SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Report back on Community Conversation
April 6, 2016
ABOUT SHERIDAN’S COMMUNITY WORKER PROGRAM
Sheridan’s Community worker program is a two year diploma program for those who
are interested in building stronger communities. Graduates have the ability to critically
engage in participatory global/local community building through innovative and
transformative problem solving to mobilize and create vibrant communities rooted in
social justice.
ABOUT LAB-B
LAB B is the only coworking space in Brampton. Their mission is to develop and sustain
the creative economy that currently exists in the city. LAB B has been a heavyweight in
maintaining the youth climate in Brampton since 2014
OVERVIEW
On April 6, 2016 twenty-five community leaders, youth and changemakers engaged in a
community conversation about building a vibrant Brampton for youth. This summary
report collates some of the highlights and themes of the community conversation in order
to cultivate and harness the ideas and energy for change. The facilitators recorded the
conversation and engaged in open coding in order to develop themes of the
conversation. While the individual voices of the participants are really important, we
elected to record the experiences and analysis of participants anonymously and sought
overarching trends to help inform how we can improve the vitality of Brampton.
INTRODUCTION
When community leaders from LAB B, staff and graduates from Sheridan’s Community
Worker program began discussing possible collaborations in December 2015, there was a
strong synergy between the community worker program’s grassroots approach and LAB
B’s creative community building approach. After a couple of dialogue sessions, we
collectively decided that a ‘community conversation’ would help galvanize LAB-B’s base
of changemakers. The goal of the ‘community conversation’ was to discuss opportunities,
challenges, and barriers impacting Brampton’s vibrancy for youth. The main themes and
trends that emerge from our discussion will be represented at a research cafe on April 15
at Sheridan College and published online to share and build on. We set out to have a
different “outside of the box” community conversation about building a better city for
youth.
HOW WE DID IT
Sheridan’s Community Worker faculty Abigail Salole, and Community Worker students
Holly Vukobrat and Vin Bharadwaj facilitated the community conversation. We wanted
to build the conversation from the premise of possibility and curiosity. The session
began with two participants reading an excerpt from Margaret Wheatley’s “Turning to
one another” (see sidebar).
Sidebar: “There is no power greater than a community discovering what it cares about.
Ask: “What’s possible?” not “What’s wrong?” Keep asking. Notice what you care about.
Assume that many others share your dreams. Be brave enough to start a conversation that
matters. Talk to people you know. Talk to people you don’t know. Talk to people you never
talk to. Be intrigued by the differences you hear. Expect to be surprised. Treasure curiosity
more than certainty. Invite in everybody who cares to work on what’s possible.
Acknowledge that everyone is an expert about something. Know that creative solutions
come from new connections. Remember, you don’t fear people whose story you know.
Real listening always brings people closer together. Trust that meaningful conversations
can change your world. Rely on human goodness. Stay together”
Next, participants were asked to consider the strengths and challenges of living in
Brampton for youth. The focus questions were: What does Brampton do really well for
youth? What challenges does Brampton face for youth?
Participants wrote these strengths and challenges on sticky notes and shared with other
participants as a way to start the conversation. Using strengths and challenges as a way
to foster conversation, the next activity involved participants building a shared
understanding of a collective context in small groups. Here, participants were asked to
use these strengths and challenges as a base to build an understanding of political
factors, economic factors, social and cultural factors that inform how youth experience
Brampton. In addition, in order to seek novelty and participants were asked to consider
the elephant in the room for youth in Brampton. We wanted to invite participants to
consider those subjects that are widely known but not often talked about. The findings
of this collective context were shared with the entire group.
In a storyboard activity, participants were asked to brainstorm the story of the ‘Vibrant
City of Brampton for Youth’. Here, participants were asked to consider the ideal future
state of Brampton by sketching an ideal vibrant future uses markers and paper provided.
Building from the Storyboard conversation, participants were asked to consider the next
possible exciting step that everyone in this room could participate in and support that
would lead to the vibrant city of Brampton. Groups consider what steps participants
could take to get there. Groups were asked to select 1–2 actions from each cluster and
then record action items on a piece of paper which clarifies “In order to / We must”
worksheet by filling out the “We must” column. Facilitators collected worksheets and
sticky notes and chatted further after the structured session.
COLLECTIVE CONTEXT: WHERE ARE WE AT?
When we were mapping the current context in Brampton, there was a contradictory
sense that there was a great deal of enthusiasm and hope for building a more vibrant
Brampton for youth while recognizing the very real structural hindrances and challenges
for doing so. There were two broad themes from this discussion.
1. LACK OF INTERACTIVE CITY DESIGN
The importance of space was a common theme throughout the ‘community conversation’.
There were a number of layers to the importance of how space and community design
structured the youth experience in Brampton. First, Brampton’s land-use structure is
what many have come to know as “typically suburban.” There are mostly designs for
single-family residential neighbourhoods that are demarcated from places of employment
and consumption. This land use structure is most amenable to transportation based on
car travel and perpetuates ‘bedroom communities’ where people return home from work
to sleep. Pedestrian, public transit and biking options are limited.
Second, there is a shortage of spaces that are designed for interaction between community
members. Indeed, there was a strong sense in this conversation that spaces are mostly
limited to commercial spaces where the focus is on consumption (and therefore excludes
people without money) and/or social services (which were also described as
limited). There was some discussion about why spaces like the library or community
centers were not seen as viable collective spaces. Some reasons that were discussed were
quality of programming, lack of awareness of programming, the low status level that that
these collective spaces have with residents. One participant described that a shortage of
third spaces (spaces that are neither home nor work spaces) contributes the lack of
interaction in community. Of course, there were exceptions to the shortage of collective
spaces - LAB-B was an obvious exception pointed out by many participants. Third,
Brampton’s proximity to Toronto means that, there is a strong pull towards more vibrant
