SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Solar Energy Innovation Symposium
June 6, 2019
Advanced Rate Design Project
NREL Solar Energy Innovation Network
Project Team
• Center for Climate Protection Lead
• TerraVerde Energy LLC Technical Development
• Lancaster Choice Energy Consultation, Virtual Pilot
• Peninsula Clean Energy Consultation, Virtual Pilot
• Grid Policy LLC Policy/Technical Advisor
• California Solar & Storage Association Policy Advisor
Project Goal
• Create a software tool for helping Load Serving Entities design
tariffs that incentivize the deployment of Distributed Energy
Resources.
What’s a DER?
Distributed Energy Resource:
Any customer-side resource for improving the quality and availability of
electric power, system-wide.
• Solar Panels
• Battery Storage
• Smart Electric Vehicle Chargers
• Smart Thermostats
• Smart Water Heaters
• Demand Response Programs
Strategy:
Consider the net effect of a deployment program:
1. Assess net economic impact of DER program.
2. Assess net GHG impact of DER program.
3. Assess value available to share with customers to incentivize DER
deployment.
Scope, as Ambitiously Envisioned
• Software tool works for any Load Serving Entity.
• Software tool sets rates for any DER type.
Actual Scope
Any Load Serving Entity >> California CCAs
• The value of a DER program depends on regulatory environment.
• California CCAs are empowered to set rates without regulatory oversight.
What’s a CCA?
Community Choice Aggregation agency:
A public agency empowered to buy electricity in wholesale markets to sell in
competition with Investor-Owned Utilities.
• Historically aligned with GHG reduction and other community goals.
• Empowered to set rates without regulatory oversight.
• Own very few energy system assets.
• Exploding reach within California.
• Young, small, & relatively nimble.
Actual Scope
Any DER type >> Solar + Dispatchable Storage
Between DER types, very significant variation in:
• Required customer investment.
• Impact on LSE revenues.
• Ability to impact wholesale procurement costs.
CCA Engagement
Through engagement with the CCA Community we narrowed our focus to
analyzing solar + dispatchable storage:
• Focus group calls
• DER values matrix
• 1:1 meetings with Virtual Pilot partners
What’s a VPP?
Virtual Power Plant:
A network of customer sited batteries that can be centrally controlled to
provide grid benefits.
• Dispatch VPP power as an alternative to buying in wholesale power markets.
• Dispatch clean energy as alternative to buying dirty energy in power markets.
• Sell power into wholesale markets when prices are high.
• Store excess generation when prices are low.
• Reduce resource adequacy and other demand-related wholesale costs.
• Participate in utility demand reduction programs.
• Sell into ancillary service markets.
VPP Suppliers
Market Access Operation Strategy DER Aggregation
Olivine x x x
Leap x
AMS x
Stem x
Engie x x
Sunrun x
Tool Creation Roadmap
1. Identify CCA goals for deploying solar + storage systems.
2. Research capabilities and limitations of VPP technology.
3. Analyze average economic benefit per kW of VPP storage.
4. Analyze GHG benefit per kW of VPP storage.
5. Research costs of installing customer-sited storage with solar.
6. Research best practices for incentivizing program participation.
7. Propose tariff structure and terms.
8. Run virtual pilot projects to demonstrate feasibility.
Analyzing Economic Benefit
1. Ingest CCA’s procurement history data.
2. Model CCA’s historic procurement costs.
3. Model the change in load from operating a VPP.
4. Analyze values streams achieved by VPP operating strategy.
Procurement History Data
8760 hours of hour-by-hour procurement cost data (24 x 365 = 8760)
• Bilateral agreements: hourly volume and price
• Scheduled Load: hourly volume
• Day-head market: hourly price
• Actual Load: hourly volume
• Imbalance market: hourly price
• Resource adequacy: hourly cost
• Other fees and credits: hourly cost/credit
Procurement Cost Model
1. Scheduled Load
a. 24 hours of anticipated load, reported one day ahead.
b. Includes bilateral hedges.
c. Scheduled Load – Hedged Load = day-ahead market purchase.
2. Imbalance
a. Imbalance = Actual Load – Scheduled Load.
b. ISO procures power to meet system demand in real time.
c. Imbalance load is deduced retrospectively from meter data.
VPP Strategy: Load Flattening
Flatten your load at: www.FlattenMyLoad.com
VPP Strategy: Load Flattening
Flatten your load at: www.FlattenMyLoad.com
Value Stream: Day-Ahead Peak Avoidance
Value Stream: Sell into Real-Time Market
Value Stream: Resource Adequacy
Stacked Value Streams
Additional Value Streams
• Offsets to customer utility distribution demand charges.
• Improved GHG profile.
• Battery resiliency benefits.
Next Steps: Propose Rate Terms
• Analyze as a program.
• Tri-lateral Agreements (LSE + Customer + Operator)
• Operate to maximize system benefit.
• Align compensation with system benefit.
Next Steps: Virtual Pilot Projects
Analyze customer’s annual retail cost and LSE’s annual wholesale
cost to supply customer under three scenarios:
1. With no Solar + Storage.
2. With Solar + Storage under existing tariff.
3. With Solar + Storage under proposed tariff.
Tool Creation Technical Support/Guidance
‣ NREL and RMI Advisors:
‣ Helped us determine the need to narrow the scope of our design model to a single type of
DER deployment
‣ Helped us determine the need to reduce the target audience from all LSEs to CCA agencies
in California.
‣ Shared procurement expertise which supported us in the process of identifying the VPP
operating strategies that are most likely to yield economic and GHG benefits.
‣ Technical Consultants
‣ Chris Sentieri, Blue Strike Environmental
‣ Jon Wellinghoff, former Chairman of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
QUESTIONS?
THANK YOU
Storn White
Director of Software Development
TerraVerde Energy, LLC
storn@TerraVerde.energy
and don’t forget to flatten your load at: www.FlattenMyLoad.com

