INTRODUCTION
StartNowHow
• Open seminar series for active and prospective entrepreneurs
• 10 sessions on monthly basis until summer 2017
• Covers relevant theoretical and practical aspects of entrepreneurship
• Based on lecture „entrepreneurship“ @Bogazici University
• Based on experiences of entrepreneurs, investors, mentors and consultants
• Each session with guest speaker (entrepreneurs, investors, mentors, etc.)
• Certificate provided for participants (from BIC Angels / Bogazici University
Entrepreneurship Center) joining at least 70% of the sessions
• Language: English / Turkish
• Thursdays 17.15h – 19.30h
• Next session: Thu 9. February 2017
• Topic: Market and Competitor Research
• Early registration for each session required (eventbrite), limited capacity!
• Priority for regular participants
Startnowhow – Seminar 212.01.2017 2
INTRODUCTION
StartNowHow - Seminar Topics (preliminary)
1. Thu 22.09.16: The entrepreneurial ecosystem in Turkey
2. Thu 20.10.16: Entrepreneurship as a profession
3. Thu 17.11.16: Financial planning for startups
4. Thu 15.12.16: Planning, developing and testing a business model
5. Thu 12.01.17: Opportunity recognition and evaluation
6. Thu 09.02.17: Market and competitor research
7. Thu 09.03.17: Funding the startup – stage financing for ventures
8. Thu 06.04.17: Startup valuation
9. Thu 04.05.17: The investment process – pitching, negotiations and termsheet
10. Thu 01.06.17: Success and failure as an entrepreneur
Startnowhow – Seminar 112.01.2017 3
INTRODUCTION
StartNowHow - Literature
• Bowers, Brent, 8 Patterns of Highly Effective Entrepreneurs, Doubleday, New York, NY 2008
• Bygrave, William D. / Zacharaiks, Andrew, The Portable MBA in Entrepreneurship, 4th ed., Wiley,
Hoboken, NJ 2010
• Drucker, Peter F., Innovation and Entrepreneurship, 1st ed. 1985, reprinted 2010, Elsevier, Kiddlington,
2010
• Harper, Stephen C., Extraordinary Entrepreneurship: The Professional’s Guide to Starting an Exceptional
Enterprise, Wiley, Hoboken, NJ 2005
• Hirshberg, Meg Cadoux, For Better or for Work, All Inc., New York, NY 2012
• Hisrich, Robert D. / Peters, Michael P. / Shepherd, Dean A., Entrepreneurship, 9th ed., McGraw-Hill, New
York, NY 2012
• Kuratko, Donald F., Entrepreneurship: Theory, Process, Practice, 8th ed., South-Western, Mason, OH 2009
• Leach, J. Chris / Melicher, Ronald W., Entrepreneurial Finance, International Edition, 4th ed., South-
Western, Hampshire 2012
• Osterwalder, Alexander / Pigneur, Yves, Business Model Generation, Wiley, Hoboken, NJ 2010
• Ries, Eric, The Lean Startup, Crown Business, New York, NY 2011
• Smith, Janet Kiholm / Smith, Richard L. / Bliss, Richard T.,Entrepreneurial Finance – Strategy, Valuation,
and Deal Structure, Standford University Press, Stanford, CA 2011
• Stokes, David / Wilson, Nick, Small Business Management and Entrepreneurship, 6th ed., South-Western,
Hampshire 2010
• Taleb, Nassim Nicholas, The Black Swan – The Impact of the Highly Improbable, revised ed., Penguin,
London 2010
• Timmons, Jeffry A. / Spinelli, Stephen, New Venture Creation – Entrepreneurship for the 21st Century, 9th
ed., McGraw-Hill, New York, NY 2011
Startnowhow – Seminar 112.01.2017 4
OPPORTUNITYRECOGNITION
Entrepreneur Profiles – Motivations
• Pull influences („opportunity-based entrepreneurship“)
• Desire for independence
• Desire to exploit an opportunity
• Turning a hobby / previous work experience into a business
• Financial incentive
• Push influences („necessity-based entrepreneurship“)
• Redundancy
• (Threat of) unemployment
• Disagreement with previous employer
• Desire for independence
• (Source: Stokes / Wilson, Small Business Management, pp.37-38)
• .... But: „Who is the Entrepreneur“?