night life and community events outside of Brampton.
The importance of space as a salient consideration for the youth experience in Brampton
might seem contradictory to the increasing role of online interaction in connecting
people. Indeed, people frequently connect with people across time and space and,
therefore, social networks or “community” cannot be assumed based on geography.
Despite this increasing fluidity, geographical boundaries and identities remain important.
One participant lamented how many online meeting apps and interfaces are not
successful in Brampton because the numbers of users are insufficient for these
applications to have the intended utility. The concern about the lack of these interactive
spaces is even more profound in Brampton because it perpetuates ethnic silos which some
participants suggest could be challenged by more inter-ethnic/cultural cross pollination.
Indeed, racism and NIMBYISM (‘Not In My Back-Yard mentality) were two negative
social phenomenon in Brampton that were identified as being perpetuated by a
segmented and circumscribed youth population.
 LACK OF MEANINGFUL YOUTH CENTERED CIVIC ENGAGEMENT AND
OPPORTUNITY
While many participants described a number of exciting initiatives that are ‘community
building’ initiatives and a promise of burgeoning creative initiatives and industries,
participants discussed a dearth of youth centered civic engagement from all three levels
of government. Specifically, there is a lack of social infrastructure for youth to access
politicians and decision making. In simple terms, participants discussed youth
disenfranchisement from meaningful decisions that ran as a theme throughout the
conversation.
Participants unanimously expressed that there are a lack of initiatives or pathways to
meaningful civic engagement in Brampton from government. The reasons offered for this
lack of engagement included blatant disregard for youth civic engagement, youth not
being represented in government, youth not having cultural capital and decision makers
not knowing how to engage young people.
Participants discussed how there were few opportunities for youth to engage in
meaningful dialogue with political representatives. While a number of initiatives like
student voting programs in schools were mentioned, participants found these programs
were often empty gestures and politicians did not have the motivation to meaningfully
engage youth which helps to contribute to youth disengagement. Participants were
unanimously disappointed by the decision from Brampton City Council to vote against
the Hurontario-Main LRT, a light rail line, and cited this decision as evidence that the city
was not considering the youth demographic, and focusing instead on the ‘elite’
Bramptonians, to inform important city decisions.
Without a more visible and concerted effort to curtail youth disenfranchisement,
participants spoke with concern about the high youth unemployment rate, high levels of
precarious work, increasing income inequality, service allocation and funding issues (for
health and social services) and limited government investment in start-ups as particularly
concerning realities for youth in Brampton. The more marginalized young people are
(those who are marginalized by racism, mental health issues, poverty and other sources
of oppression) the more likely to bear the brunt of these social problems.
The voices from the community conversation echo and bring to life the concerns depicted
in many research reports. While many performance measures for youth in Brampton (and
Peel) are generally positive, averages and aggregate information can hide the experiences
of the most marginalized in Brampton. For example, the Social Planning Council of Peel
(2015) described that many Black youth in Peel feel unwanted, devalued and socially
isolated.
Income inequality, poverty and precarious work are also important issues that have been
identified by other research. For example, the Neighborhood Change Research
Partnership (May 2013) examined long-term neighbourhood change trends in parts of
the “905 region” of the Toronto census metropolitan area (CMA). Over the period of study
(1980-2010) Brampton has increased the number of low and very low-income census
tracts from 3.4% to 65.2%. Low and very low-income is defined as less than 40% of the
average individual income of the Toronto CMA for the year being considered. This report
also demonstrated how middle-income census tracts have decreased from 86% in 1980
to 49% in 2010.
TOWARDS A YOUTH CENTERED VIBRANT BRAMPTON
Just as participants had keen insights on the strengths, challenges and barriers to building
a vibrant Brampton for youth, participants also had strong visions and commitments for
change. Indeed, there was a strong sentiment that there is a “rising tide” of creative
initiatives within Brampton that could (and should) be cultivated for enhanced city
vibrancy. While there are many push and pull factors that draw some youth away
Brampton, there was also a strong sense of commitment from Brampton’s youth leaders
and adult allies to build a stronger community.
Some common elements for change for participants included:
 Increased interactivity: A vibrant Brampton would include Brampton residents
working together to solve community problems, collective decision making,
increased third spaces that build community through entertainment, recreation
and public placemaking.
 A concerted effort on behalf of government, civil society and third spaces to engage
youth in meaningful authentic ways in order to co-create art-based, culture,
entrepreneurship and post-secondary opportunities in Brampton.
 A strong downtown Brampton that is strongly connected to residents through a
strong public transit system including an LRT.
 A concerted strategic direction to brand Brampton and develop made-in-
Brampton solutions and approaches to city and neighbourhood building.
 Revitalization of democracy on local issues including but especially local
representation, city planning, public transit and post-secondary opportunities
through people-powered change.
Many participants are already engaged in initiatives which strengthen Brampton.
Participants describe a need for more community conversations where citizen-led
initiatives can take root and Brampton residents can support issues and cultivate inspired
social change.
Plans for the next community conversation are already in motion. This group will
continue to grapple with some of the important questions and issues we started in the
first community conversation. For example:
 How can we build local solutions for change while recognizing the role that social
infrastructure and networkers have for democratic participation? That is,
neighbourhoods exist in a social context how can we build local solutions that are
centered within that social context?
 How are can we build creative innovative solutions for a more vibrant Brampton
that are inclusive? Can we address pressing social problems like poverty and
racism while trying to cultivate Brampton’s creativity and innovation?
References
Neighbourhood Change Research Partnership (May 2014). Accessed from
Neighbourhoodchange.ca
Social Planning Council of Peel (2015). The Black Community in Peel Summary:
Research Findings from Four Report. Accessed online from:
http://www.unitedwaypeel.org/faces/images/summary-sm.pdf

