This document discusses structural robustness in engineering. It defines structural robustness as the capacity of a structure to maintain its load-bearing ability after damage, with gradual rather than sudden degradation. The document outlines different levels of structural assessment from the material to the whole structural system. It provides examples of structural failure cases and how robustness can be evaluated through non-linear static analysis methods like pushover analysis. The goal is to identify the most critical structural elements and how a structure may collapse under extreme scenarios.
Effect of modulus of masonry on initial lateral stiffness of infilled frames ...eSAT Publishing House
IJRET : International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology is an international peer reviewed, online journal published by eSAT Publishing House for the enhancement of research in various disciplines of Engineering and Technology. The aim and scope of the journal is to provide an academic medium and an important reference for the advancement and dissemination of research results that support high-level learning, teaching and research in the fields of Engineering and Technology. We bring together Scientists, Academician, Field Engineers, Scholars and Students of related fields of Engineering and Technology.
Bracing elements in structural system plays a vital role in the seismic behaviour of high rise buildings during earthquake. Many of the structural failures in buildings during strong earthquake shaking have indicated that sustainable strength and stable energy dissipation capability are most desirable to maintain inter story drifts and overall structural displacements within tolerable levels. So earthquake action brings a greater concern in the structural design of buildings which is situated in earthquake prone areas. Steel bracing are the common type which mainly used to resist the lateral loads acting during a seismic activity. Conventional types of lateral load resisting systems are concentrically-braced frames (CBFs) and eccentrically braced frames (EBF). Buckling Restrained Braces (BRB) are recent developed structural system which has a stable energy dissipation property. Main advantage of BRB is its ability to yield both in tension and compression without buckling, thus obtaining a stable hysteresis loop. The BRB brace placed in a concentric frame is termed as BRBF system.
Effect of modulus of masonry on initial lateral stiffness of infilled frames ...eSAT Publishing House
IJRET : International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology is an international peer reviewed, online journal published by eSAT Publishing House for the enhancement of research in various disciplines of Engineering and Technology. The aim and scope of the journal is to provide an academic medium and an important reference for the advancement and dissemination of research results that support high-level learning, teaching and research in the fields of Engineering and Technology. We bring together Scientists, Academician, Field Engineers, Scholars and Students of related fields of Engineering and Technology.
Bracing elements in structural system plays a vital role in the seismic behaviour of high rise buildings during earthquake. Many of the structural failures in buildings during strong earthquake shaking have indicated that sustainable strength and stable energy dissipation capability are most desirable to maintain inter story drifts and overall structural displacements within tolerable levels. So earthquake action brings a greater concern in the structural design of buildings which is situated in earthquake prone areas. Steel bracing are the common type which mainly used to resist the lateral loads acting during a seismic activity. Conventional types of lateral load resisting systems are concentrically-braced frames (CBFs) and eccentrically braced frames (EBF). Buckling Restrained Braces (BRB) are recent developed structural system which has a stable energy dissipation property. Main advantage of BRB is its ability to yield both in tension and compression without buckling, thus obtaining a stable hysteresis loop. The BRB brace placed in a concentric frame is termed as BRBF system.
Comparison of Multi-Risers using Stiffness matrix method and Gazetas Semi-Ana...Roshni Ramakrishnan
The most common Superstructure modelling procedure is the fixed base approach which assumes infinite stiffness at the foundation –soil interface. The above assumption is valid only for light structures on very stiff, rocky strata. It is seen that the relative stiffness between the superstructure & foundation is the major influencing factor. The current codes do not specify the provision of Soil-Structure-Interaction effects on the super structure modelling. Literature study showed a large number of case studies of the soil structure interaction effects on the low rise buildings. The S.S.I effect for the low rise buildings is considered to be more severe because of the height as it results in much smaller time period which generally falls in the linearly increasing range in the response spectrum given in IS 1893(Part 1).The linear range gives a higher value of the seismic base shear due to increased period on account of consideration of flexibility of soils. Also the earthquake forces are the predominant dynamic load case for low to medium rise buildings.In the present study, the performance of a set of multi –risers with similar plan, geometric configuration and material properties with variable heights is checked considering the soil structure interaction model with respect to the fixed base model. The assessment of the variation in design due to the soil structure interaction effect is done. For the purpose, the study of various soil structure models was done and the pros and cons of each model were studied and a comparative assessment was done to find the best suitable model for the problem in consideration. The IS code specifications for the dynamic load case analysis of structures were studied to know the assumptions made for the dynamic analysis of structures and also select the best soil structure model. The most common dynamic load analysis methods for . the R.C.C buildings are the equivalent lateral force method and the response spectrum method for the seismic forces and the wind load analysis is done using the static method of application of wind forces calculated from the wind pressure which is dependent on the basic wind speed. Hence the representation of soil medium as static springs whose stiffness values are calculated using a continuum method where the soil is viewed as a continuum with elastic properties and the solution involves rigid body motion equations and the matrix of dynamic influence is solved using various methods like Laplace’s transformations, Fourier transformations etc. The paper “Analysis of Machine foundation vibrations” by George Gazetas has given the various soil models and the different methodologies used in the solutions which was used as reference to compute the spring stiffness. The fixed base analysis was done and an appropriate foundation was arrived at. The direct method of the interaction study in which the soil element represented as static springs using continuum are applied to the structure.
Damage tolerance evaluation of wing in presence of large landing gear cutout ...eSAT Journals
Abstract Aircraft is symbol of a high performance mechanical structure, which has the ability to fly with a very high structural safety record. Aircraft experiences variable loading in service. Rarely an aircraft will fail due to a static overload during its service life. For the continued airworthiness of an aircraft during its entire economic service life, fatigue and damage tolerance design, analysis, testing and service experience correlation play a pivotal role. The present study includes the stress analysis and damage tolerance evaluation of the wing through a stiffened panel of the bottom skin with a landing gear cutout. Wing bottom skin experiences tensile stress field during flight. Cutouts required for fuel access and landing gear opening and retraction in the bottom skin will introduce stress concentration. Fatigue cracks will initiate from high tensile stress locations. An integral stiffened panel consisting a landing gear cutout is considered for the analysis. Stress analysis will identify the maximum tensile stress location in the panel. In a metallic structure fatigue manifests itself in the form of a crack which propagates. If the crack in a critical location goes unnoticed it could lead to a catastrophic failure of the airframe. A critical condition will occur when the stress intensity factor (SIF) at the crack tip becomes equal to fracture toughness of the material. SIF calculations will be carried out for a crack with incremental crack lengths using MVCCI method. Analytical evaluation of the crack arrest capability of the stiffening members ahead of the crack tip will be carried out. Index Terms: Key Aircraft, Design, wing, landing gear cutout, stress analysis, FEM, damage tolerance, integral stiffened panel.
Damage tolerance evaluation of wing in presence of large landing gear cutout ...eSAT Publishing House
IJRET : International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology is an international peer reviewed, online journal published by eSAT Publishing House for the enhancement of research in various disciplines of Engineering and Technology. The aim and scope of the journal is to provide an academic medium and an important reference for the advancement and dissemination of research results that support high-level learning, teaching and research in the fields of Engineering and Technology. We bring together Scientists, Academician, Field Engineers, Scholars and Students of related fields of Engineering and Technology
Structural robustness analysis of RC frames under seismic and blast chained l...Franco Bontempi
In this paper the structural robustness assessment of concrete frame buildings under blast and under earthquake blast hazard chain scenarios is investigated. A deterministic methodology for connecting
the robustness with the blast hazard intensity and for conducting the robustness analysis under earthquake-triggered blast is presented and applied to a 3D RC frame building by implementing nonlinear time history analyses considering both plastic behavior and large displacements.
