SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 45
Optimum usage and economic feasibility of animal manure-based biomass in combustion systems Nicholas T. Carlin [email_address]   Under the advisement of: Dr. K. Annamalai & Dr. W. Harman Texas A&M University, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering March 9, 2009
Overview ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Introduction – CAFOs ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Sources: NASS of the USDA ASAE standard D384.2 MAR2005 www.factoryfarm.org
Dairy Cows ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Sources: NASS of the USDA ASAE standard D384.2 MAR2005 www.tnr.com   (The New Republic)
Fuel Analyses
Bulk Density of Manure Biomass Data from Chen, 1983,  Ag. Wastes   6 Curve fit to Chen’s data
Modeling Particle Distribution and Specific Heat Porosity: Specific heat of bone dry biomass solids, adapted from Bohnhoff  et al ., 1987. Specific heat of wet biomass solids
Thermal Energy Conversion of Manure OPTION 1 :  Large-scale combustion OPTION 2 :  Small-scale, on-the-farm combustion Drying Grinding and other processing Emission and dollar savings (or costs)?  Overall economic feasibility? Waste disposal plus co-benefit of usable energy or thermal commodities Design considerations.  Gross economic study. Power Plant
Option 1 Large Scale Combustion
Transporting Manure Biomass Centralized drying and composting facility <30 km (<20 miles) 80-320 km (50-200 miles) Dairy Dairy Large feedlot or CAFO Power Plant
Biomass Drying Operations boiler Natural Gas or Electric Warm Air Air Steam ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Transporting Biomass ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],40 cubic yard trailer ( www.montonetrailers.com )
Other Processing at Power Plant Existing coal injection Biomass stockpile Transport or hauling vehicle Front end loader Metal detector Magnetic separator Scale Screen Feeder Grinder Air intake Exhaust Silo Vent Scale Feeder Pressure blower Biomass reburn fuel Biomass co-fired fuel ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Higher Ash Output Overall cost estimates for these operations for reburn and co-fire systems exist in the literature [adapted from the DOE, 2004, Fed. Energy Management Program] Separator
General Combustion Model Combustion System ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],CV ref Q loss ,[object Object],[object Object],Mass balance : Energy balance :
Co-firing Blending coal with biomass in primary burn region Direct coal and biomass blend and injection if biomass  heat fraction ≤ 2% Secondary and tertiary air Additional injection system for biomass if biomass heat fraction > 2% Secondary and tertiary air ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Higher bottom ash levels CV ref
Project time (yrs) Cash Flows (Dollars) 30 15 20 25 5 10 Diesel, natural gas, propane fueling costs Labor & Maintenance Coal savings Avoided CO 2  and NO x  emission allowances Annual Cash Flows Capital Costs New plant equipment and retrofit Dryer facility and equipment Transport vehicles
Project time (yrs) Cash Flows (Dollars) 30 15 20 25 5 10 Operating cost/revenue Annual Cash Flows Capital Costs Operating cost or revenue New plant equipment and retrofit Dryer facility and equipment Transport vehicles
Project time (yrs) Cash Flows (Dollars) 30 15 20 25 5 10 Net Present Value Net Present Worth Net Present Cost OR
Project time (yrs) Cash Flows (Dollars) 30 15 20 25 5 10 Annualized cost or revenue Annual Cash Flows
Co-firing with Biomass Steps in Analysis ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Base case Inputs for Co-firing ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Base case Inputs for Co-firing ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Year One Comparison Total Operating Cost @ Y1 = $1.2 million
Annual Cash Flow for Base Case NPW = -$22.6 million
Base Case Results ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Effect of Coal Prices
Effect of CO 2  Value Co-firing with biomass becomes profitable
Cost components of co-firing vs. transport distance 70 – 80% of drying cost due to natural gas
Cases where natural gas may not be needed May be the case for dairies and feedlots in the Texas Panhandle Region NPW = -$22.6 million NPW = +$2.1 million Waste heat utilized from power plant
Reburning to reduce NO x ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],High NOx emission Lower NO x  emission 60 to 90% reduction ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Higher bottom ash levels CV ref
Different base case inputs for Reburning ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Effect of NO x  Value
Effect of NO x  Value
Option 2 Small-scale, On-the-farm Combustion
Solids Separator Pump Process  (e.g. space heating, hot water generator, etc.) Flushed Manure Slurry 90-99% moisture Semi solids 50-70% moisture Vapor Exhaust Biomass Solids  15-30% moisture Bottom Ash Exhaust Products Wastewater  1-6% solids Condensate for continued flushing Recycled wastewater for flushing or treatment lagoon Saturated Steam Remaining solids %M=?? Condensate for continued flushing Proposed Manure Waste Disposal Combustion System for on-the-farm disposal Combustion Air Air Air
Disposal Efficiency Mass of flushed manure leaving the animal housings Mass of wastewater not vaporized in the boiler Mass of remaining ash
Tracking Results in Spreadsheet
Dryer Design
Effect of Ash Percentage
Additional Fueling
Summary ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Summary (cont.) ,[object Object],[object Object]
Summary (cont.) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Acknowledgments ,[object Object],[object Object]
Questions? [email_address]

