EVALUATION OF ANTINUCLEAR RO/SS-A AND LA/SS-B
      ANTIBODIES BY MULTIPLEX TECHNOLOGY AT THE UNIVERSITY
             HOSPITAL “12 DE OCTUBRE” (MADRID-SPAIN)

  M.     Talise1,         V.   Peréz1,         M.    Sevilla 1,        S.    Lermo1,                G.          Badra2,                L.      Borque3,                   A.      Serrano1

  1Immunology      Service, University Hospital 12 de Octubre, 2University Rey Juan Carlos, Madrid, 3San Pedro Hospital, Logroño, Spain

INTRODUCTION
Autoantibodies to Ro/SS-A and La/SS-B ribonucleoproteins are found                       45


in autoimmune diseases such as primary Sjögren´s syndrome,                               40


systemic lupus erythematousus (SLE) and rheumatoid arthritis1 (RA).
                                                                                         35

Two types of anti-Ro/SSA antibodies have been described, anti-
                                                                                         30
SSA-52 kDa and anti-SSA-60kDa, historically, these autoantibodies
were considered as a uniform autoantibody-system. However, recent                        25



studies provided evidence that Ro60 and Ro52 are not part of a                           20


stable macromolecular complex and that anti-Ro52 and anti-Ro60                           15

(SS-A) antibodies have different clinical associations               and     each
                                                                                         10
specific to different antigens2, for this reason it is necessary to be
                                                                                          5
able to individually identify these antibodies in the autoimmunity
laboratory and the Bioplex         TM   2200 automated system offers this                 0
                                                                                              Anti-SSA Athena   Anti-SSA Bioplex   Anti-SSA/Ro52   Anti-SSA/Ro60   Anti-SSA Ro52 and    Anti-SSB/La   Anti-SSB/La
                                                                                                                      2200            Bioplex         Bioplex        Ro60 Bioplex         Athena      Bioplex 2200
advantage; we compare this technique with the immunofluorescence
(IIF) and AtheNA Multi-lyte® ANA test system a multiplex fluorescent                          We observed 15 discrepancies: Anti-SSA negative by Athena but
microsphere immunoassay for             the semi-quantitative of Ig G class                   positive Anti-SSA/Ro52 and/or Anti-SSA/Ro60 by Bioplex 2200; of
antibody to 9 separate analytes (DNA, SSA, SSB, Sm, RNP, Scl-70,                              which 12 were IIF positive and had some autoimmunity disease: 6
Jo-1, Centromere B, and Histone).                                                             SLE; 2 Systemic Sclerosis, 2 autoimmune Hepatitis, 1 Sjögren´s
                                                                                              syndrome + Raynaud , 1 primary biliary cirrhosis, 1
METHODOLOGY                                                                                   dermatomyositis. Only three discrepancies were Anti-SSA Athena
We studied sera from 600 patients randomly admitted to the                                    positive,           Anti-SSA Bioplex Negative and IIF negative, one had
autoimmunity section during May and June 2009, these sera were                                rheumatoid arthritis.
obtained from patients referred from primary care physicians, general                         On the other hand other 8 discrepancies were observed: Anti-
internists, rheumatologists and other subspecialties such as                                  SSB Athena’s Negative but Bioplex 2200 Positive, of which 8 were
nephrology, dermatology, etc . Antinuclear antibodies (ANA´s ) were                           IIF positive and four had diagnosis of SLE, 2 RA, 2 Sjögren´s Sx.
determined by immunofluorescence (IIF) on HEp-2 cell, AtheNA Multi-                           Only two sera were Anti-SSB Athena positive                                              but Bioplex 2200
lyte® multiplex technique and BioPlex™2200 (by Bio-Rad Laboratories,                          negative, of which 1 was IIF positive and 1 had RA.
Hercules, CA) a fully automated Luminex based system developed for
                                                                                               CONCLUSIONS
analysis of 13 antibodies including anti-SSA-52 kDa and anti-SSA-60
                                                                                               We conclude that BioPlex2200 offers a good percentage of
kDa in a primary tube and SS-B, Sm, Sm/RNP, RNPA, RNP-68, Scl70,
                                                                                               concordance with other methods, and it can be a good solution as
C e n t r o m e r e - B , d s D N A , c h r o m a t i n , J o 1 , r i b o s o m a l P.
                                                                                               a multiplex approach to diagnose autoimmune diseases like
Immunofluorescence was considered positive from the dilution 1/ 80.
                                                                                               Sjögren´s syndrome , systemic lupus erythematousus and
RESULTS                                                                                        rheumatoid arthritis because the separation of Ro / SSA 52 and 60
Six hundred sera were evaluated, 33 sera were Anti-SSA/Ro52, 42 Anti-                          antigens conferred increased sensitivity, provides greater
SSA/Ro60, and 17 Anti-La/SS-B positive by Bioplex 2200; 37 sera were                           specificity with a lower rate of false negatives.
positive to Anti SS-A/Ro and 11 AntiSS-B/La by AtheNA Multi-lyte® with a
                                                                                               REFERENCES
global concordance of 96.5% and 98.33% respectively; by IIF we obtained                        1. van Woerkom JM, Geertzema JG, Nikkels PG, et al. Expression of Ro/SS-A and La/
48 positive sera, 25 (52.08%) with coarse and fine speckled pattern, 18                        SS-B determined by immunohistochemistry in healthy, inflamed and autoimmune
                                                                                               diseased human tissues: a generalized phenomenon. Clin Exp Rheumatol. 2004 May-
(37.50%) homogeneous, 2 (4.20%) Centromere-B, 2 (4,20%) Nuclear dots.
                                                                                               Jun;22(3):285-92.
Finally, 80.70% of the patients had at least one diagnosis of autoimmune
                                                                                               2. J. Schulte-Pelkum a,M. Fritzler , M. Mahler . Latest update on the Ro/SS-A
disease.                                                                                       autoantibody system. Autoimmunity Reviews 8 (2009) 632–637