A preliminary sensitivity analysis on a 2D frame is conducted to identify the critical analysis
parameters influencing the results. The robustness curves (residual structural capacity versus the level of damage occurring in the structure), evaluated both for the blast-only and for the earthquake-blast chained cases, are compared by considering different explosion locations inside the building (location of the blast-induced structural damage). Results show that neglecting the chained load scenarios would lead to the identification of an erroneous location as critical for the
structural robustness performance.
Comparison of Multi-Risers using Stiffness matrix method and Gazetas Semi-Ana...Roshni Ramakrishnan
The most common Superstructure modelling procedure is the fixed base approach which assumes infinite stiffness at the foundation –soil interface. The above assumption is valid only for light structures on very stiff, rocky strata. It is seen that the relative stiffness between the superstructure & foundation is the major influencing factor. The current codes do not specify the provision of Soil-Structure-Interaction effects on the super structure modelling. Literature study showed a large number of case studies of the soil structure interaction effects on the low rise buildings. The S.S.I effect for the low rise buildings is considered to be more severe because of the height as it results in much smaller time period which generally falls in the linearly increasing range in the response spectrum given in IS 1893(Part 1).The linear range gives a higher value of the seismic base shear due to increased period on account of consideration of flexibility of soils. Also the earthquake forces are the predominant dynamic load case for low to medium rise buildings.In the present study, the performance of a set of multi –risers with similar plan, geometric configuration and material properties with variable heights is checked considering the soil structure interaction model with respect to the fixed base model. The assessment of the variation in design due to the soil structure interaction effect is done. For the purpose, the study of various soil structure models was done and the pros and cons of each model were studied and a comparative assessment was done to find the best suitable model for the problem in consideration. The IS code specifications for the dynamic load case analysis of structures were studied to know the assumptions made for the dynamic analysis of structures and also select the best soil structure model. The most common dynamic load analysis methods for . the R.C.C buildings are the equivalent lateral force method and the response spectrum method for the seismic forces and the wind load analysis is done using the static method of application of wind forces calculated from the wind pressure which is dependent on the basic wind speed. Hence the representation of soil medium as static springs whose stiffness values are calculated using a continuum method where the soil is viewed as a continuum with elastic properties and the solution involves rigid body motion equations and the matrix of dynamic influence is solved using various methods like Laplace’s transformations, Fourier transformations etc. The paper “Analysis of Machine foundation vibrations” by George Gazetas has given the various soil models and the different methodologies used in the solutions which was used as reference to compute the spring stiffness. The fixed base analysis was done and an appropriate foundation was arrived at. The direct method of the interaction study in which the soil element represented as static springs using continuum are applied to the structure.
Damage tolerance evaluation of wing in presence of large landing gear cutout ...eSAT Journals
Abstract Aircraft is symbol of a high performance mechanical structure, which has the ability to fly with a very high structural safety record. Aircraft experiences variable loading in service. Rarely an aircraft will fail due to a static overload during its service life. For the continued airworthiness of an aircraft during its entire economic service life, fatigue and damage tolerance design, analysis, testing and service experience correlation play a pivotal role. The present study includes the stress analysis and damage tolerance evaluation of the wing through a stiffened panel of the bottom skin with a landing gear cutout. Wing bottom skin experiences tensile stress field during flight. Cutouts required for fuel access and landing gear opening and retraction in the bottom skin will introduce stress concentration. Fatigue cracks will initiate from high tensile stress locations. An integral stiffened panel consisting a landing gear cutout is considered for the analysis. Stress analysis will identify the maximum tensile stress location in the panel. In a metallic structure fatigue manifests itself in the form of a crack which propagates. If the crack in a critical location goes unnoticed it could lead to a catastrophic failure of the airframe. A critical condition will occur when the stress intensity factor (SIF) at the crack tip becomes equal to fracture toughness of the material. SIF calculations will be carried out for a crack with incremental crack lengths using MVCCI method. Analytical evaluation of the crack arrest capability of the stiffening members ahead of the crack tip will be carried out. Index Terms: Key Aircraft, Design, wing, landing gear cutout, stress analysis, FEM, damage tolerance, integral stiffened panel.
Damage tolerance evaluation of wing in presence of large landing gear cutout ...eSAT Publishing House
IJRET : International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology is an international peer reviewed, online journal published by eSAT Publishing House for the enhancement of research in various disciplines of Engineering and Technology. The aim and scope of the journal is to provide an academic medium and an important reference for the advancement and dissemination of research results that support high-level learning, teaching and research in the fields of Engineering and Technology. We bring together Scientists, Academician, Field Engineers, Scholars and Students of related fields of Engineering and Technology
Structural robustness analysis of RC frames under seismic and blast chained l...Franco Bontempi
In this paper the structural robustness assessment of concrete frame buildings under blast and under earthquake blast hazard chain scenarios is investigated. A deterministic methodology for connecting
the robustness with the blast hazard intensity and for conducting the robustness analysis under earthquake-triggered blast is presented and applied to a 3D RC frame building by implementing nonlinear time history analyses considering both plastic behavior and large displacements.
A preliminary sensitivity analysis on a 2D frame is conducted to identify the critical analysis
parameters influencing the results. The robustness curves (residual structural capacity versus the level of damage occurring in the structure), evaluated both for the blast-only and for the earthquake-blast chained cases, are compared by considering different explosion locations inside the building (location of the blast-induced structural damage). Results show that neglecting the chained load scenarios would lead to the identification of an erroneous location as critical for the
structural robustness performance.
ANALISI DEL RISCHIO PER LA SICUREZZA NELLE GALLERIE STRADALI.Franco Bontempi
SOMMARIO
Il tema della sicurezza, quando si parla di gallerie stradali, assume ancora più importanza, dato che un banale incidente o un guasto di un veicolo possono degenerare in uno scenario che causa un elevato numero di vittime. Ad esempio, il 24 marzo 1999, 39 persone sono rimaste uccise quando un mezzo pesante che trasportava farina e margarina prese fuoco all’interno del Tunnel del Monte Bianco. Nella prima parte dell’articolo vengono spiegate le fasi logiche che un modello messo a disposizione dalla PIARC/OECD, il Quantitative Risk Assessment Model (QRAM) [1-2], segue nel processo di Assegnazione del Rischio, e come esso ricava i valori dei relativi indicatori. Nella seconda parte dell’articolo, invece, viene mostrata un’applicazione di tale modello su una galleria esistente che si trova nel sud Italia, accompagnata da un’analisi di sensitività sui parametri che influenzano maggiormente il livello di rischio.
RISK ANALYSIS FOR SEVERE TRAFFIC ACCIDENTS IN ROAD TUNNELSFranco Bontempi
IF CRASC’15
III THIRD CONGRESS ON FORENSIC ENGINEERING
VI CONGRESS ON COLLAPSES, RELIABILITY AND RETROFIT OF STRUCTURES
SAPIENZA UNIVERSITY OF ROME, 14-16 MAY 2015
Appunti sulle modellazioni discrete per ponti e viadotti.
Corso di GESTIONE DI PONTI E GRANDI STRUTTURE, prof. ing. Franco Bontempi, Sapienza Universita' di Roma
PGS - lezione 03 - IMPALCATO DA PONTE E PIASTRE.pdfFranco Bontempi
Appunti su piastre per impalcati di ponti e viadotti.