More Related Content

What's hot

Connecting Neighbours Online: Strategies for online engagement with inclusion...
Connecting Neighbours Online: Strategies for online engagement with inclusion...Connecting Neighbours Online: Strategies for online engagement with inclusion...
Connecting Neighbours Online: Strategies for online engagement with inclusion...
Steven Clift
 
Neighbors Online: Connecting Communities for All Workshop - Bay Area @ The HUB
Neighbors Online: Connecting Communities for All Workshop - Bay Area @ The HUBNeighbors Online: Connecting Communities for All Workshop - Bay Area @ The HUB
Neighbors Online: Connecting Communities for All Workshop - Bay Area @ The HUB
Steven Clift
 
A Woman's Guide to Talking About War and Peace
A Woman's Guide to Talking About War and PeaceA Woman's Guide to Talking About War and Peace
A Woman's Guide to Talking About War and Peace
Everyday Democracy
 
Creating Spaces for Change
Creating Spaces for ChangeCreating Spaces for Change
Creating Spaces for Change
Natalie Aflalo
 
Week 7 a role of clubs - putnam (2)
Week 7 a   role of clubs - putnam (2)Week 7 a   role of clubs - putnam (2)
Week 7 a role of clubs - putnam (2)
Mickielty
 
Transforming Governance
Transforming GovernanceTransforming Governance
Transforming GovernanceNicole Cabral
 
2011 Connecituct Civic Health Index
2011 Connecituct Civic Health Index2011 Connecituct Civic Health Index
2011 Connecituct Civic Health Index
Everyday Democracy
 
Core Principles for Public Engagement
Core Principles for Public EngagementCore Principles for Public Engagement
Core Principles for Public Engagement
Everyday Democracy
 
Social media and representation
Social media and representationSocial media and representation
Social media and representationclairearmitage
 
Kranich Turning Outward: Engaging Our Communities Iowa state library Librarie...
Kranich Turning Outward: Engaging Our Communities Iowa state library Librarie...Kranich Turning Outward: Engaging Our Communities Iowa state library Librarie...
Kranich Turning Outward: Engaging Our Communities Iowa state library Librarie...
Nancy Kranich
 
Understanding the role of community in online dating copypasteads.com
Understanding the role of community in online dating copypasteads.comUnderstanding the role of community in online dating copypasteads.com
Understanding the role of community in online dating copypasteads.com
jackpot201
 
Calling the Roll: Study Circles for Better Schools
Calling the Roll: Study Circles for Better SchoolsCalling the Roll: Study Circles for Better Schools
Calling the Roll: Study Circles for Better Schools
Natalie Aflalo
 
Beyond three minutes at the microphone - ICMA civic engagement workshop
Beyond three minutes at the microphone - ICMA civic engagement workshopBeyond three minutes at the microphone - ICMA civic engagement workshop
Beyond three minutes at the microphone - ICMA civic engagement workshop
Matt Leighninger
 
Inman thesis 2014 design for dignity
Inman thesis 2014 design for dignityInman thesis 2014 design for dignity
Inman thesis 2014 design for dignity
JordanInman
 

What's hot (20)

Connecting Neighbours Online: Strategies for online engagement with inclusion...
Connecting Neighbours Online: Strategies for online engagement with inclusion...Connecting Neighbours Online: Strategies for online engagement with inclusion...
Connecting Neighbours Online: Strategies for online engagement with inclusion...
 
Neighbors Online: Connecting Communities for All Workshop - Bay Area @ The HUB
Neighbors Online: Connecting Communities for All Workshop - Bay Area @ The HUBNeighbors Online: Connecting Communities for All Workshop - Bay Area @ The HUB
Neighbors Online: Connecting Communities for All Workshop - Bay Area @ The HUB
 
A Woman's Guide to Talking About War and Peace
A Woman's Guide to Talking About War and PeaceA Woman's Guide to Talking About War and Peace
A Woman's Guide to Talking About War and Peace
 
Creating Spaces for Change
Creating Spaces for ChangeCreating Spaces for Change
Creating Spaces for Change
 
Week 7 a role of clubs - putnam (2)
Week 7 a   role of clubs - putnam (2)Week 7 a   role of clubs - putnam (2)
Week 7 a role of clubs - putnam (2)
 
Transforming Governance
Transforming GovernanceTransforming Governance
Transforming Governance
 
2011 Connecituct Civic Health Index
2011 Connecituct Civic Health Index2011 Connecituct Civic Health Index
2011 Connecituct Civic Health Index
 
nvpa_lockman
nvpa_lockmannvpa_lockman
nvpa_lockman
 
Core Principles for Public Engagement
Core Principles for Public EngagementCore Principles for Public Engagement
Core Principles for Public Engagement
 
Social media and representation
Social media and representationSocial media and representation
Social media and representation
 
Social media and representation
Social media and representationSocial media and representation
Social media and representation
 
Kranich Turning Outward: Engaging Our Communities Iowa state library Librarie...
Kranich Turning Outward: Engaging Our Communities Iowa state library Librarie...Kranich Turning Outward: Engaging Our Communities Iowa state library Librarie...
Kranich Turning Outward: Engaging Our Communities Iowa state library Librarie...
 