More Related Content

What's hot

6.1_Adapting the Integrated Grid Economic Framework to Microgrids_Roark_EPRI/...
6.1_Adapting the Integrated Grid Economic Framework to Microgrids_Roark_EPRI/...6.1_Adapting the Integrated Grid Economic Framework to Microgrids_Roark_EPRI/...
6.1_Adapting the Integrated Grid Economic Framework to Microgrids_Roark_EPRI/...
Sandia National Laboratories: Energy & Climate: Renewables
 
Power to the people: shifting control over electricity to citizens and consumers
Power to the people: shifting control over electricity to citizens and consumersPower to the people: shifting control over electricity to citizens and consumers
Power to the people: shifting control over electricity to citizens and consumers
Leonardo ENERGY
 
Energy Economics Christian Feisst
Energy Economics Christian FeisstEnergy Economics Christian Feisst
Energy Economics Christian Feisst
karlsruheserviceresearchinstitute
 
ACEEE EE as a Grid Resource
ACEEE EE as a Grid ResourceACEEE EE as a Grid Resource
ACEEE EE as a Grid Resource
Patty Cook
 
Peer-to-Peer energy trading and community self-consumption
Peer-to-Peer energy trading and community self-consumptionPeer-to-Peer energy trading and community self-consumption
Peer-to-Peer energy trading and community self-consumption
Leonardo ENERGY
 
6.2_Integrated Design and Financial Model_Knapp_EPRI/SNL Microgrid
6.2_Integrated Design and Financial Model_Knapp_EPRI/SNL Microgrid6.2_Integrated Design and Financial Model_Knapp_EPRI/SNL Microgrid
6.2_Integrated Design and Financial Model_Knapp_EPRI/SNL Microgrid
Sandia National Laboratories: Energy & Climate: Renewables
 
Power System Flexibility - Strategic Roadmap
Power System Flexibility - Strategic RoadmapPower System Flexibility - Strategic Roadmap
Power System Flexibility - Strategic Roadmap
Leonardo ENERGY
 
Evaluating approaches to ghg offset aggregation c-agg
Evaluating approaches to ghg offset aggregation  c-aggEvaluating approaches to ghg offset aggregation  c-agg
Evaluating approaches to ghg offset aggregation c-aggPeter Weisberg
 
Motivation, benefits, and challenges for new photovoltaic material & module d...
Motivation, benefits, and challenges for new photovoltaic material & module d...Motivation, benefits, and challenges for new photovoltaic material & module d...
Motivation, benefits, and challenges for new photovoltaic material & module d...
Leonardo ENERGY
 
Using human-centred design to improve energy efficiency programs
Using human-centred design to improve energy efficiency programsUsing human-centred design to improve energy efficiency programs
Using human-centred design to improve energy efficiency programs
Leonardo ENERGY
 
The True Costs of Solar PV: IRENA's Cost Analysis
The True Costs of Solar PV: IRENA's Cost AnalysisThe True Costs of Solar PV: IRENA's Cost Analysis
The True Costs of Solar PV: IRENA's Cost Analysis
Michael Taylor
 
Auctioning RE projects: Lessons learned from auction design for renewable ele...
Auctioning RE projects: Lessons learned from auction design for renewable ele...Auctioning RE projects: Lessons learned from auction design for renewable ele...
Auctioning RE projects: Lessons learned from auction design for renewable ele...
Leonardo ENERGY
 