Corso di GESTIONE DI PONTI E GRANDO STRUTTRE, prof. ing. Franco Bontempi, Sapienza Universita' di Roma
Welcome to WIPAC Monthly the magazine brought to you by the LinkedIn Group Water Industry Process Automation & Control.
In this month's edition, along with this month's industry news to celebrate the 13 years since the group was created we have articles including
A case study of the used of Advanced Process Control at the Wastewater Treatment works at Lleida in Spain
A look back on an article on smart wastewater networks in order to see how the industry has measured up in the interim around the adoption of Digital Transformation in the Water Industry.
Sachpazis:Terzaghi Bearing Capacity Estimation in simple terms with Calculati...Dr.Costas Sachpazis
Terzaghi's soil bearing capacity theory, developed by Karl Terzaghi, is a fundamental principle in geotechnical engineering used to determine the bearing capacity of shallow foundations. This theory provides a method to calculate the ultimate bearing capacity of soil, which is the maximum load per unit area that the soil can support without undergoing shear failure. The Calculation HTML Code included.
Online aptitude test management system project report.pdfKamal Acharya
The purpose of on-line aptitude test system is to take online test in an efficient manner and no time wasting for checking the paper. The main objective of on-line aptitude test system is to efficiently evaluate the candidate thoroughly through a fully automated system that not only saves lot of time but also gives fast results. For students they give papers according to their convenience and time and there is no need of using extra thing like paper, pen etc. This can be used in educational institutions as well as in corporate world. Can be used anywhere any time as it is a web based application (user Location doesn’t matter). No restriction that examiner has to be present when the candidate takes the test.
Every time when lecturers/professors need to conduct examinations they have to sit down think about the questions and then create a whole new set of questions for each and every exam. In some cases the professor may want to give an open book online exam that is the student can take the exam any time anywhere, but the student might have to answer the questions in a limited time period. The professor may want to change the sequence of questions for every student. The problem that a student has is whenever a date for the exam is declared the student has to take it and there is no way he can take it at some other time. This project will create an interface for the examiner to create and store questions in a repository. It will also create an interface for the student to take examinations at his convenience and the questions and/or exams may be timed. Thereby creating an application which can be used by examiners and examinee’s simultaneously.
Examination System is very useful for Teachers/Professors. As in the teaching profession, you are responsible for writing question papers. In the conventional method, you write the question paper on paper, keep question papers separate from answers and all this information you have to keep in a locker to avoid unauthorized access. Using the Examination System you can create a question paper and everything will be written to a single exam file in encrypted format. You can set the General and Administrator password to avoid unauthorized access to your question paper. Every time you start the examination, the program shuffles all the questions and selects them randomly from the database, which reduces the chances of memorizing the questions.
NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER IN CONDENSING HEAT EXCHANGERS...ssuser7dcef0
Power plants release a large amount of water vapor into the
atmosphere through the stack. The flue gas can be a potential
source for obtaining much needed cooling water for a power
plant. If a power plant could recover and reuse a portion of this
moisture, it could reduce its total cooling water intake
requirement. One of the most practical way to recover water
from flue gas is to use a condensing heat exchanger. The power
plant could also recover latent heat due to condensation as well
as sensible heat due to lowering the flue gas exit temperature.
Additionally, harmful acids released from the stack can be
reduced in a condensing heat exchanger by acid condensation. reduced in a condensing heat exchanger by acid condensation.
Condensation of vapors in flue gas is a complicated
phenomenon since heat and mass transfer of water vapor and
various acids simultaneously occur in the presence of noncondensable
gases such as nitrogen and oxygen. Design of a
condenser depends on the knowledge and understanding of the
heat and mass transfer processes. A computer program for
numerical simulations of water (H2O) and sulfuric acid (H2SO4)
condensation in a flue gas condensing heat exchanger was
developed using MATLAB. Governing equations based on
mass and energy balances for the system were derived to
predict variables such as flue gas exit temperature, cooling
water outlet temperature, mole fraction and condensation rates
of water and sulfuric acid vapors. The equations were solved
using an iterative solution technique with calculations of heat
and mass transfer coefficients and physical properties.
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine LearningSUTEJAS
This presentation explores the concept of inductive bias in machine learning. It explains how algorithms come with built-in assumptions and preferences that guide the learning process. You'll learn about the different types of inductive bias and how they can impact the performance and generalizability of machine learning models.
The presentation also covers the positive and negative aspects of inductive bias, along with strategies for mitigating potential drawbacks. We'll explore examples of how bias manifests in algorithms like neural networks and decision trees.
By understanding inductive bias, you can gain valuable insights into how machine learning models work and make informed decisions when building and deploying them.
An Approach to Detecting Writing Styles Based on Clustering Techniquesambekarshweta25
An Approach to Detecting Writing Styles Based on Clustering Techniques
Authors:
-Devkinandan Jagtap
-Shweta Ambekar
-Harshit Singh
-Nakul Sharma (Assistant Professor)
Institution:
VIIT Pune, India
Abstract:
This paper proposes a system to differentiate between human-generated and AI-generated texts using stylometric analysis. The system analyzes text files and classifies writing styles by employing various clustering algorithms, such as k-means, k-means++, hierarchical, and DBSCAN. The effectiveness of these algorithms is measured using silhouette scores. The system successfully identifies distinct writing styles within documents, demonstrating its potential for plagiarism detection.
Introduction:
Stylometry, the study of linguistic and structural features in texts, is used for tasks like plagiarism detection, genre separation, and author verification. This paper leverages stylometric analysis to identify different writing styles and improve plagiarism detection methods.
Methodology:
The system includes data collection, preprocessing, feature extraction, dimensional reduction, machine learning models for clustering, and performance comparison using silhouette scores. Feature extraction focuses on lexical features, vocabulary richness, and readability scores. The study uses a small dataset of texts from various authors and employs algorithms like k-means, k-means++, hierarchical clustering, and DBSCAN for clustering.
Results:
Experiments show that the system effectively identifies writing styles, with silhouette scores indicating reasonable to strong clustering when k=2. As the number of clusters increases, the silhouette scores decrease, indicating a drop in accuracy. K-means and k-means++ perform similarly, while hierarchical clustering is less optimized.
Conclusion and Future Work:
The system works well for distinguishing writing styles with two clusters but becomes less accurate as the number of clusters increases. Future research could focus on adding more parameters and optimizing the methodology to improve accuracy with higher cluster values. This system can enhance existing plagiarism detection tools, especially in academic settings.
Forklift Classes Overview by Intella PartsIntella Parts
Discover the different forklift classes and their specific applications. Learn how to choose the right forklift for your needs to ensure safety, efficiency, and compliance in your operations.
For more technical information, visit our website https://intellaparts.com
Hybrid optimization of pumped hydro system and solar- Engr. Abdul-Azeez.pdffxintegritypublishin
Advancements in technology unveil a myriad of electrical and electronic breakthroughs geared towards efficiently harnessing limited resources to meet human energy demands. The optimization of hybrid solar PV panels and pumped hydro energy supply systems plays a pivotal role in utilizing natural resources effectively. This initiative not only benefits humanity but also fosters environmental sustainability. The study investigated the design optimization of these hybrid systems, focusing on understanding solar radiation patterns, identifying geographical influences on solar radiation, formulating a mathematical model for system optimization, and determining the optimal configuration of PV panels and pumped hydro storage. Through a comparative analysis approach and eight weeks of data collection, the study addressed key research questions related to solar radiation patterns and optimal system design. The findings highlighted regions with heightened solar radiation levels, showcasing substantial potential for power generation and emphasizing the system's efficiency. Optimizing system design significantly boosted power generation, promoted renewable energy utilization, and enhanced energy storage capacity. The study underscored the benefits of optimizing hybrid solar PV panels and pumped hydro energy supply systems for sustainable energy usage. Optimizing the design of solar PV panels and pumped hydro energy supply systems as examined across diverse climatic conditions in a developing country, not only enhances power generation but also improves the integration of renewable energy sources and boosts energy storage capacities, particularly beneficial for less economically prosperous regions. Additionally, the study provides valuable insights for advancing energy research in economically viable areas. Recommendations included conducting site-specific assessments, utilizing advanced modeling tools, implementing regular maintenance protocols, and enhancing communication among system components.