More Related Content

What's hot

Biogas project report
Biogas project reportBiogas project report
Biogas project reportUjjwal Joshi
 
Biomass Pyrolysis, Biochar, Syngas
Biomass Pyrolysis, Biochar, SyngasBiomass Pyrolysis, Biochar, Syngas
Biomass Pyrolysis, Biochar, SyngasAvishek Rauniyar
 
Biomass Gasification presentation
Biomass Gasification presentationBiomass Gasification presentation
Biomass Gasification presentationPritish Shardul
 
Thermochemical Conversion of Biomass to Fuel.cenusa brown 5-25-12
Thermochemical Conversion of Biomass to Fuel.cenusa brown 5-25-12Thermochemical Conversion of Biomass to Fuel.cenusa brown 5-25-12
Thermochemical Conversion of Biomass to Fuel.cenusa brown 5-25-12eXtension Farm Energy
 
20131008 Biomass Conversion Technologies
20131008  Biomass Conversion Technologies20131008  Biomass Conversion Technologies
20131008 Biomass Conversion TechnologiesMahbod Shafiei
 
Improved cook stove - Prof. K.R.Shrestha
Improved cook stove -  Prof. K.R.ShresthaImproved cook stove -  Prof. K.R.Shrestha
Improved cook stove - Prof. K.R.ShresthaDr.Krishna Shrestha
 
3. BIOMASS ENERGY.pptx
3. BIOMASS ENERGY.pptx3. BIOMASS ENERGY.pptx
3. BIOMASS ENERGY.pptxRENERGISTICS
 
Presentation pyrolysis
Presentation pyrolysisPresentation pyrolysis
Presentation pyrolysisAchu Ijah
 
Biomass gasification 1
Biomass gasification 1Biomass gasification 1
Biomass gasification 1NitinTechno
 
Biomass energy and biouels
Biomass energy and biouelsBiomass energy and biouels
Biomass energy and biouelsAshish Bandewar
 
Cofiring biomass &amp; coal
Cofiring biomass &amp; coalCofiring biomass &amp; coal
Cofiring biomass &amp; coalrwrzwart
 
Biomass energy
Biomass energyBiomass energy
Biomass energySmk Xlr
 
Plastic waste into fuel using pyrolysis process
Plastic waste into fuel using pyrolysis processPlastic waste into fuel using pyrolysis process
Plastic waste into fuel using pyrolysis processAglaia Connect
 

What's hot (20)

Biogas project report
Biogas project reportBiogas project report
Biogas project report
 
Biomass Pyrolysis, Biochar, Syngas
Biomass Pyrolysis, Biochar, SyngasBiomass Pyrolysis, Biochar, Syngas
Biomass Pyrolysis, Biochar, Syngas
 
Biomass Gasification presentation
Biomass Gasification presentationBiomass Gasification presentation
Biomass Gasification presentation
 
Biomass energy
Biomass energyBiomass energy
Biomass energy
 
Thermochemical Conversion of Biomass to Fuel.cenusa brown 5-25-12
Thermochemical Conversion of Biomass to Fuel.cenusa brown 5-25-12Thermochemical Conversion of Biomass to Fuel.cenusa brown 5-25-12
Thermochemical Conversion of Biomass to Fuel.cenusa brown 5-25-12
 
20131008 Biomass Conversion Technologies
20131008  Biomass Conversion Technologies20131008  Biomass Conversion Technologies
20131008 Biomass Conversion Technologies
 
Improved cook stove - Prof. K.R.Shrestha
Improved cook stove -  Prof. K.R.ShresthaImproved cook stove -  Prof. K.R.Shrestha
Improved cook stove - Prof. K.R.Shrestha
 
Biomass as a Source of Energy
Biomass as a Source of EnergyBiomass as a Source of Energy
Biomass as a Source of Energy
 