Understanding the role of community in online dating copypasteads.com
Understanding the role of community in online dating copypasteads.comUnderstanding the role of community in online dating copypasteads.com
Understanding the role of community in online dating copypasteads.com
 
Calling the Roll: Study Circles for Better Schools
Calling the Roll: Study Circles for Better SchoolsCalling the Roll: Study Circles for Better Schools
Calling the Roll: Study Circles for Better Schools
 
Zeynep ICWSM 2010
Zeynep ICWSM 2010Zeynep ICWSM 2010
Zeynep ICWSM 2010
 
Beyond three minutes at the microphone - ICMA civic engagement workshop
Beyond three minutes at the microphone - ICMA civic engagement workshopBeyond three minutes at the microphone - ICMA civic engagement workshop
Beyond three minutes at the microphone - ICMA civic engagement workshop
 
Inman thesis 2014 design for dignity
Inman thesis 2014 design for dignityInman thesis 2014 design for dignity
Inman thesis 2014 design for dignity
 
London's Digital Neighbourhoods Preview
London's Digital Neighbourhoods PreviewLondon's Digital Neighbourhoods Preview
London's Digital Neighbourhoods Preview
 
America speaks legacy_print
America speaks legacy_printAmerica speaks legacy_print
America speaks legacy_print
 
Smart growth citizenship
Smart growth citizenshipSmart growth citizenship
Smart growth citizenship
 

Viewers also liked

Instructional technology @ dobyns bennett high school
Instructional technology @ dobyns bennett high schoolInstructional technology @ dobyns bennett high school
Instructional technology @ dobyns bennett high school
mdavis8426
 
GEO's Presentation on In Situ Thermal Remediation to EPA Region 9
GEO's Presentation on In Situ Thermal Remediation to EPA Region 9GEO's Presentation on In Situ Thermal Remediation to EPA Region 9
GEO's Presentation on In Situ Thermal Remediation to EPA Region 9
Good Earthkeeping Organization Inc (GEO)
 
New Media 101 - Chronic Disease Coalition
New Media 101 - Chronic Disease CoalitionNew Media 101 - Chronic Disease Coalition
New Media 101 - Chronic Disease Coalition
Mike McDowell
 
UMN-Foto kegiatan Pengabdian Pada Masyarakat
UMN-Foto kegiatan Pengabdian Pada MasyarakatUMN-Foto kegiatan Pengabdian Pada Masyarakat
UMN-Foto kegiatan Pengabdian Pada Masyarakat
Indiwan Seto wahyu wibowo
 
Engineering graphics essentials slide show intro 2010
Engineering graphics essentials slide show intro   2010Engineering graphics essentials slide show intro   2010
Engineering graphics essentials slide show intro 2010
Shelly Wilke
 
Berfikir matematis 824 1732-1-pb
Berfikir matematis 824 1732-1-pbBerfikir matematis 824 1732-1-pb
Berfikir matematis 824 1732-1-pb
Afwanilhuda Nst
 
Layout plan autocad 2010
Layout plan autocad 2010Layout plan autocad 2010
Layout plan autocad 2010
Fadhlina Fisal
 
Layer command in AutoCAD
Layer command in AutoCADLayer command in AutoCAD
Layer command in AutoCAD
Ravi Bhadauria
 
Penyebaran butir soal ulangan akhir semester ganjil
Penyebaran butir soal ulangan akhir semester ganjilPenyebaran butir soal ulangan akhir semester ganjil
Penyebaran butir soal ulangan akhir semester ganjil
RevaFauzi
 
Contoh proposal ptk (2)
Contoh proposal ptk (2)Contoh proposal ptk (2)
Contoh proposal ptk (2)
nu rokhman
 
Pengantar ilmu politik
Pengantar ilmu politikPengantar ilmu politik
Pengantar ilmu politik
Novia Tri Fajar Utami
 
Construction Documents
Construction DocumentsConstruction Documents
Construction DocumentsAllan Berry
 
Design Principles
Design PrinciplesDesign Principles
Design Principles
Steve Guinan
 
Elements of Design
Elements of DesignElements of Design
Elements of Design
Steve Guinan
 
Lecture 11 shear stresses in beams
Lecture 11 shear stresses in beamsLecture 11 shear stresses in beams
Lecture 11 shear stresses in beamsDeepak Agarwal
 
MATERI LENGKAP BAHASA INGGRIS PEMINATAN KELAS X SEMESTER 1
MATERI LENGKAP BAHASA INGGRIS PEMINATAN KELAS X SEMESTER 1MATERI LENGKAP BAHASA INGGRIS PEMINATAN KELAS X SEMESTER 1
MATERI LENGKAP BAHASA INGGRIS PEMINATAN KELAS X SEMESTER 1
Nesha Mutiara
 
Metode peneltian kuliah kuliah 1
Metode peneltian kuliah  kuliah 1Metode peneltian kuliah  kuliah 1
Metode peneltian kuliah kuliah 1
Mega Zainal
 
Sikuli x 知っていますか?
Sikuli x 知っていますか?Sikuli x 知っていますか?
Sikuli x 知っていますか?
Masuo Ohara
 
HTML & CSS: Chapter 05
HTML & CSS: Chapter 05HTML & CSS: Chapter 05
HTML & CSS: Chapter 05
Steve Guinan
 

Viewers also liked (19)

Instructional technology @ dobyns bennett high school
Instructional technology @ dobyns bennett high schoolInstructional technology @ dobyns bennett high school
Instructional technology @ dobyns bennett high school
 
GEO's Presentation on In Situ Thermal Remediation to EPA Region 9
GEO's Presentation on In Situ Thermal Remediation to EPA Region 9GEO's Presentation on In Situ Thermal Remediation to EPA Region 9
GEO's Presentation on In Situ Thermal Remediation to EPA Region 9
 
New Media 101 - Chronic Disease Coalition
New Media 101 - Chronic Disease CoalitionNew Media 101 - Chronic Disease Coalition
New Media 101 - Chronic Disease Coalition
 