Technical Drawings introduction to drawing of prisms
Progettazione Strutturale Antincendio. ROBUSTEZZA
1. Progettazione Strutturale Antincendio
ROBUSTEZZA STRUTTURALE
Franco Bontempi
Professore Ordinario di Tecnica delle Costruzioni
Facoltà di Ingegneria Civile e Industriale
Sapienza Università di Roma
franco.bontempi@uniroma1.it
2. Can an airplane crash
because
it punctured a tire?
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 2
10. 1. During takeoff from runway 26 right at Roissy
Charles de Gaulle Airport, shortly before
rotation, the front right tyre (tyre No 2) of the
left landing gear ran over a strip of metal, which
had fallen from another aircraft, and was
damaged.
2. Debris was thrown against the wing structure
leading to a rupture of tank 5.
3. A major fire, fuelled by the leak, broke out
almost immediately under the left wing.
4. Problems appeared shortly afterwards on
engine 2 and for a brief period on engine 1.
5. The aircraft took off. The crew shut down
engine 2, then only operating at near idle
power, following an engine fire alarm.
6. They noticed that the landing gear would not
retract.
7. The aircraft flew for around a minute at a speed
of 200 kt and at a radio altitude of 200 feet, but
was unable to gain height or speed. Engine 1
then lost thrust, the aircraftªs angle of attack
and bank increased sharply. The thrust on
engines 3 and 4 fell suddenly.
8. The aircraft crashed onto a hotel.
17/03/2023 10
PSA - Robustezza Strutturale
19. • Capacity of a construction to show regular
decrease of its structural quality due to
negative causes.
• It implies:
a) some smoothness of the decrease of
structural performance due to negative
events (intensive feature);
b) some limited spatial spread of the
rupture (extensive feature).
19
Structural Robustness (2)
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale
38. Bad vs Good Collapse
STRUCTURE
& LOADS
Collapse
Mechanism
NO SWAY
“IMPLOSION”
OF THE
STRUCTURE
“EXPLOSION”
OF THE
STRUCTURE
is a process in which
objects are destroyed by
collapsing on themselves
is a process
NOT CONFINED
SWAY
38
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale
48. Bad vs Good Collapse
STRUCTURE
& LOADS
Collapse
Mechanism
NO SWAY
“IMPLOSION”
OF THE
STRUCTURE
“EXPLOSION”
OF THE
STRUCTURE
is a process in which
objects are destroyed by
collapsing on themselves
is a process
NOT CONFINED
SWAY
48
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale
49. • Capacity of a construction to show regular
decrease of its structural quality due to
negative causes.
• It implies:
a) some smoothness of the decrease of
structural performance due to negative
events (intensive feature);
b) some limited spatial spread of the
rupture (extensive feature).
49
Structural Robustness (2)
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale
110. 0
4
Lo scenario D4
è quello più cattivo:
l’elemento strutturale
critico individuato è la
colonna più esterna!
110
Sintesi dei risultati: elemento critico
110
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale
138. Definizioni: compartimentazione
• CAPACITÀ DI COMPARTIMENTAZIONE IN CASO
D’INCENDIO: attitudine di un elemento costruttivo a
conservare, sotto l’azione del fuoco, oltre alla propria
stabilità, un sufficiente isolamento termico ed una
sufficiente tenuta ai fumi e ai gas caldi della
combustione, nonché tutte le altre prestazioni se
richieste.
• COMPARTIMENTO ANTINCENDIO: parte della
costruzione organizzata per rispondere alle esigenze
della sicurezza in caso di incendio e delimitata da
elementi costruttivi idonei a garantire, sotto l’azione del
fuoco e per un dato intervallo di tempo, la capacità di
compartimentazione.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 138
145. For six days in January 1998, freezing rain coated
Ontario, Quebec and New Brunswick with 7-11
cm (3-4 in) of ice. Trees and hydro wires fell and
utility poles and transmission towers came
down causing massive power outages, some for
as long as a month. It was the most expensive
natural disaster in Canada. According to
Environment Canada, the ice storm of 1998
directly affected more people than any other
previous weather event in Canadian history.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 145
197. 1) Minimum number of removed hangers and most sensitive location for
the triggering of the progressive collapse: the bridge results to be more
sensible to the damage at mid-span, where the removal of just 5 hanger
for the symmetrical rupture and 7 hangers for the asymmetrical rupture is
needed in order to trigger the collapse propagation.
Shifting the initial damage location aside (about at 1/3 of the span) the
asymmetrical rupture of 9 hangers is required for the collapse propagation,
while moving the initial damage near the tower even the asymmetrical
removal of 12 hangers has no global effects on the structure and very 7
hangers must be symmetrically removed on both sides in order to trigger
the propagation of the ruptures on the adjoining hangers.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 197
198. 2) Preferential direction for the collapse propagation: to the higher damage sensibility of
the bridge central zone counterpoises a lower acceleration of the collapse progression
triggered by central ruptures, with respect to that one triggered by lateral ruptures.
This effect is due to the particular configuration of the structural system that requires a
growing hanger length from the centre to the sides of the bridge: when a chain rupture
trigger, the ultimate elongation required to the hangers adjoining the failed ones increases
as the collapse propagates (because the unsupported deck length also increases).
If the initial damage occurs at mid-span, it involves the shortest hangers and the collapse
propagation is partially slowed down from the growing element ductility of sideward
hangers. On the contrary, a more intense initial damage is required sideways to trigger
chain ruptures, but then the hanger breakdowns speeds up when moving toward the
centre, where the hanger length decreases.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 198
199. 3) Qualitative measure that could possibly lead the collapse to an halt: in the case of a
central rupture a closer increment in the section of the hangers (that remain instead the
same for about 5/6 of the span length) could possibly provide for a collapse standstill. In
the case of a chain rupture triggered in a lateral zone the preferential direction showed by
the progressive collapse would probably make less effective such a measure.
3) Qualitative measure that could possibly lead the collapse to an halt: in the case of a
central rupture a closer increment in the section of the hangers (that remain instead the
same for about 5/6 of the span length) could possibly provide for a collapse standstill. In
the case of a chain rupture triggered in a lateral zone the preferential direction showed
by the progressive collapse would probably make less effective such a measure.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 199
200. 4) Sensibility to modality of damage (asymmetrical or symmetrical failure): another
consideration about the possible collapse standstill concerns the higher susceptibility of
the bridge to an unsymmetrical hanger failure than to a symmetrical one: in the last case
the symmetrical hinge formations determines a symmetrical moment increment on the
deck box-girders, thus possibly allowing for an early deck segment detachment that would
arrest the collapse
4) Sensibility to modality of damage (asymmetrical or
symmetrical failure): another consideration about the
possible collapse standstill concerns the higher susceptibility
of the bridge to an unsymmetrical hanger failure than to a
symmetrical one: in the last case the symmetrical hinge
formations determines a symmetrical moment increment
on the deck box-girders, thus possibly allowing for an early
deck segment detachment that would arrest the collapse
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 200
213. Eccesso di Norme Tecniche
• «Ma un numero di regole eccessivo comporta vari degli
inconvenienti dianzi citati e in particolare:
- l'impoverimento dell'autonomia e della creatività, in
quanto l'opera del progettista è irretita dalle norme;
- la difficoltà di discernere ciò che veramente conta;
- la sensazione di avere, al riparo delle norme,
responsabilità assai alleviate;
- la difficoltà non infrequente di rendersi conto dei
ragionamenti che giustificano certe regole, rischiando
di considerare queste alla stregua di algoritmi, ossia di
schemi operativi che, una volta appresi, il pensiero non
è più chiamato a giustificare.»
