Usability Challenges
    for PhoneCom
          Guanling Chen
University of Massachusetts Lowell
 http://www.cs.uml.edu/~glchen/
Mobile Usability Testing




           8
Android UI Framework

          Dialog

       Button Widget
        (View Class)

        AdapterView
        (ViewGroup)


          Menu




            9
Recorded Events

Recorded	
  Android	
  UI	
  Events	
  are	
  summarized	
  in	
  
the	
  following	
  table,	
  classified	
  by	
  their	
  adhering	
  
window	
  




                                                                 Unhandled Area
                                                 10
State Machine Model
Expert	
  State	
  Machine:	
  




Expert	
  States	
  and	
  Transi3ons:	
  




                                             11
Traffic Flow Chart
User	
  Traffic	
  Flow	
  Chart:	
                  Incoming	
  flow	
  

                                                   Outgoing	
  flow	
  

                                                   Flow	
  to	
  Mistake	
  
                                                   States	
  
                                                   Backtracking	
  
                                                   flow	
  

Mistake	
  States	
  and	
  Transi3ons:	
  




                                              12
Reported Metrics




Signs	
  for	
  poten3al	
  usability	
  problems:	
  

-­‐ Too	
  many	
  backtracking	
  
-­‐ Par0cipants	
  cannot	
  complete	
  one	
  step	
  
-­‐ Low	
  correct	
  flow	
  ra0o	
  
                                         13
Evaluation
Usability	
  Problems	
  idenFfied	
  by	
  Event	
  Logging	
  Tool:	
  




     *	
  Numbers	
  in	
  parenthesis	
  are	
  problems	
  idenFfied	
  by	
  Laboratory-­‐
                             based	
  Usability	
  tesFng	
  method:	
  

     -­‐  Good	
  at	
  iden3fying	
  cri3cal	
  (major	
  and	
  catastrophe)	
  
          usability	
  problems.	
  
     -­‐  Not	
  good	
  at	
  iden3fying	
  cosme3c	
  usability	
  problems.	
  

                                                       14
Challenges

•  More precise analysis model with
   semantics
•  Integration with context
•  Inspection before deployment




                     15

PhoneCom2011 panel - Guanling Chen

  • 1.
    Usability Challenges for PhoneCom Guanling Chen University of Massachusetts Lowell http://www.cs.uml.edu/~glchen/
  • 8.
  • 9.
    Android UI Framework Dialog Button Widget (View Class) AdapterView (ViewGroup) Menu 9
  • 10.
    Recorded Events Recorded  Android  UI  Events  are  summarized  in   the  following  table,  classified  by  their  adhering   window   Unhandled Area 10
  • 11.
    State Machine Model Expert  State  Machine:   Expert  States  and  Transi3ons:   11
  • 12.
    Traffic Flow Chart User  Traffic  Flow  Chart:   Incoming  flow   Outgoing  flow   Flow  to  Mistake   States   Backtracking   flow   Mistake  States  and  Transi3ons:   12
  • 13.
    Reported Metrics Signs  for  poten3al  usability  problems:   -­‐ Too  many  backtracking   -­‐ Par0cipants  cannot  complete  one  step   -­‐ Low  correct  flow  ra0o   13
  • 14.
    Evaluation Usability  Problems  idenFfied  by  Event  Logging  Tool:   *  Numbers  in  parenthesis  are  problems  idenFfied  by  Laboratory-­‐ based  Usability  tesFng  method:   -­‐  Good  at  iden3fying  cri3cal  (major  and  catastrophe)   usability  problems.   -­‐  Not  good  at  iden3fying  cosme3c  usability  problems.   14
  • 15.
    Challenges •  More preciseanalysis model with semantics •  Integration with context •  Inspection before deployment 15