Future Electricity Markets: key pillars with high shares of wind and PV
Future Electricity Markets: key pillars with high shares of wind and PVFuture Electricity Markets: key pillars with high shares of wind and PV
Future Electricity Markets: key pillars with high shares of wind and PV
Leonardo ENERGY
 
Financing Transportation Electrification Programs by Mark Smith
Financing Transportation Electrification Programs by Mark SmithFinancing Transportation Electrification Programs by Mark Smith
Financing Transportation Electrification Programs by Mark Smith
Forth
 
Energy storage Technologies
Energy storage TechnologiesEnergy storage Technologies
Energy storage Technologies
Syed Atif Naseem
 
2.5_Rivermoor Energy_Tourtelotte_EPRI/SNL Microgrid Symposium
2.5_Rivermoor Energy_Tourtelotte_EPRI/SNL Microgrid Symposium 2.5_Rivermoor Energy_Tourtelotte_EPRI/SNL Microgrid Symposium
2.5_Rivermoor Energy_Tourtelotte_EPRI/SNL Microgrid Symposium
Sandia National Laboratories: Energy & Climate: Renewables
 
Improving the value of variable and uncertain Power Generation in Energy Syst...
Improving the value of variable and uncertain Power Generation in Energy Syst...Improving the value of variable and uncertain Power Generation in Energy Syst...
Improving the value of variable and uncertain Power Generation in Energy Syst...
CLIC Innovation Ltd
 
Heating without the hot air: Principles for smart heat electrification
Heating without the hot air: Principles for smart heat electrificationHeating without the hot air: Principles for smart heat electrification
Heating without the hot air: Principles for smart heat electrification
Leonardo ENERGY
 
Smart charging puts the pedal to the metal on e-mobility
Smart charging puts the pedal to the metal on e-mobilitySmart charging puts the pedal to the metal on e-mobility
Smart charging puts the pedal to the metal on e-mobility
Leonardo ENERGY
 

What's hot (20)

6.1_Adapting the Integrated Grid Economic Framework to Microgrids_Roark_EPRI/...
6.1_Adapting the Integrated Grid Economic Framework to Microgrids_Roark_EPRI/...6.1_Adapting the Integrated Grid Economic Framework to Microgrids_Roark_EPRI/...
6.1_Adapting the Integrated Grid Economic Framework to Microgrids_Roark_EPRI/...
 
Power to the people: shifting control over electricity to citizens and consumers
Power to the people: shifting control over electricity to citizens and consumersPower to the people: shifting control over electricity to citizens and consumers
Power to the people: shifting control over electricity to citizens and consumers
 
Energy Economics Christian Feisst
Energy Economics Christian FeisstEnergy Economics Christian Feisst
Energy Economics Christian Feisst
 
ACEEE EE as a Grid Resource
ACEEE EE as a Grid ResourceACEEE EE as a Grid Resource
ACEEE EE as a Grid Resource
 
Peer-to-Peer energy trading and community self-consumption
Peer-to-Peer energy trading and community self-consumptionPeer-to-Peer energy trading and community self-consumption
Peer-to-Peer energy trading and community self-consumption
 
6.2_Integrated Design and Financial Model_Knapp_EPRI/SNL Microgrid
6.2_Integrated Design and Financial Model_Knapp_EPRI/SNL Microgrid6.2_Integrated Design and Financial Model_Knapp_EPRI/SNL Microgrid
6.2_Integrated Design and Financial Model_Knapp_EPRI/SNL Microgrid
 
Power System Flexibility - Strategic Roadmap
Power System Flexibility - Strategic RoadmapPower System Flexibility - Strategic Roadmap
Power System Flexibility - Strategic Roadmap
 
Evaluating approaches to ghg offset aggregation c-agg
Evaluating approaches to ghg offset aggregation  c-aggEvaluating approaches to ghg offset aggregation  c-agg
Evaluating approaches to ghg offset aggregation c-agg
 
Motivation, benefits, and challenges for new photovoltaic material & module d...
Motivation, benefits, and challenges for new photovoltaic material & module d...Motivation, benefits, and challenges for new photovoltaic material & module d...
Motivation, benefits, and challenges for new photovoltaic material & module d...
 
Moma thomas wolski_cigre_13-04-22
Moma thomas wolski_cigre_13-04-22Moma thomas wolski_cigre_13-04-22
Moma thomas wolski_cigre_13-04-22
 
Using human-centred design to improve energy efficiency programs
Using human-centred design to improve energy efficiency programsUsing human-centred design to improve energy efficiency programs
Using human-centred design to improve energy efficiency programs
 
The True Costs of Solar PV: IRENA's Cost Analysis
The True Costs of Solar PV: IRENA's Cost AnalysisThe True Costs of Solar PV: IRENA's Cost Analysis
The True Costs of Solar PV: IRENA's Cost Analysis
 
Auctioning RE projects: Lessons learned from auction design for renewable ele...
Auctioning RE projects: Lessons learned from auction design for renewable ele...Auctioning RE projects: Lessons learned from auction design for renewable ele...
Auctioning RE projects: Lessons learned from auction design for renewable ele...
 