12.01.2017 5Entrepreneurship
Source: Timmons / Spinelli, New Venture Creation, p. 55
OPPORTUNITYRECOGNITION
Entrepreneurship and Innovation
Startnowhow – Seminar 1
Source: Bygrave / Zacharakis, The Portable MBA in Entrepreneurship,, p.32
12.01.2017 6
OPPORTUNITYRECOGNITION
Paths of Idea Generation
• The Alertness Path:
• Discovery by constant alertness, constant scanning of environment for opportunities
• Source of ideas: Environment
• Source of differentiation: Learning
• Process: Spontaneous
• Basis of discovery: Subconscious
• Fit with entrepreneur: Typically poor
• The Search Path:
• Discovery by systematic search for a problem solution
• Source of ideas: Information channel
• Source of differentiation: Knowledge
• Process: Deliberate
• Basis of discovery: Conscious
• Fit with entrepreneur: Typically strong
• Often, idea generation is a mix of both paths
• Ideas are often generated by a combination of play, improvisation, and observation
• (from: Bygrave / Zacharias, The Portable MBA in Entrepreneurship, pp.30-31)
12.01.2017 7Startnowhow – Seminar 3
OPPORTUNITYRECOGNITION
The Seven Sources for Innovative Opportunities
• The Unexpected
• Example: Unexpected success of IBM PC
• The Incongruous
• Examples: Invention of container ships / roll-on-roll-off ships, overnight package delivery
• Process Needs
• Examples: McDonalds, microwave ovens
• Industry and Market Structures
• Examples: Printing industry, ERP software, media industry
• Demographics
• Examples: Health care industry, universities in Turkey
• Changes in Perception
• Examples: Fashion industry, organic food
• New Knowledge
• Examples: Electricity, light bulb, internet, mobile phone, robotics, ...
• Source: Drucker, Innovation and Entrepreneurship, pp.27-117
12.01.2017 8Startnowhow – Seminar 3
OPPORTUNITYRECOGNITION
Creativity – The Fear Factor
12.01.2017 9Startnowhow – Seminar 3
Source: Bygrave / Zacharakis, The Portable MBA in Entrepreneurship, p. 37
OPPORTUNITYEVALUATION
Characteristics of Superior Business Opportunities
• Added value
• Venture creates or adds significant value to a customer or end user
• Venture solves a significant problem
• Venture adds value by solving a significant problem, removing a serious pain, or meeting
a significant want or need
• Someone is willing to pay a premium for solving this problem
• Venture has robust market, margin, and money-making characteristics
• Large enough market (min. 50 Mio $)
• High growth expectation (min. 20% p.a.)
• High gross margins (min. 40%)
• Strong and early cash flow (recurring revenue, low assets, low working capital)
• High profit potential (min. 10% - 15% after tax income)
• Attractive, realizable return for investors (Internal Rate of Return IRR min. 25%- 30%)
• Venture fits to skillset
• Good fit with founder(s) and managment team skills for that time and marketplace
• Attractive risk-reward balance
• Source: Timmons / Spinelli, New Venture Creation, p.150
12.01.2017 10Startnowhow – Seminar 3
OPPORTUNITYEVALUATION
Sustainable Competitive Advantage
• Necessary: Resource bundle that is valuable, rare and inimitable
• Resources are all inputs to production process – land, raw materials, machinery, other
fixed assets, patents, licenses, employee skills, management skills, knowledge, ...
• Resource bundle is valuable when it enables the firm to pursue opportunities, neutralize
threats, and offer products and services that are valued by customer
• Resource bundle is rare when it is possessed by few, if any, (potential) competitors
• Resource bundle is inimitable when replication of this combination of resources would
be difficult and / or costly for (potential) competitors.
• Core resource: Entrepreneurial knowledge
• In mind of entrepreneur, or in collective mind of employees / management team
• Source: Market knowledge
• Source: Technology knowledge
• Source: Hisrich / Peters / Shepherd, Entrepreneurship, pp.67-70
12.01.2017 11Startnowhow – Seminar 3
OPPORTUNITYEVALUATION
Opportunity Screening Process Funnel
12.01.2017 12Startnowhow – Seminar 3
Source: Harper, Extraordinary Entrepreneurship,, p.127
OPPORTUNITYEVALUATION
Classification Guidelines for the VOS Indicator
12.01.2017 13Startnowhow – Seminar 3
Source: Leach / Melicher, Entrepreneurial Finance, p.55
BIC ANGEL INVESTMENTS
Dr. Joachim Behrendt
Phone: +90 212 328 1939
Fax: +90 212 328 1933
www.bicangels.com
http:/twitter.com/joachimbehrendt
http://tr.linkedin.com/pub/joachim-behrendt/18/706/a7a
Email: j.behrendt@bicangels.com

Startnowhow - Opportunity Recognition and Evaluation

  • 2.
