always rational; rather investor's emotion has a major role to play with the investment decision. Individuals and Households, by virtue of their relative immobility and lack of financial sophistication, are simply more exposed to idiosyncrasies of the chit fund companies, banks, financial institution and business houses. The recent chit-fund scams exposed the loopholes in the household financial investments and hence necessitate the study. Odisha is a state located on the eastern coast of Indian peninsula. Nearly 85% of its population live in rural areas and depend mostly on agriculture for their livelihood. The state has abundant mineral resources including precious and semi-precious stones. It has also plentiful water resources. Cultivators and Agricultural labourers constitute 65% of the total workforce. Agriculture provides direct or indirect employment to 65% of the total work force and contributes 26% of the net state domestic product and it is also counted among the poorest states of the country. The economy of Odisha is one the fastest growing state economies in India. According to 2014-15 economic survey, Odisha's gross state domestic product (GSDP) was expected to grow at 8.78% in the 2014-15 fiscal years. Odisha has an agriculture-based economy which is in transition towards an industry and service-based economy. According to Dun & Bradstreet, the GSDP is expected to grow at a rate of 8.1% during 2015-2020. Odisha is also one of the top FDI destinations in India. In the fiscal year 2011-12, Odisha received investment proposals worth Rs.49, 527 crores (US$9.296 billion). According to the Reserve Bank of India, Odisha received Rs.53, 000 crores (US$8.33 billion) worth of new FDI commitments in the 2012-13 fiscal. However, in spite of all these developments the Individuals & Households of Odisha state has witnessed their hard earned money being siphoned by Chit funds companies. Although there are many avenues for savings and investment one‟s hard eared money. Chit funds and Ponzi schemes promises large returns on investments are very common avenues of parallel investment since long. But, in recent years a good number of frauds have been exposed involving thousands of crores rupees. A number of chit fund frauds in Odisha pressed the panic button and investors rushed to get back their invested money from such chit. These scams lead to domestic and social violence, harassment and even suicides. As the bottom-of-the-pyramid population continues to fret about having lost one‟s life savings in the Odisha “chit funds”. There is a necessity to analyze the determinants and rationale of frauds committed by chit funds in
  • 2. The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is certain Profit is Not www.ijbmi.org 72 | Page Odisha. The lessons learned in recent chit fund scams and suggest remedial ways of proper managing of chit funds in Odisha. II. OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY The objectives of the study are  To analyze the determinants of investment in chit funds in Odisha.  To study rationale of frauds committed by chit funds in Odisha.  To suggest the remedial ways of proper managing of chit funds in Odisha.  To study the lessons learned in recent chit fund scams in Odisha. III. LITERATURE REVIEW Chit funds are the Indian equivalent of the Rotating Savings and Credit Associations (ROSCA) that are famous throughout the world. 1 ROSCAs are a means to „save and borrow‟ at the same time. It is considered one of the best instruments to cater to the needs of the poor. There are numerous published literatures on Ponzi schemes. Ponzi schemes, which are another type of investment scam, because it promises large returns on investments that are unachievable because they are solely derived from new investor funds (2 Blaylock, 1998; 3 Entombed Albania's Pyramids, 1997). Investors in a Ponzi scheme typically send their money to either a central investment house, or a person which is supposed to send the promised returns back to investors. The fact that most investors are not told that they are destined to lose their money in these schemes is the reason why ponzi schemes are illegal. Motivating people into investment schemes is legal, and so is the giving of money to other people, but it is the deception of the investors about their expected financial returns that determines the illegality of pyramid schemes (4 Caroll, 1998; Commerce Commission, 1997). Fundamentally, deception exists because new investors are typically convinced on the promise that they will receive larger financial returns on their investments. The pyramid scheme that ran in Albania during 1995-1997 is a notable example of a pyramid