Future Electricity Markets: key pillars with high shares of wind and PV
Future Electricity Markets: key pillars with high shares of wind and PVFuture Electricity Markets: key pillars with high shares of wind and PV
Future Electricity Markets: key pillars with high shares of wind and PV
 
Financing Transportation Electrification Programs by Mark Smith
Financing Transportation Electrification Programs by Mark SmithFinancing Transportation Electrification Programs by Mark Smith
Financing Transportation Electrification Programs by Mark Smith
 
Energy storage Technologies
Energy storage TechnologiesEnergy storage Technologies
Energy storage Technologies
 
2.5_Rivermoor Energy_Tourtelotte_EPRI/SNL Microgrid Symposium
2.5_Rivermoor Energy_Tourtelotte_EPRI/SNL Microgrid Symposium 2.5_Rivermoor Energy_Tourtelotte_EPRI/SNL Microgrid Symposium
2.5_Rivermoor Energy_Tourtelotte_EPRI/SNL Microgrid Symposium
 
Improving the value of variable and uncertain Power Generation in Energy Syst...
Improving the value of variable and uncertain Power Generation in Energy Syst...Improving the value of variable and uncertain Power Generation in Energy Syst...
Improving the value of variable and uncertain Power Generation in Energy Syst...
 
Heating without the hot air: Principles for smart heat electrification
Heating without the hot air: Principles for smart heat electrificationHeating without the hot air: Principles for smart heat electrification
Heating without the hot air: Principles for smart heat electrification
 
Smart charging puts the pedal to the metal on e-mobility
Smart charging puts the pedal to the metal on e-mobilitySmart charging puts the pedal to the metal on e-mobility
Smart charging puts the pedal to the metal on e-mobility
 

Similar to SEIN Advanced Rate Design Project

Brasilia int school_solar_energy_putting_in_place_the_solar_potential_v1
Brasilia int school_solar_energy_putting_in_place_the_solar_potential_v1Brasilia int school_solar_energy_putting_in_place_the_solar_potential_v1
Brasilia int school_solar_energy_putting_in_place_the_solar_potential_v1
Jacinto Estima
 
20161006 Szaro Power Matters Conference all slides
20161006 Szaro Power Matters Conference all slides20161006 Szaro Power Matters Conference all slides
20161006 Szaro Power Matters Conference all slidesJennifer Szaro
 
DSM - a way to improve the performance of energy systems
DSM - a way to improve the performance of energy systems DSM - a way to improve the performance of energy systems
DSM - a way to improve the performance of energy systems
IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)
 
Energy efficient computing & computational services
Energy efficient computing & computational services Energy efficient computing & computational services
Energy efficient computing & computational services
David Wallom
 
April 12, 2016 CEFAC Energy Storage Presentation
April 12, 2016 CEFAC Energy Storage PresentationApril 12, 2016 CEFAC Energy Storage Presentation
April 12, 2016 CEFAC Energy Storage Presentation
Josh Erwin
 
EEI Strategic Issues Forum - Integration of DER: California and New York
EEI Strategic Issues Forum - Integration of DER: California and New YorkEEI Strategic Issues Forum - Integration of DER: California and New York
EEI Strategic Issues Forum - Integration of DER: California and New York
ScottMadden, Inc.
 
A World Full of Possibilities: Integrating DERs into Wholesale Markets – Outl...
A World Full of Possibilities: Integrating DERs into Wholesale Markets – Outl...A World Full of Possibilities: Integrating DERs into Wholesale Markets – Outl...
A World Full of Possibilities: Integrating DERs into Wholesale Markets – Outl...
Jill Kirkpatrick
 
Electricity Distribution Changes by Innovari
Electricity Distribution Changes by InnovariElectricity Distribution Changes by Innovari
Electricity Distribution Changes by Innovari
IPPAI
 
coned-presentation-in-pdf-final.pdf
coned-presentation-in-pdf-final.pdfconed-presentation-in-pdf-final.pdf
coned-presentation-in-pdf-final.pdf
Jose Morales
 
DSM in the 21st Century - Large Scale Deployment of smart applications
DSM in the 21st Century - Large Scale Deployment of smart applications DSM in the 21st Century - Large Scale Deployment of smart applications
DSM in the 21st Century - Large Scale Deployment of smart applications
IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)
 