    INTRODUCTION StartNowHow • Open seminarseries for active and prospective entrepreneurs • 10 sessions on monthly basis until summer 2017 • Covers relevant theoretical and practical aspects of entrepreneurship • Based on lecture „entrepreneurship“ @Bogazici University • Based on experiences of entrepreneurs, investors, mentors and consultants • Each session with guest speaker (entrepreneurs, investors, mentors, etc.) • Certificate provided for participants (from BIC Angels / Bogazici University Entrepreneurship Center) joining at least 70% of the sessions • Language: English / Turkish • Thursdays 17.15h – 19.30h • Next session: Thu 9. February 2017 • Topic: Market and Competitor Research • Early registration for each session required (eventbrite), limited capacity! • Priority for regular participants Startnowhow – Seminar 212.01.2017 2
  • 3.
    INTRODUCTION StartNowHow - SeminarTopics (preliminary) 1. Thu 22.09.16: The entrepreneurial ecosystem in Turkey 2. Thu 20.10.16: Entrepreneurship as a profession 3. Thu 17.11.16: Financial planning for startups 4. Thu 15.12.16: Planning, developing and testing a business model 5. Thu 12.01.17: Opportunity recognition and evaluation 6. Thu 09.02.17: Market and competitor research 7. Thu 09.03.17: Funding the startup – stage financing for ventures 8. Thu 06.04.17: Startup valuation 9. Thu 04.05.17: The investment process – pitching, negotiations and termsheet 10. Thu 01.06.17: Success and failure as an entrepreneur Startnowhow – Seminar 112.01.2017 3
  • 4.
    INTRODUCTION StartNowHow - Literature •Bowers, Brent, 8 Patterns of Highly Effective Entrepreneurs, Doubleday, New York, NY 2008 • Bygrave, William D. / Zacharaiks, Andrew, The Portable MBA in Entrepreneurship, 4th ed., Wiley, Hoboken, NJ 2010 • Drucker, Peter F., Innovation and Entrepreneurship, 1st ed. 1985, reprinted 2010, Elsevier, Kiddlington, 2010 • Harper, Stephen C., Extraordinary Entrepreneurship: The Professional’s Guide to Starting an Exceptional Enterprise, Wiley, Hoboken, NJ 2005 • Hirshberg, Meg Cadoux, For Better or for Work, All Inc., New York, NY 2012 • Hisrich, Robert D. / Peters, Michael P. / Shepherd, Dean A., Entrepreneurship, 9th ed., McGraw-Hill, New York, NY 2012 • Kuratko, Donald F., Entrepreneurship: Theory, Process, Practice, 8th ed., South-Western, Mason, OH 2009 • Leach, J. Chris / Melicher, Ronald W., Entrepreneurial Finance, International Edition, 4th ed., South- Western, Hampshire 2012 • Osterwalder, Alexander / Pigneur, Yves, Business Model Generation, Wiley, Hoboken, NJ 2010 • Ries, Eric, The Lean Startup, Crown Business, New York, NY 2011 • Smith, Janet Kiholm / Smith, Richard L. / Bliss, Richard T.,Entrepreneurial Finance – Strategy, Valuation, and Deal Structure, Standford University Press, Stanford, CA 2011 • Stokes, David / Wilson, Nick, Small Business Management and Entrepreneurship, 6th ed., South-Western, Hampshire 2010 • Taleb, Nassim Nicholas, The Black Swan – The Impact of the Highly Improbable, revised ed., Penguin, London 2010 • Timmons, Jeffry A. / Spinelli, Stephen, New Venture Creation – Entrepreneurship for the 21st Century, 9th ed., McGraw-Hill, New York, NY 2011 Startnowhow – Seminar 112.01.2017 4
  • 5.
    OPPORTUNITYRECOGNITION Entrepreneur Profiles –Motivations • Pull influences („opportunity-based entrepreneurship“) • Desire for independence • Desire to exploit an opportunity • Turning a hobby / previous work experience into a business • Financial incentive • Push influences („necessity-based entrepreneurship“) • Redundancy • (Threat of) unemployment • Disagreement with previous employer • Desire for independence • (Source: Stokes / Wilson, Small Business Management, pp.37-38) • .... But: „Who is the Entrepreneur“? 12.01.2017 5Entrepreneurship Source: Timmons / Spinelli, New Venture Creation, p. 55
  • 6.