scheme in which people invested and consequently suffered a financial loss. In this instance the scheme quickly spread through Albania and engulfed most of the populace. The debt incurred by Albanian citizens was estimated at one billion dollars, which if the Albanian government had reimbursed would have produced bankruptcy (3 Entombed Albania's Pyramids, 1997). Investors in this scheme were promised returns of 50% per month on their investments and people were motivated to sell assets in order to invest cash for the expected monetary returns. For a short period of time the returns were achieved and a few people did well, but, as with all pyramid schemes, the supply of new investors ran out and consequently further payments were dishonoured, thus leaving investors in financial ruin. The semantics surrounding deliberately misleading people includes such phrases as white lies, bluffs, and fibs, but essentially all equate to deception (5 Hyman, 1989). The definition of deception encompasses all the previous terms, but here it is confined to the parameters of deliberate economic behaviour. Cheating and dislike of it display themselves cross culturally. People perceive it to be a socially unacceptable behaviour and react adversely to known cheaters (6 Sigmund, 1993). Consequently, a cheater must assess the possible gains and risks associated with cheating before engaging in deceptive behaviour (6 Sigmund, 1993; 7 Wokutch & Carson, 1999). As such, the outcomes associated with cheating influence both an individual‟s choice to engage in deceptive behaviour and the reactions of others if this behaviour is discovered (5 Hyman, 1989; 8 Ridley, 1997). Arguably, either deliberate or unintentional deception is required for the successful recruitment of investors to pyramid schemes. People who are closer and are deceived react more severely. This closely relates to the principle of evolutionary psychology that asserts people are more likely to act altruistically to people who are members of their kin group and are themselves more likely to reciprocate (8 Ridley, 1997; 6 Sigmund, 1993). Therefore determining how these relationship factors affect people‟s economic behaviours is a worthwhile area to research, especially in respect to deception-based punzi schemes. Furthermore, when people consider holding others responsible for acts of deception, they take into consideration the agent‟s intent and knowledge of the consequences (9 DePaulo & Rosenthal, 1979). For example, a person who knowingly deceives others to invest their life savings in a fraudulent company is judged more harshly than someone who ignorantly advises someone to invest. Such distinctions about level of social undesirability are reflected in the law and are used to determine fraud. 10 Bansal (2005) suggests that the international consensus in preserving the soundness of the banking system has highlighted a number of necessities including careful attention to the audit report prepared by the internal and external auditors. 11 Sathye (2007) suggests that to prevent scams of chit funds Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU) should be formed.
  • 3. The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is certain Profit is Not www.ijbmi.org 73 | Page 12 Hudon (2008) finds that under the veil of microfinance, the chit fund companies collect fund from the poor people and the research further shows that even though the chit funds are registered under Companies Act, Societies Act, RBI Act and SEBI Act, these are equally unsafe like their unregistered counterparts. 13 Manniono (2009) concludes that Ponzi schemes‟ arrangement usually falls apart when a large number of investors want to withdraw their investments at the same time, especially during times when there is not enough new money being supplied by new investors. 14 Rhee (2009) suggests that the informal credit market is vulnerable to the credit risk, interest rate risk, inflation risk, re-investment risk, market risk, operation risk etc. Once any of the risk materializes, the entire informal credit market collapses like anything. 15 Eeckhout and Munshi (2010) finds that by bringing both, borrowers and lenders, in close proximity and by stimulating the competition, chit fund effectively created an informal credit market subject to different constraints. 16 Ferri (2010) classified Ponzi agents as those who borrow more and more in order to repay their interest with the simplistic anticipation that profit and capital gain will be available to repay their commitments when they become due. 17 Nielsen (2012) finds that whistle-blowers‟ appeals did not pay attention to the regulators. This can result in exposure of corporate‟s wrong doing, inaction by regulatory institutions and hindrance to institutional reform. 