- Proliferazione delle normative e tecnicismo. Ultima lezione ufficiale del corso di Tecnica delle costruzioni tenuta dal prof. Piero Pozzati
- nell'a.a. 1991-'92, presso la Facoltà di Ingegneria dell'Università di Bologna (3 giugno 1992).
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 213
224. Brutal audit
• The ability to deal with a crisis is largely dependent
on the structures that have been developed before
chaos arrives.
• The event can in some ways be considered as an
abrupt and brutal audit: at a moment’s notice,
everything that was left unprepared becomes a
complex problem, and every weakness comes
rushing to the forefront.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 224
225. Small events
• Small events have large consequences.
• Small discrepancies give off small clues that are hard to
spot but easy to treat if they are spotted.
• When clues become much more visible, they are that
much harder to treat.
• Managing the unexpected often means that people
have to make strong responses to weak signals,
something that is counterintuitive and not very heroic.
• Normally, we make weak responses to weak signals and
strong responses to strong signals.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 225
227. Butterfly Effect
• The meteorologist Edward Lorenz discovered that a
simple model of heat convection possesses intrinsic
unpredictability, a circumstance he called the
“butterfly effect,” suggesting that the mere flapping
of a butterfly’s wing can change the weather.
• A more homely example is the pinball machine: the
ball’s movements are precisely governed by laws of
gravitational rolling and elastic collisions—both
fully understood—yet the final outcome is
unpredictable.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 227
228. Chaos Theory (1)
• Chaos theory concerns deterministic systems whose
behavior can in principle be predicted. Chaotic systems
are predictable for a while and then 'appear' to become
random.
• The amount of time that the behavior of a chaotic
system can be effectively predicted depends on three
things:
❑how much uncertainty can be tolerated in the forecast,
❑how accurately its current state can be measured,
❑and a time scale depending on the dynamics of the
system, called the Lyapunov time.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 228
229. Chaos Theory (2)
• In chaotic systems, the uncertainty in a forecast
increases exponentially with elapsed time. Hence,
mathematically, doubling the forecast time more
than squares the proportional uncertainty in the
forecast. This means, in practice, a meaningful
prediction cannot be made over an interval of more
than two or three times the Lyapunov time.
• When meaningful predictions cannot be made, the
system appears random.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 229
232. Authorities vs Experts
• Systems that mismanage the unexpected tend to
ignore small failures, accept simple diagnoses, take
frontline operations for granted, neglect
capabilities for resilience, and defer to authorities
rather than experts
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 232
236. High Reliability Organization (HRO)
• A high reliability organization (HRO) is an organization
that has succeeded in avoiding catastrophes in an
environment where normal accidents can be expected
due to risk factors and complexity.
• Important case studies in HRO research include both
studies of disasters (e.g., Three Mile Island nuclear
incident, the Challenger explosion and Columbia
explosion, the Bhopal chemical leak, the Tenerife air
crash, the Mann Gulch forest fire, the Black Hawk
friendly fire incident in Iraq) and cases like the air traffic
control system, naval aircraft carriers, and nuclear
power operations.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 236
242. Mindfulness (1)
• Mindfulness – a rich awareness of discriminatory
detail and an enhanced ability to discover and
correct errors that could escalate into a crisis.
• By mindful, one also means striving to maintain an
underlying style of mental functioning that is
distinguished by continuous updating and
deepening of increasingly plausible interpretations
of the context, what problems define it, and what
remedies it contains.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 242
243. Mindfulness (2)
• The big difference between functioning in HROs
and in other organizations is often most evident in
the early stages when the unexpected gives off only
weak signals of trouble.
• The overwhelming tendency is to respond to weak
signals with a weak response. Mindfulness
preserves the capability to see the significance of
weak signals and to respond vigorously.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 243
244. Mindfulness Defined
1. combination of ongoing scrutiny of existing
expectations,
2. continuous refinement and differentiation of
expectations based on newer experiences,
3. willingness and capability to invent new expectations
that make sense of unprecedented events,
4. a more nuanced appreciation of context and ways to
deal with it,
5. and identification of new dimensions of context that
improve foresight and current functioning.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 244
245. Detection, Containment,
Resilience
• One attributes the success of HROs in managing the
unexpected to their determined efforts to act
mindfully.
1) By this one means that they organize themselves in
such a way that they are better able to notice the
unexpected in the making and halt its development.
2) If they have difficulty halting the development of the
unexpected, they focus on containing it.
3) And if the unexpected breaks through the
containment, they focus on resilience and swift
restoration of system functioning.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 245
246. Resilience
• To be resilient is to be mindful about errors that
have already occurred and to correct them before
they worsen and cause more serious harm.
• Resilience encourages people to act while thinking
or to act in order to think more clearly.
• Resilience is about bouncing back from errors and
about coping with surprises in the moment.
• Achieved through an extensive action repertoire
and skills with improvisation.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 246
247. Note
• Mindfulness also involves preferences that are diverse; close
attention to situations; resilience in the face of events;
sensemaking that shows whether a decision is necessary;
people with diverse interests who debate, speak up, and
listen to one another; and designs that are malleable rather
than fixed.
• When you try to move toward mindfulness, there is
resistance, partly because of threats to psychology safety.
• After all, it’s a whole lot easier to bask in success, keep it
simple, follow routines, avoid trouble, and do an adequate
job. I know how to do those things. But dwell on failure?
Question my assumptions? Linger over details? Fight fires
creatively? Ask for help? No thanks. Or more likely, “You
first!”
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 247
249. Mindlessness (1)
• When people function mindlessly, they don’t
understand either themselves or their
environments, but they feel as though they do.
• A silent contributor to mindlessness is the zeal
found in most firms for planning. Plans act the
same way as expectations. They guide people to
search narrowly for confirmation that the plan is
correct.
• Mindlessness is more likely when people are
distracted, hurried, or overloaded.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 249
250. Mindlessness (2)
• A tendency toward mindlessness is characterized by a style
of mental functioning in which people follow recipes,
impose old categories to classify what they see, act with
some rigidity, operate on automatic pilot, and mislabel
unfamiliar new contexts as familiar old ones.
• A mindless mental style works to conceal problems that are
worsening.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 250
251. Mindless Control Systems
• It is impossible to manage any organization solely
by means of mindless control systems that depend
on rules, plans, routines, stable categories, and
fixed criteria for correct performance.
• No one knows enough to design such a system so
that it can cope with a dynamic environment.
• Instead, designers who want to hold dynamic
systems together must organize in ways that evoke
mindful work.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 251
252. Plans, visions and forecast
• Plans and visions and forecasts are inaccurate and gain
much of their power from efforts to avoid disconfirmation.
• You’ll also discover that plans and visions and forecasts
create blind spots.
• Corrections to those inaccuracies lie in the hands of those
who have a deeper grasp of how things really work. And
that grasp comes from mindfulness.