“Evaluation of antinuclear Ro / SS-A and LA / SS-B antibodies by multiplex technology at the University Hospital 12 de Octubre”

  • 1.
    EVALUATION OF ANTINUCLEARRO/SS-A AND LA/SS-B ANTIBODIES BY MULTIPLEX TECHNOLOGY AT THE UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL “12 DE OCTUBRE” (MADRID-SPAIN) M. Talise1, V. Peréz1, M. Sevilla 1, S. Lermo1, G. Badra2, L. Borque3, A. Serrano1 1Immunology Service, University Hospital 12 de Octubre, 2University Rey Juan Carlos, Madrid, 3San Pedro Hospital, Logroño, Spain INTRODUCTION Autoantibodies to Ro/SS-A and La/SS-B ribonucleoproteins are found 45 in autoimmune diseases such as primary Sjögren´s syndrome, 40 systemic lupus erythematousus (SLE) and rheumatoid arthritis1 (RA). 35 Two types of anti-Ro/SSA antibodies have been described, anti- 30 SSA-52 kDa and anti-SSA-60kDa, historically, these autoantibodies were considered as a uniform autoantibody-system. However, recent 25 studies provided evidence that Ro60 and Ro52 are not part of a 20 stable macromolecular complex and that anti-Ro52 and anti-Ro60 15 (SS-A) antibodies have different clinical associations and each 10 specific to different antigens2, for this reason it is necessary to be 5 able to individually identify these antibodies in the autoimmunity laboratory and the Bioplex TM 2200 automated system offers this 0 Anti-SSA Athena Anti-SSA Bioplex Anti-SSA/Ro52 Anti-SSA/Ro60 Anti-SSA Ro52 and Anti-SSB/La Anti-SSB/La 2200 Bioplex Bioplex Ro60 Bioplex Athena Bioplex 2200 advantage; we compare this technique with the immunofluorescence (IIF) and AtheNA Multi-lyte® ANA test system a multiplex fluorescent We observed 15 discrepancies: Anti-SSA negative by Athena but microsphere immunoassay for the semi-quantitative of Ig G class positive Anti-SSA/Ro52 and/or Anti-SSA/Ro60 by Bioplex 2200; of antibody to 9 separate analytes (DNA, SSA, SSB, Sm, RNP, Scl-70, which 12 were IIF positive and had some autoimmunity disease: 6 Jo-1, Centromere B, and Histone). SLE; 2 Systemic Sclerosis, 2 autoimmune Hepatitis, 1 Sjögren´s syndrome + Raynaud , 1 primary biliary cirrhosis, 1 METHODOLOGY dermatomyositis. Only three discrepancies were Anti-SSA Athena We studied sera from 600 patients randomly admitted to the positive, Anti-SSA Bioplex Negative and IIF negative, one had autoimmunity section during May and June 2009, these sera were rheumatoid arthritis. obtained from patients referred from primary care physicians, general On the other hand other 8 discrepancies were observed: Anti- internists, rheumatologists and other subspecialties such as SSB Athena’s Negative but Bioplex 2200 Positive, of which 8 were nephrology, dermatology, etc . Antinuclear antibodies (ANA´s ) were IIF positive and four had diagnosis of SLE, 2 RA, 2 Sjögren´s Sx. determined by immunofluorescence (IIF) on HEp-2 cell, AtheNA Multi- Only two sera were Anti-SSB Athena positive but Bioplex 2200 lyte® multiplex technique and BioPlex™2200 (by Bio-Rad Laboratories, negative, of which 1 was IIF positive and 1 had RA. Hercules, CA) a fully automated Luminex based system developed for CONCLUSIONS analysis of 13 antibodies including anti-SSA-52 kDa and anti-SSA-60 We conclude that BioPlex2200 offers a good percentage of kDa in a primary tube and SS-B, Sm, Sm/RNP, RNPA, RNP-68, Scl70, concordance with other methods, and it can be a good solution as C e n t r o m e r e - B , d s D N A , c h r o m a t i n , J o 1 , r i b o s o m a l P. a multiplex approach to diagnose autoimmune diseases like Immunofluorescence was considered positive from the dilution 1/ 80. Sjögren´s syndrome , systemic lupus erythematousus and RESULTS rheumatoid arthritis because the separation of Ro / SSA 52 and 60 Six hundred sera were evaluated, 33 sera were Anti-SSA/Ro52, 42 Anti- antigens conferred increased sensitivity, provides greater SSA/Ro60, and 17 Anti-La/SS-B positive by Bioplex 2200; 37 sera were specificity with a lower rate of false negatives. positive to Anti SS-A/Ro and 11 AntiSS-B/La by AtheNA Multi-lyte® with a REFERENCES global concordance of 96.5% and 98.33% respectively; by IIF we obtained 1. van Woerkom JM, Geertzema JG, Nikkels PG, et al. Expression of Ro/SS-A and La/ 48 positive sera, 25 (52.08%) with coarse and fine speckled pattern, 18 SS-B determined by immunohistochemistry in healthy, inflamed and autoimmune diseased human tissues: a generalized phenomenon. Clin Exp Rheumatol. 2004 May- (37.50%) homogeneous, 2 (4.20%) Centromere-B, 2 (4,20%) Nuclear dots. Jun;22(3):285-92. Finally, 80.70% of the patients had at least one diagnosis of autoimmune 2. J. Schulte-Pelkum a,M. Fritzler , M. Mahler . Latest update on the Ro/SS-A disease. autoantibody system. Autoimmunity Reviews 8 (2009) 632–637