18 Roy (2012) concluded that many chit fund companies are using the media business as a stepping stone by which they will be able to establish contacts with the political establishments, more so with people in power. 19 Kapoor et al. (2013) concluded that the chit fund industry addresses the savings needs of people, is considered very safe and also offers loans at lower interest rates than money lenders. 20 Sen (2013) suggests that all the banks should conduct random check to the accounts of the chit fund companies which collect money through collective investment schemes across the country. IV. RESEARCH HYPOTHESIS In addition to answering the research objectives the study tested the following hypothesis. H0: There is no significant relationship between chit fund investment and demographic characteristics. Ha: There is significant relationship between chit fund investment and demographic characteristics.And H0: There is no relation between chit fund investments with awareness about frauds and scams, financial education, excessive greed to expect windfall gains aftermath of these scams. Ha: There is relation between chit fund investments with awareness about frauds and scams, financial education aftermath of these scams V. DATA AND RESEARCH METHODOLOGY A. Data collection The primary data to analyze the determinants and rationale of chit funds in Odisha was gathered from the investors through a questionnaire which signify the motivating factors and causes of frauds as well as their opinion regarding managing chit. The data comprised a sample survey of 112 investors covering observation for last 03 months. The primary data was collected through a well designed questionnaire. The main variables of interest related to individuals includes Gender, Age, Age group, Occupation, Education level, Religion, Caste, Tenure of investment in chit funds, Amount of investment in chit funds. The survey was entirely based on the information provided by the investors. B. Research Methodology and Data analysis The analysis of the determinants and rationale of chit funds in Odisha has been carried out in two steps. During the first stage of analysis, the data gathered was analyzed using descriptive statistics. Descriptive statistics explains the mean, median, minimum, maximum and standard deviation of the data. Examination of the characteristics of the sample was carried out which showed the level of investors all distinguished by Age group, Occupation, Education level, Religion, Caste, Tenure of investment in chit funds and Amount of investment in chit funds. The data collected through questionnaire has been further processed through SPSS (Statistical Package for Social Sciences). Non-parametric tests mainly the chi-square test has been used to test the hypotheses. A Chi- square test for independence is applied when two categorical variables are generated from a single population. It is used to determine whether or not there is a significant association between the two variables. The questionnaire with a 5 point Likert scale has been used for analyzing the behavioural attributes of the respondents. The 5 point scale in the questionnaire bears the corresponding prefix, e. g. 1 as agree, 2 as strongly agree, 3 as disagree, 4 as strongly disagree and 5 as do not know. To test the reliability using Cronbach‟s Alpha score comes out as 0.958 hence it was accepted. To consolidate the data, factor analysis was carried out. Statistical tools like Descriptive Statistics, Chi-square (x2 ) test, linear
  • 4. The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is certain Profit is Not www.ijbmi.org 74 | Page regression and Principal Component Analysis (PCA) is used to test the hypotheses. The hypotheses for the aftermath effect and managing chit funds regulation which has been tested using Chi-square test. Finally, the data were processed through the use of SPSS. Table 1: Reliability Statistics Cronbach‟s alpha Cronbach‟s alpha based on standardized items No. of items 0.958 0.958 39 Source: SPSS Analysis Result C. Demographics of the respondents The descriptive analyses for demographics profile of respondents which indicated below- Table 2: Demographics profile of respondents. Demographic Frequency Percent Cumulative Percent Occupation housewife 16 14.29 14.29 business 16 14.29 28.57 service 48 42.86 71.43 Agriculture 32 28.57 100.00 Total 112 100 Type of Job Govt. 22 19.64 19.64 Private 23 20.54 40.18 Self Employed 11 9.82 50.00 Others 56 50.00 100.00 Total 112 100.00 Gender Female 33 29.46 29.46 Male 79 70.54 100.00 Total 112 100 Age group: 18-25 years 16 