    OPPORTUNITYRECOGNITION Entrepreneurship and Innovation Startnowhow– Seminar 1 Source: Bygrave / Zacharakis, The Portable MBA in Entrepreneurship,, p.32 12.01.2017 6
  • 7.
    OPPORTUNITYRECOGNITION Paths of IdeaGeneration • The Alertness Path: • Discovery by constant alertness, constant scanning of environment for opportunities • Source of ideas: Environment • Source of differentiation: Learning • Process: Spontaneous • Basis of discovery: Subconscious • Fit with entrepreneur: Typically poor • The Search Path: • Discovery by systematic search for a problem solution • Source of ideas: Information channel • Source of differentiation: Knowledge • Process: Deliberate • Basis of discovery: Conscious • Fit with entrepreneur: Typically strong • Often, idea generation is a mix of both paths • Ideas are often generated by a combination of play, improvisation, and observation • (from: Bygrave / Zacharias, The Portable MBA in Entrepreneurship, pp.30-31) 12.01.2017 7Startnowhow – Seminar 3
  • 8.
    OPPORTUNITYRECOGNITION The Seven Sourcesfor Innovative Opportunities • The Unexpected • Example: Unexpected success of IBM PC • The Incongruous • Examples: Invention of container ships / roll-on-roll-off ships, overnight package delivery • Process Needs • Examples: McDonalds, microwave ovens • Industry and Market Structures • Examples: Printing industry, ERP software, media industry • Demographics • Examples: Health care industry, universities in Turkey • Changes in Perception • Examples: Fashion industry, organic food • New Knowledge • Examples: Electricity, light bulb, internet, mobile phone, robotics, ... • Source: Drucker, Innovation and Entrepreneurship, pp.27-117 12.01.2017 8Startnowhow – Seminar 3
  • 9.
    OPPORTUNITYRECOGNITION Creativity – TheFear Factor 12.01.2017 9Startnowhow – Seminar 3 Source: Bygrave / Zacharakis, The Portable MBA in Entrepreneurship, p. 37
  • 10.
    OPPORTUNITYEVALUATION Characteristics of SuperiorBusiness Opportunities • Added value • Venture creates or adds significant value to a customer or end user • Venture solves a significant problem • Venture adds value by solving a significant problem, removing a serious pain, or meeting a significant want or need • Someone is willing to pay a premium for solving this problem • Venture has robust market, margin, and money-making characteristics • Large enough market (min. 50 Mio $) • High growth expectation (min. 20% p.a.) • High gross margins (min. 40%) • Strong and early cash flow (recurring revenue, low assets, low working capital) • High profit potential (min. 10% - 15% after tax income) • Attractive, realizable return for investors (Internal Rate of Return IRR min. 25%- 30%) • Venture fits to skillset • Good fit with founder(s) and managment team skills for that time and marketplace • Attractive risk-reward balance • Source: Timmons / Spinelli, New Venture Creation, p.150 12.01.2017 10Startnowhow – Seminar 3
  • 11.
    OPPORTUNITYEVALUATION Sustainable Competitive Advantage •Necessary: Resource bundle that is valuable, rare and inimitable • Resources are all inputs to production process – land, raw materials, machinery, other fixed assets, patents, licenses, employee skills, management skills, knowledge, ... • Resource bundle is valuable when it enables the firm to pursue opportunities, neutralize threats, and offer products and services that are valued by customer • Resource bundle is rare when it is possessed by few, if any, (potential) competitors • Resource bundle is inimitable when replication of this combination of resources would be difficult and / or costly for (potential) competitors. • Core resource: Entrepreneurial knowledge • In mind of entrepreneur, or in collective mind of employees / management team • Source: Market knowledge • Source: Technology knowledge • Source: Hisrich / Peters / Shepherd, Entrepreneurship, pp.67-70 12.01.2017 11Startnowhow – Seminar 3
  • 12.
    OPPORTUNITYEVALUATION Opportunity Screening ProcessFunnel 12.01.2017 12Startnowhow – Seminar 3 Source: Harper, Extraordinary Entrepreneurship,, p.127
  • 13.
    OPPORTUNITYEVALUATION Classification Guidelines forthe VOS Indicator 12.01.2017 13Startnowhow – Seminar 3 Source: Leach / Melicher, Entrepreneurial Finance, p.55
  • 14.
    BIC ANGEL INVESTMENTS Dr.Joachim Behrendt Phone: +90 212 328 1939 Fax: +90 212 328 1933 www.bicangels.com http:/twitter.com/joachimbehrendt http://tr.linkedin.com/pub/joachim-behrendt/18/706/a7a Email: j.behrendt@bicangels.com