UMN-Foto kegiatan Pengabdian Pada Masyarakat
UMN-Foto kegiatan Pengabdian Pada MasyarakatUMN-Foto kegiatan Pengabdian Pada Masyarakat
UMN-Foto kegiatan Pengabdian Pada Masyarakat
 
Engineering graphics essentials slide show intro 2010
Engineering graphics essentials slide show intro   2010Engineering graphics essentials slide show intro   2010
Engineering graphics essentials slide show intro 2010
 
Berfikir matematis 824 1732-1-pb
Berfikir matematis 824 1732-1-pbBerfikir matematis 824 1732-1-pb
Berfikir matematis 824 1732-1-pb
 
Layout plan autocad 2010
Layout plan autocad 2010Layout plan autocad 2010
Layout plan autocad 2010
 
Layer command in AutoCAD
Layer command in AutoCADLayer command in AutoCAD
Layer command in AutoCAD
 
Penyebaran butir soal ulangan akhir semester ganjil
Penyebaran butir soal ulangan akhir semester ganjilPenyebaran butir soal ulangan akhir semester ganjil
Penyebaran butir soal ulangan akhir semester ganjil
 
Contoh proposal ptk (2)
Contoh proposal ptk (2)Contoh proposal ptk (2)
Contoh proposal ptk (2)
 
Pengantar ilmu politik
Pengantar ilmu politikPengantar ilmu politik
Pengantar ilmu politik
 
Construction Documents
Construction DocumentsConstruction Documents
Construction Documents
 
Design Principles
Design PrinciplesDesign Principles
Design Principles
 
Elements of Design
Elements of DesignElements of Design
Elements of Design
 
Lecture 11 shear stresses in beams
Lecture 11 shear stresses in beamsLecture 11 shear stresses in beams
Lecture 11 shear stresses in beams
 
MATERI LENGKAP BAHASA INGGRIS PEMINATAN KELAS X SEMESTER 1
MATERI LENGKAP BAHASA INGGRIS PEMINATAN KELAS X SEMESTER 1MATERI LENGKAP BAHASA INGGRIS PEMINATAN KELAS X SEMESTER 1
MATERI LENGKAP BAHASA INGGRIS PEMINATAN KELAS X SEMESTER 1
 
Metode peneltian kuliah kuliah 1
Metode peneltian kuliah  kuliah 1Metode peneltian kuliah  kuliah 1
Metode peneltian kuliah kuliah 1
 
Sikuli x 知っていますか?
Sikuli x 知っていますか?Sikuli x 知っていますか?
Sikuli x 知っていますか?
 
HTML & CSS: Chapter 05
HTML & CSS: Chapter 05HTML & CSS: Chapter 05
HTML & CSS: Chapter 05
 

Similar to Report back on Community Conversation NOSPACES

Vital_Difference_Final
Vital_Difference_FinalVital_Difference_Final
Vital_Difference_FinalJoy Amulya
 
CAVR 2009 Parker Speaking Notes
CAVR 2009 Parker Speaking NotesCAVR 2009 Parker Speaking Notes
CAVR 2009 Parker Speaking Notes
Volunteer Alberta
 
Civil society strategy Policy Labs
Civil society strategy Policy LabsCivil society strategy Policy Labs
Civil society strategy Policy Labs
Policy Lab
 
Red Cross Essay
Red Cross EssayRed Cross Essay
Red Cross Essay
Lucy Nader
 
Someone's Done that Already: The Best Practices of Sharing Best Practices, pr...
Someone's Done that Already: The Best Practices of Sharing Best Practices, pr...Someone's Done that Already: The Best Practices of Sharing Best Practices, pr...
Someone's Done that Already: The Best Practices of Sharing Best Practices, pr...
craigslist_fndn
 
Academic Libraries As Hubs For Civic Engagement
Academic Libraries As Hubs For Civic EngagementAcademic Libraries As Hubs For Civic Engagement
Academic Libraries As Hubs For Civic Engagement
Don Dooley
 
Citizenship: How do leaders in universities think about and experience citize...
Citizenship: How do leaders in universities think about and experience citize...Citizenship: How do leaders in universities think about and experience citize...
Citizenship: How do leaders in universities think about and experience citize...
Randy Connolly
 
Essay On Racial Discrimination. 003 Essay Example Discrimination Conclusion R...
Essay On Racial Discrimination. 003 Essay Example Discrimination Conclusion R...Essay On Racial Discrimination. 003 Essay Example Discrimination Conclusion R...
Essay On Racial Discrimination. 003 Essay Example Discrimination Conclusion R...
Kelly Simon
 
Short Essay On My Daily Life. Online assignment writing service.
Short Essay On My Daily Life. Online assignment writing service.Short Essay On My Daily Life. Online assignment writing service.
Short Essay On My Daily Life. Online assignment writing service.
Crystal Hall
 
Londons Digital Neighbourhoods Workshop - Background Paper
Londons Digital Neighbourhoods Workshop - Background PaperLondons Digital Neighbourhoods Workshop - Background Paper
Londons Digital Neighbourhoods Workshop - Background PaperNetworked Neighbourhoods
 
10 Best Printable Journal Paper - Printablee.Com
10 Best Printable Journal Paper - Printablee.Com10 Best Printable Journal Paper - Printablee.Com
10 Best Printable Journal Paper - Printablee.Com
Lisa Jones
 
Community Benefit Agreement Research
Community Benefit Agreement ResearchCommunity Benefit Agreement Research
Community Benefit Agreement Research
Erika Campbell
 
