Highlights from the Future Grid Forum’s
Change and Choice report
ADD BUSINESS UNIT/FLAGSHIP NAME
UNAA Victoria Securing Australia’s Energy Future Seminar
15 August 2014
ENERGY FLAGSHIP
Australia’s Future Grid Forum
• Long-term orientation to 2050 to demonstrate
key policy and technology choices not
constrained by near term electoral cycles
• Whole-of-system to provide credible
projections and quantitative analytics
especially of the role of networks
• Industry-led to enable bold and informed
discussion that examines benefits and
drawbacks of different outlooks
Participants Stanwell Corporation
Hydro Tasmania
ESAA
Trends leading up to the FGF report
Retail prices have risen
Networks have been the
largest source
Trends leading up to the FGF report
Electricity consumption and peak
demand have declined in most states
Trends leading up to the FGF report
Greenhouse gas emissions have fallen
for a number of reasons
Solar panel uptake has been rapid
> 3TWh p.a.
> 2 million installations
Future disruptors
Scenario 1: Set and forget
Sustained high retail prices,
heightened awareness about the
issue of peak demand, and new
business and technology
opportunities lead residential,
commercial and industrial
customers to adopt peak demand
management.
The demand management
systems are managed centrally
and designed to be on a ‘set and
forget’ basis after customers have
decided which level of demand
management suits them.
Scenario 2: Rise of the prosumer
Continued falling costs of solar
rooftop panels and other on-site
generation technologies, sustained
high retail prices, and increasingly
innovative financing and product
packaging from energy services
companies leads to the widespread
adoption of on-site generation with
almost half of generation on-site.
Residential consumers in particular
are empowered by their choice to
become more actively engaged in
their electricity supply and call
themselves ’prosumers’
Scenario 3: Leaving the grid
The continued dominance of volume-
based pricing among residential and
small commercial consumers encourages
energy efficiency without accompanying
reductions in peak demand growth. The
subsequent declining network utilisation
feeds increases in retail prices.
New energy service companies sensing
a market opportunity invite consumers to
leave the grid, offering an initially higher-
cost solution, but one that appeals to a
sense of independence from the grid.
By the late 2030s, with reduced storage
costs, disconnection becomes a
mainstream option with a third of
consumption eventually being removed
from the grid.
Hobart Mercury 14th August 2014
CUTTING tariffs paid to
Tasmanians with solar panels
should be considered as a
way to level a system that
penalises people who cannot
afford them, the head of
Tasmania’s newly merged
energy company says.
Scenario 4: Renewables thrive
Confidence in the improving costs
of renewable and storage
technologies, achieved by combined
efforts from government and industry
around the world, results in the
introduction of a linearly phased 100
per cent renewable target by 2050
for centralised electricity generation.
Some customers maintain fossil
based on-site power so that overall,
the renewable share, taken as a
share of both centralised and on-site
generation, is 86 per cent by 2050.
Higher on-site generation is here to stay
This means lower utilisation for our networks if we don’t manage peak demand
Will we switch to more cost-reflective
electricity pricing?
Peak demand governs the
cost of network
(kW)
Electricity is charged on
quarterly volume
(kWh)
Cost reflective pricing essential to manage peak demand
Current regime only encourages demand volume management
•Manage peak demand
•Optimise returns from solar panels
•Enable high renewables penetration
•Enable electric vehicles
•Enable full disconnection from the grid
Many possible roles for storage
Energy Flagship
Paul Graham
Chief Economist
t +61 2 4960 6061
e paul.graham@csiro.au
w www.csiro.au/energy
ENERGY FLAGSHIP
Thank you

Securing Australia's Energy Future: The Challenge - Paul Graham, Energy Flagship, CSIRO

  • 1.
    Highlights from theFuture Grid Forum’s Change and Choice report ADD BUSINESS UNIT/FLAGSHIP NAME UNAA Victoria Securing Australia’s Energy Future Seminar 15 August 2014 ENERGY FLAGSHIP
  • 2.
    Australia’s Future GridForum • Long-term orientation to 2050 to demonstrate key policy and technology choices not constrained by near term electoral cycles • Whole-of-system to provide credible projections and quantitative analytics especially of the role of networks • Industry-led to enable bold and informed discussion that examines benefits and drawbacks of different outlooks
  • 3.
  • 4.
    Trends leading upto the FGF report Retail prices have risen Networks have been the largest source
  • 5.
    Trends leading upto the FGF report Electricity consumption and peak demand have declined in most states
  • 6.
    Trends leading upto the FGF report Greenhouse gas emissions have fallen for a number of reasons Solar panel uptake has been rapid > 3TWh p.a. > 2 million installations
  • 7.
  • 8.
    Scenario 1: Setand forget Sustained high retail prices, heightened awareness about the issue of peak demand, and new business and technology opportunities lead residential, commercial and industrial customers to adopt peak demand management. The demand management systems are managed centrally and designed to be on a ‘set and forget’ basis after customers have decided which level of demand management suits them.
  • 9.
    Scenario 2: Riseof the prosumer Continued falling costs of solar rooftop panels and other on-site generation technologies, sustained high retail prices, and increasingly innovative financing and product packaging from energy services companies leads to the widespread adoption of on-site generation with almost half of generation on-site. Residential consumers in particular are empowered by their choice to become more actively engaged in their electricity supply and call themselves ’prosumers’
  • 10.
    Scenario 3: Leavingthe grid The continued dominance of volume- based pricing among residential and small commercial consumers encourages energy efficiency without accompanying reductions in peak demand growth. The subsequent declining network utilisation feeds increases in retail prices. New energy service companies sensing a market opportunity invite consumers to leave the grid, offering an initially higher- cost solution, but one that appeals to a sense of independence from the grid. By the late 2030s, with reduced storage costs, disconnection becomes a mainstream option with a third of consumption eventually being removed from the grid.
  • 11.
    Hobart Mercury 14thAugust 2014 CUTTING tariffs paid to Tasmanians with solar panels should be considered as a way to level a system that penalises people who cannot afford them, the head of Tasmania’s newly merged energy company says.
  • 12.
    Scenario 4: Renewablesthrive Confidence in the improving costs of renewable and storage technologies, achieved by combined efforts from government and industry around the world, results in the introduction of a linearly phased 100 per cent renewable target by 2050 for centralised electricity generation. Some customers maintain fossil based on-site power so that overall, the renewable share, taken as a share of both centralised and on-site generation, is 86 per cent by 2050.
  • 13.
    Higher on-site generationis here to stay This means lower utilisation for our networks if we don’t manage peak demand
  • 14.
    Will we switchto more cost-reflective electricity pricing? Peak demand governs the cost of network (kW) Electricity is charged on quarterly volume (kWh) Cost reflective pricing essential to manage peak demand Current regime only encourages demand volume management
  • 15.
    •Manage peak demand •Optimisereturns from solar panels •Enable high renewables penetration •Enable electric vehicles •Enable full disconnection from the grid Many possible roles for storage
  • 16.
    Energy Flagship Paul Graham ChiefEconomist t +61 2 4960 6061 e paul.graham@csiro.au w www.csiro.au/energy ENERGY FLAGSHIP Thank you