14.29 14.29 26-40 years 54 48.21 62.50 41-60 years 34 30.36 92.86 61 and above 8 7.14 100.00 Total 112 100 Educational Qualification: Under Matriculation 45 40.18 40.18 Higher Secondary 23 20.54 60.71 Graduate 22 19.64 80.36 Post graduate 11 9.82 90.18 Any other 11 9.82 100.00 Total 112 100 Religion: Hinduism 79 70.54 70.54 Muslim 22 19.64 90.18 Christian 11 9.82 100.00 Buddhism 0 0.00 Jainism 0 0.00 Any other 0 0.00 Total 112 100.00 Caste: General 45 40.18 40.18 Scheduled Caste 25 22.32 62.50 Scheduled Tribe 8 7.14 69.64 Other Backward Caste 34 30.36 100.00 Total 112 100.00 Tenure of investment in chit funds 0-2 years 42 37.50 37.50 2- 5 years 50 44.64 82.14 5 years and above 20 17.86 100.00 Total 112 100.00 Amount of investment in chit funds: <= Rs. 10000 12 10.71 10.71 Rs.10001- 54 48.21 58.93
  • 5. The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is certain Profit is Not www.ijbmi.org 75 | Page Rs.50000 Rs.50001- Rs.100000 13 11.61 70.54 Rs.100001- Rs.500000 33 29.46 100.00 >Rs.500000 0 0.00 Total 112 100.00 Source: Compiled from questionnaires Table 3: Descriptive Statistics Particulars N Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation Type of Job 112 1 4 2.9018 1.22261 Gender 112 1 2 1.7054 0.45793 Age group 112 1 4 2.3036 0.80359 Educational Qualification 112 1 5 2.2857 1.34519 Religion 112 1 3 1.3929 0.66247 Caste 112 1 4 1.7321 1.01326 Tenure of investment in chit funds 112 1 3 1.8036 0.72085 Amount of investment in chit funds 112 1 4 2.3839 0.80813 Valid N (listwise) 112 Hypothesis testing: Here the researcher tests whether there is any relationship between chit fund investment and demographic characteristics. Ho: There is no significant relationship between chit fund investment and demographic characteristics. Ha: There is significant relationship between chit fund investment and demographic characteristics Table 4:Chi-square test for independence result. Demographic character Value df Asymp. sig.(2 sided) Job Type 86.576a 9 0 Gender 1.019a 3 0.397 Age 1.677a 9 0 Qualification 188.290a 12 0 Religion 176.270a 6 0 Caste 29.682a 9 0 Source: SPSS analysis result Since the P-value is <0.05 the null hypothesis is rejected that is there is significant relationship between chit fund investment and demographic characteristics. The result of the chi square independence result shows that there is relationship between chit fund investment and demographic characteristics, therefore the research hypothesis accepted. D. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) Principal Component Analysis (PCA) has been conducted to find and club the component under the suitable head. The result of the PCA is as follows: Table 5: Component Transformation Matrix Component 1 2 3 4 1 .156 .733 .599 -.182 2 .950 .225 -.096 -.041 3 -.168 -.367 .631 .633 4 .134 .494 .412 .745 Extraction Method: Principal Component Analysis. Rotation Method: Varimax with Kaiser Normalization On the basis of Rotated Component Matrix, the 19 parameters in the questionnaire are segregated into four components. For each parameter, the highest factor loading has been taken for consideration for the under different components. Hence, the four components derived from PCA are as under:
  • 6. The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is certain Profit is Not www.ijbmi.org 76 | Page Table 7: Components Derived from PCA Component 1 Component 2 Component 3 Component 4 Laxity in regulatory system Rigid banking formalities High rate of return and high Commission High rate of return and high Commission Proper coordination among regulators Stringent license norms and close monitoring Stronger regulations Present Chit Funds Act, 1982 is weak in its operation Stringent license norms and close monitoring Rationalized Banking norms lack of Govt. sponsored small investment schemes friends, family and relatives pressurize Lack of financial literacy Someone known and/or one of your family member or relative persuaded to join in chit funds Financial iliteracy Requirement of stringent Act Encouragement of Investors education nexus between some politicians and chit fund companies A Bank in the locality Scope of operation should be controlled and limited Weak Chit Funds Act, 1982 Lack of financial literacy Investors education provision for caution/security deposit provision for caution/security deposit E. Liner regression analysis The researcher here also tests whether the recent chit fund scams has any impact on investors perception on their investments, where awareness about frauds and scams, financial education, excessive greed to expect windfall gains are considered independent variable and chit fund investments is dependent variables. For testing