Community Resilience: Pushing the Envelope
Community Resilience: Pushing the EnvelopeCommunity Resilience: Pushing the Envelope
Community Resilience: Pushing the Envelope
American Institute of Architects
 
A9 - Futurecasting Canada: Anticipating the role of community foundations in ...
A9 - Futurecasting Canada: Anticipating the role of community foundations in ...A9 - Futurecasting Canada: Anticipating the role of community foundations in ...
A9 - Futurecasting Canada: Anticipating the role of community foundations in ...
Community Foundations of Canada
 
Recentering Democracy Around Citizens Multimedia Report
Recentering Democracy Around Citizens   Multimedia ReportRecentering Democracy Around Citizens   Multimedia Report
Recentering Democracy Around Citizens Multimedia Report
Matt Leighninger
 
Online social networking
Online social networkingOnline social networking
Online social networking
Gurudutt Reddy
 
Screenplay Format - Format Your Script By Industry Stan
Screenplay Format - Format Your Script By Industry StanScreenplay Format - Format Your Script By Industry Stan
Screenplay Format - Format Your Script By Industry Stan
Jennifer Nulton
 
Community Hub Development_April 2013
Community Hub Development_April 2013Community Hub Development_April 2013
Community Hub Development_April 2013Michael W. Andrews
 
Social Capital, Civic Engagement And The Performance
Social Capital, Civic Engagement And The PerformanceSocial Capital, Civic Engagement And The Performance
Social Capital, Civic Engagement And The Performancecrrcaz
 
Option #1Technology Improvement PlanCommunity developme.docx
Option #1Technology Improvement PlanCommunity developme.docxOption #1Technology Improvement PlanCommunity developme.docx
Option #1Technology Improvement PlanCommunity developme.docx
amit657720
 

Similar to Report back on Community Conversation NOSPACES (20)

Vital_Difference_Final
Vital_Difference_FinalVital_Difference_Final
Vital_Difference_Final
 
CAVR 2009 Parker Speaking Notes
CAVR 2009 Parker Speaking NotesCAVR 2009 Parker Speaking Notes
CAVR 2009 Parker Speaking Notes
 
Civil society strategy Policy Labs
Civil society strategy Policy LabsCivil society strategy Policy Labs
Civil society strategy Policy Labs
 
Red Cross Essay
Red Cross EssayRed Cross Essay
Red Cross Essay
 
Someone's Done that Already: The Best Practices of Sharing Best Practices, pr...
Someone's Done that Already: The Best Practices of Sharing Best Practices, pr...Someone's Done that Already: The Best Practices of Sharing Best Practices, pr...
Someone's Done that Already: The Best Practices of Sharing Best Practices, pr...
 
Academic Libraries As Hubs For Civic Engagement
Academic Libraries As Hubs For Civic EngagementAcademic Libraries As Hubs For Civic Engagement
Academic Libraries As Hubs For Civic Engagement
 
Citizenship: How do leaders in universities think about and experience citize...
Citizenship: How do leaders in universities think about and experience citize...Citizenship: How do leaders in universities think about and experience citize...
Citizenship: How do leaders in universities think about and experience citize...
 
Essay On Racial Discrimination. 003 Essay Example Discrimination Conclusion R...
Essay On Racial Discrimination. 003 Essay Example Discrimination Conclusion R...Essay On Racial Discrimination. 003 Essay Example Discrimination Conclusion R...
Essay On Racial Discrimination. 003 Essay Example Discrimination Conclusion R...
 
Short Essay On My Daily Life. Online assignment writing service.
Short Essay On My Daily Life. Online assignment writing service.Short Essay On My Daily Life. Online assignment writing service.
Short Essay On My Daily Life. Online assignment writing service.
 
Londons Digital Neighbourhoods Workshop - Background Paper
Londons Digital Neighbourhoods Workshop - Background PaperLondons Digital Neighbourhoods Workshop - Background Paper
Londons Digital Neighbourhoods Workshop - Background Paper
 
10 Best Printable Journal Paper - Printablee.Com
10 Best Printable Journal Paper - Printablee.Com10 Best Printable Journal Paper - Printablee.Com
10 Best Printable Journal Paper - Printablee.Com
 
Community Benefit Agreement Research
Community Benefit Agreement ResearchCommunity Benefit Agreement Research
Community Benefit Agreement Research
 
Community Resilience: Pushing the Envelope
Community Resilience: Pushing the EnvelopeCommunity Resilience: Pushing the Envelope
Community Resilience: Pushing the Envelope
 
A9 - Futurecasting Canada: Anticipating the role of community foundations in ...
A9 - Futurecasting Canada: Anticipating the role of community foundations in ...A9 - Futurecasting Canada: Anticipating the role of community foundations in ...
A9 - Futurecasting Canada: Anticipating the role of community foundations in ...
 
Recentering Democracy Around Citizens Multimedia Report
Recentering Democracy Around Citizens   Multimedia ReportRecentering Democracy Around Citizens   Multimedia Report
Recentering Democracy Around Citizens Multimedia Report
 
Online social networking
Online social networkingOnline social networking
Online social networking
 
Screenplay Format - Format Your Script By Industry Stan
Screenplay Format - Format Your Script By Industry StanScreenplay Format - Format Your Script By Industry Stan
Screenplay Format - Format Your Script By Industry Stan
 
Community Hub Development_April 2013
Community Hub Development_April 2013Community Hub Development_April 2013
Community Hub Development_April 2013
 
Social Capital, Civic Engagement And The Performance
Social Capital, Civic Engagement And The PerformanceSocial Capital, Civic Engagement And The Performance
Social Capital, Civic Engagement And The Performance
 
Option #1Technology Improvement PlanCommunity developme.docx
Option #1Technology Improvement PlanCommunity developme.docxOption #1Technology Improvement PlanCommunity developme.docx
Option #1Technology Improvement PlanCommunity developme.docx
 