REBNY NYC Benchmarking Seminar: NYSERDA Commercial Incentive Programs: Commer...
REBNY NYC Benchmarking Seminar: NYSERDA Commercial Incentive Programs: Commer...REBNY NYC Benchmarking Seminar: NYSERDA Commercial Incentive Programs: Commer...
REBNY NYC Benchmarking Seminar: NYSERDA Commercial Incentive Programs: Commer...
REBNY
 
SolarСity Storage_Aug_2015
SolarСity Storage_Aug_2015SolarСity Storage_Aug_2015
SolarСity Storage_Aug_2015
Dmitry Tseitlin
 
062514NetMetering_Overview.ppt_062514NetMetering_Overview.pptx
062514NetMetering_Overview.ppt_062514NetMetering_Overview.pptx062514NetMetering_Overview.ppt_062514NetMetering_Overview.pptx
062514NetMetering_Overview.ppt_062514NetMetering_Overview.pptx
KasnilawazaidiAbdulk
 
"Next Gen Grid Tech Commercialization" for Duke University Energy Initiative ...
"Next Gen Grid Tech Commercialization" for Duke University Energy Initiative ..."Next Gen Grid Tech Commercialization" for Duke University Energy Initiative ...
"Next Gen Grid Tech Commercialization" for Duke University Energy Initiative ...
Josh Gould
 
Real Time Pricing Simulator for Smart Grids
Real Time Pricing Simulator for Smart GridsReal Time Pricing Simulator for Smart Grids
Real Time Pricing Simulator for Smart Grids
Swantika Dhundia
 
Using Demand Side Management to Support Electricity Grids
Using Demand Side Management to Support Electricity GridsUsing Demand Side Management to Support Electricity Grids
Using Demand Side Management to Support Electricity Grids
Leonardo ENERGY
 
Using Demand-Side Management to Support Electricity Grids
Using Demand-Side Management to Support Electricity GridsUsing Demand-Side Management to Support Electricity Grids
Using Demand-Side Management to Support Electricity Grids
Leonardo ENERGY
 
Blacklight Analytics - Grid connection capacity of EV charging stations
Blacklight Analytics - Grid connection capacity of  EV charging stationsBlacklight Analytics - Grid connection capacity of  EV charging stations
Blacklight Analytics - Grid connection capacity of EV charging stations
Quentin Gemine
 
GridPIQ_Webinar_2018_08_28.pptx
GridPIQ_Webinar_2018_08_28.pptxGridPIQ_Webinar_2018_08_28.pptx
GridPIQ_Webinar_2018_08_28.pptx
MThamilAlagan
 

Similar to SEIN Advanced Rate Design Project (20)

Brasilia int school_solar_energy_putting_in_place_the_solar_potential_v1
Brasilia int school_solar_energy_putting_in_place_the_solar_potential_v1Brasilia int school_solar_energy_putting_in_place_the_solar_potential_v1
Brasilia int school_solar_energy_putting_in_place_the_solar_potential_v1
 
20161006 Szaro Power Matters Conference all slides
20161006 Szaro Power Matters Conference all slides20161006 Szaro Power Matters Conference all slides
20161006 Szaro Power Matters Conference all slides
 
DSM - a way to improve the performance of energy systems
DSM - a way to improve the performance of energy systems DSM - a way to improve the performance of energy systems
DSM - a way to improve the performance of energy systems
 
Energy efficient computing & computational services
Energy efficient computing & computational services Energy efficient computing & computational services
Energy efficient computing & computational services
 
April 12, 2016 CEFAC Energy Storage Presentation
April 12, 2016 CEFAC Energy Storage PresentationApril 12, 2016 CEFAC Energy Storage Presentation
April 12, 2016 CEFAC Energy Storage Presentation
 
UE - Presentation
UE - PresentationUE - Presentation
UE - Presentation
 
EEI Strategic Issues Forum - Integration of DER: California and New York
EEI Strategic Issues Forum - Integration of DER: California and New YorkEEI Strategic Issues Forum - Integration of DER: California and New York
EEI Strategic Issues Forum - Integration of DER: California and New York
 
A World Full of Possibilities: Integrating DERs into Wholesale Markets – Outl...
A World Full of Possibilities: Integrating DERs into Wholesale Markets – Outl...A World Full of Possibilities: Integrating DERs into Wholesale Markets – Outl...
A World Full of Possibilities: Integrating DERs into Wholesale Markets – Outl...
 