• People who act mindfully notice and pursue that rich,
neglected remainder of information that mindless actors
leave unnoticed and untouched. Mindful people hold
complex projects together because they understand what is
happening.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 252
253. Mindless/Mindful Investments
• To manage the unexpected is to be reliably mindful,
not reliably mindless.
• Obvious as that may sound, those who invest
heavily in plans, standard operating procedures,
protocols, recipes, and routines tend to invest more
heavily in mindlessness than in mindfulness.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 253
257. HRO Principle 1:
Preoccupation with failure.
• HROs are distinctive because they are preoccupied
with failure.
• They treat any lapse as a symptom that something
may be wrong with the system, something that
could have severe consequences if several separate
small errors happened to coincide.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 257
258. Note
• HROs encourage reporting of errors, they elaborate
experiences of a near miss for what can be learned,
and they are wary of the potential liabilities of
success, including complacency, the temptation to
reduce margins of safety, and the drift into
automatic processing.
• They also make a continuing effort to articulate
mistakes they don’t want to make and assess the
likelihood that strategies increase the risk of
triggering these mistakes.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 258
259. HRO Principle 2:
Reluctance to simplify.
• Another way HROs manage for the unexpected is by
being reluctant to accept simplifications.
• It is certainly true that success in any coordinated
activity requires that people simplify in order to stay
focused on a handful of key issues and key indicators.
But it is also true that less simplification allows you to
see more. HROs take deliberate steps to create more
complete and nuanced pictures of what they face and
who they are as they face it.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 259
260. Note
• Knowing that the world they face is complex, unstable,
unknowable, and unpredictable, HROs position themselves
to see as much as possible.
• They welcome diverse experience, skepticism toward
received wisdom, and negotiating tactics that reconcile
differences of opinion without destroying the nuances that
diverse people detect.
• When they “recognize” an event as something they have
experienced before and understood, that recognition is a
source of concern rather than comfort. The concern is that
superficial similarities between the present and the past
mask deeper differences that could prove fatal.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 260
261. HRO Principle 3:
Sensitivity to operations.
• HROs are sensitive to operations.
• They are attentive to the front line, where the real
work gets done. The “big picture” in HROs is less
strategic and more situational than is true of most
other organizations.
• When people have well-developed situational
awareness, they can make the continuous
adjustments that prevent errors from accumulating
and enlarging.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 261
262. Note
• Anomalies are noticed while they are still tractable
and can still be isolated.
• All of this is made possible because HROs are aware
of the close ties between sensitivity to operations
and sensitivity to relationships.
• People who refuse to speak up out of fear
undermine the system, which knows less than it
needs to know to work effectively.
• People in HROs know that you can’t develop a big
picture of operations if the symptoms of those
operations are withheld.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 262
263. HRO Principle 4:
Commitment to resilience.
• No system is perfect. HROs know this as well as
anyone.
• This is why they complement their anticipatory
activities of learning from failure, complicating their
perceptions, and remaining sensitive to operations
with a commitment to resilience.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 263
264. Note
• The essence of resilience is therefore the intrinsic
ability of an organization (system) to maintain or
regain a dynamically stable state, which allows it to
continue operations after a major mishap and/or in
the presence of a continuous stress.
• HROs develop capabilities to detect, contain, and
bounce back from those inevitable errors that are
part of an indeterminate world.
• The hallmark of an HRO is not that it is error-free
but that errors don’t disable it.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 264
265. Note
• Resilience is a combination of keeping errors small
and of improvising workarounds that allow the
system to keep functioning.
• Both pathways to resilience demand deep
knowledge of the technology, the system, one’s
coworkers, and most of all, oneself.
• HROs put a premium on training, personnel with
deep and varied experience, and skills of
recombination and making do with whatever is at
hand. They imagine worst-case conditions and
practice their own equivalent of fire drills.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 265
266. HRO Principle 5:
Deference to Expertise.
• HROs is deferent to expertise.
• HROs cultivate diversity, not just because it helps
them notice more in complex environments, but also
because it helps them do more with the complexities.
• Rigid hierarchies have their own special vulnerability
to error. Errors at higher levels tend to pick up and
combine with errors at lower levels, thereby making
the resulting problem bigger, harder to comprehend,
and more prone to escalation.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 266
267. Note
• Decisions are made on the front line, and authority
migrates to the people with the most expertise,
regardless of their rank. This is not simply a case of
people deferring to the person with the “most
experience.”
• Experience by itself is no guarantee of expertise, since
all too often people have the same experience over and
over and do little to elaborate those repetitions. The
pattern of decisions “migrating” to expertise is found in
flight operations on aircraft carriers, where
“uniqueness coupled with the need for accurate
decisions leads to decisions that ‘search’ for the expert
and migrate around the organization.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 267
269. Error is pervasive.
The unexpected is pervasive.
• Nowhere one finds any mention of perfection, zero
errors, flawless performance, or infallible humans.
• Error is pervasive.
• The unexpected is pervasive.
• By now that message should be clear. What is not
pervasive are well-developed skills to detect and
contain these errors at their early stages.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 269
270. Expectations (1)
• The basic argument is that expectations are built
into organizational roles, routines, and strategies.
These expectations create the orderliness and
predictability that count on when one organizes.
• Expectations, however, are a mixed blessing
because they create blind spots.
• Blind spots sometimes take the form of belated
recognition of unexpected threatening events. And
frequently blind spots get larger simply because
one does a biased search for evidence that
confirms the accuracy of original expectations.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 270
271. Expectations (2)
• To have an expectation is to envision something, usually for
good reasons, that is reasonably certain to come about.
• To expect something is to be mentally ready for it. Every
deliberate action you take is based on assumptions about
how the world will react to what you do.
• Expectancies form the basis for virtually all deliberate
actions because expectancies about how the world operates
serve as implicit assumptions that guide behavioral choices.
• Expectations provide a significant infrastructure for
everyday life. They are like a planning function that suggests
the likely course of events…
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 271
272. Blind spots
• The problem with blind spots is that they often conceal
small errors that are getting bigger and can produce
disabling brutal audits.
• To counteract these blind spots, organizations try to develop
a greater awareness of discriminatory detail.
• This enriched awareness, which we call mindfulness,
uncovers early signs that expectations are inadequate, that
unexpected events are unfolding, and that recovery needs
to be implemented.
• Recovery requires updating both of one’s understanding of
what is happening and of the lines of action that were tied
to the earlier expectations.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 272
273. Detection / Not Error-Free
• It is the failure both to articulate important mistakes that
must not occur and to organize in order to detect them that
allows unexpected events to spin out of control.
• HROs develop capabilities to detect, contain, and bounce
back from those inevitable errors that are part of an
indeterminate world.
• The signature of an HRO is not that it is error-free, but that
errors don’t disable it.
• Resilience is a combination of keeping errors small and of
improvising workarounds that keep the system functioning.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 273
274. Error Reporting
• A necessary component of an incident review is the
reporting of an incident. And research shows that
people need to feel safe to report incidents or they
will ignore them or cover them up.
• HROs increase their knowledge base by
encouraging and rewarding error reporting.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 274
275. Assumptions
• Every deliberate action you take is based on
assumptions about how the world will react to what
you do.
• Expectancies form the basis for virtually all deliberate
actions because expectancies about how the world
operates serve as implicit assumptions that guide
behavioral choices.