Report back on Community Conversation NOSPACES

  • 1. Report back on Community Conversation April 6, 2016 ABOUT SHERIDAN’S COMMUNITY WORKER PROGRAM Sheridan’s Community worker program is a two year diploma program for those who are interested in building stronger communities. Graduates have the ability to critically engage in participatory global/local community building through innovative and transformative problem solving to mobilize and create vibrant communities rooted in social justice. ABOUT LAB-B LAB B is the only coworking space in Brampton. Their mission is to develop and sustain the creative economy that currently exists in the city. LAB B has been a heavyweight in maintaining the youth climate in Brampton since 2014 OVERVIEW On April 6, 2016 twenty-five community leaders, youth and changemakers engaged in a community conversation about building a vibrant Brampton for youth. This summary report collates some of the highlights and themes of the community conversation in order to cultivate and harness the ideas and energy for change. The facilitators recorded the conversation and engaged in open coding in order to develop themes of the conversation. While the individual voices of the participants are really important, we elected to record the experiences and analysis of participants anonymously and sought overarching trends to help inform how we can improve the vitality of Brampton. INTRODUCTION When community leaders from LAB B, staff and graduates from Sheridan’s Community Worker program began discussing possible collaborations in December 2015, there was a strong synergy between the community worker program’s grassroots approach and LAB B’s creative community building approach. After a couple of dialogue sessions, we collectively decided that a ‘community conversation’ would help galvanize LAB-B’s base of changemakers. The goal of the ‘community conversation’ was to discuss opportunities, challenges, and barriers impacting Brampton’s vibrancy for youth. The main themes and trends that emerge from our discussion will be represented at a research cafe on April 15 at Sheridan College and published online to share and build on. We set out to have a different “outside of the box” community conversation about building a better city for youth.
  • 2. HOW WE DID IT Sheridan’s Community Worker faculty Abigail Salole, and Community Worker students Holly Vukobrat and Vin Bharadwaj facilitated the community conversation. We wanted to build the conversation from the premise of possibility and curiosity. The session began with two participants reading an excerpt from Margaret Wheatley’s “Turning to one another” (see sidebar). Sidebar: “There is no power greater than a community discovering what it cares about. Ask: “What’s possible?” not “What’s wrong?” Keep asking. Notice what you care about. Assume that many others share your dreams. Be brave enough to start a conversation that matters. Talk to people you know. Talk to people you don’t know. Talk to people you never talk to. Be intrigued by the differences you hear. Expect to be surprised. Treasure curiosity more than certainty. Invite in everybody who cares to work on what’s possible. Acknowledge that everyone is an expert about something. Know that creative solutions come from new connections. Remember, you don’t fear people whose story you know. Real listening always brings people closer together. Trust that meaningful conversations can change your world. Rely on human goodness. Stay together” Next, participants were asked to consider the strengths and challenges of living in Brampton for youth. The focus questions were: What does Brampton do really well for youth? What challenges does Brampton face for youth? Participants wrote these strengths and challenges on sticky notes and shared with other participants as a way to start the conversation. Using strengths and challenges as a way to foster conversation, the next activity involved participants building a shared understanding of a collective context in small groups. Here, participants were asked to use these strengths and challenges as a base to build an understanding of political factors, economic factors, social and cultural factors that inform how youth experience Brampton. In addition, in order to seek novelty and participants were asked to consider the elephant in the room for youth in Brampton. We wanted to invite participants to consider those subjects that are widely known but not often talked about. The findings of this collective context were shared with the entire group. In a storyboard activity, participants were asked to brainstorm the story of the ‘Vibrant City of Brampton for Youth’. Here, participants were asked to consider the ideal future state of Brampton by sketching an ideal vibrant future uses markers and paper provided. Building from the Storyboard conversation, participants were asked to consider the next possible exciting step that everyone in this room could participate in and support that would lead to the vibrant city of Brampton. Groups consider what steps participants could take to get there. Groups were asked to select 1–2 actions from each cluster and then record action items on a piece of paper which clarifies “In order to / We must” worksheet by filling out the “We must” column. Facilitators collected worksheets and sticky notes and chatted further after the structured session. COLLECTIVE CONTEXT: WHERE ARE WE AT? When we were mapping the current context in Brampton, there was a contradictory sense that there was a great deal of enthusiasm and hope for building a more vibrant
  • 3. Brampton for youth while recognizing the very real structural hindrances and challenges for doing so. There were two broad themes from this discussion. 1. LACK OF INTERACTIVE CITY DESIGN The importance of space was a common theme throughout the ‘community conversation’. There were a number of layers to the importance of how space and community design structured the youth experience in Brampton. First, Brampton’s land-use structure is what many have come to know as “typically suburban.” There are mostly designs for single-family residential neighbourhoods that are demarcated from places of employment and consumption. This land use structure is most amenable to transportation based on car travel and perpetuates ‘bedroom communities’ where people return home from work to sleep. Pedestrian, public transit and biking options are limited. Second, there is a shortage of spaces that are designed for interaction between community members. Indeed, there was a strong sense in this conversation that spaces are mostly limited to commercial spaces where the focus is on consumption (and therefore excludes people without money) and/or social services (which were also described as limited). There was some discussion about why spaces like the library or community centers were not seen as viable collective spaces. Some reasons that were discussed were quality of programming, lack of awareness of programming, the low status level that that these collective spaces have with residents. One participant described that a shortage of third spaces (spaces that are neither home nor work spaces) contributes the lack of interaction in community. Of course, there were exceptions to the shortage of collective spaces - LAB-B was an obvious exception pointed out by many participants. Third, Brampton’s proximity to Toronto means that, there is