Electricity Distribution Changes by Innovari
Electricity Distribution Changes by InnovariElectricity Distribution Changes by Innovari
Electricity Distribution Changes by Innovari
 
coned-presentation-in-pdf-final.pdf
coned-presentation-in-pdf-final.pdfconed-presentation-in-pdf-final.pdf
coned-presentation-in-pdf-final.pdf
 
DSM in the 21st Century - Large Scale Deployment of smart applications
DSM in the 21st Century - Large Scale Deployment of smart applications DSM in the 21st Century - Large Scale Deployment of smart applications
DSM in the 21st Century - Large Scale Deployment of smart applications
 
REBNY NYC Benchmarking Seminar: NYSERDA Commercial Incentive Programs: Commer...
REBNY NYC Benchmarking Seminar: NYSERDA Commercial Incentive Programs: Commer...REBNY NYC Benchmarking Seminar: NYSERDA Commercial Incentive Programs: Commer...
REBNY NYC Benchmarking Seminar: NYSERDA Commercial Incentive Programs: Commer...
 
SolarСity Storage_Aug_2015
SolarСity Storage_Aug_2015SolarСity Storage_Aug_2015
SolarСity Storage_Aug_2015
 
062514NetMetering_Overview.ppt_062514NetMetering_Overview.pptx
062514NetMetering_Overview.ppt_062514NetMetering_Overview.pptx062514NetMetering_Overview.ppt_062514NetMetering_Overview.pptx
062514NetMetering_Overview.ppt_062514NetMetering_Overview.pptx
 
"Next Gen Grid Tech Commercialization" for Duke University Energy Initiative ...
"Next Gen Grid Tech Commercialization" for Duke University Energy Initiative ..."Next Gen Grid Tech Commercialization" for Duke University Energy Initiative ...
"Next Gen Grid Tech Commercialization" for Duke University Energy Initiative ...
 
Real Time Pricing Simulator for Smart Grids
Real Time Pricing Simulator for Smart GridsReal Time Pricing Simulator for Smart Grids
Real Time Pricing Simulator for Smart Grids
 
Using Demand Side Management to Support Electricity Grids
Using Demand Side Management to Support Electricity GridsUsing Demand Side Management to Support Electricity Grids
Using Demand Side Management to Support Electricity Grids
 
Using Demand-Side Management to Support Electricity Grids
Using Demand-Side Management to Support Electricity GridsUsing Demand-Side Management to Support Electricity Grids
Using Demand-Side Management to Support Electricity Grids
 
Blacklight Analytics - Grid connection capacity of EV charging stations
Blacklight Analytics - Grid connection capacity of  EV charging stationsBlacklight Analytics - Grid connection capacity of  EV charging stations
Blacklight Analytics - Grid connection capacity of EV charging stations
 
GridPIQ_Webinar_2018_08_28.pptx
GridPIQ_Webinar_2018_08_28.pptxGridPIQ_Webinar_2018_08_28.pptx
GridPIQ_Webinar_2018_08_28.pptx
 

Recently uploaded

weather web application report.pdf
weather web application report.pdfweather web application report.pdf
weather web application report.pdf
Pratik Pawar
 
Planning Of Procurement o different goods and services
Planning Of Procurement o different goods and servicesPlanning Of Procurement o different goods and services
Planning Of Procurement o different goods and services
JoytuBarua2
 
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptxInvestor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
AmarGB2
 
CME397 Surface Engineering- Professional Elective
CME397 Surface Engineering- Professional ElectiveCME397 Surface Engineering- Professional Elective
CME397 Surface Engineering- Professional Elective
karthi keyan
 
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdfCosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
Kamal Acharya
 
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdfWater Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
Water Industry Process Automation & Control
 
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptxFundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
manasideore6
 
Runway Orientation Based on the Wind Rose Diagram.pptx
Runway Orientation Based on the Wind Rose Diagram.pptxRunway Orientation Based on the Wind Rose Diagram.pptx
Runway Orientation Based on the Wind Rose Diagram.pptx
SupreethSP4
 
ML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptx
ML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptxML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptx
ML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptx
Vijay Dialani, PhD
 
DESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docx
DESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docxDESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docx
DESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docx
FluxPrime1
 
The role of big data in decision making.
The role of big data in decision making.The role of big data in decision making.
The role of big data in decision making.
ankuprajapati0525
 
AP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specific
AP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specificAP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specific
AP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specific
BrazilAccount1
 
Sachpazis:Terzaghi Bearing Capacity Estimation in simple terms with Calculati...
Sachpazis:Terzaghi Bearing Capacity Estimation in simple terms with Calculati...Sachpazis:Terzaghi Bearing Capacity Estimation in simple terms with Calculati...
Sachpazis:Terzaghi Bearing Capacity Estimation in simple terms with Calculati...
Dr.Costas Sachpazis
 