the hypothesis, a statistical test called liner regression analysis test was employed through the use of SPSS statistical package. a) Statement of hypothesis H0: There is no relation between chit fund investments with awareness about frauds and scams, financial education, excessive greed to expect windfall gains aftermath of these scams. Ha: There is relation between chit fund investments with awareness about frauds and scams, financial education aftermath of these scams. b) Dependent variable (D1): chit fund investments c) Independent variables (I1, I2 and I3): awareness about frauds and scams, financial education, excessive greed to expect windfall gains. Table 8: Model summary Table 9: ANOVA Model 1 Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig. Regression 4.507 3 1.502 2.39 .073b Residual 67.984 108 0.629 Total 72.491 111 a. Dependent Variable: chit fund _investment b. Predictors: (Constant), I1,I2 and I3 Table 10: Coefficients Model 1 Unstandardized Coefficients Standardized Coefficients t Sig. Correlations B Std. Error Beta Zero- order Partial Part (Constant) 2.411 0.174 13.895 0 I1 -0.084 0.054 -0.165 -1.536 0.127 -0.182 -0.146 -0.143 I2 0.13 0.075 0.221 1.717 0.089 0.131 0.163 0.16 I3 -0.056 0.078 -0.102 -0.713 0.477 -0.029 -0.068 -0.066 a. Dependent Variable: D1 R Square Change F Change df1 df2 Sig. F Change 1 .249 a 0.062 0.036 0.7934 0.062 2.386 3 108 0.073 a. Predictors: (Constant), I1,I2 and I3 Model R R Square Adjusted R Square Std. Error of the Estimate Change Statistics
  • 7. The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is certain Profit is Not www.ijbmi.org 77 | Page Table 11: Change in Perception of Investors after math of chit fund scams in Odisha Particulars Agree Strongly agree Disagree Strongly disagree Undecided Total 1 The chit fund agent cheated you 33.92 33.92 16.07 0 16.07 100 2 The chit fund company cheated you 25.89 50.00 8.03 8.03 8.03 100 3 You are now more confident not to invest in chit funds again 25.00 41.96 8.03 0 25.00 100 4 You won't be recommending this option to anyone else? 32.14 43.74 8.03 0 16.07 100 5 You now believe you would never receive the financial returns as promised by chit funds? 50.90 25 16.07 0 8.03 100 6 The Govt . is colluded with Chit funds and cheated you? 33.03 17.85 8.03 8.03 33.03 100 7 You believe you are more aware about frauds and scams now? 42.85 25.00 8.04 0.00 24.11 100 8 You now believe that the business models of chit funds are unsustainable in the long run? 58.03 8.04 8.04 0.00 25.89 100 9 You won't be excessive greed to expect windfall gains? 50.89 16.07 16.96 0.00 16.96 100 10 You should invest more on financial education? 33.93 41.07 8.04 0.00 16.96 100 From the above model summery R = .249a which shows there is a negative relationship between investments with awareness about frauds and scams, financial education, excessive greed to expect windfall, which means investors are more aware about frauds and scams, excessive greed to expect windfall and financial education. VI. FINDINGS As the determinants and rationale of chit funds in Odisha was gathered from the investors through a well developed questionnaire which signify the motivating factors and causes of frauds as well as their opinion regarding managing chits, the following information have been captured and summarized.  Due to lack of financial literacy and sophistication, investors are simply more exposed to idiosyncrasies of the chit fund companies.  Expectations of earning high commission and high rate of return attracted investors to join chit funds.  Someone known to investors and/or some of the family member or relative persuaded investors to join in chit funds.  Majority of the respondents believe that the chit fund agent cheated them.  Majority of the respondents claim that they were unknown about the chit fund companies and they believed the chit fund agent.  86% of the respondents the current interest rate of banks and post office is low; 65% of the respondents believe that a bank in their locality would have avoided them to invest in chit funds; 48.4 % believe that due to lack of Govt. sponsored small investment schemes investors invested in chit funds; 42% believe that the present banking formalities are rigid and somewhat responsible for chit fund scams.  The study shows that laxity in regulatory system and nexus between the political parties and chit fund companies paved way for the perpetrators to commit frauds.  The respondents also believe that the business models of the chit funds are unsustainable in the long run and believe that the rate of interest offered by chit fund companies is unfeasible.  