3. BIOMASS ENERGY.pptx
3. BIOMASS ENERGY.pptx3. BIOMASS ENERGY.pptx
3. BIOMASS ENERGY.pptx
 
Biogas technology
Biogas technologyBiogas technology
Biogas technology
 
Presentation pyrolysis
Presentation pyrolysisPresentation pyrolysis
Presentation pyrolysis
 
Hydrogen project
Hydrogen projectHydrogen project
Hydrogen project
 
Biomass gasification 1
Biomass gasification 1Biomass gasification 1
Biomass gasification 1
 
Biomass energy and biouels
Biomass energy and biouelsBiomass energy and biouels
Biomass energy and biouels
 
Cofiring biomass &amp; coal
Cofiring biomass &amp; coalCofiring biomass &amp; coal
Cofiring biomass &amp; coal
 
Pyrolysis
PyrolysisPyrolysis
Pyrolysis
 
Biomass energy
Biomass energyBiomass energy
Biomass energy
 
Plastic waste into fuel using pyrolysis process
Plastic waste into fuel using pyrolysis processPlastic waste into fuel using pyrolysis process
Plastic waste into fuel using pyrolysis process
 
Biomass conversion technologies
Biomass conversion technologiesBiomass conversion technologies
Biomass conversion technologies
 
Energy conversion
Energy conversionEnergy conversion
Energy conversion
 

Similar to Presentation - Coal and Biomass Combustion

The Positive Environmental and Economical Impact of CHP
The Positive Environmental and Economical Impact of CHPThe Positive Environmental and Economical Impact of CHP
The Positive Environmental and Economical Impact of CHPDr. Roger Achkar
 
Biomass gassification based ammonia plant
Biomass gassification based ammonia plantBiomass gassification based ammonia plant
Biomass gassification based ammonia plantDeepak Kumar Ojha, PhD
 
2016.12.14 DryFining Coal Gen presentation FINAL
2016.12.14 DryFining Coal Gen presentation FINAL2016.12.14 DryFining Coal Gen presentation FINAL
2016.12.14 DryFining Coal Gen presentation FINALSandra Broekema
 
Condition Monitoring of electrical machine
Condition Monitoring of electrical machine Condition Monitoring of electrical machine
Condition Monitoring of electrical machine Molla Morshad
 
15th EPConf 5-14-2013 SJ Final
15th EPConf 5-14-2013 SJ Final15th EPConf 5-14-2013 SJ Final
15th EPConf 5-14-2013 SJ FinalSuresh Jambunathan
 
Opportunities for biomass heating solutions (The Carbon Show 2012)
Opportunities for biomass heating solutions  (The Carbon Show 2012)Opportunities for biomass heating solutions  (The Carbon Show 2012)
Opportunities for biomass heating solutions (The Carbon Show 2012)Ricardo- AEA
 
PRODUCTION & LOGISTICS FOR AN IN-MARKET FRAC SAND SUPPLY
PRODUCTION & LOGISTICS FOR AN IN-MARKET FRAC SAND SUPPLYPRODUCTION & LOGISTICS FOR AN IN-MARKET FRAC SAND SUPPLY
PRODUCTION & LOGISTICS FOR AN IN-MARKET FRAC SAND SUPPLYiQHub
 
Biofuel-Pellets-from-Switchg-REAP-Canada.ppt
Biofuel-Pellets-from-Switchg-REAP-Canada.pptBiofuel-Pellets-from-Switchg-REAP-Canada.ppt
Biofuel-Pellets-from-Switchg-REAP-Canada.pptamdeva123
 
Performance of 3 ton/day BFB Gasification System using Pine Feedstock
Performance of 3 ton/day BFB Gasification  System using Pine Feedstock Performance of 3 ton/day BFB Gasification  System using Pine Feedstock
Performance of 3 ton/day BFB Gasification System using Pine Feedstock Md Waliul Islam
 
Carbon footprints in textile
Carbon footprints in textileCarbon footprints in textile
Carbon footprints in textileNishant Chhabra
 
Intro on different waste treatment technologies by Bernard Ammoun
Intro on different waste treatment technologies by Bernard AmmounIntro on different waste treatment technologies by Bernard Ammoun
Intro on different waste treatment technologies by Bernard AmmounBernard Ammoun
 
