This document discusses and compares two film adaptations of the Judge Dredd franchise: Judge Dredd (1995) and Dredd (2012). The 1995 version starred Sylvester Stallone and was a critical and box office flop. The 2012 version starred Karl Urban and had significantly higher box office returns due to advances in technology and a darker, more violent tone that was more faithful to the source material. Key factors that contributed to the remakes included financial motivations from studios, innovations in technology that enabled new visual effects, and keeping the story relevant to current trends like depictions of drug use.