The study further emphasizes the requirement of stringent Act is essential along with proper coordination is needed among the regulators.  The study suggests that banking norms should be rationalized; investors education must be encouraged and stringent action must be taken against the perpetrators.  The study shows that investors are now more aware about these Chit Fund companies because of the relentless media coverage and would be more careful before investing next time. VII. CONCLUSION The study empirically analyzes the determinants and rationale of chit funds in Odisha by constructing an econometric model to study the various factors of chit funds investments. The business of chit funds is running in India in various names and forms since many years. Recent Frauds have exposed these businesses of thousands of crores rupees because of laxity
  • 8. The Behavioural Finance Aspects of Chit-Fund Scams of Odisha: Loss is certain Profit is Not www.ijbmi.org 78 | Page in regulation and financial illiteracy. Weak provisions of the Chit Fund Act, 1982 along with laxity in regulatory system and nexus between the politicians trembled the bottom-of-the- pyramid. Many small investors lost their life savings in chit fund scams. Rationalizing banking norms along with financial literacy and investors education must be encouraged to safeguard the interest of the investors .The regulators must tighten their Act with proper coordination among the various agencies so as to build investors confidence and to retain their faith. REFERENCES [1] Besley, Timothy, Stephen Coate and Glenn Loury. 1993. "The Economics of Rotating Savings and Credit Associations", The American Economic Review, Vol. 83, No.4. [2] Blaylock, B. T. (1998). Pyramid Schemes, Ponzi Schemes, and Related Frauds. Retrieved from World Wide Web on 16/04/99.http://www.impulse.net/~thebob/pyramid.html. [3] Entombed Albania's Pyramids. (1997). Entombed in Albania's Pyramids. The Economist, 42(8001), 49. [4] Caroll, R. T. (1998). Becoming a Critical hinker. Retrieved from the World Wide Web on 21/04/99. http:// dcn.davis. ca.us/~ btcarrol/skeptic/pyramid.html. [5] Hyman, R. (1989). The psychology of deception. Annual Review of Psychology. Vol 40. [6] Sigmund, K. (1993). Games of life: explorations in ecology, evolution, and behaviour. Oxford [England]; New York: Oxford University Press. [7] Wokutch, R. E., & Carson, T. L. (1999). The ethics and profitability of bluffing in business. In R. J. Lewicki (Ed.), Lewicki, Roy; Saunders, David; Minton, John. (1999). Negotiation: Readings, exercises, and cases (3rd ed.) (2nd . ed., pp. 228-233). Boston, MA, US: Irwin/The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. [8] Ridley, M. (1997). The origins of virtue: human instincts and the evolution of cooperation (1st American ed.). New York: Viking. [9] DePaulo, B. M., & Rosenthal, R. (1979). Telling lies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 37(10), 1713-1722. [10] Bansal, C. (2005). Corporate Governance in the Financial Organization. In C. Bansal, Corporate governance: Law practice and procedures with Case Studies (pp. 512-543).New Delhi: Taxmann Allied Services (P) Limited. [11] Sathye, M. A. (2007). Developing financial intelligence: an assessment of the FIUs in Australia and India. Journal of Money Laundering Control, 10(4), 391-405. [12] Hudson, M. (2008). Norms and values of the various microfinance institutions. International Journal of Social Economics, 35(1/2), 35-48. [13] Mannino, L. L. (2009). 1RS Offers Reef for Investors of Fraudulent Investment Schemes. Revenue procedure, 84-90. [14] Rhee, R. J. (2009). The mad off scandal, market regulatory failure and the business education of lawyers. The Journal of Corporation Law. [15] Eeckhout, J. A. (2010). Matching in informal financial institution. Journal of the European Economic Association, 8 (5), 947-988. [16] Nielsen, R. P. (2012). Whistle-Blowing Methods for Navigating Within and Helping Reform Regulatory Institutions. Springer, 385- 395. [17] Roy, R. (2012). Media and Bad Money. Changing world of finance (pp. 9 -15). Kolkata: Department of Commerce, Serampore College in collaboration with ICAI [18] Ferri, P. A. (2010). „Financial fragility, the minskian triadand economic dynamics‟. International Journal of Political Economy, 39(9), 70-82. [19] Kapoor, M. A. (2013). Chit Funds as an Innovative Access to Finance for Low-income Households. Massachusetts: Institute for financial management and research. [20] Sen, S. (2013, May 7). Banks under Scanner for Saradha Transactions. The Times of India, Kolkata Ed., p. 4. [21] Chit Funds, the evolution, operational scenario, Role and Regulatory Framework [22] The co-operative movement in Odisha [23] The Orissa Self Help Act 2001