Biofuel Project: an anlysis to substitute 10% italian petrol by mean of non-f...
Biofuel Project: an anlysis to substitute 10% italian petrol by mean of non-f...Biofuel Project: an anlysis to substitute 10% italian petrol by mean of non-f...
Biofuel Project: an anlysis to substitute 10% italian petrol by mean of non-f...Stefano Maronese
 
Technologies for Carbon Capture in Oil Refineries
Technologies for Carbon Capture in Oil RefineriesTechnologies for Carbon Capture in Oil Refineries
Technologies for Carbon Capture in Oil Refineriescanaleenergia
 
SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)
SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)
SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)The SEAM Centre
 
Raunak_Bhatia_Energy_Engineering_PPT.pptx
Raunak_Bhatia_Energy_Engineering_PPT.pptxRaunak_Bhatia_Energy_Engineering_PPT.pptx
Raunak_Bhatia_Energy_Engineering_PPT.pptxRaunakBhatia5
 

Similar to Presentation - Coal and Biomass Combustion (20)

Session 17 ic2011 puettmann
Session 17 ic2011 puettmannSession 17 ic2011 puettmann
Session 17 ic2011 puettmann
 
The Positive Environmental and Economical Impact of CHP
The Positive Environmental and Economical Impact of CHPThe Positive Environmental and Economical Impact of CHP
The Positive Environmental and Economical Impact of CHP
 
Coal presentation
Coal presentationCoal presentation
Coal presentation
 
Biomass gassification based ammonia plant
Biomass gassification based ammonia plantBiomass gassification based ammonia plant
Biomass gassification based ammonia plant
 
2016.12.14 DryFining Coal Gen presentation FINAL
2016.12.14 DryFining Coal Gen presentation FINAL2016.12.14 DryFining Coal Gen presentation FINAL
2016.12.14 DryFining Coal Gen presentation FINAL
 
Capturing CO2 from air: Research at the University of Edinburgh - Dr Maria Ch...
Capturing CO2 from air: Research at the University of Edinburgh - Dr Maria Ch...Capturing CO2 from air: Research at the University of Edinburgh - Dr Maria Ch...
Capturing CO2 from air: Research at the University of Edinburgh - Dr Maria Ch...
 
Condition Monitoring of electrical machine
Condition Monitoring of electrical machine Condition Monitoring of electrical machine
Condition Monitoring of electrical machine
 
15th EPConf 5-14-2013 SJ Final
15th EPConf 5-14-2013 SJ Final15th EPConf 5-14-2013 SJ Final
15th EPConf 5-14-2013 SJ Final
 
Alex Hobbs Biomass
Alex Hobbs   BiomassAlex Hobbs   Biomass
Alex Hobbs Biomass
 
Opportunities for biomass heating solutions (The Carbon Show 2012)
Opportunities for biomass heating solutions  (The Carbon Show 2012)Opportunities for biomass heating solutions  (The Carbon Show 2012)
Opportunities for biomass heating solutions (The Carbon Show 2012)
 
PRODUCTION & LOGISTICS FOR AN IN-MARKET FRAC SAND SUPPLY
PRODUCTION & LOGISTICS FOR AN IN-MARKET FRAC SAND SUPPLYPRODUCTION & LOGISTICS FOR AN IN-MARKET FRAC SAND SUPPLY
PRODUCTION & LOGISTICS FOR AN IN-MARKET FRAC SAND SUPPLY
 
Biofuel-Pellets-from-Switchg-REAP-Canada.ppt
Biofuel-Pellets-from-Switchg-REAP-Canada.pptBiofuel-Pellets-from-Switchg-REAP-Canada.ppt
Biofuel-Pellets-from-Switchg-REAP-Canada.ppt
 
Performance of 3 ton/day BFB Gasification System using Pine Feedstock
Performance of 3 ton/day BFB Gasification  System using Pine Feedstock Performance of 3 ton/day BFB Gasification  System using Pine Feedstock
Performance of 3 ton/day BFB Gasification System using Pine Feedstock
 
Carbon footprints in textile
Carbon footprints in textileCarbon footprints in textile
Carbon footprints in textile
 
Intro on different waste treatment technologies by Bernard Ammoun
Intro on different waste treatment technologies by Bernard AmmounIntro on different waste treatment technologies by Bernard Ammoun
Intro on different waste treatment technologies by Bernard Ammoun
 
Biofuel Project: an anlysis to substitute 10% italian petrol by mean of non-f...
Biofuel Project: an anlysis to substitute 10% italian petrol by mean of non-f...Biofuel Project: an anlysis to substitute 10% italian petrol by mean of non-f...
Biofuel Project: an anlysis to substitute 10% italian petrol by mean of non-f...
 