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
MdTanvirMahtab2
 
ethical hacking-mobile hacking methods.ppt
ethical hacking-mobile hacking methods.pptethical hacking-mobile hacking methods.ppt
ethical hacking-mobile hacking methods.ppt
Jayaprasanna4
 
Gen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdf
Gen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdfGen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdf
Gen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdf
gdsczhcet
 
AKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdf
AKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdfAKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdf
AKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdf
SamSarthak3
 
Hybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdf
Hybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdfHybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdf
Hybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdf
fxintegritypublishin
 
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary AttacksImmunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
gerogepatton
 
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdfEnglish lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
BrazilAccount1
 

Recently uploaded (20)

weather web application report.pdf
weather web application report.pdfweather web application report.pdf
weather web application report.pdf
 
Planning Of Procurement o different goods and services
Planning Of Procurement o different goods and servicesPlanning Of Procurement o different goods and services
Planning Of Procurement o different goods and services
 
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptxInvestor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
Investor-Presentation-Q1FY2024 investor presentation document.pptx
 
CME397 Surface Engineering- Professional Elective
CME397 Surface Engineering- Professional ElectiveCME397 Surface Engineering- Professional Elective
CME397 Surface Engineering- Professional Elective
 
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdfCosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
Cosmetic shop management system project report.pdf
 
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdfWater Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
Water Industry Process Automation and Control Monthly - May 2024.pdf
 
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptxFundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
Fundamentals of Electric Drives and its applications.pptx
 
Runway Orientation Based on the Wind Rose Diagram.pptx
Runway Orientation Based on the Wind Rose Diagram.pptxRunway Orientation Based on the Wind Rose Diagram.pptx
Runway Orientation Based on the Wind Rose Diagram.pptx
 
ML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptx
ML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptxML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptx
ML for identifying fraud using open blockchain data.pptx
 
DESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docx
DESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docxDESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docx
DESIGN A COTTON SEED SEPARATION MACHINE.docx
 
The role of big data in decision making.
The role of big data in decision making.The role of big data in decision making.
The role of big data in decision making.
 
AP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specific
AP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specificAP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specific
AP LAB PPT.pdf ap lab ppt no title specific
 
Sachpazis:Terzaghi Bearing Capacity Estimation in simple terms with Calculati...
Sachpazis:Terzaghi Bearing Capacity Estimation in simple terms with Calculati...Sachpazis:Terzaghi Bearing Capacity Estimation in simple terms with Calculati...
Sachpazis:Terzaghi Bearing Capacity Estimation in simple terms with Calculati...
 
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
Industrial Training at Shahjalal Fertilizer Company Limited (SFCL)
 
ethical hacking-mobile hacking methods.ppt
ethical hacking-mobile hacking methods.pptethical hacking-mobile hacking methods.ppt
ethical hacking-mobile hacking methods.ppt
 
Gen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdf
Gen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdfGen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdf
Gen AI Study Jams _ For the GDSC Leads in India.pdf
 
AKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdf
AKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdfAKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdf
AKS UNIVERSITY Satna Final Year Project By OM Hardaha.pdf
 
Hybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdf
Hybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdfHybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdf
Hybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdf
 
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary AttacksImmunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
Immunizing Image Classifiers Against Localized Adversary Attacks
 
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdfEnglish lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
English lab ppt no titlespecENG PPTt.pdf
 