• Expectations provide a significant infrastructure for
everyday life. They are like a routine that suggests the
probable course of events. They direct your attention
to certain features of events, which means that they
affect what you notice, mull over, and remember. When
you expect that something will happen, that is a lot like
testing a hypothesis.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 275
276. Self-fulfilling prophecy (1)
• A self-fulfilling prophecy is the sociopsychological
phenomenon of someone "predicting" or expecting
something, and this "prediction" or expectation coming
true simply because the person believes it will and the
person's resulting behaviors aligning to fulfill the belief.
• This suggests that people's beliefs influence their
actions.
• The principle behind this phenomenon is that people
create consequences regarding people or events, based
on previous knowledge of the subject.
• A self-fulfilling prophecy is applicable to either negative
or positive outcomes.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 276
277. Self-fulfilling prophecy (2)
• American sociologist William Isaac Thomas was the first
to discover this phenomenon. In 1928 he developed
the Thomas theorem (also known as the Thomas
dictum), stating that,
If men define situations as real,
they are real in their consequences.
• In other words, the consequence will come to fruition
based on how one interprets the situation. Using
Thomas' idea, another American sociologist, Robert K.
Merton, coined the term "self-fulfilling prophecy",
popularizing the idea that “a belief or expectation,
correct or incorrect, could bring about a desired or
expected outcome.”
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 277
278. Note
• Self-fulfilling theory can be divided into two behaviors, one would be
the Pygmalion effect which is when “one person has expectations of
another, changes her behavior in accordance with these expectations,
and the object of the expectations then also changes her behavior as a
result.”
• Additionally, philosopher Karl Popper called the self-fulfilling prophecy
the Oedipus effect:
• One of the ideas I had discussed in The Poverty of Historicism was the
influence of a prediction upon the event predicted. I had called this the
"Oedipus effect", because the oracle played a most important role in the
sequence of events which led to the fulfilment of its prophecy. [...] For a
time I thought that the existence of the Oedipus effect distinguished the
social from the natural sciences. But in biology, too—even in molecular
biology—expectations often play a role in bringing about what has been
expected.
• An early precursor of the concept appears in Edward Gibbon’s Decline
and Fall of the Roman Empire: "During many ages, the prediction, as it is
usual, contributed to its own accomplishment" (chapter I, part II).
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 278
279. Confirmations
• Many of expectations are reasonably accurate.
They tend to be confirmed, partly because they are
based on experience and partly because one
corrects those that have negative consequences.
• The tricky part is that all of us tend to be awfully
generous in what we accept as evidence that our
expectations are confirmed.
• Furthermore, we actively seek out evidence that
confirms our expectations and avoid evidence that
disconfirms them.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 279
280. Unpleasant Feelings
• Evidence shows that when something unexpected
happens, this is an unpleasant experience. Part of
managing the unexpected involves anticipating
these feelings of unpleasantness and taking steps
to minimize their impact.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 280
282. Cognitive dissonance
• A person who experiences internal inconsistency tends to
become psychologically uncomfortable and is motivated to
reduce the cognitive dissonance. They tend to make
changes to justify the stressful behavior, either by adding
new parts to the cognition causing the psychological
dissonance or by avoiding circumstances and contradictory
information likely to increase the magnitude of the cognitive
dissonance.
• Coping with the nuances of contradictory ideas or
experiences is mentally stressful. It requires energy and
effort to sit with those seemingly opposite things that all
seem true. Festinger argued that some people would
inevitably resolve dissonance by blindly believing whatever
they wanted to believe.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 282
283. Routines and planes
• People also search for confirmation in other forms
of expecting such as routines and plans.
• Organizations often presume that because they
have routines to deal with problems, this proves
that they understand those problems.
• Although there is a grain of truth to that inference,
what they fail to see is that their routines are also
expectations that are subject to the very same
traps as any other expectations.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 283
284. Kahneman and Tversky
• We actively seek out evidence that confirms our
expectations and avoid evidence that disconfirms
them.
• We tend to overestimate the validity of
expectations currently held.
• The continuing search for confirming evidence
postpones your realization that something
unexpected is developing.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 284
285. Updating
• Whenever a routine is activated, people assume
that the world today is pretty much like the world
that existed at the time the routine was first
learned.
• Furthermore, people tend to look for confirmation
that their existing routines are correct. And over
time, they come to see more and more
confirmation based on fewer and fewer data.
• What is missing are continuing efforts to update
the routines and expectations and to act in ways
that would compel such updating.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 285
286. Plans
• This same pattern of confirmation seeking is
associated with plans.
• Plans guide people to search narrowly for
confirmation that the plans are correct.
• Disconfirming evidence is avoided, and plans lure
you into overlooking a buildup of the unexpected.
• This is not surprising since much of the imagery
used to describe plans is like the imagery people
use when they talk about expectations.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 286
287. Counteract to seek confirmation
• People in HROs work hard to counteract the
tendency to seek confirmation by designing
practices that incorporate the five principles.
• They understand that their expectations are
incomplete and that they can come closer to
getting it right if they doubt those expectations that
seem to be confirmed most often.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 287
288. Alertness
• The tendencies to seek confirmation and avoid
disconfirmation are well-honed, well-practiced
human tendencies.
• That’s why HROs have to work so hard and so
continuously to override these tendencies and
remain alert. And that’s why you may have to work
just as hard.
• All of us face an ongoing struggle for alertness
because we face an ongoing preference for
information that confirms.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 288
289. Expectations and Planning
• If you understand the problems that expectations
create, you understand the problems that plans
create. And you may begin to understand why a
preoccupation with plans and planning makes it
that much harder for you to act mindfully.
• By contrast, mindfulness is essentially a
preoccupation with updating. It is grounded in an
understanding that knowledge and ignorance grow
together.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 289
290. Redirecting Attention
• The power of a mindful orientation is that it
redirects attention from the expected to the
irrelevant, from the confirming to the
disconfirming, from the pleasant to the unpleasant,
from the more certain to the less certain, from the
explicit to the implicit, from the factual to the
probable, and from the consensual to the
contested.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 290
291. Believing is Seeing
• Trouble starts when I fail to notice that I see only
whatever confirms my categories and expectations
but nothing else. The trouble deepens even further
if I kid myself that seeing is believing. That’s wrong.
It’s the other way around. Believing is seeing. You
see what you expect to see. You see what you have
the labels to see. You see what you have the skills
to manage.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 291
292. L'occhio vede solo ciò
che la mente è preparata
a comprendere
(Henri Bergson)
Henri-Louis Bergson (Parigi, 18 ottobre 1859 – Parigi, 4 gennaio 1941) è stato un filosofo francese. La sua opera superò le tradizioni ottocentesche dello Spiritualismo
e del Positivismo ed ebbe una forte influenza nei campi della psicologia, della biologia, dell'arte, della letteratura e della teologia. Fu insignito del Premio Nobel per la
letteratura nel 1927 sia «per le sue ricche e feconde idee» sia «per la brillante abilità con cui ha saputo presentarle».
Occhio clinico
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 292
293. Forms of unexpected
I. The first form of the unexpected occurs when an
event that was expected to happen fails to occur.
II. A second form of the unexpected occurs when an
event that was not expected to happen does
happen.
III. The third form of the unexpected occurs when an
event that was simply unthought of happens.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 293
294. Start
• In each of these three cases, the surprise starts with an
expectation.
• Presumably, if you hold these expectations, you look for
evidence that confirms them rather than evidence that
disconfirms them.
• If you find confirming evidence, this “proves” that your
hunches about the world are accurate, that you are in
control, that you know what’s up, and that you are
safe.
• The continuing search for confirming evidence
postpones your realization that your model has its
limits.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 294
295. Finally
• If you are slow to realize that things are not the way
you expected them to be, the problem worsens and
becomes harder to solve and gets entangled with other
problems.