Technologies for Carbon Capture in Oil Refineries
Technologies for Carbon Capture in Oil RefineriesTechnologies for Carbon Capture in Oil Refineries
Technologies for Carbon Capture in Oil Refineries
 
SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)
SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)
SEAM Centre seminar - Sept 2010 (part 1)
 
Raunak_Bhatia_Energy_Engineering_PPT.pptx
Raunak_Bhatia_Energy_Engineering_PPT.pptxRaunak_Bhatia_Energy_Engineering_PPT.pptx
Raunak_Bhatia_Energy_Engineering_PPT.pptx
 
Ch3
Ch3Ch3
Ch3
 

Presentation - Coal and Biomass Combustion

  • 1. Optimum usage and economic feasibility of animal manure-based biomass in combustion systems Nicholas T. Carlin [email_address] Under the advisement of: Dr. K. Annamalai & Dr. W. Harman Texas A&M University, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering March 9, 2009
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 6. Bulk Density of Manure Biomass Data from Chen, 1983, Ag. Wastes 6 Curve fit to Chen’s data
  • 7. Modeling Particle Distribution and Specific Heat Porosity: Specific heat of bone dry biomass solids, adapted from Bohnhoff et al ., 1987. Specific heat of wet biomass solids
  • 8. Thermal Energy Conversion of Manure OPTION 1 : Large-scale combustion OPTION 2 : Small-scale, on-the-farm combustion Drying Grinding and other processing Emission and dollar savings (or costs)? Overall economic feasibility? Waste disposal plus co-benefit of usable energy or thermal commodities Design considerations. Gross economic study. Power Plant
  • 9. Option 1 Large Scale Combustion
  • 10. Transporting Manure Biomass Centralized drying and composting facility <30 km (<20 miles) 80-320 km (50-200 miles) Dairy Dairy Large feedlot or CAFO Power Plant
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16. Project time (yrs) Cash Flows (Dollars) 30 15 20 25 5 10 Diesel, natural gas, propane fueling costs Labor & Maintenance Coal savings Avoided CO 2 and NO x emission allowances Annual Cash Flows Capital Costs New plant equipment and retrofit Dryer facility and equipment Transport vehicles
  • 17. Project time (yrs) Cash Flows (Dollars) 30 15 20 25 5 10 Operating cost/revenue Annual Cash Flows Capital Costs Operating cost or revenue New plant equipment and retrofit Dryer facility and equipment Transport vehicles
  • 18. Project time (yrs) Cash Flows (Dollars) 30 15 20 25 5 10 Net Present Value Net Present Worth Net Present Cost OR
  • 19. Project time (yrs) Cash Flows (Dollars) 30 15 20 25 5 10 Annualized cost or revenue Annual Cash Flows
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23. Year One Comparison Total Operating Cost @ Y1 = $1.2 million
  • 24. Annual Cash Flow for Base Case NPW = -$22.6 million
  • 25.
  • 26. Effect of Coal Prices
  • 27. Effect of CO 2 Value Co-firing with biomass becomes profitable
  • 28. Cost components of co-firing vs. transport distance 70 – 80% of drying cost due to natural gas
  • 29. Cases where natural gas may not be needed May be the case for dairies and feedlots in the Texas Panhandle Region NPW = -$22.6 million NPW = +$2.1 million Waste heat utilized from power plant
  • 30.
  • 31.
  • 32. Effect of NO x Value
  • 33. Effect of NO x Value
  • 34. Option 2 Small-scale, On-the-farm Combustion
  • 35. Solids Separator Pump Process (e.g. space heating, hot water generator, etc.) Flushed Manure Slurry 90-99% moisture Semi solids 50-70% moisture Vapor Exhaust Biomass Solids 15-30% moisture Bottom Ash Exhaust Products Wastewater 1-6% solids Condensate for continued flushing Recycled wastewater for flushing or treatment lagoon Saturated Steam Remaining solids %M=?? Condensate for continued flushing Proposed Manure Waste Disposal Combustion System for on-the-farm disposal Combustion Air Air Air
  • 36. Disposal Efficiency Mass of flushed manure leaving the animal housings Mass of wastewater not vaporized in the boiler Mass of remaining ash
  • 37. Tracking Results in Spreadsheet
  • 39. Effect of Ash Percentage
  • 41.
  • 42.
  • 43.
  • 44.