SEIN Advanced Rate Design Project

  • 1. Solar Energy Innovation Symposium June 6, 2019 Advanced Rate Design Project NREL Solar Energy Innovation Network
  • 2. Project Team • Center for Climate Protection Lead • TerraVerde Energy LLC Technical Development • Lancaster Choice Energy Consultation, Virtual Pilot • Peninsula Clean Energy Consultation, Virtual Pilot • Grid Policy LLC Policy/Technical Advisor • California Solar & Storage Association Policy Advisor
  • 3. Project Goal • Create a software tool for helping Load Serving Entities design tariffs that incentivize the deployment of Distributed Energy Resources.
  • 4. What’s a DER? Distributed Energy Resource: Any customer-side resource for improving the quality and availability of electric power, system-wide. • Solar Panels • Battery Storage • Smart Electric Vehicle Chargers • Smart Thermostats • Smart Water Heaters • Demand Response Programs
  • 5. Strategy: Consider the net effect of a deployment program: 1. Assess net economic impact of DER program. 2. Assess net GHG impact of DER program. 3. Assess value available to share with customers to incentivize DER deployment.
  • 6. Scope, as Ambitiously Envisioned • Software tool works for any Load Serving Entity. • Software tool sets rates for any DER type.
  • 7. Actual Scope Any Load Serving Entity >> California CCAs • The value of a DER program depends on regulatory environment. • California CCAs are empowered to set rates without regulatory oversight.
  • 8. What’s a CCA? Community Choice Aggregation agency: A public agency empowered to buy electricity in wholesale markets to sell in competition with Investor-Owned Utilities. • Historically aligned with GHG reduction and other community goals. • Empowered to set rates without regulatory oversight. • Own very few energy system assets. • Exploding reach within California. • Young, small, & relatively nimble.
  • 9. Actual Scope Any DER type >> Solar + Dispatchable Storage Between DER types, very significant variation in: • Required customer investment. • Impact on LSE revenues. • Ability to impact wholesale procurement costs.
  • 10. CCA Engagement Through engagement with the CCA Community we narrowed our focus to analyzing solar + dispatchable storage: • Focus group calls • DER values matrix • 1:1 meetings with Virtual Pilot partners
  • 11. What’s a VPP? Virtual Power Plant: A network of customer sited batteries that can be centrally controlled to provide grid benefits. • Dispatch VPP power as an alternative to buying in wholesale power markets. • Dispatch clean energy as alternative to buying dirty energy in power markets. • Sell power into wholesale markets when prices are high. • Store excess generation when prices are low. • Reduce resource adequacy and other demand-related wholesale costs. • Participate in utility demand reduction programs. • Sell into ancillary service markets.
  • 12. VPP Suppliers Market Access Operation Strategy DER Aggregation Olivine x x x Leap x AMS x Stem x Engie x x Sunrun x
  • 13. Tool Creation Roadmap 1. Identify CCA goals for deploying solar + storage systems. 2. Research capabilities and limitations of VPP technology. 3. Analyze average economic benefit per kW of VPP storage. 4. Analyze GHG benefit per kW of VPP storage. 5. Research costs of installing customer-sited storage with solar. 6. Research best practices for incentivizing program participation. 7. Propose tariff structure and terms. 8. Run virtual pilot projects to demonstrate feasibility.
  • 14. Analyzing Economic Benefit 1. Ingest CCA’s procurement history data. 2. Model CCA’s historic procurement costs. 3. Model the change in load from operating a VPP. 4. Analyze values streams achieved by VPP operating strategy.
  • 15. Procurement History Data 8760 hours of hour-by-hour procurement cost data (24 x 365 = 8760) • Bilateral agreements: hourly volume and price • Scheduled Load: hourly volume • Day-head market: hourly price • Actual Load: hourly volume • Imbalance market: hourly price • Resource adequacy: hourly cost • Other fees and credits: hourly cost/credit
  • 16. Procurement Cost Model 1. Scheduled Load a. 24 hours of anticipated load, reported one day ahead. b. Includes bilateral hedges. c. Scheduled Load – Hedged Load = day-ahead market purchase. 2. Imbalance a. Imbalance = Actual Load – Scheduled Load. b. ISO procures power to meet system demand in real time. c. Imbalance load is deduced retrospectively from meter data.
  • 17. VPP Strategy: Load Flattening Flatten your load at: www.FlattenMyLoad.com
  • 18. VPP Strategy: Load Flattening Flatten your load at: www.FlattenMyLoad.com
  • 19. Value Stream: Day-Ahead Peak Avoidance
  • 20. Value Stream: Sell into Real-Time Market
  • 23. Additional Value Streams • Offsets to customer utility distribution demand charges. • Improved GHG profile. • Battery resiliency benefits.
  • 24. Next Steps: Propose Rate Terms • Analyze as a program. • Tri-lateral Agreements (LSE + Customer + Operator) • Operate to maximize system benefit. • Align compensation with system benefit.
  • 25. Next Steps: Virtual Pilot Projects Analyze customer’s annual retail cost and LSE’s annual wholesale cost to supply customer under three scenarios: 1. With no Solar + Storage. 2. With Solar + Storage under existing tariff. 3. With Solar + Storage under proposed tariff.
  • 26. Tool Creation Technical Support/Guidance ‣ NREL and RMI Advisors: ‣ Helped us determine the need to narrow the scope of our design model to a single type of DER deployment ‣ Helped us determine the need to reduce the target audience from all LSEs to CCA agencies in California. ‣ Shared procurement expertise which supported us in the process of identifying the VPP operating strategies that are most likely to yield economic and GHG benefits. ‣ Technical Consultants ‣ Chris Sentieri, Blue Strike Environmental ‣ Jon Wellinghoff, former Chairman of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
  • 27. QUESTIONS? THANK YOU Storn White Director of Software Development TerraVerde Energy, LLC storn@TerraVerde.energy and don’t forget to flatten your load at: www.FlattenMyLoad.com