a strong pull towards more vibrant night life and community events outside of Brampton. The importance of space as a salient consideration for the youth experience in Brampton might seem contradictory to the increasing role of online interaction in connecting people. Indeed, people frequently connect with people across time and space and, therefore, social networks or “community” cannot be assumed based on geography. Despite this increasing fluidity, geographical boundaries and identities remain important. One participant lamented how many online meeting apps and interfaces are not successful in Brampton because the numbers of users are insufficient for these applications to have the intended utility. The concern about the lack of these interactive spaces is even more profound in Brampton because it perpetuates ethnic silos which some participants suggest could be challenged by more inter-ethnic/cultural cross pollination. Indeed, racism and NIMBYISM (‘Not In My Back-Yard mentality) were two negative social phenomenon in Brampton that were identified as being perpetuated by a segmented and circumscribed youth population.  LACK OF MEANINGFUL YOUTH CENTERED CIVIC ENGAGEMENT AND OPPORTUNITY While many participants described a number of exciting initiatives that are ‘community building’ initiatives and a promise of burgeoning creative initiatives and industries, participants discussed a dearth of youth centered civic engagement from all three levels
  • 4. of government. Specifically, there is a lack of social infrastructure for youth to access politicians and decision making. In simple terms, participants discussed youth disenfranchisement from meaningful decisions that ran as a theme throughout the conversation. Participants unanimously expressed that there are a lack of initiatives or pathways to meaningful civic engagement in Brampton from government. The reasons offered for this lack of engagement included blatant disregard for youth civic engagement, youth not being represented in government, youth not having cultural capital and decision makers not knowing how to engage young people. Participants discussed how there were few opportunities for youth to engage in meaningful dialogue with political representatives. While a number of initiatives like student voting programs in schools were mentioned, participants found these programs were often empty gestures and politicians did not have the motivation to meaningfully engage youth which helps to contribute to youth disengagement. Participants were unanimously disappointed by the decision from Brampton City Council to vote against the Hurontario-Main LRT, a light rail line, and cited this decision as evidence that the city was not considering the youth demographic, and focusing instead on the ‘elite’ Bramptonians, to inform important city decisions. Without a more visible and concerted effort to curtail youth disenfranchisement, participants spoke with concern about the high youth unemployment rate, high levels of precarious work, increasing income inequality, service allocation and funding issues (for health and social services) and limited government investment in start-ups as particularly concerning realities for youth in Brampton. The more marginalized young people are (those who are marginalized by racism, mental health issues, poverty and other sources of oppression) the more likely to bear the brunt of these social problems. The voices from the community conversation echo and bring to life the concerns depicted in many research reports. While many performance measures for youth in Brampton (and Peel) are generally positive, averages and aggregate information can hide the experiences of the most marginalized in Brampton. For example, the Social Planning Council of Peel (2015) described that many Black youth in Peel feel unwanted, devalued and socially isolated. Income inequality, poverty and precarious work are also important issues that have been identified by other research. For example, the Neighborhood Change Research Partnership (May 2013) examined long-term neighbourhood change trends in parts of the “905 region” of the Toronto census metropolitan area (CMA). Over the period of study (1980-2010) Brampton has increased the number of low and very low-income census tracts from 3.4% to 65.2%. Low and very low-income is defined as less than 40% of the average individual income of the Toronto CMA for the year being considered. This report also demonstrated how middle-income census tracts have decreased from 86% in 1980 to 49% in 2010.
  • 5. TOWARDS A YOUTH CENTERED VIBRANT BRAMPTON Just as participants had keen insights on the strengths, challenges and barriers to building a vibrant Brampton for youth, participants also had strong visions and commitments for change. Indeed, there was a strong sentiment that there is a “rising tide” of creative initiatives within Brampton that could (and should) be cultivated for enhanced city vibrancy. While there are many push and pull factors that draw some youth away Brampton, there was also a strong sense of commitment from Brampton’s youth leaders and adult allies to build a stronger community. Some common elements for change for participants included:  Increased interactivity: A vibrant Brampton would include Brampton residents working together to solve community problems, collective decision making, increased third spaces that build community through entertainment, recreation and public placemaking.  A concerted effort on behalf of government, civil society and third spaces to engage youth in meaningful authentic ways in order to co-create art-based, culture, entrepreneurship and post-secondary opportunities in Brampton.  A strong downtown Brampton that is strongly connected to residents through a strong public transit system including an LRT.  A concerted strategic direction to brand Brampton and develop made-in- Brampton solutions and approaches to city and neighbourhood building.  Revitalization of democracy on local issues including but especially local representation, city planning, public transit and post-secondary opportunities through people-powered change. Many participants are already engaged in initiatives which strengthen Brampton. Participants describe a need for more community conversations where citizen-led initiatives can take root and Brampton residents can support issues and cultivate inspired social change. Plans for the next community conversation are already in motion. This group will continue to grapple with some of the important questions and issues we started in the first community conversation. For example:  How can we build local solutions for change while recognizing the role that social infrastructure and networkers have for democratic participation? That is, neighbourhoods exist in a social context how can we build local solutions that are centered within that social context?
  • 6.  How are can we build creative innovative solutions for a more vibrant Brampton that are inclusive? Can we address pressing social problems like poverty and racism while trying to cultivate Brampton’s creativity and innovation?
  • 7. References Neighbourhood Change Research Partnership (May 2014). Accessed from Neighbourhoodchange.ca Social Planning Council of Peel (2015). The Black Community in Peel Summary: Research Findings from Four Report. Accessed online from: http://www.unitedwaypeel.org/faces/images/summary-sm.pdf