• When it finally becomes clear that your expectation is
wrong, there may be few options left to resolve the
problem.
• In the meantime, efficiency and effectiveness have
declined, the system is now vulnerable to further
collapse, and safety, reputations, and production are in
jeopardy.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 295
296. Imaginations
• A significant goal of HROs is to increase their understanding
of the third form of the unexpected and to expand
knowledge of “the imagined deemed possible.”
• HRO principles steer people toward mindful practices that
encourage imagination.
• The crucial nature of imagination is reflected in the report
of the commission investigating the terrorist attacks on
September 11, 2001. It found shortfalls in imagination prior
to the collapse of the twin towers.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 296
297. WTC
• The commission’s report contains this striking
assertion:
“Imagination is not a gift usually associated with
bureaucracies. ... It is therefore crucial to find a way
of routinizing, even bureaucratizing the exercise of
imagination. Doing so requires more than finding an
expert who can imagine that aircraft could be used
as weapons.”
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 297
298. Alertness
• It takes more than a shrewd expert to forestall the
unexpected in most situations.
• It takes mindful practices that encourage
imagination, foster enriched expectations, raise
doubts about all expectations, increase the ability
to make novel sense of small interruptions in
expectations, and facilitate learning that intensifies
and deepens alertness.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 298
299. Trivialize
• People sometimes inadvertently trivialize the
importance of imagination. For example, these days
we keep hearing the hollow maxim “Expect the
unexpected.” That well-meaning sentiment
assumes that people can live their lives while
assuming that their expectations are misleading.
• The problem is, they can’t afford to. They live,
instead, as if their expectations are basically correct
and as if there is little that can surprise them. To do
otherwise would be to forgo any feeling of control
or predictability.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 299
300. Virginity
• Once you’ve accepted an anomaly or something
less than perfect, you know, you’ve given up your
virginity. You can’t go back. You’re at the point that
it’s very hard to draw the line. You know, next time
they say it’s the same problem, it’s just eroded 5
mils more. Once you accepted it, where do you
draw the line? Once you’ve done it, it’s very
difficult to go back now and get very hard-nosed
and say I’m not going to accept that.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 300
301. Leemers
• You’ll probably know when something unexpected happens
because you’ll feel surprised, puzzled, or anxious. Aviators
call these feelings leemers (probably derived from leery),
the feeling that something is not quite right, but you can’t
put your finger on it. Trust those feelings. They are a solid
clue that your model of the world is in error.
• More important, try to hold on to those feelings and resist
the temptation to gloss over what has just happened and
treat it as normal. In that brief interval between surprise
and successful normalizing lies one of your few
opportunities to discover what you don’t know.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 301
302. Learning moment
• This is one of those rare moments when you can
significantly improve your understanding.
• If you wait too long, normalizing will take over, and
you’ll be convinced that there is nothing to learn.
• Most opportunities for learning come in the form
of brief moments.
• And one of the best moments for learning, a
moment of the unexpected, is also one of the
shortest-lived moments.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 302
303. Sustained High Performance
• If you update and differentiate the labels you
impose on the world, the unexpected will be
spotted earlier and dealt with more fully, and
sustained high performance will be more assured.
• Reliability is a dynamic event and gets
compromised by distraction and ignorance.
• Mindfulness is about staying attuned to what is
happening and about a deepening grasp of what
those events mean.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 303
305. Importance of Doctrine
• When you think about mindful culture as a means to
manage the unexpected, keep the following picture of
culture in front of you.
• Culture is about the assumptions that influence the people
who manage the unexpected. Culture can hold large
systems together. Culture is unspoken, implicit, taken for
granted. You feel culture when what you do feels
appropriate or inappropriate. You feel the unexpected when
something surprises you.
• Culture produces simultaneous centralization-
decentralization by binding people to a small set of core
values and allowing them discretion over everything else.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 305
306. Churchill’s Audit
• Why didn’t I know?
• Why didn’t my advisors
know?
• Why wasn’t I told?
• Why didn’t I ask?
• Perché non lo sapevo?
• Perché i miei consulenti
non lo sapevano?
• Perché non me l'hanno
detto?
• Perché non l'ho
chiesto?
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 306
307. Culture
• Culture is a pattern of shared beliefs and
expectations that shape how individuals and groups
act.
• Descriptions of safety culture often read like lists of
banal injunctions to “do good.”
• Culture will affect what you see and how you
interpret it.
• Culture change takes a long time.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 307
308. Culture - Schein
• Culture is defined by six formal properties:
(1) shared basic assumptions that are
(2) invented, discovered, or developed by a given group as it
(3) learns to cope with its problem of external adaptation and
internal integration in ways that
(4) have worked well enough to be considered valid and,
therefore,
(5) can be taught to new members of the group as the
(6) correct way to perceive, think, and feel in relation to those
problems.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 308
309. Building on strengths
• Never start with the idea of changing culture.
• Try to build on existing cultural strengths rather
than attempting to change those elements that
may be weaknesses.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 309
310. Four Subcultures
• The problem is that candid reporting of errors takes trust
and trustworthiness. Both are hard to develop, easy to
destroy, and hard to institutionalize.
1. Reporting Culture
2. Just Culture
3. Flexible Culture
4. Learning Culture
James Reason
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 310
311. Reason (James)
• Reason (James) argues that it takes four subcultures to
ensure an informed culture. Assumptions, values, and
artifacts must line up consistently around the issues of
1. What gets reported when people make errors or
experience near misses (reporting culture)
2. How people apportion blame when something goes wrong
(just culture)
3. How readily people can adapt to sudden and radical
increments in pressure, pacing, and intensity (flexible
culture)
4. How adequately people can convert the lessons that they
have learned into reconfigurations of assumptions,
frameworks, and action (learning culture).
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 311
312. 1 - Reporting Culture
• Since safety cultures are dependent on the
knowledge gained from rare incidents, mistakes,
near misses, and other “free lessons,” they need to
be structured so that people feel willing to
“confess” their own errors.
• A reporting culture is about protection of people
who report.
• It is also about what kinds of reports are trusted.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 312
313. 2 - Just Culture
• An organization is defined by how it handles blame
and punishment, and that in turn can affect what
gets reported in the first place.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 313
314. 3 - Flexible Culture
• Adapts to changing demands
• Deference to expertise – decisions migrate to
expertise during periods of high-tempo activity
• Collect multiple signals from a variety of sources
• HROs assume that the system is endangered until
there is conclusive proof that it is not
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 314
315. 4 - Learning Culture
• An informed culture learns by means of ongoing
debates about constantly shifting discrepancies. These
debates promote learning because they identify new
sources of hazard and danger and new ways to cope.
• Culture shapes actions largely without people being
aware of how little they see and how many options
they overlook.
• When people are drawn into a culture that is partly of
their own making, it is very hard for them to see that
what they take for granted hides the beginnings of
trouble.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 315
316. Mindful Culture
• To be mindful is to become susceptible to learning
anxiety. And anxious people need what Edgar
Schein calls “psychological safety.”
• Mindfulness requires continuous ongoing activity.
• We are not talking about a “safety war” that ends
in victory. We are talking instead about an endless
guerilla conflict.
17/03/2023 PSA - Robustezza Strutturale 316
319. Progettazione Strutturale Antincendio
ROBUSTEZZA STRUTTURALE
Franco Bontempi
Professore Ordinario di Tecnica delle Costruzioni
Facoltà di Ingegneria Civile e Industriale
Sapienza Università di Roma
franco.bontempi@uniroma1.it